Western Standard - August 15, 2024


Hermaphroditical “female” boxing champion suing critics

Topics
Mentioned
CMS: with Premier Danielle Smith on immigration. Alberta Expands Addiction Treatment with Opening of Third Recovery Community

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

159.8

Word count

7,091

Sentence count

358

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

4

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nichelle hannaford and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan join us to talk about the hermaphroditical boxer who won a gold medal in her weight class at the Olympics and is now suing her critics. Plus, a new Western Standard reporter on the ground in British Columbia, Jared Yager, talks about the B.C. election, and the people of Banff voted in a referendum on making Banff Avenue a pedestrian walkway.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 the day today is august 14th 2024 i am derek phildebrand publisher of the western standard
00:00:29 and you're watching the pipeline we've got a great show for you today but joining us as usual
00:00:35 is western standard opinion editor nigel hannaford good to be here derek always good to have you
00:00:41 and uh western standard uh senior alberta columnist corey morgan always a pleasure
00:00:47 man we get so much fan mail from uh old ladies that just love you oh you're gonna get some stuff
00:00:52 from today's show uh oh yeah won't be so loving oh it'll be fun oh well my my favorite fan mail
00:00:58 is always like hate mail like yeah well you're gonna email I like like any one of you who wants
00:01:02 to write me a nice email that's great but if you write me like hate mail I love it I love hate
00:01:11 mail it's great I understand yeah okay uh well we've got a good show uh we're gonna be talking
00:01:16 about uh everybody knows the uh uh for lack of a better term they have hermaphroditical uh
00:01:22 female, male, whatever you want to call her, him, boxer who won her his gold medal in weight class
00:01:32 at the Olympics. He, she is suing his, her critics. This is really getting annoying,
00:01:41 keeping pronouns straight here, or not straight. Suing Elon Musk, J.K. Rowling, maybe soon Donald
00:01:48 Trump, essentially the whole plan, you know, the three quarters of the planet that thought that
00:01:52 this was not fair sport, suing everyone. So we're gonna be talking about that. And we'll be bringing
00:01:59 in the Western Standard's Jed Hodgson for that, who's been covering, doing all of our Olympic
00:02:03 coverage here. We're also going to be bringing in a new Western Standard reporter, Jared Yager,
00:02:08 our British Columbia reporter on the ground there. We're gonna be talking to him about the
00:02:14 election race heating up there. Polls showing the B.C. Conservatives leaving the B.C. United
00:02:20 slash B.C. Liberals in the dust, becoming the overwhelming opposition powerhouse to take on
00:02:26 the NDP government. Very interesting news coming out that this fall likely will be introduced a
00:02:34 new Alberta Bill of Rights beefing up the rights of Albertans, Alberta citizens vis-a-vis for the
00:02:43 provincial government. And it's at least has a potential to be a lot spicier than some weak sauce document like the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. And one topic near and dear to Corey's heart, the people of Banff have just voted in a referendum on a, you know, not the biggest issue in the world, but a very important issue for them, closing down Banff Avenue and turning it into a pedestrian walkway and how the citizens there 0.50
00:03:13 overturned it in a referendum and really kind of a template for how citizens can
00:03:20 fight City Hall and win something that's hard to do but quite possible if you put
00:03:24 your mind to it okay so we're gonna bring in to begin with Jen Hodgson
00:03:29 Western Standard reporter right out of our Calgary newsroom here thanks for
00:03:34 joining us Jen you guys thanks for having me on so Jen has been leading the
00:03:39 Western standards coverage of all things Olympic. And I mean, try as we might to report on
00:03:46 pole vaulters colliding with other poles and funnier stories from the Olympics.
00:03:55 The big story that's really dominated the Olympic coverage, at least for the Western
00:04:00 standards readers, has been the Algerian hermaphroditical fighter who has won the gold
00:04:07 medal in women's boxing in her weight class. Another, we believe, hermaphroditical fighter
00:04:14 also winning the gold in his or her weight class at the Olympics as well. So two of the
00:04:22 probably four or five different weight classes in the women's all going to people with XY male
00:04:28 chromosomes. So Jen, maybe just set it up for us. The Algerian boxer here, not happy with the 1.00
00:04:38 criticism he or she has received, and is, I think, suing about half the planet now, right?
00:04:46 That's right. So Keyleth, the XY chromosome boxer from Algeria, has this week launched a lawsuit 0.97
00:04:54 against an ambiguous X so what that and I'm not talking about the X social media platform 0.86
00:05:01 so what that means is that it opens up avenues for French investigators to essentially scour
00:05:09 social media to point out anyone who has gone against Keyleth in this way as Keyleth is claiming
00:05:17 saying that it's online harassment it's hate speech to be bringing up the topic of this person's
00:05:24 gender when it comes to his performance in the paris 2024 olympic women's boxing competitions
00:05:31 so he's launched this this lawsuit yes uh rowling musk are named and we have a comment from keyless
00:05:41 lawyer saying that donald trump is going to factor into that investigation as well as as you say
00:05:48 so could half of social media. Let's start with you, Nigel. I'm not sure where they draw the line
00:05:56 in a lawsuit like this. I don't understand the French court's judicial system. It's a very
00:06:00 different system than we have. In the British tradition, it's adversarial. In the French
00:06:07 tradition, the judge is also kind of a semi-prosecutor in a way, taking part in the
00:06:12 proceedings, asking questions. I'm not sure if that extends to the civil or if it's just a criminal,
00:06:17 But this sounds odd that it's a lawsuit, but the French government is becoming an active participant in it.
00:06:23 I don't understand how that system works, but it seems to me if she's essentially suing people for hurting his or her feelings on Twitter,
00:06:32 he or she would have to sue three-quarters or more of planet Earth,
00:06:39 who saw someone who was clearly not meant for the female boxing category
00:06:47 clobbering women in boxing and very obviously winning the gold medal as a result.
00:06:54 I don't know. It seems like a hell of a can of worms to open, 1.00
00:06:57 But, you know, where would this person draw the line at people who haven't defended her or therefore should be liable under French law?
00:07:06 Hard to say, isn't it? I mean, I don't understand the French legal system either.
00:07:10 I stopped at Napoleonic Code, which I gather governs things in Quebec.
00:07:15 200 years of history in that.
00:07:18 As for where she stops, I dare say that she'll draw the line at people who have deep pockets.
00:07:24 You know, clearly there's two things going on here. 0.93
00:07:28 One is a financial cash grab.
00:07:32 If she can get a judgment against J.K. Rowling or Elon Musk, they certainly have the ability to pay.
00:07:41 And the other thing is that what do you do after you have won a gold medal at the Olympics to stay relevant?
00:07:52 She's now attached herself to a cause.
00:07:56 And I've got to say, I actually had sympathy, and I believe that you did as well.
00:08:00 You did have sympathy.
00:08:02 This is not a big, beefy guy who put on a dress to go fight women.
00:08:07 This is someone in a genuinely regrettable situation.
00:08:11 You know, according to the narrative, she was born this way.
00:08:15 Well, what's the person supposed to do other than play with the cards they're dealt with?
00:08:19 But my sympathy dried up the moment when she said, right, now I'm going to sue the pants of everybody who ever said anything unkind about me, because that's now taking it into a vengeful, punitive attitude and leads me to suspect that there may be an agenda, an ideological agenda behind this, which I had been prepared to conceive maybe wasn't present before.
00:08:49 Corey, again, some of these questions are just dealing with the French foreign system, which is foreign to us and more than just the strictly legal sense.
00:09:00 But, you know, she's suing non-French citizens.
00:09:04 Perhaps French and EU law have, you know, the ability to sue people who have hurt your feelings and or who you disagree with.
00:09:15 We have human rights commissions, which semi kind of do that in Canada.
00:09:18 they make cash awards to people. But I don't know, how would she even if she was able to win 0.74
00:09:25 in court against Elon Musk and JK Rowling's and Donald Trump? How the hell would she get the
00:09:31 money? Like, I'm sure that they're not going to cut a check under any circumstance. And I highly
00:09:36 doubt that the, you know, maybe the UK will deport JK Rowling's for hurting feelings. But the United
00:09:41 States is not. Can you imagine Donald Trump as president of the United States being asked to
00:09:45 his own extradition to go to France to pay. Maybe she'll show up at their door and beat the hell out 1.00
00:09:53 of them as a collector. I mean, she's a pretty tough gal. He or she's shown the ability to beat 1.00
00:09:58 up women. I'd be doubtful she'll be that successful against. I mean, she could beat me up. I don't 0.99
00:10:05 think I'd be that tough. She looks like an athletic skilled boxer. The bigger worry, 1.00
00:10:11 No, aside from the collections anyways, and you know, the legal aspect, what I'm most concerned about is, it's gagging a conversation that needs to be had. I mean, it's one that we never imagined we'd ever have 20 years ago. But the only, you know, with so many questionable things, Leah Thomas, a clear man going out swimming, wiping women off the course, things like that with a clear male advantage.
00:10:36 at least he wasn't beating women
00:10:38 and the closest line we can draw
00:10:41 is saying well look one thing that's immutable
00:10:42 is the chromosomes, there's male
00:10:44 and there's female, there's distinctive advantages
00:10:47 that come from having male chromosomes 1.00
00:10:48 and changes with a woman 1.00
00:10:51 and if we're going to wipe that
00:10:53 out, if we can't talk about that
00:10:55 then there will be 0.82
00:10:57 outright men, cutting off their
00:10:59 nuts and berries even but they still got the
00:11:00 X, Y going on 1.00
00:11:03 and can go into women's sports and do that
00:11:05 we have to, even if it's unfair, if she was born as an unusual, you know, circumstance, 1.00
00:11:11 the bottom line is she had male chromosomes. I mean, a person born with a club foot is probably
00:11:16 never going to be a top marathon runner either. Just the way you're born sometimes isn't fair.
00:11:21 But we have to have this conversation and we can't have her shutting down discussion with this
00:11:25 lawsuit. Jen, maybe you want to flesh out the story a bit more. Has there been any response
00:11:33 from uh jk rowling's uh and for those who don't know that's she's the author of uh the harry potter
00:11:39 uh series uh any response from jk rowling's or elon musk or uh potentially donald trump to uh
00:11:48 the algerian boxer's threat to sue them for hurting her feelings so we haven't had any
00:11:53 acknowledgement from those three named individuals yet but a couple minutes ago derek you were asking
00:11:59 about how this could be allowed transatlantically. So how in the U.S. could there be laws that this
00:12:07 actually could even be a legal matter for American individuals being sued by French prosecutors on
00:12:14 behalf of an Algerian athlete. So as Variety reported, and that's who did the exclusive
00:12:21 interview with Keyliff's lawyer. And so it was reported that actually the U.S. already has
00:12:27 offices in place that work in partnership with international offices to combat online hate.
00:12:36 So it does look like this, that this lawsuit can go forward based on those grounds that there's
00:12:42 a partnership already established. And therefore, as the lawyer said,
00:12:48 Keyleth can target personalities overseas. Yeah. It'd be pretty funny if they sued Trump
00:12:54 while Trump is president. I would imagine whatever treaties are in place allowing Trump to be sued
00:13:01 for hurting an Algerian's feelings while they competed in France, I have a feeling that treaty
00:13:06 gets torn up pretty damn quick. That's right. It's quite a bold move to file a lawsuit about
00:13:13 online hate speech against someone who is running to be the next president and has already been
00:13:18 president. Yeah. Also going after the world's richest man, JK Rowling's arguably the most
00:13:26 successful author since Moses. Right. And you know what, Derek? So we actually see these
00:13:32 claims made in the lawsuit and it comes following images that surfaced after Keyleth won his medal
00:13:40 after the women's boxing match. And Keyleth, an Algerian, right? So coming from a Muslim country
00:13:46 where there are extremely strict laws about conduct between men and women and also how a
00:13:53 woman presents herself in public, what she wears, her proximity to men, and how she behaves.
00:13:59 So there's footage that has been circulating on social media of Keyleth hoisted up on the
00:14:06 soldiers or on the shoulders of his trainers. And in that moment, the trainer has his hand
00:14:13 all over keeliff's upper thighs we have other trainers coming in and patting keeliff on the
00:14:18 waist keeliff is has a bare head where he's wearing a tank top and we don't see that kind of
00:14:25 uh gender norm based on someone's sex in a muslim country like algeria what that would require
00:14:33 someone who presents as a woman to actually present as a woman then covering up her head
00:14:39 And, of course, not being sitting up on a man's shoulders.
00:14:42 Yeah, well, you can see from that footage very much at least being treated like one of the boys by some of the boys from a country not known for its less than feminist attitudes towards women.
00:14:57 Right. And for contrast, there's another video I've seen on social media of a female Algerian boxer training, and she is wearing a headscarf.
00:15:07 she's fully covered in her upper body, and she's training in the gym, and it's juxtaposed with the
00:15:12 video of Keyliff training. And Keyliff is just wearing a tank top, he's bareheaded, and it's
00:15:19 just not the way that a female Algerian Muslim would present herself. Yeah. All right. Thank 1.00
00:15:25 you, Jen. I appreciate all your coverage of this story. Thank you very much. Okay, we're going to
00:15:31 bring in the Western Standard's Jared Yager now. Jared Yager is a new, very fresh reporter coming
00:15:38 to the Western Standard. Comes to us from the post-millennial, based in beautiful Vancouver,
00:15:43 British Columbia. Jared, welcome to your first time on the pipeline here. You've got a
00:15:54 story out an exclusive poll conducted for the Western Standard, showing that the BC conservatives
00:16:04 are continuing to vacuum up whatever crumbs are left of voter support from the BC United
00:16:12 slash BC Liberals, as well as some of the other parties. Give us a breakdown of the poll.
00:16:18 okay so basically uh that poll it was uh conducted in july and i'm just getting the numbers here
00:16:32 yeah among the 804 respondents 37 said they'd vote for the ndp and for the conservatives it
00:16:42 wasn't much less than that and that uh that's been mirrored in another poll that just came
00:16:48 out a couple days ago from leger where yeah basically the conservatives and ndp are neck
00:16:54 and neck so any suggestion that bc united liberals as we have to call them now are in the race at all
00:17:02 is just out of the question and you can see they're starting to get desperate you know a couple days
00:17:08 ago they brought out the tax cuts and i was talking with uh john rusted about that the
00:17:14 conservative leader and he said you know it's easy for a party that's in single digits in the polls
00:17:19 to be able to promise all kinds of things they know they'll never have to deliver
00:17:23 and so yeah as of right now it's a it's a two-party race and the conservatives
00:17:29 just keep on eating up support from from both the ndp and the uh the bc united
00:17:36 Well, you know, they changed their name to BC United, Corey, but they've dropped in the poll since. They've lost the right entirely to the BC Conservatives. I think the little pittance of support they have left is kind of in the center.
00:17:52 So they've actually kind of more or less reverted to the name BC Liberals, trying to capitalize on some of the anemic federal liberal support left in British Columbia.
00:18:01 I think their official name is still BC United, but they've asked BC Elections British Columbia to have them listed on the ballot as BC United slash BC Liberals.
00:18:14 If you were advising Kevin Falcon right now, and I got to start, at some point it's like, you know, stop kicking him.
00:18:21 He's dead already. But they're still running. They'll be on the ballot with a full slate.
00:18:29 I'm willing to bet 20 bucks right now that this is the last election that the B.C. liberals have a full slate of candidates at this point.
00:18:37 But if you if you were advising Kevin Falcon, would you advise him to maybe double down on the older B.C. liberal brand to try and maybe recast it as the middle party?
00:18:49 and, you know, the federal liberals are on track for zero seats in British Columbia right now.
00:18:56 But those are bigger federal ridings.
00:18:58 Right now, BC United, BC liberals are on track for zero seats in all probability.
00:19:03 Do you think they're better positioned, rebranding themselves as instead of the not NDP party of the broad center and right,
00:19:09 recasting themselves, trying as like the moderate center left?
00:19:13 I don't think he can try and recast himself.
00:19:15 I mean, that's where he buggered up in the first place.
00:19:17 You had a brand and it was certainly sinking due to your actions and rebranding only made it worse.
00:19:25 But making a third effort just adds to, as Jared was saying, another indication of desperation.
00:19:31 Doubling down, I mean, to be honest, I would think they should be at a point where you should be saying fold the tent for the sake of the province and quickly see if you can.
00:19:39 I know it's not going to happen.
00:19:40 I mean, they'll go down on their pride rather than do such a move.
00:19:44 But I don't know what he can do anymore.
00:19:46 I mean, you know, all the way back to when they rejected Aaron Gunn's run for the leadership, they lost small-c conservative support.
00:19:54 They're not going to get it back.
00:19:57 They could corner centrist liberal thinking of the old liberal name, but that's not nearly enough to win a seat anywhere, not in our system.
00:20:04 I mean, you know, with first-past-the-post, they're just going to get annihilated everywhere they go.
00:20:08 But they could still be a spoiler, and that's what a lot of people are concerned about right now.
00:20:12 Well, that's where I want to go with you, Nigel.
00:20:13 I forgot who was. There was a professor at one of the universities in British Columbia who wrote an article about this. The BC Liberals, now rebranded BC United, now re-rebranded BC United Liberals, the entire point of the party was that they are the non-NDP coalition.
00:20:35 It is, there's the NDP over here, and they are this ultra mega big tent of everybody who's not a hardcore socialist.
00:20:44 And so you had moderate federal liberals all the way over to hardcore right wing conservatives in this one giant big tent.
00:20:52 That's completely gone.
00:20:54 They've lost that to the British, the BC conservatives.
00:20:59 The raison d'etre of the party is to keep the NDP from power.
00:21:02 That can now be best achieved by dissolving the party.
00:21:08 But that requires an admission of defeat and to not even go down swinging.
00:21:19 Do you think, I know we're not British Columbians, but, you know, wouldn't that be the logical thing now if the very existence of BC United slash liberals is to keep the NDP from power?
00:21:31 they can best serve that now by either dissolving the party or at least throwing in the towel on this election and not running candidates.
00:21:39 Your analysis is spot on.
00:21:42 I lived in B.C. for 25 years, so I've got a bit of a recollection of how things were.
00:21:48 And of course, the B.C. United was the B.C. Liberals and the B.C. Liberals were the social credit party that dominated B.C. politics for something like 40 years.
00:22:00 And very successfully, by the way, it was a tightly run ship.
00:22:07 There were 20 years of balanced budgets.
00:22:11 And, you know, I think people just got tired of them and tired of the same old faces.
00:22:16 So they tried the NDP in 1975.
00:22:20 That lasted 18 months.
00:22:21 They tried them again in the early 1990s.
00:22:24 Oh, no, we don't want to do that anymore.
00:22:25 and came back, they rebranded as Liberals and came back with Morton Campbell.
00:22:31 And that, you know, that went very well.
00:22:33 But there's been a lot of demographic changes in B.C.
00:22:39 And people always want something for nothing.
00:22:41 So the NDP appeal was very strong.
00:22:45 Now, to the point of your question, should they just disband?
00:22:49 Because you're right.
00:22:50 They were always anybody but the NDP.
00:22:52 And that was their card back in the 70s, the 80s, and the 90s, even in the early years of this century.
00:23:00 Yes, of course they should.
00:23:02 Will they?
00:23:02 Of course not, because personal pride gets in the way.
00:23:06 And, unfortunately, the danger of them splitting the vote with people who are either sentimentally attached to the old party or who simply haven't really been keeping up and, oh, yeah, well, I have never heard of a conservative party.
00:23:27 You know, that's a real danger.
00:23:30 Jared, sticking with this topic. So I don't know if you're familiar with the column that ran, I think it ran in the Post Media Papers about, you know, that the BC United Liberals should just throw in the towel on this. I'm not expecting them to.
00:23:47 I mean, if the BCU United Liberals stood for something other than keeping the NDP from power, well, then there'd be a good cause for them to run if they were just, you know, the liberals of BC, a traditional liberal party, if they were, say, the, you know, a more moderate version of the NDP.
00:24:08 Well, actually, I suppose they are a more moderate version of the NDP, but the raison d'etre isn't ideological.
00:24:13 It is purely to keep the NDP from power.
00:24:16 The Greens have an ideological raison d'etre for existence, and that's environmental extremism.
00:24:23 You know, B.C., I think it's the easiest province in the country to start a political party.
00:24:28 B.C.'s got something like 100 odd political parties, at least on paper.
00:24:31 But what's been the response of Kevin Falcon and the United Liberals to calls for them to essentially step down and let the Conservatives contest the election in their place?
00:24:47 I've pretty much seen no indication that that's even in their minds at all.
00:24:54 And yeah, so that's not something I think we're going to see.
00:24:59 But there have been increasing calls from the Conservative side for them to do just that.
00:25:04 For example, today, Gavin Dew, he was named as the candidate for the BC Conservatives in Kelowna Mission.
00:25:10 And he said in his press release that everyone's tired of the drama and it's time to put BC first, not egos or old party allegiances.
00:25:20 And I think that's what a lot of people are feeling right now is, Kevin, you know, you're way down in the polls.
00:25:26 There's no way to make it up.
00:25:28 It's time to just work with John and, you know, fulfill your obligation to get the NDP out of power.
00:25:37 I think, Corey, this would be just particularly impossible for Kevin Falcon to do because he's the one who kicked John Rudstad out of caucus.
00:25:48 I think what was it over his views on global warming or something.
00:25:52 and I mean it's not like John Redstadt was just like some outsider coming in like when Daniel
00:25:58 Smith was leading the Wild Rose you know this was a guy who was in his caucus on his team and he
00:26:04 kicked them out I mean there's just no way even a very humble man could bring himself to do this
00:26:11 there's just no way Falcon can't come into the room with the others I mean at and again he's
00:26:16 shown no indication of it but if he said that's it we're done we're backing out I think he would
00:26:20 just take his ball and go home. He's not going to get into the same room with Rustad and work
00:26:24 together. That's just not not in the cards. Well, Nigel, there was talks to negotiate,
00:26:33 if not a merger, at least some kind of non-aggression pact, so they don't split the
00:26:39 vote. But the BC Liberal or United Liberal proposal was outrageously naive. It would
00:26:48 guarantee the BC Liberals get to keep all of their incumbent seats, which happened to be the most
00:26:54 right-leaning conservative seats in BC. The BC Conservatives stand to win every single last
00:27:02 current BC United Liberal seat, and they were asking the BC Conservatives to just completely
00:27:07 vacate that. I don't think there was ever a way the math would work for them to do this.
00:27:14 Those kinds of arrangements always look great to people who are outside politics.
00:27:19 If you are inside politics, and that's your seat, well, and it's a terrible idea.
00:27:25 Of course it is.
00:27:26 Yeah.
00:27:27 You know, I obviously wish Mr. Rasta had all success, but he is going to have his hands full if he wins.
00:27:36 Because the NDP in the last four years has run up the provincial debt.
00:27:40 Maybe Jared has got the exact numbers, but it's an astonishing amount of money that the NDP has borrowed in just four years.
00:27:50 And getting the program spending under control, never mind making any serious attempt to bring down that debt,
00:28:01 is going to challenge any party that wants to take it on.
00:28:06 And by the way, they're all promising to get rid of income tax in B.C. for 60% of B.C. taxpayers.
00:28:15 Great idea, but I cannot see how it's going to work.
00:28:18 So this could turn out to be a poisoned chalice.
00:28:23 Well, Jared, I'll kick it back to you to finish up this segment.
00:28:27 What's next on the campaign trail?
00:28:30 What can we expect from the big campaigns?
00:28:33 well i think you're going to see the bc conservatives really doubling down on their
00:28:41 successes and the ndp just kind of riding on you know the support they already have i don't think
00:28:46 they're going to be uh bringing in any new voters and in that poll that was conducted for the for
00:28:53 the western standard it was interesting because the bc conservatives they captured 50 of the voters
00:28:59 who voted BC, well, BC Liberals, back in 2020.
00:29:04 But they also got 17% of those who voted for the BC NDP
00:29:08 and 21% of those who voted for the BC Green Party.
00:29:14 So I don't see the other two parties
00:29:17 gaining any more support.
00:29:19 But the Conservatives,
00:29:20 the only direction to go is up from here.
00:29:24 All right.
00:29:25 Well, Jared, thank you for joining us
00:29:28 on the pipeline here today.
00:29:29 Get back to work. You're doing good stuff out there.
00:29:33 All right. Well, let's bring it a little closer to home here for us at Western Standard World Headquarters.
00:29:40 This fall, we are expecting the Alberta's United Conservative Government to introduce an update.
00:29:49 It says it's update, but it's pretty much a whole new Alberta Bill of Rights.
00:29:54 A lot of people are not quite aware that there's an Alberta Bill of Rights.
00:29:58 there is it's largely been subsumed since since the Charter came into effect 1982 alongside the
00:30:07 Constitution Act 1982 but it's it's it's reportedly got might include some very spicy elements Jason
00:30:17 Marcus off at the CBC Calgary CBC reporting you know there's different groups some called the
00:30:27 black hat gang, which is no, no, that's not a cowboy posse, but
00:30:32 Southern Alberta, and they wear black hats like one. And some
00:30:35 other groups within the UCP are pressing for the inclusion of
00:30:37 things. They go well beyond some mushy document like the Charter
00:30:44 of Rights and Freedoms to give much more robust rights to
00:30:47 Albertans. Nigel, why don't you queue it up?
00:30:51 So the thing with the Bill of Rights, obviously, it's an
00:30:55 aspirational document anything put out by federal legislation so you can't as a province declare a
00:31:09 right to something which is expressly forbidden by federal law however from the point of view
00:31:16 of the politics of the province it is a good thing for a leader to reflect prevailing sentiment
00:31:24 within the province and a declaration of rights in any document issued by the provincial government
00:31:31 passed through the legislature informs a lot of people of things they need to be informed about.
00:31:38 For example, judges. If you have a clear statement on stand your ground, which is one of the things
00:31:46 that there's speculation around. It's among the rights of self-defense. Yeah, I don't personally
00:31:52 see that going the whole distance but the very fact that people are even talking about it in a
00:31:58 province where a number of families living in remote areas have suddenly found themselves
00:32:05 confronted by people trying to steal their property or even threatening them personally
00:32:10 a lot of people are interested in that idea that you should be interested in it so um okay all right
00:32:18 so now you have the province coming out and making a statement about standing your ground perhaps
00:32:25 i don't know what's in this any more than anybody else then that tells the police and it tells
00:32:32 the judiciary that we actually care about people and we are not just automatically going to assume
00:32:40 that criminals are going to come first there is a talk for example again about a right to refuse
00:32:47 medical treatment well clearly there is a there are a lot of us who were highly skeptical of
00:32:57 what the federal government and our own alberta health services were really trying to to do during
00:33:05 the covet crisis and it became an extremely personal issue for people who said either you
00:33:12 get the jab or you get out the door uh this is and ultimately the people who said you know it's
00:33:21 probably not that safe and probably not that effective we don't know about the safety thing
00:33:25 completely yet but we certainly found out that was no protection against transmitting or receiving
00:33:32 covet so you know people had a right to be skeptical and if the province is going to give
00:33:37 people are right to say, I'm skeptical, no, thanks, then that's going to be in the first
00:33:44 case, a popular move politically. And secondly, actually, personally, I think that's the right
00:33:51 stance to take. So a lot of people don't understand this, but every province has a constitution.
00:33:58 Now, the United States state constitutions are are written formal codified documents,
00:34:04 like the Canadian federal, Canada has a mixed kind of hybrid constitution, unwritten parts
00:34:10 coming from the Westminster tradition, combined with some American parts that are written and
00:34:15 codified beginning with the British North America Act 1867, updated several times,
00:34:21 most notably 1982 with the Constitution Act. But the provinces also have their own constitutions
00:34:28 subject within the federal one as well. But the provincial constitutions are, I believe,
00:34:35 all unwritten. Perhaps Quebec's got some exceptions to that.
00:34:40 They certainly behave as though they have their own constitution.
00:34:47 They have made it clear how they view the world, and that's the message to the rest of Canada.
00:34:52 So most, if not all, provinces do have their own bills of rights, but they all
00:34:57 kind of took a back burner to the Charter of Rights and Freedoms for the Constitution Act 1982
00:35:02 and Pierre Trudeau. But that, you know, the charter leaves out, Corey, some very notable rights.
00:35:10 Freedom of speech is not as robust as in the United States, it's freedom of expression,
00:35:15 but you know, using nearly mouth Canadian language like within reasonable grounds in a
00:35:21 freedom democratic society, which, you know, leaves a pretty big hole to drive a truck through
00:35:26 violating all sorts of free speech rights. You know, life, liberty, pursuit of happiness
00:35:32 gives a lot more protections arguably around bodily autonomy. Certainly the Second Amendment,
00:35:39 the right to bear arms. And I'll be surprised. I want your input on this, Corey. I'll be surprised
00:35:45 if that makes it, but there is a lot of movement to include a right to bear arms and to protect
00:35:49 yourself and your property in the new Bill of Rights. Now, that would be positively revolutionary
00:35:56 by Canadian terms. I mean, if we were to have an Alberta Bill of Rights, and also the right
00:36:03 against excessive taxation, that can be read different ways. But I would imagine that between
00:36:08 your income tax, your sales tax, property taxes, maybe we cap it all at 50% of your income,
00:36:15 which I think people would say, that should be enough.
00:36:18 God asked for 10%.
00:36:19 The government should be happy with 50.
00:36:23 I mean, these things would be positively revolutionary.
00:36:26 What do you think the chances are some of these,
00:36:28 I think we're going to get the right to refuse medical,
00:36:31 around vaccines and medical treatments,
00:36:35 firearms, self-defense, excessive taxation.
00:36:39 What do you think the chances are that they would do something that,
00:36:42 for lack of a better term, ballsy?
00:36:45 It's hard to say. They might put in property rights. That's another one that the charter is
00:36:48 quite weak on the enjoyment of property. And when you get into property rights, then maybe we can
00:36:53 expand a little further on how far is your right to defend that property. But as we said, it's
00:36:59 aspirational. I mean, this is drawing lines in the sand is what it is. And saying this is what
00:37:03 we would like to see in Alberta. But we also know this won't last any farther than the first federal
00:37:09 court challenge. Well, not necessarily. It's applicable to provincial statute, not to federal
00:37:14 law, but to provincial statute, it would be applicable. So this would have real world
00:37:19 implication, not nearly as real world as if say this was amending the federal charter of rights
00:37:24 and freedoms. But this would have real world application within provincial statute within
00:37:28 provincial statute. But again, it depends on where you're going with it. You know, if you said
00:37:32 there's a stand your ground law, that's fine. But I think it's going to be a flimsy defense when you
00:37:36 get pulled in front of the federal court afterwards. But at least it's showing where the province came
00:37:41 from on it. And it says we are different. We want to stand up for our own rights that way. I mean,
00:37:47 realistically, we know a lot of this is to make sure that some of those factions within the party
00:37:52 feel they're being represented, that their voices are being heard, and that the province is taking
00:37:56 it seriously. Even if it might not withstand a federal, you know, challenge all the way to the
00:38:02 final end of things, it's showing the province is doing everything in their power to protect their
00:38:06 right to avoid being coerced into a medical procedure they don't feel comfortable with
00:38:10 or feel that they shouldn't have any right to defend themselves or property.
00:38:14 So it'll be interesting to see how far they want to go. I think the party's probably doing
00:38:18 internals like crazy to see how little they can get away with without poking into hornet's nests,
00:38:23 but how much they're going to need to do to keep the floor of the convention happy.
00:38:27 So property rights will be a very popular one. I mean, before she was ever in politics,
00:38:32 Danielle Smith was property rights. 0.99
00:38:34 Well, which issue with like Alberta Property Rights Association or something.
00:38:37 I don't know the exact name.
00:38:38 It certainly is. 0.98
00:38:39 That was her thing.
00:38:39 Yes.
00:38:40 And that was kind of early Wild Rose parties, you know, kind of as it was taking off when she was coming in, succeeding Paul Henry.
00:38:47 And, you know, with a right to firearm ownership, it may not withstand the ultimate federal assault, but it's certainly like a tank obstacle in an advance.
00:38:57 You know, you've got to get around it first.
00:38:59 We're going to make them work for it.
00:39:00 Yeah, it makes them work for it.
00:39:01 so well god bless them if they uh if they're willing to go out this far i mean i mean it
00:39:07 politicians tend to be pretty i should say successful politicians are risk averse
00:39:12 uh but yeah it's um it's something we'll see okay uh in the tongue we've got left here we're gonna
00:39:18 get uh something you wrote about cory uh so town of banff uh just was it yesterday monday a couple
00:39:27 days ago yeah okay just the other day had a referendum uh on the issue of turning banff
00:39:34 anyone watching who's been to banff you maybe didn't even know it's called banff avenue but
00:39:37 the main road straight through banff i mean it's it's worse traffic than downtown calgary or
00:39:43 edmonton it's it's it's pretty terrible to get through sometimes but um you know that beautiful
00:39:48 street uh the i guess the the mayor and council wanted to turn it into a permanent pedestrian road
00:39:56 I don't live there. So but as someone who likes to visit from time to time, I like being able to drive. But anyway, there was a referendum on it, Corey, and you wrote a column, almost like a how to guide you using Banff as an example, but how citizens can rebel against mayors and councils that get out of their lane.
00:40:19 yeah and it was a good effort like part of this was Banff citizens determining their destiny not
00:40:25 the local media not the tourists even I mean if you go to it it's kind of nice you can walk down
00:40:29 the street you can hit the stores there's the patios I grew up in Banff though and you got
00:40:33 to remember the citizens have a different outlook and if you don't know that town Banff Avenue even
00:40:38 if it was congested while open was two lanes on each side and it's the main order it's the
00:40:43 only avenue to get to the south end of town yeah when they closed it if you go to the side streets
00:40:48 on the side, they're narrow, they're residential, they're terrible. And anybody trying to get the
00:40:53 best way to tell the administration offices, anything, we're forced on to that it was it was
00:40:57 putting possible, it was putting locals through misery. But what's great is, you know, the mayor
00:41:03 and council is often is or offside with the locals, the locals utilize the means they have in the
00:41:08 municipal government act, it's buried in there. And it's dry, you can petition, you get 10% of
00:41:15 of the voters signing that petition, they have two choices,
00:41:18 repeal the bylaw, or put it to a vote. And the guy that local
00:41:23 government still fought it, they forced it all the way to the
00:41:25 local vote. And the citizen said, that's it, it's out. And
00:41:28 now they have no choice, they have to get rid of that bylaw.
00:41:31 But Albertans should be paying attention, any town can do this,
00:41:34 every town can do this. There's limitations. And it's a really
00:41:38 boring section of the Municipal Governments Act, you can't get
00:41:42 rid of every tax increase or every rezoning, but there are a lot of bylaws you could conceivably
00:41:49 get rid of with just 10% of the vote. Like Calgary's bag bylaw, for example, if the council
00:41:54 had still been fighting that and everything, actually the citizens could have gotten that
00:41:57 through perhaps and taken it out. It's more reasonable in small towns though. 10% is reasonable
00:42:02 enough to get in Banff. I mean, you and a dozen buddies can go out for a weekend, you get 10%.
00:42:07 To do that in Calgary, that's over 100,000 people.
00:42:11 Yes, so the logistics aren't there.
00:42:12 But it certainly can put some of those elected municipal officials on notice that, hey, you've got to be responsible to us between elections, too. 0.97
00:42:19 And I just think it's fantastic, and I hope to see more towns doing that when it's stupid laws. 0.98
00:42:25 There are so many. 0.90
00:42:27 Nigel, lessons for, I'm not sure what the municipal government acts are like outside of Alberta,
00:42:31 but I think certainly lessons for people outside of Banff across the rest of Alberta
00:42:36 when municipalities get out of their lane like this.
00:42:38 And they do.
00:42:39 The problem with, there's a couple of problems.
00:42:41 People who like to interfere with things are the ones who usually put themselves forward
00:42:46 for your municipal office.
00:42:47 Everybody thinks, oh, that's a public service.
00:42:50 And for some, perhaps it is.
00:42:53 More, however, are people who have a thing.
00:42:56 They want bicycle lanes, or they want more flowerpots, or they want people to not have paper bags, or they want to close Banff Avenue.
00:43:06 They're cause people, and when they are elected, they never tell you the whole agenda.
00:43:10 They just tell you what they want you to hear, and let them go do it.
00:43:15 But the rules are made by the people who show up.
00:43:18 And this mechanism, the plebiscite, is what the citizen has to have.
00:43:28 It's a last resort after you've left it too late to really examine the candidates
00:43:32 and you're stuck with somebody you don't like.
00:43:34 At least you can do that.
00:43:36 All right.
00:43:36 Well, we're going to put a pen in it there, gentlemen.
00:43:41 Thank you.
00:43:41 And thank all of you for joining us today in the middle of our beautiful Western summer.
00:43:47 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, stop freeloading, open up your wallet, and support one of the only free media outlets left in Canada.
00:43:55 The Western Standard is one of, among significant media outlets, you can count them on one hand that don't take the federal liberals' media bailout package.
00:44:04 For only $10 a month or $100 a year, you'll get unlimited access to all Western Standard content and be supporting one of the last bastions of free press left in Canada.
00:44:14 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:44:18 You can become a Western Standard member for just $10 a month or $99 a year.