Western Standard - September 26, 2024


Hit the brakes on electric buses!

Topics
Mentioned
Stronger rights for Albertans could be a signal for all of Canada Latest spending boondoggle looming for the city of Calgary

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

194.0

Word count

9,053

Sentence count

746

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

24

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of the Corey Morgan Show, host Corey Morgan talks about some of the biggest boondoggles going on in our local government, from the Phoenix Payroll System to the City of Calgary's failure to get electric buses on the books.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Welcome to the Corey Morgan Show. Last one of September. Where's the time going?
00:00:07 Lots to cover today. I got a boondoggle theme going on. I like that word. It's just an odd
00:00:12 word. We get to use it so often, unfortunately. It wouldn't be sad if I never had to use it,
00:00:17 but I'm going to speak on one boondoggle that's kind of local in a moment or two. And I have a
00:00:22 guest author, David Sabine, who's going to talk about the Phoenix Payroll System boondoggle as
00:00:27 well. You hear about that now and then. It's a big one and it really needs to be followed up on.
00:00:31 I mean, payroll systems, who wants to talk about that? Well, a lot of the civil servants who are
00:00:36 trying to get a correct paycheck would like to talk about that. As much as I'm hard on them,
00:00:39 they do deserve to get their paychecks right. And of course, us as taxpayers who are paying for these
00:00:43 systems would like to talk about that, or at least we need to talk about that. So we'll get to that
00:00:48 in a little while as well. I see a few of you checking in on the live scroll already in the
00:00:52 comments. Paradoxy, Mr. Stanley, A-E-R-E-P. Oh my God. You guys got to make easier names for me
00:00:59 and Jordan all the other though. Good to see you in there. Use those comments, girls. Discuss
00:01:03 things with each other. Send comments my way. It can be interactive and it can be fun. So make use
00:01:09 of it. Just stay somewhat civil to each other. We don't have to be nothing but sunshine. I know
00:01:13 I'm not, but you know, we don't have to be at each other's throats either. All right,
00:01:17 let's get onto the first boondoggle, which is locally and in Calgary, but it still, it impacts
00:01:22 everybody because these are happening in cities across the country. Municipal governments, they
00:01:27 love to throw away the hard-earned money of taxpayers with wild abandon. I mean, the stories
00:01:32 of waste and corruption from local governments seem to have no end. And Calgary City Hall has been
00:01:36 working hard to outdo itself with their boondoggles and waste. I mean, on the low side, Calgary blew
00:01:42 4.8 million tax dollars and it took them four years to come up with a new slogan for the city.
00:01:48 The slogan was Blue Sky City. Yeah, almost 5 million for that, guys. There should be a forensic
00:01:54 audit of that ripoff. And then on the high end, Calgary spent 1.4 billion dollars in nine years on an
00:02:00 LRT expansion without laying an inch of track. By the time the government finally stepped in from the
00:02:07 province and pulled the funding from the project, the projected cost of this train line had ballooned from
00:02:11 $100,000 per meter to $600,000 per meter. If left alone, Gondek's Council of Clowns and
00:02:17 an inept city administration probably could have pushed the cost of that plan to a million dollars a 0.97
00:02:21 meter. It's now going to cost another $700 million just to get out of that mess with the contracts. 0.95
00:02:27 Now we've got a new disaster looming on the horizon and that's with electric buses.
00:02:31 Like most progressive mayors, Jody Gondek has a climate change obsession and one of her first acts
00:02:36 as mayor was to entrench an insane, and it is insane, 87 billion dollar climate plan for the
00:02:41 city of Calgary. Yeah, that wasn't a mistaken number. Her plan is to blow 87 billion dollars 1.00
00:02:46 just in the city of Calgary. Changing Calgary's bus fleet to electric buses is presumably part of that
00:02:52 plan. A pilot project was embraced by city council to purchase 14 electric buses for a cost of about 14
00:02:59 million dollars. The pilot was set to begin in 2022. Well, it's 2024 now and getting here towards the
00:03:05 tail end of it. The problem is no buses have arrived. The city has constructed charging stations
00:03:11 and made plans, but the buses are nowhere to be found. If you look on the city website, a short
00:03:15 terse statement statement was made in August saying the buses are delayed for now. There's some little
00:03:19 utterances about supply chain issues. Yes, indeed, there's a supply chain issue. The buses aren't here.
00:03:25 This bus supply seems to have collapsed. If you look at the company the city bought the buses from,
00:03:29 it's not hard to see where there's a delay. Vicinity Motor Corporation appears to be on the brink of
00:03:34 going broke. Their shares have dropped to penny stock value, and they've only managed to make 11
00:03:39 buses in the last quarter of 2023. They haven't responded to press inquiries, and they're heavily in
00:03:44 debt. The odds aren't looking good for the city in getting either of the buses. Of course, a refund on
00:03:49 whatever they've spent so far. But oh, it gets worse. In December 2022, the city announced they
00:03:55 would go ahead with a $489 million plan to buy and equip 259 electric buses. I mean, when questions
00:04:02 were asked why the city's moving forward with this massive purchase despite the pilot project not
00:04:07 having started even, people were told, well, the electric bus program in Edmonton was so successful,
00:04:11 they decided Calgary didn't need to wait for the pilot to finish. Edmonton's electric bus
00:04:16 program has been a complete catastrophe. The buses cost a fortune. There were 60 of them. They were
00:04:21 found not to work in cold weather. Diesel upgrades had to be added to the buses to heat the motors to
00:04:26 make them work at great expense. And then the buses began to break down en masse. But the city couldn't
00:04:30 repair them because the company that manufactured them had gone bankrupt. So now they can't get spare
00:04:35 parts and two thirds of the buses are out of service. $60 million, folks. Now the first of Calgary's
00:04:41 259 electric buses is supposed to be in service in a year or two, I believe. They're all supposed
00:04:46 to be in use not too long after that. But when you consider the pilot program buses have been,
00:04:51 they've been lost in the mix somewhere after years, it comes hard to believe that this larger order is
00:04:55 going to be arriving anytime soon. So where's the city at with the procurement of this massive electric
00:05:00 fleet? What's the progress been to date and how much has been spent already? Well, they're not telling
00:05:04 anybody. As with the green line, the city's keeping the information hidden as deeply as possible.
00:05:09 Citizens, you've got to get up and demand a progress report from the city for this half
00:05:13 billion dollar bus program. And if the city can't demonstrate it's moving along smoothly,
00:05:17 it must pull the plug on this thing immediately. These things only get worse with more time and
00:05:22 sinking more money in. Have they spent the money already? Have they already equipped bus barns with
00:05:27 259 charging stations to languish empty waiting, you know, as the pilot program has been going?
00:05:33 I mean, we likely won't get answers until the program implodes and most of the current council along
00:05:37 with the mayor have probably been replaced by then. We've got a chance to stop this train wreck or
00:05:42 bus wreck, if you want to call it that. Either way, when the time comes, nobody can pretend we didn't
00:05:46 see it coming. I'm warning you now, guys, and don't act surprised when this falls apart in a year or
00:05:51 two or whatever it might be. All right, that's what's got to be going. That's boondoggle number one for
00:05:55 today. Let's check in with our news editor, Dave Naylor, and see what else is going on in the big bad world
00:06:00 out there. And there he is from the newsroom, Dave Naylor. How are you doing? I'm missing you,
00:06:04 Corey. Normally I'm sitting right beside you. I know, I know, but we've got a bit of a camera
00:06:09 shortage today, so we've had to rely on you in the old seats there in the newsroom. Yeah, I understand
00:06:14 it's halfway to Edmonton now, and you and I are heading up there right after the show. We are indeed.
00:06:20 Yes, the toasting Ted event for Ted Byfield. I'll try not to terrorize you too much on the drive.
00:06:26 Can I sit in the back seat so it's like a real Uber experience? You certainly can, and I can scowl at
00:06:31 you in the rear view mirror like I typically do. Awesome. Looking forward to it. Yeah, we've had a
00:06:37 busy morning as usual here in the newsroom. You were alive back in 1947, right? Almost. Almost. Well,
00:06:47 that was the last time you could buy a chocolate bar for five cents. It was in 1947. And that's exactly where
00:06:54 Alberta natural gas prices today at five cents, which is not very good. It's almost cheaper to
00:07:02 keep it in the ground. But our energy expert, Sean Polzer has got a story up there explaining it all.
00:07:07 And he's actually at a press conference right now with Premier Smith, and he's going to ask her
00:07:14 about that because it's going to cause some big budgeting problems too, because the
00:07:17 the provinces budgeted that for it to be at $2.20 gigajoule. And right now it's five cents. So
00:07:25 not very good at all. We've got a strange story about an Indiana guy. I don't know if Nico can pull
00:07:31 his face up on the screen, but it's a face that only a mother could love. He strangled an 11 month old baby.
00:07:38 And then when he was in prison, he decided he would be much more comfortable in a in a women's prison. 0.98
00:07:44 So he's applied for a sex change operation. And the judge down there has ruled the taxpayers money
00:07:50 will be used to pay for it, which has sparked outrage in Indiana, as you might expect. Some drama in
00:07:57 Saskatchewan yesterday with a fugitive armed robbery suspect was spotted at a on a First Nations base there
00:08:05 and police big police chase ended up with shots fired and his vehicle driving into a field and
00:08:13 and that's where he died despite the the aid of paramedics. The Saskatchewan Court of Appeal has
00:08:20 finished listening to the 11 interveners on the the what's it called the Parents Bill of Rights.
00:08:28 That's sort of making sure parents are informed whenever their child wants to change gender. So
00:08:34 they've heard arguments on both sides and have reserved judgment on that. And you'll remember
00:08:38 Thomas Lukasik, a name from your past, Corey, a former Tory cabinet minister who managed to blow
00:08:44 $20,000 on a cell phone bill when he was on holiday in Europe. He's been doing nothing but lambaste the
00:08:51 UCP for the last couple of years and they finally had enough and they announced they were ripping up his
00:08:56 UCP membership. So our Jonathan Bradley's got a story on that. So lots more stuff up there, Corey,
00:09:04 but I'll leave it for the viewers to take a look themselves. Right on. Well, yeah, Fabio is no
00:09:10 longer a member of the UCP. Maybe he'll finally formally join the NDP where he probably belongs
00:09:15 anyhow. Well, certainly that's what he sounds like the last couple of years. I'm sure I'm sure Mr.
00:09:20 Nenshi would be happy to take him. I don't know if the room could fit both of their egos,
00:09:23 it's going to be interesting to see them try. Indeed. All right. Thanks, Dave. I'll see you
00:09:28 after the show as we whip off up to Edmonton there. Sounds good. Right on. So this one,
00:09:33 I like to remind everybody the reason we got Dave working and hustling in the newsroom and
00:09:37 Jonathan Bradley writing those stories and Sean Polzer out at the press conferences
00:09:41 is because you guys have subscribed. So this is where I got to nag you and remind you to get on
00:09:44 there, westernstandard.news slash subscription. We don't take tax dollars, which means we can report
00:09:51 things as we see them. We don't have to suck up to the liberal government like CTV did by doctoring
00:09:57 clips of the leader of the opposition or things like that. We answer to you guys, but we do need
00:10:03 you guys to step up and subscribe. That's how we can do it. You know, it's just like a newspaper
00:10:07 subscription. You get past that paywall, $10 a month, $100 for a year. It's a good deal, guys.
00:10:12 Get on there, westernstandard.news slash subscription. Take one out. And if you've already subscribed,
00:10:16 thank you. We really, really do appreciate it. We do. Great. You know, some of this stuff,
00:10:21 this, this parents bill of rights and this stuff that's going on, we're seeing that in Alberta,
00:10:26 we're seeing the discussions. I mean, because the crazed trans activists, and they are, 1.00
00:10:31 they're crazed. Maybe they just keep pushing the limit and pushing the limit. I mean, I'm 0.99
00:10:35 libertarian minded. I have no issues. If you're a grown person, you can do whatever the heck you
00:10:39 please with yourself. I don't care. It's your business. If everybody's consenting,
00:10:44 do what you like. I'm more than happy for you. But they got to go for the kids. They can't leave
00:10:49 the kids alone. The lunacy, the ridiculousness. A story that Dave didn't mention that's on the 0.99
00:10:53 Western Standard site too is in Saskatchewan, some, some brochure on lesbian BDSM sex techniques, 0.74
00:11:00 including fisting. If you really want to make yourself feel pale, you can Google that. You don't 0.73
00:11:05 need to. It's stuff that kids don't need brought into their schools, but these activists keep pushing
00:11:09 it in there. And parents have the right to know what's being presented to their children.
00:11:15 Even if you don't agree with what the parents views are, public schools have to answer to the
00:11:20 parents. It can't be the other way around. Yet these activists keep trying to wedge themselves in.
00:11:25 They keep trying to get in the way and they're telling parents they don't have the right to know
00:11:29 what their kid is up to at the school. I'm sorry, that's wrong. And Saskatchewan has put in this
00:11:34 parents bill of rights to say, we're going to make sure that's protected. And it looks, chances are,
00:11:39 if the idiot judges, and I'm afraid a lot of them are fools, will say that this is unconstitutional, 1.00
00:11:44 that's for, you know, it violates the charter, that's fine. You know, apparently it's a charter 1.00
00:11:47 right for children to hide things from their parents and have the schools stand between the
00:11:51 parents and their children. They'll use the notwithstanding clause. So, I mean, the one
00:11:55 thing we'll give credit to is Pierre is giving out of the notwithstanding clause to see past these
00:12:00 things. The government's job is not to raise our children. It's not to get between us and our 0.89
00:12:05 children. It's ironic and sad and funny when you see these same activists, these left activists,
00:12:11 and so on, going on about residential schools. Well, that's a prime example of what happens when
00:12:15 the government takes over the raising of children versus the parents. That's what happens when the
00:12:19 government says the parents don't have the right to say where their children should be educated,
00:12:23 how they should be educated, or even know what's going on in the school. Think about that. Did you
00:12:29 guys learn anything from that then? I mean, we've got a lot of hyperbole and untruths and things that
00:12:34 we can cover about what happened at the residential schools, but there was a lot of terrible things
00:12:38 happened at them. I mean, it was certainly an attempt to take a culture and jam it into a modern 0.98
00:12:43 perspective that they weren't ready for, and it did mess up a whole lot of people and we're still
00:12:48 dealing with the fallout from it today. Part of that was because the government felt it was in the place
00:12:54 to step in between the parents and their children. And how did that work out? Yet now,
00:12:59 we're doing the same bloody thing. We're saying parents actually don't even have a legal right to
00:13:04 know what their kids are up to in the schools. No, no guys, the parents have every right. In fact,
00:13:12 it's essential that the parents know what's going on in there. The other thing that my view that this
00:13:16 leads to then is a better case for a voucher system for breaking up the school's school choice. Let
00:13:22 parents choose what they want. If you want your kids to go to a woke school, fine. Again, 1.00
00:13:26 that's your choice as a parent. But if you don't want any of that trash, it should be your choice 0.99
00:13:30 as a parent to send your child to a school that doesn't deal with that. We just need a base core 0.89
00:13:35 curriculum, of course, to prepare them for a career and future and life. And after that,
00:13:41 we should have school choice so parents can choose where their kids go to so they can get what they need
00:13:46 without embracing the rest of the trash that gets shoved in together with it. I find it funny when you
00:13:51 listen to teachers when they fight against standardized testing because they say every
00:13:54 child learns differently. You can't standardize test because it's not fair because this child
00:13:58 responds this way and that child responds that way. I agree. But then shouldn't we have all
00:14:02 different kinds of schools then to address the different needs of all those kids? Oh, no, no, no,
00:14:06 no, no. When it comes to that, then they all have to be standardized schools that are controlled
00:14:09 by the school boards and, of course, wagged by the tail of the teachers' unions. Well, you can't have it
00:14:17 both ways there, guys. We either address the unique needs of different children in education
00:14:22 or we don't. But the hypocrisy never seems to end when it comes from some of those unions and such.
00:14:29 All right. But either way, I'm going to be actually saying something nice about it. Some of the union
00:14:32 folks who I'm usually beating on, which is our federal civil servant, because as I said, I'd like
00:14:36 to see it reduced. I'd like to see it cut down, like streamlined. But I don't feel that they should be
00:14:41 abused. They're not having their payroll properly managed. They have that right. And it has not been done
00:14:46 well since 2016. So we're going to bring my guest, David Sabine. He's an author. He wrote a book on
00:14:52 the Phoenix payroll system called Phoenix. And he's going to talk to us about it today. So thanks for
00:14:56 joining me today, Mr. David. Hello, Corey. Thanks for having me. So, you know, I guess just to give
00:15:05 some background, people have heard of the Phoenix system. I read most of the book. I didn't get all
00:15:09 the way through it quite yet. But part of it was, I mean, it wasn't even originally called the Phoenix
00:15:13 system. But there was a big change that was happening kind of a little bit before Stephen
00:15:17 Harper. And then it came in during Stephen Harper's time. This is one I don't even want to point at
00:15:21 specific parties, because it's had multiple parties in charge. And this disaster has kept rolling along.
00:15:27 Give a bit of background, though, what happened? How did we get into this mess?
00:15:31 It's a great question. We should talk about how the mess began. And then let's talk about when it blew up.
00:15:37 And so let me explain first the word Phoenix. The mythical Phoenix is reborn from its ashes. So we
00:15:43 need to ask from which ashes was this Phoenix project supposed to rise? And here's a quick history.
00:15:50 A core operation of our federal governments to pay the public servants. And you would think that
00:15:55 having to issue paychecks every two weeks that they would be good at it by now. They're not. And so by
00:16:01 Mulroney's term in office, it was apparent that our government had cobbled together a bunch of IT
00:16:05 systems. It was difficult to maintain, difficult to keep up to date. And so in the last weeks of his
00:16:11 term, and when power was transitioning over to Kim Campbell, his government signed a $45 million
00:16:17 contract with Accenture. The goal of that contract was to modernize the pension systems and the pay
00:16:23 systems of the federal government. Now, of course, we know Kim Campbell didn't win that election.
00:16:27 John Kretchen won that election. And immediately he terminated the contract. And so nothing but ashes,
00:16:35 you know, Accenture took us to court or took the federal government to court, there was a settlement,
00:16:39 the Canadian public doesn't know the details of that settlement. But litigation took a decade.
00:16:45 And so 10 years later, now we're talking 2004, five, six, the senior bureaucrats had renewed interest
00:16:51 in the project, they estimated it would cost about $6 million. But the scope of it continued to increase.
00:16:57 Stephen Harper's government then was persuaded to spend about 300 million
00:17:01 to replace the payroll systems and to centralize the payroll staff into one single office. That's how
00:17:07 the mess began. So, I mean, kind of, we'll cover some more of the details in between. But fast
00:17:13 forward to today, some of the estimates on what this has cost is getting into $4 billion. I mean,
00:17:18 when you started at $6 million, you got up to a few hundred million, and now we're up to $4 billion.
00:17:22 And that's just the taxpayers cost. And then hundreds of 1000s of payments over the years
00:17:28 have been messed up. Some people have been overpaid, some have been underpaid, some of them
00:17:33 paid at all, that that's a cost that we can't even begin to measure. Is the bleeding stemming at all yet?
00:17:41 Not at all. And so let's go back to 2016 for a minute. Justin Trudeau's government green lighted the
00:17:47 launch of the project. Phoenix had been delayed a number of times under Stephen Harper's government.
00:17:54 Everyone knew it wasn't ready. And no one was ready to launch it. Justin Trudeau was elected and MP
00:18:01 Judy Foote was given this file. And then her and her senior advisors agreed to launch the system in March
00:18:08 9 of 2016. So the system at that time was used to calculate the paychecks of about 120,000 of the
00:18:18 roughly 200,000 public servants at the time. 40,000 of those paychecks in that first pay run were
00:18:26 incorrect. And so your question is, are we still hemorrhaging money? And yes, we are. We're throwing
00:18:32 money at this ever since the error rate today. The backlog of corrections that need to be made today
00:18:39 is as large as it was in 2016. So as of today, 408,000 payroll errors await resolution. And every
00:18:47 two weeks, there are more errors, they fix some, there are more errors, they fix some,
00:18:52 there are more errors. It's been a disaster ever since 2016. Yeah, and you know, we saw it was
00:18:57 frustrating to read it. For people familiar with Yes Minister, you know, it's an English sitcom,
00:19:02 about, you know, a minister getting snowed by his bureaucrats who were talking to him,
00:19:07 you know, when things would fail, and so on, and they would double speak. But some of those
00:19:10 committee meetings, when they would talk to some of the, you know, asking about this,
00:19:14 they just couldn't get any straight answers out of the senior bureaucrats on it. And I believe it was
00:19:19 Foote who said at one point that she called it a success in the first little bit of a run,
00:19:23 how could you have such a massive error rate and call it a success? Yeah, it's amazing the double
00:19:28 thing that you can read into the committee minutes. So I wrote the book, your question
00:19:34 earlier was about costs, you know, I wrote the book just over a year ago, I calculated that the
00:19:39 taxpayer had already spent 4.2 billion, and I should qualify that number. And I actually think
00:19:44 journalists should really dig in and debate these numbers more deliberately. So first,
00:19:50 most journalists go with the government's own estimates, 3.2 or 3.5 billion. But those numbers
00:19:57 include the direct costs and the large settlement that was paid out to the to the union members,
00:20:03 but they exclude the costs associated with replacing the Phoenix system. And there's a huge number of
00:20:10 projects underway in that regard. And they exclude. And this is where my unique expertise was held
00:20:20 full. I looked at the full list of ongoing large IT projects, and I found numerous integration
00:20:25 projects. And so for example, $33 million was spent to integrate the systems at CBSA, CRA,
00:20:32 Parks Canada, RCMP. This money is spent only because Phoenix exists, and only because its capabilities
00:20:40 are so incompatible with the needs of those departments. And so if we include all of those
00:20:45 integration projects, as of a year ago, I calculated $4.2 billion had gone through this inferno.
00:20:52 Yeah, and I mean, it's, it sounds like there's work being done. You know, I started looking and
00:20:57 digging because we do hear about it pure periodically erupts, but it never seems to get solved.
00:21:02 They're going to replace it with something called day force, or they're they're easing into that system.
00:21:07 Now, do you think they're going to be more careful? It sounds like they're going to phase it in rather
00:21:11 than try it because I mean, something that large, you can't just flick a switch and change systems,
00:21:14 you do have to try to integrate it. But at the same time, they're trying to fix 500,000 other errors
00:21:20 that they still have built up. Yeah, good point. I mean, so they are taking a more incremental
00:21:25 approach, I think, with this new initiative. However, Corey, you know, where there's smoke,
00:21:32 there's fire. Day Force, it used to be called Ceridian. They won the contract to replace Phoenix. And
00:21:39 there's virtually nothing known about their involvement or McKinsey's. So we can see those
00:21:44 two companies show up in some committee minutes. But there, you go to the website, you find for
00:21:50 projects or RFPs or line items in the annual budget. And there's very little to discover there. I think
00:21:57 there are many questions. For example, why did Navdeep Bains step down? Why did Navdeep Bains chief of
00:22:05 staff suddenly become an executive at Day Force? And why did the CEO of Day Force tell reporters
00:22:14 after the 2021 election, he told reporters that Justin Trudeau's cabinet had requested that Day Force
00:22:21 not publicize the fact that they had won the contract until after the election?
00:22:27 It appears Justin Trudeau or one of his cabinet members specifically asked to keep that a secret
00:22:36 during the campaign until after the election. Why was that? I think there's a lot of questions
00:22:40 to be asked about their involvement and what's going on. There always are. And you know,
00:22:44 people always have to be careful, but when you get a government contract with that large amount of
00:22:48 money and their history of bad controls on it, you know the opportunists are going to come out of
00:22:53 the woodworks. I mean, it just happens. It's the way it goes. So, I mean, whether Day Force is right
00:22:59 or wrong, it's not unprecedented for an organization to have a payroll this large in modern times. I
00:23:05 mean, Canada, we've got a workforce of about 420,000, which is really huge for civil service, but still
00:23:12 there are a lot of companies and governments and others who have payrolls as large or larger than
00:23:17 this. And are they operating more successfully than us? Well, if I could take a moment here,
00:23:24 like we need to do this differently. Issuing paychecks every two weeks to public servants is
00:23:30 a core operation of the government, as you said. And we're talking about basic math and well-known
00:23:35 accounting techniques. Like this kind of software is not magic. The business rules, while complicated,
00:23:42 and there are 80 plus collective bargaining agreements, and that certainly makes things more difficult.
00:23:47 But the requirements are known and programmable. So, I believe, and so your question is, are others
00:23:53 doing this better than the federal government of Canada? Well, some are. Some governments also have
00:23:57 their own boondoggles. But I think it comes down to a simple question between lesser evils. The government
00:24:03 could do this in-house. Certainly, the taxpayer employs an army of IT professionals and software
00:24:09 developers. And they could build a purpose-built tool to operate this core operation of the government.
00:24:18 Or the government could continue to outsource this stuff to giant multinationals who supposedly have
00:24:24 the expertise, but they continue to fail, and they repeatedly fail to deliver. So, both of these options
00:24:32 are ripe for waste and corruption. But we need to think back to 2005 and six and seven. What were the conditions
00:24:40 of that time before Stephen Harper was persuaded to sign the approval of that first $300 million?
00:24:47 Let's think back to that time. Many bureaucrats and MPs complained about the existing payroll
00:24:52 systems. They were 40 years old. They were hard to maintain. And I don't doubt that. But let's
00:24:57 remember that those systems were successfully conducting paychecks every two weeks for 190,000
00:25:03 employees. The error rate was very, very low, much lower than today's error rate with Phoenix. But the
00:25:09 MPs latched on to this Phoenix myth. You know, they were absolutely taken on faith and with no empirical
00:25:16 evidence that the old systems just needed to be replaced and that a commercial system, you know,
00:25:23 purchased from some multinational company was the way to replace them. Now, both of those ideas were
00:25:29 the result of, I think, just a bandwagon effect. To your question, lots of other jurisdictions,
00:25:35 they've tried the same. They've bought systems off the shelf. They call them COTS products or commercial
00:25:41 off-the-shelf products. And their mileage may vary, you might say. But our government is absolutely
00:25:49 addicted to these giant IT replacement projects. Is the taxpayer just on the hook every five years to
00:25:55 throw billions of dollars at the cronies of the day to replace these IT systems? I think we need to
00:26:01 start asking these kinds of questions. Absolutely. I mean, yeah, you know, kind of a funny comment out
00:26:06 of Mr. Stanley, but he's probably dead right. He says, I bet the Phoenix employees still receive their
00:26:10 pay on time. Yeah, when you're inside, you can make sure that your check comes through. But, you know,
00:26:17 and I'm kind of bouncing around, but I'll bounce back. I mean, something you mentioned in the book,
00:26:20 and it's interesting, when politics gets mixed into things, that's usually when the trouble comes
00:26:24 about. So one of the things Prime Minister Stephen Harper did in his time was getting rid of the old
00:26:29 boondoggle of the liberal gun registry. And part of that was they bought themselves love and mirror
00:26:33 machine New Brunswick by setting up the administration offices there. So now they had to lay off loads and
00:26:38 loads of civil servants who were running this terribly inept gun registry. Harper thought he could kill two 0.99
00:26:44 birds with one stone and said, Well, we will re employ them with this new payroll system. 0.97
00:26:50 So they took those bureaucrats and just kind of shuffled them into something they weren't necessarily
00:26:53 qualified to embrace. But it was a way to patch a hole and try and maintain a seat. It's, you know,
00:27:00 this is just typical of governments, unfortunately. Well, I think any other Prime Minister might have
00:27:06 made the same calculation Stephen Harper did.
00:27:08 Stephen Harper said to just if the goal was to centralize this operation into one office,
00:27:13 there were just a few offices across the country that were suitable for this with available staff.
00:27:18 So I don't begrudge his decision on that point. But it also is interesting to note that it takes about
00:27:24 two years for the payroll staff to be properly trained so that they can conduct this work. Why does it
00:27:31 take two years? Well, part of that is because the regulations are so complex, there are 80 and more
00:27:41 collective bargaining agreements. The systems are difficult to use. And then they burn out. So of all
00:27:49 the people that start the process to learn how to become a payroll advisor in our government, only about
00:27:54 40% of them continue the training. Two years later, 60% of them have quit and left. And so that speaks to the
00:28:01 difficulty of the job, but also the, you know, the nightmare that is this, this work environment.
00:28:07 Well, yeah, and plus just the competency. I mean, if you have a high turnover, then you're not going
00:28:11 to have offices with long term experienced people to apply themselves to issues. But I guess if you're
00:28:17 applying yourself, and you can't fix anything, that that's how you end up burnt out.
00:28:21 What's interesting, if I could add, Corey, to that point, the solutions, the best, so if we look at
00:28:28 how the government has burned through the errors that have occurred, and we look at how have they
00:28:35 done that most effectively, it's usually that a small group of experienced people have come together,
00:28:39 they work together as a pod, and they burn through a backlog of errors, and they fix them.
00:28:45 The solution here is people, not some belief in some magical system that we can buy from a multinational
00:28:53 corporation. Well, there's not going to be any quick magic bullet, that's for sure. And I mean,
00:28:59 that's part of why you've written a book on it, the time has run out quickly, because it's such a
00:29:03 big issue here. But I'm certain you're going to continue to watch this and be speaking on it. So
00:29:08 where can people find your book? And where can they find you to keep up on what's going on as
00:29:12 hopefully this government, or the next government gets on to solving this issue, so they can move on to
00:29:17 solving with many others. Thanks, Corey, for that. They can find me at davidsabine.ca,
00:29:25 and davidsabine.ca slash phoenix, that'll take you right to a page where you can look at the book,
00:29:29 you can buy it at Amazon on paperback or Kindle version, or you can buy it at LeanPub as well.
00:29:37 Find me on LinkedIn, I'm active there. And on X, I'd be happy to connect with people.
00:29:41 Great. Well, thank you for taking the time to join us today and for watching this issue and digging into it.
00:29:47 Like I said, you know, some of these things seem kind of dry and they're bookkeeping sort of things
00:29:51 and stuff like that. But boy, it's not so dry and unimportant when you're the one whose check hasn't
00:29:57 shown up on time or when you're working in a department that's spinning its wheels and burning
00:30:03 you out. It's true. You know, some people have lost their savings, they've lost their homes.
00:30:08 It's been a disaster all around. Really, I appreciate that you brought me on to talk about it.
00:30:12 Great. Well, we'll keep bringing it up and can't let them forget it. And hopefully,
00:30:16 as I said, hopefully that problem gets solved because there's many others for them to work
00:30:20 on. So perhaps we'll talk again soon and we'll be talking about a solution at that time.
00:30:23 Thank you, Corey.
00:30:25 Great. Thanks, David. So again, yes, David Sabine, you can look him up. As he said,
00:30:28 he's on LinkedIn and on X out there. And he's got that book, Phoenix. If you look it up,
00:30:34 it's on Amazon and other spots like that. Yeah, just massive, massive bureaucracy. I mean,
00:30:41 I mean, again, you know, bureaucracy screw up a lot of things. That's hardly new. This one's one
00:30:46 of the ones when it takes a lot. As I said, I love ripping into bureaucrats and civil servants. But
00:30:50 when you get me feeling sympathetic for civil servants, you know, it's got to be pretty bad.
00:30:57 Paradox is saying, I find myself struggling to be sympathetic with the unionized, striking
00:31:00 bureaucracy that keeps supporting liberals. Yeah, fair enough. But either way, if we're going to run
00:31:05 a government, if you're going to hire people, if you're going to have them on a payroll, you have
00:31:08 to pay them. You have to pay them properly and on time. That's just morality. That's just doing the
00:31:14 right thing. And it's also not doing us any favors. As you said, with as upset and crabby and low
00:31:20 production as civil servants are, well, this is one of the areas that contributes to it,
00:31:24 contributes to it, isn't it? You know, when your morale is in the toilet, because you haven't been
00:31:28 paid consistently, you're not going to perform really well, you're not going to work really hard.
00:31:34 You're not going to, you know, go out of your way to do anything better with it. All right,
00:31:40 so let's look at that House of Commons, that gong show that we've got of the people who are running
00:31:44 our country, that minority thing. The confidence vote as of this time for folks who aren't watching it 1.00
00:31:50 live hasn't been held yet, I believe. But, you know, it's going to fail. I mean, I'll make that
00:31:55 prediction right now. I mean, if the government falls somehow, if the bloc changed its mind or
00:32:00 something, you know, I'll report on that and talk about it on the next show. But as far as things look
00:32:06 right now, Pierre Polyev, you know, is putting the motion forward, and it's going to fail. But it's
00:32:13 showing the opportunism and the weakness of the other parties that are out there. The Bloc Quebec law
00:32:19 has ramped up the demands even more to keep holding the government in power. They want
00:32:24 more legislation to entrench the supply management system, which is the dairy system, which is Soviet
00:32:28 style, which rips off Canada all the time. You wonder about your high dairy and chicken costs? 0.99
00:32:33 That's where it's at. And he wants that deeper entrenched. He also wants some OAS things increased,
00:32:38 which again, which would benefit Quebec. The only thing I'll give to the Bloc Quebecois is they're honest.
00:32:42 You know, they really are. They're the most honest party out there. Party Quebecois, Bloc Quebecois,
00:32:47 all the way back to René Lévesque. They say, hey, we're here for Quebec, and only Quebec,
00:32:53 and we don't really care about the rest of the country. They don't dislike the rest of Canada.
00:32:57 I met with Bloc members back when I led the Alberta Independence Party. They don't dislike us.
00:33:01 They're indifferent to us. They don't care. They're there for Quebec, and they make no bones about it.
00:33:07 So when they find now that Jagmeet Singh has played his little game, and it's a little game,
00:33:12 saying, I'm no longer, I'm ripping up my agreement with Justin Trudeau. We're not going to hold them
00:33:16 up any longer. Even though Singh already came around and said, well, actually, we will keep
00:33:20 holding him up because we're a bunch of losers. With no money in the bank, we can't run an election. 0.96
00:33:26 The Bloc stepped up and said, well, we can make sure you stay in power, Justin. We can keep you safe.
00:33:31 We just want this and this and this. You think they're going to stop at that? No.
00:33:35 Every time a confidence vote comes, the Bloc is going to lay out their demands
00:33:40 for getting Trudeau through it. And they're going to keep doing it because as long as they're getting
00:33:44 their demands, why would they stop, right? Unfortunately, the rest of us get to pay that
00:33:49 price for a wildly incompetent, wildly unpopular prime minister clinging to power in this country.
00:33:57 The system is broken. It really is. And again, that's a whole separate show as to what I feel
00:34:04 we need to do about it. I wrote a book on that if you want to look up my authorship. But in the time
00:34:09 we're stuck with now, what is Justin Trudeau doing in this time of crisis? What is he doing when his
00:34:14 government is sitting there teetering on the brink of falling, madly unpopular? Well, he's down doing
00:34:20 TV shows in the United States. Yes, he's sitting with Colbert and giggling and
00:34:24 playing footsie and playing celebrity. Yeah, he's not doing him any favors up here. We've got some
00:34:31 issues to deal with, Justin. But no, he runs away. He hides. That's what he does. He's a coward.
00:34:37 He is not a leader. He's there because of his name. And he's now there just because we haven't 1.00
00:34:44 the mechanism or the ability to kick him out yet. We can't get rid of him. We can't get an election
00:34:51 brought forth yet. The time will come eventually. It'll be interesting.
00:34:56 It shows, though, how bereft of ideas this government is, how exhausted they are of any...
00:35:04 I mean, what we're seeing now is deeper and deeper boondoggles. We're seeing more and more
00:35:09 spending initiatives. We're seeing a lot of them feathering their nests. They know they're going
00:35:13 down. We're seeing the appointments to the Senate. We're seeing some big contracts that are going to
00:35:17 be laid out. This is the tail end of what's going to happen. But Trudeau, if they really thought they
00:35:24 had a hope of winning, of turning it around, they got about a year to do it. They haven't changed
00:35:31 anything. They haven't changed their lines. They haven't brought in any really significantly new
00:35:35 policies. They haven't said they're going to do anything differently. When you're down into record low
00:35:41 support territory, you won't even shuffle your cabinet. You are a broken government. So no
00:35:47 wonder he runs away and hides to try and, you know, avoid the problem, leaves the rest of the
00:35:52 government to have to deal with it. Similar to a couple of years ago, we're coming up on
00:35:58 the Kamloops Residential School Hoax Day. I think they call it the Truth and Reconciliation Day. It's the
00:36:05 the holiday that Justin Trudeau created after the hoax of the Kamloops Residential School body thing
00:36:11 broke. And I'm going to keep calling it a hoax. I know some people chafe every time I say that,
00:36:14 but you know what? I'm getting sick of it. I'm getting really, really, really sick of it. When
00:36:18 all the evidence is pointing to the fact that there wasn't a single bloody body there. We turned the
00:36:22 country upside down. A hundred churches got burned and vandalized. Billions were spent. Millions were
00:36:27 given to these reserves to find these murdered children. And it turns out there weren't any.
00:36:31 We kept the flag at half-mast for six months. We didn't even do that after the wars.
00:36:40 And it didn't happen. There weren't any bodies. And yes, as Paradoxie points out, calls it Surf and
00:36:46 Recreation Day because what? It shows how tone deaf, how shallow, how stupid Justin Trudeau is. If 1.00
00:36:52 you're going to do a political thing like create a holiday, the first thing you would be expected to
00:36:58 do is be cutting your ribbon, giving a speech over at one of these things. So what happened
00:37:02 on the first holiday? Where was Justin at? He was surfing. He went surfing. Yeah. So their
00:37:09 term for it is Truth and Reconciliation Day. There's where I get a lot. This is where I start
00:37:13 getting upset and I get sick of things because you can't have reconciliation without the truth.
00:37:18 And they don't want the truth. The truth is we need to get a shovel in at Kamloops. It's been years now,
00:37:24 over three years. A shovel is supposedly 200 murdered children are buried there and dig one up.
00:37:34 We need to try and find the killers. We need to try and find what happened. But we can't,
00:37:38 of course, because there's nobody there. It's idiocy. It's wrong. And it's ripping the nation apart. 1.00
00:37:44 It's entrenching more of a sense of victimhood amongst the First Nations people who are already 0.99
00:37:48 in a socioeconomic disaster on the reserves and often off reserve when they come off there. 0.98
00:37:55 And when we continue with this divisive crap, it makes it worse. It makes more of that us, 0.98
00:38:01 them mentality. And it just entrenches the mess that they're in and the mess that we're all stuck
00:38:08 dealing with too. So this is the government we have right now. We need somebody else in there,
00:38:14 but we just can't get the chance. And what do we got also with what Trudeau has been doing? We saw
00:38:18 some great evidence. And Israel will pat ourselves on the back again on being independent media, 0.61
00:38:23 because as I said earlier, we only answer to you. You do dance with the one that brung you. That's 0.74
00:38:27 life, right? When someone's paying your bills, you tend to lean towards who's paying your bills.
00:38:32 In our case, it's the subscribers, which is great. We serve you. So what happens with media outlets when
00:38:38 they get subsidized by the government? Who do they suddenly answer to?
00:38:41 Who are they suddenly beholden to? CTV showed it in spades the other day,
00:38:48 when they actually, it's unbelievable. They took, I mean, media bias is nothing new. That's been
00:38:54 happening since the first Gutenberg press put out a sheet to give to people news. There was bias there.
00:39:01 That's fine. But to the degree of CTV now taking government subsidies, whining for more government
00:39:08 subsidies. And, uh, they took a clip of Pierre Polyev and actually hacked it into different
00:39:14 pieces and then reassembled it. So he was saying something completely different than what he was
00:39:18 saying. They really did that. And now, yeah, Polyev rightly furious. He was, they basically made it
00:39:27 look as if Polyev was trying to pull the government down on the confidence vote so that they could get
00:39:32 rid of the dental plan. That's what they did. It's actually what they did. And CTV put out this
00:39:37 apology when they were caught on it and said, Oh, it was a mistake. We made an error. You don't
00:39:42 accidentally take a video and splice it into a few chunks and reassemble it to make a completely
00:39:47 different message by mistake. Oh, I dropped the disc on the floor and it came back differently. No,
00:39:52 it doesn't work that way. You morons. You put out pure falsehood and yeah. So Polyev will not 1.00
00:40:02 no conservative party members. Now we'll give any interviews or time or clips to the CTV until they
00:40:08 apologize for purposely doing it. You see, they apologize for a mistake, but that's a load of BS.
00:40:12 It wasn't a mistake. It clearly wasn't a mistake. Some heads should roll. That's what you need to see.
00:40:17 You need to see these producers in this department went way over the line. We are sorry for that.
00:40:22 We've fired them and we've put these mechanisms in place to make sure that doesn't happen again.
00:40:25 But no, they said, Oh, it was an error. Well then fine. Screw you. We won't give you any more time.
00:40:31 Why is CTV taking such a beating like this? Well, it's because they have to keep the liberals happy
00:40:36 because they're subsidized like the newspapers. Like this is what happens when government runs
00:40:44 the media. They don't have to directly run. It doesn't have to be directly Pravda style like the CBC.
00:40:50 They can indirectly do it through subsidies because again, when they control who does or doesn't get
00:40:56 these subsidies, then the outlet is going to dance to their tune. And that's exactly what CTV is doing
00:41:03 is dancing to the tune of Trudeau's liberals. Speaking of other subsidies, why not, right?
00:41:12 The electric vehicle binge, the lunacy, the mad rush. I mean, God, we've been hearing about how
00:41:19 everybody's going to switch to electric vehicles for what, 15 years now? And what's the general use of
00:41:24 them on the streets still? Five percent? Six? We aren't massively embracing these things yet. Maybe
00:41:30 we never will. Maybe we will. I don't know. But leave the bloody market alone because you can't
00:41:36 force it. That's what's happening with these stupid electric buses that are failing all over. 1.00
00:41:40 And then with the massive subsidies being given out for electric cars and battery plants. So that's 0.99
00:41:46 what Trudeau put out, 50 billion and more to these battery plants out in Ontario. Meanwhile,
00:41:51 Ford is backing off on their electric vehicles. I think Audi's backing off. All the private
00:41:55 manufacturers saying, we're getting out of this for now. We're not totally getting out,
00:41:58 but we're backing off because people aren't buying the damn things. Well now, Northvolt, 0.97
00:42:03 a Swedish battery maker. Yeah. This is one of the ones that the Trudeau government's really been,
00:42:09 you know, hand in hand with and saying, you know, this is what we're subsidizing our battery plants
00:42:14 with and everything else. Well, what have they done over in Sweden? Oh, they've cut 1600 jobs in their
00:42:19 plants. Why? Because nobody wants the freaking batteries. We're making batteries for vehicles
00:42:24 that nobody wants. But where are we going? We're screwed. He's throwing that money. But where's
00:42:32 the money going? You see, where's the money going? We're not building these plants in
00:42:36 Southern Manitoba or Saskatchewan, Alberta. No, no, no, no, no, no, no. Quebec. Quebec. It's always Quebec.
00:42:43 You know, I saw an article saying recently that separatism is rising. It's ugly head in Quebec
00:42:50 again. It's getting big. It was never gone, guys. It was never gone. If you spoke to some 0.67
00:42:53 independence-minded Quebec people before, you realize that they are serious about it. They
00:42:57 really want to go. If people say, well, they're going to take an economic hit if they go. Yeah,
00:43:01 I know. They know that too. They don't care. They just want their French state, even if it costs them
00:43:07 more money. That's what some Albertans have difficulty recognizing sometimes. Why would they pause?
00:43:12 They're threatening. They're not real about it. It would cost them money. No, they don't get it.
00:43:15 They don't care about the cost. I mean, they'll take the money whenever the government's throwing
00:43:19 it at them, of course. But they don't care if it's going to cost them to get out. So it is
00:43:23 raising its head. It's growing again. They're moving towards another referendum. The bloc might be back
00:43:28 in power in Quebec. But you know what? Good. Good. We've got to be different this time. When they voted to
00:43:35 stay by only 1% back in the 90s, when they voted that close, that was after a giant campaign from
00:43:43 the rest of Canada saying, we love you, Quebec. Please stay Quebec. Please, please, please stay 1.00
00:43:47 Quebec. You're our friends. You're our brothers. You're our cousins. Stay with Canada. We don't want
00:43:52 you to go. Next referendum, let's try a different tactic. Don't let the door hit your ass on the way
00:43:59 out. We should be inviting them to go. Go ahead. Leave. Please save Canada by leaving Canada because 0.99
00:44:07 that's the truth of it. Our constitution is supposed to be a living document. It's a dead one.
00:44:12 It's obsolete. It doesn't serve the regions. It doesn't reflect the needs and growth of the country.
00:44:17 And we can't change it. We tried and failed with the Charlottetown Accord. We tried and failed
00:44:22 with Meech Lake. We can't even revise the constitution in relatively minor ways. So the
00:44:28 only way we're going to change that document, that agreement, it's an engine that's broken. We got to
00:44:33 tear it down and rebuild it. And the only crisis that's going to be big enough to make people ready
00:44:37 to embrace and do that will be a province pulling out of Canada. And as much as I certainly would like
00:44:42 to see Alberta independence movements growing, Quebec is much closer to it than we are.
00:44:46 So let's help them along with it for all of our sake. Go, please go, leave. And then we can rebuild
00:44:54 this from there. We can come up with a new agreement. We can come up with a new union between the bunch
00:44:59 of us or have a bunch of independent states within who knows, but it will be superior to the mess that
00:45:05 we're in right now. Look up, I'll close the show on that. I hate to go off on a negative, but look up GDP
00:45:11 per capita. That's basically the measure of wealth in Canada. And I tell you what guys,
00:45:16 it's going in the toilet. The amount of money per person has been going down for a decade and it's
00:45:21 not going to turn around. We're losing. When you go to the States, you see those houses you can buy
00:45:25 for a fraction of the cost of a Canadian house. And you look at the average income. It's higher
00:45:29 than the income up here and the groceries are cheaper. That's our neighbor. Look at the trend
00:45:34 we're going on. We've got to break this country down and rebuild it and fix it. All right. That's
00:45:40 all my time for today, guys. Again, if you're in Edmonton, check into it. The Toasting Ted event
00:45:45 is on tonight. We're going to be going up there. I'm not sure. I think there's still tickets
00:45:48 available. You can have a look if you just Google Toasting Ted. Be sure to check out the pipeline.
00:45:52 Dave hosted it this week. Yes, we have a strange schedule going on. And check out our other shows.
00:45:57 Share the links with others, guys. Be sure to subscribe to The Standard. And yes, thank you
00:46:02 very much again for joining in today. We will be back again next week at this time. And I'll have a whole
00:46:07 new set of things to gripe about. Have a good one out there, guys. Thanks.
00:46:37 Bye.