Western Standard - October 25, 2025


How Trudeau broke immigration

Topics
Mentioned
Do Calgary's new councillors have it in them to repeal open zoning? MAID violations widespread, ethicist says

Episode Stats


Length

53 minutes

Words per minute

169.38

Word count

9,051

Sentence count

257

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

22

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Tony Kellerman is a columnist with the Globe and Mail and author of Borderline Chaos: How Canada Got Immigration Right and Then Wrong. He joins me to talk about his new book, "How Canada Got It Wrong About Migrants."

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good day i'm derek phildebrandt publisher of the western standard today we're talking
00:00:17 migration mass migration uh we've got a really special guest in today tony keller he is a
00:00:25 columnist with the Globe and Mail.
00:00:27 Don't hold it against them.
00:00:28 He does some really fantastic writing
00:00:31 on the topic and
00:00:32 has
00:00:33 recently published a book
00:00:36 that I've read a good deal
00:00:39 excerpts from. Not the whole thing yet, but
00:00:40 I'm absolutely going to be ordering a copy to get
00:00:43 through the whole thing. He's the author of
00:00:44 Borderline Chaos, How Canada
00:00:46 Got Immigration Right and
00:00:48 Then Wrong.
00:00:50 Tony, thank you very much
00:00:52 for joining us here today.
00:00:54 Derek it's good to be here with you um so we'll dive straight into it as I said I didn't read
00:01:00 uh I have not read the book yet but I'm absolutely I'm gonna order it actually as soon as I'm done
00:01:04 it here I gotta read the whole thing uh we were talking just before we uh started rolling that
00:01:09 uh you know two years ago immigration only started to come onto my radar uh I've cared about it in
00:01:16 the context of Europe and do a lesser extent at the United States for a long time seeing
00:01:19 seeing some maybe some negative things happening in Europe that I have an affinity for and care
00:01:24 about but wasn't affecting me it wasn't in my face daily life um uh but it wasn't in my it only
00:01:32 started to come on my radar in the last two years as a major issue four years ago I probably wouldn't
00:01:35 have rated it in my top 20 as a as an issue I would care about as a Canadian or Albertan voter
00:01:40 uh but today it's it's number one it's it's kind of a litmus test issue of candidates I will vote
00:01:48 for uh i mean i i would i'm only slightly exaggerating to say it's a litmus test about
00:01:53 who i would vote for for school board trustee what are you going to do about immigration um
00:01:59 unlike europe and the united states though canada for at least in our modern history as long as
00:02:06 i've been alive essentially immigration has not been a major issue of polarized political debate
00:02:13 in Canada um but that that has obviously changed uh why do you think that's changed so um to go
00:02:21 back to the the subtitle of my book how Canada got immigration right and then wrong let's you
00:02:27 got to talk about the right before you talk about the wrong and and what Canada got right
00:02:32 and it's quite remarkable is we had this kind of left-right consensus conservatives new democrats
00:02:38 liberals all basically were happy with the same immigration policy um canada actually had a fairly
00:02:45 high rate of immigration but we also had a fairly high level of border control meaning that people
00:02:52 who immigrated to canada were largely chosen by canada canada had a real focus on economic
00:02:58 immigrants and on trying to attract and choose immigrants who had high levels of skills high
00:03:05 high levels of education, meaning they would benefit Canada when they came here and you put
00:03:10 it all together. And so Canada had this kind of magic situation where we actually had much higher
00:03:17 levels of immigration than the United States or most European countries. Yet we had no political
00:03:23 controversy because Canadians, I believe, largely felt that immigration was a choice. It was a
00:03:30 national choice. The level we were getting, the number of people we were getting, the type of
00:03:35 people we were getting was all a national choice and Canadians felt like, hey, this is all under
00:03:39 control. And in fact, because Canada controls its borders and controls its immigration, we're going
00:03:44 to actually have even more immigration than the United States and Europe. And I think the sense
00:03:52 of confidence that Canadians had in the system collapsed in sort of 2021, 2022, 2023. And that's,
00:04:02 you know, my book is about that, the happy past, but it's mostly about the things that then went
00:04:09 wrong over the last few years, um, that really did damage the immigration system and Canadians
00:04:16 lost confidence with good reason because the system had been changed in, in, in, in ways that
00:04:23 were, that were not good for Canada and that caused Canadians to lose confidence. So, uh,
00:04:29 Let's talk about that. I think I can't find anything to disagree with what you're saying. I mean, pretty hardcore conservatives were maybe a little more skeptical of migration. They'd say, well, let's maybe be a bit more picky and choosy.
00:04:43 about i like this country more than that country you know the people from that part of the world
00:04:48 maybe integrate a little bit better than that but on in the broad strokes pretty much was ever
00:04:53 everyone was agreed that yeah this we're choosing economic migrants yeah we had family reunification
00:04:58 stuff like that that were maybe a little more controversial but they never met it onto the
00:05:01 mainstream political debate uh the debates were always on the margins uh on this and that's
00:05:09 changed uh so but broadly speaking most people think like yourself we got migration right for
00:05:15 a pretty extended period of time and then we changed things pretty radically how did and
00:05:21 this began under the trudeau government uh i think in kind of halfway through it uh roughly why what
00:05:29 was it they so radically changed and why did they make such radical changes yeah so so a few
00:05:36 different things happened um and the the trudeau government came into office kind of wanting to
00:05:45 argue i think that that that the conservative party under stephen harper had had somehow been
00:05:54 insufficiently generous and insufficiently open to immigration um and and i think there may have
00:06:01 have been a fair number of voters who actually believed that. The truth, of course, was that
00:06:06 under the Harper government, Canada had basically the same immigration levels that it had had
00:06:11 under the Paul Martin government and under the Chrétien government and going all the way back
00:06:15 to Mulroney. I don't mean to interrupt, but are you referring to, I remember that 2015 election
00:06:21 that was right around the time as the Syrian migration crisis. Germany obviously made some
00:06:27 decisions that had big implications for itself and for the rest of Europe. And I remember that
00:06:32 became a big topic and it kind of got into a bidding war between the Liberals, the NDP and
00:06:36 the Conservatives at that time about who was going to take the most refugees. Is that what you're
00:06:40 talking about in terms of perception that the Conservatives were seen as not open enough to
00:06:45 migration? I think that was a part of the piece. But there are words in the Liberal platform and
00:06:53 And they aren't really backed by any substance, just saying, you know, we're going to be more open.
00:06:58 Stephen Harper has run an immigration policy that's not fully Canadian and generous, and we're going to do more.
00:07:05 And we're never particularly specific about this.
00:07:08 Syrian refugees was part of the piece.
00:07:10 And by the way, the Syrian refugee arrival worked really well.
00:07:13 And to me, the Syrian refugee arrival was actually an example of how the Canadian immigration system works well.
00:07:19 every single one of those people who was brought here as a syrian refugee came from overseas was
00:07:25 vetted before they came um the numbers were not excessive and the truth was what the heart what
00:07:31 the trudeau government did wasn't that much more than what the harper government would have done
00:07:35 it was somewhat more but not that much more but that was actually a fairly small piece of it so
00:07:40 there was this rhetorical push um from the trudeau government to say more immigration would be better
00:07:47 just vaguely without specifics and as they went on they started to get into it a bit more um and
00:07:53 it but it really really exploded during the pandemic so prior to the pandemic there had
00:08:00 already been this run-up in the number of temporary foreign workers and foreign students and and
00:08:09 what people don't understand is that canada basically went from having
00:08:13 one immigration system which is permanent migration you become a permanent resident
00:08:21 and you become a citizen canada that was always the core of the canadian immigration system
00:08:25 we kind of developed a second system which is people who come here as temporary foreign workers
00:08:31 or as students and a large percentage of those students are temporary foreign workers
00:08:36 in in disguise because they're they're going to not particularly high quality programs
00:08:42 and they're working full-time while they're in school the government's finally scaled that back
00:08:46 but they had scaled it up previously so you kind of had these two parallel systems and the temporary
00:08:51 system by 2022 had become bigger than the permanent system and by 2023 it was much bigger than the
00:08:59 permanent system and that's how you went from having a fairly small number of temporary residents
00:09:04 in Canada uh let's say in the year 2000 to today we have three million people in Canada who are
00:09:12 temporary residents all of whom came because they want to become permanent residents but the temporary
00:09:18 resident number is so much bigger than the number of permanent resident places available each year
00:09:26 so there was like some of this stuff is just an incredibly basic failure to count to figure out
00:09:34 that if you're going to let a lot of people through a side door who hope to get in through the front
00:09:39 door you you kind of have to count you kind of have to say hang on a second there have to be
00:09:45 some limits so the government under the trudeau government permanent immigration was doubled
00:09:50 but temporary immigration went up far far more than that it was quadrupled or quintupled um
00:09:58 that's that and and and the second part the temporary immigration part there were no caps
00:10:04 there were no caps on the number of foreign students who could come to canada and there
00:10:08 were no caps on the number of temporary foreign workers that businesses could hire and that is
00:10:14 sort of the problem that we we went from a system that had a sense of control and limits and
00:10:21 targeting high-end immigrants who got educations and skills to an immigration system that became
00:10:27 very tilted towards bringing in people who could work low-end jobs in warehouses in fast food
00:10:35 um delivering uber eats things like that we actually torqued our system towards filling
00:10:43 low-end jobs and the government became convinced um that canada had a massive labor shortage and
00:10:49 a labor shortage at the bottom of the labor market uh which i don't think is at all the case
00:10:54 but the government momentarily became convinced of that by business so it was a strange marriage
00:10:59 of progressive ideas and business lobbying.
00:11:03 So I want to go further on that.
00:11:06 You know, I think you called it, you know, it was kind of a,
00:11:09 I'm paraphrasing you, but it was, you know, it was kind of the
00:11:11 liberals, I think, view corporate and business as conservative.
00:11:16 I don't think that's necessarily true, but it was, you know,
00:11:18 kind of corporate elites wanted this, but at the same time,
00:11:23 it fit with kind of a progressivist ideological need
00:11:26 to be more multicultural, more
00:11:29 multiracial, more multilingual, etc.
00:11:32 And so they
00:11:32 saw no conflict. But I think
00:11:35 the obvious conflict, I don't know why they'd
00:11:36 ever said anything, should have been
00:11:39 labor.
00:11:41 Like, you know, like labor
00:11:42 organizations appeared
00:11:45 maybe I just missed it, but I
00:11:47 watched these guys relatively closely and
00:11:48 I didn't see a peep from labor
00:11:50 organizations. And it cut
00:11:53 the lower
00:11:54 rungs kind of out of the labor
00:11:56 market, replacing them with, you know, I think of, you know, if I go to Tim Hortons or McDonald's
00:12:02 used to be, you know, Canadian, mostly Canadian born kids with their first job, getting a little 0.79
00:12:06 experience. But if I have to pay them a $15 minimum wage for someone to fill that job, I'd probably
00:12:12 rather hire a foreign adult who's like more likely to show up for work on time than a unreliable 1.00
00:12:19 Canadian kid. And that's why I, that's at least why I think we're just not seeing as many Canadians
00:12:24 working these low-end jobs, or Uber Eats, you know, it's not entirely, but mostly, I think,
00:12:31 new migrant labor and kind of cut the bottom out of the labor market, especially when you have, 1.00
00:12:36 you know, fairly high minimum wages. Why was there no pushback from, you know, people or
00:12:44 organizations that are kind of supposed to represent that part of the labor market? I get why
00:12:48 big business wants to suppress wages at the bottom end, because then you end up suppressing
00:12:54 them kind of everywhere else when you suppress them at the bottom end to an extent at least uh
00:12:59 i might save you know 25 cents on my uber eats uh and so i guess there's a you know i'm not competing
00:13:06 for that labor market so there's a benefit for me as someone who's not at the bottom end so i i
00:13:11 benefit maybe a little bit by that uh but people at the lower end don't seem to get any benefit by
00:13:16 this why was there no pushback for those people in the canadian labor market who were displaced
00:13:21 that to me has always been sort of the the fascinating thing that this was a policy
00:13:28 where there was kind of an all stakeholder agreement um you know you have groups like
00:13:37 the century initiative so that would be sort of as you put it big business elites saying hey
00:13:42 canada does need higher immigration we need more numbers and they they had some details on
00:13:48 better immigration but they really focused on more you have all kinds of small businesses it's not
00:13:54 just big business you're all your local businesses are saying we want to be able to hire temporary
00:13:59 foreign workers um one way or another because the guy down the street has been able to do it so we
00:14:05 want to do it so it's not just sort of some people off on a tower in bay street on the 45th floor
00:14:11 it's people right down on main street who are saying look i want this opportunity because the
00:14:15 business down the street, he's getting the opportunity. You've got colleges and universities
00:14:19 lobbying for it, saying, if we can bring in more and more and more foreign students, we can make
00:14:25 some money. And some of them were super responsible about that. And a lot of institutions, lower end
00:14:30 institutions, were not at all responsible. You have a number of provincial governments who are
00:14:35 lobbying the federal government and saying, we want more immigration and we need more temporary 0.98
00:14:41 migration there's a labor shortage and some governments Ontario in particular saying we want
00:14:47 more temporary foreign more students more foreign students lots more foreign students as we think
00:14:52 that's going to help finance our higher education sector and again the students tended to go in
00:14:58 Ontario to the lowest end institutions not the highest end institutions you've got progressive
00:15:03 groups saying immigration is good inherently like it's a value it's not a it's not a practical
00:15:08 matter it's a value and if you're saying more immigration that's good and if you're saying
00:15:11 same or less that's bad the liberals themselves rhetorically kind of adopted that so there's
00:15:16 sort of nobody against it and to me the surprise is that there was not really any pushback from
00:15:23 labor um but there there really wasn't uh and yeah that that is kind of a surprise i i will say
00:15:33 that you made one point that i think is is quite important which is for someone who's upper middle
00:15:39 class like everything in the economy has costs and benefits so for someone who's upper middle class
00:15:44 having or middle class upper middle class certain things become cheaper if you have a lot more
00:15:50 people arriving to do low-end jobs if you're doing a bit of wage suppression at the bottom end of the
00:15:57 market um your burrito is going to be a little cheaper and the delivery of your burrito is going
00:16:03 to be a little cheaper and your ability to order something from amazon and have it delivered
00:16:07 is going to be a little cheaper um so it's it is about choices like there are so there are benefits
00:16:13 to that but what you have to remember is that every person in the canadian economy is you know
00:16:20 they're a taxpayer but they're a user of taxpayer services they're they're providing labor but they
00:16:26 also need benefits. So if you have a whole lot of people at the bottom end of the labor market 0.74
00:16:30 earning very low wages, all those people still have to send their kids to school and they still
00:16:37 have to use social services. They still have to use healthcare services. So if you're bringing 0.99
00:16:42 in a lot of people whose wages and hence whose taxes are going to be much lower, someone else
00:16:49 is going to have to help subsidize those services. So everything's got costs and benefits and there
00:16:54 was just not really a great deal of thought about the costs and there was an enormous focus on look
00:17:00 at the benefits and pretending as if there was nothing on the other side of the ledger so yeah
00:17:07 i know they've they've tampered things back a bit but i i'm not i'm not convinced we'll get into how
00:17:14 we fix this uh you know further in the interview but you know i saw there was an ad uh or a social
00:17:19 media post running as an ad from citizenship and immigration canada uh just uh i saw it just
00:17:26 the other week uh where i forget the exact wording of it but i think i've been fair when they said
00:17:31 like uh canada has free health care have you considered coming to canada to which i thought
00:17:37 that is the most insane advertisement ever like we're saying come to my store so i can give you
00:17:43 something for free uh that that's a one-way transaction uh you know that's why we should
00:17:49 at least in theory limit uh family unification migration because you know grandma and grandpa
00:17:55 coming from from overseas they're not spending their life as taxpayers contributing to the social
00:18:02 contract of things and therefore then able to receive the benefits later in life uh no he's
00:18:09 just saying come here and you know whatever illness you have we're going to take care of it
00:18:13 etc advertising the burden on the canadian taxpayer for it not not the benefit i and that
00:18:21 was very recently after things are supposed to have been tamped down um so you know you could
00:18:26 address that if you like yeah let's talk quickly about that before i go on to yeah so so i don't
00:18:33 want to put um too much weight on that ad because again keep in mind you know government of canada
00:18:37 puts out 5 000 web pages a day this was one that sort of got blown up and highlighted uh i forget
00:18:44 even which ministry it was in just wanted to say hey look here are the advantages of coming to
00:18:48 canada and citizenship and immigration was okay so so for what it's worth they should know yeah
00:18:53 but for what it's worth that is actually one of the benefits of coming to canada so so we should
00:18:58 try to sell the benefits of canada but we should also be thoughtful about sort of choosing who gets
00:19:05 those benefits and listen what I want to say is look my book is a pro-immigration book but it's
00:19:12 also a pro-limits and thoughtful sensible behavior around immigration book so I think people of every
00:19:21 race every nationality every ethnicity every religion should be able to come to Canada should
00:19:25 be able to apply to come to Canada but let's just be thoughtful about who we choose to allow to come
00:19:31 to Canada, which is how the system was working for a generation, and how it sort of stopped
00:19:40 working over the last few years. That to me is the key. We should try to sell Canada really hard
00:19:47 and get the best immigrants possible. And in the past, we had family reunification,
00:19:53 but that was around sort of 20% of the system, and it still is. We had refugees, that's sort of 15%
00:19:59 of the system and it still is and we had economic migrants sort of 60 something percent of the
00:20:04 system but the percentages didn't change that much what really changed was we became much less choosy
00:20:11 on the economic immigration side and we dropped standards enormously so to to kind of uh anticipate
00:20:21 a follow-up question here that's where we gotta go is be smart on who we're choosing on the economic
00:20:28 immigration side so uh i've read i think in excerpts and i've uh watched or listened to
00:20:36 some of the interviews you've already done and uh so in it you know you've said you know they
00:20:41 the liberals did not change uh uh the immigration policy as necessarily a particularly ideological
00:20:49 agenda it was not meant to replace the canadian born population um and i i very much agree that
00:20:58 yeah there was big business pushing for things there was this kind of all stakeholder at least
00:21:02 the stakeholders they'd listen to all stakeholder consensus and also I think a lot of people like
00:21:07 myself were just not paying attention to it because it just hadn't been a major issue here before
00:21:12 but historically in the broad strokes migrants have tended to vote liberal or progressive
00:21:19 there's been you know the the anomaly to that was 2011 federally where the conservatives had 0.83
00:21:26 a major breakthrough with new Canadians. But even then, you know, I think essentially mitigated the
00:21:32 liberal advantage on it, perhaps. But, you know, they didn't necessarily become a strong conservative
00:21:36 cohort, but that was a one-off. Historically speaking, and not just in Canada, but in the
00:21:42 Western democracies broadly, migrants have tended more often than not to vote for more progressivist
00:21:49 parties that are seen as more open to multiculturalism, etc. That happens in Europe,
00:21:55 habits in the states um and at least kind of the the more for it's an abused term but the kind of
00:22:03 the woke progressivist wing of the liberal party saw whiteness or westernness as inherently evil
00:22:10 and guilt-ridden is there really no partisan was there no uh partisan or ideological aspect of this
00:22:21 beyond just kind of the stakeholder consensus to do this because it would be a good in and of itself
00:22:27 to change the demographic makeup of Canada? So I'll say two things on that. One is I don't,
00:22:36 I have no reason to believe that there was any sort of conscious calculation within the Liberal
00:22:44 Party or anybody else to say, aha, we're going to change the demographic makeup of Canada. Again,
00:22:49 other people can try to look into this I have no reason to believe that's that's what was going on
00:22:55 what I will say is that the liberal party did believe and a lot of progressive people believe
00:23:01 that immigration is a is a value and and and and as a result they don't think about immigration
00:23:09 in the way I'm thinking of it I'm thinking of it as as a calculus I'm saying okay look we're going
00:23:15 to have some we're going to have immigration we should have immigration there are all kinds of
00:23:19 positive things about immigration let's try to maximize the positives and let's try to minimize 1.00
00:23:24 the negatives because every every policy choice has positives and negatives so let's just try to
00:23:28 do immigration well rather than doing immigration badly rather than simply saying however much
00:23:32 immigration we have we should have more and once we get to that higher level we should have even 0.97
00:23:36 more because it's up value what i'm saying is it let's try to do this as a rational policy analysis
00:23:42 of benefit to canada and benefit to canadians as opposed to just we we must have higher immigration
00:23:48 um so i i think that's you know that's a that's how i'm coming at this i i one other thing i want
00:23:59 to say is on the issue of how immigrants vote it's complicated um people's votes you know
00:24:08 change over time and one of the things that i've found very interesting you brought up the 2011
00:24:14 election where the Harper government did very well with, um, non-white and immigrant voters
00:24:20 and really was shifting the needle. And you also saw it in the, um, in the most recent federal
00:24:28 election where, uh, in Brampton and some other areas, the GTA analysis suggests that a whole
00:24:34 lot of immigrant and non-white voters, um, shifted to the conservative party. They were upset about
00:24:41 various issues such as crime and they shifted the conservative party so i i think one of the
00:24:47 great things about canada is that the conservative party the liberal party the ndp they all want to
00:24:54 attract immigrant and non-white voters they are no one's running against immigrants no one's or
00:25:01 historically no one has for generations and that's great there's there all the parties have
00:25:08 essentially said if you're a canadian voter we would like you to vote for us we're not targeting
00:25:13 you except we're trying to we're trying to reach you with our message to me that's that's a pretty
00:25:18 good thing because we all have to live together um and you know so i don't subscribe to any theory
00:25:26 of controlling immigration or limiting immigration for sort of racial ethnic or cultural reasons
00:25:33 Canada is already a multicultural, multiracial, multi-ethnic society. The numbers, you know,
00:25:41 Canada has changed a lot in the last generation and we can't turn back the clock on that. We have
00:25:47 to figure out how people of different races and ethnicities and faiths and beliefs can all live
00:25:53 together and all love Canada. And even as we have disagreements about which political party we vote
00:25:59 for and which part we want to have in government. But hopefully those disagreements aren't going to
00:26:03 break down on racial lines. They're going to break down on ideological lines, which is fun.
00:26:10 So I want to go down this path a bit more. I guess this is the spicy part of the topic.
00:26:17 So, you know, you've talked about the economic and labor market impacts. You know, it's, I think
00:26:24 where the sector really started to break into the mainstream conversation was around housing. All
00:26:28 All of a sudden, you know, housing is actually, it's a multilayered issue.
00:26:31 It would be very unfair to place it squarely on the feet of migration.
00:26:35 But migration is a major component of it.
00:26:38 But that's where it started to become mainstreamed is like, well, I'm not racist for talking about the fact that, you know, I'm 30 years old and I have no chance of ever owning a home.
00:26:48 That does make me racist.
00:26:49 What's behind this?
00:26:50 Oh, OK, migration started to enter the mainstream conversation from there.
00:26:55 Social services, we talked about that, you know.
00:26:58 how are people going to pay into the system when you've kind of flooded the bottom end of the
00:27:01 labor market? But one of the big things that I think has become a more mainstream conversation
00:27:08 lately, despite I think the reticence of many to talk about it, is the cultural impact. That
00:27:14 it's not just that people look differently in your communities, it's that they're acting
00:27:21 differently. That we've taken in so many so fast that there hasn't been an ability to assimilate
00:27:27 And I know we don't like to use the word assimilation in Canada, but at the end of the day, a successful migration policy has to involve assimilation to our basic values, our cultural norms.
00:27:38 You might, you know, we're all fine, keep eating, but, you know, the food from where you're from, that's all fine and good.
00:27:43 We all, we like all that.
00:27:45 But some broad cultural norms that you have to be assimilated into, language, et cetera, we haven't been able to do that.
00:27:55 And I think that is where the, uh, the migration conversation is also going.
00:28:01 It's beyond the economic, it's beyond the physical, it's beyond the labor
00:28:05 market and housing it's in the, what do you think has been the cultural
00:28:11 impact of, of this policy and what do you think has been the backlash or
00:28:16 where do you think that backlash is going?
00:28:18 So this is sort of where I, my, I'm on one side of this line and, and, and
00:28:23 you're on the other side of this line. Like I, I want to keep the conversation on, um, economic
00:28:29 issues. I want to keep the conversation on how do we benefit Canada in ways that will, you know,
00:28:35 benefit the labor market, benefit Canadians, benefit our social services. I, that's where
00:28:39 I want to focus. I don't know how to run an immigration system based on kind of, you know, 0.99
00:28:48 ways of preserving canada's culture the way it is or ways of not changing canadian culture i
00:28:55 one i don't know how to do that two i don't want to do that and i don't really think it's possible
00:29:00 look my ancestors came to canada um so on my mother's side from the russian empire
00:29:07 they practiced a weird religion they didn't speak english and were you mennonites or something or
00:29:15 they were jewish um and here i am talking to you in english and you just think i'm a white guy
00:29:21 canadian um but i if i show you pictures of them you would think they were weird exotic people and
00:29:26 i'm quite and i can tell you i can guarantee you the people who encountered them when they arrived
00:29:31 in 1894 thought they were weird exotic people um on my father's side of the family they came here
00:29:37 from from germany also jewish also wouldn't have spoken wouldn't have spoken english so and yet
00:29:43 somehow you know um canada's canada actually does has historically done an extremely good job
00:29:52 of canadians don't like to use the word assimilation um but the truth is we have we
00:29:59 you know people come here and they they become canadians and they and they come to love canada
00:30:04 and it all works i i can't guarantee you that every single person in every single place but
00:30:08 is going to you know it's going to work out but it is it is generally worked out and i don't know
00:30:14 how to do things differently and i i honestly don't want to um run this on run the immigration 0.76
00:30:25 system on on kind of cultural metrics i i think the logical way to do it is to say let's run it
00:30:33 on economic metrics.
00:30:34 And again, to kind of, and sort of flesh that out a bit, we built a system, an immigration
00:30:38 system over the last few years, the Trudeau government with the help of the provinces
00:30:41 and businesses built a system that said, we really want a hundred thousand new fast food
00:30:47 workers.
00:30:48 It would have been nice if they had said, we want 10,000 more doctors.
00:30:53 Look, I'm with you on the economic side, but I think, yeah, we perhaps are on different
00:30:59 sides of the line on the cultural side, you know, you know, we kind of woke up one day to find
00:31:07 crowds of people in our streets, not all migrants, that'd be very unfair to say, but
00:31:12 large components being migrants holding anti-Semitic demonstrations. And we're like,
00:31:17 oh my God, where did all these anti-Semites come from? And, you know, yeah, it's got the regular
00:31:21 blue haired college or university campus types. It's got them in there and, you know, your regular
00:31:28 They're crunchy professional protesters, but big components being migrants who come from a part of the world where disproportionately there's a bit of conflict and we're all of a sudden, you know, saying, oh, my God, where did this all come from?
00:31:42 And we're all kind of afraid to say it.
00:31:45 I'm a little less so.
00:31:47 But like that is that's a shocking thing to many people when we see this kind of thing in our streets.
00:31:53 And it is not entirely, but in significant measure, an imported issue that we just wouldn't have seen on our streets until that recently. And that's cultural. I don't think necessarily, you know, targeting this, recalibrating to economic issues would necessarily fix that problem. Maybe you disagree. Tell me where I'm wrong.
00:32:21 Yeah, so look, I disagree with you on two bases. One, as I said, I don't know how we can run an immigration system based on some kind of a cultural test. Two, honestly, having gone to some of those protests to see who's doing what and who's protesting and chanting from the river to the sea, boy, there are a lot of white people. 0.98
00:32:47 There are a lot of white progressives who were born in Canada and went to university in Canada. So these are cultural shifts that I think would be happening regardless of the immigration system. Um, and, and so, and I, and again, I don't know how we can talk about this given that Canada is already, um, a multicultural, multiracial, multiethnic society.
00:33:14 I just think it would tear society apart if we said there are certain religions, we don't want any more of those people in Canada. 1.00
00:33:21 They're already in Canada.
00:33:23 Canada already has millions of people of different races and different religions.
00:33:28 And I don't know, like, there's no turning the clock back.
00:33:32 We got to figure out how to make it work with the clock going forward.
00:33:36 That is my argument.
00:33:39 All right, well, let's look forward about how we fix this.
00:33:42 I think you and I will probably see eye to eye on a lot of it.
00:33:46 The guy producing this show right now, I won't get into his details.
00:33:52 He'll get bashful.
00:33:53 But he's a relatively recent migrant. 0.98
00:33:57 I'm not just blowing smoke up his arse here, but he's a hard worker. 0.98
00:34:00 He's competent. 0.98
00:34:01 Despite not being fairly recent, I think fairly assimilated.
00:34:05 He's brought some of his interesting food into the office from time to time, and we like it.
00:34:08 um you know so even in this wave some great folks have come through but obviously far too many have
00:34:16 come through and far too many who are not of the previous caliber we used to expect have come
00:34:22 through now you've said that you know the government started to turn down the taps they've
00:34:26 not turned off the taps nowhere close to turning off the taps um but you know even if we were to
00:34:33 fully turn off the taps. I mean, there's a lot of damage done here on the economic side,
00:34:40 the fiscal side, you know, just the actuaries of how this is going to work out for government
00:34:44 budgeting, for social services going forward, the housing market. And then, well, you and I might
00:34:50 disagree. I would say very much on the cultural side that we have not, we've taken so many so
00:34:54 fast that we cannot adequately assimilate people um should we not send like a lot of these folks 1.00
00:35:07 who are not citizens if you're a citizen that's sick or sanct you're here uh but should we not 0.99
00:35:11 be sending a lot back um like do we need a moratorium on this to just catch our breath
00:35:19 for some time and then you know a decade or whatever it is from now we can say okay
00:35:23 We've caught our breath. Labor markets recovered. Housing markets recovered. People have assimilated
00:35:29 a bit. Now we could start this up again. How do we fix this?
00:35:36 So, yeah, what the government said, what the late Trudeau government said and what now the
00:35:41 Carney government has said is, okay, first of all, permanent immigration, we've lowered the
00:35:46 numbers a bit. Second of all, we're aiming for considerably lower numbers of new temporary
00:35:53 migrants and foreign students um and the assumption is that a lot of the people who are here on
00:36:01 temporary visas temporary foreign workers and temporary foreign students um will some of them
00:36:06 will become permanent residents and citizens will choose some of those and everybody else is going
00:36:12 to have to go home and it's going to be challenging like that is actually going to be the hardest part
00:36:16 And this is where this is where we're going to see kind of the fallout in years to come is, you know, the last time I saw some numbers that suggested that about a million people would have their temporary permits expire, I believe, in 2025 and 2026.
00:36:35 And that's way more than the number of people who can become permanent residents.
00:36:41 We're going to pick fewer than 400,000 permanent residents.
00:36:44 Some of them will be refugees.
00:36:46 Some will be family reunification.
00:36:47 A chunk of them will be economic immigrants chosen from overseas.
00:36:50 You have less than 100,000 places left for temporary residents in Canada to become permanent
00:36:57 residents.
00:36:57 And you have like a million of them who are going to have their visas expire and who in
00:37:01 theory are supposed to just get on a plane and go home.
00:37:02 and so we're probably going to have a much larger number of people who are in Canada
00:37:08 not legally and continuing to work so this is going to be a challenge that we are going to have
00:37:15 to work the government's going to have to work through and it isn't going to it isn't going to
00:37:21 disappear instantly I think we can we can create a much better system we can choose better we can
00:37:28 get the numbers to a more moderate level and again by the way we'd still have higher immigration
00:37:33 than most European countries and we still have higher immigration than the United States but
00:37:39 we'd be doing a better job of of controlling who we choose and and choosing well as we did
00:37:47 pre-20 2015. I want to kind of come back to restate the crux of my last question though
00:37:54 about is what you're saying that we should you know refocus on my uh on economic migration
00:38:01 and bring the numbers down because i you don't think then that like so much damage has been
00:38:08 done here that we should not have like a moratorium for some period you know with some exceptions you
00:38:13 know like the extremely high valued economic migrants yeah we got high level doctors high
00:38:19 level engineers, okay, fine. We're not saying hermetically seal the border here, but in broad
00:38:24 measure, we need to more, I've been of opinion that we need more or less with some reasonable
00:38:30 exceptions, a moratorium here. You disagree with that and think we more or less just, we can get
00:38:35 away with reverting to where we were before this? I wouldn't put, yeah, I wouldn't put a moratorium
00:38:39 on immigration but to put things in perspective okay so in between 2022 and 2024 um net immigration
00:38:49 to canada so that's new permanent residents but also all this temporary stream canada took in 3.1
00:38:56 million people in the space of 36 months and again just to make that number really clear
00:39:02 that includes deducting people who left so temporary migrants who came minus temporary
00:39:08 migrants who left, you get 3.1 million. It's an enormous number. So we have to get to a much 1.00
00:39:14 lower number than that. And that's basically the government's plan. I don't have a problem with the
00:39:21 plan so much. I have a problem with the way they're going to execute it because they're basically
00:39:24 saying we're going to have around 400,000 or a little bit less than 400,000 permanent immigrants
00:39:30 a year. And for several years, the temporary immigration stream is actually going to be
00:39:35 negative. There are going to be more temporary immigrants leaving Canada than arriving under
00:39:41 the government's plan. And that has to be the case because the numbers were so large
00:39:48 over the previous three years. So if you look at the numbers in that way, you'll say, wow,
00:39:55 we're lowering immigration a lot to compensate for what happened from 2022 to 2024. But I think
00:40:05 it would be, it would make no sense
00:40:07 to put any kind of a moratorium
00:40:09 on immigration, but effectively, you know, look,
00:40:11 on the temporary migration side, what the government
00:40:13 has said is, what the Kearney government
00:40:15 has said is happening, is we're actually having
00:40:17 negative immigration.
00:40:19 That's actually their policy goal.
00:40:21 I think they're going to have a lot of trouble achieving
00:40:23 that, but that actually is their policy
00:40:25 goal for a couple years.
00:40:28 There was an old general,
00:40:31 Von Molka, said, no battle plan
00:40:33 survives contact with the enemy.
00:40:35 and I can see this on paper being a good plan,
00:40:40 but it's going to have contact with reality.
00:40:44 Do we really believe, though,
00:40:47 that all of these people who came in on a temporary basis
00:40:50 and are then here illegally are going to go back?
00:40:54 Now, of course, it would never be 100%.
00:40:56 That's never going to happen, but in the broad strokes,
00:41:00 because in your writings, you said,
00:41:03 there was a wink wink nudge nudge uh it was a wink wink agreement to these people that you're
00:41:08 going to come here as a phony student and you're going to get to work at uber you know driving an
00:41:12 uber or something uh but in the end we're gonna make you a permanent resident and a citizen at
00:41:17 some point and that's there's kind of a bait and switch here and uh you know so they i i i'm not
00:41:25 blaming the migrants i'm blaming the system as as you do in your book here it's not the fault of
00:41:29 people who want to come to a richer, wealthier, more secure country. It's the fault of the people
00:41:34 who brought them in on a misleading basis. Or maybe that was actually the intention. It's just
00:41:40 no longer the intention. But there's going to be a bunch of people, I think, who do not voluntarily
00:41:46 self-deport here. And that I think then leaves us with, broadly speaking, two options. ICE-style
00:41:56 raids where we're sending out law enforcement to round up illegal migrants or an amnesty where we
00:42:03 reward people for breaking the law uh where do you one i guess how successful do you think it's
00:42:10 likely to be in the absence of some kind of ice style enforcement against illegal migrants who
00:42:17 have not voluntarily self-deported yeah so how successful do you think that'll be and then two
00:42:22 if it's not successful, do we go the route of then that kind of hard law, that kind of hard
00:42:29 enforcement, or do we go the route of an amnesty that would reward people for breaking the law?
00:42:35 So I want to go back and talk a little bit about history to try to explain this and to do a
00:42:39 contrast between the Canada and the United States. So for the last 30, 30, even 40 years,
00:42:45 illegal immigration has been a huge issue in the United States. There's an enormous amount of noise
00:42:50 around it and there's enormous amount of performative enforcement where um republican
00:42:56 governors republican governments make a big noise and and trump is the latest of look at how much
00:43:03 we're doing um to address this and canada on the other hand has traditionally had very little
00:43:10 illegal immigration and it's because of a whole bunch of subtle bureaucratic measures
00:43:16 that used to work and could still work if we use them. So, you know, you can't just get on a plane
00:43:23 and come to Canada. It's really hard to get a visa to come to Canada if you're from anything
00:43:29 other than a highly developed first world country. It's actually much easier to go to the United
00:43:35 States. The reason Roxham Road existed is because people could get on a plane and fly to JFK airport
00:43:40 in New York and then get on a bus and come to Canada. People, for example, people from Nigeria
00:43:46 were doing this um and they couldn't have flown to canada because canada wouldn't given them a visa
00:43:52 but the united states would so canada had all these subtle measures we need to have various
00:43:58 subtle measures um at the same time a certain number of people who are temporary residents in
00:44:04 canada will be chosen year after year to become permanent residents because they have skills they
00:44:11 already have a job they already have an education it makes sense we were going to take in a certain
00:44:15 number of people 400 000 ish or a bit less as permanent residents boom they're part of that
00:44:21 quota they fit the criteria they're in so it's going to have to be a mix of yes some of these
00:44:29 permanent some of these temporary residents are going to become permanent residents and some of
00:44:34 these temporary residents are going to be by various subtle ways encouraged to leave because
00:44:41 they don't qualify for permanent residency it's going to have to be subtle tools and one of the
00:44:48 ones that i recommend in my book and a lot of people will find it harsh but i i think it's
00:44:51 sort of necessary is to have a system where employers can only hire people who are legally
00:44:58 allowed to work in canada um and that shouldn't be a controversial thing that shouldn't be a
00:45:03 controversial thing i don't i really don't think i'm not sure it is anymore actually controversial
00:45:08 um but i will say so for example in the united states you may think that that exists in the
00:45:13 united states it doesn't like the americans have a system called e-verify but no employer is
00:45:19 required to use it so in theory in the united states employers can check the legal status of
00:45:28 every potential employee for their company but the law doesn't oblige them to use it because democrats
00:45:33 and republicans have historically both agreed they don't want to happen want that to happen
00:45:36 One because they're being lobbied by progressives on one side and the other because they're being lobbied by big business on the other side.
00:45:42 And so the U.S. essentially encouraged a labor market of people who are not legally allowed to work in the United States to work, continue working in the United States or to come to the United States to work, which is which is not a good way to run things like you want people to feel that your immigration system is legal and it's and it's functioning.
00:46:03 And if you really need to bring in more people, do it legally, not illegally.
00:46:09 Find smart ways, above board ways that create confidence among voters that, hey, the government's running things well.
00:46:16 They're running things for my benefit.
00:46:18 The Americans kind of did the opposite and they ended up with 40 years of of, you know, chaos and conflict and controversy.
00:46:27 We avoided that because we were, we had a sensible, sane bureaucracy that was about being both pro-immigration and anti-irregular, illegal, and unusual immigration.
00:46:42 We got to get back to that.
00:46:44 Yeah.
00:46:44 I, you know, I, I always caution against bipartisanship because very often it's just both parties conspiring to screw the common people together.
00:46:54 We've.
00:46:54 immigration sometimes but i gotta say sometimes sometimes it's the opposite it's because it's
00:47:01 actually you know both parties sort of look at what the average person wants and they're like
00:47:05 hey you know what we can run it that way so i i really think that the canadian immigration system
00:47:11 pre-2015 was not controversial um and you're right and and and polls said that very few
00:47:19 canadians were upset about immigration because it actually was working for canada and for the
00:47:24 average person. And therefore Canadians weren't upset. And the reason Canadians are now upset
00:47:29 about immigration is not because, you know, as I say in my book, it's not because the entire country
00:47:34 caught airborne xenophobia as some kind of disease. It's because circumstances changed.
00:47:40 And so Canadians said, hang on a second. I'm, I was happy with the old system, 0.96
00:47:44 but I'm not happy with the new system. And I wish you would, I wish you would make things more
00:47:50 like they were before so let me leave with a final question on this which is both i think
00:47:56 retrospective and forward-looking um so yeah the immigration polarization is a new thing to at
00:48:04 least modern canada as we've known it today for from my lifetime it's never been a major thing
00:48:09 it's been limited largely to cranks uh who maybe in retrospect i i i feel a little bad for shaming
00:48:15 But it was really cranks on the fringes, but it's now front and center, major issue.
00:48:22 We've joined the conversation with the United States and with Europe.
00:48:26 There are different circumstances, you know, Europe also being nation states.
00:48:32 They're different than more civic constitutional creations like Canada and the United States, civic nationalism.
00:48:39 So they're not exactly apples to apples.
00:48:42 But both Europe and the United States have been having the conversation for a long time in different forms. We're new to the conversation, at least in modern Canada. How do you think the immigration debate in Europe and the United States is impacting Canada?
00:49:01 And then in reverse, has Canada and our more recent experience with largely uncontrolled mass migration, are we impacting the debate in those places?
00:49:15 So I think Canada in the past did impact the debate in the United States, a little bit in Europe, but especially in the United States, where Americans, particularly liberal Americans, would look at Canada and say, what's going on in Canada?
00:49:30 how come Canada isn't having these immigration controversies? How come immigration isn't tearing 0.97
00:49:37 up American politics the way it is Canadian politics? But I think they tended to not
00:49:42 understand the reason why. The reason Canada looked super liberal to liberal Americans
00:49:50 on immigration is because super liberal on immigration Canada was also very conservative.
00:49:56 It was both at the same time. Canada said, we're going to have higher immigration than the United 0.94
00:50:02 States. We're also going to have way more border control and a sense of control over immigration
00:50:08 than the United States. Immigration will not be perceived by Canadians as an imposition.
00:50:13 It will be perceived by Canadians as a choice. So I think that's the historical thing that
00:50:18 Canada got right. And that's what made Canadian immigration politics so different from American 0.86
00:50:24 immigration politics. And I think to avoid ending up in the place where American immigration 0.90
00:50:30 politics is now, we have to get back to that. And that to me is that that's the left right
00:50:37 coming together. That's the yin yang that a lot of people did not understand about the Canadian
00:50:45 system. It was so baked in that the liberals couldn't understand that if you want to be
00:50:51 pro-immigration, you better be pro-border control. You better be pro-limits. And if you're pro-limits, 0.63
00:50:58 then you can actually afford to be pro-immigration because people will understand while you're doing
00:51:02 it. Where the US system, things kind of fell apart. I mean, particularly under the Biden
00:51:08 administration was the last straw where a whole lot of voters said, Biden doesn't seem to know
00:51:14 what to do about these exceptionally large numbers of people coming across the Mexican border um
00:51:22 and so like he doesn't seem to have a plan to sort of handle this in a way that's going to be
00:51:27 acceptable to Americans and he didn't have a plan because the left essentially said you're not
00:51:31 allowed to have a plan um so and that re-elected that is a major contributor to re-electing Donald
00:51:39 Trump. It may be the most important contributor to reelecting Donald Trump. So I want Canada to
00:51:45 end up in a different place. But I think we have to learn the lessons of our own immigration history 0.51
00:51:50 and we have to understand how our immigration history has been better and smarter than recent
00:51:56 US immigration history and was better and smarter until a number of years ago. And that's really
00:52:03 the point of my book. All right. Well, Tony, I greatly appreciate your time. I think I'm with
00:52:11 you on a lot of it. Maybe not everything, but I'd say I'm on with you with more than even many of
00:52:16 our own columnists on any given controversial topic. I think it's a very insightful work that
00:52:21 you've done. I'm going to make sure I read the full thing in detail. I feel a little guilty not
00:52:25 doing it before here, but I think I had taken enough in that we were able to have a really
00:52:29 great conversation. So thank you for the work you've done here and sharing your time with us
00:52:34 today. Thank you very much for having me on. And, you know, like people don't always have to agree
00:52:40 about everything. It's good to be able to have conversations with people you don't agree with
00:52:43 a hundred percent because nobody should agree with everybody a hundred percent. We should still be
00:52:46 able to be civil and have conversations and listen to one another's perspectives, even if we don't
00:52:54 A hundred percent agree.
00:52:55 Yeah.
00:52:56 Well,
00:52:56 amen to that.
00:52:58 Thank you very much
00:52:59 for joining us
00:53:00 and best of luck
00:53:01 with your next project.
00:53:03 Okay.
00:53:04 Thanks, Derek.
00:53:05 Great to talk to you.
00:53:06 All right.
00:53:07 Cheers.
00:53:08 That was Tony Keller,
00:53:10 Globe and Mail columnist
00:53:11 and author of
00:53:13 Borderline Chaos,
00:53:15 How Canada Got Immigration Right 1.00
00:53:16 and Then Wrong.
00:53:17 Thank you for joining us today
00:53:18 and God bless.
00:53:24 You