Western Standard - July 28, 2022


Hymie Rubenstein on the Pope's visit & apologies

Mentioned
Triggered: Danielle Smith is a victim of her own talkativeness Triggered: Danielle Smith owned the first UCP leadership debate

Episode Stats


Length

14 minutes

Words per minute

148.2

Word count

2,165

Sentence count

129

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the wake of Pope Francis' apology for the Indian Residential Schools, many are asking when the Catholic Church is going to move past this painful legacy. In this special edition of the Western Standard's After Hours podcast, we discuss the impact of the apology, the lack of reparations, and what the church should do to move forward.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 The Indian Residential Schools has been an issue as you've been writing a lot in your newsletter
00:00:04 and in the Dorchester Times, as well with columns here in the Western Standard occasionally.
00:00:11 And it's going to be in the news scroll quite a bit right now as we have Pope Francis visiting
00:00:16 right now and making a number of apologies for the Indian Residential Schools.
00:00:23 What's your interpretation on how is this visit going to help towards reconciliation?
00:00:27 I doubt it, because the end game is not reconciliation.
00:00:35 It's never been about reconciliation.
00:00:38 We would have had reconciliation decades ago if that was the ultimate goal.
00:00:44 Even the Pope admitted in his speech, in his apology, that there's still a long way to go.
00:00:52 He said, we're at the beginning.
00:00:54 Everybody's, you know, first step.
00:00:55 He said, this is the first step.
00:00:57 My apology today.
00:00:58 It's always a first step.
00:01:00 There's never a second step.
00:01:01 I wonder why.
00:01:03 Well, and that's part of what I've seen, you know, some reactions to, though, with people,
00:01:08 even if the Pope legitimately wants to end this, it's never enough.
00:01:13 I mean, people are already saying, yeah, it is the first step.
00:01:15 But when does this ever end?
00:01:17 And there just doesn't seem to be any resolution.
00:01:21 We just keep reopening an old wound.
00:01:27 I didn't catch the last part.
00:01:28 Sorry.
00:01:29 Oh, that's okay.
00:01:30 I'm going to adjust my microphone here.
00:01:35 My earphones, I mean.
00:01:37 If that helps.
00:01:41 Sorry for that.
00:01:42 Oh, that's okay if you're hearing me a little better now.
00:01:46 Look, this is only one.
00:01:50 There have been dozens of these apologies within the Catholic Church and in other faiths,
00:01:59 faiths for many years now.
00:02:01 But we're still at a stage where we do not have the basis for the apology, namely the factual basis.
00:02:09 The Pope himself admitted that when he said, you know, more research has to be done.
00:02:17 Why did he say that?
00:02:18 Yet his apology accepted all of the accusations made in the six volumes of the Truth and Reconciliation Report of 2015,
00:02:29 including accusations directly, indirectly, and in his address about children being forced to attend the schools.
00:02:39 150,000 children were forced to attend Indian residential schools.
00:02:45 There is no evidence of that.
00:02:47 The evidence is on the other side, that most of the children who attended, attended voluntarily,
00:02:53 based on both the law and on the will of their parents.
00:02:59 There was a 27, a 28-year period between 1920 and 1948.
00:03:08 I'm sorry, it's probably a 24-year period when Indian residential school attendance was mandatory,
00:03:16 if and only if there was no day school, Indian day school, on the particular reserve.
00:03:23 And in fact, over the entire period of the Indian residential schools,
00:03:29 only a third of actual children attended these schools at most.
00:03:37 Through the entire 113-year period of the Indian residential schools,
00:03:43 most children either attended day schools or no school at all.
00:03:49 And even up to 1940, something like 40% of Indigenous children were attending no school at all.
00:03:57 That is the tragedy, Corey.
00:03:59 Yeah, and then when you see broad-based apologies, though,
00:04:04 and if we aren't even sure exactly what it's for,
00:04:06 it kind of opens one up for a lot more follow-up and liability, unfortunately, though.
00:04:11 Like, I mean, any lawyer will advise you often, I'm afraid, you know,
00:04:15 if something wrong has happened, if you're worried about liability,
00:04:17 the first thing, don't apologize yet.
00:04:19 As soon as you apologize, you're admitting guilt.
00:04:22 And, I mean, that's what I'm saying is we're hearing activists,
00:04:24 we're hearing others saying, okay, this is just the beginning.
00:04:26 That they're going to be coming after the Catholic Church for more than an apology soon.
00:04:31 There's a big disappointment this morning, and it was since April,
00:04:36 the April 1st apology about reparations not being part of the apology.
00:04:46 You know, apologies are something, but they're not enough.
00:04:50 What are you going to do to compensate for all the damage that was done to the children?
00:04:56 At these residential schools that you are responsible for.
00:05:00 The underlying assumption, of course, was that there was horrible damage done
00:05:07 to each and every student who attended the residential schools.
00:05:10 I am the last person who will deny that some students were damaged at the schools,
00:05:17 that some teachers were brutal, that some sexual abuse,
00:05:21 I'm not going to deny that some sexual abuse occurred to some children
00:05:27 at some schools during certain periods.
00:05:30 Many of those individuals involved have been punished.
00:05:34 Most of them were not clerical personnel.
00:05:38 There were other workers in the school.
00:05:40 The bulk of the sexual abuse that took place, took place between students
00:05:44 as occurs in residential schools all over the world throughout human history.
00:05:52 So, you know, when you start off with the assumption
00:05:54 that there was all this damage, and you're not giving the proof
00:05:58 of this damage, and you're saying, well, there's this legacy,
00:06:03 even among people who never went to a residential school,
00:06:07 in communities where nobody went to residential schools,
00:06:11 which as much as Eastern Canada, there's only one Indian residential school,
00:06:15 yet all of the same pathologies that we see among Indigenous people, 1.00
00:06:19 high crime, high unemployment, high suicide, etc., etc.,
00:06:25 high poverty occurs at the same rate in these other places.
00:06:31 Yeah, and I worry that, unfortunately, even if some of it might be well-meaning and so on,
00:06:35 I mean, you know, when we get, again, not getting any closer to any closure,
00:06:38 I've been watching the coverage of it, you know, it's been going around the clock,
00:06:42 and I see the language and the uncorrected language of activists and others
00:06:45 who refer to every one of them as a survivor.
00:06:48 Even if you went to a day school, you're called a survivor,
00:06:51 as if you'd endured something beyond what anybody else going to school does,
00:06:55 as if somebody was trying to kill you, or constantly,
00:06:57 and I had that in my opening monologue yesterday,
00:06:59 the word genocide keeps putting out there, and there was no bloody genocide.
00:07:03 But the more we keep driving that in through the news,
00:07:05 and with these apologies, the more people get that misconception that this all happened.
00:07:11 What I find particularly interesting about the Pope's apology
00:07:15 is it's diametrically opposite to what Pope John Paul II said
00:07:24 when he visited Canada in 1985.
00:07:28 Let me just read two sentences here.
00:07:31 He went to, I'm sorry, 1987.
00:07:34 He stopped at Fort Simpson in the Northwest Territories
00:07:38 on a particular First Nations Reserve,
00:07:40 and this is what he said about the Catholic missionaries,
00:07:43 the teachers in the schools.
00:07:45 The revival of your indigenous culture and traditions
00:07:49 that you know today is largely due to the initiatives
00:07:53 and continuous efforts of the missionaries.
00:07:56 Your ancestors knew by instinct that the gospel,
00:08:02 far from destroying their authentic values and customs,
00:08:05 had the power to purify and uplift the cultural heritage
00:08:09 which they had received.
00:08:12 So, Corey, what happened over the 30 years?
00:08:15 Why is this turnaround
00:08:17 when it's all based on the same historical evidence
00:08:21 which suggests that John Paul II was quite right, 0.99
00:08:25 that students were often instructed by priests
00:08:32 who had learned their indigenous language
00:08:34 and often spoke it to them,
00:08:36 spoke it to them in their indigenous language,
00:08:39 whether it was Cree or Ojibwe or whatever,
00:08:42 outside the classroom.
00:08:43 Inside the classroom, just as in French immersion in Canada,
00:08:46 you've got to stick to the syllabus,
00:08:48 and the syllabus says it's, you know,
00:08:50 you're learning English, you're learning French.
00:08:52 But outside the classroom and on events and excursions and so on,
00:08:58 indigenous people were allowed to speak their languages
00:09:00 and allowed to practice their cultural activities,
00:09:04 which missionaries took great zeal in recording
00:09:07 and supporting in many cases.
00:09:11 And I'm saying there weren't some rotten apples,
00:09:13 but the few rotten apples cannot be taken
00:09:17 as representative of the entire barrel.
00:09:22 Yeah, so, I mean, where do we go with this, though?
00:09:25 I mean, this tour is going to go ahead
00:09:26 and there's going to be more people
00:09:27 looking for more compensation.
00:09:29 Getting back to more of the interviews,
00:09:30 as I've done with, you know,
00:09:31 Brian Giesbrecht and Clifton and others,
00:09:34 and I want to keep on this,
00:09:36 are we ever going to finally investigate
00:09:38 and get the facts on this, though?
00:09:40 I mean, there doesn't seem to be will
00:09:41 on the part of legacy media,
00:09:43 a little bit capping with the National Post
00:09:44 and Terry Glavin.
00:09:46 But, you know, people just say
00:09:48 the mythology is overtaking the reality,
00:09:50 and I'm not sure if we could stop it.
00:09:52 It's an uphill road.
00:09:54 Slowly but surely,
00:09:55 some of the data is coming out.
00:09:56 It's all there.
00:09:57 It's all in the archives.
00:09:58 The Truth and Reconciliation Commission
00:10:01 did a very sloppy job in collecting the data.
00:10:05 They did a very sloppy job
00:10:07 in even trying to get a representative sample
00:10:14 of the tens of thousands of students
00:10:17 who are still alive.
00:10:19 They let any student come to these testimonials
00:10:23 and to these hearings who had,
00:10:27 most of them had a grievance
00:10:29 that they wanted to reveal.
00:10:32 So we're slowly getting to know that,
00:10:35 and we're slowly getting to realize
00:10:37 that there are no missing children.
00:10:42 This is something that many people
00:10:43 are now working on.
00:10:44 We're finding them in the archives,
00:10:46 archives and data that were ignored
00:10:49 by the Truth and Reconciliation Commission.
00:10:52 How can you say there's a missing child
00:10:57 when the child who's recorded is dead?
00:11:00 The child is just dead.
00:11:01 The child is not missing.
00:11:04 Yeah, and you'd corrected me on that before.
00:11:06 The very first time we had you on the show,
00:11:08 because I was under this misconception
00:11:10 that while there was poor record keeping
00:11:12 and we don't know who was where and whatnot,
00:11:14 and no, the records were actually very meticulous.
00:11:17 We knew the disposition of pretty much every child,
00:11:19 whether they died or went back home
00:11:22 or whatever happened with them.
00:11:24 But again, a lot of us are under this,
00:11:26 we're under this misinformation
00:11:29 that children have vanished,
00:11:31 and they haven't.
00:11:32 There's nobody looking for them
00:11:33 because there's none disappeared.
00:11:34 If thousands of students were missing,
00:11:39 you would have thousands of families
00:11:40 looking for them by name,
00:11:43 by name of child,
00:11:45 by the name of the individuals
00:11:48 who are looking for them.
00:11:50 You would have countless police reports.
00:11:52 There would have been investigations years ago.
00:11:55 It's simply false.
00:11:56 You're married in unmarked graves.
00:12:01 What are unmarked graves?
00:12:02 You go to any cemetery in Winnipeg,
00:12:04 you're going to find unmarked graves
00:12:06 or in Calgary from the 19th century
00:12:08 because poor people did not have money
00:12:10 to get a headstone.
00:12:12 They put in a wooden cross,
00:12:13 which disintegrated within 20 or 30 years.
00:12:17 Oh, yeah.
00:12:18 At the Calgary Union Cemetery,
00:12:19 if you go to the south side,
00:12:20 you see a big wide open area
00:12:22 where you just see some surface ground disturbances,
00:12:24 and that was what used to be called
00:12:25 the potter's field because, yeah,
00:12:27 there was a wooden cross put in
00:12:28 for transient individuals
00:12:30 or people who were poor,
00:12:32 and the visible record of it disappeared.
00:12:35 It's not uncommon at all for old cemeteries.
00:12:39 Absolutely, and we have those all over the country
00:12:42 for all sorts of groups,
00:12:44 not just indigenous individuals.
00:12:48 When students died at a school,
00:12:50 and many died as students in a school,
00:12:53 they were normally not buried
00:12:57 in the cemetery adjacent to the school,
00:13:01 which was largely for school personnel.
00:13:05 The nuns, the priests, the workers,
00:13:07 you know, they've come from thousands of miles away,
00:13:10 so there was no way to send them home
00:13:12 after they died,
00:13:12 so they had their own cemetery.
00:13:14 Very few students were buried in those cemeteries.
00:13:17 The vast majority of them,
00:13:19 when they became ill,
00:13:20 they were either sent to a hospital,
00:13:23 nearby hospital,
00:13:24 to a dedicated indigenous hospital,
00:13:28 or back to their home community.
00:13:30 When they died in their home community,
00:13:32 they were buried in their home cemeteries.
00:13:35 I mean, this isn't a historical record.
00:13:37 This is not a hypothesis on my part.
00:13:40 No, and I appreciate your ongoing work with this.
00:13:44 So, I mean, before I let you go,
00:13:46 and I'm certain we'll be talking again,
00:13:47 because this subject just keeps going,
00:13:49 and as I've been writing columns as well,
00:13:51 and pushing, we need to investigate.
00:13:53 We need to look into what really happened in Kamloops.
00:13:55 We've got to get the facts out there.
00:13:57 Where can we find your work?
00:14:00 I know you have a newsletter,
00:14:00 and you've put stuff in the Dorchester Review.
00:14:03 Where can people track that down?
00:14:04 My newsletter is on Substack,
00:14:08 and the address is simply
00:14:11 hymie.substack.com
00:14:16 Great.
00:14:18 Well, I really appreciate you carrying on with this
00:14:21 and speaking up,
00:14:21 and, you know, I'll keep on it too,
00:14:23 and eventually we'll find some resolution
00:14:25 one way or another on this issue.
00:14:27 Thank you for having me on.
00:14:28 All right.
00:14:29 We'll talk again soon.
00:14:30 Thank you.
00:14:30 Thank you.
00:14:34 Thank you.