Western Standard - September 05, 2025


Immigration, inflation and Canada's fading Carney romance

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Keeping (taxpayer-funded) porn out of schools Danielle Smith press conference at the Canada Strong and Free Network Conference

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

173.77

Word count

3,951

Sentence count

229

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In less than two weeks, Parliament resumes after a recess of three months. What s top of mind for Pierre Poirier when the House resumes on September 15th? Would it be temporary foreign workers? With me tonight to talk about these things is Ginny Roth, a partner at Crestview Strategies, a former communications director for the Conservative Party of Canada, and a long-time poly-ev surrogate.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, September the 4th.
00:00:23 In less than two weeks, Parliament resumes after a recess of three months,
00:00:29 But Canada has not been without a government for all that time.
00:00:33 It has just been without a supervised government and, importantly, without a budget.
00:00:39 What has been going on? Should we be worried?
00:00:42 With me tonight to talk about these things is Ginny Roth.
00:00:45 She's a partner at Crestview Strategies, a former communications director for the Conservative Party of Canada and a long-time poly-ev surrogate.
00:00:54 Good evening, Ginny.
00:00:56 Good evening, Nigel. Nice to be here.
00:00:58 Good to see you again. Thanks for coming back. Jenny, what's the top of mind for Pierre Poirier when the House resumes on September the 15th? Would it be temporary foreign workers?
00:01:08 I think that's up there. If you look at the latest polling, not on popularity of the leaders, but on the issues, this issue of Donald Trump and the Canada-U.S. trade relationship is starting to fall. It's just not as salient as it was during our general election campaign.
00:01:30 Cost of living is still a huge driver of concern and anxiety for people.
00:01:37 Immigration is part of that.
00:01:39 Crime remains a challenging issue for people.
00:01:41 And housing, continued shortage of housing, which also is tied to the immigration issue.
00:01:47 So I think part of the reason you saw Paliyev talking about temporary foreign workers today is he wants to point out that while the Kearney government has curtailed immigration on some fronts in some ways,
00:01:58 they continue to pursue programs that bring thousands of newcomers into the country at a
00:02:05 time when we have a shortage of supply of things. We have a shortage of supply of jobs. We have a
00:02:10 shortage of supply of housing. We have a shortage of supply of health care. And I think a lot of
00:02:15 Canadians now think that's because we have just brought in too many people for the amount of
00:02:19 things that we have. You see youth unemployment really quite high, concerningly high. And so he's
00:02:25 he's talking about temporary foreign workers to sort of say,
00:02:28 I've got real solutions to these problems, and Prime Minister Carney doesn't.
00:02:32 Now, Ginny, obviously you have better insights into what Mr. Pollyer thinks
00:02:37 than what Mr. Carney thinks by the nature of your past positions.
00:02:40 Nevertheless, can you make any sense of what the Prime Minister has done
00:02:45 when he's promised to cut back on immigration,
00:02:47 and apparently it proceeds apace and may even be increasing?
00:02:50 So to give the government some credit, the levels that they've set are quite a bit lower than the levels of the previous government for new permanent residents, for all sorts of categories across the immigration plan.
00:03:06 But the only reason that they're lower is because they were so, so, so high.
00:03:10 They were generationally high.
00:03:13 The challenge is, one, actually sticking to those levels is a challenge.
00:03:18 So they're already tracking to be above the levels that they've set for this year, which is concerning.
00:03:24 And the people that were brought in at the peak of the deluge are still here.
00:03:30 The people who have overstayed their visas are generally not being deported.
00:03:35 We don't. It's very difficult to do that.
00:03:37 So there's a bit of you can't get the toothpaste back into the tube, which I think is why you see Polly have calling for a flat population for a number of years until we can get the supply and demand dynamic. 0.70
00:03:48 right again. And even though Carney sort of pulled back a bit from Trudeau-era immigration,
00:03:54 you can tell he doesn't want to talk about it. He doesn't want to take further measures.
00:03:58 And I think that's because he's so close to corporate Canada and so many big employers
00:04:02 just like having this constant influx of labor available to them. And I don't think Carney
00:04:08 wants to be offside of that. I think he's close to corporate Canada. I think he's sympathetic
00:04:11 to their wants and their needs. And he thinks an economy needs lots of new labor. That puts
00:04:17 him against public opinion. Public opinion is saying too much, too far, you have to pull it
00:04:23 way back. And while he may think that Carney's pulled it back a little bit, they don't think
00:04:27 he's pulled it back enough. Well, that's certainly the opinion of most people by the sounds of the
00:04:32 polls and by the sounds of the news stories. The effect of all this immigration has been to 0.92
00:04:37 depress wages and actually to make it very difficult for people who've been here for years
00:04:42 to get work but you have to give mr carney i think the benefit of the doubt for about another
00:04:48 two weeks which is when parliament comes back uh although he was an advisor to mr trudeau
00:04:55 i get the sense that when he finally got into government it was a little bit like parents
00:05:01 coming home and finding that the teenagers had a party while they were away for the weekend
00:05:06 a total mess. What do you think? Should we give Mr. Carney a break for just taking over from
00:05:15 Mr. Trudeau? I think you're right that part of what Mark Carney has done successfully
00:05:21 is he's taken some middle-of-the-road common-sense positions that Justin Trudeau refused to take,
00:05:26 whether it was canceling the carbon tax or suggesting that we should continue to
00:05:32 to develop oil and gas in this country,
00:05:37 like just some basic things that Trudeau was offside on,
00:05:40 he's taken those up and said, yes, I'm on side with that.
00:05:44 And that has made people think that he is reasonable, moderate, etc.
00:05:49 But I don't think that he's gone far enough.
00:05:52 And the challenge is he's banking on the fact that expectations were so low
00:05:56 after Trudeau that even the slightest improvement,
00:05:59 You know, putting your shoes on the right feet looks looks like the height of competence.
00:06:04 And I think Canadians for a while have been happy to see that.
00:06:08 But I think that will wear thin quickly.
00:06:10 You know, the Canada U.S. issue is dropping in salience, but it is still important for a lot of people.
00:06:16 And for those people, they believe that Mark Carney promised them that he would solve it.
00:06:20 And that really is what he ran the election on.
00:06:21 He said he was the guy to deal with Trump.
00:06:23 Well, we have no deal.
00:06:25 Canada remains heavily tariffed.
00:06:28 We're about to enter the renegotiation of Kusma, our most important trade agreement.
00:06:33 And terms with the Americans do not seem like they're good.
00:06:37 Things do not seem to be going well.
00:06:38 And so while Carney, I think, has a bit of a honeymoon because his demeanor, the sort
00:06:44 of vibe he gives off, gives people a feeling of competence and calm.
00:06:49 I think that's starting to wear thin.
00:06:51 And you're right that when Parliament comes screaming back in a couple of weeks, I think
00:06:57 Polyev is going to spend a lot of his time trying to lay that bare for Canadians and make it clear
00:07:01 to them that progress has not been made. Well, I see that he's laying down a narrative now that
00:07:06 this will be an austerity budget. Obviously, he is still committed to delivering a budget
00:07:12 in the fall, but it's going to be a tough one. So how tough do you think it could be?
00:07:21 I mean, I think that's sort of hilarious because it's not going to be an austerity budget. He's
00:07:25 taken all these areas off the table. So he's done this trick where he's going to separate
00:07:30 operating and programmatic spending from capital spending, as he calls it. But he's considering
00:07:36 capital to be anything that's deemed to be an investment into the future. So any kind of
00:07:41 infrastructure, I think he's going to include sort of social infrastructure in that. He's also said
00:07:46 he's not going to mess with transfers to the provinces or social programs. So dental, child
00:07:52 care, all these huge new multi-billion dollar programs are, I don't think, being touched.
00:07:58 So that really only leaves him with sort of like narrow ministerial program spending.
00:08:02 And yes, he's talked a big game about cutting back there. But I think ultimately that's because
00:08:07 he'll settle for less. And I think what he knows is that the public right now is not terribly
00:08:12 sensitive to big deficits. They will become sensitive to those big deficits as they add
00:08:17 to the debt. And eventually we have bond rating agencies expressing great concern with the size
00:08:25 of our debt and the cost of servicing it. But for now, because we have decent fundamentals,
00:08:31 he can sort of take advantage of that. He could just push off that cost of that to future
00:08:36 generations. And I think that's what we'll see. I think you'll see historically high deficit
00:08:40 with tons of new spending, some of it on defense, but a lot of it in social programs,
00:08:46 a lot of it in infrastructure. And he will say, this is what we need. This is what people wanted.
00:08:51 They wanted more defense spending. They wanted more infrastructure spending. Because people did,
00:08:56 I think, want more major projects built. People in Western Canada want to be able to get
00:09:01 the product that they sit on to market. I just think that they wanted the private sector to
00:09:07 do that. They wanted government to get out of the way. Curry's interpretation seems to be that
00:09:12 government's going to go to the table with taxpayer money to get this done. And that's a
00:09:16 different that's a different take and it's going to lead to massive massive deficits
00:09:20 we can't keep running deficits forever
00:09:25 true true it's just the road when does this actually hit the wall um so i mean we saw this
00:09:34 we saw we saw the room that um ultimately um john croutier and paul martin had in the 1990s and
00:09:41 then the premiers in the years following had to, the political room, they had to cut back on
00:09:47 spending. That was because things got so bad that the public understood it was necessary and that
00:09:52 this sort of tough medicine was actually what they wanted from elected officials. I just don't think
00:09:56 we're there yet, sadly. I wish we were because it would be easier to deal with it now than it will
00:10:00 be whenever this time comes. I think a lot of it comes down to debt to GDP ratio and other
00:10:07 markers of the extent to which our economy can handle that level of debt servicing.
00:10:12 There is some concern, like you see some initial concern, for instance, in B.C.,
00:10:17 the credit rating agencies are starting to express real concern with the size of their debt and
00:10:21 deficit. That will happen eventually at the federal level. It's just that I think Mark
00:10:26 Carney's view is it's not happening to me this year, so I'll get away with what I can get away
00:10:30 with i worry that the chaos that he has inherited gives him an excuse for just about anything that
00:10:39 he wants to do does the conservative party leadership have anxieties that things will
00:10:47 just be taken to a different level of uh well chaos and and irresponsibility that frankly we
00:10:56 could never recover from. I think that what happened in the election that helped get Kearney
00:11:01 elected was they were sort of, I don't want to oversimplify, but they were sort of two types of
00:11:05 people. There were people who are in a precarious state due to the challenges related to cost of
00:11:11 living. They either couldn't afford to buy a home, or if they did have a home, their mortgage
00:11:15 was taking up a huge percentage of their take-home pay. In some cases, people were struggling to get
00:11:20 food, to fill their car with gas, et cetera. They were living a life where Canada was just not
00:11:25 delivering for them, where they felt like their children would be worse off than they were,
00:11:30 that they were worse off than their parents were. And those people voted for Pierre Paliyev and
00:11:34 the Conservatives. And there were a lot of them, don't forget. I mean, Paliyev did quite well by
00:11:38 historical standards in terms of the size of his voting coalition. There were also a number of
00:11:43 people, mostly older, mostly in homes that were bought and paid for, with stocks that fared well
00:11:51 in an inflationary environment who were worried about one thing and one thing only, and that was
00:11:56 their distaste for Donald Trump. And those people spent a lot of time watching CNN,
00:12:02 watching this man they didn't like at all, and wanting a prime minister who was going to
00:12:07 share their distaste for Donald Trump. And those voters voted for Mark Carney.
00:12:14 I think many of those voters cared about Donald Trump, and they also wanted someone they felt
00:12:18 was like serious and competent, could do geopolitics. So if those issues remain pressing
00:12:25 and the world seems chaotic from that perspective, that will help Carney because he is perceived to
00:12:30 be branded as someone who can deal with that. If, however, the microeconomic issues of domestic
00:12:37 economic policy become problematic, cost of living gets worse, inflation maybe goes up in
00:12:43 some key categories. Or worst of all, I think for a government, unemployment starts to really climb
00:12:49 because the economy softens. I think Carney will try to blame that on Trump, because that allows
00:12:53 him to then talk about Trump again. But I don't know that Canadians are going to totally buy it.
00:12:58 At a certain point, they're going to say, okay, but what's your plan to fix the economy?
00:13:02 You seem to be doing a lot of what the last guy did. And I think Pierre Polyev's chance is really
00:13:07 to say, I would treat our economy differently. I would get government out of the way. I would
00:13:12 deregulate i would reduce costs i would lower taxes um and say to canadians like that's how
00:13:19 we fix this problem we're in and so it depends what kind of chaos you're talking about i guess
00:13:24 um and and that i think will determine uh who can be successful all right well let's move on let's
00:13:30 talk about mr polia he's run one his uh election handily he's uh he must be in good spirits as he
00:13:37 heads back to Ottawa.
00:13:41 What do you think, what's it going to be like?
00:13:44 Should we all be tuning into Question Period
00:13:46 on the second day of the new Parliament?
00:13:51 I mean, I think Parliament is an area of strength
00:13:53 for Mr. Paliyev.
00:13:54 He likes to debate.
00:13:56 He likes the cut and thrust of debate.
00:13:58 He likes to put polls and arguments
00:14:00 show where his opponents are weak.
00:14:03 And Question Period is the forum for that.
00:14:06 And it's important.
00:14:07 So Canadians, you know, see clips of Question Period. It trickles through into the news that they consume. But it's not everything. I think Polly needs to keep that in mind. A lot of why he was successful over the last couple of years as he built his popularity and tour of the country was meeting Canadians where they were.
00:14:28 He would host rallies. He would hold roundtables. He would go into communities and meet with people. And he wouldn't just talk to them. He would also listen. And that gave him this incredible ability to see where problems were arising for people in the moment.
00:14:43 All of this was happening at the same time as Justin Trudeau was very stuck in his Ottawa bubble. He just seemed more and more out of touch with regular people. You know, Chrystia Freeland was telling people that they should cancel their Disney Plus subscription if they were suffering from inflation.
00:14:58 I think Kearney risks suffering from the same problem.
00:15:04 I don't think Mark Kearney likes meeting with regular Canadians all that much.
00:15:07 I think he'd rather be touring European capitals or chairing cabinet.
00:15:13 And I think that's a huge advantage for Polyev.
00:15:16 If he can, yes, handle question period, but also get out there and keep meeting with Canadians,
00:15:22 he will get the forefront of where they're suffering.
00:15:24 and he can then bring their problems to Parliament Hill
00:15:27 and show where the government is totally falling short.
00:15:30 Well, certainly he has.
00:15:32 He's demonstrated the talent for doing that.
00:15:34 Mr. Carney seems to have, as you say,
00:15:36 he's developed a great talent for charming foreign leaders.
00:15:40 Is that actually very helpful for him?
00:15:42 Does that play well with Canadians?
00:15:44 I think it has over the last six to eight months.
00:15:49 Donald Trump, I think, really made Canadians care
00:15:51 about geopolitics again in a way that they hadn't for a long time because of the urgency of inflation
00:15:58 and the challenges of their economy. That might remain important to people, or it might not.
00:16:04 If they're losing their jobs or cost of living is getting worse, I think, you know, whether
00:16:09 Mark Carney gets along with Emmanuel Macron is just not going to be as important to them.
00:16:16 I think not. I mean, factually, you could make the case that when leaders get too popular overseas,
00:16:21 Often it doesn't play so well at home.
00:16:28 Indeed, and especially when things are bad at home.
00:16:31 You know, when Justin Trudeau was first elected and he was on the cover of Vogue, he was beloved by world leaders, he was kind of a global celebrity.
00:16:41 Canada was doing really well at that point.
00:16:43 People were excited to legalize marijuana and see Canada have a handsome prime minister.
00:16:50 when inflation's up or unemployment's up.
00:16:53 I just think those are lower priorities.
00:16:56 Yes.
00:16:57 Well, that's kind of the way.
00:16:58 That's what I thought you would probably say,
00:17:00 but it does bear on who do you want to be popular with,
00:17:03 and that comes up to the leadership review,
00:17:06 which is what, in January of next year?
00:17:09 It is, yeah, late January in Calgary.
00:17:13 You know, now that Mr. Polly grew up in Alberta and Calgary,
00:17:17 and now that he's an MP from the greater region
00:17:20 I think it makes sense for them to host the convention there.
00:17:23 And I think the leadership is something that the party and the leader need to focus on, make sure that they're prepared for, make sure that he's talking to party members a lot over the coming weeks.
00:17:34 But I also think it's fairly safe territory for him.
00:17:38 Don't forget how much he won the leadership race by and won it very handily.
00:17:43 It was not a close race, really, at all.
00:17:46 And that's because I think the party membership really likes him.
00:17:48 He's just, he's sort of inherently popular with a party membership.
00:17:52 He can't take it for granted, but if he is sort of himself and follows his instincts
00:17:56 and pursues, granted, the same principles that have been driving him since he was 18
00:18:01 years old, I think he will fail well in that review.
00:18:05 Well, let's just push that a little further, Ginny.
00:18:07 I mean, it's not that I don't understand what you're saying, but the narrative that's
00:18:13 been pushed out by the other side is that well you know people don't really like mr polyarvia
00:18:20 there were some young men who were impressed when he took apart a reporter or two and maybe those
00:18:25 reporters deserve to come up but he did it too much and he seemed to enjoy it too much and he's
00:18:31 really not a very nice guy so uh i'm going to vote for that nice mr carney who seemed so quietly
00:18:37 reassuring and of course that's what it in fact did happen there was a demographic that just
00:18:42 Outright rejected Mr. Poliarev, even as there was a whole unexpected one of young blue-collar working-class guys who said, hey, this is the guy.
00:18:53 So, look, what about it?
00:18:57 Is his likability something that he has to deal with, or do we just carry on?
00:19:03 um i think if you focus on likability personality looks too much you risk losing what uh what what
00:19:15 made you appeal to people in the first place the reason voters vote for polyab is because of the
00:19:20 issues and because he seems like the kind of fighter who will fix those issues for them and
00:19:26 i think that's a great true north for him he should stick to the issues that um speak to
00:19:32 people because they're hurting and to show and show them that they that he's sort of the fighter
00:19:36 for them now could he do that in a way that shows that he is both a fighter who can you know tear
00:19:42 apart a journalist with silly questions um and also that he is a good guy uh i think he can i
00:19:50 mean it's interesting but people think he's not not likable um there are a couple uh subject
00:19:56 matters that he really can't even talk about without without crying without breaking out in
00:20:01 getting emotional and I think because he's so sort of laser focused on getting his message out
00:20:08 I don't know that he likes that when that happens you know it happened during the English language
00:20:13 debate it happened on a podcast episode he recorded during the campaign personally I think
00:20:18 it's great when it happens because Canadians get a little small glimpse into the sort of soft side
00:20:24 to him. The part of him that is a dad and a husband and who really is doing this for the
00:20:33 right reasons. He's doing it because he cares. And because when he travels the country, he needs
00:20:37 people who are suffering and he wants to try to find a way to help them. And I think that that
00:20:41 piece, the sort of what motive, the why, why are you doing this? Not just what are you going to do
00:20:45 for me, but why are you doing it at all? That connects with people in a different way and with
00:20:50 different voters who, and I think there are voters who need to see that side of him, so that when
00:20:54 they're making a decision, they say maybe they like him on the issues, but Mark Carney gives
00:20:59 them some comfort on the personality traits front. I think there's a way for Polyev to give people
00:21:05 that comfort on the personality traits front that is authentic to who he is, and that sticks to the
00:21:11 core issues that work for him, like immigration, crime, cost of living. And I hope to see more of
00:21:16 And I think we will.
00:21:18 I'm going to last question is going to be an agree, disagree one.
00:21:22 I'm going to put words in your mouth.
00:21:24 I'm going to say that the worst thing, the worst that things get for Canadians as a consequence of the the economy that the liberals have produced over 10 years and Mr. Carney's inability to do anything substantive about it.
00:21:38 The worst things get for Canadians, the better they get for Mr. Polioff. 0.65
00:21:43 Agree or disagree?
00:21:45 Sadly, I think I agree with that.
00:21:47 It's unfortunate, but it's the life of an opposition leader.
00:21:50 It's a pity it couldn't be won on the grounds of philosophy
00:21:54 and that we all have to suffer so much.
00:21:56 All right, Jenny, it's always a pleasure to talk to you,
00:21:58 and I do thank you for coming on the show at very short notice.
00:22:02 Perhaps we'll talk to you again after Parliament resumes.
00:22:07 Thank you.
00:22:07 Thank you.
00:22:08 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:22:14 Thank you.