Western Standard - November 18, 2026


Is Danielle Smith picking a fight with her own UCP base?

Why Quebec Wants to Talk Trade Directly With the U.S. Liberal lies continue to win Eastern Canadian electoral love

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

179.83

Word count

8,704

Sentence count

192

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 good day today is november 18th 2026 i'm derek full of brent publisher of the western standard
00:00:29 and you're watching the pipeline i've got two of our regulars here today cory morgan
00:00:34 nagel henneford and uh dave is overseas doing interesting things that i will not discuss here
00:00:42 in polite company but uh subbing in is uh the western standards josh andrus i think we'll
00:00:48 actually be seeing a bit more of them uh on these kinds of programs here uh we are going to be
00:00:53 talking about uh the confrontation that seems in the offing coming at the ucp agm some people are
00:01:02 saying oh no it's much ado about nothing it's just a tempest in a teapot from the media maybe uh but
00:01:08 it does seem to me at least that smith is forcing a confrontation uh between her and at least parts
00:01:15 of the independence movement uh related to that perhaps is uh gerrymandering not gerrymandering
00:01:24 of the boundaries of the constituencies in alberta but uh the ucp's own nominations that uh they've
00:01:31 been nominating candidates in old constituencies which no longer exist now that they've redrawn
00:01:37 the boundaries and this gives a free pass on incumbent ucp mlas who have already gone through
00:01:42 these so-called nominations do not face nominations in a new map with new voters that they actually
00:01:48 they now face and uh we're going to talk truthiness and reconciliation uh a high school
00:01:55 student in british columbia kicked out of school for questioning the so-called truth and reconciliation
00:02:01 and uh canadian genocide uh propaganda uh just kicked out of school but also perhaps some good
00:02:10 news the feds have stopped decided to finally stop putting money into searching for bodies in
00:02:15 these mass graves because every single dollar that they put into it seems to not actually be spent on
00:02:22 trying to find any bodies you could you could take your own guess about why no money's actually gone
00:02:29 to finding bodies it's just all gone to consultants and communications and propaganda but why there
00:02:34 are bodies not actually finding any before we get going though i want to thank our sponsor alberta
00:02:38 certified is a new verification service and checks who really owns and operates a business
00:02:44 and lists them in its online directory qualifying companies should apply being certified builds
00:02:50 trust uh gets you found and wins you work the western standard is proudly alberta certified
00:02:56 and we only recommend businesses that we stand by activate your competitive advantage and get
00:03:02 verified at albertacertified.ca okay so we'll start with uh truthiness and reconciliation
00:03:12 uh so we have a 16 year old grade 11 student uh isaac simpson he was permanently barred from his
00:03:20 coquitlam public high school after refusing to remove youtube videos criticizing uh the school's
00:03:27 truth and reconciliation program uh he objected to a speaker's so-called land back talk and an
00:03:34 illustration of nuns and rcmp officers taking indigenous children from their mothers he said
00:03:39 the staff are quote telling you what to think not how to think um so yeah uh he's just kicked out
00:03:49 of school for this now there's some stuff around privacy uh whatnot that he was you know he's got
00:03:54 people's faces on it who might not want to be recorded i don't think there's actually any laws
00:03:58 about that for the most part in canada uh there is in certain u.s states some states is not but
00:04:03 in canada people are surreptitiously recorded all the time you can argue if it's a good thing or bad
00:04:07 thing uh but if it violates privacy policies the school could have just said fine uh you're required
00:04:13 to blur out the faces of these people particularly students teachers i don't think should get a pass
00:04:17 students i can see an argument for you know they're minors uh but that's not the request
00:04:22 they made they said no this must come down it has to go away period um josh we'll start with you
00:04:29 um do you think they're they say they're not publishing punishing for his opinion they're
00:04:37 punishing him for uh privacy violations i find that difficult to believe in an age of tiktok
00:04:44 where everything in a school is recorded and posted on social media oh yeah 100 i think this
00:04:49 is clearly an example of an administration that is basically caught with its pants down is promoting
00:04:56 a controversial uh position when it comes to what it's teaching in the classrooms and is doubling
00:05:04 down with the hammer trying to kill any controversy that it might discuss now from the student
00:05:10 standpoint the timing might not be terrible depending on whether or not he's a grand theft
00:05:14 auto fan because not being that would be a great time that would be a great time to get kicked out
00:05:18 of school i wish i had that idea when i was a kid but what do you mean he can't play it you have to
00:05:23 be 18 to play the game don't you in theory i suppose but yeah he can't play it yeah i think
00:05:29 he can if he really wants to yeah yeah you're usually set up through a parent i'd be proud of
00:05:34 my son i'd be like atta boy yeah he's kicked out of preschool for refusing to do a land acknowledgement
00:05:43 everybody will know whose kid that is but no i think this is what you're seeing throughout
00:05:49 classrooms and it's it's not just an issue in the the k-12 system it's also an issue as
00:05:55 francis widdowson is dealing with in the uh post-secondary system you have a very committed
00:06:02 academic class that has effectively told everybody that the roman catholic church and and other
00:06:10 variations of the like essentially the residential school system is akin to genocide and if you argue
00:06:17 with it that you're effectively kicked out now yeah they're they're making the point that it's
00:06:22 a technicality i don't think this is a technicality i think they are doubling down they are bringing an
00:06:27 extra big hammer down to try and kill any dissent in the classroom and it's what's creating the
00:06:32 issue i mean kids get disciplined all the time it doesn't end up in the media it doesn't end up on
00:06:37 the national news and that's the situation that we're in right now where they've taken a position
00:06:43 on a controversial issue and are doubling down on it yeah i'm not sure what more is to say on
00:06:49 it's self-evidently ridiculous the kid disagrees with the propaganda and and veritable lies that
00:06:56 have been pushed in the classroom and like i i said stuff in high school that was very at the
00:07:03 time controversial but i i never got kicked out i i would argue with teachers about things but
00:07:08 my left-wing teachers would never think to kick me out of class for let alone expel me from the
00:07:14 school for it in this case now although they've latched on the technicality saying uh this is a
00:07:19 privacy violation but again they never made any demand that he has to blur uh the images at least
00:07:25 of the minors and i i could see that although i'm not aware of any other demands being made
00:07:29 for the hundreds of thousands of tiktok videos of students at these schools that probably come
00:07:34 out every year of them doing whatever else they're doing school fights are posted online
00:07:38 all the time and i've never heard of anyone getting expelled for for posting that um
00:07:43 the there is a new government this week being sworn in british columbia
00:07:48 uh dirksen's uh bc conservatives coming in with a big majority mandate
00:07:53 uh they have committed themselves in their platform to repealing dripa
00:07:57 uh a lot of the chiefs including so-called hereditary chiefs um have essentially implied 0.96
00:08:04 they would launch what could be charitably described as civil disobedience and less
00:08:09 charitably described as guerrilla warfare essentially to oppose this saying we don't 0.57
00:08:13 care what kind of democratic mandate you have for it you cannot repeal dripa this is sacred
00:08:18 how do you think the the the Dirksen government is going to approach this coming in with a pretty
00:08:28 hot political climate when it comes to their relationships with aboriginal groups well
00:08:33 carefully but i hope that they are actually as good as their word because what we need is a
00:08:37 government not only there but here in alberta and across canada which is prepared to stand up and say
00:08:44 so much we're sorry about the past but you're not going to teach our kids that their grandfathers
00:08:50 and great-grandfathers were murderers and uh and that there was a an attempt to actually kill
00:08:57 children at school this kid you know the ironic thing here is if this kid just didn't show up
00:09:02 they'd have the they'd have the truancy officer around to the parents say well where is he you
00:09:07 know well now he's actually said what he really thinks they don't want him in school that is uh
00:09:12 i can't help but think that there's a there's a violation of the law right there that if you send
00:09:19 you tell a child he can't be can't be at school when actually they are obliged to educate
00:09:24 there's something there's something wrong with that too the other thing about this uh young
00:09:29 fellow is what he didn't look like a um a descendant of colonialists what do you mean by
00:09:36 that i you know well we put his picture in the western standards so anybody who does what i'm
00:09:41 saying but we'll put his picture up yeah look at this look at this colonial oppressor i'm not sure
00:09:47 why he is is taking this position unless he is somebody who would be very much approve of
00:09:55 a principled young man who is conservatively inclined and doesn't like being told by the
00:10:03 school to believe something and to repeat something a compelled speech argument that is
00:10:08 almost certainly not so. Now, we don't know that for sure, but no convincing proof has been
00:10:17 adduced, only alleged. We might change our tune if we had proof that nuns and priests
00:10:26 murder children, but we have none. So, Corey, I want to bring this towards Drippa more directly
00:10:33 here uh dirksen faces a a tough tough decision even the ndp with um david eby it was well known
00:10:44 they knew internally they had to get rid of drippa this is now a crisis in property rights
00:10:49 to progressive ears this all sounded very nice uh to put into legislation and apply to all
00:10:55 provincial law in bc not thinking that there really would be any real world consequences
00:11:01 but this would make them all feel good it was a virtue signaling exercise they thought but
00:11:06 this was not virtue signaling this has real world consequences now people are having trouble getting
00:11:10 their mortgages renewed um and the you know the conservatives ran on a pretty moderate platform
00:11:17 unfortunately in bc but they did have this in uh as a must-have because the ndp even internally
00:11:24 knew they just backed down at the last second when chiefs threatened to essentially barricade
00:11:28 bridges and roads um so they know they need to do this but the threats being levied by the chiefs
00:11:35 i don't think are necessarily idle pun intended i guess and um how how do you think dirksen is
00:11:45 going to be able to navigate this he has to repeal drippa it is an absolute must it's not something
00:11:50 he can really compromise on but these guys uh the chiefs and the whole industry around them
00:11:56 are accustomed to being treated with deference
00:12:01 and as if their word is essentially sacred
00:12:04 and that they get their way
00:12:06 and that they have a veto
00:12:06 over the rest of British Columbia.
00:12:09 How do you think he navigates this
00:12:10 without sparking major,
00:12:14 at a minimum, civil disobedience
00:12:15 and shutdown of key infrastructure?
00:12:18 I don't know.
00:12:18 I mean, he got himself elected
00:12:19 kind of being that conciliatory middle,
00:12:21 which built that big tent
00:12:23 that allowed him to get through the mess.
00:12:24 I don't think the chiefs are voting for him.
00:12:26 No, no.
00:12:27 At least not these kinds of shows.
00:12:27 And they weren't going to anyway. 0.99
00:12:30 I don't think he can afford to drag his ass on it, though. 0.99
00:12:33 You've got to rip that band-aid off. 0.99
00:12:34 If he doesn't act on it in his first year, he won't.
00:12:37 That's the bottom line.
00:12:39 So the more likely, I hate to say it, but probable political approach is he'll strike some committees.
00:12:45 They'll talk about it here and then.
00:12:46 They'll do some consultation.
00:12:49 They'll circle around it.
00:12:51 And they'll just continue to drag it out until they hope it gets forgotten by the time they hit it.
00:12:55 So you don't think they actually do anything?
00:12:56 I don't think they will. 0.98
00:12:57 I don't think he has the balls to take on the Chiefs. 0.98
00:13:00 As you said, they're going to make noise. 0.99
00:13:02 They're going to block bridges.
00:13:03 If you want to get rid of it, it also means you have to stand up and say,
00:13:06 I'm sorry, guys, but you don't have the right to do this.
00:13:09 We can talk about things.
00:13:11 We can negotiate things.
00:13:12 But this is going out the door, whether you have a tantrum or not.
00:13:15 And he doesn't have that sort of, I don't see that sort of backbone in him
00:13:19 to take that on.
00:13:20 And that's the only way it's going to happen, though.
00:13:22 They have to have it out.
00:13:24 I think he would have to be prepared to use force because the chiefs are saying they are going to use force.
00:13:30 They're going to use force to block bridges, block infrastructure.
00:13:36 And short periods of that, we kind of tend to accept as part of the price of a democratic society and that, you know, the dissenting minority can can make a real fuss.
00:13:47 But we do have limits to how far you can do it.
00:13:50 you know like on the other side let's we should try to be consistent with ourselves you know i i
00:13:55 think most of us were pretty sympathetic with say with the coots blockade but that should go that
00:14:01 goes to an extent and they they knew when to through when the test when to end that they
00:14:05 ended it but if they had continued that even though i was very sympathetic with it it would
00:14:10 have been reasonable and i think the public's fatigued with this i really do i i we're seeing
00:14:15 backing off from the federal even on that front you know i think you're moving towards that on
00:14:19 this with the language even i mean i know they're taking baby steps towards it but they only do that
00:14:24 if they realize the citizens are getting tired of this too i mean it's they understand reasonable
00:14:29 dissent they understand you know some degree of protest but it's just chronic it's never ending
00:14:34 it seems that it's will never resolve it and i i think to a degree and when people are fearing for
00:14:39 their mortgages and their property the times are never going to be better electorally if he's
00:14:43 looking at the hole again to have it out i mean you don't want to go in there with the tanks and 0.60
00:14:46 But we're probably looking at the possibility of another kind of Oka crisis. 0.74
00:14:50 Eventually, it'll have to get to the point of them tearing down blockades. 0.76
00:14:53 I mean, I know it's me speaking of it.
00:14:55 I'm sick and tired of us being held hostage by these guys.
00:14:58 The interesting thing is what Ottawa is going to make of it, because obviously reconciliation is a priority for the federal government.
00:15:06 The federal government is sending many signals now that it's not totally comfortable with the narrative.
00:15:13 The fact that they are not prepared to extend funding for excavations to determine whether bodies are buried in certain places after three years when funding has been made available, but no actual work has been done, suggests to me that there is a backing away from this narrative.
00:15:37 They can't do it all at once, but they are not defending it.
00:15:41 Some of the Parks Canada write-ups have been modified and don't talk about it in the way they did five years ago.
00:15:49 On the other hand, if you get a very provocative motion, like Mr. Dirksen going and saying, right, this is it for DRIPA, we're introducing the legislation, and here we go, then that puts Ottawa on the spot.
00:16:02 What will they do?
00:16:03 Well, and I've always had questions about the concept of reconciliation when the Indian Act is still in effect. 0.86
00:16:10 like you still have reservation systems you still have mass poverty amongst the members of those
00:16:19 bands and i think that the indian act itself just being in place means that reconciliation
00:16:26 is a never-ending money trade and you can back off on certain aspects of it but you can never
00:16:32 properly reconcile when you are still committing any degree of atrocity whether you call what the
00:16:39 reservation system and atrocity is a secondary question i might let derek say it but i mean
00:16:44 you're you're in a position where you have an entire system in place you're trying to reconcile
00:16:50 a problem but the problem is still ongoing and it's not going to be resolved until the indian
00:16:54 act is in my opinion uh phased out well we're not going to get any reconciliation until we have at
00:17:00 least a little bit of truth which is uh look what i would have when a kid tried to seek it
00:17:05 yeah yeah out of school exactly i mean right before grand theft auto though that yeah timing
00:17:10 couldn't have been much better for him okay uh let's talk about um the ucp gerrymandering its
00:17:19 own nominations so you know people have probably seen in the news the ndp accusing the ucp of
00:17:24 gerrymandering uh the new constituency map in alberta that's based on the ucp declining to
00:17:32 accept the majority report of the first commission that that drew this stuff up um and the they
00:17:39 struck a second commission essentially with some different terms and it presented kind of a
00:17:42 compromise uh of it the ndp are still saying it's it's gerrymandered that's neither here nor there
00:17:48 frankly i don't care if the ucp gerrymandered this one because the ndp gerrymandered the map
00:17:53 when i was there and they they completely got rid of my constituency and blended it into others
00:17:58 so they gerrymandered the shit out of it last time so if the ucp want to gerrymander it right
00:18:03 back you know what's good for the goose is good for the gander i is it a little bit yeah it's 0.91
00:18:09 probably a little bit i don't think it's that extreme it's not as extreme as what the ndp
00:18:13 didn't when they had the reins for this in 2015 um but that's neither here nor there i'll let the
00:18:18 ucp and the ndp debate that what is definitely sure is that the ucp have been gerrymandering
00:18:24 their own nominations within these new boundaries. So what they've been doing for the last year or so
00:18:31 is they've been holding nominations where they're essentially getting in to quickly
00:18:36 acclaim incumbent UCP MLAs to get them acclaimed as the candidate for the next election,
00:18:42 but they acclaim them as the candidate under the old boundaries. So for me, I live west of Calgary,
00:18:49 outside of the city in the county, in Rocky View County, and the UCP have created some of these
00:18:54 hybrid constituencies. And so you've got writings like Calgary Bow that have areas like Bowness and
00:19:01 stuff and Cougar Ridge, Crestmont, Valley Ridge, things like that. And they've extended it way out
00:19:07 into the county to bring in and it brings in more conservative leaning voters in places like where
00:19:12 I live. That's where the NDP accused them of gerrymandering. But what about UCP members,
00:19:18 members of the party who live in a place like me we now have a candidate for us who was nominated 0.59
00:19:25 under a completely different boundary system who was an urban mla i've got no real beef with that
00:19:31 guy i think he's probably a good candidate i wouldn't see a reason to challenge him but
00:19:34 if i was a ucp member i feel like i should have some say in that and they so they've been imposing
00:19:40 this uh this happened at least was attempted to take place the last time in 2015 the last time
00:19:46 it was a boundary redraw brian gene wild rose leader at the time tried to quickly do that with
00:19:51 a bunch of incumbent wild rose mlas to try and get them to be less eager for the idea of a merger
00:19:58 with pcs to form the ucp because they would already have their nominations they're locked
00:20:01 in to win their seat next time that in the end that faded apart because the ucp was created in
00:20:07 the end but uh it was not done with the most let's call it charitable of intentions then i'm
00:20:14 doubtful to think it's being done with the most charitable intentions this time. But it is
00:20:18 depriving United Conservative Party members in very significant parts of the province of the right
00:20:25 to have any say whatsoever in selecting their candidate. Corey, I know you're working on a
00:20:30 call on this. Yeah, and I've looked at it and the numbers are high. Look, if the UCP wants to do
00:20:37 something fast, they do it fast. If they want to get this done, they didn't have to wait this long
00:20:44 as well they could have moved along and and they also seem to be doing it more in those roddings
00:20:48 that were expected to change it used to be knew those writings yeah so they're moving faster in
00:20:53 those roddings first those should be the ones theoretically you would defer you'd say well
00:20:56 wait a minute they're in question we're going to hold the nomination a little later and why i i'm
00:21:02 stumped i mean they well i'm not stumped as to why but i i just feel that they're picking some
00:21:07 battles with their own that i are really really dangerous i mean we're speaking you and i have
00:21:12 direct experience of the last time the conservatives in alberta went into a bad civil war and what it
00:21:17 took to get out of it and these guys are just sitting landmines around themselves all over the
00:21:22 place and taking off their base i i it's just uh we'll get to i know there's more i'm not going in
00:21:30 this is just one of those aspects and i and i wrote on it because a lot to be explained because
00:21:35 your average voter doesn't look at this stuff this is inside ball this is wonky stuff for people like
00:21:39 us uh but i like to make it clear you know people have kind of two opportunities to pick their
00:21:44 representative one's in the general election of course but the other is in a nomination and you're
00:21:48 being robbed of that in a whole bunch of these constituencies which is a violation of another
00:21:54 level of democratic right i mean i understand it's just within that party but it's still
00:21:58 seriously problematic and and and why well you know it's not that you're wrong but i'm just
00:22:05 wondering how big a deal this really is the last time i went to a nomination people a meeting there
00:22:11 were like 18 people there well but you're talking about the days when there used to be 800 for an
00:22:16 agm like writings we're talking about we've got thousands of people coming to an agm now this is
00:22:22 an engaged membership in ways that they've never seen and here's my issue with it so in my opinion
00:22:28 they fumbled the initial report so you have a bunch of guys that work in the legislature that
00:22:33 fumbled it and then they've now had to fix it through a secondary report but in the process
00:22:39 they re-nominated all the guys that fumbled it so like you have a fumble ruski situation that is now
00:22:45 embedded in it and it's for a lot of people who are engaged grassroots supporters they are the
00:22:51 ones who are noticing that hey i didn't get a chance to vote for my candidate because they
00:22:56 changed the riding boundaries and now i'm stuck with this guy like so i'm gonna go with the nvp
00:23:01 no but no they form another party that's the risk where it's like you continue to throw molotov
00:23:07 cocktails into an already like it's like there's a gas leak in the party everybody's mad about the
00:23:13 referendum and you're just throwing molotov cocktails into the room trying to put the fire
00:23:18 out but it's just burning even wider it to me is an absolute disgrace so this is generally the
00:23:24 reason you want to do this is to protect incumbents who might be at risk or um and then therefore
00:23:33 gain loyalty from that member of the caucus to the leader that's that's in large measure why
00:23:39 brian gene attempted to do this that was with the added backdrop of getting them to be vested in
00:23:44 not merging with the pcs and form the ucp that was that was an additional to it also be that you
00:23:49 don't want to see somebody who you know is against what you're trying to do get nominated
00:23:54 yes yeah yeah so you have uh in this case uh so it's happening generally in the two bigs around
00:24:02 the two big cities and uh actually sort of in lethbridge as well uh no definitely a lot
00:24:06 yeah so it's happening in lethbridge uh and it's happening in calgary and edmonton and
00:24:14 And at least in the areas I'm more familiar with, you know, greater Calgary area, I'm not necessarily sure any of the people in these new merged ridings that got nominated under the old boundaries.
00:24:26 I'm not sure any of them were particularly great risk.
00:24:31 Maybe they were, but I'm not aware that they were.
00:24:34 They seemed relatively solid.
00:24:36 But when you're when you're in a solid conservative seat, losing the general election is not how you you're not going to lose the general election.
00:24:43 the way you lose your seat is in a nomination and you know the leader is hesitant normally to
00:24:49 outright appoint a candidate because that looks bad this is a lighter way of helping secure them
00:24:55 because if you have an MLA and they've got their current constituency and they've been an MLA there
00:24:59 for four or eight or more years they've built a loyal base among the membership normally normally
00:25:06 that's the case and they have an easier time winning nomination in that all of a sudden you
00:25:10 add a bunch of new voters to the mix and therefore new ucp members because if you you've expanded
00:25:15 the boundaries they have no they might be loyal to the party or to the leader or something but
00:25:20 they're not necessarily loyal to that individual candidate they might want someone else this is
00:25:26 probably a way of danielle smith shoring up support among these mlas who are gonna who have 0.85
00:25:32 adjusted boundaries and protecting them if she feels she definitely wants them in you would 1.00
00:25:37 definitely see if she didn't want them in they wouldn't have gotten these early nominations
00:25:40 they would have been deferred till later but as cory says all most of these early nominations
00:25:46 done under the old boundaries they mostly took place in the constituencies where the ucp was
00:25:52 very clearly planning because we saw their original plan it was publicly disclosed where
00:25:57 they were planning on changing the boundaries yet that is where they nominated first this is very
00:26:01 intentional well i think you're probably right on that uh derek i'm just trying to look at it from
00:26:06 And how I would analyze that if I had ever been asked to pass an opinion to the political leadership, if there's some bad stuff to do, do it now.
00:26:18 Don't let it fester for the year running up to the general election.
00:26:24 You don't want stories coming out every second week about internal party strife over things like nominations.
00:26:33 and we all know if that whether it is done by fiddling around with the boundaries or whether
00:26:40 it's simply a matter of a party leader saying no we don't want that person and they just get
00:26:46 scratched this has happened in the ucp well that's what kenny did more often i it was matter of fact
00:26:52 it was yes exactly and uh so we we know that the leadership is going to do whatever it can
00:27:01 do to put the people in front of the voters that it wants to put in front of the voters and
00:27:07 not people who are going to be difficult cantankerous or have something in their past
00:27:13 you know an old post on twitter as it then was that may be dragged out by the other side and
00:27:20 made into an issue so it's a little bit like that saying that they they start off law school with
00:27:26 They say, if you don't like sausages and you don't like the law, don't watch either being made.
00:27:33 This is the grubby underside of what we're dealing with.
00:27:36 You're paraphrasing Bismarck. I like it.
00:27:39 Bismarck wasn't always wrong. 1.00
00:27:42 He was almost always right, especially about the French. 1.00
00:27:47 That's low-hanging fruit. 1.00
00:27:50 Even the Brits got to harumph that one. 0.95
00:27:52 You've just lost your two viewers in the crete.
00:27:56 um okay uh well this is this segues nicely i think into the confrontation that is in the
00:28:05 offing for the upcoming ucp uh convention agm this is just one of the things probably adding
00:28:12 fuel to the fire the big thing is uh uh around the independence question and how
00:28:20 So UCP members who supported independence or continue to support independence are allowed to fit in.
00:28:28 The party, and these things don't do in a vacuum without the knowledge of the leader.
00:28:33 We know how these things work, has a requirement that everyone running for the party's board in elections, half the board is up for election every year, that they have to sign a loyalty pledge.
00:28:45 kind of like it's somewhat akin to after you know the united states civil war during reconstruction
00:28:52 uh everyone who fought for or supported the confederacy was disenfranchised they're not
00:28:56 allowed to vote as the states were being readmitted to the union uh and they had to
00:29:01 uh say the pledge of allegiance which included the part you know the country is undivisible
00:29:08 under god um so essentially this is a pledge of allegiance to federalism that uh party members
00:29:14 are required to sign in a document uh it's highly questionable if the party has the legal right under
00:29:19 the party's bylaws to do this that's big question but and it's also being required of everyone
00:29:25 who wishes to remain or run for a local constituency party uh president position
00:29:31 um so in the lead up to this there are at least 15 of 87 constituency presidents who say they will
00:29:39 not sign the revised code of conduct which says they're not allowed to pursue independence in the
00:29:44 future it doesn't say they're banned if they ever supported independence but they're not allowed
00:29:48 to actively pursue it um i think most maybe not all but most understand hey they lost the
00:29:54 referendum they lost it by a fairly wide margin obviously you got to take some time to figure
00:30:00 things out if it's not happening tomorrow if it's ever happening i think most of them understand
00:30:05 that but uh they're taking very poorly to being given this loyalty pledge uh which they see is
00:30:11 against their right to free speech to to democratic representation within the party
00:30:14 um so so i know uh josh you you've done some work uh on this uh it doesn't look like all 87
00:30:25 constituency presidents are going to be signing this uh loyalty pledge no and so the original
00:30:30 deadline was for last friday um that was extended uh i believe it was friday uh they sent an
00:30:37 extension out now it's due uh thursday so that would be tomorrow this is have they changed their
00:30:44 minds they uh i have not heard whether or not that has been extended but i have heard that there are
00:30:49 more than 15 i have heard that there were only 15 that signed the original letter that there are
00:30:54 others that weren't uh a part of that original 15 that have come forward and want to be a part
00:30:59 of this uh i don't want to call it an outright rebellion but this is a refusal to bend to the
00:31:06 knee and kiss the ring of those in the legislature and i and i think both topics kind of have
00:31:12 a similar uh undercurrent uh this is again a top down they are making decisions in the premier's
00:31:21 office and through cabinet that are being filtered down and it is it very much about this is our way
00:31:27 or the highway now if you run into situations as we've seen in the past with this uh group of
00:31:33 decision makers they have a tendency to get dome disease where they are effectively making all the
00:31:38 decisions and if you want to be a part of the united conservative party you have to effectively
00:31:45 swear allegiance to what they decide we saw it in 2012 after uh the lake of fire um start uh they
00:31:54 lost an election allegedly well actually i don't think it's allegedly i think it's
00:31:58 um uh you know there was there were some incidents i i think one of the candidates for
00:32:04 uh one of the calgary ridings had uh yeah people know what the lake of fire is but i think what
00:32:10 you're referring to is the convention in uh the reaction november of 2014 smith tried to pass a
00:32:17 policy which was very clumsily worded and had it was like essentially a dei diversity we love
00:32:23 everyone and it just kind of pissed everyone off like a version of it could have passed but it was
00:32:28 worded in a way that was it pissed everyone off and she had staked her political capital on it
00:32:32 and then the wild rose membership of the agm voted against it and that was part of the series of
00:32:38 events that was involved with her then crossing the floor with two-thirds of the wild rose caucus
00:32:43 and it just it escalated like the she'd raised the stakes to the membership at an agm and the
00:32:48 membership like she played chicken with them and the membership did not swerve yeah and i think
00:32:54 that's kind of the situation that we have yeah i have 15 constituency association presidents
00:32:58 refusing to sign a declaration of loyalty is one thing it's it's the rationale behind it now smith
00:33:06 went on rick bell and said that it was only independent supporters that were opposing this
00:33:10 that is not not the case and the fact that she would use that label to talk about something that
00:33:17 the constituency association presidents are just they don't want to sign a loyalty pledge because
00:33:22 of the precedence that it sets if you get someone to sign a loyalty pledge on one issue what's to
00:33:27 stop it from doing another if if rob anderson and danielle smith decide that they're going to
00:33:32 double the budget are you going to have to sign a loyalty pledge for that i mean what
00:33:36 where's the line here i mean when you start down this path you set yourself up to have that level
00:33:43 of opposition and in this party that is a usually the first sign that your your leadership is up in
00:33:49 flames and they're having to buy support of cabinet members who didn't support her when she
00:33:54 first became the leader like i i am i'm watching this with a great deal of concern about the
00:34:03 decisions that are being made in edmonton and how little they're paying attention to the grassroots
00:34:09 membership in the volunteer base that's supposed to show up knock doors and deliver a victory for
00:34:14 us so yeah it's uh i almost wonder if they have a death wish on this it's you know in her interview
00:34:24 with you cory uh i think it was yesterday right uh it ran yesterday it was monday night yeah um
00:34:29 you know she said she's used a light touch with the independence movement until recently
00:34:33 and i think that was true up to a point you know she was performing a very delicate balancing act
00:34:39 and for a long time I think did a very good incredible delicate job of doing that I think
00:34:44 it's been less than a light touch lately the term I used was ham-handed in the interview because it
00:34:49 just feels like how it is yeah it seems to me that this is an unforced error on her part there are
00:34:58 some intractable personalities you got the Jeff Raths of the world who just hate her one are gone
00:35:03 and it seems fairly personal um but i think most independent supporters who are in the ucp right
00:35:10 now that was the wing that voted to make her the leader in the first place these are not people who
00:35:14 are who are intrinsically hostile to her they're people who are probably naturally sympathetic to
00:35:19 her but you know uh her reaction coming from the referendum uh and leading up to it and then this
00:35:28 whole loyalty pledge essentially following jason kenney's uh advice uh or demands to expel people
00:35:34 uh this seems to me to be a her pick in a fight that is not going to end well no and and and
00:35:44 one of the things if you look at all the 15 names though on that letter well it stands out because
00:35:49 when she said it was gordon talk he's a pretty everybody knows gordon well and gordon's also a
00:35:54 hardcore federalist he was a thorn in my butt through that whole campaign in opposition to
00:35:58 He's controlling me on independent stuff, yeah. 0.75
00:36:00 But he's also very pedantic when it comes to policy and issues.
00:36:05 Gord talk in his failed Sylvan Lake.
00:36:08 Exactly.
00:36:09 I don't know, I was pretending to hold a microphone.
00:36:11 Get ready.
00:36:11 You're going to hear that a lot next Saturday.
00:36:14 And he signed that letter, though.
00:36:17 That's not coming from the independence front.
00:36:18 That's the complete other side.
00:36:19 That's a principled man saying, I do not want to be involved in a party that's telling me what I can think and say.
00:36:25 You know, guys, you can either have a super principal party in opposition or you can have a party that's in government.
00:36:31 Or you could win with principal.
00:36:32 I don't think you have to throw everything in the toilet and crush because we've seen that error happen.
00:36:37 We've got to get this stuff out of the way at the convention.
00:36:40 It wasn't in the way.
00:36:41 This is putting the stuff right in the way.
00:36:43 This is forcing a confrontation where I think they could have gotten through.
00:36:46 Because what you don't want is, if you are the leader, you do not want a year's worth of stories about people breaking ranks.
00:36:55 You've got to get everybody on site, have the discussion.
00:36:58 You've got 7,000 people to have the discussion with.
00:37:01 Get it over and done with.
00:37:03 But respectfully, Nigel, I think this is achieving the precise opposite.
00:37:07 I'm in agreement with you, but I think this is saying you've got to.
00:37:11 She's going to spend the next year acting as the premier, not the party leader.
00:37:13 I think she's going to be fighting for her life now as a result of this.
00:37:16 I think that she's like, I mean, we're at the point I'm hearing rumors that we could have as many as 23 constituency association presidents that refuse to sign the pledge.
00:37:25 And I'd like to point out that you only need a quarter of the 87, which is 22.
00:37:30 So she's at the point where she went from 15, doubled down and is now at 23, potentially 23 constituency association presidents.
00:37:38 Now, I haven't confirmed that.
00:37:39 These guys are going to be so committed to their principles that they're going to screw the whole thing up.
00:37:44 Or is she going to be so committed to the hammer that she infuriates?
00:37:49 And, like, I mean, the base is, it's difficult to keep in line because everybody is so, like, I mean, it's, it is.
00:37:58 But she knows these people.
00:37:59 She forced this kind of confrontation as the Wild Rose leader in November 2014.
00:38:06 And they did not swerve in that confrontation.
00:38:09 and it was a part of a series of events that ended in disaster
00:38:13 and gave us the NDP.
00:38:15 I fear, you know, it's not repeating, but it's certainly rhyming here,
00:38:21 that she is forcing a confrontation with these people
00:38:24 when it was not required.
00:38:26 Well, you may be right.
00:38:29 It's turning people like me off.
00:38:31 I think of myself as pretty reasonable.
00:38:32 I have this sense that she wants to get control, keep control,
00:38:36 and then leave it behind for the run-up to the next election,
00:38:41 that would make some sense.
00:38:42 I think leading with a hammer is a good way to lose support. 0.98
00:38:46 And I think that the issue that she has is...
00:38:50 Have you noticed one thing, Josh? 0.64
00:38:51 The liberals have no principles.
00:38:54 This kind of stuff never comes up in the Liberal Party in the open.
00:38:58 It doesn't come up in the Democrats in the United States.
00:39:01 They just do whatever they feel like they need to do in order to retain power.
00:39:05 I'm not suggesting that Danielle Smith is or should act like a liberal, but sometimes you've just got to set this stuff aside. 1.00
00:39:13 I think what we're saying, though, is what she's doing won't help her retain power. 1.00
00:39:16 She doesn't understand her own base. 1.00
00:39:17 They will toss her in the dumpster. 0.62
00:39:19 I'm seeing some voices actually saying maybe we need four years of Nenshi.
00:39:23 That chills me to the bone.
00:39:25 I've barely been on here because I'm so uninspired by what I'm seeing.
00:39:29 Hasn't remembered the four years of Rachel Knopf.
00:39:31 These are the people who are the volunteers, the donors, the ground workers.
00:39:34 also i'd like to point out that the bc conservatives turfed their leader and won an
00:39:40 election 45 days later so i the the concept that we're too close to an election to have this
00:39:45 discussion i mean they had internal fighting and still formed a majority year out is a good time
00:39:50 and remember if you're right and i'm wrong jason kenny was turfed a year out yeah if you're right
00:39:56 and i'm wrong then this is the time to get no i would like to be wrong because i would like her
00:40:00 to not bring the hammer down as much
00:40:02 as she is. I want to see
00:40:05 her win an election next year 0.98
00:40:07 with a majority.
00:40:08 The last thing I heard
00:40:10 was her telling Rick Bell
00:40:12 that everybody
00:40:14 would be dealt with respectfully.
00:40:16 I don't know what that actually means.
00:40:18 It means signing a pledge or getting
00:40:20 kicked off the board.
00:40:22 It doesn't sound very respectful.
00:40:24 You can say something
00:40:26 respectful. 1.00
00:40:29 Respectfully, f*** off. 0.99
00:40:30 you know we're gonna have to believe that um i've said tweets sort of like that 0.98
00:40:36 uh with all due respect yes may i please invite you to yes uh i think cory put it well that she's
00:40:44 not understanding her own base and she's done this before and then she seemed to understand them and
00:40:50 her you know her efforts to rehabilitate herself when she was on radio and when she had a show on
00:40:54 western standard she seemed to understand the base again it looks like she's losing that yet
00:41:01 again like if you know these people like if you know gore talk i know most people watch you don't
00:41:06 know gore talk i mean with all due respect gore talk he's a pedantic guy and he's a workhorse and
00:41:13 he's but he's a workhorse for the party he you know he he helps and he's there committee he can
00:41:19 be on yeah i like the guy is it's like a full-time job for the guy and he was on the he's a hardline
00:41:24 federalist he was against the independent side hard during the campaign but he's not signing 0.73
00:41:28 because he sees this is bullshit if you understand this culture here i think the reason she can't be
00:41:34 like the federal liberals even if she wanted to because the party's fundamentally different it's 0.95
00:41:39 it's got an activist base it's not just a bunch of lobbyist donor class and that lobbyist donor
00:41:43 class is there well that's your basic support base well and i do want her to calm it down like i would
00:41:48 like to see that i want to see this resolved and i want to see them win an election and that's why
00:41:52 one of the things she said to bell was well i'm going to call up these presidents talk to them
00:41:55 that was one of the first questions i asked because i thought okay that's a good strategy
00:41:58 actually just pick up the phone and interact it's only 15 people i know she's busy but
00:42:02 it's well worth it in this case and that was one of my first questions in the interview
00:42:05 was well have you started calling and communicating with them and she gave me word
00:42:09 no she's busy with like galas and stuff like that so i mean i offered that i was hoping to
00:42:14 get the answer saying yes i've called seven of them and we've talked and you know i'm starting
00:42:18 to understand where they're coming from but instead i got a political answer which kind
00:42:21 darn it you know are you not realizing the risk perhaps that you might be igniting uh again you're
00:42:27 in a cloistered world up there you don't necessarily remember what who brung you to the 0.99
00:42:31 dance and well it's this is like classic counter insurgency and not to compare ucp members to
00:42:37 terrorists but you know you could you launch a drone strike and don't even start now i mean
00:42:43 the party launches a drone strike at a wedding and yeah you got one troublesome guy but then
00:42:48 you've created a bunch of other insurgents counterinsurgency it could be damn near impossible
00:42:53 because you whack one and you create a bunch more so yeah no sorry i'm not comparing gourd
00:42:59 to al-qaeda or wrath for that matter comparing jeffrey wrath to osama bin laden uh completely
00:43:07 but um but you know that's the problem here like and and this is the party culture you know of the
00:43:15 right the populace right in alberta it never works jason kenney tried this and look how well
00:43:21 it worked for him daniel smith herself tried it as wild rose leader it didn't work uh and it yeah
00:43:29 it's hurting cats these are extremely difficult people to lead but she was leading them like she
00:43:34 did a good job for a while there was a time where you had free alberta strategy rob and daniel smith
00:43:41 in the Alberta Sovereignty Act and they were standing up to Ottawa
00:43:44 and they were getting results.
00:43:45 93% at the AGM two years ago.
00:43:47 Now you have an MOU with Mark Carney.
00:43:49 You have an immigration referendum which passed,
00:43:51 yet they aren't moving on it because there's a lot of moving pieces.
00:43:54 Apparently they didn't do any preparation before the referendum.
00:43:57 I don't understand what that was about.
00:43:59 But they aren't moving.
00:44:01 No preparation.
00:44:02 This is a government that if anything happens with this MOU,
00:44:06 they are sitting ducks, they have no defense,
00:44:09 and maybe then we'll see free Alberta
00:44:11 Danielle, but at this point in time, I think
00:44:13 Rob Anderson should change his Twitter handle.
00:44:15 Okay. Which is what?
00:44:17 Free Alberta, Rob. It should be within
00:44:19 a United Canada, Rob.
00:44:21 Okay. We're going to have to put a pin into their
00:44:23 parting shots. I'll give the first one
00:44:25 to Josh. All right.
00:44:27 Yeah, we've got the
00:44:29 I think, I don't know what it's called.
00:44:31 Calry-Lougheed is holding a UCP
00:44:33 candidates debate tonight,
00:44:35 obviously with the deadline tomorrow. You're going for the provincial
00:44:37 board candidates. For the provincial board candidates,
00:44:39 obviously with everything that's going on with the ca presidents that will be a interesting thing i
00:44:45 don't know how far the party is going to go to actually enforce this uh clause that or the uh
00:44:50 loyalty pledge that they've made the candidates signed because i think that some candidates may
00:44:54 be a little bit offside depending on how you define the terms of that uh agreement or whatever
00:45:00 you want to call it some independence candidates have said i still support independence i'm going
00:45:04 sign it yeah kick me out kick me out but it gets to the point where it's like how many people like
00:45:09 if you're kicking out like that and then guys who actually do support the contents of the pledge
00:45:14 like gordon talker are like i'm not signing it make me yeah like i jeff wrath i understood getting
00:45:19 the door i totally understand that when you're not gonna get any argument from me but are you
00:45:23 gonna kick out 50 people uh because they are not going along with your absolute iron-fisted approach
00:45:31 you may have a bigger rebellion on your hands
00:45:34 that's it on fisting from
00:45:36 Josh
00:45:36 Nigel
00:45:38 people who like Dr. Sylvain Charlebois
00:45:42 the Canada food professor
00:45:44 will like to tune in
00:45:46 to the Hannaford show tomorrow night
00:45:48 at 7 o'clock
00:45:49 he joins me for 20 minutes
00:45:51 and he tells me this interesting tidbit
00:45:53 that
00:45:54 there is a deal in the works
00:45:57 he believes
00:45:58 that we will bring the price of beef down,
00:46:02 we being the federal government,
00:46:04 I am making a deal with the South American states,
00:46:07 Brazil, Argentina, and so forth,
00:46:09 mass imports of South American beef
00:46:11 in order to bring down the price of beef.
00:46:14 If they will bring down the price of beef,
00:46:16 I will listen respectfully to their policy platform.
00:46:20 I'm not sure what our beef counter-wrenchers might think.
00:46:24 Consumers will like it.
00:46:25 All right, well, a shameless plug for your parting shot.
00:46:29 What do you got?
00:46:30 It was.
00:46:31 It was good.
00:46:32 It was good.
00:46:32 Anybody who's been wondering if Doug Ford is looking for the federal throne,
00:46:36 watch his speech to the chamber the other day when he tried to speak French.
00:46:40 Oh, my Lord.
00:46:42 Holy cow.
00:46:43 Just play 10 seconds of Doug Ford.
00:46:45 The great tweet was me at 2.15 a.m. in Montreal trying to order shawarma.
00:46:52 Play 10 seconds of Doug Ford speaking.
00:46:54 So either way, unless Rosetta Stone performs a miracle,
00:47:07 I don't think Mr. Ford's going to be going anywhere on the federal front.
00:47:11 All right.
00:47:14 Bienvenue.
00:47:15 Merci, Monsieur Corey Morgan.
00:47:20 Je m'appelle Josh.
00:47:21 that's good is that right yeah me ammo cory all right that's that's that's all i got there
00:47:28 all right and uh my party shot uh with all due respect you too just making all the beeps we
00:47:36 yeah yeah with all due respect okay uh cory nigel josh thank you very much thank you john
00:47:43 on production i thank all of you who have joined us here on the pipeline and a special thanks to
00:47:47 Those of you who are subscribers to the Western Standard, if you're not yet a subscriber, go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe, $100 a year or $10 a month for unlimited access or upgrade to the Editor's Circle for extra perks.
00:48:00 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:48:17 Thank you.