Western Standard - April 17, 2025


Is Ford angling for Poilievre’s job?

Topics
Mentioned
Where the Sun Don’t Shine: Rural Alberta rises up against solar farms Federal leaders' debate

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

162.5

Word count

8,041

Sentence count

434

Harmful content

Misogyny

3

sentences flagged

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

What is Doug Ford up to? Is he angling to take over Pierre Poutine's job, or is he actually trying to save the Tories from defeat in the upcoming election? And what s going on in the Tory war room?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 China's killing our canola.
00:00:07 Forty-five billion dollars gone.
00:00:10 Western farmers bleed.
00:00:13 Mark Carney?
00:00:14 Silent.
00:00:16 Made millions off Beijing's dime.
00:00:19 He won't fight.
00:00:20 He's Beijing's banker, not our prime minister.
00:00:30 Good day, I'm Derek Fultebrand, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:58 Today is April 16th, 2025, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:01:03 I'm joined by our usual host, lineup of guest co-hosts, Nigel Henniford, opinion editor of the Western Standard.
00:01:11 Great to be here again.
00:01:13 And Corey Morgan, senior Alberta columnist.
00:01:16 Always a pleasure.
00:01:17 Also joining us, special co-host today is Erica Beruce.
00:01:22 She is a columnist for the Western Standard and I forget the exact title, but one of the bosses over at Macamie College.
00:01:31 What's the official title, Erica?
00:01:33 Yeah, so I look over or I oversee our external relations and then I'm the department head for applied politics and public affairs.
00:01:39 There you go. Whatever that means, I assure you, she's very smart. 0.89
00:01:43 I can tell you all about it anytime.
00:01:44 All right. Well, we've got a, today's got a pretty common theme in the show.
00:01:51 It's conservative disunity, both inside and outside of the mainstream conservative parties.
00:01:59 Or do we talk about what is Doug Ford, Ontario Premier Doug Ford, up to?
00:02:03 Is he angling to take Pierre Polyev's job?
00:02:06 Is he helping to, if he loses the election, is he actually hoping he might lose the election?
00:02:12 uh will maxine bernier's people's party play spoiler and some ridings with the conservatives
00:02:20 whether in tight races with liberals what's the ppc trying to achieve in this election
00:02:24 and uh in bc so what are some of my favorite conservative uh infighting is in the bc conservative
00:02:31 party uh where they well maybe they might be teaming up with the ndp to quash a private
00:02:39 members bill from some rebel, now former conservative MLA, who was kicked out by their
00:02:46 leader, John Rustad. We'll be talking about some of the infighting going on in that party.
00:02:52 All right. And before we get started, though, this episode of The Pipeline is sponsored
00:02:56 by New World Precious Metals, based right here in Alberta. Years of inflationary money
00:03:01 printing and rising debt have decimated the average Canadian savings. Gold and silver
00:03:05 are the only currencies that have held their value for
00:03:07 thousands of years. Last year
00:03:09 saw 30% gains. New World Precious
00:03:11 Metals offers unique platforms to help
00:03:13 protect and grow your
00:03:15 hard-earned wealth with silver and gold.
00:03:17 Check them out at newworldpm.com
00:03:19 Alright.
00:03:22 We're going to start off
00:03:23 with what is Doug Ford up
00:03:25 to? He's
00:03:27 certainly been a figure in the
00:03:29 campaign here. Is he angling
00:03:31 to take Pierre Polyev's job?
00:03:33 Erica, why don't you
00:03:34 at the table for us. Yeah. So I think for before a lot of your listeners are shocked to question
00:03:41 if Doug Ford is a Conservative or not, let's kind of look from where this is coming. And
00:03:46 earlier this week after Corey tonight has had several media appearances and an appearance at
00:03:54 the Canada Strong and Free conference where he has been criticizing Jenny Byrne and the Conservative
00:03:59 party of Canada's war room or head of office for their campaign strategies. Now, Corey Tanike
00:04:05 has ran all of Doug Ford's elections. So then the now premier and former candidate under Corey
00:04:15 Tanike, Doug Ford, was asked about these allegations. I think media was trying to get
00:04:19 between Corey Tanike, a longtime progressive conservative campaign strategist, and Jenny
00:04:25 Burns, a longtime conservative strategist who is the campaign manager and a senior advisor to Pierre
00:04:30 Paglia, asking Doug Ford in a press conference earlier this week how he felt about his former
00:04:37 campaign manager's comments. He said the truth hurts. So it looks like, you know, Premier Doug
00:04:45 Ford is siding with Corey tonight's messaging. I think that there's people that may agree with
00:04:51 Corey's sentiment that he has. I think many of us disagree with how he did it because go, you know,
00:04:59 crap on the strategy after the election. It doesn't help our Conservative Party. Now, the question you 0.76
00:05:04 asked, Derek, now that I've kind of laid out the groundwork is, is Doug Ford trying to take
00:05:09 Polly Ebb's job? And that would potentially happen if Polly Ebb is not successful on April 28th. 1.00
00:05:15 I, as a strong Alberta conservative, call the PCs under Doug Ford pretend conservatives.
00:05:23 And therefore, I think it would be very, very hard after Doug Ford has been very close with the prime minister and really aligned with a lot of the things that the liberals have been campaigning on.
00:05:33 Very difficult. Should he should there be an opportunity for leadership and should he put his name forward?
00:05:39 I think there's a lot of Western Canadians that would question the conservative in his blood.
00:05:45 So, look, it's not inappropriate to criticize a campaign.
00:05:51 I mean, it's odd for senior people to break ranks publicly, at least during a campaign.
00:05:57 I think in Canada we place far, far too much emphasis on the need for unanimity in caucuses and in parties where everyone has to think the exact same thing.
00:06:08 If you're not, if you don't think things are going well, I think you're free to speak your mind.
00:06:12 But in the case of Corey tonight here, it's hard not to see him as a proxy for Doug Ford.
00:06:19 Doug Ford has not even said he's supporting the Conservatives.
00:06:21 He's just voting for his local Conservative candidate.
00:06:24 I guess, Nigel, do you think it's fair to see Corey tonight as a proxy here for Ford?
00:06:30 And do you think this is Ford trying to lay the groundwork?
00:06:36 Maybe to sabotage the campaign.
00:06:38 If you're being uncharitable, if you're being more charitable.
00:06:41 to lay the groundwork for succeeding poly up if he were to lose well certainly he's got that as
00:06:46 an option now which he didn't really have before but you know don't overlook the personalities
00:06:53 involved here there's been a long striving between uh cory tonight and jenny byrne they have very
00:06:59 different approaches to campaigning jenny has the has the top job at the moment cory is obviously
00:07:07 had a very successful run with Doug Ford.
00:07:11 And there may be a certain amount of, I told you so, going on in that,
00:07:16 which has got nothing to do with party politics
00:07:18 and absolutely everything to do with personal ambition.
00:07:22 I could be wrong, but that's the way it is.
00:07:25 So you think this is just...
00:07:26 No, I didn't say just.
00:07:28 I think there's an aspect of that in this.
00:07:30 I mean, a lot of people don't understand
00:07:32 that these people have known each other for decades.
00:07:36 The last conservative leadership race literally had grudges left over from campus politics with Patrick Brown and Pierre Polyev and Jean Charest, but going back to when these were literally kids at one point.
00:07:50 So never underestimate how much personality is.
00:07:52 Oh, it's a heavy driver in politics, all right. But, you know, regardless of all that, it's pretty poor form for Corey tonight to be openly criticizing the conservative campaign when we're two weeks away from the election.
00:08:07 I mean, man, do you want Carney back? Would you rather have the liberals? That's a difficult one.
00:08:14 You know, there's even a little parallel here.
00:08:18 Speaking up, saying anything in favor of President Trump at the moment is just not on.
00:08:23 Regardless of whether you agree with him or not, got to be Canadian first. 0.96
00:08:27 Anybody who breaks that rule loses by default.
00:08:33 And yet somehow, Corey tonight, and I think what they couldn't have been without the approval of Doug Ford,
00:08:40 thought that it'd be just fine to criticize the conservative campaign
00:08:44 and the way that it was being run at a very tense time
00:08:48 during the campaign.
00:08:49 I just say it's a bad form, not good conservatism, not good policy.
00:08:55 Corey, I know you're a born and bred Alberta boy,
00:08:59 so you don't necessarily know all these personalities as deeply
00:09:02 as, say, someone working in the Ottawa-Toronto bubble.
00:09:05 But it's hard to see how, you know, if it was just the first thing
00:09:10 at the imperial club or whatever it was called in toronto um if it was just one thing perhaps it
00:09:16 was just cory but um it's been repeated and continuing and sustained it's very difficult
00:09:22 to see how this would not be done without the blessings of doug ford um we'll get into
00:09:29 suitability of doug ford as a leader who could uh deserve the support of western conservatives but
00:09:35 But does it look to you like this is Doug Ford trying to, at a minimum, lay the groundwork for succeeding Paulie if he were to lose and in its least charitable interpretation, perhaps hoping that there's an opportunity to succeed him?
00:09:52 I don't know if he's looking that far ahead, but there's some bad blood and animosity going on.
00:09:58 And I mean, Corey tonight is very well experienced and he knows more than anybody, okay, you don't want to toss a turd into the punch bowl in the last two weeks of a campaign that's this close.
00:10:08 And that was, the thing we question now is the motivation for it.
00:10:13 Why is he throwing sand in the gears of a campaign at such a critical time?
00:10:18 He knows exactly how troubling that has made things.
00:10:22 And whatever he is doing at this point, it's hard to see it's not without the blessing.
00:10:26 Oh, there's no doubt.
00:10:27 I mean, he's connected to Ford and that's going to reflect on Ford no matter how you look at it.
00:10:32 So Ford would have reined him in or spoken to it if he didn't want that narrative to be going out there.
00:10:38 So is there a long game he's looking at? Possibly.
00:10:41 I mean, you got to remember the Ford brothers, too, as frustrating as Doug has been, they're hard to count out.
00:10:47 I mean, such an unlikely pair made their way up through Toronto politics and up to the premier's chair.
00:10:52 And he's got ambition. You know, Doug could be looking at that top throne.
00:10:57 I think there's a lot of reasons why we'd think it'd be pretty unlikely that would happen.
00:11:00 But, you know, 10 years ago, would anybody have ever seen him in the premier seat in Ontario either?
00:11:06 Four nations.
00:11:07 Yeah, so they could be chumming the water, trying to see if they can create the environment where he could make a move.
00:11:13 You know, he's just gotten himself another majority provincially.
00:11:16 Maybe two years from now, he'll be making the leap.
00:11:19 I don't know if their game's looking that long, but it really was a bizarre move on Corey's part and the timing.
00:11:25 there's got to be something more behind it than just giving a middle finger
00:11:28 to a couple other operatives on the other side that he doesn't like.
00:11:31 Erica, I want to come back, pick up on where you were going.
00:11:37 Doug Ford, if you can, is not a conservative.
00:11:40 He is a populist, I think, in the bad,
00:11:43 the word populist has different connotations to different people in parts of Europe.
00:11:48 It literally means fascist.
00:11:50 To Preston Mene in the Reform Party school, it means anti-establishment.
00:11:54 Um, and, uh, and then there's another interpretation where it's just populists are just someone
00:12:00 who wants to be popular, runs by the polls.
00:12:03 In Doug Ford's case, I think it very much applies there.
00:12:06 Uh, he'll do conservative things if conservative things are popular, but he'll do things that
00:12:11 are extremely unconservative if he thinks that's popular.
00:12:15 Uh, not just water in his wine, it's just the goal itself is power in its own right.
00:12:20 Uh, he will, uh, he's now won three majority governments.
00:12:23 he doesn't seem to have any great
00:12:25 ambition on the policy front of what
00:12:27 to do with it other than to have it
00:12:29 he's got to want to do something
00:12:31 else but
00:12:32 I mean right now
00:12:34 tensions in the west are
00:12:37 they're
00:12:39 they're starting they're getting close
00:12:41 to a boil again I'm not sure
00:12:43 they're at the boil yet what happens
00:12:45 on election day could impact that
00:12:47 significantly but I think one of the
00:12:49 anchors that has kept Alberta and
00:12:51 saskatchewan in the federation is the hope the charlie brown football that the conservatives
00:12:58 will win and fix everything uh i've never believed the conservatives are gonna like i mean we still
00:13:04 had terrible equalization under stephen harper and he was a very pro like he was a calgarian he
00:13:09 just he just can't do these great things for the west he can't reform the senate i should mention
00:13:14 to senator a lot uh i'm hoping for that one i like the triple e yeah yeah but i mean like that
00:13:19 We essentially gave that up
00:13:22 when the Canadian Reform Alliance
00:13:25 merged with the PCs. We gave that up
00:13:26 at the partisan level in exchange for a national
00:13:29 conservative coalition that could win.
00:13:32 But, you know,
00:13:33 the hope that you could at least have a
00:13:34 friendly government in Ottawa,
00:13:37 however elusive,
00:13:39 is, I think, what's keeping Alberta
00:13:41 and Saskatchewan in Canada.
00:13:43 If even
00:13:45 the Conservative Party, if they
00:13:47 were to be led by someone like Doug
00:13:49 board then it would it in your view would it what impact would that have on support for
00:13:54 independence to have a guy who doesn't really have a conservative bone in his body who is
00:13:59 through and through toronto uh i mean toity toronto flatmate uh stereotype yeah uh someone
00:14:07 who certainly has sounded like he would be uh quite fine if ottawa were to use its powers to
00:14:13 place an embargo against the export of alberta and saskatchewan oil something that he would never
00:14:17 except for an embargo against exporting cars.
00:14:20 Well, what impact, if someone like Ford were to lead the Federal Conservative Party,
00:14:24 what impact do you think that would have on the independence or sovereignty movement here in Alberta and Saskatchewan?
00:14:29 Well, I don't think our Conservative members would let Ford pass the sniff test and elect him,
00:14:36 but I will, for the purpose of this conversation, play into that.
00:14:40 They elected Aaron O'Toole.
00:14:41 Fair. I think how he led versus how he campaigned was very different, though, too.
00:14:46 I think we have proof. He's obviously lying. Okay, well, maybe we should have learned from
00:14:53 that. So at very least, I will entertain your hypothetical, Derek, of what that would mean,
00:14:58 because I think the reason why we've seen success with other leaders, Andrew Scheer being from
00:15:05 Saskatchewan, Pierre Paglia being born in Calgary, and really looking at Western Canada and Alberta
00:15:10 as home and relating, and then obviously Stephen Harper, I think it would be detrimental for the
00:15:17 conservative movement. And the reason I say that is because it gets into that PC side of things
00:15:23 where I don't think Alberta, I don't think Saskatchewan, and even with the BC conservatives
00:15:29 now align with that type of the heavy progressive, now I call it pretend conservative, but the actual
00:15:36 acronym is progressive conservative. And I just think that it would, um, disengage, uh, we might
00:15:44 see a sphere off of a different conservative birdie. I think that people that are part of the
00:15:49 movement, um, would not see a home for them necessarily. I think we would go back. We would
00:15:55 probably see a fraction like we did in the, um, two thousands with wild bros and the PC party
00:16:01 where you didn't feel you had a place within the movement anymore.
00:16:05 So should Doug Ford somehow not make it through vetting somehow win from the the votes of
00:16:14 our membership, which it could happen.
00:16:19 But I do think we have so many members and our point system doesn't give the same benefit,
00:16:24 but it does still heavily weigh on opportunity for conservatives, especially in the West,
00:16:30 to have a little bit more say than we do
00:16:32 in our first past the post electoral system.
00:16:35 I think it would decimate our party.
00:16:37 It would move us too much towards the center.
00:16:41 And I think that populace,
00:16:43 under whatever expression you have, has its time.
00:16:46 I don't think that that is what our conservative movement
00:16:50 or leadership would need coming out of these tariff negotiations,
00:16:53 coming out of a very difficult election
00:16:56 should we not form government.
00:16:57 I would bet more money that Doug Ford might run for the leadership of the Liberal Party when Mark Carney loses.
00:17:05 So that's where I think reality sits.
00:17:08 Yeah, I'm not taking it as a given the Liberals are going to win here.
00:17:11 It's still very tight.
00:17:12 The French debate is tonight.
00:17:13 The English debate is tomorrow.
00:17:15 But the Liberals have an edge in the polls and their vote is more efficient.
00:17:18 If the two parties receive the same number of votes, the Liberals will win.
00:17:21 And since the NDB have collapsed, it's possible the Conservatives can win the most votes and the Liberals win an actual majority.
00:17:27 because the math is so wacky right now with the NDP virtually, you know, headed for a virtual
00:17:32 wipeout. Corey, so, you know, based on the, you know, hypothetical, but not wildly hypothetical
00:17:39 scenario where the Conservatives do not win here, Mark Carney remains Prime Minister.
00:17:46 You know, I'm not as confident as Erica that federal Conservative members couldn't be hoodwinked
00:17:52 again, the way they were
00:17:54 arguably
00:17:57 maybe a few times, but certainly with
00:17:58 Aaron O'Toole. Aaron O'Toole
00:18:00 had a proven track record
00:18:02 as a very squishy
00:18:04 pretend conservative.
00:18:07 But for,
00:18:09 you know, once he found out Paulio
00:18:10 was not running against him in that leadership race
00:18:13 and his main opposition would be
00:18:14 Peter McKay, he says, I'm the true
00:18:16 blue conservative. And conservatives
00:18:18 bought it. 0.95
00:18:20 They bloody swallowed it.
00:18:22 And then then conservatives were all of a sudden surprised when once he had the leadership and didn't think he needed conservative voters anymore, he campaigned as a liberal with, you know, for carbon taxes, for vaccine passports, really not running that far off from Justin Trudeau.
00:18:37 So I'm not that convinced that Doug Ford, who likes nothing more than to win elections, you know, looking at this and say, well, he'll say all the right things to win the votes of Westerners in a leadership race, but then pulls an Aaron O'Toole.
00:18:50 how do you how do you think it would pan out uh you know what would be the impact of both the
00:18:56 conservative party nationally and the canadian federation nationally if you had doug ford as a
00:19:03 conservative leader federally well if you won and i'm kind of with eric i think it'd be a bit of a
00:19:08 long shot but it's hard to say i mean if the liberals come in the big push we know from a lot
00:19:12 of people be we have to go to the center we have to go to the center that's the usual line we have
00:19:17 to out-liberal the liberals which never works but it tempts people but O'Toole could cloak himself
00:19:23 because still most people didn't really know who the heck he was uh Ford will say anything and
00:19:28 everything to get in but he's got a pretty solid track record of being very cozy with Justin Trudeau
00:19:34 and others that whoever's going to be running against him is going to be very clearly putting
00:19:38 that up there during the leadership campaign so I I think he would have a tough time winning
00:19:43 especially with it as Erica was saying too it's a weighted type of race but it's a first past the
00:19:48 vote and I couldn't see Doug winning much of any of those constituencies on this side of Ontario
00:19:54 plus frustrated people in northern Ontario but if he won it if he was the new conservative leader
00:20:01 the frustration I think among western conservatives would be pretty darn high because now they've got
00:20:06 no representation in Ottawa because they got a liberal government in there and they don't feel
00:20:10 they've got representation in the Conservative Party
00:20:12 either, so
00:20:13 crazed, independence-minded people like me
00:20:16 would certainly be fanning some flames
00:20:17 and we'll see what happens
00:20:20 locally. Alright, I'm going to give you some extra time
00:20:22 on the next questions, Nigel, because we've got to move
00:20:23 to the next time.
00:20:25 Alright, so
00:20:27 today is all about Conservatives
00:20:30 versus Conservatives.
00:20:33 Maxime Bernier's
00:20:34 PPC.
00:20:36 Could it play spoiler
00:20:38 to the Conservatives in this
00:20:40 election. I haven't watched the whole thing
00:20:42 yet, but I just saw
00:20:43 Maxi Burnie managed to score an interview
00:20:46 on Tucker Carlson.
00:20:48 I mean, it's an American program, but a lot of
00:20:50 people on the right in Canada watch that
00:20:52 too. That's no small thing.
00:20:56 Do you think he could play
00:20:57 a spoiler for the Conservatives
00:20:59 significantly in the election? He certainly
00:21:02 could. I was looking at the numbers.
00:21:04 I mean, the last election he pulled 5%
00:21:06 of the vote. In 21 of the
00:21:08 ridings where liberals, there was
00:21:10 21 ridings where liberals won, and the
00:21:12 amount of vote taken by the PPC
00:21:14 would have been the amount that could have put
00:21:16 the conservative over the edge. Now, there's
00:21:18 a lot of presumption, yes, because
00:21:20 a lot of the people who are voting PPC, even when people
00:21:22 sour on the conservatives for one reason or another,
00:21:24 a lot who would say if they didn't
00:21:26 have the PPC option might have just stayed home
00:21:28 anyways, or would vote against.
00:21:29 I wouldn't have voted for the conservatives under O'Toole
00:21:32 no matter what.
00:21:33 You can't assume that vote will
00:21:36 go there, but a degree of them will,
00:21:38 and there's going to be a lot of tight ones. He's running candidates
00:21:40 in 247 ridings in this
00:21:42 election.
00:21:44 Is that more than the Greens?
00:21:46 I think it might be, now that they've backed out of a few.
00:21:49 But he doesn't have
00:21:50 a seat, so he's still, that
00:21:52 qualification thing for the debates, he's still
00:21:54 kind of out of luck there.
00:21:56 But you can't
00:21:58 underestimate, especially when you got
00:22:00 that Tucker Carlson interview, that
00:22:02 influences a lot of people.
00:22:03 So I think it's going to impact a number of writings, and if they're very close, then yeah, absolutely, he could actually make the difference.
00:22:12 Nigel, you know, Corey raises a good point here.
00:22:17 I mean, there's a presumption on both sides of the political spectrum that NDP votes belong to the Liberals and PPC votes belong to the Conservatives.
00:22:28 And, you know, there's some logic to that.
00:22:33 But not necessarily.
00:22:35 You know, as I said, there was nothing on earth that could have moved me to vote for a conservative party under O'Toole
00:22:41 that was campaigning for carbon taxes, for vaccine passports.
00:22:45 It was just degrees of less terrible than Trudeau.
00:22:50 Things are different this time, though.
00:22:53 Polyev has moved the conservative party decisively to the right.
00:22:57 Maybe not as far.
00:22:59 I think he's still a little too soft on things like immigration.
00:23:01 But tough on carbon tax, tough on CBC.
00:23:06 You know, the party has done more to earn conservative voters this time.
00:23:12 What do you think Bernier is trying to achieve in this?
00:23:16 You know, when we first formed the PPC, this was coming after his loss to Andrew Scheer,
00:23:22 that at the very least was corrupted by the dairy cartels,
00:23:26 that at the very worst was a corrupt vote overall,
00:23:29 which is i don't know it was a questionable vote um but there was at least the case that this was
00:23:37 a point of principle that the conservative party had been corrupted and he had to leave uh the
00:23:42 same thing with aaron o'toole perhaps even more so when the party ran very far to the left for
00:23:47 a conservative party um but there seems to be less of a raison d'etre for the ppc in this election
00:23:53 What's Bernier trying to achieve?
00:23:56 That is actually a very good question, because I'm afraid, much as I like Mr. Bernier personally,
00:24:05 it's hard to see what the role of a little conservative ginger group could possibly be.
00:24:13 You've got the conservative party you said you wanted, with one exception, and that is on the pro-life issue.
00:24:22 There is not one party, federally, that represents people who believe that abortion is wrong.
00:24:32 So, Mr. Bernier, I know, does take the position that it is a mortal sin.
00:24:40 And that would be, he will give a voice, if they choose to vote for him, to those people who agree with him.
00:24:48 Which, for the record, I do on that particular issue.
00:24:51 so that's where the spoiler comes in if you're strongly pro-life and you have the choice between
00:24:59 voting for bernier who is also pro-life and for and that's your most important issue that's your
00:25:07 trigger issue as they say in the in the game well then he could take votes and that will give
00:25:14 that will take votes away from people who otherwise would vote for what is
00:25:19 by all accounts, pretty strong, strongly conservative, conservative party led by Pierre Poitier.
00:25:26 Now, is that what he's trying to do?
00:25:28 I, you know, I find it unlikely that anybody would go to go to war on that single issue
00:25:35 and say, I'm going to be the pro-life voice for Canada.
00:25:39 Or is it just a convenience for him that this is an issue on which he thinks he will draw some votes?
00:25:45 how strong is his personal convictions
00:25:48 you have to ask him, you have to make your own
00:25:50 but that's the only
00:25:52 place where Mr. Bernier
00:25:54 actually makes a substantive difference
00:25:56 other than that it's keeping a job
00:25:58 open for him as leader of the party
00:26:00 In large measure I agree with you Nigel
00:26:02 but I would
00:26:04 add to that even more
00:26:06 so the issue of immigration
00:26:07 Polyev has said he wanted to bring levels of
00:26:10 immigration down to
00:26:12 maybe I'm getting this wrong but I think about a quarter million
00:26:14 in a year, not including temporary
00:26:16 foreign workers and student visas
00:26:18 and whatnot. It's a substantial
00:26:20 drop from the insane
00:26:22 levels of Carney
00:26:24 and Trudeau. But that's
00:26:26 still pretty extreme mass
00:26:28 migration.
00:26:31 Conservatives are so
00:26:33 terrified of being labeled nativist
00:26:35 and anti-immigration. Well, guess what?
00:26:37 Canadians have become,
00:26:39 have turned against mass migration
00:26:41 because of the actions
00:26:42 of the incumbent government right now.
00:26:44 um i think there's an appetite for a a pretty maybe not 100 but a nearly a pretty watertight
00:26:51 moratorium on immigration right now uh yeah uh the ppc has become a home for pro-lifers but i'm
00:26:58 actually not seeing that as their main issues that they're putting forward it's it's mass migration
00:27:04 is really they're the really big one and and to actually try to take a unique position of
00:27:09 non-engaging and retaliatory tariffs um okay so it's not the main issue that they're putting
00:27:15 forward but it's the main issue that a lot of people are going to take from what they're saying
00:27:19 sure i mean but there's always been uh erica small like you know you think of the christian
00:27:25 heritage party it's everybody knows they're not going to win anything but it's a place to kind
00:27:30 of register your your protest vote uh i remember there was a there was a federal by-election in
00:27:35 the medicine hat riding
00:27:37 when
00:27:39 Lavar passed away and the
00:27:41 Christian Heritage Party actually beat the federal
00:27:43 NDP. But the federal
00:27:45 NDP was less than 1%. I was always
00:27:47 teasing them that the NDP are the 1%.
00:27:49 But
00:27:51 I don't know. I think
00:27:53 there's some traction with
00:27:55 the migration issue. I think the
00:27:57 Conservatives are going to still get most
00:27:59 of the votes of people who are deeply concerned
00:28:01 about masks being out of
00:28:03 control they're talking about at least moving it in a less extreme direction but it's it's pretty
00:28:10 soft because even though most canadiens like clear majority of canadians now think immigration's gone
00:28:15 too far it's out of control and the liberals have started to realize that rain aback um you know
00:28:21 there's still so many swing votes and heavily ethnic uh communities people who are often like
00:28:28 just very fresh to Canada
00:28:29 maybe second generation but very often first
00:28:32 I think they're
00:28:34 afraid of that and then conservatives in particular
00:28:36 are just so afraid with
00:28:38 being xenophobic or being
00:28:40 called xenophobic I should say
00:28:42 how much room is
00:28:46 there for the PPC on this because the last election
00:28:48 they had COVID and they rode
00:28:50 that for us hard
00:28:51 because they were so clearly distinctive
00:28:54 from the conservative
00:28:56 on the major issue of the election
00:28:58 How much room is there for mass migration or maybe something else for the PPC to try and wiggle its way in?
00:29:05 Yeah, I mean, I don't really know if I don't think they're ever going to get that 5% again, unless Doug Ford is the leader of CPC, I guess.
00:29:15 But they're sitting just under 2% now.
00:29:20 And like you said, there was a big motivation for getting behind the PPC last time with like a very left leaning leader, with the Conservative Party, with the issue of COVID and your human rights and the PPC being the one that stand up for individuals.
00:29:36 And there is within the Conservative movement, lots of individuals that are pro-life that don't see that, even if it is their top issue.
00:29:43 I think for Canadians across the board, it's about the economy and cost of living.
00:29:47 And so I do think that the play for the PBC would be the mass immigration, because if you look at Pierre Paulyevs, he's kind of reverting it back. I think we can all agree, holy crap, it's gone too far. But how far do you scale back? 1.00
00:30:02 I think because of maybe some of the sentiment that was talked about with like the fear of being compared to Trump with Trump, President Trump moving his migration, swinging the pendulum back.
00:30:16 Pierre is taking a calculated approach, kind of reforming it to the Stephen Harper era.
00:30:21 And I think folks can then tangibly see what that looks like.
00:30:25 So the PPC, if they want, they have to go even more mass because that does impact people's cost of living.
00:30:32 quality of life, all of those things. And I think that that's where people are looking,
00:30:36 maybe not on their issues based such as pro-life, even though the PPC has made that part of their
00:30:42 foundation. So I do think the immigration piece, if they want to come out of Bernier is going to
00:30:48 come out more aggressive on that. That's probably his room to play because, you know, of course he
00:30:54 doesn't support how the liberal party is navigating tariffs. Like that's no surprise. I still don't
00:31:00 think that we're going to see that 5%. I looked at the candidates from a Western Canadian
00:31:04 perspective. We have a few rural. Last time there was, I live in Edmonton Centre, the PPC vote did
00:31:11 cost us the election, but that's not the case in some of the writings like Northwest, in even
00:31:18 Manning or Riverbend. Those numbers weren't that close in the last election. So even, and even from
00:31:25 a Saskatchewan perspective, same thing. So if we're looking from the West, given its Western
00:31:30 standard, I don't think that those 5% are going to play it. Now, I don't know enough about some 0.99
00:31:36 of those ridings in Ontario and Quebec to see if that could impact. But when we're looking at what
00:31:41 that means for Alberta and Western Canada, I don't see the 5% getting that high. And I don't see it
00:31:48 impacting a close election.
00:31:52 I think where we're actually hoping
00:31:54 is that we see a decent vote split
00:31:57 continue to be on the left
00:32:00 versus a vote split on the right
00:32:02 that we're trying to manage.
00:32:04 Okay.
00:32:05 So, continuing in today's theme
00:32:08 of conservative versus conservative,
00:32:12 you know, we've talked in the show previously
00:32:14 about whatever the hell is going on
00:32:17 in the B.C. Conservative Party.
00:32:19 It's unfortunate to see.
00:32:20 I don't like seeing this, but
00:32:22 it makes good
00:32:24 talk content for a show
00:32:27 like this.
00:32:29 Nigel,
00:32:31 there's
00:32:32 one of the
00:32:34 Conservative MLA kicked out by B.C. Conservative
00:32:37 Leader Joan Rustad. It's put forward a private
00:32:39 members bill, also backed by two others
00:32:41 who quit along with her. So the
00:32:43 three independent Conservatives, for lack of
00:32:45 better term, in the B.C. Legislature
00:32:47 Why don't you set the table on what's the latest in the B.C. Conservative Party drama?
00:32:53 Well, it's interesting you should call them.
00:32:56 They're probably the only conservatives at the moment in the B.C. caucus.
00:33:01 It's tragic what's happened there.
00:33:03 Our hearts left last fall when conservatives came from not being a party at all to being a party
00:33:10 and then suddenly gaining ground to getting the traction and starting to put boots to the NDP.
00:33:15 And bless my soul, came within about two seats of doing that in the election.
00:33:19 Great success, conservative and revived NBC.
00:33:24 And I thought to myself, well, you know what's going to happen now.
00:33:27 They're going to start fighting with each other, and there's going to be, and sure enough,
00:33:32 they did not waste much time getting it.
00:33:34 They did not waste any time getting it down to it.
00:33:36 So the issue here, in this particular case, is that John Rustad, who he sort of liked first,
00:33:43 because of all the reasons we've just given,
00:33:46 has become another conservative politician
00:33:49 trying to avoid stepping on landmines
00:33:52 and avoiding controversial positions.
00:33:54 But actually, sometimes it might be better
00:33:55 to put your fists up with the elbows
00:33:57 to use the argo of the day and fight it.
00:34:01 So what's going on is that last month,
00:34:04 Dallas Brody, this is the MLA,
00:34:07 she was expelled from the conservative caucus.
00:34:10 And the reason was that she was challenging
00:34:12 the narrative about the buried bodies at the Kamloops Indian Residential School.
00:34:18 Two other conservative MLAs went with her, and a lot of people think that way across the party
00:34:23 divide because there has been no evidence presented that there are actual human remains on the grounds
00:34:30 of the Kamloops Residential School. But you're not allowed to say that. So you're not allowed
00:34:36 to say, show me the evidence. So Rustad terminated her membership of the conservative caucus.
00:34:44 Now, booing ahead, as Tom Flanagan wrote in the Western Standard just this last Sunday,
00:34:52 many elected politicians, and this is what sets Dallas Prody apart, many elected politicians,
00:34:59 unfairly expelled from their party would just hide out in their offices until their term was up,
00:35:05 take the salary, pension if there is one. That's not what she did. She came up with some very
00:35:11 conservative legislation. She called it the Tax Relief and Tariff Defense Act, and it was a much
00:35:21 needed counterpoint to Premier Eby's Bill 7, which would leave BC's high taxes untouched while
00:35:28 neutering the legislature and centralizing all power in the cabinet. We talked about this a
00:35:33 week or two ago. It was a total takeover from the Senate. Well, anyway, she
00:35:39 brings forward this very conservative piece of private legislation, and instead
00:35:45 of sort of saying, well, we can work with this, we don't like this, we don't like
00:35:49 that, but let's sort of get behind this, Rostad just cut her off of the
00:35:55 ankles and the thing has already gone into the trash can. So you have the BC
00:36:01 conservatives making column calls with the bc ndp and the bc green which is worth mentioning
00:36:07 because they actually do have a uh you know a balance of power vote in the bc legislature
00:36:13 and uh all this good conservative stuff went nowhere now you know the takeaway here is that
00:36:22 when it comes right down to it bc's conservatives are like so many other conservatives across the
00:36:28 country who would rather fight with each other than go hard on the issues that matter to other
00:36:35 conservatives we forever let the other side decide what we're allowed to oppose instead of defining
00:36:43 our own battlefield and those who are bold find out as dallas brody did that they're out there
00:36:51 on the level. So, I mean, I'm having PTSD flashbacks.
00:36:57 I was just gonna ask, I'm like, Derek, how did you feel?
00:37:01 I'll go to you, Erica. I remember, you know, I put forward
00:37:06 private members motion in the legislature to cut MLA pay, I
00:37:11 think, five or 10%. I can't recall. And
00:37:16 you eventually got your way.
00:37:17 at that time and jason kenny had actually worked with rachel notley behind the scenes
00:37:22 to ensure it was never debated uh it was introduced and then no one stood up to even
00:37:28 debate it and then the ucp under kenny and the ndp under notley you uh unanimously minus my vote all
00:37:35 voted against it and i think uh in in the case of the ucp and it's funny then jason kenny turned
00:37:41 around and did just that once he was
00:37:43 president. It's an election promise, yeah.
00:37:46 So the goal
00:37:47 wasn't necessarily opposition to the substance of
00:37:49 it, is we don't want to let
00:37:51 someone else be seen to
00:37:53 be doing this, or attention for
00:37:55 the rebel conservatives in
00:37:57 the corner.
00:37:59 To me, that's what it looks like. I'm not sure
00:38:01 John Russ said that the conservatives opposed this on principle.
00:38:04 It would appear to me to be
00:38:05 they want to starve them of oxygen.
00:38:08 That appears to have had
00:38:09 the opposite effect, at least with this
00:38:11 show but i i don't know does it look to you like that that's what it is they're just trying to make
00:38:16 starve the rebel conservatives of our of any oxygen on their own you know what if i was on
00:38:20 any other show i would have used you as an example of basically but i let you you know you telling
00:38:27 the story from your lived experience is far better for the viewers i think it is a it wasn't our idea
00:38:33 so we're going to squash it i would not be surprised if the bc conservatives um you know
00:38:40 rejigged this and brought forward their own, um, either motion or private members bill that very
00:38:47 much mimics it, but we'll want to take credit for it because looking at the value of the,
00:38:52 the private members bill, it does show a lot of things. I think that a conservative
00:38:58 party, um, can get behind. I think this was a strategy of, well, if it's not our idea,
00:39:04 speaking for both the government, I mean, the government's going to vote against it because
00:39:08 it contradicts exactly what they brought forward or enhances what they did. And that means that
00:39:13 they have to accept they're wrong. But for the BC Conservatives, I think the strategy was this
00:39:17 person was a part of our team. Listen, let's compare it to days now. Pete Guthrie, who's no
00:39:23 longer sitting with the UCP and Scott Sinclair, I can guarantee if they bring anything forward,
00:39:28 just by natural de facto of how party politics works, the government would not adopt it either.
00:39:34 so unfortunately when we think of
00:39:36 democracy where the best idea
00:39:38 should come forward and everyone should get
00:39:40 behind it regardless of partisanship
00:39:42 and what's in the best interest of
00:39:44 your residents that's not
00:39:46 the case and I think this is like
00:39:48 yours Derek
00:39:49 a prime example of that
00:39:52 this isn't just one
00:39:56 person though you know
00:39:58 when I was in my fight with Kenny it was me
00:40:00 versus him in the legislature
00:40:01 Dallas Brody here though has got
00:40:04 two others with her. This is a
00:40:06 bigger split.
00:40:08 And it's a split that
00:40:10 appears to be
00:40:12 Rostad's leadership position was not
00:40:16 as solid as Kenny's. Kenny had just been elected UCP
00:40:18 leader, was going into an election.
00:40:20 Rostad's come out of an election here, and he's
00:40:22 going to face at least some
00:40:23 questioning of his leadership. It's not
00:40:26 unassailable yet.
00:40:29 Is this
00:40:30 going to drive
00:40:32 the divides wider?
00:40:34 What impact do you think it could have on Judd and Rustat's leadership?
00:40:37 Well, it'll be tough.
00:40:38 I mean, he's got to sort this out.
00:40:40 If there's going to be any time for it to happen,
00:40:42 then they might as well do it now.
00:40:43 They've got close to four years before they have to go to the polls again.
00:40:46 So iron it out.
00:40:48 Either Rustat has to figure out his leadership
00:40:49 and pull this party back together,
00:40:51 or the caucus has to determine whether they can maintain him as the leader.
00:40:56 Like, this is the time now. 0.99
00:40:57 Spend a year getting your crap together. 0.99
00:41:00 We've got to remember, this was a party that was formed so quickly. 0.99
00:41:03 They don't have tight glue bonding them. They don't have the years of time together to figure out their internal structures or relationships even. So, I mean, it might very well tear them apart, but I wouldn't write the party off yet either. I mean, this could be just a very bad road bump in that first year after the election that they can overcome.
00:41:23 Rustin's realized he can't just lay down the law.
00:41:25 They aren't going to put up with it.
00:41:27 He's going to have to find compromise and show leadership to pull everybody together.
00:41:30 And those who left the caucus, it certainly doesn't, they'll never be able to come back.
00:41:37 I mean, things can change.
00:41:38 We'll see how this unfolds.
00:41:39 It's not a good start, though.
00:41:41 Okay.
00:41:42 Well, it starts over.
00:41:44 It's now time for parting shots.
00:41:46 And since you're our guest here today, Erica gets the first shot.
00:41:50 All right.
00:41:50 Well, the federal French debate is this evening, so I have to go and do my parting shot towards Mark Carney.
00:42:00 I can speak French. I would not say I'm fluent or bilingual.
00:42:04 And I myself think that I might have better French than our current sitting prime minister.
00:42:10 So the truth, the truth hurts.
00:42:13 So, right.
00:42:17 Man, I know one word.
00:42:19 That would be the word you knew.
00:42:23 So, like yesterday, a CBC reporter asked Carolyn Levitt.
00:42:27 I was surprised that the CBC got into the White House at all.
00:42:30 But anyway, they did.
00:42:31 I would bless them for asking, and bless the White House for letting them in.
00:42:35 And they asked Carolyn Levitt if Trump still believes that Canada should be the 51st state.
00:42:41 Now, what's wrong with that?
00:42:43 Well, the fact is there has been nothing from the White House on that subject for some weeks.
00:42:49 There's been plenty on other things.
00:42:51 But why bring that up right now in the middle of an election when the Liberal Party is riding high on the protecting Canada thing?
00:43:01 This is an example of a reporter generating a story by asking a question when there is no story.
00:43:08 And you wonder why we want to defund the CBC.
00:43:13 All right, Corey.
00:43:15 Well, I was happy to see justice finally come up in a federal election.
00:43:18 it never does often enough. And Polly, I'm pointing out what I think the vast majority
00:43:23 of people think. If you've got a multiple murderer, you don't get 10 for the price of one.
00:43:28 We should be able to get consecutive sentencing for them and make sure that we put them away for
00:43:33 life. And all of the chattering classes have been flying out of the woodworks saying you can't do
00:43:38 that. The constitution won't allow it. So to Polly's credit, so you said, I will use the
00:43:43 notwithstanding clause. But if we'd have to use the notwithstanding clause to put a multiple
00:43:47 murderer in jail for life,
00:43:49 maybe it's time to open up that constitution
00:43:51 again.
00:43:52 I forget. I'll have to
00:43:55 paraphrase it, but I
00:43:56 generally, I think the CBC headline
00:43:58 was not
00:44:01 technically inaccurate, but was wildly
00:44:03 misleading. It was something to the effect of
00:44:05 Pauliev promises to be
00:44:07 the first prime minister to use an unwithstanding
00:44:08 clause to override
00:44:10 rights or something like that.
00:44:13 I mean,
00:44:14 okay, let's talk about whose rights.
00:44:17 I mean, someone who is convicted, not someone who's not me.
00:44:20 I mean, if this was about lessening the burden of proof on the Crown or something,
00:44:24 okay, I'd be with you. That's bad.
00:44:27 But it didn't say Paulyov promises to use non-bestending clause to keep murderers in prison.
00:44:32 It was he promises to use non-bestending clause to override rights or something like that.
00:44:37 I'm paraphrasing, but that was the gist of the headline.
00:44:40 It was so classic CBC.
00:44:43 Alright, speaking of rights and court decisions, my parting shot, something good from England for once in a long time. The UK's Supreme Court has ruled that trans women are not, in fact, women under the Equality Act or whatever it was called. 0.99
00:45:05 Right now, Britain is busy putting people in prison for memes while, you know, letting criminals roam the streets and terrorize indigenous Britons.
00:45:17 But this was a sign that perhaps the UK Supreme Court isn't as loopy and far gone as our own.
00:45:28 So good for your people.
00:45:29 All right. That's it for today's show.
00:45:34 Wait a minute, I've got a question for you. Are we not having a commentary on...
00:45:40 Good. Good that you're here to remind me. Tonight might be the Francais debate, but tomorrow is
00:45:49 the English debate. Unfortunately, the way it's working, only Quebecers will get to have, or the
00:45:57 French, will get to have any part of the debate talking about immigration, which just happens to
00:46:01 be one of the single biggest issues right now uh i guess only the french get to talk about that not
00:46:07 us uh explanations i've heard are well it's it's a bigger and more important and distinctive issue
00:46:13 in quebec i thought theoretically these the french debate was not a technically quebec debate it was
00:46:18 a french debate because we have this by the i have the i have french in my cereal box in alberta so
00:46:24 i think i get to have a say over it too um anyway that's a long way of me ranting say you need to
00:46:31 all tune in and watch our coverage
00:46:33 of the English
00:46:34 leaders debate tomorrow.
00:46:38 We are starting
00:46:39 at 4.30.
00:46:40 The debate itself starts at 5, but we'll
00:46:43 be giving you our excellent, most
00:46:45 informed, extremely intelligent
00:46:47 thoughts, beginning at 4.30.
00:46:49 Mountain Standard. Mountain.
00:46:50 Of course.
00:46:53 People watch this across. Have I ever said
00:46:55 anything on
00:46:56 Eastern Time? I don't
00:46:59 think so. Calgary is the center
00:47:01 of the universe, not Toronto.
00:47:03 So 4.30
00:47:04 Berta time.
00:47:07 Tune in. We'll be carrying the
00:47:09 whole thing with a little bit of pregame.
00:47:12 We'll
00:47:12 broadcast the debate itself while
00:47:14 two of us drink beer
00:47:16 and one of us drinks
00:47:18 Diet Coke.
00:47:21 And then
00:47:23 we'll be back, hopefully not after
00:47:25 too many beers, and we're still able to give
00:47:27 you some coherent and intelligent
00:47:29 commentary. So make sure to tune in
00:47:31 and join us then. We'll be watching the comment section
00:47:33 too. We also are going to have
00:47:35 Western Standard reporter Jen
00:47:37 Hodgson on the ground in
00:47:39 Montreal. We have sent her into
00:47:41 exile out of the Calgary headquarters here.
00:47:43 Send them right into the 0.75
00:47:45 lion's den. She'll be asking the leaders
00:47:46 questions both tonight for the
00:47:49 French debate and tomorrow
00:47:51 for the English debate.
00:47:53 That's it.
00:47:54 Now that I'm actually done, thank you for the reminder.
00:47:57 And also
00:47:58 remember, thanks to your generous donations
00:48:00 we have been able to take the paywall on
00:48:02 the Western Standard down. It is free
00:48:04 for the rest of this federal election
00:48:06 because
00:48:08 you guys have just stepped up and donated so generously.
00:48:11 So read it to your heart's content.
00:48:12 There's no paywall. Share it with your friends and family
00:48:14 and colleagues and even people you hate.
00:48:16 Make them read the Western Standard too.
00:48:19 But when all that's done, we'd
00:48:20 still appreciate it. If you were to subscribe
00:48:22 and become a member, you can go to westernstandard.news.
00:48:25 Click on subscribe. We're
00:48:26 only $10 a month or $100 a year because that paywall will be back and you're going to hate
00:48:32 it if you don't have a membership. Thank you very much for joining us today. God bless.
00:48:56 Connect with one of our experienced team members.
00:49:00 Invest in gold and silver today.
00:49:26 You