Western Standard - April 25, 2025


Is Mark Carney, Trump's pick for 51st state governor?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Voting Liberal never serves the West well Pierre Poilievre Calgary Whistle Stop

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

162.76

Word count

4,265

Sentence count

88

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jack Mince joins me on the show today to talk about the federal election, the federal government's financial plans, and the impact of the Trump administration's trade policies on the Canadian economy. He also talks about the possibility of a recession in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 China's killing our canola.
00:00:05 Forty-five billion dollars gone.
00:00:08 Western farmers bleed.
00:00:11 Mark Carney?
00:00:12 Silent.
00:00:14 Made millions off Beijing's dime.
00:00:17 He won't fight.
00:00:18 He's Beijing's banker, not our prime minister.
00:00:30 good evening western standard viewers and welcome to hannaford a weekly politics show today is
00:00:48 thursday april the 24th with me tonight is dr jack mince one of canada's foremost economists
00:00:54 and original thinkers. Good evening, Jack. Good evening, Natal. Great to see you.
00:00:59 Great to have you back on the show. Jack, with the general election now upon us,
00:01:03 both the Liberals and the Conservatives have laid out their financial plans,
00:01:08 and in many ways they look a lot like each other. Both call for borrowing, although in the Liberal
00:01:12 case it's a massive borrowing. Both call for personal income tax cuts. The Conservatives
00:01:17 slightly more ambitious than the Liberal. Both have sworn off the consumer carbon tax. Both
00:01:22 have canceled proposed increases to the capital gains tax and to eliminate GST on the purchase
00:01:27 of new homes up to a million or a million three. So two questions to start. First, a lot of those
00:01:34 things started with Polyev. Have the liberals simply cut and pasted the conservative platform?
00:01:40 And second, I am astonished that Mr. Carney is going to the voters with a plan to borrow $225
00:01:46 billion dollars over four years the federal debt is already 1.2 trillion and that's caused
00:01:51 huge inflation ten dollars a dozen eggs seven dollar butter don't know what it's like back
00:01:56 there east where you are but that's how it is out west now mr carney has run two central banks and
00:02:02 by his own admission he knows how things work so he must know all this can you theorize jack why
00:02:07 he would plan a 20 increase in the federal debt well all that means for ordinary people at the
00:02:14 gas pump and the grocery checkout well first of all just in response to your questions with regard
00:02:24 to the the plans that are being proposed by both the conservatives and the liberals i i think it's
00:02:30 the numbers are less important than the philosophy underlying in the case of the liberals it's sort
00:02:36 something that Mr. Carney has said himself that the way to grow the economy is through is by the
00:02:45 government and in fact he's ready to set up a whole bunch of funds that will work with the private
00:02:52 sector to catalyze as he keeps using that word to catalyze private investment in other words the
00:02:59 government picking the winners from the losers and subsidizing private investment through various
00:03:08 grants, tax credits, you know, whatever, that would be kind of looking like a Brookfield type
00:03:14 fund that would be working with partners to, you know, make investments in infrastructure and
00:03:21 other things. That, of course, is one philosophy that basically says that the only way to get
00:03:27 things going is that the government has to throw money at it the other philosophy is to say that
00:03:33 the government should get out of the way from the private sector deregulate cut taxes significant
00:03:40 tax reform other types of policies that that will spur private investment because right now it's an
00:03:47 obstacle to investment and that's really what the conservative plan is about so those are
00:03:52 Two very, very different philosophies, and I think it's reflective in both the policy platforms of the two candidate parties.
00:04:05 With regard to the debt issue, for sure, it is a serious issue.
00:04:09 And, in fact, I don't take the numbers underlying these two platforms very seriously because they very much, I think, underestimate the impact of a potential recession that we're going to see next year, potentially even the year after, but even just a one-year recession.
00:04:31 but with particularly slow growth all due to the disruption that is now happening at the
00:04:37 international level particularly with respect to terror policy that the Trump administration has
00:04:44 been pushing and even last night Trump who I think somehow I guess he wishes Carney wins because he
00:04:51 keeps interfering at the right time saying I you know I want that auto industry all in all in the
00:04:58 United States and I don't want any more cars produced in Canada. So given that 90% of our
00:05:08 exports and autos is to United States and in fact 82% of the automobiles that are produced in Canada
00:05:17 are exported to United States, that would of course have huge ramifications for the Canadian
00:05:22 economy all this suggests is that uh the the numbers that are being used in these plans uh
00:05:29 in my view uh should have been redone with a much more prudent assumption about how much growth we're
00:05:35 going to get the plans are actually based on on average about close to four percent average growth
00:05:41 rate nominal growth rate in gdp over the over the four-year period and i don't think that's going
00:05:47 going to happen. In fact, the IMF has already marked down Canadian growth by 0.6% this year
00:05:57 and 0.4% next year based on the Trump tariffs. And the plans were really using numbers that
00:06:06 were based at the end of the fall of 2024, which I think were reasonably done at that point,
00:06:14 but needed to be revised downward but i would have taken a very risk management type point of
00:06:20 view and say what happens if this is what happens in terms of the economy where let's say we
00:06:25 virtually have no real growth this coming year and then and and the year after a very much lower
00:06:31 growth rate uh than what's being assumed and then ask the question how much debt can we really
00:06:36 afford having before it starts uh becoming sky high and and and pushes up prices as as you've
00:06:44 mentioned uh and and and potentially uh leads to uh problems in the difficulty of selling our debt to
00:06:53 to international lenders who might start looking at candidates as too risky especially given our
00:06:59 terrible growth rate that we've had over the past decade well you know jack i mean we're
00:07:03 sort of getting close to the, I won't call it science fiction, but the speculation about
00:07:10 just how bad things can get. Now, you'll be well aware that there's an office within the Privy
00:07:16 Council office, and for readers and listeners who maybe don't have the intimate knowledge that you
00:07:24 have of government, there is the Prime Minister's office, and then there's the Mirror Image,
00:07:29 the Privy Council Office, which supplies a lot of the information and the facts that the PMO can
00:07:36 choose to accept or ignore. But within the Privy Council Office, very high-level civil service,
00:07:43 there is a little department whose job it is to look ahead and make informed speculations.
00:07:50 And this little office has come out with a report. I think it actually came out in January, but it
00:07:54 it just hit the headlines now, saying that by 2040, Canada is going to be, if present
00:08:03 trends continue, well, a third world country. 0.77
00:08:08 You know, we've already got the colored money, Jack, so what do we make of a report like that 0.87
00:08:14 when you see the kind of assumptions that are underlying the policies and the platforms
00:08:23 of the two major parties.
00:08:26 I mean, everybody thinks the liberals are going to win.
00:08:28 That's what the polls say.
00:08:29 Well, if they win, then all the policies that you've just talked about
00:08:33 and the assumptions that you've talked about,
00:08:36 how the government is your friend and is going to fix everything,
00:08:39 are going to come about.
00:08:40 And then is this actually going to take us down this destructive path
00:08:45 that the PCO has imagined?
00:08:48 well it's uh so first of all i actually do know about that small operation in the in the privy
00:08:54 council it's been there actually for quite a while uh and i used to know the person that
00:08:59 actually started a number of years ago um and they do uh work on kind of like long-term trends and
00:09:04 of course i think those i think that's a useful exercise to go to how how how credible that
00:09:11 forecast is going to be is a different story but certainly uh there has been a lot of work done
00:09:16 showing that canada is going to be having the lowest growth rate of all the oecd countries
00:09:22 we have now have our gdp per capita has now fallen to close to the oecd average now we don't even
00:09:29 shine anymore and in fact if you do have a really low growth in canada compared to everybody else
00:09:35 where we are going to get down to the lower parts we we may not be a third world country but we
00:09:40 We might start looking more like a middle income country if we keep on the path that
00:09:47 we're moving on.
00:09:48 And I think this is an issue that I have been terribly concerned about.
00:09:52 In fact, last Friday, I wrote about Ontario, which is the slowest growth province in Canada
00:09:57 over the past two decades, and is now starting to look like the sick man of North America, 0.63
00:10:02 just like Turkey or the Ottoman Empire looked like the sick man of Europe back in the 19th 0.90
00:10:08 century um and in fact uh when you look at per capita incomes in in uh ontario now it's very
00:10:15 little different than the poorest states in the united states uh like alabama and south carolina
00:10:20 and and a little bit more than mississippi so it's it's it is very concerning about the direction
00:10:27 that we're going especially a province like ontario which is 40 percent of canada's gdp
00:10:32 uh that it's um it's doing so poorly and uh i think we need our politicians to wake up
00:10:38 uh and and consider that uh really what we need to look for the future is is really a big bank
00:10:45 in terms of policies and when i read the two platforms but you know both liberal and the
00:10:51 conservative uh platforms there's a lot of ideas there in fact some of them i i do like and uh
00:10:58 especially the ones with deregulation and and um particularly but i would say they're kind of what
00:11:05 a lot of them are marginal reforms because there's so many different things that are that
00:11:09 are being proposed they you know the concern the liberal platform has like 130 different measures
00:11:15 uh and they're all a little bit spent here and there splayed around the country
00:11:19 uh it's not it's not going to do much to canadian economic growth and of course if the if the
00:11:26 liberal party is going to be operating on the basis of uh you know we're going to grow things
00:11:31 by picking the winners uh that are that are going to be responsible for canadian growth
00:11:37 we know that canadian governments are very poor at picking windows from losers but we also know
00:11:41 that losers are pretty good at picking governments uh particularly when they're looking for subsidies 0.64
00:11:47 so i think this is uh you know not the right approach in fact i'm much more attuned to what
00:11:53 the conservatives are proposing which is very similar to what we did in the 1980s when we had
00:11:59 to get out of the lethargy of a high debt country with very low growth high inflation back in 1984
00:12:07 when the marooney government came in it it privatized it deregulated it introduced tax reform
00:12:15 but also most importantly they developed the free trade agreement with the united states
00:12:19 i know it's a different era but the main point is that this was the kind of approach that we need
00:12:27 now in in our public policy bold ideas that are going to get uh get the economy moving and
00:12:34 particularly relying on the resilience of the private sector which i think is very strong in
00:12:38 canada to achieve the kind of goals that we want to see in terms of better prosperity in this
00:12:45 countries does it concern you that even the conservatives who i think you tend to favor
00:12:51 in this uh in in this discussion even the conservatives are talking about running a
00:12:58 deficit for the period of the next four years 35 billion dollars i think it was was the number
00:13:06 uh no actually yeah the the total deficit sat up to 100 billion as opposed to 225 billion
00:13:13 however uh the baseline uh deficit in other words if you take what the parties assume would be the
00:13:21 deficit before doing making any policy or taking any policy actions uh is 140 billion so actually
00:13:28 the uh the conservatives actually reduce deficits relative to the baseline by about 38 billion
00:13:34 not huge but certainly in the right direction uh the liberals on the other hand uh as you mentioned
00:13:40 are raising are going up to 225 billion which is um almost uh an additional 80 80 85 billion to to
00:13:49 the deficits that were uh already expected uh according to the baseline calculations so so
00:13:56 you clearly two different directions one where there's going to be bigger deficits and higher
00:14:01 debt and the other one where there's going to be at least some constraint uh on deficits and and
00:14:06 bringing down some of the debt uh potential uh by by undertaking those constraints so
00:14:13 one might say well the conservatives should have gone harder uh in terms of reducing deficits and
00:14:18 spending uh and certainly i think that's a criticism that can be made which goes back to
00:14:23 my point that if we're going to really uh get canada out of its lethargy um and and reverse
00:14:29 what has been a bad decade of uh poor economic growth in fact virtually no economic growth
00:14:36 uh on a per person level uh then we need policies that are going to really shock the economy forward
00:14:44 we're not as bad as argentina but as we've seen argentina has taken on huge changes in public
00:14:49 policy and they're starting to write has which has been a very bad situation there we're not
00:14:54 we're not like argentina but i don't want us to become argentina either in a hundred years
00:14:59 Now, the conservatives have been criticized in that they make these promises to bring down the
00:15:07 deficit, but the means by which they mean to do it are either through programs that don't yet exist
00:15:14 or through strategies. I mean, it was talked about getting rid of consultants, and that's
00:15:18 not a bad thing to do because civil servants shouldn't be constantly trying to offload 0.78
00:15:24 responsibility to consultants. But does it all add up to enough to do the job?
00:15:28 are their plans reasonable well i think some of the things they did is quite reasonable
00:15:35 they've been criticized for uh booking revenue numbers for deregulation so for example getting
00:15:42 rid of the cap on oil and gas emissions they have a revenue number associated uh with that
00:15:48 also some you know some of the other policies like the impact assessment act which has been
00:15:55 discouraging not only pipelines but even mining and some other resource investments as well
00:16:02 and so they books numbers associated with that that's called dynamic scoring it's used by the
00:16:09 congressional budget office in the united states there's always been a criticism that if you just
00:16:15 book you know what you think is the static cost of making a change so in the case of a regulation
00:16:21 you assume there is no additional revenue uh it's a mistake and and so what what i know the
00:16:26 conservatives did um is is that they actually uh based it on studies a number of them uh
00:16:33 parliamentary budget office studies that were well done and fairly conservatively done that showed
00:16:38 the impact of let's say getting rid of the oil and gas emissions cap on the impact on gdp and
00:16:45 And then once you know the impact on GDP, given that federal revenues are about 14% of GDP,
00:16:53 then you can estimate how much additional revenue will come because of the growth that comes from deregulation.
00:17:00 I think that's a very good policy or a very good methodology because it starts putting some emphasis on things like deregulation that can help grow the economy.
00:17:12 Also, tax cuts, if we don't take into account that tax cuts can actually spur growth in
00:17:19 the economy, then you tend to exaggerate the cost of the tax cut because you're not taking
00:17:24 into account some of the pickup in revenue that you get from having more growth.
00:17:29 And so that's another reason why dynamic scoring has been used in the United States.
00:17:34 And I think it's something that we should be doing in Canada as well.
00:17:37 Well, now, I think everybody who watches this program anyway is probably nodding in
00:17:46 violent agreement with you about the quality of these policies, but here's the thing.
00:17:53 One of the crown jewels of the conservative platform is the so-called resource corridor
00:17:58 within which development can be expedited.
00:18:03 In four years, let's say they win the election
00:18:06 and they've got four years to do the work,
00:18:09 and let's say they are able to put that resource corridor in place
00:18:14 and do all the other good things you've just talked about,
00:18:17 can those things do what they are promising to do
00:18:21 in the four-year term that they would have?
00:18:26 I think you're right.
00:18:27 There are going to be some things that are going to take longer
00:18:29 to really see the fruits of.
00:18:31 but again it depends on you know how quickly you can do some of these corridors uh quarters are
00:18:38 used uh particularly in australia at a great benefit uh to the to the country it's also used
00:18:44 in a number of other countries and it's a matter of uh you know you may not do it right across the
00:18:49 whole country that's going to take a very long time uh but there may be areas that you could do
00:18:53 it for example a quarter that goes from let's say alberta to uh to british columbia uh that you can
00:19:00 can put in pipelines, electric transmission lines, et cetera. And would the benefits appear in the
00:19:07 very first four years? Maybe, maybe not. Maybe some benefits will be realized, because if you
00:19:13 can get it done within, get the corridor established within a couple of years, then by the
00:19:18 end of the four years, you might get some positive results. But certainly, I think the movement
00:19:23 towards that is, I think, very important. And I noticed even, you know, the Liberal Plan has
00:19:27 corridors as well and so it's uh this is one thing i'm actually glad to see that both major parties
00:19:33 are uh are talking about uh this approach to um getting resource development uh through
00:19:41 um the one the concern i have with respect to the liberal plan is that i think they're more
00:19:45 focused on electricity uh and it's not clear that they're interested in oil and gas when lng itself
00:19:53 we exported lng to uh china japan and other countries in europe uh it may increase our
00:20:01 own emissions but from a worldwide perspective it would reduce emissions if it's a matter of
00:20:06 replacing uh coal uh which is currently used in in a number of the countries so um but you know
00:20:12 we have to remember you know greenhouse gas emissions uh the impact temperature it's a
00:20:18 worldwide impact not any one specific country but the total amount across all countries so
00:20:25 we really have to look at how you reduce worldwide emissions not just
00:20:30 even if one action by a country increases its own emissions if it reduces worldwide emissions
00:20:35 that's a good thing so i think you know the corridor concept i think is would be very
00:20:40 valuable to have but we'll have to see of course whether how far it goes down the road given
00:20:45 that canada really is is already has a reputation internationally as being very slow in permitting
00:20:52 uh very slow in contract uh formation a number of studies have shown how poorly we do in fact
00:20:58 we're closer to the bottom of the oecd countries when it comes to the cost of doing
00:21:02 business in in this country and and so again that's an area that's going to need significant
00:21:08 change uh that will be pushed i think by any government that's going to come into power
00:21:13 especially given the Liberals have also expressed interest in quarters
00:21:17 and approving regulation.
00:21:19 Whether they have the solutions or not is another story.
00:21:23 Jack, we're almost out of time, but I do want to ask you one thing
00:21:26 that the Liberals are very proud of, and that is their plans
00:21:29 to build prefabricated housing in great quantity
00:21:32 to take care of what everybody acknowledges is a serious housing crisis,
00:21:39 one that has been generated by excessive immigration, perhaps. Nevertheless, the people
00:21:45 are here. They don't have a place to live. They're talking about prefabricated housing.
00:21:50 That, along with alternative energy, is something that Brookfield has great experience with. Of
00:21:59 course, Mr. Carney would be familiar with that, so I can imagine where these ideas are coming
00:22:04 from. But you know, I grew up in Great Britain right after the war, and we had prefabricated
00:22:10 houses everywhere, and there was a reason for that. The housing stock had been bombed out,
00:22:16 and people had to live somewhere, so they threw together what they could. But nobody ever said,
00:22:20 my goal is to live in a prefab. There are still some out there. They were well built.
00:22:28 most of them are gone but there are still some out there but typically there are social problems
00:22:34 that come with living in that kind of uh inexpensive relatively publicly funded publicly
00:22:42 operated housing do you have any more faith in that plan than i do well it's not entirely clear
00:22:50 that's the the best approach in fact i don't mind if people have a demand for it and they would like
00:22:56 to have it built in fact right now uh i did some reading on it actually atco in alberta is actually
00:23:01 one of the biggest uh builders of uh prefabricated housing and of course uh the issue is that it's
00:23:09 it requires land and i think that's going to be the biggest problem is the fact that it's still
00:23:15 land intensive housing uh and um you know we could put uh saudi hot huts on on uh on land in fact if
00:23:24 anyone wants to know what a saudi hat is you just go to calgary heritage park it's what the westerners
00:23:29 uh they lived in these grass hills hills which which were very cheap to to make and they have
00:23:38 you know a lot of land of course to live around it but uh but the prefabricated homes uh will
00:23:43 still require land and it's not entirely clear that this can be necessarily the only or best option
00:23:49 And in big urban centers, of course, condos tend to be a lot less land intensive.
00:23:57 The problem with condos, of course, is that for families that want to have a backyard and et cetera, et cetera, you need to have land.
00:24:06 So I'm not convinced that fabricated housing is going to be the solution.
00:24:10 In fact, we shouldn't try to push in any one direction.
00:24:14 I think we need to have housing built for the different demands that are out there.
00:24:21 And so I like policies, which both the Conservatives and Liberals have,
00:24:25 like reducing development charges, cutting taxes, GST, for example, on housing.
00:24:34 There's some negatives associated with that, but I think that should be done.
00:24:38 I think the provinces should get out of their land transfer taxes.
00:24:41 uh you know in in ontario and in toronto they're double uh the ontario rate because the toronto has
00:24:48 has a loan transfer tax as well it's a huge tax on mobility but but it has to purchase cost of
00:24:54 housing to a very large extent so there's a whole bunch of policies that i think we can do to lower
00:25:00 the cost of housing without telling people well you have to buy a prefab as opposed to something
00:25:05 else and this is this goes back to i think do you have policies that you know tell people what to do
00:25:12 or just get governments out of the way and that's why i prefer kind of those policies that are going
00:25:18 to get the government out of the way amen to that jack thank you for this my wife and i are going
00:25:24 to be out in the country this weekend with our little handbook of edible plants uh just in case
00:25:30 the privy council offices got it right would you care to risk your reputation on a guess on what's
00:25:35 going to happen on monday go on i dare you or maybe tuesday i think is the election
00:25:40 the 28th yes 128 okay i'm sorry i forgot i've already voted so anyway uh yes uh am i going to
00:25:50 predict yes i think the liberals will win but uh whether they get a majority is another story
00:25:54 that's uh uh we'll have to see well jack will the polls agree with you uh and some of us are ready
00:26:01 to, as I say, take to the hills. This has been great. Thank you very much, Jack. It's always
00:26:07 a pleasure to have you on the program. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.