Western Standard - October 23, 2025


Is This Municipal Election Really About the Candidates or About Control?

Topics
Mentioned
Farkas defeats Gondek: Calgary Elections 2025 Do Calgary's new councillors have it in them to repeal open zoning?

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

185.48

Word count

8,901

Sentence count

241

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

It's election day in Alberta, and there's a lot to unpack in this week's results. First, a look at the results of the two major cities, Calgary and Edmonton, and how they voted. Then, we look at Bill 20, the bill that opened the door for formal political parties at the municipal level, increased oversight of municipalities, and changed donation rules, all in the name of leveling the playing field.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Well,
00:00:29 hello there everybody and fine viewers welcome to the western standard this is the corey
00:00:34 morgan show i am not cora morgan i am lindsey wilson of link strategies i'm filling in for my
00:00:41 very good friend corey morgan who is traveling abroad right now john would you kindly put up a
00:00:46 photo of corey morgan just so people can remember what he looks like excellent yes this fine looking
00:00:53 gentleman right here he is currently overseas he is traveling i believe in israel right now so i'm
00:00:59 I'm sure when he returns to take his show back on, he will come here with lots of photos
00:01:04 and stories and adventures.
00:01:06 So Corey, we wish you well.
00:01:07 Please travel safely and make it back home to tell us all about it.
00:01:11 Well, folks, it's been quite the election week here in Alberta.
00:01:15 And if you are a political junkie living and working in this space like yours truly, you've
00:01:19 probably got more questions than answers coming out of this one, because what we've just
00:01:23 witnessed in Calgary and Edmonton is a tipping point for how politics at the local levels
00:01:27 played and how the province regulates it. Let's start with the basics. Turn out or more accurately
00:01:34 the lack thereof. Just 33% of Calgarians cast a ballot and worse yet in Edmonton, 30% is that
00:01:41 democracy in action or on life support. To make matters worse, the process itself threw up
00:01:46 unnecessary obstacles. As reported at the Western Standard, Alberta held course on eliminating
00:01:51 electronic vote tabulators in favour of paper only system and the results were exactly what you'd
00:01:57 expect. Long lines, delays in counting, confusion, and in some political polling stations, the
00:02:03 lineups were stretched so long that voters just left rather than wait. We heard reports that some
00:02:07 areas were taking two to three hours for voters to cast their ballots, and all signs point to
00:02:13 people just getting fed up and leaving. If you already think that local government has lost your
00:02:18 interest, being confronted with a voting experience that looks like it was designed for the 1980s
00:02:22 doesn't help. But for those who did vote, the results sent a message. In Calgary, Jeremy
00:02:28 Pathfinder Farkas made history. He became the first person to unseat a sitting Calgary mayor
00:02:32 since Ralph Klein did so back in 1980. That's 45 years, folks. And the margin, fewer than 600 votes,
00:02:39 separated him from Sonia Sharp of the community's first party. It's a thin win. And while Sharp has
00:02:45 officially called for a recount, as most candidates would in her position, it's pretty fair to assume
00:02:50 that it would be a long shot and fairly safe to say it won't lead to a change in the mayor's chair.
00:02:55 Trailing behind them were outgoing mayor Jody Gondek plus Jeff Davison and Brian Thiessen.
00:02:59 Respectable showings but not enough to close the gap. Up the road in Edmonton, no upheaval. The
00:03:05 mayor was re-elected for a third term. Clean, predictable, no major shake-up. So we have two
00:03:11 snapshots here in our major cities. Calgary voted for change, Edmonton chose continuity.
00:03:16 Now, was this election a referendum on local leadership? Certainly. But was it also a giant middle finger to the creeping party system in municipal politics? I would argue yes.
00:03:27 Let's talk about Bill 20. In short, it's the provincial legislation that opened the door for formal political parties at the municipal level, increased oversight of municipalities, changed donation rules, all in the name of, quote, leveling the playing field.
00:03:40 It was piloted this election cycle in Calgary and Edmonton.
00:03:44 A conservative political government wanted to create a path for conservative candidates
00:03:48 to keep up with more left-leaning candidates, many of whom were very well funded by the unions.
00:03:53 But the shakeout wasn't exactly a dream come true,
00:03:55 and with a majority of newly elected officials being independents,
00:03:58 some may call the entire experiment a total bust.
00:04:01 Instead of clarity, we saw fragmentation.
00:04:04 And where the centre-right should have coalesced, we got competing flags,
00:04:07 vote splitting, brand confusion, and outright mudslinging.
00:04:11 There is a saying that conservatives simply can't and won't unite,
00:04:14 and that they eat their own.
00:04:16 Progressives didn't completely dominate, but they quietly benefited.
00:04:19 But the story doesn't stop there.
00:04:21 On the provincial front, we now learn the government is preparing yet another bill,
00:04:25 this time to limit who can run in political elections.
00:04:29 According to recent reporting, the bill would give new rules to ensure
00:04:32 only those who truly care and are serious about representing the community
00:04:36 get on the ballot.
00:04:37 I'm not quite sure what that means, but the government says that it's about transparency and it's about clarity, but critics warn it can easily become a gatekeeping mechanism.
00:04:46 So imagine that. At the local level, we have Bill 20 stirring up the party game in our cities, and at the provincial level, the governing party is now talking about a bill to decide who can stand for election.
00:04:56 It's two big structural changes, two big questions, and a lot of controversy.
00:05:01 Does the province stick with this experiment and try to refine it?
00:05:04 Or does it blow the whole thing up before the next municipal cycle?
00:05:07 And that cycle starts today.
00:05:09 Because if the idea was to build a stronger, more coherent, conservative presence in Alberta cities, that just didn't happen.
00:05:15 Now, first time isn't always a charm, and it does take time for people to take on change.
00:05:19 After all, there are municipal parties in cities like Vancouver and Montreal.
00:05:23 But what we got this time around was instead voter fatigue, fractured campaigns and a perception that local issues are being overshadowed by partisan maneuvering.
00:05:31 The most important piece is that Calgarians didn't just reject incumbents, many rejected being told which team to vote for.
00:05:37 They're tired of ideology being measured and snow plowing schedules and pothole contracts and zoning decisions.
00:05:44 Excuse me. They want delivery. They want competence.
00:05:47 They want to believe that their vote moves something real and not just fuels another political turf war.
00:05:52 war. So where does this leave us? We have a brand new mayor in Calgary after decades of continuity,
00:05:59 a steady incumbent in Edmonton and a frustrated electorate, a provincial legislation that's
00:06:06 tinkering with both the local and provincial electoral machinery and a conservative movement
00:06:10 that must ask, have we strengthened ourselves or weakened ourselves? There is a lot to unpack out
00:06:15 of this election and we're going to do just that. I'm going to be joined by two guests today who
00:06:21 know Alberta politics inside and out. Amber Ruddy, Vice President at Council Public Affairs and
00:06:27 Stephen Carter of Decide Campaigns. He is the man behind campaigns for Alison Redford, Nahaid Nenshi
00:06:33 and Jodi Gondek. We'll hash out what this election really means for the future of Bill 20,
00:06:38 for the rise or fall of municipal parties and what people should expect for the next municipal cycle.
00:06:45 And for all of you fine folks watching today, we would like to remind you that the Western
00:06:49 standard needs your support please like share comment follow western standard news on all our
00:06:55 platforms if you're not a subscriber yet go to westernstandard.news and click on subscribe it's
00:07:00 just ten dollars a month or a hundred dollars for the year thank you for your support all right
00:07:06 john i think we are going to get right into it and we're going to move over to our guests
00:07:10 i don't know if they're waiting there in the rooms and they're ready to go but
00:07:14 i think we will get into it here so we've got amber ruddy she's a go-to strategist for 1.00
00:07:18 organizations seeking to navigate Canada's intricate political landscape.
00:07:22 Amber transforms complex policy challenges into strategic opportunities for her
00:07:27 clients. She also has previously served with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation
00:07:30 and the Canadian Federation of Independent Businesses.
00:07:34 We will also be joined by Stephen Carter.
00:07:36 Stephen Carter is an innovator.
00:07:38 He's always pushing the bounds of what is possible.
00:07:40 Best known as one of Canada's leading political strategists, he played a
00:07:43 leadership role in the rise of Mayor Nahid Nenshi, Premier Alison Redford, Mayor Jodi
00:07:49 Gondek, National Post, CBC and other political commentators have always
00:07:52 described Stephen as a political mastermind and this time around Stephen
00:07:57 was involved with the Calgary party. So folks let's get into it. Thank you so
00:08:01 much for joining me. Amber, thank you. I appreciate you coming out and taking
00:08:05 part in this today and Stephen thank you very much. So I think we'll open it up
00:08:09 and i think i think we'll just start with um amber what how was your involvement with this municipal
00:08:16 cycle um and maybe compared to other municipal cycles and then we'll take the same question over
00:08:20 to you stephen oh i think we can't quite hear you amber or is it just me john
00:08:31 oh you're on i think you're on mute amber can you hear me now yes i can hear you now
00:08:40 excellent thank you lindsay um this election i uh do admit i've been more of an observer
00:08:47 having followed quite closely the municipal scenes of calgary and edmonton for some time
00:08:53 it was a little bit refreshing to uh take a back seat on the municipal election coming fresh off
00:08:57 of a federal campaign which i was quite involved with um my observations look this is the first
00:09:03 time this system has been in place in alberta so of course there's going to be growing pains
00:09:10 of course there's going to be some kinks to work out but i think frankly the whole reason the
00:09:15 system was put in place is to give voters a bit more transparency in terms of the candidates that
00:09:21 they have to look for. And having that branding of organization, you know, I think brings value
00:09:31 to the municipal scene. And of course, there's not a sweep of any one candidate or slate across
00:09:38 Edmonton or Calgary, but this is democracy. And the incumbency factor is strong. You see a lot
00:09:45 of folks that have been in the role were either running as independent because they didn't attach
00:09:49 themselves to any one particular party um they fared quite well and so i don't think that this
00:09:55 system is going anywhere maybe there will be some tweaks to refine it uh but this is democracy and
00:10:01 i frankly think it's a little bit messy but it works okay thank you amber and stephen over to
00:10:06 you stephen just tell us a little bit about about your role in in this municipal election and and
00:10:11 then let's get into your thoughts and how everything uh kind of fell out yeah i mean i i was uh the
00:10:17 creator of two parties one in calgary and one in edmonton um you know so the the calgary party and
00:10:23 better edmonton parties uh we created we took advantage of the system that danielle smith
00:10:29 created um i think that she wanted to elect some of her own people uh under under conservative
00:10:36 banners uh we tried to put in place a our own people in in more progressive uh centrist banners
00:10:43 And I think that overall, the system itself worked fairly well.
00:10:48 I like the party structure.
00:10:50 I think I agree with Amber.
00:10:51 I think it gives us an opportunity to know who it is that we're voting for, what it is that we're voting for.
00:10:56 All too often, I think people get elected.
00:10:59 For example, Sonia Sharp ran as a progressive in 2021 and then turned into a very strong conservative.
00:11:06 And ran as a conservative today in this municipal election.
00:11:11 this gives people a better opportunity to know what it is that they're you know who it is they're
00:11:15 voting for and what their principles are what their values are what their ideology is
00:11:21 so I think that it worked out fairly well the fundraising rules are a disaster they need to
00:11:29 be rewritten immediately the hand counting disastrous needs to be rewritten immediately
00:11:35 but you know I mean I'm sure it worked really well in rural community
00:11:40 municipalities where they were only dealing with small portions of votes but
00:11:45 we have you know we have upwards of a million voters in Calgary and 700,000 in
00:11:51 Edmonton and counting is just it was a gong show and disappointing to see the 0.87
00:12:01 new rules but I'm hopeful that the new rules will be taking advantage of
00:12:05 property you know and I don't I don't doubt that elections Alberta and elections Calgary is just
00:12:11 flooded with complaints I mean you know transparency of course I most people watching
00:12:15 this will know that I worked very closely on the Jeff Davison campaign and Jeff ran for mayor and
00:12:19 came in fourth and we had an outpouring of supporters who were reaching out to the campaign
00:12:25 and you know they were cold they were standing outside they were waiting two and three hours
00:12:29 particularly heard a lot of reports in around downtown polling station as well as polling
00:12:33 stations as well as in the deep south i'm sure it was just luck of the draw wherever people were
00:12:39 throughout the city but some people said it was a good experience but we we definitely i would say
00:12:44 in my experience with elections this there was an outpouring of complaints and people just simply
00:12:48 walking away from polling stations which i know for those of us who are really engaged in municipal
00:12:53 politics that's really frustrating um we're always trying to get people to buy into municipal
00:12:59 politics after all it is the level of politics that affects you the most on the day-to-day this
00:13:03 is what affects you know the snow plowing and your garbage pickup and your property taxes
00:13:09 mostly that's provincial as well but these are these are all the things that affect you the most
00:13:13 and yet people have the least amount of engagement uh amber over to you uh you were very involved
00:13:19 with the federal election uh campaign in the spring uh and you know i know over on on on
00:13:25 our side we felt very much that voter fatigue was was had a had a part to play in this and it was a
00:13:32 very slow uptick into people even being engaged or interested i mean i don't know steven you you
00:13:37 might agree with me like i feel like nobody was really paying attention to who was running for
00:13:41 mayor and didn't even have any idea who was running for council in calgary and you can probably chime
00:13:46 in a little bit more about how that was in edmonton they didn't even pay attention until maybe
00:13:51 the last seven to ten days so amber we'll just how much do you think that voter fatigue played
00:13:56 into it and then stephen will go over to you on your thoughts on engagement you know i think it
00:14:02 is important going back to the conversation about um the voting and the lines and the new system
00:14:08 it is important to do a process that instills confidence because when you have um systems that
00:14:15 aren't working for folks and are driving uh a reluctance to vote because they feel like it
00:14:19 might not count and the way it's processed is not fair there's different iterations of how that has
00:14:25 played out um i know some folks wanted to write it in pen or you know there's different uh
00:14:31 considerations i think we do need to take seriously people's concerns so that they have confidence in
00:14:35 the system uh when they do spend an hour or whatever it is that they had to take and go
00:14:40 in line and do that so first of all just want to say that that there's got to be a pendulum there's
00:14:45 maybe some things they can do to improve it. But I think it is important to take those concerns of
00:14:51 voters seriously. When you look at overall, there is a fatigue. And again, if you follow the news,
00:14:58 you might be hearing rumors that a federal election could be imminent. I think, you know,
00:15:03 it is a layering on of issues. The municipal level is, of course, closest to the people.
00:15:08 You're most likely to, you know, drive down the street with potholes,
00:15:13 need to book swimming lessons for your kids, you know, want to go to a public library and use
00:15:19 those services. So it is important. And I'm glad we've had this kind of participation in Calgary,
00:15:26 for example. The incumbency factor is strong, but our incumbent mayor, you know, she's moving on. 1.00
00:15:34 And it is important to have choices in the system so that people can make those decisions.
00:15:41 So I think that overall, you know, there are probably a bit more reflecting and lessons we
00:15:48 can learn as the sort of ink dries on the voting results and we see who are in these roles. But
00:15:55 yeah, I'm very confident that the system will be improved and continue to work for Albertans going
00:16:02 forward. And then Stephen, you know, voter fatigue from the federal election. And then like, let's
00:16:07 throwing this teacher strike i mean this is this has been this has been wild right the last couple
00:16:12 of weeks and and how do you think that that impacted the election i know some of the candidates
00:16:17 including brian teeson had a lot to say about the teacher strike certainly so over to you stephen
00:16:21 yeah i mean i think that we had a significant uh uh number of headwinds if you will the federal
00:16:28 election was certainly a headwind uh it was hard to get people's attention uh during the during the
00:16:33 campaign, I agree with you, pushing through and trying to get people to actually pay attention
00:16:39 on this campaign. We certainly noticed an uptick in attention in the last week and a half,
00:16:44 the last 10 days, but we'd already done half of advanced polling before people had even started
00:16:50 to pay attention. I mean, yes, it is the most difficult level of government to get people out
00:16:56 to vote for, but let's take a look at the actual statistics. Voter turnout was down in Edmonton
00:17:02 on advanced polls down in calgary in advance polls down in edmonton and on voting day down in calgary
00:17:09 on voting day why well in part it was the teacher strike in part it was the blue jays game in part
00:17:16 it was uh people not really caring about municipal government but in part it was rumors of long
00:17:21 lineups people not wanting to give up an hour and a half we have a world standard elections
00:17:27 organization in elections canada and we can't seem to figure out how to run a municipal election in
00:17:32 alberta and that just makes me crazy um the rules changing the way that they did um was a significant
00:17:40 impediment to people being able to actually vote in the election um this time and uh i think that
00:17:48 that the provincial government needs to take a look at that and say what role did we play
00:17:53 and how are we going to make it better uh so far what they're indicating is that they're going to
00:17:58 make it harder to run uh which on some levels i support i think that we do have a lot of candidates
00:18:04 who who are a little bit uh junkie if you will if you're you know you're running for a stunt
00:18:10 um i'd like the candidates that run to be legitimate candidates that have uh the resources
00:18:17 volunteer and otherwise to to actually run a campaign um but that's not our primary problem
00:18:23 our primary problem is how do we get people out to vote uh i'd like to see more provincial support
00:18:29 uh in terms of advertising that the municipal election is happening we could have used a lot
00:18:34 of that uh elections canada does so much advertising to make sure that people know
00:18:38 that the vote is occurring and we had none of that really in calgary edmonton or the balance of all
00:18:43 and certainly the province was really busy there was a lot of announcements over the last month
00:18:49 uh from new license plates to a war with uh with uh the ata and and certainly that did overshadow
00:18:55 things what about the conservative predicament and and steven i really am somebody's a little
00:19:01 bit more on the other side of things i'm really interested in your perspective about this
00:19:05 there was a lot of mudslinging and and and that was between certainly the uh sharpen communities 0.99
00:19:10 first campaign jeff davison campaign there was a lot there's there was some bad blood that was
00:19:14 created there and i'm sure everybody can um you know sow these seeds of division right as as we
00:19:20 come to a close with this election but are there changes that could happen structurally do you
00:19:25 guys think where uh to prevent to say two conservative parties or two more progressive
00:19:31 parties from coming up that would prevent this you know quote vote split we've heard this term
00:19:36 vote split over and over and over right some people say you know we love democracy we love
00:19:39 the choice and others say well no this is vote splitting and you're stopping this person from
00:19:43 getting in and we all just need to get behind a candidate so there's so many different ways
00:19:48 to unpack what that really means and i know one of the one of one of the thoughts is that you
00:19:54 make it harder you make it so a party has to go out and get x amount of signatures make that a
00:19:58 really hard high threshold so you're not going to have a bunch of different parties and groups
00:20:02 running around and doing that so i mean what are your thoughts on that amber i'll let you start
00:20:07 with that one yeah and just to layer on another issue the canada post strike not having your
00:20:12 voter cards and information that's a very obvious thing to be advertised and added another step in
00:20:18 the voting booth where you had to go and you don't have a card to present right you had to go through
00:20:22 an extra step so that slowed things down as well so almost a perfect storm of issues i just wanted
00:20:26 to touch upon briefly this issue about um having legitimate candidates in elections and i think
00:20:32 The impetus of this, of course, if you've been following federal with the last by-election
00:20:37 in Battle River Crowfoot with the longest ballot, there are some provisions I think you can do to
00:20:43 tighten it up. I think over 100 of those candidates, for example, had the same CFO,
00:20:50 like the person that's signing off on the document was the same person for 100 of those candidates.
00:20:54 We could add a bit more heft to make it so that this is a serious exercise and that it's not
00:21:01 becoming a way to make a statement so i'm a firm believer of that um but yeah overall i think um
00:21:10 it is just an interesting time and i i like that there's choice i don't think um you know it would
00:21:17 be great i in my opinion to have a bit of a higher threshold and if you could bring along with it
00:21:23 um maybe if you are a serious party that you would get access to a voters list because that's
00:21:28 That's something that happens provincially and federally.
00:21:30 So that could perhaps weed out having too many parties that are all trying to act in an interest of the signature level of what you needed to create that party was higher.
00:21:42 So maybe there could be a approach of if the voters list was, you know, a certain higher threshold, being able to offer that to the serious parties, I think would be an improvement.
00:21:53 Okay, Stephen, over to you. I mean, some thoughts on this quote vote split and what's your advice
00:21:58 maybe to conservatives or, and we can take it far more generally than that. What do we do
00:22:03 and not have just all these quote competing parties? Well, I think that competition is
00:22:08 essential in politics and I don't like the term vote split. You earn the votes. We all started
00:22:13 at zero. Davison started at zero. We started at zero, right? That's just the nature of the game.
00:22:17 I think you earn your votes. But if you really are concerned about votes, let's take that premise
00:22:23 and just take it through. My recommendation would be to put a preferential ballot in place. 0.88
00:22:28 Why not put a preferential ballot in place for municipal politics? It would be fascinating to
00:22:33 see who would actually get over the 50% threshold. Would it be progressives? Would it be conservatives?
00:22:40 Would it be centrists? I don't know. I actually wouldn't be able to tell you with 100% accuracy
00:22:45 where the Brian Thiessen vote would have gone after the first ballot. I don't think it would
00:22:50 have gone en masse to Jeremy Farkas, Josie Gondek. I think that it would have gone,
00:22:57 it would have split into four or five, you know, four different directions for sure.
00:23:01 The same would be held with Jeff Davison. I don't think that Jeff Davison is the same type
00:23:06 of roaring conservative that Tonya Shark was trying to present herself as. I would have loved 0.54
00:23:11 to have seen a preferential ballot. I also would have loved to have seen a voters list. Amber is 0.85
00:23:17 completely right. Not having a voting list was just that and the postal strike. Amber, I'm glad
00:23:23 you brought both of those up. They were devastating to these campaigns. I had 500,000 pieces of mail
00:23:30 and they were supposed to land the day that the postal strike started. We had to essentially send
00:23:36 trucks to go and get them back so we can try and hand deliver 500,000 pieces of mail, which is
00:23:42 impossible. Amber's come up with two great ideas, but I think bottom line, all of this needs to be
00:23:49 looked at in the future so that we wind up with the right type of civic government. If the
00:23:54 provincial government thinks that most of the voters are conservative, then bring in preferential
00:23:59 ballot. Go for it. It is an opportunity to change our voter system in a way that doesn't impact
00:24:08 the provincial election. It doesn't impact the federal election. Give it a go. See if it works.
00:24:13 See if we like it as Albertans. If you're going to be messing around with the election anyways,
00:24:18 mess around with the election in such a fashion that it actually makes it look.
00:24:22 Yeah, you know, and this was a pilot project, right? And the province had put it forward. Hey,
00:24:25 this is a pilot project. We're going to try it in Calgary. We're going to try it in Edmonton. So,
00:24:28 I mean we have to you know have a little bit of grace for that right it's everything is a pilot
00:24:32 project you look at it you're like okay what went wrong and clearly a lot of things went wrong but
00:24:36 some things went right I think a lot of people could look at this election objectively certainly
00:24:41 in Calgary I mean in Edmonton you definitely got a lot more of the same it's more continuity up there
00:24:46 but I think certainly in Calgary there seems to be I think I feel like things were dialed a little
00:24:51 bit more to the middle I mean I'm I'm very optimistic that you know a good group can be
00:24:56 put together and people will bring a little bit more balance back to City Hall and you know
00:25:01 because it's not healthy for democracy when we have things like a recall Gondek petition and we
00:25:06 have such an unhappy electorate right we we just it's not healthy for us as you know as a city to
00:25:13 have people just pitted against one another and like this this extreme division in politics I
00:25:19 mean I've always been one for multi-partisanship and bringing things a little bit more to to the
00:25:24 centre and and maybe this maybe this path will help us get there so um Stephen you you uh you
00:25:30 you folks over at the Calgary party ran um I'd say you'd ran a very polite campaign and I think
00:25:37 there was a lot of people that were expecting a little bit more you know you've you definitely
00:25:41 you're one of the most creative people in uh in politics and you definitely sometimes can drop a
00:25:46 few bombs but you I mean your folks ran ran a very polite campaign so any thoughts on kind of
00:25:53 your candidates and how it all kind of laid out for you and Brian Thiessen himself. And what's
00:25:58 next for Brian Thiessen? Because I think there's a lot of us that thought, huh, I think that Brian
00:26:03 Thiessen is getting ready to do something maybe at a provincial level. And I know you can't probably
00:26:07 say too much to that, but just wanted your thoughts. Well, I think that the challenge for
00:26:13 us was who to attack. You know, we knew that we were definitely coming for fifth place. So
00:26:19 who do we attack? We attacked Sonia quite a bit in the debates. I called her Sonia Smith-Sharp.
00:26:26 That was the level that we wanted to go to. We didn't want to go to anything too personal or
00:26:34 pushing too hard. And we just felt like our best bet was to run a positive campaign,
00:26:41 especially with the Davison and Sharp campaigns taking such nasty smacks at one another. It just
00:26:47 felt like it wasn't necessary for us and attacking Jeremy Farkas we tried a couple of times but it
00:26:54 just didn't have the legs so we wound up actually going after Danielle Smith which did have legs 0.91
00:27:00 we did very well with that that part of the campaign obviously not well enough to win
00:27:05 so the Western Standard viewer may be turning over and getting a little bit more angry about
00:27:12 that but for our voters it worked quite well and one of the I think challenges that Tim
00:27:17 Cartmill had in Edmonton was not running a more negative campaign against the conservative,
00:27:25 the UCP and the government there. Tim was pegged as the UCP candidate and I think that was an
00:27:33 unfair positioning but nothing to un-push that narrative. So this is the challenge with campaigns
00:27:41 is when do you go negative uh people who were running against uh nenshi remember that he was
00:27:48 one of the most negative campaigners we'd ever seen in canadian municipal politics um but brian
00:27:53 wasn't that guy brian just did not want to attack unless it was uh uh 100 required and it just
00:28:02 wasn't in this campaign it just didn't work it didn't require uh us to open up the bag of dirty
00:28:08 tricks and i'm glad we did it was uh it was a good campaign yeah absolutely and before we go
00:28:14 over to you amber i just john do we have some uh do we have anybody questions on the on the live
00:28:20 stream feed happy to read out a couple of these questions so uh okay jocelyn says post office
00:28:28 strike had nothing to do with apathy just pull out your driver's license fair jocelyn i mean
00:28:34 obviously you're a dedicated voter but i guess some people aren't um let's see what do we have
00:28:38 here we got paul paul says electronics can be manipulated marks on paper so simple simple
00:28:46 marks manipulation makes manipulation more difficult use a pen not a pencil yeah we did hear
00:28:52 a lot of people that were complaining about uh about that um i think there's a little bit of
00:28:56 there's a little bit of lack of understanding around that like because when you make the pencil
00:29:00 market can't be erased and and amber maybe you can just kind of answer that question for somebody
00:29:04 who's concerned about not using a pen and uh and using a pencil instead i mean i think what the
00:29:09 election authorities often say is that the pens like if they order in bulk dry out so they have
00:29:14 pencils on hand because then you can reuse them and they have uh they're standing by but you know
00:29:19 like i have confidence in our voting system that the ballot boxes are sealed that the appropriate
00:29:25 scrutineers are available for each um candidate to observe and so i have confidence in the system but
00:29:31 i i know some folks have reluctance um i i just wanted to go back and comment a little bit about
00:29:37 um i agree with stephen that nobody's voters belong to somebody else so if you look at the
00:29:42 edmonton example you can't just simply take the conservative leaning candidates add them together
00:29:48 and assume that the top vote getter would have got those votes naturally. I think we're at a
00:29:56 bit of a crosshairs in terms of what is the conservative position because blanket rezoning
00:30:02 happened to be a top municipal topic and you don't really see consistency. There's not like
00:30:08 a conservative position on that. And frankly, you see different people coming at it,
00:30:14 progressives and conservatives coming at it from similar angles. So I think it's not so
00:30:21 cut and dry in terms of what is a conservative position on X municipal issue. So the creativity
00:30:28 that those candidates have to come up with to brand themselves and showcase what type of
00:30:34 positions they would take is, you know, a new kind of way to look at it. And there's no monolithic,
00:30:42 i'm a conservative i'm voting for this person right you you have to be able to offer ideas
00:30:47 that resonate and if you can't do that then sorry your your vote doesn't necessarily belong to
00:30:53 somebody else so i think that's something that we have to get past and if you want to um enhance
00:30:58 perhaps there's ways we can enhance those parties that you think might be the best option going
00:31:03 forward for a specific voter to park their vote yeah and i like some of what we're talking about
00:31:09 today right i like i like a higher threshold maybe not so so high i mean there's a lot of thought
00:31:13 around that i like a higher threshold i really like the voter list stephen it's um you know
00:31:18 that's that's really important and i think all of us really suffered from that certainly so those
00:31:22 are things that i i really like but yeah i mean i i i personally don't don't like the term vote
00:31:27 split because you know if this is democracy and this is democracy in action then may the best
00:31:31 candidate win right so i don't like that and it was definitely a driving force in the narrative
00:31:36 um and and certainly i think that that that won the community's first party and their candidate
00:31:41 sonia sharp uh now speaking of that no that was a very close mayor's race and i think some of us
00:31:47 were very surprised i know certainly on our camp we were very surprised uh but that it happened
00:31:52 and it's a margin of almost 600 votes that separated a new mayor elect jeremy farkas from
00:31:58 sonia sharp of the community's first uh team and and you know i think any good campaign manager
00:32:03 would would absolutely say yeah you know call for a recount i think i it would be it's fair to say
00:32:09 it would be very surprising if um if the results were anything different than having uh mayor elect
00:32:14 become the mayor jeremy farkas but uh jeremy farkas you know that's uh i'm i have a history
00:32:20 with jeremy i i worked for him in the ward 11 office when he was a counselor before i worked
00:32:24 for him for almost two and a half years and you know i felt that there was a change in his position
00:32:28 I think most of us did. But, you know, he ran a very smart campaign and he catered to everybody.
00:32:35 So he catered to the left, he catered to the right. It was confusing for some.
00:32:39 And I'm interested to see how that will play out, how that will play out in his office, if it will be a very centrist office or if it'll be if it'll revert back to more conservative people behind him or if it'll stay on the left side.
00:32:51 So, Stephen, I really want to hear your thoughts on the new mayor-elect Jeremy Farkas, who certainly with, I think it was a 26%, correct me if I'm wrong, that's not a strong mandate.
00:33:00 So that's, I think, Jeremy being, you know, the very dedicated campaigner.
00:33:05 And I know he's taking this very seriously.
00:33:07 I think, you know, he's got a, his mandate is, hey, guys, I'm here for you, Calgary, I'm here for all Calgarians.
00:33:13 So, Stephen, we'll let you start with that and then we'll carry over to Amber on that.
00:33:17 Yeah, I mean, it's a real challenge to suggest he even has a mandate, right?
00:33:21 like he's been elected by less than 100 000 people of a 1.6 million person uh city uh he has
00:33:29 um a lot of work to do um his vote total dropped significantly from 2021. 2021 he was a much more
00:33:37 popular politician than he was in 2025 but he won and you know this is where the the challenge is
00:33:44 how does he create a cohesive council when frankly he's got you know some really
00:33:52 rabid progressives i mean uh i know that conservatives sometimes dislike conservatives
00:33:57 but i'll tell you there's no there's no feud like the inter-progressive war i'll tell you that
00:34:01 um blood blood tests all around just to make sure that you're the right level of progressive
00:34:07 um but this you know he's got some people who are just rabbit uh rabbit also on the right
00:34:13 you know landon johnson not really a conciliatory type of fellow i mean he ran the uh recall gand
00:34:19 gondek campaign he's going to be a big voice in in municipal government um how does he work with
00:34:27 jeremy i think he would have worked really well with jeremy 1.0 jeremy 2.0 i'm not sure he works
00:34:34 well with at all so i'm just dying to see how jeremy takes this extremely small mandate both
00:34:41 in terms of a level of victory and overall number of votes and turns it into something
00:34:47 that Calgarians rally behind. The way that we rallied behind Dave Brown-Kanye, the way that
00:34:52 we rallied behind Nenshi, Ralph Klein. This is fascinating. This is the first time that an
00:34:59 incumbent mayor has lost in Calgary since Ralph Klein beat Rod Sykes in 1980. So this is a
00:35:07 a significant election from that point of view as well I think we're all interested Amber you
00:35:13 know we'll go over to you here we're all interested you know we all remember and that's
00:35:16 who I used to work for was he was Jeremy 1.0 and that was you know he was the bravo rouser and he
00:35:21 stood on the soapbox and he was you know the man of the people right and from in his term from
00:35:27 2017 to 2021 I guess and we're seeing a different version of Jeremy is this a more mature Jeremy
00:35:33 is this a more collaborative Jeremy? Because I would argue that whoever is leading the city,
00:35:38 you have to be collaborative. It's one of the number one skill sets. For me, that's why I got
00:35:43 behind Jeff Davison. I saw that he had that ability to bridge the left and the right.
00:35:47 Will Jeremy be able to do that? Amber, what do you think?
00:35:51 I mean, it's a first past the post system, and he won. And I think that we have to get behind him.
00:35:58 as our mayor you know we're facing a lot of different um things that are going on in the
00:36:03 in the context and we need a strong voice for calgary and i think we need to give him the room
00:36:08 to create that collaborative culture he's been signaling i've seen in his social media posts
00:36:13 he's already been meeting with some of the folks that are coming forward and have been elected as
00:36:20 we sort of hear all the results coming in and things are finalized um and i you know i have
00:36:26 confidence that he's going to put his best foot forward. I think he might surround himself with
00:36:31 some folks in his advisory capacity to the right of him and some to the left of him.
00:36:36 And that's probably where you need a mayor to be. This isn't partisan politics anymore. You know,
00:36:41 there's some major projects that we need to get forward. We need to have some discussions with
00:36:46 the federal government on some very important projects. And frankly, let's just give him the
00:36:53 space to see what he's able to do he's one vote on a council and the more that he can try to
00:36:58 collaborate with his colleagues and set a better tone uh we've had some toxic councils we've had
00:37:04 some toxic councils that maybe they got more votes uh for a certain thing but look how sideways
00:37:11 things have gone um and the fact that gondak didn't come in second i think speaks volume
00:37:17 to a change uh type of election and um i'm hopeful i'm just going to be optimistic that he uh
00:37:24 he puts his best foot forward and um let's give him the space to do that and and see how he lands
00:37:30 you know and i think we have to do that right we have to be positive and we have to build bridges
00:37:34 not walls so i i too wish jeremy parkas all the best and i hope he surrounds himself with some
00:37:40 really excellent people and uh governs with uh with collaboration as he moves forward as the next
00:37:46 mayor so i guess we'll kind of wind down the show with going into just a little bit about what's
00:37:51 happening in some of these uh in some of the councillor positions so landon johnson's very
00:37:55 interesting he won he won he had very strong numbers um so you know all the best to him with
00:38:01 that but certainly there are a lot of there's a lot of buzz that he is jeremy 1.0 and that he's
00:38:06 going to be quote the new jeremy so i too am interested to see how that'll play out um that
00:38:13 it will be really interesting. I do feel there's a lot of people that kind of hover around the
00:38:17 centre, kind of both ways. I'm trying to think if there's any other really, really big personalities
00:38:22 in there. I know we've got a couple of recounts coming. So I think it's just the mayor recount
00:38:28 coming, which I don't know that we'll see any really different results. But Ward 12. Now that,
00:38:34 Stephen, correct me if I'm wrong, I think that differentiation is 29. So that would be the
00:38:39 Alberta Calgary party or the ABC party that would be their their one seat in in this election which
00:38:47 would be Mike Jameson and Ward 12 and then that's the Calgary party candidate Sarah Ferguson who 0.98
00:38:53 who's up against him there so tell me a little bit about that and what you think about some of these
00:38:57 some of where these councillors landed.
00:38:59 counted by machine election i think it would be uh much less optimism on our side um but because
00:39:11 it is hand counted and the process uh does have a little bit more room for error so i'm we're
00:39:17 we're cautiously optimistic obviously when you do a recount it can go either way right you don't know
00:39:23 if there's mistakes number one and number two you don't know the direction that the mistakes are
00:39:27 made. When there was a recount in 2021 with DJ Kelly versus Sean Chu, Sean Chu wound up getting
00:39:33 a larger number. So we'll see how things go in 2025 for Ward 12. I think that the number's too
00:39:41 big for the mayor's chair, 500 plus strikes me as too big of an error rate. But 29 in Ward 12,
00:39:52 Like I say, it could go either way, but we are cautiously optimistic that we'll find Sarah Ferguson in council instead of Mike Jamison.
00:40:02 Yeah, very interesting. I think, John, we'll go to some of the comments here.
00:40:06 What do we got here? We've got Wayne Lustill.
00:40:09 We need to get rid of municipal politics. Nobody shows up to vote.
00:40:15 Amber, can you take that question on?
00:40:17 when people there is there is a little bit of that idea out there and what do you say to those folks
00:40:22 who are just like ah get rid of it let the province just take it all over or whatever what
00:40:26 what do you say to that well i mean when you look at the federal and provincial system we do go
00:40:31 through redistribution uh after every census because you do want to have some representatives
00:40:36 um that can speak for you and that are accessible because they have a fair number of voters that they
00:40:42 would deal with and i think uh municipally you're sort of the closest to people and in fact there
00:40:48 could probably be a case made you know fair representation would add a few councillors 1.00
00:40:54 over time but i'll leave that conversation for another another chat certainly do we have any
00:41:01 more questions in there john all right guys well i think we're gonna bring it to just some final
00:41:06 closes i mean uh stephen like your overall like what's your takeaway from this election and and
00:41:14 what do you want the what do you want everybody who's watching this to know about what went down
00:41:18 and what you want to see moving forward well first let me address the importance of municipal politics
00:41:24 the ability to reach your representative and and get your pothole fills and your and the ability
00:41:30 for water to go uphill and poop to go downhill uh are super important uh we can't be uh pretending
00:41:39 that the provincial government is going to step in and do any better job um that just frustrates
00:41:44 the heck out of me uh the the overall election um you know edmonton said they want to change
00:41:51 and they kept the same uh calgary got a massive change uh we'll see how uh these two governments
00:41:58 approach the provincial government uh how they approach the federal government and how things
00:42:03 change in the next four years uh our cities are in in the big in the midst of a huge change
00:42:11 especially calgary with our population growth but these changes are going to need to be met by
00:42:18 really quality municipal government and i wish the best to all those who want all right amber over
00:42:25 to you what are what are your some thoughts and you know i said in my opening monologue today
00:42:29 uh was this election with in as far as calgary is concerned was this election like a giant middle
00:42:34 finger to the party system because you know as of right now as of today we have one from abc we have
00:42:42 one from the calgary party carter is that correct there's there's one and then yep and then we have
00:42:49 two from communities first technically four although i think most of us would argue that
00:42:55 wards 10 with uh war 10 with andre chabot and ward 13 with dan mclean they would have been elected
00:43:01 regardless of the the party system was was really uh a complete wash for either one of them so you
00:43:07 know you technically have four with communities first but really only two of those would have been
00:43:11 viewed as as part of the party system so what do you think about that amber again i think the party
00:43:17 system is in its infancy i think we're going to see it grow and um i thought that it added a
00:43:24 transparency i thought that it added that level of uh branding and organization and perhaps that
00:43:31 helped like you say um each party got at least one candidate through right so i think that shows that
00:43:39 you know that's democracy i don't think you necessarily would expect to have an entire
00:43:44 sweep of uh one party taking over the whole system and there's differences in how the
00:43:49 parties operated right like some were more like slates while others were more like parties right
00:43:55 so like if you look at how um a better calgary had members and tried to do votes and tried to
00:44:02 you know hold their a grassroots type of style well the communities first was more like a slate
00:44:09 it was like who is the candidate that they can field for a specific seat so i think these things
00:44:15 are going to evolve and I look forward to what the next iteration does and I hope it brings us even
00:44:21 higher quality folks that continue to want to step forward given the context of how tough it
00:44:27 is to be an elected official. I think we should commend everybody that did put their name forward
00:44:32 and thank those that will be serving us for the next term here as they face some challenging
00:44:38 discussions with Ottawa, with the provincial government and with other municipalities in
00:44:43 in the region so i'm hopeful that it will you know we'll see better things the next iteration
00:44:49 and i think i think i just want to add that i think it is interesting just very quickly it is
00:44:53 really interesting how the party versus slate right and and so and um you know maybe it's fair
00:44:58 to say calgary party was a little bit of both but calgary party was very clear we are a party we're
00:45:02 running together and it was very clear on their branding and signage abc was very clear we're a
00:45:05 party and that was very clear on their branding and their signage and it wasn't as clear with
00:45:09 communities first so i'll be interested to see if there's going to be more rules that come around
00:45:12 that that people hey better or worse they want to know are you with the party or not and not be able
00:45:18 to not tell that from the signage um yes stephen i feel like you just want to jump in for like a
00:45:23 really quick comment on that listen i mean they wanted the best of both worlds they wanted to run
00:45:27 his independence and terry wong was a member of communities first too um people forget it because
00:45:34 he never ever acknowledged that he was part of it so he wants the benefit of being part of a party
00:45:40 and the benefit was fundraising the benefit was the capacity uh on a lot of different things and uh
00:45:47 you know he they want the benefit but he doesn't want to take the the hit if you will i don't know
00:45:53 anything about it i mean we we went to the debates and it was like chameleon's first i don't know
00:45:59 what that is you know i mean first of all very pleased that terry wong lost nonetheless we move
00:46:06 long and and fair enough but you know what very interesting that's very good i think i think folks
00:46:11 you can't have your cake and eat it too so you either you take a stand right and you stand and
00:46:15 you're with the party or you're not and either way but i think a little bit of clarity in the
00:46:18 next election wouldn't hurt all of us so thank you is best always yeah absolutely i would agree
00:46:25 with you i just want to thank you guys so much stephen carter from decide campaigns and amber
00:46:29 ruddy from council public affairs thank you so much for joining us today uh folks just thank you
00:46:34 thank you for tuning in i hope you found this valuable um thank you for joining us thank you
00:46:39 for your comments and you know for all of you watching today just want to remind you western
00:46:43 standard needs your support like share comment follow western standard news follow on all the
00:46:49 platforms and if you are not a subscriber yet you can head on over to westernstandard.news
00:46:55 and you can subscribe it's just ten dollars a month or a hundred dollars for the year
00:46:59 And we'll just one more time, John, we'll bring up my friend Corey Morgan's photo back up here.
00:47:04 You are going to see this handsome guy. He's going to return. This is his show. This is not my show.
00:47:09 I am not Cora Morgan. I am Lindsay Wilson of Link Strategies. Thank you all. Thank you to all of
00:47:14 you voters, all of you listeners. Like and share and subscribe to independent media and always get
00:47:20 out there to vote. Thank you.
00:47:29 We'll be right back.