Western Standard - April 24, 2025


Is this the End-DP?

Topics
Mentioned
Protesters against Poilievre Pierre Poilievre arrives in Calgary

Episode Stats


Length

51 minutes

Words per minute

170.92

Word count

8,859

Sentence count

435

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, The Western Standard's senior editor and editor-in-chief, Nigel Hannaford, and co-host, Erica Baroutes, discuss the Debates Commission's handling of the first debate.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 half of young Canadian women say they're putting off kids because they can't afford them but
00:00:08 Mark Carney wants 100 million people not for families for the machine no homes no hope and
00:00:17 no future just growth at any cost not to build Canada but to change it
00:00:30 Good day.
00:00:57 Today is April 23rd,
00:00:59 2025. I am Derek Fultebrandt,
00:01:01 publisher of the Western Standard, and you're
00:01:03 watching The Pipeline.
00:01:05 I'm joined, as always, by
00:01:07 Western Standard senior, not senior
00:01:09 goals, opinion editor,
00:01:11 Nigel Hannaford. I am
00:01:13 the opinion editor. There is no juniors.
00:01:15 I am here.
00:01:17 And I would not deign to call you a senior.
00:01:18 And I am...
00:01:20 Well, I don't know.
00:01:23 But we do have an official senior
00:01:27 here, Senior Alberta Colmas, 0.54
00:01:29 Cory Morgan.
00:01:30 Hello, senor.
00:01:31 All right. 0.73
00:01:32 Now, we've also got, she's been on with us a few times now, and we've just said, screw it.
00:01:37 We're going to make her a regular member of, or co-host of the Pipeline here, Erica Baroutes, 1.00
00:01:46 Department Head of the Applied Politics and Public Affairs Program at McAmey College in Edmonton, Alberta.
00:01:54 Well, officially welcome as our newest co-host.
00:01:57 Yeah, I'm excited to be here and that you didn't call me a senior, so we're off to a good start.
00:02:02 You're the only one who did not get called a senior.
00:02:03 I know.
00:02:04 All right, senior.
00:02:07 So we're going to talk about the debate that took place last week.
00:02:12 Much of you have already seen it or you've seen the clips of it and heard some things,
00:02:15 but now that we got a little distance from the debate, we want to kind of zoom out,
00:02:20 talk about what happened and also the complete breakdown of order and any ability to reasonably
00:02:29 inform the public uh that came from the debates commission uh the controversy of some independent
00:02:36 media versus some of the legacy media we're going to talk about that now that we've had some time
00:02:40 to breathe and digest it all we're gonna talk about um the liberal platform talk a bit about
00:02:46 the conservative platform, but primarily the liberal one, which Mark Carney is running on.
00:02:51 As it turns out, it was written by the Liberal Party before he was the leader. In fact, it was
00:02:57 written while Justin Trudeau was the leader. They've just taken it and cranked, taken Trudeau's
00:03:02 platform and cranked it up to 10 on a few things and made a couple of nips and tucks for some of
00:03:06 the less popular parts like the carbon tax. And is this the end DP? That's my dad attempt at joking
00:03:15 about the potential complete collapse and destruction of the NDP as an electoral force
00:03:21 in this election. Projections have them on track for the worst showing in that party's history,
00:03:27 potentially, next week. All right, let's get into it. We're going to begin with Erica.
00:03:35 Erica, the debate sucked. I put it to you. Yeah, I mean, I think we're done. I think that 0.57
00:03:42 captures it perfectly. So if people didn't watch us do our debate pre and post, which I was,
00:03:49 you know, sitting with you gents from afar in Edmonton, or if Derek, what you said at the
00:03:56 start of the show made no sense to anyone, which is me half the time, I will give a quick synopsis
00:04:00 of kind of what happened. So there was obviously the debate. I think Steve Pagan is the winner of
00:04:06 the debate he ended up being a very fair moderator unfortunately as you alluded to the
00:04:14 debate commission i think kind of went rogue and screwed up a lot of opportunity for media what you
00:04:20 were talking about before is that on the first night last wednesday we had the french debate
00:04:26 and rebel news managed to get the the spots at the beginning of the podium which was totally fair
00:04:32 However, they, you know, was argued by some of the mainstream and other individuals there that, you know, let's let's kind of play nice and and have more order and more discrepancy about like who who can be at those podiums.
00:04:44 So long and short, it did kind of cause a frouhaha that we focused on last week because of like, why can the commission just all of a sudden deem a security breach at the end of the English debate and not have media outlets ask questions of the candidates like they did the night before?
00:05:04 So last minute, they kind of pulled the rug out from all the media individuals that had been there, including Jen, who had been there all day to stand in line to get their fair question and to do what the media is supposed to do, which is report.
00:05:18 And so I think that that actually, you know, maybe gave the most color besides Francois Blanchet to the debate.
00:05:24 Otherwise, I think that the popcorn that we were all eating while watching was the most entertaining part of that overall debate.
00:05:31 I would challenge Erica
00:05:35 on the fair part of that
00:05:37 for Rebel News
00:05:38 you know I'm a fan of
00:05:41 a lot of what Ezra and the Rebel do
00:05:43 but they were able to take
00:05:45 I think four to five of the
00:05:47 very limited number of question
00:05:49 slots after the French debate
00:05:51 I
00:05:52 haven't actually asked Ezra this
00:05:55 particular question but what I've read
00:05:57 and I'm taking that skeptically but from what I've read
00:05:59 they were able to get that because they declared
00:06:01 themselves to be like four or five different divisions so different technically different
00:06:04 media companies uh i don't think that should have been allowed i think whatever your parent
00:06:10 company it's just one like the western standard shouldn't be allowed to send western standard
00:06:15 alberta report saskatchewan standard west coast standard no just western standard all together
00:06:19 post media can't send national post uh calgary herald you know and i guess i guess my question
00:06:26 dark phoenix and i agree with all that except i don't know how the rules were clearly just 0.98
00:06:34 they were just stupid yeah they were stupid rules and they played by it and i get how that irks some 0.94
00:06:39 people i was irked because we had jen hodgson there she didn't get to ask a question uh you 1.00
00:06:45 know uh it was just rebel there was uh some of the other independent uh conservative leaning ones as
00:06:49 well. They were stupid rules. And the rebel played by the stupid rules had won. 1.00
00:06:56 They leveraged the rules to their benefit. 1.00
00:06:58 Yeah. So I don't blame the rebel. I don't think it was fair, but I don't blame the rebel because
00:07:03 they just won under those stupid rules. But then it was the second night, the legacy media, 1.00
00:07:11 I should say the media, the legacy media guys in the media room were outraged, Corey. And they
00:07:19 I mean, we already talked about it, played some of the footage,
00:07:22 but they ended up in a, there was a screaming match 0.90
00:07:24 from one of these, a Hill Times reporter.
00:07:27 Anyone remember his name?
00:07:28 No, he's not that.
00:07:30 Very important.
00:07:31 But anyway, he was screaming, losing his mind first
00:07:34 at Kian Bextian from Juno and Counter Signal,
00:07:37 and then at Ezra LeVant.
00:07:41 And then I guess they just decided, like, I told Jen Auterson,
00:07:46 you're literally going to stand at the front of that line
00:07:47 and camp there all day like it's you're getting tickets to kiss in 1978 or something and she did 0.91
00:07:54 she wasn't born yet not it was i but it's kids come on uh me neither but i'm not a senior so
00:08:04 i don't need to disclose that yeah but um you know i i guess the debate commission saw that
00:08:11 the independent media were lining up again again i we were only there for one question i think that's
00:08:15 fair. We should have been allowed. One question. I think the
00:08:17 rebel should have absolutely been allowed
00:08:19 inquiry, but
00:08:21 the rebel, I mean,
00:08:23 I guess played by the rules
00:08:25 a little too clever by half, and
00:08:27 the debate commission lost its mind
00:08:29 over it. It just cancelled it the second day.
00:08:32 Yeah, it showed them
00:08:33 incapable, I guess, of trying to come up with a new set of rules
00:08:35 on the fly. I mean, I think
00:08:37 quickly enough, somebody should have realized the errors
00:08:39 made during the French debate
00:08:41 and just said, look, we've got to get this sorted
00:08:43 out. One question per outlet.
00:08:45 And then we can rotate and perhaps you'll get through to a second one or run with a draw.
00:08:49 It's not that hard if you've got the will, but when you get bureaucratic type groups,
00:08:53 they can't make decisions on the fly or change something when they've already written it up.
00:08:57 Corey, all they needed was a deck of cards.
00:08:59 Yes.
00:08:59 Everybody took top spades starts.
00:09:02 There you go.
00:09:02 Because otherwise, if you did do a lineup, I could see the fights getting worse.
00:09:06 I could see it if they see that it's stacked again with a bunch of one particular outlet over another in the front.
00:09:11 And people who, in good faith, legacy or not, came to get a question in and realizing they're not going to make it to the front of this lineup.
00:09:19 Plus the fact that they allowed the questioners to put in lecturing preambles.
00:09:24 Yeah, there were some of them, some of them, not all of them, but some of them had a bit of a monologue.
00:09:29 And again, as a viewer, I was frustrated with that.
00:09:32 Look, I'm viewing, I understand a slant that an outlet's going to come from and that you want to give a bit of a preamble.
00:09:38 But if you're going to spend, you know, four minutes getting to the point on a question, I want to hear from the answer, not the questioner.
00:09:45 But again, these things should have been able to change on the fly.
00:09:48 Instead, they just thought the easier thing to avoid conflict there is just to pull the plug on the whole works.
00:09:52 And maybe four years from now, we'll try something again.
00:09:54 It was a terrible failure on their part.
00:09:56 Nigel, I, you know, I kind of parted away from a lot of, you know, conservative leaning types with the establishment of the Debates Commission,
00:10:06 because i i think uh leaving it to just the legacy media big networks has got its own set
00:10:13 of perils it tends to be more arbitrary the rules about who's in and who's out change every time
00:10:18 so you wouldn't want to leave it to the whole times to decide no certainly not uh those are
00:10:23 not the people who should be deciding but uh you know we have uh you know so like the rules about
00:10:30 who's in and who's not is so arbitrary uh and sometimes they make sense sometimes they don't
00:10:35 makes sense i thought well okay the the debates commission uh will be imperfect but at least we
00:10:43 can establish some consistency at least between elections so like here's the benchmark to make
00:10:47 it in do you have to elect someone first you have to have a certain number of mps first i'd be
00:10:52 polling above a certain amount whatever it is now they they seemed to tweak those rules from time
00:10:57 to time to ensure that the green party is in and the ppc is out uh but at least it was it was more
00:11:04 consistent, at least for inclusion
00:11:05 or exclusion,
00:11:07 than having the old networks do it.
00:11:10 But it came with its own set of problems.
00:11:12 It's become more bureaucratic now,
00:11:14 which obviously happens when you put it
00:11:16 in the hands of government.
00:11:17 Is there a preferable... Which is better?
00:11:20 Just taking it back to the networks?
00:11:22 The McLean's debate, by itself
00:11:24 in 2015,
00:11:27 Paul Wells,
00:11:28 I think, hosted that one.
00:11:29 That was a good, informative debate.
00:11:32 That was just one outlet, so you didn't have
00:11:34 bunch of cooks in the kitchen every every network trying to get their airtime so to speak um i don't
00:11:40 know is it time to abolish the debates commission reform it uh or continue on all right i just i
00:11:46 just think it's time for them to do a better job i had a look at their website to see exactly what
00:11:51 we were dealing with here and there are a number of retired politicians who are the sort of the
00:11:58 governing board as it were and then you they have a staff of three that's quite a lot of people
00:12:04 to actually sit around the table and say how are we going to do this in a way that is fair
00:12:11 to the candidates and also to the media and perhaps consult with some of the media
00:12:19 including the independent media and say well what would work i mean i was making a facetious
00:12:25 comment about a pack of cards well actually it's not that bad that would have done better than what
00:12:31 they did it's perfect but it'd be better yeah so uh it's uh there's a there's eight
00:12:39 clever people some of whom are well paid for being there they should be able to fix this and
00:12:46 it just takes a good look at that footage from the other night they'll see why i also think if
00:12:53 If we're going to keep the Debates Commission, and I know a lot of people are saying get rid of it, probably get rid of the people on the commission.
00:13:01 At the very least, we've got a clean house from it.
00:13:04 And I'm sure not everybody there is bad, but I think this is such an epic gargant.
00:13:09 Everybody on all sides of the political spectrum agreed this was a total, complete failure.
00:13:13 Not even talking about the debate itself.
00:13:15 Its format was, I mean, it was for tiny, little soundbites.
00:13:21 Well, we already get that on social media.
00:13:22 This was for something a little more long form, more interactive, where you're going to be testing under fire these leaders in a form, because none of the leaders do big, outside of French media, where it's still important, none of the major leaders have done a sit-down accountability interview where they're really tested.
00:13:41 at Adeklis Polyev, Carney.
00:13:43 I can't speak to Singh because no one pays attention to him anymore.
00:13:46 But the two big guys, they haven't really been tested in a long form sit-down interview
00:13:51 where they're really held to the fire.
00:13:54 This was the opportunity for that, and they missed it.
00:13:58 But at the very least, I think we need new commissioners.
00:14:00 And it can't just be appointed by the prime minister, for God's sakes.
00:14:04 It shouldn't even just be appointed by a simple majority of parliament.
00:14:06 This kind of thing should have a super majority of parliament 0.99
00:14:10 where you've got at least the government
00:14:11 and the official opposition both buying in,
00:14:14 agreeing together on who's going to be on this commission.
00:14:18 It's got to be so far above reproach.
00:14:20 Not that I'm accusing it of necessarily being partisan,
00:14:23 but there was not bipartisan or multi-partisan buy-in here.
00:14:28 What do you think, Erica?
00:14:29 Should we throw it out?
00:14:31 Just kick it back to the networks?
00:14:34 Keep it the commission or something else?
00:14:37 Yeah, I mean,
00:14:37 i don't know how many people actually paid attention and this is one where you're like
00:14:42 this is time to pay attention i agree that we're missing kind of those editorial board style
00:14:47 of interviews that give that long-form content and now that we have technology just air those
00:14:53 um a little bit different than these debates because you're right they were really catered
00:14:58 to the attention deficit disorder that our entire nation uh probably struggles with in like these
00:15:04 quick soundbites as opposed to letting them kind of go at it and what i was hoping to see was how
00:15:09 both pierre and mark would get under and respond under pressure because i think that that was also
00:15:17 to differentiate for them and these setups and how we've seen them over the last little while
00:15:23 for the front runners it's about just not losing support i don't think anyone is winning in in
00:15:29 debates in their their current structure and to be frank like i think a lot of people already voted
00:15:34 already knew how they were going to vote so you know i don't know i i'm i'm starting to lose the
00:15:40 sense of do people actually care do they actually listen in this one we would think but even the
00:15:45 the viewership or the influence of the undecided was maybe not going to be you know weighing as
00:15:52 much as we'd hope so if if it's about tax saving tax dollars i'll say get her out of there i you 1.00
00:16:00 know what when it comes to elections it's not really about tax dollars they're going to be
00:16:03 expensive no matter what, although
00:16:05 in the grand scheme of a federal budget, they cost
00:16:07 nothing. So, I think
00:16:09 it's about doing it right, regardless of what the
00:16:11 cost is. I'd also
00:16:13 note, if we're going to have
00:16:15 a debate, we should have more than one.
00:16:18 And because, or sorry, I guess
00:16:19 technically two, but, you know, as
00:16:21 we talked about previously,
00:16:23 the French debate
00:16:25 is a de facto Quebec
00:16:27 debate, where the bloc leader gets to play host
00:16:29 to the thing.
00:16:32 He's almost like a co-moderator in a sort of unofficial way.
00:16:36 We should have maybe some regional debates.
00:16:39 Let's have...
00:16:40 Let's have why shouldn't Alberta... 1.00
00:16:43 Yeah, do Western issues.
00:16:44 They know when everyone needs to cover those.
00:16:47 Well, you know, we could have a BC debate.
00:16:48 I mean, BC, interior BC is more like us, but it's different issues.
00:16:52 So let's have a BC debate.
00:16:54 Let's have a prairie debate.
00:16:56 I mean, I've tried one for all three of the prairies, but fine.
00:17:00 a prairie debate uh an ontario debate an atlantic debate because quebec already gets its own debate
00:17:05 unofficially here so let's just do that and then we can you know maybe then a truly national debate
00:17:11 after we're not into the minutiae but let's let's have some it's a the defining characteristic of
00:17:17 canada is regions and regionalism we've already got a debate for that for quebec let's do it for
00:17:24 everybody else cabal let's have a debate and not just a recitation of talking points that we've
00:17:29 already heard from the campaign trail well they're all going to try and do that all party leaders
00:17:33 because that's generally what works it's always worked and it's even more so in the era of
00:17:38 of social media you know everyone's interrupting each other traditionally that was so you could
00:17:42 interject uh a lot of people i think have wisely noted uh before i'm saying it here that the
00:17:49 interruptions primarily from jay meeting but also from others during the debate were not actually
00:17:54 to interject your point
00:17:57 or interrupt. It was to wreck each other's
00:17:59 social media clips. So if
00:18:00 one of the candidates is going on a rip,
00:18:03 about to give a good zinger,
00:18:04 Jamie goes,
00:18:05 it wrecks their social media clip.
00:18:08 And that's all it's about.
00:18:10 This is already, social media defines the election.
00:18:13 Let's make this debate about something else.
00:18:15 A little more time, a little more interaction,
00:18:16 rather than just more social media clips for this.
00:18:20 Okay.
00:18:22 Let's
00:18:23 turn to the platforms here.
00:18:27 If we have time, we can talk about the conservative platform.
00:18:30 But let's
00:18:31 I want to zero in on the
00:18:33 liberal platform here. The liberals
00:18:35 have admitted
00:18:36 that this platform was actually
00:18:39 written, at least in most part.
00:18:41 I'm not sure if it was down to the last
00:18:43 T and I crossed and dotted.
00:18:45 But it was, this platform
00:18:47 was essentially constructed
00:18:49 and approved before
00:18:51 Mark Carney actually became Liberal leader, so it was written
00:18:53 while Justin Trudeau was still Liberal leader
00:18:55 and Prime Minister.
00:18:58 My guess is there's
00:18:59 obviously been some nips and 1.00
00:19:01 tucks here because the carbon tax
00:19:03 is no longer in the Liberal
00:19:05 platform. It's now just going to be, well, something
00:19:07 else. I don't know. Alberta
00:19:09 is going to pay slash industry,
00:19:11 capital gains, etc. But for the most part,
00:19:13 it is still the Trudeau platform, Nigel.
00:19:15 Absolutely. 0.98
00:19:17 And it is foolish to think
00:19:19 it would have ever been anything else because
00:19:21 these things take a long time to put together.
00:19:24 The old famous liberal red book
00:19:25 that characterized the campaigns in earlier years,
00:19:30 they went into production on that
00:19:31 10 months before the next election was expected.
00:19:35 It's a big document.
00:19:37 You're not going to turn it out in an afternoon.
00:19:39 So it is very important, however,
00:19:42 for the Liberal Party to make you think
00:19:45 that this is something the best that Carney
00:19:48 has had his hands on, and it's new, therefore,
00:19:52 because everything about Mr. Carney...
00:19:56 Mr. Carney is the only new thing in the liberal campaign.
00:20:02 The same people are running for seats.
00:20:04 The same people, if elected, will end up in cabinet,
00:20:07 not necessarily in the same positions,
00:20:09 but it's the old gang.
00:20:11 The only one that's missing is Justin Trudeau.
00:20:14 so you know like you put a new operating system into your computer and the thing works
00:20:20 differently so they kind of slid mr trudor slid mr carney in but it's the same thing it's not
00:20:26 it's not even a different operating system it's a different screensaver
00:20:29 if you want to get to beat your analogy uh up a little further you know the viewers should
00:20:35 understand that when we have off times we sit around talking computers in the in the in the
00:20:39 western standards so no yeah absolutely and the ones who understand it because they were there
00:20:45 when it started so anyway look um of course the uh the announcement and what there's one aspect
00:20:54 in which it is different and this was brought out by the canadian taxpayers federation in saskatchewan
00:21:00 i hadn't noticed this until i saw it in theirs the the original trudeau document
00:21:07 called for about $100 billion less in borrowing than what Mr. Carney is now proposing. Mr. Carney
00:21:15 is proposing $225 billion in new borrowing over four years. It's $100 billion more than what
00:21:26 mr trudeau's plan would be but let's sink in first in 2015 they had they they inherited
00:21:36 a federal debt of 600 billion dollars fair enough then over the next 10 years they doubled that debt
00:21:44 they'll blame covet but of course there were other considerations including just reckless
00:21:49 of venturing with the public money so mr carney comes on the scene after this party has at doubled
00:21:58 the federal debt and now he wants his own borrowing tranche and he is proposing another 225 billion
00:22:09 these people don't know that's a big thing on budget well that would be that would be the
00:22:15 The Liberal Party has never once in 10 years stayed on budget, not once.
00:22:19 So just like this, it's a contrast, isn't it?
00:22:22 Mr. Trudeau, when he campaigned in 2015, said, well, we'll have three $10 billion deficits
00:22:28 in balance in the fourth year.
00:22:30 Small.
00:22:31 This is Stingwell.
00:22:32 Mr. Carney goes out there and promises $225 billion over four years, not $30 billion,
00:22:40 225 and bless my soul 130 billion dollars in the first year like where do all these zeros come
00:22:48 from this is a banker we're all being told this is a banker you can put him in charge he knows
00:22:53 what he's doing lord knows he tells us all the time that he knows what he's doing he understands
00:22:58 the world well his understanding of the world is when you want to do big things you don't
00:23:04 borrow big money. The bankers
00:23:06 will love this, Corey.
00:23:08 But I guess
00:23:10 Justin Trudeau
00:23:12 is wildly unpopular,
00:23:14 which is why the Liberals
00:23:15 at long last
00:23:17 finally got rid of the guy.
00:23:21 But do
00:23:22 people care that this is
00:23:24 Justin Trudeau's platform? A little bit
00:23:26 of tinkering around the edges, really. This is
00:23:28 at its core
00:23:29 written by and signed off by
00:23:32 Justin Trudeau. People don't like
00:23:34 him, but are they going to care?
00:23:36 Because you've got the same team, you've got the
00:23:38 same MLAs, the same cabinet, the same
00:23:40 advisors, and now the same platform.
00:23:43 None of it's stuck so far
00:23:44 to Carney.
00:23:46 Do people care? I don't know.
00:23:48 It's not indicated in the polls so far that
00:23:50 they care that much. I don't know if the
00:23:52 average citizen has made the
00:23:54 connection and realized that when you have
00:23:56 a grossly overspending and
00:23:58 borrowing government that's going to devalue
00:24:00 your currency, that that's what's
00:24:02 hitting your cost of living. That's what's making
00:24:04 it difficult for you to pay your bills. I don't know if the average citizen has made that connection.
00:24:09 So when they put that new coat of paint on that old horse, it seems to have worked. And it's
00:24:15 frustrating. They're taking it on faith. Well, he's a banker. He knows what he's doing. Well,
00:24:19 that budget says he doesn't. Or that he knows what he's doing, but he doesn't care what the
00:24:23 impact of it is, which is even worse. And I don't know what it takes anymore. I don't know what kind
00:24:29 of fiscal kick in the butt Canadians need to get. As you pointed out, if anybody's benefiting from 0.97
00:24:34 this, it's the bankers. Yes, they love lending money because that's how they make money. You
00:24:39 shuffle numbers, you take a percentage off of the top and you do really well out of it. That's how
00:24:44 bankers work. I'm thinking we need actually an economist, not a banker. And there is a big
00:24:50 difference between the two. And people are equating it as if a banker would have the same broad
00:24:55 macroeconomic look at what these policies do to everybody, maybe Mark Carney's just looking at
00:25:01 what it does for banks and lenders. And I mean, that's the thing that has always gotten me to
00:25:06 left when it comes to deficit financing. Do they not understand when they seem to love borrowing
00:25:11 and borrowing that the big fat cats, the mustache tweaking bankers are the only ones that benefit
00:25:17 from that? Interest payments are going straight to them. That's money out of your pocket into them.
00:25:22 I thought you were there for the little guy, but they seem to have a cognitive dissonance when it comes to that.
00:25:28 And I don't know.
00:25:29 It looks like the Liberals may have pulled the wool over Canadians' eyes again.
00:25:32 Yes.
00:25:34 Erica, the Conservatives are trying to make this stick.
00:25:38 They've, you know, they went after Carney for keeping, with very little changes, the same roster of the Trudeau cabinet.
00:25:46 he moved some, but not all
00:25:49 people around to different positions
00:25:50 for like the week or two he was Prime Minister
00:25:53 before the election, but he's still got
00:25:55 the same caucus, he's still got
00:25:56 mostly the same cabinet
00:25:58 now
00:26:00 the platform, you know, the caucus
00:26:02 and the cabinet and the whole set of
00:26:04 advisors in the PMO, none of that has changed
00:26:06 and the conservatives have tried to
00:26:08 tie Carney to Trudeau on that
00:26:11 and it does not seem to have
00:26:12 stuck
00:26:13 now we've got the platform
00:26:17 This is newer.
00:26:18 What could the Conservatives do to make this stick?
00:26:22 Because nothing else has stuck so far.
00:26:24 Yeah, and I agree nothing has really stuck, unfortunately, because I think they're right.
00:26:30 They're right that this man is ultimately, whether he's trying to or not, he's doing a masterful job, Mark Carney of catfishing Canadians.
00:26:39 And he is selling how great he is on resume and that he's going to be more conservative. He's not Justin Trudeau. And the conservatives have tried and said, no, it's the same, same. Like, it is not different. It's the same people. You know, it's not this knight in shining armor that's going to make the Liberal Party actually centrist or even close to right ascender.
00:27:00 Like Justin Trudeau moved it into socialist territory and that's where they're going to stay. And even with the platform, I think that the I'll give the liberals credit. They waited so long to do it to after the debate to release their full costed budget because they know how bad it is and they know what this is.
00:27:18 I mean, I know that the Privy Council released a report basically saying that we're going to like be in Hunger Games style under the way that we're currently going.
00:27:28 And that's even expedited by Mark Carney.
00:27:31 So what do the Conservatives need to do?
00:27:32 I think they need to keep talking about that.
00:27:34 And hopefully to those that haven't voted yet, that message is getting through.
00:27:38 But I do think that the Liberals are good at campaigning by like being shiny object.
00:27:44 I'm this saving grace, Mark Carney.
00:27:45 I'm, you know, in the first week looking to be a conservative and now I am pulling full socialist agenda and I'm going to catfish and everyone's going to wake up the next day after the election and realize we made a horrible decision.
00:27:59 Should the liberals win? And I don't really know what the conservatives can do or if the runway is just a little too short at this point to close that gap.
00:28:09 Wishful thinking. I'm just hoping that conservatives don't answer their phones and answer the polls and will be surprised.
00:28:15 But if we're going off of current statistics, it looks like the runway's getting a little shorter.
00:28:20 I do have to push back on one thing you said, though.
00:28:23 You know, you said that the Liberals did not release their platform until after the debate.
00:28:28 You know, so people would be kind of too late to change their minds for many who were voted.
00:28:33 But the Conservatives also did not release their debate.
00:28:36 They didn't do that.
00:28:36 They waited until after the debate as well.
00:28:39 There's, I mean, depending how charitable or not we're being, there's different reasons for that.
00:28:42 I get that maybe you want to make most of your announcements throughout the campaign and then release.
00:28:47 If I was the Conservatives, I would have. Yeah, I would have done it as the Conservatives before the debate.
00:28:53 And I think it would have added. Totally. The morning of was when the NDP did it and that helped the UCP year win because it was a horrible budget.
00:29:02 He was hiding the Conservatives. I think with their plan, that's actually quite good and quite in contrast to Carney should have released it early.
00:29:11 and even just saying we're not going to care what these guys say and they might funk some numbers up
00:29:16 to try and not make it look so bad but so what you asked me what they could do versus what i think
00:29:21 they should have done i would have gotten that budget out before the debate all right uh so
00:29:27 we'll talk about the guys now that nobody including us is really talking about very much
00:29:31 uh is this the end dp yeah i i really thought i was clever for that one today uh so give me a slow
00:29:40 clock from home if you're watching. That was actually a headline in 2019 after the NDP
00:29:46 loss. So I don't know if we can give you any credit there. So to me, at least, it's an
00:29:54 original headline for the Western Standard. I have not seen it. Okay. All right. Corey,
00:30:01 the NDP here are, I mean, it's just polls, but polls are a snapshot of where people are
00:30:08 at today does not mean it's what they're going to do tomorrow, but it's pretty good indication
00:30:12 of at least trend lines we're on. The trend line we're on is for an absolute train wreck for the
00:30:18 NDP. 338 polling aggregator, not perfect, but they have a pretty good reputation. They're
00:30:26 generally in the ballpark. They've got the NDP around six seats, maybe even less. I mean, how
00:30:30 things go uh you need 12 seats to be an official party in uh in parliament um six seats uh people
00:30:39 can check on wikipedia correct me if i'm wrong but i i think six seats might be the uh would make it
00:30:45 the worst result in the history of the ndp uh i think you might even have to go pre-ndp to one
00:30:52 of its predecessor parties the canadian commonwealth federation to go back into you know the early
00:30:58 60s and the 1950s to find
00:31:00 something around six seats. And remembering
00:31:01 that was a smaller parliament. So actually, as a
00:31:04 proportion, this would be
00:31:05 something closer to
00:31:07 three or four seats, if we're talking
00:31:09 historically.
00:31:13 How much
00:31:13 weight do you put in the projections that the NDP is
00:31:15 headed for doom?
00:31:19 And
00:31:19 what does it mean for the future of the NDP if they
00:31:21 were to get obliterated like this?
00:31:24 Yeah, well, it's the end of Singh. I mean,
00:31:25 he's just been a terrible leader.
00:31:27 And even, you know, the most hardcore of loyalists will have to admit that after this election, whatever the NDP has to do, they got to change their leaders out.
00:31:35 Will they be gone?
00:31:37 No, I don't think so.
00:31:37 I mean, the socialists are always there. 0.91
00:31:39 They're like a social disease.
00:31:41 They might go into remission, but they'll come blossoming back later on.
00:31:44 Or are they just more at home than the Liberals now?
00:31:45 Well, that's part of it.
00:31:47 So there's kind of a number of things that hit that worked very badly for Singh.
00:31:51 Part of it was he just found himself in lockstep and constantly supporting the Liberals.
00:31:56 So to the point of people saying, well, if he's just going to be with them all the time, what's the point of bothering with a separate party? Anyhow, he's the same thing. Trudeau took the liberals to the left. He was not a conservative liberal leader. So again, that started eating a lot of Singh's lunch, slowly but surely.
00:32:14 Another thing that happened was it's almost a boomerang effect with the polls, if we looked four months ago,
00:32:20 looked that there was going to be a super majority of conservatives,
00:32:23 that Pierre Polyev was going to be the prime minister with an unstoppable force coming in.
00:32:28 And center-left supporters of the NDP said, well, boy, I'm going to strategically vote.
00:32:33 I prefer the NDP, but you know what?
00:32:35 I would still rather have a liberal group in there rather than letting Polyev take off with this.
00:32:41 And they migrated to the Liberal Party.
00:32:43 So just everything came together for a terrible electoral outcome for the NDP in this particular election, on top of which Singh has just not been an effective leader.
00:32:53 He hasn't been inspiring people to come out and support him or vote for him.
00:32:57 And I don't even know if he's wanted to.
00:32:59 I mean, his performance has been so bad, whether it's the debates or campaigning in general, you'd almost think he's throwing the race.
00:33:06 Yeah, I mean, I do not think he is an agent of the Liberal Party.
00:33:10 but if he was an agent of the liberal party he would be doing exactly what he has been doing
00:33:17 for years now so i do i didn't know that's not true i think if he's an agent of the liberal
00:33:24 party he might be in not third place in his own writing he'd be doing better right now because
00:33:30 he'd be running under a different umbrella this guy's gonna lose his own seat well i mean like
00:33:34 If the liberals had...
00:33:36 A good agent, I guess I should say.
00:33:38 If the liberals had captured a Terminator and put a Jagmeet Singh human tissue over top and used it, sent him into the past.
00:33:51 The liberals were destroyed under Trudeau and they sent Jagmeet Singh into the past to kill the NDP.
00:33:58 I mean, he would be doing exactly what he is doing now.
00:34:01 My tidbit hat isn't on firmly enough to think that that's an actual thing, but it's what he would be doing.
00:34:10 Nigel, one of my theories has been that because of Jaymeet Singh and the NDP's close association with Justin Trudeau,
00:34:19 because Justin Trudeau is at least in person no longer there,
00:34:23 that jakebeet singh is actually wearing the stink from the trudeau liberal government more than
00:34:31 mark carney because mark carney yeah however credibly or not it is can claim he's new i wasn't
00:34:39 there yeah sure he actually oh i know i know but most people who aren't following politics that
00:34:44 closely never heard of the guy until he was prime minister uh so my my theory has been that the ndp
00:34:50 is wearing the stench from the liberal government more than the liberal government is uh what do you
00:34:56 think well i would certainly be the evidence of the polls if the polls are to be believed then
00:35:03 the liberals are considerably more popular today than they were three weeks ago
00:35:08 um the ndp has not recovered they were not popular three weeks ago if anything they're worse today
00:35:15 much worse so why it may not be the specific policies however because i'm not sure everybody
00:35:25 could articulate what they were what people are rejecting is just somebody who came along
00:35:34 and hitched a ride sold out cheap it wasn't like the dental plan that he got was a such a big thing
00:35:41 to justify, if you're an NDP member,
00:35:45 you're probably just as passionate about your NDP
00:35:48 as some conservatives are
00:35:52 about their particular stream of conservatism.
00:35:55 And to see somebody just put it all on the line
00:35:58 for nothing more than to stay in office
00:35:59 coincidentally long enough to pick up the federal pension
00:36:03 is just more than flesh and blood can take.
00:36:08 I think they're just sick of Jagmeet Singh.
00:36:09 Never mind the NDP.
00:36:11 Erica, let's fast forward to next week.
00:36:18 There could be a conservative government, a liberal government.
00:36:21 Polls are leading liberal, but could be conservative if conservatives have a better turnout among their supporters.
00:36:29 But one way or another, it's going to be annihilation for the NDP. 0.98
00:36:34 How bad is up for grabs?
00:36:35 But let's just take kind of the aggregate numbers from 338 right now.
00:36:40 let's just say six seats
00:36:42 they're half the number they need for even
00:36:44 official party status the long
00:36:46 climb of the NDP that began with
00:36:49 Jack Layton in 2004
00:36:50 has been now reversed
00:36:52 and then some it's been
00:36:54 it's just been completely put down to
00:36:56 1960 early 1960s
00:36:58 levels here
00:36:59 goes without saying Jake Bietzing's gone
00:37:02 even if he somehow wins his seat
00:37:04 which if there's only six good chance
00:37:06 very good chance he loses his
00:37:08 let's just take it as granted
00:37:10 sig would be gone um let's talk about you know what would the future hold for the ndp um
00:37:17 you know do you think we would then move it looked you know after 2011 when the ndp formed
00:37:23 official opposition with jack layton but maybe we're headed towards a two-party system at least
00:37:29 outside of quebec uh actually no even including quebec because the ndp uh had swept quebec that
00:37:35 time. Do you think this would pretend maybe a move back, and we haven't had this since the 1950s,
00:37:41 a really hardcore two-party system minus Quebec with the bloc? Or do you think there's a space
00:37:47 for the NDP to come back? Where do they go from here if they're cut down to like six seats?
00:37:55 Yeah, they're really going to have to rebrand themselves. They're going to need a strong leader
00:37:59 because I think that you're all right, that there was more of a distaste for Justin Trudeau than
00:38:04 the Liberal Party by Canadians, and in this case, definitely more of a distaste for Jagmeet Singh's
00:38:09 leadership than NDP. There's always going to be NDP supporters. The far left doesn't really have
00:38:17 anywhere to go. And I don't think that the Liberals are maybe going to stay where Justin Trudeau put
00:38:25 them. They're going to spend like drunken sailors, but they might, on some other policies, be a little
00:38:31 bit more open, or at least that's what Connie's catfishing us today to believe. So what happens?
00:38:37 They're going to have to figure out first, even in Alberta on May 1st, they're talking about their
00:38:42 relationship with the federal government, or sorry, with the federal party in Alberta NDP.
00:38:47 So I think they're going to have to first work on all of their provincial partners, because I think
00:38:51 there's such a difference of a federal NDP versus each of the different jurisdictions and how they
00:38:58 go about it. So they have to do some kumbaya moments internally. And then they're going to
00:39:02 need to have a leader that actually understands what being NDP is, as opposed to being a TikTok
00:39:08 star, and focus on those things that actually matter. Now, are they going to come up and be
00:39:14 opposition in a meaningful way? No, but I don't see the NDP just because of how tied people are.
00:39:21 It'd be like removing a conservative party. There's always going to be that stronghold. I
00:39:26 think what they're going to do is just really pick their lane and have to rebrand both at the
00:39:31 provincial as well as the federal level. So maybe not next election, but I don't think that we won't
00:39:36 have a quote unquote socialist party in our country. All right. Well, let's turn to our
00:39:43 parting shots. Hopefully, Erica didn't steal your thunder too much, Nigel. Yeah, sorry.
00:39:49 No, I mean, actually, you threw me the line there. You drew attention to what you refer to
00:39:55 the Hunger Games. This is absolutely amazing. There is within the Privy Council Office, which
00:40:06 supports the Civil Service mirror of the Prime Minister's office, there is a place in there
00:40:13 which is just tasked to look ahead, try and review the big picture, what could happen, what
00:40:21 may not happen what would we suggest if it did blue skies big thinkers and periodically they
00:40:29 produce a report well they were they decided to look at what would happen if the existing policies
00:40:38 of the liberal government were continued unaltered how would canada look in 15 years time
00:40:45 He said it's going to stink. People are going to be leaving, like the high-performing,
00:40:54 anywhere people. You're going to be left with people who don't have options. They're usually
00:40:58 lower-wage earners. Things could get so bad that in this impoverished country, people would be out
00:41:06 foraging in the woods and the fields, poaching on public lands, just trying to find enough
00:41:13 food to get by on um what intrigued me about this is that it actually came to light during the
00:41:21 election campaign and i can't imagine that that is an accident because it was actually prepared
00:41:26 in january it is odd it is or is it wiped or something how did it come out no just they just
00:41:31 they just issued it so anyway someone in opposition like in the research i think just found it
00:41:38 because pierre talked about it in his platform like it wasn't really released or anything he
00:41:42 He just made reference to it like someone just published it and probably.
00:41:46 I think Blacklock's a little bit, actually.
00:41:48 Yeah.
00:41:49 Anyway, you know, I mean, this is kind of what we've been saying all along.
00:41:52 And by parting charges, I guess, during that, I'll try and get out before the rush.
00:41:59 Well, I'll just say this.
00:41:59 A Blacklock's reporter, a great news agency in Ottawa that we contract with as partners.
00:42:07 If I was Prime Minister, the very first thing I would do is hand a giant grant to those two.
00:42:16 It's literally a mom polish up.
00:42:18 It's a husband and a wife running it. 1.00
00:42:19 I would buy them off and send them to a warm island somewhere and get them the hell out of my hair. 0.75
00:42:24 Because even if you're a great Prime Minister, they're going to find something you screwed up at. 0.94
00:42:28 They're too damn good.
00:42:28 Those are old school data reporters, and they're dangerous.
00:42:32 That's why we hire them.
00:42:33 mm-hmm okay uh cory parting shot well i go on social media and lo and behold there's premier
00:42:41 smith riding a high-speed train laying the tracks uh as she has been hinting for a couple of years
00:42:47 yes in japan and a report's coming out soon that's going to paint a rosy picture on why
00:42:52 alberta needs a high-speed train even though nowhere in north america has managed to have
00:42:57 a successful high-speed train because we don't need one we don't want one they're boondoggles
00:43:01 they're a disaster every bloody time, and I'm tired of Smith's fixation on it, so I'm just
00:43:06 laying it out now. Balance the budget, get Alberta Head, then you can pursue pet projects like a 1.00
00:43:12 high-speed train, but until then, put the little train on the shelf, and we do not need this right
00:43:18 now. I don't understand why they're so hung up on this, and I'm not gonna let it go. Put it aside,
00:43:24 we've got more budgetary issues to deal with before you get onto something like that. Why
00:43:27 you know like choo-choo. I know like choo-choo 1.00
00:43:29 when I got to pay for it.
00:43:31 If I could buy the ticket on my own choice,
00:43:33 if these things are so darn
00:43:35 good, the private market will take care of it
00:43:38 and that's the way the old Premier Smith used to talk.
00:43:40 So, let's keep the train
00:43:41 on the same track with that as it used to.
00:43:44 I'm in general
00:43:45 agreement, and I'm highly skeptical of this kind of thing,
00:43:48 but some of the proposals that have been floated
00:43:50 around, or maybe,
00:43:51 that I think it was, you know,
00:43:53 if the province pays for a connection
00:43:55 to the main LRT line in Calgary
00:43:57 to the airport that they would then as as long as they're given kind of a right away and the
00:44:02 land to build it they'll build it out to vamp uh okay i mean like the lrt i i don't ride it anymore
00:44:11 it's not the greatest uh but it probably should connect to the airport but that's one thing i'd
00:44:18 probably get behind but uh i'd have to see the proposal but i i share your you just keep dipping
00:44:24 they're towing that water i haven't seen a whole lot of demand from people on the street screaming
00:44:28 i really really need that multi-billion dollar of high-speed rail between calgary and edmonton
00:44:33 because that's where it keeps leading there's the only reason this keeps coming up is because
00:44:37 the politicians you know as i've been one the politicians and so in the south driving up the
00:44:42 qe2 and then back every week it's a terrible miserable monotonous boring drive and you sit
00:44:50 they're thinking, oh, God.
00:44:52 Wouldn't it be nice if I could just lay back
00:44:54 and, you know, check my emails
00:44:55 and work along the way? Because taking the plane
00:44:58 only takes you three quarters.
00:45:00 Takes you to Leduc. Give them all
00:45:01 chauffeured limos. It'd still be cheaper than that bloody train.
00:45:04 It would be.
00:45:05 That is why this idea keeps coming back up.
00:45:07 It's because half the politicians
00:45:09 take that drive, and that drive doing every 0.99
00:45:11 week sucks. Bad. 0.99
00:45:14 Okay. My parting
00:45:15 shot. You all
00:45:18 remember Jessica Yenif, or
00:45:19 jessica yaniv i don't know what he calls himself anymore um actually i do know what he calls
00:45:25 himself so you uh you will you all recall this person this is a a trans individual uh i think
00:45:32 from vancouver if i get that right and uh he went around and tried to use the human rights commissions
00:45:38 to charge and obtain uh ransom money from uh in large uh many cases poor immigrant women and like 1.00
00:45:48 women's salons, you know, think of like the 0.97
00:45:51 Vietnamese women working in there
00:45:53 and he demanded 1.00
00:45:55 that they wax her balls 0.99
00:45:57 I mean, remember 0.99
00:45:59 this is the language of just a few years ago
00:46:01 this is, she was demanding that they wax 0.99
00:46:03 her balls 1.00
00:46:05 and things like that, anyway 0.99
00:46:07 she has a new name
00:46:09 I'm going to read what she has said
00:46:11 on Twitter, she, he
00:46:13 my
00:46:15 Métis name
00:46:16 first moment for the record
00:46:18 she is not Métis
00:46:20 as far as we could tell
00:46:21 she is white as the snow
00:46:23 but my Métis name is
00:46:26 Kaskit-O-Watis-G-Win 0.87
00:46:29 oh wow that's the closest I've gotten so far
00:46:31 which is probably not very close
00:46:33 Kaskit-O-Win
00:46:35 it means serenity in Cree
00:46:38 a word you'll choke on
00:46:40 as you watch a Métis woman 0.97
00:46:41 I mean the factual errors
00:46:43 are already incredible
00:46:45 A Métis woman, descended from buffalo hunters, La Chassigurie, and Red River Fire, dismantle the settler colonial rot you clutch like blood-soaked treaty. 0.99
00:46:58 Pope Francis is dead, but the church's genocidal legacy lives on in every stolen Métis child, every unmarked grave, every whisper of residential school. 0.99
00:47:07 I am a Métis woman. No, she says women. I am a Métis woman, so she's also now plural.
00:47:15 Okay. I do not forgive. I do not forget the Vatican falls in my name. I think it means Fitz.
00:47:22 Okay, so just from factual errors alone, woman, Métis, and women, plural.
00:47:30 I'm referring to herself in the plural.
00:47:31 I mean, at this point, I mean, referring to herself in the third person or in the plural is probably the least factual error in this.
00:47:40 but I do want to point out this
00:47:42 this is less outrageous than calling herself a woman
00:47:44 because Métis are people
00:47:46 of mixed heritage, they're people who are part
00:47:48 white, often French but not entirely
00:47:50 but part white and
00:47:52 part indigenous North
00:47:54 American
00:47:55 so, I mean, she's not Métis as far as
00:47:58 we can tell, correct, and some people in Caribbean if I'm wrong
00:48:00 she's not Métis, but she is
00:48:02 at least white, which is half
00:48:04 of Métis, but she is not
00:48:06 half a woman, so
00:48:08 claiming she is Métis 0.96
00:48:10 as factually
00:48:11 problematic as that is, is by far
00:48:14 the least problematic claim
00:48:16 that she has made. So anyway, I just
00:48:18 wanted to
00:48:19 make this a land acknowledgement
00:48:21 for
00:48:22 Jessica Yaniv
00:48:25 Kaskite-Watawiske
00:48:28 It's getting better. It's getting better
00:48:30 I think your pronunciation there.
00:48:32 There you go. I told you I could speak le Francais.
00:48:35 Alright.
00:48:37 My go?
00:48:38 Oh, is it my turn? No, you forgot about me, just as always.
00:48:42 Oh, I'm sorry. I never saved myself for last. No, I'm sorry.
00:48:45 Well, we'll just leave best for last instead. So a little bit different of a tangent. I
00:48:54 am throwing this at one person for props, another for just the legacy media's horrific fact checking
00:49:04 on these two budgets the fact that we don't have anyone but some columnists actually highlighting
00:49:11 how horrific uh one not covering the privy council stuff that uh corey talked about two not covering
00:49:17 the actual like contrast of liberal versus conservative platforms that were put out
00:49:24 so the fi the firing shot actually came from ian brody if you see him go on cbc
00:49:30 I believe it was this morning and just ripped the CBC fact checker a new one, basically criticizing everything of how they contrasted, compared and the facts that they were putting out about the liberal platform.
00:49:46 So I can't take the shots fired today. I'm giving it to Ian Brody, who, you know, really held the mainstream accountable.
00:49:52 again maybe too late to get it uh out to voters in the in the style in which we need as conservatives
00:50:00 but man he literally came on so professional the uh interviewer kind of jaw dropped didn't
00:50:08 know how to answer the questions and it was basically criticizing the people that we all
00:50:12 want to be defunded so you know our our final segment is called parting shots but you and you
00:50:18 called it Shots Fired, but yours actually makes sense.
00:50:20 No, I like mine better.
00:50:22 Shots Fired actually kind of makes sense.
00:50:24 I mean, it
00:50:25 works for yours at least.
00:50:28 Sorry that I screwed that up.
00:50:30 I won't. No, no.
00:50:32 It's it. Let's roll with it. We'll do
00:50:34 parted shots, you do Shots Fired. Perfect. 0.80
00:50:36 Alright. Erica, Corey,
00:50:38 Nigel, thank you. And our producer,
00:50:40 John, thank all of you for joining us.
00:50:42 I want to remind you that
00:50:44 on election night,
00:50:45 April 28th, starting at
00:50:48 6 p.m. Mountain Standard
00:50:50 Time. The Western Standard will be
00:50:51 live streaming. We've got a great
00:50:54 great lineup. We've got
00:50:56 pundits, campaign experts.
00:50:58 We've even got former
00:51:00 BC Premier Gordon Campbell in.
00:51:02 We've got former Saskatchewan Premier
00:51:03 Brad Wall in.
00:51:06 And of course, my
00:51:07 smile and face, Nigel,
00:51:09 Corey, Erica. We've just
00:51:11 got a great, great lineup.
00:51:14 I think you're going to find it informative
00:51:15 maybe more so than watching
00:51:17 the CBC on election night. Thank you all for joining us. We hope to see you Monday night
00:51:23 for the results as they come in from Canada's federal election. Thank you very much. God bless
00:51:28 the West.
00:51:47 You