Western Standard - January 03, 2021


January 2, 2020

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
The Pipeline Goodbye 2020! We discuss the biggest stories out of the West this year. BREAKING: Kenney sacks Allard, slap on the wrist for other snowbird MLAs. Will it be enough?

Episode Stats


Length

54 minutes

Words per minute

163.96

Word count

8,992

Sentence count

310

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard columnist Corey Morgan and news director Dave Naylor join host Derek Fildebrandt on a special edition of the Pipeline Uplift in beautiful Hawaii. They discuss the latest in the ongoing saga of the province's travel restrictions, and the hypocrisy behind them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 .
00:02:00 .
00:02:30 .
00:03:00 Happy New Year, it's 2020. I am Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard. You're
00:03:20 live on a special edition of the pipeline uh i'm joined today uh in beautiful hawaii
00:03:28 by uh western standard columnist and podcast editor corey morgan and by our uh news director
00:03:38 dave nailer who is unfortunately still in lockdown uh just outside of vancouver british columbia
00:03:44 But the weather is beautiful here in Hawaii.
00:03:48 Sorry, go ahead, Dave.
00:03:51 What's going on?
00:03:52 I'm the only staff member who's not in Hawaii.
00:03:55 Can I get a raise or something?
00:03:57 How am I stuck in Vancouver while you guys are in Hawaii?
00:04:02 You know, you're always bragging about the weather in Vancouver relative to the rest of Canada anyway,
00:04:06 so enjoy your lockdown.
00:04:09 Corey and I are sitting on a nice warm beach here sipping Coronas.
00:04:12 I'm a little overdressed for the beach, but nobody wants to see me without my shirt, I promise you.
00:04:17 And Dave, somebody's got to work.
00:04:19 That is true.
00:04:21 And you have been working hard.
00:04:23 We had 1.3 million readers in the last month due in very large measure to Dave Naylor.
00:04:30 So tip of the hat from all Western-Centered members and myself to Dave Naylor.
00:04:35 We're going to have the numbers soon, but we probably beat almost every single media outlet in Western Canada last month
00:04:41 uh with some of the news you've been uh producing so thank you
00:04:46 so uh we're here today um i think a lot of you know what this is about but we're going to break
00:04:51 it down uh you know when i was with the canadian taxpayers federation we had this thing called the
00:04:55 debt clock and it would show the debt ticking up in real time to try and help people get their
00:05:01 minds around uh how massive the debt was uh i think what we need now is a lockdown politician
00:05:08 breaking their travel restrictions clock because every few hours is just another one and another
00:05:13 one coming out. I think right now there's probably got to be a lot of politicians huddled somewhere
00:05:18 in warm climes wondering when it's just going to come out that they haven't been following the
00:05:24 lockdowns and travel restrictions that they've imposed on everyone else. But we're going to go
00:05:29 through it today about who's been caught so far, what the problem with this is, and how many more
00:05:36 could there really be uh it's quite something um i mean i don't think we need much of an introduction
00:05:41 everybody's watching this this is a huge story nationwide uh it's resulted uh at least outside
00:05:47 of the west in some resident you know at least one resignation already it's resulted in some
00:05:51 demotions uh but in the west here no consequences regardless um you know what i i think this is a
00:05:59 great uh normally go straight to dave but uh we're gonna go through dave on the piece by piece as we
00:06:04 We break it down by, you know, the Hawaii caucus, the Caribbean caucus, the American Southwest caucus.
00:06:11 We're going to go to date for that.
00:06:12 But I think this time we're going to go straight to Corey because I think we all just need to know what's on Corey's mind.
00:06:18 What does it mean he needs to get off of his shoulders right now?
00:06:23 You know, I can't set my expectations low enough, it appears. 1.00
00:06:27 How stupid can these people be? 1.00
00:06:29 And that's just what I'm going to be blunt about. 1.00
00:06:31 How stupid can you be? 1.00
00:06:32 You have locked down a province. You have told people that they can't visit families for Christmas. 1.00
00:06:39 You told them they can't have funerals for more than a few people.
00:06:42 I know it's not illegal to travel, but they're saying absolutely do not do so unless you absolutely must.
00:06:47 It's funny, you know, when I must travel, I've gone to places like Arkansas and some nasty spots for work in the past.
00:06:53 It seems that these mandatory travelers always end up in tropical nice spots.
00:06:57 The hypocrisy is just outstanding and so avoidable. 0.80
00:07:02 I'm just, what in the hell were you guys thinking? 0.97
00:07:06 You know, you've got people who are just suffering and miserable, 0.61
00:07:10 and the last thing they need to see are the people who legislated them into that position
00:07:15 just doing the opposite, going out and enjoying the high life,
00:07:18 not only the fact that we're not allowed or shouldn't be doing those things
00:07:22 if we're being responsible, as they chide us.
00:07:24 You know, they talk down to us.
00:07:25 I remember Premier Kennedy saying, knock it off to us.
00:07:27 I don't like being talked down to if somebody else isn't going to walk the bloody talk.
00:07:31 So I spent my time properly at home with a small gathering for Christmas,
00:07:37 and then we're seeing these guys jet-setting around.
00:07:39 And excuses like the one, well, it was a family tradition.
00:07:42 Well, Christmas for a lot of people is a family tradition.
00:07:44 Holding a funeral is a family tradition.
00:07:47 Sitting Shiva, whatever.
00:07:48 These people are putting off because of this.
00:07:50 And then to see our political superiors not walking the talk.
00:07:55 And this is going to come at a cost.
00:07:56 Like Kenny has already been scrambling, having difficulty in the polls.
00:08:00 I tell you what, there's no policy decision they could have made that would do more damage than a point of principle problem like this and losing their moral authority.
00:08:09 And he's really losing ground, and he better get on top of this fast.
00:08:14 I think he had a chance to get on top of it, and he failed in his leadership.
00:08:20 He could have fired Tracy Allard.
00:08:24 But then I think he probably knew he had a problem because half his caucus was away.
00:08:28 Kenny fell on his own sword and said,
00:08:31 ooh, I guess I just didn't issue enough warning.
00:08:34 And these cabinet ministers weren't smart enough
00:08:37 to realize that they shouldn't be traveling outside of the province
00:08:41 when regular people like us can't even see our grandparents, 0.94
00:08:46 can't even cross the street to see their relative in an old folks home. 1.00
00:08:51 This is without a doubt the biggest crisis of Kenny's leadership. 1.00
00:08:56 And so far, he's failed to rise to the challenge, in my opinion.
00:09:03 Okay, well, I think what we should do now is go through some of the different ones here.
00:09:10 We've got people kind of all over.
00:09:14 We're going to kind of break it down a bit here.
00:09:16 We're not going to spend too much time on each one, but we're going to go through each.
00:09:21 We're going to start with the Hawaiian Caucus.
00:09:23 Dave, why don't you tell us which of these lockdown happy politicians have found themselves in beautiful Hawaii?
00:09:32 Well, currently, and I say currently because the list seems to change every 20 minutes,
00:09:38 you've got Municipal Affairs Minister Tracy Allard, who is continuing a 17-year tradition of family gatherings in Hawaii.
00:09:48 You've got Jeremy Nixon, Calgary Klein, MLA, who is also in Hawaii,
00:09:56 but he's been ordered on the first flight back.
00:09:59 And you've got a couple of press secretaries.
00:10:01 You've got Michael Forian, and you've got Elisa Snyder.
00:10:06 Sorry for mispronouncing your first name, Elisa, but there you are. 0.89
00:10:11 They make up the Hawaii caucus that we know about so far.
00:10:14 Yeah, I guess we'll go through just a little bit here. So, yeah, two of them are press secretaries.
00:10:24 Tracy Allard is the Minister of Municipal Affairs.
00:10:28 Municipal, and as is usually the case, the Municipal Affairs Minister is responsible for disaster and emergency coordination.
00:10:35 She is overseeing the distribution of vaccines in Alberta.
00:10:39 Additionally, she is also the, I believe the chair of the COVID response committee. So she answers just directly. She oversees the COVID reaction here. So she essentially oversees this reporting directly to Kenny. So this is someone who's who can't claim to be I'm just a backbencher. Maybe I don't like lockdown, but I'm too much of a coward to say, well, this is someone at the very center of decision making on locking people down on making gathering for
00:11:09 christmas illegal on uh getting people almost tasered uh to death uh for playing hockey people
00:11:16 getting charged for attending uh peaceful protests people being uh fined and charged for all sorts of
00:11:23 otherwise everyday activities this is someone very much at the center of that decision making
00:11:29 she can't claim to be a nothing backbencher who shouldn't speak out anyway because their voice 0.78
00:11:33 doesn't matter. She's very important in this decision-making process and she's in Hawaii.
00:11:41 Didn't admit to it. It came out through other sources. When she was asked by it,
00:11:45 when media outlets asked her and her office, she did not respond. She completely ignored it until
00:11:53 the CBC was able to find other sources, quote unquote, other sources to confirm that she was
00:12:00 in Hawaii over Christmas other sources I could tell you normally means internal
00:12:05 party rivals who have information on you but you never admitted it until even
00:12:10 when she was asked about it Nixon as well I don't think admitted it it it came
00:12:16 out but you know Dave maybe you can briefly tell us about how difficult it's
00:12:21 been to get any answer out of these guys when we asked them are you in the
00:12:26 Caribbean. Are you in Hawaii? Are you in one of these places? You've been trying to track them
00:12:30 down. Why don't you tell us what kind of response you're getting? It's been basically radio silence,
00:12:36 Derek. And I think that came quickly because they realized what a bad position they were in.
00:12:43 When news of Allard broke and we tried her office and we tried Kenny's office and, you know, we were
00:12:50 trying everybody and their dog, there was absolutely no answer. And then finally it was started to
00:12:56 come out that yes alid was there and and premier kenny found out about it uh on tuesday and
00:13:02 immediately ordered her to catch the next flight home but since then it's been this drip drip drip
00:13:10 of other people being found out i don't anybody's come forward to say hey raising my hand i was in
00:13:17 hawaii or arizona it's been between the media that has has uh has found everybody out and
00:13:25 the the drip drip drip is looking extremely bad on kenny you know perhaps they may want to come
00:13:30 out and say okay well here's the full list here's everybody who went uh because right now they're
00:13:36 looking pretty incompetent indeed um yeah it's just been it's been wild they uh they just don't
00:13:44 respond to emails and phone calls uh until it's already out there essentially uh well that takes
00:13:51 us from the hawaiian caucus let's now turn to the american southwest caucus uh dave why don't you tee
00:13:56 it up well that's led by uh tanya fur who was a former cabinet minister she was shuffled out
00:14:04 by the premier in august she went to visit her sister in vegas and you know maybe took in a
00:14:11 show or two or uh or did some gambling uh jason stefan a red deer south mla he's he's been very
00:14:20 strong he's publicly admitted that he is against premier kenny's lockdowns and i guess he took his
00:14:26 opposition so far to uh to travel did jason stefan say that he has he been on the record publicly
00:14:33 opposed to these lockdowns he's certainly sent out uh a media uh statements saying that saying
00:14:40 that he is and uh go ahead uh making up the unholy triumphant is uh saskatchewan highways minister
00:14:50 joe hargraves uh he must be uh trying to lower his handicap uh because he's in uh he's in palm
00:14:57 springs at the moment well uh on the jason stefan part uh you know he is uh one of the very very few
00:15:05 uh MLAs in the current ECP caucus who have stood out with any kind of backbone
00:15:10 um so if he has previously come on the record as opposing
00:15:14 lockdowns uh if that in fact is the case uh I'd say actually that's fine uh if
00:15:19 you if he obeyed quarantining rules because you know this
00:15:22 wasn't against the law it was against the government's
00:15:24 recommendations and if he's been out there saying uh
00:15:28 that these lockdowns are wrong and he's opposing his own government on it
00:15:32 publicly well then i don't think there's a case for hypocrisy there i think that's quite different
00:15:37 uh it's the opposite of something like tracy allard who is very directly responsible in
00:15:42 large measure for the lockdowns if jason stefan's been opposed to it i don't think it's at the very
00:15:47 least it's not hypocrisy then and he certainly has right from the beginning derek and when you
00:15:52 look at hypocrisy let's talk to about jason stefan he tweets a picture of himself i'm sorry he not
00:15:59 himself but he tweets a picture from lake louise on january or sorry december 30th
00:16:05 a december 30th picture from lake louise saying what a wonderful day to be at lake louise of
00:16:11 course he doesn't say he's at lake louise and in fact it turns out he's in arizona where they
00:16:15 probably haven't seen a snowfall in a while what was a picture of him at lake louise uh we just
00:16:21 don't know when or even what year that was exactly so if you want to talk about hypocrisy uh yeah
00:16:27 jason stefan is uh is uh you know clear while uh uh i'm sorry stefan is is right up there
00:16:38 i mean it's so confusing i'm getting them all mixed up derrick yeah there's too many names
00:16:46 uh okay well let's keep on moving through uh that was the american southwest caucus
00:16:51 Now, someone who I think it's impossible for Jason Kenney to say he didn't know was gone
00:16:58 was his chief of staff who traveled to the UK where there is a travel ban.
00:17:03 He had to go through the United States to come back.
00:17:06 You know, there's a new variant or strain or whatever of COVID from the UK.
00:17:11 I think UK variant of COVID.
00:17:14 That sounds racist to me.
00:17:17 Or the UK flu, we can call it now.
00:17:20 But his chief of staff.
00:17:22 Now, I can tell you, the chief of staff is the person a politician speaks to the most.
00:17:26 You speak to them every single day of the week, normally several times, and very often on the weekends.
00:17:33 If he is overseas, you would know about it.
00:17:38 At the same time, we also had Kenny's Twitter manager, Matt Wolfe, away as well in Saskatchewan.
00:17:48 but I actually don't think that was a big deal. Whatever else you think of the guy, I don't think
00:17:52 going to Saskatchewan was a big deal, but it means he was seeing family, breaking the lockdown rules.
00:17:57 He doesn't live in that household, which means he was breaking lockdown rules about seeing your
00:18:03 family if you don't live in the same household. So, well, I don't think it's actually a big deal.
00:18:08 I still think it'd be wildly hypocritical, but maybe I'll put it to you, Corey, for,
00:18:15 is it possible Jason Kenney did not know his chief of staff was overseas for an extended period of
00:18:21 time? It's possible. I mean, it makes it hard to believe because that's a very tight relationship
00:18:29 that's usually going to have a heck of a lot of communication. I would imagine right now that
00:18:33 they're in the midst of a political disaster of their own making. They should be in some pretty
00:18:37 close communication right now. And, you know, just some of the comments that I've seen from other
00:18:41 people. Yes, it's not illegal for these guys to have done that. That's not the point. Hypocrisy
00:18:47 is the problem, not law breaking on their part. Just because you can doesn't mean you should.
00:18:52 And then somebody saying that Derek sounds like Rachel Notley. I mean, I make fun of his voice
00:18:56 when he's not listening about other things, but he doesn't sound like Notley. The thing is, I'm
00:19:01 generally supportive of the UCP, but this isn't the time to circle the wagons and take a partisan 0.77
00:19:06 approach and say, we've just got to try and cover this up or not talk about it or suck it back. I'm 0.93
00:19:12 more upset when people on my team, or at least the Conservative side, screw up. I don't care
00:19:16 when the left screws up. I mean, I'll rub their nose in it, but that's fine. It makes it less
00:19:19 likely they're going to get in. This is the sort of thing that's going to lead us to another Rachel
00:19:24 Notley government, and I do not want to see it. Derek, I don't think you can underestimate the
00:19:30 anger of Albertans in this issue. I got an email last night from a UCP voter who said,
00:19:38 no more, this is it. I'm not voting for them ever again because of their actions on these travel
00:19:45 restrictions. Before this scandal came to light, personal popularity of Jason Kenney was around 30
00:19:52 with his handling of the COVID pandemic in Alberta.
00:19:57 This will push his personal popularity into freefall,
00:20:02 down in the 20% area, which is where Rachel Notley was,
00:20:07 at the height of Albertans' anger against her.
00:20:12 So is this going to put Kenny's leadership in jeopardy?
00:20:17 Won't she get down to 20% popular support?
00:20:20 It's a very, very dangerous level, as you well know, Derek.
00:20:23 Well, actually, if you get into the 20s, that'd be lower than Rachel Nottingly, I think, ever got.
00:20:28 Her popularity consistently outstripped the UCPs.
00:20:32 At least for the last year, generally, the UCP has been more popular than Jason Kenney.
00:20:37 Now, we've seen a series of polls showing them going down.
00:20:44 We've seen both Kenney and the UCP incredibly lower and lower and lower.
00:20:49 we're gonna have to see what the effect is but right now is a great time to
00:20:53 announce we are going to we're fundraising to commission a poll right
00:20:58 now in Alberta on the popularity of the government and we're all and how people
00:21:03 would vote for the different parties right now both federally and
00:21:05 provincially in Alberta this poll is going to include where people stand on
00:21:10 different issues where people stand on lockdowns where people stand on
00:21:13 mandatory masks should Albertans have the right to recall their MLAs and we'll
00:21:18 a bit more about that later and we're going to ask people you know a variety of issues to get
00:21:23 ignored by the mainstream media where people stand on independence where people stand on
00:21:28 firewall measures like establishing an alberta revenue agency things like that
00:21:32 uh so we're going to be doing a crowdfunding for that right uh we're going to be getting today
00:21:37 because within a few within a day or two we want to be in the field pulling where albertans stand
00:21:42 on these issues uh and asking questions uh with options available for those questions that the
00:21:48 mainstream media all too often forget. So that's going to be something we're going to have in the
00:21:53 field very soon if we can raise enough money from people like you watching. Let's go. So it's not
00:22:01 all just Tories doing this. The Tories aren't the only ones locking people down and then not
00:22:07 practicing what they're preaching, but they seem to be the only ones, at least in the West, with
00:22:12 no consequences for doing it. The NDP, one of the senior members of the federal NDP's
00:22:19 caucus, Nikki Ashton, I forget what her shadow ministerial portfolio or critic portfolio 0.51
00:22:24 was, but she was found, she is one of the most vicious pro-lockdown politicians. Anyone 1.00
00:22:31 who doesn't support lockdowns is a terrible human being and should not be in politics
00:22:35 supporting her. Well, if you can't see your family in Canada, you should go see them in
00:22:40 Greece. And so she went to Greece to see her family, and she has been tossed from her critic
00:22:46 portfolio, not from the caucus, but from her critic portfolio. So some actual consequences
00:22:51 for it. Dave, why don't you give us the lowdown of what really happened there?
00:22:56 Well, Ashton was the transportation critic, Derek, and she went to Greece to visit a seriously
00:23:03 ill grandmother. And now she had to get approval from the Greek government to travel because
00:23:09 their lockdown as well the greek government gave her the approval so she traveled and and visited
00:23:15 her sick grandmother uh ashton's problem was she didn't tell anybody in the party and uh it first
00:23:21 came to light when she tweeted uh the fact that that she had gone to greece and she was able to
00:23:28 visit her grandmother and i guess that was spotted by uh you know ndp staff members uh who passed it
00:23:37 up the chain and she's being demoted uh no longer a transportation critic uh corey so at least in
00:23:48 the west you know she's from manitoba i think she represents in northern manitoba riding around
00:23:51 i think churchill or something like that um do you think her being fired from her critic portfolio
00:23:58 was the appropriate response and is that something that we should have seen uh in alberto or
00:24:04 saskatchewan with pro-lockdown politicians not following their own lockdown well you know this
00:24:11 is tough by the way i should know you see they're popping up we did miss the mexican caucus uh with
00:24:17 pat rain i believe is that again there's we're coming to the mexican caucus so many you see
00:24:25 oh okay sorry about that yeah somebody down there it's hard to keep up with it so we'll get there
00:24:29 uh i i believe it was the right response on jameet singh's part because you put that fire
00:24:33 out now while you can hypocrisy burns it burns you from within it costs you moral authority and
00:24:40 it hurts your whole party uh at least he showed that we're not you know accepting it and tolerating
00:24:45 it and he did something about it part of a problem kenny has though is if he shuts down every mla at
00:24:50 the rate he's going he's going to end up with a minority government pretty soon so uh i guess
00:24:54 maybe the problem is he's got to figure out how many of his members are actually overseas right
00:24:58 now before he can see if and when or how he might be able to disappoint it's just a disaster
00:25:03 I'm just astounded by this.
00:25:07 Sorry, I think Corey's hit the nail on the head with,
00:25:10 I'm not sure if Kenny knew how many of his caucus had gone away.
00:25:14 I was writing, I knew Allard was going to have a press conference,
00:25:18 so I wrote up a story in advance that was almost ready to go,
00:25:22 and I had written that Jason Kennedy has accepted the, quote,
00:25:26 resignation, or Jason Kennedy had fired Tracy Allard
00:25:30 for disobeying
00:25:32 recommendations.
00:25:34 And I think Rick Bell of Post Media, the Calvary Sun
00:25:36 put it best when he said, I'm gobsmacked 1.00
00:25:38 at your stupidity. 1.00
00:25:40 And as the press 1.00
00:25:42 conference progressed and
00:25:44 it became clear that Kenny was not going to
00:25:46 fire Howard, I also became
00:25:48 gobsmacked because it was such
00:25:50 a wrong political decision
00:25:52 to make. But then
00:25:54 when you see all the other people that have come
00:25:56 out next and next and next
00:25:58 and next then you understand kenny couldn't he couldn't fire alert because then he'd have to fire
00:26:03 nixon then he'd have to fire uh you know a long litany of people who had been away he was he was
00:26:10 painted into the corner his only political move was to fall on his own sword and albertans aren't
00:26:15 buying it whatsoever uh yeah well actually good follow-up here question for you here uh dave uh
00:26:24 i know the answer to it but i'm gonna ask you anyway uh the press conference where kenny was
00:26:29 uh essentially defending allard or or more or less protecting her i should say not defending but um
00:26:36 were you allowed to ask any questions or have you ever been allowed to ask a question at a press
00:26:40 conference you've been you've been at not not at a kenny press conference uh i keep dialing in the
00:26:46 20 minutes early i keep uh pressing the button to ask a question but uh hey it's you know i never
00:26:52 get selected uh i don't want to whine like a rebel reporter would but uh i also didn't get
00:26:59 selected uh the outward press conference uh but you know they seem to have their list of
00:27:04 of people that they always ask the post media columnist and uh actually several columnists
00:27:10 and reporters and they always end with a french cbc question so you know it is what it is
00:27:15 Well, we're going to now segue to the Caribbean Caucus, which will include Mexico in that
00:27:24 does much of it obviously is long along the Caribbean. There we had Ontario Finance Minister
00:27:30 Rod Phillips in St. Bart's. I think a lot of us were not even aware of the existence of St. Bart's
00:27:35 until he showed up there. That's the Ontario Finance Minister and Pat Wren, the MLA ostensibly
00:27:42 for Slave Lake let's go to you Dave about Rod Phillips and then I'm gonna punt Pat
00:27:50 ran over to to Cory well Derek if you've ever seen lifestyles of the rich and
00:27:56 famous with Robin Leach and a champagne ball that's where Rod Phillips was in the
00:28:03 luxury island of st. Barts and when when Ontario Premier Doug Ford found out
00:28:11 about it he was fuming he was angry he was furious whatever whatever verb you
00:28:17 want to use he ordered Phillips home right away and actually know Dave I
00:28:24 think you need to correct you there he was not fuming when he found out he was
00:28:29 fuming when it became public Doug Ford knew about it I think roughly two weeks
00:28:33 before maybe he wasn't pleased about it but he did not order him back as soon as
00:28:37 he found out about it. He ordered them back once it became public, and then he expressed
00:28:42 how angry he was about it, but he didn't seem to do much about it when he found out
00:28:45 two weeks prior.
00:28:46 Well, and in fairness, Phillips realized within hours of himself getting back onto
00:28:53 Canadian soil that his position was untenable, and he resigned, and Ford obviously accepted
00:29:00 resignation part of uh phillips's problem was he was also producing a string of social media posts
00:29:08 uh you know him in front of his fireplace and his writing and you know warm wishes to everybody and
00:29:15 happy new year and merry christmas all the time while he was walking on the beaches so there was
00:29:21 a subterfuge that phillips tried to create that perhaps wasn't in the other foreign travelers
00:29:28 plan so his position really was untenable and and he had to go and in
00:29:37 fairness he did which a lot of the Western politicians haven't done so well
00:29:43 and those kind of misleading social media posts either saying explicitly
00:29:48 or implying extremely strongly that he's locked down at home and snow you know
00:29:54 in snowy Ontario. We saw the same thing with the, I think the vast majority of the Alberta MLAs who
00:30:02 have been caught not being locked down. The exception being Pat Wren, who we're going to get
00:30:05 to in a second. Pat Wren just posted a picture of himself in a cave in Mexico as if it was the
00:30:12 problem. So at least hats off to Pat. He wasn't trying to hide this from people. He wasn't trying
00:30:18 to deceive people by putting out a little video of him sitting at the Christmas tree or a picture
00:30:23 of him on a mountain skiing somewhere in alberta he just said hey i'm in mexico it's beautiful and
00:30:29 warm merry christmas so uh but yeah uh rod phillips one of the most senior politicians in canada the
00:30:37 ontario finance minister that's not an insignificant position uh bit the dust over this um uh but you
00:30:44 know he did take responsibility he did fess up he took accountability um but he did attempt to hide
00:30:50 it. It's not like he just did this, didn't think it was an issue. He actively did try to hide it.
00:30:56 And that's, I think, where the biggest issue is here. And I think it's set up. I think
00:31:01 Alberta Premier Jason Kenney was not very happy when he resigned because it set a precedent that
00:31:06 this is required. This is what's expected if this happens and you're getting caught.
00:31:12 But I think as both of you have said, that's not really a possibility for Jason Kenney.
00:31:18 he can't fire these people because he'll end up losing half of his caucus probably.
00:31:23 And a ton of his staff, he'll lose his chief of staff, he'll lose a bunch of press secretaries.
00:31:27 It would not just be a symbolic bloodletting to scapegoat one or two, it would be a massacre
00:31:36 of the government and it's just not possible. So it's quite a position to be in that he's not
00:31:42 able to scapegoat anyone in this case. Corey, let's go to you about Pat Wren, the ostensibly MLA for
00:31:52 Slave Lake. Well, yeah, I mean, he's a backbench MLA. You don't hear a heck of a lot about him.
00:32:02 I don't know if it was him being honest in a little act of rebellion by actually tweeting
00:32:07 where he was or maybe just a case of not even realizing that it was going to take people off
00:32:12 or that he was doing something that would be perceived as wrong uh kind of like we talked
00:32:17 about we would accept it if there are any of them who were outright being vocal and i'd say recently
00:32:22 vocal saying you know the lockdowns are are pointless or they don't need to be followed or
00:32:27 you know we can still get out and visit and so on but they all towed the line with the lockdowns
00:32:32 and the legislation and said we're all in it together which is a statement i am loathing
00:32:36 more than ever these days and and then we see them down there not to mention there's the other
00:32:42 aspect of it aside from the principles but a lot of us are going broke this year a lot of us have
00:32:48 lost businesses we've been laid off we're dipping into our last of our savings we aren't even looking
00:32:52 at a tropical vacation for years to come and it feels almost like these six-figure people with uh
00:32:57 solid income uh are rubbing our noses in it hey you know how's that winter doing up there in
00:33:03 Canada, I'm out in the beach, you know, tanning. It's just a disaster. And as I said, in Ontario
00:33:09 and with the NDP, at least they put the fire out, you know, they had to. It's a fire. And right now
00:33:15 this fire is burning and spreading in Alberta. And I don't know what he's going to do. But again,
00:33:20 he's got to do something pretty darn soon. Backdrop, Leah. Yeah, no, that's a beach back
00:33:26 there. This is a great part of this sort of format. I'm actually wearing Speedos under this
00:33:31 jacket, but Derek wouldn't let me stay. This is a family show, Corey. We were not going to put up
00:33:38 with your speedo nonsense here. It was a bit much. I think one of the key things, Derek, is Kenny has 0.83
00:33:48 now lost the moral high ground. What if the numbers don't go down and in the next week or so
00:33:53 he has to extend the lockdown? How can he look Albertans in the face and say, look, we need to
00:34:00 be all in this together we need to extend the lockdown to try and flatten the curve
00:34:05 knowing that a good chunk of his caucus buggered off during the holidays and went somewhere warm
00:34:12 is lost the moral high ground and that's how can any premier rule from uh you know from
00:34:19 the valley he's created on on himself uh absolutely well let's um one of the issues
00:34:28 is like one reason this is so damaging is this all didn't just come out at once in one big story
00:34:32 it's a drip drip drip as dave uh dave was saying to me uh offline here um it's it's just every few
00:34:40 hours almost uh i think it's it last night it was about every two hours it comes and goes you know
00:34:45 journalists go to sleep and stop digging uh but it's every few hours it seems um i think it's
00:34:52 is it seven or is it eight and counting i think we have eight and counting in alberta at least
00:34:56 Well, I did a service for Western Standard readers, Derek.
00:35:01 I listed everybody in one story, and I headlined it the not-so-magnificant seven.
00:35:07 And then at the very end, I was very clear this list will be updated as needed.
00:35:12 And that story only lasted 20 minutes.
00:35:15 In just a little over 20 minutes, I had to scrub out the magnificent seven, and I had to say, it's eight and counting.
00:35:23 So that's up there now.
00:35:25 How long will that list?
00:35:26 last who knows it's it's just a disaster it's Kenny's worst nightmare and how he
00:35:33 how he stops this I've no idea well if Jason Kenny thought that 2021 was gonna
00:35:40 be better than 2020 I'm not sure that's correct I predicted 2021 would be worse
00:35:45 than 2020 at least that's more entertaining so far I mean honest
00:35:53 mistakes happen. You know, when you make a mistake in public life, there's a lot of lenses on you,
00:36:00 a lot of scrutiny. When you make a mistake, we want people to fess up and take responsibility.
00:36:07 But I can tell you that is not a good political strategy. You are generally better just to muddle
00:36:11 your way through, make a couple of excuses, and hope that things move on. And I think that that
00:36:17 is that has been uh generally the mo for the kenny government here but the problem is this one is
00:36:24 really touching people people have been told uh we're going to tase you for playing hockey
00:36:31 people have been told that cops are going to show up and fine or arrest you for having uh christmas
00:36:39 with your family um people have been told to make incredible sacrifices here um not asked to make
00:36:46 sacrifices but ordered to make sacrifices and then the very people making this ordering are
00:36:52 making these orders are seem to have so little regard for them and there seems to be nothing
00:36:57 he can do he he cannot fire these people it would be far far too many he would uh he would be and
00:37:05 we just don't know like they're as we've discussed earlier they're not answering calls uh they are
00:37:11 not responding to media inquiries saying hey uh even when we've got a lead like hey we've got a
00:37:16 lead that you're in hawaii we've got pretty good sense that you're in hawaii are you in hawaii now
00:37:23 the mla is probably on a beach so maybe that's the reason he's not answering his phone but his
00:37:28 office is there and i can tell you if you're um someone working at an mla office gets a call from
00:37:34 this uh from a media outlet saying hey uh boss um joe blow from uh xyz network wants to know if
00:37:42 you're on a beach in hawaii they're going to call the mla and let them know immediately that they're
00:37:46 getting those calls and they're not responding so how many are actually getting away with it so far
00:37:52 uh how many of them have already booked emergency flights back so that they can uh pose in their
00:37:58 constituency beside uh you know the town hall in their in their riding with a picture of today's
00:38:04 paper and prove that they're elsewhere i bet you there are quite a few at this point that we have
00:38:09 not found and uh several have probably already returned to try and avoid the controversy and
00:38:15 part of the problem derek for for kenny's government is that say things were back to
00:38:22 normal and people went to work and they went about their business you know this may get forgotten
00:38:26 about but because people are locked down because they're in these pandemic regulations because they
00:38:32 still can't go and visit their relatives because they still can't go and visit a relative in a
00:38:39 old folks home this anger will build and build and build every day they'll be reminded of it
00:38:46 that hey you know you you're doing the best you can you are are following the guidelines
00:38:53 but our caucus is not and that anger is going to get to a boiling point in the next weekend.
00:39:03 Corey?
00:39:07 Yeah, it's kind of just connected to what Dave said. I would bet actually a lot of the big MSM
00:39:12 outlets who have those tax funded budgets have also probably got some interns at least camped
00:39:18 out in international airports across Canada right now with lists of pictures of members of parliament
00:39:23 and MLAs. There's got to be more out there, not just in Alberta. I mean, this is the vacation
00:39:28 season for these guys, and they're sneaking back all over the place. We're going to see more of
00:39:33 this unfold. You know, I wouldn't try to put myself in their shoes. I was thinking if I was
00:39:40 you know if I was a politician coming back from Hawaii I'd probably fly first to Vancouver never
00:39:48 leave the airport and then I'd take a take a transfer to like Prince George or something
00:39:54 because they're not you know the media is not going to put any any reporters at the Prince
00:39:58 George airport looking for you no one's going to recognize you there likely especially if you're
00:40:03 out of province rent a car and then drive to where you are I bet you if there are politicians
00:40:10 making these emergency flights back, which I almost guarantee you there is, then if they're
00:40:17 smart, they're not going to fly straight to Calgary International. They're not going to fly
00:40:20 straight to Edmonton International. They're going to transfer in a little bit, and then they're
00:40:27 going to rent a car to come in the rest of the way. Well, so yeah, we don't know how many of
00:40:35 they are, but there are almost certainly many, many more. We'll probably find quite a few more,
00:40:39 but I imagine a good number are going to get away from it.
00:40:43 But this all raises the question of recall legislation.
00:40:48 You know, it's funny when an old tweet goes viral again.
00:40:52 There was a tweet from Jason Kenney during the 2019 election
00:40:54 where he tweeted about their promise to give recall legislation to Albertans the right to,
00:41:01 and he put it in big letters,
00:41:02 we're going to give Albertans the right to fire your MLA
00:41:05 when they lose the confidence of their constituents.
00:41:07 And even when I've been in trouble before, I've always believed in the right to recall from the very beginning.
00:41:15 I've been wondering why the UCP has been dragging its feet on recall.
00:41:21 Backbench MLA Mark Smith brought in a private member's bill to fulfill the government's promise on recall.
00:41:28 And even though he was high in the draw, the government was not really in a hurry to pass that bill.
00:41:34 It never got passed, I believe.
00:41:37 And that's an easy promise to keep. This is not something that requires a bunch of studies and blue ribbon panels about a police force or something or an Alberta revenue agency. This is a simple piece of legislation. It exists in British Columbia already. Alberta's planning to model its recall legislation on British Columbia's, but they haven't brought it in. I suspect if we ever do get recall legislation, it's probably going to be brought in so that there's no time to actually recall anyone before the next election.
00:42:06 Corey, why do you think we've not yet seen this otherwise easy promise to keep past the floor of the legislature?
00:42:16 To be blunt, because they're afraid it'll be used.
00:42:19 You know, I guess you go in with confidence and things like that.
00:42:22 But, you know, I've been VP of policy and model policy for recall.
00:42:27 You don't want to make the bar too low.
00:42:28 You don't want a recall effort to start the day after somebody got elected.
00:42:31 But you've got to make a realistic petitioning level.
00:42:34 and yeah if that legislation was right in right now you know some people would be leading the
00:42:38 charge in a few constituencies they sure don't want to suddenly go to a bunch of by elections
00:42:43 it's as simple as that they don't want it used against themselves uh this it would be quite a
00:42:48 gamble but it could almost be an escape hatch for kenny there slap it through fast put in recall
00:42:53 legislation say look i'll leave it to the constituents to lay judgment on these mlas to
00:42:57 see if they should continue to serve or not but that would be a pretty long shot gamble on his
00:43:01 part i i'm not expecting to see recall legislation anytime soon now uh derek uh franco terrazano of
00:43:08 the canadian taxpayers federation a very smart cookie as we all know he's uh everyone who works
00:43:14 there is i assure you exactly he's he's been on the board a few times says he makes a good point
00:43:20 he says well jason kenny's not ready to to sanction or fire his his uh mlas for this
00:43:28 transgression then albertans are and he's you know he's making the same point you guys are where is
00:43:34 this recall legislation that was promised uh is this just one of these things that they say to
00:43:39 get elected and then it'll never happen it certainly appears to be the case right now
00:43:47 uh indeed uh well here uh i need to uh i'm gonna get something for our viewers here uh
00:43:53 why don't you lead the conversation just for the uh for the next two minutes and i'll be back with
00:43:57 us with an important one. Okay. Well, that sounds ominous. I'm not sure. Is Derek changing
00:44:05 into a Speedo? God, let's hope not, Corey. Let's hope not. But as mentioned, the counter
00:44:17 clock of MLAs from the UCP side that have gone over badly and gone on Hawaii is now
00:44:25 up to eight so we're going to do our best over the holiday period and over the holiday weekend as
00:44:30 as others are no doubt scurrying back into the province to keep that figure updated and
00:44:38 i'm sure it's not going to stop at eight how high it will go remains to be seen but
00:44:44 it's going to be an interesting few days that's for sure so make sure you follow along at
00:44:51 uh standardonline.com and here he is here he is derek's back okay folks well uh as i said i
00:44:58 i promised we were going to do a poll um we need to crowdsource for this poll to make sure we've
00:45:03 got the money for it uh we have shared a link to it in the comments section right now uh i'm also
00:45:10 we're also going to put it up on the screen here in a second uh there we are uh just go to donorbox
00:45:18 dot com sorry dot org slash poll crowd sourcing campaign that is maybe more
00:45:26 complicated it should be but we're we're gonna share as well in the headline of
00:45:30 this on Facebook live so they'll be easy link for you to click but if you click
00:45:35 on that that link you're going to be able to donate to our or help us
00:45:43 crowdsource a poll. We want to see what Albertans think about this. How upset are Albertans? I
00:45:50 suspect pretty upset, but do Albertans feel they should have the right to recall MLAs right now
00:45:55 over this? Do Albertans think that there should be resignations over this? Do they think that
00:46:04 this weakens the case for lockdowns and charging people for not wearing masks while they're playing
00:46:10 hockey or something. And we want to see, has this changed the popularity of the government itself?
00:46:16 Has this changed how people plan to vote? Is this going to shift people to the NDP,
00:46:20 or is this going to shift people to the right, to something like the Wild Rose Independence
00:46:24 Party, or a centrist party like the Alberta Party, or central left, I would say? Is this
00:46:30 going to change how people are going to vote? Could this have implications for the next election,
00:46:34 and who holds power in Alberta? I don't know. I have suspicions,
00:46:39 but those are just suspicions unless we get it confirmed with good hard data uh we're going to
00:46:44 contract a um if we raise enough money we're going to contract uh a good credible third party uh
00:46:51 polling firm to do this for us we don't do the polling we we contract someone else who are
00:46:56 experts at it uh you know me and dave and corey aren't sitting around calling people saying hey
00:47:01 how do you plan on voting the next election are you pissed off we don't do that we we put this
00:47:06 out to experts who do this scientifically and we will share the results with all of you but
00:47:11 we don't accept government money at the western standard we're funded uh by some advertisers
00:47:17 and by uh members people who donate on a monthly basis so first of all uh if you enjoy what we're
00:47:23 doing if you like having a media outlet like us that are willing to punch up uh consider going to
00:47:30 to western standard uh western standard online.com and click on membership become a member or you
00:47:36 can just uh on this right now we're changing the headline of um uh of our uh of our broadcast
00:47:44 right here we're going to put the link for uh the crowdsourcing and you can donate just to help us
00:47:48 get this poll done uh but before we go i'll put it to um both of you we'll start with dave uh some
00:47:54 closing comments i think derek and corey this is a long way from being over i think at some
00:48:02 point in the next week tracy allard will realize her position is untenable and she will resign
00:48:08 and i think this whole scandal will send jason kenny's popularity and the ucp's popularity to
00:48:15 record lows all right well like dave yeah this is gonna hurt them it's gonna hurt them a lot i i
00:48:24 I imagine they've got to be meeting and discussing and trying to figure out how to get themselves the hell out of this mess of their own making.
00:48:30 2021, everybody kept talking about looking forward to the end of 2020.
00:48:33 Well, this isn't shaping up to be an easier year for the UCP right now.
00:48:38 So we're just going to keep watching and waiting to see what unfolds.
00:48:43 So, Dave, I want to kind of follow up on what you said there.
00:48:45 Are you predicting that her position in particular will become untenable and that she will eventually resign?
00:48:51 I think so, Derek. I think, you know, she could have saved herself a lot of trouble, could have saved the UCP a lot of trouble by doing what Rod Phillips did and honorably resigning.
00:49:06 I think the political pressure will grow. I think that the public pressure, we haven't even heard from the public yet.
00:49:13 We need to hear from her voters in Grand Prairie what they think. And I don't think they're going to be happy.
00:49:20 So she should take a spoonful of medicine, resign, go to the back benches, sit in the back benches for a year, 0.97
00:49:27 and maybe she'll get back in cabinet in another year. 0.97
00:49:30 I think that's her only way out.
00:49:34 It's an interesting question.
00:49:35 I mean, I'll come back to Corey on this.
00:49:38 I mean, there are far too many people for Kenny to fire every one of them.
00:49:42 He can't fire at least one minister that we know of, probably more.
00:49:47 and he can't fire what'll probably turn out to be at least half a dozen of his
00:49:52 MLAs from the caucus. And he can't fire his chief of staff, several press
00:49:59 secretaries, and God knows how many more. Corey, do you think if Tracy Allard
00:50:06 falls on her sword here and resigns, will that be enough to kind of hush this the
00:50:11 way it's been hushed in Ontario? In Ontario, people are still pissed off, but
00:50:14 you know, they got blood. There's blood on the floor. As far as they know, there hasn't been a
00:50:19 bunch of other MPPs there traveling around. But in the Alberta's case, it seems like it's a
00:50:25 cottage industry of lockdown MLAs breaking their own lockdowns. If Tracy Allard falls on her sword,
00:50:31 do you think that'll be enough to at least show enough blood on the floor that the government
00:50:38 can get past this or not? You know, I mean, she may resign on her own because of the pressure, 0.98
00:50:45 but I don't know if that'll help the government because, yes, that's falling on her own sword.
00:50:49 But you see, people want to see action now. They want to see that this isn't tolerated by the
00:50:53 leadership. So I think if it's going to have any impact, that has to come from above. She needs to
00:50:58 be actually canned. And again, may not, you know, throw out a caucus, but stuffed onto the back 1.00
00:51:02 bench uh how can you further punish a backbencher who's already a backbencher you know because we
00:51:08 got a number of them i i don't know but there definitely needs to be some sort of active
00:51:14 sanction he can't can them all and there could be more coming but he can't just let this go
00:51:18 obviously people are waiting to see some sort of punishment or backlash there has to be there's no
00:51:24 leadership if you don't well generally uh it's extraordinarily rare to officially fire a minister
00:51:30 it's generally understood that well sometimes people do resign of their own will but you often
00:51:38 get resigned you know you sit down with the leader and the leader says okay you need to go and I'm
00:51:44 asking for your resignation and it's kind of a little gentler uh like the minute the Ontario
00:51:49 Minister of Finance Rod Phillips he got resigned he probably almost certainly wouldn't have just
00:51:54 resigned because it almost certainly and I don't think Doug Ford would dispute it uh he was
00:52:00 asked for his resignation. That's generally the way things go. What you're saying, if I get this
00:52:08 correct, Corey, is that Kenny has to actively fire and put her head on a pike to make an example in 0.96
00:52:14 order to absolve enough of the others of any blame and show accountability, but that her simply 0.89
00:52:20 resigning wouldn't be enough? I think there has to be something showing that he has cracked down
00:52:26 on his caucus and ministers.
00:52:28 I understand what you're saying,
00:52:30 but politicos like us know that,
00:52:32 but your average citizen doesn't necessarily realize that.
00:52:35 They need to see that from above.
00:52:36 I mean, we know how it's played inside there,
00:52:37 but they need to see the Premier getting up
00:52:41 and getting this under control. 0.99
00:52:43 And having her resign on her own, 1.00
00:52:44 even if we know that there's still an invisible boot print on her butt, 1.00
00:52:48 wouldn't demonstrate that. 0.97
00:52:51 There has to be some action from the Premier's office of some sort.
00:52:54 Whether or not it's her, it's going to have to be something.
00:52:55 he can't let this one go all right uh well we've been following your questions and comments uh
00:53:02 they've been informing our discussion as we go along even if we haven't referred to them directly
00:53:07 but um there's just far too many for us to get through i i i can't give you a number but i think
00:53:14 they're oh i'm seeing at least 174 the last time i checked uh we can't go through them all but um
00:53:20 just a heads up remember if you're if you're put it if you're commenting it
00:53:24 can't be too long otherwise we can't put it on the screen we're not going to
00:53:27 cover up the whole screen with the comments they've got a shortened suite
00:53:30 so they go along the bottom no swearing try to keep personal attacks out of it
00:53:34 don't put links to other things in it because that's gonna make it too big but
00:53:38 we appreciate everybody's interaction with the show today great feedback and
00:53:43 even if we haven't mentioned your tweets or your your comments we it is informing
00:53:49 our discussion. Again, if you're not already a member of the Western Standard, go to
00:53:53 westernstandardonline.com, click on membership and help support an independent Western media
00:53:58 that punches up and does not accept any government subsidies. If you're already a member, we
00:54:03 thank you very much. And if you want to help out, member or not, also you can go to doorbox.org
00:54:10 poll crowdsourcing campaign and help us commission a poll to figure out what people in Alberta
00:54:18 are really thinking about this right now but uh corey dave thank you very much for joining me today
00:54:24 thanks derek and uh thank you all very much aloha from beautiful hawaii
00:54:48 You