Western Standard - January 15, 2026


Kamloops Coverup: Ottawa refuses to release 'mass grave' documents

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
HANNAFORD: Trump's bold Venezuela action a wake-up call for Canada The silent thief

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

172.38

Word count

8,283

Sentence count

404

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

35

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, we're joined by former Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford, Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan, and former WSP editor-in-chief Dave Naylor. We talk about the Kamloops Holocaust, the government blocking access to information on the mass graves found in the area, and the return of the OG Pipeline.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Today and welcome! Today is January 14th, 2026.
00:00:28 I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:33 Joined by our usual lineup of former Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:39 Great to see you all.
00:00:40 Senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:43 And an OG Pipeline member, we think probably permanently.
00:00:50 We'll see how much, how he likes it.
00:00:52 But bringing Dave Naylor back to the Pipeline.
00:00:55 Dave, I remember when, you know, this was just a tiny little wee baby company,
00:00:59 and we'd be doing this from our living rooms, just to kind of help.
00:01:03 Staring at the laptop on kind of a Zoom thing.
00:01:07 The pipeline was you and me, and sometimes Corey.
00:01:10 Corey, were you an OG pipeline?
00:01:12 Yeah, because it would be those weird ones where you had to clip out the screen
00:01:14 to get the faces in for posts.
00:01:17 It was very...
00:01:18 I think they're still on YouTube if somebody really wants to scratch.
00:01:20 God, they're rough.
00:01:21 They are rough.
00:01:22 But Dave, welcome back to the pipeline.
00:01:24 Good to be back as the eye candy of the panel.
00:01:28 You're our sunshine girl.
00:01:29 Looking pretty as there you go.
00:01:30 Yeah.
00:01:31 Okay.
00:01:33 Well, the, I guess, second petition to trigger a referendum on Alberta independence has begun.
00:01:42 The first petition on Alberta independence was launched by anti-independence federalists
00:01:49 until they realized that launching a referendum on staying in Canada
00:01:53 also means that people can vote no and therefore leave.
00:01:58 And then they panicked and pleaded not to have a referendum on that.
00:02:01 So that kind of cleared the way after wasting everyone's time and effort and money.
00:02:06 Cleared the way now to the pro-independent side to collect their signatures.
00:02:12 And it's off to a pretty strong start.
00:02:15 We'll be talking about that.
00:02:17 Will Mark Carney pivot to China as the United States becomes more assertive and dominant in its hemisphere and bellicose, some might say?
00:02:29 Mark Carney is on his way to China. China is quite explicit that Canada should pivot away from the United States and join PAX China.
00:02:40 And I'm sure that will not result in the immediate kidnapping in an overnight operation by Delta Force of Mark Carney.
00:02:49 And he'll get to show up for some kind of charges at New York State Court.
00:02:55 First, we're going to start with a great story.
00:03:01 It's been a long time coming, but the federal government has lost its appeal.
00:03:10 with the Federal Office of the Information and Privacy Commissioner
00:03:15 for an accessed information request
00:03:18 to get the report on these mass graves
00:03:22 from the Kamloops Holocaust,
00:03:25 the genocide that took place there with the mass graves
00:03:28 where people were just slaughtered by thousands or hundreds
00:03:32 or whatever the story is.
00:03:36 Some intrepid reporter, I'm not sure who,
00:03:38 do we know which, who?
00:03:39 Black locks.
00:03:40 Of course, it's black locks. 1.00
00:03:42 Those dastard little buggers. 1.00
00:03:46 They filed an access to information request. 0.99
00:03:49 And Ottawa said, no, you can't have a report on this genocide.
00:03:52 You just need to accept it.
00:03:53 Dave, why don't you fill it in a little from there?
00:03:56 Yeah, if you remember when the local band, who's got an unpronounceable name,
00:04:01 the Kamloops band, we'll call them,
00:04:04 said they had found the graves of 215 children.
00:04:07 The country collectively lost its mind, we lowered flags, and Justin Trudeau was pictured with teddy bears.
00:04:15 The ban was given $12 million to go ahead and do something to make the thing real or not.
00:04:27 And it turns out that one of the things, one of the catches on that $12 million was they had to file reports as to what they've done with it.
00:04:35 And that's the information that Black Locks first asked for. 0.68
00:04:39 And there's 576 pages and the feds said, no, we're not giving it to you.
00:04:47 So Black Locks then went to the information commissioner, appealed, and now the information officer has ordered it released within the next month.
00:04:55 So will they release it, I guess?
00:04:58 Or will they maybe go up to a higher court?
00:05:00 They fought court battles to keep papers hidden before, and they may do it again.
00:05:07 But I think, Corey, I think you were one of the first media people to speak out loud that it's a hoax.
00:05:14 I think so.
00:05:15 I mean, it really was, you know, and at first I was horrified like everybody else.
00:05:19 People ask why I get so ticked off about this.
00:05:20 Part of it was when I first saw the reports, I thought, oh, my Lord, they've murdered children in a school.
00:05:25 This is awful.
00:05:26 I mean, this is a black mark on Canadian history.
00:05:29 let's let's rectify this deal with this i don't know a month maybe two months in is it was getting
00:05:35 more evident that they're stalling any further investigation i mean anything else where you got
00:05:40 215 buried children you're going to exhume you're going to have criminal investigate
00:05:44 and uh finally enough like okay this this stinks and more and more though we saw some major you know
00:05:50 media members and others finally but but the backlash you would get initially for daring to
00:05:54 question it was was uh unreal and now it's at a point i think everybody kind of realizes there's
00:06:00 nothing there and now the government's trying to cover it up i uh we gotta we gotta insert this
00:06:04 clip uh you remember the jim carrey 90s movie liar liar he's a lawyer he can't lie for a day
00:06:11 and at one point he says i object your honor i object and why is that mr reed because it's
00:06:18 devastating to my case. Overruled.
00:06:20 Good call. I feel like that's
00:06:22 that's what's here
00:06:24 right now. You know, people are saying, I object.
00:06:26 Show us the evidence.
00:06:27 Show us the evidence. And Ottawa says, I object.
00:06:30 And we say, why? Because it'll
00:06:32 show it's a lie. I was
00:06:34 like you, Corey. I took this as like
00:06:36 I can't believe this happened in Canada.
00:06:38 I mean, no country's perfect. No country's been
00:06:40 all cooperation
00:06:42 and getting along its entire
00:06:44 history. But this is
00:06:45 a real black stain. If true.
00:06:47 yeah let's see
00:06:50 and
00:06:51 we expect basic
00:06:54 due process
00:06:55 we're going to collect some evidence
00:06:58 how many bodies have been found in any
00:07:00 of these mass graves
00:07:01 not one so far
00:07:03 not one
00:07:05 and
00:07:07 the
00:07:09 Nigel
00:07:10 the feds
00:07:14 I don't know what is it
00:07:15 I mean the obvious thing is
00:07:17 they're i think very worried that it's going to show no there there are nobodies uh but i don't
00:07:23 know am i am i being a little too out of left field and supposing that just possibly this band
00:07:30 didn't how wild speculation is it that maybe they spent some of the money on things that have little
00:07:37 to do with actually getting some evidence well that of course would justify that you request for
00:07:41 documents to these are progress reports you see that they're supposed to file as the as the um
00:07:48 condition of getting this money advanced to them uh so what you go what you see i gather if you go
00:07:55 i haven't been down to can loops to take a look but uh people who have some it's all fed stuff
00:08:00 and sacred ground and you know don't even look at it never mind try to try to uh excavate in there
00:08:06 or think of anything like that.
00:08:09 Look, there's a bigger game going on here,
00:08:12 a much bigger game.
00:08:14 I stuck my neck out a couple of years ago
00:08:16 when I was challenged on the point.
00:08:17 I said, if you show me the evidence,
00:08:21 I will say that, yes,
00:08:23 I will say what the evidence indicates,
00:08:26 but right now we have no evidence,
00:08:28 and therefore I'm not prepared to say
00:08:30 that this all happened just as described.
00:08:33 So why do they hang on to the narrative?
00:08:36 Well, look, let's be honest about it.
00:08:38 There's a move to give Canada back to indigenous people at the moment. 0.94
00:08:43 Now, most people say that's ridiculous.
00:08:44 We're not going to do that. 0.69
00:08:46 But if they're made to feel guilty, they might.
00:08:49 And you can see it at work in B.C. right now with the things that Mr. Eby has authorized.
00:08:55 You can see it with the narrative that is infecting the B.C. Supreme Court as it makes its judgments on things like the Cowichan case.
00:09:05 and you know if everybody and by the way it's just not white people and people descended from the uh
00:09:12 from white people who are affected by this everybody who has come into this country whether
00:09:16 they came from india or pakistan or the middle east all now have an interest in the outcome
00:09:24 and the outcome depends ultimately on whether you can convince the rest of canada that a terrible
00:09:30 thing was done and in recompense you have to do other things which will cost you money and could
00:09:37 even alter the character of the country so this is why this narrative is so important this is why
00:09:43 they don't want to give you the information because if you blow the narrative up that whole
00:09:48 process is set back years i i think you're you're right and it it feeds into the agenda around
00:09:55 delegitimizing Canada for
00:09:57 indigenous rights and indigenous
00:09:59 land-backed claims, all these
00:10:01 things. I think it also fits into
00:10:03 the broader agenda
00:10:04 of white guilt complex
00:10:06 that has afflicted Western
00:10:09 societies since the end of the Second World
00:10:11 War, some more than others, but
00:10:13 has afflicted everyone.
00:10:15 And this feeds into it more deeply
00:10:17 that we need to be collectively
00:10:19 guilty, collectively
00:10:21 ashamed of who we are.
00:10:23 No one alive did anything,
00:10:25 but we need to be collectively guilty of our civilization,
00:10:28 of our ancestors, of our nations, of our people.
00:10:30 That's exactly right.
00:10:32 That's what this is about.
00:10:34 That's the left-wing approach to changing the world,
00:10:36 is to move from a point of where everybody is accountable
00:10:39 for their own actions to where groups of people
00:10:43 are accountable for actions of their ancestors.
00:10:46 I'm not sure just the left is responsible here.
00:10:48 It's the left driving it,
00:10:49 but the right allows it to succeed when it acquiesces to it and you saw this with the bc
00:10:55 conservatives uh trying to kick out people for uh for questioning this uh you know it's the part
00:11:00 of the split that went on there uh you see a real muzzle put around federal conservative mps around
00:11:06 this because even though those in power in the conservative movement conservative parties they 0.95
00:11:11 know this is bullshit they still are afraid to question this because someone's going to call 0.99
00:11:17 them racist on Twitter, and so they 1.00
00:11:19 silence themselves. So it's the left driving
00:11:21 this, but I think it's the right that's actually
00:11:23 responsible for making it a kind of
00:11:25 metapolitical consensus when they acquiesce
00:11:27 to it. Well, absolutely. It's time
00:11:29 to, you know, the right has got to name it
00:11:31 and shame it. Well, if this is blown
00:11:33 off, though, this will embolden people to start
00:11:35 questioning, because this is the first domino.
00:11:37 If this is proven to be a
00:11:39 hoax, if the evidence is showing this never happened,
00:11:41 the bodies aren't there, we've got that
00:11:43 whole truth and reconciliation report
00:11:45 with a lot of questionable allegations in there too.
00:11:49 And I think people will now say,
00:11:50 well, if that was BS,
00:11:52 we should be entitled to maybe look a little more closely
00:11:54 at some of the claims that were made
00:11:56 throughout all of this,
00:11:57 because what they did with that,
00:11:59 people are forgetting two things that were problematic.
00:12:02 One, of course, they took all oral history
00:12:04 at stock value as if it was fact without evidence.
00:12:07 And there was no cross-examination.
00:12:08 No, and there was actually a scale
00:12:12 of compensation for victims.
00:12:14 So they were very incentivized to make it out that they suffered the most horrible possible things, which some I don't know were probably true, but now we will have, I think people say, well, I think I want to hear a little more because there's a whole lot of billions that got put out based on this.
00:12:31 When we can see a fraud being as large as that level, I think it's not unfair to now scrutinize some of the other claims and they're terrified.
00:12:39 No, and you're right.
00:12:40 It is the business of being a victim.
00:12:42 And this band got 12 million bucks.
00:12:46 We don't know what they did with it.
00:12:47 Wasn't there some, was it this band or a different band where they found a ton of money was spent on communications consultants?
00:12:53 No, that was this.
00:12:54 This was the same guys.
00:12:56 $12 million, by the way, Dave, if memory shares me right, is part of a $300 million program.
00:13:01 So there's a lot of the rest.
00:13:03 And you know, it's just, if only there was a way to solve it.
00:13:07 You and I could go and spend an afternoon digging and we'd solve the whole thing.
00:13:11 yeah well we're in pretty poor shape we could hire a couple but yes it is it really is that
00:13:17 simple that's what's annoying with this you don't need some evidence is right massive technology
00:13:21 you have exhume a grave it's done a lot and we won't do it why hasn't the rcmp gone because it
00:13:28 if there's 215 dead children that's a crime it was specifically told to stay out of it
00:13:33 well remember there was a huge controversy it's one reason for uh the way the last manitoba
00:13:38 election went. There was, I think,
00:13:40 one, maybe two, but
00:13:42 I think one missing body from an
00:13:44 indigenous person. Two in the wind of figs. 0.93
00:13:46 Two in the wind of figs. Two in the wind of figs.
00:13:48 Landfill. And, I mean,
00:13:50 it was wildly uneconomical. They already knew
00:13:52 what happened to them. But
00:13:54 it became a rallying point
00:13:56 for people. It was a political issue, and so
00:13:58 huge amounts of money were spent
00:13:59 to find and exhume these
00:14:02 missing bodies.
00:14:04 Okay. We knew there were
00:14:06 bodies there. This was a murder, and we knew
00:14:08 the bodies were there and we spent incredible or manitoba taxpayers spent an incredible sum of money
00:14:14 to get those bodies it's like 180 million dollars wasn't it it was something incredible
00:14:18 you know it was an incredible amount of money to find some bodies and i i don't want to be callous
00:14:23 but it was a it was a questionable decision but either way the decision was made to spend a huge
00:14:28 amount of money to find these bodies because we had to get the truth and put these people to rest
00:14:33 why won't we do it here where there should be theoretically mass graves and it's incredibly
00:14:39 cheap to do it well that exposes another part of the hoax in winnipeg there were family members
00:14:44 and records of the two missing women and everything with these 200 alleged children
00:14:49 who were buried at kamluks there's no cousins brothers mothers grandparents sons there's no
00:14:54 record of any children that are even supposed to be there so there's no advocate saying hey i want
00:14:59 my brother to be exhumed so we can return them to the home and possibly buried respectfully and all
00:15:06 that it's not there that's another missing part of this puzzle where did these mystifying 215
00:15:12 children come from and again that's why they just don't want these questions asked and we could all
00:15:18 be locked up if we're even talking about this realize this that's their answer residential
00:15:23 school denialism law we could all be thrown in the slammer denialism where this is a this is a
00:15:28 heinous crime to question, to ask any questions, to demand any evidence. Their only answer to this
00:15:35 is not to provide the extremely easy to provide evidence, is to propose jailing anyone who
00:15:42 questions it. Well, I hate to say it, but you know, well, that's the way I do things. Look,
00:15:47 if they thought there were bodies down there, they would dig up three and they'd have them
00:15:50 touring across the country in glass covered caskets and with the grievance industry showing
00:15:56 why they need even more money they would want to highlight that there really are victims down
00:16:01 there they know there aren't any as much as anybody else does we certainly certainly have
00:16:07 yet to present the evidence or even look yes so yeah in the end i mean this could go either way
00:16:14 but i think in the end uh this is going to do a lot more harm to the grievance industry uh than
00:16:20 than it ever did well.
00:16:21 They got the pound of flesh.
00:16:23 They got the blood lowered.
00:16:25 Yeah.
00:16:26 They massively have overplayed their hand here.
00:16:28 And they took advantage of everyone's good will
00:16:31 and innate sense of justice
00:16:33 to try and shame us for something
00:16:35 that just does not appear to have happened.
00:16:37 Just to your point there, Corey,
00:16:40 the fact that the federal government
00:16:43 wants to make it a criminal offense,
00:16:45 they are now in the business of controlling speech what sort of government has evolved in
00:16:55 this country because that would not have happened even under a previous liberal government there is
00:17:01 a rich end would have never done so there is a yeah there there is a motivation for control
00:17:06 and complete control uh no we've had restrictions on free speech for a long time and i'm old to the
00:17:12 point of saying if he think this and say it out loud we're going to send you to jail they might
00:17:18 have said we'll send you to the human rights commission and it'll cost you your retirements
00:17:22 plan but no we we have i mean this might be another step in it but we we have had
00:17:27 nothing you're thinking of whereas which would be comparable uh well i mean we've had like the
00:17:32 earth sundles of the world and these guys and they're generally considered cranks and whatever
00:17:36 but they did
00:17:37 time for saying things
00:17:39 that were not allowed to be said.
00:17:43 Whatever
00:17:44 their opinion,
00:17:45 we have criminalized speech before
00:17:48 beyond defamation
00:17:50 or advocating.
00:17:51 I'm always fine with defamation
00:17:53 or
00:17:54 advocating harm. Like, say,
00:17:57 I think someone should go out and kill Corey 0.99
00:17:59 or everyone should go out and kill 1.00
00:18:01 UK citizens. It's a better discussion. 1.00
00:18:04 Yeah, Zendel is odious and even 0.99
00:18:05 And, you know, with what I think, it shouldn't have been illegal for the nutcase to send the crap he said. 0.98
00:18:09 So we set the precedent there. 0.98
00:18:11 So we're living in that.
00:18:12 The other difference, too, though, was he was denying something that we had a whole whack of it, but it's supposed to really happen.
00:18:18 But if something is solid, you don't need to criminalize the questioning of it, even if they're right or wrong.
00:18:22 That's not the point.
00:18:23 The point is, if you criminalize it, you actually, in my view, legitimize questioning it.
00:18:28 Well, it makes the conspiracy theorists even more set off when, well, what are you trying to hide this?
00:18:32 My point is that we have set the precedent.
00:18:34 we did it on that and now we know there's enough legal precedent in canada there's enough case law 0.97
00:18:41 that this would totally stand up in court doesn't matter that it's bullshit it would stand up in 0.88
00:18:45 court because we have enough legal precedent here to say no it's fine to criminalize uh it would be 0.91
00:18:51 interesting if somebody got charged though and i mean i'm not a lawyer but typically these things
00:18:56 then it would go to discovery and uh because you're denying something well i mean i think
00:19:02 well who knows I mean if they're really out to get you
00:19:04 who knows how the courts will treat you but theoretically you should say
00:19:06 well then we need to discover evidence 0.99
00:19:09 that means dig in a darn hole and see 0.98
00:19:10 if I'm actually denying something that happened or not 0.99
00:19:13 I'm not sure because
00:19:14 the courts have upheld the laws
00:19:17 that you can't
00:19:18 say something that
00:19:20 could just cause
00:19:22 hurt feelings
00:19:24 hurt feelings that could hurt an identifiable
00:19:26 group etc and the truth around
00:19:28 if I said something nasty about
00:19:30 Somalis 0.68
00:19:31 true or not
00:19:35 in the aggregate, obviously not everyone
00:19:36 but if I said something nasty
00:19:38 about Somalis in the aggregate
00:19:40 even if true, that's an identifiable
00:19:43 group that I have
00:19:43 said some nasty things about
00:19:46 it doesn't matter if it's true or not
00:19:48 that gets upheld in Canadian law
00:19:51 so we can dig all the holes we want
00:19:53 discovery's not going to really matter in that sense
00:19:55 you're doing the time
00:19:56 Sonal, by the way, was
00:19:58 jailed in Germany, not in Canada
00:20:01 that we deported him.
00:20:03 We're talking about
00:20:04 the Canadian government response.
00:20:07 Well, they're even more zealous in
00:20:08 a long speech.
00:20:10 But yeah, that's a good correction there.
00:20:13 Thank you.
00:20:14 Alright, move on to something more
00:20:17 cheery.
00:20:18 Make China great again?
00:20:22 So,
00:20:22 Nigel, you wanted to talk about this one.
00:20:28 I mean,
00:20:29 the whole world has pivoted to China
00:20:31 to some extent ever since they joined the World Trade
00:20:33 Organization. It's
00:20:35 an indispensable economic partner
00:20:37 in the world now. Can't be ignored.
00:20:40 You know,
00:20:41 Trump has been rather bellicose
00:20:43 with Kennedy. Carney actually should
00:20:45 be thanking him. The way Trump talked
00:20:47 about annexing Canada, he would have never been
00:20:49 Prime Minister. Probably would have suffered
00:20:51 the same fate as J.B. Singh.
00:20:54 There's time.
00:20:56 Pardon? There's time.
00:20:57 Yeah. But
00:20:58 But he's in China, I think, right now, and the Chinese have been quite explicit that, you know, Carney should, Canada should be pivoting away from the States towards China, even if it were to happen to some extent.
00:21:12 I doubt it would ever be very explicit because Carney would get a midnight free helicopter ride for Delta Force pretty quickly, I think.
00:21:20 If the United States won't tolerate Maduro across the Gulf in Venezuela, there's a 0% chance they would tolerate it from Canada.
00:21:30 But Carney does have a very long history with China.
00:21:33 He's pretty China-friendly.
00:21:37 I don't know. Your take?
00:21:38 So my take on it is, actually, there's a lot of questions, and you've hit on a number of them there, but Trump is off to Greenland because he feels he needs it for national security.
00:21:53 No, he doesn't.
00:21:54 They already have all the military they want.
00:21:56 That's not why he wants it.
00:21:58 That's not why he actually wants it.
00:22:00 So, Derek, what nobody is talking about is that you've got a strait of water between Greenland and Canada.
00:22:07 to which america is already there in greenland and they could if they had greenland in possession
00:22:12 they could actually say well that's an internal waterway and now we can uh now we can control it
00:22:17 there's more than one reason but then i can do that on america's behalf that's not it but the
00:22:21 relevance of that to uh to china is if he establishes this sort of complete american
00:22:28 control over that northern uh space and then they've got this this this canadian thing that
00:22:36 happens with china you've got you've got your enemy right in you we're busily supporting china 0.99
00:22:41 bringing in the goods i mean i honestly don't think we're tell the force will be in get us
00:22:46 military i don't think they got us where they i don't think we'll see delta force coming calling
00:22:52 but uh you can see that if we get too close to charter the the acts aren't going to like it
00:22:58 and other people can speculate what they would do.
00:23:03 What is the American reaction going to be
00:23:07 to us Canadians replenishing the oil
00:23:11 that the Chinese have just lost for Venezuela?
00:23:14 They're not going to like it.
00:23:16 I don't know what they'll do, but that is a negative.
00:23:21 You know, Mr. Carney, all he wants is trade alternatives,
00:23:24 But what the Chinese want is to drive a very thick wedge between Canada and the United States. 0.96
00:23:32 That's not necessarily in our interest, because the Chinese are not the nice guys in the world. 1.00
00:23:39 We may not like being under American domination, but at least they speak English.
00:23:44 We do not want to be under Chinese domination.
00:23:46 and I fear that Mr. Carney and his enthusiasm to show economic progress
00:23:52 and have something to wave under the nose of the Canadian voting public
00:23:57 is going to give away too much too quick.
00:23:59 What exactly will the Americans do about it?
00:24:03 You'll know there's something going on if he comes back from China 1.00
00:24:07 and within a couple of weeks we've got authorization for a pipeline
00:24:11 and you've got to go now and do it right away.
00:24:13 That will tell you a lot about who agreed to what
00:24:18 and under what conditions.
00:24:20 It'd be fine for us, but not for anybody else.
00:24:23 I think that's one of the key things to look at.
00:24:26 This might be what, if a pipeline's going to get built
00:24:29 to the West Coast, it could stem largely from this meeting.
00:24:35 American analysts and commentators,
00:24:38 for the first time really ever, at least in a long time,
00:24:42 are talking very seriously about Canada
00:24:44 in the fallout of Venezuela.
00:24:47 A lot of them have started to connect to that.
00:24:48 Well, what does it really mean?
00:24:52 Trump's excuse for wanting Greenland
00:24:54 to station the military there
00:24:55 is about as truthful
00:24:58 as they wanted Maduro because of drugs.
00:25:00 It had nothing to do with drugs,
00:25:02 and the United States military
00:25:03 is already in Greenland.
00:25:06 These are the prima facie
00:25:09 public reasons given for these things.
00:25:11 But it's much more basic than that. But a lot of Americans have started to connect the dots that by getting Venezuelan heavy sour oil back in production, and that'll take some time, but getting it back in production, that is going to put massive pressure on Canada and specifically Alberta.
00:25:32 This is directly eating our lunch.
00:25:35 It's going to put downward pressure on prices that are already at a discount.
00:25:38 It puts the Americans in a more powerful position in demanding price points from us,
00:25:43 that our oil is going to go even cheaper than it is right now.
00:25:47 And so building a pipeline to the West Coast,
00:25:49 which should have been obvious for an extremely long time to everybody,
00:25:53 becomes more critical now than ever.
00:25:56 I guess my worry, Dave, is Trump somehow could become an obstacle
00:26:00 to building a pipeline to the west coast because that negates the advantage they get by taking
00:26:05 venezuela putting its oil back in play yeah well trump made it clear in uh water in no detroit
00:26:11 yesterday he was touring a ford plant and he was he was asked about the north american mexico free
00:26:17 trade deal and he says doesn't need it anymore he says he needs nothing from canada doesn't want
00:26:22 our cars doesn't want our lumber doesn't want our aluminum so he's put canada on notice that
00:26:28 We do need to go looking for new markets.
00:26:31 I don't think there's any doubt about that.
00:26:33 But I agree 100% with Nigel.
00:26:36 If Carney gets all buddy-buddy with Chairman Xi, it will upset Trump.
00:26:44 What he will do, I mean, who knows what that guy is thinking, right?
00:26:48 It's trying to predict him as a mugs game. 0.99
00:26:53 But he won't be happy.
00:26:55 No doubt about that.
00:26:56 Well, there's an English-language newspaper published in Beijing.
00:27:01 It's effectively an arm of the Chinese propaganda ministry, the China Daily.
00:27:07 But what they often do is, if there's something coming up,
00:27:11 they publish an editorial, and it's an informal way for the government
00:27:16 to say what they expect to get out of it.
00:27:18 So, you know, Mr. Carney's on his way in,
00:27:21 and what is the China Daily editorial talking about?
00:27:25 And it starts off with a polite recognition that Mr. Carney has already made some efforts to develop a good relationship with China.
00:27:35 It takes note of the, you know, the troubles that we've had and blames Canada for looking around for things to complain about.
00:27:47 And, you know, obviously, why would we complain about Chinese interference? 0.99
00:27:52 Well, get over it.
00:27:53 And so it's, and it has made it known in the past, and here I'm quoting, it wants to drop its U.S.-inspired tariffs on Chinese steel, aluminum, and electric vehicles before removing its retaliatory duties on Canadian agriculture and seafood products.
00:28:15 So you will sell canola to China.
00:28:17 Let us export our Chinese electric cars into your marketplace.
00:28:24 So this is all, you can get a very good idea about what the Chinese hope to get out of this.
00:28:29 And it all looks like a close trade relationship leading to political domination.
00:28:36 That is what Trump is going to reject.
00:28:39 But Canadians should also be looking at this arrangement over very carefully.
00:28:43 you may not like american domination you don't like chinese domination either
00:28:48 well i think there is look we're not a great power so we have to play the great power
00:28:53 game between them uh we're very obvious we're in the american sphere but we're hyper inside
00:28:59 the american sphere of influence um a lot of canadians might not like to hear it but guess
00:29:04 what culturally most canadians are americans they're political canadians but they're culturally
00:29:08 americans we watch american tv we listen to american music we eat american food we drive
00:29:13 american cars uh you can't distinguish someone from saskatchewan in minnesota really but other
00:29:20 than their license plate that's about that's about the only marker um but we have to play the game
00:29:25 a bit uh i mean the we we've got these tariffs against uh chinese electric vehicles to protect
00:29:33 our non-existent ev industry the problem is that the feds and ontario have sunk a gargantuan
00:29:40 amount of money into subsidizing these non-industries, and so to protect those nascent
00:29:47 industries, they put a protective tariff wall around it. Okay, fine, but then there's obvious
00:29:53 consequences to that, and that comes to seafood exports and canola. Luckily for most liberals,
00:29:59 West Coast fishermen vote conservative, and so do canola farmers. This is not affecting liberal
00:30:03 voters all that directly, at least on the negative side. Maybe it helps them on the positive side.
00:30:09 So I think he should do a deal there.
00:30:11 We should do a trade deal with China.
00:30:13 It's not a bad thing to do.
00:30:15 But we need to be leery of it, because China obviously has a very clear intention of trying to drive a wedge between us and the states. 0.54
00:30:22 Trump's rhetoric has facilitated that quite helpfully to the Chinese interests. 0.53
00:30:28 But as he's made clear, you can talk to whoever you want.
00:30:31 But if you actually get in bed with the Chinese, you're getting a free helicopter ride. 1.00
00:30:34 You know, Derek, one thing that nobody bothers to think about is that in three years less than, Donald Trump will no longer be president of the United States.
00:30:45 And you can almost guarantee that things will change at that point.
00:30:50 Because I cannot think of another U.S. politician who has the capacity to do what Trump does, the way he does it, and pull it off.
00:31:01 I don't think that's a given, Nigel.
00:31:02 You know what? He's mused about it. He's too old. He's in better shape than Biden. Or, you know, he could put mini-me in there. What's his name? Vance.
00:31:18 So, you know, maybe we shouldn't sign a five-year deal with China.
00:31:30 Maybe we should just make it for, like, about two and a half
00:31:33 and see how things go in 2020.
00:31:37 I don't know. This looks like a win-win to me.
00:31:39 We're not protecting any real industry with EEVs.
00:31:41 It's a fake industry that is just purely from subsidies anyway.
00:31:45 So, like, what are we protecting?
00:31:46 We're protecting nothing, and all we're doing is getting
00:31:48 tariffs put against our goods that are real
00:31:50 and hugely important to our economy.
00:31:52 This is what's talked about kind of from the start, though.
00:31:54 If we see dirt actually start to move between
00:31:56 here and BC to get a pipe, even if it's going...
00:31:58 There's heavy oil refiners in India that would be
00:32:00 thrilled to get our product.
00:32:03 But Mark Carney also yesterday
00:32:04 went out and met with the First Nations lobby
00:32:06 group and said, don't worry, we won't do it without
00:32:08 your permission. So that seems to be dead in the water
00:32:10 either. Mr. Dithers II,
00:32:13 that's another thing with Carney.
00:32:14 He talks a great game, but he's never committed to a damn 0.64
00:32:16 thing in a whole year in office yet. He just talks and talks and talks and talks. So we'll 0.92
00:32:20 see. We'll see what his attitude is when he comes back, but something's got to happen
00:32:25 eventually. Okay. Maybe. Yeah. Maybe. Or not. Well, speaking of shifting allegiances, let's
00:32:34 talk about the Alberta independence referendum, uh, sort of kicking off here. Um, so yeah,
00:32:42 Corey, we, you know, had Fabio there do his petition, and then they get the signatures.
00:32:49 You know, good.
00:32:49 That's a big task.
00:32:51 Good to accomplish.
00:32:51 So credit where it's due.
00:32:55 But credit where it's also due, where they handed this thing in and realized, oh, my God, this will trigger an independence referendum.
00:33:01 What do you mean?
00:33:03 A citizens-initiated referendum will actually generate a referendum.
00:33:06 So they essentially kiboshed their own thing after handing it, and all they managed to do was waste their own time and effort.
00:33:12 But now we've got, now it's the opportunity of the pro-independence side, organized by the Alberta Prosperity Project here.
00:33:19 And they just kind of kicked off the sign now.
00:33:22 Yeah, so I mean, to give a little more background, it looks like there was a bit of a battle between the government and the electoral officer, too.
00:33:27 I don't think the electoral officer was really keen on the idea of an independence referendum.
00:33:30 He used the past legislation, tossed it to a judge.
00:33:34 Right when the judge ruled, saying they couldn't hold such a referendum, they put out Bill 14, said, okay, fine, we're changing the legislation.
00:33:41 and the electoral officer actually threw up his hands.
00:33:43 I was talking to Mitch Sylvester.
00:33:45 It really caught them by surprise.
00:33:47 He said, fine, here it goes.
00:33:48 It's approved.
00:33:49 January 2nd, you can start getting your stuff together.
00:33:53 So they're scrambling like, holy cow,
00:33:54 we were thinking it's going to be another month
00:33:56 or everything else is so small.
00:33:58 So this is on the go.
00:33:59 So they got until what?
00:34:01 May 2nd?
00:34:01 May 6th, I believe.
00:34:03 May 6th.
00:34:03 So now the-
00:34:05 How many signatures?
00:34:06 177,000.
00:34:08 Realistically, you know some are going to be declined.
00:34:09 they have to get about over 200,000 if
00:34:11 it's going to be clearing the hurdles.
00:34:14 And their goal, I think, is to beat
00:34:15 Fabio and get maybe over 500,000.
00:34:17 We'll see. They've got four months to work on it.
00:34:20 But at least now that they've got
00:34:21 something to work on, they've got
00:34:23 their meetings, they've been holding them for months and
00:34:25 months and months, but now they're holding them.
00:34:27 And I was a guest speaker at one of them on
00:34:29 the weekend in Calgary. And
00:34:31 people probably saw those pictures on social media.
00:34:33 People, I've never seen anything like it. I mean, it was
00:34:35 full an hour before we were set to start speaking.
00:34:37 Where was it? He's a punny little place.
00:34:38 Queensland community center down in South Calgary.
00:34:42 So the hall was full almost an hour before we started speaking.
00:34:45 There was a guy, fire code.
00:34:46 We couldn't lay anybody else in.
00:34:47 So everybody else was going just to at least sign the petition.
00:34:50 And when we finished two hours later and I went outside, people were still
00:34:54 sneaking for blocks in the night.
00:34:57 And those are the pictures you're seeing in the snow and that's happening everywhere.
00:35:00 It's happening in smaller towns, Bicycle, Didsbury, everywhere these guys hold a
00:35:05 meeting. People are coming out and just overwhelming it. The eagerness to sign this
00:35:10 petition. I mean, this is the honeymoon phase. It's the first week, you know, it'll probably
00:35:15 cool down a bit, but there's really something unusual taking place. It caught them off guard,
00:35:21 caught me off guard. The fruits, I think, of all their work for months and months has finally
00:35:26 gotten there. They got something tangible to work on and the people are coming out. And the other
00:35:31 that's interesting was not only did thousands come out to sign the petition but of them hundreds
00:35:37 signed up to be volunteers for the campaign and uh we're in for a hell of a year that's all they
00:35:43 could say it's going to be something else uh yeah it's um and then then we'll have an actual
00:35:50 campaign i don't know when the vote will be held i mean uh governments like to hold them in the fall
00:35:55 you know americans have it in early november but their weather is a bit more forgiving for it so
00:35:59 our elections tend to be i i hate these things these things are always on like my birthday
00:36:03 it's like mid-october they pick and like so every second birthday i have all my political friends
00:36:10 can't uh can't be with me because it's a freaking election um uh so you know i'd say it's a good
00:36:15 bet we'd be looking at an october or november the fullest the good money is on this yeah yeah it's
00:36:20 uh i've been talking to some american contacts of mine and they're just shocked they're shocked
00:36:26 now they're on all under the delusion that like oh yeah this is albertans all clamoring to be the
00:36:30 51st state sorry guys it's not uh there's a few but it's it that's a pretty small fraction of
00:36:38 things of course if alberta did achieve independence would that be an option on the
00:36:42 menu to consider oh well yeah so later yeah yeah get back to me we got bigger things to do right
00:36:49 now um but it's uh it's happening almost certainly we're gonna have a vote on independence
00:36:56 in Alberta. The polls do not favor the yes side right now. If I was going to bet right now,
00:37:01 we'd probably get 40%, you know, after campaign, but campaigns matter. I mean,
00:37:09 you know, there's a lot of time to move that needle between now and October.
00:37:12 When the Quebec government called the referendum that it held in 1995,
00:37:15 independent support there was pretty comparable to where it is right here. Right now, it was
00:37:20 kind of mid thirties, you know, a significant minority, but not there yet. And they got all 0.95
00:37:24 the way up to 49.9 and you know if you ask the guys who were on the s side they think pretty
00:37:31 strongly the feds cheated and that we wouldn't put that past them and it wouldn't take a lot
00:37:35 of cheating to make the difference in that one uh campaigns matter i i think it's
00:37:41 who's going to lead who's going to lead the campaign for the independence party
00:37:44 right that's part of your side side because there's like four yeah like who's going to be
00:37:50 the chief spokesman for the for the independence group that's the one thing you're missing right
00:37:54 now yeah uh and it's not going to be jeff wrath or if it is you're going to fail uh you know they
00:38:00 they need to come up as does the other side who's going to be captain canada jason kenny wants a job
00:38:08 and daniel smith says she will not have the job she will sit so you talked about those two polls
00:38:14 derrick uh widely ranging numbers one had support as low as 17 which i didn't agree with the other
00:38:22 The other one was around 35%, which I think is probably more closer to the truth, but yeah, it's going to be a fun campaign.
00:38:28 Yeah, there is no Lucien Bouchard right now or personable person.
00:38:32 That is a missing factor, but there are some months.
00:38:34 I think the movement can get along until the end of this petitioning portion without having a distinguished individual sort of speaking for them, but there will need to be a focal point.
00:38:45 I really don't have a name jumping in mind.
00:38:48 No, well, and like in the Quebec case, you had the PQ and you had the PQ providing a pool of politicians who are experienced in this kind of thing.
00:38:58 This is a naturally political position, somewhat political experience.
00:39:03 The federal conservative, how do you be a member of the federal conservative party of Canada and then also lead an independence referendum?
00:39:10 But that's pretty hard to swear.
00:39:11 The United Conservative Party, I mean, it's a little less hard, but it's not explicitly an independence party.
00:39:17 even if a clear majority of its members support independence and its voters support independence.
00:39:22 So we lack these natural pools from which a natural leader can emerge,
00:39:27 the way you had with René Levesque or Perizot in the PQ, with Lucienne Bouchard in the BQ.
00:39:33 I don't know. Where does this leader come from?
00:39:38 Yes, but I don't have an answer.
00:39:40 That is the question of the moment.
00:39:43 If I had to go out on a limb, I wouldn't name any names,
00:39:46 But I would be looking for among people who have not had anything public to say yet, but who have a lot of money and an interest in the outcome.
00:39:56 And they will arrive and they will be the promised leader for a period of the year, you know, when it matters.
00:40:05 But again, it could be anybody we've heard of.
00:40:07 It could be very fractious, right?
00:40:08 Because you could have a lot of the independent supporters say, well, I don't really like that person.
00:40:12 There's no structure.
00:40:13 Are you going to have a leadership?
00:40:15 need to go leadership for a strong leadership convention sure it's all uncharted ground we've
00:40:21 never had a referendum in alberta before either so you know it's yeah this could blow up disastrously
00:40:26 or somebody might arise that we never anticipated and this could snowball is that larry heather oh
00:40:33 that is that's what we're talking about is somebody coming out of nowhere and reaping
00:40:39 a harvest to walk all the other people
00:40:41 He's not the leader we deserve, but he's the
00:40:43 hero we need
00:40:44 Harry Leather, that was still the best Twitter account
00:40:47 In his shift life, that was a
00:40:49 great parody account
00:40:51 I think that's the big issue
00:40:53 Jeff Rath
00:40:55 seems more intent on fighting with other
00:40:57 people that he agrees with on 99.9%
00:41:00 of issues
00:41:01 He makes me look
00:41:03 agreeable for crying out loud
00:41:04 He really does, you know, you play a crankball
00:41:07 on TV in real life, you're actually
00:41:09 fairly agreeable.
00:41:11 Their cuss is...
00:41:12 Yeah, you do have a stick as... 1.00
00:41:14 We all play assholes on T. 0.99
00:41:17 Oh, like, Corey. 0.99
00:41:18 Nigel's actually a nice guy. But,
00:41:20 you know, the independence
00:41:22 move has always been notoriously
00:41:25 fractious. That's why there's, like, four
00:41:26 independence parties. They're independence
00:41:29 minded in more than
00:41:31 one sense.
00:41:33 But, I mean, we've
00:41:35 just kind of got...
00:41:37 The cranks will never take it back
00:41:39 seat but like they they really you could you can tell for who this is genuinely about the movement
00:41:45 or and and then for those who it's like this is an opportunity to finally be listened to for once
00:41:50 in your life and uh there's a lot of ego in there um uh you know i'll i'll i'd wrap with this uh
00:41:58 jason kenney i think uh monday you know was leading him like uh here's two guys who disagree
00:42:04 on you know the status of first nations treaties after independence these guys are internally 0.98
00:42:08 incoherent a bunch of idiots and yeah to which i responded it's like yes there is internal 0.99
00:42:16 disagreement on issues as there has been in every single political coalition that has ever existed 1.00
00:42:20 in the history of the world your side the federalist side you share a side with thomas
00:42:26 lukasik you share a side with rachel notley with justin trudeau nenshi you tell me you guys don't
00:42:34 have internal contradictions uh you know so but for some reason that gets kind of paved over it's
00:42:40 it's it's that scene is more natural of of course the federalists disagree about everything and
00:42:45 that's normal but it's uh the you know the nationalists uh if they disagree on some vague
00:42:51 point of case law about the status of native treaties post-independence oh then everything's
00:42:57 chaos yeah you know if the people who want the united canada
00:43:01 want to start playing the game smartly they should get people like senator
00:43:07 pulls paula simons to just back off a little bit what she said what did you 0.99
00:43:17 have here dave in a few breaths she painted the whole alberta independence 1.00
00:43:22 movies there's xenophobic racist misogynist anti-woman transphobic and homophobic she 0.95
00:43:29 built the whole bingo sounds like cory didn't you know i mean that's just a list of my friends 0.98
00:43:33 i can't even pronounce this this is the you you go around criticizing alberta and alberta people
00:43:42 there's all of those things the reaction is not going to be oh shucks i guess you're right
00:43:46 it's going to be who the hell are you well she's mimicking uh trudeau here says you know 1.00
00:43:50 they're racists they're sexists they're uh they deny the science so you're not winning people 0.94
00:43:56 over you're not absolutely so also she's living in a world where these words used to have power
00:44:03 these words have lost their power now you can call me any ism or is in the world
00:44:07 i don't even deny it anymore because to deny it is to still give it power you just say i don't care
00:44:13 and we don't care people are sick of this that's absolutely right yeah okay that was
00:44:20 a fun one to wrap on i guess uh all right uh now that you've read off uh cory's resume
00:44:27 are you ruling yourself out oh absolutely not a chance
00:44:32 not where i'm looking no he's this bengali character in the in the background guy
00:44:37 showing the controlling the strings okay uh let's give our first parting shot to dave since
00:44:42 they've actually never really had a parting shot because that's kind of a newer feature
00:44:45 on the plane plane it is uh my parting shot will be on ambassador uh sears he was the final
00:44:53 ambassador canada had to afghanistan and he cowardly fled uh cabul in a half empty plane
00:45:01 uh leaving hundreds and hundreds of canadians behind uh he has finally admitted after several
00:45:07 years that it wasn't his best moment it's uh our own captain of the cost of concordia exactly
00:45:13 all right quite real quick with that uh for people who know cartoons scott adams who used
00:45:18 to do dilbert passed away from prostate cancer a couple of days ago but who i'm shooting at
00:45:23 wasn't him those cartoon was great uh was the associated press who put out the notice of it
00:45:28 said scott adams of dilbert died by the way right in the headline he was cancelled and shut down
00:45:34 because he'd said racist things on x you couldn't even just announce the man passed without carrying
00:45:40 on posthumously your cancel culture because he said something uh off color on x oh i thought
00:45:46 they meant it as a compliment yeah well there you go so maybe it is it's certainly powerless against
00:45:50 mr adams now anyways uh either way to the person who wrote the headline go to hell yeah so dave i 0.77
00:45:58 was actually uh going to comment on that story you had about 105 000 canadians went out of the
00:46:06 the country you receive medical treatment that's a lot of money just get in wherever they went
00:46:13 there's a lot of money and then they're paying for treatment we so i i love ralph klein but ralph
00:46:20 klein so blew it 25 years ago with bill 11 instead of banning private medicine in alberta they should
00:46:27 have said come to alberta build your hospital here we'll give you a business and people instead of
00:46:34 going to jordan or wherever or any of the other popular medical tourism sites we'd be coming to
00:46:41 alberta and albertans would be getting the benefit of it this whole thing that you know if you listen 0.80
00:46:46 to the radio right now the doctors and the nurses are panning the government all the time it's pure
00:46:51 rubbish but this should never have happened we should have built hospitals and told the world
00:46:56 come to us and charge the outsiders and make it cheaper for albertans ironically alberta leads 0.90
00:47:01 the country in the number of patients leaving
00:47:03 for the US. There you go.
00:47:06 Alright, well,
00:47:07 because we're out of time, and because I actually didn't
00:47:09 do my homework and actually get a parting
00:47:11 shot, we're going to
00:47:13 put a pen in it there. Right.
00:47:15 Dave, Nigel, Corey,
00:47:17 thank you very much, and John, run
00:47:19 in production, thank you. Thank all of you for
00:47:21 joining us today on The Pipeline. We're
00:47:23 very grateful for your support. That is,
00:47:25 unless you're a freeloader and you're not yet a
00:47:27 member of the Western Standard. It's only $10
00:47:29 a month or $100
00:47:31 a year for unlimited access to all
00:47:33 Western Standard content. Go to
00:47:35 westernstandard.news right now, click on subscribe,
00:47:38 join us, and support
00:47:39 the work we're doing, and get access
00:47:41 to all of it so you can stay up to date.
00:47:43 Thank you very much for joining us today, and God
00:47:45 bless.
00:48:01 You