Western Standard - April 20, 2025


Let's face it, nobody knows how to deal with Trump

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Saying the unsayable about coal... it's still the way to go POILIEVRE on equalization payments to Quebec

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

166.47

Word count

3,677

Sentence count

179

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Peter Coleman, President of the National Citizens Coalition, joins me on the show to talk about the upcoming Canadian election, and why he thinks PM Justin Trudeau would make a great Prime Minister. We also discuss the impact of the French debate, and whether or not there is more to Mark Carney than meets the ear.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 China's killing our canola.
00:00:05 $45 billion gone.
00:00:08 Western farmers bleed.
00:00:10 Mark Carney?
00:00:12 Silent.
00:00:14 Made millions off Beijing's dime.
00:00:17 He won't fight.
00:00:18 He's Beijing's banker, not our prime minister.
00:00:30 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:51 I am Nigel Hannaford, and it is Saturday, April 19th, for this special edition, and
00:00:58 my guest today is Peter Coleman, President of the National Citizens Coalition. Welcome to the show,
00:01:05 Peter. Thanks for having me on, Nigel. Well, you're very welcome. You've got Stephen Harper's
00:01:09 old job from 25 years ago. Are you contemplating making a switch into politics one of these days?
00:01:15 I'm not as capable as Harper is. It's been fun to be around him and get to know him as a person,
00:01:21 and I think the country would be much better served if we had Harper back around the country 0.99
00:01:25 now than what we have going on well i i think you sound here loud amens from across the country with
00:01:32 that first however a word from our sponsors this episode of had afford is sponsored by new world
00:01:38 precious metals based right here in calgary years of inflationary money printing and rising debt
00:01:44 have decimated the savings of the average canadian gold and silver are the only currencies that have
00:01:49 held their value for thousands of years last year saw 30 gains new world precious metals
00:01:55 offers unique platforms to help grow and protect your hard-earned wealth with gold and silver.
00:02:03 Check them out at newworldpm.com. Peter, in a series of columns you have recently published
00:02:12 in the Western Standard, you have argued that the stakes in this election are very high. I think
00:02:18 you're speaking for everybody when you say that, but you've actually said the future of the country
00:02:23 as we know it, is at stake. And as far as Mr. Carney is concerned, there's more to him than
00:02:30 meets the ear. He's holding something back. But mercifully, you also think the polls are wrong.
00:02:38 I want to talk to you about all of that. But let's start first with Pierre Polyev.
00:02:43 You heard him at the French debate last night. How did he do?
00:02:48 I think he was pretty measured. I thought he did a pretty good job. I think the thing for
00:02:51 Pauliev is he has to appeal across
00:02:53 broad sectors.
00:02:55 The old days of the angry Pierre
00:02:57 isn't going to fly, especially amongst
00:02:59 women. I thought he was pretty
00:03:01 calm in the debate. What I found striking,
00:03:04 Nigel, was he looked directly
00:03:06 at Carney several times in the debate.
00:03:08 Carney wouldn't even look at Pauliev.
00:03:10 The dislike there
00:03:11 is palpable, and I don't
00:03:13 think Carney likes being challenged by anybody.
00:03:16 He's proven that with the media and questions he doesn't
00:03:18 like, and I thought Pierre was good.
00:03:19 I think he got the cost of the agenda that Canada deserves better.
00:03:23 We have all the resources in the world, Nigel, and we should be shipping them to world markets and being a lot more prosperous than they are.
00:03:29 But Carney's agenda is not to get the oil out of the ground or natural gas shift.
00:03:34 And if he says different, he tries to come across as different depending on where he's speaking.
00:03:39 He's not a guy that wants to develop our resources.
00:03:43 It's as simple as that.
00:03:44 Yes.
00:03:46 That's an interesting observation you make about body language.
00:03:49 And clearly, when somebody won't look at you, there's something going on there.
00:03:59 Would you interpret that as contempt or just not wanting to, you know, feeling a little uneasy and therefore not wanting to confront your accuser?
00:04:13 My dad used to say to me, Nigel, treat your enemies with respect because it drives them crazy.
00:04:17 I thought that Paulie was respectful towards Carney.
00:04:22 I don't think Carney's been used to in his jobs at the government of the Bank of England and Bank of Canada
00:04:26 of having people second-guess him.
00:04:28 He thinks he's the smartest guy in the room wherever he goes.
00:04:32 I think he has a personality of a doormat, to be honest.
00:04:35 And I don't think he is the smartest guy in the room.
00:04:38 When he was governor of the Bank of England, his reviews there when he left were not fantastic.
00:04:45 And I think it's just a disdain for people that challenge him because he's lived in a world where everybody's told him how great he is.
00:04:51 And I don't think he personally is.
00:04:54 Well, you may be right.
00:04:56 Certainly, Prime Minister Liz Truss of Great Britain wrote a sort of an open letter to Canadians saying,
00:05:02 what are you thinking, even considering making Mr. Carney prime minister?
00:05:07 He didn't do us any good here in Great Britain.
00:05:10 That, of course, is a partisan position.
00:05:12 and uh but um i'm beginning to wonder if she's right um well how about then mr carney at the
00:05:21 debate his french is supposed to be not very good this was a french language debate but he went into
00:05:28 it um how did he come out of it i think he got okay but you know when debates as well as i do
00:05:35 nagel is always using a sound bite that comes out of it you can think back to john turner and
00:05:39 And Brian Maroney saying, you had an option, sir.
00:05:42 And last night when he said, I just got here, I thought was telling.
00:05:47 He's been an economic advisor for Trudeau for, what, five years?
00:05:51 Yeah.
00:05:52 Trying to sort of whitewash everything the Liberals have done for the last 10 years.
00:05:55 And as if it's not his problem, his fault.
00:05:57 Well, as Paul Yev said, he has the same cabinet, the same people, the same ideas, the same agenda.
00:06:03 and i think he just thinks he can just run by i'm the greatest guy coming forward and vote for me
00:06:09 without his records no different his records no better not i didn't think you know of course when
00:06:14 you're prime minister you take the shots from everybody because that's their job and you've
00:06:19 got to defend the incoming fire but uh i didn't think carney was great i thought singh was the
00:06:24 worst by far of all the debaters though well he yes he was but then with all due respect to him
00:06:32 as an individual as a politician he no longer counts his chance was six months ago if he had
00:06:38 decided to drop the liberals at that point he might have been might have been looking here
00:06:43 at a chance of becoming the leader of the opposition but as it is i gather from the polls
00:06:49 that he'll be lucky to hold his own seat but then you actually are not a big believer in the polls
00:06:55 that show mr carney ahead of mr poilier why would that be peter i think what you're seeing now is
00:07:02 As the younger generation, I conclude that people sort of 45 and under, and the 35-year-old
00:07:09 group that don't see a future as far as being able to afford a house, cost of living so
00:07:14 high, I think the polls are undersampling those people and their desire to get out and
00:07:19 vote.
00:07:20 I think they're going to vote in droves and surprise people.
00:07:24 The conservatives are strongly ahead in that category.
00:07:27 They're behind with the boomers for some reason. 1.00
00:07:30 But you're seeing more and more ads now, Nigel, online saying young kids going to their parents and saying, and it's ads we've taken forward too, is you need to give your kids a better future.
00:07:41 And a better future is not 10 more years of the same.
00:07:43 Your kids deserve a responsible government like we had when Stephen Harper was prime minister.
00:07:49 And to be honest, John Cretan, for a matter of fact, he was a decent prime minister in a lot of regards compared to what the Liberal Party is now.
00:07:56 So I think the younger generation is going to go out and vote in numbers that haven't been seen before.
00:08:01 And I think the polls that show that are not being represented as properly in the polling and the percentage that are showing right now.
00:08:10 Well, that's an interesting proposition.
00:08:14 Now, I've also heard it suggested that conservatives are less likely to respond to a pollster.
00:08:22 Either they just resent the intrusion and don't even pick up the phone, or else they think my ideas are my own and you don't have a right to ask, and that there's a bias that would tend to present against conservatives in polls for those kinds of reasons.
00:08:45 Have you any reason to think that the polls are skewed like that?
00:08:51 I think there's a lot of quiet conservatives there.
00:08:53 I mean, if you look at what's going on here in Ontario, I mean, it's ironic.
00:08:57 Every sign you see damaged, you know, in the GTA, the 905, they're always conservative signs.
00:09:04 They're always ones that are taken down.
00:09:05 I think a lot of people that are going to vote conservative are reluctant to put signs up and do that because they don't want to be harassed and bothered by that.
00:09:14 And I think that's the same with, to your point, Nigel, the polling is, how are they getting at these younger people under 45?
00:09:20 that really don't spend any time on a, they don't have a landline.
00:09:24 I know the pollsters try and get through online polling, which isn't very accurate,
00:09:29 landlines, cell phones, but I think that that generation that's voting for the Conservatives now, 0.99
00:09:34 which used to be liberal in 2015, to be honest, are much tougher to reach.
00:09:38 They're busy, they're working, and as you said, they have no interest in talking to pollsters.
00:09:42 Yes. They also tend to draw their information from different sources than the older generation, which, according to our discussion just now, does answer the polls.
00:09:58 They tend to take their information from social media, Twitter, Facebook, online newspapers such as the Western Standard here, whereas if I could compose a stereotype of the older voter, I'm thinking of a 75-year-old grandmother who watches the CBC, doesn't get a newspaper anymore, but really all she knows about what is going on is from the CBC.
00:10:28 as opposed to her granddaughter or her grandson
00:10:32 who is constantly on the phone scrolling through to see what there is,
00:10:38 they would tend to come to different conclusions.
00:10:41 And the one, the grandmother, is more likely to pick up the phone 0.79
00:10:44 and talk to the pollster, and the younger person wouldn't do that,
00:10:48 but they would get out and vote because they're mad
00:10:50 because they don't have a job or they do have a job
00:10:53 and they can't buy a house and all the rage that you were talking about there.
00:10:58 So when we're talking about the accuracy of the polls,
00:11:01 I think your position is we can't really trust them.
00:11:05 Well, look, I think your stereotype of the older voter is exactly right. 0.99
00:11:09 That's why people should listen like you and the Western Standard, Nigel,
00:11:13 because CBC has obviously a clear bias, as most of the legacy media does.
00:11:19 The online media tends to, as much as CBC people hate it,
00:11:23 the online media tends to present the facts.
00:11:25 if you research enough on all sides of the conversation,
00:11:29 CBC never does and never will.
00:11:31 So if your news comes from the Globe and Mail or CBC
00:11:35 and not great organizations like Western Standard,
00:11:40 you're going to get a biased view
00:11:41 and think you should be voting liberal.
00:11:42 I think that's as clearly the way it is.
00:11:43 But as you said, the grandkids, the 75-year-old,
00:11:49 they're getting the news from a different source.
00:11:51 There's a lot less bias.
00:11:52 They can see a lot more options is what's really gone.
00:11:54 And they're making informed decisions based on hard facts instead of propaganda from CBC, because that's all CBC TV is.
00:12:02 So, OK, well, I'm going to form my own opinions on the basis of the size of the rallies.
00:12:08 Let's move on, Peter. Let's talk about who is better to deal with Trump.
00:12:15 I mean, this phrase, dealing with Trump, I think is a bit presumptuous for Canadians because we don't really have an awfully strong hand.
00:12:22 and my own view is that the federal government of Canada
00:12:26 is basically going to accept whatever the United States says
00:12:31 as soon after the election is over as it can
00:12:35 because it doesn't really have any strong options.
00:12:40 But maybe you think something different.
00:12:43 How do you deal with President Trump?
00:12:47 And who is best to do it?
00:12:49 Pollyev?
00:12:49 Nigel, when you figure that out, it's like tacking Jell-O to a wall and see if you can stick.
00:12:56 I'm not convinced anybody can deal with Donald Trump necessarily, but the notion that Carney's the right guy, a global elitist who doesn't believe in developing resources, who doesn't believe in getting products to market, who doesn't believe in the military to any strength, doesn't believe in NATO, he believes in net zero, carbon zero, no gas running cars.
00:13:19 Does anybody seriously think that's the dynamic that Donald Trump would enjoy as far as having to deal with on a business level?
00:13:25 I think he'd have a much greater respect with Paulieff.
00:13:28 I mean, people call him the mini-Trump, and I just find that laughable.
00:13:33 There's only one Trump.
00:13:35 There never will be another Trump in politics.
00:13:37 And I think Paulieff is capable of dealing with Trump because he knows we have to get up off the mats and develop our resources and be energy independent.
00:13:46 And if we'd done what we should have done 10 years ago, starting 10 years ago, Nigel, we'd have a much stronger hand, to your point, than we have right now.
00:13:54 But we need to get going, and hopefully the people in Canada realize that we live in the greatest country in the world with all the resources that the world wants.
00:14:03 But our government refuses to let them get the marketplace.
00:14:07 And it's a crime how badly our finances have been dealt with, but it also can be turned around.
00:14:14 Yes, I know it takes time, but I think Collier is much better for that because it's a different look.
00:14:19 It's a different opportunity, and it's a much clearer set of eyes with what our real problems are than what Mark Carney's saying.
00:14:26 And I think Carney's a wolf in sheep's clothing.
00:14:28 I think he's saying stuff just to try and get himself elected.
00:14:31 And he has no intention, in my view, of developing resources to things that matter to Canadians.
00:14:35 Now, why do you say that?
00:14:37 He said that he's in favor of developing resources.
00:14:39 resources. He has said that he wants Canada to be an energy
00:14:44 superpower. He has said that he wants to see pipelines built
00:14:48 and developed. Are you suggesting
00:14:52 that he's being less than frank with us? Yeah, I think he is.
00:14:56 I think he says one thing when he's out in western Canada, one thing to Quebec. I don't think he's
00:15:00 unequivocally taken any kind of stance that would try
00:15:04 and force the province of Quebec to develop resources for energy
00:15:08 going up to the east coast and i really don't think i think he's trying to say what he thinks
00:15:14 he could say but i i think he's inconsistent in his view i think pauliev is very very clear
00:15:18 i think carney's trying to appear to be somebody that cares about developing resources but deep
00:15:25 down it's not in his dna and you tend to judge people nigel by what they've done not what they've 0.92
00:15:32 said and nothing made nothing from where i sit leads me to believe that carney really would do
00:15:39 a decent job of developing our resources i just don't well that's an interesting point what is
00:15:43 it that he's done that you're judging him on well nothing because if he's the economic advisor for
00:15:50 truda for the last five years why aren't we further along these conversations we had we've
00:15:54 had germany we've had japan we've the country's coming to us begging for a liquid natural gas
00:15:59 resource in developing that all he's done is overseen which he did with his bank of governor
00:16:04 bank of england is print money it's create inflation there's been zero fiscal responsibility
00:16:11 at all it hasn't hasn't got any better it's gotten worse the old you know budgets will balance himself
00:16:16 from trudeau but carney's been carney's been driving the getaway cartoon eyes so he hasn't
00:16:20 been doing anything about it in background scenes and he wants to say i just got here it's not me 0.79
00:16:25 well that's a bunch of crap he's been involved with this for years and it's just so i to count
00:16:32 me as a skeptic as far as believing carney will do what he's supposed to do as far as that 0.83
00:16:38 okay now you you're writing a series of articles for us during the election campaign
00:16:46 i mentioned three of them before you're working on another one right now where are you as you draw
00:16:55 your thoughts together from this election campaign i mean we're what uh 11 days away from
00:17:01 the vote as we speak nine days away from uh as we broadcast um peter you have uh you've got a
00:17:11 limited amount of time to get your message across what is in one sentence what is the message that
00:17:19 the National Citizens Coalition wants to drive home as we head for the boat.
00:17:25 We can't afford 10 more years of the same.
00:17:29 I'm sorry, say that again?
00:17:30 We can't afford 10 more years of the same policies. We need a different look and a different vision.
00:17:36 Yeah. Well, that certainly is here at the Western Standard. That would be precisely what we would
00:17:44 say. I think it's one of the astonishing things, maybe you can comment on this, that people who
00:17:52 don't want change didn't want change 10 years ago either. Now they have got it and they have
00:18:00 accepted it. Is there something about the Canadian voter who just doesn't care to
00:18:09 take a strong position on anything some people do but enough don't let you can just drift through
00:18:17 constantly accepting the status quo i think there's a lot of progressive voters in this
00:18:24 country that don't understand if you want to take care of the poor you have to create wealth
00:18:30 i mean we all see in our cities people they're living on the street that are that have issues
00:18:36 with drugs. And it's really hard to watch that kind of thing, realizing we deserve so much better
00:18:42 than we have right now. But there is a large segment of the population, unfortunately, too
00:18:47 large in my view, that thinks the government can just take care of them and take care of their
00:18:52 well-being and take care of their ability to get along and go forward in life. And there's a lot
00:18:58 better options if we can get the economy growing and humming. Everybody can be clearly better off
00:19:04 than we are right now, and that's the concern.
00:19:06 Do people say, well, you know, Poliev scares me.
00:19:10 They can't tell you why he scares me.
00:19:13 I think Carney's far scarier than Poliev
00:19:15 on any measurable statistic.
00:19:19 And you can certainly explain why.
00:19:22 You know, in one of your columns recently,
00:19:24 you said that you actually feared for the country as we know it.
00:19:30 The future of the country as we know it is at stake.
00:19:34 can you show me the road to survival?
00:19:40 Can you show me what it is that you fear
00:19:42 that could break the country up?
00:19:46 I think the liberals for 10 years
00:19:48 have pitted people against people.
00:19:51 You living out West, Nigel, region against region,
00:19:53 I think they treated the West disgracefully.
00:19:56 When Alberta's an economic engine,
00:19:58 but this country, they can't develop their resources,
00:20:00 And all they do is get fought by a radical environmental minister who doesn't seem to care about anything other than, you know, climate change.
00:20:09 When Canada's 1.6% of the world's greenhouse gases, if we could sell off our liquefied natural gas, for example, to China and India, we would take care of all that.
00:20:18 And Canada's actually probably not contributing at all to greenhouse gases because we're carbon sink because of our trees.
00:20:23 And if we can't develop our resources and get product to market, I think the people out west are going to be incredibly restless if the liberals get brought back in, heaven forbid, with any kind of mandate, because I don't think many people that are intelligent really believe that Carney's going to develop the resources.
00:20:42 So if we can't develop the resources and we keep in an economic environment and an economic downturn, we have the lowest GDP growth, the G7 by far.
00:20:51 We're not creating jobs. If we're creating jobs or government jobs, that's no future for our kids. 0.52
00:20:57 That's no future for the next generation. Kids are going to leave. Businesses are going to leave. 0.99
00:21:02 No economic investment is going to come from foreign sources.
00:21:05 And that's not going to be a good recipe to try and keep this country whole as it is right now.
00:21:10 Well, those are sad and sobering words
00:21:15 Peter, we are out of time
00:21:17 We look forward to publishing you again next week
00:21:20 But for now, we've got to say goodbye
00:21:23 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford
00:21:27 And thank you to Peter Coleman of the National Citizens Coalition
00:21:31 For joining us today
00:21:33 Thank you, Nigel
00:21:34 You're welcome
00:21:36 what does success mean to you peace of mind financial freedom generational wealth what do
00:21:45 you see in your future investing in gold and silver can help you get there through our trading
00:21:51 partners new world precious metals offer safe affordable secure international accounts to help
00:21:57 you meet your unique financial goals connect with one of our experienced team members invest in gold
00:22:03 and silver today.