Western Standard - September 12, 2024


Liberal Retreat: Mark Carney's role in the 'new' job

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Giant cat kills family's feline, tries to get in their house west of Calgary Trudeau complains Conservatives 'called their friend, Elon Musk,' to build cheaper internet solution

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

185.29

Word count

8,986

Sentence count

531

Harmful content

Misogyny

22

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

12

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, Senior Columnist Corey Morgan Morgan is joined by James Finkbiner and Editor-in-Chief of the Western Standard, Jen Hudson, to discuss all things Canadian politics. Topics covered include: - The Liberal Party's Leadership Retreat - Trudeau's leadership challenge - Why the Liberals need a new leader - Should the Prime Minister resign? - Where does the party go from here?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening. Welcome to the pipeline. My name is Corey Morgan. I'm a senior columnist with
00:00:27 western standard this is our weekly panel show usually there's other people in a different lineup
00:00:33 you always get stuck with me i always show up i really don't have much of a life but other people
00:00:37 are doing other things and different things which is fine because we can diversify our voices this
00:00:41 time around we've got a lot of subjects to cover so i'm going to start on the end and introducing
00:00:45 james finkbiner you've been on shows before i don't think you've been on the pipeline yet have
00:00:48 you i i have been on the pipeline a couple of times but not uh actually not since the first
00:00:53 week i was back um june of last year okay well yeah it's been been over a well a year and a
00:00:59 half now quite a while well welcome back thank you we got jen hudson again this is the first
00:01:05 pipeline experience for you this time okay so there in general the pipeline has gotten a lot
00:01:10 prettier on that end of things i'm still here to hold up the ugly old guy uh corner for things so
00:01:15 we got the b team today yeah happy to help no this is gonna be good i'm looking forward to it so
00:01:22 Let's jump into the subjects and the issues. We've got federal politics to kick things off here.
00:01:29 Everybody's favorite, Justin Trudeau. It's an annual thing. They have their caucus retreat.
00:01:36 All the members probably get ready to take on the new year of politics.
00:01:41 They're in dire straits. I mean, this is a party in a heck of a lot of trouble.
00:01:47 I'll start with you, Jen, actually. I'll start in the middle. What did you see for reports
00:01:50 coming out of this? I mean, they were pretty tight. I didn't see any bombshells really coming
00:01:54 out of this meeting, this retreat. Not so far, only some commentary going into it. So the liberals
00:01:59 have faced a litany of challenges from the by-election loss in Toronto, the chief of staff,
00:02:07 or the national campaign director stepping down, not to mention the dissolution of the coalition
00:02:12 government with the NDP. So Trudeau has been facing a lot of obstacles. And what commentary
00:02:18 is saying is that the Prime Minister should be facing the whole rigmarole from his caucus.
00:02:26 However, probably that's not going to happen. They seem to be sidestepping it and very few
00:02:32 are willing to actually confront the Prime Minister and make any tangible change within
00:02:39 the caucus. However, we did see the other day the Deputy Assistant Speaker of the House
00:02:45 saying that her constituents are, many of them are calling for Trudeau to resign, citing weak leadership.
00:02:51 So he's getting it from all sides.
00:02:54 Yeah, the whisper campaign is beginning, but do you think they're going to speak up?
00:02:58 No.
00:02:59 Even the MP that you're talking about, she comes out, she speaks up, and she goes,
00:03:02 but the prime minister still has my support.
00:03:05 Are you kidding? 0.99
00:03:07 So you're just, all of your constituents, you're just going to slap them in the face,
00:03:11 and they want him gone, and you're just going to say, oh, no, I still support him.
00:03:15 I don't know. The Liberal Party operates like a mafia. And the lower you are on the food chain,
00:03:23 the less likely you are to speak out because you will have no chance of promotion. You will lose
00:03:27 your committee assignments and your career is basically over. You're just decoration at that
00:03:32 point. You're not getting anything done. And I just don't see any of them actually making the move
00:03:37 to address it. You know, the Leger poll that came out, I think it came out yesterday.
00:03:44 and it is like massive like the conservatives are at 45 percent like i i think the seat percent
00:03:50 projection and i'm don't quote me on this please i i think it was 263 that is a massive super
00:03:58 majority like i i think brian mulrooney was the last one that had a majority that big
00:04:02 and there's two big by-elections on monday and i think we will find out monday because that is
00:04:09 when parliament returns how much longer trudeau is going to last because if they lose those two
00:04:14 by-elections especially the one in montreal that has been a liberal seat i think since confederation
00:04:19 how can he remain the leader and it's a three-way race right now between the bloc the ndp and the
00:04:24 liberals in that in that riding so i don't know i i can't see anyone especially in his cabinet
00:04:31 standing up to him and making a move and i don't have faith that any of the other mps will either
00:04:36 But the self-serving, I mean, I'm cynical with liberals.
00:04:39 You know, a lot of them, when the push finally comes to shove, you think they want to protect their own skin.
00:04:45 I mean, if this party is facing certain obliteration in the next election, eventually some of these MPs would have to say, I've got nothing to lose.
00:04:54 You know, I mean, oh, kick me off the committee for the next six months.
00:04:57 Big deal.
00:04:58 I've got to speak up.
00:04:59 I mean, maybe I've got a 10% chance of salvaging my seat if I can show myself as having a backbone and calling out that this weak, directionless prime minister, but they don't do it.
00:05:10 You would think. And so it would seem like if someone did stand up and have a kind of backbone
00:05:17 in the Liberal caucus to say, hey, we still as Liberals, and again, I'm playing devil's advocate
00:05:24 from the other side. We're still Liberals. We have these kinds of values. Well, maybe we can
00:05:29 implement them if we didn't have this weak leader who is just riddled with scandal. However, we
00:05:34 don't see this. We see almost uniformly the Liberal MPs doubling down, especially the top-tier ones,
00:05:41 like Gilboa, Freeland, they are lockstep with Trudeau, and you don't see any kind of derision
00:05:50 from there, even though it would be warranted. So we just see the propping up of the Prime Minister,
00:05:56 and with the Bloc Québécois leader stepping into Jagmeet Singh's empty bed, so to speak,
00:06:03 with the coalition government, or attempting to anyways, he'll come right out and say,
00:06:09 well, we don't support the Prime Minister, and we don't want to elongate his reign any more than
00:06:16 possible. However, if it's in Quebec interest, then we'll make these certain concessions and
00:06:21 prop him up just like Jagmeet Singh did. Well, yeah, going further to that, then,
00:06:25 you know, James, like the politics that are going on now, I mean, part of Singh was, he's smart
00:06:29 enough to know this is the closest he's ever going to get to power, holding the balance of
00:06:32 power in a minority government is the NDP dream. They're never going to win government. But if you
00:06:36 can really pull the levers with these guys, and he got a lot out of them. He got the dental plan.
00:06:41 He got the pharma care and lunches for kids and just a giant NDP style intrusive government.
00:06:49 But now we could be handing off the partnership to somebody even more dangerous.
00:06:53 Blanchett's smarter than saying. Oh, way smarter. Way smarter. He makes no bones of what he's about.
00:06:58 No. Quebec first, Quebec only. And he says it all the time. But
00:07:02 is that a bad thing is that a bad thing for alberta well first because no because well
00:07:08 true that too but whatever he gives to the block for quebec alberta is going to be standing there
00:07:16 going and and premier smith will be like me too we want the exact same thing and what leg will
00:07:22 they have to stand on and and then that will give alberta different legal mechanisms to say look
00:07:27 you're giving this to Quebec, you're going to give it to us the exact same way. And I think
00:07:32 that there's going to be a big coalition of premiers who are also going to say, well,
00:07:37 if Quebec's getting it, we're going to get it too. So, you know, it might give some of the
00:07:41 provinces more leverage. You know, I don't have any sort of hope that Trudeau would do the right
00:07:46 thing and give Quebec one thing and give Alberta something completely different. We've seen that
00:07:51 with home heating oil and where his vote base is. But like the Leger poll has them completely wiped
00:07:56 out on the east coast so the home eating oil did no favors for him in the end anyways
00:08:00 and i don't know i i i it's going to be interesting but how long is the bloc going to be willing to
00:08:08 do that but that's the other thing this poll is showing the bloc is going to be the official
00:08:13 opposition well they aren't getting anything as the official opposition they are going to oppose
00:08:18 everything that Prime Minister Pierre Polyev is going to do. So, you know, he's going to want to
00:08:27 hang on with this minority government and try to get all he can out of Trudeau. So we may get all
00:08:31 the way to the fall of 2025 now if the bloc decide to prop him up. Whereas I like to pedantically
00:08:36 keep reminding people constitutionally, Justin could stretch it out until the fall of 2026.
00:08:42 I know that gives chills to people, but the set election date is just legislation. They can
00:08:48 always repeal that and stretch it another year. I doubt it's going to go to that. But there doesn't
00:08:54 seem to be a sense of desperation on Trudeau's part. As I was mentioning on my own show earlier,
00:08:58 I would have expected from one of these retreats, whether the cabinet or the caucus,
00:09:02 some big announcements, some big changes, some indication they realize that they have to change
00:09:07 course. There's nothing. Melanie Jolie, in the most insane thing I've heard out of her in a while,
00:09:14 She says, what she's hearing at the doors is Canadians don't want an election.
00:09:21 They just want the Liberals to do the job.
00:09:24 Madame Jolie, it's been almost a decade.
00:09:27 It's quite clear you guys are incapable of doing the job.
00:09:31 There is no leadership.
00:09:32 You are a rudderless ship.
00:09:33 You are running around and undoing your bad policies in one place and putting worse policies in the other place.
00:09:39 Nobody knows the direction of your government.
00:09:42 We want an election.
00:09:43 All of the polls are unanimous across the country.
00:09:47 We want an election.
00:09:48 We want an election now. 1.00
00:09:49 Yeah, well, Jolie's talents, she's not an intellectual. 0.61
00:09:54 So, you know, whatever maintains her cabinet position is a lot of speculation,
00:09:57 but it hasn't been her policy depth or ability to listen to what Canadians want in general.
00:10:02 But she seems to be pretty secure in cabinet no matter what seems to happen outside. 0.87
00:10:06 But, I mean, separately, besides me being a jerk today and employ things about Jolie,
00:10:10 hey, we've got somebody coming into the mix, not in cabinet, not in caucus, but who is smart, 0.95
00:10:15 who is frighteningly so, but is no less ideological. And that's Mark Carney. What
00:10:20 happened there? How has he suddenly surfaced? Right. So he seems to have just waltzed right
00:10:25 in. I remember about maybe winter of last year at the World Economic Forum events where he was
00:10:32 waltzing around there. And I started reading up on him then and saw that he did have a lot of
00:10:37 connection to globalists, and he has this global mindset. However, he has a long history with
00:10:43 liberal political figures, and so he stepped in as a kind of advisor, financial advisor.
00:10:50 Pierre Polyev this morning said that he's the phantom finance minister that's come in to
00:10:55 push Christian Friedland aside. Smart way to poke a little division into there,
00:10:59 because she's got to feel a little threatened on her flank with him popping in there.
00:11:02 Oh, but how about the insanity of the fact that they appointed someone who is involved on so many different businesses, not to a government position, but an advisor to the Liberal Party? And Western Standards Jared Jagger, he's at the convention in Nanaimo right now, and he actually talked to Stephen Gilboa and said, do you think there's a conflict of interest here?
00:11:25 Well, of course there is. He is on the World Economic Forum. He's the chair of Brookfield Investments. He's on the board of Stripe. So how can he, like these businesses are actively lobbying the governments in different ways. They have huge financial interests in government policy.
00:11:46 And then I believe it was the Globe and Mail is reporting now. It was the CPC's Michael Barrett last night that tweeted this out. The Globe and Mail is now reporting that Brookfield Investments is looking at moving their headquarters out of Toronto into New York.
00:12:02 So is that to move it so that it's no longer a Canadian company and it's not a conflict of interest?
00:12:07 But I mean, if he's the financial advisor to the Liberal Party and he's looking at moving one of his businesses out of the country,
00:12:13 what does that signal about our country?
00:12:15 What does that signal about his faith in the economy and the finances of the country?
00:12:21 What is he seeing that he's decided to make that decision?
00:12:24 So, yeah, it's interesting.
00:12:25 like Kearney has given himself that one separation from an electable role, but still close to the
00:12:31 liberal throne. He can be involved, he can be at the higher levels of the party, but he's
00:12:35 inoculated himself for the inevitable crash when they hit the polls. That's right. He's quite
00:12:41 positioned himself rather cleverly. So he's never been elected, yet he's right there whispering
00:12:46 into the prime minister's ear. And by juxtaposition, comparing Trudeau to Kearney, they're two very
00:12:53 different characters. And after nine years of Trudeau, the drama teacher who has just had
00:12:58 scandal after scandal, perhaps to some Canadians, liberal-leaning Canadians, having a figure like
00:13:04 Mark Carney, they might perceive him to be someone who's more level-headed, someone who is, and I'm
00:13:10 not saying I agree with this, but more trustworthy, more able to handle the books and things like this
00:13:15 just because he doesn't have a track record like Trudeau does. So there might be a certain advantage
00:13:21 for him swooping in like this in case he does position himself for the next election.
00:13:28 A lot of intrigue. I mean, this is a party that's swirling the drain, and people will realize it'll
00:13:33 still be a path to power the Liberals will get in at some time or another, whether it's one or
00:13:36 two or three election cycles, but they're going to come back. But that's a tough, long game to
00:13:40 play amongst a lot of sharks to be in position when the time gets up. And it'll be interesting
00:13:45 to see if Mark Carney is still there by the time this is done. Like, this is the former governor of
00:13:49 the Bank of Canada. And he gets a lot of credit for the Great Recession and keeping the Bank of
00:13:54 Canada stable through that. I personally don't give him all the credit. I think Harper deserves
00:13:58 more credit than that than he does. I think Obama pushed both Carney and Harper to spend more money
00:14:04 than we should have coming out of that recession. And that caused some issues there. But, you know,
00:14:09 he did a good enough job that the Bank of England, he went over there. But he's on all of these
00:14:14 boards he is making so much money why would you want to dive into politics unless you're going to
00:14:22 be the prime minister at this point but even then in in four years in six years in eight years
00:14:28 is that even going to still be something he wants or is he going to be looking at like retiring on
00:14:33 uh whatever private island uh what's his face uh the leader of the ppc uh maxine bernier where
00:14:40 he's building his beach front house. I don't know. Yeah. So it'll be interesting because
00:14:46 like if it's anything like last time, like, you know, there was that big, massive liberal wipe
00:14:52 out. Jack Layton's NDP came in. They were the official opposition. The liberals were
00:14:57 essentially extinct. You know, is Mark Carney then going to pick up the corpse of the liberal
00:15:03 party and revive it to put himself in the prime minister's chair? Or is he going to sit here,
00:15:09 Make some money off the party.
00:15:11 Whisper into the prime minister's ear.
00:15:12 Try to fix Freeland's disastrous budgets.
00:15:16 And when it all implodes, say, well, I tried to fix it, but, you know, it was just way too far gone.
00:15:22 It's going to be interesting to watch anyways.
00:15:24 But we'll switch to some more insane politics in a moment.
00:15:27 Actually, I've got to get a quick plug to the folks out there to remind them the reason we have these panels,
00:15:31 the reason we've got all these stories breaking, the reason we've got the staff is because you guys have been subscribing. 0.72
00:15:35 So I'll have to jump in there and nag and remind you folks, $10 a month, $100 a year, just like a newspaper subscription in the old days. 0.55
00:15:42 And it keeps us independent.
00:15:43 We aren't asking for government dollars and we aren't taking them.
00:15:46 I don't think they're really in a rush to give us any anyhow.
00:15:48 But if you want good, honest coverage, you know, you've got to support it, guys.
00:15:51 So if you've subscribed already, thank you very much.
00:15:53 We really, really do appreciate it.
00:15:54 If you haven't yet, come on, get on.
00:15:56 It's only $10 a month.
00:15:57 You're probably paying more for like a World of Warcraft or an OnlyFans account or something.
00:16:01 So this is more productive than that.
00:16:03 Jump on boards.
00:16:04 All right.
00:16:04 So let's go on to something less controversial.
00:16:07 The Americans had a debate last time.
00:16:09 Oh, did they ever.
00:16:11 I put myself through that.
00:16:14 I watched it.
00:16:17 Boy.
00:16:19 Let's get you to start the last one.
00:16:21 We'll get James to kind of frame what was your impression or what do you think you see coming out here?
00:16:27 I actually had a conversation with actually a good friend of mine, Kristen Raworth, right?
00:16:32 So she's generally considered a bit of a red Tory. And to her, Kamala Harris won that debate. And I said, maybe, but to normies, I said, you don't understand mega people. You don't understand Trump supporters. 1.00
00:16:49 And I said, I live in that world. I'm in that world. And I'm telling you right now, Trump won that debate. And the reason why Trump won that debate is because today, every single person on earth is talking about people eating cats and dogs and executing babies.
00:17:10 Nobody is talking about policy.
00:17:12 Nobody's talking about deficit.
00:17:15 Nobody's talking about debt.
00:17:17 They're talking about the immigration, but they're talking about immigration because Trump's saying they're eating cats and dogs.
00:17:23 Trump debated to his people last night.
00:17:26 He was looking in the camera.
00:17:28 He was focused, and he was talking to his supporters, and he gave them the greatest hits. 0.81
00:17:32 He gave them their rapists.
00:17:34 He gave them their murderers.
00:17:35 He said they're coming into the country and taking our jobs.
00:17:37 They're doing this. 1.00
00:17:38 We got to deal with China. There wouldn't be a war with Russia. He hit all of his greatest hits last night. And I think Kamala failed to land any big jabs at Trump. I don't think anything she threw at him actually stuck. She took nothing away from his supporters. He gave his supporters and his people everything they wanted. I don't think she was effective last night. 0.73
00:18:03 So to go further, kind of one of the things that's amazing in American politics, these hard fought elections, a two party system, yet it's almost always only within a point or two, a calm election time. It's amazing how close it is. There's rarely a blowout. And I imagine it's similar right now. Part of it too, though, is how many undecideds watched last night? 10? 11? You know, like either side.
00:18:24 People already have their mind made up.
00:18:26 Was there anybody who was really going to change a mind in that debate?
00:18:29 Well, as James mentioned, the normies, right?
00:18:32 So people that are just tuning into politics without looking at things like policy or thinking
00:18:38 about what the implications of those policies might mean, they might go along with an emotion
00:18:43 that they feel.
00:18:44 So what really stood out to me during the debate was Kamala's biggest swing, what I 0.99
00:18:48 thought was on abortion, where she really went for that emotional factor.
00:18:53 Are you really going to do that to someone who's been raped or is a product of insistence?
00:18:58 Are you really gonna do that?
00:18:59 And I think that that really gets a lot of people
00:19:02 from the normal aspect to have that emotional response to it.
00:19:07 However, it is still talking about abortion
00:19:09 and murdering the child in the mother's womb.
00:19:12 So I think when Trump addressed these issues head on,
00:19:16 he really was, as James is saying, talking to his audience.
00:19:19 That is what they wanna hear is that
00:19:20 that's actually where we draw the line as Republicans.
00:19:24 And we don't want to just be emotionally caught up
00:19:28 with how Kamala is spinning it.
00:19:30 So getting into a different crowd,
00:19:32 I talked a little bit about that earlier,
00:19:34 and I'll give you a little bit of a warning,
00:19:35 I wanna go there, but it's different.
00:19:37 The Taylor Swift factor, which I think might really be one.
00:19:40 I think so too.
00:19:41 Not so much the undecided, but the indifferent.
00:19:43 I mean, there's a lot of young people who just never voted,
00:19:45 never paid attention really, or anything else,
00:19:47 but they are fanatically dedicated to Taylor Swift.
00:19:50 We're not talking about a few thousand,
00:19:51 we're talking millions of people.
00:19:54 And she has come out and very directly endorsed
00:19:58 Kamala Harris. If those Swifties come out and vote, that, when I'm talking about those 1% type 0.99
00:20:03 swings in an election, she could be the game changer in this. Like, what a strange time to 1.00
00:20:07 be in. Well, think of Taylor Swift's army. Think of her tour. Her tour has a GDP that's bigger than
00:20:14 most countries at this point. The amount of power and sway and celebrity that she has. People go to 1.00
00:20:20 her concerts and, like, faint. Yeah, they go to the concerts and they go and watch the concert
00:20:26 from outside and just to listen like outside of like it'd be like standing outside the saddle
00:20:30 dome just listening to the noise inside but if the Swifties mobilize like they have against some
00:20:37 other things and they actually like if if the Swifties help Kamala's team with GOTV with get
00:20:45 out the vote it could be massive honestly that that is like that is like a whole secondary army
00:20:52 coming in and like the DNC and the RNC and these elections they have armies of door knockers
00:20:59 canvassers whatever if the Swifties mobilize into door knockers canvassers stuff like that
00:21:05 the undecideds could get pushed that way very rapidly well speaking of they just
00:21:10 yeah right speaking of Swifties mobilizing though however I saw a trend on social media just
00:21:16 last night or the night before I saw it come up Swifties for Trump believe it or not yeah
00:21:22 and so there's all these it looks like a faction of swift supporters who are voting for donald
00:21:29 trump they have t-shirts they're doing dances on tick tock so there's a whole line of them that
00:21:34 are saying okay well you know our queen says this and we can still be swifties however it doesn't
00:21:40 have to be political but i think that's a small faction and the majority of them as you say
00:21:45 are going to get caught up in this mob mentality oh well taylor swift said to vote for kamala well
00:21:51 well, then we must mobilize and get ready.
00:21:53 However, Swifty's going out to door knocking for a political cause.
00:21:57 I don't know if I quite see that.
00:21:58 I don't know.
00:21:59 You never know what to expect.
00:22:00 You never know anymore.
00:22:02 We're talking about eating cats and dogs and executing babies and Swifty endorsements.
00:22:08 All of the normal rules in politics are out the window.
00:22:12 That's it.
00:22:13 I mean, celebrities, you know, speaking of politics, do nothing new.
00:22:16 And it's had a little bit of influence and so on.
00:22:18 But I mean, this is a titanic force we're talking about, like we haven't seen before.
00:22:22 I mean, we're the modern equivalent of the Beatles or something huge in their time.
00:22:28 And they didn't directly endorse candidates in elections.
00:22:32 It's just an interesting factor to be measured, you know, if it mobilizes them with her coming out like that.
00:22:37 I mean, it could bring backlash, too. 0.97
00:22:39 Yeah.
00:22:40 Well, and that's why Taylor Swift is a state out of politics, right? 0.99
00:22:43 Because her roots were in country music.
00:22:45 so you're not going to have a massive liberal leaning audience when you come from country music
00:22:50 your base is going to be mostly republican mostly rural her first tours were like with brad paisley
00:22:58 like she's not really built on a liberal platform she's built on more of a conservative platform
00:23:04 until she went to hollywood and yeah but and then there was like a few years and just certain
00:23:08 policies she's always kind of been clear that she has leaned towards the democrats because of lgbt
00:23:13 issues and her personal stance on abortion and I mean fine most uh celebrities you know like I mean
00:23:19 Kid Rock and Hulk Hogan were at the the RNC convention so I yeah why wouldn't Taylor Swift
00:23:26 jump in on the other side at this point right sure but I mean you know Kid Rock just isn't
00:23:29 gonna pull him like no no and the influence she's had like even myself as an NFL fan and now she
00:23:35 you know she's dating Kelsey so there's a whole new audience the viewership has gone up
00:23:41 For Kansas City games, just because these are new viewers, that's what I'm seeing, the factor with this voting, she didn't change anybody who already had team loyalties, but she brought in a whole new raft of people that never watched in the first place.
00:23:54 And that's what I see with the election, she's going to bring a bunch of non-voters into the mix, and their votes count just as much as a registered Republican or Democrat.
00:24:02 Well, I mean, me, if I'm in a press scrum and Kelsey's right in front of me, the first question I'm asking is, who are you voting for?
00:24:10 so you know maybe we're going to see a familial split here where you know they don't agree but
00:24:16 they agree to vote separately like that happens a lot that happens a lot in the states for sure too
00:24:21 but what if he says he's going to back Harris what if a bunch of the NFL players especially
00:24:28 with some of the BLM stuff and through some of their own movements a bunch of NFL players start
00:24:33 coming out and they endorse Harris which it would be interesting to see athletes starting to endorse
00:24:39 candidates but could that also mobilize you know the average person who sits at home who just
00:24:44 watches football on the weekends and they decide they're going to vote what if he endorses trump
00:24:48 like there's it's a fascinating whole new world well you have to wonder too if swift came out of
00:24:56 her own volition and endorsed kamala that way or if there has been some kind of influence who knows 0.93
00:25:03 where the money is moving if how do you influence her yeah how big a bribe would you need to influence 1.00
00:25:09 swift right i mean she can buy countries you know yeah there's nobody has the money to influence her 0.93
00:25:15 that way i mean they can influence her but that's what's interesting too even if she gets a bit of 0.58
00:25:20 backlash loses a bit of following she's too big to fail as the old saying goes but i mean she's
00:25:25 gonna lose uh those people maybe in the states but she still has the entire rest of the world
00:25:33 so i actually seen uh it was a while ago someone actually broke down to the median family income
00:25:39 comparing what her income is and basically to her the hundred thousand dollars each to all of the
00:25:47 truck drivers and bonuses she gave amounts to a dollar 67 or something it was basically it was
00:25:53 less than a cup of coffee is what it actually costs to her so for me making whatever I make
00:25:58 what a cup of coffee costs to me her giving one point whatever million dollars worth of bonuses 0.76
00:26:03 to the truck drivers equates to her about the same as a much of much as a cup of coffee so I 0.98
00:26:09 like I honestly think the amount of like the entire spend of Kamala's campaign wouldn't be
00:26:15 enough to influence her to endorse I think that's coming straight from her and it was funny that she
00:26:21 signed it off as the childless cat lady because trump has been calling liberal women a bunch of
00:26:27 childless cat ladies and uh you know and also kind of funny that she posted a picture of her and a
00:26:33 cat after trump said the immigrants were eating cats the internet is absolutely on fire but that
00:26:39 but that's the thing that's why trump won the internet is all full of memes about stuff trump
00:26:44 said nobody remembers policy nobody remembers policy that's part of why i was a little rough
00:26:49 on Trump on my show. And I still, I'll say it again. I don't like the guy. If I was in the
00:26:54 States, I'd probably vote for him because I'd still want to see a conservatively government
00:26:57 better than Kamala, but I do not like him, but I'm a policy guy. I want to see policies. And
00:27:02 that's why I'm frustrated. That's, but I'm in the minority. As you said, sound bites,
00:27:06 capturing news, dominating the memes is how you capture the vote now.
00:27:12 Trump called that out last night too. He said, that's a lie. And that was,
00:27:16 that was that was a soundbite and really made me angry there was four or five times I think Ben
00:27:23 Shapiro actually pointed a few of them out too last night where Kamala flat out lied and they
00:27:29 did not push back on her and that was frustrating too and but that also directly feeds into Trump's
00:27:35 narrative about the fake news the fake media they're all against me they're saying I'm a danger
00:27:41 to democracy, but look at how they behave. He has denounced Project 2025 repeatedly from the
00:27:49 beginning. Yes, some of his team did write that. He has not endorsed it. He has said he will not
00:27:55 put that policy in place. And she said he was going to do it. He had to push back on it. And
00:28:00 neither of the hosts said a damn word. And that was frustrating. That's true. And it does only 0.93
00:28:05 play into Trump when, you know, it's like the old saying, it's not a conspiracy when they really are
00:28:09 all out to get you. And the bias in the moderation of that debate was terrible. And, you know, I
00:28:16 tweeted that. I just said, geez, I hate it when moderators jump in on the debate. And I don't
00:28:19 care what side. I didn't tune in to listen to the stinking moderators. I tuned in to listen to 0.98
00:28:24 the candidates. And the role of the person to counter Trump's lies, and he lied a lot.
00:28:29 That's Kamala's role. That's your job. And Trump, likewise, the other way you correct her,
00:28:35 You know, for example, with her denying that she was donating to, you know, get Black Lives Matter people on bail.
00:28:41 She did. 0.81
00:28:42 Yeah.
00:28:42 Her own tweets out there.
00:28:43 But that's his job.
00:28:45 Keep the moderators out.
00:28:46 So when it does, when people view that and see, holy cow, those two moderators are totally against Trump, and they were.
00:28:52 Yeah.
00:28:52 That really entrenches the Trump supporters.
00:28:55 Yeah. 0.96
00:28:55 Not gay new ones, but it certainly galvanizes the existing ones. 0.60
00:28:58 See, and I actually think it does push some of the more moderates in swing states.
00:29:05 I'm thinking specifically of like Arizona, because they're not really extreme Republicans there.
00:29:11 But when you hear the media and you hear this and everybody is against the person, you kind of start to gravitate towards that person if you're a center right person.
00:29:19 Because you're like, what are they doing?
00:29:21 Because I would say ABC is an extreme liberal network, and you have probably one of the most extreme liberal candidates in the history of the presidency of the United States.
00:29:33 And if I'm sitting there as a center-right person and a moderate, and I'm seeing, okay, Kamala, the news, everyone else is all ganging up on Trump, maybe there's something here that I should push towards Trump on.
00:29:46 I also like fighting for an underdog, too.
00:29:48 Anybody with an anti-establishment attitude is going to feel more well.
00:29:51 The establishment doesn't like this guy.
00:29:53 I don't like the establishment, so he's getting my ex.
00:29:58 Yeah, and another thing last night that really stood out for me that really made me angry
00:30:03 was Kamala taking a victory lap on not having servicemen serving anywhere around the world right now.
00:30:10 Everyone's at home. We're not in an active war zone, blah, blah, blah, blah.
00:30:13 It's especially embarrassing that today is September 11th.
00:30:16 Yeah. I had friends that fought in Afghanistan for Canada. Both of them have PTSD. One of them
00:30:24 has a service dog. They have gone through extreme mental anguish. And there are so many more
00:30:31 American veterans that went through so much worse in Afghanistan and Iraq. And her withdrawal and
00:30:40 the blood on her hands from that withdrawal from Afghanistan, the people we left behind,
00:30:45 the weapons and ammunition and the machinery and the equipment that we left behind and the people
00:30:51 that died she should have apologized for that and not taken a victory lap to me it was disgusting
00:30:59 to me she pivoted off of it when Trump said you didn't even go see those families and I did
00:31:05 and she pivoted off of it to a victory lap and I think that was disgusting yeah no the veterans I
00:31:11 I think in typical or in general
00:31:13 aren't gonna be heavily Democrat these days.
00:31:15 It's just not where they're sitting.
00:31:16 No kidding.
00:31:17 All right, well, let's get onto something.
00:31:20 You know, I don't have any light going on today.
00:31:22 No, not at all.
00:31:24 Let's go to Coutts, Canadian-American border.
00:31:27 The trial is gonna be closed.
00:31:29 James, you've spent a lot of time.
00:31:31 You had my, oh, I'll say my pity while you were there
00:31:35 because it just seemed like he's gonna be back tomorrow.
00:31:36 Yep, yep, no, it's still going.
00:31:37 Tomorrow, no, weather's horrible. 0.96
00:31:40 People are crazy.
00:31:41 Art Pawlowski's Art Pawlowski and but still I mean the the fallout from this whole thing 0.60
00:31:46 the separate thing from that mean there's a lot of confusion that's what you lay out there was
00:31:50 almost two protest or two events yeah the the border protest and blockage and then the coots
00:31:56 four yeah which uh the coots four the last the two just got sentenced yeah yes so I was in coots
00:32:03 the entire time uh I would we we actually we got tipped off on this it's so the the whole way the
00:32:09 the whole coots protest went was uh my brother was a truck driver and he sent me the flyer i seen the
00:32:16 flyer and i thought holy they're gonna go to the border they're gonna shut down the border i gave
00:32:20 the story to mel and dave mel chased it down we broke the story and actually that night was the
00:32:24 night that jason kenny lifted the restrictions on the pub so we were all down at the fox and we were
00:32:30 all discussing it and i said well you know what i have family in coots i haven't seen them i'm just
00:32:34 gonna drive down there i'll check it out and we thought it was gonna be one and done we drove
00:32:38 down there that day. The highway was still moving. Everything was all good. I walked around. I did a
00:32:44 couple of interviews. I chatted with a few people. I called it Trucker Protest Fest because it was
00:32:49 like a music festival. Everybody was happy. Everybody was having a good time. And then I
00:32:55 thought the next morning when I rolled out there that it would be done. But no, there was more
00:33:00 people showing up. And Derek said, well, you know what? It's probably going to peter itself out. Come
00:33:04 back to the office. So I came back to Calgary and the next morning I came in and it wasn't even nine
00:33:10 o'clock. And actually by that time, a couple of the guys from the rebel, they got down there and
00:33:14 we started seeing their reports and it was still growing. So Derek said, go. So I raced down there
00:33:22 and I grabbed clothes for two or three days. I had all of the wrong clothes for the weather.
00:33:26 And I was there right till the end. Now there was, there was two protest areas. There was Milk River
00:33:32 just outside of Melk River and there was coots and the main area coots was the saloon and then
00:33:37 there was a house in town where some of the folks were hanging out the the coots for the folks with
00:33:43 the weapons they mostly hung around there they kind of came into the other area Marco Alex and
00:33:49 I'm sorry his name's escaping me right now those guys were mostly on kind of this committee and
00:33:56 there was some truckers and other farmers that were there as well and they made up that committee
00:33:59 And these other four weren't really part of that.
00:34:03 I never heard a word the entire time down there about weapons.
00:34:07 I never heard anybody say we're going to have a shootout with the police.
00:34:10 The closest it ever came to it was during Art Pawlowski's sermon where he said, this is our Alamo.
00:34:17 We need to stay. We need to shut down this border.
00:34:20 We can't leave when we're about to win.
00:34:22 Then he left.
00:34:23 Yeah, and then he left.
00:34:24 but that was the closest to dangerous or violent or anything that I ever heard that whole time that
00:34:33 was down there um you know uh now the trial's over they were found not guilty of conspiracy
00:34:40 to commit murder uh the people who keep continuing to say that they had a plot to kill the police
00:34:45 you're wrong that did not happen a jury of their peers examined the evidence and they have decided
00:34:51 that did not happen so people need to take that off the table and now we need to look at the
00:34:57 weapons so they had guns they had a restricted weapon it was possession of a restricted weapon
00:35:02 and from what I understand they just didn't have the license to have the weapon but this is Canada
00:35:07 we have very serious charges for weapons offenses and I have been a long-time advocate of stiffer
00:35:14 sentences no bail for criminals with dangerous history and they were charged with conspiracy
00:35:21 to commit murder, I would expect them not to get bail. Now, there are a lot of people that are very
00:35:27 upset, and understandably so, because it is very provable that people charge with more serious
00:35:33 offenses. For example, there was a shooting in Medicine Hat where someone actually got shot
00:35:38 a few weeks ago. The person who shot him is out on bail right now. So these guys just had a supposed
00:35:45 a conspiracy, yet they were held in jail without bail for 900 days, and this guy actually shot
00:35:51 someone and he's out. People are frustrated about that, the double standard in the system.
00:35:56 I agree. It's even more insane, but I support stiffer sentences, so I'm okay with their sentence,
00:36:04 but compared to other situations, I believe it was Andy Lee who pointed this out on Twitter,
00:36:10 there was somebody who cracked open a police officer's head with a skateboard, got less time
00:36:16 in jail. The two kids that ran over the cop here in Calgary and killed him, they got less time in
00:36:24 jail. You can kill a cop in this country and get less time in jail than these guys got for weapons
00:36:29 offenses. That is what people are so mad about. That is the part of the system that is broken,
00:36:34 and I agree, but I also agree that we are a country of laws and order, and there are consequences for not following those laws.
00:36:44 Yeah, well, the question, though, is the sentence, right?
00:36:46 So, Jen, like, on these charges, I mean, the judge, okay, the jury made the decision, the judge chooses the sentencing, and he picked a very large one.
00:36:55 Typically, in Canada, it's two to three times the amount you spent in remand gets credited towards your sentence.
00:37:00 I believe they gave you double time.
00:37:03 Was it double, or was it?
00:37:04 I think it was 1.5.
00:37:05 Okay, because it's judicial discretion there too.
00:37:07 I mean, he could very well have given them a sentence of a few years, but then credited and released them.
00:37:14 I mean, if you're looking to make an example of these guys, I think it's already been made.
00:37:19 That's right.
00:37:20 And he could have been a lot more forgiving in that sense.
00:37:24 I myself went down to the courthouse in Lethbridge and witnessed the sentencing.
00:37:29 The judge spent about almost three hours reading the decision. And in that decision, he cited several precedent cases, maybe 18 to 20 other cases in Canadian history, reaching back to the 80s, as recent as 23, where each of these cases had far less sentencing decisions than what he handed out to these coots boys. 1.00
00:37:56 So many of these prior cases had three years, four years, and then he turned 1.00
00:38:01 around and gave Tony and Chris this 6.5 year sentencing, and that is for the
00:38:08 weapons offense. They also got sentenced to six months each for mischief, and this
00:38:15 sentence can be served concurrently with their other ones, so it still
00:38:20 sets a precedent for others facing mischief charges, especially from the
00:38:25 time of the Freedom Convoy in Canada. So here in Alberta, the COOTS III you mentioned, Marco and
00:38:31 Alex, the three of them, and also Tamara Leach in Ottawa. So I learned that in Alberta, if there's
00:38:39 a mischief sentence or any sentence, then that is a required sentence for all other cases like it
00:38:46 in the province. So that means that the other COOTS III are expecting to get that six months at least,
00:38:53 And it sets a precedent for other provinces. So Leach in Ontario, for example, they'll look at this case, and that will at least set kind of a minimum. But the judge said outright that he was using this as an example. He said this is so that you two boys, but also the rest of Canada knows that you can't be getting up to this kind of behavior.
00:39:18 I mean, you know, how much do you think it would impact anybody who really, I don't know what was going through their minds. I know one of them, personally. He's from out in my area in Pritis and so on. And at least from, you know, my anecdotal and knowledge of him, he's not a violent guy. He wasn't going to go kill people or start a revolution. He made, in my view, some stupid decisions. And those decisions have consequences. But they weren't going to start a revolution.
00:39:47 even if they wanted to, they're four guys. Those four people could cause a lot of damage. Fair enough.
00:39:51 Now, if somebody's really convinced themselves in a crazed world of cosplay that they're on the
00:39:57 cusp of the revolution, they're on the brink of the world truly falling apart and becoming
00:40:02 dystopian, do you think any of them would really think twice or care less what the last sentence
00:40:06 was for somebody who did that? No, I don't think that that was something that was on their mind.
00:40:11 however the judge he explicitly said okay so these men had were acquitted they were found
00:40:18 not guilty for the conspiracy charges to murder a police officer and by the way he made it clear
00:40:24 too that there was no terrorism related offenses here contrary to common allegations on social
00:40:30 media yeah that that's just not a thing in this case however even though that was he they were
00:40:38 acquitted of that charge, he continued to circle back to that theme, and he was trying
00:40:45 to make this connection for using the weapons for a dangerous purpose, which brings up the
00:40:50 explosive that Tony was sentenced to further charge an extra six months, and the judge
00:40:58 came right out and said, well, I don't know that you were using this for a dangerous purpose
00:41:04 or if it's for something else like work.
00:41:06 I can't say beyond a reasonable doubt
00:41:09 that this was for a dangerous purpose.
00:41:12 However, he's still got the six month sentence
00:41:15 for that anyways.
00:41:16 Well, and the Crown is still, it sounds like appealing
00:41:18 and they're gonna try and get a conviction
00:41:20 on the conspiracy to murder RCC officer.
00:41:24 So it's your offense.
00:41:26 To be honest, in my view, I'm not a lawyer,
00:41:27 but I think they're wasting time.
00:41:28 They're absolutely wasting time.
00:41:30 And to me, it actually, I find it offensive.
00:41:34 A jury trial is selected for a reason. And a jury of their peers has examined all of the evidence and decided their case did not meet the threshold. They were not guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. And it is a waste of government money. There are serious criminals out there. There are serious crimes going on.
00:41:56 We have already spent so much on the prosecution of these protesters, and we have also seen that protesters who get charged in BC that are in alignment with the federal government and are supposed to be deported out of our country will be saved by a minister.
00:42:13 At this point, I believe someone needs to stand up and say an appeal is not in the public interest. It is not in the fiscal interest. Enough. You failed.
00:42:26 That plot did not exist.
00:42:28 They were found not guilty.
00:42:29 You held them responsible for taking the weapons there.
00:42:32 That was the crime they did commit.
00:42:34 Now, I'm 50-50 on this explosive device.
00:42:38 I understand someone did testify and said that it was something work-related,
00:42:43 but it wasn't at the protest site either.
00:42:47 It was not in Coots.
00:42:48 It was several hundred kilometers away in his home.
00:42:51 But the thing is, when you get arrested and you are charged for suspicion to commit murder, your house is going to be searched.
00:42:59 And if there is a secondary crime in your house, such as an explosive weapon, you will be charged with that.
00:43:05 That's what happens.
00:43:06 This is a terrible analogy.
00:43:08 I don't want to compare it with these guys.
00:43:10 But if the RCMP searched their house and found child porn, you would expect they also get charged with that.
00:43:19 So that is just the way the system works.
00:43:21 Now, I don't understand, but the jury, obviously, through listening through everything with the trial, decided that he was guilty of the possession of an explosive weapon.
00:43:32 So I'm going to go with what the jury decided.
00:43:35 Now, there is also the secret envelope.
00:43:38 Yes.
00:43:39 I don't know.
00:43:40 I don't even want to speculate.
00:43:42 If the defense appeals on the grounds of that envelope and said that the judge erred, I agree in defensive appeals.
00:43:50 I don't agree in prosecutors appealing a jury decision, unless it's like outright, the judge really did something.
00:43:58 But I don't think the judge did something wrong in this case.
00:44:01 And there are reasons inside law where certain evidence is excluded.
00:44:06 That is just part of the system, and it's about fairness of the trial.
00:44:10 So, you know, we will probably never know what's in that envelope.
00:44:14 Maybe someday we will know.
00:44:15 Maybe somebody does actually know.
00:44:17 Maybe the defense appeal will see what's in it.
00:44:20 but um i i just i don't know like i i think at this point it's done i realistically these guys
00:44:29 have been model prisoners they will probably be released within six months on good behavior
00:44:33 anyways um but i i just uh it it is it is uh it is a double standard they were held to a higher
00:44:43 threshold. They were held more accountable than everyone else. But me personally, I want to see
00:44:50 criminals punished more. And not them, but all of the other ones as well. Just to your point about
00:44:58 the sealed envelope, I spoke with Carbert's attorney and she confirmed of the envelope. She
00:45:05 said that she actually has seen it herself. And in closed door meetings, they had a decision to keep
00:45:12 bit client attorney privilege. And so I have also heard speculations about what is contained
00:45:21 in this envelope in terms of incriminating behavior of one of the Crown prosecutors and
00:45:29 the RCMP, but we don't know for sure. We only have this speculation. However, she did confirm
00:45:35 that in the appeals process, so she's going to be appealing the sentences handed down this week,
00:45:41 And that is when the envelope is going to be addressed again.
00:45:44 So I don't think that we've heard the last of the sealed envelope mystery.
00:45:49 And if that's what's in that envelope, then I would expect that we actually have an investigation into the prosecutors then.
00:45:56 Because I think there is a general mistrust of the judicial system in Canada right now.
00:46:01 And if we have prosecutorial misconduct going on, then I think it's time for the government to stand up and do something and bring faith back into our judicial system.
00:46:13 That's good.
00:46:14 And there's lots to be done.
00:46:15 We've heard of the clock.
00:46:16 There's going to be this.
00:46:17 Obviously, this issue isn't finished yet, though.
00:46:19 No.
00:46:19 That trial is.
00:46:20 But there's still more.
00:46:21 There's going to be appeals.
00:46:22 There's going to be discussion.
00:46:24 And there's going to be a lot of conspiracies.
00:46:26 So, you know, before I let you go, I want to clarify something on there, too.
00:46:28 So I'll say goodbye to you guys.
00:46:31 James and Jen, thank you very much for joining the pipeline today.
00:46:34 Thank you.
00:46:35 And with the online discussions, I just want to remind people too,
00:46:38 because I've seen that there's some confusion about the role of a premier
00:46:40 and what they can do. 1.00
00:46:42 She can't commute sentences. 1.00
00:46:44 She can't pardon people. 1.00
00:46:47 She can't override a conviction. 0.96
00:46:50 That's not Canada. 1.00
00:46:51 That's not the role she has.
00:46:52 It's fair critique to say you want her to speak up on this.
00:46:55 Speaking as a political guy, I put on my political wonk hat,
00:46:57 and I'd say don't say a peep because it's just something you don't want to
00:47:00 step into when you got a million other irons in the fire. I know that sounds unprincipled,
00:47:04 but that's the way politics works. But just for people thinking that, oh, she could release them 1.00
00:47:09 tomorrow. No, she can't. It's just not the way it works, I'm afraid. Scream at Justin. He's the man
00:47:13 at the helm of things. He can't pardon people either, actually, but he is the guy at the head
00:47:17 of the federal jurisdiction of this whole thing. All right. But that was a lot of crazy subjects
00:47:22 to cover. So thank you very much. Yeah, nice, light, easy stuff. You know, I just save it for
00:47:26 when you guys come to the pipeline. So thank you all for tuning in, guys. And again, be sure to
00:47:32 tune in to our other shows. Hannaford is fantastic. Once in a while, I do all right on mine at the
00:47:36 Cory Morgan Show. And be sure to subscribe to the Western Standard and catch those things as
00:47:40 they're happening. So thanks for tuning in, and I will see you next time. If the name Ted Byfield
00:47:44 brings back fond memories, well, we got a party coming up for you guys. On September 25th,
00:47:49 Toasting Ted is what it's called. It's going to honor a great conservative who published
00:47:53 Alberta Report News Magazine.
00:47:55 It's going to be bagpipes, singing, live auction stakes,
00:47:58 speeches by Premier Smith, Preston Manning, Stephen Harper.
00:48:00 Quite a lineup.
00:48:02 The Western Standard is the final incarnation
00:48:04 or the latest incarnation of Alberta Report
00:48:06 that Ted Byfield founded.
00:48:08 And I mean, he was a great Albertan.
00:48:10 He really made his mark on this province.
00:48:12 And this evening of celebration for him
00:48:14 is really going to be outstanding.
00:48:15 You get there, toastingted.ca.
00:48:17 That's the website.
00:48:18 You can get your tickets.
00:48:19 This one's going to sell out.
00:48:20 I mean, again, if you want to see Smith, Manning, Harper,
00:48:23 All in one spot one night be sure to get there you can become a Western Center member for just $10 a month or 99