Western Standard - June 16, 2023


Liberals table 'Just Transition' legislation in House

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update June 15, 2023 Here comes the Just Transition

Episode Stats


Length

13 minutes

Words per minute

155.34

Word count

2,077

Sentence count

133

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

3

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Western Standard's energy editor, Sean Pulser, joins me to discuss the Canadian government's new plan to transition to a net zero energy economy, and why it's bad for Alberta's oil and gas workers.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello, Western Standard viewers. I'm Nigel Hannaford for the Western Standard.
00:00:05 I have with me this morning, Sean Pulser, the Western Standard's energy reporter, energy editor.
00:00:12 What are you, Sean?
00:00:13 I think I'm a little bit of both. You're wearing both hats.
00:00:16 All I know is that Sean Pulser's articles are trending at the moment
00:00:19 because they deal with a very important subject that came down yesterday,
00:00:23 and that is the federal announcement of the Canadian Sustainable Jobs Strategy,
00:00:30 which sounds about as interesting as a long drink of warm water,
00:00:33 but it actually is of vital importance in this province and, indeed, to the rest of the country
00:00:39 because, really, it's just that old just transition,
00:00:43 the removal of good, well-paying energy jobs from the economy
00:00:49 and substituting with, well, I guess the famous phrase was truckers and janitors.
00:00:54 Not that we have anything against truckers and we certainly need janitors, 0.99
00:00:59 but they're not always six bigger salary jobs.
00:01:04 So, Sean, what is going on here?
00:01:07 What is the Canadian Sustainable Jobs Act supposed to do,
00:01:12 and why is it bad for Alberta?
00:01:14 Well, it's supposedly to transition people away from, I guess, 0.98
00:01:22 what they consider to be higher emissions.
00:01:26 They want to say polluting, but I don't think that that's really the case.
00:01:29 Higher emissions jobs into this so-called net.
00:01:31 Is carbon dioxide a pollution?
00:01:33 A pollutant?
00:01:35 Well, the carbon dioxide that comes from the birds and bees definitely isn't,
00:01:38 but, you know, there's probably a case to be made
00:01:41 that the stuff that comes off the top of the smoke stack could be considered polluting.
00:01:46 Well, carbon dioxide is carbon dioxide.
00:01:49 It's the other crowd they're worried about, perhaps.
00:01:51 Well, you can't breathe pure carbon dioxide.
00:01:53 If I put you in a room with pure carbon dioxide,
00:01:55 you're going to die, unfortunately. 0.86
00:01:57 That's an editorial board meeting. 0.98
00:01:59 Anyway, sorry I interrupted you.
00:02:01 Carry on.
00:02:01 What's this act about?
00:02:03 Well, it's about transitioning to net zero jobs,
00:02:06 which in itself doesn't sound like a bad thing,
00:02:08 but I guess the point is you're taking away from one pile
00:02:13 and you're putting it into the other at a time
00:02:16 when Alberta is ramping up on things like hydrogen from natural gas
00:02:22 and also to fill world oil demand,
00:02:26 which is up about 10 million barrels a day since the pandemic.
00:02:31 So it's a fairly substantial number.
00:02:33 Oil demand is going to hit over 100 million barrels a day this year
00:02:37 for the first time in the last three years.
00:02:41 So I want to circle back to that point
00:02:45 because you had an insightful article yesterday about some of the estimates.
00:02:49 But as I understand it, the Canadian Sustainable Jobs Act,
00:02:55 in which we see the just transition,
00:03:00 is in quite a lengthy suite of legislation.
00:03:03 This is just the first part of it that was issued yesterday
00:03:08 and it has to do with what, forming an advisory council?
00:03:12 Basically an advisory council that reports to the government
00:03:15 on the policies of, I guess, in some kind of totality
00:03:20 on how it's going to affect workers, presumably in oil and gas,
00:03:24 because they are assuming that world oil demand
00:03:27 is going to fall by about 75% by 2050 to 24 million barrels a day.
00:03:33 And that was the number that really caught my eye.
00:03:36 And I had to go back and do some double checking.
00:03:41 Well, forming an advisory committee doesn't sound too bad.
00:03:44 It's where it goes from there.
00:03:46 Danielle Smith, the premier, came out very strongly against this
00:03:50 and basically said, look, this is provincial jurisdiction
00:03:53 that you're interfering with and we're not going to let you do it.
00:03:56 Why is she so exercised about it? 1.00
00:03:58 Because it ties in with this idea of emissions caps,
00:04:03 decarbonizing the power grid by 2035 instead of 2050,
00:04:09 as we've agreed.
00:04:10 The whole range, the whole gamut, fuel emission standards,
00:04:18 all these things that are supposedly going to tie into this reduced demand number
00:04:23 of 25 million barrels a day, which the whole policy in its totality
00:04:28 is predicated on.
00:04:31 And where does that number come from, Sean?
00:04:34 It comes from the International Energy Agency.
00:04:36 It's called their net zero scenario, which is basically the unicorn
00:04:41 and rainbow scenario.
00:04:43 If everybody had, this is what everybody in the world would have to do
00:04:47 if we are going to hit net zero as a planet by 2050.
00:04:51 So that means immediate cessation of investment in any new oil and gas
00:04:58 or fossil fuel, including natural gas, coal.
00:05:02 So does this agency have other scenarios?
00:05:04 They do.
00:05:05 They have a policy scenario, which is what would happen if all the countries
00:05:12 did what they said they were going to do, that they've committed to
00:05:14 under the Paris Accord.
00:05:16 And that number is not 25 million barrels a day.
00:05:19 It's probably closer to about 75 to 80, maybe even 90.
00:05:25 So we're talking instead of 75% reduction in oil demand,
00:05:29 maybe anywhere from about 15 to 20.
00:05:32 So really, the writers of this legislation have just grabbed the number
00:05:37 that looked best to them, fitted their narrative best, and gone with that.
00:05:41 But it doesn't really mean that there's any strength to it.
00:05:45 Is this, what did you say, rainbows and unicorns?
00:05:47 Yeah, it fits Canada's narrative.
00:05:49 So if we are going to achieve net zero by 2050 and assuming that everybody else in the world
00:05:57 is going to do this at the same time simultaneously, and assuming that somehow Canada really makes
00:06:03 a meaningful difference in the whole totality of the emissions picture, you know, given that we are only 1%
00:06:10 of global emissions, then that is the number that they would use.
00:06:14 Now, in the U.S., they have the Energy Information Agency.
00:06:19 So it gets a little confusing because you have the IEA and you have the EIA.
00:06:23 So the Energy Information Agency is the U.S. government's energy advisory, whereas the IEA is based in Paris.
00:06:31 Now, what the EIA is saying in their base case is that oil demand is going to go up to about 105 million barrels a day,
00:06:40 and it's going to stay there.
00:06:41 That's roughly what it is now, isn't it?
00:06:44 Yeah, well, it's a little, so we've gone from about 90 million during the pandemic back up above 100
00:06:49 for the first time, and so I think we're about 102, and then so in the next couple years,
00:06:55 they're forcing it to go up to about 105, and then pretty much flatline around 100.
00:07:01 So that's what the Americans think?
00:07:02 That's what the Americans think.
00:07:03 The Canadian government chooses to think that everybody is going to do what the Canadian government
00:07:08 thinks is best, and the oil demand will plummet to 25% of what it is today.
00:07:14 Well, there's absolutely no chance.
00:07:15 And they're basing this legislation on that assumption.
00:07:17 They are, and there's absolutely no chance that the world is going to hit net zero by 2050
00:07:22 because India and China, which account for a combined total of about 40% of the world's total emissions profile,
00:07:30 have not committed to net zero.
00:07:33 I think it's 2060 in India's case and 2070 in China's.
00:07:37 So how are the Indians, and this very much relates to the assumptions behind this legislation,
00:07:45 how do the Indians and the Chinese generate electricity?
00:07:49 What do they burn?
00:07:50 Coal.
00:07:52 Coal and more coal?
00:07:53 Coal and more coal.
00:07:54 Well, I mean, China has added probably the most renewable sources of any other country in the world,
00:08:00 but the fact is that they are still adding a coal-fired power plant a week.
00:08:05 So the solution worldwide would seem to be switch from coal.
00:08:13 If the solution in Canada is to switch from coal generation to gas generation of electricity,
00:08:20 then wouldn't that be a worthwhile thing to do worldwide?
00:08:24 Yes, absolutely.
00:08:25 So we have the gas.
00:08:26 They have the coal-fired stations that need replacement.
00:08:30 So what's the hold-up here?
00:08:32 I noticed that the federal government, when it suits them, says,
00:08:36 oh, well, it's all one atmosphere, so we have a right as the federal government
00:08:40 to intrude into your provincial jurisdiction and set the rules for you,
00:08:45 something that Premier Smith is challenging, of course, but, I mean, that's the federal point of view.
00:08:49 But when it becomes worldwide, then suddenly the one atmosphere argument doesn't apply anymore.
00:08:58 What's going on there?
00:08:59 Well, we have enough natural gas in Canada that if we did export it to all these countries,
00:09:05 we could offset our whole entire emissions profile just by exporting LNG to China.
00:09:13 The problem is that we don't have the infrastructure.
00:09:16 We don't have the ports.
00:09:17 We don't have the facilities.
00:09:18 We don't have the pipelines.
00:09:19 And we have a very onerous regulatory regime that precludes these things from getting built.
00:09:25 Now, you say, Sean, that we don't have these things, but we were on the track of building them.
00:09:29 The Northern Gateway was a pipeline to the coast.
00:09:35 There were, at one point, multiple, like almost an embarrassingly unlikely large number of applications
00:09:44 to build LNG plants on the coast of British Columbia.
00:09:48 Where have they all gone?
00:09:48 Well, Nigel, I know that you're reaching retirement age.
00:09:54 So the question I have to ask you is would you put your pension into the hands of the Canadian government
00:10:01 to approve these projects to get them done?
00:10:05 And so really what the issue is, is investor confidence.
00:10:10 So the people who have these hundreds of millions and billions of dollars in New York and London
00:10:17 and Switzerland around the world, when it comes to looking at Canada as a place to be investing those dollars,
00:10:26 generating reasonable rates of return in your lifetime, hopefully, so that you can enjoy your retirement.
00:10:31 I shall live forever.
00:10:32 I'm a Republican.
00:10:33 Anyway.
00:10:33 So basically that's the other piece of it, is the investment puzzle.
00:10:40 And Canada is becoming known around the world as a place where you cannot get things done.
00:10:46 Didn't used to be that way 10 years ago.
00:10:49 Well, there it is.
00:10:51 Last question then.
00:10:54 Yesterday, the Federal Minister, Jonathan Wilkinson, made the announcement,
00:10:59 this is what we're going to do.
00:11:00 This is the first step in 10 actions that we're going to take.
00:11:06 And immediately, Premier Smith came out with a counter statement.
00:11:12 What was the gist of that?
00:11:14 That it's non-negotiable.
00:11:19 Well, you know, the Alberta advantage is predicated on infrastructure, access to resources, supplies.
00:11:30 She has a very ambitious plan to build out hydrogen infrastructure for just as one example, which is it's going to require more natural gas, not less.
00:11:43 The same thing with reaching some of these clean energy goals, because there's this attitude in Ottawa that somehow they're going to be able to do it with the NDP and the trade unions,
00:11:55 when in fact all the expertise is siloed here in Calgary.
00:12:00 I mean, we are producing the oil and gas, so if anybody's going to figure out how to do it with lower emissions, it's going to be here.
00:12:07 It's not going to be over there in Ottawa.
00:12:09 Do you put her statement yesterday in terms of her Sovereignty Act, where she basically said, look, if you try to legislate in our area of jurisdiction, we're going to say no?
00:12:20 Because that's pretty much what she said.
00:12:21 I think it's coming to that, and I think she's been very cautious right now about using it as a big stick, but it is definitely going to be the line in the sand.
00:12:33 This is going to be like, once you cross this line, then that's it.
00:12:36 We are going to have absolutely no choice but to ignore it.
00:12:43 Or to use it, however you want to.
00:12:46 Sean, thank you very much.
00:12:47 This is illuminating.
00:12:48 You're doing a great job on the energy file, and I think you're going to be the busiest man in the office here for months to come.
00:12:54 Thank you, Nigel.
00:12:55 Thank you very much.
00:12:56 Thank you.
00:12:57 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:12:59 Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:13:01 Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:13:06 These guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms regulations and legislation in Canada,
00:13:13 and more importantly, educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people.
00:13:19 To become a member, it's absolutely worth every penny.