Western Standard - December 11, 2025


Liberals vote against pipeline motion

Topics
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | 10 Dec 2025 Western Standard News Update | 12 Dec 2025

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

175.1

Word count

8,088

Sentence count

508

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Corey and Dave are joined by the late TV legend Nigel Hannaford to discuss the opposition to the proposed $1.25 pipeline between Alberta and Kitimat, British Columbia, and the opposition from the federal Liberal Party.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening i'm corey morgan and you're watching the pipeline this is the western
00:00:29 standards weekly production a panel show that's going on you know i was just thinking a little
00:00:34 while ago about this this is the western standards oldest show they were doing versions of this if
00:00:39 you really want to go into the deep bowels of youtube and see where the western standard was
00:00:44 first formed and the original pipeline pals that were put together it was uh let's just say we've
00:00:48 come a long ways either way we're much more polished and professional now or at least i
00:00:53 like to think so so i'll introduce the other folks i'm joined by today i'll start on the end with our
00:00:58 news editor Dave Naylor. It is a honor to be here with such two esteemed
00:01:03 television legends. Well there we go and thank you. In the middle we have our opinion editor emeritus
00:01:10 Nigel Hannaford. And you know my opinion on $1.25 will get your coffee in port.
00:01:17 If it's on sale. If it's a very very small one. Well yes well we've got lots to chew on today.
00:01:24 Boy, yes.
00:01:26 So where to begin?
00:01:28 Start federally.
00:01:30 Maybe Dave, I'll get you to kind of kick that off.
00:01:33 The Liberals have voted against their own pipeline, or at least as the title would put it.
00:01:37 They had a motion going through the House of Commons.
00:01:41 Do they support the pipeline or not?
00:01:43 And they couldn't be cornered.
00:01:45 Yeah, yesterday was pipeline follies.
00:01:47 The Conservatives introduced a motion saying, do you support pipelines, basically?
00:01:53 And the Liberals said, no, it's just party politics.
00:01:57 We're not going to support it because it doesn't even talk about A, B, and C.
00:02:02 Pierre Paulyev then amended his motion to include A, B, and C, and they still voted against it.
00:02:09 It was 169 to 136, so not even close.
00:02:14 So it kind of shows you what the Liberal Party thinks of pipelines, I guess.
00:02:18 Well, and these are kind of performative too.
00:02:20 I mean, this was a motion.
00:02:21 It wasn't binding, even if they...
00:02:23 Right.
00:02:24 No, non-binding motion.
00:02:26 I mean, I think to some...
00:02:28 There's two ways of looking at it.
00:02:30 One is the way the Liberals are looking at it, 0.99
00:02:32 that, well, the Conservatives are just playing silly buggers. 0.97
00:02:35 And the other way is that the Conservatives are actually trying to flush them out 0.98
00:02:39 and see just exactly how deeply and horribly committed they are to this,
00:02:44 because here in Alberta, we were supposed to think,
00:02:48 because Mr. Carney got on the plane and flew back again.
00:02:51 But they were on our side, and things were going to be made to happen.
00:02:55 And there's lots of people here who say, I don't know.
00:02:58 There's some holes in this argument.
00:03:00 It's very costly.
00:03:01 Does BC have a veto or not?
00:03:03 Do the indigenous people have a veto or not? 0.99
00:03:06 Mr. Carney said, of course, they'd need to be in agreement.
00:03:10 Well, it's being in agreement, just being consulted.
00:03:14 You know, there's a lot.
00:03:16 It's very loosey-goosey.
00:03:17 And it was a memoramandum of understanding.
00:03:20 So we all knew from the start that it was not exactly a deal inked in blood.
00:03:26 But this actually did show a certain mentality of evasion and not wishing to be pinned down and keeping all the options open.
00:03:35 Not a very pretty picture.
00:03:37 If you're in Alberta and you're dependent on your job in the energy industry, it was not a good day's work.
00:03:45 Well, and it probably have defanged the second motion when they said, okay, we need this, this, and this, as Dave said, you know, or we won't vote for us. It's okay. Well, I'll pull those things out or I'll reword. I'll change them. Now we can have a vote. And they still voted against. The question I guess is, are they really actually afraid to say that they would support a pipeline? Or is it just the case of parliamentary politics? If there was a motion from the conservatives saying the sky is blue, the liberals would vote against it and say, no, it's black.
00:04:11 I think it's a bit of both.
00:04:12 I think Polyev hit the nail on the head when he said, you know, there's no doubt there's a lot of the Liberal caucus that is against the pipelines, you know, the Stephen Gilboa faction and so on.
00:04:24 And Polyev says, well, Carney goes into his caucuses and says, everybody, take a deep breath.
00:04:30 We'll go out there, pretend we support pipelines, and we know it's never going to get built.
00:04:34 So let's, you know, try and all stay together and just put on a good ad.
00:04:39 Well, and the Bloc and the NDP happily joked in and joined this too,
00:04:43 who have made no bones about being opposed to the pipeline.
00:04:47 And, you know, that will help segue when we get into what we're going to talk about a bit next
00:04:50 with some regionalism going on.
00:04:52 But Smith is taking a battering over this.
00:04:54 And I'm sorry, but I'm saying rightly so to a degree.
00:04:57 You've taken this one to the bank, and he won't even verbally commit that this is going to happen.
00:05:02 As you said, it's an MOU.
00:05:03 You only have so much.
00:05:04 But it looks like they're taking us for a ride.
00:05:07 It's not that hard for Carney just to say, I want this to happen, and he won't say it.
00:05:12 Yeah, no, you know, I have to say, I wonder actually what Mr. Carney does want to happen.
00:05:19 It's sort of significant that there's only been about two pieces of legislation passed since they haven't even got the budget passed yet.
00:05:28 And he's been in office now more than six months.
00:05:32 So there is a blockage in the system with the federal government.
00:05:37 What they have done is they've given themselves permission
00:05:41 to borrow a tremendous amount of money.
00:05:44 That's the only thing that I can say, well, they did that.
00:05:48 That is irrefutable.
00:05:50 Everything else is moving along at a snail's pace,
00:05:53 some of which, by the way, I'm glad is moving at a snail's pace.
00:05:57 But at the same time, I don't actually understand
00:06:02 where the favorable opinion of Mr. Carney is coming from.
00:06:07 He makes these elaborate promises, haven't seen anything come of them yet, and yet he
00:06:13 still seems to enjoy the popular support, more even so than Mr. Pollyoff.
00:06:20 Don't forget, he got elected, right?
00:06:22 So he does have that base of popular support.
00:06:24 Well, that was a while ago.
00:06:25 Things could change.
00:06:26 Things could change.
00:06:27 I think the polls have been pretty steady.
00:06:30 You're right, though.
00:06:31 They raised the debt ceiling to $1.5 trillion, which enables them to go months more without having to defend what they're spending money on in Parliament.
00:06:42 And to the pipeline issue, Daniel Smith has to get a proponent out in front of this quickly, or else the whole deal is going to fall apart.
00:06:54 You know, as you guys have both said this, there's a lot of wishy-washy talk in the MOU.
00:06:58 But if a company like Enbridge steps forward and says, okay, we're going to take a run at doing this, then that moves at a huge step forward.
00:07:07 Then you can start maybe thinking that, hey, this may happen.
00:07:10 Because right now you're thinking this ain't going to happen.
00:07:13 So how would you incent a company like Enbridge or anybody else to take that step when you really don't know what political issues you're going to face in British Columbia?
00:07:23 Well, no. That's why you've got Bill C-5, which would declare it a national project
00:07:30 that, in theory, would brush aside any opposition from indigenous groups or the government of BC.
00:07:39 Mr. Carney has specifically said that they need to be on site, but he doesn't say
00:07:48 that they had a veto. It just implied that if they didn't agree, it probably wouldn't happen.
00:07:52 No, but as the head of a company, you could hold a press conference, Daniel Smith, and says, I commit our company to build this pipeline, and we'll have shovels ready as soon as you promise us, there'll be no stopping, and we're not going to spend a dollar before you give us that permission.
00:08:13 We'll see. It's a big chicken and egg thing. He's asking a lot to invest in a maybe. That's the problem.
00:08:19 You don't hear oil companies or pipeline companies losing money, so they know there is money to be made if they get this thing built.
00:08:27 They're making it in Qatar.
00:08:29 Well, I mean, the only news you can take to the bank from the oil industry in the last six months is that Imperial is leaving Calgary.
00:08:39 What does that tell you about industry confidence in anything going forward?
00:08:43 And I keep coming back to that story we ran about six weeks ago, talking about the actual mechanics of pumping carbon dioxide underground, which is the condition, that's the one condition that Mr. Carney has set for this.
00:08:59 You have to invest in carbon capture and underground storage if this thing is going to go ahead.
00:09:05 Well, for the kind of oil production that you're going to need to make the whole thing viable, that's an enormous expense.
00:09:12 I'm not aware of them. There are other places in the world where it's been tried on a large scale, but they haven't all done that well.
00:09:22 The only one that's going well actually is the one in Weyburn, but that's like a very small miscarriage operation by comparison with what's needed.
00:09:28 Yeah. Well, we'll watch and see. I mean, so I mean, leading into the next subject, patience is kind of wearing thin.
00:09:34 We've had an independence movement really kind of exploding in Alberta over this last eight months or so.
00:09:39 so it's always been simmering but it seems to be growing and hanging in there uh one of the
00:09:44 principles among them is is jeffrey rath and uh he's he's uh an outspoken man i guess to say the
00:09:51 least uh but uh you know all kind of intro this one he's been turning his guns on premier smith
00:09:57 uh he at the agm really brought the issue to a head waiting in line and and you know brought
00:10:03 Brought the room up on independence on those motions.
00:10:07 Then he got quite upset over a CBC interview that the CBC even retracted
00:10:11 because they claimed that Smith was going to campaign against independence actively.
00:10:19 And now over Bill 14, over the ability of Daniel Smith to appoint candidates,
00:10:26 which is the ability that actually every party leader in Canada has always had,
00:10:31 now he's calling for a hit on a pike. 1.00
00:10:32 I mean, he's basically saying we've got to organize the constituency associations and have a leadership review and potentially pull her down.
00:10:39 What's going on?
00:10:42 I'm sorry.
00:10:43 When he claims he was taken out of context, but he wasn't.
00:10:47 You know, he made these comments on the podcast and we quoted, I think we're the only one who had this story.
00:10:53 We quoted him verbatim and he sounded angry.
00:10:58 And, yes, I have enough constituency associations that we're going to top.
00:11:04 We're going to get a special general meeting, and we're going to kick Premier Smith out of her job. 1.00
00:11:08 That's exactly what he said.
00:11:10 Rob Smith, no relation to Danielle Smith, is the UCP president.
00:11:17 And he told us, Jeffrey Rath maybe knows two constituency association heads, and that's it.
00:11:23 and that he's upset because he didn't get all his people elected to the UCP board
00:11:30 and he's got no chance of doing this and this is just one vote.
00:11:35 And we ran that story yesterday and now Mr. Rath is responding again to that
00:11:40 and we'll have that story up.
00:11:43 Jeffrey's got to learn to take a deep breath before he opens his mouth
00:11:47 because these sort of outbursts are not helping the independence movement,
00:11:52 in my opinion, Corey.
00:11:54 There's a lot of things that aren't helping the independence movement,
00:11:57 but one thing I would like to hear from somebody who wants independence
00:12:01 is, all right, let's say that this little phone is Alberta.
00:12:05 It's about the right shape.
00:12:07 You've got Saskatchewan there and BC there.
00:12:11 And you're now independent and you want to export oil.
00:12:15 You're pretty sure it's probably not going to go through BC.
00:12:18 they're sticky enough with the federal government sort of suggesting that they ought to yield on
00:12:25 this there's basically one way out on which is south maybe that could be done but you're not
00:12:31 going to get the top dollar for it so what is this what is the independence option for developing
00:12:37 the oil industry i'm not saying it can't be done but it has not yet been explained in my hearing
00:12:44 as how it would be done.
00:12:47 The U.S. ambassador to Canada
00:12:49 in an interview with the National Post this week,
00:12:53 he said the MOU sounds great.
00:12:55 He says the MOU is going to enable Alberta
00:12:58 to produce a lot more oil
00:13:00 and the United States wants some of it.
00:13:03 So they've indicated their desire
00:13:07 that anything extra we can get to them,
00:13:10 they'll happily take.
00:13:11 But as you mentioned,
00:13:12 it's usually at that discounted rate.
00:13:14 The landlocked issue, I got stock answers for this.
00:13:17 I do get asked it quite often.
00:13:19 This is a way of Francisco.
00:13:21 For starters, if you look at a map of Alberta and BC,
00:13:25 you'll see that there are only four rail lines that come from British Columbia into Alberta.
00:13:30 If we got into a theoretical situation that Alberta was independent,
00:13:33 BC decided we're not going to let you export your oil through here.
00:13:36 We won't let them export their trains through here.
00:13:39 This standoff will last, I figure, six to seven hours.
00:13:43 before we're at a table negotiating.
00:13:45 In fact, we would finally have strength in negotiation
00:13:48 because the thing that I often point out to people too,
00:13:51 they say, you'd be landlocked.
00:13:53 Well, we already are.
00:13:54 We don't have anything to lose anymore.
00:13:56 This government is shutting us down no matter what we try.
00:13:59 If we were independent, theoretically, we could have leverage.
00:14:03 Likewise, yes, we do have a customer to the south
00:14:05 who would be happy to take a lot of product,
00:14:06 but that's not an ideal situation.
00:14:08 When you have a single customer, you can end up being,
00:14:11 you know, losing on a premium with things like that. And that's
00:14:15 where the patience is running out. I mean, part of the deal
00:14:18 and keeping independent minded people quiet and patient is
00:14:21 saying, well, we can work something within the Federation
00:14:24 to get it done. And that's why this pipeline is such a symbol.
00:14:27 Because if we can't even get that, then that's where people
00:14:31 are saying, well, what have we got to lose? But it's, you know,
00:14:34 it would certainly be challenged. It's not like we go
00:14:36 overnight and have a pipeline laid through BC as an independent
00:14:39 Alberta is a bullying neighbor, uh, putting the elbows out and 1.00
00:14:42 shoving them from, from our area. 0.78
00:14:43 But, uh,
00:14:44 I've heard that works, elbows up.
00:14:46 Yes.
00:14:46 Well, it's not as well as some, but I think that's part of the problem we have
00:14:50 is some crabbiness and impatience with independent supporters in general.
00:14:54 I mean, they've been spinning their wheels for a while now.
00:14:56 Uh, my view on it, I mean, again, is schedule at our referendum.
00:15:01 I said as much in the column or, you know, the tea kennels plugged up and
00:15:04 it's pressuring up people like wrath who were a little even more
00:15:08 bombastic than others but even i guess if you use the term if it's not an oxymoron moderate
00:15:13 independent supporters give them something to work on schedule that thing let them get working
00:15:19 on petitioning let them get on the ground and that pressure will come off haven't you always
00:15:24 been a proponent though that a referendum this quickly is not good for independence yeah in the
00:15:30 movement so how do you explain the oxymoron then of saying okay let's get a call out because the
00:15:35 ball's rolling too fast. No, there's too big a movement that is impatient and not, and champing
00:15:40 at the bit for this. In my view, if you don't give this outlet to it, they will form a party
00:15:46 of an effective one. I mean, there's a bunch of little ineffective ones already, but they will
00:15:49 form one that's going to pull 10 or 20%. It's not going to win, but it's certainly going to cause a
00:15:54 heck of a lot of damage. Plus if we're looking at 30%, if we have a referendum with 40%,
00:15:59 I'm still only 54. I think it's conceivable
00:16:02 if it doesn't come
00:16:04 this time, I could see it in my lifetime.
00:16:06 It's a step towards. Plus, with
00:16:08 six months of campaigning on it,
00:16:10 maybe actually that
00:16:11 ball will move closer to the end.
00:16:14 Ideally, yeah, I think it should be a couple more years
00:16:16 to work on it, but they just
00:16:18 can't anymore. It's like the
00:16:19 horses, when you see them in a gate at a race
00:16:22 and they're just ready to go, you can't keep that gate closed
00:16:24 for too long or it's going to get
00:16:26 out of hand. I would argue that your
00:16:28 movement does not want Jeffrey Rath as its main focus and spokesman.
00:16:34 So that's an issue you have to fix.
00:16:36 I don't have to, that's the Alberta prosperity projects, but I know he's
00:16:42 speaking independent sport in general.
00:16:43 I mean, that's a, it's been an interesting discussion because I'm not a member of
00:16:47 any of those groups, I'm certainly, you know, supportive of them.
00:16:49 I'll be a guest speaker at their events, things like that.
00:16:53 That group has to figure out who's speaking for them and in which capacity.
00:16:58 because there's an advantage of, I guess, not having a single
00:17:02 sole voice and that you can have different people
00:17:04 representatives speaking around.
00:17:05 But then when one goes perhaps to the point of irritating
00:17:08 even your own members, you've got to clarify who's speaking
00:17:12 for whom.
00:17:12 And yes, I don't know if necessarily my movement needs
00:17:15 to, but I think the Alberta Prosperity Project had
00:17:17 better start examining who spoke.
00:17:18 The other thing, Corey, is all the discussion surrounds
00:17:24 the pipeline.
00:17:25 there is a lot more to becoming an independent country oh yeah than that one issue that's just
00:17:33 the symbol it's a symbol it's a useful symbol but one of the unfortunate things which dave alluded
00:17:39 to very delicately is that the people who are most to the front and foremost would you really
00:17:48 follow them into independence and trust their judgment for everything that has to come next
00:17:56 the constitution how we're going to run things what are we what are we going to do about basic
00:18:01 civil liberties do we have them there's an assumption among uh independence-minded people
00:18:06 that alberta will be more free when it is removed from some of the canada you know some of the
00:18:13 structures of Canada that will have different values than those people at
00:18:17 back East who consistently elect liberals.
00:18:22 And that may be true, but it also may not be.
00:18:27 Oh, yeah, if you could make a smaller bad version of what you just escaped.
00:18:30 You know, one of the things I talk to in rooms that I speak to people is,
00:18:34 well, there's no way we embrace the Westminster parliamentary system
00:18:37 if we just managed to rip ourselves out of it. 1.00
00:18:39 That would just be idiocy. 0.96
00:18:40 I mean, if this hasn't served us, we have to examine new systems. 0.98
00:18:43 And I have some of those discussions.
00:18:46 Well, I don't actually say you could embrace the Westminster system because it's the people
00:18:50 back east who are separating themselves from it.
00:18:54 If we could just have things done the way the Westminster system is supposed to work
00:18:58 with the politicians, make the laws and the judges interpret them as they are written
00:19:03 and not according to the latest fancy that coming from the Liberal Ministry of Justice.
00:19:09 Well, the Westminster system is pretty good.
00:19:11 It's what the liberals have done with it for the whole country that makes
00:19:14 us suspicious and frustrating at all.
00:19:17 You know, I don't want an appointed Senate.
00:19:21 I don't want a centralized government.
00:19:25 Have an elected one, but have a Senate, you know, it's a...
00:19:29 But then we're getting into a new system, a bicameral one we can have without... 1.00
00:19:33 But you're right.
00:19:33 See, that shows that there does have to be discussions, nuanced ones.
00:19:36 Those discussions are not happening, as I've heard.
00:19:39 They are, but they aren't necessarily embraced.
00:19:40 It's funny. I've had, for example, Bruce Barty from Queen's University, a law professor, who's put out his very libertarian version of a very scaled-out constitution, which I think is a pie-in-the-sky level.
00:19:54 I don't know. That appeared in C2C. I think we ran a version of it here in the Western Standard when I was still at the desk.
00:20:02 And I interviewed Bruce about that, you know, as a Libertarian,
00:20:05 but I quite agreed on it.
00:20:06 I mean, very much from that, empowering the individual, you know,
00:20:10 reversing the relationship with the government.
00:20:12 But, uh, Jeffrey Rath went on a rampage about Bruce party just yesterday on X.
00:20:17 And as I said, so that's where they've got to start to centralize some of the
00:20:20 discussion, but you're right.
00:20:21 You've got to, the movement has to come up with more answers for what's
00:20:24 going to happen the day after.
00:20:25 Yep.
00:20:26 And, uh, you can't answer every one of them.
00:20:28 That's part of the problem too.
00:20:29 If you want to go into what about isn't to the point that you never have a
00:20:31 a referendum you'll never have a referendum at some point people will have to vote there's going
00:20:35 to be some question marks but the more you can feel in advance the better you'll get the confidence
00:20:39 of citizens right now as we said if we voted tomorrow it's not going to do well it's it's
00:20:45 there's much more to be done but if you have six eight months of a campaign on independence we'll
00:20:49 see what surfaces you know and you think right now the the leading the pro-canada side would be
00:20:55 Tom Lukasik.
00:20:55 Well, there we go.
00:20:56 Lukasik versus Rath.
00:20:59 The stories will never end.
00:21:02 That'd be a nice, cool and rational discourse.
00:21:08 He's certainly got nicer hair than Jeffrey.
00:21:11 Well, I mean, this is the only place I'll give Thomas credit.
00:21:13 I mean, he's got nicer hair than most of us.
00:21:15 He's one in the hair.
00:21:16 Yeah.
00:21:17 Well, listen, if we're going in the hair stakes, we've had nicer
00:21:19 hair and it hasn't got us anywhere.
00:21:21 No, no.
00:21:22 We had that in Ottawa for more of time.
00:21:24 and that's it, that pay off.
00:21:25 He's prancing around with Katy Perry now.
00:21:29 All right.
00:21:30 Well, let's see.
00:21:32 Nigel, perhaps you want to lay down Bill C9.
00:21:37 So, look, what's happening in Canada right now
00:21:41 is that the Liberals, for the last five years,
00:21:43 have been trying to control the Internet,
00:21:47 and they've put out seven bills,
00:21:50 which two just fell by the wayside,
00:21:53 two got passed uh one died on the order or the paper as well and they've got a couple out this
00:22:01 session that's bill two and bill eight and then there's still nine and what bill nine is strictly
00:22:10 speaking not about controlling the internet it's about it's a as marketed as an anti-hate bill
00:22:19 and so this is the bill for for people who are following this at a distance
00:22:23 This is the bill that would make it illegal to raise a Nazi flag on your flagpole in your backyard.
00:22:33 Now, I'm not aware that, you know, only cross burnings are more unlikely than that.
00:22:40 I mean, people just don't do that.
00:22:42 So you have to ask, why is this the object of legislation?
00:22:47 I have a suspicion that the answer lies not in Alberta, but in Quebec, where the Quebec government is anxious about its own people and some of the extremes of hatred that they're experiencing back there.
00:23:06 But anyway, this Bill 9 has hit the national news, and apart from the swastika, there is one amendment that has been pushed by the Bloc Quebecois, which you know they're very anti-religious symbolism.
00:23:30 if you were a muslim you're not supposed to wear your muslim gear to work if you're a christian
00:23:35 you're not supposed to display your cross and they want to make it that you cannot use
00:23:46 your sincerely held religious beliefs as a defense if you are accused of saying something unkind 0.82
00:23:55 about homosexuals, the gay lifestyle 1.00
00:24:00 to which the Bible has a number of references
00:24:04 so if you are
00:24:07 pulled before a human rights commission
00:24:09 and you say well I pulled my kid out of school
00:24:13 because I didn't like what they were teaching
00:24:14 and they say well that's discriminatory
00:24:18 and you say well that's my sincerely held religious belief
00:24:20 up to this point you are okay
00:24:22 if this bill passes as amended
00:24:26 then you would not be okay now the justice minister sean fraser is trying to say no well no
00:24:34 he makes various promises about how this thing will be fenced in and it's not going to be the
00:24:38 problem you think it's going to be and i don't doubt that he's perfectly sincere in his assurances
00:24:43 it's just that he cannot he is not in a position even as minister of justice to give those
00:24:48 assurances because you don't know what happens to this legislation when it comes before the courts
00:24:53 on the judges start thinking for themselves well it seems pretty pretty off to me i think you're
00:24:59 guilty you know well but the minister said oh i said that two years ago you know now you're
00:25:05 in front of me so it's a very serious issue of religious freedom that's on the line here with
00:25:11 bill c9 um it's uh it's dangerous and what that has to do with the internet is this people use
00:25:21 use the internet to put their opinions out, you do.
00:25:25 Oh, certainly.
00:25:26 I do.
00:25:28 You have opinions.
00:25:29 I try and keep them neutral.
00:25:30 You try and keep them to yourself.
00:25:32 But the thing is, people may wish to comment on things related to trans, LGBT, and you
00:25:42 know, a lot of people don't like that, but we believe in free speech in this country,
00:25:49 and therefore we do what we do.
00:25:51 However, if somebody who says, well, I said what I said because I actually believe what it says in the Bible,
00:25:58 now you can't say that anymore, or that's the intention of the act.
00:26:01 And so it's going to have the effect of cramping free expression on a lot of things.
00:26:09 People are not going to want to take the chance of getting too close to these issues.
00:26:14 And that's where this bill of C9 works together with Bill 2,
00:26:20 which makes it possible for the government to walk into your internet supplier's office
00:26:29 and look at the files and see who you've been corresponding with
00:26:33 and what sites you've been, without a warrant.
00:26:36 And then, yeah, so it goes on.
00:26:39 It's a real tightening of the grip, and it's been going on for about five years, been fits and starts, but it's relentless.
00:26:47 So, Dave, I mean, you know, in news, you see this maybe as a solution looking for a problem, though?
00:26:52 I haven't heard a lot of cases of people using a religious defense if they've been…
00:26:57 No, I can't remember.
00:26:59 That was a very good, long, Derek-like explanation of the…
00:27:03 Somebody had to do it.
00:27:04 So I appreciate it.
00:27:05 Yes, I appreciate it, because you certainly know more about it than I do.
00:27:07 But does it, would it mean that a priest in a pulpit who reads scripture, somebody in the congregation could say, well, I really don't agree with that and make a complaint.
00:27:20 Yes, it does.
00:27:20 And that priest could end up in trouble for just reading the Bible.
00:27:25 You could get into trouble as a pastor just by objecting to a drag queen story hour if you live in Calgary.
00:27:32 So, yes, you absolutely bet there will be keeping an eye on what's said from the pulpit.
00:27:36 But, you know, a lot of pastors preach the Bible.
00:27:39 They start at Genesis and they go through to Revelation.
00:27:41 So there's going to be some places where they've got to deal with it
00:27:44 or else admit that you're afraid to deal with it.
00:27:47 Well, something that would really, truly put this to the test, though,
00:27:50 I could see some busybodies trying to charge a minister or so on for saying it.
00:27:56 I dare one of them to take an imam for quoting the Koran. 1.00
00:28:01 Because it's supposed to apply to that, too.
00:28:03 Yes, it does.
00:28:04 you bet they wouldn't dare for a second.
00:28:07 And I tell you what, I mean, any ancient religious text
00:28:10 doesn't, you know, stand up to the measure of what's considered acceptable today or not.
00:28:14 That's just the nature of it. These are written thousands of years ago.
00:28:18 We just interpret that as older thinking and don't practice,
00:28:21 perhaps, you know, stoning people and all those goodies that are packed into the Old Testament.
00:28:26 We can leave it at that, typically.
00:28:29 If there's any area where they seem to be working on the literal interpretations
00:28:32 and wanting to bring it in it's coming more out of islam than anywhere else yet that's the one
00:28:36 area they won't touch no and you're you're right cory there there's some amounts that there's a
00:28:40 guy in victoria i think who whose name is case right but he spews hateful hateful rhetoric on
00:28:46 a weekly basis and i know there's been complaints made but he hasn't been brought up before before
00:28:52 any court any board uh you know and you know he calls for wiping out of israel and really very
00:29:00 very anti-Semitic stuff that is quite vile. And Cory's right, everybody's afraid even to go with him.
00:29:07 That's a very negative attitude.
00:29:08 It is, it is. And you're right, Cory. Once again, it'll be Christians who are bearing 1.00
00:29:15 the brunt of it while Islamics get off scot-free. 1.00
00:29:20 I'm just, you know, I'm of the free speech mind. I mean, I don't have to like everything
00:29:24 that I hear from every faith or what they put forward, but it's their right to do it. And I
00:29:27 I will counter it through discourse and go from there.
00:29:30 I just see this as a showing as well.
00:29:32 If they're going to be selective with the application,
00:29:34 well, they shouldn't apply it at all.
00:29:36 But if it's selective, this is really a worthless piece of legislation.
00:29:40 Amen.
00:29:41 If I may say that.
00:29:42 Praise the Lord.
00:29:43 Inshallah.
00:29:46 Let's start with the Parliamentary Budget Officer.
00:29:48 He's recanting.
00:29:50 Yes.
00:29:51 Jason Jax is his name.
00:29:53 He's the interim budget officer.
00:29:56 By all accounts, doing an exceptional job.
00:30:03 When the Liberals first brought down their budget, he called it shocking and unsustainable.
00:30:09 And stupefying.
00:30:10 And stupefying.
00:30:12 And he's now obviously had a word in his ear and walked back his comments and is now saying,
00:30:19 oh, yeah, all right, it might be sustainable.
00:30:21 So, yeah, somebody got one.
00:30:23 Yeah, well, I mean, this takes you back to the budget discussion.
00:30:26 You mentioned before how the government had extended its credit limit to 1.6, 1.5, at any rate, you know, when the Liberals took office in 2015, the national debt was about $600 billion over COVID plus a year, they managed to get it up to 1.2.
00:30:51 They doubled it.
00:30:53 And, you know, I thought it was wrong, but a lot of people would probably forgive them for saying, well, we had to get through, we had to get ourselves through COVID.
00:31:01 I think it's a poor argument, but at any rate, that's the one they went with.
00:31:05 Well, now, Mr. Carney comes in and says, we can do another 25%.
00:31:10 So this is borrowed money, and ostensibly, it's so that we can develop Canada.
00:31:16 There were all these big projects, pipelines, for instance.
00:31:20 You know, this is how this extra money is going to be used,
00:31:24 and there was a very strong commitment made to national defense.
00:31:28 I think it was $80 billion.
00:31:30 Well, that's great, except that we don't know how to buy equipment in this country.
00:31:36 So whether that will ever get spent on defense
00:31:38 or whether it will be diverted to something else, we don't know.
00:31:42 Point is that the parliamentary budget officer looked at this and said,
00:31:46 This is stupefying, you know, and he said so out loud, and then he got whacked and said, well, maybe I was a little hard on them, but we know what he really thought, because he said what he really thought, and you know what?
00:32:04 It was what a lot of other people were thinking without necessarily having the expert knowledge that he had to be able to go out into the public square and point the finger.
00:32:13 Well, he did.
00:32:14 and it's it's also created problems with looking for his replacement the the finance committee down
00:32:22 in Ottawa passed a motion that they want to interview any candidates for this job just so
00:32:28 they can see what he thinks money-wise and and whatnot and they were shut down by the Privy
00:32:34 Council office there's no chance you're not gonna you're not gonna get a chance to interview any of
00:32:39 these nominees.
00:32:41 Well, that's what we've pointed out.
00:32:42 He is the interim parliamentary budget officer.
00:32:45 What, then what would his motivation be in recanting?
00:32:50 Is he pursuing, you know, that job as the full time, you know, trying to
00:32:54 unburn the bridge that he did when he dared to criticize the horrific budget
00:32:59 that was placed before him?
00:33:00 I mean, why are you not sure that he's not ready for retirement.
00:33:04 So even if he is only the interim parliamentary budget officer,
00:33:10 he still has 20 years to work or 15 years or something like that.
00:33:14 And he has chosen to make his career in the civil service.
00:33:19 Well, I guess he's not looking private because I mean, you know,
00:33:21 that coming from that role, if you had a principal controller in a corporation,
00:33:26 actually a lot of companies would seek that out.
00:33:28 Hey, you're willing to say the emperor has no clothes and we could use that.
00:33:33 Just to show you what kind of job he's doing, the Canadian Taxpayers Federation on Monday released their naughty and nice list.
00:33:41 So leading off the naughty list was Doug Ford, quite rightly, and leading off the nice list was Jason Jax.
00:33:50 They were just thrilled with the job he's doing in holding on the water account.
00:33:54 It could also be that, you know, here's a man who's been decades in government and second by everything that he saw.
00:34:03 I mean, I don't know the man, so I'm just making this up as I go along.
00:34:06 But it could be that he just said, you know, I've got a chance to actually say what I really think for once and for all.
00:34:12 Had his mad as hell and not taking any more moments.
00:34:15 Yeah, one of those moments.
00:34:16 But he didn't carry forward with it.
00:34:17 He's unfortunately settled back.
00:34:19 A rare moment in the civil service.
00:34:21 Somebody actually speaking the truth.
00:34:25 Well, it's just unfortunate because it is an important role to have somebody who will at least speak up on these things somewhat candidly.
00:34:31 And they're making it clear that we want a yes person to fill that role in the future that the Privy Office will choose.
00:34:37 And it's just going to be a useless.
00:34:39 Reading what he said carefully in his recant, I got the impression that he was not actually recanting what he found,
00:34:47 merely saying that he could have been more circumspect in how he made his report.
00:34:53 And perhaps that's so.
00:34:54 It was certainly an unusual expression of grim determination for a civil servant.
00:35:03 But, hey, that's great.
00:35:05 Well, Auditors General, we see that quite often, too,
00:35:08 when they actually poke into an area that the government doesn't like
00:35:11 and suddenly the pressure's on to move them out of that position, too.
00:35:15 They really want neutered senior bureaucrats. 1.00
00:35:17 when it comes to watching their own activities and it's not a you know to be fair it's not just
00:35:21 liberals who are like that no government likes it when somebody's poking into their misdeeds
00:35:27 but it's just in the last 10 years those supervisory agencies have been so much
00:35:32 busier than they were oh boy i mean uh where was it the arrive can is that ever gonna nobody's
00:35:41 Nobody's ever going to pay a price for that, are they?
00:35:43 Well, RCMP is still investigating, but you and I will long be in the retirement home
00:35:49 for journalists before anything happens.
00:35:52 Just speaking of federal agencies that are neutered.
00:35:55 I mean, come on, how many years does it take you when there's such clear fraud?
00:35:58 You know, if it was you and I doing it in the private market, oh, don't we, we'll all
00:36:00 be handcuffed already and out the door, but they're just ragging the puck. 0.99
00:36:05 Yeah.
00:36:06 Well, I believe they were friends of the government.
00:36:10 The RCP, that's a separate discussion all into itself.
00:36:16 Why don't we move a little provincial?
00:36:17 We've got a new party leader in Alberta has appointed himself.
00:36:22 That's right.
00:36:22 And as a sitting member, he becomes the Alberta Party's only sitting MLA.
00:36:28 Peter Guthrie, MLA from Erdry, was booted out of the UCP caucus earlier for basically complaining about the procurement scandal.
00:36:39 and he'd been a sort of a needle in the side of Daniel Smith for a while.
00:36:44 So he moved over to sit as an independent
00:36:46 and now has joined forces to lead the Alberta Party.
00:36:52 I guess he's not on his own.
00:36:53 He's got Scott Sinclair there with him as well.
00:36:57 Yeah.
00:36:57 Has Scott moved to the Alberta Party
00:37:00 or is he just sitting as an independent?
00:37:01 I believe he's with them.
00:37:02 I believe he's moved over, yeah.
00:37:04 But Guthrie's declared himself the leader of this two-person caucus.
00:37:08 Yes. So, well, I mean, so they have the Alberta Party, and according to what you were printing
00:37:18 earlier, the idea is that they're going to do whatever they have to do to call it the
00:37:24 Progressive Conservative Party. I guess an earlier attempt to just take that name was
00:37:30 resisted by the UCP, which still has the rights to the name. But really, however they knew
00:37:38 maybe the new party they should have a new name i don't know but what uh the what the game is here
00:37:44 is that they want to give what they call sort of a more centrist um option to people who want to
00:37:52 vote in the next election well i'm not sure that this i'm not sure that anybody in alberta has
00:37:59 asked for a centrist option there are some people who want separation independence and there are
00:38:07 people who are going to back up daniel but danielle smith but nobody has said if only there was
00:38:13 somebody who was just you know like he used to be 40 years ago a little corrupt but not too corrupt
00:38:20 you know a little malleable look like you're doing something but not actually do anything
00:38:26 too too drastic because actually we're all very good at doing big things so let's just keep the
00:38:32 bills paid and move ahead and give out the proceeds of the oil patch, except the proceeds
00:38:38 aren't there anymore.
00:38:39 So it's an odd sort of thing.
00:38:41 Well, the Alberta party has just sat there as a home for homeless MLAs for four or five
00:38:47 election cycles saying, we're running in the middle.
00:38:49 We're the happy middle.
00:38:50 Albertans want the middle.
00:38:52 And they get electorally obliterated every time.
00:38:55 Two percent support, three percent support.
00:38:57 The media treats them as if they're viable, but the electors never do.
00:39:01 Yeah, 2023 election. The Alberta Party of 2023 got 12,576 votes. The UCB got 928,900. Even the Greens got more than the Alberta Party. Maybe it was weak leadership, but under Mr. Guthrie, things will be different.
00:39:22 but Stephen Mandel led them. A few people have gone through it. I mean,
00:39:27 to give him the long history of that, what that vessel has been, some trivia, but I was, that was
00:39:32 the very first provincial party I was a member of. I was on the board. Myself and some board members
00:39:38 marched off and formed the Alberta Independence Party. Then we turned around to try to get
00:39:42 registered status by trying to take over the Alberta party, and we failed. But the Alberta
00:39:47 party has been used for exactly that by other groups year after year they take over that withered
00:39:52 board and they get party status then they turn it into what they want to and then they they fail
00:39:57 i mean the problem here is that they're never going to win no but they have the power to take
00:40:04 the win away from the ucp and make room for you know how many how many uh seats would they have to
00:40:11 flip for the ndp to uh to to to come in i mean the one that govery is in uh was it airdrie cochran
00:40:20 yes cochran whatever just looking at the uh looking at the numbers here it would be a bit of
00:40:27 a fluke if uh if having a progressive conservative auction in that particular uh writing was going
00:40:34 constituency was going to upset the situation.
00:40:39 Well, there are a number where, you know,
00:40:42 lose a couple of thousand votes and change the party.
00:40:45 The very last thing we need is Premier Nahid Nenshi.
00:40:48 Well, there's something to keep in mind.
00:40:50 Despite what the Alberta Party always claims,
00:40:52 part of why they always get rejected as well is really when it comes out to
00:40:55 policy-wise, they almost always land pretty far to the left.
00:40:58 So if anything, they might end up pulling votes from Nenshi.
00:41:01 Don't assume that they're going to pull from the Conservatives.
00:41:04 Uh, voters have seen through that, so we'll see.
00:41:08 Either way, they're a known entity.
00:41:09 Yeah, at this point.
00:41:10 If they were a color, they'd be beige.
00:41:13 Forgettable.
00:41:15 All right.
00:41:15 Well, let's try about to be too forgettable.
00:41:17 We'll move on with the, uh, parting shots.
00:41:20 I guess I'll start at the end with Dave.
00:41:21 What do you got?
00:41:22 I'm going to use my parting shot to plug my friend Nigel's show,
00:41:26 Hannaford show, tomorrow night, exclusive interview with Premier Daniel Smith.
00:41:30 Must watch TV.
00:41:33 Thank you very much, Dave.
00:41:34 I was going to say the predictive capacity of the Hanford show is remarkable.
00:41:39 Last week we interviewed a lady who was leading a charge in Canada
00:41:46 to cross legislation that you have to be 16 years old
00:41:50 before you can get access to social media.
00:41:53 Well, bless my soul, I really picked up the paper this morning.
00:41:56 Australia has just done that.
00:41:59 I thought, well, this is an interesting idea,
00:42:01 but I don't know how practical it is.
00:42:03 well, if the Aussies can do it, but we can.
00:42:06 It would be a workout.
00:42:08 It's a, enforceability is a challenge with that sort of idea, but I mean,
00:42:11 they're the principles.
00:42:12 Okay.
00:42:12 They don't necessarily need those accounts.
00:42:14 To that point of enforceability, the first thing I thought of is that my
00:42:19 guest told me that in actual fact, they can tell, they being the social media
00:42:26 company, they can tell, they know who's got a credit card and who doesn't.
00:42:29 And you know, who has, who's only been online for six months and so forth,
00:42:36 probably a kid, you know, and then just the deal doesn't go through.
00:42:40 Interesting idea.
00:42:41 Yeah.
00:42:42 Well, there's certainly pretty prescient.
00:42:43 I mean, I swear I drive it along the road and I'll just think to myself,
00:42:45 geez, I'm creating a Mars bar and suddenly the next dad that pops up through
00:42:48 Meta, I'll be one for Mars bars for some bloody reason.
00:42:50 They know us better than we do.
00:42:52 They sure should be able to figure out who's under 16. 0.99
00:42:56 They probably can.
00:42:57 Marty Masters. So, I mean, before I get on to my Let You Go, though, with you having, being able to bend the ear of the Premier, you've got a couple of things you can hint at where you might want to go in that discussion with her?
00:43:09 You know, I haven't even had that discussion with her staff, and I'm not going to have that discussion with her staff. So if I tell you today...
00:43:22 Oh, I don't want you to give any spoilers to keep her off guard.
00:43:26 I think the thing that everybody wants to know is where do we go from here?
00:43:32 Yeah. Well, hopefully she's got some good answers. I'm sure we'll all be tuning in for it.
00:43:36 Yeah. I think we're going to do it at eight o'clock, not seven o'clock though. We just
00:43:41 need that extra hour of production time. So if you are likely to tune into the Hannaford Show
00:43:49 at seven o'clock, give it an hour. It's past my bedtime.
00:43:53 Take yourself a bowl of chips and some cocoa and watch the Hannaford Show.
00:44:02 You can't not now that you've promoted it.
00:44:03 No, I don't.
00:44:04 All right.
00:44:05 I'm trying to stay awake.
00:44:06 I'm certain if there was a late Seahawks game, you wouldn't miss it.
00:44:08 No, I'm not.
00:44:09 All right.
00:44:10 All right.
00:44:11 To myself, I just wanted to point out, yeah, I saw in the National Post,
00:44:14 this is stuff that's been going on.
00:44:15 And the B.C. court has ruled B.C. laws must be interpreted through the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous People, UNDRIP.
00:44:26 I mean, B.C. already kind of, you know, embraced, said we're going to model it.
00:44:30 But now we've got the courts actually saying you have to follow that.
00:44:33 People have read that vile document, and it is vile.
00:44:36 Again, if you think that my cause as an independent supporter is hopeless, keep bringing stuff like this in and see how long this nation's going to stick together.
00:44:45 But B.C., boy, are they ever got a serious problem.
00:44:49 So what happens when you want to remortgage your house?
00:44:51 Well, if you're in Richmond, you're pretty much out of luck.
00:44:54 Yeah, we're seeing those stories popping out,
00:44:55 businesses that are canceling developments
00:44:57 because they can't get their financing behind it
00:44:59 because the status of the ownership of that land now is unsure.
00:45:02 And some individuals have been popping up saying,
00:45:04 we're trying to renew our mortgages, and the bank's saying,
00:45:06 nah, sorry, we're not committing to give you 20 more years
00:45:09 because we don't know if you're going to own it in a few years or not.
00:45:12 Crazy.
00:45:12 But that's B.C. crazy.
00:45:14 at least we can hide from a little bit over here yes no craziness in alberta no i'm here
00:45:20 all right well thank you very much dave and nigel uh for helping us cut through some of the crazy
00:45:26 and uh yes i'll close it off and thank everybody else for tuning in and as dave said make sure to
00:45:31 tune in to nigel's interview it's going to be great and subscribe to western standard that's
00:45:35 how we pay the bills we uh aren't getting all those tax dollars like some outlets are anyways
00:45:40 So keep us independent.
00:45:42 Check it out.
00:45:42 Westernstandard.news.
00:45:43 Slash subscription.
00:45:44 $100 for a year.
00:45:45 $99 for a month.
00:45:48 $9.99 for a month.
00:45:50 Always going to hang just under $10.
00:45:51 It's a special, isn't it?
00:45:53 Yeah, there is a special.
00:45:54 Check out the website and see what you can get.
00:45:56 Get a deal while you can, guys.
00:45:58 So if you're subscribed already, thank you very much.
00:46:00 We really do appreciate it.
00:46:01 If you haven't yet, get on it and buy a subscription for one of your friends or kids.
00:46:05 It's spreading information and independent thought.
00:46:08 Thank you very much.
00:46:09 and we will catch you on the next one.