Western Standard - September 21, 2021


LIVE: Election Night 2021

Topics
Mentioned
PPC Rally in Strathmore Alberta Alberta doctor says hospital capacity numbers manipulated by AHS

Episode Stats


Length

6 hours and 3 minutes

Words per minute

156.56

Word count

56,857

Sentence count

2,837

Harmful content

Misogyny

41

sentences flagged

Toxicity

21

sentences flagged

Hate speech

30

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

A special election edition of the Western Standard's election edition featuring a Western Canadian perspective on the campaign trail. Hosted by Dave Naylor, Corey Morgan, and Shauna Lane, the three hosts are joined by a special guest to discuss the candidates and the issues at stake tonight.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 .
00:02:00 .
00:02:30 .
00:03:00 .
00:03:30 .
00:04:00 .
00:04:30 .
00:05:00 .
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 Good evening.
00:06:43 Today is, what is it?
00:06:46 September 20th.
00:06:47 It's election day.
00:06:48 Voting day.
00:06:48 I can never remember.
00:06:49 It is September 20th.
00:06:51 It is election day in Canada, or at least the East is voting.
00:06:55 Yes.
00:06:56 We're voting, but, you know, we'll see what's going to happen.
00:06:58 Thank you very much for joining me tonight.
00:07:00 We're very excited to have you here on a special edition.
00:07:04 This isn't not even the pipeline.
00:07:05 This is just an election special.
00:07:07 We've got a really great program set up for you tonight,
00:07:10 focused on a Western Canadian perspective for election 2021.
00:07:17 I'm joined, as usual always, by the intrepid news editor of the Western Standard, Dave Naylor.
00:07:23 Top of the evening to you, Dave.
00:07:24 It's going to be a long one and a good one.
00:07:26 I think at some point the water might get replaced by beer.
00:07:29 We endeavor to keep things at least half in the bag, or half out of the bag, I should say, throughout the evening.
00:07:37 We do need nourishment.
00:07:40 We've got Corey Morgan, our Alberta political columnist, in studio with us, always adding some color.
00:07:46 Corey is also going to be co-hosting with me tonight.
00:07:48 It's going to be a long evening, so we're going to be rotating duties.
00:07:52 We're starting off here together, but Corey or I will be, at least one of us, will be here at all times hosting this evening.
00:08:00 But we've also got a lot of other really great guests coming on.
00:08:04 Coming to us from British Columbia, we have Aaron Gunn, who is a leading conservative and libertarian activist in that province.
00:08:14 Someone who's come to a fair bit of prominence lately from BC.
00:08:17 We also have Shauna Lane, who is with the Western Standard, acting as a correspondent for us there.
00:08:23 In Alberta, we have Jonathan Dennis, who is the former Alberta Minister of Justice and Solicitor General.
00:08:29 He'll be joining us from the Calgary campaign headquarters of the Conservative Party of Canada.
00:08:35 We'll have Vitor Marciano coming to us from Edmonton.
00:08:37 He is a longtime political strategist, former chief aide to both Danielle Smith and Brian Jean,
00:08:46 two former Wildrose leaders.
00:08:48 We've also got Franco Teresano coming to us from Ottawa.
00:08:52 He is the former Alberta director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation,
00:08:55 and he is now the federal director of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation.
00:08:59 He'll be trying to give us an Albertan's perspective from Ottawa, if that makes any sense.
00:09:05 And last but not least, we've got Clinton DeVoe.
00:09:08 He's coming from us somewhere in the Atlantic.
00:09:10 Halifax.
00:09:11 Halifax.
00:09:11 Good Halifax boy.
00:09:12 I like Halifax people.
00:09:14 We're also going to be speaking with some of the candidates out there tonight,
00:09:16 By checking in with them, we have Michelle Rempel of the Conservative Party of Canada, 0.96
00:09:21 the Conservative candidate for Calgary Nose Hill, will be joining us live, Jay Hill, leader
00:09:26 of the Maverick Party, Maxime Bernier, leader of the People's Party, and Nadine Wellwood,
00:09:32 a People's Party candidate in the riding of Airdrie Banff.
00:09:37 And I'm sure we'll probably have some others pop in from time to time as things come up
00:09:40 and we see what transpires tonight.
00:09:43 So I think we're going to have a fascinating show coming to you from our new fancy studio.
00:09:49 Look at all the space in here.
00:09:50 Oh, yeah.
00:09:51 Great.
00:09:52 Not even touching your leg for a change.
00:09:53 Well, some things get worse with time.
00:09:58 So yeah, we're set up now.
00:10:03 I guess actually the first thing we're going to start off with, I'm going to ask every
00:10:06 guest when they first come on is predictions for the evening.
00:10:09 We're going to take, actually, I'm not sure we can do it because we have the first results
00:10:13 It's coming in now.
00:10:14 So actually, we're really just going to do results of the three of us or predictions
00:10:17 of the three of us because it's just too early.
00:10:20 Nothing is crazy happening right now.
00:10:23 Liberals are leading with seven seats and the Conservatives with three in the Atlantic
00:10:27 provinces.
00:10:28 But these are very early numbers.
00:10:29 So it's still fair enough, I think, to make predictions we haven't seen too much yet.
00:10:33 So really, it's just going to be the three of us with our predictions for the evening.
00:10:35 The loser buys the beer, runner-up buys the pizza.
00:10:40 I'm not sure which will be more expensive tonight.
00:10:43 So, Corey, what do you think is going to happen?
00:10:47 I am regretfully forecasting an increased liberal minority with a conservative opposition.
00:10:56 The NDP, of course, will hold the balance of power, and the bloc will hold their own.
00:11:00 The green are going to get decimated.
00:11:02 I think they're going to get skunked.
00:11:05 And it's a toss-up.
00:11:07 I think perhaps the PPC might take one seat.
00:11:10 I would hope to see maybe a surprise here and there with some strong individual candidates.
00:11:14 I think they're going to make some surprising showings and some excellent ones.
00:11:18 I just am not confident they're necessarily going to be able to get over that hump and pull in seats.
00:11:21 You said NDP holding the balance of power.
00:11:23 So are you predicting the NDP will have more seats than the block?
00:11:26 I believe so.
00:11:28 Wait a minute.
00:11:28 Where are we sitting now?
00:11:30 Right now the block is the third block.
00:11:31 Yeah.
00:11:31 No.
00:11:32 No, I'm sorry.
00:11:32 It's going to be pretty much similar to what we're at.
00:11:34 I think that the Liberals are going to pull in a couple more seats from each side there.
00:11:38 Okay.
00:11:38 But not enough for a majority, I don't think.
00:11:40 So you're predicting the NDP is in fourth?
00:11:42 Yes.
00:11:43 And are you predicting that the NDP would have by itself enough to hold a balance of power with the Liberals?
00:11:49 I'm getting confused. You're getting all mathy.
00:11:51 Okay, well, I'll let you figure that out.
00:11:53 They're going to have a minority and they're all going to fight. 0.99
00:11:54 Dave, what do you think is happening tonight?
00:11:57 I was talking to a gentleman I consider the most smartest man in politics.
00:12:02 He's an Ottawa insider.
00:12:03 Oh, you're kind.
00:12:04 And he is predicting, and I will join him in predicting, a handsome conservative minority government.
00:12:13 I think they'll have a safe minority.
00:12:18 I think the Liberals will lose out in B.C.
00:12:23 I think they'll lose some seats in Atlantic Canada.
00:12:26 I think the NDP will gain a few seats off the Liberals.
00:12:30 And unfortunately, I don't think the PPC will win any seats.
00:12:34 But they'll do well. They'll finish second in some...
00:12:37 This is extra points in case we have a tie on some issue.
00:12:40 Predicting how many seats for the greens and the NDP will get you some points.
00:12:44 So green, you say zero seats for the PPC. How many seats for the greens?
00:12:47 Zero green, zero PPC, 37 NDP.
00:12:51 Okay, so Melanie, who is helping produce tonight's show with our operations director, James.
00:12:58 Melanie, you want to keep track of these numbers here.
00:13:00 We have to see who pays for the beer tonight.
00:13:01 All right.
00:13:02 So Dave says, a healthy, handsome conservative minority with no green and no PPC seats.
00:13:13 Correct.
00:13:14 Corey says, an increased liberal minority?
00:13:16 Yeah, I don't want to say handsome when it comes to the liberals, no.
00:13:19 Would you say robust?
00:13:20 Robust, certainly.
00:13:21 I do think they're going to have more seats than they went in with, but they're not going
00:13:25 to get that majority they want.
00:13:26 Are the conservatives going to gain or lose seats?
00:13:30 I think they're going to lose a couple.
00:13:32 Okay.
00:13:33 And the third party is?
00:13:34 Third party, I guess the block.
00:13:35 Oh, who's your third party?
00:13:37 Oh, the block.
00:13:38 Block, block, and green and PPC seats.
00:13:43 I'm going to go out and say one PPC, zero green.
00:13:46 We can hope.
00:13:48 Hope.
00:13:49 Okay.
00:13:50 I suppose after that, now that I've gotten your bets, the good thing is the hedge in the
00:13:54 middle.
00:13:55 That's right.
00:13:56 Price is right strategy.
00:13:57 Yeah.
00:13:58 I'm going to go with a reduced liberal minority.
00:14:03 Actually, first I'm going to just preface by saying
00:14:05 there's no such thing as a minority government
00:14:09 technically on an election night
00:14:11 because the party with the most seats
00:14:13 does not get to form the government.
00:14:15 Andrew Scheer was lying through his teeth
00:14:17 when he said that, and he knew it.
00:14:18 He was a Speaker of the House.
00:14:19 He knows these rules.
00:14:21 It is more often than it is most of the time
00:14:24 the party with the most seats gets to form the government,
00:14:26 but it is actually the party or the person or group of MPs who can hold the confidence of the House.
00:14:33 So just if, even if the Conservatives have a plurality of seats,
00:14:36 that does not necessarily mean that they get to go and form the government on Tuesday.
00:14:41 Justin Trudeau is still the Prime Minister Tuesday,
00:14:44 and if he can continue to hold the confidence of the House of Commons, he will remain the Prime Minister.
00:14:49 So that was just my way of saying, if the Conservatives have the most seats tonight, but not a minority,
00:14:54 Unless they're really just shy of a majority, then they're almost certainly still the government.
00:14:59 But if the conservatives have the most seats, but not all of the, not a majority,
00:15:08 we're going to call that a conservative plurality.
00:15:10 And same with the liberals, although the liberals have an easier time
00:15:13 because they have more ideological dancing partners in parliament than the conservatives do.
00:15:17 So this is a roundabout way of saying, I think we're going to see a reduced liberal minority.
00:15:22 I think the Conservatives, they're going to be right around where they're at right now.
00:15:29 I'd chance the Conservatives might lose a little bit along the edges.
00:15:32 Not a lot, but I can see the Conservatives potentially losing a couple of seats.
00:15:38 The Bloc, I think the Bloc will remain the third party, but the NDP are going to see
00:15:43 very significant gains.
00:15:44 The NDP is going to have a very good election.
00:15:46 They could even see themselves as the third party.
00:15:48 It's not inconceivable.
00:15:48 people. I think we'll see one green seat. And I know our, we've got a lot of people.
00:15:57 He's on deck.
00:15:58 Oh, ah, there we go. I think we're going to see, I think we're going to see at least
00:16:06 one PPC seat. I have a feeling Max will eke it out and boast. We'll see what else happens.
00:16:13 We just don't have enough electoral history yet with the PPC to see where that support
00:16:16 concentrated we know there's a lot in alberta but it's quite possibly too spread out to be
00:16:21 concentrated and get a seat um so we're going to turn uh now to our first speaking of the ppc we're
00:16:27 going to turn to our first guest of the evening uh we have on the line with us uh people's party of
00:16:34 canada leader maxime bernier um we'll bring him into the stream now um bonjour how do you do max
00:16:45 yes great thank you very much very pleased to be with you well thank you very much for having us
00:16:51 um how are you feeling in boast tonight do you think uh you're going to be coming back to
00:16:56 represent uh the long time writing of yourself and your family i hope so i spoke with my team
00:17:04 right now i'm in saskatchewan for the election night but i spoke with my team today over there
00:17:09 in votes it's going very well when we started the campaign over there we were 10 points behind and
00:17:16 now we are in the margin of error so i believe it will be a tight race and we'll see the results
00:17:23 but like i said in the beginning of this campaign we want to grow our percentage of the vote all
00:17:29 across the country and i think it will happen tonight uh interesting decision to spend election
00:17:37 night in Saskatchewan. You've spent a lot of time in the West. You've spent more time in Alberta than
00:17:43 all of the other party leaders combined. Probably, I'm going to guess almost 10 times over. You've
00:17:49 spent quite a bit of time here. I know you were in Strathmore Saturday, Calgary Sunday,
00:17:56 really making your way around the prairies here. My question is, are you concerned as the Green 0.86
00:18:03 party, say, was building up. I mean, a somewhat, obviously, a radically different party than
00:18:07 yourself. But as the Green Party was building up, you know, it was trying to get votes across the
00:18:12 country. But when they won their first seat, they actually had a reduced amount of number of votes
00:18:18 when Elizabeth May won her first seat because they concentrated on her constituency on Vancouver 1.00
00:18:23 Island just outside of Victoria. Are you concerned that while your party has seen a very significant
00:18:29 increase in the polls you're probably going to outdo your 2019 numbers many times over but are
00:18:35 you concerned that the the vote is perhaps not concentrated enough to yield a seat in the house
00:18:40 of commons maybe we don't know but you're right that our party is popular now all across the
00:18:48 country and that's what we wanted to create a real national political party across the country
00:18:54 I was looking at the public polls today and in Canada, we're supposed to be at 14 percent.
00:19:01 In Alberta, the same thing. In Ontario, it's going very well. We are around 10 percent there.
00:19:07 Yes, and we'll see that's an important step for our party and for us that would be an historical
00:19:14 election. If we went from 1.6 to 6, 7, 8 or 10 percent of the votes, that would be a huge victory.
00:19:22 don't forget after 38 years now the Green Party is around 4% in the polls and if after three years
00:19:30 we are able to have on average across the country six seven eight percent that would be great and
00:19:36 we'll build from there but you are right to say that we don't know if we are more popular in the
00:19:43 region or in another one in Alberta it's going very well and yes I was there and also I spent a
00:19:50 a lot of times also in Ontario, in southern Ontario, northern of Ontario, we have a lot
00:19:57 of support there. So we'll see what will happen. But for me, the most important is this political
00:20:03 party will be there and we will build from that result of tonight. I'm going to throw it to Corey
00:20:10 in one second. But actually, before I do that, I just I have another question. After yourself,
00:20:17 I'm asking you to rub your crystal ball here for a second.
00:20:21 After Boats, if the PPC was to win a second seat, where do you think that would be?
00:20:28 I know you've got some strong campaigns running around the London, Ontario area with Chelsea Hillier. 0.99
00:20:36 Obviously, there is significant strength here in Alberta.
00:20:40 But after Boats, let's say you do well tonight and you win Boats, where do you predict your second seat comes from?
00:20:46 It would be very difficult to predict because we don't do any internal polls,
00:20:53 but I can tell you, you're right, Chelsea Hilliard, she's very popular in Alberta.
00:20:59 We have great candidates, but as you know there, the competition is huge with the conservative
00:21:05 when they're winning by 70%. But I can tell you that more and more people are fed up with the
00:21:11 conservative party with the united right at the provincial level so i don't know what can happen
00:21:17 but i hope we'll have a seat also or two in alberta we we don't know but for me like i said the most
00:21:25 important is to grow our percentage of the vote all across the country and that's an important
00:21:31 step and after that we'll know a little bit better and we'll be ready because after this election
00:21:36 for us it's only a new beginning we'll be back i will be back also across the country
00:21:43 uh working and building that that party because i believe that it
00:21:51 oh i think we've had a little trouble with max's feed
00:21:58 uh okay until we get max back here uh hopefully we can get this figured out
00:22:02 Okay, we're going to throw to Corey here.
00:22:07 Yeah, well, and I just want to say I appreciate you being out here lighting the prairie fire that you have
00:22:12 because the West and the prairies have been neglected and ignored, and we do get tired of that.
00:22:18 And I believe, you know, it's been appreciated.
00:22:21 Those rallies have been impressive.
00:22:23 You've been bringing issues to the table that other parties won't touch.
00:22:26 You're most definitely going to make a mark on this election no matter how things come about.
00:22:30 And you were kind of starting there, though.
00:22:31 So you've started, you're going to have a foundation after this election, a base,
00:22:36 but you're still really going to have to build that.
00:22:38 Is there going to be plans for a convention and more formal organization
00:22:43 and such for your party going forward?
00:22:45 Because it is difficult between elections.
00:22:47 Absolutely, absolutely.
00:22:48 What we want to do, we want to build a strong organization all across the country.
00:22:53 That would be my first task after this election, to be sure to build on that momentum
00:22:58 and to be ready for the next election.
00:23:02 Actually, like I said, this party is there for the long term.
00:23:05 And yes, you're right to say that we are speaking about issues
00:23:09 that are important for Western Canadians,
00:23:11 but also for all the country.
00:23:14 You know, when you have people in Alberta that are ready to separate,
00:23:18 I believe that it is important to speak about, you know,
00:23:21 changing the equalization formula to be less generous,
00:23:24 being sure that we'll build pipelines.
00:23:26 That's important for the prosperity of our country, but also for the unity of our country.
00:23:34 Max, we had some fun with predictions a few minutes before you came on.
00:23:40 All pundits seem to think it's going to be a minority.
00:23:44 The question is, will it be liberal or conservative?
00:23:48 Do you have any predictions early this evening?
00:23:51 I really don't know. You know, I'm concerned. I'm working about our party and I know that it would be a minority government. But for me, a conservative minority or liberal minority, it would be the same. They have the same platform on climate change. It will impose a carbon tax on pipelines. They won't do anything to build pipelines on mass immigration, on vaccine passport. They offer a mandatory vaccine passport.
00:24:19 So they're the same for me, a conservative minority or liberal minority, that would be the same.
00:24:26 I believe that the PPC will be the real opposition after this campaign, because with our platform, we will be the real opposition and we are speaking about the real issues for Canadians.
00:24:40 Max, you've obviously really tapped into the movement around mandatory vaccine passports and lockdowns.
00:24:48 lockdowns, that has very much propelled your campaign forward. I mean, your party has gone
00:24:53 from, I mean, most polls had the party, but somewhere between one and two percent, really
00:24:58 when the RIT dropped to the lowest polls have you at six percent, the highest polls have
00:25:03 you just a little over 11 percent right now. I think very much driven by the lockdown and
00:25:12 mandatory vaccine passport issues, but we're going to be coming, I mean, every election's
00:25:18 got its own set of issues.
00:25:20 After this election, what do you think is going to, eventually COVID will go away.
00:25:25 I'm terrified that in two years, we're still going to be dealing with this.
00:25:29 I'm not terribly optimistic that this is going any way, anytime soon, but let's say that
00:25:34 in a year from now, we're beyond this and vaccine passports have been dropped, lockdowns
00:25:41 a thing of the past what is the what are the issues that you're going to press on to be able
00:25:46 to kind of keep this momentum going because clearly these issues have massively propelled
00:25:53 interest and excitement for your party going forward but those issues are eventually hopefully
00:25:59 going to go away so what is it you're going to be focusing on when we get past this but you know we
00:26:05 are running right now on the same platform that we had in 2019 and that would be the same one at
00:26:12 the next general election because we are doing politics differently because we base the foundation
00:26:18 of this party on four principles individual freedom personal responsibility respect and
00:26:23 fairness and you are right to say that this campaign the focus was uh on the violation of
00:26:29 our rights and freedoms and we are the only political party that is speaking against the
00:26:34 vaccine passport so yes we have a lot of support and because of that we were we were able to be
00:26:43 known with more canadians that was a big challenge for us before this election so for the next
00:26:48 election that would be the same platform and i don't know maybe the focus will be on immigration
00:26:54 next time. Maybe it will be on balancing the budget. But we will always have the same platform
00:27:00 at every election until we win our battle. And we need to have, like I said, an ideological
00:27:07 revolution in this country. We are going to the left. We are a socialist country right now.
00:27:13 We have four socialist political parties. And we need to do this battle of ideas and to win that.
00:27:21 I don't know what will be the focus for the next election, but for us, people can look at our
00:27:26 platforms and we will always fight for a clearer and a more prosperous country.
00:27:33 Max, before I let you go, I want to ask you about the impact of Alberta Premier
00:27:39 JC Kenney in this campaign. I know it's had a significant impact in Alberta, I think,
00:27:44 for voters on left and right, and some pundits are suggesting outside of Alberta,
00:27:50 And you certainly had some words for the Alberta Premier while you were in Strathmore and in Calgary.
00:27:56 What impact do you think the actions of the Kenney government and their about face on things like vaccine passports and a fourth lockdown,
00:28:07 what impact do you think this has had on your campaign before I let you go?
00:28:11 Well, I believe that now people understand that Jason Kenney that supported O'Toole for this campaign
00:28:17 and Jason and O'Toole are the same on the mandatory vaccine passport, and both of them
00:28:24 are flip-flopping on every important issue. Now O'Toole on every important issue for Western
00:28:30 Canadians is like the Liberals, so he won't fight for Western Canadians, and that's why I believe 1.00
00:28:37 that we have more and more support. So, O'Toole just shows us that he's not a conservative anymore
00:28:44 like who too well max thank you very much for joining us and being generous with your time
00:28:50 this evening uh good luck in the boats and uh i guess where you are right now in the west thank
00:28:56 you thank you i appreciate that have a nice evening au revoir okay well uh we're gonna go
00:29:03 to an update on the numbers right now uh gabe why don't you give us a breakdown i think uh
00:29:09 the polls are only uh showing any results only in the atlantic right now yeah right now we're
00:29:15 getting results from newfoundland and nova scotia in the last election the liberals took 27 seats
00:29:23 the tories four and the ndp won right now the the writings that are coming in we've got the liberals
00:29:31 at an even dozen Conservatives for an NDP-1. So still a few more regions coming in from
00:29:40 Atlantic Canada, but it's pretty well going as expected at the moment, I think.
00:29:46 Where, so this is Newfoundland and Nova Scotia, right?
00:29:50 Correct.
00:29:51 Okay. These are obviously, at least Newfoundland has been traditionally, at least in the last
00:29:56 few cycles, a liberal stronghold. Why don't you give us a lay of the land in, actually you know
00:30:02 who we have. Oh, we don't have anymore. We have Clinton DeVoe coming. He's coming a little later.
00:30:06 I think he was testing his link. Okay, we're gonna have Clinton DeVoe giving us some Atlantic
00:30:09 update. Our next guest is gonna be in 20 minutes, Jonathan Dennis. So actually, Mel, why don't you
00:30:18 pull up the map, show us where we're at right now. And we're gonna have Josh Andrus is gonna
00:30:25 to join us with some thoughts soon.
00:30:27 And I think you'll take us through Jonathan Dennis
00:30:29 and I'll be back in time for Mr. Vitor Marciano.
00:30:32 Sure.
00:30:33 So let's pull up the map, put up the board
00:30:35 and let's see where we're at.
00:30:41 Pull up the big screen, all the way.
00:30:44 There we go.
00:30:48 Yeah, sorry, I'm just trying to make
00:30:52 this Elections Canada website work.
00:31:00 I'll zoom in a bit here.
00:31:02 Yeah, my poor eyes, my poor eyes.
00:31:05 So you guys are ahead of the Elections Canada site.
00:31:09 You got 15 Liberals leading,
00:31:12 Conservatives five, NDP one.
00:31:15 As you say, Derek, it looks like
00:31:18 Newfoundland is staying solidly liberal.
00:31:22 Nova Scotia's got a little bit of Tory blue in it.
00:31:30 Where is that NDP seed?
00:31:37 Shout it out, Mel.
00:31:38 Where's the NDP seed?
00:31:40 A little chunk of red down in the...
00:31:42 Oh, the little chunk of red.
00:31:43 Or is that liberal?
00:31:44 Why is the NDP red?
00:31:46 No, there should be an orange piece.
00:31:48 Should be orange.
00:31:49 Should be orange.
00:31:49 All right, ignore that red.
00:31:51 That's, oh, there it is. Holy cow. It's really tiny.
00:32:00 So certainly it looks like the Conservatives are now leading in one more seat than they had a disillusion.
00:32:10 So the Ottawa insiders are saying the Liberal campaign out in the Maritimes is a bit of a mess at the moment.
00:32:18 and they're expecting to lose up to three Liberal seats.
00:32:23 Apparently the fisheries minister's seat is in play.
00:32:29 Well, and I see actually we do have Clinton DeVoe in the lobby,
00:32:33 you know, and we're talking about the Maritimes
00:32:34 and those results that are starting to trickle in there.
00:32:38 Clinton's from Halifax.
00:32:39 He's been on our shows a number of times.
00:32:42 He's quite the poll watcher.
00:32:44 Let's bring Clinton in and see what he's got to say.
00:32:48 How are you doing, Clinton?
00:32:49 Good evening.
00:32:50 Pleasure to chat with you folks out west.
00:32:52 How are things going so far?
00:32:54 Well, so far so good with, you know, we've got a great viewership.
00:32:58 We've got a lot to look forward to and a lot to talk about.
00:33:01 And in the usual nature of Canada, we're going to be moving from east to west.
00:33:05 So what are your, I guess we'll start with your predictions.
00:33:09 I mean, Dave just ran through what's kind of coming in, but they're pretty early numbers.
00:33:12 What do you figure is going to happen on the east coast there?
00:33:14 Well, look, for the Conservative Party of Canada to have a good night, it needs to win the riding in Newfoundland of Bonavista-Burin-Trinity.
00:33:24 So that's a riding where there's a strong conservative candidate that's well known in the community.
00:33:30 It's a riding that in the past has voted conservative on a number of different elections.
00:33:36 And if we're going to see the conservatives win a minority or a majority government, it's going to have to start in that riding.
00:33:44 The other thing that we need to see happen is the riding of St. John's East.
00:33:50 So that's a riding which used to vote Liberal.
00:33:55 It became a new Democratic Party stronghold in Newfoundland.
00:34:00 And the Liberals really want that riding.
00:34:03 So if the Conservatives can win Bonavista, Burren, Trinity, and the Liberals can lose St. John's East,
00:34:11 That could be the start of a potential change as we work our way west.
00:34:20 In Nova Scotia, there's a couple of ridings that the Conservatives need to pick up and hold.
00:34:26 So the federal riding of West Nova is one the Conservatives desperately need to hold on to.
00:34:33 The other one to look for in Nova Scotia is Cape Breton Canso.
00:34:38 It's an incredibly important riding for the Conservatives.
00:34:40 Again, they have a popular candidate.
00:34:42 And if they're going to start to change the tide in this country blue,
00:34:46 that's another one of those key ridings that they need to pick up.
00:34:50 And another riding to look for is Colchester Muscat-Aubit.
00:34:54 So that was former Conservative MP Bill Casey's old riding,
00:34:58 who eventually became a Liberal.
00:35:01 So those are the first steps in Atlantic Canada.
00:35:05 The other spot to look for is in the province of New Brunswick.
00:35:08 There's a provincial party there that's called the People's Alliance New Brunswick.
00:35:13 They have a strong critical mass of supporters and they have an infrastructure there,
00:35:19 infrastructure base within their organization.
00:35:22 And there's a well-known former progressive conservative MLA by the name of Jake Stewart,
00:35:29 who the conservatives are pinning their hopes on in order to pick up a seat in New Brunswick.
00:35:35 i've also been hearing that the people's party of canada is polling quite strongly
00:35:40 in the province of new brunswick and that's something we want to watch for if they get into
00:35:44 double digits in that you know 10 or higher uh they could deny jake stewart the riding of mayor
00:35:51 and that would be devastating for the conservatives because they need to
00:35:55 start developing momentum in atlantic canada as they work their way west
00:35:58 yeah well it's everything's a battleground when an election's this tight i mean
00:36:07 the polls there's been so many uh not too many outliers of course pollsters have been kind of
00:36:13 hit and miss when it comes to elections this last few years as well uh you know cell phones have
00:36:16 really thrown a mess into their ability to reach a broad spectrum do you feel the the polling is
00:36:22 going to hold its own tonight well uh you know what that's uh i guess that's anyone's guess right
00:36:29 now so uh the liberals are desperate to uh hold on to their base in atlantic canada it's i mean
00:36:35 let's be honest it's a it's a huge amount of seats they have here and it can make the difference
00:36:38 between a minority or majority government and the liberals are actually hoping to pick up
00:36:43 a couple of those seats so west nova which is currently held by the conservatives they do want
00:36:47 to pick that up. And look, if the People's Party of Canada can create a vote split in Miramichi,
00:36:55 in all likely that riding will remain Liberal. So there's a lot at stake here in Atlantic Canada,
00:37:00 and it could be the difference between a minority or a majority government.
00:37:04 Well, they're the first numbers in. So we're looking at 20 Liberals,
00:37:08 five Conservative and one NDP at this time. But it's very early, of course,
00:37:12 and things can shift as different polls come in. So we'll be looking forward to checking in with
00:37:17 you periodically as those come in and those numbers solidify and we'll see what kind of race
00:37:21 we got. Great. Thanks for having me on. Looking forward to chatting with you guys later this
00:37:25 evening. Excellent. Thanks, Clinton. Okay. So we've changed our lineup while Clinton was in there and
00:37:32 we have Josh Andrus in who's been working with Project Confederation. Yes. Okay. So many groups
00:37:39 now it's hard to keep track. So we've had Clinton give us kind of an Eastern update. What kind of
00:37:44 update or what are we looking for for the West? That's your specialty here.
00:37:48 Well, obviously the key question is how well does that PPC vote come in? Early returns from
00:37:55 the East, at least that I've seen, indicate that the NDP is coming in under what they were polling
00:38:00 at. So if the PPC continues to pull or manages to pull strong numbers from the CPC in the Western
00:38:10 Canada, it will potentially create a situation where the Liberals could pick
00:38:15 up more seats than we originally anticipated. Again, this is very early in
00:38:19 the process. The Maverick Party is another outlier here. They're coming in
00:38:23 polling at roughly 2% from what we've seen. If they can poll 5-6%,
00:38:27 again, they're polling from the Conservatives, so it might lead to
00:38:32 more Liberal seats. That being said, for most of the Western Canadian ridings
00:38:36 you're looking at very strong conservative numbers they're bringing in set 80 75 80 percent a lot of
00:38:45 these ridings so it'll be really interesting to see how these two parties impact the results and
00:38:50 whether or not early returns from the NDP coming in lower impacts the liberals check in with Dave
00:39:00 Do you realistically see the PPC picking up any seats in the West?
00:39:06 No, but I think from their point of view, if they're pulling enough from the Conservatives
00:39:12 that it puts them on the map, I think it's good for them.
00:39:15 The big thing is that I think there's a strong protest vote, especially in Western Canada.
00:39:21 The Conservatives seem to be using this strategy to try and pull as many votes in Ontario and
00:39:28 Quebec, and it's an interesting strategy because it is going to lead to bleeding in
00:39:34 Western Canada.
00:39:35 We have a very strong right-leaning conservatism brand that's popular in Alberta, especially
00:39:43 rural Alberta, Saskatchewan, and places like that.
00:39:45 So I think realistically, if there's riding so the PPC comes in second, in a strong second,
00:39:50 I think that's a result that they should be very proud of and very happy with.
00:39:54 How do you assess the Maverick Party's campaign?
00:39:57 in? Personally, I liked a lot of their policies. I didn't see a lot from them. I don't want
00:40:05 to be too critical on the air, but it seemed a little lackluster in some areas. But at
00:40:10 the same time, I think this really became a COVID election. Western alienation wasn't
00:40:15 a topic that really was at the centerpiece of a lot of conversations, whether it be at
00:40:20 the coffee shops, the bars, or on live television. So it's one of those things where as we head
00:40:26 into getting results from Western Canada,
00:40:29 we're still a couple hours away.
00:40:30 It'll be interesting to see where they come in.
00:40:31 But then again, there is strong undercurrent
00:40:34 of Western alienation that has really been
00:40:38 on firm display over the last two years in Alberta.
00:40:40 So it'll be interesting to see
00:40:42 if the Maverick can pull above that 2%,
00:40:44 if they can get 10%, 15%, or even finish
00:40:47 top three in some of these ridings.
00:40:49 I think that's a huge win for them.
00:40:51 The Reform Party didn't win any seats
00:40:52 their first go-round either.
00:40:54 The protest vote sometimes takes
00:40:56 a couple of election cycles to manifest itself into something that we can really, well, reform
00:41:01 did end up sweeping the West in 93, but it was their second full election campaign, so
00:41:05 it took a while.
00:41:06 And what's your prediction for the night?
00:41:08 I think it'll be a liberal minority, I think 154, 155 seats to 120 for the Conservatives
00:41:16 with the 30 to 35 for both the block and the um ndp with the greens maybe pulling one out and i don't
00:41:27 i i hate to say it but i don't think the ppc is going to be strong enough to win anything
00:41:32 okay well and to segue i'll just respond to one comment or two too is confused perhaps thinking
00:41:36 you know that we're claiming western alienation isn't an issue i mean it most certainly is and
00:41:41 it's been one for a long time and it's going to be it just hasn't become an election issue in this
00:41:45 one. I mean, you know, Jay Hill and the Maverick have been out there, but it's just been overwhelmed
00:41:50 by the COVID events, the other things that it just didn't quite hit the docket like it would
00:41:54 have typically, but it's not going away by any means. No, definitely not. I mean, it is, it's
00:41:59 something that is on the forefront of people's minds, but given the events of the last couple
00:42:03 months with the case numbers coming up, with public health officials coming out crying,
00:42:07 you know, on CTV news or on global news, and you've got, of course, Joe Vipond out there
00:42:15 doing his thing you've essentially created an environment where people are going to be going
00:42:19 to the ballot box and the one thing on their mind is going to be do i want to be stuck in my house
00:42:24 locked inside for the next four months or do i want to vote for something that really
00:42:33 you know isn't the direct issue right now and i think this is going to be the covet election i
00:42:39 think that's why we've seen the surge in the ppc it's not the western alienation isn't an issue
00:42:44 It's just that's the ballot box question this time around, especially when it comes to that protest vote.
00:42:48 I think one of Maverick's biggest challenges is the existence of the PPC.
00:42:52 I know that there's a lot of overlapping policy, but it's just one of those things where until those two parties can find a way to work together,
00:42:59 it might be challenging for either one of them to break through in much of Canada.
00:43:04 Well, it's hard to get the COVID out of your mind when you go to vote when you've got to put a chin diaper on in order to go in and do it.
00:43:10 So it is literally in your face when you go to cast your ballot.
00:43:14 So you can't help but think about it.
00:43:15 You know, I'm just going to break for a second.
00:43:17 I mean, something that's been interesting that keeps coming up, though,
00:43:19 the big factor in this election that's different is the PPC coming up,
00:43:22 perhaps the Mavericks seeing what they do.
00:43:24 But what's been interesting is the development's been through alternative media.
00:43:27 You know, he's come in under the radar.
00:43:29 He hasn't gotten coverage from the conventional media.
00:43:32 And just as our own pat on the back to ourselves in the sense that the world is changing.
00:43:35 The parties are changing.
00:43:36 We can see them come up without coming through the conventional channels.
00:43:39 It might be Maverick.
00:43:40 It might be others.
00:43:41 And I want to thank, you know, the hundreds of people who are tuning in right now
00:43:44 and more coming on all the time, our subscribers.
00:43:47 The Western Standard is out there.
00:43:48 You know, we don't have to have the conventional media anymore.
00:43:51 And just to those who are listening, you know, be sure to share this.
00:43:54 Share the link to this.
00:43:56 Let's get people on here. 0.98
00:43:57 Let's get people watching this.
00:43:57 We don't have to watch that dirty old CBC cover this, even though we have to pay for it.
00:44:02 Share that link.
00:44:03 We do think of you as the Rosie Barton of the Western Standard.
00:44:05 Well, thank you.
00:44:06 I can't wait for Rosie Barton to call the election for the Liberals
00:44:11 because I think it's going to be way too early when she does it.
00:44:14 She's been stumping pretty hard for them this entire campaign.
00:44:16 Oh, yeah, no, it is interesting.
00:44:18 I do at least get some dark comedy out of watching her blow kisses at Justin 1.00
00:44:22 during any interviews, but that's where our tax dollars go.
00:44:25 So, I mean, I just want to thank those who subscribe to The Standard already
00:44:28 and, again, just kind of appeal to the other people out there.
00:44:31 You know, we've got an election night.
00:44:32 We've got millions of Canadians watching,
00:44:34 and be sure to contribute and help in and share this link
00:44:38 so other people come in and we just keep building this foundation
00:44:41 so that we can get direct information to Canadians, Western Canadians
00:44:44 through the standard and all that good newsprint.
00:44:47 So that's enough patting ourselves on the back there.
00:44:49 Dave, have we got some new numbers?
00:44:50 Yeah, I can do a bit more of a rundown on Atlantic Canada.
00:44:55 Prince Edward Island, solidly liberal.
00:44:58 All three seats have gone the grit's way.
00:45:02 Moving to Newfoundland and Labrador, Liberals are winning or leading in four seats, Conservatives
00:45:10 two, NDP one.
00:45:12 Nova Scotia is a race between the Liberals with seven seats, it looks like, Conservatives
00:45:20 three and the NDP one.
00:45:23 And last but not least, New Brunswick, Conservatives three, the Liberals seven.
00:45:30 So add them all up, and which Elections Canada has nicely done for me,
00:45:34 it's the Liberals leading or ahead in, elected in 19, Conservatives 8,
00:45:41 the NDP 3, which seems to be a fairly significant increase for the Conservatives.
00:45:48 And the NDPs also gained two seats out of there, and the Liberals seem to be down quite a bit.
00:45:55 Well, I mean, if we can look at the Maritimes as a bellwether,
00:45:59 we might see a bit of a trend here.
00:46:00 The Liberals are getting nibbled at.
00:46:01 I mean, that's kind of a stronger area for them.
00:46:04 We know the Conservatives probably won't dominate out there,
00:46:07 but if they can pick up some seats, as Clinton was saying,
00:46:09 that's going to be quite a significant coup for them in this election.
00:46:14 It will, obviously, early days in the vote counting
00:46:17 and all the usual, you know, it's not over yet until it's over.
00:46:25 No, and it sure is nice to know nowadays.
00:46:27 You're probably too young to remember, Josh,
00:46:29 but it used to be that you'd have to pick up the phone
00:46:32 and phone somebody in the East Coast to get those election results early.
00:46:35 It was a criminal act.
00:46:37 You were not allowed to find out how anybody voted
00:46:40 until your time zone closed its polls.
00:46:43 The world has changed, though.
00:46:44 Do you think that impacts how people vote nowadays?
00:46:46 Do you think people look at some of the...
00:46:48 Because that was the fear.
00:46:49 They're going to look at these results coming out of the East.
00:46:51 In the next two hours, they got left to vote in Alberta,
00:46:53 or three hours in BC,
00:46:54 and they're going to cast their ballot based on what they saw
00:46:57 is a trend happening out there i i'll just ask somebody who never had to deal with that would
00:47:00 you think that that'd be a factor i i don't think i don't necessarily think so i think this is one
00:47:05 of those elections that most people have had their mind made up for a while there hasn't really been
00:47:10 any events well minus the ppc's the purple wave as it's called um but it is interesting given like
00:47:19 i mean i've read articles of people standing outside the calgary herald office in 1911 waiting
00:47:24 for election results massive crowds back when reciprocity was the issue and it's one of like
00:47:29 i think we live in in the information age where information is available at the tip of your
00:47:35 fingers wherever you are whereas you know 20 30 years ago even that wasn't the case so the internet
00:47:40 has definitely made information much easier to come by and uh but i mean live live live uh
00:47:48 live feeds aren't that easy to come by so I'm hoping that maybe we're shifting
00:47:54 some decisions here. I know polls close here I think is what is it 7 30 so.
00:48:00 Is it 7 30 or 8 o'clock? 7 30 or 8. It's usually been 8.
00:48:05 If you haven't voted yet, get down there.
00:48:09 So maybe just to catch up because that's something that's gonna be
00:48:12 different tonight too. We've got a whole lot of mail-in ballots that we
00:48:15 typically didn't have and advanced polling and advanced polling is usually
00:48:19 counted the night of the election but it's usually the last ones to come in but
00:48:23 they believe the mail-in ballots are gonna take a few days and I think it's
00:48:25 just a million they've said several days so you know we could be in theory if
00:48:30 it's close several days away from knowing who who wins certainly there'll
00:48:35 be some seats that are close enough to require that that mail-in boat so yeah 0.88
00:48:41 Yeah, they say Elections Canada, two or three days
00:48:43 until they get all those votes counted.
00:48:46 And mail-in ballots were way up, way up.
00:48:49 Well, I believe we'll have a very good idea by the end of the night
00:48:52 where we're sitting, though.
00:48:53 So I see our next guest is coming in here.
00:48:55 Jonathan Dennis is in the lobby over there.
00:49:00 Many Albertans know Jonathan from his time in provincial office.
00:49:03 I believe he was our Solicitor General is the role there.
00:49:07 Justice Minister.
00:49:07 Justice Minister, okay.
00:49:09 I knew I had to mail my speeding tickets to somebody with that sort of title or name or
00:49:13 something like that. How are you doing tonight, Jonathan? I'm doing well, and listen, if you have
00:49:16 more speeding tickets, I can represent you now. That's right. Jane just pays them for now, 0.74
00:49:23 but if I get too many, we might have to come to that yet. So we've been kind of hitting everybody
00:49:28 with it. You know it's got to come. What are your predictions? Where do you think we're going to
00:49:32 head tonight? Give us your ballpark, Jonathan. I'll tell you this. This is probably the closest
00:49:37 election in any of our collective lifetimes here. It's too close to call. The one thing
00:49:43 I'm going to put my money on is a minority government. Politics is becoming more and 0.79
00:49:46 more polarizing. And as we see some of the results from Atlantic Canada, some like really
00:49:51 razor thin margins here, it's very certain to have recounts in multiple writings. I am
00:49:59 concerned about the increased use of mail-in ballots. They've always been somewhat
00:50:03 controversial. My concern always with mail-in ballots is
00:50:07 the ultimate secrecy is behind the ballot box
00:50:11 where an individual goes in. You don't know exactly who the mail-in ballot's
00:50:15 going to. If the person's subject to undue influence, we don't know.
00:50:19 The best option is still an X on the piece of paper.
00:50:23 Steve, you got any questions for Jonathan while we got him?
00:50:28 Jonathan, can you talk about the effect that
00:50:31 premier kenny had on this uh election campaign well it's uh i'll tell you this i say this as a
00:50:37 uh conservative party federal supporter and a ucp supporter provincially uh the pandemic response
00:50:43 has been abysmal i uh the pandemic uh response in the province of alberta has managed to efficiently
00:50:51 uh upset uh people on the left right and center i have not met one person who is happy with the
00:50:57 pandemic response some people want more restrictions some people want less restrictions
00:51:01 but the most important thing is that the it appears that there's a real instability in the
00:51:07 whole government as a result of of the pandemic response and it's the instability of any government
00:51:13 that paralyzes it and frankly plays into the ndp's hand here um the fact that i see mr kenny who
00:51:20 who I've known for many years, listed as a factor by both federal and even the municipal campaign here
00:51:28 by candidates on the left as a negative, he's kind of become a lightning rod here.
00:51:33 Why do you think the PPC has got a purple wave in Alberta?
00:51:39 So the PPC, first off, the PPC is kind of the Maxine Bernier party.
00:51:44 And I know he was on here earlier. I've met him a few times.
00:51:47 There isn't a constitution in the party.
00:51:49 It's really what he goes and dictates, but it is attracting a lot of disaffected Conservatives.
00:51:54 The question I always ask myself, are these votes that would not show up at all?
00:52:00 Or are these votes that are bleeding off of the Conservatives?
00:52:04 I don't think the PPC will elect a single seat tonight, but it remains to be seen if the PPC is actually a vote spoiler and ends up electing Justin Trudeau in some writings, like some of the mainstream media has been predicting.
00:52:17 Do you think it's a case that they'll bleed from the Tories, or will they stir the usual non-voters, those who don't normally go and vote?
00:52:29 I will take the Abraham Simpson quote from The Simpsons, a little from column A and a little from column B.
00:52:34 In Alberta, if they bleed off 5, even 10%, that's still probably enough to elect a full swath of blue candidates,
00:52:42 with the exception of Edmund Stratkona, which will likely go back to the NDP.
00:52:46 What I'm worried about is that the PPC is strong enough in Ontario.
00:52:50 They're likely not strong enough in Quebec.
00:52:52 And you see Maxime Bernier showing up in Alberta and not in his own riding of votes,
00:52:57 likely knowing that that's a lost cause.
00:52:58 If the PPC gets beyond about 5% in Ontario, you may very well see a vote split there
00:53:04 and fewer Conservatives elected.
00:53:07 Again, it remains to be seen.
00:53:09 We're an hour away from the polls closing and I'm waiting with beta breath.
00:53:11 okay and uh do you think kenny was deliberately hidden by the federal conservative party they
00:53:19 didn't want him around at all and it was only when alberta the the covet crisis uh you know
00:53:26 reached its pick that he was he was forced to come out and make some sort of statement well
00:53:32 dave you make a very interesting point because if you look at the beginning of aaron o'toole's
00:53:35 leadership, which, full disclosure, I did support, was contributing to the campaign.
00:53:41 Kenny had endorsed O'Toole, and that was not an issue.
00:53:44 But you didn't see him over the last couple of months.
00:53:47 So when I look at a politician, talk is cheap.
00:53:50 What he or she may say may be fleeting and maybe just a puff.
00:53:54 You look at their actions.
00:53:55 And the reality is, is that I do think the federal party did see the pandemic response
00:54:01 in Alberta as a negative.
00:54:03 And the fact that you saw both Jagmeet Singh and Justin Trudeau invoke the pandemic response in Alberta as a negative does tell you that both the Conservative campaign and the Liberal and NDP campaigns felt that the record in this province was a liability.
00:54:23 And again, some people want fewer restrictions, some people want more restrictions, but it seems to me that he was kind of behind a rock and a hard place.
00:54:33 What's coming out now just doesn't really endear a lot of confidence in anybody.
00:54:39 Let's talk about Calgary and Edmonton, Alberta's two big cities.
00:54:44 Do you see the Conservatives losing their iron grip in Calgary and seeing more Liberal seats?
00:54:51 So my prediction in Alberta is that you will see a complete sweep of the Conservatives with one exception, and that is an Edmonton-Straff corner where NDP MP Heather McPherson, I think, will win with quite significant spread.
00:55:08 The NDP really has put a lot of their efforts into Edmonton-Straff corner.
00:55:12 An NDP source of mine has told me that they were looking at Edmonton-Griesbach as well.
00:55:16 I know that popular city councillor George Chahal is running for the Trudeau Liberals in Calgary's northeast, in Calgary Skyview.
00:55:26 My calculus on this is that the local candidate really matters very little in the grand scheme of things.
00:55:32 It looks at the demograph of the riding, the leader and the party.
00:55:36 And I just think that being a Trudeau liberal in Calgary has such a negative, present and historical connotation that Jag Sohota will win in Calgary Skyview again.
00:55:48 Interesting. Corey?
00:55:51 Yeah, I guess my question is regarding the Tories' much ballyhooed shift to the left.
00:56:00 Do you think that's impacting the purple wave?
00:56:04 And do you have any thoughts on that?
00:56:07 The reality is that the Conservatives ran a stronger campaign in the beginning.
00:56:13 If you look at the average polls, and I'm not talking the websites, but just the average polls towards the end,
00:56:18 the Liberals have really caught up.
00:56:20 And at the end of the day, I do think ultimately, unfortunately, the edge does go to the Liberals because their vote is more efficient.
00:56:27 And Alberta, Saskatchewan, Eastern B.C., you see wide spread for the Conservatives.
00:56:35 It is going to be a little lower this time because O'Toole's tried to appeal more to Ontario at the expense of Western Canada.
00:56:42 But I still think the Liberal vote is a little more efficient this time around.
00:56:49 If Justin Trudeau has a minority, of course, he has the first opportunity under the Constitution to try to form government.
00:56:57 the one thing worse to me than a Trudeau majority would be a Trudeau minority propped up by the NDP
00:57:04 and just letting you know, this is my wallet. I'm hanging on to it.
00:57:08 All right. Well, you had a question for Jonathan?
00:57:12 No. Okay. Well, thank you very much for coming in with us tonight, Jonathan.
00:57:15 It's going to be a really interesting night to watch.
00:57:20 And Corey, I'm coming back at you three hours back from my home, just west of Calgary.
00:57:26 Let's go over on how my predictions are.
00:57:32 Certainly.
00:57:32 Okay, so let's pull up the map, and we will be seeing you in a little while there.
00:57:35 Jonathan?
00:57:36 See you in three hours.
00:57:37 Take care.
00:57:38 Great, thanks.
00:57:39 All right, we've got a few more results coming in from the Maritimes.
00:57:43 I've got a total of 32 seats now counting.
00:57:50 Liberals ahead were elected in 23.
00:57:53 three Conservatives elected are ahead in eight, the NDP in one.
00:58:00 So again, that seems to be a pickup of several seats for the Conservatives.
00:58:09 They only had four last election and it looks like they're doubling it to eight.
00:58:15 So the Atlantic Canada is starting out not a good evening for the Trudeaus down there. 0.62
00:58:22 And it looks like Derek's back in the host chair and bringing in another guest, Derek.
00:58:31 Yeah, we're going to wait a second just to bring up Vitor Marciano.
00:58:37 Josh, right now I think we're seeing some, yeah, Josh, we're seeing some gains for the
00:58:42 Conservatives in Atlantic Canada.
00:58:44 I mean, the Atlantic has traditionally been, you know, a typical red Tory area.
00:58:53 Is this a sign, do you think, that O'Toole's pivot to the left, pivot to the center, if you will, is succeeding and that we might see replicated across the GTA?
00:59:03 Yeah, that's a definite potential opportunity.
00:59:06 It worked for the provincial, I think it was the provincial Tories in Nova Scotia with their health care platform at the very beginning of the federal election campaign.
00:59:18 That being said, yeah, if it does pull in at the 905, we could be looking at a conservative minority, but we're still early in the process.
00:59:27 We'll see how it goes from here.
00:59:29 Well, let's bring in Vitor Marciano for his analysis right now.
00:59:34 Vitor Marciano was the, I guess, various hats he's worn,
00:59:40 but he's essentially been the chief aide to the two major Wild Rose leaders
00:59:45 in the history of at least the first party named Wild Rose,
00:59:48 Danielle Smith and Brian Jean.
00:59:54 Welcome to the show.
00:59:56 Thank you for having me, Derek.
00:59:57 It's going to be an interesting and historic night.
01:00:00 yeah well I appreciate you joining us I mean there's a few people I think who are at least
01:00:06 has got a political analysis in Alberta but we're going to get you put your hat on
01:00:10 to at least see what we're seeing out of Atlantic Canada right now and try to extrapolate westwards
01:00:17 at least to the GTA I'd put the same question to you as I put to Josh Andrus is obviously the
01:00:24 conservatives are not winning Atlantic Canada there was no expectation that they would but
01:00:29 But they seem to be certainly outperforming 2019.
01:00:33 Do you think this is a harbinger of things to come in the GTA with the centre shift?
01:00:40 I have to tell you, if I'm a Conservative, if I'm Team Aaron O'Toole, I'm looking at this and feeling pretty good.
01:00:45 I mean, it's still very early on.
01:00:48 There are margins.
01:00:49 Only one of the eight Conservatives, the eight places where the Conservatives are leading in Atlanta, Canada, are they actually winning.
01:00:55 But they're leading in seven other ones.
01:00:57 and that's noticeably better than 2019 uh it's an indication of good things to come it's it's
01:01:06 concerning for the liberals to begin with now a lot of these seats are still really close and
01:01:10 lots of things can still change over the course of the evening i do know from having spoken with
01:01:14 conservative friends they felt really good about the job they did getting out their early vote in
01:01:19 the advanced polls um you know this is a better start to the evening right now than what's
01:01:25 happening in 2019. And, you know, it'll be interesting to see what happens when we get into
01:01:31 starting to count Quebec and Ontario at the same time, what happened in the 905, whether or not
01:01:36 O'Toole's effort to moderate the party to pick up seats in Ontario while risking some seats in
01:01:44 Western Canada, whether or not that will be a gamble that was worth playing. It'll also be
01:01:48 interesting to watch what happens in Quebec, whether or not the bloc's late surge in this
01:01:54 election will take away a bunch of seats from justin trudeau so right now you know justin
01:02:00 trudeau's four seats down coming out of atlantic canada from where he was before i have reasons
01:02:05 to believe he might lose another seven or eight in quebec the polling in ontario is all over the
01:02:12 place so some pollsters have him doing quite well other pollsters have it a mixed bag um
01:02:18 this is going to be a fascinating election and uh you know i'm going to call it right now that we
01:02:23 won't know who's won the election until late sometime tomorrow, like well past
01:02:29 tonight, and that, you know, there's a chance that we won't really know who's
01:02:35 going to be the next Prime Minister for maybe even a day or two after that.
01:02:39 Well, yeah, I was going to say that winning the election doesn't necessarily
01:02:44 mean winning the government. You have to win Parliament, and that, without the
01:02:50 risk. I don't want to go down that rabbit hole, although I think Canadians are in a 1.00
01:02:56 bad need of a civics lesson on the issue. It certainly is a much better start to the
01:03:03 evening than it was for Erin O'Toole than it was for Andrew Scheer. That being said,
01:03:10 mail-in ballots and advance polling was, I think, a significantly smaller issue in 2019
01:03:16 than it is this election.
01:03:18 My expectation is that advanced polling
01:03:21 and mail-in ballots will be a smaller issue
01:03:24 than it was say in the United States presidential election.
01:03:27 That time COVID, I think fear of COVID
01:03:31 was probably a lot greater.
01:03:33 There was, it was still less understood.
01:03:36 Why don't you, what are your thoughts on the impact
01:03:38 of what you would expect from mail-in ballots
01:03:42 and the advanced polls?
01:03:44 Are conservatives counting their chickens before they hatch here with these leads before we've counted those mail-in ballots?
01:03:51 These leads are super early.
01:03:53 Mail-in ballots are not a huge, huge thing in Atlantic Canada, and there's no reason to believe that there was going to be a big difference.
01:04:02 But they're going to be a huge, huge issue when we get to the end of the evening in British Columbia.
01:04:07 There are ridings in British Columbia that have over 8,000 potential mail-in ballots.
01:04:12 So that means in a lot of the places in British Columbia where you're going to see three-way races or a variety of different two-way races, somebody could have a 2,000, 2,500 vote lead tonight and get a call late tomorrow from Ottawa saying you lost because there's that many ballots to be counted in British Columbia.
01:04:33 And you said, you know, we weren't going to have a sort of a Trump style problem.
01:04:37 We kind of run that risk of having a Trump style problem because I expect this election is going to be decided by 40 or 50 close ridings.
01:04:46 And in those 40 or 50 close ridings tonight, our margin is not going to be anywhere near the number of ballots that are sitting in Ottawa waiting to be counted.
01:04:55 And those are going to arrive middle to late tomorrow afternoon, tomorrow evening.
01:05:00 and there's just this sense of it's going to break that usual sense of trust and certainty
01:05:06 that canadians have about their elections you know we do so many things better than the americans
01:05:10 we've got our you know we we count paper and there's my pile is bigger than your pile i won
01:05:15 it's not going to go that way tonight and it's going to be really interesting to see what comes
01:05:21 that. I'll ask the question about Jason Kenney's effect on the Alberta Tories federally. How do
01:05:34 you think it played out? I think Jason Kenney's effect plays out in the sense that he gave a
01:05:41 last-minute surge and push to the People's Party, which won't matter at the end of the week, but
01:05:49 could matter an awful lot tonight and tomorrow when these votes are being counted. I agree with
01:05:53 Jonathan Dennis, who was just on your show, that they're not going to win any seats, but they're
01:05:57 going to be the spoiler in lots and lots of places. And I accept that not all of their votes
01:06:01 are coming from conservatives, but in a lot of places, enough of their votes are going to come
01:06:09 from conservatives to make a difference. And there are five, maybe six seats in Alberta,
01:06:15 maybe two or three in Calgary, three in Edmonton,
01:06:23 that that could be the difference at the end of the night.
01:06:25 So I agree with Jonathan that my base prediction is that it will be, you know,
01:06:31 one orange seat and everything else is blue.
01:06:34 But if the People's Party have as much of a difference in Edmonton Grease Spa,
01:06:39 Edmonton Centre, Edmonton Millwoods, Calgary Confederation, Calgary Centre,
01:06:42 calgary skyview we could be seeing the liberals pick up as many as four or five seats in alberta
01:06:50 they could have like one eighth of the seats in alberta even though they're immensely unpopular
01:06:54 um the ppc is a really weird creature it's a vote for change that runs the risk of actually
01:07:00 accentuating the status quo well okay so i suppose my question is uh the ppc is it's funny it's it's
01:07:09 It's not particularly likely to win any seats in the election.
01:07:14 I think at best, one, the biggest optimist I would say would be two.
01:07:20 We don't really know where their votes constitute because we just don't have those historical
01:07:23 patterns to really base it on.
01:07:26 And I don't think the regional polling, particularly in the West, because elections are not decided
01:07:32 here so no one's going to spend the money.
01:07:34 Other maybe a few internal polls for the parties, so they know things that maybe we don't, or
01:07:38 at least I don't. But it has, for a party that's not likely to win seats, or at least at the very
01:07:44 least, not many, it seems to be having an outsized effect on this election now. It's
01:07:51 certainly capturing the attention of people on both sides of the divide. I don't intend for
01:07:58 this question to be loaded. You always, Vittorio, you know where I'm coming from.
01:08:01 Hit me with a loaded question.
01:08:02 Yeah. But the PPC vote, if there's enough PPC vote to hand, you know, enough roddings over to the liberals, if you accept the theory of vote splitting, this is, I suppose, an editorialized question, but I appreciate your editorialized answer. Whose fault is it?
01:08:21 Oh, it's a combination of faults. And it's the other side to the coin of O'Toole's strategy of moderating the party to chase the 905 is that in the process of moderating the party, he exposes his flank to something and Maxime Bernier took advantage of it.
01:08:38 But it's also Maxime's fault. I mean, I'm sorry. The Bosa is the only seat that could win. The final weekend, he was in Calgary and in Saskatoon. It left the impression that he was chasing donations. It left the impression that he was settling scores. It didn't make him a serious player vis-a-vis politics.
01:08:57 And that's really frustrating because I actually think Maxime's got some interesting things to contribute to the overall debate of the country.
01:09:04 And if he won a seat or two, he'd get to participate in them over the next year and a bit.
01:09:08 And if he wins no seats, he won't matter again until the next election rolls up.
01:09:13 And maybe if he's lucky, he'll be polling well enough that he can get into the leadership debates.
01:09:19 But if he had a seat, he'd be in the next election's leadership debates.
01:09:23 He chose not to campaign in his home riding.
01:09:25 He chose not to participate in chasing that seat.
01:09:28 And, you know, he's going to have to answer for that at some point.
01:09:32 In fact, we were speaking to him earlier this evening.
01:09:34 He's in Saskatchewan right now for election night.
01:09:37 That actually surprised me a bit.
01:09:39 But let's go to you, Josh.
01:09:43 Yeah, I guess I to start.
01:09:46 I've noticed that the Conservatives have taken a very strong shift to the left, even trotting out Brian LaRoune.
01:09:55 in the campaign. I was just wondering what your thoughts are on that and whether that is something
01:10:01 that Albertans and Westerners should be concerned of moving forward, especially given the rise of
01:10:07 the protest vote in PPC and Maverick. If you're a movement conservative like me, or like, frankly,
01:10:13 lots of the people on this show and watching this show, it feels like they've lurched to the left.
01:10:18 But if you're a normal everyday Canadian and you went and read that platform,
01:10:22 It's pretty darn conservative.
01:10:24 I have to tell you, I mean, you know, I went and read it carefully in terms of energy issues
01:10:28 and some of the things I care about on climate and the response to the just transition of that.
01:10:33 And if somehow Aaron O'Toole ends up, you know, calling the shots, he ends up in the PMO after this election,
01:10:40 and he does one third of the things that are in that energy platform, it will be really good for Alberta.
01:10:47 There are places where I think he has moved the party to the center and chasing Ontario votes.
01:10:55 That's just the nature of how this country is built.
01:10:58 I mean, in all honesty, there are more conservatives across the country than ever vote conservative because there's a variety of flavors and styles of conservative.
01:11:08 And you can never get a leader that can get all of the flavors and style of conservatives into one tent.
01:11:14 And that's just the fact of life.
01:11:16 I think it's going to be that way. Even when you have a leader as disliked as
01:11:24 Justin Trudeau, you can't get all of the conservatives into one tent. So it's going
01:11:30 to be complicated. I'm going to poke at the energy platform a bit.
01:11:38 the carbon tax. You know I had to go there. And I do not mean to paint you as the O'Toole guy.
01:11:48 Your job is not to defend him here. Don't worry. I'm not trying to use you as my foil
01:11:52 too much. But how much do you think O'Toole's complete reversal on the carbon tax is going
01:12:02 to be a factor here in uh it was it was a factor in it it upset us and it upset a lot of people
01:12:08 but it's also a factor this way timo tool told people that if they did that carbon tax thing
01:12:16 that climate change would not be a factor in the general election they were in effect
01:12:19 taking climate change off of the topics that got that dominated the federal election and he ended
01:12:25 up being right one of the shocking things about this election is that we didn't talk very much
01:12:32 about climate change. Climate change was not the central focus of the election. If you had asked
01:12:37 me a month ago, I would have said, yeah, it's going to be all about climate change all of the
01:12:40 time, and O'Toole's going to get beaten up over his carbon plan. That did not happen. And if his
01:12:47 policy succeeded in taking climate change off the table, that's pretty successful. It's my least
01:12:54 favorite part of his energy policy. It's the least favorite part of my view on his overall policy in
01:13:01 terms of energy and climate you know his odd climate plan I don't even know what to call it
01:13:07 because frankly I think they screwed up the politics of introducing it but he did make the
01:13:11 issue go away from him at election time and if the election had been all about climate change
01:13:15 uh he wouldn't be leading in new seats in uh in the maritimes uh that he's leading in so we'll
01:13:23 you know Derek when I'm on later on today for various segments we'll have a chance to to measure
01:13:27 it more as the pieces play out, but it's, you know, it's too early in the evening to tell
01:13:31 how all of this is playing out. Well, thank you, Vitor. We're going to be coming back to you soon.
01:13:37 We appreciate your contributions. We'll see you in about an hour from now. Sounds great. Thank you.
01:13:44 Well, let's go to Dave for an update on where we're at. We've got a few more seats reporting
01:13:50 right now, Dave. Sure. Speaking of energy issues, Derek, Natural Resources Minister
01:13:58 Seamus O'Regan has been re-elected in his writing, so that will be of interest to the
01:14:05 West. And polls have closed in Saskatchewan. I mean, who knew that they were closing this
01:14:11 early, even before some of the eastern time slots? Don't ask me why, because I don't know.
01:14:20 In the seat standing at the moment, we have Tories gaining four seats and the Liberals losing three.
01:14:28 We've got Liberals, this is just the Maritime Provinces, Liberals sitting at 24, leading and elected, Conservatives 8, leading and elected.
01:14:38 And it looks like we're starting to get some Quebec results in now.
01:14:44 We've got the Bloc leading and elected in one.
01:14:48 again apparently a lot of these results just going through them a lot of these results are
01:14:56 very very close and as Vitor just told us could be tomorrow until we hear whether or not or what
01:15:06 the final what the final decisions are so I understand that we've got Franco in the waiting
01:15:14 room, James?
01:15:38 Okay, sorry for that
01:15:40 short delay there.
01:15:42 I think we've got
01:15:43 you've got my pretty face back in the middle here again 1.00
01:15:48 sooner we get franco in the better then yeah it'll brighten things up he brings some of that 0.77
01:15:55 you know hipster look into things rather than my scowling old butt here so franco tarazano from 0.50
01:16:02 the canadian taxpayers federation uh i i can't believe that he's not a you know gray like i am 0.52
01:16:08 after tracking the spending and taxing and the promises coming from all of our parties during
01:16:13 this campaign. How are you doing tonight, Franco? You know, I'm doing well, man. How are you guys
01:16:17 doing? Really good. I mean, the night's young, though, and we'll see how these numbers go as
01:16:22 they come in. I guess, you know, we kind of hit every guest with it, and I know it's a tough one.
01:16:28 I know you're not a partisan sort, but we get people to throw out a guess and see what do you
01:16:33 see happening at the end of tonight? What prediction you got? Oh, man, you know, I don't
01:16:38 have that crystal ball with me. It's going to be a tough one. I don't think anyone really knows
01:16:41 exactly what's going to happen. But unfortunately, it's going to be bad news for taxpayers in some
01:16:47 way here, because really, we've seen every single one of these major parties that have a chance
01:16:52 of forming government really ignore that $1 trillion elephant in the room, Corey. And of
01:16:58 course, I'm talking about the federal government debt, right? We've seen all parties promise
01:17:02 billions and billions of dollars in additional spending but we're still waiting for a credible
01:17:07 plan to balance the budget right we have the ndp the liberals they have no idea how they would
01:17:13 balance the budget and the conservatives i mean they are talking about balancing the budget within
01:17:17 a decade but but even the conservatives are really just paying lip service uh because their plan to
01:17:22 balance the budget is not credible uh core uh franco sorry uh we had a feature on the western
01:17:30 standard where you and i working on a taxpayer's guide to voting and uh could you could you just
01:17:36 briefly review the the financial economic predictions and the debt focus of the the
01:17:42 three main parties for us yeah absolutely dave thanks so much uh thanks for much for running
01:17:46 that but so essentially what we wanted to do with that guide is not just show each canadian what
01:17:52 the parties are saying but also give a little background and first we have to start with the
01:17:55 debt you know i mentioned that it was a trillion dollars in debt federally so that breaks down to
01:18:00 about thirty thousand dollars that each canadian is on the hook for and if these politicians don't
01:18:05 find a way to save some money that has to come from taxpayers one way or another whether it's
01:18:10 taxes today taxes plus interest tomorrow or inflation um so now moving on from the debt we
01:18:16 also have to talk about the massive amount of spending that is coming from the federal government
01:18:21 or I should say massive amount of borrowing even before the pandemic in 2018 the Trudeau
01:18:27 government was spending all-time highs in Canada's modern history so what that means is that before
01:18:32 the pandemic the Trudeau government was spending more money than the federal government had spent
01:18:38 in any single year during World War II which is absolutely mind-boggling and then finally we also
01:18:45 put out some information about taxes and even during the pandemic the average canadian family
01:18:51 paid about 36 percent of its budget to taxes which is more than what an average canadian family
01:18:57 was paying for housing clothing and food combined so if these politicians really
01:19:02 care about affordability then they got to take a good hard look in the mirror
01:19:10 yeah i guess uh you talked a lot about the the massive spending coming out of the federal
01:19:14 government um in alberta here on october the 18th we go to the polls to vote on equalization
01:19:20 do you think that this spending given the current political circumstances will leave a heavier mark
01:19:26 on alberta and the west in general given the amount of money we send east through equalization
01:19:31 yeah that's that's a great question and for that we really have to look at the context
01:19:35 right of of how much money for decades alberta taxpayers have contributed to the rest of canada
01:19:41 to Ottawa, and of course, by extension, the other provinces. As you gentlemen know, since the 1960s,
01:19:47 since the early 1960s, Alberta taxpayers have paid about $600 billion more to Ottawa
01:19:54 than Alberta taxpayers have received in federal spending. So if you look at the broad context
01:20:00 of Alberta's economy, certainly Albertans tend to pay more than their fair share when it comes
01:20:08 to federal taxes. So I think certainly for our Alberta viewers who are watching this, that has
01:20:12 to be a huge concern that they are going to be facing a heavier debt burden because of all this
01:20:19 spending from the federal government and all of these major parties. It seems that the massive
01:20:24 spending promise is coming from all sides. I almost wonder if, you know, a number of them,
01:20:30 we can almost count on them just not following through on. I know that's a terrible way for us
01:20:33 to have to look at things, but do you think there's some areas where maybe they were just
01:20:38 playing lip service and they might kick it down the road later on? Well, I mean, certainly we're
01:20:42 not, certainly we hope that we're not going to see this massive amount of government borrowing
01:20:46 and, and, and Corey, and, and for all you gentlemen there, you know, when I talk about
01:20:50 billions and billions of dollars in additional spending, let me just break it down for you.
01:20:53 So the NDP is promising to spend an extra $200 billion. They are so, so divorced from the actual
01:21:02 financial reality of planet earth then the liberals they're promising an extra 78 billion
01:21:07 dollars in spending the conservatives they're promising about 50 billion dollars in additional
01:21:12 spending now the key word there is additional spending because all of that new spending would
01:21:18 be on top of the massive amount of spending that was in the last liberal government's budget
01:21:23 released only a few months ago and just remember when that budget was released back in april i
01:21:28 mean we're all scratching our head wondering how we can afford it I mean the truth of the matter is
01:21:33 we couldn't afford the last Liberal government's budget we certainly can't afford all of these
01:21:38 massive spending promises on top of it and I just want to make one more point clear just to really
01:21:43 illustrate the massive spending in the last budget remember the Trudeau government's last
01:21:48 budget would be nearly doubling the pre-pandemic debt in just six years yeah one prize they've
01:21:56 been looking at we're hearing rumors about quite often and the liberals deny it but we keep seeing
01:22:00 these warning signals. There's a big chunk of capital in Canada called home equity and there's
01:22:05 a lot of rumor that they might be considering taxing our primary residences. Has the Taxpayers
01:22:10 Federation been watching that I imagine? Oh absolutely this is a huge issue. It's a huge
01:22:15 issue for Canadians right. Right now there is no home equity tax which is fantastic news
01:22:20 because a home equity tax would just be so much pain for so many Canadians. I mean think about
01:22:25 the Canadians who want to retire well they rely on the proceeds of the sale of their home to fund
01:22:31 their golden years or even think about the young family who wants to sell their starter home to be
01:22:36 able to purchase a bigger family size home in a nice neighborhood well they too rely on the sale
01:22:42 of their home to be able to fund that and a home equity tax would take a huge chunk of the proceeds
01:22:47 away from Canadian families now one thing that we have to point out is that the Liberals are
01:22:52 absolutely sniffing around our homes in their platform they have a so-called anti-flipping tax
01:22:59 and what that means is that if you sell your home before the liberals think you should then they'll
01:23:04 send the tax men after you and we have to also look at some other context here we know that the
01:23:09 federal government is spending 250 000 of our tax dollars studying home taxes and also in 2016
01:23:17 Ottawa put in a requirement that we have to report the sale of our home with the CRA with
01:23:22 the tax man. Well, I got a question for the CRA and I got a question for the federal government.
01:23:26 If the tax man isn't going to come after us with a home equity tax, then why do we have to report
01:23:31 the sale of our home with the CRA? Well, that is that scary thing. You know,
01:23:36 they're doing it incrementally. They're setting up the system. They're setting up the means to take
01:23:39 it. We're all sliding in. We're all registering. And boy, it sure makes it easy just to kind of
01:23:45 ramp it up or say we'll just reduce the turnover time that you're allowed you know when you're
01:23:49 selling a house or I should just say extend it one way or another they're going to come after it
01:23:53 and Corey can I just jump in real quick I mean look we saw the Trudeau government we saw Trudeau
01:23:58 during the English leaders debate uh say that he wasn't going to put a home equity tax we've seen
01:24:03 other liberal candidates go to social media say hey they're not going to put in a home equity tax
01:24:07 but why should Canadians believe them if they want us to believe them that they're not going
01:24:12 hammer us with a home equity tax and they have to remove the reporting requirement with the CRA.
01:24:17 And let's not forget about the Liberals track record here. Hey, remember before that last
01:24:21 federal election, they said that they had no intention of raising the carbon tax beyond $50
01:24:26 per ton. Well, what happened last Christmas? Well, Trudeau hammered us with the announcement that
01:24:31 they're going to be raising the carbon tax to $170 per ton, right? So I think there is every reason
01:24:37 why taxpayers should be skeptical and let's just transition to the conservatives really quick now
01:24:42 in their platform the conservatives explicitly reject a home equity tax now that's good but
01:24:48 again taxpayers need to be skeptical because hey even i'm old enough to remember uh erin o'toole
01:24:54 promising that he would scrap carbon taxes when he was running for leader of the conservative party
01:24:59 and what did he do only a few months ago well he flip-flopped on that and now is going to hammer
01:25:04 Canadians with a carbon tax of his own. So if these politicians want us to trust them,
01:25:09 they need to remove that reporting requirement. Franco, let's talk a minute about inflation
01:25:15 and how that's going to affect the country's prices. I had to remortgage my own house on
01:25:21 the weekend. I think I got a good rate, but it worries me, especially that 4.1 figure
01:25:26 that came out last week. What do you see inflation doing and how will it affect the debt?
01:25:33 Well, Dave, first, I just want to say, look, no economist has a crystal ball.
01:25:38 So nobody really knows what's going to happen when it comes to inflation.
01:25:42 But I am worried as well.
01:25:43 And we have to understand that when we're talking about the cost of living, we have to talk about how the government drives up that cost of living.
01:25:50 Right. We already talked about how in 20, even during the pandemic, the average Canadian paid more to taxes than on housing, food and clothing combined.
01:25:59 But another thing that we have to talk about is the inflation tax.
01:26:02 And essentially what that means is when the government prints more dollars, it means your
01:26:07 dollars buy less.
01:26:08 And the government's printing press has been on overdrive during the pandemic.
01:26:13 Since February 2020, the Bank of Canada has printed about $370 billion.
01:26:20 That's a 300% growth in the bank's assets, which is significantly more than what we saw
01:26:26 in the recession of the 80s and the 90s and in 2008-09.
01:26:30 To put that into context, the 300% growth is similar as to what we saw in the growth of banks of Canada's assets during the entire six years of World War II.
01:26:43 So, Dave, with that amount of money printing, it's no surprise to see prices going up.
01:26:50 You must be tossing and turning at night with all those figures bouncing around in your head.
01:26:56 Let me give you another figure.
01:26:58 sorry to cut you off there but you know we heard uh 4.1 increase in consumer prices over the year
01:27:04 right we saw that from stats canada but even that downplays just how prices have been continually
01:27:10 to march upwards you know over the last two decades we have seen consumer prices increase by 40 percent
01:27:20 i certainly haven't gotten a 40 percent raise in those years
01:27:24 well there it is right when the government prints more dollars your dollars buy less
01:27:28 So you're a good old cowboy, Calgary kid, Franco.
01:27:32 You just moved to Ottawa with your promotion.
01:27:36 How are you finding it?
01:27:37 Did your intelligence shrink as soon as you entered city limits?
01:27:42 Well, you know, I'm certainly having a good time.
01:27:45 There's a lot of waste, government waste here in Ottawa,
01:27:48 so I'm sure I'm going to have my hands full.
01:27:50 Yeah, Ottawa's a great city.
01:27:52 You'll enjoy it.
01:27:54 Yeah.
01:27:55 Yeah, actually, I did have one question
01:27:57 well conservative platform they had a gst holiday in december as well as a massive program for
01:28:06 front for the what is it restaurant tax credit i think i can't remember what exactly what it was
01:28:13 but do you think that this is going to have any impact on cost of living or any or anything like
01:28:18 that yeah that's a good question so what we saw from the conservative platform is that month-long
01:28:24 GST holiday, I believe for the month of December. And we saw a whole raft of these niche boutique
01:28:30 style tax credits. Now, I don't want to put down any policy that keeps more money in Canadians
01:28:37 pockets, but that is not the approach that we would have liked to see. I mean, what Canadians 0.99
01:28:41 need is broad-based tax relief. But instead, we're not seeing that from the Conservatives.
01:28:47 We're not seeing broad-based income tax, business tax, sales tax relief. We're not seeing the broad
01:28:52 ones. And so the analogy that I like to put forward is right now, especially Canadians are
01:28:59 hungry for relief. We need a big meal of steak and potatoes. And what the Conservatives are giving us
01:29:03 on tax relief is like bar pretzels. Great. Well, thanks for checking in with us, Franco. We'll all
01:29:10 be glued to our screens. The results haven't changed too much in the short time. We'll talk
01:29:14 to you a little later tonight and see how everything's lining up in the taxpayer front.
01:29:18 All right. Sounds good, gents. We'll talk later.
01:29:21 Great. Thank you.
01:29:22 So the Atlantic provinces, you know, the numbers haven't changed too much.
01:29:27 It's interesting the NDP seem to be shut out for the time.
01:29:29 Yes, a drop of one seat for them.
01:29:32 Yeah. So we've got Clinton DeVoe on deck there again.
01:29:36 Perhaps he can give us an update, some interesting numbers in New Brunswick and where things are sitting out there.
01:29:41 Hey, Clinton. 0.96
01:29:42 Well, there's some positive news and some potential negative news.
01:29:47 if you're a Conservative Party supporter.
01:29:50 So the positive news is that the party is currently leading
01:29:55 in a number of ridings in Atlantic Canada.
01:29:57 So that's a great sign.
01:29:59 I do see some potential problems and some fault lines
01:30:02 that could really develop in Ontario and Western Canada.
01:30:06 So the People's Party of Canada is not really a factor in Atlantic Canada.
01:30:12 You know, in the Atlantic provinces, people are generally glued to tradition
01:30:15 and they don't generally move to third parties or fringe parties.
01:30:20 What I will say, however, is that in New Brunswick right now,
01:30:23 the PPC is polling at almost 8%.
01:30:26 And that's a problem because provinces like Ontario and Western Canada
01:30:32 historically have been more open to voting for third parties
01:30:37 and those kinds of things.
01:30:39 And look, I think 7.8% in New Brunswick could become a real problem
01:30:45 in the prairies in Ontario, and that's something that Conservative Party supporters are going to
01:30:50 need to follow very closely, especially if they want to win, because they need that PPC vote
01:30:56 to collapse in Ontario and the West. Is that PPC vote in the Maritimes
01:31:07 going to cost the Tories any riding, or are they just too inconsequential at the moment?
01:31:14 It's actually potentially going to cause them a problem in the riding of St. John.
01:31:18 So there's a popular Liberal member of Parliament, Wayne Long,
01:31:22 who's been known from time to time to stray from the Liberal Party
01:31:26 and sort of be known as a bit of an independent.
01:31:29 And the last time I checked, he was leading.
01:31:32 And there is a fair amount of PPC strength in the Ross-Ace St. John area.
01:31:36 That's southern New Brunswick.
01:31:38 And then there's a couple of other ridings that we'd want to watch carefully
01:31:43 The other one where there's a fair amount of PPC strength is in the riding of Miramichi.
01:31:48 And that could be a potential problem in New Brunswick.
01:31:54 So, you know, the conservatives are having a good night so far compared to 2019,
01:32:01 where they've almost doubled their seat count in the early counting of the polls now that it's still early in the night.
01:32:07 but I am concerned about that 7.8% number
01:32:12 because that could really throw a wrench
01:32:14 as this night progresses
01:32:16 well I know something we found
01:32:19 I mean a lot of people presuming all of the votes
01:32:20 the PPC are drawing are coming directly
01:32:22 from the Conservative Party of Canada
01:32:24 and I would say it's predominantly coming from them
01:32:27 I think we can say that
01:32:28 but there have been some numbers coming from
01:32:30 like the green collapse actually contributed to a degree
01:32:33 to the PPC
01:32:35 because I mean there's some people who are very opposed
01:32:37 to conventional medicine. They gravitated to the Greens. And the PPC has also engaged a lot of
01:32:44 people who didn't vote, period, but they got quite stirred up again and got restrictions,
01:32:48 vaccinations. So I know everybody's going to be chewing into this probably for months to come
01:32:52 later on, but it'll be kind of impossible to measure just exactly how many were coming out
01:32:58 of the Conservatives and how many were never the Conservatives' votes to begin with.
01:33:02 Well, I mean, there's a fair amount of polling data that's occurred in the last 48 hours from
01:33:06 people like Main Street Research and a few others that have pointed out that somewhere in the
01:33:12 vicinity of three quarters of the PPC support are disaffected conservatives or people who have
01:33:19 voted conservative at one time or another. And there is that remaining quarter that obviously
01:33:26 has picked up support from a collapsed green vote, maybe a disaffected Liberal Party supporter,
01:33:34 that kind of thing but let's not kid ourselves if they get into that 10 15 20 25 of the vote
01:33:42 in a bunch of ridings in ontario and western canada a significant portion of that would
01:33:47 be what we would traditionally classify as conservative party supporters
01:33:51 and i've had an opportunity tonight to talk to some of the folks uh in party headquarters
01:33:56 And they've indicated that, you know, when they call voters to get out the vote over the last few days, that a significant number of CPC supporters had indicated to them that they were moving their vote over to the PPC.
01:34:16 So this could be a real problem.
01:34:19 So I just wanted to bring that to your attention that not all is well in New Brunswick.
01:34:23 there is some positives and there's some positives coming out of atlantic canada but like i say there's
01:34:29 some some fault lines that we should be monitoring carefully just a bit of breaking news out of
01:34:35 newfoundland cp is projecting a long time liberal mp scott sims has gone down to defeat to the
01:34:44 tory candidate clifford small so a tory winning a seat in newfoundland that's a that's a tremendous
01:34:52 win in newfoundland that's one i've been watching carefully that no one really predicted would
01:34:56 happen uh and that's not a knock against the conservative candidate the conservative team
01:35:01 on the ground there was very well organized uh and they had a great get out the vote and it is
01:35:06 a bit of a surprise because it is a it's a well-known liberal member of parliament that uh
01:35:12 you know that's that's respected and so clearly uh the folks in that riding decided that it was
01:35:18 time for change so these are the kinds of things that the conservatives need to do uh as we move
01:35:23 more west uh throughout the province of quebec um you know stephen harper used to call it his blue
01:35:29 arrow that you know that used to sort of cut through the heart of quebec and come right out to
01:35:34 uh to riviel delou you know mary dumal's old stomping grounds so there is a lot of potential
01:35:41 upside but like i said we we want to monitor some of these fault lines with the ppc which
01:35:47 could lead to some major problems as the night progresses yeah well we're seeing some liberal
01:35:53 weakness and i mean they are a campaign machine and they definitely lost some steam as this thing
01:35:57 got going we've seen that coast to coast maybe i'll kind of go around a bit and talk to josh
01:36:01 though like a big issue of all things that came up was the early election call people saying why
01:36:06 did we call election we didn't need an election and the liberals never really in my view solidified
01:36:11 the need for an election and i think that has damaged their brand to a degree people just were
01:36:16 happy with having to go to the polls without seeing a good reason for it particularly when
01:36:19 we're such a crisis do you think that impacted the votes in the west uh josh you mean these
01:36:25 no i'm talking last actually we're here together i'm looking at a whole panel right now
01:36:28 uh no yes and no um i do think that it seemed a little bit unnecessary obviously with the
01:36:35 afghanistan story floating in the wind wind there as we call the election but as time went on it
01:36:45 It certainly did impact things because it was an issue that Trudeau couldn't really
01:36:49 speak to and it was an issue that kept coming up, it was a successful attack, but I think
01:36:56 out west most people had their minds made up that they weren't going to vote for Trudeau
01:37:02 anyways, so how much of an impact it had out here, especially on the prairies, I don't
01:37:08 think it had a huge impact just because trudeau has is historically unpopular out here yeah do
01:37:16 mind if i jump in there just for a quick second of course yeah so look i think it's important
01:37:22 not to sort of dismiss those pockets of liberal party strength in western canada and let's not
01:37:28 kid ourselves there's a lot of liberal party strength in western canada we go to places like
01:37:33 british columbia we go to places like the greater winnipeg area and an election that could potentially
01:37:38 come down to a minority government where both parties are almost the same percentage of popular
01:37:43 vote. You know, one or two or three ridings in the prairies and a handful of ridings in Atlantic
01:37:51 Canada could mean the difference from being in opposition to sitting at the seat of power.
01:37:57 So I do think it's important to recognize that there are some pockets that, you know,
01:38:03 the conservatives need to pick off and i do think the liberal party brand itself is actually still
01:38:09 a strong brand i think uh mr trudeau actually is a drag on that brand and i think the the trudeau
01:38:17 of 2015 you know mr sunny ways and all of that kind of thing you know that that guy doesn't
01:38:23 exist today and uh and i think that's one of the reasons why the conservatives have been able to
01:38:30 sort of tighten up this election a little bit yeah justin trudeau has definitely been on edge
01:38:35 this time around like this was a uh uh crabby or thinner skinned uh trudeau i think if you were
01:38:41 going to say anything about him like we saw some slips in this campaign yeah maybe he saw the
01:38:46 writing on the wall you know the closer to the end of the campaign uh clinton if uh if trudeau
01:38:53 does win a minority is that enough for him to stay on as party leader or will the internal knives come
01:38:59 mode well uh geez i look i'm a believer that um that the liberals in a minority government
01:39:10 situation are going to come out on top because my feeling is is that they're going to reach out to
01:39:15 the new democrats and they're going to say pick whatever cabinet positions you want and we are
01:39:20 going to form a government uh i think for the conservatives it's it's all or nothing so they
01:39:26 got to win a majority tonight and as much as we sort of want them to win a minority government
01:39:31 so we can say we got a moral victory uh the reality is is that they're probably never going
01:39:37 to get to the seat of power with a minority government because the liberals uh along with
01:39:42 the new democrats will go to the governor general and they'll say look we have enough uh combined
01:39:48 support in the house uh in order to maintain a government and i have a hard time believing
01:39:53 that Jagmeet Singh is prepared to form
01:39:57 any sort of coalition with the Conservatives.
01:40:01 And well, further to kind of what Dave was talking about
01:40:03 is almost what each leader would consider a victory.
01:40:06 I mean, I think unless they take a catastrophic loss,
01:40:10 O'Toole is probably going to get two kicks at this cat.
01:40:12 I mean, he can come in as a, you know,
01:40:14 he didn't invoke this election.
01:40:16 He didn't ask for it.
01:40:17 He didn't put us into it.
01:40:18 So they can say this was his formative one,
01:40:20 even if it's a stalemate
01:40:21 and he's still in a in a opposition position. Trudeau, on the other hand, is in a bit more
01:40:26 tenuous position. I mean, that'll be two attempts at this now where he's led to a minority and the
01:40:32 powers that be within the Liberal Party or some of the people with ambition might not be as
01:40:37 supportive of him and thinking, do we want to give him a third time to get a third minority?
01:40:41 Well, look, I'll go a step further and say, depending what the results are tonight,
01:40:45 we might see four, three of five, three of six national political party leaders replaced.
01:40:54 So let's keep in mind a few things.
01:40:56 So Mr. Bernier, he lost the riding of the BOS in 2019.
01:41:00 He then ran in a by-election in Ontario in 2020, and I think he got maybe two, three hundred votes.
01:41:08 And it's pretty clear to me that he's probably not expecting the win in the BOS tonight,
01:41:13 because instead of being in the BOS, he's in Saskatchewan.
01:41:16 So that's a pretty strong indication that he has no plans on winning in the BOS.
01:41:21 So after losing three consecutive elections, you have to wonder whether you can hang on.
01:41:27 As far as Mr. O'Toole goes, look, I think he needs to do two things.
01:41:32 The first one is he needs to do better than Andrew Scheer did in 2019,
01:41:37 and that means winning more seats.
01:41:39 And I think the other goal is for him to finish the night with more popular support.
01:41:44 I think if he finishes with less than 34% when the night is said and done and fewer seats,
01:41:51 I have a hard time believing he's going to hang on.
01:41:53 I think that there'll be a lot of conservatives that will be calling for him to step down, in fact.
01:42:01 And I also think for Mr. Trudeau, if he has a reduced minority,
01:42:06 We may also see the knives come out for him.
01:42:10 The only difference in Mr. Trudeau's case is that the old Liberal Party that we grew up with and that we remember, you know, the party of Jean Chrétien and all that kind of thing, that party really doesn't exist anymore.
01:42:22 It's essentially become a cult of personality around Justin Trudeau.
01:42:26 And so he because of that, he might be able to hang on, especially if he can form a coalition with the New Democrats and bring them to the cabinet table.
01:42:35 That might be enough to satisfy Liberals.
01:42:38 Oh, and Glassman, I just wanted to hear you.
01:42:39 This isn't the Trudeau that it was six or eight years ago, too.
01:42:42 I mean, he's kind of evolving, but is it evolving into something that people can really gather around?
01:42:47 Do you think, Josh, you know, as a younger person, perhaps?
01:42:51 I don't think so.
01:42:52 I mean, there was obviously a certain degree of celebrity around him six years ago.
01:42:58 But right now, I think the younger people are starting to look at the cost of living going up
01:43:04 and looking at six years of a Trudeau government in which taxes have gone up,
01:43:09 interest rates have stayed low, a housing crisis that's continued to be a major player.
01:43:15 We've seen Jagmeet Singh and the NDP definitely swing to try and get the younger voters on board.
01:43:22 They're very robustly active on TikTok and other social media sources like that.
01:43:30 So I don't necessarily, I think it's wearing off.
01:43:32 The question is whether or not it's enough to get those young people to go vote for another party,
01:43:40 whether the Conservatives have put anything on the table that might make them a viable option.
01:43:43 The Greens appear to be imploding and have been for a while.
01:43:46 So it'll be very interesting to see what the demographic breakdown is at the end of the day.
01:43:52 I did have a question for you, Clinton, about the Bloc and what your thoughts were on François Blanchet's performance over the last 36 days or so.
01:44:03 Yeah, so the Bloc Québécois are, look, they're a real thorn in the side of both the Conservatives and the Liberals.
01:44:13 And that's really because, look, the Liberals generally have a lot of voter support in urban Quebec.
01:44:20 and the Conservatives tend to be in rural Quebec and sort of splitting that vote with the bloc.
01:44:28 Mr. Blanchet, look, one of the big problems with how our parliament is designed is that you have
01:44:37 a provincial government in Quebec that essentially passes what everyone recognizes as a discriminatory
01:44:43 law with Bill 21. And let's remember, this is a province whose democratically elected premier
01:44:49 stood up on the October 30th, 1995 referendum and blamed the referendum loss on ethnic people.
01:44:58 So, you know, the Liberals and the Conservatives, unfortunately, when it comes to the political
01:45:05 dynamics in Quebec, really refuse to stand up for religious minority rights, ethnic minority 1.00
01:45:12 rights, English-speaking minority rights. It's really, it's shameful. And the fact that the 1.00
01:45:18 Bloc leader was able to organize, you know, media sources in Quebec to attack the various political
01:45:29 party leaders and the moderator from the English debate. It was really sad and pathetic, I think. 0.97
01:45:36 And what was even worse was watching Jagmeet Singh, Aaron O'Toole, and Justin Trudeau sort of all get 0.95
01:45:45 together and kind of put out a joint statement saying they apologize for the behavior of the
01:45:50 moderator for asking legitimate questions, legitimate tough questions that I think,
01:45:56 you know, Anglophone minorities in Quebec would like someone to defend them. I think religious
01:46:03 minorities in Quebec would like someone to defend them. And unfortunately, all of our mainstream
01:46:09 party leaders are prepared to sell out all of those people in order to curry the votes of
01:46:14 block Quebecois supporters. 0.81
01:46:19 Absolutely ridiculous where you took the top three.
01:46:24 I mean, it's not, I don't like the precedent being set to have participants in a debate
01:46:29 telling the moderators what issues they're allowed to dip into and what they're not.
01:46:33 Bill 21 in Quebec, for those not familiar with it, yeah, it's the one that will block
01:46:37 people, religious minorities from showing any displays in the civil service, you know,
01:46:42 judges, police officers. You can't wear a turban or a crucifix or a kippah. I mean, it's the
01:46:50 hypocrisy when we had all of these leaders declaring Canada as being systemically racist.
01:46:55 I mean, we saw Stockwell Day cancelled for life for just daring to say that we weren't.
01:46:59 And then when we have a bill that really actually personifies systemic discrimination,
01:47:04 they aren't even allowed to talk about it. Well, what's even more troubling, and by the way,
01:47:09 I'm not a supporter of Bill 21 and some of that legislation that goes on in Quebec.
01:47:15 But if any other province in Canada were to pass similar legislation to that,
01:47:19 you can be certain that the entire parliamentary press gallery would rightfully so point out how terrible that is.
01:47:28 But for whatever reason, most of the media in Canada,
01:47:34 Most of our political leaders are prepared to look the other way because they want those 78 seats, because those 78 seats can help you form a majority government.
01:47:47 And just to circle this back to what I was saying earlier about leaders that could potentially be replaced tonight.
01:47:54 Look, I realize a lot of the Western Standard audience is not necessarily a big fan of the Green Party.
01:47:59 But I do think that's an important thing to remember as well,
01:48:02 that Anna Mae Paul, I believe her political career is coming to an end tonight. 0.98
01:48:06 I mean, this was a party who you mentioned Stockwell Day.
01:48:10 The closest treatment I can think of of another politician in Canada
01:48:16 who experienced what Anna Mae Paul experienced was probably Stockwell Day.
01:48:22 So, you know, you had a party that threatened to suspend her membership,
01:48:25 that threatened to remove her as leader of the party. 0.63
01:48:28 And essentially, the Green Party went from being a national party to essentially running a series of disjointed, independent candidates across the country with no real sort of oversight from a national campaign.
01:48:43 So the Green Party's collapsed completely.
01:48:45 And I also think that could benefit the Liberals tremendously as this night drags on.
01:48:50 Absolutely.
01:48:52 I mean, and that was unanticipated just from the crazed, I would almost say, infighting going on.
01:48:56 I mean, they basically defunded their own leader.
01:48:58 left her stuck in her own riding and we'll see what's left at the end. 1.00
01:49:04 But the Greens do have a longstanding brand.
01:49:06 I mean, I think they're hurting, but they'll rebuild and eventually be around for what they are.
01:49:11 So maybe I'll let you go for a bit, Clinton, and we'll come back to you a little later tonight
01:49:15 as some more results come in.
01:49:16 It's been a while since we've had a good update there.
01:49:19 Great. Thanks very much.
01:49:20 Looking forward to chatting with you later.
01:49:22 Enjoy the night, folks.
01:49:23 Right on. Thanks, Clinton.
01:49:24 We'll see you in a bit.
01:49:24 so i have another face on the the front of the crowd here now we've got jeff calloway
01:49:32 uh lined up with us how you doing tonight jeff good thanks for having me good so like everybody
01:49:38 else we're hitting well it's going to be a bit of an interesting night as we see results pour in
01:49:45 from across the the country um obviously we've seen the rise of the the people's party in
01:49:51 in Western Canada but also so we'll have to see if that actually gets some strength reflected
01:49:56 and Maxime Bernier can actually win his seat um but as it's been interesting to watch a lot of
01:50:01 these polls we've seen some of the decline in the in the Green Party they obviously had a lot
01:50:05 of momentum going into the last election that looks like that's been been lost somewhat uh
01:50:09 after the last uh federal election at least from a Western Canadian perspective we saw a lot of the
01:50:14 rise in the Wexit movement and as a result of Trudeau's Trudeau's victory and I think some
01:50:19 Some we're hoping to see perhaps a little more momentum for the Maverick Party in Western Canada.
01:50:25 So that'll be an interesting thing I'm going to keep my eye on tonight.
01:50:29 And looking at the Conservative Party and the positioning of leader Aaron O'Toole
01:50:37 and how he's moved the Conservative Party a little more to the centre, I would say,
01:50:42 relative to what Andrew Scheer was doing.
01:50:45 We'll have to see if that's going to end up paying off in additional votes.
01:50:48 potentially at the expense of voters on the right side
01:50:52 or base part of the party.
01:50:56 So who's winning?
01:50:58 You know, I think there's a lot of people in this election
01:51:03 that were polled, were asked.
01:51:06 I think the pundits are sort of expecting kind of
01:51:10 probably Trudeau to pull it out.
01:51:14 But this has the feeling of a lot of people
01:51:17 maybe going into the ballot box and voting a little bit differently this time.
01:51:23 Just talking to people around the province, it has that sort of a feel.
01:51:29 Now, we'll see how that gets reflected across the country.
01:51:32 I think there was obviously a desire from the Conservative campaign to be an election more focused on change
01:51:39 versus status quo, which is, I think, what Trudeau was looking for.
01:51:45 And, you know, I think there's little drips and drabs of events that will perhaps sway
01:51:54 a few people to change their votes from last time.
01:51:58 One of the things that I think was a huge issue, at the beginning of the campaign at
01:52:01 least, was our government's response to events in Afghanistan.
01:52:06 That's not necessarily how people are going to make their decision, because I think as
01:52:11 the election campaign really wore on, other than all of the old standard attacks that
01:52:19 we've seen for many elections.
01:52:23 Things that were really hitting people in the pocketbook, cost of living, cost of their
01:52:28 utility bill, just an ability to get by, we're going into another fourth wave, are people
01:52:34 going to have to go on, is there a CERB coming back to help defray this fourth wave that
01:52:41 we're in right now, are those going to be issues that ultimately sway people in either
01:52:47 wanting bigger government handouts, which I think NDP leader Jagmeet Singh had no qualms
01:52:53 about running around and promising everyone under the sun some extra money, or is it going
01:52:59 to be reflected in people kind of going to the Conservative Party saying, you know, we've
01:53:04 got to get our fiscal house a little bit more in order, we've got to get people back to
01:53:09 word get an economy functioning again get back to a little bit more of a normal operating society
01:53:15 while recognizing the fact that COVID is going to be with us with us for a long time to come.
01:53:21 Do you think western issues got a fair play in the election?
01:53:25 No no I think about the only thing we well I mean I'm racking my brain a little bit here
01:53:32 but in terms of western issues getting play in the federal election but the only thing that I
01:53:38 can really think of was some of the news about how Erin O'Toole flip-flopped on his gun promise.
01:53:45 I mean, that's something that's more near and dear to the hearts of Westerners. Obviously,
01:53:50 there was a little bit of talk about pipelines, but not very much. The only other thing that we
01:53:55 saw was promises from Trudeau and the NDP to get rid of these mythical subsidies for the oil and
01:54:04 gas sector, which isn't the case at all. So, if there was any play for Western issues,
01:54:12 it sure as heck wasn't in our favor as Westerners. I think the Saskatchewan platform mentioned
01:54:21 Saskatchewan once, the NDP platform mentioned Saskatchewan once and didn't mention Alberta at
01:54:27 Yeah.
01:54:28 So I guess we know where we stand with the MVP anyways.
01:54:32 Yeah, and yeah, this election was really, and we actually saw this in the position of
01:54:40 the Conservative Party going more to the moderate, trying to appeal to the GTA area, some of
01:54:46 those softer seats, trying to flip them.
01:54:49 And I mean, it was a clear strategic move to position away from the sheer campaign strategy
01:54:54 of, you know, running up the score in ridings where they were going to win, sticking more
01:54:59 into a more true conservative base type of message, but at the expense maybe of winning
01:55:05 some more of those really close flip seats in Ontario.
01:55:09 I think the corollary to that, though, is I think you've seen a lot of people look
01:55:14 for an alternative, and that's where I think we've seen some strength come from the PPC
01:55:21 party being reflected in the polls.
01:55:22 Again, that's something I'm going to be watching tonight with keen interest.
01:55:25 Do you think Kenny has cost O'Toole votes in Alberta?
01:55:31 You know, people say Kenny obviously was a high-profile federal conservative.
01:55:40 There's a lot of people unhappy with Kenny.
01:55:42 Did it actually change, or will it change their vote with O'Toole?
01:55:47 I'm a little skeptical about that because, you know, we've seen the premier of Quebec,
01:55:53 Francois Legault, come out and effectively endorse O'Toole.
01:55:56 And, you know, that didn't seem to move the needle that much in Quebec voter intention.
01:56:02 So we'll, it might change.
01:56:05 People may change their minds in the ballot box.
01:56:07 We'll see.
01:56:08 But where is the PPC support coming from then?
01:56:11 You know, in Alberta, where is the PPC support being drawn from?
01:56:16 You know, I think there's a lot of support from the PPC party.
01:56:22 It's not just about anti-vaxxers or things strictly of that nature.
01:56:28 I think there's a bit more of a populist amount of support out there.
01:56:32 And, you know, as someone who, I mean, going back to time,
01:56:36 I wrote the business plan for the Wild Rose Party,
01:56:39 was there from the beginning until, you know, the merger.
01:56:42 So I got to know so much of our base very well.
01:56:45 Corey, you could say the same thing.
01:56:47 You know, there's a strong independent streak.
01:56:51 There's a belief that folks that are inclined to vote that way
01:56:55 will want their political leaders to stay true to their words,
01:56:59 true to their campaign promises.
01:57:01 They don't like to be taken for granted.
01:57:04 You know, your word is your bond.
01:57:06 A handshake means something.
01:57:08 They don't want to hear mixed messages from across the country.
01:57:11 and they respect a strong leader who will, you know, take it on the chin
01:57:17 even if other parts of the country may not agree and punch back.
01:57:22 And bluntly, Bernier was the guy to reflect that kind of sentiment.
01:57:27 I think there was a lot of attraction to that kind of message.
01:57:30 Now, polls in Alberta close very shortly.
01:57:33 How many non-conservative seats do you see?
01:57:37 You know, northeast Calgary, we're seeing, I think, George Chahal actually could have a good chance at winning up there.
01:57:48 It's flip-flopped a little bit back and forth the last couple of elections.
01:57:52 He is, while he's on the side of the city council that doesn't exactly win gold stars amongst the conservative base,
01:58:01 he is well-respected.
01:58:03 You know, just talking to people, like he was the coach on the soccer team, he was there through the hailstorms that happened, he was accessible, a personable type of person.
01:58:15 So on an individual basis, people give that a lot of credence.
01:58:19 And my read, understanding is he's been far more active and connected to the community than the Federal Conservative MP.
01:58:29 That's just feedback I'm hearing on the ground.
01:58:31 I mean, of course, in Edmonton, you'll probably have an NDP hold there.
01:58:37 You know, a bit of insight I've had into the Calgary Centre campaign with Greg McLean and that.
01:58:42 I'm confident that they'll hold that.
01:58:45 They don't have the high-profile Liberal candidate that they had in the last election.
01:58:51 I don't think that, you know, in the past when Calgary Centre flipped and Kent Hare won,
01:58:59 Kent was more of a, you know, semi-popular liberal MLA at the time.
01:59:06 And when he lost, it was for some questionable, scandalous type of behavior.
01:59:12 So that was working against him.
01:59:14 But they also, there was a bit of an upswing, a change type of vote for when that went to Kent Hare too.
01:59:20 If there's a change in this election, it's the swing away from Trudeau and the liberals and towards Kent Hare.
01:59:26 So all of that, I think that's going to be a whole.
01:59:29 Well, the updates, I mean, they kind of started strong and then just stalled.
01:59:34 Nothing much has changed.
01:59:35 But let's pull up the map and have a look.
01:59:37 We're still looking at 25 Liberals leading, nine Conservatives.
01:59:41 The bloc was on the board very briefly there with one seat.
01:59:46 They've gone back down to zero, so there must be a close one.
01:59:49 Again, when you get small numbers, those are going to change pretty quickly.
01:59:52 and the Conservatives are hanging in there with nine.
01:59:57 I imagine, though, as usual, once they'll start rolling in from central Canada,
02:00:02 we'll see quite a flood of change all at once.
02:00:06 And that's when we'll really be able to start digging in and drilling down
02:00:09 to seeing what's been happening with this election.
02:00:12 Has the PPC factor really been at play in Ontario, Quebec, and where are we going with things?
02:00:19 Yeah, like I say, you know, one of the other elements that we saw this evening was the
02:00:25 rise in the BQ, in particular after the English, well, after the both debates really, I think
02:00:33 there was some thought that the BQ may be weakening some of their stance, or weakening
02:00:38 their position and voter base a little bit, but, you know, they really seem to get a little
02:00:44 bit more rejuvenated out there, so that's going to be another interesting thing to see
02:00:48 that ends up actually coming through.
02:00:50 And, you know, we saw one of the Rousseau,
02:00:54 the former NDP MP come back and throw her hat in the ring. 0.97
02:00:58 You know, we'll see if that ends up flipping a seat
02:01:00 to the NDP again from the Liberals.
02:01:04 But Quebec's an interesting voter dynamic.
02:01:08 It can change from time to time.
02:01:10 If you look provincially, and that's, again,
02:01:12 we're not seeing provincial dynamics
02:01:15 are harbingers necessarily for a federal race,
02:01:19 but obviously in Quebec,
02:01:21 we've seen some change at the provincial level
02:01:24 going from the current Legault,
02:01:27 more nationalist government
02:01:29 from a liberal government,
02:01:31 from a Bloc Québécois,
02:01:33 or sorry, Parti Québécois type of government.
02:01:36 So they do kind of move around from time to time
02:01:38 and we'll have to see how that ends up
02:01:40 playing out this election.
02:01:42 Yeah, it's hard to keep reading in
02:01:45 until we get some good results popping up on the board,
02:01:48 which hopefully are going to be coming along soon.
02:01:51 We do have Vitor Marciano back in to add some comments,
02:01:55 and we've got Derek Fildebrand back on the panel.
02:02:00 So please, welcome back to the panel.
02:02:03 Vitor, how's it going up there?
02:02:06 It's really early, but it's off to a good start.
02:02:10 If I'm the Liberals, I'm a little concerned
02:02:12 because atlantic canada is not going their way and uh uh you know some of these seats are really
02:02:19 close um you know nobody thought the liberals were going to lose any seats in newfoundland and
02:02:26 right now they're significantly behind you know 900 votes almost behind in uh costa bay central
02:02:33 notre dame um they you know that wasn't the one i would have picked that the conservatives would
02:02:39 have done well then. I thought the Conservatives had a shot in Long Range Mountains in Bona Vista
02:02:43 Bureau and Trinity, and the Liberals did too, and they put extra effort into winning those seats,
02:02:47 but they, you know, they seem to have ignored Scott Sims' writing, and, you know, it's, there's
02:02:52 only 16 polls left to count there, and the Conservatives are up by 900 votes. That's kind
02:03:00 of interesting stuff. So it's not great right now for the Liberals. And Nova Scotia and New
02:03:11 Brunswick can sometimes be harbingers of what happens in the 905. If you can do well in sort
02:03:18 of red Tory Nova Scotia, you can do well in red Tory New Brunswick, and right now the Conservatives
02:03:24 are picking up seats in both provinces, that starts to worry people about what's going to
02:03:29 happen in, you know, what's going to happen in the rest of the country. So, you know, in very few
02:03:36 minutes, we're going to start getting results from Ontario, results from Quebec, results from all of
02:03:40 the prairies. And, you know, if I'm the Liberals right now, I'm a little nervous. I'm, you know,
02:03:46 I'm a lot nervous. And if I'm the Conservatives, it's still really early, but it's better than
02:03:52 they were at this point last time. And the things that are doing better are things that give you
02:03:58 some hope yeah i'm certain they'd be wanting and hoping to see a a liberal sweep going on out there
02:04:04 as they had in the past and that and that just doesn't seem to be developing so i mean if it is
02:04:08 a bellwether it's not a pretty one at this time no and and we didn't you know we didn't see there
02:04:16 were a handful of polls that suggested that conservatives were doing this well but most of
02:04:22 the polls were not suggesting that so um it looks like there was a little bit of lack of enthusiasm
02:04:27 on the part of the liberal waters again in atlantic canada some of these writings are getting
02:04:32 down to you know 15 or 20 polls left to count out of 200 so uh you know some of them are still early
02:04:39 though and so they can still change a lot but it's if i'm timo tool i'm feeling pretty good
02:04:46 vitor one of the the trends i'm noticing across atlantic canada right now is a fairly repressed
02:04:54 NDP vote. I mean, the NDP have not traditionally been particularly strong outside of a few
02:05:03 pockets, normally in Nova Scotia, sometimes in the Franco areas of New Brunswick. But we're 0.79
02:05:10 seeing some pretty weak NDP numbers out here that I guess we're talking about the other side of
02:05:16 vote splitting, if you will. If we're looking, Acadia Bathurst, 12.2% for the NDP. That has the
02:05:22 the Liberals trouncing things, 61.7% ahead of the Conservatives at 13.5. Again, in the Franco areas 1.00
02:05:32 of New Brunswick, Madawaska, Restagouche. Just destroying. Something like that. 49.9% for the
02:05:44 Liberals, way ahead of the Conservatives at 27.1. The NDP down to 8.2. This is a riding that the
02:05:51 NDP held not very long ago. Do you think, so the NDP are underperforming their polls in Atlantic
02:06:01 Canada right now. What are your thoughts on how this might develop? The overall impression is
02:06:07 there for that. But realistically, they've only got a shot in two places, in my opinion, in Halifax
02:06:13 and they're 800 votes behind with about half the polls counted. So that isn't great, but it's not
02:06:20 insurmountable yet and then i'm sliding over to newfoundland to go check on on st john's east uh
02:06:28 you know there's only 40 polls left to count and they're losing by 1300 votes there so i i think
02:06:34 the the you know the ndp has not had a good start in atlantic canada they really in my opinion they
02:06:39 really only two seats that they were chasing this time it's been a while since since they've done as
02:06:44 well in Acadie Bathurst as they used to. I mean, right now, Acadie Bathurst is overwhelmingly
02:06:52 liberal. I mean, the Liberals winning it by 10,000 votes, and there's still like 40 polls left to
02:06:57 count. So, you know, Jagmeet Singh didn't spend too much time out there, but he probably should
02:07:05 have visited Halifax one more time. And, you know, Harris's seat in St. John's isn't looking good
02:07:13 for them so you know right now i'd say the new democrats have as much reason to be a little bit
02:07:18 annoyed as the liberals again that opens the door to something interesting happening in 905
02:07:24 where you know it's still too early to tell but there's a possibility of of good things coming
02:07:32 the i mean i don't know what new democrat voters would be particularly terrified of this election
02:07:39 I mean, Aaron O'Toole has gone out of his way to move into the center.
02:07:44 And I think there's two elements of a strategy of moving into the center.
02:07:48 One is to make red Tories, blue liberals more comfortable with voting conservatives.
02:07:53 The other is to make new Democrats less terrified of not voting for who they want.
02:07:59 I think that's a key part of the strategy.
02:08:01 But the NDP vote, at least in Atlantic, maybe we shouldn't read too much into it.
02:08:05 But the NDP vote is pretty damn soft as if as if I was running or something.
02:08:12 Well, let's put it this way. It is soft.
02:08:17 I do agree with you that it was part of Aaron O'Toole's strategy.
02:08:20 And I'm going to go a step further. It worked across Canada in the last few days.
02:08:25 The New Democrats were running television ads that basically said the liberals and the conservatives both suck.
02:08:31 vote for us and the last time the new democrats did that was 2011 and they had a really good
02:08:38 election that way in 2015 in the last week and a half of a very long election thomas mulcair
02:08:44 brought out his new slogan of stop harper and and it was you know the the the the hidden message in
02:08:50 that slogan was leave the ndp behind and go vote liberal to stop harper and it was a dreadful
02:08:55 mistake. In 2019, with again, about two weeks to go in the election, Singh made it clear that he
02:09:02 wasn't going to do anything to help Scheer. Well, that just tells his voters that stopping Scheer is
02:09:08 more important than voting NDP. He didn't do that this election. And that's going to have an impact
02:09:14 in British Columbia. That's going to have an impact in and around the seats that border
02:09:20 hamilton where hamilton is a liberal ndp fight but the seats the border hamilton are conservative
02:09:27 liberal fights with you know with usually the ndp vote collapsing to the liberals it might not this
02:09:34 election so there's there's so many of these really interesting splits that are available to be played
02:09:42 i was just going to chime in on the race in fredericton there where we've got
02:09:48 you know, Andrea Johnson actually leading there right now, which is an interesting one to watch 0.92
02:09:53 because, of course, that was a bit of a surprise for the Green Party in the last election.
02:09:57 And then, of course, the MP, Jenica Atwin, crossed the floor to the Liberal Party.
02:10:03 And there were no government announcements until she crossed the party.
02:10:07 And then the Liberals, you know, shoveled a bunch of cash in through seven different
02:10:10 announcements into that riding. And now she's behind a little bit to the
02:10:16 The Conservative candidate there in the Green Party is trailing woefully behind.
02:10:22 Yeah, it's definitely an interesting one.
02:10:24 About 300 votes difference, half the polls still to count.
02:10:28 So it's still quite early, but it does look like the voters there are not too enthusiastic
02:10:35 about their Green Party person becoming a Liberal.
02:10:39 You know, she's carried over a lot of that vote with her, but it's, you know, it's still
02:10:45 early she could still pull it out but uh there's got to be a lot of liberal campaign managers that 1.00
02:10:50 are worried about that and i see the the green somewhere do uh have a seat leading on the board
02:10:59 somewhere that might be some early results popping in someplace or something but the results are
02:11:02 oh we just had uh ontario and quebec open up yeah uh why don't we go to the map and uh run through
02:11:10 an update uh corey why don't you uh tell us tell us where we're with the initial uh rash of results
02:11:17 we don't have all of ontario showing uh vitor maybe if you also we have also clinton devoe
02:11:22 standing by uh the two of you want to take a look at the numbers as we prepare for an update here
02:11:27 i want you to lead us through corey certainly i i can't quite see the breakdown of where they're
02:11:31 all coming from but we're getting some bigger numbers in okay well i can run through the
02:11:36 the leading elective. I've got the interactive map here. Okay. So we've got 39 liberals continuing
02:11:41 to lead with 39, the conservatives 16, the block four, the NDP one, the green one, and PPC at nil
02:11:53 so far. That green seat appears to be, I thought it was maybe Toronto Centre where Anime Paul is
02:12:01 running. We're going to have to track that down, but these are very early polls, early
02:12:06 reporting. There's not a lot of results in yet. Most of the ridings in the East that
02:12:15 have just moved up, or I should say Central Canada, there's not a lot of results showing
02:12:21 yet. I know we're also going to have Jay Hill standing by here in just a moment. Oh, actually,
02:12:26 we have Jay Hill now. Vito, we'll come back to you in a bit here. I appreciate your time.
02:12:32 We're going to go to Jay Hill now, leader of the Maverick Party, someone whose area of the
02:12:38 country that they're running in is very much not yet reporting. Jay, welcome. Let's bring
02:12:45 Jay into the stream. There he is. Jay, welcome to the show. Great to be with you, Derek.
02:12:50 Well, we appreciate your time. Obviously, no results in from the West yet. But what's your
02:12:59 initial reaction in the East? We're starting to get some fairly firm results in Atlantic Canada,
02:13:05 some moderate, reasonable conservative gains, but still far behind the Liberals.
02:13:12 The results in Quebec and Ontario, I think I wouldn't... Actually, it looks like Manitoba
02:13:17 just perhaps opened up its first ones as well.
02:13:20 Conservatives James Bazan and Mary Maguire leading in two seats in Manitoba.
02:13:26 But these are all early showings right now.
02:13:30 What's your reaction so far to the results from a Western perspective
02:13:34 and your perspective as the Maverick leader?
02:13:38 Well, there are no real surprises yet, I don't think.
02:13:41 although, you know, give Mr. O'Toole some well-deserved due, I guess, in the sense that
02:13:48 his party is doing a little bit better than Atlantic Canada. It certainly would appear so
02:13:54 to me, especially if you compared it back to 2015 when the Liberals swept Atlantic Canada.
02:14:01 So I think the general consensus is that if the results coming out of Atlantic Canada hold true
02:14:08 across the nation, then Erin O'Toole and the Conservatives could indeed do better than expected.
02:14:14 I guess that's about the only thing that observation we can make at this stage, because
02:14:18 as you say, it's very, very early on. Many of the races are very close. A lot of ballots to be
02:14:27 counted, even where they're indicating that a Conservative or a Liberal is leading, that could
02:14:33 change so uh it's going to be a long evening i suspect just as uh as all the pundits and pollsters
02:14:40 were telling us jay we don't yet have any of the results of the west other than two uh two single
02:14:47 polls reporting out of manitoba one in uh each of the two constituencies that uh are technically
02:14:54 reporting uh but what is your expectation for the evening how do you think maverick
02:15:00 I mean, I know you're going to, I've been a politician as well. I know how dangerous giving
02:15:07 good answers is. We're trained to dance around them, but I've got to put it to you.
02:15:12 What's your expectation for Maverick tonight? Well, I mean, it's really hard to get a handle
02:15:20 on Derek in the sense that to my knowledge, there's been little or no riding by riding
02:15:28 polling done. It's extremely expensive to do. The only real accurate way is completed phone calls.
02:15:34 It's not via email or social media. To my knowledge, we certainly have not had the
02:15:43 financial resources to do that type of thing in the 29 ridings that we're contesting
02:15:48 as Mavericks. I don't know if other parties have done that on a riding-by-riding basis. If they
02:15:53 are they're obviously keeping that information to themselves so we're really in the dark uh you know
02:15:59 our candidates gave it by far the best shot they could i'm immensely proud of them and i'm not just
02:16:05 saying that is as you suggest uh we both we were both former politicians we know how this game is
02:16:11 played and you try to put the best spin possible on it but i'm being very sincere and honest uh the
02:16:17 29 people that we had running for us in this campaign are just super down to earth western
02:16:23 canadians that are doing it for the right reasons and i'm i'm just so proud of the effort that
02:16:28 they've put in now having said all of that i mean uh as you know my history goes way back to the
02:16:35 beginnings of the reform in the middle mid 1980s it ran in 1988 as did our campaign manager val
02:16:43 Fraser now, Val Meredith at the time and so Val and I went through the defeat of 1988 when reform
02:16:51 didn't elect anyone when it was less than a year old when we contested that election and you know
02:16:59 so I see a lot of similarities between the reform party in its early infancy and Maverick Derek so
02:17:08 my expectations are is that uh the voters will have their say uh obviously we hope that they
02:17:13 opt for real uh western representation that's what we ran on and uh but we will ultimately see
02:17:21 how well our message resonated with voters in these 29 ridings so i'm going to ask you the
02:17:27 same question that i asked people's party leader maxime bernier when he was on uh a bit before you
02:17:33 here. My question to you is, if you were to win only one seat in this election, and that'd be a
02:17:44 very big accomplishment for a new party and one especially as new as Maverick in its very first
02:17:48 election. If you were to win one seat, let's put your pundit hat on here. We'll take the leader
02:17:53 hat off, put the pundit hat on, if I could force it onto your head here. Which seat do you think
02:17:58 that would be well i would say that it would quite possibly either be my former constituency
02:18:07 in northeastern british columbia where we have a young man by the name of dave jeffers running
02:18:12 up in the writing is called prince george peace river northern rockies it's uh roughly
02:18:17 a quarter of the land mass of british columbia i'd like to say that writing name 10 times fast
02:18:23 prince george peace river northern rockies uh um yeah it's easy for me to say because i i said the
02:18:31 early part of that prince george peace river is it was known the entire uh six parliaments that
02:18:37 i represented the good folks up there so i think it'll it would either be them or possibly peace
02:18:44 river westlock we have a again a young family man uh colin krieger running there he's run an
02:18:51 absolutely outstanding campaign, getting around the myriad small communities in that huge Northern
02:18:58 Alberta riding. So that's another possibility. And we've got a couple of pretty strong
02:19:02 ridings as well in Saskatchewan, Derek. So, you know, I really have no idea how this is going to
02:19:11 go. I mean, obviously, we're very hopeful that we have a strong showing at the least. We were
02:19:17 already getting plans in place to begin the next campaign tomorrow and because in all likelihood
02:19:25 as we know this will likely be a minority parliament one way or the other either Trudeau
02:19:30 or O'Toole and either way it's probably not going to last any more than the average which is about
02:19:36 18 months to two years so we're going to start working towards the next campaign as soon as
02:19:41 tomorrow very good i'll give uh let's give the last question to uh jeff calloway here and then
02:19:50 we're going to be bringing uh dave nailer back in for an update on uh the results as they're coming
02:19:55 in thanks eric yeah good to speak with you jay you know a couple of things that i'm thinking about
02:20:01 as in folks in building a party i was there with wild rose you were there with reform i watched
02:20:07 all of that, Bill, you know, some of the parties' advantages come from the missteps of your
02:20:15 opponents and who was in government at the time.
02:20:18 You know, it's looking like we'll get either the Trudom minority or a O'Toole minority.
02:20:26 You want to say whether you would prefer one or the other, at least as a way to help build
02:20:33 the momentum behind the Maverick Party?
02:20:36 And then actually, just secondarily, so much of a party's success is dependent on building
02:20:42 that organization.
02:20:45 It's that back room, shake the hands, coffee shop, organizing constituencies, fundraising,
02:20:52 getting efficient, doing the mail outs, having town halls, all of that grunt hard work that
02:20:57 goes into that you've lived many times before myself too.
02:21:02 does that look like for for the maverick party after this election well that's two great questions
02:21:08 i mean first of all do i have a preference i've been very outspoken right from the beginning
02:21:13 because uh obviously i come from conservative roots i think the majority of certainly of prairie
02:21:18 westerners if you look at from basically the continental divide uh to the suburbs of winnipeg
02:21:26 are predominantly Conservative. So I think for the betterment not only of Western Canada,
02:21:32 but indeed the entire country, we would be better off with an Erwin O'Toole Conservative
02:21:38 government rather than a Justin Trudeau repeat of his Liberal administration. So I've been very
02:21:45 clear about that. That would be my personal preference. That's not the best preference
02:21:51 for Maverick, but I'm looking at what's best for the West, which is another one of our rallying
02:21:57 prize for Maverick. Because the reality is that the best scenario for us is that Mr. O'Toole
02:22:05 wins a handful more seats, but Justin Trudeau refuses to give up government. And under our
02:22:12 system, that could well happen. And I can't imagine the anger that would radiate across
02:22:20 Western Canada in particular were that to happen. But that wouldn't be the best scenario, obviously,
02:22:26 as I said, for Canada. As for our plans going forward, as I indicated, we're planning on
02:22:33 starting our next campaign tomorrow. We're going to be rallying people around. We're certainly going
02:22:39 to study the data and see exactly where our strengths and weaknesses lie. And one of our
02:22:45 first priorities will be to organize in the remainder of the four western ridings we need to
02:22:51 get our uh electoral district associations up and running we need to attract enough volunteers to
02:22:57 have strong organizations that can field a quality candidate just as we did in the 29 ridings that we
02:23:04 contested today well jay uh thank you very much for your being generous with your time and joining
02:23:11 us today. I appreciate your insight as always. Not obliged, but if you would, if you care to
02:23:20 drop in later for your results, I'd be fascinated to get your take on things as the Western results
02:23:26 come in. Certainly. Thanks, Derek, for the invite. And we'll see if, you know, it's past my bedtime
02:23:34 or not. Sounds good. I just got to chime in on one thing. And thanks, Jay, for joining as well.
02:23:40 you're you're truly a gentleman with your answer on that that last one so kudos to you
02:23:45 but I do have to point out that we just saw on the screen what may be an emerging national trend
02:23:53 the green wave Gatineau is going green one poll in Gatineau was going green it's it's a start
02:24:01 but they've got 67 of the vote I I don't know if there's a Sierra Club branch that has its own
02:24:09 pole station, but they are going green right now.
02:24:13 No, no.
02:24:13 I went to university in Ottawa, and you know what the problem is?
02:24:18 The capital is there. 0.98
02:24:19 It's full of insane bureaucrats. 1.00
02:24:20 That's why it's going nuts. 0.99
02:24:23 All right.
02:24:23 Thank you for your time, Jay.
02:24:25 We're going to be going to Franco Teresano of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation next.
02:24:29 We'll hopefully get with you again later, Jay.
02:24:32 Franco, let's bring Franco into the show right now.
02:24:36 Franco looking spiffy as always.
02:24:38 I was actually noting earlier, I was in the green room while Corey and the others were
02:24:43 interviewing you, that cabinet over your right shoulder, I think I assembled it when I worked
02:24:47 in that office at one point.
02:24:49 Yeah, we even have the taxpayer priorities just over my shoulder there.
02:24:53 Oh, there you go.
02:24:55 Franco, we've got pretty firm results now coming out of Atlantic Canada and the initial
02:25:02 results coming into central Canada. Although, I don't know, I think everything east of
02:25:10 superior is the east. But you might agree with me as well. Let's just, actually, before we go to
02:25:19 Franco, though, I want to get Franco's reaction. Let's get a brief update of where things are at
02:25:23 from Dave Naylor as we're getting the central Canadian polls coming in. And then we're going
02:25:28 to go to you, Franco, for reaction. Yeah, we're getting some Quebec numbers and Ontario
02:25:35 numbers. What it means across the country, including the Meritage. Let's get the map
02:25:39 up on the screen as we're going through here. Okay. Apparently there is a technical difficulty
02:25:47 and we do not have a map available. So let's just go to Dan. I'll just whip through them
02:25:51 Liberals leading or re-elected in 63, Conservatives 32, NDP 8, Bloc, Quebecois 7, and other would
02:26:04 be one.
02:26:05 I guess that's the green wave.
02:26:08 The green wave.
02:26:09 One poll in Gatineau does not a wave make.
02:26:14 How do you eat an elephant?
02:26:15 One bite at a time.
02:26:17 It's a start.
02:26:18 Jeff, I know we're not very deep into the beers yet here, but I will bet you right now the
02:26:25 beer cost for the evening that the Greens are not going to win Gatineau.
02:26:29 Well, I'm not taking that bet.
02:26:31 Okay.
02:26:32 See, that's an easy way to settle it.
02:26:35 That's an easy way to settle it.
02:26:37 Okay.
02:26:38 Franco, let's go to your reaction and then we're going to get into the policy a bit.
02:26:41 Yeah.
02:26:42 Well, my initial reaction is that it's still an early, it's still a very early point in
02:26:47 the night, right?
02:26:48 And I remember hearing one of the things that a lot of people have been talking to me, at least, about is that this is a very expensive election election, maybe the most expensive in Canadian history, six hundred and ten million dollars.
02:26:59 But, Derek, the way things are shaping out, the real cost to taxpayers tonight is going to come from these massive spending announcements that we've that we've heard from these leading parties.
02:27:12 Well, Franco, I've been in your position before.
02:27:16 I know you're supposed to talk about taxpayer stuff.
02:27:18 You're not the politician, but sometimes you can play a little bit of both.
02:27:24 How much of a part of Canadian elections is vote buying, though?
02:27:31 You and I are probably not the typical voters.
02:27:34 We probably generally don't appreciate it when people try to bribe us with their own money.
02:27:39 But how successful do you think parties have been at vote buying, using taxpayers' money to move the needle electorally in this election?
02:27:50 And do you think any party has stood out both as the most egregious example and perhaps as the best example of not doing so?
02:27:58 Yeah, a lot to unpack there.
02:27:59 So, Derek, this whole election has been vote buying.
02:28:02 But just one thing that I have to push back on there, they're not trying to buy our votes with our own money.
02:28:07 We're way past that.
02:28:08 They're trying to buy our votes with Canadians' kids and grandkids' money, right? 0.92
02:28:13 Remember, under the current trajectory of the Trudeau government, we wouldn't see a balanced budget until 2070.
02:28:19 Five decades of deficit spending, which is completely unacceptable.
02:28:24 That would add trillions of dollars to the already engorged debt.
02:28:27 Trillions of dollars that we would lose out to interest charges in the meantime.
02:28:30 Now, in terms of who is the biggest spending, it would have to be the new Democrats.
02:28:34 We heard $200 billion in additional spending coming from the NDP.
02:28:39 So they are completely divorced from financial reality.
02:28:43 They're not even in the same planet as we are right now, Derek.
02:28:47 In terms of the next highest spenders of the Liberals, $78 billion in additional spending.
02:28:53 And then there's the Conservatives with about $50 billion in additional spending.
02:28:58 And the key word there is additional spending.
02:29:00 So that's an additional $50 billion above what was in the last Liberal government's budget, which was a huge spending budget.
02:29:08 Did you do, so you did the Liberals and the Conservatives there.
02:29:12 Did you guys do a breakdown of spending commitments in the platforms of the NDP or People's Party?
02:29:19 Yeah, so we did the NDP.
02:29:21 About $200 billion in additional spending coming from the NDP, which is more than the Liberals, which is more than the Conservatives.
02:29:28 is an absolutely crazy amount of spending. And Derek, one thing that I have to point out with
02:29:33 the NDP is it seems like they want to raise every tax under the sun. They want to raise income taxes
02:29:38 on top earners. They want to raise business taxes. They want to raise capital gains taxes.
02:29:42 They want to put in a wealth tax. They want to put in excess profits tax. And Derek, they're
02:29:46 going to spend so much money that despite all of those tax hikes, they would still have no idea
02:29:51 how they would balance the budget. And essentially what the NDP is trying to sell Canadians on is,
02:29:56 hey, don't worry. It's just going to be the wealthy or big businesses who end up paying
02:30:00 these taxes. But the truth of the matter is, it's going to be everyday Canadians who feel
02:30:05 the pain of those taxes through higher prices at the till and through fewer job opportunities.
02:30:11 All right. Let's do one question from Dave for Franco. And then we're going to go to our next
02:30:18 guest, Aaron Gunn from British Columbia. I don't have anything for Franco to be anything.
02:30:25 I'm looking at Edmonton-Greesbeck results, of which there isn't any.
02:30:32 It's a bit early.
02:30:33 I'll just dig in a little bit.
02:30:36 Franco, as we were listening to the debates, we're seeing promises, more spending across the board on a variety of things.
02:30:46 We see a lot of programs, costs, expenses, be it there's explicit spending promises,
02:30:53 but then there's also downloading onto consumers and voters through higher taxes and levies and policies
02:30:59 that result in those cost of living increases that all Canadians are struggling with,
02:31:06 are going to struggle with increasingly so.
02:31:09 One of the questions in the debates that I was pulling the last half of my hair out on
02:31:15 was, you know, how are you going to respond to cost of living increases?
02:31:19 And the general response by all the party leaders was, spend more money, send more checks.
02:31:26 So, you know, from your perspective, you know, what are some of the things that we should be demanding of our elected officials to get those cost of living increases down?
02:31:37 If it's not handing out more checks.
02:31:40 Well, that's an easy one.
02:31:41 And that's, hey, take a look in the mirror and take a good long look in the mirror because you can't talk about the cost of living without mentioning how the government is significantly increasing that cost of living.
02:31:51 You know, we touched on it in the last segment, but even during the pandemic, the average Canadian family spent about 36% of its budget just to taxes, which is more than what the average Canadian family was paying for housing, clothing and food combined.
02:32:05 So imagine if we actually had politicians that let families keep more money in their own pockets. 0.92
02:32:10 I mean, that would improve affordability for all aspects of life. And there's one thing that I have
02:32:14 to point out because we talked about this, but we also heard recently a 4% year over year increase
02:32:21 in consumer prices. Well, hey, look at any one time, there is a myriad of factors that
02:32:26 can influence prices, but we got to talk about the elephant in the room and that's the government's
02:32:31 printing press the central bank the bank of canada uh during the pandemic it um it printed 370
02:32:37 billion dollars uh worth of new dollars right so it's no surprise that as the as the printing
02:32:43 press has been on overdrive for the last 18 months that we're seeing higher consumer prices
02:32:50 well i think uh we'd petition that in the next election the bank of canada should be on the
02:32:54 ballot and let uh let voters decide if they should be spending this much money uh franco thank you
02:32:59 very much for your time. We're going to come back to you in a bit. We're going to move now to Aaron
02:33:04 Gunn. Aaron Gunn is a conservative activist from British Columbia, also a Canadian Taxpayers
02:33:11 Federation alumni. I swear to God, this is not the CTF reunion club here, but we do manage to
02:33:18 get around when we're done our tour of duty there. Good evening, Aaron. Oh, Aaron is still muted right
02:33:26 now no aaron is uh still here right now we're gonna have to get oh there i think there is
02:33:34 good evening aaron can you hear me now derek good evening how's it going excellent where
02:33:40 are you coming to us from we're in a little uh watch party here in uh kitsilano and that's kind
02:33:47 of a suburb of vancouver and a bunch of mainly conservatives i'd say have gathered to watch the
02:33:52 the results come in. You're a pretty keen observer and sometimes participant in British Columbia
02:34:01 politics. Obviously, B.C.'s polls, we're sick and tired enough here in Alberta of learning our
02:34:09 results long after the country has generally voted and decided things. But I suppose we've got
02:34:14 nothing on British Columbia. You're a bit further on. Why don't you give us your prediction of what
02:34:19 you expect at least in british columbia uh when we what can we expect to see in the results when
02:34:24 the polls uh start reporting there well if it's a close election it definitely will come down to
02:34:32 british columbia a bunch of the closest ridings in the entire country are in bc so people will
02:34:38 be watching very closely and unlike most places uh it's three-way races and a lot of times it's
02:34:44 it's conservatives fighting ndp it's ndp fighting liberals and uh and conservatives fighting the ndp
02:34:50 mixed in with obviously the green uh strongholds that they're going to be trying to keep on
02:34:54 keep a hold of on vancouver island so if it comes down to the wire it will come down definitely to
02:34:59 british columbia the the ndp are really the ones to watch they're pulling about five points uh
02:35:06 better than they performed last time and of course we'll keep an eye on the ppc spoiler effect as well
02:35:12 well since you went there let's let's talk about that uh the people's party you said it's a spoiler
02:35:19 effect um in your estimation is the ppc vote coming um mostly just from the conservatives
02:35:26 uh or i mean there's a bit of analysis of trying to build the profile the voter profile of a ppc
02:35:32 voter who are they um really where do you think the vote is coming from for the ppc in british
02:35:40 Columbia? And what kind of effect do you think it's going to have on the outcome?
02:35:47 Well, I think as you pointed out, it's coming from multiple places. The Greens obviously have
02:35:53 their stronghold in British Columbia. So with the collapse of the Green Party, I think just a good
02:35:59 chunk of those votes went to the PPC. And I would say that was up until a point until about two
02:36:04 weeks ago when O'Toole started flip-flopping on guns and other issues. And then I think you see
02:36:09 ppc gain another couple percent uh directly at the expense of the conservatives so we'll see if that
02:36:14 costs them ridings uh particularly well i think where they're trying where they're trying to hold
02:36:23 on and uh or where they're trying to pick up south okanagan and west kootenay it's you know it's
02:36:31 before uh some of the pollsters got into it uh cory morgan who's going to be rejoining us here
02:36:36 in a minute uh cory morgan predicted in a column that the ppc would actually pick up quite a bit
02:36:42 from the greens uh kind of the hippy dippy type you know people who believe in naturopathic medicine
02:36:47 and you know strong connection to nature uh people who are certainly not conservative uh green
02:36:53 switchers um but you know as you get into you know forced uh vaccine passports and issues like that
02:37:01 he predicted that these people would come over i thought he was a bit nuts but i mean cory has
02:37:06 been right where i've been wrong well i guess that once and uh is that much of a factor there
02:37:13 i know you originally hail uh at least in my experience when i first met you from vancouver
02:37:17 island and that is sort of the epicenter of uh of the green party in canada is is that your
02:37:22 experience uh about where these kinds of people hello yeah it's a mix look i think that the ppc
02:37:32 obviously the rent can hear me yeah we can hear you go ahead
02:37:42 i think aaron's having some trouble hearing us aaron okay well i was gonna
02:37:51 go ahead aaron
02:37:55 i'll just keep talking i don't i don't know if you can hear me or not but just cut me off if
02:37:59 if you can't but we can hear you i was just gonna say i think it's a mix and i think obviously last
02:38:04 time the ppc were running as a as a conservative party as they tried to frame themselves as the
02:38:09 true conservative party i think this election it's just been consumed by the vaccine passport 0.57
02:38:14 so you basically have a coalition of people opposed to vaccine passports coming together
02:38:19 to support the ppc and that includes lots of green voters and that includes lots of conservative
02:38:24 voters as well. Okay, we're going to come back to Aaron Gunn in a bit. I've got some results. Yeah,
02:38:34 we're going to go to Dave Naylor, pull up the map right now. Dave Naylor is going to give us some
02:38:39 results as we're having more polls reporting. And you'll be joined very soon by Corey Morgan.
02:38:46 Okay, map people, I'm going to be moving from Quebec East, sorry, Quebec West. So we'll start
02:38:53 in Quebec where there's 78 seats up for grabs. Currently, it's almost a dead tie between
02:39:00 the Liberals with 19% and the Bloc Quebec, sorry, 19 seats leading and elected. The Bloc
02:39:07 Quebecois is 18 seats leading and elected. New Democrats have two and the Conservative
02:39:14 6. If you're interested in the PPC voting there, they are currently polling only 2% of the vote,
02:39:26 so not really a factor in Quebec. Moving into Ontario, 121 seats up for grabs.
02:39:35 Conservatives currently leading and elected in 25. The Liberals, 52. And the New Democrats,
02:39:43 PPC doing a little bit better in Ontario, they're polling at 6%.
02:39:52 Moving into Alberta, we've got a few polls starting to report.
02:39:57 Conservatives, not unexpectedly, are leading in 15 and the Liberals won.
02:40:04 People's Party in Alberta at 6.2%.
02:40:09 2%, so initially not as high as they thought they were going to be.
02:40:16 Saskatchewan, again, not surprisingly, a majority Conservatives.
02:40:21 They're leading and elected in nine.
02:40:23 The New Democrats in two.
02:40:26 And the People's Party almost at 9% there in Saskatchewan.
02:40:32 So nationally, that takes us to 99 Liberals leading and elected,
02:40:38 62 for the Conservatives,
02:40:41 18 for the Block,
02:40:43 NDP at 15,
02:40:45 and the others would be, I guess,
02:40:47 Jeff Calloway's Saginaw Green Party.
02:40:51 They're leading in one.
02:40:53 Keep in mind, 170 needed for majority status,
02:40:58 so we've still got a long ways to go,
02:41:01 and I'll check in on Manitoba
02:41:03 and be back with you guys.
02:41:07 All right.
02:41:07 Well, we've gotten some numbers to chew through now.
02:41:11 We're not, I mean, it's early numbers, but we're not seeing a conservative breakthrough quite yet.
02:41:18 Okay, I've got Manitoba right here asking, you shall receive.
02:41:22 Conservatives leading or elected in six, Liberals in three, and the New Democratic Party in three.
02:41:31 People's Party polling at seven and a half percent.
02:41:35 okay well we've got a bunch to chew through and we do have our political stats man on standby
02:41:43 there if clinton's ready to come in we can pop him in and interpret uh what we got to date
02:41:48 so far it's been a good night for uh the conservative party they picked up uh what
02:41:56 looks like they're picking up some wins in atlantic canada they desperately needed that
02:42:00 I think one of the interesting things is that in Atlantic Canada, to some of your earlier discussion, the Liberals are at 42%.
02:42:09 The Conservatives are at 32%.
02:42:11 So that's a big difference there.
02:42:16 The New Democrats aren't even breaking 20% in Atlantic Canada.
02:42:20 They're down to 17%.
02:42:22 So they're basically down to the core of their vote.
02:42:24 And the PPC is at 5%.
02:42:26 What I find really interesting for the New Democrats is that specifically in the greater Halifax area, if we look at the provincial, the most recent provincial election, there was a number of NDP MLAs elected in the greater Halifax area.
02:42:42 And historically, the New Democrats have done well in the city of Halifax in recent elections over the last 20, 25 years.
02:42:52 What we're seeing now, however, is that, you know, the NDP vote essentially collapsed here in Metro Halifax and the Liberals were able to hold on.
02:43:03 And I'm also a little bit concerned with the national numbers.
02:43:06 Now, obviously, a lot of this is going to is going to shift as the prairie vote starts to roll in.
02:43:12 But if we look at like Ontario, Quebec and Atlantic Canada, the Liberals are at 42 percent right now and the Conservatives are at 32.
02:43:21 When we look at Ontario East and look, I think that's a potential problem because we're still early in the counts.
02:43:33 And we're, you know, there's only so many polls are reporting it in each riding.
02:43:39 But, you know, we really need the Conservatives to to perform really well in the prairies to tighten up those national numbers.
02:43:50 And it may, in fact, come down to British Columbia tonight.
02:43:54 That may be the deciding factor of who's going to form a government.
02:43:58 There's a lot of key ridings there.
02:44:01 And British Columbia, unlike any other province in Canada, is one that you have four political parties competing for seats, depending on what geographical region of the province that they're in.
02:44:14 So it's been a good night for conservatives.
02:44:18 The Liberals are holding their own.
02:44:22 And look, I think for the Liberals, they want to win in Ontario.
02:44:26 If they can't win in Ontario, this may be the beginning of the end of Justin Trudeau.
02:44:33 So I haven't had a chance to look, but the mail-in ballots are a large factor coming into this election.
02:44:39 Are there a lot of close races that you've noted in the Maritimes?
02:44:43 Because quite often mail-in ballots tend to favor the progressive candidates when they're counted eventually.
02:44:49 So they could be underreporting a bit of progressive support right now on some of those early ridings.
02:44:55 Well, look, I agree with you.
02:44:57 And I think that's going to be a problem specifically, you know, in Nova Scotia.
02:45:03 So one of the ridings that the Conservatives are performing well in right now is the riding of South Door.
02:45:10 and uh and that's a riding which is uh it makes up part of the greater halifax area
02:45:17 and uh look a lot of people in halifax travel overseas for work uh they have multiple homes
02:45:25 in different countries that sort of thing you know halifax is like any other major urban
02:45:29 center across the country and so those mail-in ballots could actually create problems in uh
02:45:38 You know, ridings like South Shore or perhaps, you know, even ridings like Fregerton in New Brunswick and that kind of thing.
02:45:49 So I think it may be not just a long night, but it could be a long couple of days as they count in those mail-in ballots, depending on just how many there are.
02:46:00 So, Josh, you've been watching the numbers coming in.
02:46:03 Are you seeing patterns, anything you feel you can read into this so far?
02:46:08 Well, for starters, in Newfoundland, the NDP's support has utterly collapsed.
02:46:14 It's still early in Quebec.
02:46:16 I haven't been super impressed with the block.
02:46:19 Quebec was early return, but that being said, it is very early in the process.
02:46:24 There's a pretty solid state of blue in southern Ontario.
02:46:28 I haven't had a chance to take a look at the 905 yet.
02:46:32 But it's still really early regarding the Ontario and Quebec results.
02:46:38 So it'll be interesting to see what happens moving forward.
02:46:43 Yeah, I'm really looking forward to see the prairies come in.
02:46:48 It should still solidly be blue, but I'll be watching the PPC to see if they can hit 10 to 15% in Alberta and Saskatchewan.
02:46:59 But yeah, that's what I'm looking at right now.
02:47:01 Corey, interesting stats in Ontario. Liberals are ahead in 70 ridings. Conservatives only 26. But when you look at total vote, the Liberals are only ahead by 5000 votes in all of those. So there's sure to be 5000 votes over 96 ridings.
02:47:22 So it is early days yet.
02:47:26 As Josh said, less than 3% of polls counted.
02:47:32 We'll keep an eye on them for the rest of the night, obviously.
02:47:36 And look, I just want to throw something in there to your point.
02:47:40 Look, Ontario is not just the big prize when it comes to the sheer number of seats,
02:47:45 But we have seen over multiple elections over the last 25 years that, you know, Ontario really is like Ontario and British Columbia are the two most competitive provinces in the country.
02:47:59 And if you can mobilize your get out the vote as, you know, your go TVs, it's often referred to.
02:48:09 That can be the difference between forming a government and sitting in opposition.
02:48:14 And what's interesting about Ontario and British Columbia is unlike Atlantic Canada and the Prairies that sort of have kind of one party that they tend to support over another, you know, Ontario is a province which is happy to switch back and forth between the Liberals and Conservatives.
02:48:34 Conservatives. And so that makes those tight races that you're referring to that much more
02:48:40 important. Because if you have a spread of 5,000 votes over the course of 70 or 80 ridings,
02:48:47 that really comes down to who's going to get out their vote and who's going to mobilize their vote.
02:48:53 Yeah, well, and with the numbers we've got coming in, and we're seeing kind of
02:48:57 128 for the Liberals, 61 to 78 with the Conservatives somewhere.
02:49:03 I'm seeing a different reports.
02:49:05 NDP, 17, 18, Bloc Quebec, 25.
02:49:10 Well, we're definitely seeing a good early Liberal lead.
02:49:13 Like they really need some of those swing ridings out in the West.
02:49:16 And that's where, you know, for a change in some senses,
02:49:19 Alberta might become a bit of a player here. 1.00
02:49:20 We've got actually a lot more hanging in those urban ridings
02:49:23 than people realize.
02:49:25 Calgary Centre, Calgary Skyview, Confederation,
02:49:28 Edmonton has a number of ridings, again,
02:49:30 that could very easily swing to the Liberals.
02:49:33 So the Conservatives have really, at this point,
02:49:35 they'll got to hope to see a strong Western breakthrough
02:49:38 as those votes start coming in.
02:49:40 Well, and one of the other things,
02:49:41 just to touch on the Ontario side of this,
02:49:43 and again, not to sound like a broken record,
02:49:45 but I mean, it really is important.
02:49:48 You know, these PPC numbers in Ontario as this night drags on
02:49:51 really could become the problem that we touched on in the beginning of the night.
02:49:56 And that's because if you have Liberals and Conservatives with a 5,000 vote spread
02:50:03 over the course of Ontario in the early vote counts,
02:50:06 the last thing you want is for a large critical mass of Conservative Party voters
02:50:11 to abandon the Conservatives and go to the PPC,
02:50:16 and then you end up electing a whole bunch of Liberals all over Ontario.
02:50:20 Now, as a Liberal, obviously they would love that because that makes their job winning that much easier and it could potentially pave a roadmap for a Liberal majority government.
02:50:35 Just an early look at Calgary Centre, one poll in incumbent Greg McLean leading with 50% of the vote ahead of the Liberal, Sabrina Grover, who you remember had two campaign workers attacked in Calgary and spit upon and took some abuse.
02:50:58 So that's only one poll reporting though.
02:51:00 So, yeah, this has been just such a polarizing, heated campaign.
02:51:06 I mean, we've really seen some upset people.
02:51:11 You know, that's something we haven't really talked about tonight.
02:51:13 The vitriol, the stuff going on, the protests dogging Trudeau.
02:51:20 If anything, I believe it gave even a little bit of sympathy to them, to the liberals, because these weren't, I mean, you got the right to protest.
02:51:29 But the screaming, the giving the finger, the swearing, the throwing rocks, I mean, it makes the opposition to Trudeau look insane.
02:51:35 And this does not help, you know, build a rational case to not vote liberal.
02:51:41 I think some of that vitriolic response backfired for those who really want liberals gone.
02:51:46 Well, look, I agree with you.
02:51:48 And, you know, one of the other things we saw occur in this campaign is not just the heightened sense of the rhetoric,
02:51:56 But in some cases, you know, all like not quite, but almost calls for violence in the sense that, you know, you had candidates for this particular political party that were hinting at public hangings of our political leaders.
02:52:16 I mean, just completely unacceptable behavior and unacceptable language.
02:52:21 And so, you know, it has revealed sort of an ugly, seedy side of a small percentage of Canadians.
02:52:32 And I do think that that kind of thing has helped generate a sympathy vote for the current prime minister.
02:52:41 Because, look, if it was a conservative prime minister, I think it would have the same effect as well.
02:52:46 I don't think Canadians want to see our elected leaders being pelted out with gravel or rocks or, you know, having their vehicles surrounded and rocked and this kind of thing.
02:52:59 No, it's intolerable all over the place. 1.00
02:53:01 Plus, I mean, Maxime Bernier got hit by an egg as well by some idiot. 0.99
02:53:06 That just didn't get as much coverage because it was a further out party. 0.99
02:53:09 But it shows that polarization.
02:53:10 and you're going to say something?
02:53:12 Yeah, there's definitely a lot of anger out there.
02:53:16 It's never something you want to see when somebody resorts to violence.
02:53:20 Obviously, and sympathy is a real thing in any election campaign.
02:53:26 Going even back to the prime ministership of Pierre Trudeau,
02:53:30 of course, Justin's father, who was pelted by rocks during a parade during the,
02:53:37 I think it was the night before the 1969 election.
02:53:39 Of course, Pierre Sr. would win a majority there.
02:53:44 Yeah, I believe it was the Saint-Jean-Baptiste day in Quebec
02:53:47 where he got pelted with those rocks.
02:53:49 That's right, I forgot about that.
02:53:51 Yeah, so there's definitely some parallels there.
02:53:55 Obviously, the separatists in Quebec were very, very angry.
02:53:59 I think there's a certain element of anger with the undercurrent
02:54:05 that's driving the purple wave.
02:54:06 People are definitely reacting emotionally given the polarization that COVID has brought
02:54:16 and how essentially all four of the major parties that are in contention
02:54:22 to really hold the balance of power in Parliament have the same policies regarding COVID.
02:54:29 So, but I don't know if it's going to translate to too many sympathy votes for Trudeau.
02:54:37 The difference between 1969 and today, of course, is that Pierre Trudeau was new to the leadership of the Liberal Party and Justin has been around for seven years.
02:54:49 We've seen him cry about 400 times.
02:54:51 So I don't know how much sympathy he's going to get from the general electorate on that.
02:54:56 And, you know, but to me, just one of the real worrisome issues in this case is so if we just we if we draw the comparison and for the record, it's unacceptable that someone hit Mr.
02:55:10 Bernier with an egg. And it is unacceptable.
02:55:14 The difference in this case between these two sets of events that we're describing, as far as we know at the present time, the individual who acted inappropriately and in an absolutely wrongheaded way by pelting him with an egg, as far as we know, that individual wasn't an active member of a party.
02:55:35 know if if he was um i'm happy to be corrected on that the difference in this case is that we
02:55:41 actually have ppc candidates uh calling for public hangings we have another ppc candidate
02:55:48 referencing the nuremberg trials um we had a former ppc riding executive
02:55:59 um who's recently been removed from the party you know throwing rocks and gravel
02:56:05 um we have the leader of that party himself um you know actually referencing the words weapons
02:56:14 uh in some of his speeches and open calls for revolution and so uh there is kind of a a
02:56:23 heightened sense of rhetoric uh amongst that uh you know this political group and uh look i i think
02:56:33 the ppc is a is in some ways it's a cult of personality because it's a party that doesn't
02:56:39 have a national council governing it it doesn't have an official money fund on managing its
02:56:46 donations it doesn't have a leadership review process and it doesn't have a voter member and
02:56:53 and created a voted member constitution and then when we look at the leader of this party
02:57:01 they lost in the 2019 federal election and uh you know the same person ran in a by-election
02:57:08 in ontario last year he got maybe two three hundred votes and uh he's most likely going
02:57:14 to go down to defeat again tonight so perhaps uh you know this might be the beginning of the end of
02:57:21 of the PPC, assuming that Mr. Bernier goes down to defeat.
02:57:24 Because I believe over time, as the vaccination rates start to rise,
02:57:30 hopefully if we can put COVID behind us, then the issue that's giving
02:57:36 that party oxygen is going to disappear.
02:57:39 Yeah, well, and I don't think we can dismiss, though, the anger and the feeling
02:57:44 on the part of the people that have been taking part in those protests,
02:57:47 The people who feel cornered, they feel they have no other outlet.
02:57:51 They don't trust the system.
02:57:53 I think one of the worst things that could happen is we get a bunch of ridings decided by the mail-in ballots
02:57:57 because some people are really not going to trust those results and they're going to be very distressed afterwards.
02:58:04 But there's been a lot of, and it's been political play.
02:58:07 I mean, this is a significant number of people.
02:58:10 This is millions of people actually who are now backing that area.
02:58:13 and they are being treated with a lot of disrespect and scorn when it'd be any other
02:58:19 kind of minority even if the majority doesn't agree with it they wouldn't be as as to be blunt
02:58:24 pissed on as as people concerned about the restrictions about the vaccinations and other
02:58:29 such things i just got a feeling the inflammation has been coming from both sides and it's leading
02:58:34 to an ugly polarization that we might pay a terrible price for over the long run well look
02:58:39 I actually think that all of us that that are on programs like this are
02:58:44 elected politicians.
02:58:46 I think there is a potential problem that's going to develop over the coming
02:58:50 days. And that's the ballots, the mail-in ballot issue.
02:58:54 And I think it is very important for everyone that understands how the process
02:58:58 works,
02:58:59 actually explains it to those who are suspicious of how votes are counted in
02:59:04 Canada in general elections.
02:59:06 we all know that there's a representative from each political party there they call them a
02:59:12 a scrutineer and then there is a returning officer from Elections Canada and each representative of
02:59:20 a party in a particular riding signs off on this is how many ballots were counted and who received
02:59:26 what votes and so I do think that there's a responsibility on all of our parts on all of us
02:59:33 to explain to those that are you know prepared to do potentially dangerous things because they
02:59:43 don't understand how ballots are counted all right well let's go back to the map and Clinton
02:59:50 we'll come back to you in a little while thanks again for the input and update we'll see where
02:59:55 our numbers at now they're all starting to come in and we're going to come back with Vitor Marciano
02:59:59 shortly here as well so uh if we could pull up the map and uh we'll start we'll start in quebec
03:00:07 again uh remember we've got uh 30 sorry 78 seats up for grabs in quebec uh right now the bloc
03:00:16 quebecois leading or elected in 28 conservatives nine the liberals 34 and the new democrats
03:00:25 in three it's only about seven and a half percent of the ballots counted at
03:00:33 the moment and for those interested in the PPC they're bringing in about two
03:00:39 point seven percent of the votes so not what they would have hoped for moving to
03:00:45 Ontario where you've got a hundred and twenty-one seats up for grabs the
03:00:49 Liberals 75 leading or elected, the Conservatives 33, New Democratic Party 10.
03:01:00 Just so you know, a disillusion, the Liberals had 79 seats there,
03:01:05 so they're down a handful now, but only 6% of polls reporting.
03:01:11 Moving to Alberta, the Conservatives leading and elected in 29 seats,
03:01:17 the Liberals 2 and the New Democrats 2. Early days in Alberta, 3.5% of the polls reporting.
03:01:27 In British Columbia, only 1.6% of the polls in, and it's got the Liberals with six seats
03:01:36 and the Conservatives with three, the NDP party with four. What that means nationally is you're
03:01:45 looking at 147 Liberals elected and leading, 103 for the Conservatives, 27 for the BQ,
03:01:55 the NDP is leading in 23, or other is one. Maybe the PPC is leading somewhere, or the Greens.
03:02:06 Yeah, the Greens, I believe, are leading in Kitchener, actually. That's an interesting
03:02:12 interesting one right there. I believe that, unless I'm mistaken, that is a constituency where
03:02:18 the Liberal candidate was forced to step down, but was already locked onto the ballot. It could
03:02:26 be changed in time with Elections Canada. So the Liberal is on the ballot, but says he's not
03:02:31 running anymore. And so as a result, the Green candidate is leading there with about 36% of the
03:02:38 vote when I checked. Let's quickly check in. Do you know if it's Kitchener Centre or Kitchener South?
03:02:43 Try Kitchener Centre. Let's look at Kitchener Centre. Kitchener Centre in fact has the Green
03:02:49 Party ahead. Yeah, Mike Maurice, the candidate there. Only two polls reporting, so I'm not sure
03:02:57 how much we can read into that. Calgary Skyview, the Conservative Jag Sohota is leading former
03:03:04 City Councillor George Sahal after two polls with 40% of the vote and Calgary
03:03:11 Centre Greg McLean comfortably ahead. So we're gonna go to Vitor Marciano
03:03:17 right now but while we do that if production wants to try to rig up so
03:03:23 that Dave can have the map up on his screen so we can we can share his
03:03:30 screen up when he's going through the results. Vitor, right now we're seeing, I mean, if these
03:03:38 numbers hold, the Liberals are not far from a majority. Is it 155 for a majority or what is it
03:03:46 for majority? 170. It's 170 and they're not going to get there. Okay. Either way, they're in strong
03:03:53 minority government territory already. Yes, but it's ridiculously early and you're falling into
03:03:59 the trap that the cbc is doing and frankly i don't want you to do that uh granted there aren't that
03:04:04 many people watching in ontario the reason rosie barton's doing it on the cbc is because there are 0.59
03:04:09 people still in line waiting to vote in places like kingston and york and places like that and
03:04:15 you know the cbc is projecting a liberal government it's still too early uh half of the global news
03:04:20 also just uh called a liberal government uh yeah they haven't said it's a majority or not
03:04:27 uh you are quite correct to point out there is a lot still coming these are some of these are
03:04:33 one pole two poles out you can't read a lot into it that is unless it's uh like you know if when
03:04:39 a single pole opens up in crowfoot uh uh battle river crowfoot or something we can call that for
03:04:45 the conservatives because we just know what it is you don't even have to open a pole so you know
03:04:49 some of these writings you can uh but it it's a bit stuff actually let's bring that's one down
03:04:54 for now we don't have a proper map uh but where do you think this is going vitor well listen
03:04:59 10 15 minutes ago it was 130 to 60 now it's 146 to 105 or thereabouts uh 145 to 99 uh cbc's now
03:05:08 got conservatives at 105. um these are all the very very early results they really don't mean
03:05:15 anything unless you know where they're coming in from uh in atlantic canada the liberals didn't
03:05:19 have a great day it's too early to tell how they're doing in quebec or how they're doing in ontario
03:05:27 um you know i don't you know i don't believe that there's enough results yet in to tell how it'll
03:05:33 happen now are the liberals probably going to get the most seats yeah i think everybody uh knew that
03:05:41 if the liberals weren't going to get the most seats it was because they're going to be 30 or
03:05:44 40 extremely close ridings and frankly we wouldn't know until tomorrow um but the most seats are
03:05:51 probably going to be somewhere south of 145. um you know there's there's a lot of seats that
03:05:57 they're leading in that they're not going to win uh there's a lot of seats that the conservatives
03:06:01 aren't leading in yet that they have a good shot at winning i mean the alternative if you're if
03:06:05 you're thinking that way it's you know you're you're missing it there's still a lot of seats
03:06:10 that aren't reporting at all um you know the new democrats only have one person declared elected so
03:06:16 far so we take out the leadings when you take out the leadings and you go to elected on the seats
03:06:22 that we know it's roughly 27 for the liberals 24 for the conservatives seven for the bloc one for
03:06:27 the new democrats thereabouts it's going to go up and down by one or two over the next little bit
03:06:31 uh this is a close election i mean it's we knew it was going to be a close election um
03:06:38 Um, it's still very much up in the air. I think you can project that the liberals are going to
03:06:45 have the most seats, maybe still even a little too early to do that. I'd want to see another
03:06:51 half hour's worth of results come in. I mean, you know, basically the projection is coming in on
03:06:56 about 1.5 million seats. I mean, there's 1.1 million, 1.5 million votes. There's 1.1 million
03:07:03 votes to be counted in ottawa tomorrow so there's still so much counting to do that you can't make
03:07:09 these projections so many of these seats not how to had enough polls that you could extrapolate
03:07:14 that i mean once you get to 10 of a writing voting and somebody's got a clear lead yeah
03:07:19 you can project that nothing strange should happen with the rest of the writing but it's it's it's
03:07:25 too early uh i think there's every reason to believe that the liberals are probably going
03:07:30 going to end up in the 137 138 range and the conservatives are going to be in the mid 120s
03:07:37 that's a reasonable projection with what we see right now um this is going to be an election
03:07:46 that was largely for naught uh even as we sit right now uh justin trudeau's 11 seats back
03:07:53 from 12 seats back from where he was after the last election.
03:07:59 And it's, you know, the places that are left to report
03:08:04 are unlikely to deliver him even those 12 seats.
03:08:09 Yeah, I'm inclined to agree that the liberals are probably headed for another minority.
03:08:15 On this track, I think they're actually headed to pick up some seats.
03:08:18 I predicted they would probably shed a few seats, probably mostly at the expense of the Block and NDP would pick up a couple of Liberal seats.
03:08:33 But I thought the Liberals would still squeak through.
03:08:36 But it looks so far, again, your Vitor asteris is accepted.
03:08:44 The Liberals look set to pick up some seats.
03:08:46 Let's bring it home to Alberta, though, here.
03:08:48 Let's get Dave's map up on the screen.
03:08:53 Let's pull up Dave's map here.
03:08:57 Oh, okay, sorry.
03:08:58 One second here.
03:08:59 We're going to get Dave's map up on the screen,
03:09:00 but there's some very interesting results in rural Alberta.
03:09:05 It's not changing anything in terms of who's actually going to get elected,
03:09:08 but there is a not insignificant number of seats I'm seeing in rural Alberta,
03:09:13 at rural Saskatchewan while the PPC is running second or sometimes third.
03:09:20 They're quite distant seconds and thirds, but, I mean, we could look at Battle River Crowfoot,
03:09:27 Bow River in Alberta.
03:09:29 We can look at the Cypress Hills area in Saskatchewan.
03:09:36 Do we have, yeah, let's pull up Dave's screen now.
03:09:39 Do we have, there it is.
03:09:41 See that for a second.
03:09:43 So let's look at some of these results.
03:09:46 Medicine Hat, Cardston Warner.
03:09:48 We've got, so the PPC is in third.
03:09:51 Again, these are distant seconds and distant thirds,
03:09:54 understanding what it is.
03:09:56 Bow River, PPC in second.
03:09:59 Let's see, Foothills.
03:10:03 PPC in third.
03:10:05 In Saskatchewan, we're going to go to Cypress Hills Grasslands.
03:10:10 uh ppc in third okay uh so vtor obviously this is not going to change any um actual results uh
03:10:22 let's go back to to vtor on the screen uh this is not going to change anything in terms of the
03:10:26 results um but is this something for the conservatives to take notice of beyond a shrug
03:10:33 um in most of rural alberta it's a shrug because they can hold it uh it's you know in lots of
03:10:39 places i'm looking at banff airdrie right now the ppc is fourth um it's a shrug but the when when
03:10:47 the dust settles out tomorrow uh you know it won't be a shrug because uh the liberals may end up
03:10:55 winning edmonton center because of the ppc vote uh the you know edmonton greece spot right now
03:11:03 well it's still really early on in 15 polls dejaulet is ahead of carrie diont but it's just
03:11:08 super super early um the in edmonton center with uh 20 polls counted james cummings a little bit
03:11:17 ahead he he should be okay but the part that scares me is brock crocker for the people's party
03:11:23 he's got he's sitting at four percent with about ten percent of the polls counted if he stays at
03:11:27 four percent randy bossano has a shot at uh at winning that election when the uh when the votes
03:11:34 come in um it's it's yeah the ppc might end up being a spoiler right now it doesn't look too bad
03:11:43 edmonton millwoods uh you know very few polls in but tim upple's in good shape
03:11:48 uh on the very few polls that came in early um ultimately so far the ppc in alberta isn't
03:11:56 making a big impact um but there are six seats in alberta where they could end up making a big impact
03:12:03 um i think if you go to your tally now we should be getting closer to you know 145 to pushing 120
03:12:10 for the conservatives let's uh let's bring up the map again and we got the map here i can tell you
03:12:21 the national well let's zoom out i want to see it with the counter here here we are zoom out
03:12:33 Okay. All right, we'll not use this one for now.
03:12:38 Okay, let's just go back to Vitor.
03:12:40 Actually, Dave, give us an update first.
03:12:44 I've got the numbers here.
03:12:46 Nationally, you're looking at 145 for the Liberals,
03:12:50 117 for the Conservatives, 29 for the Bloc,
03:12:54 26 NDP, two others.
03:12:58 So that's 319 writings reporting out of 338.
03:13:03 So we've got about 20 more ridings to go.
03:13:06 The Liberals, some of the ones that they're in the lead on, they won't be in the lead on.
03:13:10 If they swept the 20 ridings to go, they'd still be short of a majority.
03:13:14 They're going to actually lose some of the seats that they're ahead on right now.
03:13:20 You know, Derek, I still hold that the Liberals are headed, you know, I guess, depending on what happens tomorrow in the votes that get counted in Ottawa.
03:13:29 but if i had to predict right now the liberals are in the 136 to 142 range probably you know i i call
03:13:36 it at 138 and the conservatives therefore are uh about 126 127. um the part that's surprising to
03:13:46 me right now is you know what happens with the missing seats so far you know that so far the
03:13:51 new democrats are underperforming um and the bloc quebecois is underperforming so but it's still
03:13:58 ridiculously early i mean we're still at the you know we haven't counted 3 million ballots yet
03:14:04 5 million canadians 5.5 million canadians voted in the advanced polls we haven't counted 3 million
03:14:10 ballots yet and you know that's why i think you know cbc and global projecting a liberal government
03:14:18 they're they're kind of jumping the gun here i mean you know uh when we go to a writing like
03:14:23 edmonton center that i know really well i know a poll by poll straight by street
03:14:28 it's still too early to say that you know with 10 of the polls in you know uh james cummings is
03:14:35 doing okay but i wouldn't you know without knowing exactly which polls they are i wouldn't know how
03:14:41 to interpret that result um it's it's it's still it's still too early to call the liberals will
03:14:49 probably have the most seats but it isn't a certainty yet that they will the uh the block
03:14:56 and the ndp are certainly underperforming most polls most polls uh i mean on on a really good
03:15:03 day today based on the numbers if the splits broke the their way the ndp were looking at
03:15:10 up to 40 seats which is about as good as they can do uh with the exception of that one big orange 1.00
03:15:17 wave in Jack Leighton's last election.
03:15:21 The Bloc also certainly underperforming.
03:15:24 They got all upset when it was mentioned in the English language debate that it's just
03:15:29 possible Quebec could be as racist as the rest of us.
03:15:33 That's not kosher stuff and that became a really big part of the debate there.
03:15:39 Vitor, I suppose you really have to bite them off piece by piece, the Bloc and NDP are such
03:15:44 different creatures uh but they're both underperforming and it appears to be to the
03:15:50 benefit of the liberals and and part that's why i say it's still really early because i don't
03:15:57 believe that the ndp only pulled out 16.3 percent of the popular vote and that's what they're sitting
03:16:02 at right now i mean 16 is what they got last time every pollster every poll every projection had
03:16:09 them doing better so i still believe that this is the result of early counts um the block at 6.8
03:16:15 that's within the range conceivably of where the polls had them the polls had them at 7.6 7.8
03:16:21 some of them had them over eight which is you know a big number in quebec um right now the liberals
03:16:29 are winning in the popular vote and i do not believe that that will hold i mean um i think
03:16:37 that this is a function of the fact that we're still, again, like I said, now we're getting
03:16:42 closer to 3 million votes counted. Again, 5.5 million Canadians voted in the advance
03:16:47 poll. So this next half hour will make the difference. I think the Liberals are going
03:16:52 to get the most seats. But I'm going to point out to you that right now, assuming that they
03:17:00 don't lose any of what they have and they don't pick anything up, I guess they could
03:17:06 govern with the NDP, that the liberals and the NDP combined would be 176. So they could actually
03:17:12 pass legislation with just the NDP. But if they start slipping a little bit, and if those slips
03:17:19 happen to the conservatives, then this becomes a different game. Now, the other thing to look at is
03:17:26 actually declared elected. If you go to just declared elected, the conservatives are ahead.
03:17:30 The conservatives have been declared elected. CBC is declaring 49 conservatives elected to 39 liberals elected.
03:17:39 So, you know, on the seats, taking away the seats that are still in play, the conservatives are doing OK.
03:17:45 That's not a surprise. There's lots of places where, you know, like you said, when when Crowfoot starts counting,
03:17:51 if the first three polls come in and there's no surprises, you know, there's not going to be any surprises in Crowfoot.
03:17:55 But, you know, I just look now, CBC has just, you know, CBC has now just moved the Conservatives into the 120 range.
03:18:04 You guys have them at 117.
03:18:05 That will change in, you know, the next few minutes.
03:18:09 Right now, Aaron O'Toole is headed in the direction of at least holding what the Conservatives had.
03:18:15 And I think there's every reason to believe that they're still picking up a few more.
03:18:18 I want to turn briefly to, let's just say the two, maybe could, let's see if they could possibly win their seats leaders.
03:18:34 We're going to start with Anime Paul.
03:18:35 Let's bring up the map, Dave's map here.
03:18:39 If we're looking at Toronto Centre here, there is only five of 137 polls reporting.
03:18:45 that's just 1,404 votes. Keep in mind, as Vitor said, you have to know where the votes are coming
03:18:53 from in a constituency. Certain streets will vote certain ways, and different streets will vote
03:18:57 others. But the early results coming out of that constituency have Green leader Anna Mae Paul in
03:19:04 fourth place behind the Liberals, the NDP, the Conservatives, and then of course her as the
03:19:11 Greens at 8.3%. It's obviously still very early to call that one. A very long way to
03:19:20 go. We're going to go in now to Bose, if we could just find that there. We're going to
03:19:26 bring up Bose. That is the constituency of PPC leader Maxime Bernier. A fair number of
03:19:32 polls voting, a long way to go, but not a very good trend for the PPC leader. 45 of
03:19:38 272 polls
03:19:40 reporting. Incumbent
03:19:42 Conservative Richard
03:19:44 Leroux
03:19:45 leading significantly with 48.4%
03:19:50 of the vote.
03:19:51 Maxime Bernier in second, but with
03:19:53 just 18% of the vote.
03:19:56 He's not yet been...
03:19:58 Some of the networks I'm seeing
03:19:58 are not yet declaring...
03:20:00 CBC has declared that one?
03:20:02 I believe CBC has.
03:20:03 Vitor, your thoughts on both of
03:20:05 these constituencies?
03:20:07 uh surprised with one not surprised with the other uh i'm sure quebecers were insulted 0.78
03:20:13 about maxine being in saskatoon today rather than being elsewhere so you know it's going to be one
03:20:19 of those things um uh with enemy paul really kind of shocked with that derek i'm going to see you in
03:20:25 an hour okay very good thank you very much for your time we'll see him again soon i think uh
03:20:33 we're Franco next? Okay, well, we're back to Franco Tarrazone with the Canadian Taxpayers
03:20:38 Federation. Before we go to Franco, though, let's get a general update of the board
03:20:42 from our news editor, Dave Naylor. Okay, let's start in British Columbia and work our way east
03:20:49 this time. Liberals and Tories basically tied. Liberals have 13 seats. Conservatives have 12
03:21:01 seats. The NDP seven. Alberta we've got the Tories leading in 32 seats. Liberals not leading in any
03:21:12 and the New Democrats leading in two. The key battleground obviously being Ontario as we all
03:21:19 know. Liberals leading or elected in 74. Conservatives 37. NDP nine. And in Quebec
03:21:29 We've got the Bloc with 28 seats, Conservatives 11 seats, the Liberals with 37, and the New
03:21:40 Democratic Party with two.
03:21:43 So what that means nationally is Liberals leading and elected in 152, Conservatives
03:21:50 121, Bloc 29, NDP 3, and others 3.
03:21:59 Okay, thank you for the update. We're going to go now to Franco Tarzan with the Canadian Taxpayers Federation. Franco, I know policy pays a big role in campaigns, and I know you're a policy guy, you're less of the operational politics in terms of your field, but there's going to be a big impact.
03:22:23 I don't know. It looks to me, I'm a bit more pessimistic than Vitor Marciano is.
03:22:30 I think it's in the bag for the littles at this point.
03:22:34 The conservatives have to, there is no such thing as a conservative minority government unless they have a very decisive plurality of deeds.
03:22:43 I'd be quite shocked if they catch up.
03:22:46 Of course, some of these things can flip.
03:22:47 mail-in ballots though look i mean the conventional wisdom is not always wrong and in this i accept
03:22:54 the conventional wisdom that convention uh that the mail-in ballots are going to favor new democrats
03:22:58 and liberals those are going to be voters who are scared stiff of covid and uh can't leave
03:23:03 obviously not entirely but are predominantly voters who uh feel they can't leave their house
03:23:10 to vote, at least in many of those cases. What's this looking like for you?
03:23:17 Well, okay, there's two things that we need to talk about. One is if these results hold,
03:23:23 what would it look for Canada's finances? So let's start there. I mean, first, this would be
03:23:28 hugely expensive, right? Let's look at the Trudeau government's track record heading into this
03:23:33 election. They put out a budget in April, which would nearly double the pre-pandemic debt in six
03:23:40 years, the Trudeau government put us on a trajectory where we wouldn't see a balanced
03:23:44 budget until 2070, right? In the meantime, we would rack up close to $4 trillion just in interest
03:23:51 charges on the debt. That's trillions of dollars over those decades that can't go to healthcare,
03:23:56 that can't stay in our pockets through lower taxes, because that would be going to the bond 0.85
03:24:00 fund managers on Bay Street. Now we're hearing the Trudeau liberals promising $78 billion in
03:24:07 additional spending on top of that. So, I mean, hugely expensive to taxpayers. And look, I think
03:24:13 we also have to bring up an important fact here. If these results hold, if the O'Toole Conservatives
03:24:19 lose, they will have loss after flip-flopping on key issues for taxpayers. Indeed. Now, Franco,
03:24:30 I know one of the great traditions of the Canadian Taxpayers Federation is the day after the election,
03:24:35 I'm sure you and your staff in the office there are busy right now calculating the pension
03:24:42 eligibility of defeated and retiring members of parliament, if you haven't already done it and
03:24:48 just put them all in the bag. Can we expect those numbers as per your tradition tomorrow?
03:24:55 Oh, well, stay tuned for that. We're definitely going to be releasing them relatively soon. I can't
03:25:00 you the exact date but yep we'll have uh mp pension calculations and severance checks rolling out as
03:25:06 that is outrageous franco when i was there i had it done that night i'd be on don martin the next
03:25:12 day with the numbers in my hand you gotta you're running a sloppy operation you're you're a man of
03:25:17 efficiency my friend that's what i can say there uh so if these numbers hold up uh it looks like
03:25:24 another probably liberal minority government probably a strengthened liberal minority government
03:25:30 uh again these numbers could still fluctuate quite a bit but even if they go up or down
03:25:34 uh that appears to be what we're likely looking at um what what can we expect from the canadian
03:25:41 taxpayers federation um over probably the next two years of a minority government what would be
03:25:46 you're going to keep holding them accountable uh for the massive amounts of spending and i think
03:25:51 really the key issue uh for taxpayers right now is is the government debt right the federal
03:25:55 government is already more than a trillion dollars in debt which means that each canadian is on the
03:25:59 the hook for about $30,000 in federal government debt alone. But, you know, I referenced the fact
03:26:05 that under the Trudeau government current trajectory, but even before this election and
03:26:09 all the massive spending that we wouldn't see a balanced budget until 2070. Well, if that were to
03:26:14 happen, then per person federal debt in Canada would balloon to $67,000, which would be just a
03:26:21 massive bill for Canadians, kids and grandkids to pay back. So I really do think the key issue
03:26:27 for taxpayers is going to be the government debt is going to be the billions of dollars that we're
03:26:31 losing every single year to the bond fund managers just in interest charges uh so i think that's
03:26:36 going to have to be the key issue for canadian taxpayers to really push back on uh so regarding
03:26:42 spending you keep you mentioned the liberals really expensive platform now it looks like
03:26:48 they're headed into a minority government potentially propped up by the ndp do you think
03:26:53 that your estimates or that wouldn't be your parliamentary budget offices estimates are on
03:26:59 the low end given the fact that the NDP could be holding the balance of power? Well I think that's
03:27:05 a great point because remember during this election the NDP are saying they would want to spend more
03:27:11 than 200 billion dollars on top of the last Liberal government's budget which was just massive
03:27:17 spending and you know what Josh I think you bring up a good point because when you look at that PBO
03:27:21 data that was forecasting deficits for five decades um that was still assuming steady economic growth
03:27:28 that was still assuming relatively low interest rates well what if reality isn't that rosy
03:27:33 what if canada stumbles into another economic downturn what if interest rates spike i think
03:27:38 that would be a huge a huge huge concern for for our federal government finances which are already
03:27:43 in shambles okay uh franco thank you very much we're going to come back to you soon very soon
03:27:51 We're going to have a PPC candidate from Airdrie, Banff, Nadine, Wellwood up.
03:27:56 But before that, we're going to go to Jonathan Dennis, one of our guests, the former Minister
03:28:05 of Justice and Solicitor General of Alberta, coming to us from at least one of the Conservative
03:28:10 campaign headquarters in Calgary here.
03:28:15 Let's bring Jonathan Dennis up.
03:28:20 There.
03:28:20 Okay, thank you. We're going to come back to you soon. Jonathan, how are things over there?
03:28:25 Well, so I've retreated back to my house just west of town, but you've looked here after Franco. It's a really tough act to follow.
03:28:33 Well, you're before me.
03:28:35 There you go. There you go. I'm going to tell you the big surprise tonight in Alberta, though, is Everton-Greisbaugh.
03:28:40 I'm looking right now, 42% for the NDP, 33% for my friend Kerry Niaud.
03:28:46 It's very clear to me that the NDP are seeking to expand their base in Edmonton.
03:28:50 They played the two election strategy against Raheem Jaffer in 2006, beat him in 2008,
03:28:57 and they've held the riding ever since.
03:29:00 I'm hoping that I'm wrong, but I think Kerry's in a bit of trouble tonight.
03:29:05 Well, you know, I hope so.
03:29:08 I mean, I think there's a lot of useless MPs in all the parties, but I actually like Kerry.
03:29:12 I think he's been solid.
03:29:15 Let's see.
03:29:15 Yeah, so there's only 40 of 232 polls reporting in Edmonton-Greisbaugh.
03:29:20 Still a lot of time for him to make that up, but he is down by exactly 10 points right now, 5,205 votes in in Edmonton-Greisbaugh.
03:29:31 It's going to be tight.
03:29:32 I know the NDP have really focused on that as an offensive operation.
03:29:38 They've been confident in holding Edmonton-Stratkona, which has really been, I mean, if there is a single left-leaning federal seat in El Paso,
03:29:45 Alberta. It's been largely Edmonton, Strathcona. But Edmonton, Grisbach, they've really gone
03:29:52 after that one. Kerry Diot is, I mean, I don't even think the guy's a red Tory. He's actually
03:29:58 a pretty solid true blue conservative. He's not an Aaron O'Toole true blue. He actually
03:30:04 does seem to hold to it. So the Edmonton really have made an effort going after him. Jonathan,
03:30:10 what's your take on how some of these tighter inner city Calgary races are going?
03:30:14 Okay, so my friend Greg McClain, I was working on his campaign today. He's running away with it. He's a very likable guy. He's a good guy for the ride. He's a little redder than me and probably of you as well. He represents the riding well. He works really hard. Intelligent guy. Calgary Skyview, it looks like Jag Sahota is running away with it as well.
03:30:31 I long predicted that the moniker of Trudeau Liberal in Calgary was not going to do well for George Chahal.
03:30:37 He had endorsements from people like Jeff Davison, Drew Farrell, Ward Sutherland.
03:30:41 That didn't bear fruit for him, trying to unite the left there.
03:30:44 I don't see him succeeding here as well.
03:30:47 Edmonton Centre is going to James Cumming, it looks like.
03:30:50 The only two races really to watch in Alberta are Edmund Strathcona.
03:30:54 That's going to the NDP.
03:30:56 Edmonton-Greesbaugh, too soon to tell.
03:30:58 I'm looking nationally, though, and I'll say this, is that the benchmark for Aaron O'Toole
03:31:05 is 130 seats. That's the amount of seats that Andrew Scheer got in 2019. It does appear that
03:31:13 there's going to be a Liberal minority government here, which I fear. The Liberals have a much more
03:31:17 efficient vote than the Conservatives do. The PPC may have been a deciding factor in Ontario. It
03:31:23 It hasn't been in Alberta because the spread is just so strong.
03:31:27 You're going to Ontario.
03:31:29 That may cost the Conservatives some seats.
03:31:31 It's going to be very interesting to see what happens.
03:31:34 But, you know, my eyes tonight are on Carlton.
03:31:36 My friend Pierre is doing over 50% and a seventh straight victory.
03:31:41 Yeah.
03:31:42 Josh Andrus has got a question for you in one second here,
03:31:45 but we'll just kind of run through some of the numbers in inner Calgary here.
03:31:49 Calgary Centre Greg McLean leading clearly as Jonathan Dennis said 42.9% of the vote well ahead
03:31:56 of Suprina Grover of the Liberals at 29.6 although still quite a bit to come in 15 of 228 polls
03:32:04 I can't say the number but I believe there was a very significant advance poll in that
03:32:11 constituency which is distinctive from the mail-in ballot I don't I think the mail-in ballot will
03:32:16 lean towards the leftist parties. Advanced polls, I think, just leans towards the more
03:32:21 organized parties, and that could be different parties and different constituencies. Another
03:32:26 constituency that the Liberals were targeting, Calgary Confederation, doesn't appear to be in
03:32:32 too much trouble yet. Incumbent Conservative Len Weber is leading 45% of the vote with 35 of 260
03:32:44 the polls reporting. Josh, let's go to you.
03:32:48 Yeah, so you mentioned that you think the Liberals are going to hold on to a minority
03:32:52 government. Oh, I'm sorry. We have to, I'm sorry to interrupt. Maxime Bernier is currently
03:32:58 speaking to supporters right now. Have we got the feed ready for that? Production, have
03:33:06 we got that ready? Almost. I'll put a pin. Okay. We're going to go to Max. Jonathan Dennis,
03:33:16 thank you very much. I know we were going to go to Jonathan. Maybe we'll check in with you later
03:33:19 tonight if you're available. We appreciate your time. We're going to go to Nadine Wellwood.
03:33:25 We'll actually just get some thoughts from her if we pull Nadine in right now. But Nadine, 1.00
03:33:32 We're going to go to Max as soon as we have that feed up.
03:33:37 Oh, I believe.
03:33:38 Here we go.
03:33:38 We're going to go to Nadine as soon as we're done hearing from Mr. Bernier.
03:33:48 We are standing by to hear from Mr. Bernier in just a second.
03:33:55 Jonathan, how quickly do you think George Sahal declares for his old council seat?
03:34:01 Well, actually, it's funny you say that, because for him to declare for his council seat, he would have had to file today. There's been no news media to indicate that he did. I would put a spike in his political career at this point.
03:34:18 I know the Liberals were very much gunning for that seat.
03:34:21 They were.
03:34:22 They put everything in there.
03:34:25 Where are we at with getting Mr. Bernier up? We're ready to go?
03:34:30 Okay, we're going to go to Mr. Bernier speaking to his supporters right now.
03:34:38 My friends, today we made history.
03:34:40 Let's try to turn it up if we can.
03:34:42 Again, when we started, when we started this campaign five weeks ago, everybody thought we would only be...
03:34:53 That's a good time. I need to sub.
03:34:55 at the beginning the media did not even cover us and then they had to start paying attention
03:35:12 yes they have to start paying attention because thousands of canadians were coming to our rallies
03:35:21 all across the country everywhere we looked you could see purple a purple wave a sea of purple
03:35:39 my friends this is not just a political party it is a movement it is an ideological revolution
03:35:50 that we are starting now
03:35:59 today over a million canadian said they've had enough enough of this
03:36:08 covid hysteria enough of the flattening our rights
03:36:14 and freedoms. Enough of the massive spending, deficit and government overreaching. Enough
03:36:24 of the lives of establishment politicians. Like me, like me, they are mad. They are mad. 0.97
03:36:35 They want to have their normal lives back.
03:36:47 They don't want the tyrannical Chinese model that you admire, Mr. Prime Minister. 0.99
03:36:56 They don't want that.
03:36:59 The other parties are all in favour of lockdowns of vaccine passports and segregation.
03:37:19 The other parties are all in favour of a bigger government that increase the debt every day,
03:37:26 control your lives and that limit your freedom of expression during the last 19 months it has been
03:37:34 quite clear quite clear that our rights and freedoms are threatened if we do nothing to stop
03:37:42 this authoritarian drift we can say goodbye to our way of life the people's party of
03:37:50 Canada is now the only true opposition party in Canada we will continue to
03:38:03 fight for our freedoms outside of Parliament in the street in order to
03:38:08 influence public opinion of the order parties will fight for your rights and
03:38:14 And that's why today the People's Party has become Canada's only, only real opposition
03:38:23 party in Ottawa.
03:38:31 The only, the only party that's opposed to all this nonsense that is destroying our society,
03:38:41 economy and our country. If we had a proportional voting system, we would have elected about
03:38:55 20 MPs today. Unfortunately, we won't be able to carry on this fight in Parliament,
03:39:06 But we will continue this battle to unite Canadians under the freedom umbrella.
03:39:16 Canadians who oppose the rise of tyranny and authoritarian government need a voice.
03:39:27 are going to be that voice all right listening to some of what the People's
03:39:39 Party of Canada leader Max Bernier has to say the supporters in his speech
03:39:43 tonight People's Party of Canada hasn't won a single seat tonight they've got
03:39:49 Dave Coletti you've got more information about exactly how many votes they've
03:39:53 garnered so far and what kind of an impact they've made so far we'll will
03:39:58 continue to watch they may be making a difference in some seats but certainly
03:40:02 not winning any seats tonight and Max Bernier talked about they've collected a
03:40:07 million votes we're certainly not seeing yet so he's still got audio okay well
03:40:15 that was Maxime Bernier the first leader to come up with a speech in this
03:40:20 election that seems to have led nowhere so we do have from the ppc though next nadine wellwood
03:40:27 she's been on our show a couple of times before and uh she was running up in banff airdrie
03:40:34 so how are you doing tonight nadine i'm doing great you guys how are you
03:40:41 good good thanks so i i haven't had a chance to look directly at the numbers out in banff
03:40:45 Ferdrie, how are you doing there?
03:40:47 Um, we currently sit at 7.6% and of course the conservatives are at 56.4.
03:40:54 Um, I think the big surprise probably for most people will be the, um, NDP that are
03:41:01 now polling at about 16.8, but, uh, of course there are only 55 of the 300 polls.
03:41:08 Uh, so 18.3% in so far.
03:41:11 We've been as high as 10.4 this evening, and hopefully it keeps going up.
03:41:19 Yeah, well, it's still early in a lot of room for things to change.
03:41:24 So maybe I'll just get your thoughts on this general election across the board.
03:41:29 I mean, I still think the PPC was impressive.
03:41:31 You've really established, made waves, definitely impacted many races and the tone of the election itself.
03:41:38 How do you feel about the campaign as a whole?
03:41:40 You know, I think as a whole, we have done an amazing campaign, you know, from 1.6% nationally to seeing numbers like 7, 6% in multiple ridings. And, you know, we now are truly a national party and we're getting the right recognition.
03:41:59 And Max said it right. He just explained we are really the only opposition left in Canada.
03:42:06 And it's going to be nice to have some higher numbers, even if it is just a popular vote, because, you know, we have a lot of Canadians right now that are feeling that there's not a party other than the People's Party of Canada that represent them when it comes to their rights, their freedoms, smaller government, less spending on so many different platform issues.
03:42:29 Nadine, Derek Sloan came in with a bang, a big announcement, basically drawn flies tonight.
03:42:39 Why was not his campaign received so well? Derek Sloan's from Ontario. Albertans are not going to
03:42:46 give their support to somebody from Alberta. And I said that, I said that in my announcement when
03:42:52 I made it very clear to Derek to go home. He was wasting his time here. You know, and nobody here
03:42:59 in the the west really knows who he is i mean i went door to door just as well as he did
03:43:04 and uh we didn't bring up his name but nobody asked either and so many of my friends and
03:43:10 colleagues close by who you know we did kind of test the water to see you know well what do you
03:43:16 think of derek well who they honestly did not know who he was yeah well in parachuting
03:43:24 particularly from ontario into the west when we're a country that's got a lot of regional division
03:43:28 going on. I mean, it was just a very bizarre decision on the part of Mr. Sloan. I remembered
03:43:35 his kickoff. I mean, he did have some old classic reformers there, Art Hanger and Eric Lowther.
03:43:40 Rob Anders.
03:43:41 Rob Anders was there. But really, I mean, this hasn't translated any support on the ground.
03:43:46 I'd imagine this is probably going to be the end of Derek's career.
03:43:49 I suspect so. You know, right now he's here right now at 2.5%.
03:43:57 And, you know, I understood before he came to this riding that he was polling at eight percent in his old riding where his wife is currently running this evening.
03:44:11 And, you know, I stayed in this riding. This is my home.
03:44:14 I didn't just pack up and leave, you know, when I got three point four percent in the last election, you know, because this is my home.
03:44:21 Where do you go if you're not willing to stand and defend your home?
03:44:24 So I think he hurt himself by packing up and coming to Alberta.
03:44:29 But, you know, we reap what we sow sometimes, too.
03:44:33 Yeah, well, so going farther forward now, though, you've built a solid base.
03:44:38 Definitely a large part of it, though, was cornering the individual freedoms against the restrictions, the vaccinations, the passports, things such as that.
03:44:46 We talked a bit with Maxime Bernier when he came on earlier on our show tonight.
03:44:50 Where do you go after that, though?
03:44:52 like for one that the pandemic is going to go aside I know the need for individual rights won't
03:44:56 go away but there won't be that very evident flash point like where are you going to go to
03:45:02 maintain or increase those gains that you've made well I think I disagree with you I think they're
03:45:07 going to stay and I think especially if we see strong support like what we're seeing right now
03:45:12 with the liberals I think you're going to see a lot more people become disenfranchised with
03:45:18 these lockdowns. Even people who are double vaccinated are not happy about having to show
03:45:24 their papers to go to a restaurant. And what happens when one night you go to a restaurant
03:45:29 and you forgot your phone, you know, and you're busy and you forgot your phone and they're like,
03:45:34 well, where's your papers? Well, it's on my phone. Well, where's your phone? Well, I forgot it at
03:45:39 home. You know, so I think this has got a short lifespan, but I think Canada really is at a
03:45:44 crossroads, to be honest. And we're going one of two directions. We are going full-on socialist,
03:45:51 you know, the full-on let's, the government has complete control over everything in your life,
03:45:56 or more and more people are going to take a harder stance and fight back for their freedoms.
03:46:02 And I think that probably within the next, you know, four to six months, I think that's going
03:46:07 to be a very telling time for Canada to see which direction that we truly do end up going.
03:46:11 okay um you know just uh it's interesting where we've seen some of the smaller parties get a
03:46:21 varying levels of support of course um so what do you sort of see for the the ppc or the green party
03:46:28 or some of these smaller parties uh in terms of you know say maybe wanting to support uh
03:46:34 uh proportional representation we've heard trudeau talk about looking at uh reviewing
03:46:40 in the electoral system again, moving away from a first-past-the-post voting system that we have
03:46:46 today, more towards maybe that European type of system. Do you have any more comment on
03:46:51 if this election may change or cause a bit of a wave of voter sentiment towards a different kind
03:46:58 of voting system? Well, I don't think there's any incentive for Justin Trudeau to do any of that.
03:47:03 This system works quite well for the Liberal Party. And, you know, he made a lot of promises
03:47:08 in 2015 about electoral change, and we're still here in 2021 doing the exact same thing. Why?
03:47:15 Because it works for him and it works for his party. So, you know, I don't believe anything
03:47:18 that Justin Trudeau has to say with respect to making electoral changes. He's had plenty of
03:47:24 opportunity to do that. And in defense of, or to add to that, I have no trust or faith in the
03:47:31 Conservative Party of Canada either that is run basically on a liberal platform. Every policy is
03:47:37 exactly the same. And they won't push for electoral change either. Because when, you know,
03:47:43 they finally find out the formula that works, you know, they're going to want to keep the power as
03:47:47 well. I mean, so it's the problem with government that we have, you know, the role of government is
03:47:52 polling, you know, they go, they poll, and then they buy the votes. And then they, you know,
03:47:57 bicker about who's going to do what. And it's just really, it's about who's going to give more money
03:48:01 to whom. So I mean, I think that this is the part that I really do appreciate about some of the
03:48:06 smaller parties. And I think they're even shifting away a little bit from, you know, their values and
03:48:12 what they stood for. But this is where the People's Party is really fantastic, because
03:48:16 it is values-based. It is principles-based. And when we run again in 2024, 2023, or whenever it's
03:48:24 going to be, the platform's still not going to change. Why? Because the values are still the
03:48:29 same. And Max made it very clear. We are the only opposition right now in Canada. The rest of the
03:48:38 parties are all sitting so far left that I noticed in the news the last couple of days, we're no
03:48:47 longer far right. We're just slightly right of center now. And it's not because we're right of
03:48:53 center. We've always been, I think, center, but everybody else has moved so far left that it just
03:49:00 skews the scale. Well, a lot of that consideration is regional. We've definitely still have the same 0.96
03:49:07 regional divide. I mean, the Conservatives are solid in the prairies. Ontario and Quebec are still
03:49:15 very much liberal along with the Maritimes predominantly. But I remember after the last
03:49:22 federal election when the liberals came in with a minority we had a very strong resurgence
03:49:26 of regionalism and secessionism in Alberta. I got a feeling we're going to see that flare up a lot
03:49:32 again tomorrow and while the Maverick party didn't really make a big splash this time around
03:49:38 I got a you know the appetite for a regional voice is going to be a heck of a lot stronger
03:49:44 tomorrow than it is today and that's also kind of dipping into the same swimming pool of where
03:49:48 you're going is there room for talks or coalitions or somehow because because you guys are all kind
03:49:53 of targeting the same alternative vote well i mean i'm looking at the maverick party and they
03:49:58 got 1.6 percent and so i said this at the beginning with the maverick party the problem is not east
03:50:04 versus west um they're making it regional but and and we do have some regional issues absolutely i'm
03:50:10 not disagreeing with that but the people's party of canada under our platform and our policies we
03:50:15 address that because the issues are actually not about geography. I've said this before,
03:50:20 you know, we have less in common with the lower mainland of BC than we do with some
03:50:25 conservative rural ridings in Ontario and Quebec. This is a battle of ideology. Right now,
03:50:33 what we're seeing is Canada slide towards this socialism and social, and I'm saying socialism
03:50:39 because people don't like to think of it as communism, but we really are there. We're at
03:50:44 that crossroads where Canada right now, the government is dictating what they can and cannot
03:50:49 put into your own body. You have no freedoms left. So, you know, what is there left when you can't
03:50:55 defend your own autonomy as an individual? So, you know, when I look at that, I think they have
03:51:02 to give real consideration to, you know, what direction they want to take, because this is not
03:51:07 necessarily a regional issue. This is a battle of ideology. And I think anybody who really stands
03:51:14 for freedom i think we do need to consolidate we need to come together under one banner and uh and
03:51:21 and fight for what what's most important we can bicker about the details after but uh right now
03:51:27 we've got you know our freedoms and rights under attack and i think that's what we need to stand in
03:51:31 defense of yes well and when i did speak to mr bernier about um how to deal with the regional
03:51:37 issues he spoke of greatly decentralizing the the power in ottawa and and backing out of the
03:51:42 the provincial authority because of course that's the rubbing point of quebec and alberta is when
03:51:45 the feds come in start messing around with with our jurisdictions but i'm perhaps you guys could
03:51:51 be the stronger lone voice pushing for that because uh we seem to have nothing but authoritarians in
03:51:55 the predominant parties right now absolutely and we are advocating we always have for more
03:52:01 provincial autonomy but here's the problem and you guys both know this um it's not the federal
03:52:08 government's job to give back uh the autonomy to the provinces it's the province's job to take it
03:52:14 back it's theirs it's already there you know people talk about police forces they talk about
03:52:20 pensions which is what a lot of the maverick party has been talking about they belong at
03:52:24 the provincial level fighting for the province's rights that they already have the ucp under jason
03:52:32 kenny is flawed why because again we have another ontario politician who came in he was going to
03:52:38 save and rescue alberta that hasn't worked out so well but he's not doing for albertans what
03:52:44 albertans asked of him and we already it's already there we don't need to make any constitutional
03:52:50 changes or anything at the federal level at the provincial level we just need to take back the
03:52:55 powers that we the province already has yeah well the provincial hornet's nest is fodder for a whole
03:53:01 other special and show down the road. Alberta is in a special place right now and a very volatile
03:53:07 one. I got a feeling we're going to be seeing a lot of activity on the provincial front in the
03:53:12 next few weeks now that a lot of people have been biting their tongues as this federal election goes
03:53:17 by there. So I'll let you go and I appreciate your checking in with us and well we'll be watching
03:53:23 closely to see where things go in Banff Airdrie. As I've mentioned before Banff's the town I grew
03:53:28 up in. I've still got a soft spot for that area. There we go. I just can't afford to live out
03:53:33 there anymore. So good thing I got in early then. Yeah. Well, if Derek could give me a raise, you
03:53:39 know. Okay. So we'll check in again. Thanks again for coming on tonight, Nadine. And I'm certain
03:53:45 we'll talk again soon. My pleasure. You guys have a wonderful night. Corey, I can update a couple of
03:53:52 Alberta writings. The Tories are winning in every writing in Alberta except for two.
03:53:59 Edmonton, Strathcona, Heather McPherson, the NDP candidate, the incumbent, is comfortably ahead.
03:54:07 She's got 58% of the vote. The conservative candidate, more than 3,000 votes behind with
03:54:15 27%. And the close one, as mentioned before, Edmonton Greaseback, the new Democratic candidate,
03:54:25 Blake Desjarlais, with 41% of the vote, 4,611 votes to the commentator, Terry Deox, 36%,
03:54:36 4,045 votes for about a 550-vote differential there.
03:54:43 Taking a quick look provincially, the predicted three-way race in British Columbia has come to fruition.
03:54:52 The Liberals leading in 15, the Conservatives 14, and the New Democrats 12.
03:55:00 Alberta, as mentioned, 32 to 2.
03:55:04 Ontario, obviously, where the election will be likely won or lost.
03:55:08 Liberals leading and elected in 76, in the last election they had 79, so they're down just a little bit.
03:55:17 Conservatives leading or elected in 36, which is exactly the same number they had last time,
03:55:23 and the New Democrats, 8, which I think is also pretty well close to the same as they had last time.
03:55:31 So it doesn't appear to be a great swing in momentum in Ontario at the moment,
03:55:37 And Quebec, Liberals, 35 seats leading or elected in the last election.
03:55:45 They're also leading or elected in 35.
03:55:48 Conservatives have 12 seats.
03:55:51 That's up two from the last election.
03:55:56 And the Bloc kind of underperforming with 29 seats, down by three from the last election.
03:56:03 So nationally, interestingly, the Conservatives now have more of the popular vote.
03:56:11 They've got 34% of the popular vote, but that only is translating into 123 seats, while the Liberals have 156 seats with 32.7% of the vote.
03:56:26 The block, 29 seats, the NDP, 28, and looks like the Green Party with two.
03:56:35 Well, you know, I was going to say, Dave, I think of it, I think I'm feeling like Bill Murray over here.
03:56:40 It's Groundhog Day all over again.
03:56:45 $600 million for nothing.
03:56:47 And that national map that disappeared quickly there, but that picture of it really shows a regionally divided country.
03:56:55 You got this big blue mass in the middle and you've got every other color in the rainbow on the outsides.
03:57:02 Like the prairies did not have a liberal breakthrough.
03:57:05 We didn't switch away from conservatives, but we got the short end of the stick as usual.
03:57:11 I mean, basically the arrogant attitude from central Canada is, well, if you guys want in, you're just going to have to vote liberal.
03:57:17 And it's clear Alberta's not going to do that. 1.00
03:57:19 I mean, the rebellious Albertans went in NDP.
03:57:20 you know we've got some very heavy regional wounds to heal after this election it wasn't an
03:57:28 anti it wasn't really originally divisive campaign but the outcome you can see this this country has
03:57:34 some some very different perspectives i think the big winner out of this election is paul hinman
03:57:39 the leader of the wild rose uh independence party i mean he must be rubbing his hands in glee as
03:57:45 He's watching these results roll in and seeing that he's got Trudeau.
03:57:49 I mean, every time Trudeau opens his mouth,
03:57:51 Hinman gets more people signing up for his independence party.
03:57:57 You know, and I think there's two other things.
03:57:59 I just picked up when you were doing the vote count there.
03:58:01 Of interest to Calgary voters,
03:58:05 it looks like Greg McLean's got a really strong lead there,
03:58:09 so he'll be comfortably re-elected as I was expecting.
03:58:11 But the latest refresh I saw was the MP Sahota in Counter-Skyviews, just leading by less than 100 votes.
03:58:21 So it's still quite close. There's only about 50-some polls, I think, of 200 and some there yet.
03:58:27 So early yet in the night, who knows how these mail-in ballots will work out.
03:58:32 We often see that change the course of an election as they get counted.
03:58:38 But, you know, beyond that, too, when you're seeing Paul Hinman potentially being a good leader,
03:58:43 it'll be interesting to see what happens with the Maverick Party after this.
03:58:47 Obviously, a bit of a disappointing result from what perhaps I think a lot of people had been hoping they would get.
03:58:56 And the other interesting thing for me is you saw the Conservative Party send more of a traditional message
03:59:04 and run a traditional Conservative campaign under Andrew Scheer.
03:59:07 And that led to a result where, you know, minority government for the Liberals, but won the popular vote marginally.
03:59:16 Here we are again.
03:59:17 Yes. 0.60
03:59:18 Same thing, different strategy, better strategy, replace that incompetent old team.
03:59:24 We're going to go win this time.
03:59:26 Same result.
03:59:27 Just the latest has George the Hall actually leading in Calgary Skyview by 160 votes.
03:59:34 So that's going to be going back and forth all night long.
03:59:37 Okay.
03:59:38 So we've got a couple of guests in the queue back there.
03:59:40 We got Jonathan Dennis and Vitor Marciano.
03:59:43 So welcome back guys.
03:59:45 Um, I think we're beyond the point of saying that we can wait and things
03:59:49 might shift dramatically.
03:59:50 Uh, we're, we're starting to get a pretty good picture on where this
03:59:53 is all heading and going to end up.
03:59:55 Uh, we'll start with you though, Vitor, uh, what are you reading today?
04:00:00 Wow.
04:00:00 I mean, we knew that it would end up exactly in the same place.
04:00:04 strikingly yeah um the part that's amazing is that the new democrats they're they're four or
04:00:12 five point lead in the polls relative to where they were in 2019 has evaporated tonight uh there
04:00:19 wasn't a single poll that had them below 18 most of them had them around 20. uh they're polling 16.9
04:00:26 so you're literally going to get the liberals at about the same number the new democrats
04:00:30 at roughly the same number the conservatives at roughly the same number the blocks up a little
04:00:37 bit but it's not winning them any extra seats um wow uh what an interesting interesting mix on this
04:00:45 um as as the numbers come in and there's still a lot of votes to be counted but um you know my
04:00:54 last segment i said the liberals were going to end up in somewhere in the 136 to 142 range nope
04:01:00 they're going to be at least 150 and uh it's uh you know the with the support of the new democrats
04:01:07 they can pass anything they want with the support of the block they can pass anything they want
04:01:11 so they don't need to kind of deal with anybody uh because they'll both be available to them as
04:01:15 somebody but i don't know how jagmeet singh survives this two elections in a row with
04:01:21 the new democrats around 16 i think he's done um it's it's a big surprise to me it certainly
04:01:29 wasn't a gain uh so yeah we got a 600 million dollar stalemate basically uh uh look looking
04:01:36 through calgary alberta where you've been watching those ridings are you seeing any
04:01:40 we got a horse race going on in skyview is there anything outstanding going on out there
04:01:44 so the big surprise here is how close it is that average uh it's clear that the ndp uh over the
04:01:51 last few years have had to have a strategy to consolidate they've tried to move over to having
04:01:55 in a green spot.
04:01:56 I wouldn't be surprised if you see a recount in that area.
04:01:59 There's only about a 700 vote difference.
04:02:03 Typically you get a recount under 100 votes.
04:02:06 You can ask for a judicial recount,
04:02:07 otherwise we've been able to do that before.
04:02:10 It'll be interesting to see what that goes
04:02:11 with the mail-in ballots.
04:02:12 The mail-in ballots typically favor
04:02:14 the more left-wing parties.
04:02:16 So the bigger story to me though is, as you mentioned,
04:02:19 I look at the conservative vote federally, 34%,
04:02:22 the Liberal vote, 32.5%,
04:02:24 but the Liberals are gonna form a minority government here.
04:02:27 The Conservatives are getting 10 fewer seats
04:02:30 than we had in 2019.
04:02:32 So we have to ask ourselves,
04:02:33 do a bit of soul searching here.
04:02:35 What is the strategy that works?
04:02:37 Stephen Harper won 2006, 2008,
04:02:41 and a majority in 2011 as a Conservative.
04:02:45 So we have the PPC, which are not a factor in Alberta
04:02:48 because the margins are so high.
04:02:50 I wanna see how many votes on the post-mortem
04:02:52 PPC took away from the Conservatives and maybe we want to regroup our strategy. We can never
04:03:00 forget our right flank and I've seen this from my own personal experience,
04:03:04 Conservatives win when we're united. I got a question for you, both you guys. You're both
04:03:11 a lot of deep experience in organizing and really doing that grunt work like GoTV,
04:03:19 identifying your vote. And one of the things that I'm thinking with some of the disappointment
04:03:24 that's coming from the NDP, the PPC, the Maverick, the Greens, is obviously the Liberals and the
04:03:32 Conservatives are much more experienced in organizing and doing GoTV. PPC is very new.
04:03:40 NDP in the last election was a disappointment. They've continued that streak, but they've lost
04:03:44 a lot of perhaps organizational capacity maverick didn't have a lot of organizational capacity it
04:03:50 seems to me ppc was more of a feeling than organization do you guys think that's played
04:03:57 into this uh these election results in in in many ways i think what we've established with this is
04:04:04 that you can change policy in a little bit you can change message you can change leader
04:04:09 I think the Conservatives are winning 120 seats on the strength of their organization.
04:04:15 I mean, in all honesty, you know, we were at 121 last time.
04:04:20 We're sitting at 120.
04:04:21 There's every reason to believe that we'll end up back at 120.
04:04:24 I actually thought they were going to head closer to the 130-some mark.
04:04:30 It's almost like we're not finding a way to get to that next level of convincing voters.
04:04:37 And in this election, if, you know, last election, I think it was, you know, 2.6%, 1.6% of the vote, the PPC helped the liberals win five or six seats, depending on how you want to parse the vote.
04:04:52 I think with 5.2%, when it all gets counted, the PPC is probably going to help the liberals win 10 or 12, maybe even 15 seats.
04:04:59 But that still wouldn't have been enough.
04:05:01 I mean, 15 seats would have put O'Toole in the 135 range, so it would have been roughly tied with the liberals.
04:05:07 um fundamentally uh you know part of this is the fact that the country's stacked against us never
04:05:15 forget the 2.5 million atlantic canadians elect 32 mps 4.4 million albertans elect 36
04:05:23 so literally you know we have almost twice the population we get four more seats
04:05:28 when you when you combine alberta and british columbia we have a million more people which
04:05:34 should be 10 seats. We have two more seats than Quebec. We have a million more people than Quebec.
04:05:39 We only get two extra seats, not 10 extra seats. There's an awful lot of built-in imbalances in
04:05:46 how Canada runs, but that's relatively unchangeable. And in this election, if that NDP vote
04:05:55 was at 20%, where all the polls had it, or 18 or 19, it would be a little different. But right now
04:06:03 it's at 16.9 and that's going to elect 156, 157, 155, 158 liberals. And that's where it's going.
04:06:14 So something I pointed out on the map just before you came in, and it's certainly an issue near and
04:06:19 dear to my heart. I got a feeling we're going to see quite an uprising of regionalism going on.
04:06:23 There's that big blue hole in the middle of Canada, that frustration. A lot of people out
04:06:29 here, Phil, that we did moderate, you know, the CPC backed off. I mean, we can argue about whether
04:06:34 it's a carbon tax or not a carbon tax. He certainly got in on carbon pricing. You know, he softened
04:06:40 the stance on the firearms, and it feels like it led to nothing. How is O'Toole going to be able
04:06:47 to stem that rising ire, I guess you'd say? You know, Jonathan, I don't think he's going to.
04:06:55 Like, I think O'Toole's in a little bit of trouble because he needed to add to the overall play.
04:07:03 And if he comes in in the exact same place, I don't know how he holds up.
04:07:07 He hasn't come in the same place.
04:07:09 We're looking at 121 seats right now.
04:07:11 Last time on our average year was 130 seats.
04:07:13 Very similar result.
04:07:15 It was 121.
04:07:16 Okay, then I stand corrected.
04:07:18 So you're at the same place.
04:07:19 A leader has to go in advance his or her cost.
04:07:22 So there will be some decisions to be made.
04:07:25 Whether he stays on is up to him.
04:07:27 At the end of the day, though, I'll just put this out there.
04:07:31 I'm out on Saturday night downtown with a friend of mine.
04:07:35 A couple of people out there came.
04:07:37 Somebody came to me and says, you know, I'd like to see Pierre Polly as the leader.
04:07:40 And I said, really, are you political?
04:07:42 He says, no, I'd like to see Pierre Polly.
04:07:43 I said, why?
04:07:44 He says, he gives me a reason to vote.
04:07:46 He's fighting for me.
04:07:47 He's fighting for my family.
04:07:48 And whether it's him or somebody else, the Conservative Party always has to be the party of the average Canadian, fighting for the average Canadian.
04:07:58 There's way more average Canadians than there are CEOs.
04:08:01 Maybe we have to do some soul searching here.
04:08:05 Jonathan, I've got to pick up on you.
04:08:08 Everyone I talk to says, you know, Conservative Party.
04:08:10 But you know who I'd really like to see is Pierre Paulie.
04:08:15 it's just i hear that all the time guys but that's us conservatives we like fighters yes
04:08:22 yep and and and let's be clear it's by no means proven that ontarians like fighters or quebec
04:08:28 likes fighters this is one of these things we have not figured out i mean stephen harper who's
04:08:34 the last one to win was a very gentle fighter malrooney when he won was a very gentle fighter
04:08:39 so we'll we'll see what it looks like in an hour when i'm back but uh vitor i'll just tell you this
04:08:45 I'm looking at Carleton, where Pierre has cruised to his seventh straight victory at 47%.
04:08:50 Jonathan, let's be clear, that's heavy conservative territory in Carleton.
04:08:57 Oh, no, actually, in 2004, Pierre beat the Minister of National Defense at age 24.
04:09:05 That writing has gone liberal many times throughout our history.
04:09:08 He carries that on his own.
04:09:10 Well, and then I think that's what Jeff's poking the stick at.
04:09:13 I'm being sarcastic.
04:09:15 is that fire in the belly populism can turn Ontario voters potentially.
04:09:21 If the right person's putting it out there, it could happen.
04:09:25 I will just leave you with this, okay?
04:09:27 We're in some deep doggy view as a country here because you have 156 Liberals, 0.98
04:09:32 you have 29 Bloc, 29 NDP, they vote together, hang on to this.
04:09:38 Oh yes, and I mean, the other thing is, Trudeau's going to come into this,
04:09:42 he's going to be able to govern like he has a majority for a little while because Canadians
04:09:47 are ticked off. We just, as I said, at a $600 million stalemate, none of those parties is going
04:09:52 to pull him down on a confidence vote. I mean, they would be annihilated if they dared to do
04:09:56 that. So he can put in some policies that it can be pretty, whatever he likes. Nobody's going to
04:10:02 call him on it right now. We're doing this again in 18 to 24 months. Instability does not do well
04:10:08 Canada, particularly in a precarious situation like COVID-19. We've racked up ridiculous amounts
04:10:15 of debts, some of which was necessary because of the crisis. The question is, is this government
04:10:21 actually going to pull back the spending, or are we going to run perpetual deficits? We're already
04:10:25 seeing the effects of this. Inflation has already doubled over the last two years, making things
04:10:30 more expensive for average people. You know what I would say, my only piece of advice to a 0.95
04:10:36 conservative leader that I think would guarantee victory in the next election.
04:10:40 Hands down,
04:10:42 common support across the country is if they got rid of all of those calls from
04:10:48 the CRA and the RCMP that are just pure scams.
04:10:55 You were behind all those calls I keep getting.
04:10:59 They're annoying. Okay. We're going to pivot now.
04:11:01 We've briefly got Michelle Rempel-Garner in the lobby there coming from the conservative campaign. 0.92
04:11:09 If we can pull her up.
04:11:10 Thanks for joining us there, Jonathan.
04:11:13 Thank you.
04:11:14 Oh, I'm going to go through some numbers.
04:11:15 Oh, no, Dave's going to go through some numbers.
04:11:17 Sorry.
04:11:18 But we're going to have Michelle shortly.
04:11:20 And so hang on there.
04:11:24 And let's look at what we're doing nationally.
04:11:27 as uh we've been talking about it looks like we've got a liberal minority government uh liberals are
04:11:34 uh leading and elected in uh 156 seats
04:11:41 Block 29,
04:11:43 28, 29
04:11:45 also, and
04:11:47 the Green Party too.
04:11:49 Looking here
04:11:51 at Marine Hall,
04:11:53 looking at the
04:11:57 West,
04:11:59 it's basically a dead heap.
04:12:01 British Columbia
04:12:03 with the Liberals slightly ahead
04:12:05 with 15 sheets to the conservative
04:12:07 13, and then the Democrats
04:12:09 also matching them with the first game.
04:12:13 In Alberta, the Conservative seats are almost there.
04:12:18 The Liberals are leading in one, that's Calgary and the NDC are leading in two,
04:12:27 both in Edmonton, Edmonton Stratford, and Edmonton-Griesbach.
04:12:32 In Ontario, Liberals 76 seats leading in elected.
04:12:38 The Conservatives with 36 seats meeting and elected, and the New Democrats with 8 seats.
04:12:47 Quickly to Quebec, the Bloch with 29 seats, the Conservatives with 12, and the Liberals
04:12:54 with 35 seats.
04:12:56 So what it gets nationally is the Conservatives have 34 percent, so 34.1 percent of the popular
04:13:05 vote with the Liberals at 32.3% of the vote. So Derek, those are the latest numbers to now.
04:13:14 All right. Well, we're going to be turning now towards the campaign headquarters of Michelle
04:13:20 Rempel. She is the newly reelected Conservative Member of Parliament for Calgary Nose Hill.
04:13:28 Let's bring her into the feed. Good evening, Michelle. How are you doing?
04:13:31 I'm well, thank you.
04:13:34 Oh, I'm sorry.
04:13:35 I didn't have my headphone in there for a second.
04:13:37 How are you doing?
04:13:37 I'm well, thanks.
04:13:38 You can hear me?
04:13:39 We're good?
04:13:40 I can hear you now.
04:13:42 Thank you so much for joining us.
04:13:44 Big surprise, Michelle Rempel re-elected by a very hefty margin. 1.00
04:13:51 How are you feeling right now?
04:13:54 I'm really honoured to have been given another mandate by my constituents,
04:13:58 and I'm ready to get back to work for them.
04:14:01 Obviously, it's a bit bittersweet. You've obviously secured re-election in your constituency, but we have, I mean, if someone bumped their head and went into a coma two years ago and woke up today, they'd probably think it was the same day.
04:14:19 looking at the results of this election, Justin Trudeau headed for his third consecutive government
04:14:25 or third term, second consecutive minority government. I know you can't be that pleased
04:14:32 about it, but where do you, I think we probably share some common ideas about what this means,
04:14:39 but where do you think the conservative campaign went wrong in really trying to convince Canadians
04:14:48 that it was time not just for change but for a conservative government? Well I think that's the
04:14:55 wrong question. I've knocked thousands upon thousands of doors over the last six weeks and
04:15:00 what I've heard from my community is that they want stability and they want a path out of the
04:15:04 pandemic. There's a lot of fatigue and there's a need for hope. So I think what you're seeing
04:15:12 tonight you know if you if you think back six weeks ago you had national media strategists
04:15:17 and pundits saying that this was going to be a cakewalk to a majority government for Justin
04:15:22 Trudeau. And what you saw, I think tonight is reflected in the fatigue and in the desire of
04:15:27 the Canadian public to have solutions and leadership when it comes to the crisis that
04:15:31 our country is in right now. And, you know, that is what I am going to be doing tomorrow morning
04:15:36 is getting back to work. There are so many things that I wish we could have done as a parliament
04:15:41 over the last six weeks that we could have turned our attention to, but we had this election. And
04:15:46 And to your point, you know, the results are very much, I don't think, what Justin Trudeau expected them to be.
04:15:54 But now we have a duty and an obligation to the Canadian people to put our heads down, get back to work and chart a path out of this.
04:16:04 I know you've got a lot of media requests.
04:16:07 We're not going to overstay our welcome with you.
04:16:09 We're going to let you go in a second.
04:16:12 Let me ask this.
04:16:13 What do you think it is?
04:16:15 You said I asked the wrong question.
04:16:17 Let me try a different question or put it a different way.
04:16:21 What do you think that the Conservative Party needs to do differently?
04:16:25 It appears the Conservatives are headed, like last time, for a victory in the popular vote.
04:16:31 But the popular vote obviously doesn't decide the government or seats necessarily.
04:16:35 What is it in your mind that could have gone differently?
04:16:41 let's put it that way, that could have changed the outcome of tonight?
04:16:47 I mean, I'm just coming off of like, you know, six weeks of hardcore door knocking and I'm trying to get my bearings.
04:16:53 But based on what I've heard in my community, it's people just want to stability and they want a path forward.
04:17:00 I think what people don't want right now is a bunch of infighting and political instability.
04:17:06 Our path forward as a party, but more importantly, as a set of parliamentarians of all political stripe has to be a clear and non-divisive and unifying bringing set of policies to get us through the pandemic.
04:17:23 I can't stress that enough. I heard it over and over and over and over and over on the doors.
04:17:29 we need to get through this um so i mean i'm sure there's going to be a lot of questions about how
04:17:35 that is achieved um and as always you know i i put my community first and i'm proud to speak on
04:17:42 behalf of alberta i think alberta has a lot of unique challenges coming out of uh the pandemic
04:17:48 we were already in an economic crisis going into it um so what i'm focused on now is making sure
04:17:53 that those needs are loudly and strongly voiced at the national table but also that the right
04:18:01 frustrations that my constituents have expressed over you know the need for stability and unity
04:18:06 after a completely unnecessary election that's it's get back to work time. Okay just before I
04:18:15 let you go one last question and I don't mean to put you on the spot but it's a question I think
04:18:21 a lot of people are getting right now.
04:18:23 It's a topic of discussion
04:18:24 pretty much everywhere.
04:18:27 How much impact, if any,
04:18:28 do you think the,
04:18:30 let's call it just the current confusion
04:18:32 in the provincial government had,
04:18:35 how much of a bearing did that have
04:18:37 on the provincial campaign?
04:18:39 Well, certainly I received
04:18:41 a large mandate from my community
04:18:43 and I would say that
04:18:44 that's based on my track record,
04:18:45 my results,
04:18:46 and as well as our party's platform.
04:18:49 That's something that
04:18:50 I'm going to take to heart and move forward in executing. Okay, Michelle, thank you very much
04:18:56 for your time. Congratulations on your victory tonight and good luck in the next week. There's
04:19:02 a lot of work ahead. Take care. All right, you take care. All right, that was Michelle Rempel-Garner.
04:19:09 She is the newly re-elected Member of Parliament for Calgary Nose Hill. Certainly someone I think
04:19:17 we're going to want to keep our eyes on over the next term of Parliament.
04:19:21 She is certainly one of the more prominent frontbenchers,
04:19:25 probably the most prominent Conservative or Federal Member of Parliament period
04:19:30 in Alberta from any party.
04:19:33 I've got to ask, why do you look like a giant compared to Josh and I?
04:19:38 I think he does that on purpose.
04:19:39 I'm bigger.
04:19:40 I'm 95% sure he's done this on purpose.
04:19:43 Okay, my chair is about half an inch higher because mine needs a swivel
04:19:46 because it's in the middle.
04:19:48 Do you want to change chairs or would you like a phone book?
04:19:50 No, no, no, that's fine. 0.91
04:19:51 I just wanted on the record to say that, you know, Joshua are not midgets. 0.62
04:19:59 I'll lean back here. 0.54
04:20:00 Okay.
04:20:02 Who do we have up next here?
04:20:06 Let's see.
04:20:08 Okay, we're going to have Aaron Gunn up next,
04:20:10 but I think it behooves us to go through the numbers right now.
04:20:15 So, Mel, let's pull up the map.
04:20:20 I don't know.
04:20:21 Oh, my goodness.
04:20:22 Someone has just walked into our office with pillows for the bums of... 0.99
04:20:27 You can't see it, but there are pillows flying across our screens.
04:20:31 It is pandemonium in the studio right now
04:20:36 so that these guys can have big boy chairs and sit up with me.
04:20:42 Dave Naylor is going to run us through the numbers before we redecorate the office anymore.
04:20:48 Okay, thanks, Derek.
04:20:50 Let us start off in the West, where we all good things are.
04:20:55 In the West, let's start with British Columbia, 14 to 14 for the Conservatives and the Liberals,
04:21:03 both tied with that number, the NDP, only one behind at 13 seats.
04:21:09 Moving eastward in Alberta, the Conservatives performing strongly again with 31 seats, leading or elected, and Liberals leading in one, which would be Calgary Skyview, and the NDP leading in the two Edmonton seats.
04:21:28 Ontario, not much has changed, you've got the Liberals at 76, the Conservatives at 37,
04:21:39 and the New Democrats at 7.
04:21:43 In Quebec, the Bloc Quebecois is 29, the Conservatives 12, and the Liberals with 35.
04:21:53 Tell you what, I'm just going to quickly call up Manitoba and Saskatchewan, see how things are doing there.
04:22:04 Manitoba.
04:22:07 In Manitoba, Conservatives leading seven seats, the Liberals four, the New Democratic Party three,
04:22:17 The People's Party, who had campaigned strongly in parts of Manitoba, with a respectable 8.2% of the popular vote.
04:22:28 In Saskatchewan, I've got to credit the Elections Canada website. It seems to be working pretty good tonight.
04:22:36 In Saskatchewan, well, it's 14 to nothing.
04:22:41 Conservatives have won every single seat in Saskatchewan.
04:22:46 Yet again, I think that's the second election in a row.
04:22:50 So what you're looking at nationally, Canadians, is Liberals leading and elected in 156,
04:22:58 The Conservatives in 123, the BQ with 29, the NDP 28, and the Green Party with 2.
04:23:09 Conservatives continue to lead the popular vote, 34.1% to 32.1% for the Liberals.
04:23:18 Derek?
04:23:19 Thank you, Dave.
04:23:21 All right.
04:23:22 The popular vote's pretty interesting in this.
04:23:25 The Conservatives, for the second consecutive election, have won the popular vote but lost the election.
04:23:31 Tell it to Hillary Clinton. 0.68
04:23:33 Someone tell Hillary Clinton that this is an illegitimate election. 1.00
04:23:37 It doesn't count because someone else won the popular vote.
04:23:41 Second consecutive election, the Conservatives are up, at least at this point,
04:23:44 two whole percentage points over the Liberals, 34.1 to 32.1.
04:23:51 It is incredible, though, that the two biggest parties, together, barely cobbled together two-thirds of the vote.
04:23:59 That is incredible.
04:24:01 In Canada, people have lost so much faith in the big parties that only two-thirds of Canadians have voted for the big so-called center-right and the big so-called center-left party.
04:24:12 The NDP underperforming the polls pretty considerably tonight with 17.2 block, as you said, 8.2.
04:24:19 You know, the Bloc actually didn't do that bad in the popular vote.
04:24:22 I'm surprised they didn't yield more seats out of that.
04:24:26 We're going to have to dive into those numbers a bit more,
04:24:29 because that must be a lot of bad splits for the Bloc.
04:24:32 The Bloc must have had a particularly inefficient vote today, at least by Bloc standards.
04:24:36 They got pretty much half the votes of the NDP and just as many seats.
04:24:41 So the Bloc has, yes, a very efficient vote, but by their own traditional standards, it was not a good election.
04:24:47 The PPC is the least efficient vote in Canada.
04:24:50 Right now, they've got 5.2% of the popular vote.
04:24:55 Pretty respectful.
04:24:56 Dave, maybe you can pull up while I'm going through this.
04:25:00 I'd like to see the popular vote of the PPC in Alberta,
04:25:03 and then if we get to see the provincial breakdown for that.
04:25:07 I can.
04:25:08 The popular vote for the PPC in Alberta, 7.3%.
04:25:12 7.3%.
04:25:14 Yeah, so they're going to need a fair bit more,
04:25:16 and they're going to need to cluster it in some particular constituencies.
04:25:19 The Green Party absolutely shellacked in the popular vote, 2.2%.
04:25:25 Yet, they are right now leading or elected in two seats.
04:25:30 You know, the Greens spent quite a few of their, you know, they were a fringe party for a long time.
04:25:35 The first election under, their first election under Elizabeth May,
04:25:39 they actually did fairly decently in the popular vote, right around what PPC actually got this time.
04:25:44 Didn't get any seats.
04:25:45 But then, I forget which election it was.
04:25:47 I think it may have been 2011.
04:25:49 Elizabeth May said, okay, I'm not going to care about the popular vote anymore. 0.91
04:25:54 I want to get some seats.
04:25:55 And they found a spot where they thought she could win.
04:25:59 And they focused on it.
04:26:00 And they drilled in.
04:26:01 And they drilled in.
04:26:02 And they got a beachhead.
04:26:03 Last election, they had three seats.
04:26:05 A record for them.
04:26:06 This election looks like they're getting two. 0.95
04:26:08 At least they're in Parliament.
04:26:09 It seems to me it behooves the PPC to, I don't know, try to get some seats.
04:26:16 They've certainly had a big impact, but I think at some point, Josh,
04:26:24 do you think they're going to change strategy away from just trying to harvest as many votes across the country as possible?
04:26:31 PPC?
04:26:32 Yeah, do you think they're going to undergo something like the Greens and actually try to concentrate their support?
04:26:37 support? Or do you think their goal right now is just to continue to try and get as
04:26:41 harvest as many votes as possible, regardless of where they are?
04:26:43 I don't know how much of this was strategic and how much of this was just the fact that
04:26:48 COVID became a bigger ballot box question than I think we thought in mid-August. They
04:26:55 definitely cordoned off a large section of the unvaccinated or vaccine-hesitant people.
04:27:02 and I don't necessarily know if that's going to be an issue in two years from now,
04:27:09 but they definitely made an impact.
04:27:11 I think I heard, I think it was Vitor mentioning Edmonton Giesbrecht,
04:27:17 where it looks like longtime MP Kerry Deyotte is going to...
04:27:24 Well, I'm not sure long time. He's had a few terms.
04:27:27 Yeah, he's not quite. I think he's a couple weeks short of his pension,
04:27:31 so that's unfortunate.
04:27:32 Well, there's just a little over half the polls reporting there.
04:27:35 So I think that Knight is not done yet.
04:27:38 I mean, he's behind.
04:27:41 6.5% for the PPC, that definitely makes up the gap in Griesbrecht.
04:27:48 I think that's the only riding in Alberta that they're going to have that kind of an
04:27:52 impact.
04:27:53 So all the fear...
04:27:54 Oh, we've got a Calgary seat here, Calgary Sky, Georgia Hall has pulled ahead, PPC 4%.
04:28:01 Yeah, so it's definitely, it's been a play.
04:28:05 I know a lot of people in rural Alberta were using the vote split argument
04:28:10 as a reason not to vote PPC,
04:28:13 even though it may have been a party that better aligned with their interests.
04:28:18 But, like, we're seeing massive wins in a lot of these rural ridings.
04:28:23 Damian Couric is up 71%.
04:28:26 He's got to 10% over the NDP.
04:28:28 You've got Martin Shields in Bow River, 69.8% to 11.9% PPC.
04:28:36 So the don't split the vote argument in a lot of those ridings doesn't come into play.
04:28:42 But yeah, definitely Calgary Skyview, Edmonton Griesbeck.
04:28:47 Looks like Len Weber.
04:28:48 How's Centre doing?
04:28:51 Centre is Greg McLean, 50.
04:28:54 It's shocking to me that Centre was that much of a blowout.
04:28:58 The center is often fairly competitive.
04:29:00 Sabrina Grover, the Liberals had pretty high hopes that she'd be able to make it happen 0.96
04:29:05 this time.
04:29:06 I mean, they held it under Kent Hare.
04:29:09 Kent Hare was actually pretty broadly liked.
04:29:11 I mean, even people who aren't Liberals like him because he's a nice guy, but obviously
04:29:15 had a bit of trouble and wasn't particularly supported by Trudeau in that.
04:29:22 So yeah, I'm shocked that Sabrina Grover and the Liberals were not more competitive this
04:29:26 evening.
04:29:27 Actually, more than half of the polls to come in.
04:29:29 Yeah, more than half left to come in, so...
04:29:30 I mean, it's highly likely, like, that's a pretty damn big lead.
04:29:35 5,000 votes, yeah.
04:29:36 Yeah, and he's been declared elected, at least by some of the networks here.
04:29:39 He's probably elected, but there's a lot to come in.
04:29:42 Glenn Weber's been declared elected as well, so...
04:29:44 Yeah.
04:29:45 Yeah.
04:29:46 Well, and just in case it wasn't obvious, I mean, we have said so,
04:29:49 but just to make it official, the Western Standard, for what it's worth,
04:29:54 we're absolutely calling this for the Liberals.
04:29:57 The Liberals are going to form a minority government tonight.
04:30:02 The mail-in ballots are still to come, but if the conventional wisdom holds to be wise,
04:30:10 then that's probably only going to compound Liberal victories.
04:30:13 I think some of these, I'm not sure how much of a change it's going to be in Liberal NDP
04:30:19 switchers, but in conservative, in close conservative Liberal races, if there's a close margin
04:30:25 victory there there's a not insignificant chance that we're going to see uh several conservatives
04:30:32 um probably not be as happy a few days from now once those ballots come in yeah and i wish we had
04:30:38 more time with uh michelle because i was she of course was one of the leaders of the buffalo
04:30:46 declaration signed by i think it was four mps back in 2019 and if you look at the map and there's
04:30:52 There's very much a blue hole in the middle.
04:30:56 Well, it looks exactly like it did last time.
04:30:57 And it looks like the Liberals are leading, but I'm going to refresh this.
04:31:02 Okay, well, we're going to come back to that in a moment.
04:31:04 We've got another guest here.
04:31:06 We have Aaron Gunn joining us from British Columbia.
04:31:10 Aaron, we're about to add Aaron.
04:31:13 Here's Aaron Gunn.
04:31:14 Aaron, it doesn't look like you're at a happy party anymore.
04:31:19 No, it doesn't.
04:31:20 That's, I mean, we'll see, we try to get a better internet connection, so we came out here, but some, I mean, mixed feelings from people.
04:31:28 I think, to be honest, this is what everyone was expecting.
04:31:32 This is almost identical to what we got last time, and here we are again.
04:31:37 So, I don't know, I just got to this new location, so it looks like, what are we at, the Liberals down a couple, Conservatives up a couple, maybe NDP up a couple.
04:31:50 Okay, well you're obviously not pleased about it. I know you're not a liberal.
04:31:57 We're going to have another fascinating guest coming to us from the west, but this time to the east of Alberta.
04:32:02 We're going to have Quick Dick McDick joining us from Saskatchewan.
04:32:07 I'm trying not to lie. It's just the greatest name ever.
04:32:10 I think I love him. I think he's great. I'm looking forward to it.
04:32:13 Aaron, where do you think the Conservatives went wrong here?
04:32:16 They, again, won the popular vote.
04:32:19 Erin O'Toole moved sharply to the left or to the center, depending on how you're considering this.
04:32:26 A pretty hard move to the left, adopting most of the key liberal policies around balanced budgets, around carbon taxes,
04:32:35 very closely mirroring the liberal positions on things like vaccine passports.
04:32:42 I mean, I don't think you could ask for a much more progressive conservative than you
04:32:48 could get with Aaron O'Toole.
04:32:51 Where do you think the conservative campaign went wrong?
04:32:55 Well, I think they tried to campaign as liberals and I don't know how much more electoral evidence
04:33:02 you need to showcase the fact that when conservatives don't present a clear alternative to people,
04:33:09 they don't campaign on conservative ideas and conservative platforms um they don't win they
04:33:14 don't go anywhere i think if voters want to vote liberal they know who to vote for and when
04:33:18 progressives want progressive options they already have three or four options depending on what part
04:33:23 of the country you're in so um i think they went wrong i think the flip-flop on on uh the trudeau
04:33:29 gun ban was terrible and hurt them i think um going into the the pre-campaign flip-flop on the
04:33:35 carbon tax conservatives. And at the end of the day, I just think he didn't, he didn't stand for
04:33:40 anything. And if you don't stand for anything, how can you ever hope to, to earn new voters?
04:33:48 Yeah. Well, what do you think happens next? Aaron O'Toole was elected as the true blue
04:33:55 conservative. He is the heir to Stephen Harper and Preston Manning. You know, he was able to,
04:34:01 at least on the final ballot, win with significant Western support and dominantly from the right side of the Conservative Party.
04:34:09 Do you think Aaron O'Toole is long for the political world, or do you think he's going to be able to get another kick at the can?
04:34:16 I think there's definitely, there's already a movement within the Conservative tent that's pushing for that to happen.
04:34:24 I'm not in a position to count who's got more power.
04:34:27 I do think that Aaron O'Toole has a lot of supporters within the Conservative Party establishment in Toronto and Ottawa, which tend to pull a lot of the levers within the party.
04:34:36 But I think among the grassroots, there's a lot of people that are frustrated.
04:34:40 But maybe more importantly, Derek, the question becomes, is there someone who's willing to step up to take his place?
04:34:46 I think that becomes the next big question, and who might that somebody be?
04:34:50 And that might make the decision a little bit more interesting.
04:34:54 Well, I'm just going to have to put you on the spot because you just opened yourself up for it.
04:35:00 Who do you think would be a short list of potential candidates if the leadership of the Federal Conservative Party was to open up?
04:35:08 Well, look, I think everybody, if Pierre wants it, Pierre Polyev, obviously he's got the biggest following.
04:35:16 There's still some uncertainty with why he didn't go last time.
04:35:20 Some people might wonder if Peter McKay will take another kick at the can.
04:35:23 I mean, one thing I will say about Peter McKay is if you were going to run on a kind of progressive conservative platform anyways, I'm sure he would have been the better choice or the more presentable choice to Canadians.
04:35:37 And then you've got a bunch of new younger MPs in the West and maybe someone make a name for themselves or we will see.
04:35:45 But look, I mean, if Pierre Polyev is able to assemble a team, I think it's, I think it's, it would be his to lose.
04:35:53 I mean, I guess Rona Ambrose's name you could throw out there.
04:35:56 Some, some conservatives may still fantasize about a return to Stephen Harper, but I think that's, that's the reality on the ground and that's where the energy would be.
04:36:05 Yeah.
04:36:06 Okay.
04:36:06 Thank you very much, Aaron.
04:36:07 We're going to come back to you in a bit here.
04:36:09 We're going to want to, next time we see you, we're going to want to chat more specifically about some of the results in British Columbia specifically.
04:36:16 Before we go to quick Dick McDick out of Saskatchewan, I know Green Leader NMA Paul is speaking right now.
04:36:25 I don't think we're going to go, we're not going to listen to her speech, but if production wants to pull up on a second screen, pull her up on the side just as she's speaking.
04:36:36 We'll keep her on muted if that's possible.
04:36:39 But in the meantime, let's bring Quick Dick McDick into the conversation here.
04:36:46 Quick Dick is a farmer and I don't know what else to call him, a social media phenomenon,
04:36:54 or maybe just a phenomenon from Saskatchewan.
04:36:57 What part of Saskatchewan are you in right now, Quick?
04:37:00 Tothnold, Eric.
04:37:01 Yeah, the best part of Saskatchewan.
04:37:05 It's a de facto capital.
04:37:07 I'm pretty sure that they went for Regina, but Tufnall was a close second, I think, is where it was.
04:37:13 The population of 40 really catapulted us to the front.
04:37:21 Well, actually, you know what?
04:37:22 Right before we come to you, we kind of came to you,
04:37:25 but let's really quickly maybe get a brief on where we're at in Saskatchewan.
04:37:29 I don't think we've actually done our due.
04:37:31 14 to nothing.
04:37:33 Clean sweep.
04:37:34 Clean sweep again.
04:37:35 You're beating us now.
04:37:36 We used to be rat-free and liberal-free and New Democrat-free,
04:37:42 but, you know, we've got little pockets coming up.
04:37:45 You guys did a clean sweep.
04:37:47 Before I ask you for your overall reaction,
04:37:50 what's your reaction for tonight in Saskatchewan?
04:37:53 Well, I think everyone is really watching.
04:37:55 DMC really close here tonight with Buckley Belanger
04:37:58 was actually probably what most people were watching,
04:38:01 the closest in Saskatchewan.
04:38:04 And I think it might have been a little bit of a shock
04:38:06 to a lot of people too that he actually didn't kind of pull out front there uh but like honestly
04:38:12 guys i i literally just just got sat down here and i'm actually a little bit behind and i was
04:38:18 shocked uh when i came home here tonight and kind of got caught up on things that that we're at where
04:38:25 we're at we are at the exact same spot that we were in our last federal election you know 600
04:38:32 and odd million dollars change later, uh, with no change whatsoever. What, what is happening here,
04:38:39 guys? Yeah. The results in Saskatchewan, well, as I said, it's a clean sweep. Uh, the only really
04:38:47 news is, uh, some of the seconds and thirds. Um, yeah, there was, uh, I mean, the PPC is broken
04:38:56 through. I shouldn't say broken through that's probably too generous, uh, but placed some,
04:39:01 some thirds and some seconds around uh at least around rural uh saskatchewan um
04:39:09 they failed to win any seats anywhere tonight uh really failing to concentrate their vote in any
04:39:16 inefficient way but um what did you see on the ground you're in rural saskatchewan
04:39:23 um this was this party just a pure protest or do you think it has any
04:39:27 really room for growth in the future no it's it that's a good question i think where we saw a lot
04:39:32 of things with the pbc specifically i mean if you want to call it rural saskatchewan or even
04:39:37 central saskatchewan kind of thing um side note i'm not shocked that bernier did not win his seat
04:39:45 and i i think anyone that was supporting pbc or does support pbc you need to have a real close
04:39:52 look at your leader um and i i think that was a very epic failure of the party but uh specifically
04:40:00 saskatchewan wise here i i think that you saw a lot of protests and a few different things going
04:40:07 on pre-election that maybe set a little bit of a stigma if you want to call it for the ppc that was
04:40:13 maybe not the best stigma that you'd want to have set for your party um i'm i'm i'm actually kind
04:40:19 of shocked that the maverick party did not do better than they did uh and full disclosure i
04:40:25 will say that the the maverick party was running some great candidates uh in in a lot of their in
04:40:31 a lot of their ridings that they were running in and uh i i think they actually put up a pretty
04:40:37 good fight with the candidates that they had and and gained no support off of it um but i don't
04:40:44 know if their timing is quite right on this election to be trying the platform that they're
04:40:49 trying and it's it it's almost saddening for the simple fact there's the maverick party speaks for
04:40:56 a lot of what rural saskatchewan is um but i just don't think it's to the point where everybody's
04:41:03 ready to say hey it's it's the west or get bent kind of thing if that makes sense yeah i was quite
04:41:10 shocked by i was not shocked tonight by the results of the maverick party almost non-existent
04:41:16 really um i i think there actually is a very significant appetite for at least the concept
04:41:24 of what the maverick party is offering i think it's an idea that this time has come
04:41:29 but the problem they ran an uninspiring campaign first of all they said we're not going to run
04:41:37 anywhere where the
04:41:39 liberals are
04:41:41 sorry, where the conservatives could possibly
04:41:43 lose. And while I appreciate
04:41:45 that argument, first of all, voters don't
04:41:47 understand vote splits.
04:41:49 Some might think they do, they don't. There is
04:41:51 no such thing as a vote split in
04:41:53 the Cypress Hills or in the Round
04:41:55 Medicine Hat, but
04:41:57 people still think there is. Voters don't understand it
04:41:59 first of all. Second of all, it kind of presumes
04:42:01 that the conservatives have some
04:42:03 inherent right to the vote
04:42:05 and you don't have
04:42:07 and you should never violate that inherent right.
04:42:10 But most importantly, they didn't seem to grasp the zeitgeist around, you know,
04:42:19 the resistance to authoritarianism that we're seeing right now,
04:42:23 resistance to vaccine passports, resistance to lockdowns, to other intrusions on liberties.
04:42:29 I know that's not why that party was founded,
04:42:31 but it's very much the concerns of huge numbers of Westerners,
04:42:34 particularly Westerners outside of the largest metropolitan centers.
04:42:39 And they just really failed to capture that.
04:42:41 So I went into this election expecting probably Maverick to mildly outperform the PPC.
04:42:49 It wasn't that inspiring coming in.
04:42:52 I mean, I don't really fault their leader much.
04:42:54 I think they benefited tremendously by having a guy like Jay Hill brought them a lot of credibility and organized them.
04:43:00 But the party lacked any fight.
04:43:03 It wasn't very fighty, and so by election day, it really didn't have much.
04:43:09 Josh, you have a question.
04:43:11 Yeah, no, it's not really a question.
04:43:13 It's just more of an observation.
04:43:16 I think another reason that Maverick and the PPC had a difficult time breaking through
04:43:20 was because there is a tremendous anti-Trudeau sentiment,
04:43:25 and for a lot of people, they're going to vote against Trudeau,
04:43:27 even though they may align with Maverick or PPC or some combination of both.
04:43:33 that it's just hard to break through when all anybody's thinking about
04:43:37 when they go to the poll is we've got to get rid of Trudeau.
04:43:40 And I really think that, like, the Reform Party didn't win in 1988 with Pierre,
04:43:49 sorry, 93, they didn't win the West in 93 with Pierre Trudeau as prime minister.
04:43:55 At the time, Brian Mulroney was prime minister.
04:43:58 and no separate or third party broke through.
04:44:05 New right league parties almost always only succeed in breaking through
04:44:11 when you have a very centrist or even center-left conservative party in power.
04:44:16 You saw that with the Reform Party and Brian Mulroney slash Kim Campbell.
04:44:19 You saw that with the Wild Rose Party and Ed Stelmack and Alison Redford.
04:44:28 Thank you, Rapunzel, if that's your real name.
04:44:31 Quick Dick is the best. 1.00
04:44:32 We do have great guests today.
04:44:35 Josh accepted.
04:44:38 Well, that's just rude.
04:44:41 I think so.
04:44:42 So, let's just quickly, what's your thoughts nationally?
04:44:47 I actually expected to see a little bit more of a swing in the Maritimes than we saw,
04:44:53 uh to be perfectly honest especially with what happened with uh with Nova Scotia's provincial
04:44:59 election um I was a little bit shocked by the GTA I I thought O'Toole would do better in the GTA
04:45:06 and uh that's obviously not the case I'm I'm not shocked uh by our Prairie Provinces results here
04:45:14 right now uh yeah there's some mail-in votes and some things to come in yet but I really don't
04:45:18 think we're going to see that much of a change and it just I guess maybe a question that a lot of
04:45:23 canadians are going to be asking themselves now is is where do we go from here and i even find
04:45:28 myself asking that same question is it's not what i expected i did not expect to see the liberals
04:45:33 have the support that they do um and i don't know where we do go from here uh and i i i keep falling
04:45:42 back to the maverick party here with with the candidates that they were running and and and
04:45:46 they did really fantastic but we saw in the maverick party with a bigger part of their
04:45:53 platform was that uh they were not going to split the vote because they were only running
04:45:58 predominantly in conservative ridings and it it just in canada unfortunately just it boils down
04:46:05 to to a seat count and and that's all that it boils down to and whether one seat would go to
04:46:10 a maverick or whether we see a party like the ppc and i've i've had a lot of you know comments and
04:46:16 whatnot on my social media channels being like oh ppc this ppc that it that was the one party that
04:46:23 was really going to split the vote if we really have a close look at it and uh that's unfortunate
04:46:28 and i think you can kind of see that in a few of the numbers too um where we go from here honestly
04:46:34 fellas i i really don't have much of an idea where we do go from here i'm hoping that
04:46:39 justin trudeau landing back at the same place that he was when we called the 600 million dollar
04:46:45 election in the middle of a fourth wave of a pandemic and everything that was happening in
04:46:49 Afghanistan, a drought being dealt with by farmers on the prairies, BC completely up in flames.
04:46:57 This is where we land at after that. I'm not sure where we go from there, but I'm hoping that
04:47:02 we can maybe see a change in leadership from the Liberal Party. And I don't know if we'll get it.
04:47:08 And I guess that's kind of concerning. Okay. What do you think this means for Aaron O'Toole?
04:47:16 I mean, you're in the heart of Conservative country.
04:47:20 I mean, Calgary, we might kind of fashion ourselves the capital,
04:47:24 but, I mean, there's still Liberals within walking distance from our office here.
04:47:29 I mean, they're here.
04:47:32 They're here.
04:47:33 What do you think this means for Aaron O'Toole, and do you think he survives as leader?
04:47:37 That's a good question.
04:47:38 I'm not sure.
04:47:39 If you look back when when they did the conservative, the conservative candidate election, we saw predominantly in Saskatchewan was support for Lesley Lewis.
04:47:52 I can't honestly sit here and say that I think that Lesley Lewis would have run a better campaign than Aaron O'Toole did when O'Toole started flopping on a few of his policies, i.e. gun ban, carbon tax and a few different things.
04:48:04 I think that was maybe a little bit of a faltering point for him.
04:48:08 And I'm not sure where Leslie Lewis could have done better than that, to be perfectly honest.
04:48:14 But I feel like she might have done better in the GTA area where it's so important.
04:48:22 But I don't think there's any statistics that would either support or deny that claim that I've made.
04:48:28 And you never really know until you get down to election night.
04:48:30 And I think there was a lot of people that were looking at coming into this election with a lot stronger conservative support than what we've seen.
04:48:38 And I think there are going to be a lot of people that are very dumbfounded by the results that we've seen.
04:48:44 And also, I feel like there's going to be a lot of PBC supporters that are not going to see what has happened here with what they've done with their votes.
04:48:54 and I think that's going to continue to cause us a little bit of stress in future elections as well
04:48:59 because I don't feel like we're going to see Maxine Bernier go anywhere.
04:49:05 I've got some breaking news that may bring a smile to Quick Dick's face.
04:49:11 Maryam Monsif, the Liberal Women's Minister, has gone down to defeat in the Peterborough writing.
04:49:18 You remember she was the Cabinet Minister who said the Taliban are our brothers.
04:49:24 She should have got them to vote for.
04:49:26 She has been defeated by conservative Michelle Ferrari.
04:49:31 I would just say that.
04:49:34 Yes, you did. 0.98
04:49:37 Quick, Dick. 0.98
04:49:40 Miriam's biggest election fault, not bringing Taliban? 1.00
04:49:46 So her biggest election fault, I would assume being referring to the Taliban as her brothers or our brothers.
04:49:54 And I'm sorry when you say something like that.
04:49:57 How much time do you have?
04:50:00 A few more minutes.
04:50:01 What do you guys got?
04:50:02 Okay.
04:50:03 Well, we appreciate your time.
04:50:04 We're going to go back to Dave now.
04:50:05 We're going to pull up the map and get an update on the seat count.
04:50:08 Look at some of the key swing races.
04:50:10 And we're going to bring Corey Morgan back into the conversation here.
04:50:14 I know that Corey guy.
04:50:15 He's okay.
04:50:16 We can have him in, I guess.
04:50:17 He's not bad.
04:50:18 And quick, you're welcome back anytime.
04:50:21 Thanks, fellas.
04:50:22 Okay.
04:50:23 Across the country we'll start with the national picture and if you're a
04:50:27 conservative it's not a happy one. The Liberals leading and elected with 157
04:50:36 writings. Conservatives leading and elected in 120, the Bloc 32, the NDP 27,
04:50:44 and the Green Party too, not including their leader Anna Marie Paul who has
04:50:51 gone down to defeat in Toronto Centre. In Saskatchewan they pitched a no-hitter
04:50:57 who was 14 to nothing. For the Conservatives, Alberta still a few
04:51:03 seats up in the air. Conservatives 30, the Liberals leading in two and two New
04:51:10 Democratic Party candidates are leading in their writings.
04:51:16 Quickly, two Ontario, 37 Conservatives, 77 Liberals, and one Green Party, six New Democrats.
04:51:27 So let me just quickly call up British Columbia.
04:51:35 In British Columbia, that heat continues between the Conservatives and the Liberals with the New Democrats at 13.
04:51:45 So the Redding's in play in Alberta.
04:51:49 Well, certainly not Calgary Nose Hill.
04:51:51 We know Michelle Rempel has cleaned up on that one. 1.00
04:51:56 In Calgary Skyview, George Sahal, the Liberal candidate,
04:52:01 is ahead of the Conservatives, Jacques Sahota, 7,192 votes, 6,778.
04:52:12 In Edmonton, there's two ridings that are fairly close.
04:52:20 Let me just call them up here, see what's happening in Edmonton, Greaseback.
04:52:28 Where the NDP's Blake Desjardins is leading with 9,857 votes.
04:52:36 Incumbent Kerry Diot trailing by more than 1,000 now.
04:52:40 And that's with 67, 68% of all the polls reporting there.
04:52:48 So Kerry Deott's got a bit of a fight on his hands, Corey, to keep his seat.
04:52:59 And where are we going, production team?
04:53:00 Is Quick Dick still with us?
04:53:04 All right, why don't we throw him back up and he and Corey can have a chat.
04:53:08 yeah i gotta get that guy because i've been trying to corner him online for months
04:53:14 it's it's this pesky agriculture thing keeps getting in my way i'm not sure i uh as you can
04:53:20 see that i i came out of my tractor with the exact same clothing that i wear day to day i
04:53:25 couldn't get as dressed up as you guys could my apologies yeah derek made me wear a tie and
04:53:30 and everything. It's going to take me a while to forgive me for that.
04:53:34 I mean, I don't know.
04:53:35 I mean, just looking at this whole thing, and all I can
04:53:37 say is what a brutal 0.99
04:53:40 waste of damn time 0.99
04:53:41 and money and resources and 1.00
04:53:43 energy and emotion.
04:53:46 There was no winner in this
04:53:47 whole bloody election. There really wasn't.
04:53:49 Every party leader is now looking weak.
04:53:52 The regions are divided.
04:53:53 People are divided. Neighbors are divided.
04:53:56 I hate,
04:53:57 you know, I've been crabby on many election nights,
04:53:59 So I don't think I've ever felt this dejected on something that didn't change anything.
04:54:03 Yeah, I think what you say, Corey, is bang on.
04:54:06 And that's the feeling that I've got from most, you know, I wasn't in touch with a whole lot of people before I actually made it home here tonight.
04:54:12 But I think the general feel that you get from a lot of people from this election, what we've just gone through, I mean, it was short 36 days leading up to where we're at here right now.
04:54:23 And what you get from most people in communities that I'm involved with right now is this.
04:54:32 Well, is that the kind of feeling that you really want resonating throughout your country at a time where we're at right now with, you know, with the divisiveness going on between vaccines and passports and lockdowns and whatnot?
04:54:47 Not only was this a really terrible vanity project for Justin Trudeau to dump himself into, but to what it's done to make things worse, specifically through Canadians, I think is worse.
04:55:04 And I hope that that's something that he will have to wear going forward from here.
04:55:08 But when you look at the results of this election, you question whether anyone will actually wear it that does support the Liberal Party right now.
04:55:18 And that's kind of concerning.
04:55:20 Yeah, there's a lot of soul searching to be done.
04:55:22 I see you've still got the dirt of the field on you, so I will let you go.
04:55:26 I just wanted to catch you quickly before you took off there.
04:55:28 So thanks very much for joining.
04:55:30 We'll be watching things as they go ahead.
04:55:32 And I look forward to seeing you more on there.
04:55:33 Where do people find you online, Quick Dick?
04:55:35 Yeah, you can catch me at quickdickmcdick on YouTube.
04:55:40 Oh, man, Twitter.
04:55:42 Instagram's the only place I'm not quickdickmcdick.
04:55:44 I have to be QDmcdick there because apparently somebody had that name taken,
04:55:50 which good for them, I guess.
04:55:53 I don't know.
04:55:55 Great coverage tonight, guys.
04:55:57 Thanks very much.
04:55:58 Fantastic.
04:55:58 Thanks for talking to you.
04:55:59 okay so we have sean
04:56:07 production team i think erin o'toole is about to start speaking hello i'm afraid i can't hear you
04:56:16 but uh uh anyways i'm here with julius hoffman from the pit meadows maple ridge riding for with
04:56:23 the people's party i believe this riding has actually already been called for mark dalton
04:56:29 But with Julius Hoppen here, so tell me, a lot of the popular vote of the People's Party actually surprised, I think, a lot of pundits and did get more than anticipated.
04:56:41 But it doesn't look like it's resonated into any seats.
04:56:44 Can you tell me what you think on that?
04:56:48 Well, I was hoping that we would start to see some concentrated voting in certain ridings and getting some seats.
04:56:56 um the the amount of support that we've seen out in public is uh it was actually overwhelming and
04:57:07 you know what that might be oh sorry we're back yeah the like i was saying the the support that
04:57:15 we've witnessed um has been overwhelming and uh i was hoping that we would see more more actual
04:57:23 votes uh representing that support that we witnessed um we've been out in the public and and
04:57:30 a lot more uh positive response than than negative and however there is that majority that's silent
04:57:39 that uh as especially in sign waving you know we can see that there's a silent majority still
04:57:46 but those that are supportive of us are very very outgoing and expressive of it
04:57:53 all right as i mentioned i can't hear you guys but i'm gonna ask you at least one more question
04:57:56 uh tell me what do you think for is this set a good result for next election for the people party
04:58:03 to grow i believe it was over five percent of the popular vote yes i think so um uh we're we're
04:58:09 definitely going to keep try and keep that momentum happening uh we're going to plan some act uh
04:58:14 various activities to um to keep uh our party momentum going in between elections we gotta go
04:58:21 to yeah get our message out that's the main thing um we we certainly tried to get our platform out
04:58:31 to for people to consider and and and show the common sense uh approach from from it actually
04:58:38 just one more question so maxime he didn't win his seat uh do you uh believe that uh there should be
04:58:45 a leadership review do you believe he's the person to keep on or oh absolutely i i'm 100
04:58:50 supportive of maxine um i uh i'd love to see him continue and uh he did he did express um
04:58:58 that possibly there might be a leadership competition uh to see if if uh if there was
04:59:05 uh more support for for a new face but um he's got a tremendous following uh strong support and i
04:59:12 don't want to see him uh give up the leadership anytime soon all right guys well that's uh julius
04:59:18 julius hoffman hit meadows maple ridge riding um back to you thanks for that field hit sean
04:59:28 that's it thanks thanks again sean yeah thank you yeah hopefully we see
04:59:31 See you.
04:59:43 Those are lip-rating ones.
04:59:47 Practicing.
05:00:01 Okay, we might have to go back to the panel for a little while.
05:00:10 Has he resigned yet?
05:00:14 Well, we knew we wouldn't get through the night without...
05:00:17 ...the nation as leader of Canada's Conservatives, so it's fitting I address you later.
05:00:22 Now I'm getting buffered.
05:00:25 He's having some technical difficulties.
05:00:39 Aaron O'Toole, we're hoping to go live.
05:00:43 Region against region, neighbor against-
05:00:49 Well, okay, so at this point, Aaron O'Killis is getting his speech.
05:00:59 I doubt he's going to do anything as profound as resign or declare power or anything like that.
05:01:04 It's going to be a standard consolation speech, I imagine.
05:01:09 I'll see if I can't follow what he's saying on Twitter here.
05:01:13 Certainly.
05:01:14 But we do have Vitor Marciano back in the lobby there.
05:01:19 Perhaps we could pull him up there and get another rundown of where things are sitting.
05:01:40 Oh yeah, I got somebody.
05:01:43 Canadian press is predicting Shahal wins Calgary's Skyview.
05:01:48 Okay, so I don't know if you heard that, Vitor.
05:01:50 I look at your mic mute, but I think they're predicting Shahal is going to win, 0.99
05:01:54 so there might be a little liberal toenail hold in Calgary. 0.58
05:01:57 And Blake Deschardins has won Edmonton-Greaseback.
05:02:03 There is – it's very clear that, as I predicted, tomorrow the PPC won't matter at all.
05:02:11 But tonight they elected probably a dozen or more liberals across the country.
05:02:17 In Alberta, they're probably going to elect two. 0.99
05:02:21 If you take half of the PPC vote and give it to the conservatives, then the conservatives don't lose Skyview.
05:02:28 They may still lose Edmonton Center where it's a nip and tuck three-way race, but with 5% of the vote sitting with the PPC.
05:02:36 and Greasefly is going NDP. And if you take half of the PPC vote and give it to the conservatives,
05:02:44 which I think is, you know, a reasonable expectation, they win that seat too. So
05:02:49 Maxime Bernier has achieved what he set out to achieve. He elected more liberals across the
05:02:55 country, including, you know, probably a few in Alberta. He spent his final weekend campaigning
05:03:02 in Alberta and campaigning in Saskatoon. He didn't go to the boats. He didn't win his seat.
05:03:12 He probably picked up a few extra donations in Western Canada. His party, which isn't really
05:03:19 a party and belongs to him as a source of income, remains a source of income. And he made Justin
05:03:27 Trudeau's night because we've now run an election and exactly nothing has changed uh the popular
05:03:36 votes almost exactly the same for the conservatives probably go down a little bit once they count those
05:03:40 ballots in Ottawa uh it's still going up a little bit as they count more votes in Alberta
05:03:45 Saskatchewan um the liberals are in the same place in the popular vote they'll hold their seats
05:03:50 because of Maxime uh the bloc picked up a significant amount of popular vote in Quebec
05:03:56 but didn't pick up any extra seats uh the new democrats are up two or three seats
05:04:01 maybe they may end the evening at four because the greens are down one seat at least um
05:04:08 yeah it was 600 million and nothing's changed i mean o'toole was correct about that um
05:04:14 and trudeau has promised us that we'll go again in the next 18 months because he's not going to
05:04:20 stop trying for his majority uh maybe at that point you know there'll be less people getting
05:04:25 yeah well i i kind of wonder i mean are the it was a stalemate like it's not like trudo's coming 1.00
05:04:35 out of this strongly either i mean he put the party at risk he jumped into this election and
05:04:40 he didn't make gains i mean he was fortunate not to have taken losses um i i gotta wonder if some
05:04:46 of the sharks are starting to circle under his feet too i mean will he necessarily make it to
05:04:50 the next campaign okay um i don't know if you guys want to catch aaron but um he'll make it to the
05:04:58 next campaign because he brought his party from third to first and most of his caucus is completely
05:05:04 beholding to him so he'll make those gains are we going to try aaron again approach to combat
05:05:10 COVID-19. 18 months later, our nation needs that more than ever.
05:05:18 The Canadians have spent too many sleepless nights worrying about the health of the people
05:05:24 close to them, the loss of jobs and the future of their children. The pandemic has increased
05:05:30 the small differences between us and it has also aggravated the division amongst Canadians.
05:05:37 unfortunately this election has only made things worse but i'm here tonight once again more
05:05:46 determined to fight for our wonderful country five weeks ago mr trudeau asked for a majority
05:05:57 he said the minority parliament was quote unworkable but tonight canadians did not give
05:06:03 Mr Trudeau the majority mandate he wanted in fact Canadians sent him back with another minority at
05:06:15 the cost of 600 million dollars and deeper divisions in our great country just days ago
05:06:23 he said he would hold yet another election within 18 months if he didn't get his way
05:06:28 A few days ago, Mr. Trudeau was saying that he would hold another election in 18 months
05:06:37 if he didn't get what he wants.
05:06:40 Mr. Trudeau was hoping for a quick power grab.
05:06:43 Instead, he has thrust us into what he has promised will be 18 months of perpetual campaigning.
05:06:52 Our country is facing the most serious economic challenge since the Great Depression.
05:06:58 Even before the pandemic led to record debt and deficits, investment and jobs were leaving
05:07:04 Canada.
05:07:05 The prices are increasing from clothes to gas and everything.
05:07:15 Inflation is its highest level in 20 years and it is continuing to climb every day.
05:07:21 Families have difficulty in making ends meet.
05:07:27 face up to this challenge we have to work together we have to continue the fight too long
05:07:34 we have been divided for too long we have seen politicians pit region against region neighbor
05:07:42 against neighbor but when we are divided canadians get left behind mr trudeau thinks canadians
05:07:50 should endure 18 more months of divisive campaigning so he can try once again to get
05:07:56 the election result he wants. We need to heal the divides in Canada, not risk worsening them
05:08:03 for selfish gains. A few months ago, I told Conservatives that our party needed the courage
05:08:16 to change because Canada has changed. Over the past 36 days, we have demonstrated to Canadians
05:08:24 that we've set out on a path to engage more canadians in our conservative movement one
05:08:30 that addresses is the challenges of today while advancing the dreams of tomorrow ours is a
05:08:37 conservatism that dwells not in the past but learns from it to secure the future our new
05:08:47 conservative movement a new conservative movement to deal with today's challenges
05:08:53 a movement conservative conservative movement to actually realize the dreams of tomorrow
05:08:59 a conservative movement that's not only looking backwards but learns and moves forward
05:09:09 it is a conservatism that reveres strong communities and compassion for one another
05:09:16 for our environment and for those in need at home and abroad. It is a conservatism
05:09:24 that respects hard work and character and the fact that millions have come to this great country
05:09:30 for liberty and opportunity. It's a conservatism that believes reconciliation is more than a box
05:09:37 to check. It is the very keystone of Canada reaching its potential and it starts with clean
05:09:44 drinking water as a basic human right still denied to Indigenous children born today.
05:09:52 And above all else, it is a conservatism that believes Canada is the greatest country on
05:09:58 earth and that our best days are on the horizon.
05:10:02 A conservatism that builds Canada up.
05:10:19 Let's build it up.
05:10:24 In the months ahead, as Mr. Trudeau gears up for yet another election, we must continue
05:10:34 this journey to welcoming more Canadians to take another look at our party.
05:10:40 More people voted for Canada's Conservatives than any other party, and that's a strength
05:10:45 to build on.
05:10:49 Our support has grown, it's grown across the country.
05:10:53 But clearly, there is more work to do to earn the trust of Canadians.
05:11:01 We're the founding party of this country, we're the party of its future as well.
05:11:06 The Conservative Party will beat the Liberals, but only if the party continues to grow.
05:11:13 We have the courage to be bold and to have the courage to change.
05:11:19 We must hold fast to that courage.
05:11:22 We must show Canadians that we will not waver
05:11:25 in our commitment to growth.
05:11:28 On doit continuer de gagner la confiance des Canadiens.
05:11:31 We must continue to gain the trust of Canadians.
05:11:35 We've made progress, we've worked hard,
05:11:37 but the progress has to continue.
05:11:40 So, once in another 18 months,
05:11:44 we will take stock of what worked and what didn't.
05:11:48 And we will continue to put in the time showing more Canadians that they are welcome in the Conservative Party of Canada.
05:12:00 Above all, we must continue to show Canadians that whether you're black, white, brown, or from any race or creed,
05:12:08 Whether you're LGBTQ or straight, whether you are an indigenous Canadian or came to Canada five weeks ago or five generations ago.
05:12:19 Que le français soit votre premier.
05:12:22 Be the free French or first or second language. 0.65
05:12:26 Whether you worship on Fridays, Saturdays, Sundays, every day or not at all, you are an important part of Canada and you have a place in the Conservative Party of Canada.
05:12:38 Friends, I'm standing here tonight because of the steadfast support of my true partner,
05:13:03 the love of my life, Rebecca.
05:13:05 you for being my rock and my safe harbor. And I'm so glad more Canadians got to know
05:13:14 the wonderful person you are these last five weeks. I also want to thank my children, Molly
05:13:19 and Jack, for being my inspiration. It's because of you that I believe so strongly
05:13:27 in securing Canada's future. My mother passed away when I was nine, but I know she is here
05:13:33 tonight because i see her in my daughter molly who shares her name i've been so grateful to have
05:13:40 my second mother to guide me to this very day i'm thankful that she
05:13:45 and my dad who inspired me into public service are here tonight thank you
05:13:54 to thank my fantastic campaign a team thanks for your trust thanks for your commitment to serving
05:14:03 this big and marvelous country thanks to our incredible slate of candidates and to our
05:14:08 fantastic volunteers as well at 18 to serve canada and its people and some of the people
05:14:16 i served with are in the room tonight i will never stop serving this great country
05:14:25 and my pride in canada has deepened these past five weeks as i've gotten to meet more
05:14:30 incredible Canadians from all walks of life. My family and I are resolutely committed to
05:14:37 continuing this journey for Canada. Tonight I talked to Mr Trudeau and I congratulated him
05:14:48 on a hard-won campaign. ...unity of this country and the well-being of its people first.
05:14:55 And I told him if he thinks he can threaten Canadians with another election in 18 months,
05:15:00 The Conservative Party will be ready.
05:15:07 And whenever that day comes, I will be ready to lead Canada's Conservatives to victory.
05:15:13 Thank you, Canada. Let's get to work.
05:15:22 All right, Peter Van Dusen watching along with you as we listen to Conservative leader Erin O'Toole.
05:15:27 clearly wants to keep the job
05:15:30 that he made clear at the end
05:15:32 he plans to continue to fight
05:15:33 did say we'll take stock of what worked
05:15:36 and what didn't work
05:15:37 that's going to be important
05:15:39 as conservatives go over
05:15:41 what worked and what didn't work
05:15:43 in this campaign
05:15:43 Corey I can't hear you
05:15:57 Thank you.
05:16:27 Got you for a second.
05:16:57 Thank you.
05:17:27 Thank you.
05:17:57 Oh, hold on, now I hear something.
05:18:27 okay i think we we're back here yes okay believe it or not this is broadcast was but it's a
05:18:43 just we've got some equipment starting to overheat now we've been running so much stuff through it
05:18:49 uh okay so we we finished with our tool speech there vitor what do you gather out of where he's
05:18:55 looking to go and what his attitude is right now? Well, I mean, he's trying to make the best of it.
05:19:00 And he sent a very clear signal to the party that he wants to hang on. The part that's complicated
05:19:08 for him is, you know, I'm looking at a handful of the seats where the conservatives are still
05:19:13 leading and they're still in British Columbia. There's reason to believe that he'll lose those
05:19:17 ones when they get counted in Ottawa tomorrow. So it's possible that he will end up with a result
05:19:23 that is essentially the same number of votes as Andrew Scheer got,
05:19:29 but might end up being two or three less seats.
05:19:32 As the evening's gone on, this election has looked ridiculously like the last election.
05:19:37 I mean, the Liberals are in the exact same spot.
05:19:39 Right now, the Conservatives are up one, but likely to lose a few.
05:19:43 The Bloc has done much better in Quebec in terms of overall vote count,
05:19:47 but they have the exact same number of seats.
05:19:50 Their vote's been very inefficient.
05:19:51 uh the new democrats are up uh about three right now um it's it's kind of a complicated mess and
05:20:00 i think o'toole is gonna find that that there'll be some knives and some pressure on for him tomorrow
05:20:05 where people are gonna ask well you know you moderated on a bunch of places where the party
05:20:11 didn't want you to moderate and you um ran a better campaign than sheer but you didn't do any
05:20:19 better you've got probably right now a little bit less popular vote and uh and and a little bit less
05:20:26 results right now he's tied but that's probably going to go down um he's going to be in a tough
05:20:32 tough spot i mean ultimately uh you know i think o'toole and team o'toole was counting on on team
05:20:40 singh uh delivering some results and that didn't happen the the new democrats did not uh did not
05:20:48 improve their performance very much and you know the conservatives needed the democrat the new
05:20:54 democrats to improve their performance because those were all going to be seats pretty much
05:20:58 that the liberals lost um that's not happened at this stage so um you know it's it's still going
05:21:06 to be tight um well it's not going to be tight i mean the liberals are going to be in the 150s
05:21:12 uh probably the high 150s might even be higher one or two seats higher than they were last time
05:21:17 even though they got they're getting less of the popular vote that's how efficient their
05:21:22 their votes are that's how frankly undemocratic canada is um and you know the knives will be
05:21:30 out for o'toole i i you know i uh i i wouldn't want to be in his position
05:21:36 well we might finally see conservatives in canada embrace the idea of electoral reform
05:21:42 two consecutive elections, winning the popular vote and getting a less than ideal result in the
05:21:49 seat count. Here's the interesting part, and nobody talked about this at all during this
05:21:55 election. We have to redistrict next year. 2021 is a census year. So next year, we take the census
05:22:04 numbers, which will be coming out, frankly, any day now. They've probably been delayed by the
05:22:07 election. Usually they'd be out right about now and reapportion seats. And then I'm going to let
05:22:15 in Alberta, I'll let Albertans in on a dirty little secret. The minute they reapportion seats,
05:22:21 Alberta will be underrepresented again because we're a growing part of the country and the
05:22:27 shrinking parts of the country will benefit again from the reapportionment. So not only do they
05:22:31 benefit from a formula that's stacked in their favor, the one thing that is not allowed to be
05:22:37 considered when you reapportion seats is who's growing and who's drinking so we're growing the
05:22:42 minute you know those seats will get reapportioned in 2022 they'll go into effect in 2023 and by that
05:22:48 point we'll already be behind the eight ball again after reapportionment uh and the formula doesn't
05:22:53 make it fair for alberta anyway so it's vitor i want to kind of go pick up where you you left off
05:23:00 at the end of your last answer before that, Aaron O'Toole is probably in a very difficult
05:23:07 position tonight. His speech doesn't sound like the guy who lost the election. I mean,
05:23:15 yes, he held what Andrew Scheer had achieved, but that was probably not considered a great
05:23:20 achievement. It wasn't a disaster, but this is a man who, he's a very different leader
05:23:28 Other than was elected by the Conservative members, and I don't think there's really
05:23:33 anyone who would dispute that, and generally, a leader might get away with that if they
05:23:39 can deliver victory.
05:23:40 You can say, well, you might not have liked some of this stuff, but I got you into government
05:23:46 and I must be right.
05:23:50 To make the...
05:23:51 Pivot's probably an understatement.
05:23:55 the very significant shift that he made in party policies away from conservative dogmas for better
05:24:01 or worse and to come up with virtually the exact same result as Aaron O'Toole did. Do you think,
05:24:10 how secure is Aaron O'Toole in this job? Because this doesn't sound like a man planning on
05:24:14 stepping down. He's not secure and he's not planning on stepping down and he took big risks
05:24:19 and he got no rewards for them. He can make the excuse that the PPC made it harder for him
05:24:24 that's going to be true. The analysis will show that quite dramatically. But he didn't get
05:24:30 anything for it. He kind of lied to win the leadership. He went from being the second most
05:24:37 red person two leaderships ago to claiming to be true blue this last one. It's coming back to
05:24:41 haunt him. Yeah, he's in a rough spot. But that's also why every paragraph in that speech mentioned
05:24:49 Trudeau's threat of calling another election in 18 months. That was sort of a hint to the party
05:24:54 that you can't afford another leadership race.
05:24:56 We're getting another election in 18 months.
05:24:59 You know, give me a second kick at the can. 0.99
05:25:00 I also found he was using some interesting, for lack of a better term, literary devices.
05:25:10 He was linking his moves as leader with growth, his direction for the party with going forward,
05:25:21 And then by implication that a return to the party's more traditional policies or perhaps I should, if I'm being a bit more cynical, a return to the leader they thought they were electing, that would be taking the party backwards and it would be shrinking the party.
05:25:43 What's going to be his argument for, I guess he said, yeah, election's coming, you can't afford, you don't have time to change leaders.
05:25:50 But in addition to the time argument, really, what's going to be his case before the Supreme Court of the Conservative Convention that reviews his leadership?
05:26:01 In all honesty, I think you nailed it.
05:26:04 He was using that literary advice about saying that he was looking forward, not looking backwards.
05:26:09 And that's an exercise in trying to get the pundits and the political commentators on his side to sort of prop him up.
05:26:16 you know, to, to get them to, to discuss any change in his leadership as a step backwards,
05:26:23 to get them to frame this discussion in a way that's favorable to him.
05:26:29 It's still a tough, tough spot. And frankly, his team made a mess of the last conservative
05:26:37 convention. And, you know, in some ways he suffered for that because, you know, it was
05:26:43 things that happened at that convention he was still getting attacked on even into the last week
05:26:47 of the campaign um i think when they do the post-mortem on this election as people do more
05:26:52 of the post-mortem they'll come to the conclusion that he had a pretty good start to the campaign
05:26:56 but a pretty weak finish to the campaign um you know having had a good start to it he could have
05:27:02 narrowed down to three things that he wanted to talk about every day or five things you know do
05:27:07 the harper's five priorities and then just go and hit on that every day um they stopped doing that
05:27:12 and they kind of hit him from the media a little bit i don't know why um you know if you're a soft
05:27:20 red tory you better be counting on at least some percentage of the media as your base and if you're
05:27:25 hiding from the media what's the point of being a soft red tory um so yeah he's in a rough spot
05:27:31 and again like i said right now he's in the exact same spot as sheer with a slightly lower
05:27:37 voter share count i think by the time they finish counting everything uh he'll have a slightly lower
05:27:44 voter share count and probably have three or four less seats than sheer did and that's going to be a
05:27:50 tough tough circumstance to recover from because it was an awful lot of people you know timo tool
05:27:56 people that had the knives out for uh for andrew sheer and you know some of those people are going
05:28:03 to be looking to, you know, to return some payback. Yeah, I think that's going to be coming
05:28:11 right away. I'm only half surprised that O'Toole did not try tonight to explicitly blame Jason
05:28:22 Kenny, although I don't think he has to say it himself, because the pundits are saying it for
05:28:28 him. For him to say it himself would probably look like poor form. It'd look like a sore loser.
05:28:33 and it looked like he's just not taking any responsibility for anything. 0.93
05:28:38 And everyone's already saying it for him.
05:28:42 I mean, right now, Alberta is a rumor mill. 1.00
05:28:49 I do not need to tell you.
05:28:50 You're probably hearing much of what we're hearing.
05:28:54 If Kenny's had roles, do you think that'll almost serve as a sacrifice to the gods
05:28:58 to satiate conservatives looking for blood right now?
05:29:02 Will that, if Kenny's head rolls, does that help O'Toole keep his attached to his head?
05:29:11 If Jason Kenney gets ousted, that in effect gives value to the unspoken argument that Jason Kenney kind of messed up the last week of this campaign for Aaron O'Toole.
05:29:25 I think there's some point to that.
05:29:28 I'm not sure that that's going to be enough.
05:29:31 it might make this easier. It won't make it not hard. You know, it becomes an argument that's
05:29:41 available for O'Toole. It does not become the overwhelming, convincing argument that swings
05:29:47 the day. I mean, ultimately, right now, he's not really delivered in 905 or in British Columbia.
05:29:57 And when you look at the close races that still remain in British Columbia, and you think
05:30:01 about how many you know some of those writings have six seven thousand ballots to be counted in
05:30:05 ottawa those ones you know i think the conservatives are going to lose the seat that they have in
05:30:10 in newfoundland i think they you know that they're ahead in newfoundland i think they're going to
05:30:15 lose a few more in bc i think they're going to lose a few in alberta so all of a sudden you know
05:30:20 if you dropped seats in in bc alberta um you really only picked up one or two in nova scotia
05:30:29 and New Brunswick, I think they picked up one in Quebec.
05:30:37 It's a tough argument to make that your strategy was a good strategy.
05:30:42 I don't know what his strategy is from here.
05:30:45 I mean, is he going to say we didn't go left or center enough?
05:30:51 I'm just not sure what his, like, other than the kind of very vague language
05:30:57 about we have to keep growing what's going to be his argument beyond vague bromides uh
05:31:06 for why he should keep the leadership and i suppose i'll stack a second question more of
05:31:11 a technical question that you might be aware of because you watch these things uh is there
05:31:15 a conservative convention scheduled um in a timeline that's likely to be before the next
05:31:21 provincial election let's say within the next year year and a half where his leadership would
05:31:24 come up for a vote his leadership definitely comes up to a vote at the next convention
05:31:29 but going from memory it's the a convention is every other year they just held one in 20 so he's
05:31:36 got to suffer one in 2022 he can do it at the back end of 2022 uh but he can also get national
05:31:44 council to delay it because they're a minority government situation uh or to call it earlier to
05:31:51 get it out of the way so that he can secure it you know all of the the mechanics of that are bad
05:31:57 uh the number one thing that he would need to do really quickly to sort of mitigate everything is
05:32:04 fix his relationship with his caucus and so you know for example he dumped derrick sloan
05:32:10 but you know leslin lewis won today he doesn't have a choice but to elevate her pretty high 0.96
05:32:16 um that's going to be he's never actually had to have other than derek sloan i guess once it's kind
05:32:24 of almost a rite of passage now that the the token socon candidate in the leadership race gets um
05:32:29 well he's you're not long for this political world once the leadership race is over and you've
05:32:34 delivered your votes to the guy who wins um so other than derek sloan he never had to actually
05:32:40 have any leadership rivals in his caucus he didn't have to have leslin lewis he didn't have to have
05:32:44 have Peter McKay. Leslyn Lewis, I think is actually, I mean, I know how well she liked
05:32:50 she is, but she never, it was almost a meme leadership campaign. She didn't actually really
05:32:54 have to shine in front of the camera much on her own. It was far more digital than that.
05:32:59 So we'll see how well she shines or not. And I know many elements in caucus were
05:33:05 less than pleased when the carbon tax policy was announced without even consulting them. It was
05:33:10 just presented to them. And they said, this is the policy. And if you don't like it,
05:33:14 you can walk out the door. But I have less insights into his relationship with the federal
05:33:20 caucus than I do in, say, the provincial dynamics here. How solid is O'Toole with caucus right now,
05:33:26 do you think? He's a little bit better than Jason Kinney is with his own caucus.
05:33:33 That bad. That bad. Well, he's done. Yeah. I don't think he's in a great spot.
05:33:40 um this is you know when you do these bold strategies and you don't bring people along
05:33:48 with you you gotta make those strategies work and lots of powerful and influential people in
05:33:55 that caucus didn't know those strategies were coming they uh had to chew on the inside of
05:34:01 their lip a lot to you know not talk about it too much and and not sabotage the leader in his bold
05:34:08 strategy. The bold strategies didn't work. You know, if I'm Aaron O'Toole, I'm trying to do
05:34:15 an awful lot of fence mending in the next week. And he didn't look particularly good at fence
05:34:23 mending before. So this could be a problem for him. Indeed. Well, Vittorio, I want to thank you
05:34:32 for your time. You've been more than generous with it, giving us a very good insight here.
05:34:36 we're going to have to have you on
05:34:39 at some point again
05:34:40 I normally don't run these shows
05:34:41 I do something once a week
05:34:42 but I don't really do the interviews
05:34:43 but I know Corey does
05:34:45 I'd love to have you reappear
05:34:48 on the Western Standard
05:34:49 provide your insight
05:34:50 I've just got a sneaking suspicion
05:34:52 this is not even the most interesting day
05:34:55 in politics this week
05:34:57 I have a horrible feeling
05:35:02 that you might be right
05:35:03 this is going to be probably
05:35:04 one of the most interesting weeks in politics in Alberta history.
05:35:09 I think today is going to probably go, could go down as the second most interesting day of the week.
05:35:15 Yeah, I would say so. I think there's a possibility of that.
05:35:19 You know, I hope you guys found some value in what I said.
05:35:23 I have a perspective that not everybody has all the time.
05:35:26 And it was an absolute pleasure talking to you, hearing what, you know, Jeff had to say
05:35:31 and and some of the other people and you know i wish we'd had a better day for the conservative
05:35:37 movement even if it was a slightly warm conservative movement i'm on record as saying
05:35:42 that for all of the things i didn't like about erin o'toole if he could deliver on one third of
05:35:47 his energy policy the albertan in me would be happy enough um but we're going to get trudeau's
05:35:52 energy policy for the next little while and uh hopefully hopefully uh whatever damage he does
05:35:59 isn't permanent, so. Well, before you go, I'll leave you with this thought. I actually think
05:36:05 tonight is a, in a really weird, perverse way, better for conservatism. It is not better for
05:36:12 the conservative party. Well, actually, in the long term, I think it is better for the conservative
05:36:16 party. Think of it this way. If you are an ideological liberal or social, like small L, 0.87
05:36:23 center left liberal, and you don't really care about what party's in power, you would want Aaron
05:36:28 no tool to win tonight, because then you get to lock in the other major governing party
05:36:34 of Canada with the basic tenets of your ideology around carbon taxes, gun control, well, now
05:36:43 gun control, that was a new one, I suppose, but a whole host of these other issues, deficits,
05:36:50 and that would become, just the way the revulsion against deficits became mainstream for all
05:36:57 parties left and right in the 90s, that was a victory for the right because no matter who was
05:37:01 in power, everybody was for balancing the budget. I think it would have been a victory for kind of
05:37:07 center-left progressivism, moderate progressivism for O'Toole to win tonight because then you get
05:37:12 to lock in the conservatives. The fact that he went down this road and failed to achieve victory,
05:37:18 I think is probably going to, I would bet it probably means the end of his leadership
05:37:23 and a pretty nasty schism in the conservative party where you're going to have another leadership
05:37:29 election where everybody's going to try and out-true-blue each other, but no one's going to
05:37:31 know if any, you can't even trust the written promise anymore. It's going to be a nasty, nasty
05:37:36 fight. But I think for conservatism, they needed to learn a lesson. They might have, they might
05:37:44 learn it from tonight, but I've been wrong many times before. Derek, I'm probably going to write
05:37:51 something for uh jen gerson's asked me to write something for the line on the future of the
05:37:55 conservative party i've been a long time conservative i was there on the original
05:37:59 national council when this party was put together i'm going to write something heretical um because
05:38:04 i'm getting to the stage of believing that we need to like explore some heresies uh before we can
05:38:09 win and if we don't win we're we're kind of doomed because you know we can't actually handle too many
05:38:17 more liberal government wins the amount of damage they're doing with each successive liberal
05:38:22 government uh extends this further and further and further into my daughter's lifetime and uh
05:38:29 i'm i'm scared for that so uh you know conservatives need to think outside the box
05:38:33 thank you for having me on it's been a lot of appreciate it thank you very much i look forward
05:38:38 to reading it on the line sounds good bye-bye uh we're going to bring uh actually we're going
05:38:43 bring Aaron Gunn in just a minute. Let's just get an update. Actually, we're going to go to Aaron
05:38:47 Gunn now, but we're going, just to note, we're going to be standing by. Justin Trudeau is going
05:38:55 to be speaking very soon with his victory speech, having secured three, his third term, second
05:39:04 conservative minority government. So let's bring Aaron Gunn into the show right now. Aaron, how are
05:39:10 you doing? Aaron, you are on mute. We cannot hear you. Aaron, I'm going to get my grandma
05:39:19 to teach in tech. There he goes. There we go. I'm just taking the results as I'm sure
05:39:25 all of you are right now. And one of the most, I don't know the record if there's ever been
05:39:29 that back-to-back elections that have mirrored each other as they have tonight. And I think
05:39:34 just might be the closest I've at least ever heard of back-to-back elections that so little
05:39:39 changes i also think this is the lowest share of the popular vote someone has ever formed
05:39:46 government with in canadian history although you might need to double check that i know i i'm
05:39:50 almost positive you're correct because the liberals had that record last time
05:39:54 when they when they won the 2019 election they have an even smaller share of the popular vote
05:39:59 this time so they just beat their previous record um but i i would i had a chance to say there's
05:40:05 There's also another record in here, we're going to have to fact check this tomorrow,
05:40:08 but I can say with a fair degree of confidence that no Canadian election has ever had the
05:40:14 two biggest parties receive less than two-thirds of the vote.
05:40:20 That is unheard of.
05:40:21 Between the Conservatives and the Liberals, they've certainly got more than two-thirds
05:40:24 of the seats combined because we have a first-past-the-post system.
05:40:27 But in terms of their combined share of the popular vote, the two biggest parties are
05:40:34 still a hair shy of two-thirds of the popular vote. Aaron, do you think that says something
05:40:40 about how people are feeling about the main options in front of them right now?
05:40:45 Yeah, I think you can read a lot into that. I think you can, the Conservatives seem to have
05:40:51 hit a ceiling over the past two elections that they can't seem to get through. And I think,
05:40:57 Justin Trudeau, I think there's going to be some very serious questions being asked within the
05:41:01 liberal camp because i wonder if it is based basically mathematically impossible for this
05:41:06 guy to ever get a majority government i think there's just too many canadians have already
05:41:10 made up their mind that they're not going to vote for justin trudeau under practically any
05:41:15 circumstance so i think that's something that the liberals are going to have to think a lot
05:41:19 a long and hard about
05:41:20 all right i just i'm still processing this you know i i would have anticipated some movement
05:41:29 some change. I've, I'm disgusted. I mean, I'll be blunt about it. I've never been through such a
05:41:36 huge, expensive, divisive democratic exercise to change absolutely nothing. I mean, even a larger
05:41:44 liberal win, I mean, life would suck, but it would show that there was a purpose to this.
05:41:50 And we're all coming out of this worse for it. Nobody is coming out of this election better.
05:41:55 No party's coming out better. No leader's coming out better. I can't see any Canadian sitting
05:41:59 tonight, looking at things, saying, boy, I'm sure glad we did that, except maybe a few contractors
05:42:03 to the parties. It's like trench warfare. It's just the parties are slugging at each other,
05:42:10 and we're just sending poor scrutineers into no man's land. They get shot up,
05:42:15 and nothing's changing. It's the battle of the Somme all over, and there's just ballot boxes
05:42:23 laying spread everywhere. Dave, you've given us news. Yeah, I mean, to me, Canada's the big loser
05:42:34 tonight. Six hundred million dollars down the drain for no good reason. Well, we borrow that
05:42:40 in a day. Still, look what it could have done. It could have been spent on so much else. As Corey
05:42:48 said if there'd have been some change, any change, you know, give us a scrap. Canada as a country
05:42:57 comes out worse because the bickering and the partisanship isn't going away. And it's only
05:43:03 going to get more bitter. Those who said Trudeau, if Trudeau won, they would, you know, join a
05:43:09 Western separatist party. Well, you know, they'll be joining the Western independents tomorrow or
05:43:14 the maverick tomorrow but you know nothing changes in canada sun comes up tomorrow
05:43:21 judo's still our great leader and uh hang on uh uh erin uh let's talk a bit about bc that's what
05:43:31 i said i wanted to talk about with you last time we didn't really get to uh what are some of the
05:43:35 interesting races you saw in bc some of the interesting holds and some of the interesting
05:43:40 flips? Well, I would say it's still a little bit early in the night in BC, actually, to call some
05:43:47 of these nail biters. I'm keeping a close eye on Nanaimo on Vancouver Island. The NDP currently
05:43:53 have a 1% lead there. That's a seat formerly held by the Greens, who are now in third, kind of part
05:44:00 of their cross-country collapse. And then we have seats moving in different directions. It looks
05:44:07 like Tamara Jensen has lost her seat in Cloverdale Langley City or hasn't lost it yet I guess she's 0.94
05:44:15 down by three percent so that's going to be another nail-biter and then I will say one that
05:44:22 I'm really disappointed to and let me just navigate it on my screen here is it looks like
05:44:27 the Conservatives have lost Stevenson or Stevenston Richmond East which was Kenny
05:44:34 uh choose seat who is a very vocal critic of uh china's communist regime and they launched a lot 1.00
05:44:41 of attacks uh against him through the chinese canadian community through whatsapp or or whatever
05:44:47 that we um there's that other social media yeah so um that's kind of unfortunate to see even there's
05:44:54 still a whole bunch of nail biters though um but it seems like the liberals honestly in the lower 0.76
05:44:59 mainland are getting kind of a lot of those swing seats are going their way in richmond
05:45:03 in Coquitlam, Port Coquitlam, and so the one that I'm still keeping an eye on, Nanaimo,
05:45:10 and then another one is over in Kootenai, Colombia.
05:45:16 Rob Morrison is back in the lead.
05:45:17 He's up 4%, the PPC's drawing 7% in that riding.
05:45:22 That's the riding that just borders southern Alberta there, kind of just west of Lethbridge.
05:45:30 I will note de facto Green Party leader Elizabeth May winning comfortably in Saanich Gulf Islands.
05:45:39 Winning comfortably with just 36% of the vote, actually some of these weird Vancouver Island,
05:45:47 like essentially four-way races, well the Conservatives are never really in contention
05:45:51 but actually well yeah they're actually second or technically third but like third by a hair.
05:45:59 four-way races on Vancouver Island. I know, Aaron, I met you actually working on a campaign on
05:46:04 Vancouver Island, and those are some weird creatures on the island where, vote split?
05:46:10 What's a vote split? Let's split the vote 12 ways. You could win a seat with 20% of the vote.
05:46:17 Do you think this means Elizabeth May is going to have to be Green Leader? She's obviously going to 1.00
05:46:22 become, have to be interim Green Leader. I mean, NMA Paul, I don't know if she was in the right
05:46:28 or the wrong and that internal fight that's not uh not my cup of tea but uh she seems pretty toast
05:46:35 is elizabeth may gonna become the new leader of the green party beyond intern do you think
05:46:39 are they gonna go back to the drawing board and elect another new leader
05:46:45 well a green party internal politics is not my specialty either um but elizabeth may i i mean i
05:46:51 thought she was she was hanging them up for for uh for life so we'll see if she jumps back in i 1.00
05:46:57 I don't know who this new Green Party guy that's been elected in Kitchener is or what his deal is or if they're just going to have another leadership race.
05:47:04 But one of the in a in a night where the main story is pretty boring and nothing changes, there are some sub stories that are quite interesting.
05:47:13 And one has definitely been the national collapse of the green vote.
05:47:17 It's actually a kind of bizarre that we've had PPC go up, Green Party crash, a bunch of seats change hands on either side of the country.
05:47:25 And yet kind of the top line result is still pretty much the same.
05:47:30 It's really odd.
05:47:32 The two big parties have been so boring and then static in their trench warfare that we spend so much time now just talking about the two.
05:47:41 Well, actually, by popular vote.
05:47:43 No, the block did fairly fine by popular vote.
05:47:45 We talk about the marginal parties.
05:47:47 We talk about the PPC and the Greens and their ups and downs, because that's really all there
05:47:55 has that's been of any interest this campaign, the collapse of the Greens, but still getting
05:48:00 two seats, and then the surge of the PPC, not getting any.
05:48:08 The NDP have really underperformed today.
05:48:13 The seats you're watching in British Columbia, I know that's really where the NDP needed
05:48:16 to perform strongly was around the lower mainland and on Vancouver Island are there any seats right
05:48:23 now do you think they could still flip that they're under right now because I know BC has
05:48:27 got so many different kinds of fights you've got NDP conservative fights you've got NDP liberal
05:48:33 fights you've got three-way fights you've got four-way fights with the greens for god's sakes
05:48:38 BC's got the most diversity of these kinds of of battles it's it's fascinating stuff
05:48:45 What do you think happened to the NDP in BC, and I suppose nationally, that has them on?
05:48:52 No, I'm sorry, I jumped the gun there, no pun intended.
05:48:59 We've got Liberal leader and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau walking to the podium right
05:49:03 now.
05:49:04 Aaron, I want to thank you for your time this evening.
05:49:07 You've been very generous with it, provided a lot of great insight.
05:49:11 I'm sure we'll be speaking again soon.
05:49:14 wonderful evening out on the left coast you too derek have a good one cheers
05:49:23 much friends uh you are sending us back to work with a clear mandate to get canada through this
05:49:31 pandemic and to the brighter days ahead my friends that's exactly what we are ready to do
05:49:38 There are still votes to be counted, but what we've seen tonight is that millions of Canadians
05:49:50 have chosen a progressive plan. Some have talked about division, but that's not what
05:49:57 I see. That's not what I've seen these past weeks across the country. I see Canadians 1.00
05:50:03 standing together together in your determination to end this pandemic together for real climate
05:50:12 action for ten dollar a day child care for homes that are in reach for middle-class families
05:50:24 for our shared journey on the path of reconciliation as canadians you've elected parliamentarians
05:50:33 to deliver on all this and our team our government is ready
05:50:47 when i became prime minister six years ago i couldn't know what the future held we
05:50:54 didn't know that we'd be facing up to a once in a century pandemic or a worldwide economic crisis
05:51:03 but what i did know is that together canadians that can overcome any obstacle and that is exactly
05:51:11 what we will continue to do i have heard you i know you don't want to hear any more talk of
05:51:20 elections and politics but you want us to concentrate on the work that is necessary for you
05:51:27 just want to get back to the things you love not worry about this pandemic
05:51:33 or about an election, that you just want to know that your Members of Parliament of
05:51:38 all stripes will have your back through this crisis and beyond.
05:51:44 The moment we face demands real, important change.
05:51:50 And you have given this Parliament and this government clear direction.
05:51:56 You made a choice.
05:52:00 You gave to Parliamentaries a clear mandate so that we put an end to this pandemic once
05:52:07 and for all and build a better future.
05:52:10 You have elected a government in Ottawa that will fight for you and that will deliver for
05:52:17 you every day.
05:52:19 We hear you.
05:52:21 We hear you when you say you want more daycare spaces and a stronger healthcare system, affordable
05:52:30 housing and good green jobs to continue moving forward on the path to
05:52:36 reconciliation investments for the middle class and for all those who are
05:52:41 working hard to join it
05:52:52 friends i am ready to carry on with the work my team is ready
05:53:00 but above all tonight i want to take the time to thank some people some special people
05:53:08 the other parties and their families thank you for being part of this important moment
05:53:15 political life isn't easy this is the path you choose because you believe
05:53:20 in serving those around you thank you for your service to the election
05:53:30 To the Elections Canada staff and volunteers who signed up to be part of
05:53:36 this democratic process and who will be working around the clock to count votes
05:53:41 and tally results, thank you. This election has confirmed that our
05:53:53 democracy and our institutions remain strong. And to my fellow Canadians, there is no greater honor
05:54:02 than serving you and serving this country. If you voted for our party, thank you. Thank you
05:54:10 for putting your trust in our team to keep moving forward for everyone. And if you did not vote for
05:54:18 us I want you to know that we will stand up for you and work for you every single day
05:54:31 because no matter how you voted just like no matter where you come from what language you
05:54:38 speak the color of your skin the way you pray I hear you I hear you when you say that we can
05:54:46 only move forward if no one is left behind. Our shared future is built vote by vote, door by door,
05:54:56 and above all, person by person. That's something I learned when I first ran in Papineau 12 years ago.
05:55:11 during the last 12 years as a the member for papino i had the opportunity to read to so many people
05:55:24 from different backgrounds and lifestyles and it's an honor for me to represent you so it's with you
05:55:31 that i started this wonderful adventure so thank you for your trust as well and i will continue
05:55:37 to be there for you my friends from papino riding there are a lot of people who've worked hard very
05:55:46 hard to get here tonight first off my fellow liberals my friends congratulations whether
05:55:53 you're a candidate staff or volunteer i know there have been a lot of late nights and early
05:55:58 mornings there have been tough days but together we've done something incredible bravo mes amis
05:56:06 bravo friends
05:56:14 and above all i would like to thank my family as always my mom who's here tonight
05:56:19 who started going through election nights like this when she was a little girl when
05:56:29 my grandfather was running for parliament in vancouver north but thank you mom for always being
05:56:36 there and sophie 12 years ago when we made the decision to become involved together in politics
05:56:49 it's because we wanted to defend our values,
05:56:53 because we wanted to contribute to build a stronger Canada.
05:56:57 And since the very beginning, we did it together.
05:57:01 So thank you.
05:57:11 And to my children, Xavier.
05:57:13 Ella Grace.
05:57:14 Ella Grace here.
05:57:15 And Adrien, who's been sleeping for some hours now upstairs.
05:57:19 As we also need to do, we're working hard to build a better future for you, a better
05:57:26 future for your generations and those to follow.
05:57:30 Every day, you remind me that this work is important, this work that we're doing together.
05:57:36 So thank you for your patience while I have to be off on the job.
05:57:43 And thank you for the sacrifices that you are doing.
05:57:49 We've all worked so hard over the last few weeks and over the last few years, and we
05:57:56 have come so far.
05:57:59 My friends, tonight I think of something Prime Minister Wilfrid Laurier said as his generation
05:58:06 was at the dawn of a new century.
05:58:09 He said, let them look to the past, but let them still more look to the future.
05:58:17 us not forget the past and the dark days we have come through together but let us still more look
05:58:24 to the future and all that is still to come and all that we have still to build together let us
05:58:33 feel the warmth of a new dawn and above all let us seize the promise of a brand new day
05:58:40 Thank you, my friends.
05:58:42 Thank you, my friends.
05:58:44 Thank you, everyone.
05:58:46 Thank you, everyone.
05:58:54 All right, Peter Van Dusen watching along with you.
05:58:57 That's our last speech to hear tonight from Justin Trudeau,
05:59:00 the Prime Minister, the Liberal leader, as we,
05:59:03 you heard him invoke the words as you will for Laurier,
05:59:06 getting close to that dawn of a new day.
05:59:09 it's uh it's almost here uh restating justin trudeau did the liberal promises now that they're
05:59:17 back as a minority government affordability on housing and reconciliation on managing
05:59:21 a way through the pandemic climate change uh i hear you he said uh get back uh we want to get
05:59:28 back to normal and don't want to hear about an election so we'll see that's the kind of talk
05:59:34 How long does that last in a new parliament?
05:59:36 But sending out a...
05:59:38 Well, folks, we've just heard from Liberal Prime Minister Justin Trudeau,
05:59:43 re-elected for his third straight term,
05:59:47 one majority and now two consecutive minority governments.
05:59:52 I mean, as I said earlier, if you went to a coma two years ago and woke up today,
06:00:00 you'd think you might have missed the afternoon.
06:00:01 It's the exact same thing.
06:00:05 Final thoughts, Corey?
06:00:07 Just as you said, there's a whole lot more interesting going to be coming up out of this.
06:00:12 So, I mean, we've come up with a stalemate on the federal front,
06:00:15 but there's a whole lot of machinations, political churning provincially and federally
06:00:21 to look forward perhaps with dread, but all the same is coming.
06:00:26 Final thought to you, Dave.
06:00:28 All eyes back on Alberta as of tomorrow morning.
06:00:31 I can promise our viewers, those of you interested in Alberta, it's going to be an interesting week.
06:00:38 We've got some very interesting irons in the fire.
06:00:41 And, of course, we're going to be working every trapline we've got about what I think is a fairly good expectation,
06:00:50 that things are not going to be very quiet in the Federal Conservative Caucus either in the coming weeks and months.
06:00:55 I really want to thank all of you who watched with us today.
06:00:59 We had a few technical difficulties towards the end, but we have really, really, just wildly improved the quality of the broadcast.
06:01:08 We've had a big part of that.
06:01:10 There's really two to thank here.
06:01:12 One is the producers of today's show.
06:01:15 James Finkbeiner are a director of operations at the Western Standard.
06:01:20 And Melanie Rizdin, who is a new Alberta correspondent with the Western Standard in our Calgary office here.
06:01:28 and she has done great work helping to produce today's show.
06:01:33 And most importantly, we have to thank Western Standard members
06:01:36 who generously support the Western Standard every month.
06:01:41 Without you, there would be no Western Standard.
06:01:44 Without you, we wouldn't be able to do anything like what we're doing right now.
06:01:47 It's such a privilege to be doing it.
06:01:50 I'm so grateful for the position that we're in right now.
06:01:53 So thank you.
06:01:53 And if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
06:01:55 go to westernstandardonline.com, click on Membership.
06:01:58 You could try it free for 15 days before you get charged a penny.
06:02:02 It's only $10 a month or $99 a year to support bailout-free Western media.
06:02:07 Thank you all so much for joining us tonight.
06:02:10 I know it's not the result many of you were looking for.
06:02:13 In fact, I don't think it was even all that interesting.
06:02:16 But I think we had some really interesting guests.
06:02:18 I think we had some very interesting analysis.
06:02:21 And I hope that we've been able to contribute to the democratic debate for Western Canadians here.
06:02:26 What do you have against Hawaiian pizza, by the way?
06:02:29 It's an abomination.
06:02:30 Okay, I finally fully agree with Derek on something.
06:02:33 It's the only thing in which I'm a totalitarian.
06:02:36 I'm a full totalitarian.
06:02:37 This is what I'm stuck with working on.
06:02:39 If, you know, I'm not a dictator in many places, but I'm a dictator in the office.
06:02:44 And I am decreeing, I'm signing an order right now, banning Hawaiian pizza in the Western Standard office.
06:02:50 I'm forming a union.
06:02:53 I'm a...
06:02:54 How are the workers?
06:02:55 I'm folding the company.
06:02:57 James is in.
06:02:58 You heard it here.
06:03:00 I have just closed the Western Standard.
06:03:03 Thank you all very much for watching.
06:03:05 Very much appreciate it.
06:03:07 God bless the West.
06:03:08 Solidarity.