Western Standard - May 22, 2026


Making sense of Alberta’s kinda-sorta independence referendum

Topics
Mentioned
Chaos at the Select Special Citizen Initiative Proposal Review Committee THE PIPELINE: Pipeline later, carbon tax now

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

160.97

Word count

6,351

Sentence count

202

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us for a special edition of The Pipeline, where we talk about the news that Alberta will be holding a referendum on independence from Canada on October 19th, and the reaction from the independence and pro-Calgary independence camps.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 and we're live
00:00:05 live Derek
00:00:10 he's on mute
00:00:12 he muted himself
00:00:16 Derek you're on mute
00:00:21 my apologies
00:00:25 this is the perils
00:00:27 of going live
00:00:29 Just found out I was on mute.
00:00:31 Welcome to a special edition of The Pipeline.
00:00:33 It's not just our normal Friday gab fest.
00:00:37 You know what we're going to be talking about.
00:00:39 We're only going to be talking about one thing,
00:00:41 and that is the announcement by Alberta Premier Danielle Smith
00:00:44 that Albertans are going to be heading to the polls October 19th
00:00:49 to sort of vote on independence.
00:00:54 Maybe I'll throw it to Dave just to start to kind of set it up,
00:00:57 just kind of the background with the different petitions for citizens initiative campaigns
00:01:02 and the question that Albertans are going to be voting on on October 19th.
00:01:08 Yeah, it really is a referendum to have a referendum.
00:01:14 You'll remember the petition, the independence petition was blocked by a court of appeal justice.
00:01:24 So that couldn't go ahead.
00:01:26 So we had the stay in Canada petition by Thomas Lukasik that basically the Premier has accepted that question.
00:01:37 So on October 19th, the Albertans are going to be asked, do you want to stay in Canada or do you want to start the process to leave Canada?
00:01:47 And the reaction has been, you know, what you expect.
00:01:55 Those leading the independence sides are kind of going crazy.
00:02:00 People like Corey will tell you that the independence group should use this
00:02:06 and, you know, get themselves more organized and whatnot.
00:02:10 But, yeah, Albertans will have a say October 19th.
00:02:13 Do you want to stay as part of Canada, or do you want to start the process to become an independent country?
00:02:22 So this referendum isn't precisely what anyone asked for, but it's a combination of what people had asked for that I don't think makes anyone quite happy.
00:02:34 If you talk to the Forever Canada petitioners, they claim that the referendum petition they signed was to not have a referendum.
00:02:43 I mean it's kind of like the pull-out method of not having referendums like accidents are
00:02:52 going to happen guys especially with the act you're engaging in so they're getting so father
00:02:58 of the nation of Alberta nationhood Thomas Lukasik got his way legally speaking he's going to get
00:03:06 a referendum on should Alberta stay in Canada, as Dave said, there were injunctions against
00:03:15 the State Free Alberta petition, which was a straightforward Clarity Act compliant question on
00:03:22 should Alberta become, seems to be a province and become an independent country. That's not on the
00:03:28 ballot because of some very bizarre court rulings saying that, you know, massively expanding the
00:03:35 duty to consult with indigenous groups to be the consultation has to be before even deciding to
00:03:43 pursue something so i guess if we were to apply this to say a pipeline before you announce you
00:03:48 even want to build a pipeline you have to do the consultation it's it's absolutely insane
00:03:53 very good chance this gets struck down in appeal in higher courts at some point but that's years
00:03:59 down the road everybody probably remembers how many years it took in fights over the carbon tax
00:04:03 going to the supreme court uh fights over the no more pipelines act those kinds of things these
00:04:09 things take years so if there is going to be a referendum in the fall it's not allowed oddly
00:04:15 enough the the federal courts ruled that alberta cannot have a referendum in compliance with the
00:04:22 federal clarity act and the supreme court of canada's ruling around uh the secession reference
00:04:29 case. So it's very contradictory, but these things take years to sort out. So I think what,
00:04:38 Corey, I want to go to you here. I think this is not going to make a lot of in the independence
00:04:44 camp happy because it's not a vote on independence. It's a vote on if Alberta should begin the process
00:04:51 of moving towards a formal vote on independence. It's a referendum on if we should have a referendum.
00:04:59 I don't know, how charitable should we be, say, from a pro-independence perspective, how charitable should we be, you know, on is this the best that could be hoped for in the circumstances with these court rulings?
00:05:14 Or is it as, say, guys like Jeffrey Rath are saying this is a cop-out and Smith needs to be overthrown and someone else installed?
00:05:22 Well, I mean, I don't like this.
00:05:24 I've been an independence advocate since I didn't have gray hair.
00:05:27 and uh you know we were coming closer to what we thought might be a definitive clear vote
00:05:32 based on the clarity act an actual binding one closer than we'd ever seen before
00:05:37 and now it's it's sort of been kicked down the road but that said uh despite what with some of
00:05:43 the people like mr wrath and others who it seems have spent years trying to get rid of premier
00:05:48 smith she can't put a binary question on the ballot i've talked to a number of people because
00:05:53 i was wondering about it like is it possible for her just to say too bad we're going to put it on
00:05:57 And no, the second a binary question goes on the ballot, it will go to court and the courts will rule the same thing.
00:06:04 This appeal process has to be drawn out, unfortunately.
00:06:08 This is the uncharted water of a modern independence movement.
00:06:12 Because, yeah, I know Quebec didn't have to deal with that in 1995, but the world has changed a lot legally since then.
00:06:18 And the requirement is ridiculous and it's something appealable and hopefully winnable because, as you said, it'll apply to things like pipelines and such.
00:06:24 but the independence movement can't just toss up their hands and give up they've been given a
00:06:29 question to chew on which is still important and they can campaign for it they can you know
00:06:34 don't worry about freaking out at the provincial government you'll have time for that later
00:06:38 you still want to at least get as good and affirmative to wanting to move on in the process
00:06:43 to becoming independent than uh you know rather than sitting around waiting for an appeal so you
00:06:48 were given something to work on and even if i don't even like the way the question's structured
00:06:54 But all the same, you kind of got to make do with what you got or, you know, the lemons and lemonade thing and see what you can make of it, because otherwise you're just giving up.
00:07:05 And if you get that affirmative, then you really do have some grounds to say, look, the premier now has a mandate.
00:07:12 Now she should, well, whatever it might take, start what would be called a consultation process or something, but move those mechanisms forward towards a real referendum.
00:07:21 And to be honest, it might be a bit of a blessing in disguise.
00:07:24 Keith Wilson said the quiet part out loud.
00:07:27 The movement hasn't actually been gaining any steam in the polls,
00:07:30 and they might not have been leading to a win this fall anyway.
00:07:34 Yeah, there's a few ways to go with this.
00:07:37 I know you said you weren't happy with the structure of this.
00:07:39 I actually do like a referendum that's not necessarily yes or no,
00:07:44 but it's more of an A or B.
00:07:46 So, you know, rather, do you want this yes or no?
00:07:48 it's, do you want option A or do you want option B? I actually kind of like that. I think it's a
00:07:54 bit more neutral than a yes or no. I don't like that they use the word separation in it. Because
00:08:00 separation and independence, while they largely mean the same thing, they don't necessarily mean
00:08:05 the same thing. Because separation, some of it is just rhetorical. The analogy I always use is
00:08:12 separation is like going to the bar and saying, hey, I'm divorced. Independence is like going to
00:08:19 the bar and say, hey, I'm single. They kind of mean the same thing, but they imply something
00:08:24 different. Separation, I think, could be a whole other kettle of worms, including 51st state
00:08:31 annexation of stuff that overwhelmingly people are not particularly interested in. I know there'll
00:08:36 be a few people who are, but it's a very, that's a vanishingly small group. Independence means
00:08:40 independence alberta becomes its own country with its own alliances its own trade agreements
00:08:44 separation could mean that or it could mean other stranger options that are
00:08:50 have have less mainstream appeal um uh to uh to cory's point nigel um you know keith wilson
00:09:00 i i think our he's kind of said part of the quiet part the quiet part out loud uh yesterday last
00:09:05 night after the premier's speech, that this is a safer question. It's more likely to get a better
00:09:13 showing and even possibly succeed. Again, this is still an uphill battle to succeed, but a lot of
00:09:20 people who are soft sovereignists or very frustrated federalists, depending on the terminology you're
00:09:28 using here. This gives them permission to vote for the have a vote to have later vote or have
00:09:37 a referendum to hold a referendum option, the kind of pro-independence side of it. It gives them the
00:09:41 permission to vote for it without the risks involved, that it's, you know, voting for this
00:09:49 doesn't mean we wake up tomorrow in the Republic of Alberta. This is a way to send a message to
00:09:54 advance things along to demonstrate 1.00
00:09:56 Alberta's grievances, that it's upset
00:09:58 and wants a radical change to the status
00:10:00 quo, without actually
00:10:02 firing the shot,
00:10:04 without actually throwing the tea into the harbour.
00:10:07 How do you
00:10:08 take to that?
00:10:10 I think you said it all there,
00:10:12 Derek, really.
00:10:14 I'm just looking at it from the point of view
00:10:16 of what else could
00:10:18 Scremier Smith realistically
00:10:20 do? On the one hand,
00:10:22 if she does nothing, just says, well, they are, the judge spoke, and that settles the matter,
00:10:28 that's not going to satisfy very many people on either side of the argument.
00:10:32 This, at least, as you said, puts it out there and gives people a chance to express an opinion.
00:10:42 I mean, whichever side you're taking, 700,000 people out of a population of four and a half
00:10:48 million, not all of whom are old enough to vote, 700,000 people have said that they want to express
00:10:54 their opinion on Alberta independence, either staying in Canada or going a different way.
00:11:00 That's a sizable amount of people who would be frustrated, rightly so, if they don't get that
00:11:08 opportunity. So it wasn't a perfect solution from the Premier's point of view, but it certainly
00:11:14 will satisfy, for now, that part of her caucus, which is independence-minded, without alienating
00:11:22 that part of the caucus, which I see to be now in the ascendant, which is hammering, well, more
00:11:29 time in the very least, but probably a pro-Canada position. So I think, you know, there's some,
00:11:36 the other thing about the timing of all this, very significant, last Friday, we had a
00:11:42 The Premier had a meeting with Prime Minister Carney.
00:11:46 They agreed something which a lot of people are pretty cynical about.
00:11:49 But anyway, apparently, if all goes well, you'll get a signal on October the 1st about the pipeline, whether there's going to be one, whether it's going forward.
00:12:03 Right. Well, that's just a couple of weeks before this referendum vote, which is still not really a referendum vote, but it's a signal of how people are feeling.
00:12:11 And I would think that you'd get a pretty significant read on how Albertans really feel
00:12:16 if they believe, as many will, that, on Mr. Carney's word, something is being done and
00:12:22 it'll be good.
00:12:24 We'll see how keen they are to pursue the independence track.
00:12:29 I think actually that's going to be a significant moment for the independence movement to see
00:12:33 where people are still with them if they think that maybe something better could come out
00:12:37 of central Canada after all.
00:12:39 So anyone can pick up on this one. I come back to an earlier point I made that the courts, by making this bizarre ruling that the duty to consult indigenous groups has to take place before the vote,
00:12:59 They have maybe unintentionally gutted the Clarity Act and gutted the Supreme Court of Canada's late 1990s secession reference case, which required that to begin the process of a province seceding or becoming independent, that there must be a clear majority on a clear question.
00:13:22 And because they have refused to allow a referendum on a clear question, they have essentially thrown us back to where we were with Quebec's two independence referendums or quasi-sovereignty referendums, which is kind of the point here.
00:13:42 very much to its credit the Alberta independence movement has had no truck or trade with
00:13:48 these weird convoluted questions that we saw in Quebec both I think first in 1980 or whatnot
00:13:57 with Rene Levesque circa 1980 which was this long convoluted essentially it was a paragraph
00:14:03 saying you know blah blah blah blah blah and sovereignty and association very convoluted
00:14:11 And then a still convoluted, although less so, but still quite messy question asked in 1995, the one that nearly passed with 49.9%. Alberta's independence movement has said, we don't want any part of that. Those are mushy questions. They're wishy-washy.
00:14:29 Maybe it helps get you a higher vote turnout on your side, but we want to be clear.
00:14:35 Does Alberta want to be independent or not?
00:14:38 Very clear, to its credit.
00:14:40 And the court, by mucking with this, has said you can't have that question, kind of necessitating Alberta then to have these more convoluted, indirect questions.
00:14:50 I put it to any of you
00:14:54 has the
00:14:56 Supreme Court of Canada gutted its
00:14:57 own decisions here and
00:14:59 thrown us back into Quebec style weird
00:15:01 convoluted unclear questions
00:15:03 well let me pick up on this Derek because I think
00:15:06 what you what the
00:15:07 Judge Shania 1.00
00:15:09 Leonard did was actually 0.99
00:15:12 establish the Supreme Court
00:15:13 as a piece of government as
00:15:15 opposed to a judicial proceeding
00:15:18 and I think for anybody
00:15:20 you seriously interested in the politics of the country, that's a tremendously important
00:15:25 decision that she made there because she's no longer arbitrating the actions of Parliament.
00:15:34 She has actually inserted herself into the whole decision-making process.
00:15:40 Well, that's not a new thing.
00:15:42 Our courts have been doing that really ever since the Charter in the Constitution Act
00:15:47 in 1984.
00:15:48 situation knows very well that by making the decision that she made which many people think
00:15:56 is highly questionable she has effectively punted that referendum into some time in the next
00:16:01 20 years which was her whole goal now that is a governmental action that is something if that's
00:16:10 how people feel about it that's something that the parliament of canada should have had the guts to
00:16:15 uh bring forward the the the clarity act and propose an amendment and say no we're not going
00:16:21 to do this anymore then the judge could arbitrate whether that was properly done but for the judge
00:16:26 to simply rewrite the constitution which is effectively you're right they've been doing it
00:16:31 for a long time but the force of example has pushed this particular judge into a situation
00:16:36 where she is interfering with a very delicate political process and uh you know in fact if
00:16:44 Alberta ever does become independent let there not be that kind of relationship between the judiciary
00:16:52 and the politics between the the unelected officials and the elected officials. This is
00:16:58 something that needs to be dealt with by elected officials not by judges. Well Corey this kind of
00:17:04 judicial activism inserting itself into the governance process going into the realm that
00:17:10 is supposed to be the purview of parliament or the legislatures this has been going on since the
00:17:14 the Constitution Act 1982. This is not a new thing. But what I think is interesting here,
00:17:21 kind of going back to my earlier point, is the federal court here, which remember is still below
00:17:27 the Supreme Court, but the federal court in Alberta, it contradicted the Supreme Court in
00:17:35 the secession reference case. So this is not just a court against parliament or a court
00:17:42 against a provincial legislature it is a court against the supreme court um and so we're left
00:17:50 because of this contradictory ruling the supreme court says you have to have a clear majority on
00:17:55 a clear question and then the federal court here a true to appointed judge the federal court says
00:18:02 but you're not allowed to have a clear question so this leaves you either with no question
00:18:08 or a convoluted question and then that convoluted question the supreme court would then say very
00:18:14 rightly is not legitimate grounds to begin the process of negotiating independence um so uh is
00:18:23 it is it fair to say then that this court has essentially thrown us back into the pre-secession
00:18:29 supreme court reference case landscape where it's just kind of a wild west and it's forcing
00:18:35 us to have a convoluted Quebec style question on the referendum. Yeah, it changed the requirements
00:18:43 and inserted a poison pill into it. But it is temporary, or we'll see about temporary. There's
00:18:49 another level now that this is going to go up when it goes into appeal. And from my understanding,
00:18:53 the appeals court will have three justices looking at it, and they'll be basically judging
00:19:00 the judgment and this could become more nuanced and there's a better chance that they're going to
00:19:06 look at this and say no you didn't have the authority or this wasn't legitimate to be able
00:19:11 to override a prior supreme court reference case where so much time and effort and dedication was
00:19:17 put into it or maybe they'll they'll hold it up if they hold it up then this is going to go all
00:19:22 the way to the supreme court the other wild card and i'm surprised with how silent they've been so
00:19:26 far, though, is Quebec. You know that the sovereignist movement over there can't be
00:19:31 impressed with this. And, you know, they may not have a majority support for independence in Quebec
00:19:37 right now, but even soft independent supporters and so on don't like being told you aren't allowed
00:19:41 to consider it, whether it's Alberta or in Quebec. And Justice Leonard might not care if she infuriates
00:19:47 Quebecers, but I suspect a higher level of court might take those kind of things into consideration
00:19:52 before changing the rules on what a province may or may not do under the Clarity Act.
00:19:56 I'd like to get back into the speech itself last night, Derek, and for the first time
00:20:04 Smith coming out solidly on the side of Canada.
00:20:09 She said that she's always been in favour of a sovereign Alberta within Canada, but
00:20:15 for the first time she said that she will be voting to stay in Canada.
00:20:19 So is she positioning herself to be Captain Canada for the referendum?
00:20:24 Is she going to join forces with Jason Kenney, as weird as that could be?
00:20:30 And will those two be the top fighters for the Stay in Canada movement?
00:20:35 It's going to be interesting because she sure was as strongly as I've ever heard her say that Alberta needs to stay in Canada.
00:20:44 Well, maybe she had no point, Dave.
00:20:48 Maybe there was really no alternative.
00:20:50 they're so busy uh organizing to booster that she is forced now to take a side and she's not going
00:20:58 with the crazies on the uh on the um radicals shall i call them on the independent because
00:21:05 they've clearly rejected her yeah oh you're talking about cory
00:21:12 now there's talk about uh doing the same thing to smith as uh as they did to kenny and getting uh
00:21:18 individual constituencies to declare non-confidence and i think they need
00:21:23 22 or 23 of different constituencies to do that and then that would force a leadership review and
00:21:30 we all remember jason kenny just barely squeaking by but but realizing that it wasn't good enough
00:21:35 and uh and he had to resign so i guess well let's remember he he he rigged it several times they
00:21:41 changed the rules multiple times as they knew they were going to fail so he cheated just to
00:21:45 to get like 52 percent or whatever 53 i'm not sure exactly what it was but they cheated just
00:21:51 to get that much uh so let's be clear he didn't he didn't actually win but yeah i i take your point
00:21:57 i want to i want to get into dave's point further cory um the uh smith has uh
00:22:05 we'll just zoom out for a second she is keenly aware that no alberta conservative premier has
00:22:11 completed a single term since
00:22:14 Ralph Klein in 2004. I was
00:22:15 in high school when that happened.
00:22:17 She is very aware of it. She
00:22:19 very much wants to break
00:22:21 that curse and be the first
00:22:23 conservative premier to at least
00:22:25 finish a single term. Quite
00:22:27 an accomplishment.
00:22:30 And she knows that
00:22:31 the threat is not primarily
00:22:33 from the NDP. It is always from the right
00:22:36 populist flank of
00:22:38 her own party. 0.93
00:22:40 And she has...
00:22:41 They quite masterfully kept that flank in the party. Now, it's not universally independence. It's, as I said, it's right populist. So it's a grab bag of issues. There's a Venn diagram. There's all sorts of things. And, you know, the energy behind it was against COVID restrictions at a time. But a lot of those people were also independence.
00:23:00 Now, independence is the issue at the fore of it.
00:23:04 So I know that I think we saw some of the guys on maybe some of the harder edge of the independence movement.
00:23:13 We had Jeff Raff, David Parker.
00:23:15 They're calling for the overthrow of Smith here.
00:23:19 I'm not sure how representative that is of the movement more broadly.
00:23:22 I know Parker called for the overthrow of Smith at her last leadership review.
00:23:27 she still got like 93 per circa 93 percent so it didn't seem to have really any impact then
00:23:33 um wrath uh i don't maybe has a bit maybe he's got more pull i don't know but uh
00:23:41 this question is not going to satisfy a lot of people in the independence movement obviously
00:23:47 because it's not a clear question but her hands are largely tied by the courts until this gets
00:23:51 through the appellate stage so she's given this as a sort of amuse-bouche or an appetizer to
00:23:57 keep something going at least in the meantime at least let Albertans speak out on the direction
00:24:05 they want to go if not the decision itself do you think that is going to be enough to keep most of
00:24:12 the independence camp happy with her leadership supporting her continuing as premier or do you
00:24:18 think this is not going to be enough and actually opens up a threat to her leadership.
00:24:24 Yeah, I think that could be wrong. I mean, it is true that the threat always comes from the right
00:24:29 and she's got to watch that flank. But they're the same vocal actors, a minority within a minority
00:24:34 that have been screaming about her for a couple of years now. And as you said, a number of those
00:24:39 same actors were very active in trying to get a negative leadership review years ago, and they
00:24:43 garnered 93% support for. Speaking anecdotally, I mean, I've been speaking at a lot of those public
00:24:49 meetings lately, and I didn't get home till two in the morning last night from one of them up in
00:24:52 Round Hill, which was a good opportunity, actually, to speak to some people on the ground. And, you
00:24:58 know, when you get face to face with people, and that's exactly the sort of discussion we were all
00:25:03 having last night, people aren't necessarily thrilled with where things have gone or how they
00:25:07 have, and they'd like to see, you know, more movement towards independence. But I'm not seeing
00:25:12 the inclination to get out the torches and pitchforks for premier smith at that point even
00:25:16 if they're not fully happy with her i think it's more of a vocal element on social media of a few
00:25:23 rather than representative of the whole who might have a bit more of a pragmatic streak or like
00:25:28 other actions smith has done she still can't avoid it i think that's why she's you know if there was
00:25:34 no risk at all i think she would just avoid having a referendum altogether she had to offer some kind
00:25:38 a bone and this is what it was whether it'll be enough to satisfy I think it will but we'll see
00:25:43 I guess in coming weeks uh Nigel I'd like your take and maybe Dave as well on the other side
00:25:52 here Smith has been walking the most incredible tightrope I have ever seen a politician walk
00:25:58 and she has she has thus far successfully succeeded but the the headlines across Canada
00:26:05 last night and in the evening was Alberta's having more or less an independence referendum-ish
00:26:14 and she is denounced as a traitor despite her saying that she would vote to stay in Canada
00:26:22 but she thinks this question needs to be settled the people of Alberta need to speak
00:26:25 she doesn't want this to preoccupy us for all time we have to be able to move forward in one
00:26:29 direction or another um the ucp is a weird coalition right now it's got a majority of its
00:26:39 voters and probably even bigger majority of its members are alberta uh nationalists broadly
00:26:46 speaking uh but probably uh but independents as well but there's a there's a big minority of
00:26:52 federalists who still vote ucp there's a big minority of federalists who are still members
00:26:57 of the ucp i think the higher up the food chain of the party you go the more federalist it gets
00:27:02 and the lower to the grassroots you get the more the more nationalist it is um cory spoke on on
00:27:09 the nationalist side about if it's enough does this go too far do you think to keep most federalists
00:27:15 who are in the ucp uh from breaking into open revolt against her because i i she uh she's she's 0.99
00:27:24 facing uh this is kind of her schlieffen plan she's trying to fight on two fronts and strike
00:27:30 one quickly before she can go after the other and uh she's getting it from the federalist side
00:27:36 she's getting it from uh you know obviously the left wing you know the nanshiite she's getting
00:27:42 it from the federal liberals uh jason kenny has measured his language not to go after her
00:27:49 personally he goes after the movement and his criticisms of her have been indirect and tactile
00:27:54 but other proxies around him have have gone after her directly and we've got people in the ucp nate
00:28:02 horner guys like that who are no longer in cabinet who have spoken against there being a referendum
00:28:07 but have not gone after her directly where do you think the risk is for her with federalists
00:28:15 in her party right now as a potential risk to her leadership, that they break an open revolt?
00:28:21 I don't think that's very strong at all, Derek. And the reason that I would say that is that
00:28:26 if she has declared, and she has, that she is pro-Canada as opposed to pro-Alberta independence,
00:28:34 she is in sync with the larger part of the opinion in Alberta. I mean, the most optimistic
00:28:41 polls, and Corey, by all means, correct me if I'm off by a few digits, but the most optimistic
00:28:47 polls that I have seen in support of Alberta independence are less than 40%, which means that
00:28:56 60% of the people polled are pro-Canada, and she has aligned herself with that faction.
00:29:04 So if this ever comes to a real election issue, then she has got those people who might not
00:29:12 otherwise have been supportive of the UCP on her side. They may not all vote for her, but at least
00:29:20 they're not... Well, but that's not where I'm going with this question. Also, I would say,
00:29:24 I wouldn't call the other side necessarily pro-Canada. It involves a lot of people who
00:29:27 hate Canada, tear down the statues of Sir John McDonnell, James the Anthem.
00:29:30 i would call those people federalists uh but i i take your point i know i know you're going
00:29:37 but i know my point is um yes she has declared that she's on the federalist side she'll vote
00:29:43 federalist in the referendum but the federalists are pretty outraged that the referendum is taking
00:29:50 place anyway even though 400 000 of them signed a petition demanding a referendum on this uh i mean 0.99
00:29:57 play stupid games win stupid prizes is uh is the warning i'd have for them but um they're outraged 0.98
00:30:04 that she's called the referendum to begin with um so even though she's said she'll vote on the 1.00
00:30:09 federalist side she is proceeding with the referendum and they're angry about that referendum
00:30:15 so that's where i i'm asking i want your opinion on if there's a threat from the federalists within
00:30:21 the ucp that she has from their perspective pandered to the nationalists uh that she has
00:30:27 uh facilitated them and let this go on too far by allowing a referendum to begin with
00:30:32 well 24 hours after the event there probably will be some anger but as they think about it they'll 0.90
00:30:37 realize there wasn't really much else that she could have done how would they have felt if she
00:30:41 had done nothing probably well the issue remains unresolved you've got to get well that's that's
00:30:46 they say they want they want her to do nothing yeah well what was your cute phrase there the 1.00
00:30:53 silly arguments stupid play stupid games win stupid prizes no this is this has to be dealt 1.00
00:31:01 with i mean you may be a federalist but you can't just say that when 37 40 of your neighbors think 1.00
00:31:09 very differently to you that this is something that the premier of the province would just
00:31:14 overlook carry on as if nothing had happened it needs to be dealt with and this actually
00:31:19 in terms of the of the phrasing of the of the referendum question is about as benign as it
00:31:26 could get if you are a federalist the um just to just to remind us all the uh the question
00:31:35 is um should alberta remain a province of canada or should the government of alberta commence
00:31:42 legal process well you know in fact you're a federalist get up there and vote the way you feel
00:31:51 i think it was apropos i just had my cuckoo clock i have to apologize for my cuckoo clock going off
00:31:56 and the whole conversation is a bit cuckoo so i i think it was a bit apropos uh dave go ahead
00:32:03 i i think the federalists will will all see that uh the courts have had tied premier smith's hands
00:32:09 She's played the only card she really has left and I think played it quite masterfully.
00:32:14 Coming out and then saying that she's going to be Captain Canada will thrill the Federalists
00:32:21 because they've now got their leader. And I think she's also taken away the argument that
00:32:30 the Nenshiites have that she is a separatist herself. Well, no, she's denied that now and
00:32:36 equivalently such that she is not. And she says her party is not. Sorry, yeah, you know, the UCP
00:32:43 caucus is not. So that takes away all the Nenshi arguments that she's a separatist leader running 0.99
00:32:50 a separatist government. For anybody to say that Daniel Smith is now a separatist, they're just
00:32:56 silly. It's just silly. She's not a separatist at all. Yeah, well, I think their argument is, 1.00
00:33:01 even if she is not their argument is she's pandering to the nationalists she's facilitating
00:33:08 the nationalists and there is some argument there she is allowing the process to go forward
00:33:13 and and I would say the government is not uh pro-independence but the membership and the
00:33:20 voters are dominantly pro-independence and I think that is a fair criticism but you know as
00:33:26 as nigel said what is she going to do she's damned if she does damned if she doesn't uh if
00:33:31 she didn't didn't call a referendum and the the anger would would would grow and i think the
00:33:37 independence uh independence thoughts would would would get higher but by doing this now i think 0.54
00:33:42 she's cutting the uh you know she's trying to cut the legs out from the uh from the independent 0.72
00:33:47 supporters and if it comes back in october that let's say 30 percent of people vote for uh you
00:33:55 know trying to succeed from canada and 70 say to stay then i think she's got the argument that she
00:34:01 can uh you know this this may go away for several years the whole independence argument not necessarily
00:34:07 replace her as leader but uh certainly the the independence yeah i uh i i'm not with you dave
00:34:16 in saying that she is going to be the leader of the federalist side here i mean she's declared
00:34:21 that she's going to vote that way um but i'm i'll put this to whoever wants to pick up uh in the
00:34:28 group here but i don't think she's going to be out stumping every day at pro-federalist rallies
00:34:35 the people who are going to come out to pro-federalist rallies are overwhelmingly going
00:34:38 to be ndp supporters federal liberal supporters uh because the majority of her own voters and the
00:34:46 and the probably the big majority of her party's members support independence they're nationalists
00:34:51 or Alberta nationalists.
00:34:53 So I think she's declared herself for it.
00:34:55 She'll probably make a few statements.
00:34:58 But I suspect she's going to keep a fairly low,
00:35:02 try to keep a fairly low profile during the campaign.
00:35:05 I think the leaders of this
00:35:09 are going to be dominantly Jason Kenney and Nahid Nenshi.
00:35:15 And Pierre Pauly, I've said yesterday
00:35:17 when this was announced
00:35:19 that he's going to be out here campaigning.
00:35:20 He'll be here as well. But I would posit that Danielle Smith has declared herself on one side, but she's going to fight kind of a phony war. 1.00
00:35:31 She's going to sit behind the lion's ear and let this play out.
00:35:37 Well, I would agree with that.
00:35:41 Go ahead, Corey.
00:35:43 Well, I'm just saying that, again, she's still she's put something out there, but she's still maintaining the tightrope walk.
00:35:50 And she can't fall too heavily on one side or the other.
00:35:54 So she's standing in the middle right now.
00:35:56 She's declared herself a Federalist, yet offered the mechanism for independence people to continue to move the movement forward. 0.84
00:36:03 But to actually get out and overtly campaign on this would really split her movement. 0.99
00:36:10 It really would upset the independence side of things that she's trying to keep piped down and quell them.
00:36:17 There's no sense in flaming them further.
00:36:19 They're already a little upset with the phrasing of the question.
00:36:22 So I think occasionally she's going to pop up and reassert that she is indeed in favor of a United Canada.
00:36:28 But she will leave it to Lukasic, Kenny, and the rest to do the actual formal campaigning.
00:36:34 And she can sit in the background because Paul Lingsaldi on one side or the other is asking to split the party.
00:36:42 Yeah.
00:36:42 Okay.
00:36:43 Well, we had a great conversation.
00:36:45 I like pipeline was just one really good topic and we can really dig into it.
00:36:50 And we're not, we're not too limited by keeping it into shorter segments.
00:36:54 So I think we had a, I think we had a great chat today.
00:36:56 I want to thank everyone, Dave, Corey, Nigel,
00:37:00 and John on production and everyone who joined us here today.
00:37:03 Before I let everyone go though, I want to introduce,
00:37:05 this has been six and a half years coming.
00:37:09 It's just, we finally had the right staff to make it happen.
00:37:12 The launch of the Western Standard Store.
00:37:14 there's no conspiracy about the timing
00:37:18 here but we've
00:37:20 got some really great items I want
00:37:22 to point you to I don't know if John could
00:37:24 bring up a screenshot here of the store
00:37:26 or not but
00:37:27 westernstandardstore.news
00:37:30 is where you can go we've got
00:37:31 lots of great stuff we've got
00:37:33 the Alberta Proud collection
00:37:36 we've got a Ralph Klein collection
00:37:37 some great images of
00:37:39 Ralph flipping the bird you can put on your
00:37:42 shirt
00:37:42 a lot of really cool items you can check out
00:37:46 we've kept the profit margin absolutely minimal
00:37:49 most of what you're paying for is just the manufacturing and the shipping
00:37:53 what very small profit margin we have is going to go to support
00:37:58 the newsroom and columnists of the Western Standard
00:38:02 keeping our operations going
00:38:04 but we've got a lot of really cool stuff there
00:38:07 so check us out at westernstandardstore.news
00:38:10 Also, if you're not yet a subscriber, make sure you go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe, $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content and to support the work we do.
00:38:21 We're going to have a lot more to say about this.
00:38:23 This is going to dominate everything in Alberta, possibly in Canada, all the way through to October 19th.
00:38:30 We're just getting started.
00:38:32 The cuckoo's just begun.
00:38:34 So the Western Standard is where you're going to get a front row seat to all the cuckoo.
00:38:38 Thank you very much, everyone, for joining us and God bless.
00:38:40 Imagine showing up
00:39:09 Thanksgiving dinner with your grandma from Ontario wearing this or imagine
00:39:14 going to Christmas with your Ottawa loving elbows-up uncle wearing this these
00:39:18 are designs you're not going to find anywhere else go to westernstandardstore.news
00:39:23 join the club today