In this episode of The Pipeline, we're joined by our brand new BC Political Columnist, Nathan Guida, to talk about the latest lockdown in British Columbia, and whether or not it's worse than the ones in the Soviet Union.
00:02:30.000G'day, I'm Derek Fildebrandt. Welcome to The Pipeline. Today is March 31st, 2012. Pleased to be with you. Today I'm joined by Dave Naylor, news editor of the Western Standard. G'day, Dave.
00:11:16.100that we're going to be following in your footsteps soon.
00:11:19.180But, you know, what's really the reaction on the ground here? Are British Columbians, I know here the government loves the, Jason Kenney is kind of envious of Doug Ford. The more he cracks down in Ontario, the more his popularity goes up. We seem to have quite the opposite phenomenon here. The government seems to think its popularity is vital, or that lockdowns are vital to maintaining public support, but the more they do it, the more it goes down.
00:11:45.940um what's what's the politics to this on the ground in british columbia if uh you're you're
00:11:52.440now in another lockdown lockdown 2.5 as you said uh is this going to have any effect on the
00:12:00.040popularity of the government i know they were re-elected with a big majority um but also how
00:12:04.140are the bc liberals handling this are they um are they at all different uh than how the bc uh ndp
00:12:10.160is handling it i think something that's interesting about what happened last year
00:12:14.560is that the B.C. Liberals, for the most part, played the lapdog to the B.C. NDP.
00:12:20.240They didn't resist any of their projects or policies around the pandemic
00:12:24.780or maybe question them or bring up some kind of oppositional sort of ideas,
00:12:29.480alternatives to the way that things were going.
00:12:31.540For that, they were rewarded with an absolutely crushing defeat at the polls.
00:12:37.340And so I think without contrast, without providing an opposition,
00:12:40.740any party, and that goes for any party, left wing or right wing,
00:12:43.420is always in deep danger of losing its supporters because what's the alternative? They could vote
00:12:48.120for you, but they'll get it with the other guy. I think coming back to what's going on in British
00:12:52.040Columbia on the ground, there seems to be essentially, as there always is, at least
00:12:56.240kind of four camps. You have your extremities both for and against the lockdown, and then you
00:13:00.720have people who are kind of in the fair to Midland. Where it goes for us in the northern interior is
00:13:06.320that for the most part, it doesn't really seem to affect us that much. Of course, it affects us when
00:13:10.160We try to get into a church door, and now the restaurants are closed.
00:13:14.320And, of course, that's a deep tragedy, and these people need to be compensated.
00:13:17.820And, honestly, they just need their businesses reopened.
00:13:19.920It's absolutely ridiculous, and they were given no warning.
00:13:22.340But the fact of the matter remains is that it just feels like it's all above our heads.
00:13:26.960The average person, I don't think, really tunes in anymore to when Dr. Henry speaks.
00:14:34.360like there's probably a bit more of a debate
00:14:35.920about lockdowns, about mask restrictions. You know, the war on fun, I think, has now gone nuclear,
00:14:44.240it's fair to say. There's a bit more of a debate on that, I think, here in Alberta, where I think
00:14:50.240opposition is, you know, there is opposition in every province, but I think I'm very proud that
00:14:55.040the opposition is the largest here in Alberta. We had a very interesting debate challenge,
00:15:02.000I think yesterday come out that, Dave, you had the scoop on. Why don't you tell us what happened?
00:15:09.380Yeah, Dirk, this involves a group of very respected medical people, former military,
00:15:16.120high-ranking people, and they've got together and sort of formed their own emergency response
00:15:23.060unit, and they've issued a formal challenge to Premier Kenney to come out and publicly debate
00:15:29.560them. I think he gave them a list of six questions that they were willing to debate. They had a
00:15:35.480moderator all picked out. And they're basically against all of the Alberta COVID lockdown
00:15:41.880regulations saying they're doing more harm than more good. So the challenge was issued.
00:15:48.760One of the people interestingly involved is Dr. Dennis Modry, who we've all dealt with before.
00:15:55.320He's a world-famous heart surgeon in Alberta, performed the first heart transplant at the
00:16:01.160University of Alberta in 1985. He's got an absolute alphabet of initials past his name that
00:16:09.000I don't even understand, but he's very well respected. He wrote a letter to the Premier
00:16:15.000last year that got literally hundreds of thousands of views worldwide. Kenny finally responded a
00:16:20.920a couple weeks ago. And Dr. Modray has actually responded today. I've got a hold of a letter
00:16:26.040he has sent to the Premier this morning. I'll be publishing that as soon as we're done the show
00:16:32.220here. And again, he doubles down and challenges Kenny to a public debate. Western Standard reached
00:16:41.740out to Premier Kenny's office for comment. And we've heard not a peep back. But I think there's
00:16:48.840Two chances of a debate. One is slim and the other is none. I don't think it's going to happen, Derek.
00:16:56.480Thanks, Dave. Corey, Dr. Modry originally penned some private letters to Jason Kenney.
00:17:05.520Both Kenney and Redman, Colonel Redman, they both wrote, I think this was this in November or was this December?
00:17:15.320I think the private letters were in November.
00:17:16.600Private letters were in November. Nothing happened. Both of these gentlemen came to us. We published Dr. Dennis Modry's open letter in the Western Center in December. Up until that time, at least, it was our most read story ever, this open letter. It was very fascinating stuff.
00:17:34.400uh kenny has only just now responded to to dennis modry um after this has now gotten a lot of a lot
00:17:42.160of play finally and uh is this modry's reply to the reply on our site now or no not yet uh still
00:17:48.920it'll be coming up uh he it's a very detailed response uh paragraph by paragraph uh he cuts
00:17:55.600apart the premier's arguments uh very interesting lots of links in there uh so yeah make sure you
00:18:02.300check back at westernstandardonline.com and we'll put all three letters up and you can you can judge
00:18:08.500for yourself we should do a poll which one people like more absolutely although i i might predict
00:18:13.640the results from our yeah yeah you don't need to be a top pollster to figure out i i i think i know
00:18:18.280our readership well enough to know how uh people would vote on that um cory how how damaging do
00:18:24.720you think this is of the government um this back you know there is dr motory's letter but now
00:18:29.240others that the debate challenged Kenny and Hinshaw. When I first saw this come across my
00:18:34.000desk, I think my reaction was, yeah, I don't think they're taking it up. I won't even ask you if you
00:18:40.180think they're going to take it up because there's no chance they're taking it up. But do you think
00:18:44.800this is going to have much effect on things? Because these are not, it's not you and me
00:18:48.420challenging them to a debate. We have opinions on these matters, but we're not experts. These people
00:18:53.320are incredible experts though. This is Dr. Dennis Modry, one of the most respected and renowned
00:18:58.240doctors still alive in Alberta today. Redmond was in the letter, right? Yes. Redmond, a retired
00:19:06.160Lieutenant Colonel David Redmond, who was also the head of Alberta's emergency response
00:19:11.680agency for the province here. These are not casual people. These are not angry people
00:19:19.620commenting on a Twitter thread. These are about as credible and high ranking as you can get.
00:19:25.140Do you think this is going to have any kind of effect?
00:25:09.260And he showed up on Sunday back at his packed Grace Life Church and actually did preach.
00:25:17.500Stunningly, the RCMP and Alberta Health Services attempted to enter the church minutes before he took the pulpit and were blocked by church elders.
00:25:28.580So it was a great interview last night with Danielle Smith and Pastor James.
00:25:33.380And he talked about that. I mean, just how stunning it was to see the RCMP show up, you know, after just being getting released from jail. Imagine the nerves that that would cause.
00:25:46.420He told Danielle about his time in jail, two weeks in solitary COVID confinement, only allowed out of his cell a couple times a day for 15 minutes at a time.
00:30:17.320You are bullying religious people from going to a very important service.
00:30:21.400I think we're going to see a lot of them coming out this weekend.
00:30:23.580You know, we need to, as Pastor Coates said, though, and then we need more Albertans to get up, whether it's restaurants, whether it's individuals and push back.
00:30:31.520I've said it before, and I know it'll upset people now, but we've got to get, we've got to overpower the crazies.
00:30:38.360I'm sorry, but I've gone to these demonstrations and there are some very out there people.
00:30:42.720There may be well-meaning, but it puts people off.
00:30:45.280They show up and they say, I'm not coming back to this crowd again.
00:30:47.780We need your common Albertans to come out.
00:30:49.460I'm going to come out this Saturday to the next one.
00:32:36.180Let's see some folks come out and speak up for themselves.
00:32:39.880Dave, before we wrap up here, what does it really look like, at least the government in Alberta and in Saskatchewan, is looking at doing, as we were discussing at the top of the show, British Columbia, Ontario, already under lockdown 2.5 or 3, depending on how you're slicing it.
00:32:58.620What's it looking like we're going to see?
00:33:02.180What's the feeling, what signals is the government sending about what they're going to do when we're past Easter?
00:33:07.320Well, it's a difficult question, Derek. They're holding the cards to the chest. As you've said,
00:33:15.320Premier Kenney is not making himself available. They're leaving it to Dr. Dina Hinshaw.
00:33:22.120NBP leader Rachel Notley has been looking for more, I think. She was tweeting on the weekend
00:33:29.240about Grace Life Church and how the RCMP and Jason Kenney should be doing more
00:35:05.740We can't take four more years of those bloody borderline communists running this province.
00:35:09.460I mean, they're screaming to lock up people for holding services.
00:35:12.140But at the end of the day, Jason Kenney, just one week later,
00:35:15.280did exactly what Rachel Notley wanted him to do last time.
00:35:19.480So, I mean, I don't have a lot of faith that,
00:35:22.740because to not lock us down again requires an admission
00:35:25.740that the first two lockdowns were a mistake.
00:35:27.900And you know, I can forgive the first lockdown. We all, we did not properly understand this virus was coming out of China and China was jailing reporters, jailing doctors who were speaking up on it. We just didn't know how bad it was going to be. The initial reports showed that this was going to be more serious than it turned out to be. I can forgive the first lockdown. I know some of you watching or listening cannot. I can forgive the first lockdown.
00:35:52.340I cannot forgive the second lockdown because that was political.