Western Standard - April 01, 2025


MAXIMUM MADNESS: Making sense of the wild polls in this election with *THE* expert

Topics
Mentioned
Chaos after Germans vote to move right This election could shatter Canada

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

155.64

Word count

3,933

Sentence count

181

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Just a few months ago, Pierre Trudeau and his Conservative Party were on track to win potentially the biggest majority government in Canadian history, surpassing those of even Brian Mulroney and John Diefenbaker. But since replacing Justin Trudeau with Mark Carney, the Liberals have risen like Lazarus from the grave to first place in most polls. Are the polls telling the truth? And which of those polls is the most credible?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 This is who Rod Loyola praised, Fidel Castro, a brutal communist dictator.
00:00:10 Now, Loyola's jumping ship from the radical NDP to run federally for Mark Carney's liberals.
00:00:18 Mark Carney, embracing hard-left radicals who celebrate anti-capitalist tyranny.
00:00:25 Which leads the critical mass to surpass the imbalance of the capitalists to the oppressed working class.
00:00:31 If this is Carney's team, imagine his Canada.
00:00:55 The polls are drunk right now.
00:01:03 Just a few months ago,
00:01:04 Pierre Polyev and his Conservative Party
00:01:06 were on track to win
00:01:07 potentially the biggest majority government
00:01:09 in Canadian history,
00:01:11 surpassing those of even Brian Mulroney
00:01:13 and John Diefenbaker.
00:01:15 But since swapping out Justin Trudeau for Mark Carney,
00:01:18 the Liberals have risen like Lazarus from the grave
00:01:21 to first place in most polls.
00:01:23 Are those polls telling the truth?
00:01:25 which of those polls is most credible? How would those polls break down on a riding-by-riding level
00:01:31 into actual seats in an election? I have ideas about most of this because I mostly just borrow
00:01:37 my opinions on the matter from the man who knows the most about it in Canada. Our guest today,
00:01:43 Monsieur Philippe J. Fournier. Monsieur Fournier is the founder and owner of 338Canada.com,
00:01:48 a polling aggregator and seat projection website that has a pretty good record.
00:01:53 Welcome, Mr. Fournier.
00:01:55 Thank you, Derek. Much appreciate that introduction.
00:01:58 All right. Well, the polls have just swung wildly since the Liberals swapped out Trudeau for Carney.
00:02:07 Parties have had big bumps before.
00:02:10 You know, Alison Redford for Jim Prentice, Brian Mulroney for Kim Campbell.
00:02:15 And sometimes it has not worked, but sometimes it has worked.
00:02:17 Like when Jason Kenney was swapped for Danielle Smith here in Alberta.
00:02:22 What's different this time is that Carney called an election immediately after becoming leader without giving people time to remember that they're still angry at the governing party.
00:02:33 My question to you is, is it working and can Mark Carney keep it up long enough for the rest of the campaign?
00:02:40 Well, this is a very good question.
00:02:42 We do not know the answer, but we can go with the indicators and with the data to see, to have a better idea of how the next four weeks could turn out.
00:02:54 Right now, there is no doubt that Mr. Carney is going through a honeymoon, which is not uncommon for new leaders.
00:03:02 But honeymoons don't always last very long.
00:03:06 The hope for the liberals and Mr. Carney is that it lasts long enough.
00:03:10 So, again, we have four more weeks to go.
00:03:14 But voting intentions are one indicator, one of many.
00:03:18 And when we look at the other indicators, such as preferred leaders, such as also the regional numbers, the mood of the country, they all seem to point towards a liberal recovery.
00:03:30 We don't know how long it would last, but it looks to be more solid every day we get into this campaign so far.
00:03:37 well i want to talk about that honeymoon uh and matt gurney the at the line called it a sugar high
00:03:45 i think that might be an apt term we'll we'll see but uh some polls are indicating the most are
00:03:51 indicating the liberals are riding high how high depends on what poll you're looking at
00:03:54 uh but a lot of the polls are showing that the vote isn't very solid you know that it is kind
00:03:59 of an artificial sugar high if you will uh and that it could like a sugar high crash as quickly 0.87
00:04:05 as it came on. How solid is the liberal vote right now? I know one of the indicators is how
00:04:13 likely are you to stick with your party or how firm are you in sticking with your choice? I think
00:04:19 most polls have showed the conservative vote is more solid, but the liberal vote is high overall,
00:04:24 but less solid. How soft is that kind of sugar high liberal vote right now?
00:04:29 I would say your description is correct, that the Conservative vote is far more committed, and I would say even enthusiastic, than other parties' vote.
00:04:41 However, Derek, this is not new.
00:04:44 We see this indicator at every recent elections, at least.
00:04:49 Conservatives in this country are very committed, they're committed to the cause, to the party.
00:04:53 And since Mr. Harper won in 06, the party never had below 32% in a general election, whereas we have seen the Liberals swing all the way down to 19% and swing all the way up to 39%, and now we see them in the low 40s right now.
00:05:11 So the Conservative voters are generally more faithful to their parties, whereas the Liberals and NDP clearly are not.
00:05:21 So how solid is this?
00:05:24 Well, I could answer your question by a question.
00:05:28 Is the NDP vote going to recover?
00:05:32 And if the answer is like, well, I'm sure Jack Mead Singh can turn this around, then the liberals are in trouble.
00:05:39 But if you look at Jack Mead Singh's campaign and think, oh, they're done, well, that's bad news for the conservatives.
00:05:47 Well, you've now forced me to switch around the order of my questions.
00:05:50 I'm going to go straight.
00:05:51 I had saved this one for the last, but we're going to have to go to it now.
00:05:56 I think that has been the big story.
00:05:58 I think it's getting somewhat overlooked in the media talk and the punditry around this campaign.
00:06:05 The conservative vote has come down a bit, but much more movement has been from the NDP to the liberals here.
00:06:16 Just that the NDP vote has melted down.
00:06:19 So, you know, I have you here in your capacity as a man who understands polling and analysis, not as a pundit.
00:06:27 It means it's a bit more meat when you talk about things than when I talk about things.
00:06:32 But in a strange way, do you think the NDP are wearing the legacy of the Trudeau liberals more than the Carney liberals?
00:06:42 Well, that's fair.
00:06:43 Although I am not certain that the NDP going down into single digits because this is what we see right now is as much because they supported Trudeau for almost two years.
00:06:59 Maybe some of it is, but here's what we have to remember.
00:07:04 Pierre Poilievre has had a permanent campaign since he became leader and has done quite well
00:07:11 doing so, took the lead in every region. Even though he's not leading in Quebec, he is pulling
00:07:17 higher in Quebec than Renaud O'Toole, than Andrew Scheer, and in some cases than the late stages of
00:07:22 Stephen Harper. So he's been doing his part. But it's always been the case in this country that the
00:07:30 anti-conservative vote is a bit higher than the conservative vote it's just that the entire
00:07:35 conservative vote is split and so you could see a majority with 38 37 or 39 rather with
00:07:43 stephen harper whereas you know for the liberals they really have to hope the ndp goes down to win
00:07:49 an election and we see those ingredients right now uh so the conservatives uh they cannot win
00:07:57 in this context right now with the NDP solo. In single digits, perhaps winning a handful of seats,
00:08:05 maybe a little more than that, if you're optimistic of their local MPs. But for the
00:08:11 Conservatives to be at 38%, my podcast partner Eric Grenier mentioned that the last time the
00:08:17 Conservatives had 37% in a general election and did not win, you have to go back one century.
00:08:25 So this is a normal right now.
00:08:27 When you when the conservatives have 38% of the vote, they win.
00:08:31 It's just that right now there seems to be, as you said, the sugar high
00:08:36 for the Liberals, that's keeping them afloat and keeping the NDP very low.
00:08:42 You know, your answers are forcing me to mix up the order of all my questions here.
00:08:47 Apologies.
00:08:47 So we know the Liberals, they're on the sugar high.
00:08:49 They're up in the polls.
00:08:50 but it is, as is pretty predictable, most strongly east of Saskatchewan
00:08:56 and in the less conservative-leaning regions of British Columbia.
00:09:02 You're an Easterner.
00:09:04 What is it that has Easterners viewing the political landscape 0.96
00:09:09 so differently than Westerners right now?
00:09:12 Besides, you know, the traditional, you know,
00:09:14 there are east-west divides politically.
00:09:16 There have been for over a century.
00:09:19 um but you know there was this moment and i i you know i would talk with conservative
00:09:25 leaning people in calgary here and you know and in the country and you know they'd always say oh 0.61
00:09:31 the eastern bastard's gonna screw us again i'd say you know i'd say well no the polls are pretty 0.96
00:09:36 strongly they they seem to be coming around at least this time to be voting similarly not as 0.99
00:09:43 strongly but similarly to people in alberta and saskatchewan and now they're running back
00:09:48 but Westerners
00:09:51 you know there's a few pockets at Edmonton
00:09:53 where perhaps a few Albertans have moved over
00:09:55 too but
00:09:55 what is it that's got Easterners 1.00
00:09:59 giving the liberals
00:10:01 another chance here the way that
00:10:03 people in Alberta and Saskatchewan
00:10:04 are just not giving them any
00:10:06 well I'm not sure I can
00:10:09 give you a very satisfactory
00:10:11 answer
00:10:13 Derek on this but I can
00:10:15 look at some numbers and say that
00:10:17 We in the East, in Ontario, in Quebec, in the Atlantic provinces, it's not like there's no conservative voters.
00:10:26 But as you very well know, there are many flavors of conservatives.
00:10:30 I mean, Doug Ford just won a third majority in a row in Ontario.
00:10:36 He calls himself a conservative.
00:10:38 Many of his voters call himself.
00:10:40 We don't call him a conservative out here.
00:10:42 Yes, in Ontario, he is considered one.
00:10:45 Yeah, so that's the thing.
00:10:46 And Francois Legault, the premier of Quebec, I mean, he would be, I mean, he's a nationalist
00:10:52 government, but compared to precedents in the province and in eastern Canada, he would be a
00:10:59 moderately PC leader if he wasn't for the CAQ. And of course, New Brunswick just switched red
00:11:06 in the fall, but the PEI and Nova Scotia just swung hard towards the progressive conservatives.
00:11:13 So there are many flavors of conservatives, and the fact that Western-style conservatives has not taken a strong foothold in those provinces, I'm not sure I can explain it.
00:11:27 I guess I'm aware it's a very different kind, very different kinds of flavors of conservatism. Even in Alberta, we've got our factions here. But my question is more towards, you know, why have Eastern conservative voters, at least in some numbers, or swing voters who are considering voting conservative, why are they willing to give the liberals a fourth chance here?
00:11:54 the way that Western conservative voters
00:11:57 are just not even really considering it?
00:12:01 Yeah, that's a good question.
00:12:03 I wish, again, I wish I had a good answer for you.
00:12:05 I'm just looking at the numbers,
00:12:06 but I would say this,
00:12:07 and you may disagree with it,
00:12:08 but there are a lot of voters,
00:12:11 again, that voted for Doug Ford,
00:12:13 that look at Mark Carney
00:12:14 and they see a progressive conservative,
00:12:19 a blue liberal,
00:12:20 a more centrist liberal than, for instance,
00:12:23 which was Justin Trudeau for a decade.
00:12:25 Is that conservative enough for many Westerners?
00:12:29 Probably not.
00:12:30 But Mr. Carney is running to the right of his recent predecessors of his party.
00:12:36 So the goal here is to make a big tent.
00:12:42 That's how you win elections, right?
00:12:43 And then you could say perhaps Mr. Poilievre has not built a tent wide enough.
00:12:50 uh i'm gonna put my theory to you uh okay that it's not there is a bit of policy i mean he's
00:12:58 jettisoned uh at least he says he's jettisoned the consumer carbon tax and then there's capital
00:13:05 gains he's uh and he's dropping some of the more extreme woke language at least in public uh so
00:13:11 you know there is some policy difference at least on the surface between carny liberals and trudeau
00:13:16 liberals. My theory has been more that, uh, he's less annoying than Justin Trudeau. Uh, there's,
00:13:26 there's, there's a term I've used on this show before, uh, a German word, Bechfeifengesicht,
00:13:30 which translates as a punchable face. Uh, you know, just when someone's got an annoying face
00:13:36 and you just don't like them because of the way they look and, you know, that a lot of people,
00:13:42 maybe they want liberalism they like the liberal party but they were just sick of his face is it
00:13:48 that you know eastern and you know bc lower mainland and island voters uh they actually
00:13:54 kind of liked the trudeau government's record and its policies but they just did like trudeau's face
00:14:01 and socks oh well in the last weeks of justin trudeau before he announced his resignation
00:14:08 his personal numbers were atrocious, and they were atrocious throughout the land, from coast to coast.
00:14:15 And those numbers were not coming from one or two firms.
00:14:20 There was a consensus that Monsieur Trudeau's time was done, and I do mean everywhere.
00:14:27 When you look at the personal numbers right now for Mark Carney, he seems to be hitting the right notes.
00:14:35 Again, he was prime minister for what, 10 days before he called the election.
00:14:39 So we do not know really what a Carnet government looks like,
00:14:45 but the early campaign so far and the early vibes and the numbers that we see.
00:14:50 Again, we look at the voting intentions, but you also look at personal numbers.
00:14:55 Monsieur Poiliev had strong numbers, but he was consistently compared with
00:15:00 Justin Trudeau. Now he's compared to the new flavor, the Mr.
00:15:04 Carney, who has, whether you like him or not, he has an impressive resume.
00:15:08 And for a lot of people, it resonates.
00:15:12 So you may have noticed, Derek, that Mr.
00:15:16 Poiliev, so far in the campaign, he's been in a better mood. He's been
00:15:20 smilier. And I'm not saying it's all about this, but
00:15:24 he spent the last two years as an attack dog in the House
00:15:28 commons and that works to a point at some point you have to run for the the role of prime minister
00:15:35 not the role of the uh official opposition leader uh well three months ago uh polyev was measuring
00:15:44 the drapes for the prime minister's office and today or today uh maybe he'd pull off a minority
00:15:50 government but that seems to be as the polls at least as they're locked in today there's a lot
00:15:54 campaign ahead campaigns change things but yeah you'd be lucky to pull off a minority
00:15:59 from the data you've analyzed where has polyev fallen short uh it's not all carny and liberal
00:16:07 magic here there's the other side of the equation where do you think uh polyev has fallen short in
00:16:14 his ability to connect with the times as we're in right now and uh going into april so if we go from
00:16:23 east to west the atlantic canada numbers that we saw in december those were also kind of a sugar
00:16:30 high they were abnormally high poiliev was doing better than at the height of stephen harper's
00:16:35 reign and so we had an idea that historically it would get a little tighter uh in quebec
00:16:43 poiliev has not moved you saw the numbers as i said poiliev and the conservatives have gone down
00:16:48 about seven points in the last two months, but in Quebec he's holding strong and he could win
00:16:54 12 to 15 seats, which is not nothing. But where it hurts the most, it's really Ontario.
00:17:02 When I crunched the numbers at some point, and I know it fluctuates, you know,
00:17:06 polls and projections fluctuate, but at some point I had 100 seats for the federal conservatives
00:17:12 in the province's 122 seats. That may have been a tad high, but even if you have 85 or 90,
00:17:22 that's still a huge tally that would have destroyed the Liberals. And now I have the
00:17:27 Conservatives more around 40 seats, basically identical score to the previous election.
00:17:33 So it's like all this progress that Mr. Poilievre has done since he became leader,
00:17:39 this permanent campaign this advertising campaign that worked so well against justain trudeau all
00:17:45 of this is just we're back to square one for the conservatives now if i was mr poeliev and his team
00:17:53 uh this is where i would put the most efforts and uh and resources because they are swing voters
00:17:59 this is the important thing those voters in the suburbs of toronto in the the gta i know it's a
00:18:04 classic but we'll say those gta there are 30 seats in the gta dog ford just won 28 of them
00:18:12 how come is poelyev projected right now to lose most of those this is where he has to improve
00:18:17 his numbers and if he does then watch out because you take seats directly from the liberal totals
00:18:24 into the conservative column i want to finish as i intended talking about the ndp because no one is
00:18:31 No one's talking about the NDP.
00:18:34 And I guess for fairly good reason, except the only reason to talk about them is what happened to them.
00:18:41 I cannot think of a single announcement.
00:18:45 Oh, no, I was going to say, I can't think of a single announcement that Singh has made this election,
00:18:49 except I do recall he said something about we're going to end corporate grocery stores.
00:18:54 So I'm not sure what he's planning on replacing Sobeys and Safeway with, you know,
00:18:59 some kind of commune vegetable farmer's market i'm not sure but uh i mean really just not landing
00:19:06 yeah uh if you were advising uh sing in the ndp campaign right now what do you think it is they
00:19:13 could do to get themselves i mean not in the race for the win that's yeah obviously wildly out of
00:19:19 the cards but to get them into the race to at least hold on to most of the seats they have right
00:19:24 now? What can they do to get in this race? I would advise them to look at what happened in 1.00
00:19:31 the Ontario election in February, where the NDP vote basically tanked everywhere, except where
00:19:38 there were already NDPs. They have to save the furniture. They have to have local campaigns,
00:19:47 put resources in a dozen or maybe 15 seats and just throw everything at them because the survival of the party is at stake.
00:19:56 They have to reach that 12 seat threshold to have more funding for research and for staff and stuff.
00:20:02 And right now they're short of this total in my projections.
00:20:06 So I would tell Mr. Singh, forget the national campaign or at least some of it.
00:20:12 Do local campaigns because there's a wave coming and it won't look good for you.
00:20:17 i'm going to close on a question i know you're not going to like i'll be surprised if you answer
00:20:25 but i have to try for your best guess and i know uh that you're going to start with an asterisk
00:20:32 saying well the polls are not how people are going to vote it's how they would vote if an
00:20:37 election was held you know within like the three days that the poll was taken i i get that but
00:20:42 there are trends there are indicators and it's not just how people say they're going to vote it's
00:20:46 it's on issues and personalities, things like that. Uh, if, if I put a gun to your head and 0.97
00:20:53 make you answer the question, I know you don't want to answer, what would be your best guess 0.59
00:20:57 based on the trend lines today about how the selection ends? Oh, you're asking me for a
00:21:02 prediction. Oh God. And I'm not going to hold you to it because, uh, I can have a prediction today
00:21:11 and i know there's a very high probability i'll be wrong so i you know you're not getting held to
00:21:16 this okay uh if i were to say anything else than a liberal win i would have to give you strong
00:21:25 reasons if i just go with the data which is what i do and i think that's what my readers expect of
00:21:31 me i will tell you that unless there's a big outside event or a major fumble like a major
00:21:39 fumble, not just somebody misspeaking, but just something major happening. The Liberals are headed
00:21:45 for a fourth win here. What gives me pause is that sometimes the Conservative vote is a bit
00:21:54 underestimated in the polls. I say a bit because usually in Canada, with rare exceptions like
00:22:00 Saskatchewan, we're talking about a point or two. And here a point or two more for the Conservatives
00:22:06 would not save them.
00:22:08 They would have to at least get
00:22:10 well within range of the liberal number
00:22:12 to say maybe we'll get a ballot box bonus.
00:22:17 But with a ballot box bonus
00:22:18 in the right places,
00:22:20 could the conservatives
00:22:21 reduce the liberal to a minority
00:22:23 or have the minority of their own?
00:22:25 It's possible.
00:22:27 But that's as far as I go.
00:22:28 If right now you're asking me
00:22:31 for what the landslide blue sky
00:22:34 with the data,
00:22:35 I'm going to say a liberal win.
00:22:36 you know that was a very good answer for a very difficult question that
00:22:42 thank you people would be very afraid of having thrown back at them uh i appreciate that uh mr
00:22:48 fournier thank you very much for uh joining today uh i appreciate your perspective and analysis i
00:22:53 hope we can call on you again at some point absolutely and thanks for this i appreciate
00:22:58 have a great campaign yeah oh and uh before i let you go where can uh people find you
00:23:02 338canada.com is the website where all the numbers 338canada.ca is my newsletter if you're
00:23:11 so inclined to uh to uh subscribe right and i strongly recommend people do this is uh
00:23:18 anything i'm saying is largely just doing my best impression of uh what miss uh monsieur fournier
00:23:23 does he uh he he knows his stuff a lot better than any of the talking heads like me uh thank
00:23:28 you very much for joining us today. Thank you. Merci beaucoup. All right. The sponsor of today's
00:23:34 show is New World Precious Metals, based right here in Alberta. Years of inflationary money
00:23:40 printing and rising debt have decimated the average Canadian savings. Gold and silver are
00:23:45 the only currencies that have held their value for thousands of years. Last year saw 30% gains.
00:23:51 New World Precious Metals offers unique platforms to help protect and grow your hard-earned wealth
00:23:56 with silver and gold.
00:23:57 Check them out at newworldpm.com.
00:24:00 They're just a great sponsor of the Western Standard.
00:24:03 They're going to do great work for you.
00:24:04 And by doing business with them,
00:24:05 you're helping support your favorite shows
00:24:08 and writing on the Western Standard.
00:24:10 Remember, if you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
00:24:12 go to westernstandard.news, click on subscribe.
00:24:15 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year
00:24:17 for unlimited access past the paywall for all our content.
00:24:21 Thank you very much for joining us today.
00:24:23 And God bless.
00:24:24 what does success mean to you peace of mind financial freedom generational wealth what do
00:24:31 you see in your future investing in gold and silver can help you get there through our trading
00:24:36 partners new world precious metals offers safe affordable secure international accounts to help
00:24:42 you meet your unique financial goals connect with one of our experienced team members invest in gold
00:24:49 and silver today
00:24:54 Music