Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan join me to talk about a bunch of stuff, including: - Justin Trudeau's climate change plan - Alberta's new anti-pipeline legislation - The Other Randy - Randy Boisoneau s scandal - A $20 glass of orange juice - And much, much more!
00:00:21.500Yeah. Oh, man. So much good stuff. So much good stuff.
00:00:24.980We're going to talk. Justin Trudeau says, I did not believe this at first.
00:00:31.960You guys were with me. We actually had to check the transcript. Didn't believe it.
00:00:36.060I saw our own headline. I was like, has one of our reporters tweaked things?
00:00:39.280No, they did not. He says the families should prioritize climate change, the fight against climate change over food and rent for your family.
00:00:50.440I didn't even believe our own reporter. I said, who did that?
00:00:53.240They're torquing the headlines. That's clickbaity.
00:00:56.740Nope, it wasn't. My God. We're going to talk about it.
00:01:00.160Alberta NDP leader, Nahid Nanchi, has asked the UCP to please give him a seat.
00:01:08.740The Alberta NDP leader does not appear to be able to convince a member of his caucus in a safe seat to step aside to trigger a by-election for him to get in and become the leader of the opposition in the legislature.
00:01:24.680So instead, he said that the UCP, the UCP cabinet minister should resign so he can run.
00:04:31.300But Mr. Randy Boisano is as white as pure Colombian cocaine.
00:04:36.480Speaking of white, pure Colombian cocaine, it now seems that his company has had at least some role to play in some major cocaine smuggling operations.
00:05:55.280Each one of these was a clearly fireable or resignable offense.
00:06:00.360What took so long before they saw the inevitable here?
00:06:03.700You know, I think if the Liberals had been a strong majority government and he had the room to just turf somebody and absorb it and move on, they would have.
00:07:15.960But if somebody is, if a serving politician is accused of something like this, then the appropriate thing is, yes, you step out of cabinet and you resolve it.
00:07:26.180And some people have, I can't think of one, but some people, I can't think of a liberal anyway, who has actually successfully defended themselves against charges of fraud.
00:07:36.080But maybe he will, and so you don't actually tie concrete blocks to his feet and drop him over the side.
00:07:44.760You just say, well, you've got some business to attend to, sir.
00:07:48.720Go attend to it and let us know when you're in the clear.
00:07:53.380The thing that I, you can't help, as Corey was talking about, it was just yesterday.
00:08:01.140But the prime minister was reported as saying, I have every confidence in Randy.
00:09:40.480They didn't think it was funny enough to get him off the, out of cabinet at that point.
00:09:45.960So, obviously, the standard for hiring is pretty low.
00:09:50.540Well, I mean, they went by the honor system, though.
00:09:53.040I mean, you can't expect a liberal government to say, okay, anybody applying or saying they're indigenous, you know, we're going to make you submit to a DNA test.
00:10:53.320So, no one looking at a, no one sitting in the liberal website design desk said, you know, took a look at his picture and said, this guy's indigenous.
00:11:01.760Where did they, someone had to tell them.
00:11:04.540Who would have possibly said, this man's indigenous?
00:11:07.240It obviously has to come from him, so he was making the pretendian claim.
00:11:11.020Um, yeah, he's, he's claiming this was all just some accident.
00:11:26.400And then, his business is registered as wholly indigenous.
00:11:31.520Uh, I've never bid for federal contracts, but I, I've had to go through some dumb paperwork.
00:11:38.040Uh, when we applied for, um, the federal government's media license, uh, as a joke to see if we could get it, I, I had to answer, uh, what percentage of the company was indigenous.
00:11:49.380Uh, I don't think it was any, but I, I certainly didn't list myself as indigenous.
00:11:58.020So, he has told the liberal party at some point, uh, by the, by simple logical deduction here, he's told the liberal party he was indigenous for at least some time before that was quietly changed.
00:12:08.540And he told federal bureaucrats for his company bidding on federal contracts, which he's not supposed to have anything to do with when you're a federal cabinet minister.
00:12:18.380This guy is like, he's a, he's a classic pretendian.
00:12:23.740Well, and you know, the, uh, the thing is the story kept changing.
00:12:27.460Uh, originally he was indigenous and then when he was put on the spot, he said, well, actually I'm sort of an adoptive Cree and the adoption came from my grandmother.
00:12:40.080Now, I don't know what the rules say about indigenous companies and whether you can be adopted into the, into the tribe and claim to be indigenous for the purposes of getting a government grant.
00:12:56.660Maybe that's allowed, but that was the, that was, that was the shtick.
00:13:00.900And then there was another examination of him by, uh, uh, more serious, um, uh, indigenous person who I think is connected to the program.
00:13:10.940And although he had more political savvy than to come out and say, this guy is just putting us all on, it made it very clear that, uh, clear to me anyway, that the adoptive side of the story didn't really hold up.
00:13:25.600Well, it indicates kind of a bigger problem too.
00:13:28.780It's almost, you know, fodder for a different discussion, but a lot of government programs, hires and so on, they're desperate to bring in as many indigenous companies as they can.
00:13:37.660They have to say, see, look at all of these indigenous companies that are doing well, thanks to our government programs.
00:13:42.700And unfortunately, uh, there's a lot of socioeconomic challenges for indigenous people and indigenous companies.
00:13:49.740And there's just a shortage of a pool of good qualified ones to fill those roles.
00:13:55.420So when a government office sees one that looks like it's got its stuff together and will fill the role, they tend to grab them pretty quickly without a lot of scrutiny.
00:19:33.000So, zoom in a bit more local into Alberta here.
00:19:38.660Alberta NDP leader Nahid Menchi is still not yet the leader of the opposition.
00:19:44.480Now, when someone becomes the leader of a political party that forms the government, they instantly become the premier as soon as this one.
00:19:52.560They get sworn in as premier right away.
00:19:53.800The constitutional convention is that they have to seek a seat in the legislature at a reasonably earliest available opportunity.
00:20:03.760That means either immediately calling a general election or triggering some by-elections.
00:20:07.900You know, a lot of people remember Jim Prentice became PC leader.
00:20:10.720He was sworn in right after as the premier.
00:20:13.760And then he triggered a series of by-elections that had a whole other – with ripple effects that we're still feeling today.
00:20:22.800The rules are different for an opposition party leader.
00:20:25.400You can be the leader of an opposition party, but you're not yet the leader of the opposition in the legislature until you have a seat in the legislature.
00:20:33.220So Nahid Menchi's not breaking any constitutional convention here, perhaps breaking political convention.
00:20:39.580I mean, if it's a small party without a bunch of seats to trigger a by-elections, there's not really a huge expectation.
00:20:44.760You know, if you have four seats, you might not trigger a by-elections.
00:20:51.800They're a pretty big opposition party caucus.
00:20:54.360They got a lot of MLAs in Calgary, a lot in Edmonton.
00:20:58.640And yet it appears not a single one of them is willing to resign to let them in.
00:21:04.620I would have thought at least maybe Rachel Notley, you know.
00:21:07.780Like, she's got the safest NDP seat in Alberta, Edmonton, Strathcona, right in the dead center of Edmonton, full of hipsters and weird folks there, bureaucrats, things like that.
00:21:20.740But he hasn't been able to trigger a by-election.
00:21:22.460And there's a by-election happening right now in Lethbridge in a relatively reliable NDP seat.
00:21:28.640Well, we can pass that off saying, oh, okay, he's a big city guy.
00:21:39.220So then I think, maybe a mistake, but I think this is in response to a question from Western Standard reporter Jonathan Bradley, asking him,
00:21:48.020are you going to get a seat anytime soon?
00:21:50.020I told him, ask him every time you see him.
00:22:26.320But this strikes me, Corey, as a classic kind of ninchy arrogance that, you know, the government should just, you know, plow the way for him to get into the legislature.
00:22:40.580One of his people shouldn't have to resign, as we've done for, I don't know, 400 years of Westminster tradition.
00:22:46.400Well, I think some of it, too, is that it is getting under his skin.
00:22:49.420You know, Jonathan asked the question he really didn't want to touch.
00:22:51.900It's already a weak position to be in.
00:22:53.580It's almost, you know, a little humiliating.
00:22:55.540You're standing in the atrium begging for coverage.
00:22:57.280You're down there when you should be getting those quotes in the legislature and hammering on things.
00:23:02.620So, I think he tried for something he thought would be one of those quotable things.
00:23:12.660And I think it's an indication, though, of just how much it is actually bugging him when it got to his composure rather than giving a good answer on it.
00:23:20.040Well, I guess it was a quotable moment.
00:23:28.880I mean, anybody who is not following politics closely and who stumbles across this is going to say, well, that's kind of a dumb thing to say.
00:23:38.640Why on earth would the government ask one of their people to step aside so the opposition leader can come in?
00:29:26.940You know, to be honest, Derek, I would have thought that he was at that point now, or maybe last month, when, if you haven't already got yourself into the legislature, people have got to seriously ask, well, what's the matter with you?
00:29:42.420Well, it's a curious thing that there is not one of those NDP MLAs who has got enough dedication to the party to actually say, well, I will give up my seat so that you can run, sir.
00:30:02.500And the only thing that I think permits him to get away with it is that eyes are so focused on Daniel Smith and on what the government is doing.
00:30:13.620And it has been doing a lot that nobody is really paying very much attention to the NDP if they were paying more.
00:30:20.820Like, if the NDP mattered more, then the fact that he's still outside the legislature would matter more.
00:30:26.380So the answer to your question is, yes, I think he's actually passed the point, but he can probably get away with it for another six months.
00:32:04.120So I'm starting to wonder, like, yes, this is unusual.
00:32:07.840This is showing signs that, you know, he may have won the party membership over, but perhaps the caucus is probably not going to revolt against them.
00:32:15.340But no one's putting their hand up to take one for the team.
00:32:26.880I think he's got to get at least one year in there before the next election.
00:32:30.680I mean, this would be hard on him to continue outside of it, but he could get through it.
00:32:35.180He did get a strong mandate from members.
00:32:37.520They aren't the types of caucuses that tend to revolt, even if they don't seem to support him enough to want to have anybody fall on the sword for him.
00:32:44.640But he's going to need one year in that legislature.
00:32:47.740People still want to see him holding Premier Smith to account.
00:33:41.180It wouldn't have been an issue if he said, I want a Calgary seat.
00:33:44.500But he said he wants a Calgary or Edmonton seat.
00:33:47.020This is what he said because of why he's not running in Lethbridge West.
00:33:49.300And I think among the new Democrats, even among some conservatives, there's a bit of snobbishness that senior ministers, leader of the party, they have a Calgary or an Edmonton seat.
00:34:01.600They're a bit more prestigious than having something way out in the sticks in Lethbridge.
00:34:06.120I mean, it's surrounded by blue, for God's sakes.
00:34:08.480You know, it's a little orange island.
00:37:10.200And Trudeau, speaking at a global citizen conference at the G20 summit in Brazil, touted his government's carbon tax and said more countries need to take climate change more seriously.
00:37:26.100It's really, really easy to say, okay, let's put climate change as a slightly lower priority when families are worried about how to pay the rent this month and how to buy groceries for the kids.
00:37:42.100Said Trudeau, we can't do that around climate change.
00:37:47.040So, don't pay the rent, just suck up the extra cost that is incurred by this wretched carbon tax and every other government policy that has contributed to inflation and a rapidly rising cost of living.
00:38:06.140Easy to say when you're born into wealth and privilege that the government pays for your housing and the government pays for all of your food and your family's food.
00:38:17.040Nigel, I don't think he just hears himself sometimes.
00:38:22.760He's just living on another planet from the average Canadian who does have to worry about paying rent or your mortgage, who does have to worry about putting food on the table, who's actually had to work in a job outside of government at some point in their life.
00:38:37.340No, I think when he got back to Ottawa, there might have been a couple of people within the prime minister's office who said, sir, did you really have to say that?
00:38:45.260I don't know if anybody says that to him anymore.
00:38:49.920I wouldn't be an elected member, but some of the senior heads with whom he does must confer from time to time about strategy.
00:38:58.640Well, that wasn't really a winning comment.
00:39:00.820We can play it down, but, you know, you can bet that that's going to be like both bad budgets that balance themselves.
00:39:08.080And not worrying yourself about monetary policy has got to come back, sir.
00:39:13.120You know, Corey, this, I try, no matter how crazy and out there someone sounds, I try to try to get in their head, however scary a place that is.
00:39:23.780I try to understand why he would say something like this.
00:39:27.920And what makes sense to me is that among, you know, the urban, like kind of Laurentian progressive elite, climate change, global warming is the most important thing in the world.
00:39:42.940That it is on par with, you know, fighting a world war for your very survival as a nation, as a people.
00:39:52.500If you lose that, you will cease to exist.
00:39:55.200And from that perspective, if you truly believe that, you know, this is that level of danger and crisis, then he's actually quite reasonable.
00:40:05.520I mean, in wartime, extreme wars, we ration food, we have wages and price controls.
00:40:13.400So, I mean, from that perspective, it's actually an entirely reasonable situation if the world will end if we don't, you know, have carbon tax.
00:40:21.620I think there's ideology of that with him believing that there's climate change, but I think it's more selfish than that when it gets down to the basis of it.
00:40:28.760That he wants his legacy, though, to be the one who held off, staved off climate change through his initiatives, through the carbon tax.
00:40:35.580And he is kind of realizing that people are rejecting it.
00:41:32.000I said only a person who never really has to, has lost sleep wondering how to pay the rent or, you know, how you're going to get better clothes for the kids for the school year or build a car up to get to work.
00:41:43.800He's never had to deal with any of that.
00:41:45.820So it's pretty easy to flippantly say, this is the sort of thing you can stop worrying about because climate change is a bigger deal.
00:41:51.040Well, it's, he's just disconnected from reality.
00:43:09.980Well, to get in on the Trudeau pile on with insanity, North Volt, some people might remember it.
00:43:14.760They announced a great fanfare that it was going to invest in Quebec and build a big battery plant and employ thousands of Quebecers and bring the EV revolution.
00:45:44.960All right, gentlemen, thank you much, very much for joining on the pipeline today.
00:45:50.240And thank all of you for, for joining us here on the pipeline.
00:45:53.380Remember, the Western Centre is one of the very last independent media left in Canada that refused to take Justin Trudeau's big federal media government bailout.
00:46:03.320We don't take tax dollars to fund what we're doing, and we're one of the very few left who don't.
00:46:09.300That means we need your support to continue to produce what we do to produce independent and fearless news for Westerners.
00:46:17.980If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, please go to westernstandard.news right now.