Western Standard - July 15, 2021


Mountain Standard Time - July 14, 2021

Topics
Guests
Mentioned
Mountain Standard Time - July 13th, 2021 Mountain Standard Time - July 15, 2021

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 49 minutes

Words per minute

150.69

Word count

16,523

Sentence count

516

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

15

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Dr. Grant Havers, the Chair of the Philosophy Department at Trinity Western University, joins me to talk about conservatism in Canada, the upcoming federal election, and the future of the Conservative Party of Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Good morning, and welcome to Mountain Standard Time.
00:02:46 I'm your host, Nathan Gita, and of course, today I'll be joined by Dr. Grant Havers,
00:02:51 who's the chair of the Philosophy Department of the Trinity Western University, my alma mater.
00:02:56 And, of course, he'll be talking to us about conservatism in Canada
00:02:59 and the prospective results of the upcoming federal election
00:03:03 and what does it all look like.
00:03:05 Be sure to like us on Facebook, follow us on YouTube,
00:03:08 and take out a subscription online at The Western Standard,
00:03:11 especially if you wish to continue supporting the free voice of the West.
00:03:14 We don't take government money, neither should you.
00:03:17 As I have stated many times since I began broadcasting for The Western Standard,
00:03:22 There ought to be no divorce in understanding between you, yourselves, the viewers, and myself, the man on the TV.
00:03:30 I am not worthy of your unconditional affection, and I must tell the truth as much as possible.
00:03:35 When I get a piece of information, my job is to share it, not lord it over you, or use it to look important.
00:03:41 I have been in media for a few years now.
00:03:44 I've got some friends who work in politics, and they've worked there for about the same amount of time, if not longer.
00:03:49 Occasionally they tell me things, and sometimes those things turn out to be accurate.
00:03:52 As it stands, at least one trusted source has told me that he figures the Conservative Party might very well fall below 60 seats federally in the upcoming election, due to both vote splitting and people not voting.
00:04:05 In the event of such a fall from grace, it will either spell doom for the Tory party with a rebirth of sectional regional parties, or a final revitalization of the party from within, complete renewal from the ground up.
00:04:16 I'm hopeful of the latter, as I do believe in a single federal right-wing party, if only it would learn to stick to its principles, even in times of crisis.
00:04:25 But there is another theory for what could happen to conserves in this country, and it is best represented by the sovereignty that we have within our midst here at The Standard and a few other places, namely that the time has come to elect sectional or regional parties to better represent our interests.
00:04:43 This was a point raised by Stuart Parker last week, and I would like to dwell on it for a short while.
00:04:48 As I've stated before, I am ambivalent about sovereignty.
00:04:54 Essentially, I'm a Diefenbaker Federalist, waiting for the Pearson-Trudeau consensus that ruined this nation to come to an end.
00:05:01 But there might be an alternative way forward beyond my own insane idea of using the Church's boundaries for new provincial lines,
00:05:08 which would create more than 40 provinces with metropolitan areas entirely separate.
00:05:14 As an aside, if you're looking for a kind of crazy map of Canada that Nathan could probably endorse,
00:05:22 you would look at, just punch into Google, Catholic diocese map.
00:05:28 Maybe the other diocese maps would work too.
00:05:30 But the point is they cut up the provinces we already have.
00:05:33 And some of the borders actually go across provinces.
00:05:35 most pointedly, and in my opinion, most appropriately, Churchill-Hudson Bay, which includes
00:05:41 all of Nunavut, and of course, Churchill-Manitoba, which identifies much more strongly with the
00:05:48 rest of Northern Canada and not even with Thompson or the rest of Manitoba, even Northern
00:05:53 Manitoba. It feels quite isolated. And I feel like that's the kind of thing we need. We need to have
00:05:58 our provinces recut into sensible shapes and sizes and regions that actually represent the people
00:06:04 that are in them. And then those could be their own little
00:06:06 provincial governments. But that's a different
00:06:08 discussion for another time.
00:06:11 Maybe it is time for Canada
00:06:12 to finally become like Switzerland, though.
00:06:14 A group of cantankerous cantons that
00:06:16 come together in a loosely federated empire
00:06:18 capable of vetoing anything beyond
00:06:20 basic infrastructure. Someone might
00:06:22 say that sounds like a lot of redundant government, but
00:06:24 I say it's a way forward to freedom.
00:06:27 And whether you're going to do it with ten provinces
00:06:29 and three territories, or you're going to do it
00:06:31 with a huge amount
00:06:32 of provinces
00:06:34 that are newly created through the system I just proposed,
00:06:38 all I'm saying is that what we have right now isn't working.
00:06:43 And if that couldn't be more clear,
00:06:46 I think that the last couple of, well, probably decades for that matter,
00:06:50 but certainly the last couple of years have proven to us
00:06:53 that the federal government will run pretty roughshod over provinces
00:06:56 indiscriminately, save Quebec,
00:07:00 and doesn't really care what you think of it.
00:07:04 And our federal government doesn't represent us at a local level. It just has its agenda and it's interested in getting its way.
00:07:13 What's going on with the upcoming federal election when it comes to the Tories is it's dangerous. It's very dangerous because we need a right wing party in this country.
00:07:22 We need somebody to oppose that consensus of liberalism that's been ever growing and ever more manifested and ever stronger since since after Laurier and especially after after King, who kind of perfected the liberal dominance of this country and and since then has just never really waned.
00:07:45 It's always waxed. Very briefly, they fell to third place against Stephen Harper's Conservatives.
00:07:51 It looked like Canada might have a new way forward.
00:07:54 You had the NDP. Tom Mulcair was a great opposition leader.
00:07:58 I think he did a great job of articulating his positions against Stephen Harper.
00:08:02 Certainly much better than the various leaders, interim leaders of the, well, the leaders they tried to put forward in the Liberal Party.
00:08:09 probably the best leader they had for the interim
00:08:14 was Bob Ray
00:08:15 he was very articulate, he had been a parliamentarian a long time
00:08:19 he knew how to do his job and he was distinguished
00:08:22 he had been I believe the Premier of Ontario
00:08:25 and so there we were
00:08:29 we had this brief moment
00:08:33 where not only the Conservatives were dominant
00:08:35 but the Conservatives were capable of reducing the Liberals
00:08:39 to third place but we haven't returned to that moment since and i i don't there's various theories
00:08:44 for why but in the end all that matters is that we can't i mean we can't rely on the liberals to
00:08:52 trip themselves up and if we don't have a solid right-wing party with right-wing principles that
00:08:56 campaigns like conservatives not just like liberal light we are in big trouble i am being
00:09:01 reminded by my producer that it is time for our resistance coffee endorsement resistance coffee
00:09:06 noted the other day that it was a little bit late in the hour when i finally gave them their
00:09:11 endorsement and that was just because i had let that slip that's on me but we're back so resistance
00:09:18 coffee company is based in waver in saskatchewan of course they are a local roaster they bring
00:09:24 their beans and they roast them locally inside of waver and what's fun about the the resistance
00:09:29 coffee company is that they choose to use their if if they have a little bit on the side if they
00:09:36 have a little bit extra and people are talking about a specific cause that would further their
00:09:40 freedoms instead of curtail them so whatever's not woke these days and more about personal freedom
00:09:46 liberty and autonomy they help those causes so whenever you think of a coffee company that you
00:09:53 would like to support because we all love coffee we all love drinking coffee but the problem of
00:09:58 course is that a lot of coffee companies unfortunately are run by the same kind of
00:10:01 people who would take your freedoms away so that's not fun but luckily we have of course
00:10:06 the coffee company wayburn saskatchewan resistance coffee do be sure to grab as much of their coffee
00:10:12 as you can and use our promo code 10 off your first order use western standard for the promo
00:10:18 code all righty so back to where we're at with things so
00:10:24 the upcoming federal election what's going to happen i i mean i've been talking about this a
00:10:32 little bit for a few days now viva la resistance thanks john appreciate that uh john you're a gem
00:10:40 uh i've been talking about this a little bit and what's what it's coming down to of course is that
00:10:45 the tories are completely divided and they're all over the place and they can't seem to get
00:10:51 a solid footing on what they're going to fight the election on. 1.00
00:10:55 Now, back in the day, we used to say, it's the economy, stupid. 0.99
00:10:59 And that was actually a Democrat who came up with that one, who carried his home state 0.99
00:11:02 of Arkansas, which is now a solid red state. 1.00
00:11:08 But we said back in the day, right, it's, you know, it's the economy, stupid, right? 0.98
00:11:15 And I have to admit that in our own time, we've kind of gotten away from economic arguments. 0.97
00:11:20 everything becomes about social arguments and social issues and social justice issues and so
00:11:26 is it about you know is it about transgenderism or is it about parents and their children in the
00:11:31 school system or is it about whether just freedom or is it about the right to feel safe is it trigger
00:11:36 warnings and safe spaces it's it's all over the place there's cruelty to animals it's all over
00:11:41 the place and of course climate change so so in a way the last thing we talk about anymore
00:11:48 is economic issues, but in the end, those are still what determine every other issue, right?
00:11:53 I don't care how rich or poor you are, well, in the sense that if you, you know, it doesn't feel
00:11:59 good to be bullied, whether you're rich or poor, it doesn't feel good to have something bad happen
00:12:06 to you in a social sense. But in the end, you know, if you have enough economic leverage on
00:12:11 your own half, you got enough capital or enough opportunity, economically speaking, you can go
00:12:16 make your way in the world, right? You can't. And so that's what we've kind of based a lot of
00:12:22 especially English speaking government on is the idea that if you give people economic opportunity,
00:12:27 then they can really chart their own course in the world. And that's not a weak argument. That's
00:12:34 a great argument. But the problem becomes that if you're not going to articulate that argument ever
00:12:39 and keep it at the forefront, because you have to shape the narrative. So what's happened since
00:12:45 liberalism kind of took over and i don't mean the liberalism of yesteryear which was also very
00:12:50 economically based particularly particularly according those economic freedoms to people
00:12:54 who didn't have them minorities women the disenfranchised the recent immigrants uh the 0.97
00:13:01 the underclass so so you know second and third wave liberalism were were about those things and
00:13:07 i appreciate that i think that's right and just we need all groups of people regardless of class
00:13:13 create a background to have economic opportunity that's not a question discrimination based on
00:13:18 immutable characteristics that do not necessarily determine your outright character are not are not
00:13:24 fair bar none no argument from me but where we've gone wrong is we've kind of reversed it into of
00:13:32 course a new discrimination right all based on immutable characteristics where we don't let
00:13:36 certain groups of people study together anymore we don't let certain groups of people use the
00:13:40 same computer lab we put other groups of people into easier testing systems there's funding just
00:13:47 because of your particular skin color that's all that's all gone way overboard to the point where 1.00
00:13:52 of course we now denigrate whatever the majority population is or at least the most significant
00:13:56 minority the largest minority population is and that's and that's also a problem it's beyond a 1.00
00:14:01 problem that's that's evil it's wicked and it's evil and you have to shape the narrative so what
00:14:07 has happened is leftism, progressivism,
00:14:09 liberalism, however you want to call it, but it's not really
00:14:11 liberal anymore, because of course, the literal
00:14:13 translation of the word liberal
00:14:15 is free, right? Libra
00:14:17 is freedom, right?
00:14:19 In Latin,
00:14:21 I want to say. Econo is a
00:14:23 Greek word, meaning
00:14:24 oikos, I think, from 0.99
00:14:26 household. But
00:14:29 so, liberals
00:14:31 aren't liberals anymore, right? Or in the sense,
00:14:33 at least most people who think of themselves as a liberal,
00:14:35 they're actually a leftist, a progressive,
00:14:36 and a person who's kind of not always fascistically so,
00:14:42 but often using methods that are not democratic or free.
00:14:48 They are forceful and coercive.
00:14:51 And what's happened is conservatives have given away the argument.
00:14:54 They've given away our universities.
00:14:55 They've given away our schools.
00:14:56 They've given away a lot of workspace too, right?
00:15:00 Business used to be about business.
00:15:02 One thing that I will say,
00:15:04 I remember reading that blog some time ago.
00:15:06 And, um, it was a blog about what was, what it was actually about the young Pope, but then it referenced back to Mad Men. And then it referenced back to kind of why, like why sometimes artists get it better than the people practicing the faith, how this stuff works. Like the business of the Catholic church is the business of Catholic church, you know, as Calvin Coolidge might've put it. And the same thing when it comes to the question of Mad Men and that era, it's like business was about business.
00:15:30 it was not about team meetings and what's the next garbage cleanup thing we can do and look at
00:15:35 this motivational poster on the wall and isn't it just so wonderful to have this office space where
00:15:39 we're all coming together and doing these things and we're having solidarity together with these
00:15:43 things no it wasn't about those things yeah it's about making money it was about making money and
00:15:48 it's about doing business right that was what it was about and and it's actually been a bit of a
00:15:54 mind-boggling thing as I bump into people who genuinely think that work is about having fun
00:15:58 and I'm like I don't really know what you're talking about
00:16:00 like work is for work that doesn't mean
00:16:02 that you're not supposed to have a decent relationship with the people
00:16:04 around your work that's not my argument whatsoever
00:16:06 but it's just kind of mind boggling that
00:16:08 anybody thinks that work is beyond that
00:16:10 it's like
00:16:11 no it's not about
00:16:13 you know recycle day or united
00:16:16 way or any of this other nonsense
00:16:17 it's about it's about work
00:16:20 productivity you're not
00:16:22 producing you're not working you're not
00:16:24 I don't really know why you're here
00:16:26 doesn't mean like being like a
00:16:28 slave doesn't mean that you don't have your coffee breaks and you're entitled you're entitled to
00:16:31 your entitlements uh but it's but work is about work and so just as work has stopped being about
00:16:36 work just as politics has stopped being about anything political it's now about social personal
00:16:41 questions questions of privacy like i mean we used to say that the government had no business
00:16:46 knowing whether or not you were a homosexual or whatever now the government does nothing but
00:16:51 explain that only being you know non-normative in certain respects is the best thing you can be
00:16:58 that's essentially what's being telegraphed certainly so it's being telegraphed with
00:17:01 government money through non-profits all over the place with the posters on the wall
00:17:05 and and so the great irony is that we we we have just completely flipped everything on its head
00:17:14 which of course was always a sign of the diabolical if you ask you know saint thomas aquinas but
00:17:19 deeper than that it's a fundamental question it's like do you want things to work if you
00:17:23 were going to just be a materialist right do you want things to work are you going to be a pragmatist
00:17:27 and and do you want just things you want two and two to equal four you want to know when you cross
00:17:32 a bridge that it functions do you want to know when you go under for surgery you are going to
00:17:36 be opened up and and taken care of you care about competence you care about pragmatism you care about
00:17:42 functionality right and that is also being lost because it's funny because functionality used to
00:17:49 be again another big word of the left where it's like well it's dysfunctional to let the private
00:17:54 sector do this it's dysfunctional to leave this in the hands of families that might be abusive
00:17:58 it's dysfunctional to leave this in the hands of the church it can't be trusted its values can't
00:18:03 be checked that was their argument well we're we're here now we're here now where they dominate
00:18:10 their their big state tactics dominate everything and they shape the narrative tell me if you think
00:18:15 it's any more functional i don't i think we pay more money for worse results it doesn't mean there's
00:18:20 no place for a public sector but it does fundamentally mean in my humble opinion that
00:18:25 that ironically whether it was abusive before or not at least we were paying less for it maybe you
00:18:31 should have improved on the abuse not just up the cost and created about the same amount of problems
00:18:35 you know more children are apprehended today than were ever apprehended during the residential
00:18:40 schools the same is true of a whole host of other issues if you think that the records of the
00:18:44 residential schools are being kept under lock and key to avoid prosecution wait until you go to your
00:18:50 local school board wait until you go to every school board in canada that's how it is go to
00:18:55 the hospital go to the grievance go go talk to some shop stewards and give them a you know give
00:18:59 them a drink or two fate you know fuzz out their face give them a voice modulator and turn on the
00:19:03 camera and let them tell you the various things that they've had to kind of keep under the wraps
00:19:08 people are sinners we're human beings we're fallen creatures that's how it is
00:19:12 and at a certain level in a more i would say conservative time but certainly in a time of
00:19:17 more limited government. People understood that, and they understood there was no way in heaven or
00:19:23 hell for government to be our perfecting cause, our perfecting instrument. That was never going
00:19:30 to happen. Government's job was to keep the lights on, to keep the roads paved, etc.
00:19:37 But the problem is, the problem is that everything has become about not the thing that matters.
00:19:44 canada cannot survive with the debt load it's carrying from covet it can't i will never make
00:19:52 enough money to pay that back i am part of a generation of ever ever shrinking opportunities
00:19:59 unless we do something drastic when it comes to our red tape and start a lot of infrastructure
00:20:04 real quick and the generation after mine there are people my age who have children right my
00:20:09 brother's one of them he's a year younger than me he's got kids what do you think those kids are
00:20:12 going to do for a living where is the money going to come from to pay back the debt and and that's
00:20:20 a reality that's a reality my my nephew who is not even five years old owes the government what
00:20:27 30 40 50 000 he hasn't even earned a penny yet he's being subsidized he's got a child benefit
00:20:34 that's going to his parents he doesn't he doesn't earn an income yet and he's already 50 000 in debt
00:20:40 or whatever it is, thanks to the trillion we're at
00:20:43 or whatever we're at, it's nonsense.
00:20:45 Like this can't go on, like that can't go on,
00:20:47 especially if there's shrinking opportunities
00:20:49 and we aren't thinking about
00:20:50 how we're going to build an economy that is equitable,
00:20:53 that ensures that everybody has a family living wage
00:20:56 so that they can continue to keep
00:20:58 the economic system running.
00:21:00 The economy is an entirely man-made object.
00:21:02 You think that we would be able to figure it out.
00:21:05 It's not rocket science.
00:21:06 You can't have cheap money, creates booms and busts.
00:21:09 You can't have people who can foreign speculate and come in and just buy up all the property that other people are entitled to because they were born here.
00:21:17 They took care of it.
00:21:18 They mowed the lawns.
00:21:19 They did all the work on it, but they can't afford the property in their own backyard.
00:21:23 That's not okay.
00:21:26 You know, you have to build a better country than that.
00:21:28 And that's the only thing, again, when I talk about sovereignty, that's kind of where I stand with it,
00:21:33 is that it's like I would get more on side with sovereignty
00:21:37 if I knew that's what its ultimate goal was,
00:21:40 which was building a better country,
00:21:43 not just cutting out a piece of the country we're currently in
00:21:46 and having the same amount of problems.
00:21:48 I don't think that's the way forward.
00:21:50 But if you're telling me that there could be a better way forward
00:21:52 and a new social contract, I could be amenable to that.
00:21:56 And again, though I am a son of privilege
00:21:59 and I wasn't raised around a lot of the status First Nations issues
00:22:03 and non-status and Métis and all the other issues
00:22:05 that can come up through that, Inuit.
00:22:08 I guess what I'm
00:22:09 trying to say there, a lot of issues
00:22:11 that face First Nations people, especially on reserve 0.66
00:22:13 and in poverty and in squalor and all sorts of
00:22:15 stuff. I still think
00:22:17 that in a sense, their group
00:22:18 mentality around
00:22:20 belonging and ownership
00:22:22 has some validity, especially
00:22:24 if it at least is the last counter
00:22:26 to some foreign
00:22:29 power having complete dominance
00:22:30 over us and that took me a long time to understand i used to be bar more libertarian and free market
00:22:35 on this but as i kind of watched over and over again as as foreign foreign interests influenced
00:22:41 our world negatively while they just were laughing all the way to their next scrooge mcduck
00:22:46 money bolt they like they don't care so some semblance of common good the common wealth which
00:22:54 is a part of our british heritage needs to be accrued it has to happen or else we're
00:23:00 in deep trouble. And that links us all the way back to the question of Toryism.
00:23:07 Toryism always had
00:23:10 a question of how do we protect
00:23:14 the common good, the common wheel. We say common wealth
00:23:18 now, but common wheel, very medieval term, the idea of there being
00:23:23 this kind of common existence altogether.
00:23:27 And we all live that. And in a certain sense, the last
00:23:30 ones who are kind of defending that to a point don't agree with them on a lot of their principles
00:23:35 is of course the uh the greens not not the greens in particular but i mean anybody who's
00:23:43 very very environmentally minded because a lot of their arguments are common based the idea of
00:23:50 the commons we all breathe the same air we all drink the same water we should probably try and
00:23:54 preserve that for future generations we need to do something about you know these issues i again
00:24:00 don't agree with their methodology and i don't agree with their assessment that that that climate
00:24:04 change is man caused um i don't agree with that at least not in its entirety i have a lot of
00:24:10 caveats around that but i do agree and the reason i have people of that ilk on on the show is that i
00:24:16 like to hear somebody articulate the idea of the common the commonwealth and and common good
00:24:24 because we conservatives have a really hard time doing that anymore which is ironic because that
00:24:29 used to be the thing that was about
00:24:31 conservatives. It was the liberals who were chomping
00:24:33 at the bit to rip up everything,
00:24:35 to put people in enclosures, to take up
00:24:37 all the land and make it more efficient
00:24:39 and just exploit everybody
00:24:41 and exploit. It's called Manchester
00:24:43 liberalism, right? It was ripping ship, right?
00:24:45 This is basic, basic
00:24:46 Tory history.
00:24:50 And what happened was,
00:24:51 of course, Tories
00:24:52 had
00:24:55 to
00:24:56 kind of come back to the people in particular
00:25:00 and create a different kind of philosophy of like, no, well, there's king, there's country, there's
00:25:04 throne, there's altar, there's the serf or the freeholder on the land
00:25:08 and his overlord. But they are
00:25:11 bound together. The worker upon the land and
00:25:16 his lord over him, they can't survive apart. That can't happen.
00:25:20 But we've lost our ability in conservatism to articulate this
00:25:24 question of the Commonwealth. And until we can, I don't think we're going to have a narrative
00:25:29 that can properly counter those on the left. And I think this is exactly the problem with what's
00:25:34 going on with Toryism generally. I think Stephen Harper had moments where he was able to kind of
00:25:39 talk about, you know, strong, stable, conservative majority government, you know, for working class
00:25:43 families, we're going to do, we're going to working families, we're going to make sure that
00:25:46 taxpaying families are taken care of, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. So he tried to, he kind of
00:25:50 created a sort of semblance of of not an ethnicity but an identity that could identify with
00:25:56 conservatism identity that people could identify with when it came to conservatism but i think i
00:26:01 think this is exactly the problem there isn't there isn't an articulation on the right as to
00:26:07 what is the commonwealth you know at least not in canada you know we don't have forgotten man
00:26:13 speeches coming from the right that was trump in the united states in 2016 we don't have you know
00:26:19 you know, empire of evil speeches in Canada. That was Reagan back in the 80s. So Canadian 0.81
00:26:26 conservative rhetoric needs to recapture, in my opinion, some some imaginative narrative that
00:26:33 helps people understand that, hey, it's worth it's worth going on about. It's worth going forward.
00:26:39 And this country is worth building. I think Diefenbaker was probably the last guy to really
00:26:43 articulate that but we'll we'll look for more uh you know uh we'll look for more help with that
00:26:50 uh in a few minutes here but we're going to go to our favorite philosophy professor
00:26:55 dr grant havers who's going to help us understand a little bit more about the state of conservatism
00:27:00 in canada today it's good to have you on dr havers good morning nathan good morning um i i maybe you
00:27:07 can take off where i left off there of of again this this what is the toryism in canada it just
00:27:14 it is different than american liberalism people don't seem to understand that they think like
00:27:18 republicans and conservatives could be the same people but they're not and in canada it seems like
00:27:23 we've lost track of of how to articulate a vision that is i don't know it's so it's softer than just
00:27:30 brutal capitalism but it doesn't need to be the leftist kind of fallacies we see nowadays
00:27:36 Yeah, I think there are some differences. Going back to the different origins of Canada and the United States, of course, as you know, the United States was based on a grand constitutional experiment that had never been undertaken in history.
00:27:56 I think that was the last thing on the minds of the Fathers of the Confederation
00:28:01 who simply wanted to unite a country without engaging in experiments whatsoever.
00:28:10 In fact, MacDonald in many ways thought that the United States was a failed experiment due to the Civil War.
00:28:20 But then the other big difference between Canada and, say, your typical nation state is that we've never had kind of a shared ethnic, linguistic or religious identity in contrast to, say, European nation states where there is that shared identity.
00:28:45 There are shared narratives that are important to at least the majority of people within the nation.
00:28:54 So it's very hard for a conservative movement in Canada to come up with a vision that would be national or to come up with a national narrative that would somehow unite the country.
00:29:11 I mean, even the building of the railroad can't really count as a national narrative because Quebec was not invited to be part of that.
00:29:23 And so as a result, even that narrative, which goes back quite a ways, could not be a unifying one.
00:29:35 So I think that's a challenge that any conservative movement faces in Canada.
00:29:42 One of the things, and maybe it's false remembrance for those of us who are Tories, we think back to, I mean, I wasn't even alive, but I mean, we think back to Diefenbaker's articulation of his Bill of Rights.
00:29:56 We think back to even his national vision, his national strategy, seemed to try and pivot towards developing the North.
00:30:02 that seemed to be extremely important to him.
00:30:04 And it seems like all of that kind of got left behind
00:30:06 the moment Pearson was installed by the Kennedys.
00:30:10 How much of that is true and how much of that is myth-making?
00:30:16 Well, I think it's a bit of both.
00:30:18 I mean, it is true that Diefenbaker was a master of rhetoric
00:30:24 and was probably one of the most eloquent political leaders
00:30:30 of Canada's ever produced.
00:30:32 I think it's important to bear in mind, though, that Ethan Baker's administration, in a way, set the tone for later unfortunate patterns in Canadian politics.
00:30:46 I mean, he was really the first prime minister to see the role of government as defining identity or defining Canadian values and to be the arbiter of public virtue and social justice.
00:31:02 And I certainly don't want to place all the responsibility for our managerial state on Diefenbaker, but I think it did begin with Diefenbaker, namely this idea of the state having to tell Canadians who they are and what they represent.
00:31:23 I mean, that went down like a lead balloon in Quebec at the time of Diefenbaker's reign.
00:31:29 But then the Pearson and Trudeau liberals built on that, especially Pierre Trudeau,
00:31:36 who even more ambitiously saw the state, or at least one purpose of the state, as the arbiter of identity.
00:31:46 And I think Canadians often forget that other nation states don't operate this way.
00:31:51 I mean, the French government doesn't tell the French citizenry what it means to be French.
00:31:59 People in France already know what it means to be French or what it means to be a citizen of France.
00:32:06 They don't need the state to tell them that.
00:32:08 But the Canadian state is unique because it's invested in this purpose or role of telling people what it means to be Canadian.
00:32:21 And what it means to be un-Canadian, which is, I think, a very chilling use of language.
00:32:27 It almost sounds like a totalitarian regime.
00:32:30 There are Canadians who represent Canadian values, and then there are un-Canadian values.
00:32:36 And we have to watch out for those people.
00:32:38 one of the things that's a big misunderstanding in canada as well and even among its own right
00:32:45 wing in different places is is that canada while it while it was so large a country that the state
00:32:52 just couldn't really enforce its will everywhere at once and that maybe some of its freedom was
00:32:57 kind of latent from the just the sheer limitations of state power by geography it also was never a
00:33:04 small state country certainly not in a sense of that that somehow limited government was its was
00:33:10 its reason dietra uh it was it was always right from the beginning with with the building of the
00:33:16 railway there's clearly a national strategy there's clearly a strong federal government
00:33:20 it was never not that how how do modern conserves again with so much kind of american ideas about
00:33:26 limited government or libertarianism how do they square that with the canadian experience
00:33:31 yeah i mean certainly as you said from the beginning canadian tories have not been shy
00:33:38 about using the state uh or or creating collaborations between the state and the
00:33:45 private sector of course the rail national railroad is a good example of that uh but of
00:33:51 course that was a temporary arrangement uh which clearly was discontinued with the completion
00:33:59 of the railroad. But it is true. I mean, generally, Canadian Tories have shied away
00:34:07 from ideological debates about what the state should and shouldn't do, without, of course,
00:34:15 being indifferent to the undue expansion of the state as well. I mean, I think one advantage
00:34:24 from Canadian history is that we've avoided those ideological debates that often make
00:34:30 American politics so colorful. But of course, the disadvantage is that if we don't have those
00:34:37 debates, as ideological as they are, then it's hard to answer the question, well, what do we
00:34:42 stand for? What are our principles? What are our traditions that are worth preserving? So
00:34:50 So, you know, it's important to avoid excessive ideological debates.
00:34:55 But at some point, I think political parties, especially the Tories, have to engage in them.
00:35:03 A party in search of an ideology or a thing to be is a criticism that's been leveled at the Tories probably since Diefenbaker and maybe even before him.
00:35:14 But certainly, certainly they've been lost in the wilderness many times, particularly throughout the 20th century.
00:35:18 And now it appears to be again in the 21st century. They will be lost for some time the upcoming federal election. What do Tories need to think about in that respect in order to try and articulate that? What would be a proper articulation of conservative values in Canada?
00:35:38 Because we aren't Americans, but we're also not Britain anymore, and we aren't Australia, and we aren't New Zealand.
00:35:44 We're part of the major English-speaking countries of the world, including a little bit the French-speaking countries of the world.
00:35:51 But what do those values look like 150-something odd years into our nation-state status?
00:36:01 Well, I think Canadian Tories need to emphasize freedom more or the idea of freedom, not just economic freedom, but freedom in a civil or intellectual sense or freedom of conscience.
00:36:22 So what I mean by that is that the Tories, I think, currently have an opportunity to really put a dent into the liberals because the liberals are, I think, threatening freedom of speech in this country, not to put too fine a point on that.
00:36:42 They are doubling down on censorship of the Internet, or certainly threatening censorship, and at the same time, they want to revamp anti-hate speech laws.
00:36:56 So I would think that Tories, who in part come from a kind of classical liberal tradition, I say in part, should emphasize that they are the party of freedom.
00:37:08 They should warn against these threatened incursions by the liberals into the private sphere of life that includes all the cherished freedoms that we have.
00:37:21 And they've done some of that, but I think they need to really educate Canadians on how dangerous it is for the elected liberals to threaten freedom of speech.
00:37:37 And, of course, that would be consistent with the best of conservative traditions in Canada, to have freedom of speech, to have a sense of ordered liberty, which certainly encourages or should encourage civil discussion, but at the same time keeps the private sphere of freedom off limits to that of the state.
00:38:03 I think they really need to do more work on that front.
00:38:07 it it's it's a brilliant reversal a complete inversion of his own father's words in a sense
00:38:14 when it when you think of our current Trudeau Trudeau Jr. and Trudeau Sr. in comparison
00:38:20 who you know famously Trudeau Sr. said right government has no business in the bedrooms of
00:38:25 the nation Trudeau Jr. appears to think that they they don't just have business in your bedroom
00:38:31 they have a business in your phone your your Facebook account where you go where you eat
00:38:36 apparently whether or not you're going to you know take take a shot or not and wear a mask
00:38:40 apparently the government has business literally everywhere on every square inch of your body uh
00:38:45 not i guess just the soul that they don't believe in is the only thing they don't possess of yours
00:38:52 how how did we get here uh in in modern canada i i if even trudeau senior who was no one's idea
00:39:00 of a freedom lover from a right-wing perspective,
00:39:06 if that is where we were in that generation
00:39:09 and his own son is where we are today,
00:39:11 how do we transform as a country to the point
00:39:13 where we thought that that was okay?
00:39:17 That's a great question.
00:39:18 I think the Liberal Party is liberal in name only.
00:39:22 One would have to look at the history of the term liberalism
00:39:27 And then see how that word, liberal or liberalism, has been reinvented beyond recognition, because the earliest liberals, the classical liberals, were very concerned with imposing constraints on state power and in the process, defending the private sphere of life and including freedom of conscience, religious freedom, intellectual freedom.
00:39:57 from the purview of the state. So in a nutshell, that's what liberal used to mean, at least in part.
00:40:05 But since at least the 1970s and beyond that, liberal, quote unquote, now means clamping down
00:40:18 on offensive or hateful speech, which sounds wonderful in principle, except that the state
00:40:25 is given the authority to decide what hateful speech is, and therein lies the danger. So
00:40:32 again, I think the Tories, I mean, they shouldn't engage in an academic exercise necessarily, but
00:40:39 they should try to educate Canadians as to what liberal, small L liberal, used to mean,
00:40:47 because the Liberal Party has totally reinvented and adulterated that term. Again,
00:40:55 they're they're not liberals in any traditional sense indeed they aren't indeed they aren't and
00:41:03 and one of those one of the funny things that happens though inside of canadian conservative
00:41:08 uh tradition often is they often somehow some way they often just become liberal light with
00:41:17 their policy when conservatives campaign as conservatives they seem to do well but when they
00:41:21 campaign as Liberalite, then everybody's like, well, why wouldn't I just vote for the Liberal
00:41:25 Party of Canada? If I can get light beer, I might as well get regular beer and just carry on.
00:41:33 Right. Well, Louis Saint Laurent once said that the NDP or the CCF are just Liberals in a hurry.
00:41:42 I think the Tories need to realize that they should not be Liberals in slow motion.
00:41:48 in other words they should not be a pale or slower version of the liberals because we already have a
00:41:58 liberal party in fact perhaps we have more than one liberal party i.e the NDP but we don't need
00:42:06 another liberal party that is slightly to the right of Justin Trudeau we we need a party that
00:42:15 obviously offers an alternate vision. And I don't know if it's too late for the Tories to
00:42:22 reverse their electoral fortunes right now, but I would think one way is to try to educate Canadians
00:42:31 as to the importance of freedom. And of course, that's an uphill battle, because people who live
00:42:38 democracies are usually convinced that they're already free. I mean, don't we elect our
00:42:45 government? Don't we have freedom of speech? And isn't it a good thing for the government
00:42:52 to clamp down on hate speech anyway? I think most Canadians are very trusting of their
00:43:00 government in a way that, of course, sharply contrasts with Americans who tend to be more
00:43:06 distrustful but uh i would think that again the the tories have to explain what they mean by
00:43:15 freedom and why freedom is actually a good thing that is part of the canadian experience and i
00:43:21 i don't think they've done enough of that yet and imitating the liberals is just uh a ticket to
00:43:29 electoral defeat it seems to me indeed it does seem like a ticket to electoral defeat as my
00:43:35 My opening statement this morning, I made mention of a trusted source
00:43:40 who I've been close to for many years, making the point that he has heard
00:43:44 as low as 60 seats returning to the conserves after the current contest
00:43:49 or the upcoming contest.
00:43:51 And those are bad numbers.
00:43:54 But even so, polling where they're at, it doesn't seem good
00:43:58 for Aaron O'Toole and his gang of Tories.
00:44:02 Yeah, I've even heard that O'Toole might lose his own seat if an election were called today.
00:44:10 I mean, that's right. And I'm not suggesting that the Tories should articulate a grand vision of what they plan to do.
00:44:24 We have to be careful with visions as they enter politics.
00:44:27 Usually visions are imposed on people. They're not desired by people. And certainly Canada has had its experience with different visionary leaders.
00:44:39 But at the same time, I would think that given the fact that many Canadians are exhausted with the lockdown, of course, we're just coming out of that, and many Canadians, I hope, are worried about the survival of freedom in this country, the Tories should take advantage of that and really distinguish themselves from all the other parties, not just the Liberals,
00:45:07 who actually support a clampdown on free speech and on the exchange of ideas on the internet.
00:45:20 I think those are themes that would resonate with many Canadians.
00:45:24 I mean, there'll always be a high number of Canadians who do not care about their freedom.
00:45:32 I know that sounds a little harsh, but there'll always be some Canadians who are more than satisfied with the way the government might restrict their speech because they don't believe that they're guilty of hate speech anyway.
00:45:47 But I think there are others who are tired of this and are looking to the Tories for a better understanding of what freedom means and a party that stands up for freedom.
00:46:05 Party that stands up for freedom. That'd be refreshing anywhere in the English speaking world, in the Western world generally. But I guess we can continue to hold out hope for it.
00:46:17 Perhaps something we can kind of get into here a little bit then is what is likely to happen in this coming federal contest, not just maybe in its results, but where should the conversation have been, but where is it likely to go, and why is Justin Trudeau likely to triumph?
00:46:39 Yeah, and I hope that's not the case, but it certainly looks that way.
00:46:44 Well, I would think one other challenge that the Tories face is an old one, the divide between Central Canada and the West. And of course, O'Toole represents the 905 area code in Southern Ontario.
00:47:01 And I would think that his understanding of conservatism, to say the least, is deeply informed by the interests of Southern Ontario.
00:47:14 Of course, I would explain why he replaced he wants to replace one carbon tax with another carbon tax, which goes down like a lead balloon in Western Canada.
00:47:25 I know that he has made some gestures towards reconciling the West with Central Canada, but I think he needs to develop themes that are radically different from that of the Liberal Party.
00:47:45 Again, the emphasis on freedom is important. The emphasis on good economic management
00:47:54 is important as well. I think the liberals are vulnerable on that front. But I don't know if
00:48:04 there's enough time left in this pre-election cycle. I mean, the election hasn't been called
00:48:10 yet, but everyone's feeling that we are in a pre-election cycle. I don't know if the Tories
00:48:17 have time to turn things around. I have friends in Alberta who are right-leaning, who probably
00:48:26 will sit out the next election. They will not vote for O'Toole. I mean, if O'Toole can't get
00:48:32 votes in alberta of all places then it's not good no it's not good maybe something else that
00:48:41 needs to kind of be touched on here is how how is the guy from papineau you know our current
00:48:48 prime minister uh how is he doing doing better amongst you know all sorts of classes people
00:48:54 including the working class uh while while the guy who represents durham which literally has
00:48:59 the oshawa car factory in it can't seem to connect with the people next door what what's going on
00:49:04 there i was hopeful that being being the representative for durham was going to be the key
00:49:08 to i'm a part of the industrial heartland of canada i know what what the industrial class
00:49:13 needs i'm going to reach out and make sure that that that everyone uh in in the well under class
00:49:19 at some extent but certainly the working class in canada which has been marginalized for decades
00:49:23 at this point uh how do how do we how do we bridge that gap why can't why can't mr durham see to do
00:49:29 that yeah i i think uh i i mean i i can't speculate as to what goes on in in the mind of uh uh mr
00:49:41 o'toole but i would think that many tories around him are probably afraid to play a populist card
00:49:49 uh even if it is a justified populist uh card like economic populism because it may remind
00:49:57 canadians too much too much of you know who uh donald trump who is still very much with us
00:50:03 so i i think uh the the tories at least uh the ontario establishment tories are are reluctant
00:50:12 to engage in that kind of populism.
00:50:18 And perhaps they even think that Doug Ford has cornered the market
00:50:22 on populism in Ontario, which has not resonated with all Ontarians.
00:50:31 I think Ford isn't doing that well in the polls either.
00:50:34 But Trudeau, yeah, it is astounding that a man of privilege,
00:50:41 i almost said a child of privilege a man of privilege uh is still seen as more receptive
00:50:51 to uh working class people and disadvantaged people uh than uh uh the the the tory leader i
00:51:01 mean trudeau does have a certain charm and i think there is this perception that he's done his best
00:51:08 during this time of pandemic and lockdown.
00:51:13 At least I think many Canadians feel that way.
00:51:17 But at the same time, I think the Liberal Party
00:51:22 is simply better at disseminating propaganda.
00:51:27 They're very good at using rhetoric like equality
00:51:34 and diversity and tolerance, rhetoric that's obviously
00:51:38 to their advantage when tories use that rhetoric it does it just doesn't fit them nor should it
00:51:45 i think these words uh invite or ought to invite great suspicion but from a purely uh political
00:51:52 perspective liberals have always been better uh propagandists and as a result uh they they're
00:52:01 they're more effective or more successful a better propagandist indeed it's been
00:52:07 but but but isn't that somewhat a cultural thing too are not are not those of us those of us who
00:52:16 who have friends to the left they always they're always better storytellers in some respects than
00:52:21 than those of us to the right uh it's not that the right can't tell stories they're very good
00:52:25 they're very good at history perhaps even embellishing history but but stories that
00:52:29 point towards the future or a vision of the future is it it's a purely culture or psychological
00:52:35 trait or does it have some more depth than that yeah i'm not sure how much depth is involved but i
00:52:42 i think when a party can position itself as more compassionate than its main rival on the right
00:52:50 then it then obviously it's going to do well in a time of uncertainty and anxiety over uh not not
00:52:59 just COVID, but other challenges. So I think this is what makes the Liberal Party one of the most
00:53:07 successful political machines in the history of the Western world. I mean, credit where it's due,
00:53:13 right? The Liberals are very good at using rhetoric or propaganda that appeals to the
00:53:24 the democratic psyche uh they're they're able to use uh rhetoric in almost a quasi-religious way
00:53:32 uh where words like diversity and tolerance and inclusivity uh almost become uh
00:53:42 new god-like words that uh require uh not just obedience but almost worship
00:53:50 in the Canadian public square.
00:53:52 So I think the Liberals really understand their voter base
00:53:59 who respond to this language, even if it is just empty rhetoric.
00:54:07 But they've been far more successful.
00:54:10 Far more successful.
00:54:13 Maybe what's needed then is just an totally alternative
00:54:18 conservative discussion but but one of the problems i find when it comes to conservative
00:54:23 discussions or conservative rhetoric is that if i've if i've learned anything from my experience
00:54:29 in politics and analyzing what's happened over the years is that austerity gets you the votes
00:54:36 the first time around and loses you the the votes the next time around so you can talk about how
00:54:42 there's government waste and everything else and indeed there's a lot of government largesse and
00:54:46 that needs to be taken care of but what always seems to happen is that it's always frontline
00:54:51 staff that get cut so of course it's it is the least of these and those who actually need access
00:54:56 to frontline people that that don't have the means to go to a private clinic or whatever else
00:55:01 they they lose so somehow the the senior bureaucrats always keep their positions and
00:55:07 the middle managers always keep their positions but it's it's you know again and most people who
00:55:11 would actually probably be most identifiable with the working class and the people they're serving
00:55:15 across from them at the wicket those people are the ones who get cut and that seems to be
00:55:20 the conservative problem is that it can't get out of this boxed in kind of pigeonhole
00:55:25 that it's just pegged you guys always cut frontline staff you never you always promise
00:55:31 a more efficient government but all you ever do is just cut frontline staff and that hurts people
00:55:36 and it takes people's jobs away and stuff like that and i think that that's a that's a narrative
00:55:41 that needs to be countered by conservatives pretty strongly.
00:55:44 I think a lot of people at the bottom rung,
00:55:47 even in the civil service,
00:55:48 are actually pretty conservative in their personal lives.
00:55:51 And they would be happy to see their overseers lessened
00:55:56 and to have more of their own brethren on the front line
00:55:59 so they can lighten the load
00:56:00 and have less people over them
00:56:02 who they don't really know what they do for a living either.
00:56:04 And they would like to see that reduced.
00:56:08 Yeah, I think that's a good point.
00:56:10 And even if austerity conservatism has some economic justification at times, it's hardly a vote getter, because I think Canadians have just got used to a very interventionist state that, at least in principle, is supposed to promote the common good or the general welfare.
00:56:35 i mean again these are terms that are that liberal party uh is quite uh comfortable with
00:56:42 of course the sad fact is or the unfair fact is that uh liberals can uh impose austerity measures
00:56:51 as well and sometimes that has cost them votes uh both the blood to the ndp uh as a result of that
00:57:00 uh certainly the the fruto liberals have completely abandoned the the austerity
00:57:07 liberalism of the past i'm thinking of the uh martin era of the 1990s and the early 2000s the
00:57:16 last thing that the liberals are interested in is balancing a budget or reducing uh the uh the 0.80
00:57:24 deficit or the national debt so the liberals have certainly cornered the market on the anti-austerity
00:57:33 uh kind of politics of our time which would explain in part why the ndp are not doing well
00:57:40 uh either because the liberals have already um really scooped up that voting block that would be
00:57:49 opposed to uh austerity so but yeah i i think you're right uh the the tories have to offer
00:57:57 alternatives that do not remind people of the image of the tory as cruel and scrooge-like
00:58:05 and uh indifferent to uh disadvantaged people but but at the same time i i think the tories
00:58:14 need to position themselves better as uh more fiscally responsible i i think one can do that
00:58:23 without necessarily threatening people with uh draconian austerity measures maybe we can do a
00:58:31 little bit of a history lesson here uh dr havers there's a there's a quite a question that's grown
00:58:36 in my mind is that a lot of a lot of conservatively minded people today or libertarian minded or even
00:58:43 even some social conservatives every now and again uh they reference the 19th century as like that
00:58:48 great age of classical liberalism and then of course the 20th century is seen as the growth
00:58:53 of the state of course the totalitarianism that came with it and i guess my question is is there
00:58:58 any reason as a conservative to hope that the mistakes of the 20th century are ever going to
00:59:03 be corrected income tax was supposed to be temporary for canada um the expansion of the
00:59:09 state in order to fight both the great wars uh has never left us and and indeed it is appears
00:59:16 that again the minimum the minimalist or the kind of freedom again of the 19th century the burgeoning
00:59:21 freedom jacksonian america uh the wild west um even even the beginnings of the railroad and
00:59:27 everything else this this kind of nascent freedom that happened particularly in the new world but
00:59:32 throughout the western world suddenly comes to an end with the great war is is made even worse in
00:59:37 the interwar period, and then is kind of solidly statized, you know, and there's a status element
00:59:42 forever, thanks to what happens in the Second World War. Is there any way out of that? 0.78
00:59:50 I'm inclined to say no. I mean, I don't think anybody wants to go back to the 19th century,
00:59:55 except people who romanticize the 19th century, but that's not going to happen. We're not going
01:00:04 to go back to a canada where the franchise uh was limited to a very small number of canadians
01:00:12 mainly uh male voters uh that's not going to happen and and any politician who proposes that
01:00:19 had better find a different job or career but i think the managerial state as i like to call it
01:00:26 uh is here to stay uh by that i mean a state that has to intervene in the economy and in
01:00:36 areas of social welfare uh to help people when they need help i i think that's going to stay
01:00:44 and there can be some tinkering or reduction uh of that role uh regarding the managerial
01:00:52 state but i i don't think we're going to be able to turn the clock back i think what should be
01:00:57 reversed though is what i would call the therapeutic state uh the managerial state on the one hand
01:01:04 which came out of the new deal era in the 1930s and of course its counterpart in canada
01:01:12 very legitimately responded to challenges of economic stability unemployment etc
01:01:19 But the therapeutic state is really a creation of the late 1960s, in which you have a state that's concerned with the consciousness of people.
01:01:30 And it goes back to the era of Diefenbaker I referred to.
01:01:34 The therapeutic state wants to practice therapy on the population by tracking prejudice, real or imagined, or by tracking attitudes that are un-Canadian.
01:01:46 I think that state is far more dangerous and far more destructive and, I would hope, far more unpopular than the managerial state.
01:01:57 And this is where I would go back to the focus on freedom.
01:02:02 Tories really have to push back on this therapeutic state that sees the role of the state as the arbiter of consciousness and thought and values.
01:02:15 uh none of which uh really resonates well with the canadian experience but the liberals are
01:02:24 very comfortable with that that's why they're trying to revamp anti-hate speech laws
01:02:29 uh that's why they often give the impression that right-leaning canadians are just the most
01:02:35 dangerous people in the world of course they get a lot of their ideas from the democratic party
01:02:40 uh which does the same thing south of the border so i think that state that state which uh is
01:02:48 preoccupied with the consciousness of canadians needs to be uh pushed back otherwise we're we're
01:02:55 going to lose our freedoms and uh they won't be recovered uh any as a result indeed indeed it
01:03:06 And let's parse this a little bit more for the viewers and the listeners, just a little bit more, because even I sometimes think I miss, well, I use these words kind of interchangeably, but I know the managerial state versus the therapeutic state, when we think of the managerial state, what I really think of mostly actually is kind of like basically hospital administrators, really.
01:03:28 I think of non-clinical staff pulling the levers of power inside of a hospital, which is kind of like, well, why is there a single non-clinical person here who isn't also a janitor?
01:03:39 This is a hospital. It's a place of healing people and treating the sick.
01:03:44 I understand somebody needs to count some beans somewhere to ensure that the lights stay on.
01:03:48 But the idea that there would be anybody other than clinical staff in here makes no sense to me.
01:03:52 And yet there's a whole host of managers doing the business of managing, which appears to be meetings, finger sandwiches, brainstorming, visions, values, posters on the wall through the comms team, which is another group of exempt staff, and a lot of busy work that really doesn't necessarily help anybody get well.
01:04:12 but but they're they're clearly trying to i guess keep the rank and file in an orderly fashion and
01:04:17 make sure there's somebody at a desk somewhere in order to receive you when you come in for triage
01:04:22 when we talk about the therapeutic state it's something a little bit different uh and and
01:04:27 the idea that people would would need the state to help them i don't know get over their anger
01:04:34 get over their issues uh try to try and teach them how to be better people not just economically
01:04:41 but psychologically i think i think that is a dangerous thing and maybe i don't know is it all
01:04:46 just one flew over the cuckoo's nest or is there something a little bit more nuanced to that story
01:04:51 yeah it's worth noting that we already have laws against speech that is threatening or slanderous
01:05:00 or libelous uh so it does raise a question why are liberals uh trying to bring back section 13 or
01:05:08 or the old law against hate speech that the Harper administration got rid of years ago.
01:05:17 I think the official answer is that hate is growing, prejudice is growing.
01:05:23 We have to clamp down on it.
01:05:26 But it also raises a question that I think any classical liberal would raise,
01:05:32 and that is who defines what hate is?
01:05:36 Do we want bureaucrats to do that? 1.00
01:05:38 You mentioned managers or administrators in a hospital who I think could be trusted in the role of making sure that a hospital doesn't go broke or managing it efficiently.
01:05:54 I don't think Canadians have a problem with that.
01:05:57 We do need efficient managers to be in charge of governments or corporations, depending on the responsibility that they have.
01:06:09 But monitoring consciousness, monitoring speech, monitoring thoughts and opinions, I don't think anybody has the expertise to determine what exactly is offensive and what isn't.
01:06:26 or at least they shouldn't be trusted with that kind of responsibility.
01:06:31 And, of course, the very term therapeutic state implies
01:06:34 that a large part of the population are neurotic or repressed.
01:06:42 As you said, they don't know how to deal with their anger.
01:06:46 But it's not the purpose of the state to be a therapist.
01:06:51 That's something new, not just in the Canadian experience,
01:06:55 But even in the United States, which has a very strong tradition of freedom of speech, and of course, different European countries have imposed anti-hate speech laws as well.
01:07:09 Of course, usually hate speech is associated with the right.
01:07:13 So it's already a political agenda on the part of the therapeutic state, which obviously raises questions about how objective or unbiased these bureaucrats are going to be.
01:07:25 this arbitration of consciousness or this this design to form the consciousness of the people
01:07:32 uh which which definitely definitely had a lot of a lot of play in the totalitarian regimes
01:07:38 of the interwar period and of course later uh throughout the 20th century i mean it maybe this
01:07:45 is a bit of a reach but didn't didn't we kind of invite this upon ourselves as as we in the west
01:07:51 went went through modernity if we were going to abstract uh values from or or at least the
01:07:58 value-making role of of the church or religion of of worship or whatever of of pastors and priests
01:08:06 in in the populace if that role was going to be reduced and reduced and reduced uh as secularism
01:08:12 did uh do that did did we not invite that somebody would step into that vacuum and is that is that
01:08:18 not in a sense somewhat the socially conserved argument nowadays of like well the state the
01:08:23 state has to retract in so many respects because it is forming the consciousness of people and
01:08:27 until you get it to retract it will just be there and it'll fill that vacuum fill that gap
01:08:32 that's right i mean i i i don't think uh the liberals will necessarily be stopped
01:08:41 from uh bringing in uh stronger anti-hate speech laws i mean if they're re-elected god forbid
01:08:48 But if they're reelected, I think they'll be fully committed to that type of agenda.
01:08:54 And part of the problem, too, is that many voters, not just in Canada, but across the Western world, don't see a problem with governments clamping down on so-called hate speech.
01:09:08 I mean, who could be against policies that restrict or eliminate hatred?
01:09:14 But, of course, people have to think about what is meant by hatred or what is meant by offensive speech.
01:09:22 I mean, if somebody is critical of the liberal government, is that offensive?
01:09:27 Is that hateful or is that legitimate dissent?
01:09:31 I would think maybe just the Augustinian inside of me, but I would think that all governments are sinful.
01:09:38 I mean, now it's time for a little theology here.
01:09:41 All governments are frail and sinful in the sense that no government really wants criticism.
01:09:51 And usually we think of that attitude as linked to totalitarian governments.
01:09:57 Of course, they won't tolerate criticism and they'll suppress it quite brutally.
01:10:02 But unfortunately, it's true of democracies as well.
01:10:05 I mean, despite the lip service given to freedom, I think most elected politicians, frankly, do not want to be criticized.
01:10:15 And the fact that they can't control the flow of information and speech on social media, I think, bugs the heck out of them.
01:10:23 And as a result, if they see an opportunity to restrict that speech or to restrict criticism, even legitimate criticism of government policies, they will take that stand and call it a clamp down on hate speech.
01:10:44 Indeed, they will. There's no question. I mean, I mean, if you could if you could silence and silence and control your opposition with complete impunity, like who wouldn't?
01:10:53 it's a terrible temptation
01:10:56 it's a diabolical deal
01:10:57 you can do whatever you want
01:10:59 without any worries
01:11:01 about who's coming down
01:11:03 to tell you what's what next
01:11:06 I mean, speaking of theology
01:11:08 it's one of those things
01:11:10 from the beginning of this year
01:11:11 I kind of resolved that I would get through
01:11:13 the good book in a year
01:11:15 through all of the Bible
01:11:16 and somebody's reading it on this audio thing
01:11:19 and as I get through it
01:11:22 and now I'm into the Old Testament kings.
01:11:24 I mean, this is the story over and over again.
01:11:26 Only the prophet ordained by above
01:11:28 is able to tell the king he has no clothes
01:11:31 or he has done a terrible thing.
01:11:33 And we need this criticism,
01:11:36 whether it's a democracy
01:11:37 or whether it's just an autocracy.
01:11:40 Obviously, the self-criticism is necessary.
01:11:42 It's been necessary since the beginning of time,
01:11:44 but it's not well taken often.
01:11:46 It's often rather...
01:11:49 It causes a lot of anger
01:11:50 and the person who's getting criticized.
01:11:53 Well, that's right.
01:11:55 And of course, most voters will shake their heads
01:11:58 over any association between democracy on the one hand
01:12:03 and tyrannical measures on the other.
01:12:06 I mean, I think we, not just in Canada,
01:12:09 but in the Western world,
01:12:10 are moving towards something
01:12:12 called democratic totalitarianism.
01:12:15 That was a term coined by James Burnham,
01:12:18 a famous right-wing thinker from the 20th century.
01:12:24 Burnham argued in a few of his books
01:12:27 that democracies can become totalitarian,
01:12:32 not because democracies will engage
01:12:37 in the same brutal tactics that the Nazis 0.75
01:12:40 or the Stalinists in Russia practice.
01:12:45 I mean, democracies don't have to be brutal.
01:12:47 All they need to do is use propaganda in order to convince the people that this is for their own good.
01:12:56 And unfortunately, many voters are quite happy to sacrifice their freedoms if that means fighting something called hatred without actually worrying about the ramifications of that.
01:13:11 So that's what concerns me. I think there'll always be a high number of voters who don't really want their freedoms, unless it's a freedom to consume, like to buy stuff online or go to the shopping mall.
01:13:26 That freedom is very important to voters, as long as they have their technical gadgets to distract them from politics.
01:13:39 But as far as intellectual freedom or religious freedom or the freedom to disagree, I'm not sure that a majority of Canadians necessarily care about those freedoms.
01:13:54 I hope we do. Otherwise, we're going to see a therapeutic state growing in leaps and bounds in the years to come.
01:14:07 I must admit that I was consulting the other week on the show. I put it up on the screen there. It was the second coming by Yates. It did seem like the best lacked all conviction and the worst were full of fury.
01:14:24 But it's it's if if we're going to try and map our way out of there and and and get out of I think there's another Canadian thinker, his name escapes me, but he talks about socialistic or tyrannical, socialistic, collectivistic, but libertinism.
01:14:42 Right. So you can you can consume what you want. You can do whatever you want to do in your bodily autonomy when it comes to sex and and or your gluttony and whatever. But you but but of course, there's no freedom. You can't shop for your medicine. You can't shop for for your insurance. Right. At least in British Columbia, you can't shop for anything else.
01:15:00 You have no choices around anything that kind of might have brick and mortar ramifications on your life or principles of freedom.
01:15:08 But you can you can watch whatever you want on the Internet and you can you can copulate with whoever you want to and you can buy whatever you want on Amazon.
01:15:15 It seems like we might be there.
01:15:16 Yeah, this is a new type of social contract, very different from the traditional liberal social contract, which emphasized the desirability of a limited state, a state that basically respects and preserves the private sphere of life.
01:15:39 But if people simply equate the private sphere of life with consumption, as you suggested, why should they care about whether the government will restrict their right to disagree or their right to embrace ideas that may well be wrong, but that is an expression of their freedom to disagree.
01:16:05 So I think it is a type of new social contract.
01:16:11 I mean, let's take a controversial example.
01:16:13 It's perfectly legal to change your gender now in Canada, 0.99
01:16:18 but it's not legal to criticize the politics of gender constructivism.
01:16:26 So I think many Canadians would see the first freedom as important,
01:16:31 but then would be critical of the freedom to disagree or to object to gender constructivism.
01:16:41 So I think that's disturbing.
01:16:44 If people no longer have the freedom to disagree, then really they don't have any freedom.
01:16:51 And I think, again, it's sad that many people are just satisfied with the freedom to consume products
01:16:59 that they probably don't need anyway.
01:17:01 i mean you're you're an educator uh you've been an educator for for years it it you know as as
01:17:09 you bring students into contact with some of these ideas have you have you seen a change in
01:17:14 the students that you know when you were trying to introduce concepts to them you know in another
01:17:19 time maybe they were more open to questions around these things or having lively debate around these
01:17:25 concepts and these principles and and contesting with one another but but today is there more
01:17:30 conformity and less and less
01:17:32 disagreement about what ought
01:17:34 to be, or even perhaps a fence taken
01:17:36 at the idea that there was ever somebody
01:17:38 who, I guess you could use all their identity
01:17:40 tropes, right? There was a cisgendered 1.00
01:17:42 white dead male somewhere in the
01:17:44 past who maybe proposed at some
01:17:46 point that, you know, like there was supply and demand
01:17:49 and like there should be labor applied
01:17:50 to items in the material world
01:17:52 and that becomes property, that somehow
01:17:54 that all has to be dismissed because it obviously
01:17:56 is being reasoned from a wrong place.
01:17:59 Yeah, I think there has been definitely a shift in academia, not just my own university.
01:18:07 I mean, in fairness, there's always been conformity.
01:18:10 There's never been such a thing as unlimited freedom of speech.
01:18:14 I mean, the old bourgeois ethos that once dominated North America did not allow unlimited freedom of speech.
01:18:25 there were still rules and unwritten restrictions.
01:18:30 But, yeah, I'm inclined to say, without sounding too nostalgic about the past,
01:18:38 that there was more freedom of speech in academia even 20 years ago than there is today.
01:18:45 I mean, one thing that strikes me is that the Marxist professors with whom I studied
01:18:51 as an undergraduate, most of them have passed on by now, were quite tolerant. They were quite open
01:18:59 to dialogue. They didn't mind being challenged by uppity undergraduates who thought they knew
01:19:05 everything. But they enjoyed the give and take of the classroom and were not offended by
01:19:15 disagreement. Without generalizing too much, I think many people on the left today in academia
01:19:23 do not have that kind of easygoing tolerance. They tend to believe that if you disagree
01:19:30 with me, you're not just wrong, you're a reprobate. You should be cast out. There's almost something 0.94
01:19:37 quasi-religious about this attitude. I think the left itself has changed. The left, again,
01:19:46 without sounding too nostalgic, was somewhat more liberal or pluralist in tolerating the exchange
01:19:54 of ideas, but that kind of left is an archaic left. It's going the way of the dodo bird and
01:20:02 being replaced, I think, by many people who are not tolerant at all, despite their lip service to
01:20:11 tolerance. One of the things that's kind of an interesting sidebar within this discussion is
01:20:16 that on this channel, particularly this show, we've had multiple discussions. Some of our
01:20:23 regular contributors are actually Marxians. And actually, you know, I've got one guy who calls
01:20:27 himself an old school Leninist. I got another guy who calls himself a Marxian. And they like to
01:20:31 wax philosophical every Thursday explaining
01:20:33 from their perspectives what exactly is going wrong
01:20:35 and ironically the only place they have to talk
01:20:37 about it is here on a right wing channel
01:20:39 because they couldn't get a hearing on the left
01:20:41 maybe something that
01:20:43 you can articulate for us a little bit
01:20:45 is as somebody who
01:20:47 had dealings with
01:20:49 Marxism in its time and Marxian
01:20:51 ideas in its time and how things have evolved
01:20:53 from here, one of the ideas that
01:20:55 my other two contributors contend
01:20:57 is that political
01:20:59 correctness is actually an imposition
01:21:01 that it actually doesn't follow proper Marxist theory at all
01:21:05 because it causes division amongst the underclass
01:21:08 that would need to have solidarity to overcome the oligarchs.
01:21:12 And it actually plays into the hands of the oligarchs 0.73
01:21:16 to have these divisions within people who are underprivileged.
01:21:22 What happened there?
01:21:23 How did the workers' revolution turn into a fistfight
01:21:28 and a bit of a catfight amongst non-profits
01:21:30 over whose pronouns are better.
01:21:34 Yeah, exactly.
01:21:35 Well, one of the ironies of the post-Marxist left
01:21:38 is that it's abandoned any serious discussion
01:21:41 of social class, which, of course, was central,
01:21:43 not just to the Marxist left,
01:21:45 but to the old left in general.
01:21:48 If there's any discussion of class or social class
01:21:52 to be had today, it tends to be on the right,
01:21:55 which is something that I didn't really anticipate
01:21:57 10 years ago.
01:21:59 I would have been astounded if somebody had told me that today the right would be the real movement concerned with social class or a class divide.
01:22:12 I mean, there are still some hardcore Marxists who are focused on class, but the more powerful or more prevalent left doesn't want to deal with class.
01:22:24 Of course, it wants to deal with race. 0.69
01:22:25 I mean, Robin DiAngelo, the author of White Fragility, has said this more than once, that the focus on race is far more important than a focus on class.
01:22:37 So what everyone thinks about that, that's quite a shift in the history of the left.
01:22:42 And related to that, who would have predicted that the left would cozy up to big business, especially big tech or other corporations that have embraced not just the rhetoric, but the policies of so-called progressivism today?
01:23:02 I certainly would not have been able to anticipate that years ago.
01:23:07 So the left is not really anti-capitalist anymore, despite some rhetorical excesses.
01:23:14 They've made their peace with capitalism, or at least with certain sectors of capitalism.
01:23:20 And their aim is not to heal or address the class divide, but rather to clamp down on anybody who dissents from what they call their anti-racist agenda.
01:23:36 Although I think they themselves are engaging in racism on their own.
01:23:42 So, yeah, the left has really changed.
01:23:45 In a way, this creates an opportunity for the right, though.
01:23:47 I think we talked about this.
01:23:48 But if the populist right can, again, take advantage of this class issue, the class divide, which is getting worse and worse,
01:24:02 then there's some electoral potential there.
01:24:07 But so far, I think, as we just discussed, the Tories have been outmaneuvered by the Liberals, at least for now.
01:24:17 I'm not sure if the Liberals have any real solutions to the problem of home ownership or the decline of the middle class in Canada.
01:24:25 We'll have to see.
01:24:26 it's it's a great irony isn't it that uh i mean again when dr seuss was getting banned uh i my
01:24:35 in a show that i used to do well it's on hiatus uh but when one of those contributors aaron ekman
01:24:40 uh we were we were all co-hosting he we would we would sit there when we kind of go back and forth
01:24:44 he'd be the left-wing guy i'd be the right-wing guy and one of the jokes that we made while we're
01:24:48 both discussing this whole thing where they've just canceled dr seuss is that aaron looks at me
01:24:53 He's like, you know, I don't really understand it because, you know, from my parents' perspective and from my perspective, because his parents were pretty left wing, too.
01:24:59 It's like he was one of our guys. I'm like, yeah, from our perspective, he was one of your guys.
01:25:03 And I don't know when we decided that Dr. Seuss was somehow, you know, a crazy right winger.
01:25:08 But he that was just like we were both laughing.
01:25:11 I was like, I don't know who's decided that, you know, Dr. Seuss is Goebbels.
01:25:16 But I don't I don't agree with that assessment.
01:25:19 And it's funny that you make this point about the class divide being ignored, because at some point, I'm sure that a left wing undergrad or graduate student, for that matter, is going to start writing a paper or thesis about how obviously, you know, Victor Hugo and and Charles Dickens need to be banned.
01:25:35 Because because despite the fact that they tried to do so much for the underclass, they were obviously just people of privilege and they have no right to speak. 0.96
01:25:42 They should be taken off the shelf.
01:25:43 well that's right and just to connect this back to the the hate speech issue i i think people
01:25:50 in the left who support anti-hate speech laws because they assume that these laws will go
01:25:56 after those terrible right-wingers are being really naive uh because the left will cancel
01:26:03 its own heroes or its own present-day celebrities and as you said that's just happening i was just
01:26:10 reading this morning that a statue of emily murphy uh one of canada's most famous feminists
01:26:16 part of the famous five uh i think her statue in edmonton uh was vandalized with red paint
01:26:23 because uh she was a feminist who happened to have racist views who happened to endorse eugenics 1.00
01:26:30 and other nasty ideas that hopefully we have completely done away with.
01:26:37 So I think eventually the left will devour itself.
01:26:45 I mean, this is what happens with any revolution.
01:26:48 The revolution will devour its own architects because nobody is morally pure at the end of the day.
01:26:56 And as a result, I think this new left will end up alienating or splintering important parts of its own coalition, which I think is quite shaky.
01:27:14 I mean, it's too bad that Donald Trump is no longer president from a leftist point of view, because I think hatred of Trump was probably the one thing that united all these different factions on the left.
01:27:26 And now that he's gone, the big differences between these factions will become more obvious.
01:27:36 And I think one faction will end up accusing the other of engaging in hate speech or celebrating the wrong heroes or not pulling down the right statues and so forth.
01:27:49 it and i think that a lot of this is all connected back to again a sense of a sense of place or a
01:27:56 lack thereof um and uh one of my one of my favorite quotes is always of course i will not raise my
01:28:02 hand against virginia um whatever one might say of of the lost cause uh and and of the various
01:28:07 individuals involved with it in the end also a sense of place and fundamental loyalty is an
01:28:13 important one i think a strong value regardless of your of your left or right leanings the problem
01:28:18 is though that that we live in a time where there is no sense of place people are cosmopolitan either
01:28:23 by choice or by force they can't afford a home in their hometown they have to move somewhere else
01:28:28 they can't can't get decent work in where they grew up they have to go somewhere else is that
01:28:34 rootlessness also a part of the chaos we're sensing that that the people don't have a sense
01:28:39 of place a sense of regardless of national identity they don't have a sense of local identity because
01:28:44 they don't have a neighborhood. They don't have a home. Well, that's right. If people,
01:28:48 especially young people, no longer feel that they have a vested interest in the system
01:28:53 and, for example, cannot afford a home or will not have the money to raise children
01:29:01 or to have a job that places them in the middle class, that's a very dangerous situation for any
01:29:09 political party right or left as I think the the extinction or decline of the
01:29:19 middle class is a dangerous threat that not only Canada faces but the Western 1.00
01:29:29 world as well because if we don't have a middle class we're not going to have a
01:29:34 real democracy i think barrington moore famously said no bourgeois no democracy i mean we'll have
01:29:43 a kind of democracy which is governed by shall we say the mob or whoever shows the loudest but
01:29:51 we're not going to have a democracy that respects the rule of law or freedom of speech or other
01:29:59 important restraints on public authority uh so no middle class no democracy i i think it's kind
01:30:07 of funny i've had this discussion with some of my leftist friends as well there's i mean on a good
01:30:11 day on a good day i sympathize with orwell and on a bad day i i have i i have less doubts about some
01:30:17 of franco's uh designs and so it's this is the problem we we we and if you had told me that 10
01:30:24 years ago too it's like well it's like you know you you would meet people who would kind of sit
01:30:29 there and be like you know what i i don't know if if uh if if franco and the gang were wrong all the
01:30:34 time in or the other way too it's like well you know i like i like uh what or what was trying to
01:30:40 do but i i also disagree with maybe his methodology if you told me 10 years ago people are going to
01:30:44 have discussions like that where they were where literally either the foundations of democracy
01:30:48 were being shaken to the point that people were kind of trying to pick which kind of totalitarianism
01:30:53 they thought was best.
01:30:55 I think you
01:30:57 and I would both laugh that off. I think we would both
01:30:59 laugh, that's hilarious. Nobody's going to have a serious
01:31:01 discussion about it. No one's going to have a forum
01:31:03 about that somewhere except for someone living
01:31:05 in their mom's basement. It's like, no, there are
01:31:07 people who are legitimately all
01:31:09 but getting into street fight. We see this in America
01:31:11 and in some places in Canada as well.
01:31:13 We saw people, whether
01:31:15 it was Antifa or BLM, and then
01:31:17 there was people who called themselves
01:31:19 patriots and all sorts of things.
01:31:21 on the other side that society is clearly dividing because the system that we're in right now is not
01:31:26 working for a lot of people well that's right and and the center uh will not hold or and uh
01:31:34 it's legitimate to ask whether there is a center anymore i mean much of what uh president biden
01:31:40 is doing in the united states is far to the left of of obama uh and even farther to the left of
01:31:48 the Clinton administration of the 1990s. And yet, of course, it's all presented as mainstream and
01:31:56 moderate and not radical at all. But meanwhile, yeah, I think you're right. Polarization will
01:32:05 just continue. And we haven't quite seen that in an obvious sense in Canada, not yet. But of course,
01:32:13 there are serious regional divides that are fueling polarization as well. So the idea that
01:32:21 somehow our liberal democracies can depend on a consensus which encourages bipartisan
01:32:29 collaboration is just becoming an illusion because so many people feel alienated from
01:32:37 the political system again across the western world uh so i i think we're we're in for very
01:32:44 interesting times uh interesting times are not necessarily good or stable times of course but
01:32:51 uh and what's further depressing is that we don't seem to have a political leadership that really
01:32:57 understands uh how dangerous uh these times are and how there really is no political center anymore
01:33:07 no and and one of the one of the things that shows just how far gone we are again again you
01:33:17 know you and i are sitting down 10 years ago somebody walks up to us and says oh yeah there's
01:33:21 a whole bunch of churches burning we're both like well yeah i mean in the middle east obviously or
01:33:25 sudan or or or in north africa with boca haram and it's like no no no no there's uh there's the
01:33:32 problem is that we're we have we have churches burning in canada and uh and and we'd both look
01:33:39 at each other again we'd be like that's not happening that that's nonsense that's something
01:33:42 that happens over there not over here i i'd be interested to get your take on on what's happening
01:33:47 right now with with the oh yeah uh not not only do we have churches burning but uh we also have uh
01:34:02 uh powerful people in the media and in politics at least some powerful people who are either
01:34:11 downplaying the seriousness of these church burnings or even celebrating these church
01:34:17 burnings like uh that representative of the bc civil liberties association uh not too long ago
01:34:24 So, again, I wouldn't have been able to anticipate any of this years ago.
01:34:31 And, again, it raises questions about who exactly is our leadership class.
01:34:40 I mean, are they comfortable with any traditions in the history of Canada?
01:34:44 Or do they want to reinvent the entire country using not just propaganda, but also coercion?
01:34:55 But again, the problem is that I think many Canadians probably don't have a problem with many of these attitudes.
01:35:06 I think there probably are Canadians who think that the church burnings are understandable, as Gerald Butt put it.
01:35:13 And as long as you have that attitude, not just among our ruling class, let's say, but also the governed, it's very hard to convince the people that the rule of law is a good thing, that freedom of disagreement is a good thing, that we shouldn't try to demonize our entire history.
01:35:38 Again, I think that's what the right has to do
01:35:43 It has to engage in this re-education
01:35:47 And hope for the best
01:35:49 And it all falls into the same thing
01:35:54 Again, these questions of tradition, questions of narrative
01:35:57 The other big thing that's of course been happening throughout Canada
01:36:00 Longer than the church greetings
01:36:01 And will continue maybe after those finally extinguish themselves
01:36:05 If enough people are caught and punished
01:36:07 is the removal of statues and the
01:36:09 desecration of our
01:36:11 kind of monumental history
01:36:13 quite literally
01:36:15 in forms that are just kind of
01:36:18 bizarre. People who weren't
01:36:20 they were progressive for their time
01:36:21 but they've been dismissed. I mean you mentioned this earlier
01:36:23 when it came to the
01:36:25 suffragette but this is happening to John
01:36:27 A's statue. It's happening to
01:36:29 Queen Victoria's statue.
01:36:31 These symbols in
01:36:33 Canada are being torched
01:36:36 removed uh vandalized pushed over destroyed i mean i again i didn't think that i was entering
01:36:43 revolutionary france but apparently that's where i am yeah and i i think we both agree that
01:36:52 obviously canadians need to learn their history they need to learn that uh our history does
01:36:58 consist of periods of injustice and periods in which, you know, terrible things happen,
01:37:10 to put it very simply. So I don't think we want to support the erasure of history in that sense
01:37:17 either. But I guess the big question for me is, what is the new history that's being trotted out
01:37:25 here and who will present this alternative history and i i think unfortunately it will it'll
01:37:33 consist of people who are comfortable with the therapeutic state who want to expand the therapeutic
01:37:40 state to include as one of its functions uh the rewriting of history to equate canada with being
01:37:49 a genocidal nation that must be rebuilt uh from the ground up i mean that term genocide is is of
01:37:58 course a loaded term uh which is being bandied about i think in a very uh irresponsible way
01:38:05 i mean i i often ask my my diminishing number of friends on the left well are you comfortable with
01:38:12 that term genocide as it applies to canada because if you are you're basically putting canada on the
01:38:20 same immoral plateau as that of uh stalinist russia and nazi germany i mean one cannot celebrate 0.86
01:38:30 anything good about canada while at the same time saying that it perpetrated genocide when
01:38:35 that would be a contradiction
01:38:37 that's an exercise
01:38:40 in illogic
01:38:41 so I think this is what Canadians
01:38:43 have to think about but they also
01:38:45 have to think about who is presenting
01:38:47 this new type of
01:38:49 history and whether
01:38:51 it will actually do any good
01:38:53 or will in fact split the country
01:38:55 apart
01:38:56 and it doesn't get
01:38:59 much stronger than that
01:39:02 it really doesn't
01:39:03 We're here. We're here at the end of these things, and we wonder where it's headed to next.
01:39:09 And indeed, I think it's that simple. And maybe maybe we do have to ask Orwell for for his intercession on that count.
01:39:16 You know, I believe Samuel is is the donkey and in Animal Farm.
01:39:22 And he reminds everybody that, you know, if you didn't like if you didn't like your old masters, just wait till you've got your new ones.
01:39:28 This seems to be a perpetual amnesia when it comes to any revolution, right wing or left wing, any radical right or left, is that, you know, at some point the new oligarchs are going to show up and the new oligarchs might be far more cruel than the old oligarchs.
01:39:47 Well, that's right.
01:39:48 And I think that's where a knowledge of history is incredibly important.
01:39:52 I mean, I say that as a philosopher.
01:39:54 I mean, philosophy is important, too, but even more important, dare I say, is a knowledge of history.
01:40:03 And one of the most depressing lessons from history is that for most of human history, we did not have freedom.
01:40:13 Most of human history is really the history of not just violence, but tyranny, or at least governments that suppressed freedom or saw freedom as an alien idea.
01:40:24 the idea of freedom in the classical liberal sense is pretty new. It's a newcomer in the history of
01:40:31 civilization, perhaps 250 or 300 years old, which is just a drop in the bucket. Unfortunately,
01:40:40 human beings by nature do not desire freedom. Perhaps they desire freedom for themselves,
01:40:46 but not for others but that's not really freedom then so it's depressing that uh we
01:40:54 may be going back to a familiar pattern in history in which freedom just disappears
01:41:01 and uh going back to uh attitudes that i i think unfortunately are more natural to human beings
01:41:09 which is to be intolerant and disagreeable and willing to use coercion to get one's own way.
01:41:19 I hope I'm wrong about that.
01:41:22 But, again, the trend lines are not reassuring.
01:41:26 I believe, maybe as a concluding thought, I'm just recalling something that was made,
01:41:32 probably still one of the best speeches ever made at a modern conference by Mr. Stein,
01:41:39 anyways, at least one of his best little bits
01:41:41 when he addressed the Manning Conference, and I believe
01:41:43 in 2014.
01:41:45 And he made the point of
01:41:47 that freedom
01:41:49 is a rare thing, and at one point
01:41:51 in the 1940s,
01:41:53 there was not a free government
01:41:55 in the Eurasian continent.
01:41:57 It's from
01:41:58 Lisbon to Hong Kong,
01:42:01 there were no free governments.
01:42:04 They were all totalitarian,
01:42:06 and an entire
01:42:07 group entire populations of people of multiple races classes and creeds were were under the thumb
01:42:13 of of you know five people effectively and and we need to think about that and and i i at one point
01:42:21 the world managed to to to the free world what was left of it managed to get enough motivation
01:42:27 and and momentum that it went and reimposed freedom by defeating tyranny i don't know if
01:42:34 that same motivation lies inside
01:42:35 of us today to counter it, not just
01:42:38 in our own countries, but
01:42:39 abroad, but certainly in our
01:42:42 own minds, accepting tyranny
01:42:43 as a kind of
01:42:45 the
01:42:46 day's play
01:42:49 that that's how we are.
01:42:52 Yeah, to make matters worse,
01:42:54 we have representatives of China
01:42:56 and Iran
01:42:57 hectoring Canada about
01:42:59 its human rights record. I mean, that
01:43:01 would almost be funny if it weren't so grotesque but uh it is troubling that there's a new kind
01:43:09 of self-confidence on the part of dictatorships today not just china but also iran and others
01:43:16 who i think sense perhaps for some justification that the west is losing its resolve uh that the
01:43:23 West, including the United States, has lost its determination to stand up to dictatorships
01:43:32 and, meanwhile, is being bogged down over debates as to their moral legitimacy altogether.
01:43:40 So that's a troubling feature, because if people no longer believe in democracies, democracies
01:43:48 will not last.
01:43:51 And as a result, the alternative, which of course is dictatorship, becomes more palatable or at least is not seen as something inferior to democracy.
01:44:09 Yeah, the lights are going out all over the West, if we want to appropriate that particular line.
01:44:15 I do hope to see them lit again in our lifetime, but perhaps not.
01:44:18 uh that was that was a little bit of a downer but that i mean reality sometimes is that way
01:44:25 and that's why we console ourselves with philosophy uh and allow ourselves to have a
01:44:31 bit of a philosophic view perhaps we can end on on that old line by benedict a contemporary of
01:44:36 augustine at one point as augustine saw the world burn and was worried that it was all over i believe
01:44:42 benedict said pruned it grows again so we can only make that our prayer yeah and the good news is uh
01:44:48 with a nod to augustine is that none of this is inevitable i mean plato and to some extent
01:44:54 aristotle thought that it was inevitable that tyranny would replace democracy because they were
01:45:00 fatalists they were resigned to the cycles of fortune and misfortune but uh this is where i
01:45:06 like augustine augustine uh who admired plato still thought that no this is a matter of will
01:45:12 human beings, at least human beings who are open to the grace of God, are still responsible for
01:45:23 their actions. There's nothing inevitable about decline and fall. That is a choice that people
01:45:30 make. So like all choices, people need to think that through. Agreed. Agreed. Thank you so much
01:45:39 for joining us today and we hope to see you again soon thank you nathan absolutely
01:45:44 well we've come to the end of our time here today uh very thankful of course for dr haver's
01:45:53 contribution and what we have discussed here we went all over the place but in good places
01:45:57 uh fundamentally obviously uh the ethic of freedom needs to be reinvigorated throughout the west but
01:46:03 but particularly here in
01:46:05 Canada as we see 0.54
01:46:07 quite frankly just
01:46:08 slow acts
01:46:11 of cowardice to that precipice of
01:46:13 suicide when it comes to our civilization
01:46:14 that's what I see when it comes to our leadership
01:46:17 but whatever we'll do more hot takes like that
01:46:19 tomorrow. Of course we have Aaron on
01:46:21 tomorrow we don't have Stuart on tomorrow
01:46:22 Stuart is flying through the air
01:46:24 somebody asked me the other day if he bought some carbon
01:46:27 offsets we can ask him that later
01:46:29 the comments can come up for that
01:46:31 one if they want but the point is that
01:46:33 Stuart's not here, unfortunately, to teach us more about dependency theory and the issues thereof.
01:46:37 So we're going to have to figure out whether we're going to have Aaron on for the whole time or we're going to do some comment stuff at the end of tomorrow's show.
01:46:44 But in any case, what we're going to end on here now, of course, is the same thing we always end on, which is we're going to throw up the old email, remind people that if they would like to suggest guests and that sort of thing, bring it on.
01:46:56 We're happy to take those suggestions.
01:46:57 And the other thing we're going to bring up at the very end here is that I am getting married not so long from now.
01:47:06 And the question of when that hiatus is going to begin is up in the air.
01:47:11 I'm going to be discussing that with my overlords in Alberta, who are a little far away.
01:47:17 I got to find a time to kind of chat with them and figure out when exactly this hiatus is going to begin.
01:47:22 and you guys are gonna have I'm sure either something that replaces the show entirely as a
01:47:30 as a stand-in or a stand-in host for a while I'm just going to make sure that I you know consult
01:47:36 with both both both the people thereof and of course let all of you know our viewership and
01:47:41 listeners who I appreciate very much that that that is going to be an ongoing discussion I'm
01:47:46 not sure when exactly that hiatus is going to come to pass but it's important for you to be
01:47:50 given that forewarning. So you're not, you know, tuning in on a Tuesday and suddenly I've
01:47:54 disappeared. Uh, last points, uh, I guess would just be that again, uh, keep, you know, keep on
01:48:01 the straight and narrow, pray, pray for what's left of this country. And I am hopeful as well
01:48:07 that as we, uh, kind of journey forward, uh, we're able to kind of see what exactly, not just the
01:48:14 question of sovereignty, but also the wider question of regionalism and identity, uh, for
01:48:18 what it means to be, you know, at least a Western Canadian or someone who loves freedom,
01:48:23 what that could mean. We look forward to the federal election with some anxiety. I'm not sure
01:48:29 exactly how that's going to go. But hopefully, hopefully people make the right choices going on,
01:48:36 going on. Well, we hope. A couple of good comments here. Sheldon doesn't want me to disappear. He
01:48:42 still has to give me my rating on my hair uh and of course uh mr blair uh reminding me that
01:48:49 it's good it's good to be getting married that's awesome so that's all for us today uh that was
01:48:55 the last thing that's what escaped me two seconds ago when i looked like i was scrambling uh the
01:48:59 pipeline is on in a few minutes uh which i believe occurs always at uh what am i thinking 12 p.m
01:49:06 Mountain, 11 a.m. Pacific
01:49:09 on Wednesdays. So I'll throw
01:49:11 it to them right away. Thank you so much
01:49:13 for watching, and we'll see you again tomorrow
01:49:15 bright and early, 9 a.m. Pacific,
01:49:17 10 a.m. Mountain.
01:49:36 Amen.