Western Standard - August 18, 2026


NATION OF PEOPLE | Canada’s biggest problem is hiding in plain sight

Topics
Mentioned
Cory Morgan: The Senate is still wasting your money Western Standard News Update | Trump pauses tariffs, Keystone XL back on table | 19 Aug 2026

Episode Stats


Length

26 minutes

Words per minute

150.44

Word count

4,031

Sentence count

259

Harmful content

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Countries need a unified vision, like businesses need a mission statement.
00:00:04 What is Canada's unifying vision?
00:00:06 Well, there isn't one.
00:00:08 We'll see that there are actually three, each distinct and unrelated and often at odds with each other.
00:00:15 None of them acknowledge the existence of the other two.
00:00:19 It renders the nation deeply dysfunctional and accentuates our already deep regional divides.
00:00:27 What are they? Where did they come from? And how can they be addressed?
00:00:31 Welcome to the Nation of People.
00:00:50 Hi, I'm Natalie St. Hilaire. With me is Randy Royer.
00:00:54 royer how can a country survive and prosper without a sense of common purpose that comes from a
00:01:00 unifying vision instead of one unifying vision people across canada state their regionally
00:01:07 accepted vision and assume that the rest of the country is in agreement and they are not
00:01:14 and it is tearing the country apart literally
00:01:17 So we ended last episode talking about the great vision for Canada and the potential for bringing together all the different provinces and the seemingly impossible tasks that that might be.
00:01:33 And I'm wondering if we go back into the British North America Act, if there's actually some indication of a vision, of a unifying vision for Canada there.
00:01:42 The only thing that's there is peace order and good government, and that's not really very much
00:01:46 guidance. That's not really a vision. It's just sort of, I don't know, let's go and create a
00:01:51 government. What we actually have is we have three different visions. They're mutually exclusive,
00:01:58 and no one recognizes the other two. So we've got about three different ideas about, in Canada,
00:02:04 how things should be done and where we're going. And we're not talking about the conflict there,
00:02:10 is what you're saying that's correct and the the consequence of not talking about it is that we
00:02:15 lack a sense of national purpose what is the vision of the country what are we trying to
00:02:19 achieve what does it mean to the individual well if you listen to trudeau jr there's no we're
00:02:26 post-national we don't need to sort that out but uh i guess i i digress so tell me what are the
00:02:33 three different visions randy i i'm i'm actually going to confess that a vision in as it is in a
00:02:39 business plan, the vision of your company is important. We can cite the American vision,
00:02:46 we can cite the vision of many different countries, but we can't define what Canada's vision is.
00:02:53 So the three visions that are in Canada are number one, Big Brother Confederation,
00:02:59 number two, Equality Confederation, and number three, the two nation policy.
00:03:04 Well, I know it sounds better to me. So let's start with what sounds worse,
00:03:08 which is Big Brother Confederation. Can you explain what that is, Randy?
00:03:12 Sure. Big Brother Confederation comes from the original confederation.
00:03:16 It's held in Ontario and the Maritimes. And it is basically the concept that when the first four
00:03:24 colonies got together, it was really about the dominant position of Canada, which was
00:03:29 upper and lower Canada, Quebec and Ontario. Part of it was the deindustrialization of the Maritimes.
00:03:37 As we talked about in another intro introduction for the videos, that created the de-confederation
00:03:45 separatist movements in the Maritimes in the 1870s.
00:03:49 But Ontario and the Maritimes hold that today.
00:03:52 And that is, the country will focus in on the two main provinces, and they'll take care
00:03:58 of everybody else.
00:04:00 That worked until Quebec kind of hit their quiet revolution, and then their economy ended
00:04:06 up suffering over the years because they focused on linguistic and social issues and not economic
00:04:12 issues. And so it was all left to Ontario. And Ontario was actually a good big brother. I
00:04:17 mentioned in the last episode that when Alberta was trying to develop its its oil resources,
00:04:23 Ontario, even though it was more expensive, agreed to use Alberta oil and gas and whereas
00:04:30 Quebec didn't. And Ontario also was one of the early stage investors in the oil sands. I think
00:04:39 they bought it 5% of the oil sands. So Ontario has actually been a very good big brother to Canada.
00:04:45 And as I mentioned in the previous episode, they were walking away from the crow rate, 0.83
00:04:54 which was an example which benefited Ontario, and it was detrimental to the West. But Ontario
00:04:59 accepted that we got rid of that. So Ontario really was a good big brother. And they were
00:05:05 quite prepared in my view to continue to pay reparations to the Maritimes and pay for
00:05:11 Confederation until they couldn't anymore. And then Alberta was the focus. They turned to Alberta
00:05:18 because Alberta could pay for it. But we don't view big brother Confederation. We view equality
00:05:25 confederation yeah there's sort of a natural tension there where if i'm paying for something
00:05:32 then i don't need a big brother i'm not being taken care of because financially taking care
00:05:38 of somebody is is sort of taking care of them so that i can see where that would naturally create
00:05:44 some real tension uh what about equality confederation what do you mean by that
00:05:49 the tension that it creates is that ontario doesn't understand why we don't want to pay
00:05:54 today, and it's because we believe in equality confederation.
00:06:00 And where this comes from is in 1931, Alberta, Saskatchewan, and Manitoba received their
00:06:08 natural resources and became what in our eyes were equal provinces.
00:06:14 That wasn't exactly the idea that Ontario had and Quebec didn't have that idea.
00:06:19 But we thought that meant equality.
00:06:21 So throughout Alberta, we think equality is the essence, the vision of Canada, and we
00:06:28 think everybody's supposed to be equal.
00:06:30 And we base that on the 1931 Resource Act.
00:06:38 Ontario looks at the 125 years of the national economic policy, which focused attention on
00:06:44 the Big Brother, and believes that they're right because that's what the original confederation
00:06:50 and 125 years of economic policy.
00:06:53 That's what that indicates.
00:06:54 And then the 82 Constitution specifically says
00:06:58 that the BNA Act is still accepted in its entirety.
00:07:02 So they rationalized that the 82 Constitution 0.86
00:07:06 re-emphasized the Big Brother Confederation.
00:07:09 So we in Alberta, we believe that we have equality.
00:07:14 They don't believe that.
00:07:16 Well, I can see where that would cause conflict.
00:07:19 you said something was different about BC. What's that about?
00:07:23 So if Alberta is the abused child of Confederation, and the family analysis is a pretty good one,
00:07:30 they were the older brother, we're the younger brother, and we feel that we have been abused in
00:07:35 Alberta. British Columbia is the abandoned child of Confederation. They have a very distant view
00:07:43 of Ottawa. They don't look to Ottawa to solve their problems. They don't see problems coming
00:07:49 out of Ottawa, they're disassociated with it. And just nobody thinks about the federal government.
00:07:55 The coast is called the BC coast for a reason. It's not called Canada's west coast. It's called
00:08:00 BC's coast. So they're very disassociated and that has a lot of implications. And we talked
00:08:07 in a previous episode about the land issue in British Columbia. Well, they focus on what
00:08:12 province of British Columbia did to cause that. They don't focus on the 82 constitution or what
00:08:18 the federal government has done and so that's there there's got a bit of a variation they
00:08:24 kind of believe in equality but it doesn't really matter because ottawa is way way way
00:08:30 on the other side of the rocky so we don't care about it and another another example of that is
00:08:37 a friend of mine was the was the head of the gaming commission in british columbia and he saw
00:08:44 the period of time where it was guys going into the casinos with bags of cash. And he said that
00:08:50 the federal government knew what was happening. They knew that money was being laundered,
00:08:54 but they chose to do nothing. And they didn't really do anything until the money laundering
00:09:01 problem hit Toronto. Because in Ottawa's eyes, if it's just Vancouver, we don't care about it.
00:09:07 But when it hit Ottawa, it became a national issue. And that was very, very clear about the
00:09:13 different views of different visions of Canada. Well I know that there's some rumblings in BC
00:09:18 about things that have been happening and the 1982 constitution so maybe that's going to change
00:09:24 but we still need to talk about the two nation policy which is the next vision. So this vision
00:09:29 is held by Quebec and the political elite and political establishment in Ottawa and this is
00:09:36 was created in the 1982 constitution and it is the vision of Canada that it is two separate
00:09:43 countries. That's probably why Justin Trudeau made that comment. They were post-national because we
00:09:49 have two different countries inside of Canada. One is an autonomous Quebec, and the other is
00:09:58 English Canada that is a unitary state, all run out of Ottawa, and the provincial governments
00:10:06 have whatever rights Ottawa decides that they have from time to time. So they can give very
00:10:13 different rights to Quebec versus Alberta. And there's been a lot of problems around that.
00:10:20 And so they rationalize it because they think that that's what the 82 Constitution was all about,
00:10:25 specifically, where it says in equality will be determined by the federal government.
00:10:32 So their view of it is that.
00:10:34 And then inside Ottawa, the Prime Minister has all the power.
00:10:39 There's no checks or balances on the power of the Prime Minister.
00:10:42 And he is only beholding to the electorate from Toronto to Montreal.
00:10:48 And that's whether you're a Liberal Prime Minister or a Conservative Prime Minister.
00:10:53 Your electoral base that you need to satisfy is that corridor from Toronto to Montreal.
00:10:58 Nobody else counts.
00:10:59 And that is the two-nation policy.
00:11:03 I see.
00:11:05 Well, if it indeed is true that these three separate visions of Canada exist all at the same time,
00:11:12 I feel like this would be very, very problematic for us.
00:11:17 And I can see where some problems could come from, these sorts of misunderstandings and goals and visions.
00:11:25 But do you have a list, Randy?
00:11:27 I certainly do.
00:11:29 Do you happen to have a list of grievances?
00:11:32 Yeah, I mean, the Impact Assessment Act, it was a clear infringement upon the rights of the
00:11:39 province, the sovereign rights of the province. The Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals in Alberta,
00:11:43 so it's not called the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeals definitively said this is against the
00:11:48 Constitution. And so you have to ask, how did the federal government justify this? How did they
00:11:54 rationalize it? And why are they still doing it, even though the court said that they can't?
00:11:58 And the reason is, is because they view the country, their vision of the country is the two
00:12:03 nation policy. They think that they're the superior government, and the Alberta government
00:12:08 is inferior. So that's one example. BC trying to stop the pipelines. I mean, when you think about
00:12:16 it, they went to court to the Supreme Court to see if BC had the ability to stop the Alberta pipeline
00:12:23 years ago under Horgan. The court said, no, you don't have that right. But somehow, Quebec does
00:12:29 have the right to stop. And just nobody challenges it because everyone in the political elite
00:12:35 accepts the two nation policy strategy. Another example is healthcare. In Quebec,
00:12:43 they go by very different rules than they do in English Canada. The last one, and I'll repeat it
00:12:48 again as national energy policy. That was an example that even though section 92 of the 82
00:12:55 constitution says clearly that resources belong to the provinces, the NEP was an expression that
00:13:03 Alberta sovereignty was subservient to the federal government's sovereignty. And it was
00:13:08 an expression that the two nation policy says that the provincial governments are subservient.
00:13:12 subservient so lots of examples and the toughest thing about it is that we don't even communicate
00:13:19 what the underlying problem is you know we we communicate on the superficial problems but we
00:13:24 never say you actually view the country differently than i do and we need to decide who's right or
00:13:29 who's wrong and that's the problem that the country is going to be stymied until it actually addresses
00:13:34 this issue i can see where that would be the case and so uh say i want to do something about it say
00:13:42 I'm the kind of crazy person that decides I'm going to get into politics and I want to actually
00:13:48 contend with the situation in front of me, like in reality, not just in an ideal way.
00:13:53 What can I actually do about it? How do I handle it based on what political party I'm in?
00:13:59 What do they do? What are they currently doing to deal with these conflicts?
00:14:03 Nobody, nobody addresses the conflict. It's just, it's verboten. Nobody talks about it.
00:14:08 nobody addresses it. Nobody even wants to admit it. The Premier of Alberta is talking about
00:14:15 equality. They want equality. The Premier of Quebec says, we want sovereignty and autonomy.
00:14:21 And Ottawa is talking about the two nation policy. They don't talk about it. They don't address it.
00:14:28 And in terms of the actual parties themselves, the Liberal Party is all in for either a combination of
00:14:35 Big Brother Confederation in Ontario, or the two nation policy in Quebec, they kind of fudge it
00:14:40 and say, those are what we do, particularly the Trudeau Liberals. The Conservatives trying to
00:14:46 push the equality side, but when they're actually in power, they have to realize that they got to
00:14:52 treat Quebec differently. And they really have to accept the two nation policy. So they campaign on
00:14:57 one and do something different. The NEP is their structure in their constitution is very similar
00:15:06 to the two nation policy that all provincial NDP parties have to adopt the federal policies
00:15:14 and Quebec is completely independent. So they're all in on the two nation policy.
00:15:19 So what I'm gathering from what you're saying is that because there's something structurally
00:15:25 set up in our constitution that requires us to be governed a certain way like electoral districts,
00:15:33 etc. Even when we have a conservative government that might campaign on equality,
00:15:39 they can't govern that way. It won't work for them. That's correct.
00:15:43 Okay, so that's one of the, I think, areas where people really start to feel alienated,
00:15:50 you know, is even when we get what we want, we don't get what we want because it's structurally
00:15:55 impossible, is what you're saying. Yeah. Stephen Harper, for example, he famously wanted to have a
00:16:04 single financial control. And that, of course, was going to be the OSC in Ontario. And so he's
00:16:13 going to move all financial stuff out of Calgary and move it to Ontario. And that was a progressive,
00:16:18 a conservative government. And the court said that finance was a provincial sovereign right,
00:16:28 and so he didn't do it. But that expresses that even in the conservative party,
00:16:33 they really have to play to Ontario and Quebec in order to get elected again.
00:16:38 Well, I mean, I think that it's not gone without my noticing and a lot of other people's noticing
00:16:42 in Alberta that change is really difficult and that getting that sense of equality or action
00:16:48 in an equal way is really difficult for our province.
00:16:51 What's new for me here is how connected it is to the Constitution.
00:16:55 Yes.
00:16:55 So how does this end up impacting the relations that Ottawa has
00:17:01 with the various provinces and regions in the country?
00:17:04 Well, Alberta is probably the wealthiest of the equality confederation provinces.
00:17:12 The other ones are Manitoba, Saskatchewan, and to some degree, British Columbia.
00:17:17 And so it's the odd, you know, the odd child out.
00:17:21 It's the one that raises the most fuss about it.
00:17:23 It's the one that says we demand equality.
00:17:26 And the 82 Constitution fudges it.
00:17:30 It kind of says, yes, you know, the BNA Act.
00:17:34 Yes, everything that you assume is correct, but also we're going to have the two nation policy, which is also correct.
00:17:40 So, you know, what we need to do is as a family is we need to grow up and admit who we are.
00:17:45 And even if, you know, parts of Canada separate, they need to understand the vision of what that part is.
00:17:51 So this is a fundamental issue that needs to be addressed.
00:17:55 Okay.
00:17:56 So what's the, at the end of the day, what's the conclusion here?
00:18:02 How can this even work?
00:18:04 Like what's, I mean, you know, even you just said like, even if parts of Canada separate, like what, because I know you've thought about this a lot.
00:18:12 you've written books. And I know you do have a suggestion or two for how we can find ourselves
00:18:20 out of this mess. So I'm curious, Randy, to hear from you what that is. Well, I think there is
00:18:26 an opportunity to weave a solution. And the three most vocal provinces are Quebec, Ontario, and
00:18:34 Alberta. And the objective is to weave a solution that works for everyone. The two-nation policy
00:18:42 is in direct conflict with the concept of equality, so we can't have that. The Big Brother
00:18:48 Confederation, it's run its course. All of the participants need to grow up, and they need to
00:18:55 contribute, and contribute whatever they can to the prosperity of the country. And so Big Brother
00:19:01 has got to kind of go by the wayside. And so if we look at Alberta promoting equality, Quebec wants
00:19:10 autonomy, and Ontario wants unity. Well, those three things are not mutually exclusive. We can
00:19:17 actually work with those things. And so what does that mean? It means that we define what autonomy
00:19:23 means. And by the way, there's 40 countries in the world that have autonomous regions within them.
00:19:30 And Canada is considered to be one of those regions already. And they work well. And the
00:19:35 reasons for autonomous regions is either cultural differences or geographic differences and industry
00:19:43 differences. We certainly have that. So one possible direction to go in is to say, okay,
00:19:50 Quebec, you can have autonomy, but we also have equality. So all of the provinces have that same
00:19:56 autonomy. Now, some provinces are too small that they are not, I mean, Prince Edward Island is 180,000
00:20:04 people. You can't have a full provincial government in that it just doesn't have the
00:20:10 economies of scale. So for example, perhaps the maritime provinces, sorry, Atlantic Canada,
00:20:16 needs to come together, and that includes Newfoundland, needs to come together and form
00:20:21 a regional autonomous zone. Western Canada, for example, Alberta and Saskatchewan don't have
00:20:30 ports, we don't have access to the sea. So we need that. So perhaps, and this is what I talk
00:20:35 about in my most recent book, perhaps British Columbia, Alberta, Saskatchewan and Manitoba
00:20:41 need to come together and form a regional autonomous district. And I actually call that
00:20:46 the Prairie Pacific Autonomous Region, PAPAR, which all the golfers like that name.
00:20:51 Pa-par. Pa-par, pa-par. But then that Pacific Prairie Autonomous region would be 14 million
00:21:02 people. They'd have common access to two oceans. It would have some of the greatest resources in
00:21:10 the world in oil and potash and lithium and agriculture. It would be an incredible autonomous
00:21:17 region then ontario is 14 15 million now quebec is almost 10 million maritimes is almost 5 million
00:21:26 so we could be a country of regions rather than this confusion that we have of what we are and
00:21:32 what we aren't to summarize where we're at so far we need a single vision yes and what you're saying
00:21:41 is that we need some economically viable solution that has us on equal footing with Ottawa or
00:21:52 Eastern Canada or other regions in the country. And so you're proposing these autonomous regions.
00:21:59 It's like a way of establishing your sovereignty without leaving, finding ways to have agreements
00:22:08 that respect people's equality or provinces' equality. So one specifically would be the Pacific
00:22:16 Prairie Autonomous Region. Okay, got it. And so there would be, I'm thinking,
00:22:23 other ways that we would also support each other that would be equal and a-partisan,
00:22:28 and that would create some sense of fairness between the provinces and the regions of the
00:22:34 the country? So the idea is to give all the provinces equal sovereignty, and then they
00:22:41 take that sovereignty and they work together in the region. So for example, building a pipeline
00:22:46 or railroad to Hudson Bay, the three provinces can work that out. Building something to the West
00:22:52 Coast, the two provinces, and I'm going to include the Indigenous on both of those,
00:22:58 we can work together. We don't need Ottawa's interference in that. We can actually take our
00:23:03 sovereignty, and agree to work with our neighbors under a regional sovereignty.
00:23:10 I mean, that all sounds really good. But when I hear you say that, I immediately think
00:23:15 Ottawa isn't going to like that. Like what you're saying is, guess what? We don't actually need
00:23:20 Ottawa. What we need Ottawa for is to promote best practices across the country, to promote
00:23:29 that each province and each region needs to be a contributor,
00:23:35 economically, socially, environmentally, in every way.
00:23:40 Each province should put on their big boy panties
00:23:43 and do something and be positive.
00:23:44 This idea that we have Atlantic Canada
00:23:47 is basically a award of the national government.
00:23:51 And it's eternally getting equalization payments is a bit insane.
00:23:55 And again, because we believe in equality, and Ontario believed in the Big Brother Confederation,
00:24:04 it was willing to pay those reparations, as I call it, but Alberta is not.
00:24:09 And so I think that's actually, our lack of willingness to do it is actually something
00:24:14 positive for Ontario and Quebec.
00:24:17 What on the Ottawa government, nobody's going to like losing power, but what's the alternative?
00:24:25 But Ontario, sorry, the Ottawa government needs to look at different things.
00:24:32 We're going to talk about that in future episodes.
00:24:35 Things like how does Canada brand itself?
00:24:38 How do we make us the exporter of preference in Europe, in Asia?
00:24:45 You know, it needs to be supporting all of the provinces equally.
00:24:51 They have a big role to play.
00:24:52 It's also in defence too.
00:24:54 and so we just need to redirect them.
00:24:58 Well, I like what you're saying, Randy,
00:24:59 and I have a lot of questions specifically
00:25:01 about how we can possibly get to what it is that you're saying
00:25:05 based on our current construct
00:25:09 and the fact that nobody likes to lose power,
00:25:12 particularly not Ottawa.
00:25:13 But I'm sure we'll get there as we discuss more and more
00:25:16 or at least have some good ideas along the way.
00:25:19 Well, I think the first step is what we've talked about already
00:25:21 is we have to break the egg.
00:25:24 And breaking the egg is voting on the Constitution and rejecting it.
00:25:29 And so then if we do that, and if British Columbia does it, if Saskatchewan does it, if Manitoba does it, you have all of the West, which fundamentally has the same character that we talked about in the last episode, we can break that stranglehold that the Constitution has over us.
00:25:46 And this is trying to distinguish, extinguish, extinguish our character, extinguish our concepts
00:25:53 of our vision of Canada.
00:25:55 And we can say, no, this is what we want.
00:25:58 And the four Western provinces can come together, in my view, and say, this is a Canada that
00:26:03 we think works.
00:26:05 And it can be prosperous.
00:26:06 It can defend itself.
00:26:08 And it can have a very bright future that can influence other parts of the world.
00:26:12 And that's kind of my dream.
00:26:14 That actually is my dream.
00:26:15 Well, thank you for that, Randi, and for giving us all a vision of a different future.
00:26:23 Join us next time and find out how Canada has two separate social contracts.
00:26:28 Find out how the two are mutually exclusive. 0.86
00:26:31 And once again, the West is left paying the bill for the East. 0.67
00:26:35 See you then on A Nation of People. 0.66
00:26:45 Should I go now?