Western Standard - September 26, 2024


NDP & Bloc got so much confidence in Trudeau

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Stronger rights for Albertans could be a signal for all of Canada Latest spending boondoggle looming for the city of Calgary

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

164.71

Word count

7,740

Sentence count

538

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

18

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Editor-in-Chief Corey Morgan join host Derek Fildebrandt and co-host Erica Barutz to discuss the latest in Canadian politics, including the Trudeau-Blumenfeld break-up, the Bloc quebecois vote on confidence in Justin Trudeau, and more.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening. Today is September 25th, 2024. I am Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:09 I'm joined, as usual, by Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford. How are you, Nigel?
00:00:15 Good to be here on this day of expanded rights.
00:00:19 Indeed. Not with us today is Western Standard Corey Morgan.
00:00:24 In his place, we have the wonderful Erica Barutz, who is, well, kind of sitting out in a bit of independent media herself, but I like to refer to her as Senator-Elect Barutz. 0.99
00:00:40 Welcome to the show.
00:00:42 Thank you, and I will let you use that title. I think it's Senator-Elect waiting longer now, given Mr. Trudeau's appointments, but I'll keep fighting the good fight.
00:00:50 I'm not using Senator in waiting. I like Senator-Elect.
00:00:53 I think it sounds more official as well.
00:00:55 This will be elected MLA, or the MP, before they're sworn in.
00:01:00 You know, they're MP-Elect, they're MLA-Elect, Premier-Elect. I like Senator-Elect.
00:01:04 Me too.
00:01:06 Okay, well, we've got a good show today.
00:01:08 Okay, the NDP and Bloc Québécois still have so much confidence in Justin Trudeau.
00:01:17 They have, Justin, Jagmeet Singh has torn up his agreement with Justin Trudeau.
00:01:24 It's torn up.
00:01:25 I've got to emphasize, it's torn up.
00:01:27 But, you know, breakups, they're not always so clean.
00:01:33 He may have moved out, but they're still going to the movies together.
00:01:38 Jagmeet Singh still has had his NDP vote.
00:01:41 But it has confidence in Justin Trudeau's Liberal government.
00:01:44 And Mr. Blanchet's Bloc Québécois, well, he heard that the relationship might be testy, so he's moving in.
00:01:53 He's making a play to be Trudeau's new girl.
00:01:56 And so the Bloc Québécois has also voted that it has very much confidence in Justin Trudeau's government.
00:02:02 I mean, I know I don't need to rile any of you up anymore about the state of the legacy mainstream media in Canada, but CTV has gone to a whole new depth, not in just spin, not in an angle, not in advancing a bias, but full out lies and fabrication.
00:02:25 They have incredibly taken, they fabricated a clip of Pierre Polyev saying that we should have an election based on the carbon tax, and they fabricated it so that it says we need an election to kill dental care.
00:02:41 I actually agree.
00:02:42 I don't think the federal government should have anything to do with dental care, but that's not what he said, not what he said whatsoever.
00:02:47 And facing a very hefty defamation lawsuit, CTV has eaten shisa over it.
00:02:55 And, oh, what a good day.
00:02:57 What a good day, Alberta's new Bill of Rights.
00:03:02 We don't have the exact text of it, but Alberta Premier Daniel Smith laying it out yesterday, giving a significantly expanded and beefed up Alberta Bill of Rights.
00:03:15 Oh, I know a lot of you are going to love it.
00:03:18 It's good.
00:03:19 All right.
00:03:19 Well, let's get into it.
00:03:20 We're going to go start right at the top.
00:03:22 So, Nigel, J.B.
00:03:27 Singh, a few weeks ago, said he's breaking up with Justin.
00:03:30 He's tearing, no, he's ripping up the agreement with Justin Trudeau.
00:03:36 Rip, tear.
00:03:37 Whipping it up.
00:03:38 Done.
00:03:38 And then he was asked over and over and over and quite comically, he was asked over and over, do you have confidence in Justin Trudeau?
00:03:48 And he would just say, I ripped it up.
00:03:50 Do you have confidence?
00:03:50 I ripped it up.
00:03:51 Well, the question was settled, and he very much does have confidence in Justin Trudeau, the NDP voting to keep his government power again.
00:04:03 And Blanchet's Bloc Québécois also voting now, discovering a newfound confidence in Justin Trudeau.
00:04:11 So, I mean, if they are trying to undermine faith in Canada, that's actually not a bad way to do it.
00:04:16 The Bloc Québécois should probably keep Trudeau in power longer.
00:04:23 Who's the winner?
00:04:23 Who's the loser among the different parties here?
00:04:28 Well, among the different parties, I'll come to that.
00:04:30 But obviously, we, the Canadian people, are all the losers in this, because you have a government that basically no longer has legitimacy.
00:04:40 I'd have to say that on the matter of Mr. Blanchet's confidence, he is confident that as long as he keeps it reasonable or even a little bit unreasonable,
00:04:50 he can put in his chet, and it will be signed and delivered by the Trudeau government, because that's what it's going to take to keep them in office.
00:05:03 So, I think that Mr. Blanchet is just doing what any smart politician would do in the same circumstances.
00:05:12 The person who really is in the very awkward dilemma that you describe is, on the one hand,
00:05:19 having no confidence but voting in favor of a vote of confidence, is Mr. Singh.
00:05:24 I cannot imagine what his electoral future is going to be.
00:05:29 Certainly, he may keep his seat, but what his legacy in the history books is going to be is a very strange one,
00:05:39 and I think at the end of it all, he's going to wish he'd never done it.
00:05:41 Erica, I was watching a video, some live footage from the House of Commons of Jagmeet Singh speaking to the motion of non-confidence in the Trudeau government,
00:05:54 and I had previously thought I'd never seen a politician debase and humiliate himself so much as Jagmeet Singh,
00:06:02 but that changed yesterday when I saw him standing up debating this motion, saying,
00:06:08 I don't have confidence in Justin Trudeau, but I'm voting to have confidence in Justin Trudeau.
00:06:14 I think it's because the NDP stand to have zero influence in the next parliament.
00:06:19 Even if they were to somehow pick up some seats, they're going to have less influence,
00:06:22 because it's going to be a majority conservative government, very likely.
00:06:24 And, most importantly, they have no money to fight an election.
00:06:30 So I want to focus in on Jagmeet Singh and the NDP here.
00:06:33 He tried to make a big to-do about ripping it up, yet he's still voting to have confidence in it.
00:06:41 Do you think it's...
00:06:42 What do you think is the...
00:06:44 What's the triangulation going on in this man's mind right now?
00:06:47 I think there's a few things at play.
00:06:49 One, it's completely embarrassing, right?
00:06:51 You're talking from both sides of your mouth, as he did when he said,
00:06:54 I'm tearing this up, but wouldn't answer how he would vote in a non-confidence vote in the House.
00:06:59 So I think what he was trying to do is to separate the NDP-Liberal coalition as a brand,
00:07:07 to maybe try and detach that in hopes when the next election people aren't going to say a Singh-Trudeau alliance.
00:07:14 Don't think that that was successful for him.
00:07:17 I think that that brand's cemented, and we're going to see the Conservatives leverage that.
00:07:23 But when it comes to how...
00:07:24 So he tried to do that by ripping everything up, then stands up and is saying,
00:07:29 basically, I don't have confidence in democracy.
00:07:33 I don't have confidence that Canadians are going to pick the left because they've been such an embarrassment. 1.00
00:07:42 And so he's looking at this as like his party keeps, you know, they're actually holding pretty par,
00:07:49 and if not going up where the others are going down, like the Bloc and the Liberal Party in their seat counts.
00:07:54 But you're right.
00:07:55 He doesn't have money.
00:07:57 He's trying to protect his own brand, it seems, more than he's actually trying to protect his party's brand.
00:08:01 And he's doing a horrible job at it based on his speech.
00:08:05 Now, I do think his pension is the lingering issue that it's like he wants to collect a pension.
00:08:12 Listen, I get it.
00:08:13 He's put his time in, and he'd like to have him, you know, receive that because I don't think after his performance,
00:08:20 the last couple of months, people are going to be knocking down his door for a job.
00:08:23 But I think that's another piece, which is also embarrassing to democracy and to all the people of Canada,
00:08:30 that that's why it's basically that was the underlying tone I heard, is I don't believe in this man,
00:08:35 but I got some skin in the game, and I need to hold on for my own selfishness.
00:08:40 Plus, my party brand's failing, and I'd like to give him the best chance possible.
00:08:43 To be fair to Mr. Singh, which is always difficult, I must say that he is not the only member of Parliament
00:08:55 waiting for his pension to vest.
00:08:57 There are, in fact, out of a 338-seat House, I believe 80 MPs in a similar situation of all parties,
00:09:07 including the Conservatives, and therefore, there's a lot of support for keeping this thing.
00:09:14 If you've got 25% of the House with you, keeping this thing going and going and going,
00:09:19 it's got a fairly good chance, I would say, of going the distance.
00:09:22 I mean, if your seat is safe, you're not going to worry about it too much.
00:09:25 But a lot of seats aren't safe anymore.
00:09:28 Yeah, and I do think that that would hurt his internal brand and his party to not call it.
00:09:33 But I think we would be remiss by not pointing that out to the viewers,
00:09:38 that that is, I think, a nugget that's being considered.
00:09:41 There are a lot of Conservatives that will be vesting when that class comes due,
00:09:46 but I don't think there's a single Conservative MP who's really worried about losing his seat right now.
00:09:51 They're confident that if there's an election, well, actually,
00:09:54 they're more likely to get a bigger pension because they're guaranteed their seats for four years after.
00:09:58 So, you know, the math, I always try to get inside the head of people I don't agree with.
00:10:11 I want to at least understand them if I don't agree with them.
00:10:14 So, you know, maybe you guys can help me just understand the math of Singh here.
00:10:18 So he rips up the agreement with Trudeau, but wouldn't say if he has confidence or not.
00:10:25 The Bloc wants to be the dancing partner now.
00:10:28 So with the Bloc voting that it has confidence in the Trudeau government,
00:10:33 Trudeau didn't need Singh's NDP to keep it afloat anymore.
00:10:38 So why did he order the NDP to still vote for it?
00:10:43 Is it that, you know, because the Bloc and the Liberals, as far as we know publicly,
00:10:47 have not struck in a deal yet.
00:10:49 The Bloc have laid out some pretty high prices to pay off Quebec at the expense of the rest of Canada.
00:10:56 We don't know if the Liberals are going to meet that price or not.
00:11:01 But at least for this one particular vote, at least, Singh still sided with the Liberals,
00:11:09 even though, even if he voted non-confidence, had demonstrated a bit of independence.
00:11:14 The government wouldn't have fallen and he wouldn't have had to worry about an early election.
00:11:17 And, Erica, what do you, try to get inside his mind for a moment.
00:11:24 If you could channel your J.B. Singh, why did he still vote confidence in Trudeau government,
00:11:31 even though it wasn't going to fall because it had Bloc support?
00:11:34 I think it's because he doesn't have any money.
00:11:36 And he's still trying to talk to the base from his party that,
00:11:41 like some of the stuff he maybe tried to accomplish or accomplished under the Liberal coalition,
00:11:45 by detaching himself.
00:11:47 I mean, his numbers are staying the same, but his piggy bank isn't getting any bigger.
00:11:51 And so I think the big piece of that is to not alienate maybe part of his party that wouldn't vote Liberal
00:11:58 and would vote NDP.
00:12:00 And he's just trying to hold on to be able to rebrand.
00:12:03 I also think that if I was being strategic,
00:12:06 and I don't know if that's something that Mr. Singh is capable of,
00:12:11 but let's give him the benefit of the doubt,
00:12:13 being strategic on there's still probably some items that his caucus would like to move forward.
00:12:17 And if he shows that he's trying to be divisive and not be a quote unquote team player,
00:12:22 that there might be still room for negotiation.
00:12:24 He might know that depending on the Bloc's decision, he might have a chess piece to play.
00:12:29 So I think him not coming out of the gates, you know, demonstrating in the vote,
00:12:35 not necessarily how he feels, that he doesn't support Trudeau,
00:12:39 that he doesn't get that wiggle room to try and have further conversations
00:12:43 and leverage that relationship because he can really only go up from here,
00:12:48 from a fundraising and brand perspective.
00:12:50 I want to talk about the block.
00:12:54 It's times like this where I really kind of wish we had one ourselves.
00:12:58 I want a block too.
00:13:00 They're just so damned pragmatic. 0.91
00:13:04 And not in an ideological sense, but in a let's make a deal sense.
00:13:07 Like you could tell these guys read the art of the deal.
00:13:10 And they are willing to just say things out loud about the transactional nature of Canada
00:13:18 that no one is willing to say.
00:13:22 Because that's really what Canada has been denigrated to at this point.
00:13:25 It is a system of extortions and transfers.
00:13:32 And who can be extorted the least and transferred to the most is the winner.
00:13:36 And the block is just ruthlessly pragmatic about it.
00:13:40 They're not even saying it's a good thing or a bad thing.
00:13:42 They're saying that's the way it is and we're here to play ball.
00:13:44 The block after the Conservatives is probably the most election-ready party in Parliament.
00:13:51 They're doing okay in the polls.
00:13:53 They stand to lose some seats from the Conservatives,
00:13:55 but to pick up a fair number from the Liberals.
00:13:59 They just won a historic seat in the Verdun.
00:14:03 I don't know the rest of the name of the writing.
00:14:04 But the Verdun writing on the island of Montreal in a...
00:14:06 That seat is of Liberal royalty.
00:14:11 It is the keep of the castle.
00:14:13 It's literally got the moat, the island of Montreal, around it.
00:14:17 But some of their incumbents would lose.
00:14:19 So, I mean, that's cold comfort that, hey, you know,
00:14:21 they might net win, but those members of their caucus
00:14:23 who would lose their seats to the Conservatives,
00:14:25 they wouldn't be eager for an election.
00:14:27 But they've got at least some money in the bank.
00:14:29 They're decent in the polls.
00:14:31 They're the most election-ready after the Conservatives.
00:14:36 Nigel, maybe kind of game out how they're feeling here.
00:14:40 Because, I mean, there's a seat projection that came out today
00:14:44 that showed the Bloc Québécois forming official opposition
00:14:46 for the first time since between the period of 1993 to 1997
00:14:51 under Lucien Bouchard in their first major election.
00:14:54 The Liberals dropping to fourth place since the Accountant House of Commons.
00:14:59 They stand to pick up, but that would be in a majority government
00:15:02 where they have less leverage.
00:15:03 Maybe kind of game out for us, you know,
00:15:06 the thinking of the Bloc Québécois here.
00:15:08 Well, and I think you just gave us the clue right there in your last sentence.
00:15:13 They will no longer, they may be the official opposition,
00:15:16 but they will not have the votes that you would need
00:15:19 to actually force the government to do anything.
00:15:23 The strategy for Quebec has always been to hold to ransom the government of the day.
00:15:29 When you have a government that is as weak as today's liberal government,
00:15:34 you can actually ask for fairly big money.
00:15:38 When you don't have the votes, there's only so much you can do.
00:15:43 They are going to go for it for the next year,
00:15:46 which is one reason why I don't think there's any danger of an imminent election.
00:15:52 Because they've got 12 months to see what they can get.
00:15:57 The high likelihood is that after the next election,
00:16:00 they will not be in such a strong position
00:16:04 to demand big money be transferred from the rest of Canada to Quebec.
00:16:09 So it's really not that hard.
00:16:13 Motivations are pretty clear.
00:16:15 I guess it's funny.
00:16:17 We're talking about everyone except for the liberals.
00:16:20 They're old news.
00:16:21 They're old news.
00:16:22 They're gone.
00:16:24 It's like they're not even the government anymore.
00:16:27 Like, yeah, they're there,
00:16:28 but they're already in the terminal waiting to depart.
00:16:33 Like, we've already kind of checked them out.
00:16:36 They're the biggest party in the House of Commons at present,
00:16:39 but we're not even really talking about them
00:16:41 because they don't really have...
00:16:43 Well, they do have some cards to play, 0.98
00:16:45 and they're going to play every damn card possible 0.98
00:16:48 to do anything to stop an election. 0.98
00:16:52 I know Jen Gerson at the line, 0.99
00:16:54 you know, she's had some smart writing on this.
00:16:58 Well, to what effect?
00:17:00 What do you want this year for?
00:17:01 Or, you've...
00:17:04 It's just, I guess, a year without Polyev 1.00
00:17:08 is a contextual victory in this case, perhaps.
00:17:11 But, you know, the liberal line has become
00:17:14 that pure Polyev and the conservatives
00:17:16 only want an election for themselves.
00:17:19 Well, yeah, of course they want to be in power.
00:17:22 That's what...
00:17:23 Other than, like, the Greens,
00:17:25 that's the intent of...
00:17:26 And the Bloc Québécois.
00:17:27 That's the intent of every political party
00:17:29 that has ever existed.
00:17:30 That's why we have political parties. 0.75
00:17:33 But then I saw on...
00:17:35 I'm not sure it was maybe Vashi Capelos at Global
00:17:37 kind of turned it around on them saying,
00:17:40 well, aren't you avoiding an election
00:17:41 for your interests?
00:17:43 It's your interest to not have an election.
00:17:46 So maybe I'll get your input on this, Erica.
00:17:49 Why do you think...
00:17:53 I'm going to ask you to kind of be the Justin Trudeau whisperer here,
00:17:57 get inside his head.
00:17:59 Why do they want a year?
00:18:01 Like, why are they willing to sell out the kitchen,
00:18:05 like, throw everything at,
00:18:07 doing anything possible to avoid an election for a year?
00:18:09 What can that year give them?
00:18:11 I think that there's two parts.
00:18:15 That one is the Liberal Party
00:18:17 and one itself is Justin Trudeau.
00:18:20 And, you know, he's been doing
00:18:23 kind of a little bit of a celebrity road show
00:18:25 where I think he truly believes
00:18:28 that he can, you know, refresh his brand,
00:18:32 that he can come back and pull a 2015,
00:18:35 we like this guy for who he is,
00:18:39 even though his record is poor now,
00:18:40 but we still like him to be our spokesperson.
00:18:45 So I think that this next year
00:18:47 can maybe help him.
00:18:50 I don't know.
00:18:52 And then I think the other thing is,
00:18:54 I mean, you said it earlier,
00:18:55 they're basically fighting for a podium spot, right?
00:18:58 Like they're third or fourth.
00:19:00 And when you're in that position in your government
00:19:03 and you can control triggering an election,
00:19:05 you're never going to do that.
00:19:07 I mean, and we haven't seen a lot of
00:19:10 pull the trigger early work well.
00:19:12 We saw, you know, how Harper approached it
00:19:15 and it was the longest writ.
00:19:16 I was running a local campaign.
00:19:18 I was like, what was it?
00:19:18 65 days or something.
00:19:21 And then we saw it with Jim Prentice here.
00:19:23 Like it hasn't boded well to not play out your term.
00:19:27 I can't think of policies
00:19:29 that they want to bring forward,
00:19:31 except maybe a horrific budget
00:19:33 that they would love to then have
00:19:35 a new conservative government have to manage.
00:19:38 So it's almost like they're just trying to leave
00:19:41 little nuggets of their legacy for when they go
00:19:45 and making it harder.
00:19:47 Senate elections, I think, was a prime example
00:19:48 of making it harder for the next government,
00:19:50 not looking out for the best interest of Canadians.
00:19:53 And I think Trudeau's narcissism
00:19:55 is playing into that as well.
00:19:57 Well, I would agree, Madam Senator-elect.
00:19:58 Okay, let's switch it up to this astonishing video from CTV.
00:20:11 You know, let's just begin.
00:20:13 First, we're going to play what CTV says
00:20:18 Pierre Paulyev said.
00:20:19 That's why we need to put forward a motion.
00:20:24 Okay, now let's play the clip of what he actually said.
00:20:29 That's why it's time to put forward a motion
00:20:35 for a carbon tax election.
00:20:39 Okay, Nigel, you've been around the media business
00:20:43 for some time.
00:20:44 Less on the TV side, more, you know,
00:20:46 you come from the Congregate Herald
00:20:47 and the Western Standard.
00:20:49 I mean, it's easier to manipulate words,
00:20:53 take things out of context in print.
00:20:56 I could make you say anything
00:20:57 if I had a transcript of our time together.
00:21:00 I could splice different things.
00:21:02 It would be easier in print.
00:21:04 But it is much more difficult
00:21:08 to take video of someone here,
00:21:14 cut their sentence off here,
00:21:15 insert different sentence here
00:21:17 than a third sentence there.
00:21:20 And that's what CTV's done.
00:21:22 Media make errors.
00:21:24 We make errors.
00:21:26 But they're normally honest errors
00:21:30 and they might flow from our biases.
00:21:32 They might flow from our point of views.
00:21:34 But we don't go out of our way
00:21:37 to outright fabricate something
00:21:39 that someone never said.
00:21:41 How the hell can, you know...
00:21:47 How can they live with themselves? 0.94
00:21:49 Yeah, like how the hell
00:21:50 can something like this happen?
00:21:50 Because this is not an error.
00:21:53 This is not an error-mated goodwill
00:21:55 based off of our point of views and biases.
00:21:58 This was fabrication.
00:22:00 This is the kind of thing
00:22:01 the liberals like to pretend
00:22:03 Vladimir Putin's behind all the time in Canada.
00:22:06 This was beyond even disinformation.
00:22:10 This was fabrication entirely.
00:22:12 How the hell can something like this
00:22:13 get through a newsroom?
00:22:14 Well, it never used to happen
00:22:15 before the government started paying for newsrooms, did it?
00:22:19 Probably less frequently.
00:22:21 Less frequently.
00:22:22 Look, as long as there have been newspapers,
00:22:26 there have been people who have been interviewed
00:22:29 and said, well, I never said that.
00:22:30 I was misquoted.
00:22:32 And that's when tape recorders came into vogue.
00:22:34 That was a bit of a protection
00:22:36 for the average reporter.
00:22:39 So, yes, mistakes were made.
00:22:41 Sometimes things were made
00:22:42 that weren't even mistakes.
00:22:44 And the idea that the press
00:22:47 is slanted politically
00:22:48 in one direction or another
00:22:50 is a very old one.
00:22:51 For the 50 years
00:22:52 that I've been in the business,
00:22:53 it's been always accused
00:22:56 that the press is biased.
00:22:57 So, this is just bias,
00:23:00 but on the grand scale
00:23:01 and with a degree of sophistication
00:23:03 that we seldom see.
00:23:06 There is a...
00:23:08 There is within the profession
00:23:10 a degree of dishonesty
00:23:14 that's always been there,
00:23:16 but it's been very much enhanced
00:23:17 in recent years.
00:23:18 You asked me how this could happen.
00:23:20 Well, there are some people
00:23:22 who honestly believe
00:23:23 that as media,
00:23:25 they are part of the process.
00:23:26 If you want to see it writ large,
00:23:29 look at the coverage
00:23:30 of the United States election
00:23:32 at the moment,
00:23:33 where even people
00:23:35 who don't like Trump
00:23:37 have to admit
00:23:40 that the coverage of Trump
00:23:42 by what we refer to
00:23:45 as the mainstream media,
00:23:47 basically everybody except Fox,
00:23:49 is highly one-sided,
00:23:51 90% negative.
00:23:54 All right.
00:23:54 Well, guess what?
00:23:56 That happens in Canada, too.
00:23:58 And in the classrooms
00:24:00 at the journalism colleges today,
00:24:03 young people are taught
00:24:04 that as a journalist,
00:24:06 their job is not to get
00:24:07 both sides of the story
00:24:09 and let the reader
00:24:11 make up their mind,
00:24:12 the listener,
00:24:13 make up their own mind,
00:24:14 the watcher.
00:24:15 It is to interpret the news.
00:24:18 Now, we had this...
00:24:19 I had an issue
00:24:19 this time last year,
00:24:21 you may recall,
00:24:22 from remarks
00:24:22 at the prayer breakfast,
00:24:24 which were literally taken
00:24:27 and out of context
00:24:29 and inaccurately reported.
00:24:32 Nobody actually cut
00:24:33 and spliced pieces of tape
00:24:37 to make it sound like
00:24:38 I said something
00:24:39 I didn't say,
00:24:40 but they certainly judiciously cut
00:24:43 and moved things around
00:24:46 to...
00:24:48 That was global.
00:24:49 That was global.
00:24:50 What was the reporter's name again?
00:24:52 You know, I...
00:24:52 I want to shame him.
00:24:53 You're nice. 0.54
00:24:54 I want to shame him.
00:24:56 I'm sorry.
00:24:57 It's the old man thing. 0.99
00:24:58 I can't remember.
00:25:01 I'm going to chalk it up
00:25:02 to you being a nicer guy.
00:25:03 All right.
00:25:03 Chalk it up to me,
00:25:04 but at any rate,
00:25:06 I do believe he now works
00:25:08 for Mayor Gondek,
00:25:10 so there's your clue.
00:25:13 Anyway, look,
00:25:15 all I'm...
00:25:16 This is a real bad one,
00:25:17 the fake Polyev quote.
00:25:20 It is a really bad one,
00:25:21 and I just wish people
00:25:23 in the media
00:25:24 would understand
00:25:26 that nobody respects them.
00:25:28 They haven't respected them
00:25:30 for years.
00:25:31 We're, as a profession,
00:25:33 we're down there
00:25:34 with car salesmen
00:25:35 who actually,
00:25:37 in my experience,
00:25:38 have turned out
00:25:38 to be a good deal
00:25:39 more ethical
00:25:40 than some of the people
00:25:42 we're talking about now,
00:25:44 and there is a reason
00:25:47 why people are going
00:25:49 to alternative sources.
00:25:50 They don't trust
00:25:51 the old mainstream media,
00:25:53 and this is exactly
00:25:54 the kind of thing
00:25:55 which is going to push
00:25:56 them further away.
00:25:58 Erica,
00:25:59 I'd like your thoughts
00:26:00 on the fabrication here,
00:26:03 but maybe also
00:26:04 you're kind of zooming out
00:26:07 a bit about
00:26:08 the broader consequences
00:26:09 this might have
00:26:10 for the legacy
00:26:11 in mainstream media.
00:26:13 You know, Polyev.
00:26:16 The next election,
00:26:19 the media are going
00:26:20 to know
00:26:20 that if one side wins,
00:26:23 they're probably
00:26:23 going to lose their job 0.98
00:26:24 when he kills 0.98
00:26:26 the English CBC 1.00
00:26:27 and kills
00:26:28 the media subsidies.
00:26:29 Most of these guys
00:26:30 are going to literally
00:26:31 lose their job
00:26:32 or keep their job
00:26:33 depending on the outcome
00:26:34 of an election.
00:26:35 That's a pretty impossible
00:26:37 spot for a reporter
00:26:38 to be in
00:26:39 and do a fair job.
00:26:41 So maybe you want
00:26:42 to talk your thoughts
00:26:43 about this fabrication
00:26:45 from CTV,
00:26:46 but then also maybe
00:26:47 the broader effect
00:26:48 this might have.
00:26:49 Like what we'll see
00:26:50 in the next election.
00:26:51 So yeah,
00:26:51 I'll start with,
00:26:52 first off,
00:26:53 I think you guys
00:26:54 missed this opportunity
00:26:54 to say like,
00:26:55 this is something
00:26:56 I would expect
00:26:57 from the CBC,
00:26:58 not CTV.
00:26:59 I think they can do better.
00:27:01 But when it comes
00:27:02 to how this works,
00:27:03 because you've asked
00:27:04 me to put the hat
00:27:05 on a few times
00:27:06 of the other side,
00:27:08 I started doing that
00:27:08 as Nigel was kind
00:27:09 of sharing,
00:27:10 you know,
00:27:11 I think a very good point.
00:27:13 But if they're looking
00:27:15 at it,
00:27:16 I'm like,
00:27:17 okay,
00:27:17 they would argue,
00:27:18 but like attack ads
00:27:19 do this,
00:27:20 political parties do this.
00:27:22 We see,
00:27:23 you know,
00:27:23 this whole purpose
00:27:24 of quoting,
00:27:25 they did say this,
00:27:26 you know,
00:27:26 and then that argument.
00:27:27 When it comes to like
00:27:28 other strategies
00:27:29 outside of journalism,
00:27:30 which has its own ethics,
00:27:32 you know,
00:27:32 even if they were like,
00:27:33 well,
00:27:33 in the 2023 election,
00:27:35 you guys were all taking,
00:27:36 you know,
00:27:36 one line that if you look
00:27:38 at it in context,
00:27:39 means something
00:27:40 totally different.
00:27:42 Yes,
00:27:42 but those are campaign strategies.
00:27:44 And I think that,
00:27:45 again,
00:27:45 journalists should be held
00:27:47 to a higher standard.
00:27:49 And that this is kind of,
00:27:51 you know,
00:27:51 again,
00:27:51 embarrassing.
00:27:52 It's not something
00:27:53 that I think CTV
00:27:54 or in Nigel's case,
00:27:55 Global should do slicing up. 1.00
00:27:57 Even political parties
00:27:58 don't do that.
00:27:59 You don't slice up a video
00:28:01 to get a different story outcome.
00:28:03 You might pull one line
00:28:04 and use that,
00:28:06 that in the,
00:28:07 you know,
00:28:08 the paragraph
00:28:08 may have a different resonation,
00:28:10 but that is their words
00:28:12 and that is in the order
00:28:13 in which they said that.
00:28:14 So it's even below
00:28:15 like an attack ad
00:28:17 that people criticize,
00:28:19 you know,
00:28:19 becomes too dirty
00:28:20 or too dark
00:28:21 or it's a different type
00:28:21 of politics.
00:28:22 So,
00:28:23 you know,
00:28:23 journalists are supposed
00:28:24 to be rising above
00:28:25 and they're going even
00:28:26 beneath that.
00:28:27 So shameful.
00:28:28 I just want to say that.
00:28:29 On the strategy,
00:28:30 I think that,
00:28:32 you know,
00:28:32 the conservatives
00:28:33 are used to it
00:28:34 and need to know
00:28:35 that when it comes
00:28:36 to how are journalists
00:28:37 going to play out
00:28:39 this next election.
00:28:40 They obviously,
00:28:42 we've learned
00:28:42 that the mainstream media
00:28:43 doesn't remove their bias
00:28:45 to tell the story
00:28:46 so that viewers
00:28:47 can come up
00:28:47 with their own.
00:28:48 So I do think
00:28:49 it's a big opportunity
00:28:50 for,
00:28:51 shameless plug,
00:28:52 my podcast
00:28:53 called The Discourse
00:28:54 that talks about
00:28:55 those types of things
00:28:55 as well as the pipeline
00:28:56 and all the
00:28:57 Cory Mortgage,
00:28:58 you know,
00:28:58 Nigel's show,
00:28:59 all of these types
00:29:00 of alternative media
00:29:01 that,
00:29:03 you know what,
00:29:03 sometimes we have our bias,
00:29:05 but we're clear about it.
00:29:07 And that's what I think,
00:29:08 or you can play devil's advocate
00:29:10 and criticize,
00:29:12 you know,
00:29:12 both your side
00:29:13 and the other side,
00:29:14 but give people
00:29:15 the opportunity
00:29:16 to truly come up
00:29:17 with their own conclusions
00:29:19 without jamming it
00:29:20 down their throats
00:29:21 or misleading people.
00:29:23 So I think that
00:29:24 you're going to see
00:29:25 the traditional media
00:29:27 get very biased
00:29:29 in how they are
00:29:30 reporting the next election
00:29:32 for Canadians.
00:29:33 I think that
00:29:34 they're getting kind of
00:29:34 sick of it.
00:29:35 They're seeing that
00:29:36 clear correlation
00:29:37 to the left
00:29:38 and starting,
00:29:39 that's why we've seen
00:29:40 such an uptick
00:29:40 of alternative media
00:29:42 outlets,
00:29:42 especially to get
00:29:43 the right side message out.
00:29:46 And I do think that,
00:29:48 you know,
00:29:48 as Canadians,
00:29:49 I just hope people
00:29:50 do more research
00:29:51 than read a headline
00:29:51 or do more research
00:29:53 than like find one article
00:29:54 and that we do see
00:29:56 the opposite,
00:29:57 maybe a benefit
00:29:58 of the divisiveness
00:29:59 in society
00:30:00 where people are actually
00:30:00 educating themselves
00:30:02 more than they have
00:30:03 to be able to truly
00:30:04 understand an issue,
00:30:05 a party's position
00:30:06 and all of that
00:30:07 going forward.
00:30:08 But I don't think
00:30:09 the Conservatives
00:30:09 are going to be
00:30:11 leveraging mainstream media
00:30:12 to get their message
00:30:13 out this election.
00:30:14 We'll see more
00:30:14 of the type of communication
00:30:16 that Pierre has done
00:30:17 so well.
00:30:19 Okay.
00:30:20 All right.
00:30:20 Well, let's,
00:30:21 we're going to bring
00:30:21 a little closer
00:30:22 to home here
00:30:22 in Alberta.
00:30:25 Yesterday,
00:30:26 Alberta Premier
00:30:26 Danielle Smith
00:30:27 announcing,
00:30:30 well,
00:30:31 what we've known
00:30:31 is coming
00:30:32 for some time,
00:30:33 a new Alberta
00:30:34 Bill of Rights.
00:30:36 Alberta's had 0.61
00:30:37 a Bill of Rights
00:30:37 for a long time.
00:30:38 I believe
00:30:38 the first one
00:30:39 was brought in
00:30:41 under Peter Lougheed.
00:30:43 It effectively forms
00:30:45 a part of the
00:30:46 provincial constitution.
00:30:48 Many,
00:30:48 I think all the provinces
00:30:49 have these
00:30:50 to some extent.
00:30:50 And the provincial
00:30:51 constitutions are,
00:30:53 they resemble
00:30:54 more the British
00:30:55 constitution
00:30:55 that it's
00:30:56 both unwritten
00:30:57 and a series
00:30:58 of documents
00:30:59 that make up
00:31:00 a constellation,
00:31:02 a constitutional
00:31:03 constellation,
00:31:03 if you will.
00:31:05 So this would
00:31:06 have no effect
00:31:07 on federal laws
00:31:08 in Alberta,
00:31:09 but it would
00:31:09 certainly,
00:31:10 it trumps
00:31:12 all other
00:31:12 provincial statute.
00:31:13 statute.
00:31:15 So,
00:31:15 you know,
00:31:15 already there's,
00:31:16 the current
00:31:18 Bill of Rights
00:31:18 as it stands
00:31:19 is very similar
00:31:20 to the Federal
00:31:21 Charter of Rights
00:31:22 and Freedoms.
00:31:24 But this one
00:31:24 is going to,
00:31:25 this one's going
00:31:26 to beef it up
00:31:27 now.
00:31:28 This is,
00:31:29 you know,
00:31:29 very much a nod
00:31:30 to basic rights
00:31:32 violations coming
00:31:33 from the COVID
00:31:34 era.
00:31:36 Our crack judges
00:31:38 in Canada did
00:31:38 not seem to
00:31:39 think that,
00:31:40 you know,
00:31:42 sovereignty of the
00:31:42 person in many
00:31:43 cases had anything
00:31:44 to do with the
00:31:44 right on whether
00:31:45 they take a medical
00:31:46 treatment or not.
00:31:46 So that's going
00:31:47 to be put quite
00:31:48 explicitly into
00:31:48 here.
00:31:49 That is,
00:31:50 freedom in
00:31:51 medical decisions,
00:31:53 whether they take
00:31:53 a vaccine,
00:31:54 that kind of thing,
00:31:55 the right to
00:31:55 refuse treatments.
00:31:57 It is going to
00:31:58 include something
00:31:58 that has long
00:32:00 been called for
00:32:00 to be included
00:32:01 in the Federal,
00:32:02 the Canadian
00:32:02 Charter of Rights
00:32:03 and Freedoms.
00:32:04 That is property
00:32:04 rights.
00:32:05 It's a fundamental
00:32:06 right that was,
00:32:08 I was going to
00:32:08 say inexplicably,
00:32:09 but I think we
00:32:10 would have our
00:32:10 suspicions about
00:32:11 why Peter Trudeau
00:32:12 really did not
00:32:13 want property
00:32:13 rights included.
00:32:15 But this is
00:32:15 going to include
00:32:16 property rights
00:32:17 and the right
00:32:18 to not have it
00:32:19 deprived without
00:32:19 proper due
00:32:21 process at the
00:32:22 courts, etc.
00:32:24 And this one
00:32:26 was rumored
00:32:27 to be in,
00:32:28 and I just
00:32:30 didn't think
00:32:31 they had the
00:32:32 political gonads
00:32:33 to do it,
00:32:34 but I was
00:32:35 pleasantly wrong.
00:32:37 Gun rights. 0.90
00:32:38 This will be
00:32:38 the first formal
00:32:40 expression of
00:32:41 gun rights in
00:32:42 a Charter of
00:32:43 Rights or Bill
00:32:44 of Rights in
00:32:45 Canadian history.
00:32:46 I mean,
00:32:49 some would say
00:32:49 that's kind of
00:32:50 a part of
00:32:50 property rights
00:32:51 as a part
00:32:52 of the right
00:32:52 to life
00:32:54 and personal
00:32:55 freedoms,
00:32:55 but the courts
00:32:56 have been less
00:32:57 generous in
00:32:58 their interpretations.
00:33:00 This is going
00:33:00 to put it in,
00:33:01 not using quite
00:33:01 the American
00:33:02 language of
00:33:02 right to bear
00:33:03 arms as a
00:33:03 part of a
00:33:04 well-regulated
00:33:04 militia,
00:33:05 but I don't
00:33:07 have the exact
00:33:07 text in front
00:33:07 of me,
00:33:08 but it's the
00:33:09 right to safely
00:33:10 own, acquire,
00:33:10 and use firearms,
00:33:12 which is pretty 0.93
00:33:15 damn, it's a lot 0.96
00:33:16 better than, I 0.99
00:33:19 didn't expect them
00:33:19 to do it at all
00:33:20 because, while I
00:33:21 know they've been
00:33:23 taking some courageous
00:33:23 positions on a few
00:33:24 things, this one,
00:33:26 oh, the late, the
00:33:28 government-funded
00:33:29 media is losing its 0.98
00:33:31 bloody mind, Nigel. 0.99
00:33:32 Well, and we're
00:33:34 just finding ours,
00:33:36 aren't we?
00:33:37 My word.
00:33:38 They are, no,
00:33:40 this is an
00:33:42 extraordinary
00:33:42 document.
00:33:44 We haven't seen
00:33:45 the legislative
00:33:46 details yet, but
00:33:47 looking at the
00:33:48 statement that the
00:33:50 premier released
00:33:51 yesterday, it is
00:33:53 a very strong
00:33:55 statement of
00:33:57 personal belief on
00:33:59 her part, I'm
00:34:00 sure, and the
00:34:01 reason that I'm
00:34:02 sure she made,
00:34:03 she very gallantly
00:34:04 made reference to
00:34:05 old discussions we'd
00:34:07 had 20 years ago
00:34:08 when we were on the
00:34:08 editorial board at
00:34:10 the Calgary Herald
00:34:10 and chose to
00:34:12 remember that, and
00:34:13 you know, so much
00:34:14 of what I see
00:34:15 coming from her
00:34:16 generally, but
00:34:17 also specifically
00:34:18 in this rewrite
00:34:19 of the, or these
00:34:21 amendments, it's not
00:34:22 a rewrite, these
00:34:22 amendments are
00:34:24 things that have
00:34:24 been on her mind
00:34:26 in one form or
00:34:27 another for a very
00:34:27 long time.
00:34:29 So I know she's
00:34:30 absolutely sincere
00:34:31 about it, but
00:34:32 because there is a
00:34:33 tendency for people
00:34:34 to say, well, she's
00:34:35 got to do that for
00:34:35 the people who
00:34:36 supported her, you
00:34:37 know, during the
00:34:38 leadership campaign
00:34:39 or whatever.
00:34:40 No, this is what
00:34:41 she really thinks.
00:34:42 She does believe in
00:34:43 property rights.
00:34:44 She was in the
00:34:45 property rights
00:34:45 business before she
00:34:46 was ever in the
00:34:48 politics business,
00:34:49 and now we're going
00:34:50 back nearly 30
00:34:51 years.
00:34:51 and she was, and with
00:34:55 the gun rights, she 0.51
00:34:56 honestly believes that
00:34:58 people should be free
00:34:59 as long as they're not
00:35:00 criminals, to own, keep
00:35:02 and safely store and
00:35:03 use firearms.
00:35:05 Why not?
00:35:06 I mean, it's a free
00:35:06 country, right?
00:35:07 We say that, a free
00:35:08 country, but in so many
00:35:10 ways it's not, and it
00:35:11 would be less so if the
00:35:12 federal government had
00:35:13 its way.
00:35:14 This is, the thing
00:35:15 about this is going to
00:35:16 send a message to the
00:35:17 rest of the country, it's
00:35:19 going to encourage other
00:35:20 people to think like us
00:35:21 and some possibilities
00:35:23 pushing back against
00:35:24 Ottawa to say, no, you
00:35:26 just can't do this.
00:35:27 You can't mandate people
00:35:29 to have a vaccine, you
00:35:30 can't take away guns, and
00:35:32 you can't build a highway
00:35:33 through my backyard.
00:35:36 Erica, this is a big
00:35:41 deal.
00:35:41 It's not going to stop
00:35:42 federal intrusions, and
00:35:43 the federal government
00:35:44 can violate, is a huge
00:35:46 violator of gun rights,
00:35:47 but the province has
00:35:49 taken direct control
00:35:50 from the, of the office
00:35:52 of the chief firearms
00:35:52 officer, which is
00:35:55 essentially the
00:35:56 application of the law.
00:35:58 And I'd say that's been
00:36:00 pretty successful for gun
00:36:02 owners in Alberta.
00:36:03 It's been, it's been an
00:36:04 absolute coup.
00:36:05 It was, you know, you
00:36:08 know, out of the good,
00:36:09 the good things and the
00:36:10 bad things of the, of the
00:36:11 Kennedy government, this
00:36:12 one's got to be at the
00:36:13 absolute, near the top of
00:36:15 the good things that it
00:36:16 was able to achieve.
00:36:17 Um, but I, I mean, on
00:36:21 the one hand, I'd say, uh,
00:36:23 the whole thing, not
00:36:24 just the guns, but the
00:36:25 entire thing, this is an
00:36:26 act of bravery, but on
00:36:28 the other side, there's
00:36:30 political danger here.
00:36:31 This is going to be, I
00:36:33 mean, this is going to
00:36:34 make heads explode.
00:36:36 We don't have the actual
00:36:36 text of the legislation
00:36:37 yet, but I think we got a
00:36:38 pretty good idea from the
00:36:39 premier's, uh, speech
00:36:40 yesterday.
00:36:41 Um, maybe you want to
00:36:43 weigh in on the balance
00:36:45 here of political bravery
00:36:47 and delivering something
00:36:48 that I, I think, I think
00:36:49 she genuinely believes in
00:36:50 and that her base, I
00:36:52 think very much is going
00:36:53 to be pleased by, but on
00:36:55 the other hand, uh, you
00:36:58 know, the, the, the
00:36:58 political dangers here
00:37:00 and have the legacy media
00:37:02 unanimously against her
00:37:03 and, you know, all, all the
00:37:05 usual pearl clutching
00:37:07 groups and individuals that
00:37:09 you would expect.
00:37:09 Um, yeah, so I think that
00:37:12 to your point, this is, this
00:37:15 is a communication and a
00:37:17 change of something she's
00:37:18 talked about for a long
00:37:19 time.
00:37:19 Like Nigel dates back, you
00:37:21 know, years, but she ran on 0.81
00:37:22 this, she ran on reviewing
00:37:23 and what started out and
00:37:25 just want to remind people
00:37:26 is the human rights
00:37:27 infringement on COVID, um, and
00:37:29 the vaccinations.
00:37:30 And so she expanded that,
00:37:31 which I actually think gives
00:37:33 her a little bit more
00:37:34 political run, uh, runway
00:37:35 because it wasn't just
00:37:37 about changing it for
00:37:38 COVID.
00:37:38 It's like, well, if we're
00:37:39 going to open up the human
00:37:40 rights act, let's open up
00:37:41 the whole thing.
00:37:42 And in there, I think, as
00:37:44 we all know, when you amend
00:37:45 a bill, you amend it
00:37:46 because it is no longer
00:37:48 relevant to the time or
00:37:50 there's something that
00:37:50 happened.
00:37:51 A lot of these things are
00:37:52 actually responses to what
00:37:53 the Trudeau government has
00:37:55 done, the gun buyback and,
00:37:56 and, you know, attacking gun
00:37:58 owners, property rights has
00:37:59 been a longstanding issue in
00:38:01 Alberta.
00:38:01 And we've seen the federal
00:38:02 government infringe on
00:38:03 those rights.
00:38:04 Like these are in the
00:38:05 Charter of Rights and
00:38:06 Freedoms and the
00:38:06 Constitution.
00:38:07 Like they're, they're
00:38:08 coming into our
00:38:09 jurisdiction and that we
00:38:11 are a province, strong and
00:38:13 free is, you know, um, our,
00:38:15 our motto that in the
00:38:17 fundamental freedoms that
00:38:18 we had and are in the,
00:38:21 the Charter of Rights and
00:38:21 Freedoms are now being
00:38:22 attacked and challenged.
00:38:24 So I think the amendments
00:38:25 and the timing, whether
00:38:26 it's on your choice of
00:38:28 vaccination, you know,
00:38:30 whether you got one or
00:38:30 not, I think you being able
00:38:32 to choose if you should get
00:38:34 a vaccination.
00:38:35 Most people can agree with
00:38:37 from that fundamental
00:38:39 freedom of choice.
00:38:40 Uh, when it comes to the,
00:38:42 the property rights, again,
00:38:44 we've seen it in Saskatchewan
00:38:45 and, and Alberta where the
00:38:47 federal government is going
00:38:48 outside of their reach.
00:38:49 They're coming in.
00:38:50 Uh, we've seen Premier Scott
00:38:52 Moe take some pretty good 0.95
00:38:54 stances on that as well as,
00:38:55 uh, the, the, uh, that we
00:38:59 are not like the United States.
00:39:00 Punishing gun owners is not
00:39:02 going to remove the crime of
00:39:04 people that illegally have guns
00:39:06 in this country and are
00:39:08 shooting people in downtown
00:39:09 Toronto. 0.74
00:39:09 Like that is all things that I
00:39:12 think as an Albertan, they, if
00:39:15 you break it down that I, I
00:39:16 really don't think if you come
00:39:17 it back to freedoms and your
00:39:19 ability to choose, and that we
00:39:21 do have good regulations in
00:39:22 place to protect some of the,
00:39:24 the things that will be
00:39:25 fear-mongered.
00:39:26 I think most people in common
00:39:27 sense can understand why these
00:39:29 three things came out of the
00:39:31 review and that it wasn't once
00:39:32 upon a time, it was about COVID
00:39:34 and this premier took a, uh, like
00:39:37 you said, uh, an aggressive move
00:39:39 to address it, but she's
00:39:39 addressing it holistically.
00:39:41 So even at that point, I think
00:39:43 people should appreciate that it
00:39:45 was more than what she campaigned
00:39:46 on.
00:39:47 Absolutely.
00:39:48 She's can't go ahead.
00:39:48 Nigel jump in.
00:39:49 No, no, no, no.
00:39:50 I want you to finish.
00:39:51 Well, we actually, we know we
00:39:52 actually have to, we got to wrap
00:39:54 it there and move on to, uh,
00:39:55 I was going to say though, I
00:39:57 just want to add though, that I
00:39:59 think that it, she is speaking
00:40:01 to her base.
00:40:02 She's got a leadership review
00:40:03 before she's got another
00:40:05 election.
00:40:05 So, and then in two years of
00:40:07 Amanda, you put a lot of tough
00:40:08 things through in your first two
00:40:09 years.
00:40:10 So as she does that, the people
00:40:12 that are hate, this are going to
00:40:13 hate it.
00:40:14 And they were always going to hate
00:40:15 it.
00:40:15 You're going to, the ones that are
00:40:16 lighting their hair on fire had
00:40:17 their, their lighter ready, um,
00:40:20 when Danielle Smith became
00:40:22 premier.
00:40:22 So I don't think it's going to
00:40:23 change anything outside of some
00:40:26 loud noise that we're going to
00:40:27 have to listen to, but these
00:40:29 people were never going to
00:40:30 support it, whether it was just
00:40:31 about COVID or in the
00:40:32 comprehensive way we see it.
00:40:34 All right.
00:40:34 Thank you.
00:40:35 All right.
00:40:36 Well, we're going to move to our
00:40:38 new ending segment, parting
00:40:41 shots.
00:40:42 Uh, we're going to go first to
00:40:43 Nigel.
00:40:44 So you, you, you can follow
00:40:45 along, get the, get the spirit of
00:40:47 things, uh, Erica.
00:40:48 Sounds good.
00:40:48 Nigel, your parting shot.
00:40:49 My parting shot, well, actually I
00:40:50 have two.
00:40:51 One is watch my interview with.
00:40:53 I didn't say you could have two.
00:40:54 Well, I made an executive decision.
00:40:57 I get to do that.
00:40:58 I'm the opinion editor.
00:40:59 Right.
00:40:59 So look, um, watch my podcast with,
00:41:02 uh, premier Smith about the, uh, about
00:41:04 the, uh, it's the Hannaford show.
00:41:06 Okay.
00:41:07 Second one is got to do with the
00:41:09 story.
00:41:09 It came out of Toronto about
00:41:11 teachers who took their students,
00:41:13 grades seven, eight, and nine to, with
00:41:16 permission of parents believing that
00:41:20 they were going to, a demonstration
00:41:22 to do with water on Indian reserves.
00:41:29 They wanted better water.
00:41:31 The parents signed and said, sure, I'm
00:41:32 in favor of that.
00:41:33 My kid can attend the protest and watch.
00:41:36 And then they ended up down there and
00:41:37 the kids were told to wear blue
00:41:39 pullovers to signify that they
00:41:42 recognize themselves as colonialists
00:41:45 and oppressors.
00:41:46 And then the next thing was that they
00:41:47 were chanting pro Palestine
00:41:49 slogans and were just the play
00:41:53 things of the teachers to pursue
00:41:55 their own wretched personal policies.
00:42:00 That's wrong. 0.75
00:42:01 There needs to be a sacking day.
00:42:03 And also coming back to the subject of
00:42:07 the, what we were talking about earlier,
00:42:08 losing trust in things.
00:42:09 This is how people lose trust in the
00:42:12 education system.
00:42:14 It's just one incident, but you hear
00:42:15 about this kind of thing so frequently.
00:42:17 And it's why right here in Alberta,
00:42:19 probably 20% of the students would be
00:42:22 out of the public system if they could
00:42:24 only get there as it is probably about
00:42:27 12% or outside it.
00:42:29 So trust is, trust is broken and it
00:42:31 can't be easily repaired.
00:42:33 All right.
00:42:33 Erica, you get one parting shot.
00:42:36 Okay.
00:42:37 Mine is, you know, this frustration I
00:42:40 have with the left using the term
00:42:42 inclusive and it's getting really sick
00:42:45 and, you know, an old buzzword because
00:42:47 it's actually the most exclusive club
00:42:49 you can be a part of.
00:42:51 And I think of how the trans individual
00:42:55 that was, has, you know, sent their
00:42:57 video with Jennifer Johnson, MLA for
00:43:00 Lacombe Pinocca viral saying that this
00:43:02 woman is a bigot. 1.00
00:43:03 She does this and that. 0.98
00:43:04 And the outset was this trans person 0.99
00:43:06 asking for Jennifer Johnson before even
00:43:09 engaging in conversation to declare that
00:43:13 a, like a trans woman is a woman. 1.00
00:43:17 And to me, that's not about being
00:43:19 inclusive.
00:43:19 Inclusive is truly being open-minded,
00:43:23 listening to the other side, respectfully
00:43:25 disagreeing.
00:43:26 Something that Jennifer kept coming back
00:43:28 to was like, well, can we respectfully
00:43:29 disagree on this and continue our
00:43:31 conversation?
00:43:32 I'd like to hear your story, et cetera.
00:43:34 And instead the left just went off, you
00:43:37 know, in a tyrant that Jennifer hasn't
00:43:39 learned and she shouldn't come back to
00:43:41 caucus.
00:43:41 And it all comes back to them using this
00:43:43 term about it's inclusive.
00:43:45 It's to create this inclusive space.
00:43:47 But to me, that is the exact opposite of
00:43:49 inclusivity.
00:43:50 It's excluding Jennifer because she may not
00:43:52 agree with someone, but that doesn't mean
00:43:54 she wasn't there to be open and listen and
00:43:56 hear that person.
00:43:57 So it's something that gets me really
00:44:00 fired up, as you can tell.
00:44:01 And I think that the left could learn
00:44:03 from how we're maybe a little bit more
00:44:04 tolerant with other views than our own.
00:44:07 All right.
00:44:08 And my parting short and sweet, if you've
00:44:12 got the stomach for it, make sure you
00:44:14 watch Justin Trudeau's slow pitch
00:44:18 love-in with Stephen Colbert.
00:44:20 It's painful to watch, but I love, I like
00:44:24 hate watching.
00:44:25 I love hate reading.
00:44:27 It was something to behold.
00:44:30 I think Colbert was briefed very vaguely
00:44:34 that Justin Trudeau's not very popular
00:44:36 anymore.
00:44:37 I think he's, I think maybe that briefing
00:44:40 was a bit gentle, though, that he is
00:44:43 outright, almost universally loathed in
00:44:45 Canada now, even among his own party.
00:44:47 But these, these just slow pitch
00:44:50 questions saying, you know, with the
00:44:53 rise of fascism around the world, and
00:44:55 you know, you've got your own Trump
00:44:56 far-right guy in the Conservative Party.
00:44:59 What are you doing, Justin Trudeau, to
00:45:01 stop Canada from becoming as bad as
00:45:05 America? 0.97
00:45:06 And it was just sickening.
00:45:09 But I love, hate watching stuff like
00:45:11 this, because I remember when Stephen
00:45:14 Colbert would do a great job being a
00:45:16 pretend Bill O'Reilly right-wing
00:45:18 pundit.
00:45:19 That was funny.
00:45:20 That was comedy.
00:45:21 But Stephen Colbert is, I think, Steve
00:45:23 being a comedian a long time ago.
00:45:24 He's just another pompous, far-left,
00:45:27 late-night host.
00:45:28 So it's too bad.
00:45:30 All right, that's my parting shot.
00:45:32 Nigel, Erica, it's been a slice.
00:45:35 Really appreciate you joining us as a
00:45:38 guest on the show today.
00:45:39 Added a little colour, one less old
00:45:42 white guy.
00:45:44 Always happy to be that person.
00:45:46 All right.
00:45:46 And thank you all for joining us this
00:45:48 evening.
00:45:48 If you're not yet a member of the
00:45:50 Western Standard, what's wrong with
00:45:51 you?
00:45:52 The Western Standard is one of the
00:45:53 very, very last media in Canada not
00:45:56 taking Justin Trudeau's federal media
00:45:59 subsidy.
00:46:00 We rely on advertising and membership
00:46:02 subscriptions from people like you.
00:46:04 Go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:46:07 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year to
00:46:10 get past the paywall and get unlimited
00:46:11 access to all Western Standard content.
00:46:14 You'll, I'm sure you're going to love
00:46:16 it and you'll be supporting one of the
00:46:18 last free media outlets left in Canada.
00:46:21 Thank you very much for joining us today
00:46:23 and God bless.
00:46:25 You can become a Western Standard member
00:46:26 for just $10 a month or $99 a year for
00:46:29 unlimited access.
00:46:30 Thanks for joining us.
00:46:34 Thanks for joining us today.
00:46:35 Bye.
00:46:37 Thank you very much.
00:46:39 Bye.
00:46:40 Bye.
00:46:40 Bye.
00:46:41 Bye.
00:46:42 Bye.
00:46:43 Bye.
00:46:43 Bye.
00:46:43 Bye.
00:46:44 Bye.
00:46:45 Bye.
00:46:45 Bye.
00:46:46 Bye.
00:46:47 Bye.
00:46:47 Bye.
00:46:47 Bye.
00:46:47 Bye.
00:46:48 Bye.
00:46:48 Bye.
00:46:49 Bye.
00:46:49 Bye.
00:46:49 Bye.
00:46:50 Bye.
00:46:50 Bye.
00:46:51 Bye.
00:46:51 Bye.
00:46:52 Bye.
00:46:53 Bye.
00:46:53 Bye.
00:46:54 Bye.
00:46:54 Bye.
00:46:55 Bye.
00:46:55 Bye.
00:46:55 Bye.
00:46:56 Bye.
00:46:56 Bye.
00:46:57 Bye.
00:46:57 Bye.
00:46:58 Bye.
00:46:58 Bye.
00:46:59 Bye.