Western Standard - July 17, 2025


NDP faces financial apocalypse

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
What remains? Inside Dr. Frances Widdowson's expedition to Kamloops Can independence solve Alberta's 'Ottawa problem?'

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

173.93

Word count

8,784

Sentence count

434

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard Opinion Editor Nigel Hannaford and Editor-in-Chief Corey Morgan join host Derek Fildebrand and Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan to discuss the break-up of the United Conservative Party of Canada (UCP) and the push for Alberta independence from Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Today, today is July 16th, 2025.
00:00:29 I'm Derek Fildebrand, publisher of the Western Standard
00:00:32 And you're watching The Pipeline
00:00:33 I'm joined by our usual posse
00:00:37 Western Standard Opinion Editor, Nigel Hannaford
00:00:39 Good to be here, Art
00:00:40 And Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist, Corey Morgan
00:00:44 Good afternoon, evening
00:00:45 We've dropped the cosplay cowboy garbs
00:00:49 Back to our regular office suits here
00:00:52 You guys had a good stampede?
00:00:54 The best, is that right?
00:00:56 Yeah
00:00:56 I think I'm finally old
00:00:58 i took it slow this year i just um yeah first year i wasn't like free beer i was like oh no 0.62
00:01:07 more free beer shit a lot of events yeah yeah okay no it's a great time you know everybody's 0.56
00:01:14 happy it's good mood about the place it is all right i'm 100 stampede yeah right um all right 0.97
00:01:22 Well, the NDP, the federal NDP, is facing total and complete financial apocalypse following its defeat in the spring federal election.
00:01:36 There's all sorts of reasons now why that party faces bankruptcy.
00:01:41 Could it be the actual end of the federal NDP?
00:01:44 It's not as crazy as an idea as you might think.
00:01:47 uh alberta concern uh this is a scoop in the western standard alberta ucp members uh at the
00:01:56 constituency level have put forward a ton of policy resolutions to be debated at the party's
00:02:03 next convention coming in november to uh make the ucp officially a supporting uh make the ucp
00:02:11 officially support Alberta independence.
00:02:14 That would be a pretty radical change for a nominally federalist party to be making.
00:02:21 So we're going to be talking about what's happening there and what that's going to mean
00:02:24 within the conservative party, the conservative movement in Alberta, and the independence
00:02:29 movement as the Venn diagram shrinks ever closer over top, as they become closer, at
00:02:36 least to one and the same.
00:02:37 We're going to start first with Danielle Smith's roadshow.
00:02:41 I think those things will dovetail nicely into each other.
00:02:44 Nigel, Danielle Smith hit the road last night, I think, in a red deer.
00:02:49 In a red deer it was, with 450 people attending.
00:02:52 Very well populated.
00:02:55 So last month, the Premier announced a province-wide consultation
00:02:59 to gather public input, as she put it,
00:03:02 on how to strengthen Alberta's autonomy
00:03:05 and redefine its role in Canada.
00:03:08 Now, I say as she put it
00:03:09 because although she's seeking public input,
00:03:14 she is also delivering a message.
00:03:17 And she is inviting people, I think,
00:03:21 to tell her how much they agree with her
00:03:23 when it comes to things like the Alberta pension plan,
00:03:29 immigration, the provincial police force.
00:03:32 And frankly, this is what I've got a special heart for, is whether Alberta should collect income taxes and send what is due to Ottawa or continue with the same process where Ottawa collects it and gives us what we think we should have.
00:03:49 um quebec collects its own income taxes this is an idea worth pursuing because it just once more
00:03:58 demonstrates the uh you know the uniqueness of the in quebec's case of quebec and it could be
00:04:05 for alberta anyway the meeting quickly turned to independence alberta independence and i don't
00:04:16 imagine the premium was disappointed by that
00:04:18 but building the case for a strong
00:04:20 Alberta, including independents
00:04:22 if necessary, to strengthen her hand
00:04:24 when she comes to deal with the
00:04:26 federal government
00:04:27 as she must in due course because the six
00:04:30 months that she gave Mr. Kearney
00:04:32 is starting to get
00:04:34 a little bit close.
00:04:36 That was last night
00:04:38 in Red Deer. Tonight, as we speak,
00:04:40 it's in Edmonton.
00:04:42 You're not going to go through that whole list, are you?
00:04:43 No. How do you know? I mean, the people in
00:04:46 Fort McMurray probably care, but they're taking a hiatus for about a month.
00:04:51 Edmonton, Scarbury, Lloyd-Bennister, that's the August show,
00:04:56 Medicine Ad, Lethbridge and Airdrie in September, Grand Prairie too,
00:05:00 back to Calvary for later in September.
00:05:03 So, look, these are actually quite important meetings,
00:05:05 and I would urge people to pay attention to what's being said,
00:05:10 and maybe go to one if you can.
00:05:11 uh cory a lot of people have i think fairly compared this to jason kenney's fair deal panel
00:05:19 um you know that came right after i think it was 2019 uh federal early shortly after his
00:05:27 general election yeah it was 2019 no uh provisional election no it was 2019 provisional
00:05:32 then there was federal right after i think oh i came right after a minute the federal 21 was
00:05:37 a federal election okay yeah well there was a 2019 as well so yeah it's okay right after a federal
00:05:42 election where uh independence under the name wexit at that time it flared up it became a big
00:05:49 problem for him within the ucp as a huge number of ucp members are sympathetic if not outright
00:05:55 supportive of independence um you know kenny being an un he's an declared himself an unconditional
00:06:01 federalist there is no circumstance under which he ever supports independence okay that's fine
00:06:05 but he realized he needed some kind of
00:06:09 release valve
00:06:10 because there was all this
00:06:13 steam pent up and
00:06:15 if he didn't find a way for people to blow it off
00:06:17 it would have blown up his party
00:06:19 and it still nearly did
00:06:20 but
00:06:23 not much
00:06:25 came out of that, we got the referendum on equalization
00:06:27 that had already been an election promise anyway
00:06:29 that was just kind of rehashed again
00:06:31 in the report
00:06:31 this time though
00:06:35 Kenny, the Premier herself, is chairing it. That one, Preston Manning, chair it. It was ostensibly at least arm's length. He was not writing the report. He wasn't sitting on the panels. Smith is directly chairing this panel, so these panels are actually fairly large.
00:06:51 How is it, in what ways do you think this could be substantially different in any way from the Kenny Fear Deal panels that didn't really leap much?
00:07:01 Yeah, well, I mean, I think most realize that Kenny's efforts were just a deferral, an event, but he had no intention of really following through with any of those.
00:07:09 Let's just make them feel like they've been listened to and we'll move on with government how we will.
00:07:13 Or to be a little fair, maybe he had bigger plans.
00:07:15 COVID did hit and government priorities kind of changed all over the place.
00:07:19 But either way, the panel went nowhere to speak of.
00:07:24 I think with Premier Smith chairing it herself, that was a purposeful effort.
00:07:27 It's very rare when a sitting premier will commit to a whole bunch of public
00:07:31 readings. Yeah. I was saying rare in that, uh, I'd have to research,
00:07:35 I wouldn't say never, but it's certainly not common. And I think she,
00:07:40 she realizes that she's owning this. If nothing comes to this,
00:07:43 it's going to be on her lap. Like, why did you do this?
00:07:46 Why did you waste our time yet again?
00:07:48 So I think she's serious with where she wants to go on this kind of,
00:07:52 as you said in the opening too, though, it's kind of like they're,
00:07:54 they just want to get answers to the questions or answers.
00:07:56 The answers they reiterated they already have.
00:08:00 Something's interesting is she's talking about what they conclude will likely be going to a referendum next year.
00:08:06 So there's probably a number of questions they already have in mind.
00:08:09 So this is kind of the warm-up.
00:08:11 This is moving towards it.
00:08:13 And it's going to be put to a general question sometime within a year, I think,
00:08:16 which is radically different than what the fair deal panels were.
00:08:21 uh nigel smith has already talked about putting a series of other sovereignty related not
00:08:29 independence but sovereignty related questions on the ballot that would probably go in conjunction
00:08:35 with the expected independence referendum uh yeah the independence referendum that being one that
00:08:40 is likely to come from citizens initiative uh petitions to get that on the ballot
00:08:44 uh this might appear at the same time is there any grand strategy in that that
00:08:52 and maybe she doesn't think independence will succeed but then you know i've seen critics of
00:08:57 hers uh on the left say well she's gonna use you know these things would never pass on their own
00:09:02 like a pension plan and police uh taxes that kind of thing they wouldn't pass on their own
00:09:07 what if independence is on the ballot at the same time they'll seem more moderate and then has a
00:09:12 chance of passing. And then there's the
00:09:14 other side that I'm a bit more partial to,
00:09:16 and I think having those things on the
00:09:18 ballot makes it less likely that independence
00:09:20 succeeds, because then people can, they can check
00:09:22 a number of these sovereignty
00:09:24 within Canada options
00:09:25 without going the whole hawk.
00:09:28 How do you see it?
00:09:29 I'm pretty sure that this is a backup plan.
00:09:33 She
00:09:34 wants to,
00:09:36 what she doesn't want is to go
00:09:38 into a meeting with her federal opposite 0.57
00:09:40 numbers,
00:09:40 and they are able to turn to her and say i don't know why you're here the people you're
00:09:46 representing don't want this that's what she wants to avoid so she needs a good showing in these uh 0.74
00:09:53 in these meetings she needs to have plenty of public support for the positions that she's 1.00
00:10:00 adopted and the relationship between the the referendum question and these other things
00:10:07 is probably not
00:10:09 the one that you're
00:10:11 hoping for, but it is
00:10:13 if the one doesn't go, well, at least
00:10:15 the others might.
00:10:17 From a political point of view,
00:10:19 that's a win for the Premier.
00:10:22 Not the big win,
00:10:23 but enough of a win that you didn't
00:10:25 lose.
00:10:27 She's also talking in
00:10:29 this Alberta Next panel, The Roadshow,
00:10:32 about a suite
00:10:33 of constitutional amendments
00:10:35 uh you know to the federal constitution uh we talked about that last week uh i'm still unsure
00:10:43 what the strategy is there because you know she's a smart lady she knows that there's virtually no 1.00
00:10:48 chance that the rest of the country primarily in the east eastern central canada that they're
00:10:55 ever going to agree to any substantive constitutional changes one because they'd be
00:10:59 giving up tons of power uh pei is not going to give up having essentially more representation
00:11:04 and Harlem and almost then Alberta
00:11:05 with the population
00:11:08 of like Erdry.
00:11:10 They're not going to give that up.
00:11:11 Nova Scotia, Brunswick
00:11:13 and then Quebec is
00:11:16 you know, if we're talking
00:11:18 constitution, Quebec, they're going to open
00:11:20 up their crazy grab bag of ideas
00:11:22 and say, okay, we want some French
00:11:24 supremacist stuff.
00:11:25 People in Lethbridge can only speak French.
00:11:29 You know, they're going to come to their crazy ideas that
00:11:32 there's a 0% chance that English Canada, especially in the West, could accept.
00:11:36 Where are you going with that stuff?
00:11:38 Well, I think...
00:11:38 There's no chance.
00:11:39 I'm really guessing, but I think they're being quite strategic and tactical with this.
00:11:43 So this will finish, I believe, towards the end of September.
00:11:45 There'll be the hearings.
00:11:46 Give them a month to chew on it.
00:11:48 And as we said, this is probably predetermined.
00:11:49 They'll have the report that comes out.
00:11:51 And part of it will say, oh, well, look at that.
00:11:52 At our hearings, we found that most people support these proposed constitutional ideas.
00:11:56 So we'll wrap it up in a pretty little bow and submit it to Ottawa and the provinces
00:12:00 and say, look, this is what we're asking for in Alberta.
00:12:02 Well, by Christmas time, most of the provinces and whatnot
00:12:04 will at best have ignored it.
00:12:07 At worst, some will just say, roll it up and stick it back up
00:12:09 wherever you pulled it from.
00:12:10 And that's where she's well positioned to say, look, see,
00:12:14 that's where we're going to get trying on the constitutional front.
00:12:17 Now we've got a referendum coming next year with this, this, this, this,
00:12:21 and this on it that don't require constitutional changes.
00:12:24 This is the path Alberta must go.
00:12:26 So I think they're setting it up knowing it's going to fail.
00:12:29 but at least to demonstrate to Albertans that if you want to keep firing these guns at a target
00:12:35 that's invulnerable we're wasting our time so it's just one more way to show and she'll have 1.00
00:12:40 a mandate say well we we offered this is what we got now we have to try something else.
00:12:45 Nigel do you share that? I mean I'm thinking that she's setting up she's let them say
00:12:51 screw you to us so that to strengthen her case to get these other facts. Absolutely I mean she knows
00:12:57 that the the amending formula for the canadian constitution is seven provinces with two-thirds
00:13:04 of the population and you're never going to get that kind of buy-in they couldn't get it back in
00:13:11 when we were they were negotiating the charlatan or the beach lake accords um it's actually held
00:13:19 up on the indigenous one indigenous vote there so now we got more i she knows exactly and i and
00:13:27 Corey's nailed it precisely there, that once it is very clear,
00:13:32 there's this visible reminder to a new generation of Albertans
00:13:35 that you can't get constitutional change in Canada,
00:13:41 then she's free to go on to plan B.
00:13:46 She's tried.
00:13:47 Gave it a good shot.
00:13:48 Okay, well, that segues nicely into what's happening within the UCP
00:13:54 on the independence question.
00:13:56 So this was a story our reporter, Tula Mazulam, broke last week, that there have been something in the neighborhood of 50-odd resolutions from individuals and constituency associations.
00:14:15 um the way the way the policy conferences uh for the ucp in alberta work is uh individual members
00:14:23 and constituency associations can all submit policies and then before they go to be voted on
00:14:29 at the convention the different constituency associations sit down and they rank how much
00:14:33 they like each one so that essentially the ones with the most agreement go to the front of the
00:14:37 lineup and then theoretically you know if if the convention spent 10 seconds on each then you'd go
00:14:43 well, if they're all 300 resolutions or something to get there,
00:14:45 more likely they get to 30, 35, something like that,
00:14:49 ranked in order of what's got the most interest.
00:14:52 There is, I think, a certainty that independence is going to get ranked high enough.
00:14:57 It could be damn near the first question that will come up.
00:15:01 Now, I guess the question that the UCP is wrestling with right now is,
00:15:06 I don't think they're looking at not allowing it there.
00:15:10 I think that would create a revolt in the UCP.
00:15:12 you'd probably get a special general meeting called essentially
00:15:14 to recall the board
00:15:15 of that party. But they're either going to have it
00:15:18 at the convention or what they're doing
00:15:20 is giving consideration to right now
00:15:22 having
00:15:25 essentially a party plebiscite
00:15:28 on the policy as a standalone
00:15:30 rather than having it at the convention itself.
00:15:35 This,
00:15:36 I mean, I think
00:15:37 I'd argue probably would be a big step forward
00:15:40 for, I mean,
00:15:41 But separate from the partisan interests of the UCP, of which this would be very divisive, I mean, it would be an earthquake success for the independence movement to essentially capture the governing party of Alberta at a convention.
00:15:55 so the again it's creating the sense of occasion i mean you could put these you could put these
00:16:05 resolutions at the front of the regular party meeting and anybody who's ever been to one of
00:16:11 those meetings knows this would be about the only interesting one for 10 years so it's uh
00:16:15 you can drink a lot of warm water while you're waiting for those things to develop but this
00:16:21 would capture the attention but even more would it capture the attention if
00:16:25 it became its own separate convention because then again when you're facing
00:16:32 the federal government's representatives they're saying this is so important to
00:16:37 all burdens that we know that this 5,000 person convention came together to
00:16:45 discuss it and you're going to find I think I'd be very surprised if the
00:16:49 independence movement isn't the majority in the ucp membership this is about i think it's about
00:16:55 124 000 people isn't it it's high i don't know lately renewals after past campaigns it's higher
00:17:03 during leadership races and when there's nominations going on so it's probably a little
00:17:07 lower than that right now but yeah strong i mean it's a six-figure number i'm sure yeah um well
00:17:13 actually know what they're not talking about i think having a separate convention it'd be
00:17:16 technically a special general meeting that's separate
00:17:18 but that'd be like when the PC
00:17:20 and Wild Rose members voted technically
00:17:22 in a special general meeting but it was a remote one
00:17:24 so you could vote on the phone, you could vote
00:17:26 online, you could vote in mail, that kind of thing.
00:17:28 So I think it's talking about being more of a
00:17:30 referendum. There'll probably be a physical location
00:17:32 somewhere where people
00:17:34 gather but mostly voting
00:17:35 everyone could vote at home so
00:17:37 it wouldn't be 5,000 people voting
00:17:40 actually wasn't the last convention something like
00:17:41 8,000 or something crazy? It was a massive
00:17:44 amount. It was the biggest political intervention
00:17:45 of Canadian history, and this was just
00:17:47 for a provincial party
00:17:49 in the fourth largest province.
00:17:51 You still managed to get a quarter of them drunk in the hospitalities.
00:17:53 Yeah.
00:17:56 The red gates of hell,
00:17:57 I remember it well.
00:17:59 Corey, if polls are to be
00:18:01 believed, and they're pretty consistent on this point,
00:18:04 two-thirds of UCP voters
00:18:06 support independence.
00:18:08 It's not a majority of Albertans,
00:18:09 but it's two-thirds of UCP voters.
00:18:12 And traditionally, members of a party
00:18:13 tend to be more strided,
00:18:15 more ideological uh more right wing than the than the public at large i if this goes to a vote of
00:18:23 ucp members i i have a hard time seeing how this is anything but a pretty resounding yes well it's
00:18:30 a delicate balance i for them to say you can't have it on at policy especially with so many
00:18:36 having been submitted already as as was scooped uh would just be if you want to see somebody
00:18:41 grinning your ear to ear it'll be cam davies because you'll finally have the grouse and say
00:18:45 look you see that's the only way for independence they won't even allow you to discuss it easy so
00:18:48 you have to that's why you see you has to allow it personally i think they should allow the
00:18:52 discussion and just speaking my own point of view i think the members should reject entrenching it
00:18:57 into party but that's where that discussion can come and then people will read in different things
00:19:02 with it why do you like you support independence what why do you think the members should not make
00:19:06 that party policy because you make that party policy and you got to remember three two-thirds
00:19:11 of the UCP voters support independence, but this is a very polarizing issue. It's not one where
00:19:16 there's much fuzziness with people. It's a deal breaker for a lot of them. And when you've got
00:19:20 0% of the supporters, the NDP who support independence, you cut away a potential 20%
00:19:25 of your base. And you look at the electoral math and that next general election can look really,
00:19:30 really bad when you have actually carrying independence in your policy set. Again, I think
00:19:35 that's where the tactic of being able to say, we're putting it in the hands of Albertans if
00:19:40 they initiate a referendum, they can have that vote.
00:19:42 They can make that decision.
00:19:44 That's where it belongs and not within the party.
00:19:47 Cause then you can rip your own party very dangerously, or at least your base of
00:19:51 support in a general election.
00:19:53 So, I mean, that's just my view on it.
00:19:56 Not every UCP MLA is necessarily pro-independence.
00:20:00 So, no, I mean, even if I'm just saying the Lord do if that party makes it policy.
00:20:05 Yeah.
00:20:05 And we know MLAs are bound by party policy as a longer discussion of things,
00:20:09 But, uh, I would hope there'd be a spirited discussion and
00:20:13 maybe along those lines of, again, I mean, this is as pro
00:20:15 independence as we've ever seen from a governing party in this
00:20:18 province and, and there's still room to push it further.
00:20:22 Uh, I was VP policy for the Wildrose for a number of, of terms.
00:20:26 It's a thankless, miserable job.
00:20:27 And, uh, well, but you do, there's, there's no doubt there's
00:20:31 mechanisms to try and get policies to go the way you want them and the
00:20:34 way you don't without, you know, directly interfering or being bad.
00:20:37 So with the order you set them in, I don't think they could put that question at the top of the agenda.
00:20:41 You're going to put it down a ways where you'll reach it.
00:20:43 No, it's actually, but it's determined by how they get ranked.
00:20:47 The party itself does not get determined what order they're in.
00:20:50 Because given the ability, I mean, I would have said maybe question 10, but maybe put a three concession questions before it.
00:20:57 That'll make the independence people feel a little happier.
00:20:59 We're going to take on a provincial police.
00:21:01 We're going to entrench a pension plan.
00:21:02 Those sorts of things.
00:21:03 But I think it's determined more by rankings.
00:21:07 Well, and it might be.
00:21:07 I'm just speaking from how it was before, but how you try to adjust policy discussions so that maybe by then there's been a lot of debate on it and members in the room are starting to think on things a little further that maybe we could put this to referendum rather than entrenching in party policy.
00:21:22 But, I mean, they can't ignore the question, but I do think it would be very dangerous if they actually put it into party policy.
00:21:31 It really could bode poorly in a general election.
00:21:34 I do agree it's politically dangerous.
00:21:36 I mean, if that becomes the defining issue
00:21:38 it actually gives the NDP a better shot of winning
00:21:40 because their voters are
00:21:42 unified. 95% of NDP voters
00:21:44 are federalists. Only 5%
00:21:46 support independents
00:21:48 as New Democrats
00:21:50 whereas with UCP voters, it's a bigger pool
00:21:52 of voters, you know, the more
00:21:54 popular, but it's two
00:21:56 thirds in sport of independents, one third of
00:21:58 votes. And that is not a marginal
00:22:00 question. It's not like what the tax rate should be or what's
00:22:02 in the curriculum. It's an existential
00:22:04 Yeah. And as an independent supporter, I mean, I want to see a referendum and I want to see as strong as showing as humanly possible. And I still think unless things change pretty dramatically, which is possible in this next eight months, it's still going to be hard to get over 50% in the referendum. So it better be pretty darn good. But if you come in at 40% and then the NDP get in, is it going to be a decade before we get another vote on it? Because, you know, the next chance you get, you're not going to get a chance at all with the NDP.
00:22:32 I'm just saying, will the members think that strategically?
00:22:35 I don't know.
00:22:36 But that's the way I kind of look at it.
00:22:38 I don't know.
00:22:39 The thing is, you're going to have huge political machines on the Federalist side in this referendum.
00:22:47 You're going to have the Alberta NDP.
00:22:49 You're going to have whatever small machines are for the Federal NDP and the Liberals, which in a few pockets there's something, but nothing big.
00:22:58 But the Conservative Party of Canada is going to do everything it can.
00:23:02 they have the most to lose politically
00:23:04 with independency.
00:23:06 And that's why I'm so committed to it
00:23:09 being a grassroots individuals
00:23:10 or groups and movements rather
00:23:12 but trying to get into the party.
00:23:13 And they will under any circumstance.
00:23:17 And you'll have the Alberta NDP opposing it.
00:23:21 I don't see any chance of winning
00:23:22 unless you've got at least one major political machine
00:23:24 on your side.
00:23:25 And that means the only one in town
00:23:27 is the UCP.
00:23:28 Or the machine has to be something that isn't a party.
00:23:30 sure the parties have infrastructure they they have hierarchy absolutely organization and the
00:23:37 independence movement i mean i'm pretty impressed with what some of the folks have done so far
00:23:41 but they pale in comparison to a well-oiled political machine like the ucp or the ndp
00:23:46 you'd be bringing a bb gun to an artillery fight if if you're going against a conservative party
00:23:53 of canada the ndp the federal liberals the federal ndp and then the ucp just sits on the sidelines
00:23:59 They cannot win under those circumstances.
00:24:02 They need the UCP.
00:24:02 Tough hill to climb.
00:24:03 I mean, I don't know about that.
00:24:04 Again, we're talking about Venn diagrams.
00:24:06 You're going to have 80% of the UCP members, operatives.
00:24:09 I mean, some of it is allowing perhaps the freedom of MLAs to come out in support or against.
00:24:15 I mean, let it be that debate.
00:24:17 But I just feel nervous with the party entrenching that outright in the policy book.
00:24:23 That turns you into a single-issue party.
00:24:26 And I tell you, you better win that next referendum then because you aren't winning the next election.
00:24:32 So I'm just fearful of it.
00:24:35 I know what you're saying.
00:24:35 I mean, there's no doubt.
00:24:36 I mean, having the ability, those 87 constituencies that are organized, campaign managers, volunteer lists, donors, essential.
00:24:45 And it's a huge disadvantage without that.
00:24:47 But I'm just really fearful of the consequences of the party taking on an independence stance itself.
00:24:53 It's give us the means and don't jump into the fray.
00:24:56 But it could be unavoidable. I don't know.
00:24:59 I do agree that it would be, I mean, it gives the NDP a better fighting chance of the next election if the UCP is officially wedded to independence.
00:25:08 But by the time we go through that referendum, I feel like it's already going to be kind of baked into the cost that the UCP will be widely perceived as pretty much an independence party.
00:25:20 They're going to be labeled anyway.
00:25:20 They're going to be labeled no matter what.
00:25:22 They have already amended the legislation
00:25:25 to make citizens' initiative
00:25:26 referenda on any issue, but
00:25:28 this is obviously the issue people want it for.
00:25:32 They
00:25:32 will have amended the legislation to make it possible.
00:25:35 Smith
00:25:36 certainly never condemns them.
00:25:39 She
00:25:39 invites them to be a part of her
00:25:43 party.
00:25:44 Wouldn't it be baked into the political math
00:25:47 anyway? By the time we get to the next election, we've been
00:25:49 through a referendum.
00:25:50 Win, lose, or draw. Whatever
00:25:52 happens in that referendum,
00:25:54 the UCP... I mean, like I said, we win.
00:25:56 I mean, no one's going to then trust the NDP to
00:25:58 take over. I mean, it'd be like putting
00:26:00 Labour in charge right after Brexit. They're not
00:26:02 going to do it. So, let's
00:26:04 say there's a referendum loss.
00:26:06 The math doesn't favour independence right now
00:26:08 very well, but
00:26:09 if there's a referendum loss
00:26:12 and then we're going into an election with
00:26:14 UCP versus NDP and that's,
00:26:16 you know, say a year out from there,
00:26:18 isn't it already kind of just baked
00:26:20 into the math? Oh, hello, she said.
00:26:22 The UCP comes out,
00:26:24 Peter Smith comes out and says,
00:26:26 well, we had the referendum.
00:26:27 It lost.
00:26:29 You know, that's what happens
00:26:30 when you have a referendum.
00:26:31 You ask people what they think.
00:26:32 They tell you what you think.
00:26:34 Now we move on.
00:26:36 However, let Ottawa be under
00:26:38 no misapprehensions about the strength
00:26:40 and depth of feeling in Alberta
00:26:43 about how relations between Ottawa
00:26:49 and Alberta have gone.
00:26:51 Meanwhile, we still have the same set of demands, and we're continuing to press them because clearly we do have a constituency for it.
00:27:00 My question, though, is about in an election.
00:27:03 So, you know, we go through a referendum.
00:27:05 Let's say the referendum was not successful.
00:27:07 And then a year out from there, we're in an Alberta general election versus the UCP versus the EP.
00:27:14 You know, Corey raises the point, I think, fairly that, well, the UCP, if it officially adopts independence, it's then going to split off voters.
00:27:24 But even if it doesn't officially support independence as a policy, I think voters will still, from both sides, will still say you're the independent party and the NDP are the unconditional federalist party.
00:27:37 I'm actually not sure it actually changes the electoral math that much once you're a year out from that referendum.
00:27:44 the ucp would be regarded as a home and a haven for traitors and people who would hold down the 0.98
00:27:54 canadian flag yes of course they would and that's because they would be wouldn't they if i if the
00:28:01 majority of the ucp membership actually does favor independence of some kind well it doesn't matter
00:28:09 whether it becomes party policy doesn't matter whether it becomes a bit of the
00:28:14 referendum passes the UCP has defined itself on that issue and that is
00:28:21 probably the issue that most people care about so change the channel to something
00:28:26 else so what do you think Cory you know there's a referendum it's not
00:28:30 successful a year from there does it actually matter with voters at that
00:28:33 point if the UCP officially supported independence or not because I think I
00:28:38 I think everyone's going to perceive it anyway. A couple of things will depend on, I guess,
00:28:41 how well the referendum fared. If you were looking at it was 46, 47%, there's some safe 0.94
00:28:48 ground that they can still cultivate as an independence party and still sit on. If it
00:28:52 came in at 25, but they've got it entrenched in their policies and independence party,
00:29:01 they're caught in a rock in a hard place. I mean, you don't want to remove policy that members have
00:29:04 of entrenched, but at the same time, if you're coming towards an election, you want to change
00:29:08 the channel. You'll want the next election to be on something else besides the independence. I guess
00:29:13 as Nigel said, well, there, we did put it to the citizens of Alberta, and that trumps the members
00:29:18 choices in this. You know, the party favors this, the members favor this, but at this time, that's
00:29:23 not where Alberta is, and we're going to continue to govern and stand up and all the rest of the 0.62
00:29:28 things, but they'll have to carefully distance themselves from that 26% or whatever, while not
00:29:34 alienating them. But as you said, they're going to wear it anyway. I mean, they already are.
00:29:39 It doesn't matter what. So shouldn't they then just own the policy? Get on and ride that aura?
00:29:45 Well, no, because it's not 100% of them. So it's not fair for them wearing it. And you shouldn't
00:29:49 wear it. I know as frustrating as it may be, just because you're being labeled with it doesn't mean
00:29:55 you have to accept it. Yeah, well, I mean, put yourself in a position of a UCP MLA who actually
00:30:01 does not support independence i don't know how many people there are like that
00:30:05 but if you say okay that's it this is our policy this is what we're going
00:30:08 through in the next election a person who does not support
00:30:12 independence is going to think well do i actually want to run for this party
00:30:16 and even before the uh before the election is called
00:30:20 they may be asking themselves do i even want to support it
00:30:24 while i am a sitting mla sorry i'm gonna sit on the sidelines i'm not
00:30:30 resigning my seat because i need the money but i am not going to be identified as a separatist
00:30:40 because that's not who i am and that's not what my family wants it's not what my voters want
00:30:45 and it's not what i want so now you've got a situation where the ndp could conceivably
00:30:51 contrive a situation that splits the um splits those people away the government falls you go
00:30:57 a snap election. I think making it official and owning the policy and putting your MLAs who are
00:31:05 either Federalists or sitting on the sidelines and uncomfortable and making them make a choice
00:31:09 could be a bad policy. I'm coming from a position of a man who I want independence. I want to see
00:31:16 Alberta leave the Federation. They have no ifs, ands, or buts. I've written quite clearly on that
00:31:20 and that's where I stand. But I also just always want to remain realistic of what might be our best
00:31:25 path to actually get there. And there's a whole lot of different branches and pitfalls we can hit
00:31:30 on the way. We're kind of on the best track we've been since 1982. We're, you know, as close as we've
00:31:38 seen in a generation. So, I mean, you also don't want to lose this opportunity for fear of failure
00:31:45 because it's sitting back and being overly cautious. But I'm just also want to make sure
00:31:49 that we always think of things strategically
00:31:51 so we can win.
00:31:52 I agree.
00:31:54 But I see being timid
00:32:00 and just the UCP being totally neutral
00:32:03 as an institution during a referendum.
00:32:06 It's betting on it losing.
00:32:09 And there's a...
00:32:10 I give it a one in three shot of succeeding.
00:32:13 Maybe it's one in four.
00:32:14 It's not the good money.
00:32:16 But I think...
00:32:17 But it's in the realm of possibility.
00:32:18 I think it can win.
00:32:20 It's just not the good money.
00:32:23 But without the UCP throwing its full institutional weight into the fight,
00:32:29 the chance of winning goes down to near zero.
00:32:31 Because you're just going to have every other major political machine in Alberta all against you.
00:32:37 And you're not going to defeat the combined forces of the Conservative Party of Canada,
00:32:41 the Liberal Party of Canada, the federal NDP, the Alberta NDP,
00:32:44 much of the business establishment the union establishment all of them are going to be against
00:32:51 you we'll see i mean it's a different kind of campaign too you gotta keep in mind this is a
00:32:55 campaign of yes and no a general election is a campaign of 87 candidates and a thousand different
00:33:01 policies this one can let focus sit i mean i again i know if you had the ucp actively campaigning
00:33:09 putting all those resources would definitely be an advantage but it's not quite the same
00:33:13 disadvantages face we're going to dive into a general election with a whole bunch of independent
00:33:17 candidates because then you're just killing yourselves as i was saying that was kind of
00:33:21 actually slightly talking myself out of my position because the charlatan accord the federal pcs
00:33:27 in support was the federal pcs the federal liberals the federal ndp every single provincial
00:33:33 government and every single provincial opposition the entire business establishment the entire
00:33:39 labor establishment, anyone who was, anyone
00:33:43 was in support of the Charlottetown Accord, and then there was, like, the
00:33:47 Reform Party, which had one seat in Parliament, and
00:33:51 they won. They were on the side of the right. Now, Brexit,
00:33:55 you know. Yeah, Brexit was similar. The establishment was certainly opposed,
00:33:59 but the citizens felt otherwise. You've got to remember, if the establishment overplays,
00:34:04 that's the sort of thing that makes an Albertan feel like, boy, I've got to lash back.
00:34:08 You know, it can be dangerous if it seems like you've got the world against you.
00:34:12 And, hey, you know what?
00:34:13 My pen can actually send them a middle finger.
00:34:15 No, I wouldn't recommend to the Premier that she make it party policy.
00:34:21 She's absolutely sure that she's got the majority of voting Albertans on her side.
00:34:27 Well, I don't think she does right now.
00:34:28 I think to get that majority, though, you're going to need the UCP.
00:34:31 It's a difficult chicken and egg thing going on, I guess you could say.
00:34:35 Okay.
00:34:37 Well, we'll switch gears back to Ottawa a bit here.
00:34:44 So Fred DeLore is a former executive director of the Federal Consumers Party during the Aaron O'Toole era.
00:34:51 He's got an interesting substack page, and it's a few, it's like a week or two old now.
00:34:58 But Corey, I think you were right to put this on as one of our topics today was his story.
00:35:03 um kind of just give us the background on that with the pretty perilous financial situation the
00:35:10 NDP finds itself sure I mean because it kind of slides under the radar for people because it's a
00:35:14 bit wonky I mean people don't necessarily understand how the funding works for federal
00:35:17 political parties and there's been a they get their campaign expenses reimbursed and they don't
00:35:24 like talking in the open about that a whole heck of a lot because Canadians don't quite realize how
00:35:27 much they're shelling out of pocket to give to these parties you know provincially there's nothing
00:35:31 like that. You have to rely on donors. So the NDP has become very dependent upon that. And,
00:35:36 you know, they had enough support numbers that they could count on. If you got over 10% in a
00:35:41 constituency, you'll get your campaign expenses reimbursed. So they borrowed under the assumption
00:35:46 that they would get at least 10% in a whole number of constituencies. Instead, they got completely
00:35:53 obliterated in the federal election with, there has to be a couple of hundred writings they didn't
00:35:59 get over 10%.
00:36:01 A pretty small minority, they got 10% or more.
00:36:03 So now they've found themselves with no party status, no leader, seven members of
00:36:08 parliament, millions of dollars into debt.
00:36:12 And due to our laws, there's a time clock ticking now because if three years pass, that
00:36:20 means the bank loan will now be considered a contribution, which is a really bizarre
00:36:24 thing because that's illegal for a bank to contribute to a political party. 0.96
00:36:28 Only individuals are allowed to legally donate.
00:36:30 Yeah, so it's uncharted in a sense.
00:36:33 I mean, how do you punish the bank for loaning?
00:36:36 I mean, if they thought it was a loan, it's not really a contribution,
00:36:39 but if it loses that status as a loan, it's odd.
00:36:42 But it highlights just how much the NDP are in trouble.
00:36:47 That federal party, it doesn't matter who they get for a leader at this point or what goes on,
00:36:51 how on earth are they going to get rid of that debt before the next election?
00:36:56 Do we know how legally in debt they are?
00:36:58 No, it's a few million.
00:36:58 I don't think it's been reported.
00:36:59 It hasn't been reported yet at all.
00:37:00 I'm not sure.
00:37:01 They said they ran a fully funded campaign.
00:37:04 Yeah.
00:37:04 And that is, I think, 35 million you're allowed to spend, something like that.
00:37:08 Presumably, they would have had some contributions and some return.
00:37:11 But let's say it's 10 million.
00:37:12 I mean, for a party on the ropes like they are, who's giving them that money in the next few years?
00:37:16 It was 10.
00:37:17 Because they had no war chest going on that election.
00:37:19 That's true.
00:37:20 They just paid off their last work.
00:37:22 They had nothing in the bank, effectively.
00:37:24 So, I mean, it's just that most people aren't paying much attention to them.
00:37:28 Eyes are on Carney, eyes are on Polly Ave.
00:37:30 But that third party of Jack Layton is actually, I think, at a very high risk of being wiped out.
00:37:38 Essentially, they may have to declare bankruptcy and reform.
00:37:41 So, Nigel, the closest comparison I can think of is the Federal Progressive Conservative Party in 1992 went from a majority government to two seats.
00:37:50 it actually holds the world record for the worst electoral defeat of a political party in the
00:37:56 history of democracy uh i don't know the returns on athens here but uh as far as we know it's the
00:38:02 worst a governing party has ever been defeated in the history of the world of democracy uh they
00:38:08 actually never did come back uh they you know sort of hobbled on in a much much diminished form for
00:38:14 you know a decade and a half before merging with the alliance become the modern conservative party
00:38:18 But there was different rules. They had a huge number of senators at that time, and they kicked part of their salaries into the party to try and keep it afloat. I don't think they had the same kind of debts here. But, you know, they faced a similar existential issue.
00:38:34 too. It is entirely possible here that the NDP will not financially recover. There's just nowhere
00:38:48 for the money to come from. Other than the PCs back then could rely on corporate donations. You
00:38:51 could go to a business and be like, guys, we've got to save the PC party. Get a couple guys running
00:38:55 some big checks. That's not allowed legally, federally. The limit's like 4,000 something
00:39:00 and only individuals.
00:39:03 If the NDP cannot pay it back,
00:39:07 then the party and its official agents,
00:39:10 a bunch of people, get massive fines.
00:39:12 They could get millions of dollars.
00:39:15 And at that point,
00:39:16 are political parties allowed to declare bankruptcy?
00:39:18 I don't.
00:39:19 That's actually a...
00:39:20 I've never actually heard of them doing so.
00:39:21 I mean, that would be a hell of a bad look
00:39:24 to declare bankruptcy as a party.
00:39:25 Before they rent back,
00:39:27 they'd have to give up their signature headquarters,
00:39:30 the Jack Leighton building that is their assets
00:39:32 that would be a part of bankruptcy
00:39:33 you give everything
00:39:36 I don't know and I mean I know
00:39:38 there used to be some pretty hard limitations
00:39:40 on the ability for a party to borrow
00:39:42 money you would have to secure it some way
00:39:44 or another
00:39:45 well so it's secured against
00:39:48 the building and I think in some way
00:39:50 I'm not sure if it was technically secured
00:39:52 this way or just depended on this way
00:39:54 those refunds that they were not
00:39:56 eligible for I don't think a bank should accept
00:39:58 variable as a security on
00:40:00 something. It's like, you know, yeah, if the six
00:40:02 horse comes in, I can pay back my loan.
00:40:04 You know, that's a pretty dangerous
00:40:06 way to finance something, but the building itself
00:40:08 or some hard assets,
00:40:10 some security behind it somewhere
00:40:12 because, I mean,
00:40:14 it's a whole complicated mire on every level
00:40:16 of politics, but I know they do try to
00:40:18 discourage candidates and parties
00:40:20 from borrowing money because then you can't
00:40:22 attribute it to a particular donor.
00:40:24 That's why the bank
00:40:26 would be found to be the donor because you basically have to break that all up into a
00:40:30 bunch of different names as it got paid back. And that's how it technically now becomes a whole
00:40:34 bunch of donations instead of just one lump sum of money. Sort of like a certain Alberta party
00:40:38 that somehow got $120,000 and then a whole number of people showed up out of the woodworks and
00:40:43 donated $5,000 each that covered it. Amazing. But that's the way it works. You have to attribute
00:40:50 those donations to people. And if they run out of time in three years to dilute that bank loan
00:40:55 into actual donations.
00:40:57 Yeah, they're really up the creek.
00:40:58 Would you like to be the bank manager who actually said,
00:41:01 yeah, okay, we can work with you on this.
00:41:03 He's probably already in the Bahamas by now.
00:41:05 You know, if you lend money to the socialists,
00:41:07 you've got to come.
00:41:10 It's really weird.
00:41:12 I think they're, maybe I'm wrong,
00:41:15 but it looks to me like their best case plausible scenario,
00:41:18 plausible best case scenario,
00:41:20 is that they sell the Jack Layton building,
00:41:22 their big asset, I'm not sure how much that's worth,
00:41:24 they sell that off
00:41:26 and then they limp along
00:41:29 they're refinancing
00:41:31 debts on top of debts
00:41:33 and they make it to the next federal election
00:41:34 probably four years from now
00:41:36 still pretty heavily in debt
00:41:37 but they've been able to refinance
00:41:40 so they're not technically illegal contributions
00:41:43 no one's gone to jail
00:41:44 the party's not been fined
00:41:46 and they haven't declared bankruptcy
00:41:47 but then they've lost their building
00:41:48 that seems to me
00:41:50 probably their best plausible case
00:41:53 scenario. Maybe it works out. I don't
00:41:56 know. In regular cases, whether it's a
00:41:58 business or individuals, even a bank might still say
00:42:00 we'll settle. We'll
00:42:02 accept the loss, we'll eat that, and then
00:42:03 we'll... You can't do that in this case.
00:42:05 That would be a contribution for sure.
00:42:07 So then the other two worst
00:42:09 case scenarios are
00:42:11 I think...
00:42:13 Let's take a note of this.
00:42:15 Let's do kind of an analysis
00:42:17 piece, kind of following in Delores there.
00:42:20 Can a political party declare bankruptcy?
00:42:22 Because they have a bank account. They are
00:42:23 a legal corporate entity,
00:42:25 they're a not-for-profit society,
00:42:28 can
00:42:29 they declare bankruptcy? And how
00:42:31 does that then affect the
00:42:33 election law, which is a separate body of law?
00:42:36 Can they do that? So, possibly
00:42:38 they declare bankruptcy? I mean,
00:42:39 that's a really bad look, but that might actually
00:42:41 be their best way out of this.
00:42:43 If selling the building, at least
00:42:46 then you've got a clean slate financially, those are to lend them money.
00:42:49 Their
00:42:50 only real asset, to be honest, is their
00:42:52 name and if they can
00:42:54 but that's not an asset anymore
00:42:55 in the long run
00:42:57 that's the third scenario
00:43:01 is
00:43:02 they just shut the party down
00:43:05 it's a disaster
00:43:07 no one's going to want to take it over
00:43:09 because it's not all that debt
00:43:10 so they just kind of
00:43:13 vote themselves out of existence
00:43:15 essentially declare bankruptcy but then
00:43:17 start another political party
00:43:19 and it's like
00:43:20 you know, kind of how
00:43:21 in Saskatchewan, the Liberals and
00:43:24 PCs, they just more or less
00:43:26 shut down their parties and then all joined a new
00:43:28 one. It was a coordinated effort. It wasn't really a floor
00:43:30 cross. I mean, they just kind of switched labels.
00:43:33 So do they
00:43:34 literally just shut the doors on the
00:43:36 NDP and just
00:43:37 have the DDP? Or the
00:43:40 new, new Democratic Party. Yeah, you've got
00:43:42 a financial collapse there,
00:43:44 a financial bankruptcy, but they've actually
00:43:46 had a policy bankruptcy ever since
00:43:48 Jack Layton
00:43:50 took over the leadership and took it away from the classic social democracy into this kind of
00:43:57 politicized wokeism that that the ndp is has had going for it ever since
00:44:04 they don't have any ideas that people are ready to vote for and support i mean the evidence is
00:44:11 right there in the last in the results of the last election nobody cares i i disagree i think
00:44:18 I thought you would, but that's...
00:44:20 There's... Jack Layton
00:44:22 got them their best results by far
00:44:24 in their history.
00:44:25 And they took things in a different direction.
00:44:28 Well, his successors did. His last
00:44:30 election was his best electorate, where they formed official opposition.
00:44:33 Now,
00:44:34 do I think their ideas are bankrupt? Sure.
00:44:36 But they're not trying to get my vote. They're not trying
00:44:38 to get, like, a rural, white,
00:44:40 gun-owning Albertan to vote for them.
00:44:42 I'm not their demographic.
00:44:45 Apparently, they don't have one anymore.
00:44:47 No. But
00:44:48 But people voted for a largely NDP agenda under Justin Trudeau for a long time, taking their votes away.
00:44:55 And then the left kind of coalesced around the Liberals this time to stop Polyev. 0.52
00:45:01 I think that was just the utter uselessness of Jagmeet Singh as a leader.
00:45:06 I think Jagmeet Singh was just a terrible leader, but I think there's still a huge market for a pretty hard left party in Canada.
00:45:15 There's a market for it.
00:45:16 So, I mean, even if the NDP shut its doors, they sold the Jack Layton building, declared bankruptcy, and then they created the new New Democratic Party.
00:45:26 There's a market for it in Canada. 0.94
00:45:28 I mean, there's enough crazy people.
00:45:30 It's not a big market, though.
00:45:31 I mean, look where the Labour vote went in this last election.
00:45:35 Sure, but under better leadership, they formed official opposition in 2015.
00:45:40 Sorry, no, in 2011.
00:45:42 That was then.
00:45:43 they've lost a lot of credibility
00:45:46 and a lot of it is
00:45:47 seeing its fault, no question
00:45:49 but
00:45:50 can you imagine how
00:45:52 can you actually imagine the
00:45:55 sequence of events that would bring them back
00:45:57 to public acceptability
00:45:59 best if I can
00:46:00 that's why you have to have the new new Democratic Party
00:46:02 New Coke
00:46:04 sure
00:46:05 okay, well we're out of time on the main
00:46:08 part of our show, so we'll go to
00:46:11 Um, Corey's parting shot. Sure. I'll just be quick with it. Just another example of our
00:46:15 immigration issues. I mean, we were going to reform immigration. We can't even get rid of 1.00
00:46:20 the worst. Uh, a gentleman, uh, a cash come our cunt was found trying to solicit a 15 year old 0.99
00:46:27 girl for sex in Mississauga and the job to pay her for sex. Yeah. Yeah. Solicit pay. Yeah. But 1.00
00:46:33 either way, the, the charge was discharged by the judge because it would interfere in his attempts
00:46:37 to gain citizenship and citizenship in canada if we can't even get rid of a man who's trying to 1.00
00:46:43 hire sexual services of children who on earth can we filter out of our immigration system 1.00
00:46:49 excellent question canada's already circled the brain here i think 0.93
00:46:53 nigel so yes um i think we will gather around the television and the newsroom there this morning
00:46:59 listening to mr carney talking about the steel workers in hell i got i got all kinds of uh
00:47:05 empathy for steel workers who fear they're going to lose their jobs because of a tariff from the
00:47:12 united states but what bicarney actually said was that we have the potential to become our own best
00:47:19 customer for steel well how about sir you canada becomes its own best customer for oil out of
00:47:30 Alberta and then maybe you put some of those uh steel workers to the to work making pipe and then 1.00
00:47:37 string it along somewhere to get it to where it's wanted in eastern Canada into horizontal
00:47:42 integration right now we're we're importing 600 000 barrels of oil to eastern Canada
00:47:49 western Canada could fill that demand all right uh we're real short on time so i'll keep it super
00:47:55 short uh i was listening to an episode of canada land uh yesterday uh and they were talking about
00:48:02 the uh grassy mountain coal mine uh and they said just no one the one thing albertans agree on
00:48:09 is that we're all against coal mining uh in the rockies i didn't isn't that odd uh because the
00:48:17 community where they're proposing to do this the crow's nest pass had a plebiscite on this and 70
00:48:22 odd percent voted to mine coal you know mine baby mine uh you know so it just it it's just 0.96
00:48:32 maddening when you see you know there's a like just a couple of dipshits living in downtown 0.68
00:48:37 edmonton downtown calgary uh and then they'll go out to a town hall somewhere in rural alberta 0.82
00:48:42 uh and kind of you know maybe they'll put on their boots like they're like they're at stampede or
00:48:47 something uh try to blend in with the locals uh no the people in downtown edmonton downtown calgary
00:48:56 uh your voice does not get to trump uh that of the people who actually live in areas where these
00:49:03 resources are being extracted where people need jobs and opportunity the crow's nest pass is one
00:49:08 of those gorgeous places on the planet um and so yeah if they're gonna mine it it should be done
00:49:13 very responsibly and should be done
00:49:15 with proper recovery when it's done.
00:49:17 But guess what? The people there need jobs.
00:49:19 They don't live in Banff with a huge tourism
00:49:21 industry. It's too far off the beaten path
00:49:23 to be able to rely on it the same way, even
00:49:25 though it's equally as gorgeous.
00:49:28 So
00:49:28 just another example of
00:49:31 just kind of a coalition of the hippies
00:49:33 and the yuppies working together
00:49:35 to take jobs away from people
00:49:37 who want to live where they grew up.
00:49:40 Amen.
00:49:40 in. All right, that's it for today. Thank you for joining us. Remember, if you're not a member of
00:49:46 the Western Standard yet, you need to be. Stop freeloading. Go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:49:50 Click on subscribe. It's $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard
00:49:56 content, and you'll be supporting the work of the great journalists you can see in the newsroom
00:50:01 behind me here. Thank you very much for joining us today, and God bless.
00:50:10 We'll see you next time.