Western Standard - May 02, 2025


No fear, no surrender, Poilievre not going anywhere

Topics
Mentioned
Alberta Premier Smith on high-speed rail Can the Western independence movement keep it together?

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

178.9

Word count

4,207

Sentence count

204

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

What's next for Canada's Conservatives after losing a seat in the House of Commons to the Liberal Party of Canada? In this episode, we talk to Jenny Roth, a partner at Crestview Strategies, former communications director for the party, and a long-time Poilier of Interpreter.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Mark Carney has three passports, Canada, United Kingdom, Ireland, a globalist with
00:00:12 options. He hasn't seen Canada in a decade, calls himself a European, not a Canadian.
00:00:23 Told U.S. Congress last year, he's a Brit. He's back to lord over you.
00:00:30 Canada's not his home, it's his throne.
00:00:51 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:56 It is Thursday, May the 1st.
00:00:57 On our minds tonight is what's next for Canada's Conservatives.
00:01:02 Since 2011, they have never won more seats in Parliament than they did on Monday,
00:01:07 and with 41% of the popular vote any party leader would expect to be Prime Minister.
00:01:13 But thanks to the migration of the NDP vote to the Liberals,
00:01:16 Pierre Polyev is not Prime Minister.
00:01:20 In fact, he lost his seat.
00:01:22 With me tonight to talk about these things is Ginny Roth.
00:01:25 She is a partner at Crestview Strategies, former communications director for the party, and a long-time Poilier of Interpreter.
00:01:35 Good evening, Jenny.
00:01:37 Lovely to be here, Nigel.
00:01:38 Very nice to have you. Thank you for taking the time.
00:01:41 Jenny, there's a lot of talk about here in Western Canada, in Calgary, in the circles in which we move, about how Mr. Poilier will now have to face a leadership review.
00:01:51 Does he have the support to stay as leader?
00:01:55 Yes, much more so, historically so, I would say. If you look at the last two leaders and Aaron O'Toole and Andrew Scheer, people might remember they had to go to many ballots to win their leadership race. I mean, they just barely won the leadership race.
00:02:10 They then, you know, maybe more members fell in behind them and supported them as they went on. But when they lost, they really had to confront some members who were already displeased with them and just were not predisposed to be big fans.
00:02:23 Pahliev is sort of in the opposite situation. He has a strong hold on the membership. They're all
00:02:29 naturally big fans of his. There will be people who will certainly be disappointed with the results.
00:02:34 But I think that there's quite a bit of unanimity, both in the membership and in the party caucus,
00:02:40 in the parliamentary caucus, that he is just the best chance we have at winning the next election.
00:02:45 And that he grew the coalition, he increased the vote share, he increased the seat count.
00:02:51 And so, you know, the wrinkle of him having lost his own seat is unhelpful, certainly.
00:02:56 It allows for a media narrative that's a bit more negative.
00:02:59 But I don't think that will ultimately be something that undermines him with the membership,
00:03:03 which feels actually, I think, quite energized and excited about getting to the next election.
00:03:10 Certainly, when you see some of those vast rallies that he assembled,
00:03:14 it's hard to imagine how that level of support could just melt away in a moment.
00:03:18 uh jenny where when is the uh leadership review as i understand it there is one uh scheduled uh
00:03:27 at a convention in the fall i think it's september um and i think if i were probably
00:03:32 i would really welcome that you know i would sort of say um you know we shouldn't try to delay this
00:03:37 we've got a mandated process in our constitution the members should always have their say and i
00:03:41 really look forward to a leadership review because i'm just confident i'm going to i'm going to do
00:03:46 well and i'm going to give a strong endorsement from the membership um i think that that presents
00:03:50 a kind of a confidence um and uh and the comfort that that the members will support him um and it
00:03:56 gives him some time to kind of speak to caucus speak to canadians um maybe maybe you know talk
00:04:03 about what was successful and maybe potentially talk about areas for improvement and there and
00:04:07 ways that we can maybe do better next time do you think do you think he can get a seat between now
00:04:12 and then? I don't know that he could get a seat between now and then, in part because the prime
00:04:19 minister gets to control the timing of the by-election. And if I were the prime minister,
00:04:23 I would say, you know, what would Pierre Polyev do for me if I was trying to get a seat in that
00:04:27 house of commons? And I don't, I think he would be right in suggesting that Polyev would not give 0.98
00:04:31 him any grace. And so I don't expect, and I think Polyev should plan that the liberal to the prime
00:04:37 minister will make the timing as difficult for him as possible. And I believe they don't have
00:04:42 have a by-election until six months after a vacancy so um so there they could drag that out i think
00:04:48 it's fine um because polyev can appoint someone to lead question period in the house of commons
00:04:54 uh he can still talk to media in ottawa the way he would after question period working the leader in
00:04:59 the house of commons and he can tour canada he can meet with numbers he can meet with canadians
00:05:04 he can host rallies he can do everything else he would do as a leader he could post social media
00:05:07 videos etc okay well that's uh any ideas who might volunteer to take one for the team
00:05:15 i don't know there have been some rumblings about alberta uh you know he has quite a deep
00:05:19 connection to calgary having grown up uh in the city uh and calgary also has the benefit of being
00:05:25 a safer um environment in the city for for conservatives there are parts of calgary as
00:05:30 you know that are very safe territory for conservatives um someone will have to give
00:05:34 up a seat uh you know they it'll have to be done voluntarily he's not going to make someone do it
00:05:39 uh i think someone would have to come forward and think it makes sense you know maybe maybe there
00:05:43 are some mps who were giving it one last shot thinking i'll get i'll get to be part of a
00:05:48 governing caucus who are now a little bit disappointed and ready to move on um i don't
00:05:52 know i don't know i'm sure these conversations are happening behind the scenes um my hope for
00:05:56 him is that he gets a strong conservative seat so that he can have the support there build some
00:06:01 relationships there do some constituency work but mainly focus on trying to lead the conservatives
00:06:06 across the whole country jenny before we examine the entrails of the campaign itself a lot of you
00:06:13 you're right that he has a very large following here in calorie can you just tell people who are
00:06:18 concerned about him personally how he's doing and he and anna they have to move out of stornoway i
00:06:23 guess so there's lots of things happening all at once i think they will have to look we're only
00:06:28 three days from the election um and this is a guy who goes non-stop um i don't know if you i think
00:06:36 you know him a little bit and you know he's almost he's a borderline workaholic and for those who saw
00:06:41 some of the video footage from the last rally he had at home in ottawa before election day uh they
00:06:48 looked they looked exhausted and almost emotional um and who can blame them uh you know i would be
00:06:54 too. And so I think they're trying to get some rest. But he's still working, you know, I think
00:06:59 he's basically spending all day on the phone with supporters, with members of caucus, trying to talk
00:07:04 about trying to gather insights on how people felt the election went. I think he's meeting with his
00:07:09 advisors, he's giving a lot of thought to all of this. And as I understand it, caucus is likely to
00:07:15 meet next week in Ottawa, there's there's orientation for new members of Parliament, so that's a natural
00:07:20 time to do it. And I imagine the public will be hearing a bit more from Pollyov around that time
00:07:24 as well. I wouldn't be surprised if he sort of speaks to the plans nearly up to the next election.
00:07:31 Maybe there'll be some sort of review that's undertaken to look at ways the party can do even
00:07:35 better. I think he does need to do that, by the way. I think he needs to sort of take some
00:07:40 accountability for not having won. He should dwell on the successes, certainly, but he should
00:07:44 also take some accountability for not having won and maybe gesture at some openness to change.
00:07:50 and to evolution. Knowing him, even though he probably needs a lot of rest, I actually imagine
00:07:57 he's not taking much because he cannot sit still for very long.
00:08:01 Yes. Well, look, that actually segues into where I wanted to take you next, and that is
00:08:07 what went wrong. I know Trump appeared on the scene, but Trump will all be over in months as
00:08:13 far as things will get resolved one way or the other. Once they're resolved, then we're back to
00:08:19 dealing with the same things, young people who can't afford homes, haven't got jobs, older people 0.95
00:08:25 fighting with inflation, all the same problems that we went in. So there were some people who
00:08:31 thought that he should have become a militant anti-Trumper. He didn't. He said what he needed
00:08:37 to say, I think, but he focused on those same issues that were there before and that will be
00:08:43 there again. I didn't think he made a mistake, but you're saying there are elements where he
00:08:49 needs to take accountability. So what are they? Yeah, I agree with your assessment, by the way.
00:08:55 I think it's very simplistic and not good analysis to say, well, he should have talked about Trump
00:09:01 every day, or he should have been very hardline about Trump and talked about him every day.
00:09:05 I think had he done that, he would have accepted that as the ballot question,
00:09:10 And voters would have chosen Mark Carney as their preference for that question.
00:09:16 Instead, he sort of, he addressed the Trump issue.
00:09:21 He presented his plan, but he spent more time talking about cost of living and crime,
00:09:26 two major areas of contrast where he and Carney are different
00:09:29 and where voters were, I think, much more motivated to vote for him
00:09:32 if they felt like he was right on those issues.
00:09:34 I think that was like basically the way to go.
00:09:36 And I would say, I think strategically, the campaign was almost right on the money.
00:09:40 I think it was very well done. The areas for improvement that I see are on the sort of tactical operational side of things. For instance, you know, thousands and thousands of Canadians showed up to these rallies. And these were not people who'd been Conservative Party members before, maybe not even Conservative voters before, maybe not even voters at all before.
00:09:59 And they had a real emotional connection to Polyev, a real connection to the issues, people who showed up at rallies and also people who engaged with his social media content.
00:10:09 I'd like to see more thought go into over the long term.
00:10:13 How do you convert those people into activists and volunteers?
00:10:16 How do you get them to join their writing association?
00:10:18 How do you get them to show up on E-Day and poll vote like we all do, those of us who have been activists for years?
00:10:24 How do we how do we how do we get them to get their friends to show up?
00:10:27 How do we basically convert those rally goers and voters and, you know, give them credit?
00:10:33 They didn't just show up rallies. They definitely voted. But how do we get them to volunteer?
00:10:37 How do we get their manpower on Election Day? How do we nominate candidates sooner so that we can have more candidates identifying more vote at the doors and then getting out the vote on Election Day?
00:10:51 These are problems, I should say, that plague all political parties.
00:10:54 political parties just in 2025, they just can't get enough volunteers, they can't get enough
00:10:58 activists. But I think we have an opportunity that the other parties don't, and that we have this
00:11:02 movement that Polyev has built. So converting that movement into a machine, a political machine,
00:11:09 I think is like the biggest area for growth and opportunity.
00:11:14 Right. Given that the NDP collapsed almost entirely, is there actually anything
00:11:23 that a cleverer, smarter critic
00:11:27 might have been able to do
00:11:28 that the campaign didn't do?
00:11:33 Well, you make a good point.
00:11:35 So there are a lot of areas of the country
00:11:37 where the Conservative number
00:11:39 is higher than it's ever been.
00:11:41 But because the NDP number was so low,
00:11:43 so historically low,
00:11:45 the Liberals still beat us
00:11:46 because the NDP collapsed almost entirely
00:11:48 in some writings to the Liberals.
00:11:50 Having said that,
00:11:51 The NDP collapse is also attributable to many NDP voters voting Conservative.
00:11:58 So whether it's Windsor or Hamilton, Ontario, or more blue-collar working-class parts of the province, or North Vancouver Island.
00:12:08 Also, you know, more natural resources, fishing community, blue-collar type Conservatives who are worried about drugs and crime.
00:12:16 These are many voters who went from the NDP to the Conservatives.
00:12:20 And I see that as a huge opportunity.
00:12:22 I also think it's a good reason why we shouldn't hang our future hopes on some hope that the NDP will do better, because we want to keep those voters.
00:12:31 And so we really have to think about how do we go from 42% to 46%, 47% in a potentially almost a two-party system.
00:12:38 I think the number is 49.3%.
00:12:41 Yeah, sure, sure.
00:12:42 Now, look, we may get lucky, right?
00:12:44 The NDP are likely at a low watermark historically.
00:12:47 You know, if they get a new leader and that leader gets some engaging media, they may pick up a few points.
00:12:52 And if they do, I think it will be at the expense of the Liberals.
00:12:55 That's great. I hope that happens.
00:12:57 But we need to build a sort of like a 50% plus one style movement, to your point, or 49.3%,
00:13:04 because that, to me, is the more durable way of building a long-term coalition that can succeed in a potentially two-party system.
00:13:13 Certainly, I think it's pretty possible to hang on to some of those blue-collar NDP supporters.
00:13:19 They are actually true conservatives in the sense that they don't want anything to change.
00:13:24 They've got things the way they want them, and that's Vancouver Island. I happened to be there
00:13:29 when the Reform Party was becoming established, and people were coming across from the NDP to
00:13:36 join hands with conservatives who were fed up, and that's how the Reform Party started out there.
00:13:41 Same thing is possible today, I do believe. This is a touchy subject because it's got to do with
00:13:54 the internal struggles of the Conservative Party. We've seen this every decade that
00:14:00 Conservatives would rather fight with each other than the Liberals. You have this bizarre
00:14:04 situation that there's bad blood between the Polyariv campaign and the people who work for
00:14:11 Doug Ford. And the only explanation I've seen in print is that, oh, well, somebody said something
00:14:17 nasty to somebody else and everybody took umbrage. And then with that, they started to bring down
00:14:23 the person most likely to replace the liberals after 10 years of misrule. That doesn't make
00:14:28 much sense to me. What do you think happened there? You know, I think conservatives care
00:14:34 more. And that's why we have these fights. Really, I think there's more substance to the
00:14:40 disagreement, as you implied. And I think it started at the tail end of COVID, when many of
00:14:47 us were saying that some of the restrictions were just too significant. And indeed, Polyev was,
00:14:53 I think, quite successful in his leadership campaign, in part because he questioned a lot
00:14:57 the remaining discriminatory restrictions. And in hindsight, it seems like most people agree that
00:15:04 we shouldn't have had kids out of school for so long, etc. And the Ford government was quite a
00:15:10 bit more dogmatic about keeping things shut down, about restrictions, etc. And I think that that was
00:15:16 sort of the beginning of the disagreements. And then over time, you had, you know, people like
00:15:22 Jamil Javani and others who were drawn to the Federal Conservative Party around a lot of the
00:15:26 anti-woke stuff. And PolyEv was very committed as well to coming out against DEI and the federal
00:15:33 government, cutting funding for universities that pursue this ridiculous ideology, etc.
00:15:39 And you just didn't see the same thing happening in Ontario, despite us having a majority government
00:15:45 there. Us meaning conservatives, like ostensibly conservatives are in control in Ontario and have
00:15:50 been for some time, and yet you don't see progress on some of these issues. And so I think there are
00:15:54 genuine ideological differences. Ultimately, I think probably did become personal, as many of
00:16:00 these things do. And I hope that we can continue to disagree on the key policy areas, because that
00:16:07 is, you know, a substantive area where you want to tell the orders where you stand. And if it's
00:16:11 different from others, you should make that clear. But the sort of like added personal stuff is
00:16:17 probably not necessary and probably not additive to a big coalition. And so I hope that part can
00:16:22 kind of be put to bed and we can stick to the issues.
00:16:25 Well, I guess we all held that, but you make a very good point. There were people saying
00:16:29 before the election that although the Liberal Party called itself Liberal, it didn't look
00:16:34 like any Liberal Party that we'd ever seen prior to the Stephen Harper government. It
00:16:40 seemed much more like an NDP government, but I don't think even the NDP was always quite
00:16:48 that crazy that's right um at any rate and so now we've got a what have we got in ontario a
00:16:54 conservative party that's not it's sort of a populist centrist party i would say like i don't
00:17:00 know that there is much of a core worldview there um or a set of objectives this is a i mean this
00:17:07 is it's a it's an old thing when it is actually conservatives who want to change things
00:17:11 how do we how do you market the idea of being a conservative and wanting to reform everything
00:17:17 you see in front of you reform i think is the right word um and i think the way you know the
00:17:22 the rationale for me because i i am a conservative and i sort of have this like intuitive uh fall
00:17:28 back to common sense and to not wanting to disrupt uh etc but i think the reality is when you apply
00:17:35 that uh worldview to a country that's been under not just as you say liberal but pretty hard left
00:17:42 progressive rule for a decade um that is so that that has uh it has moved so far away from common
00:17:50 sense that there is a sense that reform is needed in order to restore um like i think of it more as
00:17:56 restoration than i do reform um towards some brave new future i think it's much more about
00:18:01 a return to common sense but that but that requires reform um do you make do you jenny do
00:18:08 Do you make a connection between this intra-party spat, between that and somebody's bold leadership
00:18:16 aspirations, who may even have engineered the situation to weaken Poliev so that somebody
00:18:23 else could step up and claim the leadership?
00:18:27 You know, I honestly don't know.
00:18:29 When I don't see an obvious rationale behind someone's behavior, I sometimes think,
00:18:36 is there something else going on here you know either in politics sometimes that looks like
00:18:40 ambition um or personal interest business interest whatever um but i don't know i can't i can't tell
00:18:47 you um you know i i don't know uh how albertans um or people at west would feel about a dud ford
00:18:53 uh as a federal conservative leadership candidate um i don't know how uh francophone canadians would
00:18:59 feel about someone who doesn't speak french you know there's a bunch of reasons why it doesn't
00:19:02 seen to make all that much sense to me, but you never know.
00:19:07 Well, you know, having editorialized for many, many decades, I have peeled back the onion
00:19:13 layers. 1.00
00:19:14 When you get right down to the bottom, you often find just plain stupidity and malice. 1.00
00:19:18 So it could be just nothing more than that. 1.00
00:19:21 But I had to ask.
00:19:22 I also have to ask, Mr. Carney is very, very close to a majority.
00:19:30 I think 172 is needed.
00:19:33 He has 169.
00:19:35 If I can ask you to do something really hard, and that is to imagine that you were advising the liberal prime minister, would you perhaps suggest he recruit a few people from the opposition?
00:19:51 You know, that isn't so hard.
00:19:53 As a consultant, I often have to put myself in the shoes of my opponents in my private life.
00:20:00 What I would advise is, I would say to Mark Kearney, look, you actually have three dance partners. You have NDP MPs, you have the Bloc, and you even have Conservatives. And were I him, I think I would try to approach a parliamentary agenda by having smaller bills, not these big omnibus trying to jam everything into a fall economic statement or a big budget. Obviously, you have to do those things as well.
00:20:27 But I would go on a case by case basis and say, who is the best dance partner for me on this legislation to advance what I want to advance? And surely he'll find it. I think on a lot of his progressive climate agenda, etc., yes, he will go to the NDP. But he may have a major project piece of legislation he wants to bring forward.
00:20:48 the Conservatives may feel pressure to support if they want to see major projects built.
00:20:52 He may have an approach to dealing with Trump that the Conservatives may feel pressure to support.
00:20:58 He may have other policies that the Bloc could get behind if he can't get the NDP to support him.
00:21:05 And the NDP, look, more often than not, I think the NDP are going to fall in with the Liberals.
00:21:08 But I think that if I were him, that is how I would resist being just drawn into this dynamic
00:21:13 where I have to move to the West, left on every issue. Now, will he do that? I'm not so
00:21:18 sure. I think there are a lot of people out there who think Mark Carney is this great business
00:21:22 liberal, Paul Martin-esque, you know, blue liberal type. And I don't think that's true. I mean, this
00:21:27 is a guy who wrote the book on, literally, the book on net zero, on like the radical climate
00:21:32 agenda. He wears an expensive suit, but that is not making business liberal. So we will see if
00:21:38 he takes my approach. I think more likely he will take a Trudeau-like approach of appealing to the
00:21:43 NDP and running as though he has a de facto majority. And I don't even think he needs to have
00:21:47 them switch parties to do that. I think they'll just vote with the Liberals.
00:21:51 So what you're really recommending is the model that Stephen Harbour used in 2006.
00:21:56 Exactly. Yep. I think that was wise of Harper at the time. And I think it would be wise for
00:22:00 Carney to do it now. I'm not sure he will. Well, fascinating insights. We're almost out of time.
00:22:07 And I want to thank you, Jenny, for coming on the show. Any last words?
00:22:13 No, all I will say is actually, I feel a lot of optimism as a conservative. Obviously,
00:22:17 I wanted to win the federal election. There's no question that's disappointing. But this new
00:22:21 coalition of voters is young and energetic and different from anything we've seen. And I think
00:22:26 it is more durable and easier to grow than the Liberal Coalition, which I think has hit its
00:22:31 ceiling. And so I hope some of your views will take some hope in that message.
00:22:36 Well, I have one last question from which they might derive. Do you think we'll be
00:22:40 going to the polls again within 12 months?
00:22:43 Unfortunately, I don't have a hopeful answer to that question.
00:22:45 I think because the NDP is so not functioning like a proper political party right now,
00:22:53 they're broke, they have no future, they don't have a leader.
00:22:59 I think for all those reasons, it'll be easy for the Liberals to pass legislation.
00:23:03 I don't think anyone apart from the Conservatives is going to want an election in the next couple of years.
00:23:08 Jenny Roth from Crestview Strategies.
00:23:10 thank you very much for joining the show today very much appreciate your insights
00:23:15 for the western standard i'm nigel hanaford