Western Standard - November 14, 2025


Ottawa’s energy rules are crippling the West

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Indigenous reserves must embrace personal responsibility Does climate change cause hurricanes?

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

136.9

Word count

3,452

Sentence count

168

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The government wants Alberta's oil sands companies to produce oil without increasing the amount of carbon in the atmosphere. What does this mean for the environment and the economy in general? Is this a good or bad thing? In this week's show, I speak with environmentalist Ron Wallace about this.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, November 13th. Here is a factoid for you. The government of Canada wants Alberta's
00:00:29 oil sands companies to produce oil without increasing the amount of carbon in the atmosphere.
00:00:36 You probably knew that, and you knew it as net zero emissions and so-called emissions cap.
00:00:42 This costs a lot of money and is a competitive handicap for Alberta oil, a severe one actually.
00:00:49 In the prime minister's mind, this is decarbonized oil that we make here, and if any new pipelines
00:00:56 are built out west. It is decarbonized oil that they'll be carrying. However, it's not the same
00:01:05 for eastern Canadian refineries importing oil from other countries. There is no equivalent added
00:01:12 cost. Now, I find this unbelievable, but apparently it is so. There are two energy economies in
00:01:19 canada one based on expensive oil out west the other on cheap oil with me today is dr ron wallace
00:01:28 who served on the old national energy board that the liberals got rid of and by proposing to
00:01:35 modernize it you're the first professional ecologist appointed to the national energy board
00:01:41 You have a long career in energy regulation, and in fact last month, Dr. Wallace, you were testifying to the Parliamentary Energy, the Standing Committee on Energy, about this.
00:01:55 Welcome, Ron.
00:01:56 Thank you.
00:01:56 Ron, you know, this sounds outrageous, but I'm drawing my understanding of it from an article that you've published recently in C2C Journal.
00:02:12 And that said, you laid it out all in broad terms.
00:02:19 They don't pay a premium in the East to import oil.
00:02:22 We pay a premium in the West to produce it.
00:02:27 What is going on here?
00:02:29 Well, this is a situation that's developed since the last election
00:02:34 and been brought to a head by Prime Minister Carney's reference
00:02:40 to what he called decarbonized oil.
00:02:42 It wasn't something that was raised during the election,
00:02:47 but it's come up since then.
00:02:48 and I have some figures here,
00:02:53 is that since 1988,
00:02:57 marine terminals along the St. Lawrence
00:03:00 have seen imports of foreign oil valued
00:03:02 at more than $228 billion.
00:03:06 Yes.
00:03:07 And that's not including the Irving oil refinery
00:03:13 in New Brunswick,
00:03:15 which between 1988 and 2020,
00:03:17 imported 136 billion dollars worth of oil now there's two things here first none of that oil
00:03:26 is quotes decarbonized it's originating from the united states explain i mean i don't think people
00:03:32 necessarily believe me decarbonized oil like what makes oil attractive is carbon so like dehydrated
00:03:40 water what do we what do they mean dehydrated water is a good example what they're saying is
00:03:45 is that this is an attempt to limit the emissions
00:03:50 that are going to the atmosphere in Canada.
00:03:53 And so the idea of that behind decarbonized oil is that oil sands production will,
00:04:02 the emissions from oil sands production will be captured and sequestered in the ground.
00:04:08 And this is an attempt to ensure that Canada moves towards, it'll never reach net zero, but that it'll
00:04:19 theoretically move towards producing more oil, but maintaining or reducing the emissions in Canada.
00:04:27 And so what you're doing is you're capturing these emissions from these oil sands producing
00:04:34 facilities, re-compressing them and re-injecting them into geological formations underground.
00:04:41 But this happens under very, very high pressure, requires pipe manufactured to extreme
00:04:50 specifications, and costs a hell of a lot of money.
00:04:53 It's a great deal of money. It's the minimum estimate so far that industry has spent through
00:04:59 the Pathways Project are reported a billion dollars just on the basic engineering so far.
00:05:04 Okay, for people who don't follow the energy industry as closely as you do, the Pathways
00:05:09 Alliance… The Pathways Alliance has been established by
00:05:13 the big oil sands producers, four of them, to construct a facility to capture these emissions
00:05:21 and inject them underground. They're already doing that in Weyburn,
00:05:25 Saskatchewan, I believe, and not Pathways. Well, that's a different
00:05:29 situation. In Weyburn, what's doing on is called EOR, Enhanced Oil Recovery, where they're capturing
00:05:36 emissions from coal facilities, and they're re-injecting those underground to pressurize
00:05:42 wells to bring more oil to the ground. And they've produced a lot of oil by doing this. That wouldn't
00:05:48 normally be productive. Now, the government doesn't like this because you're adding oil to the
00:05:55 equation. In fact, what has happened is that the government of Canada has specifically set out
00:06:04 tax relief for companies that can decarbonize or capture emissions, but they specifically excluded
00:06:15 EOR from those tax regulations. So they're two different situations.
00:06:22 So to be clear, Weyburn demonstrates that you can compress carbon dioxide and force it underground.
00:06:29 And underground and produce oil.
00:06:31 But for the way you're talking about it, it sounds like it's a sort of a high school chemistry experiment in scale compared to what you would have to do to bury carbon dioxide sufficient to…
00:06:44 Very much so.
00:06:45 Well, the major difference between what's being proposed at Pathways is there is no oil recovery.
00:06:51 You're just simply taking all that carbon from those emissions,
00:06:55 pumping it under the ground, it's gone.
00:06:56 In Weyburn, at least, their cost is being offset by the production of the oil.
00:07:02 So when you build a plant that's going to cost $16 to $24 billion,
00:07:09 you then have to operate that facility.
00:07:14 And the operating costs are not covered in that $16 billion.
00:07:18 It's estimated that those operating costs could be as much as $1.4 billion a year every year.
00:07:24 So what would that do to the cost of the oil that's produced that way?
00:07:28 Well, precisely.
00:07:29 We're an export market. We've got to sell against the world.
00:07:32 We've got to sell against the world. Nobody else is doing this.
00:07:35 Now, let's just start a little bit further back.
00:07:38 This idea of an emissions cap, which is now apparently in play,
00:07:44 There's no other country in the world that is doing that to its oil producers, not one.
00:07:50 Canada is an outlier in this, as I explained to the Standing Committee to the House.
00:07:56 Not even Norway, which is pursuing injection facilities for carbon to inject the emissions
00:08:05 underground, is doing that for its oil industry.
00:08:08 It has a major facility that's under production, but that's for cement production from Germany.
00:08:15 So that's the starting point here. When you move past that discussion, you move into, well,
00:08:23 where will you take emissions? Well, what's happening is that the government of Canada is
00:08:29 selectively picking Canadian oil production,
00:08:34 not, as you pointed out, Eastern oil imports
00:08:37 or transportation emissions or whatever.
00:08:41 They're specifically targeting, in fact,
00:08:45 the oil sands before that oil can be released.
00:08:48 Now, when you add 16 to $24 billion
00:08:51 onto your cost of production,
00:08:55 before you build a 20 to $34 billion pipeline,
00:08:59 you're looking at very significant penalties for Canadian Western producers.
00:09:06 Well, I won't ask you to go out on a limb and say how much per barrel this could add,
00:09:11 because who knows?
00:09:13 Nobody knows.
00:09:13 Well, nobody knows.
00:09:15 It's estimated between $100 to $200.
00:09:19 Okay, well, oil is about $57 a barrel when I looked this morning.
00:09:23 It's down a lot.
00:09:24 So who is going to want to buy Alberta oil?
00:09:28 Well, who could afford to produce that oil at those prices?
00:09:34 That's the question, and carry that cost.
00:09:36 And so, you know, the government loves talking about stranded assets.
00:09:42 If we're going to get out of oil, all of these facilities will be stranded assets.
00:09:46 Well, let me tell you, this huge decarbonization project could be a gigantic stranded asset
00:09:54 if the price of oil goes below where it is now.
00:09:57 In fact, it's a very critical price point right now for all these plants.
00:10:04 So how does this affect Canada?
00:10:07 Well, if you can't export that oil, and there are estimates that these policies have cost Canada around $680 billion in capital that's fled the country over the last 15 years.
00:10:21 Say that again. 0.71
00:10:23 $680 billion.
00:10:25 $680 billion.
00:10:26 Nearly a billion.
00:10:27 nearly three-quarters of a trillion dollars in 680 to 750.
00:10:34 And that's just capital that's left by projects that haven't been built.
00:10:39 If you look specifically at the numbers involved with some of the pipelines, for instance,
00:10:46 these pipelines and the production from them that's going offshore is not only competing with
00:10:53 oil that's coming in from Venezuela and the United States.
00:10:56 I mean, of those imports to Eastern Canada, 72% originating in the United States.
00:11:04 They have none of these penalties.
00:11:06 So this idea that Canada is going to seek out markets because it has decarbonized oil,
00:11:13 the question is, who's asking for that oil?
00:11:17 No one that I'm aware of.
00:11:19 No one is saying we need to have a premium for decarbonized oil over what's coming in
00:11:24 from Venezuela.
00:11:25 Well, let me ask you this, Dr. Wallace, I mean, I hate to ask you to put yourself inside the liberal mind, but how do you think that they could ever justify that to themselves?
00:11:37 We're talking about the smoke-filled room, the back room where everybody's sitting around.
00:11:42 How are we going to, do you think we could ever stick it to the Alberta oil industry and not put something similar on importing oil from outside the country?
00:11:55 Well, most people would say, no, you never get away with that, but they're getting away with it.
00:11:58 Well, as you said in your opening comments, we appear to have two oil policies in Canada,
00:12:06 one for the East and one for the West. East unrestricted imports of any kind,
00:12:11 which is taking vast quantities of money as the numbers I cited are
00:12:18 well over $500 billion over the last 20 or 30 years.
00:12:24 So a very interesting thing happened this week.
00:12:27 Bill Gates came out just in advance of the COP30 conference in Brazil
00:12:32 and suddenly changed his position on global warming to say we're concentrating too much
00:12:39 on emissions as opposed to practical solutions to cope with the warming.
00:12:44 Now, this is a position that's been taken by scientists
00:12:47 and ignored by the media largely for the last 20 years.
00:12:50 This is a very significant commentary
00:12:55 because what's happening is that the world is,
00:12:59 there was a quote I saw just this morning,
00:13:01 the world is transitioning away from the energy transition.
00:13:07 That is something that's putting the Carney government
00:13:11 and the Canadian government in a very difficult position.
00:13:14 The rest of the world is pivoting away from the idea
00:13:18 that you can,
00:13:20 eliminate a hydrocarbon economy and an energy producing economy and replace it entirely with
00:13:27 renewables. Just saying, look, we know that's now wrong and now we're moving into a situation to say
00:13:33 we have to focus on adaptation. Bill Gates has been a very strong
00:13:40 proponent of cutting carbon emissions to fight global warming. He has now recanted.
00:13:45 before he recanted he was very quotable as long as he said that right now of course everybody's
00:13:51 oh well you know bill gates fit a little old night and maybe he's losing his losing his grip
00:13:56 well nobody's really uh picking up on that i mean i i think that's highly significant well it's
00:14:01 tremendously significant and the fact that he decided to make that announcement just before
00:14:06 cop 30 and you know it is almost predictable the u.n conferences this is the 30th conference now
00:14:15 And aside from the costs of jetting all these people to the Brazilian rainforest, 0.99
00:14:21 well, to come back specifically to Canada,
00:14:27 Canada has set out these emissions guidelines.
00:14:31 Ever since 1998, Canada has not hit one of its objectives for emissions, not one.
00:14:38 It's now looking like it's trying to double down on it
00:14:42 and keep the myth that you can stabilize or reduce your emissions through decarbonized oil.
00:14:51 The cost of this proposal, even though it's been looked at by industry as a viable option,
00:15:01 it's not the question of whether or not we can do this. Engineers in Canada are more than capable
00:15:07 of doing it. Although the technology is unproven and the largest comparable facility in Australia
00:15:13 that's run by Chevron has never come even close to meeting its requirements. And so assuming it
00:15:20 works, assuming that you spend that 16 to 24 billion dollars and assuming that there's a
00:15:27 market for that oil at the other end, you still only bring down your emissions in Canada by less
00:15:35 than two percent oh that happens really less than two percent yes we do all that you do all that
00:15:41 all the rest of us are driving our cars and we're breathing and exhaling and well and the the comment
00:15:47 i heard from the prime minister that made me laugh that he said you have to realize that this
00:15:51 decarbonizer oil is going to generate enormous jobs and enormous industries in canada well it will
00:15:58 it's not going to be if you're going to spend 16 billion dollars you're going to employ a lot of
00:16:02 of people. The point is, it never makes money. It's a constant negative impact, not only in
00:16:10 operations, but on your pre-capital cost and on the penalty it imposes on the pipeliners and the
00:16:17 oil producers who are going to have to pay for this. Now, the part that he's leaving out is that
00:16:23 it is not the pipeliners and the producers and the federal government that's going to pay for this.
00:16:29 This is going to probably land very heavily on the Alberta taxpayers to the tune of between maybe $500 million to $1.4 billion a year to operate that facility.
00:16:44 Well, okay, let's talk about that, because there is a sort of an understanding, I think, that Premier Smith has, or hope, perhaps I should call it, that we will be able to develop the oil-producing industry and have pipelines going to the coast and lift the tankard ban as long as we can decarbonize the oil in the manner prescribed.
00:17:12 it now at the price of the decarbonizer well nobody's going to want to buy it we're not going
00:17:19 to be able to afford to use it even locally or sell it or sell it so what chant what chat two
00:17:27 questions first of all is when you laid this out for the uh for the parliamentary committee what
00:17:32 did they make of it and the second question is do you think this grand bargain has got lengths yeah
00:17:38 Well, the Parliamentary Committee didn't ask me one question.
00:17:42 The Conservative members did, but the Liberal members did not rise to the occasion.
00:17:48 So quite frankly, I know what Honorable David Bextie and his Tory colleagues thought of it
00:17:57 because they were asking me questions where I used these numbers.
00:18:01 The Liberals, not so much.
00:18:02 So I don't know what they're thinking about.
00:18:06 As for Premier Smith, you know, I really congratulate her for trying so hard to find outcome when she emerged from the Premier's meeting in January in Saskatoon and came up with the idea of a grand bargain where a new pipeline could theoretically pay for this and be a grand bargain, which meets the requirements of the federal government and Alberta's expectations for oil export and development.
00:18:33 my only comment is is that if you're going to spend between 16 and 24 billion dollars
00:18:39 you need to do something more than a back of the envelope calculation and that uh if in fact the
00:18:46 federal government is presenting that as an alternative for alberta i think at alberta
00:18:52 government needs to look at this very very carefully so the parliamentary committee
00:18:57 basically
00:18:58 you've had a chance to get the message
00:19:01 out to more people on this interview
00:19:03 than probably you have through the
00:19:05 parliamentary committee because the liberals
00:19:07 just wouldn't pick up the ball
00:19:09 and play
00:19:10 but
00:19:12 if the grand bargain
00:19:17 doesn't happen
00:19:18 what is
00:19:21 the future
00:19:23 of the oil and gas
00:19:25 industry in Alberta
00:19:26 Well, if you look at and you listen to what, it's interesting to listen to the prime minister say that they've set up this new major projects office that's going to accelerate these projects.
00:19:43 Well, that may be true.
00:19:45 I mean, I don't think it's going to be that effective.
00:19:48 They're paying people very significant amounts of money to make it work.
00:19:53 I hope it does.
00:19:53 But in effect, they're trying to countermand their own regulatory process and end run it.
00:20:01 That's something that I find to be unique in any parliamentary democracy.
00:20:06 If your legislative base is so formidable that it's preventing things, as has been documented,
00:20:13 to the extent of the billions of dollars that have left Canada,
00:20:17 if you would think it would be reasonable
00:20:22 to change that legislative base
00:20:24 rather than and run it.
00:20:27 So that's what we've chosen to do.
00:20:28 But to come to your point,
00:20:31 if in fact these projects are going to be built,
00:20:37 they're not going to be built by the federal government.
00:20:41 They may be funded in part by it,
00:20:43 but they'll be built by industry
00:20:44 and by private capital.
00:20:48 And when you listen to the presidents of TransCanada and Enbridge,
00:20:53 they're giving messages out very clearly
00:20:55 that they're directing their money for capital investment
00:20:59 into the United States.
00:21:01 Now, they may be, in fact, looking at a potential project in Canada
00:21:06 after the cancellation of Gateway.
00:21:07 I mean, Enbridge had to eat, it's been reported,
00:21:11 something like a billion dollars when Cabinet,
00:21:15 unilaterally overruled the National Energy Board approval for Gateway.
00:21:21 If you had to be a producer in a capital markets, as I said to the committee,
00:21:27 would you be interested in investing in Canada when A, you had to build a $16 billion
00:21:33 decarbonization project, then face $20 to $30 to $40 billion in pipeline costs,
00:21:41 for which you would have to go through what's called an expedited regulatory review process
00:21:48 when you've got Aboriginal communities and the premier of British Columbia in completely opposing
00:21:57 those ideas and a tanker ban on the West Coast, which would allow you to transport that oil to
00:22:03 market. Those are tremendously formidable barriers. And it explains why TransCanada, or TC Energy,
00:22:12 excuse me, and Enbridge, the presidents are making very clear statements saying,
00:22:18 our money, our capital investments is going to the United States.
00:22:22 Well, I know some people are watching this and they're saying, this is all very interesting,
00:22:25 but Mr. Carney said he was going to lift the emissions cap. So surely we don't have to do
00:22:30 this anymore. Well, he said that they wouldn't need it if they did all of the other things.
00:22:35 All these things. All of the other things, which is
00:22:42 the current suite of emissions and climate regulations. You've got to understand that
00:22:48 there's the clean fuel regulations. This is the tanker ban. The list of regulations goes on and
00:22:54 on. What he's saying is that if we do all those things, then you won't need an emissions cap.
00:22:59 well it's the same thing yes it's the same thing only different we're just about out of time dr
00:23:05 wallace but let me pitch let me pitch something that's just really crazy because all of this is
00:23:09 crazy so i can be crazy too we've got uh the trans trans mountain expansion line out to the coast in
00:23:16 bc if it gets so if it gets to be that we alberta oil becomes so expensive we can't even afford it
00:23:24 never mind sell it to anybody else right the industry goes down and we start reversing the
00:23:29 flow and bringing imported oil in just like they do from in eastern canada and bringing it up to
00:23:35 alberta through the tmx well i think well is that crazy is well you'd have to reverse the line that's
00:23:41 a very difficult situation but you know trans mountain represents a very viable alternative
00:23:49 for Canada to very quickly increase its export oil by simply optimizing that line like Enbridge
00:23:58 and TC Energy are presently doing. You don't need a new pipeline. You can optimize existing ones
00:24:05 and get it there. Now, if you've got it, the only way you can optimize those lines is to
00:24:12 buy, quote, decarbonized oil, then you've got a very difficult process.
00:24:17 Dr. Wallace, it's a funny world we live in, except it's not really that funny.
00:24:23 But that was an amazing article.
00:24:24 And I think you're one of the first people to bring it to light.
00:24:27 Thank you for doing that.
00:24:29 And I think we may be having you back to talk about this as things develop.
00:24:34 So thanks for coming on the show.
00:24:35 Thanks for having me, Nigel.
00:24:39 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:24:47 so
00:24:58 foreign