Western Standard - October 17, 2025


Pipelines and the Constitution: Ottawa’s vanishing act

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
HANNAFORD: Could the Alberta Teachers’ Association pull a TBA trick? Should conservatives vote for Sonya Sharp?

Episode Stats


Length

24 minutes

Words per minute

148.48

Word count

3,577

Sentence count

159

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Chris Oldcorn joins me on the show to talk about the need for a new oil pipeline between Alberta and B.C. and why it would be a good idea. Western Standard Editor Chris Oldcorn has been a long time contributor to the Western Standard and now writes for the Opinion pages.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:22 of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, October the 16th. With me today is my friend and colleague
00:00:31 Chris Oldcorn, who has been actually attending to the opinion pages since I sort of retired a
00:00:39 couple of months ago and doing an excellent job. Chris, I see the numbers every day and you are
00:00:45 you're doing great. So you're also a pretty skilled writer in your own right and paying
00:00:52 attention to the things that matter. And you had an editorial in the Western Standard just,
00:00:59 I think it was yesterday, and it drew attention to a really oddball situation that has happened
00:01:09 And where we have the federal government having claimed responsibility for pipelines when it's to their advantage, now just sort of, you know, go and sort it out among yourselves.
00:01:23 The article I'm talking about is E.B. can't, that would be the B.C. premier, E.B. can't veto a nation-building pipeline.
00:01:33 What's going on, Chris?
00:01:35 Yeah, well, when Carney came in, he talked about this major projects office, which is now up and running.
00:01:42 They picked the first five projects, most of which were actually already well on the way to completion, but at least they're doing something.
00:01:50 And obviously, Danielle Smith, the Alberta Premier, has been asking for another pipeline. 0.97
00:01:56 She wants it obviously to be one of the major office projects that they have going on and has started the process of that.
00:02:05 The Alberta government is going to pay the first little bit of the work that needs to go in before a private investor would come in.
00:02:11 However, you see Premier David Eby calls it basically a dream and it's never going to happen.
00:02:17 And he also says it's not allowed to come into B.C., which he can't do because it's a federal project.
00:02:26 as soon as you go over a provincial line.
00:02:27 Well, you've seen this movie before, haven't we,
00:02:29 with the Trans Mountain expansion line?
00:02:31 Yes, and they went all the way to the Supreme Court,
00:02:34 and B.C. lost.
00:02:37 B.C. attempted to stop the Trans Mountain pipeline.
00:02:40 So even the Supreme Court is really doing on this.
00:02:42 It's really pumping, like that got finished,
00:02:45 and it's pumping oil, right?
00:02:47 That's correct, yeah.
00:02:48 Yeah, the last numbers I saw on the Trans Mountain pipeline
00:02:52 is that it is operational.
00:02:54 depending on who you listen to anywhere from 25 to 80 capacity uh they haven't really been
00:03:01 too forthright with the exact numbers going through but i've heard numbers anywhere from
00:03:05 25 to 80 percent of the max capacity of what the transmountain pipeline can pump through it
00:03:10 so in other words we do need another pipeline it it's not going to take much to to fill up the
00:03:17 transmountain pipeline and need a second one uh and especially if we want to get our uh oil
00:03:22 out of Canada and the U.S.
00:03:25 Because right now, 96% of what we pump out of the ground
00:03:30 goes to the U.S.
00:03:31 And we're not even getting the market price for it
00:03:35 because they know that we can't sell it to anybody else.
00:03:38 We need to be able to create competition
00:03:40 by being able to export to Asian nations.
00:03:43 And right now we can't.
00:03:46 I mean, what we have, we put on rail
00:03:47 and into the Trans Mountain, but it's not an out.
00:03:49 We definitely need a second pipeline. 1.00
00:03:51 especially for the economic development of the country particularly the west these are good
00:03:57 middle class paying jobs now it seems to me chris that we actually uh back 10 years ago
00:04:03 there was a pipeline a second pipeline approved it was called northern gateway
00:04:09 and it was going to go out to the west coast up around prince rupert okay uh and then the
00:04:19 new federal government under Justin Trudeau deep-sixed that. It was fully approved, fully
00:04:25 permitted, but they just arbitrarily canceled it. Then we had a number of other pipeline projects
00:04:38 fall off the table because, frankly, the federal government didn't want them to happen.
00:04:44 And then we had the No Pipelines Bill, the famous Bill C-69.
00:04:50 And we had another bill, which is still in force, that makes it illegal for tankers to show up off the West Coast.
00:05:01 There isn't a comparable law banning tankers from the East Coast, but there is from the West Coast.
00:05:08 Now, that law is still in place.
00:05:12 The no new pipelines law is still in place.
00:05:16 So what is the game plan that Premier Smith is following here and demanding to reopen the old Northern Gateway route, essentially?
00:05:29 Well, I think it plays to her advantage politically since the energy sector is massive for Alberta and they export most of it. 0.98
00:05:39 so it's in their advantage to be able to get more out of the ground take it out faster i mean we're
00:05:45 not going to run out of oil in canada for you know 100 plus years if not longer um and we can
00:05:51 if we get more oil out of the ground it creates more jobs it creates more taxes that get collected
00:05:57 that then can be spent on things like health care and stuff but when we hear that chris but you know
00:06:02 at the moment you still can't back up a tanker to the dock and uh and take on a load so
00:06:07 So do we not have to clear those legislative obstacles first?
00:06:13 Possibly.
00:06:14 I mean, Premier Smith could be playing the angle of if she creates enough momentum, 1.00
00:06:20 it would force the federal government to have to move.
00:06:24 So if she gets someone who's willing to come in here and build the pipeline
00:06:28 and pay for it all, and she can make an economic case for it, 0.94
00:06:33 then she might be able to get enough pressure on both the BC government and the federal government
00:06:39 for them to back off some of their anti-oil policies. And Premier Smith has even talked
00:06:48 about, you know, being carbon neutral and all this other stuff for pipelines too. So she's
00:06:53 even trying to appease the environmentalists who think that, you know, carbon is the worst thing
00:06:57 ever um and in this at the same time she can get her pipeline built which would provide plenty of 1.00
00:07:06 jobs not just in alberta but also in saskatchewan as well and so what is the what is the point that
00:07:12 mr eby seems to be stuck on that uh he says there there couldn't possibly be a case so don't even
00:07:20 try where where's he coming from on this that's a great question other than maybe it plays well
00:07:27 for him politically by trying to block
00:07:29 a pipeline, but it doesn't play
00:07:31 well for him economically, because
00:07:33 it would create jobs in B.C. as well.
00:07:36 And
00:07:36 for
00:07:39 EB to be
00:07:39 against it from the very beginning,
00:07:43 like not even willing to
00:07:44 hear
00:07:46 out the people who want to invest in this,
00:07:49 maybe behind private doors,
00:07:51 they're not going to come out publicly yet, but
00:07:52 he's not even,
00:07:55 he's basically saying don't even trust.
00:07:57 which the argument that you shouldn't try something
00:08:03 just because there's a premier against it
00:08:06 that doesn't fall under his purview 0.98
00:08:09 is completely ridiculous. 0.92
00:08:12 This is something that should be regulated 0.94
00:08:13 by the federal government.
00:08:15 It shouldn't be regulated by Alberta or BC.
00:08:17 This should be done through the Canada Energy Regulator.
00:08:20 That's what they do, cross-border energy.
00:08:24 And this is a pipeline that goes over a border.
00:08:27 But did not our new energy minister, Mr. Hodgkin, just say, go work it out among yourselves?
00:08:34 That's exactly what he's saying.
00:08:36 He's telling Daniel Smith to go convince David Eby to let this pipeline go through.
00:08:42 And if she can't get his support, then the federal government's not going to support.
00:08:46 So in one sense, this government oversteps into provincial jurisdiction where they shouldn't.
00:08:50 And then when they're supposed to oversee something in federal jurisdiction, they're abdicating it to the provinces.
00:08:56 It's not how our country is supposed to be running.
00:09:00 Well, we could speculate at length of what the hidden motives driving the federal government might be.
00:09:07 I'll take one stab at it.
00:09:09 I don't think they actually ever want to see any further oil development in Western Canada.
00:09:16 Wouldn't you say?
00:09:17 Absolutely.
00:09:18 I was saying this before Carney got elected.
00:09:21 But they can't come out and say it in so many words, because that would look bad.
00:09:26 Correct. So they have to look like, oh, we're trying, but it just didn't happen.
00:09:31 And, I mean, Carney is essentially Justin Trudeau, just slightly older.
00:09:37 But the policies that he's been following are basically essentially the same.
00:09:42 And that includes the environmental policies of the former government, former prime minister.
00:09:48 and we're not seeing any real change at the top of the country when it comes to pipelines
00:09:54 and when it comes to the West in particular.
00:09:59 Carney played up the fact that he announced his campaign in Edmonton and all this stuff.
00:10:04 But at the end of the day, he has basically been out of the country for over a decade.
00:10:11 And prior to that, he was the Bank of Canada governor.
00:10:13 but he got parachuted into into canada for this election more or less to try and save the liberals
00:10:20 and get them back in again which he did um but he also campaigned on being pro-business you know
00:10:28 he tried to steal some of the stuff that the conservatives were saying uh and then he gets in
00:10:34 and his words are not matching what he was saying as a matter of fact almost every bill that's been
00:10:41 introduced since the Kearney came back in, officially was elected as prime minister,
00:10:48 none of them have really been any use to the West. And this is another example of something
00:10:55 that's completely not useful to the West when the energy minister won't even do his job and
00:11:00 sidesteps the federal responsibility of managing cross-provincial border energy, which is a
00:11:08 pipeline. And he needs to step in and actually do his job and figure out some way to get EB on board
00:11:15 that makes EB happy, makes Smith happy, and the federal government can manage the actual building
00:11:21 of that pipeline. Well, I don't know how much effort it would take to, or whether we should
00:11:27 take to make the premier of BC happy. There is a legal obligation to accept a pipeline if it is
00:11:35 approved by the CER. I don't know what's kind of a trade-off that there could possibly be that would
00:11:41 be ethical. I want to take you one step back here. There was a meeting of the premiers with the new
00:11:50 prime minister in your city, I do believe. I was up in Saskatoon, yeah. Yeah, I'm in Regina. He was
00:11:58 in saskatoon he was obviously okay your promise anyway yes yep hard to spell easy to draw saskatchewan
00:12:06 so um look what happened at that meeting that's relevant to this discussion we're having about
00:12:12 driving a pipeline through to the west coast well at that meeting they talked about nation building
00:12:21 and nation building projects they hadn't quite announced the major projects office yet but they had announced
00:12:28 at that meeting and a lot of their discussions were about breaking down
00:12:32 interprovincial trade, for example, and then also major projects to get our
00:12:39 exports to new countries other than the U.S., whether it was going to Europe or
00:12:45 Africa or going the other direction to Asia, Australia, New Zealand, but to get 0.63
00:12:50 our products to world markets, which was a word that got said a lot, get our
00:12:55 get our products to world markets in other words not the u.s and coming out of that meeting
00:13:02 particularly at the press conference at the end of the day uh doug ford in particular
00:13:08 made a comment about how easy it was to deal with carney compared to his predecessor and that he
00:13:17 was actually confident for once that the federal government was actually going to help provinces
00:13:22 get their products out of just going to the U.S. and to going to new markets because we have markets
00:13:30 that want our stuff. It's just we can't get it to them. And that is where the issue is, is how do we
00:13:37 get what we have to those world markets? And the only way to do it is off of our East Coast and
00:13:45 our West Coast. And if the West Coast isn't playing ball, but the East Coast is, guess what?
00:13:51 that actually is a disadvantage to Alberta and Saskatchewan in particular because it takes a lot
00:13:57 to get oil from Alberta all the way to the east coast which is basically next to impossible
00:14:02 because there is no pipeline to go through Quebec either so the only way to actually get our stuff
00:14:07 to large markets like Asia we're talking billions of people here is to get it off the west coast 0.96
00:14:13 but if you got a tanker ban and a no pipeline bill that's going to be next to impossible and
00:14:19 we are literally saddling future generations with debt that they shouldn't have to be saddled with
00:14:24 because we would have more money flowing through the system, which would create less deficits
00:14:29 because we'd have more money to pay for stuff. And this government seems intent on running
00:14:33 massive federal deficits and not doing the things that would make Canada wealthy.
00:14:41 So, Chris, at the end of that meeting, Premier Smith came out and talked about a grand bargain.
00:14:52 What was the bargain?
00:14:58 They didn't say specifically what the grand bargain was, but it did look like whatever happened behind closed doors, there was something that was going to happen.
00:15:09 It looked like, and I'm speculating here, but it looked like they were going to have a pipeline to the West Coast.
00:15:18 She seemed somewhat confident in that.
00:15:21 And then also ways to get our stuff out through the Arctic through Churchill, Nanitoba.
00:15:26 They did indeed talk about that, but they also talked about something else, decarbonized oil.
00:15:33 Yes.
00:15:34 and now you know down the road from where you are you've got wayburn which has demonstrated over
00:15:41 more than 20 years in fact i think it's almost 25 years that you can take carbon dioxide compress it
00:15:49 push it down a hole effectively bury it under very high pressure the purpose of that experiment was
00:15:56 actually to retrieve the last oil, enhanced oil recovery is what they were calling it.
00:16:04 But in recovering something like another 100 million barrels, they actually demonstrated
00:16:10 that you could capture and sequester carbon. Yes, we even have a coal plant in Saskatchewan
00:16:17 that's carbon capture. Okay, so now I thought that the grand bargain was that you could have
00:16:25 new pipelines if they carried decarbonized oil.
00:16:32 Smith has talked about it.
00:16:35 Obviously, it's the carbon in the oil that gives it any value as a fuel. We are talking about
00:16:43 dehydrated water in a way, but I think the principle is that whatever carbon you burn
00:16:51 to extract the oil you put an equivalent amount of carbon dioxide down the hole and and seal it
00:16:59 and there is in fact a group in alberta the pathways alliance that has been working on this
00:17:03 project for some years now my understanding is that the grand bargain would involve taking that
00:17:11 technology applying it on a very large scale and we know it works from from the wayburn example
00:17:17 but to ramp it up and that's where things get sticky what is it going to cost to actually
00:17:27 take that much carbon out of the process pump it underground i mean we're talking we're talking a
00:17:34 couple of million barrels a day yep is is this viable in your opinion who is going to want to
00:17:43 invest uh they're talking about 16 billion dollars in order to sell 20 billion dollars worth of oil
00:17:52 you know i mean there's a there's a lot of crazy talk around this and i'm not sure that this so
00:17:58 called grand bargain has got legs but how do you see it daniel smith has has to the best of her 0.86
00:18:07 ability tried to appease environmentalists with regards to the pipeline uh and whether or not it's
00:18:16 economically viable that will come from a private investor on whether or not they think it is
00:18:21 economically viable um danielle can pitch it uh and see what happens but at the end of the day
00:18:28 it's if if the if the dollars don't add up you won't get an investor and we have policies
00:18:36 in this country that let's say they got rid of the tanker ban and they got rid of the no pipelines
00:18:43 bill. Let's just say Carney woke up one day and decided to actually do something nice for the
00:18:47 West. Let's say those two disappear. But let's say we start building a pipeline. You're going to go
00:18:54 through at least one, if not two elections before that pipeline is finished. Meaning the government
00:19:00 could change and come back in and literally campaign on a no pipeline bill and a tanker ban
00:19:06 again and you could have your pipeline only half built and then you've wasted all that money it's
00:19:11 the economic uncertainty that is the greatest hindrance in this country when it comes to energy
00:19:18 projects and the fact that we have a government that's hell-bent on net zero even though one net
00:19:25 zero is not possible ever you can't go to zero so the entire movement is a joke because it's not
00:19:34 even possible to get the net zero. But we have a government that has, for lack of a better term,
00:19:40 conned people in particularly eastern Canada that somehow we're the greatest polluters on the planet,
00:19:47 even though we are probably the least polluters on the planet. I mean, I saw a study just the
00:19:52 other day that showed that if Canada and the U.S. went completely dark, we would have almost zero
00:19:59 change on the global environment. Like that's how little we already put out because we're already
00:20:05 using environmental techniques, both in Canada and the U.S. to appease environmentalists on
00:20:12 energy projects and so on. So this is a, once again, the federal government needs to actually
00:20:19 step in, do their job, build the pipeline, and make sure that there's certainty for an investor
00:20:26 to be able to come in and spend that type of money.
00:20:29 Because you're not going to get an investor
00:20:30 if you're not going to be willing to be long-term open
00:20:35 to whatever it is that they're going to invest in.
00:20:37 So the rest of your knowledge, Chris,
00:20:40 is the oil that's imported from offshore into eastern Canada
00:20:43 required to be decarbonized in this way?
00:20:48 I'm not sure.
00:20:49 I've never heard that it was.
00:20:51 I've only ever heard the West talk about it.
00:20:53 I strongly suspect that there is no such requirement because when you're talking about
00:20:59 places like Nigeria and Russia, they don't have the technology to compress carbon dioxide and
00:21:06 pump it underground even if they did, even if they wanted to. So I have a feeling that we've got,
00:21:14 again, one of these problems of confederation where the West is getting treated differently.
00:21:20 Yes, you can have a new pipeline, but you have to decarbonize the oil in the East.
00:21:25 No such requirement exists.
00:21:28 Eastern oil is cheaper.
00:21:29 There's this big cost that is imposed upon Western Canadian oil.
00:21:34 And then, of course, you're supposed to go out and sell it on the export market,
00:21:38 which is, of course, where Eastern Canada is buying its oil from.
00:21:43 You know, the whole thing goes around and around.
00:21:44 And I strongly doubt that the economics are going to support this.
00:21:51 And then if it happens, it'll be supported by the taxpayer, not by private enterprise.
00:21:57 But I could just be a bit of a Jeremiah on this.
00:22:01 Do you have any optimism to give us here as we talk about the premier of BC and the prime minister of Canada and the premier of Alberta trying to make this thing work?
00:22:11 I think there's only one of those three people trying to make this work.
00:22:15 And I think the other two are just simply passing the buck to each other.
00:22:21 And I don't think Kearney has any intentions of ever building a pipeline.
00:22:25 And I think he's going to use Evie to make sure that that doesn't happen.
00:22:29 And then going the other direction into Manitoba,
00:22:31 he'll use Wob Canoe to make sure that no pipeline goes through Manitoba up to Churchill.
00:22:38 So you're a pessimist.
00:22:40 ah realist unfortunately it's usually the um the the realists usually turn out to be pessimists
00:22:48 don't they unfortunately in this country especially when it comes to energy we'll leave it to the
00:22:54 we'll leave it to the viewers to make the judgment but uh chris you're doing a great job back there
00:22:59 in uh saskatoon and i'm sorry in regina and thank you so much for coming on the program today and
00:23:05 and explaining what Mr. Eby is up to
00:23:10 and why he shouldn't be allowed to get away with it.
00:23:13 Thank you so much.
00:23:14 Thanks, Nigel. Thanks for having me.
00:23:16 All the best.
00:23:17 You too.
00:23:18 For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel Hannaford.
00:23:35 Thank you.