Western Standard - January 29, 2026


Poilievre’s leadership on the line this week

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | $885 million on health for illegal immigrants, refugees | 27 Jan 2026 Carney talks big in Davos, delivers little at home

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

179.42

Word count

8,323

Sentence count

410

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join the usual suspects as they discuss the upcoming Conservative Party of Canada National Convention in Calgary, the upcoming leadership review of Jason Kenney, and much more. Plus, a look at the latest on the independence movement in Alberta.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day and welcome. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're
00:00:28 watching the pipeline today is january 28th 2026 i've got the usual lineup but not uh not entirely
00:00:38 we've got one additional one from us and uh cory morgan coming from elsewhere we've got as usual
00:00:44 uh nigel hannaford former opinion editor hi folks dave naylor senior news editor good evening and
00:00:52 joining us for the first time with the pipeline david veitschnik westminster business reporter
00:00:57 Thanks for having me.
00:00:58 And coming to us from an undisclosed location on a luxurious, warm compound somewhere in the Empire of America is Corey Morgan.
00:01:10 Hey, I'm a little overdressed today.
00:01:13 You're, you are rubbing it in. 1.00
00:01:15 You are sitting by a pool with a tan already, you son of a bitch. 1.00
00:01:20 That is, you are rubbing it in. 1.00
00:01:23 Okay.
00:01:24 Okay. Well, it was just yesterday we had, there was a huge rally and petition signing event held at the Big Four on the Stampede Grounds in Calgary for Alberta independence.
00:01:40 This is almost certainly the biggest independence rally in Alberta history.
00:01:46 We'll be talking about that event, the media's coverage of that event,
00:01:49 and where things are going in the effort to get a referendum launched in Alberta on independence.
00:01:56 Oh, and the loyalty pledges.
00:01:58 Don't let me forget, we've got to talk about the Nenshi's loyalty oaths that he demands of the UCP.
00:02:03 But first, we're going to start with what's coming up beginning tomorrow.
00:02:10 Here in Calgary, going all the way to Saturday, the Conservative Party of Canada's National Convention is in town.
00:02:17 Held every two years, members get together to vote on important things like constitutional resolutions and policy resolutions.
00:02:28 Mostly they get together just to drink.
00:02:31 And this time also, though, to vote on the leadership status of Pierre Polyev.
00:02:38 I'm not sure how the rules are set right now
00:02:40 if they have to face it, no matter if they win
00:02:42 or lose an election. I know in Alberta
00:02:44 win or lose an election, incumbent premiers
00:02:46 still have to face a leadership review. I don't
00:02:48 think that. I know it wasn't the case for the federal
00:02:50 conservatives. I'm not sure if that's changed or not.
00:02:52 But obviously, Pierre Polyev did not
00:02:54 form a majority government. It has to face
00:02:56 a leadership review.
00:03:00 And that's
00:03:00 that'll become... Dave,
00:03:02 which day of the convention is the leadership review?
00:03:05 I think the voting starts
00:03:06 on, is it Friday?
00:03:08 Yeah, so I think it was Friday, yeah.
00:03:09 I know, right.
00:03:10 Yeah.
00:03:10 So, yeah, Dave, Pierre Polyev facing a review to see if he gets to keep his job this week.
00:03:16 Yeah, it's important to note that all members of the Conservative Party do not get a vote.
00:03:21 It's only those who show up in Calvary.
00:03:24 So, expect several thousand of them at the BMO Centre.
00:03:28 As you said, Derek, arriving Thursday night, hospitality suites open, policy discussions throughout the day.
00:03:38 throughout the day on friday uh keynote speech by pier poliev voting opens on friday and i assume
00:03:45 they'll put out the release on or the number that he got on on saturday at some point there's no
00:03:51 specific time set for that uh nigel you know despite i i was chatting with with a guest we 0.95
00:03:59 have in uh office today uh you know about two hours ago uh you know saying oh what's all the
00:04:06 media saying oh i don't know if how polyev is going to do i i mean that's not that we haven't
00:04:12 done stories like this like but there is there are a dime a dozen speculation stories like is
00:04:17 there going to be an election and sometimes it's a legit like we had a column the other day hey
00:04:22 there might be an early election it's sometimes just legitimate speculation on the day by the way
00:04:27 okay there we go yeah uh and then sometimes it's just a slow news day and you know if a column has
00:04:34 If a columnist has nothing to write about, what's the go-to you can always do?
00:04:38 Should there be an early election?
00:04:40 Number two is, are they going to keep their leadership?
00:04:43 In Canadian federal history, I think only two people have ever lost a leadership review in Canadian history.
00:04:49 That's John Diefenbaker, for who the process was created, and then Thomas Mulcair.
00:04:54 Normally, a leader knows going into a convention if they're going to make it through.
00:04:59 And they save themselves the indignity of losing outright.
00:05:02 um yeah we had the funny situation in alberta uh with jason kenney yeah it's complicated but
00:05:09 uh no one i don't think is actually predicting poly of lose uh i think the question is you know
00:05:15 how strong a level of support is it uh you know joe clark's at the unofficial bar 68 69 percent
00:05:23 if you're below that well you probably if you can't get more than that with your own party
00:05:27 members you probably are not going to earn the trust of the broader public um how do you think
00:05:33 it's going to play out well i have no doubts that mr bollier is going to get a such a strong
00:05:40 vote that all this will seem very academic next week um i have no problem predicting that he'll
00:05:48 pull in over 80 percent there is nobody else nobody else is organizing and uh so if if they
00:05:55 were to turn him down, then there'd be this big question, well, what's this about? What are we
00:05:59 going to do now? You know, we suddenly go into a leadership race for which the party's totally
00:06:05 unprepared, either in organizational terms or even intellectually. So the question really is
00:06:14 what is he going to say in his speech, which, by the way, I see is on the schedule here for 6.30
00:06:21 on friday night and what is he going to say i mean he can either just give the usual thing or
00:06:28 he can be he can condemn mr carney which he's already done in his response to the carnage
00:06:34 devil speech or he can be forward-looking and put out a vision that um people haven't
00:06:44 haven't heard yet and i think you heard some i think we got a bit of a taste of what he might
00:06:49 have when he was saying in his response to Carney's Davos speech, just pointing out some
00:06:58 of the hokum in that speech, talks about the trade agreements, what stops us from growing
00:07:04 our trade. It's not the trade barriers they impose on us, the Americans, but the trade
00:07:09 barriers we impose on ourselves. They're all laws like C-69 and C-48.
00:07:15 He mentions the wire management in there, right?
00:07:17 Yeah, I'm not going to...
00:07:18 No, I'm joking.
00:07:20 I'm joking.
00:07:20 He did not.
00:07:21 No, he did not.
00:07:22 I know you do.
00:07:23 Let you wear it.
00:07:25 So, yeah, we're going to hear how we're going to do things differently,
00:07:30 and that's what's going to be the story out of this.
00:07:33 That's the story they want.
00:07:34 So do you think he's going to say Canadians on a nice house,
00:07:37 on a safe street, under a proud flag, guarded by a good military,
00:07:41 you know, a line that it was ad nauseum?
00:07:44 That seems familiar.
00:07:45 Yeah.
00:07:45 and hopefully it comes up with something new uh cory i i his what it's what's going to be a
00:07:53 speech is interesting i was kind of i was discussing this uh and the individual was
00:07:57 visiting us here today and you know i know his his go-to line was you know they'd always got
00:08:03 the biggest applause from the moment he launched his leadership race i remember you know his
00:08:06 leadership race came to cal calgary at an event at uh spruce meadows just packed the place and
00:08:14 when he said, and we're going to defund
00:08:16 the CBC, the place would go crazy.
00:08:19 Now, I thought
00:08:20 he would stop saying that once he had the leadership.
00:08:22 And to his credit, he did not. He kept on
00:08:24 saying that all the way through
00:08:25 until about halfway through the election
00:08:28 campaign. And he says,
00:08:30 he stopped saying it. It was no longer at his
00:08:32 rallies. When asked
00:08:33 from the media about it, because it was like the first time
00:08:36 he would never talk about it.
00:08:39 He said, you know,
00:08:40 we'll get to it eventually. It was always going to be like, this is the first
00:08:42 day kind of thing. We're going to shut them down.
00:08:44 We're going to sell the buildings and, you know, make it affordable housing for Canadian families.
00:08:51 I don't know.
00:08:52 Is he going to start talking?
00:08:53 You know, and then he backed down on getting rid of the media subsidies, more of the saying, I'm not going to get rid of them anymore.
00:08:58 I'm just going to make it available to everybody instead.
00:09:02 I don't know.
00:09:03 How well would that kind of stuff sit where he had backtracked on some of his positions?
00:09:07 it seems to me that
00:09:09 you know, once
00:09:11 this is nothing original I'm saying
00:09:14 but Justin Trudeau's resignation
00:09:16 he kind of lost his mojo
00:09:17 you know, Carney stole
00:09:19 you know, a fair number of chunks of his platform
00:09:22 obviously not everything
00:09:23 but he stole some of the big things like getting rid of at least
00:09:26 the consumer carbon tax
00:09:27 how is Polyev gonna
00:09:31 get his mojo back in an important
00:09:35 speech like this?
00:09:37 Yeah, I'm not sure how he's going to do it, but he's going to have to change some things.
00:09:41 As you pointed out, all those things he said were excellently received when he was running for the leadership,
00:09:46 as well as going into the last election.
00:09:48 He knows how to speak to conservatives, and I suspect, as Nigel was saying,
00:09:52 he's very comfortably going to win the leadership review.
00:09:56 I mean, most of the people who think that he's at risk, those are pundits we're hearing who are from outside of the party.
00:10:00 They're hoping for some intrigue. They're hoping for some upset.
00:10:03 but he's also obviously realized that he's not been able to reach that mushy middle of Canadians
00:10:10 and and you know us we certainly would love to see the demise of the CBC but even if we might
00:10:16 not like to admit it that's not a top of mind issue for most Canadians I wish it was it really
00:10:21 should be it's a billion a year down the toilet but that's not what's got to grab him so I'm
00:10:27 guessing he's going to have a measured you know that the leadership race will be or the review
00:10:32 will be behind him. The campaign kind of to try for a few years from now to win the next election
00:10:38 starts and it's going to be modeled. He's in Calgary. He's strong here. He doesn't have to
00:10:43 worry about reaching out to those conservatives. He's already got them. He's got to figure out how
00:10:47 to reach that mushy middle, particularly in central Canada. And we'll see how he models
00:10:53 his approach and which issues he wants to take on. He can't try to carve out of Carney's thing
00:11:00 going on the offensive with the Americans 0.99
00:11:02 or the trade deals, but at the same time,
00:11:04 that's that vulnerability that won the last election.
00:11:06 So where can he say he's standing up for Canada
00:11:09 yet not throwing rocks at the United States?
00:11:12 It's going to be a very carefully crafted speech.
00:11:15 I think he's going to be reaching for people
00:11:17 outside of the Conservative Party now
00:11:18 rather than the burden hand he has right now in Calgary.
00:11:23 I think actually to your point there, Corey,
00:11:25 when it comes to, he points out
00:11:28 that it doesn't matter what mr carney says we live right next door to the united states we do
00:11:34 90 of our business with them about eight times what we do with china you can't just turn that 0.89
00:11:39 around on a dime and start doing something different he made that point in his response
00:11:43 to the davos speech so i wouldn't be looking for anything other than we've got to fix it
00:11:49 up with the americans somehow and trump's only got three more years uh david um
00:11:54 Um, I was just, you know, kind of making fun of early election speculation columns, but
00:12:00 I think it is reasonable speculation right now. 0.98
00:12:03 One poll has got the liberals at 47%, which is damn, damn high. 0.89
00:12:08 I mean, uh, I don't, I don't really see the need for an election. 0.96
00:12:13 I think Carney is going to get his majority without an election.
00:12:16 I don't think he needs an election to get a majority.
00:12:18 You got, you know, he's very demoralized new Democrats sitting there.
00:12:22 You know, you could look to a conservative, a conservative MPs who are, you know, at the end of their political career or something, and they can say, whatever, I'll take a cabinet spot and maybe I don't get reelected because I'm in a hard conservative writing.
00:12:33 But, you know, that's a good way to finish my political career.
00:12:36 Then I can go lobby or conservatives in marginal seats who are fearful of losing their seat as conservative.
00:12:42 Maybe they'll actually have a better chance as a liberal because the liberals are higher in the polls right now.
00:12:46 I agree with that. He might get his majority one way or another, but there is some serious speculation.
00:12:51 and I don't think it's unfounded
00:12:53 that he pulls the trigger
00:12:55 in the spring. He's doing pretty high in the
00:12:57 pulls. A lot of
00:12:59 normal people I talk
00:13:01 to who just couldn't stand
00:13:03 Justin Trudeau's face and his voice
00:13:05 the bar
00:13:07 was set so low that they're
00:13:08 looking at Carney and saying, well, he's a grown
00:13:11 up. He shows up to work
00:13:13 with his pants on and he comes on time
00:13:15 to the office. And
00:13:17 you know, he
00:13:18 has a chance of getting a majority here.
00:13:22 But if that
00:13:23 happens, and Polyev was
00:13:25 to lose, I think, I mean,
00:13:27 it's been a while since a Conservative leader,
00:13:30 the Monoconservative
00:13:31 Party of Canada has only actually had one leader
00:13:33 be allowed to lose an election and contest
00:13:35 another. That was Stephen Harper 2004.
00:13:38 But that was a brand new party
00:13:39 and they brought them from majority to minority. There was progress.
00:13:42 But no one else
00:13:43 has even gotten two cakes at the can. Polyev is
00:13:45 almost certainly going to get two. But if he
00:13:46 doesn't make it at the next one, which
00:13:48 Could be as soon as this spring.
00:13:50 He's probably toast at that point, right?
00:13:52 Oh, I would assume so, yeah.
00:13:53 What are the Conservatives pulling it right now?
00:13:54 Because I saw something that was, what, 36% or 38%?
00:13:58 36% to 38% is what I'd say.
00:13:59 Yeah, that's what I was thinking as well.
00:14:01 So, yeah, early election, I think, well, I think maybe the Liberals could possibly get another point or two
00:14:05 and definitely get a majority for the government.
00:14:07 Because, I mean, there's a lot of people that talk about the Conservative leadership in Polyev,
00:14:10 and they don't like Polyev, and they wouldn't vote Conservative just based on him from some of the people I've talked to.
00:14:15 So, I don't really know leadership-wise.
00:14:17 I mean, obviously, like you guys said, that he's going to obviously get his leadership review.
00:14:20 He's going to get probably over 80%.
00:14:21 But on the offhand, chances of 20% that he doesn't get the leadership bid and they hold an early election.
00:14:28 What do you think would happen then?
00:14:29 Well, I think there's no way he's going to lose this leadership review.
00:14:33 Like, I think the bare minimum he gets is 75.
00:14:36 The bare minimum he gets in here is 75.
00:14:40 I'd be shocked if it was lower than that.
00:14:42 I would be too.
00:14:42 But is that good enough?
00:14:43 Yeah, exactly.
00:14:44 So when you've got 25% of delegates voting against you, can you honestly go forward as the leader and say, I'm the best part, I'm the best choice for this party?
00:14:53 I think he does better in 75. 75, 77, 78 is kind of a kiss of death number, at least in Alberta. That was the number Stelman got. He survived the leadership review, but he was ousted within a year. It was the number that Alison Redford got. She was ousted within a year.
00:15:09 So you get to fight on, but not necessarily for that long if you get those kinds of numbers.
00:15:14 I think he's probably going to get higher than that.
00:15:16 So I think he gets through this weekend unscathed.
00:15:21 Probably not with the numbers he would otherwise expect into the 90s.
00:15:25 What was it, Daniel Smith got?
00:15:26 Ninety, uh, 94?
00:15:29 94, something.
00:15:30 And there was apparently an organized effort against her that obviously...
00:15:35 One of the things here, Derek, is that if you're really against Pierre Poirier when you live in
00:15:41 central Canada, it's going to cost you a lot of money, $1,000 for the conference alone, plus hotels,
00:15:48 plus airfares, plus your wife, double times everything by two. To get here, to do what?
00:15:54 To say, I don't like the guy. So I think a lot of people who don't like him will probably just
00:15:58 watch from afar. Important in that, in particular,
00:16:02 is the interesting choice of timing for Doug Ford's Ontario PC Party convention this weekend.
00:16:09 It's being held at the same time.
00:16:12 They've known the timing of the Federal Consumer Convention forever.
00:16:15 And then the Ontario PCs intentionally booked a convention at the same time.
00:16:20 I think it's well known Doug Ford wants Pierre Polyev gone, probably wants his job.
00:16:25 It's been very obvious he was all but campaigning for the Liberals in the last federal election.
00:16:29 but I think they knew that
00:16:32 they couldn't out-organize Polyev
00:16:34 they couldn't beat him so this was a way of saying
00:16:36 well we're obviously not even trying
00:16:38 we're doing our thing at the same time
00:16:40 but it does mean
00:16:42 it probably strengthens
00:16:44 Polyev's hand a bit
00:16:45 because Ontario delegates make up one third
00:16:48 of the delegates at the convention
00:16:49 and the hardcore
00:16:51 Doug Ford guys are much more likely
00:16:54 to save a few bucks
00:16:55 and go to the Ontario PC convention
00:16:58 this weekend, rather than spend a bunch of money,
00:17:00 come out to Calgary, get yelled at
00:17:02 by people, just to register a vote
00:17:04 against PolyEF.
00:17:05 They would be hell.
00:17:08 But anyway, I think
00:17:09 the choice of timing for the Ontario PC
00:17:11 convention is going to strengthen PolyEF's
00:17:14 numbers a bit from Ontario.
00:17:18 Okay.
00:17:20 Anything else for the convention you guys
00:17:21 want to touch on?
00:17:24 No. Okay.
00:17:27 It's funny.
00:17:28 Because it is going to be held not in the same building, but on the Stampede Grounds.
00:17:33 The Conservative Convention, I think, is at the BMO Center on the Stampede Grounds, right?
00:17:36 Yes, it is.
00:17:37 Also on the Stampede Grounds is the Big Four.
00:17:40 And yesterday at the Big Four.
00:17:42 Monday.
00:17:43 Monday.
00:17:43 Monday night.
00:17:44 Was it Monday?
00:17:45 Oh, yeah, yesterday was Tuesday.
00:17:46 Sorry.
00:17:46 Monday.
00:17:46 Monday evening.
00:17:48 David, you were on the ground for the Western Standard there for a big independence rally.
00:17:54 There was people lining up long, long before to sign the location to get a referendum on independence.
00:18:00 Tell us about the event.
00:18:02 Well, I mean, what can you say?
00:18:03 It was absolutely historic.
00:18:04 I mean, the turnout, I think the official numbers came in.
00:18:06 I think it was 4,900 and some people.
00:18:08 They counted just under 5,000.
00:18:10 And yeah, they had, I think, people were lining up, I think, at 10 o'clock in the morning.
00:18:14 It opened at 11 to sign the petition.
00:18:16 I think one of the organizers told me there was 750 people already lined up at 10 a.m. to get in, waiting an hour.
00:18:22 and then it just was kind of just progressive throughout the day and they didn't i asked how
00:18:26 many um signatures they got they wanted to release the actual numbers but it had to have been in the
00:18:30 thousands because i went down to where the 150 campuses were and it was packed and this would
00:18:34 have been probably at about five o'clock at night and it was absolutely packed so yeah i wouldn't be
00:18:37 surprised if they got several thousand signatures from that alone in just this one event and then
00:18:41 it was yeah probably like you said earlier it's probably the well it is the largest indoor
00:18:46 independence event that's ever been held in alberta history the biggest one's actually the
00:18:49 one that they had at the legislature, Armidson,
00:18:51 that I think got about 14,000 people.
00:18:53 But yeah, this was unbelievable, really.
00:18:55 It was just great to be there.
00:18:55 It was a historic night,
00:18:56 and I can't believe that Corey didn't actually get there,
00:18:59 of all people.
00:19:02 Well, I know it ate me up.
00:19:04 I mean, talk about a part of history,
00:19:06 but I've got to keep the stability of my marriage in mind
00:19:12 versus my political loyalties.
00:19:14 And if we passed up on our trip to the South in January
00:19:16 for me to go to a rally,
00:19:18 Jane probably would have gone without me. 1.00
00:19:20 But I'm certain there's going to be more rallies.
00:19:23 I mean, the strength of this is just striking.
00:19:26 That's the first of, you know, we've got months of campaigning that's going to happen.
00:19:29 There's going to be a referendum coming up.
00:19:31 I mean, the signatures are just going wild.
00:19:33 There's no doubt they're going to pass that bar.
00:19:36 I would suspect the organizers are going to be planning some huge rallies
00:19:40 because then you can start using outdoor venues again in May and June
00:19:44 and getting into fall and kicking it off like this is something else.
00:19:48 I mean, yeah, as a longtime independence advocate and, you know,
00:19:51 person who worked on this for longer than I like to think.
00:19:54 I mean, the largest really famous one, if people remember,
00:19:57 there's a picture of Doug Christie with the Western Canada concept.
00:20:00 I think it was 1981 at the Jubilee Auditorium and he had his hands up
00:20:03 and it was a photo that went across the entire nation
00:20:07 that something was building in Alberta.
00:20:09 and this rally
00:20:11 blew that out of the water with the turnout
00:20:13 and only because the room was full
00:20:15 I mean if they could have booked a saddle dome it would have been
00:20:18 interesting to see just how many people
00:20:20 would have gotten up and come out to this
00:20:22 rally we're seeing something really
00:20:24 unique building up right now
00:20:25 and assuming the organizers don't blow up
00:20:28 or something it's only going to get
00:20:30 stronger
00:20:30 yeah I mean it was
00:20:34 an incredible event to see
00:20:36 the room looked totally
00:20:38 packed
00:20:38 um dave did you watch uh the video from there i've seen dave's videos they were excellent yes
00:20:44 what stood out as the main uh well just the overwhelming number um you know i i i don't
00:20:53 think there's there's no doubt they're going to get enough signatures right there's there's
00:20:56 absolutely no doubt about that so behind the scenes if they want to succeed then they need
00:21:02 to be making their, their, their plans on the day that the government announces the, the, uh,
00:21:08 the, the petition has passed that somebody comes out and becomes the leader of this independence.
00:21:14 Yeah. Uh, because right now you've got petty squabbling between, uh, various people, uh, who
00:21:21 are, are all claiming to be leaders to be, none of them right now are going to win the, win the day.
00:21:29 So they need to, you know, I've said this before, they need to, when the petition is ratified by Elections Alberta, they need to have a press conference and say, this is our leader.
00:21:41 And I would hope they're smart enough that those discussions are going on behind the scenes.
00:21:47 Yeah, Naito, this seems to be the big question hanging over it right now, is leadership.
00:21:56 I'm not sure it could just be a noitant. 0.92
00:21:58 maybe it could be, uh, hard to say. Normally, you know, when we have had Quebec referendums in the
00:22:05 past, the natural, the natural leader is the Quebec premier. You had René Levesque, and then you had,
00:22:11 um, uh, uh, no, no, Lucien Bouchard took over after because, uh, the premier Jacques Perizeau
00:22:20 was kind of a, he was kind of a, he was not going over very well. And so, uh, actually on paper,
00:22:26 he remained the leader of the S-Side, but
00:22:28 they made Lucien Bouchard chief
00:22:30 negotiator or something, and he became
00:22:32 the de facto leader, the
00:22:34 de facto spokesman. But you had
00:22:36 a clear political, you had
00:22:38 political parties from which to draw
00:22:40 on. The UCP's membership
00:22:42 is dominantly pro-independence,
00:22:44 not uniformly so, but dominantly.
00:22:46 There are UCP
00:22:48 MLAs who support independence, but it's 0.99
00:22:50 very quiet. There are UCP
00:22:51 cabinet ministers, very quiet.
00:22:54 It's not really, they're not really out there
00:22:56 publicly. Some are
00:22:57 wink-wink-nudge-nudge more than
00:23:00 others, but we're not really
00:23:02 able at this time yet to draw on a political
00:23:04 class. Danielle Smith has said,
00:23:06 it's for the Alberta people. I'm staying out of it. I'm staying neutral.
00:23:08 The other side is going to be
00:23:10 at least
00:23:12 a pantheon of leadership. It'll be very
00:23:14 entertaining seeing
00:23:16 Nahid Nenshi,
00:23:18 Thomas Lukasik, and Jason Kenney have to share
00:23:20 a stage on the
00:23:22 Federalist side
00:23:23 with Antifa supporters.
00:23:25 We've got a story coming out on that.
00:23:29 That'll be fun.
00:23:31 But on the pro-independence side,
00:23:34 the politicians are naturally risk-averse.
00:23:38 And this is a risky political position to take,
00:23:41 to come out and say, yes, I'm pro-independence.
00:23:44 You're not going to see federal conservative MPs do it
00:23:47 because they're in the Conservative Party of Canada.
00:23:49 There are certainly some who sympathize,
00:23:51 but they can't.
00:23:51 They're sitting in a federalist party.
00:23:53 so it'd have to come from the ucp so we don't have the natural reservoirs of political talent
00:23:59 to draw on that the federalist side does we don't have the natural reservoirs of political talent
00:24:04 that they do in quebec where you have the pq you have the bloc uh i'm not sure where this is coming
00:24:09 from but if we don't figure this out soon it's all for nothing it's all for nothing and there's
00:24:16 some good folks involved right now and you know some of them i like more than others but i mean
00:24:21 They're all generally trying to pull in the same direction.
00:24:24 Some of them tend to let their own personalities, I think,
00:24:27 dominate things more than they should.
00:24:30 But they're trying to pull in the same direction.
00:24:32 But there's no clear, recognized leader at this time.
00:24:36 If the movement does not figure that out,
00:24:39 it's got no chance of success.
00:24:41 Right, so really what tends to happen
00:24:43 in other successful examples of the genre
00:24:46 is that you have a political conference.
00:24:49 You get all the people together,
00:24:51 and you try to decide exactly what you're going to do.
00:24:56 It happened in the early days of the United States.
00:24:59 It happened during the French Revolution.
00:25:01 There's a number of precedents for this, but you get all sides out there.
00:25:06 They actually have a, if they want it, they have a constitution
00:25:10 courtesy of Bruce Party, who wrote up an Alberta independence constitution.
00:25:15 Probably wouldn't satisfy everybody, but at least there's a starting point.
00:25:19 Well, that's for a state.
00:25:20 for the movement, for a yes side of
00:25:22 a referendum camp. And you need all the
00:25:24 groups. This is the point you're making.
00:25:26 Unless we know what we're going to do with this when we get
00:25:28 there, then it could be all for nothing.
00:25:31 It's not a bad idea to have an
00:25:32 idea of whether at least we're going to be a monarchy
00:25:34 or a republic.
00:25:36 Some things like that could be set in fairly
00:25:38 easily. Monarchy, and I'm the
00:25:40 camp. That's simple.
00:25:42 Well, there we go.
00:25:44 That stuff I actually think is best done
00:25:46 after. You do that in a constitutional convention,
00:25:48 you get people to agree on the independence or not i mean if we started arguing now about are
00:25:54 we a constitutional monarchy are we a republic these things i mean you lose i gotta i gotta
00:26:01 disagree with you i gotta disagree with you sorry nigel but if if if i if i'm being offered uh 0.84
00:26:07 independence yes or no i want to know what independence looks like i want to know whether
00:26:11 you're going to support the monarchy or not but no i want to know what you're i know of course
00:26:16 It's not even a government-led initiative.
00:26:19 This is a citizen initiative petition.
00:26:22 So unless it's like, the referendum would have to be then adopt this constitution or the status quo, not independence.
00:26:30 Because the premier is not even openly campaigning.
00:26:33 So there's absolutely no way to say, we can have discussions about monarchy versus republic and these kinds of things.
00:26:41 But there's absolutely no way you could do that.
00:26:44 You have to decide first, well, do we want to be independent?
00:26:47 When the United States, when the Continental Congress declared independence,
00:26:51 there was still every possibility that they would become a monarchy.
00:26:55 That was not decided until the Constitutional Convention.
00:26:59 It was the Continental Congress with a variety of different states,
00:27:02 and then they figured it out.
00:27:03 Well, then you'd have to do another referendum.
00:27:06 Yes.
00:27:07 I think you would.
00:27:08 Okay, so yes or no.
00:27:09 Yeah.
00:27:10 Then you have a referendum with specific plans.
00:27:13 this is what we're going to do here here you know involving everything because it's quite
00:27:17 complicated to become your own country i imagine and i don't want a bunch of people that have no 1.00
00:27:23 idea what they're doing in charge of it if i'm going to vote for independence so i i would i
00:27:29 i would think that there would be some some platforms put forward during the during the
00:27:35 campaign saying okay this is what we would do if we were in charge in terms of you know agriculture
00:27:41 or something like that, or even just
00:27:43 cross-border business with
00:27:45 B.C. What's going to happen to
00:27:47 B.C. wines if an independent
00:27:49 power comes into Alberta?
00:27:51 But it's all speculative. I think you'd first
00:27:53 vote on independence, and then you'd have to have a
00:27:55 constitutional convention. They write
00:27:57 a constitution, and then that
00:27:59 constitution's put to the people for ratification.
00:28:01 That's the way the United States did it after
00:28:03 independence. I think that's a generally
00:28:05 responsible way to do it.
00:28:07 The founding father, the Continental Congress
00:28:09 didn't sit around and devise
00:28:11 three orders of government and you know but you know they have the senate they have the house
00:28:15 they have the judiciary and the president they didn't figure that out uh until after independence
00:28:21 was achieved i i think it would be similar if it goes down this way well you may be right but the
00:28:28 the point when you know you know people who aren't into this stuff the way we are come to be asked
00:28:37 they would say well i don't know what i'm voting for yes i don't like ottawa and i think
00:28:42 equalization is a terrible thing but i don't like the attitude from some of the people with down
00:28:47 east but like what's this going to look like well i still have my count of the pension trial the
00:28:53 answer is yes you should but you know well that's something i know that they want certainty on all
00:28:58 of those those things have easy answers those are those are policy questions they're not fundamental
00:29:02 constitutional questions fundamental constitutional questions uh that's a whole other process who is
00:29:08 actually who am i voting for here yeah well technically you still have the same great
00:29:15 i'm saying getting back to kind of where we began with this they they can get away with it for a
00:29:20 while with having a number of voices because the goal is just getting the signatures on a petition
00:29:25 to get a referendum going but they need when they move past the petitioning portion that's into the
00:29:30 the real campaign and they're going to have to have a centralized figure, a face speaking for
00:29:36 the movement because you can't have mixed messaging starting to come out or people won't vote. As Dave
00:29:41 said, well, is it this? Is it this? You need sort of one voice who's going to say, this is where
00:29:46 we're coming from with it. And we've seen, as was kind of referred to, and I'll mention names, you
00:29:51 know, we had Jeff Rath said something that stirred a bunch of people up and then a statement came out
00:29:56 backed by Mitch Sylvester saying well Jeff when he tweets is speaking for Jeff he's not speaking
00:30:01 for the movement and then Jeff recently says I'm down in the United States and I'm negotiating a
00:30:07 500 billion dollar line of credit with the USA where on earth did that come from and that's just
00:30:12 kind of fallen by the wayside they're not going to win a campaign if they got to keep correcting
00:30:16 and going back and forth as was said I think once the petitioning phase is over some sort of
00:30:22 convention has to be held it's uncharted territory so that's what makes it difficult as Derek said
00:30:27 when you have a premier doing it it's not a natural position in Quebec but we don't have that
00:30:31 they're going to have to select somebody who's at least the official spokesperson the the one who's
00:30:36 going to speak for the movement when it comes to these things and that you still have other voices
00:30:40 contributing but right now you've got a number of names and nobody really kind of taking that
00:30:44 authority and responsibility and I think human nature still says even though they're voting on a
00:30:49 concept rather than a party or a person. They want to see one
00:30:53 figure, one person as the voice speaking to this
00:30:57 and they just don't have that yet. I think they can get away with it a little longer, but once
00:31:01 it moves into the referendum campaign stage versus the petitioning stage,
00:31:05 it's going to have to change. It's up to the leadership, I guess, of those guys to figure out how
00:31:09 they're going to do that.
00:31:12 Let's bring it back then to what I was getting at a little bit earlier.
00:31:16 who is a spokesman
00:31:18 for the Federalists, the no side
00:31:20 of the referendum. Thomas
00:31:22 Lukasik wants the job. I don't think
00:31:24 many on that side want him to be
00:31:27 their spokesman.
00:31:29 But for sure.
00:31:31 Well, Nick Nenshi will
00:31:32 want the job.
00:31:34 In Quebec,
00:31:36 you would have a PQ Premier,
00:31:38 which is the official yes guy.
00:31:40 The no side would be a combination of
00:31:42 federal liberals, federal conservatives,
00:31:44 but generally led by the provincial liberals,
00:31:46 the leader of the opposition.
00:31:48 That's traditionally it,
00:31:49 but this is not a premier versus opposition leader thing anymore.
00:31:53 Nancy would probably want the job. 1.00
00:31:56 It would appear to me J.C. Kenney wants the job.
00:31:59 It's kind of a way to get himself back out into the public.
00:32:04 I'll put it to any of you.
00:32:05 Who do you think are the leading contenders
00:32:08 to lead the no campaign, the Federalist side?
00:32:12 Well, I'm not sure there's the same necessity for somebody to personally represent that side of the campaign. All I've got to say is, I just don't want any change. Nobody needs to articulate that for me. The people who do need to have a leader, we've just spent 20 minutes on it, is the independent side. Yeah, they've got to have a focal point.
00:32:33 But if anybody can go out there, and you've mentioned three people,
00:32:38 we're all keen to do so and say, we just shouldn't change anything.
00:32:42 We should stay part of Canada.
00:32:44 It doesn't need to come together as one credible point.
00:32:48 So you've got these two opposites going head to head.
00:32:51 You have somebody who's very driven on the independent side,
00:32:54 or you would like somebody very driven on the independent side,
00:32:57 just pushing against the storge of everything going on just as it's ever been.
00:33:02 I agree that it's not as critical
00:33:04 the status quo side is
00:33:06 stronger, they've got much more
00:33:08 institutional support
00:33:10 and
00:33:12 they've got several obvious potential
00:33:14 nothing's going to change
00:33:15 but
00:33:17 I don't know, but it is, they're still going to have
00:33:20 to pick someone, that's the way the rules work, there's going to be a
00:33:22 yes committee, there's a no committee, there's going to
00:33:24 be a leader on the other side
00:33:26 who do you guys think are the obvious guys?
00:33:29 Any names beyond what I've
00:33:30 side i don't think so really to be completely honest i've been just thinking like you guys
00:33:34 have more about the independence movement they need a charismatic leader that people can actually
00:33:38 look to to see what they have to say so maybe cory should get out of the desert and step up
00:33:41 then maybe he's already ruled that out not a chance uh another name to bring up though who
00:33:48 we haven't who's been kind of quiet on this so far is mark carney you're the prime minister of
00:33:52 this country with a budding independence movement within it and i don't know what so much coming in
00:33:57 opposition to the independence movement because that would probably just inflame it further
00:34:00 but something of an approach trying to you know reach out to albertans and say guys i think this
00:34:06 isn't the route you should go this is why the future is bright with not going that path the
00:34:11 thing that we've seen a lot in in this so far was the difference in attitude in 1995 when again
00:34:16 everybody was saying please go back please don't go right now the federalist forces are saying you
00:34:20 aren't allowed to go or you're rednecks if you want to go or you're selfish if you want to go 0.85
00:34:24 So that attitude is pretty different, which is fine as an independent supporter, because I think that only helps build the base.
00:34:28 But as a national leader, Mark Carney has got a bit of a responsibility then to quell this movement, to convince Albertans why this isn't the path they want to go.
00:34:37 And so far, he's held his tongue on this.
00:34:39 So we'll see if he comes out more vocally and trying to make that case for why the status quo should be maintained, because he hasn't done anything yet.
00:34:47 yeah ironically he's in a meeting uh this afternoon with uh david eby and daniel smith
00:34:54 yeah and i think the topic of discussions will be pipelines i assume so um if if we get a pipeline
00:35:02 going uh before the end of the year i think that would kill off any independence uh vote possibly
00:35:08 um because i mean that would end the ottawa's against us i don't know what he says uh you know
00:35:15 It would have to come along with the lifting of the tanker ban and stuff like that.
00:35:20 But Danielle Smith seems to be happier with Kearney than she was with Trudeau.
00:35:29 And she's sort of saying, you know, I know what's going on behind the scenes.
00:35:32 Let's let this process play out.
00:35:35 So I think she's very optimistic that she's going to get pipeline approval by the fall.
00:35:42 And if that is the case, I think that's going to take a good chunk of wind out of the sails of the independence movement.
00:35:49 Just to make sure, Mr. Carney is pushing ahead with the gun grab so that if Alberta does vote for independence, it will be a disarmed Alberta, he would hope.
00:35:59 Yes. Well, I don't think they're getting many calls from Alberta to say there is my gun.
00:36:04 Yeah. During the 1995 Quebec referendum, there was a Quebecer as Prime Minister, Jean Chrétien, and the yes side generally tried to keep him at arm's length because they didn't like the perception of federal politicians intervening.
00:36:23 uh he did intervene somewhat but it was it was gentle i don't uh he'll try to portray himself
00:36:30 as an alberton uh if you haven't lived here in a better part of half a century i don't think
00:36:36 i think you lose your alberta card at some at some point um but one to watch and i would not
00:36:43 be surprised at all to see some nod to it at the convention this weekend is pure polyev pure
00:36:48 polyev is born and raised alberta he spent the majority of his life and his entire adult life
00:36:52 in Ontario, in Ottawa.
00:36:55 But he's still born and raised out here,
00:36:58 has a lot of support out here,
00:36:59 and since he lost his seat in Ottawa
00:37:01 and ran a by-election in Battle River Crofit,
00:37:04 he now represents an Alberta constituency.
00:37:07 That is someone who is not going to be able
00:37:09 politically to stay silent.
00:37:11 I'm not sure how aggressively he'd be here
00:37:14 campaigning or not,
00:37:17 but he'd be a powerful weapon
00:37:21 on the Federalist side
00:37:23 you know because
00:37:25 the independence movement in Alberta is
00:37:27 almost uniformly a phenomenon of the right
00:37:29 it's a right wing and it's a center 0.61
00:37:31 right thing it's there's not
00:37:33 really any notable lefties
00:37:35 of any number who
00:37:37 support independence so I
00:37:39 would keep my ears open
00:37:41 this weekend for him to
00:37:43 mention in his speech like you know
00:37:45 I understand the frustrations
00:37:48 he'll say something like that
00:37:50 But, you know, leaving is not the way to go.
00:37:52 The way to go is to vote for me, and I'll fix everything.
00:37:55 It'll be great.
00:37:56 You'll probably see, I'd be surprised, actually,
00:37:58 if we didn't see something along those lines come from him.
00:38:02 Interestingly, though, he said he's not going to run again in Alberta already.
00:38:06 You know, he just got into power, and then the Conservative Party has already said,
00:38:10 nope, he's running somewhere else.
00:38:11 Well, he's had to give his seat back to Damien Kirk.
00:38:13 Yeah, exactly.
00:38:14 So he won't be a, he won't be a sitting, he won't be a future Alberta MP after the next.
00:38:21 But during the likely coming referendum, he will be.
00:38:24 And there's no way that the leader of the opposition with an Alberta seat is going to be quiet on that.
00:38:29 He's going to be campaigning on the other side.
00:38:32 Okay.
00:38:33 Well, let's, we'll then go to our parting shots.
00:38:37 Let's start with Dave.
00:38:39 Well, the final bill is in for the Great Ostrich Massacre of 2024 in British Columbia.
00:38:48 A total of $6.1 million, Nigel, to have 6.1 million.
00:38:56 How much per bird is that?
00:38:58 Yeah, it's a lot.
00:39:00 But they apparently ate a lot of hay in the time that they were under.
00:39:05 They fed them?
00:39:06 they wanted they wanted to be well fed when they were slaughtered yeah so they all wanted steak
00:39:13 so yes 6.1 million that could have could have helped a lot of the poor families in the country
00:39:19 i mean it would have helped more poor families if they have i mean i'm just truly against this 0.98
00:39:24 anyway but if you're going to kill them at least get them on the dinner plate for heaven's sake 0.62
00:39:28 yeah exactly feed the homeless yeah uh nigel so i'm just delighted to learn that uh we're now 1.00
00:39:34 getting into the you know into the days before our return to the moon that nasa's artemis 2
00:39:42 expedition supposed to take off between now and february the 6th the astronauts have entered the
00:39:47 entered the um the room that says like quarantine so somebody gets a cold before they leave
00:39:54 we've got one canadian aboard uh this is a speaking of somebody kind of said you don't
00:40:00 late watching the the moon landings in 1973 first shot around the moon in 68 and all that sort of
00:40:06 thing uh sorry about the moon landings in 69 and the subsequent uh skyline up and all that went
00:40:13 with it and then they stopped doing it you know the great adventure became sending remote control
00:40:20 that's because we never went around to the soldier that's because it was it was recorded in the
00:40:25 the deserts. Until now, you haven't done this.
00:40:27 But anyway,
00:40:28 this is by the Western standards.
00:40:31 You know.
00:40:34 Anyway,
00:40:35 great. Go, guys.
00:40:37 Go for where we are going for the first time now.
00:40:39 If you're interested, David did
00:40:41 an in-depth story on it yesterday.
00:40:43 It's on our website.
00:40:44 I'll give you all the details.
00:40:48 David, your first
00:40:50 parted shot.
00:40:52 Oh, I don't really have one, but the gun grab's annoying me again
00:40:54 the whole program, because yet again I saw that
00:40:56 there is another police department
00:40:59 in Ontario that's saying that they're not going to have
00:41:00 anything to do with this. So when are the Liberals going to wake up
00:41:02 that even people in Ontario, Liberal
00:41:04 Powerhouse Ontario, want nothing to do with the gun grab
00:41:06 program, and how much more money are they going to spend on this?
00:41:09 Lots. Lots and lots and lots. 0.99
00:41:11 Yeah, they will spend money until
00:41:12 they work on half a billion dollars, I think,
00:41:14 if I remember correctly, what the numbers are.
00:41:17 This is funny. It's like a stick hub,
00:41:18 except we have the guns. Basically,
00:41:21 yeah. Give us your
00:41:22 guns! No?
00:41:24 yeah this is an odd stick up isn't it okay uh cory your parting shot well just desperately
00:41:32 seeking political and moral courage on on medical assistance and dying it's the stories are really
00:41:37 coming out now you know a woman that sounds like possibly put to death against her will because of 1.00
00:41:44 caregiver fatigue another one now we hear of obesity you know i i do believe perhaps people
00:41:50 in a case with extreme
00:41:52 circumstances and pain
00:41:54 can make a decision to go with dignity at the time
00:41:56 of their choosing, but it's clear that Maid's gone
00:41:58 totally off the rails and out of control
00:42:00 with whatever the original intents were
00:42:02 and nobody's got the courage to hit the brakes
00:42:04 on this thing and say, let's get this
00:42:06 back in order for what it was supposed to be meant for
00:42:08 so I don't want to read about any more
00:42:10 of these stories. Let's get on
00:42:12 our politician's case to say, hey
00:42:14 speak up on this because this is
00:42:16 really reprehensible
00:42:17 That's disappointing
00:42:20 do you have anything else to add to your parting shot i know you want me to jump in that pool
00:42:25 and i'm just not gonna do it uh for the sake of my gracious hosts uh who have to pay to have it
00:42:34 clean you know i mean i'm just not dressed for the event just just so all our viewers know cory
00:42:38 morgan uh is above bribery i offered him money before that we started the show when we were off
00:42:44 I offered him money.
00:42:46 Not enough.
00:42:46 I don't know.
00:42:47 Obviously not.
00:42:47 Okay, yeah.
00:42:48 So maybe he still has a price.
00:42:50 Maybe he has a price and I'm just too cheap.
00:42:53 Name your price, Corey.
00:42:55 Oh, I just don't have one at this point.
00:42:58 I wish you'd know.
00:42:59 Everyone has a price.
00:43:01 Everyone's got a price.
00:43:02 If I said $1,000, I bet you would have.
00:43:06 Yeah.
00:43:06 $1,000 I would, but I know you're not going to do that.
00:43:09 So we'll get an AI image of me for the next show or something.
00:43:13 I'll put myself in a spot where I'm not imposing as much
00:43:16 But yeah, but now it's going to be
00:43:18 AI of you and a speedo
00:43:20 Yeah, there's something to look forward to
00:43:22 There we go
00:43:23 Okay, ladies, make sure you get the 1.00
00:43:26 2026 Western Standard calendar
00:43:27 Swimsuit calendar
00:43:28 My parting shot
00:43:30 I mentioned the Ontario PC Convention
00:43:33 And the timing of that has some impact
00:43:35 I think on how the vote will go with the National
00:43:37 Conservative Convention taking place in Calgary
00:43:39 But
00:43:41 Very interestingly, our new Ontario legislative reporter, we've got Jeremy, he tells us that the Ontario PCs have banned the media from covering their convention.
00:43:57 Now, it's not the first political party to ever do it.
00:43:59 I know it's happened in Alberta before, and I think it was Tom Korski of Blacklocks who snuck in. 1.00
00:44:06 yes we smoked into the kitchen and listened to literally a glass on the door yeah so uh guys
00:44:13 you could like it says ralph klein tried it and failed in the 90s because an intrepid reporter
00:44:19 put a glass against the door and listened in on the whole thing you've got thousands of people
00:44:24 at this thing all with recording devices in their pockets you're not going to keep anything secret
00:44:32 it uh i don't know what doug ford's trying to do the ontario pc party is the shittiest political
00:44:38 party in the country it is the most vanilla of pull of of vanilla parties whenever you want to
00:44:44 know forget whatever they vote on at policy resolutions whatever they're going to do is
00:44:47 whatever the polls say they should do whatever is going to make doug you know give doug ford a one
00:44:52 percent bump in the polls that day that's what they're going to do i don't know what the hell
00:44:56 they're trying to hide um anyway uh we wouldn't be the western standard if we took no for an answer
00:45:04 so stay tuned all right gentlemen uh nigel david dave and mr sunshine 0.54
00:45:13 thank you very much and uh john on the studio thank you very much thank all of you for joining
00:45:19 us today remember the western standard is only ten dollars a month or a hundred dollars a year
00:45:23 for unlimited access to all western standard content get you past the pesky paywall so you
00:45:28 can read us with your morning constitutional uh thank you very much for joining us today
00:45:33 and god bless
00:45:53 We'll be right back.