Western Standard - October 31, 2024


Premier Smith’s role is secure as UCP leader as review looms

Topics
Mentioned
Coal, Culture, and Conflict - Grassy Mountain Coal Project in #CrowsnestPass Documentary UCP AGM: Alberta Bill Of Rights - Special Debate

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

191.63

Word count

9,158

Sentence count

574

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The United Conservative Party Annual General Meeting is this weekend in Alberta, and a lot of attention is being paid to the fact that the party is hosting the largest political convention in Canadian history, and that it s being attended by over 6,000 delegates. But is this a good or bad thing?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Transcription by CastingWords
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 You know, Justin, while he's our problem today, doesn't have much between his ears.
00:01:54 His father, unfortunately, was smart and caused a lot of problems we're still dealing with right now.
00:01:59 Okay, according to a lot of folks, my sound wasn't on for the first part, but it must be going by now.
00:02:04 So welcome to the show and good to see you all there.
00:02:08 Be sure to use that comment, scroll to send me questions, suggestions, and even let me know if the sound happens to pop off so we don't miss anything on there.
00:02:16 So again, welcome, use it, thanks for coming on, and let's get on with things.
00:02:22 So I'm going to talk about we've got a big weekend coming up in Alberta, and it's the United Conservative Party annual general meeting.
00:02:30 The registrations for that UCP AGM, all these acronyms, is just shy of 6,000 delegates.
00:02:37 It's going to be the largest political convention in Canadian history.
00:02:41 And for fans like me, we're fans of grassroots political participation.
00:02:44 I mean, this is a fantastic development.
00:02:46 Having that many engaged members taking the time and spending the money to take part in a convention.
00:02:50 and this is between elections, indicates these members feel they can make an impact on the
00:02:54 direction of the party. Now, the question remains whether the impact is going to be a positive one
00:02:59 or not. Internal squabbles and division, those are hallmarks of conservative movements. I mean,
00:03:04 when partisans aren't going to battle with opponents in other parties, they have this
00:03:07 habit of turning their guns and firing at each other. Ralph Klein, Ed Stelmack, Alison Redford,
00:03:13 and Jason Kenney, they all left the premiership due to a collapse of support not around the
00:03:17 province, but within their own parties. Only Rachel Notley and Jim Prentice left the roles
00:03:21 due to electoral losses. The threat to conservative leaders from within their parties is quite real.
00:03:27 But is Daniel Smith facing an ouster this weekend as she stands up in front of the members for
00:03:33 a leadership review? I really doubt it. We've got factions making noise, trying to fan the flames
00:03:39 of internal division within the party, and they're trying to create the impression that Smith faces
00:03:43 is a real threat of losing or at least getting a low level of support at the leadership review.
00:03:48 None of these factions have the interests of the UCP or probably the province at heart.
00:03:52 They don't think they're aiding the party by pushing Smith from the leadership. In fact,
00:03:56 they're hoping the leadership is destabilized and the party will become weaker. Disgruntled and
00:04:01 unemployed political leftists like Thomas Lukasik have been, yeah, you remember Fabio? Yeah,
00:04:06 they've been trying to create issues through buying memberships in the party and then he was
00:04:10 playing victim when he found himself declined for his membership. Look, guys like him have no
00:04:14 interest in supporting the party and they never did. There's no benefit allowing these trolls to 0.89
00:04:18 enter and work to disrupt things from within the organization. Parties are private entities and
00:04:23 they can limit membership to whoever they please. Yes, being grassroots focused, they should
00:04:27 embrace as many members as reasonably possible, but to bring in somebody like Lukasik is just 0.99
00:04:33 foolish. I mean, he's telegraphed quite clearly his only intention is to cause damage. If someone 0.93
00:04:36 told you they plan to come into your house and purposely plug your toilet, would you still open
00:04:41 the door and let me use your bathroom? The lukastics out there are vocal, but are few and far between. 0.99
00:04:46 While folks are spreading rumors of organized groups of leftists flooding the convention floor
00:04:50 to unseat Smith, there's little evidence of any real organization happening, and they won't have,
00:04:54 if there are a few, they won't have a measurable impact on the review. Again, thousands of people.
00:04:59 If anything, it's inspiring supporters of Smith to get out there, attend the meeting, and cast
00:05:03 their ballot. Legacy media, of course, is working their hardest to give the impression that are
00:05:06 rebellions forming within the UCP. Some of that's inspired by the hard left tilt that most legacy
00:05:11 outlets have embraced since becoming beholden to Trudeau's subsidies to pay their bills.
00:05:16 Another reason for fostering division, of course, is simple. It's just they want to build excitement
00:05:20 and draw readers and viewers. I mean, blowouts are boring in both sports and politics, and it's
00:05:25 only the close races that make for excitement. The next group trying to stir things up are the
00:05:30 conservative faction I've recently referred to as the chronic malcontents. They just exist to
00:05:35 oppose, and nothing any leader can do will keep them happy for long. They join parties and purport
00:05:40 to support them, and maybe they initially do. But then they draw lines in the sand and create
00:05:44 policy hills for themselves to die upon. As soon as the party leader crosses one of these lines,
00:05:49 and there's many of them, the mercurial malcontents shift into opposition mode and put all their 0.99
00:05:53 efforts into deposing the leader. If you've been in conservative politics long enough, you'll notice
00:05:57 it's actually usually the same names that keep showing up and trying to tear things down.
00:06:02 But grumpy conservative members can be organized and galvanized to take down leaders. We've seen
00:06:06 it many times. The work by Take Back Alberta to remove Kenny from the party leadership was
00:06:10 effective and striking. Take Back Alberta now, though, is a little more than a shell of what
00:06:14 it used to be. And the atmosphere of discontent just isn't in the air as it was a couple of years
00:06:18 ago. New groups have been emerging with new policy demands and threats to unseat the leader if they
00:06:23 don't get their way. These groups have every right to do so and working to influence policies
00:06:28 while at AGMs. Oh, that's how the democratic game works. The threat to Smith's leadership
00:06:33 is hollow though. With nearly 6,000 members dedicating hundreds of dollars crossing the
00:06:37 province to take part in an AGM, it would take a very visible and well-organized machine to swing
00:06:42 even a significant number of these people to vote against the leader in her second year in the role.
00:06:47 The AGM is going to be an interesting event, but the battles to watch are going to be over the
00:06:50 proposed policy amendments, not the leadership review. So I'm making my prediction now. Smith's
00:06:55 going to garner over 85% from the members in support. I could eat crow on that, I guess.
00:07:00 Politics are a crazy business, but I'm feeling pretty confident on this one. Either way, guys,
00:07:04 I will see you at the AGM. It's going to be a fun one. And the Western Standard will
00:07:09 have a hospitality booth. I got our news editor, Dave Naylor in here. I'm sure you'll be partaking
00:07:13 at the hospitality room. No, sadly, I've got to stay here and mind the store.
00:07:17 Oh, really? Yeah. I thought you were coming out.
00:07:19 No.
00:07:20 Oh, jeez.
00:07:20 No, I've got to work from here.
00:07:22 Oh, you've been robbed.
00:07:22 Well, I hope you're getting some hospitality booze while you're here.
00:07:24 Well, I hope you bring me some down.
00:07:26 I'll see what I can do.
00:07:27 I won't be drinking it.
00:07:27 You stole my prediction, though.
00:07:28 I was going to say 85% to 90%.
00:07:30 Okay, well, yours is on the higher side of 85%, so we'll throw the prediction into that.
00:07:33 Yeah, just back from a nice weekend in Fort McMurray.
00:07:37 How did that go?
00:07:39 Well, Fort Mac is Fort Mac.
00:07:41 I mean, it's not a bad city.
00:07:43 Well, how did you spend your time?
00:07:45 Well, Jane has a barn quilt painting business and then she was teaching a course up there.
00:07:51 So I was there to assist.
00:07:52 I was the official driver in helping Jane set up.
00:07:54 She's busy as all get out.
00:07:56 I'm enjoying my role as a kept man and driver.
00:07:58 So as I sat in the hotel room, I just wrote my columns for the week and then waited for my wife to earn the money so I could have a good dinner. 0.99
00:08:05 So Fort Mac last weekend, Red Deer this weekend, man, you're living the life.
00:08:08 I'm covering the province, I tell you.
00:08:10 Awesome.
00:08:11 Speaking of covering the province, we have a rare Western Standard documentary leading the website right now.
00:08:18 It's called Coal Culture and Conflict, and it's about the debate whether or not to allow coal mining again in the Crow's Nest Pass.
00:08:26 It was done by a documentarian extraordinaire, Heidi McKillop, helped by our business expert, Sean Polzer,
00:08:35 and put together masterfully by Nico Abuto, our production guy.
00:08:41 And last mining was done down there in 1983.
00:08:46 And it tells us, you know, they're trying to, they only survive right now on tourism.
00:08:51 And the mine is arguing, look, we can bring jobs, we can bring economic benefits.
00:08:55 And the opponents are saying environmental damage and concern.
00:09:00 So they've got a vote on that next month.
00:09:03 And it's really interesting.
00:09:04 I urge everybody to watch it.
00:09:06 It's very well done.
00:09:07 Other news leading the site this morning.
00:09:09 a former liberal mp by the name and i've got to read her name uh selena caesar shevens she was an 1.00
00:09:17 ontario mp for a term or two and she writes about her uh or she talks to jordan peterson about her
00:09:24 interactions with prime minister trudeau and it's quite eye-opening and uh he's a piece of work for
00:09:30 sure a couple of crime stories we had a guy who uh randomly stabbed a customer and tim hortons
00:09:38 three years ago. He got three years in the slammer. He was released after two. And you're
00:09:43 not going to believe this, Corey, but he's being re-arrested again for committing crimes.
00:09:47 Wouldn't have seen that coming.
00:09:48 Wouldn't have seen that coming. A disturbing case in Saskatchewan where four teenagers have
00:09:53 been arrested for assault, the youngest being 11. And obviously you can't charge an 11-year-old,
00:10:01 so they're walking free. But you've got these gang of kids, you know, you figure they'd
00:10:06 home working on their halloween costumes uh we've got a privy council study out today showing that
00:10:13 people think that other canadians who take vacations are wealthy they're in the upper
00:10:18 class because they can't afford to go on vacation with all the economic pressures so
00:10:23 if you're going to arizona for the winter you are lifted to the uh the wealthy of canada the elite
00:10:30 yeah i'll be living in a fifth wheel and it's a working trip but aside from that it's hey that
00:10:34 That elitism taste good.
00:10:36 At least it's warm.
00:10:37 And still leading the site at the moment is crazy Stephen Gilbo's attack on cats.
00:10:44 And he's got cats in his target because they kill birds.
00:10:50 Well, so our own cat lady, Linda Slobodian, has got a great column dissecting Mr. Gilbo.
00:10:57 So it's fun.
00:10:59 It's up there.
00:10:59 I urge you to read it.
00:11:01 And before I let you go, I'm going to put you on the spot.
00:11:03 quick U.S. election prediction.
00:11:06 I think Trump's going to squeak it through.
00:11:08 Yeah, I agree too.
00:11:09 You stole my answer there.
00:11:10 Oh, well, we're just on the same page, right?
00:11:12 Same page.
00:11:13 It's going to be a fun Tuesday night
00:11:14 and we're going to be here broadcasting
00:11:17 and yeah, it's going to be historic
00:11:21 one way or the other.
00:11:22 Absolutely.
00:11:23 And yeah, at least, you know,
00:11:25 when our politics feel a little insane,
00:11:27 at least we can look south of the border
00:11:28 and think, well, it could be worse.
00:11:29 It could always be worse.
00:11:30 Right on.
00:11:31 All right.
00:11:31 Well, thanks, Dave.
00:11:32 and sorry to discover here that you won't be at the AGM there,
00:11:35 though I've got a feeling you're not missing too much in some ways.
00:11:38 You know, raise a drink to me.
00:11:40 Well, my Diet Coke, it will be.
00:11:41 Your Diet Coke.
00:11:42 Yes. All right. Thanks, Dave.
00:11:43 All right.
00:11:44 So, yes, and as you can hear, lots going on.
00:11:47 A fantastic documentary, you know, and it is.
00:11:49 It's a nuanced issue down there in Blairmore, Coleman,
00:11:52 that coal hub down there between, you know,
00:11:54 people supporting coal mining, people opposing it.
00:11:57 It's not this dusty open pit thing people might think it might be,
00:12:00 but at the same time, people are concerned.
00:12:03 There's a lot of ranchers down there,
00:12:04 a lot of conservative supporters
00:12:05 who have a problem with this.
00:12:06 It's not just your usual craze, it's greenies. 1.00
00:12:08 So check that documentary out, guys.
00:12:10 It's good stuff.
00:12:11 And yes, Linda Slobodian, boy, she loves to rip them up 1.00
00:12:14 and you don't want to get in her crosshairs.
00:12:15 And Gilbo provides a ready target with going after cats.
00:12:21 Man, there's nothing we're allowed to do anymore.
00:12:23 So yes, this is what I like to remind you folks though,
00:12:25 the reason you can see those things,
00:12:27 the reason we can produce them,
00:12:28 the reason it's happening is because you've subscribed.
00:12:30 we don't take any subsidies no tax dollars here at the western standard and we aren't asking for
00:12:36 them but we rely on you guys 9.99 a month 100 for a year you've been coming through that's why we've
00:12:41 got reporters all over the place that's why we're putting out these documentaries and that's why we
00:12:45 can do the show like we do today so get on there guys westernstandard.news slash subscription take
00:12:50 out a subscription and you know if you have already again thank you very much we really do
00:12:55 appreciate it. If you haven't, come on, get on there, spread the word, buy a subscription for
00:13:00 a liberal friend for Christmas, get them worked up. It's, it's, it's, uh, the gift that just keeps
00:13:05 on giving. So yeah, lots going on. Like I said, with the AGM coming up this weekend, it's going
00:13:10 to be busy and interesting, uh, you know, statement from Jordan, uh, uh, the commenter
00:13:14 is Smith's greatest threat, internal party division or her own impulsive tendencies. Yeah. 0.93
00:13:19 So, I mean, I, I, again, I've known Premier Smith for, for quite some time. I mean, we're,
00:13:24 We're not close compatriots, but I certainly dealt with her a lot over the years.
00:13:27 And I mean, it's her impulsiveness I kind of find endearing.
00:13:31 She's not the careful, you know, methodical politician that you would expect out of a lot of people.
00:13:38 But of course, it leads to a lot of danger, too, because she speaks her mind and she jumps right in on things, perhaps not necessarily being too well prepared.
00:13:46 but I get tired of the politicians being hyper careful, spinning their wheels, afraid to make
00:13:53 any big decisions and shake things up. As far as it being, as I said though in my opening monologue,
00:13:58 I don't think there's much threat of internal party division at this time. It's only year two.
00:14:02 It's the usual suspects making all the noise. I don't think there's a realistic threat against
00:14:08 her role. Now give it a year or two, that can certainly change. And as I said, the big threat
00:14:13 for conservative leaders usually comes from within. Conservatives are a grumpy bunch. They
00:14:17 really like tearing down their own quite often in a self-destructive manner. So we'll watch.
00:14:24 And boy, what a year for elections, right? So yeah, we'll be doing live coverage on Tuesday
00:14:27 night of the American election as it comes in. Hopefully it doesn't run us until the wee wee
00:14:32 hours as so many elections have these days. It's funny, you know, with elections and vote counting
00:14:37 and so on. And again, I've been over this online and, you know, our great reporter out in BC
00:14:43 Jared Yeager has put out a story on that, saying we got results denialism coming up. It's a trend
00:14:50 that's been happening of people, they don't like the results of an election and they jump on every
00:14:56 conspiracy they can think of as to why it was rigged. Look, I've worked on a lot of elections
00:15:01 from the ground volunteer to managing campaigns to running in them. And I've been in there as a
00:15:09 volunteer scrutineering. Look, the process is very difficult to rig. It really is. It's pretty
00:15:15 good. I worry about changes being made to it. I think they're making it more inefficient. They
00:15:19 bring in these ridiculous counting machines that somehow make the counts take even longer
00:15:24 than they did prior when it was just simple paper ballots. And that's what fosters a lot of the
00:15:29 mistrust. That's what fosters people to make theories as to why an election went one way or
00:15:33 another. But no, even the campaign manager, you know, for Rustad and BC's came out and said,
00:15:37 know that we lost. You know, it was tight. It was close, but they lost. Likewise, in Saskatchewan,
00:15:42 Scott Moe won, but it was close. These elections are really, really close. We'll talk a little
00:15:46 more about that later. I'm not a big fan of Trump, I got to admit. You know, if I was in the States,
00:15:50 I'd probably vote Republican all the same, but I'm not big on him. And one of the reasons is
00:15:54 that baloney over the last election being rigged. I'm sorry, he lost that one too. I know we'll get
00:15:59 all the comments people thinking otherwise, but I just don't feel that's the way things have been
00:16:04 going, okay, let's turn the page and get on to something more domestic. I've been looking forward
00:16:07 to this. And his name is Andrew Spence. He's worked in the banking industry and he's put out a book
00:16:13 called Fleeced Canadians versus their banks. And I did read it and it was, you know, it's a good 1.00
00:16:18 read. It covers a lot up, it covers a lot up, doesn't cover it up, it exposes it. And banking
00:16:24 is one of those things where you have no choice. You have to use banks. It's part of life. Thus,
00:16:28 you should hope to get a reasonable rate or reasonable competition within the industry.
00:16:33 And we're kind of lacking that in Canada.
00:16:34 So thank you very much for joining me today to discuss your book, Mr. Spence.
00:16:39 I appreciate it.
00:16:40 Thank you, Corey.
00:16:41 It's a pleasure to be here with you today.
00:16:42 Thanks.
00:16:43 So I guess I'll just kind of begin at the beginning, you know, because people, even when you travel, you don't think going to another country to look into their banking systems or see differences.
00:16:51 So it never really occurs to us to compare for other comparable markets such as the UK or Australia or areas like that, you know, their banking systems, which might be similar to ours.
00:17:02 but looking that they're certainly not paying nearly as much to bank as we are, are they?
00:17:06 No, they're not. And there's a very good reason for that. And I don't want to get too wonkish
00:17:10 from the very beginning here. But in those jurisdictions, here in Canada, we pride ourselves
00:17:17 on good and close regulation of the banking system because safety matters, right? The matter is
00:17:22 stability isn't everything, but without stability, everything is nothing. Well,
00:17:26 in the UK, they have tight regulation too, but the regulator also has a competition mandate,
00:17:33 which means that they not only keep their banking system safe, but they also make sure they're fair.
00:17:41 And in Canada, we don't have until recently a well-empowered competition bureau to ensure
00:17:48 that we're getting good value for our money. Yes. And so, I mean, a lot of it, and you kind
00:17:54 of cover at the start and you cover more at the end of the book though that the I mean the high
00:17:59 horse Canada got on was in 2008 when the bank runs happened in the states things were you know went
00:18:03 badly and that's where a lot of people said well we've got our hyper regulated market we didn't
00:18:08 suffer through those things thus it justifies having such strict controls on our banking system
00:18:13 so I mean there's some degree of rationale behind protecting but if you over protect then your
00:18:18 consumers are going to lose yeah there's no question but I mean I think there's a degree
00:18:22 misunderstanding here right we can have and we should have tightly regulated banks banks are like
00:18:29 unlike any other industry we have right we it's but it's not just the choice between hyper safety
00:18:35 and a casino and a free-for-all with the advent of financial technology we can now make our banking
00:18:41 market what we call contestable right we can contest it and that means that these um these
00:18:47 fintechs or financial technology companies are able to come in if they were given access to the
00:18:51 the payment system in Canada, which they're not, not across the board and not in the sense
00:18:57 that really creates a degree of competition that would give the banks a run for their
00:19:00 money.
00:19:01 So if you go to Europe, for instance, everybody wanders around Europe with an app called Revolut.
00:19:05 And then Revolut, you can figure out, if you want to do a foreign exchange transaction,
00:19:09 you just look at your phone and you see the best rate at the lowest possible cost.
00:19:14 And the transaction is done instantaneously.
00:19:18 We don't have that option in Canada, and we should have that option in Canada.
00:19:22 And the banks know that this is coming, but they're dragging their feet.
00:19:26 They're slowing the process down with the complicit shelter of the federal government, which means we don't see open banking in this country until 2026 at the earliest.
00:19:38 And we don't even have an instantaneous real time transactions payment system.
00:19:44 And over 50 countries have this in place.
00:19:47 And we don't even have a beta testing instantaneous payment system ready until 2026.
00:19:55 It's shameful. 0.95
00:19:56 It is ridiculous. 0.97
00:19:57 I'll throw an anecdote that just recently happened in our household.
00:20:00 Actually, we've done some changes in our finances and things.
00:20:03 We had a loan combined.
00:20:05 And then one major bank was to pay off a loan with another major bank.
00:20:09 But apparently the only way they would accept it is with a bank draft.
00:20:12 A physical bank draft had to be sent from one major bank to the next major bank.
00:20:17 and of course they sent it to the wrong branch and now it's stuck in limbo but why on earth when i
00:20:23 could tap to make a payment in seconds anywhere i go can two major banks not do a transaction
00:20:28 on my behalf without charging a fortune and getting it wrong because they don't have to
00:20:34 because there's no competition right so necessity is the mother of invention so if we had a degree
00:20:39 of competition in the canadian banking system and i can assure you that the performance of the banks
00:20:45 and the price at which we transact would improve very very quickly we've seen this in the past
00:20:50 when in the mortgage market uh 20 odd years ago 25 years ago you know you'd go and apply for a
00:20:56 mortgage at the bank it would take you two weeks to know whether or not you were given the mortgage
00:20:59 and it was kind of a painful nail-biting exercise for many many aspiring homeowners and there was
00:21:05 a degree of competition at the time for non-bank providers of of mortgages and once that group
00:21:12 began to get a decent critical mass all of a sudden banks could process your mortgage overnight
00:21:18 and so we know that if they're given the incentive to respond they will the question the key question
00:21:23 we have to ask ourselves i think as as citizens and as electors is why is the federal government
00:21:29 sheltering the banks um to persist with these practices that keep competition at bay and the
00:21:36 answer is they can because for some reason the federal government does not want to take it on
00:21:41 now we brought up the financial crisis right sure the banks didn't go under here and we should all
00:21:46 be extremely grateful for that and regulation was a big part of that um but that doesn't mean
00:21:52 to say that the banks should be free of competition because of it what people don't understand is that
00:21:58 the banks did receive substantial help in terms of liquidity provision from the bank of canada
00:22:03 the federal finance department department freed up a lot of liquidity in the system by buying
00:22:08 mortgages from the bank's balance sheets and um if the financial crisis that had happened another
00:22:14 12 months later i think you would have found that some of the canadian banks have will have
00:22:18 would have got themselves into some similar trouble it's just that because um more than
00:22:24 or about half of their income comes from fees rather than from providing financial transactions
00:22:30 they didn't have to reach out into the risky stuff to to retain uh high profitability targets because
00:22:36 they didn't have to. Yeah, so when the government's reticence in going into this, and it's funny
00:22:42 because, I mean, they really dedicated a lot of time and energy going after the retail grocer
00:22:46 oligopoly that we're dealing with and dragging the CEOs in front of committees and demanding 0.95
00:22:51 that they explain their 4% profit margins, you know, and demonizing these guys. And I don't
00:22:58 think they should drag bank heads in and demonize them. But boy, if you really want to show an area
00:23:02 where Canadians are kind of being taken to the cleaners.
00:23:05 Look at the margins on financial institutions right now,
00:23:08 and it makes the grocers look like pikers in comparison.
00:23:13 I think this is fair comment, Corey.
00:23:16 If you look at the performance of the domestic commercial
00:23:23 and personal lending and payments provision
00:23:27 within the domestic market itself,
00:23:29 the bank's return on equity until recently
00:23:31 was in the high 30 percent which is absolutely staggeringly high and luckily for us both TD 0.70
00:23:39 Bank and Bank of Montreal have similar businesses in parts of the U.S. banking market that are
00:23:46 that are much more competitive and what you find is that their return on equity in those markets
00:23:53 is about half of what it is at home so you know you can you can see that they're extremely well
00:23:59 protected. And whenever you bring this up with cabinet ministers and others in the federal
00:24:04 bureaucracy, they say, oh, but the crisis, you know, we did so well. Well, the banks are expensive,
00:24:10 but we say they're safe. But we've had a couple of recent scandals where we can begin to question
00:24:15 that narrative. Are they as safe as they say they are? And are they as safe as we have been led to
00:24:22 believe? I'm not entirely convinced. So another area, I mean, the banks have really spread out
00:24:26 into all sorts of side industries, I guess you could say,
00:24:29 and you sort of speak a bit to that,
00:24:30 like areas where if we were going to sort of break up
00:24:33 some of the areas that banks get into
00:24:34 and allow some more competition,
00:24:36 financial advising, investment products, 0.99
00:24:39 things like that, where the banks really try to suck,
00:24:40 you know, customers into further, I guess,
00:24:43 being entrenched into their financial lives.
00:24:46 Those are areas that other businesses can set up
00:24:49 and provide those services
00:24:50 without putting your banking structure at risk.
00:24:53 Yeah, I think that's right.
00:24:54 I mean, I'm often asked, okay, so fintechs would be good.
00:24:58 Let's get on and get that done.
00:24:59 And, you know, we sit and whistle in the wind and wait for that to happen.
00:25:04 I think one of the things that we could do with the stroke of the ministerial pen, if
00:25:10 we were so inclined, or our political leaders were so inclined, is to demand transparency
00:25:16 from the banking system, right?
00:25:18 I mean, if I have a stock trading account at a discount brokerage at the arms of one
00:25:25 of the banks, they will probably charge me about $10 to do a transaction, right?
00:25:30 Buy a stock, sell a stock, buy a mutual fund, sell a mutual fund, buy an ETF, sell an ETF.
00:25:36 I'd like to know what the cost of them is of facilitating that transaction.
00:25:40 I'm willing to bet you, Corey, and your listeners and your viewers that it's a couple of cents.
00:25:45 So why am I being charged $9.99 or $10 for it?
00:25:50 It's the same with credit cards, right?
00:25:51 I mean, the interest rate on credit cards has barely budged over the foremost 40 years,
00:25:55 and yet inflation is significantly lower.
00:25:58 The funding rates, the deposit rates that fund those things are very much lower.
00:26:03 We're told that there's a lot of fraud in credit cards
00:26:06 and that there is potentially high losses because borrowers are more marginal.
00:26:11 And yet, when banks securitize those credit card receivables into trusts, S&P have to rate them.
00:26:22 And they say, well, you know, a third of all the borrowers are super prime, so you don't lose money on them.
00:26:28 The charge-off rates are 3%, and fraud may well be high.
00:26:32 But again, we don't know because we can't see it, right?
00:26:35 So I think there is a general sense amongst the population that it's expensive, they're dissatisfied, the lack of choice, the frictions that are put in the way to just do simple payments, five-day holds on checks.
00:26:49 I mean, seriously, in a world where countries like Brazil have instantaneous payment systems available for people, why don't we have it here?
00:27:00 let's see um uh and then we can see whether or not you're justified in charging what you do
00:27:05 for access to the banking system my guess is we'd be pretty shocked well they yeah they haven't
00:27:11 adjusted their rates for the realities of today i mean if it was the days of you know 40 years ago
00:27:16 and if you were going to transfer funds from one account to another you'd have to have conversations
00:27:20 between real people paper documents would have been brought up and amended and changed and it's
00:27:25 going to be cost, you know, time takes up time and cost. But I mean, we're talking a digital
00:27:31 transaction, as you said, pennies, if that, and still, though, the rates stay the same. Same with
00:27:35 credit cards. You point out in the book, I mean, yeah, we suffered through double digit interest
00:27:40 rates in the 80s and into the early 90s for even mortgages. Those have come down, but the credit
00:27:45 card rates haven't changed a bit. And people carrying high credit card balances on unsecured
00:27:51 debt, that's a lot of actually what's pushing a lot of people to some financial distress more
00:27:55 than mortgages or other borrowing tools yeah there's no question and i want to come back to
00:28:01 the point i made right at the beginning corey if you don't mind which is to to you know osfi
00:28:06 um osfi does a good job of regulation right ensuring safety no question about that and i
00:28:13 think they're an important agency and they need to be free to do their job but they don't pay any
00:28:18 attention to the competition here issues right so in the united kingdom for instance the financial
00:28:24 conduct authority actually has responsibility for competition as well and so there are many charges
00:28:31 that the people who are financially marginal usually the poor who find themselves in difficulty
00:28:39 will find themselves over drawing their accounts where they will be charged a simple fee every
00:28:44 time they are overdrawn uh will be charged interest on the money that they've essentially
00:28:49 borrowed from the bank that tolerates that they'll be charged 50 bucks for an nsf check
00:28:54 non-sufficient funds to bounce a check um and uh this is allowed to go on so in the uk the financial
00:29:03 conduct authority looked at these various charges and said sorry you no can do you're not allowed to
00:29:09 do that moreover you have a duty to of care if you can program your system to assign a charge
00:29:17 and a fee every time someone's overdrawn you can identify given the profile of the customer whether
00:29:22 or not that person is marginal or not or maybe in some difficulty and now uk banks have a duty of
00:29:29 care they have to find out what's going on in that person's life to ensure that the banks don't
00:29:35 essentially levy a port act and meanwhile there's no agency here in canada that's charged with that
00:29:42 responsibility so we have some gaps in our regulatory structure if we're not going to
00:29:47 allow competition regardless of where you are on the political divide all of us need a degree of
00:29:52 protection if we cannot look to competition to protect us and the reason we like competition
00:29:57 is because um it prevents the most egregious of these of these charges emerging and it also
00:30:05 forces incumbents to become more efficient um and so to my mind we've known this in economics
00:30:12 well over 100 years, why aren't we doing something about it?
00:30:15 Yeah, well, and in Canada, the government pressured, actually, and, you know, they didn't
00:30:19 impose, but they really twist the arms hard and brought about a grocer's code of conduct that they
00:30:24 have to abide by now for, depending on how they deal with suppliers and pricing and things like
00:30:28 that. I guess before I let you go, the main thing is getting the political will, because there
00:30:33 doesn't seem to be interest or will on the parts of our government. But right now, we're going into
00:30:37 election year now is a good time to get the pressure on the folks running for election saying
00:30:42 hey can you speak up on this and of course the best way to do that is to get the public informed
00:30:46 because they don't realize how they are being fleeced as your book puts it so I mean before
00:30:50 I let you go you know where can people find a copy of this to find out for themselves and see
00:30:55 how well you've broken down you know how badly we're kind of getting it in the Canadian system
00:30:58 and and how we can work towards solving this you can get it on Amazon you can get it directly from
00:31:03 publisher sutherland house books my wife encouraged me to record it so you can lull yourself to sleep
00:31:09 with my voice if uh if you so desire i think at the end of the day corey with this book we've
00:31:15 deliberately written it for a general readership and we want people to have the ideas have the
00:31:21 knowledge um and have the language to understand their predicament and to ask for more and to demand
00:31:29 better. Democracy is not about showing up every four years to cast a vote. It's about engaging
00:31:34 with your MPs, engaging with your representatives every day. Because if we don't, then we get what
00:31:42 we deserve. Well, absolutely. And if we can arm ourselves with information, it makes it harder for
00:31:46 them to baffle us with BS when we try to ask them why things are the way they are. So I really
00:31:51 appreciate you writing this and coming on today to talk about it. And I hope we can talk again
00:31:56 down the road after the banking system's been fixed up for us. Well, we will see. Thank you
00:32:01 very much, Corey. It's been a pleasure to be here with you. Thank you. So that is author and he's
00:32:05 worked in the banking industry as well. Our Andrew Spence, he wrote fleeced Canadians versus their
00:32:11 banks. And yes, as you say, if you Google it, you can find it. It's a good read. As he said,
00:32:15 he wrote it for people. It's, it's not, you know, it's a bit wonky, but not too terribly. I mean,
00:32:19 we can understand all of these things. Anybody who does a household budget, you see all of these
00:32:23 things, whether it's your mortgage, your credit card bills, your investment tools, if you're,
00:32:28 you know, saving for retirement and things like that. It's not terribly complicated. And what I
00:32:33 really appreciate though, especially because it's early in the book too, is the comparisons. We
00:32:37 don't just compare it to the American system where there are dozens and dozens and dozens of
00:32:41 competitors. Let's look then at others like the UK, like Australia. And as he said, we don't have to
00:32:46 embrace that system or throw things open as he used the casino comparison, but we could
00:32:52 better regulate and add transparency. Transparency in so many levels with so many things
00:32:57 makes things better for us. If we don't know what's going on, how can we solve them? And
00:33:01 again, that's just where I was stumped. As I said, I keep, because I've just been watching while
00:33:06 the country's been beating on grocers for quite some time and fine, you know, and they say it's
00:33:12 because it's a need. You can't afford, avoid buying groceries. Well, that's true, but you can't avoid
00:33:16 banking either. So you're kind of stuck in that same sort of thing. So check it out, guys. I like
00:33:21 these things. You know, even if they seem a little dry, they're important and we're all into them.
00:33:25 All right, let's look at some of the comments here and things such as that. You know, we're
00:33:32 talking again about election fixing and so on. You know, a couple of people saying no one would
00:33:37 ever cheat on an election or, you know, can't trust human nature not to cheat an election. No,
00:33:41 people have tried to cheat on elections. They have. And that's why there are so many checks
00:33:46 and balances right now for the elections. And we still have to always be on guard. Absolutely,
00:33:51 we have to be vigilant. And we got to make sure that these things aren't being rigged. We got to
00:33:55 make sure that there's not funny business because there are people willing to, but just because
00:33:59 people are willing to do it doesn't mean they've been getting away with it. I mean, it's not that
00:34:05 easy. It really isn't. If you've worked as a scrutineer, I'm just going to put you through
00:34:09 the process of what you can do. I threw that out on the X as well, as boring as it might be.
00:34:13 anybody can go in. You can swear in at a polling station. You can be there from before the polling
00:34:19 station opens. It's like a magician with their tricks. They will open the boxes, show you that
00:34:23 they're empty. They're not pre-stacked with ballots. Those boxes then get taped up. They get
00:34:27 sealed. You can watch them being sealed. You can stay all day and watch every ballot going into
00:34:33 those boxes. Then you can stay in the evening and watch the envelopes being ripped open as far as
00:34:39 Scrutineering, you can be at every part of it and plus into the boxes and watching the count.
00:34:45 It's very, very hard. Now, the tabulating machines, those aren't networked. I know people
00:34:51 start going on with Dominion and the rest of that. Okay, that's fine, but we weren't using that here.
00:34:54 And they're just for counting the votes. They aren't networked. And again, the scrutiners are
00:34:58 there watching it all the time. I don't like them. I don't think we need them. There's chances for
00:35:02 them breaking down. And they also add to the mistrust. But just because they're there doesn't
00:35:07 mean somebody's rigging it. The reason I get worried is that the bureaucrats keep changing it.
00:35:15 You know, I fall back to the old statement about it. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. The system
00:35:20 works. We can count the votes. We can get the results into the evening sometimes because people
00:35:25 are saying, oh, wow, it took so long in BC to get those. And it did. It took too long. Absolutely.
00:35:29 But by the same token, it's always been the case. If there were any elections where the results were
00:35:34 under 100 and there had to be recounts, it's going to take a few days before they recount that.
00:35:38 But again, scrutineers are allowed to be there for the recounts. As for mail-in ballots and special
00:35:44 ballots, yeah, there's room for some funny business, but the margin and volume of it in
00:35:49 difficulty is very small. I worked in the oil field. I used to, you know, if I knew I was going
00:35:54 because I've always been a political weenie, I knew if I was going to be out of town on voting
00:35:58 day, I would go into the returning office and get a ballot and do a special ballot. I could also
00:36:02 apply for and get a mail-in ballot when I was out in the field. But there's checks and controls on
00:36:07 all of that too. And for you to be able to get through that whole process to bring in enough
00:36:11 to actually swing an election again, very, very difficult. Very difficult. You're going to have
00:36:18 a better chance, for example, in BC, where again, nobody who worked within the election,
00:36:23 even on the conservative side, is saying it was rigged. It's people outside of it who are making
00:36:26 those claims. They're going to be better served working on how can we win the next one rather
00:36:31 than chasing unfounded allegations. Hey, if there's proof or evidence, then bring it forward.
00:36:36 But as it is, it's just a lot of speculation. We got to watch our elections carefully. Absolutely.
00:36:42 They are integral. And trust in the election is essential. If people don't trust the process,
00:36:49 that's where things fall apart and they get into trouble. And that's where people feel helpless.
00:36:55 That's one of the bigger areas. Again, you see, as I said, where I am sour on Trump.
00:36:59 and again, I suspect he's probably going to nearly win it. I think he'd be better than Harris. If I
00:37:05 was an American, I would probably vote for Trump. I was in the standard newsroom that we were here,
00:37:10 a bunch of us watching, you know, fascinated when it all broke on January 6th, when that whole mess
00:37:14 happened. And the reason these guys felt that they should storm the Capitol was because they
00:37:21 were convinced the election had been fixed. And then when Trump finally spoke, he got up and said,
00:37:28 you know, people should calm down. They should stop this. Okay, fine. Good. Thank you. It's
00:37:31 about time you spoke to them and just told them that. But then he goes back into, I know the
00:37:35 election was stolen. So then he just went and poured gasoline on the bloody fire. Irresponsible,
00:37:41 ridiculous, and stupid. So I worry about that when a person who's going to be leading the most 1.00
00:37:47 powerful country on the planet has those tendencies. Again, I see him as a lesser evil
00:37:52 of the two, but I really thought the Republicans could pick somebody better. But we'll see what
00:37:57 happens as things move ahead. The bottom line is electoral systems need to be trusted. Absolutely.
00:38:03 Will people try to fix them if they can get away with it? Yes, they will. But they aren't that easy
00:38:07 to fix. They really aren't. Especially if you've participated in you see the reason these checks
00:38:11 and balances are in because all these things have been tried before. That's why they show the box at
00:38:15 the start because somewhere 80 years ago in some country, some person duct taped or whatever a
00:38:20 bunch of ballots inside a box so that when they opened it, they would all fall in with the rest
00:38:23 the votes or things like that. So there are a lot of processes and checks. And there's no better
00:38:27 check than having every candidate have the ability to have people in there watching the process from
00:38:32 start to end. And that is what we have. So again, it's not perfect, but there are ways. There really
00:38:40 are. Let's see what else we got going on. See, here's another one. Old Wolf, if you don't believe
00:38:46 there may be cheating in the US elections, then you don't understand human nature. No, my point is
00:38:50 people will try. I didn't say they won't, but there hasn't been any good evidence that they
00:38:54 got in the way with it. It really isn't. So, I mean, you need better. You need better.
00:39:00 So let's see. Oh, here we go. Another commenter saying, hi, Corey, a new article by Reuters just
00:39:06 came out. Leader of the NDP says he won't help bring down Justin Trudeau. Please express your
00:39:11 shock. I'm going to guess that Ward, the commenter, follows me on X because I've been poking at for a
00:39:16 long time in pointing out to people, even though the bloc is rattling their sabers and they're
00:39:22 saying we're going to bring it down. Look, as long as Jagmeet the weak is leading the NDP,
00:39:27 Trudeau is not going anywhere. The NDP is broke. They're going to get slaughtered in the next
00:39:33 election. They have something like 300,000 in the bank. And he's not going to go to the polls.
00:39:41 There's just no way. So he'll talk big, but he'll cave every time. The term I keep using when I'm
00:39:47 teasing him online, which I do often, is I call him Justin's little parliamentary chihuahua. You
00:39:51 know, he's like a little chihuahua. He's yap, yap, yap, yap, yap, yap, but he's got no teeth. He's
00:39:55 got no power. He's a coward. He's quivering with rage and quivering with fear. He's a wimp. He's 1.00
00:40:00 got no principles. If he had principles, he'd be pushing for what he is. You see, I have more
00:40:05 respect. It doesn't mean I like, but I have more respect for honest socialists rather than
00:40:10 opportunists. You know, that's where I see, for example, I have more respect for in Alberta,
00:40:15 Rachel Notley, who led the NDP, because she's always been true to her ideology as broken and
00:40:22 flawed as her ideology is. Her replacement, Nahed Nenshi, he's a political chameleon who will do
00:40:27 whatever he has to do and say whatever he thinks he has to say to try and win power. I mean, he
00:40:34 campaigned as a conservative when he took the mayoral race in Calgary. He pretended to be
00:40:40 conservative. He had groups of people pretending he was conservative. He was anything but. He was
00:40:44 spenshy. He bloated the government. He brought everything inside. He ended transparency. Look
00:40:49 at him now. This is a man who pretended to be conservative, who is now leading a literal
00:40:54 socialist party. I don't trust him. He's deceptive. He will go whatever way the wind blows.
00:41:05 So Jagmeet Singh, similar.
00:41:07 He's not going to die on a hill of principle.
00:41:10 He'll instead drag out this mess at the expense of the country
00:41:13 because his stinking leadership, which has been terrible, 0.86
00:41:17 has led his party into such dire straits 0.86
00:41:19 that he's as afraid of going to an election as Trudeau.
00:41:22 So folks thinking and hoping that the Trudeau government
00:41:26 is going to be pulled down by a confidence vote in the near future,
00:41:29 it's not going to happen.
00:41:31 And some people saying the 24 Liberals who anonymously penned the letter asking Justin to step aside,
00:41:36 please, please, please, Justin, please step aside.
00:41:39 They could come out and vote on a confidence vote and bring it down.
00:41:42 Yes, they could, but they would be cutting their own political throats.
00:41:44 Look, the Liberal MPs who are concerned, and they're legitimately concerned,
00:41:47 they don't want to rush to an election either.
00:41:49 They just want Trudeau out.
00:41:51 They're hoping if Trudeau is out, with another year to work on it,
00:41:54 they might be able to salvage their seats.
00:41:56 They know if they went to an election tomorrow, they're going to lose their seats.
00:41:59 So they're not, again, we're getting into self-serving rather than serving the country, but that's the reality of it.
00:42:06 They're not going to vote to pull Trudeau out either.
00:42:09 The only hope is that Trudeau gets tired of being attacked on all sides from within his party, outside his party.
00:42:15 One of the bigger turning points we saw recently was, you know, with Christy Clark and Mark Carney,
00:42:21 both coming out in the open, sniffing around, saying, yeah, you know what, I'm gunning for Justin's job.
00:42:27 I mean, one of the things people always said to try and defend, well, who's going to replace him
00:42:30 if he leaves? Well, here's two people raising their hands saying they will. God, I don't want
00:42:35 to see either of them as prime minister, but it takes that question away. Like, you know, and the
00:42:40 MPs are, like I said, the sharks are starting to circle under his feet. He's in serious, serious
00:42:44 trouble. It was funny seeing some of the things put out. You know, somebody put out a picture of
00:42:50 his bawling. Remember when Justin used to, every week he was crying about something? He was crying
00:42:54 this apology, crying at that apology, crying at this, crying because the toilet was plugged,
00:42:58 whatever it might be. He was always crying. Apparently he'd put the tears on during his
00:43:02 caucus meeting last week too. Shows a couple of things. I think he's a drama teacher and
00:43:07 his tears are as fake as Anna Nicole Simpson's chest was, but it shows he does feel the pressure.
00:43:15 He knows he's desperate. He knows he's trying to do something to save his skin. He's stubborn.
00:43:19 and he's foolish. You know, people say, and I was wrong. He proved me wrong. A year ago, I figured 1.00
00:43:25 he'd be gone. Obviously, he proved me wrong. I don't know what it's going to take. Some people
00:43:29 are saying he's too vain to leave her. Now, I see what you're saying, but with that vanity, I mean,
00:43:35 you've got an out, right? You can do the old political. I've, you know, I've done the walk
00:43:40 in the snow like my dad, and I've decided that I need to spend more time with my family. It's
00:43:47 important to me right now. Our family is at challenges. We're going through a divorce. The
00:43:51 pressures of politics have been hard on my kids. I need to leave office so that I can focus on that
00:43:56 because what I've been doing right now has been unfair to Canadians and unfair to my children
00:44:00 because I've been splitting my time between the two. So thank you for giving me these 10 wonderful
00:44:05 years in power and I'll step aside for someone else. See, it can be done. I could be true to a
00:44:09 speechwriter, though I would put a bunch of ums and ahs in so he feels comfortable about it.
00:44:12 No, he can get out right now and maintain at least a little bit of pride, but to hang and cling all the way to the bitter end so that when you do leave, it's with a boot on your butt, whether it's from the electorate or from your caucus seven months from now or whatever, just getting so desperate that they practically, you know, do a Roman Senate thing on you.
00:44:33 as somebody you know old wolf says you know he has mental stability issues yeah i don't know
00:44:38 i think he is delusional i mean the only thing i can try and guess is he thinks he can turn it
00:44:44 around he really thinks that given another 10 months 11 months to work on this that he could
00:44:51 potentially you know win back public support and here's something on x i had some conversations
00:44:57 with people on there earlier too they're saying oh well he's going uh you know in in october 2025
00:45:03 no matter what, if we could just make it to that. Well, if you read the Constitution, actually,
00:45:06 he can go till 2026. So if people say, yeah, but look at the Elections Act, it says it's October
00:45:12 2025. Yeah, that's an act. That's legislation. They can change that in a heartbeat. Alberta used
00:45:18 to be illegal to run a deficit. That was a day I was sitting in the legislature and I watched we
00:45:22 had the Balanced Budget Act. And I'm pretty sure it was the Stelmack government. I was sitting in
00:45:26 the gallery there at the legislature. They came in, they tabled a bill to, or a motion to repeal
00:45:34 their balanced budget act. Bang, everybody voted. It was repealed. It was gone. And then they tabled
00:45:38 a deficit budget. That's how easy it is. And if you've got a majority government sitting there,
00:45:43 or if you've got Jagmeet Singh and Justin Trudeau, you can say, we're going to change
00:45:48 the elections act and make the date 2026. There's nothing stopping them from doing that. The
00:45:53 Constitution is the only hard line, and that gives him five potential years. Do I think that's going
00:45:58 to happen? No, probably not. I really don't. I mean, as others are saying, he's on the brink of
00:46:03 going down as it is right now. I can't see him surviving two more years in there. I can't see us
00:46:08 surviving two more years of him in there. But who knows? Politics are bloody crazy. We're in for a
00:46:14 crazy time, a crazy month, a crazy year. By the next time I'm on this show, the American election
00:46:20 will have finished. So we'll be able to break that down and see what we're looking forward to.
00:46:25 The AGM will have been done from the Wildrose UCP and Red Deer. I'll be able to report on that.
00:46:32 We're going to have the pipeline on this evening. Tune in for that, guys. We're going to break down
00:46:35 a bit more of these things. We're going to be broadcasting from the AGM floor, by the way. So
00:46:40 keep an eye on all those Western Standard channels. You know, we're going to be interviewing some
00:46:44 interesting people, covering stuff as it happens down there. This is your source. This is right on
00:46:49 the ground this is unfiltered global's going broke no sense watching their stuff anyways but
00:46:53 if you really want to watch the dark story watch their stock levels right now guys it's pretty
00:46:58 scary out there so either way i've bent your ear long enough thank you very much for tuning in
00:47:04 today guys i do appreciate it even if we don't always all agree that's all part of the fun be
00:47:10 sure to tune in again to our other shows and to this one next week at this time we'll have a whole
00:47:15 bunch of new issues, a new guest, and we'll solve the world's problems. Thanks again. See you then.
00:47:45 You