Western Standard - December 04, 2025


‘Professionally incapacitated’: John Rustad voted out

Hosted by
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | 3 Dec 2025 Get kids off their phones!

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

170.28

Word count

8,110

Sentence count

336

Harmful content

Misogyny

6

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Jared Yager and the usual suspects are in the studio to talk about the sudden ouster of John Rustat as leader of the BC Tory Party, and the deal between Alberta Premier Daniel Smith and Prime Minister Mark Carney on the proposed Keystone XL pipeline.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day and welcome to The Pipeline.
00:00:26 Today is December 3rd, 2025.
00:00:29 I'm Derek Felderbrandt, publisher of the Western Standard.
00:00:32 I'm joined by the usual crew in the studio here,
00:00:35 former Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:38 Good to be here.
00:00:38 And Western Standard senior operator columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:41 Always a pleasure.
00:00:43 And joining us for a very special day,
00:00:46 you're going to find out in a second why we've got Western Standard's
00:00:50 VC Bureau Chief, Jaron Yeager.
00:00:53 Welcome to the pipeline, Jared.
00:00:55 Hi, thanks for having me.
00:00:57 So we'll be talking about Bill C-9, a bill in Parliament right now,
00:01:03 which is designed to make sure you can't hurt people's feelings online,
00:01:07 but now is going to quite explicitly strip people of freedom of speech
00:01:15 and freedom of religion around saying, quoting things from religious scriptures,
00:01:21 which, you know, the Bible, that could be construed by some has, hateful, removing any provisions that were in that bill.
00:01:28 We're going to be talking about that.
00:01:31 We'll be talking about the pipeline deal between Alberta Premier Daniel Smith and Prime Minister Mark Carney.
00:01:39 We were talking about it in anticipation of it on the pipeline last week.
00:01:43 Now we actually see the deal.
00:01:46 Is it a Faustian pipeline bargain?
00:01:48 I don't know. I'm not convinced one way or another yet, but it's not quite as shiny and pretty as we were hoping it would be.
00:01:57 But first, the reason we've got Jared Yager on the program today.
00:02:03 BC Conservative leader John Rustat walks the plank.
00:02:07 earlier today
00:02:09 our BC Bureau Chief
00:02:11 Jared Yager broke the story
00:02:14 that
00:02:14 a majority of the BC
00:02:17 Conservative Caucus signed a letter
00:02:19 declaring non-confidence in him
00:02:21 and then just moments
00:02:23 ago the board of
00:02:26 the BC Conservative Party voted to remove
00:02:28 him as leader. Jared
00:02:29 why don't you add a bit more detail about
00:02:31 what's been going on. There's a lot of moving parts
00:02:34 to this story. It's just developing as we're
00:02:35 talking but uh why don't you just give us a little background and what's been going on today
00:02:40 yeah so it's been a pretty busy day but uh for anyone who's been paying attention to bc politics
00:02:46 over the past few months this shouldn't come as too big of a surprise so more and more people
00:02:51 have been calling on restat to resign from both within and outside the party and today was kind
00:02:57 of a kind of the final nail in the coffin 20 out of the 39 mlas in his caucus signed on saying that
00:03:04 they no longer supported his leadership and so once that came out he held a press conference and
00:03:10 basically said like i'm not going anywhere that's it and then like you said just moments ago the
00:03:18 board of directors passed a resolution to oust him as leader of both caucus and the party and
00:03:25 surrey white rock mla trevor halford has been appointed interim leader of both the caucus and
00:03:32 the party so okay let me get this straight so that there was the letter released by the majority
00:03:38 of the bc conservative caucus declaring they had no confidence in rostat as leader and requesting
00:03:45 the employment of interim leader rostat then held a press conference after that saying doesn't matter
00:03:49 if the majority of my caucus have voted to remove me i'm still the leader right yeah someone asked
00:03:55 him like does this put you in an untenable position and he said no not really and he he
00:03:59 basically so he he said his argument was uh there's too many things that are going on in bc
00:04:05 under the bc ndp and ordinary people don't care about this you know internal party squabbling
00:04:13 which is true people don't but when it comes down to it there's how much you can do as a party if
00:04:19 you're not united and if there's all this stuff going on inside it takes time away from actually
00:04:26 tackling the issues that matter.
00:04:28 Well, look, Cory, I mean,
00:04:31 John Russ, that
00:04:32 blasted his heart. I mean, he did
00:04:34 obviously incredible things for this party,
00:04:36 getting it to where it is, but
00:04:38 his leadership ran into really
00:04:40 tough waters. He appears to have become
00:04:42 paranoid trying to fire everyone from
00:04:44 caucus that he suspected of 0.82
00:04:46 anything or disagreeing with him
00:04:48 on things, which is ironic because that's
00:04:50 how he got kicked out of the BC Liberal Caucus,
00:04:53 very strangely.
00:04:54 um but he doesn't seem to understand the simple i don't think most people understand the
00:05:01 constitution but the leader of a political party and the leader of an opposition should understand
00:05:05 one of the simple parts of our constitution and it's the idea of confidence whoever can hold the
00:05:11 confidence of the whole legislature or parliament is the premier or the prime minister but to stay
00:05:16 the leader of your party in your caucus you have to have the confidence of your caucus and today
00:05:22 the majority of his caucus declared non-confidence in him that is like the prime minister or the
00:05:28 premier saying i don't care if the house has voted non-confidence in me i'm not going to be
00:05:32 distracted by that i'm still the prime minister or i'm still the premier that's not the way the
00:05:37 system works john rustad appears to be totally off the reservation here i think you know what
00:05:45 i can't help but draw a parallel to former premier jason kenney when it all comes to it he did a lot
00:05:49 of work too he united two parties he managed to win over the ndp but then shortly after getting
00:05:55 in just everything started to fall apart but it he stubbornly i guess you know they get the sense
00:06:01 of accomplishment i did all this damn it you guys i own i i have the right yeah to to stay in the 0.73
00:06:07 leadership this long and they just aren't going to give out until they dragged out kicking and 0.95
00:06:12 screaming with premier kenny it took a whole vote he tried every mechanism he could to to hang in
00:06:16 there and hold on but when it finally even push came to shove the members voted him out I think
00:06:20 Rustad's in a simple simple a similar mindset just the you know I've got to use every possible way
00:06:26 they don't understand what they're doing I deserve to be here and he just won't read that writing on
00:06:32 the wall and it's a shame because yeah already the amount of dignity lost is massive but if you're
00:06:39 pulled out virtually by your ear from that seat you know you just don't have any left whatsoever
00:06:44 when you go. There's a difference between building something and getting there and being able to
00:06:48 maintain it once you're there. And he can't hold this together, obviously. The only person who
00:06:52 doesn't know it anymore is him. You know, Nigel, sometimes leaders have failed, but they've been
00:07:00 able to still have a political career in that same caucus afterwards. You know, Joe Clark comes to
00:07:07 mind. Stockwell, they had a pretty messy one, but he did manage. He was a tougher one, but he did
00:07:13 manage to stay on
00:07:14 as a member of the Alliance and then Conservative
00:07:17 Caucus federally and as Captain Minister.
00:07:21 Brian Jean
00:07:21 did not initially with Jason Kenney because
00:07:23 there was so much bad blood there, but he did
00:07:25 come back.
00:07:27 Serbs now under Daniel Smith.
00:07:29 Andrew Scheer. Andrew Scheer
00:07:31 wasn't too bloody. He went down pretty quickly
00:07:33 so there wasn't too much blood on the floor.
00:07:36 But John Brustat
00:07:37 has held on so hard,
00:07:40 tried to kick out so many people.
00:07:42 I mean, I guess there's some parallels with Stockwell Day
00:07:44 in that respect, but does it seem like there's too much blood
00:07:48 on the floor for him to even be able to remain as a member
00:07:51 of that team, or is this just he now just needs to completely
00:07:54 exit the stage?
00:07:55 Well, the latter.
00:07:57 I mean, look, he's not leading anybody at the moment.
00:07:59 He's just going for a walk.
00:08:02 Like, who is going to back him up?
00:08:06 Who's going to want to run under his banner if there was a snap
00:08:09 election in British Columbia?
00:08:11 I mean, he couldn't manage duty, he almost won, but he didn't win.
00:08:15 So that's like losing.
00:08:17 So therefore, he has no leverage.
00:08:23 He is not in a position to reward, he's not in a position to do anything.
00:08:28 So he's going to have to accept that somebody else is going to do it.
00:08:33 Whether he can hang on, as a member of the party, as the respected former leader,
00:08:38 very much up to him what he does in the next 24 hours and if he says you guys you know if the
00:08:45 ship goes down i'm you're all going down with me then he's done but you mentioned stockwell day
00:08:52 uh stockwell day is a man of tremendously fine character and um he he accepted the judgment of
00:09:01 the party at that time and he did it in such a way that he was able to serve the new conservative
00:09:07 government under Harper
00:09:08 was extremely valuable.
00:09:11 He was brilliant in foreign affairs.
00:09:13 And, you know,
00:09:15 there is that, but you've got to be humble.
00:09:18 And
00:09:19 I don't see that in Mr.
00:09:21 Rustout's response here.
00:09:23 Jared, so he
00:09:25 refused to step down
00:09:26 unconstitutionally when his caucus
00:09:29 had
00:09:30 voted non-conflict.
00:09:32 A lot of this is just kind of behind
00:09:35 the scenes, but I've had people
00:09:36 pretty senior people well-placed people in the bc conservatives tell me that members of caucus for
00:09:42 quite some time had been trying to bring a vote of non-confidence against him in the caucus
00:09:46 but then uh the caucus john brustad's caucus chair was just refusing to allow their a vote to take
00:09:52 place which i mean i really wish i had a boring book of robert's rules of order to give them you
00:09:58 could then impeach the chair at that point you just impeach the chair if the chair is not allowing
00:10:02 a vote and then you can get to there but i mean the other way around was what they did today which
00:10:07 is you just sign a letter they would then just give that to the speaker and at that moment you
00:10:12 cease to be you you don't have the confidence of your caucus you cease to be the leader of that
00:10:17 caucus otherwise literally legally speaking anyone could declare themselves a leader of the caucus
00:10:22 that's the way i work it's confidence-based just by convention if you were elected the leader of
00:10:26 the party you're the leader of the caucus but the caucus can remove you at any time and replace you
00:10:31 it anyone that they like um he refuses to go when the caucus votes to oust him unconstitutionally
00:10:38 um but now the party as uh the party's borders were voted remove him so i i don't know
00:10:45 one of the things i've been told was that the party was at least strongly considering
00:10:49 um maybe this will be kind of a further carrot and stick uh i don't know if they've done it yet
00:10:55 But one one of the things told by some of the sources I've talked to is that if he would not step down, they would also revoke his party membership and ban him as a local candidate.
00:11:06 Now, that is that's not even just the nuclear option.
00:11:09 That's the Carthaginian option. 0.98
00:11:11 You're salting the earth, murdering everyone and selling the women and children to slavery at that point. 0.97
00:11:16 But I suppose that would be one further.
00:11:19 As far as you know, that is not judging by the look on your face.
00:11:22 That is not what we know that they've done yet.
00:11:24 right no i haven't heard anything about that yet no okay well i i i got i got the impression
00:11:31 folks i'm talking to that that is kind of like that's the ultimate stick as opposed to the
00:11:36 carrot it's like you're going to accept our judgment or you're literally not even a grassroots
00:11:43 member of the party and you're not allowed to be a local candidate uh any sign have you seen
00:11:50 any sign yet, Jared, that John Rustad
00:11:52 is going to, now that his caucuses
00:11:54 voted against him, and now
00:11:55 he did not accept that.
00:11:58 But now that the party's board has voted
00:12:00 to remove him as the leader, has there been
00:12:02 any indication as yet? I know this just
00:12:04 happened. Any indication that he's going to accept
00:12:06 that, or is he
00:12:07 going to bring them to the Carthaginian auction?
00:12:11 I mean, I don't
00:12:12 know how you can't accept that, because, you know,
00:12:14 he's been the MLA
00:12:15 up north in his writing
00:12:18 for almost 20 years.
00:12:20 and so i'm sure he wants to continue doing that so i mean or maybe he's just gone too far to give
00:12:27 up and he might just push it all the way to the end it's really too hard to tell at this point
00:12:31 oh what is further than this i guess exactly like it was you know i've never i've fired people in
00:12:38 my career i've never had to hire security to escort someone out i've had staff walk out
00:12:44 in extremely rare occasions staff has walked someone out but at this point it sounds like
00:12:50 you're going to have to hire Brinks or something to come 0.97
00:12:53 and get him to pack up his box and escort him out of the office.
00:12:57 Well, so the question that I have for Jared is,
00:13:00 whatever happens to Mr. Rustad,
00:13:03 what is Dallas Brody and her fellow's thinking at the moment?
00:13:08 Is there likely to be a rapprochement between these rogue MLAs
00:13:15 and the rest of the party?
00:13:16 Because really their fight was...
00:13:18 Yeah, there's the independent ones expelled by Rustad on the left end of the party.
00:13:23 Then there's the 1BC ones on the right.
00:13:25 Yeah, Jared, your thoughts on rapprochement with the rebels?
00:13:30 I think 1BC, they've been successful as a standalone party.
00:13:34 You look at the polls and they're, you know, almost at the same popularity as the BC Greens.
00:13:40 And so I think they're just going to keep doing what they're doing and let the BC Conservatives kind of figure out their mess themselves.
00:13:48 Really?
00:13:48 But Eva, with Rustad gone, they wouldn't, like, I don't know.
00:13:52 I get the impression Brody would be a contender to win the leadership of the United Party.
00:13:57 I could be reading it wrong, but I'm gathering this is the typical battle we have with any big tent conservative party, though.
00:14:03 You know, you get your red Tories and your blue Tories, and they've really fractured to the far sides.
00:14:07 I think a lot would depend on what the leadership race is, because I imagine there's going to be candidates sort of representing,
00:14:13 you know, we're just getting ahead of ourselves, but still, like, presuming Mr. Rustad's gone.
00:14:17 there's going to be a race and there's going to be candidates
00:14:20 representing each of those sorts of factions
00:14:22 they're trying to find a way to pull it together
00:14:23 and anybody who's on the outs
00:14:25 with the party right now I think would be taking a wait
00:14:28 and see as to who's going to end up winning
00:14:29 the party confidence. I think Brody should run
00:14:32 let Brody run
00:14:33 very few people knew who she was
00:14:36 until she was expelled and then she's built some 0.99
00:14:37 significant profile
00:14:39 what are your thoughts Jared
00:14:41 if Brody were to go
00:14:44 back in and run for the leadership do you think
00:14:45 she be a competitive candidate she's kind of thrown all her cards on the table and like you 1.00
00:14:51 were saying cory it's it's hard to keep a party together when there are so many different factions
00:14:56 but i think the the majority of those who have stayed in the bc conservative party
00:15:02 haven't joined one bc or or split off because they kind of want to be a part of that big tent
00:15:08 coalition and bringing brody back in i think would kind of i don't know just put the party
00:15:15 back in the same place it was
00:15:16 when it was more fractured at the beginning.
00:15:19 Well, then it's not a Big Ten coalition
00:15:21 if it's not got a place for people like
00:15:23 Brody.
00:15:24 It depends on how big you want to make the coalition, yeah.
00:15:27 Well, I mean, it's a pretty fundamental part
00:15:29 of it. If you're going to be the conservative party, you've got to
00:15:31 have the conservatives.
00:15:33 Otherwise, you're just kind of the old liberal
00:15:35 coalition, and we're
00:15:37 back to where we were 15 years ago.
00:15:39 That's also a possibility.
00:15:41 It's a big discussion. I think some of that,
00:15:43 assuming even if Brody wanted to make a go at it, I guess that would land on the party executive
00:15:49 committee on whether or not a lot reestablish your membership even in the party, which I imagine
00:15:54 right now is void. I mean, there's a whole lot of rabbit holes to go down with this.
00:15:58 And if she did win the leadership, that would lead to quite a split in the remaining party.
00:16:03 I could see a center left breaking off. Welcome to conservative politics as usual.
00:16:08 Yeah. You know, I had congratulated BC Conservatives on having such a quick and neat and nice unification relative to the Alberta experience. And it is still a lot less messy. Like, we've got to remember how friggin' messy it was. Remember, like, the mass floor crossings and then just total death and it's still not as bad as it ever got in Alberta.
00:16:33 but you're you're really working on it bc you guys are really working on replicating to how
00:16:38 nasty and messy talk to some of the veterans of the pc wild rose battles yeah there's still blood
00:16:47 dried on the floor yeah um okay uh well where does it go from here jared like
00:16:52 oh actually let me put it this way so if john rustad finally bows to yes my caucus has voted
00:17:01 me out. Yes, my party board has voted me
00:17:03 out. That's it. Okay, then we know
00:17:05 more or less where it's going to go.
00:17:07 What happens if he
00:17:09 chains himself to the radiator,
00:17:12 handcuffs himself to the radiator,
00:17:14 locks the door,
00:17:15 says, I'm not leaving my office.
00:17:17 I'm the leader. You guys can go to help.
00:17:19 What happens then?
00:17:21 Does someone go to court or something?
00:17:24 I have no idea.
00:17:26 Start by turning up the heat on the
00:17:27 radiator.
00:17:29 Well, you have to send me out to Victoria, because that'd be some
00:17:31 great footage yeah yeah i well again you know what this actually might we're ever so slightly
00:17:39 pre-recording here with this already might be answered by the time we're done uh jared keep
00:17:43 your twitter feed open as we're talking we'll come back to this if uh if we get an update but uh
00:17:50 john john you know you probably got other things to do tonight but if you're watching this
00:17:55 for god's sakes for the good of the bc conservatives and for british columbia
00:18:00 I know you feel you've been wronged here
00:18:03 and that you're on the right side, but
00:18:05 it's time to fall on your
00:18:07 sword and do the right thing. It's
00:18:09 over.
00:18:11 It's just bloody over.
00:18:13 Okay.
00:18:17 I guess it kind of segues with BC
00:18:19 a bit here. The pipeline.
00:18:22 So,
00:18:24 last
00:18:25 Wednesday, last time
00:18:27 we did the pipeline,
00:18:28 our general comment thing was
00:18:31 it's got to be pretty good because Smith is facing
00:18:33 UCP members Friday night
00:18:35 at the annual
00:18:37 UCP convention in Edmonton
00:18:39 and I mean for her
00:18:41 to be able to do a peace deal with Ottawa
00:18:43 with a party that does not like peace with Ottawa
00:18:45 right now is better be
00:18:47 pretty good
00:18:48 saw the agreement
00:18:51 Thursday
00:18:51 it's kind of
00:18:55 conflict there's a lot of ins and outs of it
00:18:57 but there's some odd stuff
00:18:57 But yeah, Corey, you were with me at the convention, and I think to the shock and horror of the rest of Canada, Alberta Conservative members were not glowing in their praise of this agreement on Friday, were they?
00:19:15 Not even slightly. I mean, they're absolutely mortified by it and they expressed it. And watching that parallel and talking to a lot of people, we talked to probably hundreds of people over that two days. Smith is still wildly popular. Among the members, they love her, but they think she signed on to a stinker. And it's not just, there's two aspects.
00:19:37 One is just some people don't believe the pipeline's ever going to go anyways.
00:19:41 And the other is some of a, you know, basically as you're putting out, is a Faustian deal.
00:19:46 We're looking at some of the commitments that have to be made in order to do this.
00:19:49 A massive carbon capture project, which could benefit some crony capitalists and possibly suck some subsidy dollars into certain directions,
00:19:58 which blue conservatives aren't necessarily thrilled with that sort of trade-off.
00:20:02 A large hike in the carbon tax industrial.
00:20:05 what i see is actually a lot of junior operators in alberta probably not really happy with this
00:20:10 whole deal at all yeah because that's crushing their ability to be competitive on the markets
00:20:15 while the major players play the subsidy game yeah the the big players they they pay but they
00:20:20 also get to collect yes all guys don't know they only pay if you're sucking it back out through 0.77
00:20:25 the carbon capture thing then you can perhaps recluse yeah it's just getting uglier and uglier
00:20:29 as we look at it and then with our own dave winning talking about some of this stuff with
00:20:32 obligations uh domestic purchases of materials for it which could price this out of the range
00:20:38 uh you know rather than having a wide option of areas to source your uh materials and so on
00:20:44 it's just it's just a bad deal i i mean we did expect a lot because we'd seen that hard you
00:20:51 know and we'd gotten on our case premier smith said hey these nine things have to be gone by
00:20:54 gray cup or else and then we came all the way up to gray cup and it was or else well i'll tell you
00:20:59 in two weeks and we come up on two weeks
00:21:01 and okay this is going to be something big
00:21:03 and she said seven of nine
00:21:05 is not bad but you don't even get the seven of
00:21:07 ten and this is a commitment on
00:21:09 paper to seven of nine
00:21:11 and it just flew like a lead
00:21:13 balloon so
00:21:14 and now we're seeing the debates we're seeing the discussions
00:21:17 we're seeing that the Bloc Quebecois
00:21:18 you know demanding the Prime Minister
00:21:20 basically stop this. BC saying
00:21:23 we're not going to have it. Indigenous groups are saying
00:21:25 we're not going to have it and the Prime Minister has just kind of
00:21:27 said eh I'm going to say
00:21:28 step out the door and let Premier Smith deal
00:21:31 with this. Because
00:21:32 the only way this is going to happen
00:21:34 is with ongoing support
00:21:37 from the Prime Minister saying it's going to get done
00:21:39 and he's not doing that.
00:21:40 So she's holding on
00:21:43 to a dead document, I think.
00:21:45 Nigel, you know, one of the
00:21:47 reoccurring themes you've talked
00:21:49 about with Mark Carney is he
00:21:51 you know, he likes to have his
00:21:53 cake and eat it too. He likes a process
00:21:55 where the process is
00:21:57 his decision, not
00:21:58 not what we're actually trying to achieve in the process you know i will recognize a
00:22:02 palestinian state if they do x y and z and well then allows him to just pretend the process made
00:22:08 something up um i got a bad feeling this might be something somewhat this is not an agreement to
00:22:15 build a pipeline it's an agreement for a process to potentially build a pipeline it potentially makes
00:22:23 it wildly
00:22:24 uneconomical to do if you have
00:22:27 to use these buy Canadian steel
00:22:29 provisions. We've got the
00:22:31 carbon tax built in.
00:22:33 And then it talks about
00:22:34 there's a verbal
00:22:37 agreement and then there's the written
00:22:39 agreement. The written agreement does not say B.C.
00:22:41 and First Nations have a veto, but talks about meaningful
00:22:43 consultation and them being involved.
00:22:46 But, you know,
00:22:47 I'm going to go to Jared and a bit
00:22:49 about David Eby, but
00:22:50 verbally he said
00:22:53 No, B.C. and First Nations have to be on side.
00:22:55 And if that's the case, there's a zero...
00:22:57 We may as well just bury this document right now.
00:23:00 It's the only thing that's getting in the ground.
00:23:03 There's a zero percent chance this thing gets built.
00:23:07 Do you think...
00:23:08 Smith seemed genuinely proud of us,
00:23:11 and she does not have a reputation for being weak on Ottawa. 0.97
00:23:15 But do you think she got snuckered here?
00:23:18 Well, I'm not going to say that just yet,
00:23:20 But boy, oh boy, you've raised such a raft of questions in what you just said there.
00:23:28 We're very good at trying to look at things from Alberta's point of view, and we should.
00:23:32 But I've been trying to think, well, all right, if I were Kearney, what would I be wanting out of this?
00:23:38 You want to give the impression that you have a national reach, that you're not just central Canada.
00:23:43 You want to give the impression that difficult, though, Danielle Smith is to deal with.
00:23:48 I'm the man to do it, and I will go out and I'll engage with the rebel premier, and we'll sit down at the table and we'll work something out.
00:23:59 And that's the image I want to portray in eastern Canada.
00:24:04 Now, so many of the things that we're talking about, we just brought in the price of steel into the discussion.
00:24:11 Yeah, that's a big deal.
00:24:13 the attitude of Quebec.
00:24:17 I mean, you have to say, why
00:24:18 would we care what
00:24:21 Quebec thinks? This is all Western Canada
00:24:23 stuff. They've had their say. They don't want a pipeline. 0.77
00:24:25 They didn't get one. So why
00:24:27 are we...
00:24:28 What's their spot on the table there?
00:24:31 But it's all... These are the details
00:24:33 that people forget.
00:24:35 You know? Even we
00:24:37 have to make notes before we come into
00:24:39 the meeting to make sure we don't forget
00:24:41 anything. So
00:24:42 Well, what sticks in eastern Canada is that the Prime Minister went out and met his biggest political opponent,
00:24:50 they shook hands, they signed something, and everybody smiled as they went their separate ways.
00:24:56 That's a political win for Mr. Carney.
00:25:00 Don't ask about the details, because then it doesn't look so good.
00:25:04 And with Premier Smith, I mean, she did do this two days before she had a big speech to make at a convention.
00:25:11 uh at which point most people hadn't well she may have expected that most people wouldn't have got
00:25:18 into the details it kind of sounds as if enough had that you know some of the applause was muted
00:25:24 uh i can just see this whole thing as a charade as a as a as a little bit of political theater
00:25:33 that met the temporary needs of two leaders at the same time well car you were there with me
00:25:38 And as this agreement was booed, it was roundly booed by the members on two days, the first day during a bear pit kind of accountability session with the members, you know, Smith went into this, I think, you know, beaming, genuinely believing she had a win and she could hold this up.
00:25:59 and, you know, in front of the people and say,
00:26:03 we played tough, you know, and we won, we got this,
00:26:08 and people booed it.
00:26:10 The next day, you know, she said, you know,
00:26:14 let's not give up on our, I'm going to paraphrase it,
00:26:15 let's not give up on our country just as we're winning,
00:26:18 you know, for a sovereign Alberta within a united Canada,
00:26:21 and people booed again.
00:26:23 Now, that time there was also some applause interspersed with it.
00:26:25 The room wasn't unanimously opposed to it.
00:26:27 That would be an unfair characterization.
00:26:30 But she went into this convention, I think,
00:26:34 expecting this to be a triumphal victory entry into Rome.
00:26:39 And I was kind of of two minds.
00:26:43 I was still not...
00:26:45 I'm still not 100% one way or another,
00:26:47 but I was still very much taking stock of it, analyzing it.
00:26:51 I was shocked for one of the first times in my life
00:26:53 to find myself the moderate in the room
00:26:55 where most people were hard against it.
00:27:01 Smith's brilliant, and I think highly of her,
00:27:03 but she's got a tendency to forget what the membership thinks.
00:27:07 If anything, you give me a flashback of a time where she held up a thing
00:27:11 and told Alberta, we won. It's over.
00:27:14 She negotiated a great deal with a political leader,
00:27:18 and they're going to say it. I know I'm going to say it.
00:27:20 And it was the mass floor crossing, which was a political catastrophe
00:27:23 and cost every one of them their seats.
00:27:26 The promised cabinet positions,
00:27:29 again, that leader fled on his commitments
00:27:32 once he got pushback from his own party,
00:27:33 as we're seeing Carney doing right now,
00:27:35 and he rug pulled her.
00:27:37 And I could see Carney doing it to her again.
00:27:39 I think some of it is Daniel Smith
00:27:40 trying to see the best in people.
00:27:42 She really does and tries to think this is genuine,
00:27:45 this can go somewhere,
00:27:46 but forgot what the members might think instead.
00:27:49 And she better be really, really careful now.
00:27:52 And hopefully it was a wake-up,
00:27:53 as i said everybody at the agm really does seem to love premier smith they think very highly of her
00:27:58 but we know how quickly conservative minds can change she's gotten a warning shot and i hope
00:28:04 she's thinking really really hard about it yeah i um i was gonna say but i i you know i get
00:28:11 prentice vibes from carney i mean looks good and professional is comfortable in the corporate
00:28:19 boardroom, accomplished
00:28:21 very much
00:28:22 hailed and respected by
00:28:25 the Blue Bloods, that type of crowd
00:28:27 and
00:28:29 I mean, Danielle fell for it
00:28:30 with him, to catastrophic
00:28:33 ends
00:28:33 and I'm not
00:28:37 saying this is the same thing, but I get
00:28:38 I get Prentiss vibes
00:28:40 that's what I mean, I'm not saying it's the same, but some of that
00:28:43 feel is coming up, and thankfully she's
00:28:44 just learned from it
00:28:45 and I think that she's always, the members do
00:28:49 love her, but they still remember
00:28:51 that. And I
00:28:52 mean, and it took a lot for forgiveness
00:28:54 to take place there. But they did.
00:28:57 But they have not forgotten.
00:28:59 So I don't know. If I was Smith, I'd be 0.99
00:29:00 treading very cautiously around
00:29:02 Kearney here.
00:29:05 Let's get the BC perspective
00:29:06 on this.
00:29:09 David,
00:29:10 according to the written agreement, David Eby
00:29:12 has to be meaningfully
00:29:14 consulted. First Nations along the route need to
00:29:16 be meaningfully consulted.
00:29:18 according to Carney, verbally
00:29:20 they have to agree
00:29:22 if the verbal one is the case
00:29:25 and actually because it's an MOU
00:29:26 it's not actually a legally binding contract
00:29:28 it's a memorandum of understanding
00:29:30 you can't take an MOU to a court
00:29:32 it is not a contract
00:29:33 but
00:29:34 if they are given some kind of veto
00:29:38 there are consents required
00:29:40 it is just done and there's no sense discussing it
00:29:43 but I know
00:29:45 David Evey responded by
00:29:46 he said something very odd he's open to another pipeline but so long as the northwest coast
00:29:52 tanker band remains in place so you can you can build the pipeline but you're just not allowed
00:29:58 to spend the oil anywhere like it could just sit in you know infinitely accruing pile of barrels
00:30:05 in a port somewhere on the west coast um where is ed on this one right now uh so that yeah you
00:30:14 summed it up pretty well there uh the thing with the bc coast is the the tanker band covers pretty
00:30:20 much everything north of vancouver island and then obviously you have vancouver island in the way so
00:30:25 you're not going to build a port anywhere along there and there's no cities anyways leaving only
00:30:30 one option vancouver and burrard inlet it's already too shallow to allow the existing tmx pipeline to
00:30:39 operate at full capacity so nobody's going to want to build a third pipeline next to two that
00:30:48 already don't fully work so i think what eb is doing is kind of in a beat around the bush way
00:30:56 saying yeah this has never happened yeah um i wouldn't imagine so like he i mean the the hardcore
00:31:05 eco green movements you know a pretty major part of the bc ndp coalition um at what point does the
00:31:13 federal government actually exercise the power it says it has to control movement of product across
00:31:19 provincial buildings maybe he does maybe he does i like i'm i'm trying not to be overly partisan or
00:31:27 ideological about this maybe he does maybe he still remembers this pardon where did that start
00:31:33 You're not being over-partisan.
00:31:35 Ideological.
00:31:36 Look, I mean, the federal government comes to Alberta and says,
00:31:41 you better do things our way.
00:31:43 We want net zero by 2035.
00:31:45 Okay, make it 2050.
00:31:48 Your pipeline projects are not going anywhere unless we say so.
00:31:53 All right.
00:31:53 Well, no, you're saying they will.
00:31:55 Are you stating that still aren't going to go anywhere?
00:31:57 Either the federal government has control over interprovincial trade movements, or it doesn't.
00:32:06 And right now, he seems to be hiding.
00:32:08 This is the bad thing about Carney.
00:32:11 It always tells you something, and then says, of course, you made reference to it earlier, but it's conditional on something else.
00:32:17 Well, I'd maybe end with this, that we have a likely independence referendum coming up in 2026.
00:32:25 there needs to be a hard
00:32:28 deadline for approvals
00:32:31 I mean and by
00:32:33 Canadian standards that is warp speed
00:32:34 to get there that fast but there needs to be
00:32:37 a hard deadline on approvals
00:32:39 before that vote takes place
00:32:40 we should probably schedule the vote for next fall
00:32:42 and we should know this
00:32:44 the answer to this by September
00:32:47 so Albert's
00:32:48 federal legislation
00:32:50 it's in Carnies
00:32:51 bring that in
00:32:54 Is this even feasible? Because has the conditions attached to this made this thing economical between the carbon tax, between buy Canadian steel provisions, carbon sequestration, between all of this stuff? Is it even going to be economically viable?
00:33:09 But there are some deadlines built into the MOU.
00:33:11 That's one thing positive to kind of be said about it.
00:33:13 There's some April ones and some June ones that at least start some, you know, road signs to say whether you've actually made any progress working towards this.
00:33:21 And if they don't hit those, then, you know, again, I already think this thing's dead, to be honest.
00:33:25 I'm getting from skeptical to cynical, but those are in there.
00:33:29 And yeah, if there's an active independence referendum campaign going and these deadlines come with even those relatively modest goals haven't been reached, it's going to look really ugly on voting day.
00:33:41 And Daniel doesn't have to defend it any longer after that.
00:33:43 No.
00:33:44 So that changes the equation as well.
00:33:46 Yeah.
00:33:47 Or will she move the goalposts again? 1.00
00:33:49 That's where she's getting in some real danger.
00:33:50 Yeah.
00:33:51 We can't allow that.
00:33:52 We're going to have to hold her feet to the fire on this stuff. 1.00
00:33:54 there's no we we got a referendum likely coming up here and these dates mean something in this mou
00:34:01 you hold to them if they don't we declare this thing dead yeah well that's it and we vote
00:34:06 accordingly if she can say that the dates have come and passed despite my best efforts
00:34:10 they didn't happen then uh whose fault is it obviously the federal government's not hers
00:34:16 referendum gives her some some leverage yes she does it does okay uh we don't have a ton of time
00:34:23 for it but let's talk about bill c9 nigel this is uh i guess the new uh you know hurt feelings 0.84
00:34:29 online act uh there had been provisions in it that you know if you express a sincerely held
00:34:35 religious view uh you know i mean there there's some spicy verses in the bible and in the quran
00:34:41 around homosexuality and things like that um that you know don't go over well in a modern
00:34:48 progressive cocktail party
00:34:50 but there was protections
00:34:53 ostensibly for
00:34:54 sincerely held religious views
00:34:57 expressed that
00:34:59 in order to secure
00:35:00 the support of the bloc
00:35:02 of the legislation have been stripped out
00:35:04 well you know
00:35:06 I think the liberals are brave
00:35:08 if you're going to go up against God
00:35:10 get ready
00:35:12 it's not going to go hand well
00:35:14 look Bill C9
00:35:16 there's two things to say
00:35:18 One is Bill C-9 is ostensibly about online protection for children.
00:35:25 And what it says in there is, you know, fair enough if that's what you want to do.
00:35:30 We actually already have the legislation to do all that stuff about protecting children from online predators,
00:35:37 making it illegal to distribute non-consensual erotic pictures and that sort of thing.
00:35:44 But it's in the bill, and they're defending it on that basis.
00:35:48 What they have also done is they introduced a second stream in there
00:35:53 which deals with anti-hate, and that's where they, you know,
00:36:00 I don't know who would actually want to hoist a swastika
00:36:03 on their flagpole in their back lawn.
00:36:07 I don't see that happening, but if they did,
00:36:10 they would be breaking the law, a big accomplishment.
00:36:13 I think it's more aimed at Muslim expressions of Muslimism in Quebec.
00:36:21 I think that's what's driving this.
00:36:23 But to kind of make it look fair, they have also said,
00:36:28 well, by the way, the Bible says some unkind things about homosexuality.
00:36:34 We've got to ban that as well.
00:36:35 and it's part of a back-scratching deal between the government and the Bloc Quebecois.
00:36:44 Now, the second thing to say is that although it would be possible for Christian conservatives
00:36:49 to get mightily angry about this, and they should, because it's wrong,
00:36:55 nevertheless, they'd have to understand that the Liberal Party, which is backing this,
00:37:02 has got a very different world view, and within their world view,
00:37:07 they are being entirely consistent.
00:37:10 So it illustrates the deep cultural divide in this country at this time.
00:37:18 You know, the temptation when you see Mark Miller out there saying,
00:37:22 well, you know, we're going to have to ban these passages of the Bible.
00:37:26 They're not going to be used as a defense of genuinely held belief anymore.
00:37:31 you know your back goes up and you think well who are you to say that the bible is wrong
00:37:35 within their essentially uh atheistic point of view that's that they're doing exactly what
00:37:45 you would expect them to do um i'm surprised it's taken this long to get here yeah uh cory
00:37:53 the bill was i mean ran into similar trouble in the previous parliament under trudeau they've
00:37:59 essentially just trying again here,
00:38:02 I guess. They said, ah, we're going to avoid
00:38:03 some of the pride falls of the last one. They do
00:38:05 not appear to be.
00:38:08 The UK, I think,
00:38:10 Ukraine arrests, not even accounting
00:38:11 for the difference of population size, the UK
00:38:13 arrests
00:38:13 in gross numbers
00:38:17 three times as many people a year
00:38:19 for online comments as Russia.
00:38:22 Now, to be fair,
00:38:23 in Russia, they just de-denisrate you in some cases.
00:38:25 They fall off a bell. Yeah, you
00:38:27 fall out the window
00:38:29 So I'm not accounting for those numbers.
00:38:31 And that's real.
00:38:32 But that's probably not a big number.
00:38:34 But it's a harsher punishment than you get in Canada or in Britain for hurting feelings.
00:38:39 But Britain arrests three times as many people a year.
00:38:43 And Russia has a significantly larger population than Britain.
00:38:48 The worry is this is going to put us on the same trajectory.
00:38:52 You go to prison for sharing memes.
00:38:54 um there doesn't appear to be much of the way in pushback uh there's elements of the i guess you
00:39:03 know the center-right establishment mainstream conservative media uh you know like the post
00:39:07 media stuff is it is it's around it on their opinion sections but there doesn't seem to be
00:39:12 any major major pushback from this even the conservatives i think are a little tepid on it
00:39:19 makes for hard political games to play because you know how it always works you're defending
00:39:23 hate. You're defending fascism.
00:39:25 I mean, you want to be the guy who defends the right
00:39:27 to fly a National Socialist flag. No,
00:39:29 that's not good politics.
00:39:31 Exactly, and I find that, I'll
00:39:33 take that stance as a libertarian. I find the flag
00:39:35 disgusting, and anybody who wants to wave it
00:39:37 is doing so, but I don't think it should be 0.93
00:39:38 legalized. You know, it should just be
00:39:41 pointed out and let the public
00:39:43 bury that down. Likewise with religious
00:39:45 texts. I mean, most of them, in every religion,
00:39:47 if you go back, they don't
00:39:48 match the standards of modern living. If you want to take
00:39:51 a literal interpretation of them, well,
00:39:52 There'd be people pushing to have slaves and, you know, have sacrifices and things, depending on how far of the Old Testament you want to go.
00:40:01 But the modern world has moved past that without banning the text.
00:40:04 There's been reformation.
00:40:05 There's been, you know, just realizing that we don't take those interpretations as they are in public.
00:40:11 Well, I guess part of the problem, Islam, Islam's a different... 1.00
00:40:16 We, I think, generally the Christian world, which has a more elastic interpretation of some of these texts, whereas in Islam, it's, you know, the Quran is the literal divine, not divinely inspired, but is the literal written word of God.
00:40:34 And it is, and of course, not every Muslim takes it this way, but very significant numbers of Muslims do.
00:40:42 And so, yeah, some of their texts, spicier sections, if you will, a lot of people do take it very literally.
00:40:52 And I get that some groups don't feel safe from that.
00:40:56 But guess what? That's the price of a free society.
00:40:58 They're going to get to say some stuff that makes you feel very uncomfortable.
00:41:01 Well, certainly. I mean, we have to go after the crime rather than the text.
00:41:05 I mean, I'm an atheist and my views in some of the countries in the Middle East, if I tried to put those out in the open, that's the same crime because my thoughts and speech wouldn't be allowed and I would be beaten down because it's a theocracy.
00:41:17 On the same other side of the coin, you can't ban the texts.
00:41:21 You just ban the acts and, you know, and murder and honor killings and some of the other things that people might use their texts to try and justify.
00:41:29 We just don't allow that.
00:41:30 But the government's using that, I think, just as an easy target, low-hanging fruit, to bring in another bill that's controlling speech.
00:41:36 So they'll go after those extreme elements and say, we need to do it because of this.
00:41:39 But as you said, it's going to come to the point where people are going to be getting incarcerated for memes, and then we all lose.
00:41:45 It's dangerous, dangerous territory.
00:41:47 I mean, I always err on the side of freedom.
00:41:49 Yeah.
00:41:49 Okay.
00:41:50 Well, we're going to put a pin in that and go to our parting shots.
00:41:55 First one, Jared, I'm going to give you a little more time since you're new to the show.
00:42:00 We'll start with Nigel.
00:42:03 Okay, so what Nigel thinks is that we just have the numbers on medical assistance in dying,
00:42:09 and they reveal that the practice continues to grow.
00:42:16 You know, you try to be so organized with these things,
00:42:19 but look, 16,499 people received medical assistance in dying in 2024.
00:42:28 The figure's just out on Friday.
00:42:30 And what a lot of people have missed is that more than 22,000 were actually approved for medical assistance in dying.
00:42:38 Some did back off, decided to change their minds.
00:42:41 But, you know, there were more than 4,000 who were approved who didn't get it.
00:42:47 And here we are.
00:42:48 How often do we hear about somebody who wants a life-saving procedure, dies on the waiting list?
00:42:54 You can't even get a death procedure.
00:42:56 you'll die on the waiting list waiting for assisted suicide so that is the most canadian thing ever 1.00
00:43:02 it's uh yes it's a hell of a thing dying for death dying waiting to be killed yes yeah cory 0.95
00:43:08 uh just uh reminding folks that it's not just uh the pipeline that's being held up going to the
00:43:14 west there's indigenous leaders as reported in the standard saying that the ring of fire
00:43:18 development's never going to happen in ontario as well which is in the major projects office so
00:43:23 Kearney, you can't hide from this.
00:43:25 You've got to take a stand one way or another.
00:43:27 Either nothing's getting done, or you're having a fight
00:43:29 with the Indigenous leaders.
00:43:32 Jared, your parting shot.
00:43:35 So,
00:43:35 I actually don't have a parting shot,
00:43:37 but I have something that's even more...
00:43:38 I didn't actually tell you to have one ready, so I sprung this on
00:43:41 yet.
00:43:43 So, the BC Conservative Party
00:43:45 just released a statement saying that they
00:43:47 the board certified
00:43:49 that Rustad is professionally incapacitated
00:43:51 and thus unable to get
00:43:53 continuous party leader under the constitution there's only there's a number of ways you can
00:43:58 get rid of a leader either they die or they're not saying they didn't kill him they didn't kill
00:44:04 him right all right all right put that on record just his career resignation death incapacitation
00:44:11 or a leadership review vote and so they got creative and uh incapacitation it's it's kind
00:44:18 of like article 25 of the u.s constitution usually deals with with health issues and
00:44:24 they argued that he's professionally incapacitated so there you go and it's now uh if it's if the
00:44:34 party is structured anything like in alberta that's a bylaw under the societies act and it
00:44:38 could technically be challenged in court but i mean do you really want to have also in the meantime
00:44:43 but there is always the option um one small party in alberta did this uh they ousted their leader
00:44:49 the wild rose independence party to oust their leader they just literally revoked his membership
00:44:53 and if you're not a member of the party you can't be the leader of the party and so that's
00:44:56 like there there are ways okay all right well that's that's interesting uh that's a good party
00:45:04 shot it's not really a party shot but it's a it's a good bulletin thank you uh all right mine um
00:45:09 I'm jealous of this one
00:45:12 a Canadian
00:45:14 manufacturer sold 20
00:45:16 APCs armored personnel
00:45:18 carriers to ICE
00:45:20 in America to help
00:45:22 root out and get rid of 0.99
00:45:24 illegal immigrants 0.99
00:45:25 my only problem with that is I want
00:45:28 them here
00:45:28 the vehicles not the immigrants 0.99
00:45:31 yeah
00:45:32 I want them here rounding up
00:45:36 all the people that we
00:45:38 illegally allow in
00:45:39 out. We're going to need some
00:45:42 APCs here. So that's my only problem
00:45:44 with it, is America stealing our APCs
00:45:45 to deal with their illegal migration problem.
00:45:48 Okay.
00:45:50 Nigel, Corey, Jared,
00:45:52 and John running the studio.
00:45:54 Thank you very much for joining us.
00:45:56 Thank all of you for joining us here today on
00:45:58 the Pipeline. Remember that
00:46:00 the Western Standard needs support
00:46:02 for people like you to continue doing our work.
00:46:04 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
00:46:06 go to westernsnetter.news right now.
00:46:07 click on subscribe it's ten dollars a month or twenty dollars a year for unlimited access to
00:46:12 all western standard content to get past that pesky paywall i know when we were at the united
00:46:17 conservative party convention this week and some people said oh you guys have that paywall i'm
00:46:20 like well stop being a freeloader we're not working for free here we could you see this
00:46:25 newsroom behind us we got we got people busy pretending to work back there me i'm pretending
00:46:31 to do my job and whatnot this is a real business so um if you're hitting that paywall
00:46:37 that means it's time to pay up
00:46:39 become a member
00:46:40 only $10 a month
00:46:41 or $100 a year
00:46:42 thank you very much
00:46:43 for joining us today
00:46:44 and God bless
00:47:07 Thank you.