Western Standard - August 01, 2025


Rachel Gilmore vs Alise Mills debate on free speech

Hosted by
Mentioned
RCMP officer dragged during arrest of suspects in stolen vehicle in Gibbons Montreal Firebombing: Why Won’t Canada Protect Christian Artists? | The Pipeline

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 5 minutes

Words per minute

168.85

Word count

11,098

Sentence count

311

Harmful content

Misogyny

12

sentences flagged

Toxicity

43

sentences flagged

Hate speech

29

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Derek Vildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and Elisha Mills, editor-in-chief of the Calgary Spectator, join host Evan Handyside to discuss the recent ban on country music by country music singer Sean Faust.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day and welcome. Today is July 31st, 2025. I'm Derek Vildebrandt, publisher of the Western
00:00:20 Standard. We're coming to you live today. I'm in our Calgary headquarters here, but I'm going to
00:00:26 bring in Elyse Mills, coming to us from an undisclosed location on beautiful Vancouver 0.98
00:00:32 Island. There she is. Thanks for joining us, Elyse.
00:00:38 Hello. So happy to be here. Best part of my day.
00:00:44 Yeah. Okay. Well, let's just talk about why we're here. It's not quite windy.
00:00:49 Yeah. I don't have time for many shows, but we're doing a little special one today.
00:00:57 you know why why don't i leave it just put it to you to introduce why we're here
00:01:07 hello well we're here today um because uh a not so well known until quite recently country music
00:01:16 singer from california i wanted to come into canada and play several venues from west coast
00:01:25 to east coast east coast to west coast and our government agencies representatives of our
00:01:31 government elected officials city hall uh every level of government tried to block him from playing
00:01:38 his music in this country and the argument that they gave was that it if it was not aligned with
00:01:46 their government whether it was the federal provincial or municipal aligned with their values
00:01:52 not aligned with our public spaces values i wasn't aware that our public spaces have values
00:01:57 but uh and so it ironically has turned into this very important discussion around the charter and
00:02:07 the gentleman's name is faust as you know your publication today printed one of my opinion pieces
00:02:14 about why it's amazingly ironic that a country music singer from California schooled our
00:02:22 government, our politicians, and what the Constitution really, or what the Charter really
00:02:27 means in Canada. And so we're here today to talk about those who have tried to silence
00:02:32 him and believe that the Charter is handed a permission slip instead of it actually being
00:02:39 So everybody's right to say what they want to say, do what they want to do, write what they want to write until it edges hate speech and willful promotion of propaganda, which this gentleman isn't even close.
00:02:53 So that's why we're here today. And I will then bring in the other part of why we set this up today.
00:03:01 If you want, I don't know, Derek, you want to talk about it, but I had been reading a former journalist, former journalist, Twitter, I guess, X.
00:03:11 Her name is Rachel Gilmore. She is a former pundit and now runs, I don't know what it is, her own channel. 0.57
00:03:18 And she was saying some of the most egregious things, which I believe to be her attempt to spread misinformation at best, disinformation at worst, and what the Charter really means.
00:03:29 And it was through the lens of Sean Faust coming into Canada.
00:03:34 And it absolutely infuriated me, Derek.
00:03:37 I couldn't believe a person that constantly, a woman that constantly talks about her education, her background in journalism, could get the Charter so wrong. 0.97
00:03:47 And then also manipulate it and twist it so that it fit her political persuasion. 0.99
00:03:53 And this is something I've been seeing in Canada or happen in Canada for a long time now.
00:03:58 We're not just on a slippery slope.
00:04:00 The whole edge has given out.
00:04:02 And so I challenged her to a debate.
00:04:05 I said, if you feel that strongly about your position and you can back your tweets or back your posts, then I'd like you to join me in a debate.
00:04:13 And that's when Western Standard and yourself, Derek, or you entered the conversation, said we'd be very happy to host it.
00:04:22 And so that's why I'm here today, and unfortunately we're here today.
00:04:26 Okay, so yeah, we, yeah, I kind of entered, you know, Derek enters the conversation, where it kind of ended, I guess.
00:04:36 I said, you know, Western Centre would be happy to host the debate. Now, I can understand why, you know, kind of a hard left personality might have be leery. But, you know, I've hosted debates before. I hosted a UCP leadership debate where I privately definitely had favourites. Some I like a lot more than others.
00:04:57 But I think I've been a pretty fair moderator and host on these kinds of things.
00:05:05 Even when, I mean, every moderator has always got a favorite.
00:05:10 And I don't care if you're debating your favorite color.
00:05:11 You've got your own favorite color.
00:05:13 So we promised, you know, to use her words, a safe space to, you know, have this out.
00:05:21 You know, she thinks it's fine for the government to just ban a musical act simply because it's Christian and conservative.
00:05:29 All right.
00:05:30 Well, I mean, you should probably be willing to debate.
00:05:32 I don't think I've ever actually seen her.
00:05:34 Somewhere in her life, I'm sure she's actually had a public debate where she's actually had to defend and be challenged and defend her ideas.
00:05:41 But I've never seen it myself.
00:05:43 It's always just a couple of mean girl tweets.
00:05:46 I don't think so, Derek.
00:05:48 Yeah, I've never seen it. So what we did is we invited her to the debate. She kind of snarkily declined. Is her right? Fine. But we said, well, we're going to do it anyway. So what we're going to do is we're going to schedule it for 2 p.m. Mountain Standard Time, 1 p.m. Pacific, where you are. And we sent her a private invitation. We sent her a link.
00:06:13 said like if you'd like to join us
00:06:14 here's the link, you can join us at any time
00:06:16 we're going to be there at 2pm
00:06:17 I'm not expecting her to show up at this point
00:06:20 but hypothetically Rachel Gilmore might 0.99
00:06:22 pop into the stream
00:06:23 I got production over here, John
00:06:25 I think I was copied on that, yeah we sent her the link, right?
00:06:28 Alright, Rachel Gilmore's got the link to the back end
00:06:31 here where she can enter the stream
00:06:33 at any time
00:06:34 right now I don't have to be
00:06:37 a neutral moderator 0.99
00:06:39 so we can both just shit talk and see 0.98
00:06:41 whatever we want really right now
00:06:42 But if at some point she decides to enter the chat, join the debate, you know, I promise to be as best as I humanly can, neutral and fair moderator and let the two of you at it.
00:06:56 I mean, that's good TV. That'd be good TV to see the two of you go head to head on this issue.
00:07:02 I doubtful we will, but instead we're just until or if such a time as she were to join us, I think we're going to have a discussion about the dangerously authoritarian trend in this country and across the Western world more broadly, but we'll talk about Canada more specifically, to just censor those we disagree with.
00:07:28 And also, but the need for those of us on what is normally the receiving end on the right to be aware of when we're trying to do it.
00:07:36 So, you know, we've got this FOICT Act, as I said on the pipeline yesterday, I'd never heard of them.
00:07:43 Never heard of them before this.
00:07:45 I doubt most, like if I have not heard of them, they're probably not well known at all among the broader Canadian public who don't pay as much attention to politics and the news.
00:07:54 But now everybody has heard of these guys.
00:07:58 set on the pipeline again, I'm not a big fan of Christian rock. I find it a little too on the nose 1.00
00:08:02 for the most part. I haven't liked a Christian rock act since Creed. But it doesn't matter if 1.00
00:08:09 it's good or not, or if you like it or not. We traditionally in this country have not been in
00:08:14 the business of banning musical acts that we disagree with. So maybe let's talk maybe one,
00:08:20 it's a UK, I think, example, where we're going to flip it around on its head, where we have to be
00:08:26 the defensive so there was uh there was a concert recently in the uk maybe it was glasgow um and
00:08:33 there were two acts there that um people on our side of the fence would find extremely offensive
00:08:40 and distasteful putting it mildly um i i can't remember do you remember the names of these guys
00:08:49 do you remember the names of these guys at least there's a little delay i think uh so
00:08:52 so it's kneecap they're an Irish band and they are they were playing at a BBC
00:08:59 or they were playing at a London music festival and actually it was I can't
00:09:08 remember what was in celebration of it was some sort of national I believe it
00:09:12 was the national holiday there and BBC was live streaming it and jury and they
00:09:17 were obviously anti not only anti-israel but i believe anti-somatic and that is my opinion and
00:09:27 they came right out and started chanting death to the idf death to israel and then but the bbc was
00:09:34 sliding it so bbc similar to the cbc taxpayer funded and they didn't cut away and people you
00:09:41 could tell people the presenters other people were horrified and that has led to the ban from
00:09:50 shows across the eu uh uh being banned um in the united states and i will say that i have written
00:10:04 and posted several times to our government and so I find it ironic that they've come
00:10:10 out and immediately tried to ban Sean Faust. Meanwhile, this is a hateful group who has
00:10:19 nothing pleasant to say whatsoever. And I would say quite pleasurable. Happily.
00:10:28 Oh, okay. So we've lost Elise there. She's had a pretty rough internet connection.
00:10:33 And she's going to be back in.
00:10:35 But, yeah, so at least we've had troubles with your connection.
00:10:40 I don't know.
00:10:42 I'll say something.
00:10:43 Maybe if you could try to strengthen your signal, if that's possible.
00:10:48 You know, what kneecap this band was saying at a concert in Glasgow.
00:10:56 I thought it was hateful.
00:10:58 I thought it was obviously anti-Israel. 0.99
00:11:01 Obviously anti-Israel chanting death, death, death. 0.94
00:11:03 I can hear myself now. Okay, there we go. 0.87
00:11:07 Chenin, death to the IDF, the Israeli Defense Force. 0.97
00:11:12 I think they probably were anti-Semitic, but I don't think that language in itself is technically.
00:11:22 It's fine to very much dislike a state or a government, even to hate a state or a government.
00:11:30 I'm not sure I use the word hate, but I have a pretty strong dislike for some regimes or I'm not sure about states themselves, but certainly some regimes around the world.
00:11:40 You know, I hate the People's Republic.
00:11:42 You know, if I chanted death to the People's Liberation Army, I don't think that necessarily means I mean death to all Chinese people. 1.00
00:11:51 Now, did these guys mean death to all Jewish people?
00:11:54 yeah maybe they did but i you know i want to be cautious about uh you know conflating the 0.85
00:12:01 difference between dislike or even hate of israel with hate of jewish people although there's a
00:12:06 pretty big overlap you know affair um but you know there were some calls on the right uh and
00:12:12 from jewish groups to ban these musical acts and to censor these musical acts and i and i thought
00:12:17 that was that was the wrong way to go about it uh you know if you're the concert organizer you
00:12:24 have a right to not have them and i think they probably shouldn't have had them but i uh i would
00:12:29 have had a bigger problem i bigger problem with governments intervening to uh pull these guys
00:12:37 off the air or stop them from from playing their concert um i would have had a bigger problem with
00:12:42 that than actually the act of these guys performing. However, probably and arguably
00:12:48 hateful their content was. And what we call hate, I think one of the big
00:12:55 promises here is what actually is hate? We used to draw the line at hate as
00:13:00 actively inciting violence or harm against an identifiable group. You know, if you said,
00:13:06 kill all the jews okay that's hateful uh we said kill all the muslims kill all the christians 1.00
00:13:13 well all the traditionally christians have not been allowed to be included because it's seen 1.00
00:13:17 as a majority privileged uh group if you if you buy into that stuff but it was pretty clear that
00:13:21 was hate but now you know then it went to you could say i'm not a big fan of x y group and
00:13:28 then that got banned and i think you should be allowed to not be a fan and say you're not a fan
00:13:32 of a group and maybe that is an odious opinion but guess what it's an opinion and that should
00:13:36 be defensible in a free society and if it's a bad opinion we should let the marketplace of ideas
00:13:42 hopefully the good ideas went through they don't always um but now it's not even just i'm not a fan
00:13:48 of that group it's um i have something negative to say about an individual who even belongs to a
00:13:53 group um and so you you get the types like rachel gilmore the federal government parks canada
00:13:59 municipalities provincial governments where it's not that's not the line of hate anymore it's um
00:14:06 you've said something that i find disagreeable that does not agree with my ideology at all
00:14:12 and then that's hate and we can cancel it i think the problem is we have moved the line on what is
00:14:18 so far and i i think i've gotten to the point where we cannot trust anyone to draw the line
00:14:25 on what is legally defined hate and perhaps we have to drop the idea of hate speech laws altogether
00:14:31 because the state simply can't be trusted to draw the line in a responsible place anymore
00:14:35 well you said a couple of things derek and i hope you can hear me because my headset's now
00:14:40 not working because i flipped to my phone okay great so let's just remember that unpopular or
00:14:48 distasteful or contrarian ideas and opinions don't immediately mean hate. This is where
00:14:56 people are confused. If you are offended, turn the TV off, disassociate from X, do whatever you have
00:15:05 to do. But you are not to ask the government to intervene on something that doesn't meet the
00:15:11 standard of hate speech or willful promotion of hate, which is the propaganda side. And to give
00:15:18 you an example of that, that would be burning flags, inciting violence, things like chanting
00:15:28 death to Canada, or standing outside of a Jewish nursery school or nursing home yelling death to 0.99
00:15:34 Jews. That is hate speech. And I think the reason why people like myself are so irritated, and I do 1.00
00:15:41 agree with you, I may have to put up with kneecap coming to Vancouver. But it makes my blood boil.
00:15:47 And I think it makes my blood boil and others' blood boil as well because of the huge disparity in what this government is willing to accept and almost agree to and sign off.
00:15:59 You look at what's happened in Toronto on Bathurst.
00:16:02 You look at downtown Toronto. 0.98
00:16:04 Last weekend, Scotiabank was covered in red paint and they were screaming death to Canada, death to Jews. 1.00
00:16:12 i think a lot of us are wondering okay so how is sean banned he's not burning flags he's not
00:16:19 inciting hate he's a christian musician that is that is singing in a peaceful worship type festival
00:16:27 that's exactly what's going on um i i as you know i i may not i don't know his music i don't think
00:16:34 it's my thing either but that's not that's not the point of all of this and i think the points
00:16:40 you're making Derek about kneecap are absolutely true but I think my tolerance and many of people
00:16:45 many of the people I speak to and my followers all agree that when we're watching what's been
00:16:51 happening in places especially like Toronto I I the tolerance for anybody for any hate is is zero
00:16:59 and it's because there is a huge gap between what the government says what the government does and
00:17:05 what our criminal code says and what our police officers do. And I have an intolerance for the
00:17:12 tolerance of that type of hate. I also think that certain people like Rachel Gilmore really believe
00:17:18 freedom of expression is a progressive perk, that it's not a constitutional right for all of us to
00:17:26 have. And I think that is something that's becoming increasingly obvious. It's almost like she
00:17:32 believes or her ilk believe that there's almost a political purity test to see if you pass so that
00:17:37 you can have the privilege of having your rights around freedom of expression and speech and i
00:17:43 think that's where people have really lost their minds on this issue and when i say lost their
00:17:48 minds i mean they're just extremely angry and outraged and i think the pendulum has swung
00:17:52 governments are not going to get away with censoring uh for no good reason and our public
00:17:58 spaces do not do not supersede or the government does not supersede the charter so you know i was
00:18:07 talking about hate laws and you're talking about hate laws but the censorship of foict here is not
00:18:13 been done under the guise of hate laws there's a lot of hate rhetoric around it there's uh you
00:18:18 know the the justifications around it in many cases oh rachel's joined us look
00:18:23 um the big picture oh there we go come on we don't need that much too much i was excited
00:18:32 too too much rachel that's a lot of rachel maybe her connection's about as good as yours
00:18:38 um um but you know the censorship of foict here uh hasn't been done through the criminal code
00:18:46 with hate speech laws hasn't been done by the human rights commission
00:18:49 kind of the traditional venues of the state censoring in Canada. It's been done largely,
00:18:56 for the most part, by pulling permits. Permits that were all approved, as far as I'm aware,
00:19:02 before they ended up landed in this country. There was Parks Canada once with some federal land,
00:19:08 provincial land, places under municipal jurisdiction. And Parks Canada put out this
00:19:16 mealy-mouthed statement. They didn't say, this is hate, and we're shutting it down and prosecuting
00:19:21 it. They put out a statement saying, well, we can't guarantee the safety and security of the
00:19:25 place. Bullshit. Okay. But then they had this mealy-mouthed part attached to it that says, 1.00
00:19:30 you know, it's not compatible with Parks Canada values. You're talking about this and diversity.
00:19:38 I mean, the only diversity Parks Canada should care about is biodiversity.
00:19:41 But if they're going to care about diversity, no one ever cares about diversity of thought,
00:19:45 diversity of opinions, diversity of perspectives. If we're talking about diversity of religion,
00:19:49 it's certainly never Christianity. You know, that never seems to fit into the mix. But 0.98
00:19:54 they were pulling permits. Some municipalities, like I think Quebec City, Montreal, the mayors
00:20:03 just said, this is hateful and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, not compatible and not welcome in our
00:20:08 city, which is funny because Quebec is probably the has the most discriminatory laws in North
00:20:14 America on the books. And I don't see much resistance from the mayors of Montreal and
00:20:19 Quebec City towards extremely discriminatory legislation against Muslims or against
00:20:26 Anglophones in Quebec. They're quite happy with that kind of discrimination. And fine, whatever.
00:20:33 Quebec's going to Quebec, and I've stopped caring. It's their own place. But 0.83
00:20:38 um you know they're quite happy with it on on their own terms uh and so but but they did it
00:20:44 under the guise of permit so then you know they they found a way around it and fine we won't do
00:20:49 it at a regular concert venue we're gonna we're gonna have a concert inside of a church uh they
00:20:54 didn't even bring in this is in montreal and they didn't even bring in um additional sound equipment
00:20:59 i've seen it reported at least they just used the stuff the church already had uh so there was
00:21:04 No, it was just like a pretty much a regular night.
00:21:07 Churches do operate outside of strictly on Sunday morning at 10 o'clock.
00:21:12 And now they're fined by the city of Montreal.
00:21:17 I would imagine if there's even a half competent judge and half fair judge, that's going to get defeated in court.
00:21:24 I think the Canadian Constitution Foundation is fighting on that one.
00:21:27 These guys are not fighting under the strict hate speech laws anymore.
00:21:31 They're just using, you know, permits and whatnot to disrupt it.
00:21:37 I don't know if there's any defense to that.
00:21:39 I mean, we get one of the problems with democracy is you get the government you deserve and people elect people.
00:21:47 Presumably the politicians in these places think it's going to make them more popular to do this.
00:21:52 And I'm not sure when you're when they're fighting through the permitting phase that there really is any kind of defense against this.
00:21:58 when you have an electorate
00:22:00 that's willing to reward politicians
00:22:02 for this kind of behavior.
00:22:04 Well, I think a great example
00:22:07 of where this has gone completely off the rails.
00:22:10 So Abbotsford, BC had a scheduled show
00:22:13 or Sean had a scheduled show there.
00:22:15 Abbotsford pulled the permit,
00:22:18 which is shocking because you might know this, Derek.
00:22:21 Abbotsford has one of the largest Christian communities
00:22:23 in all of British Columbia.
00:22:25 I was surprised to see Abbotsford do something
00:22:27 so explicitly anti-Christian. Yes, and their reasoning for it, and this is something that I 1.00
00:22:33 think that we need to take a look at, and it really falls under the file of intimidation,
00:22:40 but, and I want to say that the BC conservative MLA out there has written a letter, made a
00:22:46 statement, I have reposted that, and I absolutely 100% agree with her, and unfortunately her name
00:22:51 is slipping my mind, and I apologize, but they were saying that they weren't pulling it because
00:22:56 they disagreed with sean and his music and they didn't feel that there was any evidence of hate
00:23:02 contrary to what the premier um was talking or premier eby was was remarking on yesterday that
00:23:07 he said that it was unacceptable unacceptable values well we can get into sean's lyrics in
00:23:13 a second because there is no hate or unacceptable values in his music um but the problem abbotsford
00:23:20 has is that they're responding to safety concerns they cannot assure the safety of sean
00:23:25 or those in attendance and i think when you know what was was a strong intimidation factor threats
00:23:34 of violence there for concert goers or festival goers smoke bombs were released that's really
00:23:40 dangerous there were lots of young people in that crowd uh so now we're talking about the 0.78
00:23:45 intimidation as well and when low information voters and i don't mean that to be derogatory
00:23:51 even though it sounds that way but canadians are busy trying to pay their bills they're not
00:23:56 necessarily paying attention and they trust i think a lot of people still trust what their
00:24:00 government is saying so if the government is going out there saying we don't want this guy
00:24:04 playing he's a dangerous guy which is what some liberal mps this is how this all kicked off uh
00:24:10 which some liberal mps were calling him dangerous and hateful if i heard that and i wasn't in this
00:24:16 business and i wasn't actively pursuing information i would think yeah then of course
00:24:21 the government wouldn't make a statement like that unless it's true what's it so it's verbal
00:24:26 intimidation it's asking you to to just avoid him he's a bad guy because he has these values
00:24:31 and then now the outcome of that is you've almost endorsed people to hate him and you've endorsed
00:24:39 what is will become acceptable violence because when you shrink away and pull the permanent permit
00:24:44 you're giving over to that very small group of people who seem to be the loudest in the country
00:24:49 right now um uh to take it it's the illegal behavior that we see in our cities as well
00:25:00 have blocked roads and stopped ambulances going through we are acquiescing to the illegal and
00:25:07 sometimes violent behavior yeah uh so that's a break in the charter yeah sorry your stream is uh
00:25:16 getting a little rough again um it was good for a bit but it's getting a little rough again um
00:25:25 yeah i i i don't know i don't i don't think i'm not sure there's a good way to defend this anymore
00:25:30 um i mean the um i mean this mostly started from the cbc the cbc did some hatchet job on uh
00:25:37 on FOIT here, and it just said he's anti-LGTBQ plus 2SI.
00:25:45 Maybe I got the full alphabet acronym, right?
00:25:48 I don't know.
00:25:49 They said he's a Christian nationalist.
00:25:52 Well, what does that mean?
00:25:53 Does he mean, you know, he believes that America
00:25:55 was founded as a Christian country, because it was.
00:25:59 I mean, it was a secular state,
00:26:01 but it was populated by Christian people.
00:26:05 Like us, like Canada.
00:26:07 Yeah, just like Canada.
00:26:09 But, you know, anti-LGBQ, 2SI plus XYZ.
00:26:15 What does that mean?
00:26:17 They didn't elaborate.
00:26:18 I mean, maybe he said something nasty there.
00:26:21 But, I mean, that could mean something as simple as saying,
00:26:24 I don't like drag queens dancing in front of little children. 1.00
00:26:31 And the CBC would consider that to be hateful and anti-alphabet stuff.
00:26:37 I mean, maybe he said something worse than that.
00:26:40 I haven't seen it.
00:26:41 Maybe he's got songs about it.
00:26:43 I haven't heard it, perhaps.
00:26:46 But they didn't provide any examples of this stuff.
00:26:49 They just said, he is anti this.
00:26:51 He is this phobe.
00:26:52 He is this, that ism.
00:26:55 They didn't actually demonstrate any of it.
00:27:00 Well, they took on the CBC took on the persona of lobbyists.
00:27:04 that article was not written with journalistic integrity in my belief it was written with a
00:27:11 political agenda meant to influence government wholeheartedly and full-throatedly to block him
00:27:20 from coming in and i would love to do a deeper dive on who who who the person was that wrote
00:27:27 that piece um and how somehow parks canada got involved in this i will tell you and i have spent
00:27:34 a lot of time reviewing sean's music the issue is not sean's music if you listen to it it's very
00:27:41 what you would expect i mean derek if you and i pranced off to one of his shows to one of these
00:27:47 festivals we would see a lot of swaying and hand holding and love and he's very charismatic it's
00:27:55 what he has said on his social media and he has said as a christian i do not want drag a drag queen 1.00
00:28:04 reading to my children at the public library and i'm paraphrasing here um he hasn't used hateful
00:28:09 language i get what i would say is hateful language in the in the terms of you know inciting violence
00:28:14 or anything he simply has given his opinion and by the way if he was canadian he is allowed to do
00:28:21 that he is allowed to say controversial and statements he's allowed to give that opinion
00:28:30 he can people aren't going to like it but it doesn't it doesn't go into hate speech or the
00:28:37 willful promotion of of you know hate propaganda or whatever it is and that's the other thing people
00:28:45 are confusing criminal code all the time in this conversation um so it's what he's been saying and
00:28:53 he has what we would expect eric very traditional christian values there's a lot in there i don't
00:29:04 but you know he has the right to say it i feel that uh this this demonstrates the power that
00:29:13 that the CBC has in the ability to influence,
00:29:16 and it also demonstrates the CBC's role
00:29:20 in taking a very activist type role.
00:29:24 I'm not interested in the CBC
00:29:26 becoming an activist journalist outlet.
00:29:29 You know, I'm not willing to pay for that.
00:29:31 Well, too late, it has been for a very long time, I think.
00:29:37 Okay, well, let's, maybe we'll steer this back
00:29:39 towards Gilmore.
00:29:40 Um, I mean, she doesn't deserve the attention she gets, but she's kind of, uh, you know, 1.00
00:29:48 she's become kind of a symbol of, she's fun to pick on because she's an idiot and she, 1.00
00:29:56 she comes across some ditzy and I, she's actually kind of leaning into it, I guess, 1.00
00:29:59 the bubble pop thing.
00:30:01 Maybe that would have been cute if you're like 20, you know, 20 years old in university
00:30:05 or something and you have lots of likes, ums, you know, like you do the kind of the Valley
00:30:10 girl thing maybe you'd play then but uh you know you're also trying to pass yourself off as a
00:30:15 serious journalist uh now i don't think she's held a journalism job for more than a week and
00:30:20 i i don't know how long it's been a long time i think uh but she wants to try to pass herself 1.00
00:30:25 off as a credible professional journalist um but then both her content and the presentation of that
00:30:34 content is is so juvenile like the content is like first year university breakout seminar like just
00:30:45 repeating like uh well you know you're just repeating kind of a like a really
00:30:49 ditzy version of what your professor told you um kind of regurgitating that um
00:30:55 so i know she she gets more attention than he deserves she doesn't have a very big audience 0.95
00:30:59 uh she hasn't held a job in a credible media organization in an extremely long time now i
00:31:05 think at least by by the span of her own career i think she's probably been unemployed longer than 1.00
00:31:09 she's been employed as a journalist but uh but she's she's kind of fun for us to kind of keep 0.99
00:31:17 going back to because she's just so stupid and uh and and she's easy to pick on so you know i i do 1.00
00:31:25 do worry sometimes about picking on these folks that maybe we're being unfair towards kind of a 1.00
00:31:31 whole broad side of the spectrum because we got we've got idiots on our side too and i i hate it 0.95
00:31:36 when they pick on our art but you know they could pick on our ideas and it's all fair game um so i 0.98
00:31:42 don't want to smear everyone on one side is like that you know there are liberals a very small
00:31:47 number but there there are still some traditional liberals who might hate the sound of something
00:31:54 but will defend to the death your right
00:31:56 to say it. Mostly in the States
00:31:58 for prominent ones. You've got guys like Bill Maher.
00:32:01 You know, he's a liberal.
00:32:03 Increasingly, he actually
00:32:04 sounds pretty middle of the road
00:32:06 actually, but he's traditionally was
00:32:08 considered a pretty hard liberal for a long
00:32:10 time. But, you know,
00:32:12 you've got him,
00:32:13 maybe John Stewart-ish
00:32:16 a little bit.
00:32:19 But for the most part,
00:32:21 the left has lost all sense
00:32:22 of humor. They've lost any sense of that free speech is for anyone except for your own mealy
00:32:30 mouth, politically correct speech. And the left has lost this. But that's an old story. They lost
00:32:36 it a long time ago. So maybe we don't want to retread that too much. But maybe we'll go back to,
00:32:42 you know, the dangers on our side, because you can't police the other side's commitment to free
00:32:47 speech but you could police your own side's commitment to free speech is there anywhere
00:32:51 you see maybe on our our side of the aisle where maybe we're a little bit weak on this and we
00:32:58 maybe we need to be a bit tougher and on guard against uh ourselves trying to censor people on
00:33:04 the other side well i think we begin actually with our rachel gilmore's there's many of them
00:33:11 and I call them the YouTube tech bros and Barbies, right?
00:33:15 During this election, we seemed to grow an amazing amount of voices,
00:33:23 which I was so happy about, especially the 18 to, you know, 48 or whatever that demographic is,
00:33:29 them coming out, speaking, wanting to talk policy.
00:33:32 I love all of that.
00:33:33 But what also emerged was a cottage industry, and that's an old-fashioned term,
00:33:39 but the cottage industry on youtube of conservatives that were proclaiming to be
00:33:44 policy experts constitutional experts um and they were you know they they all kind of look like tech
00:33:51 bros and the girls look like you know kind of barbie and they're they are inciting anger and 1.00
00:33:58 inflaming anger in a way that i haven't seen and i find it um i've been really ticked off derek i've
00:34:05 seen some of this stuff and then and then they're infighting with each other they don't know policy
00:34:10 they've incited uh convoy number three or whatever over some random issue that really wasn't a 0.95
00:34:18 constitutional matter it was so stupid i can't even remember what it was now but here's the problem 0.79
00:34:23 rachel gilmore her type on the left the people i've just identified this whole industry on youtube 0.95
00:34:31 where you know some of these commentators who we've never seen you know as a staffer a journalist
00:34:38 an opinion writer a pundit suddenly have emerged as these experts and people are listening to them
00:34:44 our people are listening to them but for both sides what really concerns me is how much
00:34:51 the need to monetize every word they're saying is influencing what they're saying and I think we've
00:34:57 just traveled down a really dangerous road you know I as you I'm not being paid to sit here
00:35:05 today and I'm very happy about that I'm here to talk about the freedoms that are eroding in our
00:35:09 country I'm here to speak on the charter something that I wouldn't say I'm an expert in but I have a
00:35:15 fulsome understanding of I understand how legislation is made I understand how it's passed
00:35:20 I understand how our parliamentary system works much like you Derek you and I both come from very
00:35:24 similar backgrounds we have experience and background in that and i would never take
00:35:30 money or promote myself to monetize untruths and that's a real concern and i'm not suggesting
00:35:37 gilmore is in that financial relationship but we all know there are many others that are in that
00:35:43 business and they're using tick tock they're using youtube and they are they they're sort of drumming
00:35:49 up these fake conspiracies as well and that whether it's coming from the side that rachel's
00:35:55 on or our side that weakens our country it's intended to break our country and no matter what 0.99
00:36:03 i still believe in this country i think it's got more than a fighting chance but it's up for it's
00:36:08 up for up to all of us to start contradicting some of that pushing back on it i'm an equal
00:36:14 opportunist i'll take my own out as quickly as i'll take rachel gilmore's statements out 0.97
00:36:18 Well, where I wanted to go, though, was not just like our equivalents of Rachel Gilmore, who were kind of idiotic TikTokers on the right side of the spectrum. 0.99
00:36:27 I want to talk about, you know, maybe where are our blind spots for free speech on the right side? 0.92
00:36:33 You know, like the left, I think it's pretty fair comment to say the left is clearly much more censorious than the right.
00:36:41 But I do see some worrying signs on the right where the right's trying to silence views on the left or from other groups that it disagrees with.
00:36:51 I have a harder time coming up with ready examples because there are a lot less, but I think we need to be on guard for that.
00:36:57 That's why I kind of started us off with the kneecap example.
00:37:01 I think around the Israel-Palestine issue, I think there's an instinct from some on the right to want to censor those with a pretty hard anti-Israel view.
00:37:14 And I think we need to be on guard for that.
00:37:18 Now, sometimes it does go into outright hate, and that's different.
00:37:21 But I know, as I said earlier, I don't really have faith in the state to actually fairly draw the line on what is hated or not anymore, because they just push it one way or another, depending on who the group is that they favor.
00:37:33 So I kind of lean towards maybe we just don't have the government draw the line anymore because it's so unable to be trusted.
00:37:40 I see it a bit on the Israel-Palestine issue as a reflex on the right that tries to censor the other side.
00:37:47 is there and you could talk about that if you like uh but also if you know is there any other
00:37:52 areas or examples where maybe we need to be on guard against uh the right trying to censor the
00:37:58 left or other groups where we're in disagreement with i i'm gonna be fully self-aware i have
00:38:07 struggled anytime i see the anti-israel thing i'm immediately there have been times where i've
00:38:12 lost my mind on on x or twitter whatever you want to call it and i've had to self reflect i've had
00:38:18 to pull myself off of it and go i can't look at any anymore um i'm outraged a lot of the time and
00:38:25 then that question that you're asking is something i've asked myself as i've not only you know was on
00:38:31 the show with you yesterday and we're here today and i've written the op-ed for the western standard
00:38:34 that caused me to reflect on where i have started to uh control speech and i had to look at my own
00:38:43 root cause and the reason i'm bringing this up is i bet you there are people watching right now
00:38:47 uh that either follow me or follow you or both of us that could probably say the same thing about
00:38:53 themselves is that the moment that you see the other side and and you're seeing some of this
00:38:58 most horrible imagery i'm going to use bathhurst as the example the the the effigies um the the
00:39:06 absolute hate speech um i'm shocked that this is my country so when i see that it ignites me
00:39:13 and being a human being i want to shut them up and i ha i'm not taking the time to think okay does
00:39:20 that how far deep into hate speech is this uh or to the criminal code i should say uh am i stopping
00:39:27 their charter rights and it hasn't really been until the sean issue showed up that i've had to
00:39:32 really self-reflect so i want to start with me because i really feel they're speaking to me
00:39:37 there derek is watch ourselves right and i would say israel is the top issue i have a hard time
00:39:45 finding any other example on the right and i would say i mean everything from center to more
00:39:54 hardliner right um i have a hard time finding another example where i've seen any conservative
00:39:59 uh shut down free speech but israel is definitely a achilles heel it's a soft it's the soft 0.97
00:40:07 soft underbelly and i think that anger and that willingness to shut someone else's charter rights
00:40:13 down is because we feel like ours have been shut down yeah uh you know as you're talking i was 0.79
00:40:20 thinking uh maybe i have another example imperfect because i uh well i'll try not to be a hypocrite
00:40:29 here i want to be try to be honest with myself our viewers and you um you know uh and it's quite
00:40:35 adjacent to what just happened with foict in montreal because we've all seen the videos of
00:40:40 these public islamic prayers uh in the streets of montreal and i'm conflicted on that one it could
00:40:47 go either way i'm not a muslim i have no sympathy with it uh but i do believe in the right to public
00:40:55 prayer even for a faith i don't share or in some cases have very strong disagreements with beyond
00:41:02 just a theological level i'm talking on a cultural level um now you know islamic prayer if it's in a
00:41:10 park it's in an area where you would have a concert or something and they want to do that
00:41:13 you know i'll be honest with myself i don't like it but they're here it's their right to do it
00:41:21 so okay and i think i need to rein myself in from you know my own instincts to be like no
00:41:28 that doesn't belong here it's alien to us and we should stop it and so we have to kind of rein
00:41:34 that in on ourselves now the public prayer where they're doing it in the middle of the street
00:41:38 blocking traffic with no permit
00:41:41 and no fines were levied for not
00:41:43 having a permit
00:41:44 inside of a church
00:41:47 private property no
00:41:49 disruption to anyone except for the opponents
00:41:51 of them going and they
00:41:53 get the fine but yeah
00:41:55 if you do these Islamic prayers in the middle
00:41:57 of the street blocking traffic no permit
00:41:59 it's not like a designated parade or something
00:42:01 or protest
00:42:03 okay but
00:42:05 then we have to be prepared to
00:42:07 apply that to ourselves but we apply that to christians or mainstream canadian society quebec
00:42:12 society etc uh although that's not really a christians generally don't shut down an intersection
00:42:18 and start kneeling and whatnot that's it's not a it's not our bag but you know we we have to be
00:42:23 careful to apply carefully across the board but i i would see that as a potential soft uh underbelly
00:42:30 as well, where we need to be
00:42:32 on guard against being censorious ourselves
00:42:34 to, you know,
00:42:37 actually within Quebec, they've
00:42:38 passed laws that are
00:42:40 kind of on the surface neutral against
00:42:42 a wearing of religious imagery,
00:42:45 but we know what it's about.
00:42:47 Like, wink, wink, guys.
00:42:49 We know what it's about.
00:42:50 And so, and that's kind of the Quebec Nationalist
00:42:52 thing, which is, nationalism's
00:42:54 traditionally a phenomenon on the right, but that's
00:42:56 not really necessarily the case in Quebec. It's
00:42:58 more mixed and maybe even dominantly on the left but yeah i know i i would see that maybe as another
00:43:04 area where we need to be self-reflective and there i agree is a place to stop things like
00:43:08 you know holding a prayer of that kind outside of a church outside of a catholic church blocking
00:43:14 the street i think that's meant as a sort of political religious or cultural intimidation
00:43:19 and saying this is our place we're the dominant yeah active religion here now maybe not in numbers
00:43:25 but in terms of active participants you know islam is possibly more powerful in montreal now
00:43:30 than catholicism at least as an active cultural and religious force um i i think they were sending
00:43:36 a message there but so anyway i i'm not sure where i think it's intimidation yeah uh an intimidation
00:43:44 again where are we drawing the line so not all intimidation should be illegal
00:43:48 overt intimidation should be well i i think that i think honestly uh you're right okay so public
00:43:57 prayer yes you're you're charter right but what i'd like to invite all of us maybe to do is um
00:44:07 why don't we all try and block a inter a very popular intersection with our christian prayers
00:44:13 or our Jewish prayers, I invite all faiths to maybe join us and see how very quickly,
00:44:21 very quickly, the VPD or Toronto Police or Montreal Police would remove us, or even Calgary
00:44:26 Police, since Calgary couldn't, wasn't willing to stand up for Sean either, contrary to what
00:44:33 people may understand. I think we do get caught. This is a blind spot for people like myself,
00:44:39 and i and i'll and i'll throw myself out there to the wolves the when i'm looking at it i know it's
00:44:45 an attempt for social engineering i know it's intent to influence and to uh to there is and
00:44:54 you can't deny this there is a movement to uh change our society to to be to reflect more islamic
00:45:04 values. I'm happy to debate that as well and to discuss that. But when you watch it, your
00:45:13 immediate response is you understand what it is and you forget about the charter. And I think
00:45:20 you're bringing up really great points, Derek, because you're making me self-reflect. You're
00:45:24 making me think about this as well. I think it's been, I don't think the right has really been
00:45:32 caught on its back foot in regards to free speech or freedom of expression which by the way free
00:45:37 speech is hidden in there and um uh under free freedom of expression but um you are bringing
00:45:44 that up and that's something that we need to be really aware of because the people that we were
00:45:48 just talking about people that have styled themselves as influencers on the right they have
00:45:54 they themselves i think that is the achilles i think that's actually where that problem around
00:46:00 freedom of expression uh that you're talking about where we're not properly
00:46:08 ensuring that we understand charter rights apply there that is where it's growing the
00:46:12 most common and um you know i i think today you've reminded me to catch myself as well
00:46:19 but i was very quick to point it out with everybody else right so uh you know and
00:46:24 that's normally how it goes but i think it also and i will say this it's easy for conservatives
00:46:29 whether they're big c or small c conservatives fiscal conservatives social conservatives are all
00:46:34 types of conservatives to when they see these moments happening whether it's bathhurst or it's
00:46:39 downtown toronto these massive uh prayers it's hard for them not to see uh that even you know
00:46:47 a couple of years ago or even maybe now they would be removed uh from blocking that intersection they
00:46:53 they wouldn't be allowed to walk around with, you know, effigies or yelling hate, you know,
00:47:01 death to any other religious group. And it's got conservatives twisted up. Like I said,
00:47:08 no matter whether you're conservative, fiscal, social conservative, whatever, what we all seem
00:47:11 to share is this libertarian streak and also this belief in our fundamental freedoms and liberties.
00:47:17 And we understand that there's two tiers of justice and two tiers of charter that's happening
00:47:23 in this country Derek and I think that's the better question to ask because I think conservatives feel
00:47:27 stifled I think they feel they can't say anything about it without being labeled a racist or
00:47:33 intolerant um and it and that has enabled people that would normally be the first fighters around
00:47:41 charter rights to shrink back from that and say well but they but we can't get away with it and 1.00
00:47:46 they can't. So maybe I'm going to take a different track now about where this might go.
00:47:58 You know, eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth. What's good for the goose is good for the gander.
00:48:04 I feel like our side is fighting with a hand tied between our back.
00:48:10 And I don't know how long that lasts. And, you know, the opponents of freedom of expression never stop to think that perhaps the laws we've passed today or the intimidation tactics we use today to silence our opponents could ever be used against us.
00:48:29 and you see that with totalitarian right-wing regimes totalitarian left-wing regimes or even
00:48:38 ostensibly democratic societies like ours when you've got the center left in power the center
00:48:44 right no one ever stops to think could this be used against us and it's not just free speech
00:48:49 it might be accountability laws a government might change the law to make the government less
00:48:53 accountable and everyone thinks that's great you know like this is gonna be advantageous to us
00:48:57 politically. But chances are, you're not going to rule forever. No regime lasts for all time,
00:49:02 except in Alberta. But, you know, you never stop to think the other guys are eventually going to
00:49:09 be in power. And they might use these laws or these tactics against us. But on freedom of
00:49:15 expression, for a very long time now, as long as I've been alive, and I think longer, it has been
00:49:21 the left that has been the more censorious kind and it's become more and more extreme and it means
00:49:28 that we can win some battles but aggregate we're on the losing side because we don't use the same
00:49:33 tools the same tactics does this inevitably lead us to a place where we're not defending to the
00:49:43 death your right to say something i disagree with because you won't defend to the death my right to 0.68
00:49:49 say something that you disagree with. If this is a one-sided, for freedom of expression to work,
00:49:54 it has to be a grand bargain, collectively made as a society, as a body politic, as a state,
00:50:01 that this applies to everyone. But when it doesn't apply to everyone, eventually,
00:50:05 if this is a one-sided bargain, stops being a bargain, and it will collapse. And so I foresee
00:50:14 at some point our side is going to stop being the the side tolerant of freedom of expression and
00:50:20 it's just we're going to start we're going to untie that hand and what do you think the tipping
00:50:27 point was for when conservatives and and i'm part of this i have to admit i've i've committed a few
00:50:32 offenses along my along the way too when it came to israel but what do you think the tipping point
00:50:37 was because i think it was was it bill c63 which was the if you're thinking of a bad thought we'll
00:50:43 know about it and we'll come and arrest you legislation um for me i think that was the
00:50:48 tipping point in our in our conservative conversations well i mean that was no i i
00:50:55 think that was uh the conservative side broadly speaking i think was still in the no we're
00:51:01 defending free speech what i'm talking about is at what point does the right side stop being
00:51:06 this benevolent defender of free speech because we see it only applying to us tolerating them but
00:51:13 them not tolerating us and if and if and if that bargain only goes one way eventually our side is
00:51:20 going to say well why should we be noble defenders of your rights when you will not be no noble
00:51:24 defenders of our rights and so in in the long term i i i can see it is is entirely plausible that
00:51:32 our side uh stops and and we start applying censorship and suppression to the other side
00:51:40 because we're going to be in a perpetually losing battle if we're the only if in a battle only one
00:51:46 side observes the geneva convention and it's a and you're losing the war and you're observing
00:51:51 the geneva convention you're going to stop following the geneva convention you're going
00:51:55 to start shooting prisoners so that's kind of what our where i see things potentially going on our
00:52:00 side the problem is is i do not see how we stop and i used to say it was slippery slope and i've
00:52:06 said it before the cliff is now like given away right it's now just a torrent of of a debris
00:52:13 coming down in regards to freedoms and rights because the government whether i like like some
00:52:18 of the bills or not you know the for example moving big projects in this country with no
00:52:24 consultation is exactly like trudeau moving forward with marine mapping and controlling
00:52:31 bullying and i would say appropriating british columbia's resources without consultation which
00:52:36 i was opposed to but suddenly i'm very happy we're going to move big projects forward um for the
00:52:41 under pretty much the same legislation i opposed um i don't want to go too far in the weeds in that
00:52:46 but i think that's a really good example as well but i do think that when government is leading us
00:52:51 to a two-tier charter two-tier constitution two tiers of judiciary uh we have activist judges
00:53:00 this will set a conservative's hair on fire and if the conservative no longer feels that the state
00:53:08 is being truthful and is and is is operating within the the the guardrails of the charter
00:53:15 and the for example the criminal code and i know i've been there myself the conservative will do
00:53:22 exactly what you're doing they will stop being the defenders of when it doesn't matter or relate
00:53:28 issues that are important to them and i agree but it's not a slippery slope we're already there
00:53:33 i see it all the time i've admitted i've had to catch myself but this is when when government
00:53:41 this responsibility as this country has experienced from all levels of government for a decade 0.70
00:53:46 what did they goddamn expect derek they have removed themselves from the very things that 0.76
00:53:52 we've demand that we require them to do which is to lead us to do the very thing that you're talking 0.98
00:53:57 about which doesn't matter whose rights that are it is we will defend it and it's only in recent
00:54:04 modern times that liberals have contorted themselves into positions not to be uh in
00:54:10 line with the or find excuses as to why they they this they're not in line with the charter right
00:54:16 and we have a whole generation that has been privy to this what i call calamity um it's an
00:54:21 exercise of disaster and it is decaying this country which is the whole premise as to why
00:54:26 i was infuriated with rachel gilmore you know and and so i think you're asking great questions but i
00:54:32 i'm very concerned about what i see in the future you know and and i mean the very near future
00:54:38 because if we continue down this road where only certain groups have certain rights or certain
00:54:44 uh avenues to on the judiciary or or their or their charter rights are the only ones that are
00:54:49 protected we're going to be in a whole world of hurt and i think we're we're very close to that
00:54:55 doorstep you know perhaps what we need kind of going along with my geneva convention analogy
00:55:03 maybe we need to shoot a few hostages like i i would prefer us to return to the grand bargain
00:55:10 where we'll defend your right to free speech but you have to defend mine you don't have to agree 0.96
00:55:14 with me you can argue with me and whatever but we're gonna have to agree on the the basic ground
00:55:19 rules here but you know in my analogy you were there's a war and let's say it's a rough stalemate
00:55:23 Like, no one's really winning.
00:55:24 You know, one day one's up, one day the other's up.
00:55:26 But only one side has signed the Geneva Convention here.
00:55:30 The way to get the other guy to sign the Geneva Convention in that case might be like, 0.97
00:55:34 okay, if you don't sign it, we're going to shoot a couple of your guys. 0.70
00:55:39 We're going to play by your rules on a small scale for a brief period of time 0.94
00:55:44 just to let you know how unpleasant it is.
00:55:47 so maybe you know kneecap wants to come to alberta and we very publicly ban it and i think that would
00:55:55 be wrong that is wrong that is a bad thing to do but maybe we need to do something like that it's
00:56:00 gonna feel so good derek it's gonna be like birthdays and christmases rolled into one
00:56:06 i wouldn't even feel good about it like i i know i wouldn't i would although although yeah maybe
00:56:12 you will a bunch of people you know i'm maybe i could find something i'd feel good about like
00:56:16 you know let's just ban a david suzuki speech like i don't know it doesn't really matter but
00:56:21 let's just ban let's ban rachel gilmore that's a good example okay let's ban rachel gilmore from 1.00
00:56:27 coming down like a great rachel gilmore poetry reading or whatever she gets up to slam poetry
00:56:33 yeah you know uh like and we should not do that but maybe we need to just shoot a couple of these 0.94
00:56:42 prisoners to make the point be like okay guys we can do it too yeah let's stop and take a breath 0.68
00:56:50 and kind of come back to agreement on what the ground rules are in this game and you know this
00:56:58 might be this is an important fight we both sides believe this is existential nearly at this point
00:57:03 but here's our ground rules and if you don't follow them we're not going to follow them so
00:57:08 we're we're gonna ban a rachel gilmore slam poetry reading and uh david suzuki uh whale call
00:57:15 session or something the best equivalent honestly derek is banning that massive islamic prayer 0.96
00:57:21 session because if you're gonna ban sean and his religious music this is an equivalent and so i'm 0.94
00:57:27 gonna pull all those islamic worshipers off the street and we're going to we might even put you 1.00
00:57:34 jail for some of the city bylaws that you've you've broken on mischief charges for seven years 0.99
00:57:41 throwing if an ambulance can't get through well then we're in a whole other level
00:57:44 um you know and let's try it that way because i will tell you i don't think they'll jump
00:57:50 um they'll they'll support kneecap uh because even the most crazy uh of the left are i i don't want
00:57:58 to be seen as supporting that but we could definitely the equivalent would be the islamic
00:58:02 massive prayer thing that goes on what by the way no other faiths are invited to and
00:58:08 this is the other thing the Muslim leadership they across this country are silent and silent 1.00
00:58:15 and silent and it and I would they're very little reached out to other things when terrible
00:58:23 things happen or committed by Muslims or from the Islamic community and I think that you
00:58:30 You know, some of the, I would say, there isn't a level of interfaith connectivity there that I would like to see.
00:58:40 So I'd like to scoop up the Islamic prayer.
00:58:43 I can do that.
00:58:44 We can do that.
00:58:44 That, I think, is a really good equivalent to what we've been dealing with.
00:58:48 There's our hostage.
00:58:49 I mean, and then we should try to go back to not doing that.
00:58:53 But this might be it.
00:58:56 I think we've got to make a point that we can both play dirty and we should both go back to trying to be a little more gentlemanly.
00:59:05 You know, we can both fall. I think we make a lot of excuses.
00:59:08 I think conservatives apologize way too much. I think we're always the first one to sort of put, well, maybe less today than during the Harper years.
00:59:16 but I remember being a, you know, a very active regular pundit on CBC. And I was very careful in
00:59:26 my tweets at that time. I post what I was saying. I tried to sort of give a lot of runway and legal
00:59:33 and legislative context as to why I believed in something. But I learned very quickly that any of
00:59:39 my good graces was completely lost on these people. These people are lunatics half the time. 0.99
00:59:44 and i think what i started to hear not just from average working canadians that are friends of mine 0.94
00:59:50 but you know certain politicians and it was do you feel this is canada anymore do you feel very
00:59:55 canadian anymore do you feel like our rights are being honored and it was in whispered tones hush
01:00:00 tones in private circles but that now has gone viral it's gone public people have just sort of
01:00:06 throwing the baby out with the bathwater and they go i don't know you need to establish something
01:00:13 um good for the goose good for the gander and all the other lovely things that you said
01:00:19 um but yes it would be a wonderful wonderful present to me if we could do something like that
01:00:26 okay well maybe the the left should take this as the warning uh you've you've got to comply
01:00:35 quickly or we're uh we're gonna start shooting our hostages metaphorically everyone metaphorically
01:00:40 yeah there you go uh okay well what i'd like to see is if i could just say this i know there's a
01:00:47 lot of people that are tuning in and i just want to give a shout out to somebody that uh connected
01:00:51 with me and said i'm not monetizing and that's the twitter account or x account uh at cbc watcher
01:00:57 fantastic work this guy does i love him fantastic but that means there's a lot of people watching
01:01:02 and i would say just on what derek and i were last speaking about i'd love to hear from people
01:01:06 on twitter whether you agree with derek and i or not i'd love to hear if you understand what
01:01:11 we're actually talking about and what your own personal experience is because the more we talk
01:01:15 the more we engage the more we debate and exercise our charter rights and freedoms the more we have
01:01:21 a chance of pulling ourselves back from the abyss that i think we're teetering on and i think derek
01:01:25 you think we're probably teetering on it too right uh i i i not i'm not even sure we're teetering
01:01:31 anymore. I think we're hurdling our way down. Yeah. I think we're hurtling downwards at this
01:01:38 point. So do I. We're going to places I don't like a society, and I don't think the left is
01:01:43 going to like it either. I think we're losing the ability to talk to one another, come to an
01:01:49 equilibrium that maybe we all don't particularly like, but we can accept we're getting to an
01:01:55 i think we are very quickly approaching an unacceptable place and uh and that's not just
01:02:01 canada i think it's right across the western civilization that uh that we're going there
01:02:06 and i just think we're headed for a nasty place and one side's got it's both hands untied if the
01:02:15 other side takes enough to it's it's gonna get nasty so i'll tell you it's it's the country
01:02:22 worth fighting for but we are not even close to restoring our values our freedoms and our rights
01:02:28 and it's not i i don't want to see any more political gaymanship i want people to lead first 0.60
01:02:33 with being canadian and thinking about what they want for their children i would recommend you look
01:02:39 at what's happened in the uk they're having to crawl or claw back their country in a way that
01:02:44 i had never thought i would ever see my in my entire lifetime and um we just have to remember
01:02:50 not to let the fear cloud our judgment on how we're going to proceed to bring this country back
01:02:55 to what it once was. Not that many years ago. By this country, I assume you just mean Alberta.
01:03:01 Yeah. Well, actually, just some of Western Canada. Yeah, just West, you know. I mean,
01:03:07 we'll include British Columbians. You want to hear something funny? A Torontonian tweeted at me and
01:03:13 said, hey, what time is this debate? And I wrote back 2 p.m. Mountain Standard Time.
01:03:21 And he's like, well, wait a second. What does MST stand for? Is it cow time or something
01:03:26 like that? And I thought, I said, only a Torontonian doesn't need to understand anyone
01:03:29 else's time zones because they have the privilege of just being in that EST zone or whatever
01:03:35 it is. And I just thought it was the perfect lead into our call or into our time together
01:03:41 today because this is the stuff that drives western canadians nutso uh you know don't be 0.99
01:03:47 calling it cow time you ignorant jerks so anyway but uh yes we have so many fights on our hands 0.98
01:03:53 derek and um and i and i just want to thank you for giving us or giving me the time i really wish 0.98
01:03:59 rachel had shown up because contrary to what she made we're waiting for you rachel oh yeah we're
01:04:04 waiting and i just want to say to everybody that's that tuned in she what she read oh rachel okay
01:04:13 do her okay rachel shared this on x uh i'm told by production here uh i'm sure she added a little
01:04:19 uh comment uh some thoughtful commentary to it but yeah good on her okay all right well that's nice
01:04:27 that's nice yeah you gotta go into clubhouses like i as a conservative i do i go into the left's
01:04:34 clubhouses all the time i did almost a decade on cbc power and politics with rosie barton
01:04:39 so you've got to go in and hold your space yeah i i yes about two years did a cbc punditry job as
01:04:46 well and uh i know i know it was calgary you know you you were you were on the national one that's
01:04:51 that's much worse okay well let's let's uh put a pin in it there uh at least uh thanks so much
01:04:57 this was a great conversation i thought we maybe we're gonna go 20 minutes uh assuming
01:05:01 Rachel didn't show up. We've got an hour and five minutes here. And I think it was,
01:05:07 I think at least, in my humble opinion, this was a very thoughtful discussion. So thank you very
01:05:12 much. Thank you. I thought it was very thoughtful and friendly. All right. And thanks for everyone
01:05:19 who joined us today. Thank you for joining us. Westernstandard.news, where you can find us.
01:05:26 Go there, click on subscribe. It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to
01:05:31 all Western standard content, getting past that paywall.
01:05:33 And you'll be supporting the work that we are doing here
01:05:36 between BC and Manitoba and all the great places in between.
01:05:41 Thank you very much for joining us today.
01:05:43 God bless.