Western Standard - August 01, 2025


Raped by the system

Hosted by
Mentioned
RCMP officer dragged during arrest of suspects in stolen vehicle in Gibbons Montreal Firebombing: Why Won’t Canada Protect Christian Artists? | The Pipeline

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

133.52

Word count

3,067

Sentence count

146

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In the upside down world of woke Canadian politics, where nothing makes sense and appearance is always more important than reality, this week we re talking about the incredible practice of the liberal government of Canada to jail men who say they re women in women s jails.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, July the 31st. In the upside-down world of woke Canadian politics, where nothing
00:00:28 makes sense and appearance is always more important than reality. I thought I'd seen
00:00:32 everything in 50 years of journalism and government service. But this week we're talking about
00:00:37 the incredible practice of the liberal government of Canada to jail men who say they're women
00:00:43 in women's jails. The women are pushing back. No surprise there. There's an organization, 1.00
00:00:50 Cause Bar, which is leading the charge on that. And with me today is their lawyer, Chris Fleury.
00:00:57 Mr. Fleury, welcome to the show. Great, thanks for having me, Nigel. I'm glad you're here. Mr.
00:01:02 Fleury, you're legal counsel for Cause Bar, the women fighting this. You're with Charter Advocates,
00:01:08 and I think the case is being funded by the Justice Center for Constitutional Freedoms.
00:01:15 Lay it out for us. Yes, thank you, Nigel, again for having me. So this is a case challenging
00:01:24 what is the government's policy of placing male inmates, trans-identified male inmates,
00:01:30 male-to-female trans inmates, into female institutions.
00:01:36 This is a practice that fundamentally changed in 2017 following the passage of what was called Bill C-16.
00:01:46 So Bill C-16 amended the Canadian human rights legislation.
00:01:51 And also following that, there were amendments to Correctional Services Canada's governing legislation, which essentially protected trans persons from discrimination within the penitentiary system.
00:02:06 So after that, the Government of Canada changed their policy, and up until that point, what were called preoperative trans individuals could not be placed into a female institution.
00:02:20 So following basically the amendment of their, it's called a commissioner's directive, essentially their policy, the inmates will be placed presumptively according to their gender of their choice, the gender to which they identify, unless there are overriding health and safety concerns.
00:02:39 And I think what you might find interesting is that prior to 17, the government of Canada opposed the placement of these individuals into female institutions, including in court cases.
00:02:53 So there's a court case from the early 2000s called Kavanaugh, where a male to female trans inmate wanted to be placed in a female institution. They were denied. This person brought a human rights claim.
00:03:08 and the government of Canada opposed that and they opposed it in court and they brought expert
00:03:15 evidence which essentially said the risks presented by the transfer of these individuals
00:03:21 are just far too high and that case went in the government of Canada's favor. The person was
00:03:29 denied the transfer. Ultimately after the case they did complete the surgery and were transferred
00:03:36 But the point is that the government of Canada actually agreed in part with what we're arguing in this lawsuit right up until 2017 and the passage of this legislation.
00:03:50 Different party, different outlook, right?
00:03:54 That's right.
00:03:55 Yes. That Kavanaugh case that you just described, did you say that was 2003, 2004?
00:04:01 It was in that range. I don't have it in front of me.
00:04:04 I know it was before the Canadian Human Rights Tribunal and then it went to the federal court as well, which upheld the tribunal's decision.
00:04:12 So, okay, so 20 years ago, you know, it was a bit of a struggle, but somehow or other we got it right.
00:04:19 Let me just put it to you.
00:04:22 If some Nancy boy wants to go and do his term among the girls, is that a big deal? 0.95
00:04:28 there's and this is perhaps what people might be missing because the the penitentiary system is
00:04:37 I would say largely misunderstood by the Canadian population that it's just not something that
00:04:42 many people ever have exposure to so one thing that people might not know is that first of all
00:04:48 in addition to being convicted of a criminal offense most female inmates are themselves 0.84
00:04:56 victims. So they're disproportionately, wildly disproportionately likely to have been the victim
00:05:01 of physical or sexual violence at the hands of men. And that's who we are placing, who the
00:05:08 government of Canada is placing male inmates into. That's the population that is being exposed to
00:05:15 this. Well, I still grab the male inmates a little bit, Mr. Fleury. I'd probably use what
00:05:21 many people would consider an offensive term in characterizing them as effeminate, but are they?
00:05:29 Well, this is, and that's sort of where I was going, Nigel, is that there are fundamental,
00:05:37 it's not just about physical differences necessarily between men and women, although
00:05:41 obviously those are present, there are profound psychological differences between men and women
00:05:47 that actually lead to them committing different types of crimes,
00:05:53 them finding themselves, them being essentially behaving differently in the carceral context.
00:06:03 So, for example, men are much more likely to have been convicted of a serious violent crime.
00:06:10 They're much more likely to be found guilty or to be designated as a dangerous offender.
00:06:15 they're much more likely to essentially be aggressive and act aggressively within the
00:06:21 prison system. And that's the population that is being transferred. We're not talking about the
00:06:28 average male, the average woman, the average trans person. That's not who we're talking about in this 1.00
00:06:33 case. We're talking about, as a starting point, individuals who have been sentenced to a penitentiary
00:06:40 term meaning more than two years in custody so they must have by definition committed a serious
00:06:46 violent crime and had a have a lengthy criminal record in most cases or both in order to even
00:06:53 find themselves in that situation and i mean there are statistics about this that the government of
00:07:00 canada has produced actually here's another one that i missed is that men are much more likely to
00:07:06 be sex offenders and convicted of a sexual offense than women are. And not only are men 0.94
00:07:13 disproportionately likely to have been found guilty of a sexual offense in relation to women,
00:07:19 the rate of sexual offenders among this population that is seeking transfer is just
00:07:25 disproportionately high. We're talking 40 to 50 percent are convicted sex offenders and are being,
00:07:32 Those are the individuals who are seeking transfer into a women's prison. 1.00
00:07:39 So really, we're talking about putting the wolves in among the sheep.
00:07:43 Now, I can't imagine that even our corrective system would actually have them sharing cells.
00:07:51 How are things organized in the prisons to keep the obvious from happening?
00:07:57 it the short answer is that it varies there are just like in a male institution a female 1.00
00:08:06 institution will have different cert security designations so you'll have a minimal a medium
00:08:12 and a maximum security in the maximum security you will get individual cells in some cases
00:08:19 trans persons are housed there there are community living units within the female institution
00:08:25 those do involve sharing what are essentially like cottages and being in a community living
00:08:34 situation if I can call it that sharing kitchens and bathrooms and this sort of thing with the
00:08:40 inmates I hope you're going to tell me that those community living facilities are not available to
00:08:49 somebody who's claiming to be a woman but has actually been convicted of raping women
00:08:53 And no, there's nothing precluding them from being housed in there.
00:08:59 And we have certainly heard from inmates to confirm that they are being housed in that sort of situation.
00:09:06 How are things working out?
00:09:09 We have heard the stories have been awful.
00:09:14 I'm not going to go into a tremendous amount of detail because it is still before the courts.
00:09:19 And some of this evidence hasn't come out yet.
00:09:22 But in general terms, we've certainly heard about physical assaults happening, sexual assaults, harassment, abuse, certainly psychological impacts on the part of the women who are, again, you can imagine someone who has been the victim of a physical or sexual assault then being confined in close quarters with essentially a man.
00:09:51 the impact that that might have on someone. And in the context of the carceral system,
00:09:58 it's about punishment, but it's also about rehabilitation. And part of our argument in
00:10:03 this lawsuit is that the placement of males within female institutions, not only does it 1.00
00:10:12 present these sorts of harms, physical and psychological harms, but it also impacts their
00:10:17 prospects at rehabilitation. So it's extremely, extremely concerning.
00:10:23 Mr. Fleury, how many men, trans men, are presently incarcerated in Canadian jails
00:10:30 within women's institutions? 1.00
00:10:34 We don't know exactly, unfortunately. There's no publicly available statistics to tell us this.
00:10:41 It's not a, the percentage of female inmates in and of itself is actually very, very low.
00:10:49 They're a small portion of the overall incarcerated population.
00:10:54 It's mostly men in federal institutions.
00:10:58 But the transfer of even, so it's in that context that the transfer of even a small
00:11:04 number, a handful of individuals can have a disproportionate impact.
00:11:09 Unfortunately, I can't say exactly how many that is at the moment.
00:11:12 Okay.
00:11:14 And how many women's jails are affected by this? 1.00
00:11:19 There's six across Canada.
00:11:21 So there's five, what we would usually think of as a penitentiary,
00:11:28 five located across Canada, as well as what's called a healing lodge,
00:11:32 which I believe is in Saskatchewan, which is also impacted by this.
00:11:36 so in terms of scale this is not a huge problem but in terms of principle it seems to me as an
00:11:48 editorialist and i'm not putting words in your mouth but it seems utter folly as well as deeply
00:11:54 evil to put the as i say the wolves in among the sheep i i cannot imagine who came up with this
00:12:02 an idea but who actually when you follow the trail of command from the prison warden through the
00:12:12 up through the bureaucracy to the department of justice and ultimately the federal cabinet
00:12:18 where does the responsibility for this decision rest it seems i i have difficulty answering that
00:12:28 question. The Bill C-16, as I imagined, or sorry, as I mentioned earlier, was passed by the federal
00:12:36 government of the time that was under Justin Trudeau and his cabinet. Justin Trudeau certainly
00:12:43 did make public statements prior to that. He was asked directly about the transfer of men into
00:12:51 women's prisons, and he did say this was, I believe, immediately prior to the changing of
00:12:57 the directive, he did say that that was something that they were considering. So it certainly,
00:13:05 it seems to go right to the top, I would say, in terms of Justin Trudeau and his federal cabinet.
00:13:13 Well, certainly every member of parliament who voted for that legislation, most of whom
00:13:19 obviously would have been liberals, has some responsibility for it. But it just seems,
00:13:26 It's one of those things, how can such a stupid situation come about, especially when you have referred to an earlier precedent where the courts had looked at it and decided, no, it's not a good idea, and then the government comes along and changes it. 0.58
00:13:46 Now, this case that you are now engaged upon, does it have the capacity to actually reverse the effects of that 2017 legislation that made all this possible? 0.55
00:14:03 So what precisely we're asking for in this case is a declaration that this particular, it's called a Commissioner's Directive, Commissioner's Directive 100.
00:14:16 is in violation of female inmates' constitutional rights.
00:14:21 Their right to life, liberty, security of persons, Section 7 of the Charter.
00:14:26 Their right under Section 12 to be free from cruel and unusual punishment.
00:14:31 And their equality rights under Section 15 of the Charter.
00:14:35 So we're asking the court to declare that this particular policy
00:14:39 is in contravention of their rights.
00:14:43 and then ultimately once we've done that then the the legislation will have to be amended
00:14:50 and in the amendment it would presumably put an end to this practice i mean i can't see how
00:14:58 you would amend it otherwise um that's me speaking as i might correct on that
00:15:04 there are um i would say it would be open to the federal government to attempt to uh bring the
00:15:16 policy back into line to where it was prior to 2017 which was uh pre or sorry post-operative
00:15:24 uh trans inmates um i don't want to get too graphic but essentially they've had the surgery 0.98
00:15:30 cutting off their bits. And those individuals could be transferred prior to 17 on a case-by-case
00:15:40 basis. It would be open to the federal government to attempt to bring the legislation back to that
00:15:46 state. We would oppose that. We would say it's certainly, there are serious risks that are
00:15:52 present there. It's not just about the presence or lack of genitalia. It's about physical and 0.56
00:16:00 psychological danger that's created by men in women's prisons. And that's not necessarily
00:16:07 alleviated just by a surgery. Mr. Fleury, let's just talk about, I think there was a particular
00:16:14 case involving a young man, I think this may be in BC, I'm sure you're familiar with it,
00:16:20 raped a baby and then ended up in a in a prison where there were mothers with their babies 0.98
00:16:27 can you just talk about that case a little bit and how it how it illustrates the the dilemma
00:16:33 we're dealing with here i've heard the i've heard the story i'm not um particularly familiar with it
00:16:40 um what i will say is that it is a it shows the problem with the system as it is that there is
00:16:48 as I said, a presumption that individuals will be placed in a penitentiary according to their
00:16:56 chosen gender. And that can only be overridden on the basis of proven health and safety concerns.
00:17:04 So essentially a proven risk. And it's a pretty high bar to prove that. And in this case,
00:17:12 notwithstanding that, as you mentioned, there are convictions for serious offenses involving
00:17:16 women and children uh they um the government of canada presumably uh did an assessment uh and did
00:17:25 not believe that there was a um a serious risk in that case of placing that inmate with uh with
00:17:32 female offenders and it is um as you say it's it's ludicrous it's uh the average person on 1.00
00:17:38 the street it's just never going to understand uh why this is happening and they're they're right not
00:17:43 to tell us about your client sir calls bar who are they and and frankly what are their chances
00:17:54 so cause bar is the canadian women's sex-based rights they're a national non-profit organization
00:18:02 they advocate across the country for as the name suggests women's sex-based rights in the context
00:18:10 of prisons, certainly. They've done a lot of advocacy work there, but also in the context of
00:18:17 bathrooms, changing rooms, sports teams, this sort of thing. Venues where traditionally there's been
00:18:26 a sex-segregated environment that now in 2025 we find these sorts of protections reversing.
00:18:35 And they're certainly advocating on behalf of women in that context broadly.
00:18:42 And so is it a new organization?
00:18:46 They are relatively new.
00:18:49 I don't have it in front of me in terms of exactly when they were founded.
00:18:52 It's certainly been within the last decade or so.
00:18:56 But to be fair to them, these issues, I don't recall them really existing a decade or so ago.
00:19:03 So they're responding to these new sorts of issues that we find ourselves with.
00:19:08 Now, are the women, and I'm sure it is mainly women, are the women driving this organization former inmates themselves?
00:19:16 There is one. One of their directors is a former inmate and is how essentially this case came to our attention is through her.
00:19:27 The rest of the women are just members of Canadian society, 0.93
00:19:32 if I can put it that way, who are deeply concerned about these issues.
00:19:36 Well, bless their hearts for coming forward.
00:19:39 Do they have a, you mentioned bathrooms, and that's pretty obvious.
00:19:43 Have they had any successes in that area?
00:19:46 So my understanding is that this is the first legal action that they've taken.
00:19:52 everything else has been
00:19:54 advocacy work that they're doing
00:19:57 so they hold protests
00:19:59 they do conferences and speeches
00:20:01 and this sort of thing
00:20:03 Okay, and
00:20:05 the Justice Center for Constitutional
00:20:07 Freedoms I think is fairly well known to
00:20:09 our readers and our viewers
00:20:11 but
00:20:12 they are funding this
00:20:15 defense
00:20:15 did they approach
00:20:19 Colesbar or did Colesbar come to them?
00:20:22 This case, you know what, I can't recall offhand exactly how that happened.
00:20:30 I know that this is something that the particular director who I was talking about,
00:20:35 who's been incarcerated previously, has certainly been thinking about for quite some time.
00:20:43 Okay, we're rapidly getting to the running out of time here,
00:20:47 but you mentioned Mr. Trudeau's personal opinions on the matter
00:20:53 and the success of the legislation that followed in 2017.
00:21:02 Mr. Trudeau obviously had a lot of ideas
00:21:06 that Western Standard viewers tend not to agree with,
00:21:10 and in fact, I think now that he is out of office, 1.00
00:21:13 It's probably safe to say that a majority of Canadians find these kinds of things utterly stupid. 0.99
00:21:21 But what is the genesis of a philosophy that could actually make the argument for putting men into women's jails 0.99
00:21:33 with a straight face saying that this was the fulfillment of the ultimate human rights?
00:21:41 where does that come from i truly nigel i i wish i had a good answer for you on that one
00:21:49 um as i said it's it's not something that we've uh seen you know 10 20 years ago it appears to
00:21:57 from my perspective have come out of left field uh that i again i i don't recall anyone talking
00:22:04 like this 10 or 20 years ago and if you had have said something like this to someone 10 or 20 years
00:22:10 ago, I think 99% of the population would have said that's absolutely crazy.
00:22:16 You know something, Mr. Fleury?
00:22:17 I think that the number would have been higher than 99% and that it still is. 0.75
00:22:24 Wish you good luck and everything that a lawyer needs to make the case.
00:22:31 This is actually a symbolic case.
00:22:34 If you can turn this one over, a lot of us will take tremendous encouragement for reversing 0.95
00:22:39 some of the folly and the stupidity that we have seen so thank you for joining us and i'm sure all 0.96
00:22:46 western standard viewers join me in wishing you well with this case thank you nigel ladies and 0.99
00:22:53 gentlemen, thank you for being with us. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel
00:22:57 Hannaford.