Western Standard - March 01, 2023


RE-BROADCAST: Budget 2023 media briefing and news conference - February 28, 2023

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update Feb 28, 2023 CMS: The Liberal chain of CCP corruption

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 2 minutes

Words per minute

158.22

Word count

9,832

Sentence count

298

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Budgets 23 and Budget 23 will also serve as the 22/25 Third Quarter Fiscal Update. Budget 23 secures Alberta s future by growing and diversifying the economy, strengthening health care and education, improving the safety of communities across the province, and establishing a new fiscal framework.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 everyone thank you for joining me to go over some highlights of budget 23 which will also serve as
00:00:16 the 22 23 third quarter fiscal update budget 23 secures Alberta's future by growing and
00:00:23 diversifying the economy strengthening health care and education improving the safety of
00:00:28 communities across the province and establishing a new fiscal framework. This plan achieves the
00:00:34 priorities of Albertans, which include ensuring the government lives within its means. Over the
00:00:39 last four years, our relentless focus on investment attraction, job creation, and diversification
00:00:44 has secured our position as the economic engine of Canada. Alberta's economy has momentum,
00:00:50 and Budget 2023 continues that positive fiscal trajectory with another balanced budget and
00:00:56 forecasted surplus of $2.4 billion in 2023-2024 and projected surpluses of $2 billion next year
00:01:04 in the mid-year and $1.4 billion in 2025-2026. Budget 23 also continues our successful Alberta
00:01:11 at Work initiative that's helping Albertans build their skills and fill thousands of new jobs
00:01:15 as businesses grow and more corporations invest in our province. We're investing even more towards
00:01:21 building capacity in our health care system to deliver better care for albertans we're
00:01:26 strengthening our education system so that our children and grandchildren are prepared
00:01:31 for their future we're improving safety and security in our communities while responding
00:01:36 to the needs of vulnerable populations and we're saving for tomorrow and paying down provincial debt
00:01:43 so that the services we rely on are secure for decades to come job growth in alberta has been
00:01:49 phenomenal this past year and people from across Canada and around the world
00:01:53 continue to move here in record numbers and take advantage of our job
00:01:57 opportunities high wages low taxes and affordable living national and global
00:02:02 companies have expanded in Alberta creating new jobs diversifying our
00:02:06 economy and taking advantage of our extremely competitive corporate income
00:02:10 tax rate budget 23 is securing Alberta's advantage building on the 600 million
00:02:16 committed over three years to the Alberta at work initiative budget 23 includes an
00:02:21 additional 370 million to get more unemployed Albertans back to work we
00:02:26 critically need more doctors and nurses to provide care for Albertans so we're
00:02:31 creating 1,800 new seats for health care aides licensed practical nurses
00:02:36 reg and registered nurses now we're also committing 30 million dollars over three
00:02:41 to create 120 more seats in medical degree programs at the University of
00:02:47 Alberta and the University of Calgary, a 40% increase in the total number of
00:02:52 seats, seats that will be in place to train future physicians. We're expanding
00:02:58 training opportunities in other sectors as well. Another 35 million over three
00:03:03 years will expand enrollment and non-trade construction programs and
00:03:06 and training in the energy, technology, business, and aviation sectors.
00:03:11 We're strengthening Alberta's economy across all industries and creating opportunities
00:03:15 so every family can participate in the Alberta Advantage.
00:03:20 While economic growth is strong, times remain tough for many families and households.
00:03:25 New relief measures are helping post-secondary students with lower student loan interest rates
00:03:31 and more repayment assistance. We're providing more grants and bursaries to low-income Albertans
00:03:36 upgrading their skills to fill jobs in high demand sectors these measures will
00:03:41 keep a hundred and seventy eight million more dollars in the pockets of students
00:03:45 each year as they upgrade their skills and acquire new knowledge on their road
00:03:49 to successful careers this adds to our comprehensive affordability measures
00:03:54 including the suspension of the fuel tax electricity rebates the indexation of
00:03:59 personal income taxes and social supports to inflation and targeted
00:04:03 supports to our seniors, families and most vulnerable. We're also making record
00:04:08 investments in kindergarten through grade 12 education to secure the future
00:04:13 for our youth. In total, Budget 23 provides an additional $1.8 billion over
00:04:18 three years, including a 5.2% increase in 23-24 to fund enrollment growth,
00:04:24 reduce class size, meet the specialized learning needs of students and improve
00:04:29 transportation. The 23 capital plan supports 58 school projects including
00:04:35 new schools that will provide new and improved student spaces, create jobs and
00:04:40 revitalize Alberta communities. During our budget consultations we heard from
00:04:45 Albertans across the province who identified the need to strengthen our
00:04:49 health care system and increase its capacity. We've heard you. Budget 23
00:04:54 commits 965 million more this year for health care. That's a 4.1% increase to reduce wait times
00:05:02 in hospital emergency rooms, provide more surgical capacity, and get more ambulances on the road to
00:05:07 respond to emergencies. We're supporting the Alberta Surgical Initiative with 237 million
00:05:13 over three years, including 120 million in new money to build and expand operating rooms in 14
00:05:19 communities to allow thousands more surgeries across the province 150 million
00:05:26 apparently 158 million this year alone will support a plan to increase the
00:05:31 number of health care professionals in Alberta especially in rural areas another
00:05:35 hundred and fifty million over three years for emergency medical services
00:05:39 will hire more staff and improve ambulance response times and 15 million
00:05:43 will put more ambulances on the road our health care action plan will
00:05:48 fundamentally transform and improve health care delivery in the province.
00:05:53 Public safety and a fair and efficient justice system are key responsibilities of government.
00:05:59 Budget 23 commits $1.2 billion in operating funding to public safety and emergency services
00:06:05 and $655 million to justice.
00:06:08 This represents a 12% increase overall.
00:06:11 This funding will increase the number of Crown prosecutors and add support staff to address
00:06:15 the backlog, increase capacity, and modernize our courts. It means more boots on the ground
00:06:21 to better fight crime in our communities. Budget 23 also provides $22 million over three years to
00:06:27 strengthen First Nations policing. This will fund a new First Nation police force in Siksika
00:06:32 and additional officers in Indigenous communities across the province.
00:06:38 Alberta's strong balance sheet wouldn't have been possible without our commitment to responsible
00:06:42 fiscal management. We intend to lock in this commitment and secure Alberta's future with
00:06:48 a new fiscal framework that requires balanced budgets, controls operating spending, and
00:06:52 provides a framework for surplus cash. A balanced budget requirement and limiting spending increases
00:06:58 to population growth and inflation will ensure appropriate and sustainable spending. The
00:07:04 spending ceiling will challenge government to focus on how we can transform the way we
00:07:08 do things to improve the way we deliver services and programs while making sure
00:07:13 Albertans hard-earned tax dollars are respected and used efficiently the
00:07:18 fiscal framework will ensure the government continues to prioritize
00:07:21 saving for the future and the paying down of debt and balanced budgets will
00:07:26 become the norm instead of the exception well while our forecast revenue of 70.7
00:07:33 billion for 2324 is down from our 2223 revenue forecast of 76 billion we're projecting another
00:07:40 surplus of 2.4 billion for 2324 and further surpluses the following two years record bitumen
00:07:48 royalties of 12.6 billion have helped keep our province in the black but corporate income tax
00:07:53 revenue is a big part of that story as well just over four years ago alberta's corporate income
00:07:59 tax rate sat at 12 percent based on the assumption that a higher corporate tax rate would categorically
00:08:05 result in more government revenue the problem with that thinking is that there are lots of other
00:08:11 places corporations can choose to do business and many of those other places had more had a more
00:08:16 competitive business environment so companies passed over alberta and went elsewhere investment
00:08:21 in alberta declined during those years as did corporate revenue so our government set out to
00:08:27 create a business environment that would attract business investment back into Alberta.
00:08:32 One of our first steps was the job creation tax cut.
00:08:35 Now at 8 percent, our general corporate tax rate is significantly lower than the next
00:08:39 lowest provinces, Ontario and Quebec, and our combined federal provincial corporate
00:08:44 tax rate is lower than 44 U.S. jurisdictions.
00:08:48 The result is investment across sectors, aviation, technology and financial services to name
00:08:53 a few is exploding and with it expanded fiscal capacity resulting from higher
00:08:59 corporate income tax revenue pardon me resulting in higher corporate income tax
00:09:04 revenue record high corporate income tax revenue of 6.4 billion this year and 5.9
00:09:10 billion next year to be exact that's significant this is why fiscal
00:09:15 responsibility matters why investment attraction matters why diversification
00:09:19 matters. This is how we fund programs and services that support Albertans.
00:09:25 Total expense is forecast at $68.3 billion in 2022-23, higher than at budget last year
00:09:31 as we have helped Albertans deal with the rising cost of living, covered agreements
00:09:36 with doctors, teachers and other public sector workers, and increased capacity in the justice
00:09:40 system. In 2023-24, operating expense is forecast at 3% higher than last year, then grows moderately
00:09:47 by 2% for each of the following two years.
00:09:51 Alberta's oil and gas sector continues to play a vital role in driving our economy and
00:09:55 creating prosperity for hardworking families and for our entire nation.
00:10:00 The government is forecasting a price of $79 US for a barrel of West Texas Intermediate
00:10:05 in 23-24, dropping to $76 and $73.50 in the out years.
00:10:12 We continue to stand up for Alberta's energy industry and the Albertans whose livelihoods
00:10:16 depend on it and we continue to invest in projects and programs that reduce emissions
00:10:22 and help grow and diversify alberta's energy sector alberta's economy is poised to grow
00:10:27 at 2.8 percent this year continuing to lead the country canadians are taking notice of our
00:10:33 incredible value proposition of low taxes opportunity and affordability and they're
00:10:38 moving here at record rates with alberta's population expected to grow 2.9 percent in 23
00:10:44 the fastest pace since 2007 budget 23 is a budget that secures alberta's future
00:10:52 we're securing the health and education of albertans by increasing access to family doctors
00:10:57 surgeries and emergency services and making sure our children and grandchildren have the
00:11:01 education system they need to reach their full potential we're securing economic success and
00:11:07 prosperity by charging albert pardon me yes charging albertans 20 billion less than they
00:11:13 They would pay under the tax system of the next lowest province, positioning Alberta
00:11:17 for investment attraction, diversification, and job creation.
00:11:22 And we're securing our future with a new fiscal framework that will require appropriate and
00:11:27 sustainable spending, prioritize debt repayment and savings in surplus management, and ensure
00:11:33 the next generation is not encumbered with a debt they did not incur.
00:11:38 Budget 23 is securing Alberta's future, your future.
00:11:42 you and I'm happy to take some questions media Q&A you'll have one question one
00:11:47 follow-up either give us two at the top or one and one we'll start with those
00:11:51 in the rooms before we go to the phone just a reminder to introduce yourself
00:11:54 your name and your outlet with that we'll start with the first question here
00:11:58 at the mic Graham Thompson today I'm with the Toronto Star
00:12:01 minister this is a pre-election budget you may not see it that way but it
00:12:07 certainly is so how is or how has the upcoming election influenced or affected
00:12:15 today's budget well well Graham you're right we have an election here in a few
00:12:20 months and this is a budget just ahead of that election but really budget 23
00:12:25 continues the direction the course that we set in 2019 and that course was
00:12:31 twofold it was about bringing responsible fiscal management back to the province
00:12:34 As you know, we set a fiscal anchor at that time of aligning our per capita spending,
00:12:41 per capita cost of delivering government services with that of comparative provinces,
00:12:45 and we've delivered on that objective.
00:12:47 At the same time, we set a path back in the day, back in 2019,
00:12:51 to ensure that Alberta's business environment was most competitive
00:12:55 so that we could attract investment, see a growing and diversified economy,
00:13:00 which we knew would result in increased job opportunities for Albertans,
00:13:04 but also increased revenues for the government as we had expanded fiscal capacity.
00:13:09 Budget 23 continues on those two main themes.
00:13:12 Now, we're going to add to that because following COVID,
00:13:16 it's been clear in this province and every other province in Canada
00:13:20 that health care is a challenge.
00:13:23 And everywhere I traveled in my pre-budget consultations,
00:13:26 Albertans were concerned about our health care system.
00:13:28 That's why we're increasing health care funding by 4% this year.
00:13:32 Almost a billion dollars in one year alone to ensure that Minister Copping and all the great folks in our health care system have the funds they need to improve, transform the system to deliver better for Albertans.
00:13:46 To reduce surgical wait times, to reduce wait times in emergency rooms, to reduce the wait times for our paramedics to get out and assist somebody in an emergency.
00:13:57 Now, the other thing, Graham, we did is we supported Albertans at a time of inflation, at a time when affordability is a challenge, right across the province.
00:14:09 And so, again, we signaled our affordability support in our mid-year report.
00:14:14 Of course, this budget funds a number of affordability measures, certainly in the upcoming budget year and even in the future years.
00:14:22 But again, that's simply a response to the fact that, you know, in Alberta, over the last three years, we did the heavy lifting fiscally.
00:14:30 We got our fiscal house in order.
00:14:33 We're running a surplus, thanks to very high energy prices, a very significant surplus in the current fiscal year.
00:14:40 All of that gave us the ability as a government to support Albertans during a time of affordability challenge.
00:14:46 And speaking of elections, will you run in the next election, upcoming election?
00:14:52 Graham I've been focused on preparing this budget and and presenting it I'm
00:14:57 going to be making finalizing a decision and announcing that in the days ahead
00:15:01 but why I'm you know now sorry okay hi Audrey never had the Canada I want to
00:15:11 know what are the consequences of the Alberta government if it ever happens
00:15:15 that it does not respect the fiscal framework that it will set out in
00:15:19 legislation what's the consequence except just saying oops we broke our own law 100 days of jail
00:15:26 time how's that you tell me just just um just kidding look the um for a government to contravene
00:15:35 its its own legislation and that's regardless of which government legislation that was passed in
00:15:41 the house would be um far more than embarrassing it would be a public spectacle and there would
00:15:49 be a huge political cost to bear for breaking that legislation i believe that simply passing
00:15:54 legislation around these fiscal dual rules provides real teeth in terms of the impetus
00:16:01 for governments to follow them that's why crafting the fiscal rules and the details in the fiscal
00:16:08 rules are so important we have a revenue structure here in the province and a resource-based economy
00:16:13 where we have revenue volatility and these rules have to accommodate that kind of revenue structure
00:16:20 and economy and i believe they do and my second question is do the massive investments well big
00:16:25 investments we see in the alberta shares paved the way for an alberta provincial police right now
00:16:32 we're focused on better enforcement and less crime that's the focus of our government so we're making
00:16:37 very significant investments both in our public safety ministry as well as our justice ministry
00:16:43 And we're going to be funding well over 200 additional enforcement officers across the province.
00:16:51 That's significant. That's our focus right now.
00:16:53 And, of course, the second part of that is to ensure that we have a justice system with the capacity to deal with, you know, every case that needs to be heard.
00:17:02 Every perpetrator needs to have their day in court.
00:17:06 Justice must be served.
00:17:07 That's why we're increasing, again, public safety and justice ministry budgets by about 12% on average.
00:17:14 Great. Thank you, Audrey.
00:17:18 Hi, Minister. Julia Wong, CBC National.
00:17:20 Considering how volatile things have been for Alberta in the last 10 years,
00:17:25 could you have saved more?
00:17:27 Could you have paid down the debt more considering interest rates are so high?
00:17:30 we have i mean look we inherited a government that was spending 10 billion dollars more than
00:17:39 comparator provinces back in 2019 we we set out a fiscal plan to thoughtfully carefully surgically
00:17:46 bring our cost of delivering government services down we didn't take the ralph klein approach of
00:17:51 doing it in one year with 20 cuts we took four years to do it which we believed would be easier
00:17:57 on Albertans to take that route, and we've delivered on that.
00:18:02 This year, in 22-23, our per capita cost of delivering government services
00:18:07 is right in line with the average of B.C., Ontario, and Quebec,
00:18:10 and so that's significant progress.
00:18:12 That's what set the stage for this province to ultimately deliver balanced budgets into the future.
00:18:20 So we immediately went to work on bringing fiscal responsibility back to the province,
00:18:24 And it's that work that ultimately prepared us, led us to a very significant surplus last year, which allowed us to reduce our debt by over $13 billion, saving Albertans $260 million in 22-23, about $550 million in 23-24, and just under $600 million in 24-25 in debt service costs.
00:18:47 That's almost $1.2 billion that can go to education, go to health care, or maybe go to the Heritage Savings Trust Fund.
00:18:54 Again, you know, would it have been better that previous governments would have brought fiscal responsibility in the years earlier?
00:19:01 Yes, it would have been.
00:19:03 But the minute we took office in 2019, we went to work.
00:19:06 And we had a few bumps.
00:19:08 COVID, the largest contraction in the global economy since the Great Depression,
00:19:12 and the largest collapse in energy prices in history was all in the mix.
00:19:16 But again, we stuck to the plan.
00:19:18 And I have to give credit to Albertans, who dug in and worked hard and showed incredible resilience.
00:19:24 Alberta entrepreneurs who saw opportunity that governments never could and stepped out and invested and grew this economy towards leading the nation right now.
00:19:33 That's what dug us out of the hole.
00:19:35 That's why we're able to pay down the debt and save Albertans these debt service costs.
00:19:40 You mentioned the Heritage Fund earlier.
00:19:42 I want to ask you about the Alberta Fund because we all got a crash course on it a little bit earlier.
00:19:46 because what it sounds like is it's a way for the UCP government to say hey we
00:19:51 have 1.4 billion dollars left over right before the rates dropped and before
00:19:55 there's an election the purpose of the Alberta fund is to bring discipline to
00:20:01 the use of a surplus that's really the purpose of the Alberta fund look I I
00:20:06 know in our businesses or even in our households in my experience if you have
00:20:11 unallocated surplus hanging around, it's pretty easy to spend it irresponsibly. The Alberta fund
00:20:18 will provide guardrails, will provide a framework, will require discipline in ultimately spending
00:20:25 that money. There's only three uses for funds that end up in the Alberta fund, which of course
00:20:31 is all of the surplus that's not being used for debt repayment in the year that it's achieved.
00:20:39 And, of course, those uses are holding the funds for future debt repayment,
00:20:42 additional deposits into the Heritage Savings Trust Fund,
00:20:45 and, of course, one-time expenditures on strategic government priorities that are non-reoccurring.
00:20:53 In other words, not just dumping it into programs
00:20:57 and ultimately inflating the cost of delivering programs to an unsustainable level.
00:21:03 The whole purpose of the Alberta Fund is, in fact, to bring discipline to the process.
00:21:08 Great, thank you. Catherine?
00:21:10 Catherine Rukowski, Alberta Today.
00:21:12 So the last few weeks and months have been told,
00:21:15 stay tuned, stay tuned, stay tuned,
00:21:17 stay tuned for the Liability Management Incentive Program details,
00:21:20 for the CPP, for Alberta Provincial Police,
00:21:23 and there's a whole bunch of these promises.
00:21:25 I'm not seeing details, I'm not seeing line items.
00:21:28 Why are so many of these not accounted for in this budget?
00:21:32 Well, look, a budget is ultimately a strategic plan
00:21:37 strategic plan laid out numerically for the upcoming year and so you're not seeing an alberta
00:21:43 pension plan in this budget you're not seeing a definitive alberta alberta police force in this
00:21:47 budget and you're not seeing an r-star program in this budget because none of those none of those
00:21:52 policies have been approved right now we as a government are reaching out on all of them
00:21:56 and consulting with albertans as the minister of finance i'm looking forward to the day when i can
00:22:01 release the report that we've been working on with respect to an alberta pension plan right now that
00:22:06 report's being updated for a fresh data set that we received in December. The work will be done
00:22:11 sometime in May and it will be important that Albertans receive the report and can take a look
00:22:16 at the opportunities and the risks of an Alberta pension plan and ultimately make the decision.
00:22:22 So no, right now in this upcoming year we don't have plans to move to an Alberta pension plan and
00:22:27 in terms of an Alberta police force, again there's no budget line in there because we haven't made
00:22:33 definitive plans to do that all of these policies require engagement with Albertans and ultimately
00:22:38 Albertans a need to decide and on health care you mentioned this 4.1 percent increase but
00:22:46 on your own self-imposed limitation of population plus inflation you could have spent up to 8.7
00:22:52 percent and we're even seeing cuts still in health to things like cancer research and prevention
00:23:00 why not use that full amount that you could have why not go even bigger for health our our fiscal
00:23:09 rules around a limitation on increasing expenditures no higher than population growth
00:23:17 and cpi creates a ceiling it doesn't create a target our target continues to be the fiscal
00:23:24 anchor that we identified in 2020 and that is to align our per capita government spending
00:23:30 with that of other provinces we believe in alberta we can deliver programs at least as efficiently
00:23:36 as the other provinces a four percent increase in health spending on top of a four percent increase
00:23:42 the year before is very very significant and if you know if we take uh the covid costs
00:23:49 out of the year before out of 21 22 which were significant we were right in the middle of covid
00:23:54 then our increase in health spending is actually closer to 11%.
00:23:58 We need to ensure that we're funding health adequately.
00:24:02 We also need to ensure that we're continuing to bring fiscal discipline to the province.
00:24:07 I believe this budget achieves both.
00:24:11 Hi, Lily Polanchuk from The Gateway.
00:24:14 For my first question, for three years in a row, the Campus Alberta grant has received cuts,
00:24:19 but with Budget 23, it seems like this trend is reversing.
00:24:23 so if so why have you decided to reverse this trend now so in in budget 2022 we as as we as
00:24:32 a province started to recognize that we have you know thousands of unfilled positions that require
00:24:39 specific skills and competencies we started reinvesting again in a significant way in our
00:24:46 in our great world-class post-secondary institutions that was really our workforce
00:24:51 initiative. That was $600 million in total over three years. A portion of those funds were used
00:24:58 to buy specific seats in specific occupations and disciplines where there was great demand.
00:25:04 Just a really quick story. For the funds we set aside, we believed we could buy 7,000 seats,
00:25:10 and these were seats in high-demand areas. And Minister Nicolaitis, to his credit,
00:25:14 worked with our great post-secondary institutions, and ultimately for that same amount of money,
00:25:19 they're providing 10,000 additional learning seats we're building on that as you point out
00:25:24 in budget 2023 this is about again recognizing a great need a great need by for Alberta employers
00:25:33 but also a really important great need for Albertans to have the skills they need to
00:25:39 participate in this great Alberta advantage that's why we're investing but we're doing it in a
00:25:44 different way. Much of our investment is targeted towards the specific seats in the occupations and
00:25:50 professions that are in great demand. An incredibly valuable and worthwhile investment.
00:25:55 Great. Thank you. And for my second question, you earlier said that Budget 23 is a continuation
00:26:02 of Budget 2019. And in Budget 23, you are changing the interest rates for student loans from the
00:26:11 prime plus one percent rate to the prime rate but in 2019 it was the opposite it was changed
00:26:17 from already being at the prime rate to prime plus the one percent so what affected this change
00:26:25 sure sure that that's a great question an astute question in terms of delivering a budget and a
00:26:31 fiscal plan that's fiscally responsible that was the direction we set in 2019 budget 2023 aligns
00:26:38 with that overall principle here's the good news we've spent three years doing
00:26:43 the heavy lifting making difficult decisions all of us as Albertans and
00:26:47 we've got our fiscal house in order we've achieved the fiscal anchor of
00:26:51 aligning our per capita cost of delivering services with that of
00:26:54 comparative provinces that's a key anchor and now that gives us the ability
00:26:59 to move spending up prioritize and fund key priorities of Albertans and again
00:27:05 right now we are really facing an affordability challenge that's been
00:27:08 unprecedented in recent time and this is a way that we can provide real tangible
00:27:13 relief for Alberta Alberta students thank you we're just gonna switch to the
00:27:17 lines because we have quite a few people waiting right now we'll come back to the
00:27:20 room in a little bit so operator can you put through the first caller thank you
00:27:25 I'm a greenie Globe and Mail yeah good day minister I want to ask you about the
00:27:31 new Alberta fund um can you expand on the reason why it is that your government
00:27:36 shifting what could be significant capital expenses even if just one time to a separate
00:27:42 fund i mean you could have billions in targeted spending here but you're choosing to omit that
00:27:46 from budget so can you say why well again emma we're establishing the alberta fund to bring
00:27:53 discipline to the use of our surpluses i i really believe it's critically important that
00:27:59 Albertans get full value and have their surpluses managed, you know, in a publicly beneficial way.
00:28:07 That's the purpose of the Alberta Fund.
00:28:09 It's not, you know, it's to be more transparent with Albertans on the use of those funds.
00:28:13 As I've mentioned, when a surplus is achieved, effectively that surplus can be used for debt repayment,
00:28:20 additional deposit into the Heritage Savings Trust Fund,
00:28:23 or for one-time non-reoccurring strategic priorities of the government.
00:28:28 And again, the Alberta Fund is so that we can be more transparent and bring more fiscal responsibility on behalf of Albertans.
00:28:38 The budget process is the place where we identify priorities of Albertans and needs within government-delivered services such as health care and education.
00:28:48 And it's in that budget process that we look to make thoughtful, durable, and sustainable decisions, appropriate decisions around funding programming.
00:28:57 Emma, did you have a follow-up?
00:29:01 Yeah, I do.
00:29:02 I mean, you're saying that it's going to bring discipline,
00:29:05 but in fact, you can spend this on anything you like
00:29:08 that is a one-time spend.
00:29:10 I mean, there's an election coming up,
00:29:11 to Graham's point earlier.
00:29:13 You can find anything in a writing where you need votes
00:29:16 and polling is shown as being closed.
00:29:18 So explain to Albert why this is not simply
00:29:21 a pre-election slush fund.
00:29:24 Emma, I appreciate the question.
00:29:26 it's anything but a slush fund. Again, it was conceived to bring discipline to the use of
00:29:35 surplus, and so surplus could only be used for three uses, with a priority being saving and
00:29:42 debt repayment. Now, included in these fiscal rules is a balanced budget requirement. Included
00:29:49 in the fiscal rules is, in fact, an expenditure ceiling, and including in the fiscal rules is a
00:29:56 requirement that the government deliver based on the budget with effectively only the contingency
00:30:03 for use for emergencies disasters or unforeseen expenditures that may arise in the year so again
00:30:10 the series the fiscal framework the layering of protection I believe will ensure that governments
00:30:17 cannot act irresponsibly ahead of an election per se and and spend a surplus that's sitting
00:30:25 in the count. Look, even if the funds are in surplus, we're going to, you know, running a
00:30:29 significant surplus this year. Now we're paying down a lot of debt, which I believe is the best
00:30:34 use for a surplus. But any surplus that sits in that Alberta fund has to be, to spend it, it has
00:30:42 to be reflected in the budget. It can't just be, governments just can't go in there and take it,
00:30:47 run off and spend it. It has to be spent in a consistent way with the budget that I'm going
00:30:53 to look to present to the legislature and hopefully pass within the next three to four
00:30:57 weeks.
00:30:58 So, again, there's a series of controls that will bring fiscal discipline to any government,
00:31:05 and the Alberta Fund is just another mechanism to bring that discipline.
00:31:10 Operator, can you put through the next caller?
00:31:15 Thank you.
00:31:16 Jeremy Thompson, CTV.
00:31:19 Hi there. Thanks for taking my question here. Firstly, just wondering about the spending on major cities, Edmonton and Calgary. How much of an effort was made to make the spending, you know, relatively equal? It looks like they're both getting about $2 billion. What can you say about the division between the two major cities?
00:31:42 look when ministries bring requests whether it's operating requests or capital requests to treasury
00:31:52 board we at treasury board take a look at where's the where's the greatest need and where's the
00:31:58 greatest return on investment what what are the biggest priorities for albertans regardless
00:32:02 of geography that's the reality the fact is that calgary and edmonton are both great big
00:32:09 world-class cities, and so there's going to be significant capital funds spent in both of those
00:32:15 regions and both of those municipalities, but also right across Alberta. We, again,
00:32:22 make decisions based on need and priority and defensibility, and that was the way the
00:32:27 decisions were taken this year. Did you have a follow-up? Yeah, and then just when it comes to
00:32:34 cities i'm sure you know they might be interested in accessing some of the funds uh in that alberta
00:32:40 fund you know it's over a billion dollars is there is there a process for cities to sort of
00:32:46 request access to that perhaps for you know a new arena or upgrades to uh to a stadium like
00:32:52 commonwealth well in terms of municipalities directly access accessing the fund the answer
00:32:58 is no there is no mechanism and that's by design again the alberta fund was established to bring
00:33:04 discipline to the use of surplus. There's only three uses for those funds. The priority will be
00:33:10 given to debt reduction, debt repayment, further investment in the Heritage Savings Trust Fund,
00:33:16 and also an allowance for one-time spending that's non-reoccurring that aligns with
00:33:22 strategic government priorities. Operator, can you put through the next caller?
00:33:27 Janet French CBC. Hello there. Some of the structural costs that you've built into this
00:33:36 budget rely on oil revenues to sustain. This seems to me to be completely opposite to the work that
00:33:42 you've done to slim down the government during the last three years to rein in these structural
00:33:46 costs. So what's your long-term plan to sustain these service levels without relying on resource
00:33:51 revenues that's been an age-old question here in alberta job number one was bringing responsible
00:34:00 fiscal management to the bottom half of the income statement to our expenditures and that's
00:34:04 that's what we believed was uh the first job and we've worked hard at that over the last four years
00:34:09 again doing it thoughtfully surgically but getting it done bringing our expenditures in line to where
00:34:14 they're at a much more sustainable level going forward there to the point where we can make
00:34:19 additional reinvestment. We can invest in Alberta's priorities. We can meet emerging needs because
00:34:24 we've done the heavy fiscal lifting. Now, with respect to Alberta's revenue structure, it does
00:34:31 remain volatile. We do depend at this point, certainly to a significant degree, on non-renewable
00:34:37 resource revenues. And that's our reality right now. At the same time, we've focused on, again,
00:34:45 creating a business environment that would attract investment and further
00:34:49 diversify the economy that's also happening and that's in part reflected
00:34:54 in the increasing corporate tax revenue and personal tax revenue that we see in
00:34:58 the province so that is also part of the equation and and we're focused on that
00:35:03 there's great value in a more diversified economy in Alberta not only
00:35:06 so that Albertans can have you know find and pursue careers perhaps that they
00:35:11 couldn't in alberta a few years ago but it also will create more stability for government revenues
00:35:17 going forward did you have a follow-up i do but if we're looking at the numbers for 22 24 i mean
00:35:24 18 billion dollars of the revenue you're expecting is coming from resource revenues and we're going
00:35:30 to spend 68 billion what's to prevent you if oil prices crash from having to come back and then
00:35:36 lay off all these healthcare workers these education workers that you're hiring
00:35:41 Look, we went through a period of time where WTI oil prices hit the negatives in 2020, and the WCS prices stayed at $10 for far too long.
00:35:55 We managed through that, and we managed through that while we continued to deliver government services.
00:36:00 In fact, at the time, we were dealing with a pandemic, and we were having to support Albertans at a much higher level because of that.
00:36:08 You know, I talk about the importance of paying down debt.
00:36:12 Paying down debt creates fiscal room.
00:36:15 And when you have fiscal room, you can more effectively deal with an economic shock that might be coming in the future.
00:36:21 Ultimately, that's the whole goal of paying down debt, or certainly one of the goals.
00:36:26 One of the other benefits, of course, is reduced debt servicing costs.
00:36:30 You know, I've said in previous years, and I continue to believe it,
00:36:34 after the government of Alberta gets their spending in line, which we've achieved that,
00:36:40 at some point in the future it'll be important that Alberta takes a look at its revenue structure
00:36:45 to ensure that it's most appropriate, that it's most efficient.
00:36:49 There's a time when that will be important, and that time will probably be in the not-too-distant future.
00:36:53 But right now, we're focused on delivering very efficiently.
00:36:58 We're also focused on positioning Alberta's economy for economic growth and diversification,
00:37:03 which also diversifies the government's revenues.
00:37:06 We're going to take two more on the line, then we'll come back to the room.
00:37:09 So, operator, put in the next caller.
00:37:11 David Staples, Edmonton Journal.
00:37:14 Hi, thanks for taking my call, Minister.
00:37:17 So, I'm looking at the increase in non-renewable resource revenue from two years ago to now.
00:37:27 Two years ago, it was $3.1 billion.
00:37:30 Now, it's $27.5 billion.
00:37:32 So that's a 790% increase in non-renewable resource revenue.
00:37:38 Someone looking at that might say, well, you know, you're taking a lot of, you know,
00:37:43 why do you deserve credit for balancing the budget and paying down the debt when you get that kind of economic windfall?
00:37:48 What would you say to someone who poses such a question to you?
00:37:52 What credit do you think your government deserves here?
00:37:55 David, that's a great question.
00:37:56 question, and energy revenues, non-renewable resource revenues, oil royalties, if you will,
00:38:02 continue to play a big part in our revenue mix. And of course, the energy industry is a major
00:38:07 industry in the province, and so it contributes to economic activity, which of course support
00:38:12 personal income tax revenue and revenues from corporate taxes as well. So it's a major
00:38:18 player in Alberta. But it's the combination of things. Granted, the recovery in energy prices
00:38:25 was very very significant but David if you recall when we presented budget 2022 a year ago we did
00:38:32 we presented that budget based on fairly modest energy prices energy prices that were were
00:38:38 realistic based on on the time in the day and we were projecting very modest surpluses we're
00:38:44 projecting a surplus last year of 500 million dollars and we also had done the work we'd
00:38:52 extrapolated where our spending would be had we continued on the spending
00:38:56 trajectory of the previous government and instead of a 500 million dollar
00:39:00 surplus we would have had a six billion dollar deficit so a balanced budget is a
00:39:06 combination of things firstly we absolutely been blessed as Albertans
00:39:11 over the last year and a half with an increase in recovery in energy energy
00:39:15 prices certainly a big part of the story at the same time we've seen
00:39:19 government revenues grow broadly as we've seen a more diversified economy
00:39:23 contributing to more personal income tax revenue and corporate tax revenue for
00:39:28 the province of Alberta and at the same time our fiscal discipline bringing our
00:39:33 spending in line with other provinces bringing our spending to sustainable
00:39:37 levels has been a big part of the story it's really been all three David did
00:39:43 you have a follow-up yeah if that same person then you know same voter asked you well you know
00:39:50 if the ndp was in power right now and enjoyed this same kind of massive windfall in reverse
00:39:56 revenue wouldn't they also have a big surplus that also being have paid down the debt significantly
00:40:02 and and if not what why wouldn't they have done it well well david again based on the spending
00:40:09 trajectory of the NDP when they were in office from 2015 to 2019, increasing spending by
00:40:16 four percent a year when our economy was flatlined and revenues were declining. Had they been
00:40:23 in office the last four years, again, given the revenue assumptions that we made at budget
00:40:28 time, again, they would have been reporting a $6 billion deficit, not a $500 million surplus.
00:40:34 And the fact that we're now projecting a $10 billion surplus for the current year that
00:40:40 we're in, I think we could also extrapolate holding all things constant.
00:40:45 It wouldn't have been 10, it would have been more like four had the NDP been in office
00:40:49 and had they continued to spend on the same trajectory.
00:40:53 Fiscal discipline matters, David.
00:40:55 And it's a big and key ingredient in presenting a budget that's ultimately balanced for all
00:41:02 three years of the fiscal plan.
00:41:03 Awesome. Operator, can you put through the next caller?
00:41:07 Thank you. Josh Aldridge, Calgary Herald.
00:41:11 Good afternoon, Minister. Thank you for taking my question.
00:41:15 You've talked a lot about what's happened since 2019 when the UCP came into power,
00:41:21 about the impacts on the economy and the investments that are made there.
00:41:26 But going through the budget this year, there's not a lot that really stands out that's new
00:41:31 in terms of that investment in the business sector.
00:41:33 are you looking at this as more just kind of stability to further invigorate that sector or
00:41:41 are there specific programs or specific things that are in this budget there that you're looking
00:41:46 at to provide more of an injection into that business community because looking at it right
00:41:50 now not a lot there that's uh that's a great question and i'd love to answer that because
00:41:58 again back in 2019 we worked hard to create a very competitive business environment broadly that's
00:42:06 why we brought down our corporate tax rate our general tax rate from 12 to 8 percent that's why
00:42:12 we've been focused on red tape reduction regulatory modernization across sectors and we've done that
00:42:19 because we believe it's important that broadly govern we should have a very competitive business
00:42:24 environment because there'll be opportunities that government could never see and if we have a very
00:42:30 broad-based competitive business environment entrepreneurs and investors can take advantage
00:42:36 of opportunities regardless of what sector and that's what we're seeing today and that's uh
00:42:42 that's been very very gratifying and it's resulted in a in a diversifying economy
00:42:47 of significant proportion awesome Josh did you have a follow-up was there any
00:42:54 real consideration into further lowering the corporate business or the corporate
00:42:59 tax and small business tax to further address some inflationary pressures
00:43:04 especially with a global slowdown coming you know what we consider our tax
00:43:10 structure as we look at every budget right now we are very very competitive
00:43:15 more than competitive from a Canadian standpoint, and very competitive with U.S. states.
00:43:22 So we believe that we've calibrated our corporate tax rate at the right level.
00:43:28 I should also mention that we have done some very specific, unique things in this budget
00:43:33 with respect to our business environment.
00:43:36 We have brought in the AGRA food processing and manufacturing tax credit,
00:43:41 non-refundable corporate tax credit which again will further improve the competitiveness of our
00:43:48 agri-food processing and manufacturing sector and our agriculture industry broadly. We've increased
00:43:54 the film tax credit going forward which again will improve our competitiveness in that space
00:44:00 and we've seen the film and television industry absolutely explode over the last few years.
00:44:06 So two things. Budget 23 is about stability. And business investment craves stability. I know as a business owner and manager, stability and certainty are critical. That's what Budget 23 does. It brings stability. At the same time, we're making tweaks to even further improve the competitiveness of our business environment.
00:44:28 awesome we'll take it back to the room thank you Charlotte it's Lisa Johnson
00:44:32 from the Edmonton General High Minister I just want to go back to Emma's
00:44:35 question about the Alberta fund you're saying that that the purpose of the fund
00:44:40 is to have guardrails up to direct how the government spends a surplus or what
00:44:46 it does with a surplus but this is discretionary one-time funding are you
00:44:51 saying are you promising that you are going to detail any spending from the
00:44:56 alberta fund if there is any before the election in the legislature because there are no details
00:45:02 in this document in the documents today about what the government plans to spend potentially
00:45:07 1.4 billion dollars on potentially a month before the writ is dropped any spending that's done
00:45:15 between now and the election needs to be reflected in the appropriations bill and fiscal plan that
00:45:21 i'm presenting in the legislature later today that's that's a reality for the upcoming budget
00:45:26 year again there's a contingency amount 1.5 billion dollars in the budget that i'm presenting
00:45:32 and that contingency uh fund is crucially vitally important to ensure that we can deal with
00:45:38 disasters and emergencies that we're unable to budget or plan for but again any any plans and
00:45:45 programs need to be reflected in this appropriations bill and and so no it
00:45:50 again the Alberta fund really does provide guardrails and firstly at least
00:45:56 50% of a surplus has to be used towards debt that's maturing in the year the
00:46:01 surplus is attained that's that's number one it prioritizes debt repayment that's
00:46:05 our fiscal rule but anything that ends up in the Alberta fund only you know
00:46:09 debt repayment additional investment into the heritage trust fund or again
00:46:14 one-time non-reoccurring investments that align with government's strategic
00:46:20 priorities could could could fit as well but that needs to be reflected those
00:46:24 plans need to be reflected in a budget
00:46:29 follow-up sure yeah I mean but we won't see a fiscal update until after the
00:46:34 election so we won't have those details but you're saying that it's going to be
00:46:40 reflected in appropriations in detail just to clarify but I have a second
00:46:46 question which is a bit of a niche question in a mandate letter to her
00:46:51 Minister Premier Daniel Smith asked for a digital innovation tax credit for
00:46:56 video game creators I'm wondering why that was abandoned in this budget I
00:47:00 don't see it anywhere in the budget sure I mean you know what we constantly
00:47:04 evaluate our competitiveness in every sector where we know we're naturally
00:47:09 competitive. Certainly the tech sector is an area where we're naturally competitive. The numbers
00:47:15 speak for themselves. And I should point out that in 2022, Alberta set another record in terms of
00:47:22 venture capital investment at something like $729 million. And we did that. We set a new record at
00:47:29 a time when provinces, other large provinces with large tech sectors, saw a decline in investment.
00:47:36 So the point there is that Alberta is very competitive in the tech space.
00:47:41 We have a growing tech sector in Alberta.
00:47:45 We evaluate the competitiveness of every sector ahead of every budget,
00:47:49 and a digital media tax credit is not included in this budget.
00:47:54 We continue to work with the sector and the industry to understand what they're going to need to remain competitive.
00:48:02 If I take a look broadly at the tech sector, what we're doing, again, broadly as a province,
00:48:08 and that includes governments, includes our academic institutions, it includes our world-class tech sector,
00:48:13 what we're doing broadly is working because we're winning with venture capital investment.
00:48:17 Great. Thanks, Lisa.
00:48:20 Good afternoon. It's Safe Kaiser, Global News.
00:48:22 Minister, a couple of questions back a couple of times you sent.
00:48:25 This is not an election budget, but when we actually look at the budget,
00:48:28 we see Calgary which is a battleground mentioned almost double the amount of times Edmonton is
00:48:35 more money going to Calgary for more things. Why would that be the case if you're claiming this
00:48:40 isn't an election budget? Again I can tell you as the President of Treasury Board our practice when
00:48:47 we consider requests from ministries whether they be operating but especially capital. You can
00:48:53 imagine every ministry lobbies hard for capital and of course we hear you know interventions from
00:48:58 every MLA, rightfully so, as they're working to do their job. At Treasury Board, we have a
00:49:04 comprehensive rating process that rates capital projects based on the need, based on the priority,
00:49:11 based on the return of investment to Albertans, based on the readiness of that project.
00:49:16 And it's through that checklist that ultimately informs our decisions at Treasury Board as to
00:49:23 which projects we approve and move forward with. And so, you know, from time to time,
00:49:26 some years it's going to be rural alberta other times it might be the north i can't wait for that
00:49:31 day being from grand prairie other times it'll be the south or calgary or edmonton but again
00:49:36 at as the president of treasury board we take a disciplined view and we want to ensure and we work
00:49:42 to ensure that the highest priority the most defensible projects are the ones that are funded
00:49:48 budget 23 is no exception right so what you're saying then is uh all of the requests you've
00:49:54 received from edmonton i mean edmonton has just as big of a population and as many problems as
00:49:59 calgary does you're seeing the requests you've seen don't give you a large enough return of
00:50:07 investment that you think it's worthwhile investing into those problems in edmonton
00:50:13 well you know the the projects are ranked based on need and priority they have a ranking based on
00:50:19 safety they certainly have a ranking based on readiness all of those factors are considered
00:50:25 when treasury board makes the final decisions around the capital plan and i can tell you this
00:50:30 that again from time to time it'll be calgary edmonton or rural alberta that seems to you know
00:50:35 get a disproportionate amount of that investment but that's the process we stick to and that's the
00:50:40 process we undertook in budget 23. thanks eve hi minister morgan black also with global news
00:50:47 on the topic of priorities i know affordable housing has been a big priority for edmonton
00:50:51 for a number of years i didn't see that explicitly in the budget i don't know if
00:50:55 that's included in msi funding but why was that not encompassed within this budget
00:51:01 that's a great question we are funding affordable housing in budget 23 we're increasing funding
00:51:08 for affordable housing and it will be a key part of budget 23. there's a great need
00:51:13 out there both in our municipalities edmonton and calgary especially but more than that you know we
00:51:18 can go to grand prairie fort mcmurray lethbridge medicine had other regions as well and we have a
00:51:24 long-term strategy around affordable housing our goal is to add 25 000 additional doors over time
00:51:31 we're sticking with that plan budget 23 ultimately delivers on the long-term plan to add more
00:51:38 affordable housing options for albertans do you think oh all right um and my colleagues asked
00:51:43 such great questions that i just thought this one um if you had any more surplus what would
00:51:50 you have invested in that's not encompassed in this budget and why that's a great question you
00:51:55 know if with additional surplus i believe that we should really be making debt repayment a priority
00:52:03 in the future. Over the last few years, of course, with the shock of COVID, I talked about, it's kind
00:52:09 of the triple black swan event, huge crash in energy prices, contraction in the global economy.
00:52:15 Alberta's debt grew. That's the reality. We had to deliver for Albertans during that time.
00:52:21 And there was a time in March, April of 2020, when there was great global uncertainty economically,
00:52:29 And all sub-national governments in Canada, none of us could borrow, none of us could float a bond issue.
00:52:35 And that lasted for quite a long period of time.
00:52:39 And it was at that time I recognized the great need to create fiscal room
00:52:43 so that a province like Alberta can handle an economic or fiscal shock in the future.
00:52:48 That's why debt repayment, I believe, should be a great priority.
00:52:52 Because as you pay down debt, you create fiscal room so that you can handle a shock in the future.
00:52:57 The good news is this. We set a fiscal anchor of keeping our net debt to GDP ratio below 30 percent, keeping a relatively strong balance sheet even during those dark days. By the end of this year, that net debt to GDP ratio is 10 percent, the strongest balance sheet of any province in the country by far. That's good news for all of Albertans.
00:53:16 Thank you. We have time for two more questions from the line. Then we have a hard stop at 145. So, operator, can you put through the next caller?
00:53:27 One moment, please.
00:53:39 Thank you.
00:53:40 The next question is from Chris Varko, Calgary Herald.
00:53:44 Minister, what will be the split for how your government treats future surpluses from the
00:53:50 Alberta Fund?
00:53:51 In other words, how will you decide how to divvy that up between the three different
00:53:55 buckets that you've already laid out today?
00:53:57 I correct Chris that's a great question and we've allowed flexibility in the use of the Alberta fund again flexibility for debt repayment further investment in the heritage trust fund or perhaps one time strategic projects and you know my mind goes probably if it is going to be used for those purposes those are probably capital projects but I believe that we need to leave flexibility because for governments of the day they're going to need to
00:54:27 evaluate the cost of capital, cost of borrowing. They're going to need to evaluate expected returns
00:54:33 in the Heritage Savings Trust Fund. They're going to need to take a look at their overall debt
00:54:37 levels. All of those features, I believe, should inform decisions around ultimate surplus allocation.
00:54:44 Again, Chris, if you heard my answer to the previous question, you know my preference. My
00:54:50 preference right now is debt repayment debt reduction in order to create fiscal
00:54:56 room because fiscal room gives a province such as Alberta more optionality
00:55:02 more flexibility should we hit another economic shock in the future and at the
00:55:06 same time right now our cost of capital like every government around the world
00:55:11 has been creeping up with interest rates even though our cost of capital
00:55:16 relative to Ontario was going down because of our strong balance sheet the
00:55:20 reality is is we're in a time of increasing interest rates and so right
00:55:24 now debt repayment also materially lowers debt service costs which that
00:55:30 funding can be available for programming or future investment in the heritage
00:55:34 savings trustman Chris did you have a quick follow-up yeah this is a bit of a
00:55:40 two-part question minister but is it your target to drive net debt down to
00:55:45 zero and just going back to the earlier comments about the effectiveness of
00:55:49 balanced budget bills, given the fact that we've already seen them in the past in this province in
00:55:53 the 1990s and in the 2000s, and they were subsequently ignored by future governments,
00:55:59 how successful or how effective are they?
00:56:03 Chris, I believe a well-thought-out set of fiscal rules, a well-thought-out fiscal framework,
00:56:13 like the framework that I'll be ultimately presenting in the House
00:56:19 in the form of proposed legislation.
00:56:22 I believe that type of fiscal framework can be very durable.
00:56:26 But there needs to be enough flexibility in the framework
00:56:29 so that it can account and adjust for a very volatile revenue structure,
00:56:35 which we have in this province.
00:56:37 And I believe these fiscal rules will accommodate that.
00:56:40 And at the same time, bringing real fiscal rigor
00:56:43 to financial decisions by a future government.
00:56:48 So again, as you know, we have a balanced budget requirement,
00:56:51 or we'll be proposing legislation that will require a balanced budget.
00:56:55 But there are exceptions, exceptions with material drops in revenue
00:56:59 that we have to have in this province,
00:57:02 or the fiscal rule simply won't work and it will need to be repealed.
00:57:06 When it comes to our fiscal rules around limiting expenditure increases
00:57:11 to population growth and inflation, again, we're building on the previous year's expense ceiling,
00:57:19 not the previous year's actual results. That's significant.
00:57:24 That will ensure that wise governments start to create a little bit of unused room 1.00
00:57:28 so that they can deal with a shock that would inevitably come.
00:57:34 I believe these fiscal rules will deliver well for Albertans for years, hopefully decades to come.
00:57:41 and we'll help ensure sound fiscal decision-making.
00:57:46 Thank you. That is all the time we have for today.
00:57:48 Our media landscape is dominated by a few big players,
00:57:52 almost all of which are owned by big eastern and foreign corporate interests,
00:57:56 or by the government itself.
00:57:58 As taxpayers, we're forced to pay billions of dollars every year to support the liberal CBC.
00:58:03 But now even the non-government-owned mainstream media are on the take,
00:58:07 receiving hundreds of millions of dollars a year in a massive taxpayer bailout from the federal government.
00:58:13 This means that even those few bright spots of independence and free thinking in the mainstream media
00:58:18 are now on the government dole and cannot speak without fear that the government could pull their funding at any time.
00:58:25 There are a few great journalists in the non-government-owned media,
00:58:28 but they mostly work for large corporate interests owned and operated out of Toronto, Ottawa, Montreal, and New York.
00:58:37 western voices voices that speak for the west without fear of what their bosses in toronto
00:58:43 will say are far and few between the west needs a strong and independent voice that is willing to
00:58:49 take on the issues facing our people this is why we refounded the western standard in 2019
00:58:55 since then the western standard has burst onto the scene and shaken up western canada's media
00:59:00 landscape with a growing and dedicated team of reporters and opinion columnists we have quickly
00:59:07 become the third most read online news platform in western canada with an average of 3 million
00:59:12 readers per month and hundreds of thousands of people watching our videos and listening to our
00:59:17 podcasts our news team is made up of credible reporters largely recruited from the mainstream
00:59:23 media but who focus on issues that are all too often ignored by the old players our opinion
00:59:28 colonists fearlessly take on controversial issues that most of the old players are too afraid to
00:59:33 touch directly the western standards mission is to be the independent voice of the new west this
00:59:39 is why we need to see the receipts what did you actually spend the money on we got some major news
00:59:46 breaking at the moment for you we're making a big difference and giving westerners a homegrown
00:59:50 alternative to the big government-owned and government-funded mainstream media we're changing
00:59:56 the conversation now obviously i condemn those symbols i think those are for sure we all do at
01:00:01 the western standards what are your thoughts on that debate i think that tom clark the moderator
01:00:06 certainly lost there's issues with the current avlet system run by the province we refuse to
01:00:12 accept a penny of the big media bailout that has corrupted canada's once free breasts because we
01:00:17 are one of the only genuinely independent media in canada we are able to speak freely and cannot
01:00:24 be cancelled by ottawa we have a large and growing team of journalists with bureaus in calgary
01:00:30 edmonton vancouver regina and on parliament hill our reporters and columnists are fearless and
01:00:36 work tirelessly to give you straight news and cut through the spin that is why we need you
01:00:43 the reader to step up and become a member of the western standard you can become a western
01:00:49 standard member for just ten dollars a month or 99 a year for unlimited access much cheaper than a
01:00:55 subscription to one of the big government funded newspapers we are reinvesting every penny of that
01:01:01 back into improving our ability to provide you with real independent and original western news
01:01:07 and opinion coverage supporting independent media with your membership is the price of having any
01:01:13 media left in this country that isn't on the government take if you want there to be any
01:01:18 independent western media left then we need you to step up and support it without people like you
01:01:24 supporting independent media all that will be left is the corrupt government-owned and government
01:01:29 funded press we've built something great that is challenging the old media and we're making a big
01:01:36 difference together we can make sure that we have a voice that speaks for a west that is strong and
01:01:42 free canadian shooting sports association without the cssa our gun rights would have been taken 1.00
01:01:51 long long ago these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms
01:01:57 regulations and legislation in canada and more importantly educating the public about
01:02:02 how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people who become a member it's absolutely worth
01:02:07 Every penny.