Western Standard - April 19, 2025


Saying the unsayable about coal... it's still the way to go

Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Federal leaders' debate Let's face it, nobody knows how to deal with Trump

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

143.3

Word count

3,605

Sentence count

165

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Joseph Fournier is a long-time columnist with the Western Standard, specializing in controversial subjects. In this episode, he talks about the risks of writing about controversial topics on social media, and how to deal with them.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 China's killing our canola.
00:00:05 $45 billion gone.
00:00:08 Western farmers bleed.
00:00:10 Mark Carney?
00:00:12 Silent.
00:00:14 Made millions off Beijing's dime.
00:00:17 He won't fight.
00:00:18 He's Beijing's banker, not our prime minister.
00:00:30 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:50 I'm Nigel Hannaford. It is Friday, April the 20th, and my guest today is Dr. Joseph Fournier,
00:00:59 a longtime columnist with the Western Standard, specializing in controversial subjects, let's say.
00:01:05 Welcome to the show, Joseph.
00:01:08 Why, thank you, Nigel. Appreciate you having me.
00:01:10 Oh, we've been wanting to do this for a long time.
00:01:13 Joseph, you're a PhD physicist.
00:01:17 You're an energy industry veteran.
00:01:19 Worked in Calgary in the oil sands at Fort McMurray down in Utah.
00:01:23 Do they have oil sands down in Utah?
00:01:25 We were trying to make a run at it.
00:01:27 They have got every kind of hydrocarbon under the sun in Utah.
00:01:31 But 2020 happened, just put it that way.
00:01:35 Oh, I see.
00:01:35 All right.
00:01:36 Well, 12 years in the pit, and you've gone deep on some of the things that affect our lives deeply.
00:01:42 energy security, coal mining, climate science and policy.
00:01:47 Basically, for nearly three years now,
00:01:50 you've tried to make clear to our readers
00:01:51 what doesn't seem obvious on first reading.
00:01:56 It's quite a challenge.
00:01:59 Joseph, first a word from our sponsors.
00:02:03 This episode of Hannaford is sponsored by New World Precious Metals,
00:02:07 based right here in Calgary.
00:02:08 Years of inflationary money printing and rising debt have decimated the savings of the average Canadian.
00:02:15 Gold and silver are the only currencies that have held their value for thousands of years.
00:02:21 Last year saw 30% gains.
00:02:23 New World Precious Metals offers unique platforms to help protect and grow your hard-earned wealth with gold and silver.
00:02:32 Check them out at newworldpreciousmetals.com
00:02:36 newworldpm.com
00:02:38 So, Joseph, let's get right down to the meaty stuff.
00:02:41 You got kicked off LinkedIn recently for a while.
00:02:45 Nobody gets kicked off LinkedIn.
00:02:46 What do you do?
00:02:49 How deep did you go?
00:02:51 You know, the thing is, LinkedIn, the professionals, white-collar professionals,
00:02:56 town square, social media is where lately I've been,
00:03:00 the last couple of years where I've been usually posting my comments,
00:03:04 my articles I write for Western Standard.
00:03:08 other long form pieces um i have no idea what it was that i posted sad uh that got me restricted
00:03:18 for a few weeks this is the second time this year and you know one thing that i did you ask them
00:03:27 many times yeah and how does it go when you take things up with linkedin well it's
00:03:31 It's not like you can pick up a phone, right?
00:03:35 It's like an automated help desk.
00:03:37 You try to send them a message.
00:03:42 I tried both through the help desk on X as well as try to get back in through a identity verification step on LinkedIn.
00:03:53 And probably about 36 times I tried.
00:03:57 But I had.
00:03:58 You've tried 36 times.
00:04:00 Yeah.
00:04:00 to find out why you have been restricted on your use of linkedin right and with and you still don't
00:04:08 have a any idea no i think one of the things that happened was i've got about 14 000 followers on
00:04:14 linkedin and you know and pretty avid avid group of people who really high five me a lot of course
00:04:20 there's a lot of people who push back on some of the things i say but a lot of my followers were
00:04:25 really quite disappointed and they were they were sending me emails and some and people who had my
00:04:30 texts were were also relaying information to me but make a long story short i had there was dozens
00:04:38 of people who were writing linkedin demanding that they re uh unrestrict my account but i think in
00:04:45 the end that helped a bit just people i think maybe linkedin started getting tired a little bit
00:04:50 but this is a common thing uh that linkedin does and it doesn't matter sometimes if you've got only
00:04:56 500 followers or 50 000 it's if you if you start to talk about topics that are not it's usually
00:05:07 criticism of left to center ideas right those ones are usually will be what gets you you restricted
00:05:16 they usually will let you back
00:05:19 sometimes they'll give you a permanent ban
00:05:21 it could last years
00:05:23 but
00:05:24 in the end
00:05:26 it's just a technique
00:05:28 to
00:05:29 intimidate you
00:05:33 and to discourage you
00:05:35 from using the platform
00:05:36 to talk about
00:05:37 their favorite narratives
00:05:40 yeah well I mean we're very
00:05:42 familiar at the western standard
00:05:44 with the risks of publishing on social media i mean it's one thing when you are an old-fashioned
00:05:51 newspaper if you've got your printing press you you run it you take your newspapers out and sell
00:05:57 them deliver them to the door that's pretty hard to interfere with but here it can be somebody
00:06:03 who's um you know does linkedin have fact checkers no thank god what for the benefit of
00:06:11 of people who may not be quite as into this stuff as we are what is a fact checker well fact checker
00:06:18 you saw them come out really and really a lot in 2020 it's just if you post something a link to
00:06:26 western standard article that uh is flagged as having some keywords say maybe talking about
00:06:33 covid lockdowns they'll give you post that article the algorithm automatically goes oh
00:06:40 western standard article it's talking about something that we don't want them talking about
00:06:44 so we're going to attach a warning label yeah and and some facts that are accepted you know the first
00:06:54 joseph the first time i heard of fact checkers i thought of some genial old gentleman with glasses
00:07:00 in a library with a bunch of leather brown books and something comes across the screen that he
00:07:05 thinks is questionable and he actually checks to see whether it is true or not but the impression
00:07:11 that i've got since and you've only helped to solidify that impression is that it's probably a
00:07:16 25 year old kid whose last job was serving coffee with pink hair and they just know what to take out
00:07:23 and that's what they do it's you know fact checking they're censoring to your point you know the the
00:07:28 what my followers like the most of what of all the things that i talk about or the contact i
00:07:37 create they love it when i take a scientific paper something that's hot off the press
00:07:44 and i will pull out a figures a couple figures or two i'll make a meme a simple meme because
00:07:51 no one has the time of day to find their way around paywalls and to sit down and read a dry
00:07:57 scientific paper but they don't tell a story Nigel about a complex thing to break it down
00:08:05 so the average person can understand it people just love that you know and but so I'm a PhD
00:08:11 scientist breaking it down condensing it providing relevant commentary on publications
00:08:19 and that gets me banned that was not banned but restricted well restricted I mean it's a ban
00:08:25 yeah it's a bad and you can't put your word out so finally now you know thank you know i'm glad i
00:08:30 was allowed back because my profile is also my curricular vitae right if you want to see who i
00:08:35 am and what i've done you can go to my account so if i get restricted from it it's a bit of an
00:08:40 inconvenience i think you said 14 you had 14 000 followers yeah how many impressions in a year do
00:08:46 you i had 10 million you had 10 million impressions on linkedin in a year in in about 18 months so
00:08:53 So it was about $7 million I had in 2024.
00:08:59 But then something happened.
00:09:01 I got restricted in the new year, and then I got restricted again.
00:09:05 Each time I got allowed back.
00:09:06 But when I'm allowed back, my analytics plummet.
00:09:10 They just get totally throttled.
00:09:12 So if I have someone share my post or my article,
00:09:17 they'll often generate about 1,000 impressions,
00:09:20 meaning about 1,000 people saw it go through their feed.
00:09:23 it's about a thousand to one but now that i'm back i'm getting about it's about 150 to one
00:09:29 but do you know what's so cool it's like my my followers who are a high five in me for the last
00:09:36 week about hey thank god you're back on we missed your content now they are even more supportive
00:09:43 now they're the number of reshares i'm getting okay so you're obviously you've got a relationship
00:09:48 of going with the people who follow you,
00:09:52 you know, we all know Facebook will drop you
00:09:55 like a brick if they don't like you.
00:09:58 But is your experience typical on LinkedIn
00:10:02 or a little on the unusual side?
00:10:05 It's a bit unusual because of the fact
00:10:07 that I focus so much on science.
00:10:09 That's okay.
00:10:10 That's the great thing.
00:10:12 If we have a columnist here at the Western Standard
00:10:16 who is unusual that he gets dropped off LinkedIn for writing about science,
00:10:21 that tells me we are bringing a fresh perspective.
00:10:24 I think so.
00:10:25 Or you are bringing a fresh perspective to us.
00:10:27 So in the last year, I know you've been writing a fair bit about coal mining.
00:10:35 And back three years ago, you were very detailed on energy security
00:10:41 with a focus on Alberta.
00:10:42 At the time, Mr. Trudeau, the then prime minister, was insisting upon net zero by, I think, 2035.
00:10:52 The provincial government was willing to work with it, but not to meet that particular goal.
00:10:58 And you drew attention to the fact that we didn't have enough generating plants of the kind that you can just switch on when you need power.
00:11:05 I mean, wind, solar, you know, if it's a cold, dark night, you're not getting any power.
00:11:10 So that's what you need to generate.
00:11:14 And you really brought that subject forward.
00:11:17 And I saw very soon after that announcements from the provincial government,
00:11:22 maybe they were in the works all the way, I don't know.
00:11:25 But it wasn't long after that that they started announcing the development
00:11:30 of more natural gas generated.
00:11:33 Now, correlation causation, I don't know.
00:11:36 How's it going now?
00:11:37 Is Alberta catching up with its needs?
00:11:42 Well, power markets have improved substantially over the last, you know, Daniel,
00:11:47 Premier Smith has been in for two years plus, right, on an exact date.
00:11:52 Some of the initiatives that she's had put through her and her ministers.
00:11:57 Plus, over the last year, there's been two large gas plant power generation facilities that have been commissioned.
00:12:05 And that's really brought prices down, at least on the generation side.
00:12:11 You know, transmission fees and distribution fees are still through the roof, which is like 40 percent, 35 percent of your monthly bill.
00:12:19 But at least we've walked away from the edge of the abyss a bit in terms of risks of blackouts.
00:12:27 And, you know, it's, you know, Premier Smith is a hardcore supporter of natural gas power generation.
00:12:35 um i support coal because you know i moved back to by roots no last six years seven years i moved
00:12:43 out to rockyford area and um you know just you can't drive around alberta without understanding
00:12:49 number one coal built this province and you know like there was a time in rockyford where up to
00:12:58 the early 80s where you could hop on a train a coal-powered train and it would take you basically
00:13:03 downtown calgary for shopping you could be home by the end of the day and you know it's rural
00:13:09 rural alberta is is got deep roots in coal and i'm i'm very much as a philosopher as someone who
00:13:18 sees down the road a long ways at least i'd like to think i do um i think we're going in the wrong
00:13:25 direction as a society and i very very much want to see a reinvestment in rural infrastructure
00:13:31 I'm sure we're probably kicked off LinkedIn.
00:13:33 You're praising coal.
00:13:36 I'd say the most craziest things, according to some people, yeah.
00:13:39 Okay, well, all right.
00:13:40 You obviously like coal, and as a matter of fact, I do as well,
00:13:43 but that's not a here nor there.
00:13:48 Everybody says that coal is just a terrible generator of carbon dioxide.
00:13:53 Natural gas is better.
00:13:54 Well, that may be so.
00:13:55 um so why you obviously that argument doesn't doesn't interfere with your thinking much what
00:14:03 is it about coal that you like and it gives you the allows you to overlook the the knock on it
00:14:10 that it's just right gonna burn up the earth everything has costs and benefits you can't
00:14:16 look at just the negatives you have to look at the positives as well okay from point the third
00:14:22 highest cause of death in Canada is accidents by frontline healthcare workers. You know,
00:14:30 only a mentally unstable person would focus on that fact and demand we shut down hospitals, 0.83
00:14:39 right? But we've done that with coal. I'm assuming that you're, I've never heard that.
00:14:45 Did you say the third highest rate of accidents among that line item of accidents?
00:14:52 It's a dangerous thing going into a hospital in an emergency room.
00:14:55 You go spend the night in the ER, and you can see how easy it is for our overworked, critical,
00:15:01 frontline health care workers to make accidents and bad diagnoses by, you know, just they're overworked or they're over, you know.
00:15:07 Okay, so is it the patients who are dying or the frontline workers who are dying?
00:15:12 Patients.
00:15:13 Patients.
00:15:13 Oh, okay.
00:15:14 That makes sense.
00:15:15 I was also saying that you meant that that was a dangerous profession.
00:15:18 Oh, no, sorry.
00:15:20 It was just an example.
00:15:21 We have to get back to looking at pros and cons, costs and benefits.
00:15:26 And the benefits of coal are absolutely immense.
00:15:31 In North America, if you look at the resource base of coal versus oil versus natural gas,
00:15:39 there's more energy in coal than there is in oil and gas combined.
00:15:45 And so the future is coal, unless we find an alternative primary energy source like uranium or thorium.
00:15:57 And so I try to provide this counter argument to remind people that we've lost perspective on coal because it has some negative things.
00:16:09 Some people think CO2 emissions is a bad thing.
00:16:12 I don't.
00:16:13 I think there's actually more benefits to CO2 emissions than any measurable negative.
00:16:20 Definitely coal can be a problem when it comes to ink.
00:16:24 You know, if you don't got good technologies on your stack, on your exhaust, you can have pollution in certain cases.
00:16:33 That was not the case here with Alberta's coal power plants.
00:16:37 And they were decommissioned early.
00:16:39 they were they were operating quite well okay so this actually takes us to the stuff of the
00:16:48 election that's coming up in in 10 days mr mr carney has obviously been famous for a long time
00:16:59 for being an advocate for shutting in energy not just coal coal first but but also oil also natural
00:17:08 gas uh he what is he missing when he he thinks that the the emissions are going to uh fry the
00:17:19 earth he thinks that although canada's contribution to the overall level of carbon dioxide in the
00:17:29 atmosphere is pretty small nevertheless we should do it i guess to set a good example
00:17:34 So if you could have Mr. Carney here and you could talk to him for two minutes about it, knowing that he probably isn't going to agree with you anyway, but what would you tell him?
00:17:47 What is it that you would wish he understood or wish he would acknowledge?
00:17:52 Well, if I was to speak as a citizen, I probably wouldn't want to say on Hannaford what I would say to him, but as a scientist.
00:18:01 It's good for ratings.
00:18:04 um it's i'd tell him to stick stick with um monetary policy and quit trying to be a messiah
00:18:12 because he does not know the science the science i don't even like using that word but it's thrown
00:18:17 around a lot uh the the truth of the matter is the literature is showing that satellite data
00:18:25 has been monitoring every square inch of our top of the earth's atmosphere now for
00:18:30 I don't know, 40 years. And I just posted an article, a publication that came out last year
00:18:37 that shows that there is no evidence that heat flux out the top of the atmosphere
00:18:47 is declining as we add more and more CO2 into the atmosphere. That's a problem for people like
00:18:56 carney because he says your tailpipe is trapping heat in the earth's atmosphere so you should see
00:19:04 less heat escaping into space we're gonna boil we're gonna burn because you're trapping heat
00:19:10 with greenhouse gas so-called but there's no evidence of it in fact the what measurements
00:19:19 show is the opposite.
00:19:22 Heat flux
00:19:23 out the top of the atmosphere
00:19:25 is increasing
00:19:26 quite fast. The Earth
00:19:29 is releasing heat. There's no
00:19:31 evidence of heat being
00:19:33 trapped. The only place
00:19:35 the evidence exists
00:19:37 is in computer models.
00:19:40 And
00:19:41 one of my favorite climate scientists is
00:19:43 Dr. Curry, Judith Curry.
00:19:45 And on this topic, she just says
00:19:48 we need to do a lot less modeling and a lot more observational observations.
00:19:55 Get back to the basics. But there is no evidence of the boiling effect that the alarmists,
00:20:06 politicians, activists, even academics who need the funding, claim is there. It's just not.
00:20:13 Okay. See, there's no evidence.
00:20:16 People point out all the time that glass ears are melting.
00:20:20 Oh, there's your evidence.
00:20:22 How do you answer them?
00:20:23 Well, because there's a big difference between a warming climate
00:20:28 and a climate that is warming because heat is being trapped by CO2, as an example, gas.
00:20:40 Well, what is the difference?
00:20:41 because some people probably wouldn't say, well, it's a distinction without it.
00:20:44 There's a question I'll ask you.
00:20:46 The question should help you answer your own question.
00:20:50 In the morning, you get up just before the sun rises,
00:20:55 and you go aside for, you know, start your car and come back out an hour later.
00:21:03 It's gotten warm.
00:21:05 Why has it gotten warm?
00:21:08 Sun's up.
00:21:09 Sunshine.
00:21:10 Right. Exactly.
00:21:14 Another thing that you'll notice is a night that has a lot of cloud cover versus a night that has no cloud cover.
00:21:22 The cloud cover, the cloudy night will have a warmer temperature.
00:21:25 Yeah. So the crux of it is there's increase in sunshine, changes in cloud coverage, changes in the types of clouds like a low stratoform cloud right on the deck or cirrus cloud way, way up in the air.
00:21:41 different types of clouds scatter incoming shortwave radiation back to space or let
00:21:48 solar radiation hit the ground and warm up to dirt melt glaciers the hydrological cycles driven by
00:21:55 sunshine and clouds is a mediator and what we're finding from the satellite record now is that
00:22:02 we don't understand the physics clouds cloud dynamics and um it's i'm really quite excited
00:22:11 about it. We don't know the math, so we can't write a computer code to describe what it is we're
00:22:17 seeing. But what we're seeing shows we don't have the answers. Well, Joseph, I'm glad you're
00:22:23 monitoring this. And, you know, these, although it sounds very, you know, it's a great discussion,
00:22:31 but people say, well, tell me about the election. The fact is we are having an election, and this
00:22:39 is an issue in the election as to how we deal with the our atmospheric policy in in the years
00:22:48 going forward i'm going to ask you this last thing and then we're going to we're going to be out of
00:22:52 time okay but um when you have watched what mr polyev has to say about the uh about this subject
00:23:00 of climate change are you at all reassured by his answers no why not i'm not i don't see a single
00:23:06 conservative out there yet who's who is able to speak
00:23:14 probably jen from a genuine point of a genuine position on this topic um
00:23:21 maybe scott moe's get the closest i've found yes right like last year what was it the the
00:23:26 rural municipalities to saskatchewan all voted like 97 in favor to co2 is not a pollutant it is
00:23:36 the gas of life net zero is not zero like crazy talk right so it's very clear the the conservative
00:23:44 base in saskatchewan wants the saskatchewan party to go in a certain direction but he
00:23:50 politicians have to pivot to the center they have to represent the fuller spectrum
00:23:54 of their citizens right so pierre probably is doing the same thing he's he's he's trying to
00:24:01 get elected right so he can't actually speak to the science and um you know at least he's not
00:24:08 advocating for penalizing energy use and i'm sure and he is he is advocating for pipelines
00:24:16 so that's the good jobs and jobs and all that goes with it yeah joseph this has been great
00:24:23 really appreciate you coming in thank you for the western standard i'm nigel hanaford
00:24:30 what does success mean to you peace of mind financial freedom generational wealth what do
00:24:36 you see in your future investing in gold and silver can help you get there through our trading
00:24:42 partners new world precious metals offers safe affordable secure international accounts to help
00:24:48 you meet your unique financial goals connect with one of our experienced team members invest in gold
00:24:55 and silver today