Western Standard - December 12, 2023


SCHEER Fergus acting like biased hockey referee

Mentioned
Alberta's $31M Funding For Nine New Emission Reducing Projects Freeland accuses Poilievre of not standing with Ukraine

Episode Stats


Length

6 minutes

Words per minute

155.16

Word count

961

Sentence count

50


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, the Speaker of the Ontario House of Commons, Kathleen Spivens, faces questions about her appointment of a chief of staff with a close relationship to the Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, as her Chief of Staff.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Mr. Scheer.
00:00:00 Thank you, Madam Chair.
00:00:02 I think it's really important for Canadians to understand why this is such a big deal.
00:00:08 You have come from a very, very partisan past, what some might describe as a hyper-partisan role,
00:00:14 given the fact that you have served in executive-level positions.
00:00:18 I think you said national, was it director of the Liberal Party, president of the Youth Wing.
00:00:22 You were parliamentary secretary to the prime minister right up until the beginning of this fall session.
00:00:31 Those are roles in which you are very close with the government, very close with the prime minister himself.
00:00:38 And then to transition into becoming speaker, to running for speaker,
00:00:42 members of parliament have to kind of, once you've won, we have to park that history of yours
00:00:47 and trust that you're going to be non-partisan and objective.
00:00:51 The fundamental rule of being speaker is also one of the easier rules to follow,
00:00:59 and that is you just don't do partisan things.
00:01:01 You don't participate in partisan events.
00:01:03 You don't say things publicly or certainly not in a capacity wearing speaker's robes
00:01:11 or in his office that would have any connection to partisan activities or partisanship
00:01:17 or indicating partisan favor.
00:01:18 You did the interview with the Globe and Mail where you praised a sitting Liberal politician
00:01:24 who, as far as we all know, is planning.
00:01:27 He's currently an MPP.
00:01:29 He's given every indication he's going to run again as a Liberal in Ontario.
00:01:34 So it's not like it was a retirement party or he's going off to do something else.
00:01:38 He's going to continue being an active partisan player in Ontario politics.
00:01:43 You referred to the Ontario party as our party.
00:01:46 So all of this comes to light.
00:01:48 In addition to this, we understand that your Chief of Staff,
00:01:53 which I understand your hesitance to name certain people at committee,
00:01:57 but he is listed on a public website, the Government Employee Directive Service,
00:02:02 and that is Tommy DeFoss.
00:02:05 I understand that he was very close with the current Prime Minister, Prime Minister Trudeau.
00:02:09 He was his executive assistant at one point, and now he's your Chief of Staff.
00:02:14 So having that hyper-partisan role in your very recent past,
00:02:19 hiring someone very quickly out of the PMO with a very close relationship,
00:02:23 personal relationship with the Prime Minister, and now this comes to light.
00:02:27 So again, I ask you, you talked about the arbitrator,
00:02:30 and you didn't quite address the nature of my question.
00:02:32 If you're a hockey player and you're about to play a game
00:02:35 and you just saw the referee in his uniform giving a pep talk
00:02:41 to the locker room of an opposing team,
00:02:44 it wouldn't matter what the context was, would it?
00:02:46 You wouldn't want that official referee in your game.
00:02:50 If you were involved in some kind of dispute that needed an arbitrator
00:02:53 and you saw that judge in his robes at an event with opposing counsel,
00:02:59 it wouldn't matter what the context was.
00:03:00 You can't unsee that.
00:03:03 You've now acknowledged there was a grave error of judgment.
00:03:07 As many colleagues have mentioned,
00:03:09 you are trusted to make on-the-spot decisions
00:03:12 without time to run things through filters or decision-making treaties,
00:03:16 and we have to trust that that's coming from a non-partisan and objective place.
00:03:20 And I would suggest the fact that you didn't see that
00:03:22 shows that you're still too close to the partnership of it.
00:03:25 You're too close with these partisan players that you don't see
00:03:28 that for members of other parties, it would be a problem.
00:03:31 So again, we'll just ask you, would you want to hear your case adjudicated?
00:03:36 Would you want to play in a sports game,
00:03:40 having seen the referee or having seen the judge or arbitrator,
00:03:43 involved in that type of display with an adversary or with an opponent?
00:03:48 Would you trust that process, having seen that?
00:03:52 Madam Chair, through you, I think it's really important,
00:03:55 and I thank the Honourable Member for his intervention,
00:03:59 the person who has sat in this role before.
00:04:01 To go back to the ref analogy, quite frankly,
00:04:10 it was a different league in which we were involved,
00:04:14 A, but B, I also recognize that the member is right,
00:04:18 that talking about my past, although in that reference to the notion of our party,
00:04:25 that was when I was actually a resident of Ontario back in the late 1980s, early 1990s, up until 1994.
00:04:35 That was at that time that it was referred to that.
00:04:39 Now, I do not like talking, I don't want to talk about my past here,
00:04:44 because every time I do, I know that it sounds like I'm being partisan.
00:04:48 That is, it was a matter of record that, at that time, we were both members of the same party.
00:04:56 It's just, it is a fact that I don't want to, I'm not validating that today.
00:05:03 So I just want to make sure about that.
00:05:05 Second thing, you'd raise the issue of my Chief of Staff.
00:05:10 When I, as you know, being Speaker, that you are administrating a large organization here,
00:05:17 my Chief of Staff left Parliament Hill in 2008, early 2018,
00:05:23 almost six years that he's been occupying a senior management role in the private sector.
00:05:33 He's someone who can help manage this, but more importantly,
00:05:37 someone who also has political experience,
00:05:40 who understands what it is to be a third political party,
00:05:43 to be in official opposition and in government.
00:05:47 So someone who has an ability to really hear and respond to the needs,
00:05:53 which are brought up by all folks.
00:05:57 So that's the reason why this person was hired.
00:06:00 He's calm, he's collected, and has a great reputation on the Hill.
00:06:04 Thank you.
00:06:06 Thank you.