Western Standard - May 30, 2025


Sex cartoon books in the school library? Ottawa is the enabler

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Throne Speech — was this a unifying message? The House of Commons is finally back in session. Nothing has changed.

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

142.45

Word count

3,271

Sentence count

111

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

This week on the Western Standard, we talk about graphic novels with explicit sexual depictions in Alberta elementary school libraries, and who are the gatekeepers in the system that keeps them there? Guest: John Hilton O'Brien, Executive Director of Parents for Choice in Education.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:22 of the Western Standard. It is Thursday, May the 29th. The story this week is that there
00:00:27 are graphic novels with explicit sexual depictions in Alberta elementary school libraries.
00:00:35 Now, we're not putting anything on the screen, but trust me, we're not talking about pen-ups.
00:00:39 We're talking about well-drawn fantasies depicting teenagers in sexual activity, and in some
00:00:45 cases with adults, both gay and straight. And the provincial government wants to know
00:00:50 what Albertans think about it. There is a survey that you can answer if you want to
00:00:56 see what we're talking about, you can preview these images when you take that survey. With me
00:01:03 today in the Western Standards John Galt studio is John Hilton O'Brien, the Executive Director
00:01:08 of Parents for Choice in Education. Welcome, John. Well, thank you very much for having me,
00:01:14 Nigel. Oh, you're so welcome. It's good to see you. Now, John, you've been, this frankly seems
00:01:20 incredible that there would be pornographic
00:01:22 material in
00:01:24 elementary school libraries.
00:01:26 When you were at school, when I was at school,
00:01:28 anybody who'd ever tried to pull off
00:01:30 anything like that would have fired me and even have
00:01:32 gone to jail. Something has
00:01:33 obviously changed, but
00:01:36 can you give us some
00:01:38 scope of the problem?
00:01:39 What exactly are we talking about?
00:01:41 At least comic books, graphic novels,
00:01:43 and how many are there?
00:01:46 Let's then talk about who's the
00:01:48 gatekeeper in the system.
00:01:49 all right go ahead tell us about it first of all it's not just graphic novels there are other books
00:01:55 that are at least verbally revealing and what a graphic novel is it's like a comic book but where
00:02:02 a comic book serializes things over several issues a graphic novel combines it all together
00:02:08 to make one complete story usually the qualities are better it's better bound the art is usually
00:02:17 better in a graphic novel as well so again is this all over the place it seems largely so so
00:02:28 what happened is a couple of years ago a group of volunteers that are affiliated with parents
00:02:35 for choice and education that call themselves the sidewalk education gang started doing some
00:02:41 research because we knew that these books were available. We had anecdotes about them in schools,
00:02:48 so they decided to see if they could prove it. And they amassed a file with quite a number
00:02:55 of references where they could pinpoint exactly where a given book was in a library and say,
00:03:02 this is really here, in some cases with photos of it on the shelf. Last fall, a lot of this
00:03:09 information made its way to the Ministry of Education. The minister, of course, can't take
00:03:14 any of this for granted, so he had the department go check into it. And they say in a number of
00:03:21 cases, I think it's 46, they found that there were in fact a book like this, and I'd hesitate to use
00:03:28 the name pornographic, but at least explicit graphically sexual material was in a real school
00:03:35 library in grades K to nine. And they were particularly concerned about its access to
00:03:43 children as young as first grade, which is as young as five years old.
00:03:48 So you're saying that in the 46 instances that they were able to check, which is not in, what is
00:03:55 a thousand schools in Alberta? This is not an exhaustive survey, this is a sampling.
00:04:01 When they sampled, they found 46 books in elementary school libraries.
00:04:06 And they took that as a sign that perhaps we need to have some sort of policy that helps you decide as a librarian when a book is or is not appropriate for your school library.
00:04:19 Now, I think probably some viewers are still reeling with what we're saying here because it does seem so unbelievable.
00:04:27 can you just like what sort of titles do these books have and without getting them into graphic
00:04:35 detail so to speak uh what are they about there's books like gender queer or flamer
00:04:41 i believe the department identified 10 particular graphic novels they were concerned with
00:04:47 and these are framed as coming of age stories but the way they're done up lays heavy emphasis
00:04:55 on the sexual aspect of it and there's a concern that due to what the author notices
00:05:02 we're talking about things that are really focusing the reader's attention on the sexuality
00:05:08 and of course in ethical criticism in literature you can never omit the context that these are
00:05:15 done in the context of trying to promote alternative sexual and gender minorities okay
00:05:23 who would promote that sexualization of children
00:05:29 who could also get it past the library gatekeepers.
00:05:35 I mean, I would think that if you want to put a book in a school library,
00:05:39 first of all, it's not your decision.
00:05:41 It's the decision of the librarian or a committee or somebody, but not you.
00:05:46 uh i mean how do how do books get into libraries and how did this slip past the screen well federal
00:05:54 and provincial governments have paid substantial grant monies to advocacy organizations that are
00:06:01 locally looking to normalize sexual and gender minorities is this heritage canada amongst others
00:06:08 so this is where stephen gilbert just ended up yes i suppose it would be it is yes okay i had not
00:06:15 made the connection myself. But in any case, teachers associations get very much into the act
00:06:22 in across Canada. This is not just an Alberta problem by any means. And so if you look, say,
00:06:30 at the PRISM toolkit for this that the ATA puts out, you have a note there from Senator Christopher
00:06:38 Wells that mentions how he made a book that's available online on how to create, how did he
00:06:48 put it? It was an inclusive library. And so the ATA encourages teachers to form committees for
00:06:59 diversity, equity, and human rights, I think they call them. And those are expected to press for
00:07:07 what they call inclusive materials in libraries, including these books. So there's quite a number
00:07:14 of people who are working on getting these books into school libraries. Well, you mentioned Senator
00:07:18 Wells. For the benefit of viewers who may not be as familiar with him as we are, who is he?
00:07:26 Oh, Senator Wells was a very prominent advocate for sexual and gender minorities,
00:07:32 did a lot of work in psychology, generally using survey methods to press the issue,
00:07:40 and he's very famous as an activist.
00:07:44 And he was appointed by which Prime Minister?
00:07:46 By Prime Minister Trudeau this past fall. He is one of Alberta's senators now.
00:07:51 And presumably this book that you referred to that he wrote,
00:07:54 he wrote before he became a senator.
00:07:57 yes this so that was actually uh that that was a positive when they were reviewing who they should
00:08:04 make a yes i'm sure that's the case the federal government seems to have had a a great interest
00:08:13 in this well that's that is interesting because although i don't know too many people of that
00:08:19 persuasion the few that i know just roll their eyes when they hear about this they don't want
00:08:24 any part of it. They don't want to be associated with it. They don't think these books should be
00:08:28 in school libraries. I'm sure the parents aren't getting together to advocate for this,
00:08:36 but we do have the federal government advocating for it. Well, of course.
00:08:41 Well, what the hell is going on? Well, the federal government does hope to
00:08:47 be able to get enough influence to get votes. It's an opportunity for distributing political
00:08:55 patronage through the grant system. And people who owe you for the grants they've received are
00:09:01 always going to be on your side. They're always going to be your advocates.
00:09:06 Well, I could try advocating for something else, couldn't I? You would think so.
00:09:11 there these books probably aren't a very good idea back in 07 the american psychological
00:09:19 association did a special task force on the sexualization of children and they found that
00:09:25 children who were prematurely sexualized that is exposed to the idea of people as sexual objects
00:09:32 primarily so people taken primarily as sexual interests they found that these people these
00:09:40 children would exhibit effects similar to actual sexual abuse very concerning negative outcomes
00:09:49 across a variety of psychological domains and they were studying the effects of media
00:09:56 and their conclusion was that media was not intense enough to produce these effects yet
00:10:02 but they weren't looking at schools and in schools when you put a book on a school library shelf
00:10:11 there's only so much space you're taking something else off it's a deliberate choice
00:10:17 and so material presented in a school and in a library has the stamp of authority
00:10:24 when they see this on the shelf children are being told this is how you should think this is who you
00:10:32 should be or at least this is okay it's more than okay there's a stamp of approval that amounts to
00:10:40 teacher set and it's a problem when we look at things like the psychology of moral development
00:10:49 What we find is that there's some agreement that teenagers, both in their early teens, let alone children, and even in their late teens, are very much driven by what is socially acceptable.
00:11:08 Convention matters to them.
00:11:10 And so when we're putting this in that context, even if it didn't have official support, then they would be inclined to take this as morally right.
00:11:26 It's perhaps beyond the scope of this discussion to ask why the federal government would want to promote the sexualization of children.
00:11:36 But is that a conclusion that we can honestly draw from the fact that you have a ministry within the government giving money to activists for, well, I guess they're mostly gay activists, but the books themselves seem to be gay and straight.
00:11:58 So that's not wholly the issue.
00:12:00 i'm looking to see what the the public interest is in in promoting the sexualization of children
00:12:09 do you have a theory okay so this isn't really uh about promoting sexual and gender minorities
00:12:18 in our view the real problem here is that it is about being able to offer political patronage
00:12:26 which secures one's spot a bit in the firmament of Ottawa, as it were.
00:12:32 The more grants and poorly sourced contracts you can put out,
00:12:37 the more powerful you are because the more advocates you have.
00:12:42 And that is probably what this is about.
00:12:44 The fact that this is all related to promoting alternative sexual or gender ideas
00:12:52 may in fact be largely beside the point this is just a reason for promoting oneself or promoting
00:13:03 the government's ability to give grants. What's really happening with all of this is we have
00:13:09 bureaucrats and politicians who put up the image of someone who's vulnerable in some way like a
00:13:18 sexual or gender minority. And they exploit that for political power. There was an activist once
00:13:26 upon a time called Saul Alinsky, who criticized this as political pornography, because you're
00:13:33 exploiting the image of someone without power to get more power for yourself.
00:13:39 Well, he was recommending it. Alinsky was absolutely criticizing it.
00:13:43 I mean, he was a revolutionary of the 1960s, wanted to tear everything down and restore it.
00:13:49 Mr. Alinsky is widely misunderstood, and he criticizes the left very harshly. He is not
00:13:57 himself a leftist. And in fact, at one point he said to have worked as a union buster.
00:14:04 So the fact that some of his disciples put it to different use is not Alinsky's problem.
00:14:11 What was his book?
00:14:12 He wrote two books, one of them called Reveille for Radicals and another called, oh my goodness,
00:14:20 Rules for Radicals. And in fact, he was encouraged to write those books by a friend by the name of
00:14:28 Jacques Maritain. Jacques Maritain was one of the architects of what's called the Christian
00:14:33 Democratic Union, a conservative party in Europe. Okay, we may hear from readers with a different
00:14:39 view of Saul Alinsky's books but I stand corrected if that's in fact when he was satirizing the left
00:14:46 when he wrote Rules for Radicals. Let's get back on to the pornography thing. What is the
00:14:51 provincial government looking to do? The provincial government is just taking input right now and
00:14:58 what they seem to want to do is to help provide a framework by which school boards can decide
00:15:05 what books are going into their libraries make no mistake there will still be arguments about
00:15:11 books after this and you will still see things like catcher in the rye they're not going to be
00:15:17 taking books off of school shelves but they will be having a conversation about what's appropriate
00:15:25 and what's not where is the line to be drawn and they won't be doing that without talking
00:15:32 to school boards and librarians either i i just can't see what there is to discuss here
00:15:39 john you have a you have a graphic knowledge a graphic novel with a couple of teenagers depicted
00:15:48 having sex straight or gay either way that doesn't belong in an elementary school i'm 0.95
00:15:54 not saying it should be banned i mean you still get it at uh at a bookshop if you've got to have
00:15:59 it but it doesn't belong in a school library and i don't think you think that either oh absolutely
00:16:07 so so what's where's where does the provincial government see the discussion well i understand
00:16:13 that the provincial government has already noted these books to the school boards and more
00:16:18 importantly to their superintendents and it's most likely that these particular books are
00:16:24 being taken off of the main shelves as we speak but more are being produced every day
00:16:31 and there are still going to be activists trying to get their pet projects into school libraries
00:16:38 that's the concern of the provincial government at this point not these particular books but
00:16:44 all of them that we're concerned about and not just the graphic novels either how do we make
00:16:51 decisions about what books belong on what school shelves there's a much larger conversation taking
00:16:58 place here and when that's done i'm sure it will serve as best practices across the country we're
00:17:04 just the first to notice the problem confirm that it exists and start to do something about it
00:17:11 you see i i forget who it was it might have been james dobson who said but somebody said years ago
00:17:19 you know don't ask me to define pornography but i know it when i see it
00:17:24 and it seems you were you were a little delicate about using the word pornography you preferred
00:17:30 sexually explicit fair enough i may not be able to define it but again i know sexually explicit
00:17:37 when i see it and when you take the survey and you have a quick look at what the provincial
00:17:42 government has put there for you to draw your conclusions upon you're gonna say that doesn't
00:17:48 belong and why do we have to go through a process like this to to determine what is kind of obvious
00:17:58 well part of the question is whether the minister of education wishes to dictate
00:18:03 all contents of all school libraries everywhere in the province or whether he thinks that your
00:18:10 local school board should have a hand in that so that's part of the concern i imagine he's also
00:18:17 trying to avoid blowback but underlying that concern even if the minister was abolishing
00:18:24 all school boards there would still have to be some basic lines of where do we define this as
00:18:32 starting so clearly sexually explicit materials should probably not be in any school libraries
00:18:41 at any grade but some things are also going to be inappropriate for junior high elementary school
00:18:48 beyond that and they can't just go this book is banned because what about next week's book
00:18:57 it's brand new and it's on the shelves all of a sudden that's the minister's concern
00:19:02 i see well he's i i see it's a sticky one but as i said sometimes we seem to spend a lot of time
00:19:11 Somebody has to be responsible for what is permissible in school libraries, period.
00:19:17 And you have written a number of articles in the past
00:19:22 about how the education system actually works and who has input into it.
00:19:28 Not everybody who seeks input into the education system,
00:19:33 not everybody who runs for school board
00:19:37 It's necessarily working in the best interests of the children.
00:19:42 Sometimes there are other interests that they represent.
00:19:45 And you have written about this, so I get a little anxious when it is too far distributed.
00:19:51 I think we're almost out of time, so I'm going to let you wrap up the argument for us.
00:19:58 And then just tell us where to go to look at this survey.
00:20:03 The key problem here is that this is much bigger than the 10 books that the minister has
00:20:10 identified. These are simply very obvious cases. We need to look at the broader problem as well.
00:20:20 Where are we going to draw that line? One of my concerns is that there are a whole lot of
00:20:27 people who are referred to as experts they're bureaucrats they're employed by schools or
00:20:34 teachers unions or by advocacy groups probably by our tax dollars and they are going to write
00:20:41 articles they're going to send in their own feedback they're going to get every supporter
00:20:47 they have to just overwhelm this particular public engagement so that the minister feels he has no
00:20:56 choice but to kowtow to their demands the only solution is for as many people as possible to get
00:21:03 in on this survey and give this feedback if you go to the parents for choice website or to
00:21:10 articles that have been appearing in the western standard recently you'll find links to this
00:21:17 public consultation it's also on the department of education's home page and we need everyone we
00:21:24 can to go in and give reasoned feedback on this. John, Parents for Choice in Education, in 15 seconds
00:21:32 what do you do? What we do is we stand up for parents. Our object is to achieve educational
00:21:39 excellence through maximum parental involvement. What you have told us here this afternoon,
00:21:45 this evening, is staggering. It's that the federal government would be pushing something like this
00:21:51 and that they would find earnest, willing supporters
00:21:55 who would then try to browbeat the government of Alberta
00:22:01 into saying, yeah, it's okay if you want pictures
00:22:05 of this kind of sexual activity in the school libraries
00:22:08 where a 10-year-old can find it.
00:22:11 I think a lot of people just find this mind-blowing.
00:22:14 I do.
00:22:16 At least you and your colleagues in the Parents for Choice
00:22:19 and education are able to do something about it so we are going to encourage the viewers if they
00:22:25 feel strongly about this to find the survey we're going to put it up on the screen here in a moment
00:22:31 where the link is or you can go to the articles in the western standard that have recently been
00:22:36 published about this from jen hodson and myself and you can find it there and just click the link
00:22:41 and have a look say what you think and you will have done a good thing john thank you very much
00:22:48 for coming in today.
00:22:49 It's been a pleasure to see you here.
00:22:51 Thank you very much, Nigel.
00:22:55 For the Western Stant,
00:22:56 I'm Nigel Hannaford.