Western Standard - February 21, 2026


Smith’s Big Referendum Gambit

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Premier Danielle Smith to deliver special address to Albertans CORY MORGAN SHOW: Canada’s bureaucratic class contributes to the mass immigration mess

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 30 minutes

Words per minute

150.98

Word count

13,686

Sentence count

723

Harmful content

Misogyny

20

sentences flagged

Toxicity

25

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The Western Standard's Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, joins me to discuss Alberta Premier Danielle Smith's landmark speech on the economy, immigration, the budget, and the referendum. We also talk about the reaction to the speech, and whether or not it was a good or bad thing.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 Thank you.
00:04:00 Thank you.
00:04:30 Thank you.
00:05:00 Thank you.
00:05:30 Thank you.
00:06:00 Thank you.
00:06:30 Thank you.
00:07:00 Good day, good morning. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, coming to you with a live stream this morning on February 20th, a nice cold morning here in Calgary.
00:07:17 We're going to be chatting today about the big speech from Alberta Premier Danielle Smith last night, broadcast at a quarter to seven Mountain Standard Time.
00:07:30 Quite a landmark speech, one that will probably be remembered when the books on her premiership are written.
00:07:38 Where it goes, we're going to speculate.
00:07:40 We're totally going to speculate, do our best to analyze here.
00:07:46 But I want to involve you guys in this.
00:07:49 You can post, if you have comments, questions, put it in the comments if you're watching this on X, YouTube, wherever.
00:07:56 um but also you can call i have not done uh the call-in before we've just got set up for
00:08:02 kind of the call-in here you can join the conversation at uh 1-866-479-west extension
00:08:11 711 you got the number right there at the bottom of the screen uh 866-479-west extension 711 you
00:08:20 can you can call in uh hopefully you have something intelligent to say if not i'll hear
00:08:25 yet anyway but uh i know uh cory and marty up north have been doing the call-in feature on
00:08:31 our shows lately i've i've enjoyed watching and listening to that uh maybe we'll have maybe we'll
00:08:36 have fun here too um okay so let's talk about the speech um it's the reaction right across
00:08:46 canada has been uh furious fast and furious response to what she's had to say um there is
00:08:54 a series of referendum questions. We're going to get to that, but we'll kind of start with
00:08:57 the earlier parts of her speech first. She talked about, you know, there's a budget coming
00:09:03 for Alberta next week. It's not expected to be good. Huge, huge deficit, possibly a record
00:09:10 deficit. She, I mean, like most Alberta premiers who have had deficits, pointed to oil and oil
00:09:19 is down and it's it is a mugs game try to predict this stuff uh sometimes it works out sometimes it
00:09:25 doesn't but uh you know anyone who could predict this stuff accurately would be uh would be a rich
00:09:30 man um and the government got it wrong i mean and it's pretty common to get it wrong it's it's
00:09:36 difficult stuff to predict but she's pointing to uh oil and uh yeah to some extent yeah oil is uh
00:09:44 is down quite a bit but didn't really fess up to she can't control that no premier can control the 1.00
00:09:53 price of oil but what can you control you can control your taxes and you can control your
00:09:58 spending and controlling spending is not something that alberta's government's been doing for a very
00:10:02 very long time uh spending has been wildly out of like danielle smith is i think run pretty good
00:10:10 government on a few different fronts. One of those fronts is not the budget. The budget's
00:10:17 been a disaster. It's been a pretty free spending government. And she says, oh, we're not going
00:10:24 to slash spending or anything, but we're going to limit spending to below inflation and population
00:10:29 growth. That's helpful. If they would have done that for the last three years, we'd be in a better
00:10:39 spot than we are now. J.C. Kenney, in his time as Premier, did not cut spending. He limited growth
00:10:46 in spending, and that was better than his predecessor, Rachel Notley, and Rachel Notley
00:10:52 continued largely what her predecessor, Alison Redford, had done, which is just an Ed Stelmack
00:10:57 before that. The budget is totally out of control, and there just doesn't seem to be any appetite
00:11:02 in the government for cutting spending, which is what's necessary here. But she's talking about
00:11:07 putting the brakes on spending increases it's better than nothing but it's not going to fix
00:11:13 the problem here we've got we've got structural budget problems and no one seems to really have
00:11:17 the appetite to do anything serious about it so okay uh one thing she did point to though
00:11:24 that i think is is a fair criticism um that she's made or i should say fair defense she's made
00:11:31 about some of the spending problems we've got is around immigration.
00:11:36 We've had 600,000 people come into Alberta recently,
00:11:41 wild numbers that we simply cannot integrate, we cannot assimilate,
00:11:48 we cannot make work in that kind of time.
00:11:52 And so she's pointed at these numbers largely controlled by Ottawa
00:11:55 and pointed at least put some of the blame on immigration.
00:12:00 And, I mean, the reaction to it from the usual suspects has been extremely predictable.
00:12:05 Oh, you're blaming immigrants, blah, blah, blah.
00:12:08 Rachel Notley, let me pull up this one. 0.75
00:12:10 Rachel Notley more or less said that Danielle Smith is a Nazi. 0.98
00:12:17 Let me see, where is this one?
00:12:20 Hold on.
00:12:22 This is, yeah, so Rachel Notley's response here, it's not, it's far from the craziest response.
00:12:29 but it's um it's definitely not out of line with uh with a lot of the response we've seen
00:12:36 uh rachel notley says danielle smith making racism great again first they came for the trans people
00:12:45 then a then they came for the unionized workers next it was judges now it's immigrants i think
00:12:53 that you or someone you love won't be next if you think someone you love won't be next you're
00:12:57 sorely mistaken and then it goes on and on and on but uh you know that that's taking from a poem of
00:13:03 uh of a lutheran i think lutheran pastor during the second world war who was imprisoned who wrote
00:13:08 you know first they came for the jews because i was not a jew and then they came for the unions etc
00:13:14 so this is rachel notley saying uh controlling immigration simply limiting the number of
00:13:23 immigrants we have coming into alberta is nazism nazism this is um it's the alberta reich uh i
00:13:32 mean so it's predictable crazy stuff but no we've got uh our schools are swamped anyone who knows a
00:13:38 teacher uh in our big cities particularly parts of our big cities in alberta that have a significantly
00:13:45 higher uh proportion of migrants in them will tell you the big problem in our schools is that 1.00
00:13:52 we've got a huge number of students who do not speak English adequately. In many cases, not at
00:13:58 all. Like no, no English. There are a very significant number of students in our schools
00:14:05 who speak no English. Like we've brought in people to this country who don't speak our language. 1.00
00:14:14 And then in addition to people who speak no English, huge number who also speak poor English.
00:14:20 And so you have completely dysfunctional classrooms, classrooms where you can't focus on a lesson being taught because a huge number of the students can't understand what's being taught.
00:14:32 So strains like that or people who are coming in and are drawing on social services, they have not paid into this.
00:14:40 They haven't been a part of the social contract.
00:14:41 They have not been paying taxes in, but they're withdrawing services out.
00:14:46 Maybe they're working, but they're working in low-wage jobs where they're not paying very much, if any, tax, but they're able to draw on social services.
00:14:57 They're able to draw on health care, these kinds of things.
00:15:01 And so this creates a huge net negative financial pressure on Alberta, in addition to all the social problems this obviously creates.
00:15:11 So she pointed to this as one of the culprits, at least, for the budget deficit we have, some of the strain we've got on infrastructure, on education spending.
00:15:27 And the usual suspects have just completely lost their minds.
00:15:32 So, OK, then she proposed a series of referendum questions. 0.77
00:15:37 Let's see. One, two, three, four, five. I think it's ten. Six, seven, eight, nine. Okay, it looks like nine. I'm going to go through each of these. It's pretty broad ranging. Referendums are not new to Canada. They're not new to Alberta. But they're not usual. They're very unusual in our system.
00:16:02 And I generally favor us having at least some more direct democracy, but I'm not sure about this, the way this is being, yeah, having nine, ten questions, in addition to citizen initiative questions like independence, which is likely for a vote in the fall.
00:16:25 So in, I think it's October.
00:16:28 What's the date we've got for this thing?
00:16:31 John, can you find me the date of the referendum?
00:16:33 I don't know why I don't have that handy.
00:16:35 I should.
00:16:37 So the premier in her address laid out these questions.
00:16:41 The first are a series of non-constitutional questions, largely the things that Alberta can do on its own.
00:16:47 And the second are a set of constitutional questions that would require negotiation with the federal government and other provinces.
00:16:54 So let's go through. We'll start with the non-constitutional questions. We'll call them the domestic Alberta questions first.
00:17:02 Do you support the government of Alberta taking increased control over immigration for the purposes of decreasing immigration to more sustainable levels, prioritizing economic immigration, of migration, and giving Albertans first priority on new employment opportunities?
00:17:17 Okay. So, I mean, it's a big question, but it's important. I wouldn't be a surprise to anyone that, yeah, of course we should. Of course I think we should. But I'm wondering why that is a referendum question. Just do it. Like, why are we waiting until the fall to vote on this?
00:17:39 ask any poll albertans the super majority of people including most uh successful and integrated
00:17:49 migrants will agree with this that yes we should take control of immigration from ottawa quebec is 0.99
00:17:55 allowed to do it in large measure so we should do it too uh you know let's let's send notice to
00:18:00 ottawa right now that we're demanding the same powers as quebec has and we're going to use those
00:18:06 powers to limit migration, to focus on economic migrants, and prioritize Albertans getting jobs
00:18:16 before we bring in people to fill those jobs. I think almost everyone except for the Rachel 0.52
00:18:22 Notley's and those types are going to agree with this. I'm not sure why we have to wait
00:18:27 until the fall to vote on this. We should just do it right now. And I think the government's
00:18:35 got a mandate for it you know we've been talking about this this was uh you know not hidden that
00:18:41 this is something the ucp wants to do the ucp has been talking about taking control of immigration
00:18:45 for some time especially since uh danielle smith became the leader of the party and the premier
00:18:50 albertans know that this is something that's been in the books uh that's been that's been cooking
00:18:55 i don't know why we don't just do this all right second question do you support the government of
00:19:01 Alberta introducing a law mandating that only Canadian citizens, permanent residents, and
00:19:06 individuals with an Alberta-approved immigration status will be eligible for provincially funded
00:19:11 programs such as healthcare, education, and other social services. Okay, so what's implied there is
00:19:19 that there will now be an Alberta-approved immigration status. In addition to the federal
00:19:23 immigration status, Alberta will decide, do we want someone here or do we not want this person
00:19:33 here? And if Alberta does not want this person here, we're not going to give them social services 0.81
00:19:41 funded by taxpayers. So healthcare, education, we could put in there, driver's licenses, that kind
00:19:47 thing. Again, I'm not sure. I'm not sure why we would vote on that. I think most people would
00:19:55 agree. Of course, not everyone. No one agrees on everything. But I chance to say a majority of
00:20:00 Albertans, including a majority of well-integrated and successful migrants, would agree with this.
00:20:06 Let's just do it. Let's just go ahead and do it.
00:20:14 All right. Next question was, assuming that all Canadian citizens and permanent residents continue to qualify for social support programs as they do now,
00:20:24 do you support the government of Alberta introducing a law requiring all individuals
00:20:29 with non-permanent legal immigration status to reside in Alberta for at least 12 months before
00:20:34 qualifying for any provincially funded social support programs? I think that's pretty similar
00:20:41 to the previous question, question number two. Again, I think most people would agree with it.
00:20:48 In fact, that's just common sense stuff that's crazy that we're not already doing. And we don't
00:20:52 need anyone's permission for that. We don't need Ottawa's permission for that. We should just do it.
00:20:58 So again, you know, this is a question that the Premier wants to put to a referendum that
00:21:02 I agree on. I think it's good policy that we should do. We should just do it. We should not
00:21:06 wait until the fall to do it. I would be shocked if this kind of thing was defeated in a referendum
00:21:12 question. Let's just make this government policy. Next one. Do you support the government of Alberta
00:21:22 introducing a law requiring individuals to provide proof of citizenship, such as passport,
00:21:27 birth certificate, or a citizenship card to vote in Alberta provincial election.
00:21:32 Again, why the hell are we not? Are we actually going to have the referendum without checking
00:21:37 people's proof of citizenship first? Absolutely, we should be checking proof of citizenship. 0.91
00:21:43 And for all of you people saying, oh, it's fascism, it's racism, it's mean to ask people
00:21:48 to show identity before voting uh some kind of card before voting just remember where you stood
00:21:55 during covid when people had to show a special identification to get in and buy a sandwich at a
00:22:01 restaurant or to get groceries oh it's like groceries you didn't need it but you had to you
00:22:06 know they made you mask up but you want to you want to go to a restaurant you want to watch a
00:22:10 movie you want to do anything really you had to uh you had to show you know uh jason kenny's uh
00:22:17 COVID vax card. So all of you who think that this is somehow racist and bigoted and fascistic
00:22:25 to show identification and proof of citizenship when you're voting, just think about where you
00:22:31 probably, in all chances, think about where you probably stood during COVID when people had to
00:22:36 show identification to buy a bloody sandwich. Also, you know, people saying, oh, some people,
00:22:44 you know, it's difficult for them to get ideas. If you are too stupid to get an identification 1.00
00:22:49 card, I don't want you voting. You're too stupid to vote. No, I don't agree that everyone should 1.00
00:22:55 vote. It's everyone's duty to vote. No, if you're too stupid to be able to go get yourself a driver's
00:23:02 license, you're probably too stupid to decide how much tax I should be paying. You're probably too 1.00
00:23:07 stupid to decide what the foreign policy of our country should be. You're too stupid to figure 1.00
00:23:12 those things out you're doing society a favor by not voting so it's a pretty low bar to set 1.00
00:23:19 that you've got the iq to go in and get a driver's license some kind of identification
00:23:26 if you can't do that or if you can't be bothered to do that we shouldn't be bothered to countervote
00:23:33 it's a pretty damn low bar to set so again i would have a hard time imagining most albertans would
00:23:42 have uh oh that was question five question five should be it right now there we go i have a hard
00:23:49 time imagining that most albertans would have a problem with this we're going to require proof
00:23:54 that you're eligible to vote before we let you vote i have to show proof that i'm eligible to
00:24:00 drive a car before i'm allowed to drive a car i have to show proof that i'm legally eligible to
00:24:05 own a firearm before I'm allowed to own a firearm. When I go buy a gun at Cabela's, I have to provide
00:24:12 my PAL. I have to provide my possession and acquisition license and show that I am legally
00:24:19 eligible to own a firearm. Why are we not required to do that when we vote? Now, I don't know what
00:24:28 what number of people are voting that are ineligible to vote. I can't say.
00:24:36 I know some areas in the States, it's rampant. There's probably significant scales of voter
00:24:44 fraud taking place there. What scale here? I don't know. But it does become a bigger concern
00:24:50 the more you have large numbers of people living in your society who are not citizens.
00:24:55 when everybody living in an area is generally a citizen it's less of an issue it's less likely
00:25:01 to be voter fraud people who are ineligible to vote to vote it's going to be less of an issue
00:25:05 at least maybe not no issue but it'll be less of an issue but when you've got massive numbers
00:25:11 of people massive numbers of people coming in who are not eligible to vote
00:25:17 it's something we got to be paying attention to so again i i'm not sure why we're having a
00:25:24 referendum on that. I like voting on stuff, I guess. But, you know, and citizens should have
00:25:32 a right to vote on some things. That's why I like the idea of citizens initiative, like we've got
00:25:37 going on for the independence referendum. That's something that the political class considers a
00:25:41 little too spicy to touch. Okay, I get that. I can appreciate that. But to their credit, the UCP
00:25:50 strengthened the citizens initiative legislation first they introduced it under kenny but it was
00:25:56 kind of unworkable at that time then they made it workable under smith um so to their credit
00:26:01 they've brought this in so when there's an issue that's too spicy citizens can do an end run around
00:26:07 the political class and require that we vote on this together and people can vote yes or no
00:26:12 so that's a good that's a reason for referendum and i think uh on major constitutional questions
00:26:18 that's that's a place for people to vote in direct democracy but this stuff is pretty standard you
00:26:26 know these five questions i've laid out here from the premier speech last night these are pretty
00:26:30 standard government policies that i think have broad support i like if people don't like them
00:26:37 those the opponents can go and do a citizen's initiative petition
00:26:41 and bring in uh their own referendum to repeal these laws you know when a government does
00:26:47 something that's not broadly got a democratic mandate that people don't broadly support.
00:26:53 Like, you know, think of the NDP, Rachel Notley's carbon tax. They did not have any democratic
00:26:57 mandate to do that, but they had the legal right to impose it. Okay. So if we had citizens initiative
00:27:03 legislation at that time, the people of Alberta could have gathered enough signatures and held a
00:27:08 referendum on overturning that legislation. That'd be an appropriate way to do it. Similarly here,
00:27:14 If people didn't like the five points put out by Smith here and she had just legislated it and passed by the legislature, then the opponents of this legislation could go out, collect the signatures and try to overturn these laws.
00:27:29 I don't think they'd be successful.
00:27:31 Maybe they'd get enough signatures for a vote, but I doubt they'd win the vote.
00:27:34 So I don't know, these five points around immigration, these are all very moderate things.
00:27:39 And like, my only problem with these policies is that they probably don't go hard enough. We have been swamped. You know, we have taken a migration model that, I mean, had its problems. I think it was over generous in the past, but it wasn't at least disastrous.
00:27:59 and then and we totally screwed the pooch we totally screwed or ottawa screwed the pooch on 1.00
00:28:04 it and we've got to reverse that we've got to engage at some level at least of of humane
00:28:11 remigration she's not talking about anything like that these are very moderate immigration policies
00:28:18 very moderate um that i think have got the broad support of the alberta public my only problem here
00:28:26 Two problems. One is it's probably a little too light, but, you know, I'll take what we can get.
00:28:30 This is a good step in the right direction, these policies.
00:28:33 Okay. But why would we have a referendum on this?
00:28:38 Just do it. Legislate this tomorrow. The legislature is in session.
00:28:43 There's a budget next week. Everyone's there.
00:28:45 Introduce the legislation. Pass it. Let's make this policy right now.
00:28:50 Let's do it. Let's not wait for the fall in a referendum campaign.
00:28:53 let's let's just do it now and if the opponents of these laws don't like it guess what we have
00:29:01 citizens initiative legislation you know Rachel Notley and these people can go out and they can 0.80
00:29:07 go in gather signatures in the cold like independent supporters are doing right now
00:29:12 they can go out they can gather signatures and they can force a referendum on repealing this
00:29:16 I don't think they'll be successful but you know that's up to them we'll see I think that's the
00:29:22 to do it you know um i like a degree of direct democracy but we do elect people for a reason
00:29:29 and that's to make decisions tough decisions complicated decisions and you know alberta has
00:29:37 pioneered a degree of direct democracy in this to check the ability of the political class to run
00:29:44 roughshod over um uh to to override the politicians if the politicians go astray
00:29:55 but this is a this is what we elect people to do to make to make decisions similarly uh when kenny
00:30:00 was premier you know we had two referendum questions uh held in conjunction with municipal
00:30:05 elections one was on uh getting rid of equalization which you know i'll talk a bit more about that in
00:30:10 in a bit but that got completely ignored obviously by ottawa nothing happened on equalization
00:30:15 whatsoever and the other one was around changing daylight savings time i forget it was pretty
00:30:21 complicated and that's the problem is like i think i think broadly people don't like our system
00:30:26 around daylight savings time uh but people also didn't necessarily like the reform that was
00:30:31 proposed in this referendum question it was confusing people don't know because that's
00:30:36 something that requires study it's not a strict yes or no question on something i don't even say
00:30:43 it's simple but say like independence do you believe alberta should be an independent country
00:30:47 or remain in canada people are going to have a thought about that they're going to have strong
00:30:51 feelings on it and they're going to know which way to vote for the most part daylight savings time
00:30:57 i don't even remember how i voted i remember i looked into it and i was like i could go this way
00:31:01 and go that way but the proposal there was one proposal that a lot of people liked which wasn't
00:31:05 even an option. That's something that a committee of MLAs for both parties, NDP and UCP could
00:31:11 probably actually agree on. It's totally non-ideological. It's a technical question.
00:31:17 Put it to a committee of MLAs, bring in some experts, they can study it, and then they just
00:31:23 make a decision. And if we don't like it, we can have a citizen's initiative to overturn it.
00:31:27 That's the way our system should work. We elect people, we pay these people to study the issues
00:31:33 and make a decision. And if we don't like the decision, we've got two options. We can throw
00:31:38 them out the next election. Or now, this is a new thing in our system, we can have a citizens
00:31:43 initiative petition to trigger a referendum to overturn their decision. And I think these first
00:31:51 five referendum questions concerning immigration fall into the category of this is what we elect
00:31:58 you to do. Just do it. Do these things right now. Immigration is a problem right now. And it's 1.00
00:32:05 something we got to deal with right now. And this is not a constitutional question. This is just
00:32:10 a straight up policy question. This probably got pretty broad public buy-in for these kinds of
00:32:15 measures. So just do it. I don't know why we have to have a referendum on it. I'm probably a bit
00:32:22 more forgiving, not entirely, but I'm a bit more forgiving on the second round of questions,
00:32:27 the constitutional ones let's talk about these
00:32:34 all right the first constitutional question is do you support the government of alberta working
00:32:40 with the governments of other willing provinces to amend the canadian constitution to have
00:32:45 provincial governments and not the federal government select the justices appointed
00:32:51 to the provincial king's bench and appeal courts
00:32:53 okay well that's interesting uh you know uh premier smith has talked a bit about this that
00:33:04 you know quebec has some say in a point in the appointments over federal judges in its area
00:33:10 and alberta should too the problem is quebec got that without a constitutional amendment
00:33:14 quebec got that uh because they're quebec they're special uh they get a say over uh supreme court
00:33:22 justices that are appointed for the three Quebec seats. Quebec actually kind of gets a de facto
00:33:27 veto over even Alberta's seat on the on the Supreme Court because they have to be bilingual now and
00:33:33 there's really not many fully bilingual Albertans. It's a very very small number because there's
00:33:40 really no functional reason to outside of like a couple small communities like maybe like
00:33:46 Wacklebish and stuff in the in the northern part of Alberta other than some very small communities
00:33:51 there's not a lot of french mother tongue speakers in alberta and there's no practical reason to
00:33:56 really be learning french growing up in alberta unless your parents want you to be a supreme
00:34:01 court justice or the prime minister like so there's that's literally there's nine supreme
00:34:06 court justices in the country one of which sometimes goes to alberta so one and then
00:34:12 prime minister so like it's a pretty there's like two jobs two job openings where you got to speak
00:34:18 French. Or unless you want to move to Ottawa and be a bureaucrat or something. It's just in terms
00:34:24 of the effort we put into our kids' education, we just don't put a ton into making them fluently
00:34:30 and permanently violating you because it doesn't make any economic sense. You're way more likely
00:34:35 to run into someone who speaks Punjab in Alberta than someone who speaks French. You're way more
00:34:40 likely to run into someone who speaks Mandarin or Cantonese than someone who speaks French.
00:34:45 So anyway, I've got to get, it's kind of a, I'm getting off track here, but Quebec gets 0.99
00:34:52 a big say over the judges, and they even kind of get an indirect say on the judges from
00:34:57 our part of the country.
00:34:59 So what Daniel Smith is asking for here is reasonable, and I do think most provinces
00:35:03 probably would like this power, that our appellate courts, you know, court of king's bench, things
00:35:12 like that uh that the provinces um uh are able to select those justices that makes good sense
00:35:20 this is good this is a good constitutional reform but i don't think it goes anywhere likely because
00:35:26 quebec more or less already gets this without a constitutional amendment just because they're 0.99
00:35:32 quebec and quebec will not agree to amend the constitution for things we want unless they get
00:35:38 all the other things they want and then we're into the big grab bag of issues like meech lake
00:35:42 in Charlottetown, where they're going to ask for things that we can't possibly give them.
00:35:48 Second question. Do you support the government of Alberta working with the governments of other
00:35:52 willing provinces to amend the Canadian constitution to abolish the unelected federal
00:35:57 Senate? Okay. Again, you're going to run into the same kind of political issue around it. Quebec is
00:36:04 not going to allow this, because even if Quebec wanted to get rid of the Senate, they won't agree
00:36:10 to get rid of the Senate on just a one-off issue here because they're going to want all their 0.99
00:36:14 language and cultural issues put in and separate status, asymmetrical federalism. They want all
00:36:21 of that enshrined in the Senate a la Meach Lake and Charlottetown. That's what they want. And
00:36:26 they're not going to agree to give us anything unless they get that. And we can't give them
00:36:30 those things because those things create an even less fair federation. Also, I'm not sure we want
00:36:38 no senate um i mean would no senate be better than the current senate yes it would the current senate
00:36:46 is grossly unfair it's appointed by the prime minister so most of the time it's just appointed
00:36:51 by liberals without any real democratic mandate from alberta so even alberta senators quote unquote
00:36:58 are not they're not even appointed by someone who has the backing of alberta in most cases
00:37:04 And the numbers in the Senate are crazy. Roughly a quarter of the seats are for Ontario. Roughly a quarter are for Quebec. And, you know, the territories, I think, get one each or something. And then things get completely screwy. Alberta, BC, Saskatchewan, I think we get six each.
00:37:27 Alberta alone has roughly three times the population of all four Atlantic provinces.
00:37:34 Roughly three times the population of all four of the Atlantic provinces, Newfoundland and Labrador, Prince Edward Island, Nova Scotia, New Brunswick.
00:37:43 New Brunswick alone has nearly twice the senators of just Alberta.
00:37:51 New Brunswick alone has nearly twice the senators of Alberta.
00:37:55 But Alberta has three times the population of all four of those provinces.
00:38:01 And that's set in stone for all time.
00:38:03 It doesn't change based on populations of a province going up or down.
00:38:07 It's just set in stone for all time.
00:38:09 So the current Senate is practically medieval in the way it's designed.
00:38:15 It wildly discriminates against the Western provinces.
00:38:19 Wildly.
00:38:20 So would no Senate be better? Yes. But here's the thing. There is no functional federation
00:38:28 in the democratic world that doesn't have a balanced upper legislative chamber of some kind.
00:38:36 So the U.S. Senate, the German Bundesrat, the Australian Senate, you know, we're talking
00:38:44 democratic countries that are also federations. Britain is evolving, the United Kingdom is
00:38:49 evolving into a quasi-federation. And so its House of Lords is probably going to need a shake
00:38:55 up at some time too. But among actual federations in the democratic world, every single one has a
00:39:02 functional upper house of some kind that represents the subnational units. In the United States,
00:39:10 it's very simple. Every state has two senators, and that's it. Those senators used to be actually
00:39:16 appointed by the state governments until roughly the turn of the 20th century, then they became
00:39:19 directly elected. I actually think that was a mistake, because the idea was to integrate the
00:39:26 state governments with the federal government, make them coordinate with each other. In Germany,
00:39:30 the Bundesrat, that's the upper house of the German parliament, they don't all have an equal 0.95
00:39:38 number, but the smaller states, small, small ones like Saarland, have more, let's call them
00:39:45 call them senators for shorthand here, they have more than their population would normally
00:39:49 account for, and bigger ones would have less. But the bigger states, you know, like Nordrhein-Westfalen
00:39:54 will have more senators than Saarland, but not as much as of a straight representation by population
00:40:01 the way it is in their lower house of parliament, the Bundestag. So that's another way. And those
00:40:07 senators are directly appointed by the state lander governments. So when there's a state election in
00:40:12 Germany, the delegation to their Senate, the Bundesrat, it turns over. And so you've got
00:40:18 direct collaboration from the state governments into the federal government. There's different
00:40:23 ways of doing it, but they've all got some version of having an upper house representing
00:40:28 the subnational units or subnational governments, and gives some greater representation to the
00:40:34 smaller provinces, the smaller states, the smaller lander. If Canada got rid of the Senate, we would
00:40:40 be the only democratic federation on the planet that i'm aware of that has no upper house and
00:40:47 it's an important function otherwise the big the big provinces or the big states say ontario
00:40:52 california new york in order to invest fallen they would too easily dominate the smaller ones
00:40:59 this is a protection for the smaller and even the mid-size sub-national units so i don't like the
00:41:05 idea of having no senate but i mean if you gave me a straight up or down question between
00:41:09 uh no senate and the current senate i i we'd have to pick no senate the current senate is
00:41:16 under we're a fairly big province in canada not as big as ontario quebec but we're fairly big
00:41:23 but we have less say than even than the big ones and we have less say than the really small ones
00:41:28 so it makes no sense so i don't know uh smith has put forward the position i think it was first
00:41:36 famously put forward by Brad Wall when he was the Premier of Saskatchewan, just getting rid of the
00:41:39 Senate. I'm not sure I like this one. Again, if it's just a binary decision between current status
00:41:45 quo Senate and no Senate, I take no Senate. But I don't think you can have a functional federation
00:41:50 without some kind of functional and legitimate upper house of Parliament. All right, next question.
00:41:58 Do you support the Alberta government working with the governments of other willing provinces
00:42:01 to amend the Canadian constitution to allow provinces to opt out of federal programs that
00:42:06 intrude on provincial jurisdiction, such as health, education, and social services without a province
00:42:11 losing any of the associated federal funding for use in its social programs. That's kind of
00:42:20 something, like that's something that Quebec has actually wanted for itself, not necessarily for
00:42:26 other provinces. But Quebec doesn't really care if other provinces have it or not. You know,
00:42:31 The dynamics have been that they demand it for themselves.
00:42:34 That is something you probably would get the backing of Quebec on.
00:42:37 But, again, they generally will not open the door to the Constitution at all unless they get their grab bag of sovereigntist, Quebecois, nationalist issues.
00:42:47 They're not going to give you anything unless they get those things.
00:42:49 But this is an item Quebec wants.
00:42:53 My problem is that the provinces should lose the associated federal funding.
00:42:59 The federal government should have no role at all in funding health care. It should have no role at all in funding social services because these are areas of provincial jurisdiction.
00:43:10 They are illegitimately involved in funding health care and social services. That is the jurisdiction of the provinces.
00:43:19 The federal government's been allowed to weasel its way in by funding these things on a provincial level.
00:43:29 And then, oh, can you let Dave know?
00:43:36 We've got a 10 o'clock, Dave.
00:43:36 We've got to move that back.
00:43:40 They're able to then attach strings to the funding that's involved.
00:43:43 Well, there just should be no funding, period.
00:43:45 Because if Ottawa is funding something, it should be allowed to attach strings to it.
00:43:48 So the answer is to not allow them to fund it. But I get, you know, some of the poorer provinces, Quebec, Atlantic provinces, Manitoba, they don't want to lose the funding that comes along with it.
00:44:02 So I don't know. I get where she's going on that one. And you know what? This would be better than the status quo.
00:44:09 So I don't want to make the perfect, good the enemy of the perfect, or perfect the enemy of the good. It would be a significant improvement on the status quo. But one of the reasons for this is so that we subsidize other provinces less. That should be something we want. It's just obviously not something most other provinces are going to agree to.
00:44:31 And the last constitutional question, do you support the government of Alberta working with other willing provinces to amend the Canadian constitution to better protect provincial rights from federal interference by giving provinces, giving a province's laws dealing with provincial or shared areas of constitutional jurisdiction priority over federal laws when the province's laws and the federal laws conflict?
00:44:55 i gotta give that one more thought but that one strikes me as potentially negative
00:45:03 and negative in a alberta way in particular um you know a lot of critics of you know alberta
00:45:14 sovereignty uh and you know sovereignty not being just full independence but people you know
00:45:19 daniel smith says a sovereign alberta within a united kingdom a lot of critics of that uh you
00:45:24 you know, pro-Ottawa types, you know, they don't understand, you know, when they say,
00:45:29 well, Alberta's demanding that, you know, a pipeline should go through BC over BC's wishes. 0.61
00:45:37 The idea isn't that, the idea is division of powers, not that the provinces should have
00:45:43 unlimited power. The idea is about clear delineation and separation of powers and
00:45:49 interprovincial infrastructure, you know, infrastructure that crosses provincial boundaries
00:45:55 is supposed to be a federal national jurisdiction. So, you know, perhaps I'm trying to read this
00:46:04 charitably. I'm trying to read it charitably, but I could see areas where this would be
00:46:11 in our favor, but I can see areas like, say, pipelines where this would not be good,
00:46:15 where this would say, okay, well, BC's got some jurisdiction on this and Ottawa's got some
00:46:21 jurisdiction on this. And so BC or Quebec, they just get to veto a pipeline.
00:46:28 Okay. You know, if someone's reading this differently than me, you know, put it in the
00:46:33 comments or call in. I want to hear it out. I could go both ways on this, but the way I'm
00:46:41 reading this one right now, I'm not sure it's good for a functioning federation.
00:46:45 You know, the idea, a good federation should have maximum powers as low as possible, as close to the people as possible at the subnational and at the local levels.
00:46:58 And those subnational units delegate powers to higher levels of government, say the federal government, where cooperation among jurisdictions is required.
00:47:09 Things like national defense, things like foreign policy, infrastructure that crosses boundaries, currency, that kind of thing.
00:47:21 Those are the kind of things that we want delegated to the so-called higher levels of government.
00:47:27 So I see this proposal as potentially problematic.
00:47:32 I'm going to have to suss it out a bit more.
00:47:34 I'm not saying it's not a hard no, but that one's a soft no right now.
00:47:39 I'm not sure.
00:47:42 On some things, it should be pretty clear.
00:47:44 Should Ottawa be allowed to ban paper straws in Alberta?
00:47:47 What possible national benefit does that serve?
00:47:52 You know, why does every province have to have paper, I should say ban plastic straws, sorry.
00:47:58 Why does every province have to have no good straws?
00:48:00 Why does every province have to have paper straws? 0.94
00:48:04 There's no good reason I can think of why all 10 provinces and all three territories have to have the exact same law on straws.
00:48:13 That's an area where, obviously, the subnational units should win out. 1.00
00:48:17 There's no national interest in banning old-fashioned, great plastic straws.
00:48:24 Okay. But, you know, infrastructure crossing provincial boundaries, pipelines, power lines, railroads, highways, canals, these kinds of things, that is a clear area of national interest.
00:48:43 And you can quibble about it if an individual project is a good thing or a bad thing. That's circumstantial.
00:48:49 That's something that should be federal.
00:48:50 So, I don't know.
00:48:52 I think I appreciate the spirit of where that referendum question is coming from,
00:48:57 but I think it's got to be sussed out a bit more.
00:48:59 It's got to be sussed out a bit more.
00:49:01 Okay.
00:49:05 At the bottom, at the end of it all, though, you know,
00:49:07 four of those five constitutional referendum questions
00:49:10 that the Premier is going to put to Albertans in the fall,
00:49:14 I'm a pretty hard yes on.
00:49:16 three of the five I'm a hard yes on
00:49:18 one I'm a soft yes, another I'm a soft no
00:49:21 but here's the thing
00:49:24 we're going to get ignored again
00:49:27 because we just did this a couple of years ago
00:49:29 do you remember when we had this referendum on equalization
00:49:32 that we were going to use
00:49:34 the Clarity Act ruling around Quebec's secession
00:49:37 that says that if a province has a referendum
00:49:41 and achieves a clear majority on a clear question
00:49:43 of constitutional importance
00:49:44 that the federal government and other provinces are constitutionally obliged to negotiate in good
00:49:48 faith on that question. Doesn't mean they have to agree, but it means they have to negotiate in good
00:49:52 faith. Alberta had a referendum on equalization, and a big majority voted to abolish it from the
00:49:59 Constitution. And what happened next? Can we play crickets? Do you have a cricket? You have crickets
00:50:06 on the soundboard can we play crickets i don't know um no oh oh i wouldn't set up i didn't warn
00:50:14 him to do it just just flying by the seat of my pants here it was crickets um now i guess the
00:50:20 fair uh the premier at the time jesus kenny had lost all political capital his premiership had
00:50:26 large was in the process of collapsing uh over his actions during covid over his failure to press
00:50:32 Ottawa harder on a lot of issues, so
00:50:34 he didn't really have a lot of political capital to go
00:50:36 with. But he nonetheless sent
00:50:38 a letter to Ottawa saying Albertans
00:50:40 have voted to abolish
00:50:42 equalization, and let's talk.
00:50:44 I don't think he even got a...
00:50:48 Oh! 0.60
00:50:49 We could do crickets.
00:50:51 I don't hear crickets.
00:50:53 Oh, there was a call.
00:50:54 Oh, his call.
00:50:56 Oh, okay, sorry, I missed the call.
00:50:58 Alright, sorry, if you're calling in, you can call back here.
00:51:00 Sorry, I thought we figured crickets on the soundboard.
00:51:03 Sorry.
00:51:04 We'll be set up for next time.
00:51:06 I love crickets.
00:51:07 Nothing happened.
00:51:10 I mean, if Quebec holds a referendum on a constitutional question, you better believe everyone's coming to the table and we're treating Quebec very politely and nicely and asking them to, you know, maybe negotiate down what they're asking for.
00:51:23 But Alberta did it. 0.90
00:51:25 Big majority voted to scrap it from the Constitution.
00:51:28 And it was nothing.
00:51:30 It was crickets. We didn't even get a letter back from Ottawa. They didn't even tell us to pound sand. They just didn't answer the door. We rang the doorbell and no one came. We heard the party inside. We just weren't invited in. They didn't even open the door. I'm not even sure they peered through the window to see who was there.
00:51:46 so my concern is we're going to hold this these referendum questions and we're going to get
00:51:51 ignored um that's not a reason necessarily to not hold it though i've always said you know like when
00:52:01 i was in the alberta legislature i was i was the first elected member of the alberta legislature
00:52:06 since 1982 who openly supported alberta holding a referendum on independence uh maybe you kids
00:52:14 weren't ready for that. Maybe you guys weren't ready for that, but your kids are going to love
00:52:18 it. It was maybe ahead of its time. But I felt at that time that Alberta needed to start moving in
00:52:25 the direction of independence. But, you know, some people thought it was too soft, the policy
00:52:31 because the policy was called equality or independence. Because some of the more hardcore
00:52:37 of you are not going to like to hear this, but this is the reality. A majority of Albertans
00:52:41 will never vote for independence unless they believe that Alberta has exhausted all other
00:52:48 attempts at good faith negotiation for equality and fairness in Canada first. They're just not
00:52:55 going to be prepared to pull the trigger on a admittedly pretty radical idea of becoming
00:53:03 their own sovereign and independent country unless they are confident that we have tried
00:53:12 everything else first. Similarly, you know, the American founding fathers in the Continental
00:53:16 Congress, they sent the, the American Revolution was shooting for a year before they declared
00:53:23 independence. They were literally fighting a war for a year against the British Empire
00:53:28 for a whole year before they declared independence. And before they declared independence,
00:53:32 they sent the olive branch petition to the king and then the the king responded uh go to hell i'm 0.96
00:53:40 gonna hang you all for treason but they they reached out to the king for redress saying like 0.97
00:53:45 we're your loyal subjects we want to stay a part of mother england the british empire uh we love 0.91
00:53:51 britain we just want to be treated fairly we want representation with taxation i mean see the seats
00:53:57 in parliament or that the 13 colonial legislatures have more power than they currently do and can't
00:54:04 be overridden by parliament and the king. They sent a very reasonable proposal to the king
00:54:10 called the olive branch petition, extending an olive branch of peace to the king. And it was
00:54:16 the king's response saying, to hell with you all, I'm going to hang you all for treason. 0.99
00:54:20 And then the Continental Congress voted with a hook and crook unanimously for independence. 0.99
00:54:29 It's a very different circumstance in Alberta where no one's shooting each other.
00:54:33 No one's talking anything that crazy.
00:54:36 But I think the principle remains that a majority of Albertans will not vote for independence unless they believe that every possible measure that can be taken to make it work in Canada first has been done has been done.
00:54:57 If we don't do that, you know, the moderates who are maybe sympathetic to independence and angry and have grievances with the federal government or other parts of Canada, they're not going to vote for it unless they understand that.
00:55:12 And yes, I'm probably in the chats here.
00:55:14 We're going to get people saying, hey, we've been trying forever.
00:55:16 We had the Reform Party.
00:55:18 We had Social Credit.
00:55:19 We had the Reform Party.
00:55:21 We had the Canadian Alliance.
00:55:22 um you know we've tried all of these things and they've always ignored us you're right and i think
00:55:29 it's a practically zero percent chance that we get major constitutional reform on the senate on
00:55:36 dividing federal provincial jurisdiction on on equalization i think the chances of that are
00:55:41 damn near zero percent it's not happening as long as quebec holds a veto over the constitution in
00:55:48 this country it's not happening because what we would have to do to get those things would be 0.97
00:55:52 giving up even more so uh yeah those of you and i got one guy saying we have done that already
00:55:58 i agree we have but here's the problem uh well i'm not gen z here but you know i've studied
00:56:08 history i i know the history of this you know my family were in the reform party i grew up knowing
00:56:13 about this stuff you know uh you know alberta cora here over 100 years of being treated unjustly 1.00
00:56:21 isn't enough for albertans uh donna donovan kelly you know we've already done that
00:56:29 um majority of the 30 percent devoted were obviously ndp voters i'm not sure what that is
00:56:36 but i mean you know i totally expect this we've tried it all before and we've gotten nowhere you
00:56:42 You know, remember Preston Manning and the Reform Party?
00:56:45 That was started in 1987.
00:56:47 We've tried this forever.
00:56:48 We've gotten almost nowhere.
00:56:51 I agree.
00:56:53 But there's a lot of people who do not have that institutional memory right now,
00:56:57 particularly younger people who get to vote.
00:57:00 They don't remember Preston Manning.
00:57:01 The Reform Party started when I was two years old.
00:57:04 I know this stuff because, you know, I've been a political junkie.
00:57:08 I studied history.
00:57:10 I studied politics.
00:57:12 I know this stuff, and I grew up with a lot of it, but I was still a little kid.
00:57:18 So older people might remember this, but a lot of younger people don't.
00:57:23 And even older people, they've maybe, they've forgotten this.
00:57:26 So, yeah, I agree.
00:57:28 You know, putting forward reasonable proposals for constitutional reform to make things work in Canada is probably a non-starter, just like the equalization referendum.
00:57:37 It's going to go nowhere.
00:57:39 But I think there is value in at least letting the rest of Canada say no.
00:57:46 And who knows? I hope I'm wrong.
00:57:49 I've always wanted Canada to work.
00:57:51 I grew up as a Canadian nationalist.
00:57:54 I grew up loving Canada, believing it was the greatest country in the world.
00:57:59 And, you know, for a time, it probably was.
00:58:02 Although everybody thinks the country is the greatest, at least in the West.
00:58:06 It was a great country.
00:58:07 But that country is lost now. And I don't think it's capable of reforming itself. I think it's probably past the point of no return at this point.
00:58:20 I hope they would say yes. I don't think they will. I think the chances are extraordinarily small.
00:58:27 But I think we owe it to our own history, our own heritage, and our institutions to try.
00:58:36 Just try.
00:58:37 It's, you know, think of it as a marriage is at a total dead end road.
00:58:42 You got to at least go to counseling once.
00:58:43 You got to sit down with a counselor once before the courts will let you go to the courthouse and get your divorce. 1.00
00:58:49 They're going to require you to sit down with a counselor at least once, look each other in the eyes and say, I still hate you.
00:58:58 You know, you got to do that.
00:58:59 And who knows?
00:59:01 Maybe we fall in love again.
00:59:04 Probably not.
00:59:06 But at the very least, at a minimum, even if those of you say there's a zero percent chance, I think it is important that we do this, if nothing else,
00:59:17 so that your fellow Albertans know
00:59:20 that the rest of Canada has no interest
00:59:22 in fixing the Constitution, fixing the country.
00:59:25 Give them the chance to say no.
00:59:28 And who knows?
00:59:29 Maybe I'm naive.
00:59:32 But I think there's probably a 1% chance they say yes.
00:59:35 And I hope it's a lot more than 1%. 0.97
00:59:37 But I think it's about 1%.
00:59:38 They're just not going to do it.
00:59:41 And I hope I'm wrong.
00:59:41 So,
00:59:42 So, yeah, I mean, okay, Missy Forever says the referendum will prove that the Constitution doesn't work because they won't do anything.
00:59:58 I'm not sure that proves the Constitution doesn't work, but it might prove that federal reform doesn't work because they are very likely to do nothing.
01:00:07 People on both sides are going to say, well, the rest of the country will do nothing.
01:00:09 And, you know, the federalists who say, well, why are we holding these referendums?
01:00:13 They're going to do nothing.
01:00:14 Well, you're kind of proving our point. 0.99
01:00:15 The rest of the country doesn't give a shit. 0.99
01:00:18 You're kind of making that point. 0.99
01:00:21 So let the rest of Canada say no.
01:00:23 We have to say yes to compromise ourselves.
01:00:27 We have to say yes to compromise.
01:00:29 We have to say yes to good faith negotiations.
01:00:32 And then we see what they have to say.
01:00:34 It's very likely going to be no.
01:00:36 Very likely going to be no.
01:00:38 But give them the chance to say no.
01:00:39 And if they say no, then, you know, during the independence referendum campaign, when you go knock on a door and someone says, hey, well, I want to work it out, you know, you find someone who's not a elbows up forever Canada guy, you know, people, but you find someone who's a bit more moderate in the middle and they say, you know, yeah, I get independence, but I'm not there yet.
01:01:00 But I really think we should, I really think, you know, we got to make Canada work.
01:01:09 Well, you could talk about the history of the Reform Party and the Wild Rose and all of these things till you're blue in the face.
01:01:19 But chances are most normal people haven't experienced that.
01:01:22 Most people haven't opened up the history books and, you know, remembered Preston Manning railing about a Tripoli Senate in a church basement in 1988, you know.
01:01:34 They're just not going to remember that.
01:01:36 They have to know it for themselves.
01:01:38 So at least to be able to look them in the eyes and say, hey, you probably voted to reform the Constitution, and these guys said no.
01:01:46 So at a minimum, I think it strengthens the hands of an independence campaign if the rest of Canada says no, after we've put forward good faith reforms to the Constitution first.
01:01:58 So that's me trying to be a pragmatist.
01:02:04 But on the logistics of this all.
01:02:06 So this is, I think, what?
01:02:08 It was nine referendum questions, is it?
01:02:11 Nine or ten?
01:02:12 Nine.
01:02:13 I think it's nine.
01:02:15 But we're probably going to have 10 referendum questions, I think, because there is that citizens initiative referendum on independence.
01:02:27 Can't be sure. But if I'm a betting man here, I'm betting they get the signatures to trigger an independence campaign, a referendum campaign, which would also be held probably, I think, at the same time.
01:02:39 October 19th, October 19th.
01:02:44 how is this going to work?
01:02:46 So like nine referendum questions minimum on the same day,
01:02:51 it's going to feel a little bit like California.
01:02:54 California is crazy.
01:02:55 They'll vote on like,
01:02:56 should we build this overpass on this particular highway or,
01:02:59 or this,
01:03:00 you know,
01:03:00 LRT line.
01:03:02 It's a bit crazy how much they vote on things.
01:03:03 Again,
01:03:04 I think there's a,
01:03:05 there is definitely a role for direct democracy.
01:03:07 I don't think it's for every little issue there is,
01:03:09 but that's California.
01:03:11 We're going to have nine.
01:03:13 Where does the independence referendum fit in on that?
01:03:17 Does it get held the same day and it's just one of 10 options?
01:03:23 If so, that would seem an effort to help that referendum probably lose.
01:03:31 I know people can reasonably take both sides of this argument.
01:03:34 I know the federalist side, they're going to say,
01:03:38 these nine referendum questions are designed to help an independence referendum win.
01:03:42 And I've seen some of that from the usual crowd on X. I don't think so. I think it hurts it. Because then it, you know, a bunch of people who would otherwise vote for independence, they can say, well, I'm not all the way there. I'll vote for these more moderate options of we're going to take control of immigration and we're going to demand constitutional reform.
01:04:03 I see it as weakening their hand.
01:04:07 So we don't know the timing because the petition has not been successful in getting enough signatures.
01:04:12 That's ongoing.
01:04:15 I think the way this should work is that if the Premier says we're going to have this, we're going to vote on these nine items October 19th.
01:04:27 um i think if we have a successful petition drive for a referendum on independence which
01:04:36 again i think they're very very likely to get the signatures for that it should be scheduled for
01:04:41 perhaps a month afterwards you know i don't know what day of the week it is but you know roughly
01:04:46 like november 19th as long as it's not a weekend or a holiday or something um november 19th or
01:04:53 early in the new year, something like that. It should be after. So you give Albertans a chance
01:04:59 to vote on these questions here, immigration reform, etc. Okay. And then you've got the
01:05:05 constitutional questions. You've got to give then a little bit of time, a reasonable amount of time,
01:05:12 so maybe more than a month. You also don't want to do it during Christmas. But you have to give
01:05:17 the other provinces in the federal government time to consider these questions? To consider,
01:05:23 okay, Alberta says we want to get rid of the Senate. We want the provinces to appoint
01:05:29 their appellate court judges for their own provinces. We want to allow a clearer separation
01:05:38 of powers on things like health care, social policy, and we want the provincial legislation
01:05:45 to trump federal legislation where there's shared jurisdiction okay uh and then you allow the other
01:05:51 provinces and the federal government time to consider it and if they ignore it or they say no
01:05:56 well then albertans can be informed by that reaction when they go a month two three months
01:06:03 later to vote on the potential independence question they should not be voting on the same
01:06:09 day? Because these are very big things. Why would you vote? Because if people voted for
01:06:15 independents, I know it's a minority opinion right now. We got a poll coming out today.
01:06:18 It's in the mid-30s. It's around 34%, 34, 35. I think it gets up to 38%. We had a poll.
01:06:29 We polled Albertans, a pretty big sample size, 1,500 people. We asked if the pipeline MOU deal
01:06:36 between Daniel Smith and Mark Carney falls through,
01:06:38 how do you vote on independence?
01:06:40 I could be getting this wrong, but off the top of my mind,
01:06:42 I think it gets near 38%.
01:06:44 That's, you know, that's not striking distance,
01:06:47 but that's getting into competitive territory
01:06:50 for a referendum.
01:06:52 But how would, why would you be voting
01:06:55 on constitutional reforms at the same time?
01:06:58 Proposals for constitutional reforms,
01:07:00 and you have no idea how the rest of the country
01:07:02 is going to react to them.
01:07:03 Why would you be voting on those
01:07:05 on the exact same day as independence like that's very conflicting that's sending very conflicting
01:07:12 messages uh also you know if say the reform proposals pass but the independence one fails
01:07:19 then you've you've completely wasted all of your leverage for actually negotiating with the other
01:07:23 provinces so i think what make a lot more sense is that you know the nine questions put forward
01:07:29 by premier smith those get voted on october 19th if we're actually going to vote on all these things
01:07:34 And, you know, as I've already said, I'm not sure they should all be referendum questions. Some of them should just be enacted as policy immediately. But we're going to vote on these things October 19th. And then we give, you know, say three months from October 19th. So say, you know, January 19th, roughly, as long as it's not a weekend or something, something like January 19th, roughly, 2027.
01:07:53 then we can vote on the Citizens Initiative referendum on independence.
01:08:01 And if in those three months the rest of Canada has found Jesus
01:08:06 and we reform the Constitution, we either get rid of the Senate
01:08:11 or we reform the Senate into something democratic,
01:08:14 something with more fair representation to acknowledge
01:08:20 that the country's population among provinces has changed a bit since 1905
01:08:27 when Alberta and Saskatchewan were admitted as provinces
01:08:29 and assigned our senators and never changed since.
01:08:32 But, you know, we reform the Senate, we reform area, you know,
01:08:38 the Constitution around areas of shared jurisdiction, appointment of judges.
01:08:40 You know, we get some significant constitutional reform in Canada.
01:08:46 I'll vote against independence. 0.62
01:08:47 i mean yeah if we could fix this place that's the best i want my canada back
01:08:56 i want my canada back i don't think i'm gonna get it back i think it's gone 0.98
01:09:01 but if we can get our canada back shit i'll vote against independence 0.97
01:09:07 but we're probably not gonna get it i don't know the gong went off in the background something 0.99
01:09:13 big up in the nose. I don't know. Jackson's chuckling here. Look, I'm going to scratch
01:09:18 his beard, his mustache. No, I can't do it. Anyway, pick it on him. We used to have David
01:09:27 Veitsynik sitting here, but we caught him eating noodles once live on air, and we blew up a big 0.99
01:09:32 picture of him savagely eating noodles, and he's been ashamed of it ever since, so he moved his
01:09:36 seat. No one likes to sit there. That's the chair. Anyway, it'd be crazy to have the
01:09:47 referendums all on the same day. Having the referendum for these nine, especially the
01:09:53 four constitutional questions from Danielle Smith, along with five domestic immigration
01:09:58 questions, on the same day as the independence question, makes no sense. That is a bad, bad,
01:10:04 bad idea. Have these nine questions. You know, the first five, you should actually just make
01:10:09 policy and do it. We shouldn't even have a referendum on that. Let opponents of it trigger
01:10:13 an initiative vote if they want to. But either way, have at the minimum the constitutional
01:10:19 questions that Premier Smith is proposing. Have those on October 19th. Three months later in
01:10:26 January, then we can have the Citizens Initiative vote on independence. And there's some flexibility
01:10:32 on the part of the government to schedule when exactly that's going to be. I think that makes
01:10:36 sense. That way, when Albertans go to likely vote on independence, they're going in with their eyes
01:10:42 wide open. We have voted on a series of constitutional reforms that I'm not even thrilled
01:10:48 about, but they're compromises. They're compromises. These are very watered down compromises,
01:10:55 but might be good enough. We put that forward and we see the reaction. And so when Albertans go
01:11:02 to vote on independence, they're not doing it the same day wondering how the rest of the country
01:11:05 would react to these constitutional amending proposals. When they go to vote on independence,
01:11:11 they know how Ontario, Quebec, you know, Manitoba, New Brunswick, Newfoundland, and Ottawa, we know
01:11:18 how they have responded. We know if they have said, yes, these are reasonable proposals and
01:11:24 we're willing to sit down and negotiate in good faith. Or if they've said pound sand,
01:11:28 or if they've just ignored us, again, as they did on the equalization vote.
01:11:36 I think Albertans would then make a much more informed decision.
01:11:39 And frankly, if the rest of the country has told us to pounce and or ignore it,
01:11:44 it probably strengthens the hand of the independence campaign
01:11:50 because the rest of the country will have rejected negotiation at that point.
01:11:55 It was the old policy I ran on.
01:11:57 it was not very successful with in 2019 equality or independence because i know some of you don't
01:12:03 want to hear this just independence without making it very clear and real and visceral
01:12:09 for people in the middle that equality has with other provinces has to be achieved first 0.99
01:12:14 they're not going to vote for independence we're you're you're at uh oh we okay yeah we're gonna
01:12:20 go to a call we got a call now let's uh patch in
01:12:22 hello derek hello who am i talking to uh actually you're touching on exactly my name's uh
01:12:35 jeffy from gp sorry what's your name i didn't hear you clearly
01:12:38 jeffy from gp jeffy from gp how you doing jeffy
01:12:43 good thanks uh great show love the call in format um keep it up i missed cory yesterday but i'll
01:12:52 I'll try and get off work to call into him as well.
01:12:56 Oh, thank you.
01:12:56 What I'm calling about is actually what you're talking about right now,
01:13:00 so you've already touched on it,
01:13:01 is a lot of people are calling for the referendum now, now, now.
01:13:04 And it can't be now.
01:13:06 People need to understand that.
01:13:09 As much as they want it to happen, we're not there yet, right?
01:13:14 We have a lot of the support for it, but we need to campaign for it.
01:13:21 so i just wanted to uh yeah well yeah it's exactly that look i i know i know the independence crowd
01:13:29 i've rolled with these people a long time and i get it you know they want it they they just want
01:13:37 it so bad they want to do it now but you know growing up our parents teach us about uh delayed
01:13:43 gratification you know do you want do you want half a cookie now or do you want a full cookie
01:13:47 later you know after you do your chores and we don't even get if we just have a vote we you know
01:13:54 we get to blow off this steam and then we lose did how much it's good it would suck to lose
01:13:59 i mean even if we do everything right it's still a pretty big uphill battle you know we've you know
01:14:06 the polling we've got coming out today you guys can check it out at westernstandard.news
01:14:09 should be out anytime uh independence it's around 34 on a generic question uh with undecideds
01:14:16 removed and i think as i said i think it gets up to around 38 ish 38 give or take uh if the pipeline
01:14:24 mou between smith and carney falls through okay that's a respectable number that's a big number
01:14:29 but guess what it's not the 51 you need it's not the 51 you need exactly and we're not quebec we're
01:14:36 not gonna get to do this over and over you know like we got one shot so if we're gonna do it
01:14:40 like hold a referendum right now why just just to feel good about it i mean that's that's crazy
01:14:47 let's take the time uh try to achieve reform in canada which i don't think is really possible but
01:14:52 at least make a good faith attempt and maybe we're successful and at the minimum everybody else
01:14:58 could see that we've been rejected with good faith proposals and then you'll have a better
01:15:02 chance at your referendum you know exactly and the more we get uh uh declined from wishes and
01:15:13 let's say the federal election is called within the next uh you know a couple months six months
01:15:19 whatever the referendum will pass after the liberals gain the majority which they will
01:15:26 I guess. So people just need to wait for that full cookie, as you said, in my opinion.
01:15:33 Slow the roll. Let's campaign. Let's canvas. Let's get as much momentum as we can.
01:15:41 Get as much information out there as we can. And I'll leave you with that.
01:15:45 But I do want to say one last thing. Good.
01:15:49 Everybody, get a subscription to the Western Standard and stop watching the CBT.
01:15:54 That's the best advice I've heard all week.
01:15:56 Thank you very much, Jeffy from GP.
01:16:00 All right.
01:16:00 Thank you.
01:16:01 Have a great day.
01:16:01 Thank you.
01:16:02 Thank you, Jeffy.
01:16:03 Yeah.
01:16:04 Well, and you know, the polls are looking pretty good for the federal liberals.
01:16:08 We've got one out.
01:16:09 Actually, we put it out last night.
01:16:11 We put out two poll questions last night.
01:16:12 We polled 1,500 people through Main Street Research, so a very big sample size for Alberta.
01:16:17 uh it had the liberals federal liberals pretty close on the heels of the conservatives in alberta
01:16:25 now uh john pull up the images from those two stories the federal and the provincial one uh
01:16:30 let's pull up the federal one first um i'll throw it up on the screen here i didn't believe it uh
01:16:37 the liberal the federal liberals have never been near tied the conservatives or previous iterations
01:16:43 with the alliance or reform they have never been even close to tied really uh uh since uh
01:16:51 since deepened baker deepened baker wiped the liberals out as a dominant prairie party in the
01:16:57 1950s and and the liberals have not been anywhere close to tied with the conservatives or reform
01:17:02 etc ever since the 1950s so i i i i talked to the pollster keto maybe i was like i i'm not buying
01:17:10 this one and um but the problem is the other questions we asked on say provincial voter
01:17:16 intention or on independence they all kind of lined up with the conventional wisdom it showed
01:17:21 the ucp well ahead of the ndp uh on the provincial voter intention it showed independence in the mid
01:17:27 30s that's that's pretty decent higher than some other polls uh but you know within the realm of
01:17:33 conventional wisdom so actually it's possible i want to see some other polls like just because
01:17:38 we paid for this poll doesn't mean it's the be all end also maybe you know maybe it's wrong but
01:17:42 let's scroll okay let's scroll down show this federal poll here where's the image there it is
01:17:48 so there's federal voter intention in alberta according to this main street poll commissioned
01:17:53 by western standard sample size of 1500 that's a pretty big sample size you could go bigger but
01:17:59 it's kind of diminishing returns at that point so i don't know if that's true uh but i i think
01:18:06 the impact of the liberals winning a majority government and also they're going to get the
01:18:09 majority government like floor crossers anyway they've already got a de facto majority i think 1.00
01:18:13 it's actually already baked in i think people angry at the liberals winning bringing supporters
01:18:17 to independence i think it's already kind of baked into the baked into the price at this point
01:18:22 with independent support so i think the liberals winning again winning a majority
01:18:25 maybe it gives a small bump but i don't think it gives a particularly big bump uh here now
01:18:31 Now, do you have the provincial vote numbers there?
01:18:35 No, that'd be a different story.
01:18:37 That'd be a different story.
01:18:38 All right.
01:18:38 Well, all right.
01:18:39 Don't worry about that for now.
01:18:42 So I think that's baked in.
01:18:44 We got a super chat.
01:18:45 I've never done super chats before.
01:18:47 Let's.
01:18:48 Super chat.
01:18:49 $20 from JP Alberta first.
01:18:51 If Smith was being serious and not just gaslighting Albertans,
01:18:55 she would hold her referendum questions on June 2nd, 2026,
01:18:59 including the Lukasik question.
01:19:01 And October should be for the independence question.
01:19:04 Okay.
01:19:06 Okay, JP, thanks for the super chat, by the way.
01:19:10 I've never done super chats before.
01:19:12 Really appreciate it.
01:19:13 Yeah, if you do super chats, even if you insult me, you can say anything about me.
01:19:19 Well, if you give a dollar, I'm not going to put an insult up.
01:19:22 But, you know, $20, you can insult me.
01:19:24 It costs $20 to make fun of me.
01:19:26 And I will read your comments.
01:19:27 It's, you can make fun of my hair, my beard, the way I talk.
01:19:32 You can make fun of me for money.
01:19:34 I could, I'll be, it's like the dunk tank at the carnival.
01:19:38 I'll be the guy.
01:19:40 I take your point.
01:19:41 I think you're, I think JP Alberta First is saying something pretty similar to what I'm saying,
01:19:45 except he's just saying to do it earlier.
01:19:49 That, you know, she could have her referendum questions along with Lukasik's question.
01:19:54 I don't think Lacan's questions coming up for a vote because he seemed to realize after he got the signatures that he doesn't actually want a referendum.
01:20:01 He had triggered his own independence referendum.
01:20:03 He's like, well, I didn't read the legislation.
01:20:07 So I'm not sure we're actually going to vote on that.
01:20:11 But anyway, so have her referendum questions.
01:20:16 He wants, JP Alberta First wants to do it in June and then have the independence vote in October.
01:20:22 um so i i we're on the same page that those questions should be held before the independence
01:20:28 vote i agree with that uh but i i i think you want more time for a referendum i mean independence
01:20:37 it's a big deal and frankly like the movement i've been in the movement and it's not as old
01:20:45 and well developed as it is in quebec in quebec you know they develop all these cultural institutions
01:20:50 around this stuff and they spent decades before they even had their first referendum you know
01:20:54 then another roughly 15 years before their second referendum and it's been god knows how long uh you
01:21:00 know 1995 they might have another referendum in the next two three one to three years who knows
01:21:06 um more runway is not a bad thing i know some you just you just want to start shooting you just want
01:21:13 to pull the trigger and vote on it now because it's going to feel good but it's not going to
01:21:19 feel good if you get slaughtered and having more time allows a a more thoughtful campaign it allows
01:21:26 people to consider this idea because guess what it is a radical idea forming your own country is a
01:21:32 radical idea radical you know canadians have all been taught radical equals a bad thing anything
01:21:39 that is not you know if you have you have three numbers one two and three canadian always picks
01:21:44 two they always pick what's in the middle you know canadians have been conditioned to think
01:21:48 that anything big, anything aspirational, anything outside the box is bad. Anything radical. Radical
01:21:54 equals bad. And radical often equals bad. Anywhere. But not always. We've done radical things before
01:22:01 that have been good. We've done radical things that are bad. But this is a radical proposal.
01:22:08 And it's going to take time for people to take it in. Because remember, you're talking to your
01:22:13 friends you know uh you know i have a beer with my buddies in my barn we've got a big alberta flag
01:22:20 and wild rose country mud flaps on the wall we sit around we all agree
01:22:23 but a lot of people don't a lot of people don't you know it's uh a lot of people need some some
01:22:34 convincing here and you know in the federalist circles they say well everyone i know is a
01:22:39 federalists they're forever canada and uh we love uh jason kenney and nahi denji and thomas
01:22:45 lukasik and anyone who doesn't think like that is crazy i don't know anyone who's you know not 0.92
01:22:50 a federalist these separatists are crazy i don't know any well guess what we have the same problem
01:22:54 on our side too we roll in our circles and we tend to talk with people who agree with us more often
01:23:00 than not there's a lot of people who've got to be one over here and so having more time especially
01:23:07 after a uh a series of referendum proposals where we're we albertans are being the reasonable ones
01:23:14 proposing amendments to the constitution compromises to make canada work let canada
01:23:20 stew on that let let them give them a reasonable amount of time to consider it and come back to
01:23:25 the table um you know that um give some time for that to happen i know some of you just want to
01:23:33 vote now. It's a bad idea. And I know that's always been the attitude of so many people in
01:23:37 the independence movement. I was in it when it was not a very popular idea at all, when it was
01:23:44 pretty fringe. So, you know, I don't take positions on things to be popular. I've taken
01:23:50 very unpopular positions before. It was not very politically advantageous to do so. But don't just
01:23:57 pull the trigger because it feels good and you want to do it now. Because guess what? It's going
01:24:01 to feel good when you get your referendum scheduled and it's going to feel like shit when you get 0.98
01:24:05 beaten badly you want to set yourself up as Lucien Bouchard said for winning conditions
01:24:11 give yourself the best chance possible that means giving a bit more time and letting this set of
01:24:16 referendum questions go first and give the rest of Canada the provinces and the feds a good faith
01:24:23 uh, period of time to negotiate reasonably. All right. All right. All right. I'm going to leave
01:24:40 it there. I actually have to get back to the rest of my job and try to run this shop here.
01:24:44 Uh, but I've enjoyed the chat this morning. Oh, geez. I got, I've been ignoring text messages from,
01:24:51 uh from john here uh all right okay well i know we have uh okay this oh this that's because this
01:25:03 was on x um uh george uh he's got a long long name here but george uh he says aren't these
01:25:10 referendum questions just proof that smith is completely out of touch with the feelings of
01:25:14 majority of albertans uh they are either that simply her way of dodging responsibility to an
01:25:20 legislature will be criticized by those outside of Alberta. George says Smith has federal political
01:25:26 ambitions. She knows that doing what needs to be done arbitrarily, as is her job, she will have
01:25:33 these policies thrown back at her by her eastern competitors. When she runs federally, she wants 1.00
01:25:37 to hide behind a referendum. If you want to say she's dodging taking a tough position by holding 1.00
01:25:46 these referendum questions? Maybe. You can make the argument. You can make it fairly on either
01:25:51 side. As I said, I don't think there should be referendum questions on these immigration things.
01:25:55 I think we should just do it. Do it yesterday. The constitutional questions, no, those are
01:26:02 rightfully put towards a referendum. I do not agree, though, that she's got any kind of
01:26:07 significant political, federal political ambitions, and she's trying to appease an East. 1.00
01:26:11 a lot of pundits get it wrong about why jason kenny is no longer premier they thought it was
01:26:17 because of covid covid was what pushed it over the top but ultimately it's because he always
01:26:21 had his peripheral vision on ottawa that he saw the premier's chair of alberta as the stepping
01:26:27 stone a way station on the way to the prime ministership he was going to come back to
01:26:31 alberta save alberta unite the parties defeat the ndp uh be popular and then once the federal
01:26:38 leadership the conservative party comes open he could hop over there and it was self-evident to
01:26:43 everyone and and it was we kind of put up with it for a bit but it became very obvious you know he
01:26:49 talked a bit tough for alberta but wouldn't actually do anything uh there's no way in hell
01:26:55 he would have allowed a citizens initiative uh referendum on independence he has made clear even
01:26:59 very recently he would never allow this this is just not allowed these people are hijacking the
01:27:04 system. They're bad people. They should go away. Shut up. No referendum for you. He had his
01:27:09 peripheral vision on Ottawa. And we could see that. And it became tiresome. And when we needed
01:27:15 someone to really fight back against Ottawa on equalization, and then during COVID, he had
01:27:22 nothing but words for Trudeau, really. Words and a few court interventions. But otherwise still
01:27:28 followed the lead of Ottawa on COVID restrictions, vaccine passports, mandates, masking, all this 0.88
01:27:38 crap. He followed their lead. We saw that. We don't see that from Smith. Smith is probably the least 0.95
01:27:45 popular politician outside of Alberta. Even a lot of conservatives, right-wing conservatives in the
01:27:53 East don't like her because she's Alberta first. She might not be all the way there as a full 1.00
01:27:59 Alberta nationalist supporting independence. She's not there. But she has been Alberta first.
01:28:06 Hard for Alberta sovereignty. We got the Alberta Sovereignty Act, albeit a very watered down one
01:28:10 from what was originally promised during the leadership campaign. But we still got it. It
01:28:14 was a significant action. I would have liked the original as proposed, but we still got something
01:28:18 good there. We got the Citizens Initiative legislation making an independence referendum
01:28:27 possible. You know, I really just have a hard time squaring the accusation that she's got
01:28:35 federal political ambitions with her actions, with her language. She would be wildly unelectable 1.00
01:28:42 outside of Alberta. And I like that, because I want my Alberta Premier to see the Alberta
01:28:47 premier's chair as the highest job the way a quebec nationalist sees being quebec premier
01:28:54 as more important than being canadian prime minister i want my premier i want the alberta
01:28:59 premier to see being alberta premier as more important than being prime minister that's the
01:29:04 top job and i and she gives me that she very much gives me at least me that impression um
01:29:11 Um, you know, I, uh, tough on her sometimes, you know, earlier in the live stream, I was
01:29:16 tougher on, on some things, but that's, that's, you know, I, I, you don't even have to be
01:29:22 that charitable to see it. 0.97
01:29:23 Her, her opponents, I'll say she's just crazy Alberta nationalist closet separatist, yahoo 0.93
01:29:29 shooting guns in the air that, you know, her opponents see this. 0.90
01:29:34 So people on her side should also see it for what it is.
01:29:37 I, I don't think that's, I don't think that's a fair accusation.
01:29:40 I don't think if I was her advisor and I am telling her, advising her on how she should prepare the way for a federal run, I would tell her to do the exact opposite of everything she's been doing here.
01:29:57 So I have to respectfully disagree with you on that one.
01:30:02 Okay.
01:30:04 I'm going to pull the plug on it there.
01:30:08 I want to thank you all for joining the show today.
01:30:11 Also, if you're not watching live, I know a lot of you will watch after the fact.
01:30:14 But all those of you who watch live, thank you very much for your comments, your questions, and your call-ins.
01:30:21 I've got to get back to my job.
01:30:23 That's it for today.
01:30:24 Thank you very much for joining.
01:30:25 Remember to go to westernstandard.news, click subscribe.
01:30:28 It's $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access to all Western Standard content
01:30:32 and to support the work that we're doing here in Alberta and across the West.
01:30:36 Thank you very much for joining me, and God bless.