Western Standard - October 31, 2024


Smith’s leadership up for review this Saturday

Topics
Mentioned
Coal, Culture, and Conflict - Grassy Mountain Coal Project in #CrowsnestPass Documentary UCP AGM: Alberta Bill Of Rights - Special Debate

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

171.71

Word count

7,687

Sentence count

440

Harmful content

Misogyny

10

sentences flagged

Toxicity

13

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Join us this weekend as we cover the United Conservative Party Convention in Red Deer, Alberta, where members of the party will vote on whether or not to keep Alberta Premier Danielle Smith as their next leader. We'll also look ahead to the UCP leadership review this weekend, and talk about what we expect to happen at the convention.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 good evening today is october 30th 2024 i am derek fildebrand publisher of the western
00:00:29 Standard and you're watching The Pipeline. I'm joined by my usual good friends, Western Standard
00:00:35 opinion editor Nigel Hannaford. Lots of opinions here. And Western Standard senior Alberta columnist
00:00:41 Corey Morgan. Always a pleasure. All right, it's one of those days where we had no trouble figuring
00:00:46 out what we're going to be talking about. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith faces a leadership review
00:00:52 at a UCP convention in Red Deer this Saturday. Members of that party will give their thumbs up
00:00:58 or down on if they want her to continue as the leader of that party and premier of Alberta we're going to be talking about it perhaps a slightly bigger deal this coming Tuesday Americans will vote in the general election for dog catchers local sheriffs and of course the next president of the United States we're going to break it down about what we at least what we expect and while we do have the results from Saskatchewan they came a little quicker than they did in British
00:01:28 columbia uh the saskatchewan the conservative saskatchewan party has defeated uh the ndp
00:01:34 challengers winning a fifth consecutive term very rare in canadian politics possibly the first in
00:01:40 saskatchewan politics uh we'd have to go back maybe chris old corn is going to come on in a bit uh he
00:01:46 can fact check us if that is the longest running uh continuous government in saskatchewan history
00:01:52 maybe it will be okay well gentlemen uh let's start uh close to home here uh this saturday
00:02:01 uh we're all heading up to red deer covering the alberta united conservative party's convention
00:02:05 they're going to be uh revising the party's bylaws and constitution they'll be voting on
00:02:10 policies and whatnot but the really big item on the agenda is the review of alberta premier
00:02:17 Danielle Smith's leadership. There's been a lot of talk about it. Some, some organizations and
00:02:27 individuals trying to take her down a peg. We'll start with with you, Corey. What do you think we
00:02:33 can expect with Danielle Smith's leadership review this weekend? Again, similar to my prediction
00:02:37 before, I believe she'll come in at over 85% support. I think the organization trying to give
00:02:43 a negative review has been overblown. It's quite different this time than, say, if we're comparing
00:02:48 to when Premier Kenney was in power. There were a lot more upset people. And for example,
00:02:53 Tayback Alberta was organizing. They had large meetings across the province. They were pulling 0.99
00:02:57 people together. None of that's been happening. We've got an AGM with almost 6,000 people coming
00:03:02 out. It's going to be amazing. But to influence that many people, you would have to have a machine
00:03:07 that's been operating for months and we would have seen it. And all I'm seeing is very vocal
00:03:11 individuals and small groups who are upset for reasons I guess that are debatable, good or bad,
00:03:18 but to the point where it would put her at any sort of risk, I just don't believe she's at any.
00:03:23 Nigel, the conventional wisdom, in elections at least, is that high turnout normally bodes
00:03:28 poorly for incumbents. This is different, this is an internal party leadership review,
00:03:34 but I mean it certainly bode, it certainly was not a good sign for Jason Kenney when there were
00:03:39 thousands of people signing up for his leadership review vote they they saw the numbers coming in
00:03:44 and then they knew they were in trouble they changed the rules a few times to try and get a
00:03:47 better result um but generally you know high turnout like this for convention is a bit unusual
00:03:55 uh there's already five and a half thousand people registered probably another thousand
00:03:59 register uh last minute coming in talking six thousand people plus which would make it the
00:04:05 largest political convention in the history of Canada for any political party, federally or
00:04:10 provincially. Ontario parties, you know, much bigger province have never come close to this.
00:04:14 National conservative liberal conventions never come close to this. Do you think the
00:04:19 what do you think is behind the huge turnout expected for this convention?
00:04:24 Actually, I think it is a measure of support for the Premier. You mentioned the earlier
00:04:31 conventions where Mr. Kenny was dressed down. The resentments there stemmed principally, I think,
00:04:42 from COVID and his government's response to it. And that was an issue about which people felt
00:04:49 bizarrely. And it was worth paying the money to go and just put your vote in the no column.
00:04:56 there is not an issue at the moment that I can think of which would make a negatively inclined
00:05:05 person fork out $400 plus go to Red Deer, probably incur a hotel room in order to do what?
00:05:15 Tell Danielle Smith that you don't like the job she's doing. They may not like it,
00:05:20 but I don't think they're prepared to spend $400 on it.
00:05:24 However, people who do want to support the Premier
00:05:27 and who have been alerted partly by some of the columns that Corey has written
00:05:33 and also some of the news articles in the Western Standard
00:05:36 that have been pointing out that there are people who are actively working to undermine her
00:05:41 make supporters defensive.
00:05:44 They say, right, I'm going to go to Red Deer and I'm going to vote for her.
00:05:47 So my expectation, rather similar to Corey's, is that it's going to be very satisfying for her at the end of the day.
00:05:54 She's going to get a good score.
00:05:56 And the people who don't like her don't like her badly enough to spend $400 to say so.
00:06:02 All right.
00:06:03 Well, let's talk about the results she needs.
00:06:06 I know we've discussed this before, and you said 50% plus one.
00:06:10 I mean, that's, you know, generally when a leader is asked, you know, what percentage do you need to stay on as leader?
00:06:16 And that's the answer they give, because that is within the constitution of political parties everywhere.
00:06:22 That's the bar that's set. But no one can maintain the confidence of a party of 50 percent plus one.
00:06:30 Jason Kenney do that, you know, and he's stepped down.
00:06:34 If you're at 50 percent plus one, the next day, the caucus nikes you and it's over.
00:06:38 So we know it's more than 50 percent plus one effectively, but we know it's less than 100 percent.
00:06:45 Rachel Nottingham used to get close to 100% within her party. 0.96
00:06:49 Conservatives, particularly in Alberta, are not such a sanguine bunch.
00:06:54 There's always going to be a chunk to vote against the leader.
00:07:00 I'm not sure there's a magic number, but I think, well, perhaps there is a poison number.
00:07:05 I think, is it 77 or is it 78?
00:07:08 There's a magic number to both Stelmac and Redford God.
00:07:11 I think it was 77 or something.
00:07:13 but I think the real danger zone at this point, that would be maybe 70. It's a little lower,
00:07:20 but then we're talking about a much larger group of people going on. That's a large plurality of
00:07:25 6,000 people. But if she came in at 70%, there's going to have to be some questions asked. And 0.97
00:07:31 this is a trend that you don't like because as a new leader, typically there's a grace period
00:07:35 with members and so on, and that she's obviously not enjoying it. So I think that level is where
00:07:41 you're really going to have to start sweating. I mean, anything above 70, you're still sitting
00:07:44 pretty good with a large crowd like that. Nigel, perhaps not the resignation number,
00:07:50 but what do you think is the trouble number that if Smith hits this number and below,
00:07:56 you know, she's going to be dealing with sniping within caucus and, you know, perhaps organization
00:08:01 against her in the future. Not gone that day, but what number is she safe? Well, certainly she'd be,
00:08:07 I would say she'd be safe at 70%.
00:08:09 You've also got to look at where that 70%.
00:08:11 Remember, Stelmack and Redford both got 77,
00:08:14 and both of them were gone within one year from there.
00:08:17 There could have been other reasons.
00:08:19 True.
00:08:21 You know, given the campaign that we believe has been waged against her
00:08:28 by people who may not necessarily be bona fide members of the party,
00:08:33 buying a membership for the express purpose of embarrassing the premier,
00:08:39 I would have to say, well, how many of the 30% that we're assuming voted against her
00:08:42 fall into that category and make your estimation from there?
00:08:46 Among bona fide, you know, long-term people who buy their subscriptions for five years at a time
00:08:52 and keep on going to the conventions, my sense is that her popularity is very high,
00:08:57 and why wouldn't it be?
00:08:59 Look at the things that she said she would do that she then went on to do.
00:09:03 If that's what you voted for, that is what you got. Why wouldn't you support her? So I would not be troubled at 70%.
00:09:10 Well, both sides will sign up people the last minute trying to get it. I remember, you know, with the battle over Kenny's leadership, both sides were going out and selling.
00:09:19 you know, and both, particularly Kenny dipped into some ethnic groups, take back Alberta,
00:09:27 signing up people who tended to vote conservative, but many of which hadn't been members of the
00:09:31 party. Both will try to sign up people, and maybe it's a wash at the end of the day. Hard to say.
00:09:39 All right, but, so, okay, Smith has been making some pretty big policy announcements in the lead
00:09:46 up to this. These are things I think she always intended to do, but they seem to be coincidentally
00:09:53 time to be right before the leadership vote here to kind of gin up the base. But I think
00:10:01 the media is really missing the area of the party that's not perhaps loved her the most.
00:10:06 And that's kind of the left wing of the party, red Tories, for lack of a better term. She 0.98
00:10:12 She was not, to put it lightly, she was not very strong with them when she won the leadership of the party.
00:10:18 They've never been totally enthralled with her leadership.
00:10:21 She came very much, obviously, from the Wildrose wing of the UCP.
00:10:26 But Red Tories tend to be much less revolutionary and rebellious than the right wing of the party.
00:10:34 They tend to go along with it.
00:10:37 the leader is the leader and they'll back the leader unless there's something so particularly
00:10:41 egregious they can't abide it any longer. Corey, we don't hear much from them, but we tend not to. 0.98
00:10:49 When the red Tories are angry, they tend to operate more in the back rooms and organize
00:10:53 quietly. Do you think she has anything to worry from kind of the left wing of the of the UCP in
00:10:58 this vote? I don't think so. Again, the very far the reddest of the red Tories probably already
00:11:04 left. They're not going to show up. They're perhaps mulling over Ninchy if he's made the
00:11:08 NDP pragmatic enough for them or not. The moderate ones, as you said, they tend to put their heads
00:11:12 down. They'll grumble behind closed doors, but they don't have that conservative habit of saying
00:11:16 we've got to rip out our leaders. I look at past comparisons, for example, with Ralph Klein and
00:11:20 Nancy Bethkowski. I'm going, you know, dating myself. This was early 90s, but that was a hard
00:11:24 fought race and a close race, and it was a red versus blue race. But when that ended, Klein's
00:11:30 initial party review type supports, again, you're getting into the 90%. Like this was very, very
00:11:35 high. Those red Tories just grinned and bared it, even though Ralph Klein took things on at least
00:11:41 very fiscally conservative front. So again, I don't think there's going to be a big threat from
00:11:46 them. There's going to be some people upset. I mean, the EGM is an opportunity for people to
00:11:50 air their concerns. And there's concerns legitimately to be had with the caucus and
00:11:53 Smith's direction. But there's other ways to air those concerns rather than vote to tear them out
00:11:57 the leadership. I think some of the people go that route, you know, rather than, again,
00:12:02 I mean, you got to think, what's the day after then? If you doctor down to 49%, well,
00:12:06 what now? I don't think that'd be the outcome anybody wants.
00:12:10 Nigel, you were the chief speechwriter to Stephen Harper for a long time,
00:12:14 long period of his prime ministership. If you were writing Danielle Smith's speech that she's
00:12:19 going to give before people go out and vote, the way these things work, the leader gets the last
00:12:24 word. The leader gets to give a speech, and they say, now, go vote. You know, they don't, the leader
00:12:28 doesn't speak, and then someone who doesn't like them gets up to speak. The leader speaks, then you
00:12:31 vote. If you were writing Smith's speech, what are the big things you'd want her to be saying
00:12:37 right before these people vote? Well, I'd be wanting, first of all, to remind everybody that
00:12:43 I said I would do these things, and I have done them, and these are some other things that I have
00:12:48 promised to do, and if that's the vision for Alberta that you want, and it's certainly the
00:12:52 vision that i am offering that i am prepared to put stake my name on to make this a better brighter
00:12:59 more prosperous alberta then you need to stay with proven leadership and i am at your service
00:13:07 the things that she promised to do she has always constrained by what is possible so you want an
00:13:16 alberta police force as some of the dissidents within the party very very strong on that all
00:13:21 All right. That's a little easier to promise than to perform, but what she has done is she has expanded the sheriff's service and moved sheriffs into police roles.
00:13:31 You want an Alberta pension plan? Well, when that actually got floated out, not as many people were in favor of that as she probably thought would be.
00:13:44 Well, then, you say you want to represent your voters, maybe it's time to throttle back
00:13:50 on that and build the case.
00:13:53 You could go through the list of the things that she's put out there.
00:13:57 The latest one that she introduced this week, the Alberta Bill of Rights Amendments, I mean,
00:14:01 there are some serious concerns on that, but at least she thinks about the Alberta Bill
00:14:08 of rights and what it means to how you keep the government out of your backyard so maybe there's
00:14:16 some fine tuning to be done on that but nevertheless it is a it shows where her heart is and i think
00:14:24 that where her heart is is where the heart of the voting members of the party is i don't see a
00:14:29 problem coming here so my speech would very much be one of hope and aspiration uh corey uh it's
00:14:37 not unusual to tap and increasingly in Alberta politics is not unusual to tap into different
00:14:43 ethnic or religious groups to kind of support you on mass and something happens in leadership
00:14:48 races where you're selecting the leader it happened when Kenny's leadership was up for
00:14:53 review happens in general elections where you kind of tap into ethnic groups because they can
00:14:58 more so than I'm gonna get in trouble with this old stock Canadians 1.00
00:15:02 people like us you mean yeah you know it they might there's a degree of homogeneity that
00:15:11 they're more inclined to vote in a block due to a community leader telling him to do so as opposed
00:15:16 to exactly and you know there's been some reports in the you know we've reported on the standard in
00:15:22 our newsroom that that there's some Islamic schools that that are bringing people up to
00:15:29 support Smith in the leadership review vote because they're back, you know, because she's
00:15:34 been pretty strided in her defense of independent schooling, choice and education. And, you know,
00:15:41 Christians benefit from that, but also other religions, including Muslims benefit from that.
00:15:47 But I mean, there's been some pretty serious tension, I'm overly generalizing here, but
00:15:52 between conservatives who tend disproportionately to support Israel and Islamic groups, which
00:15:58 disproportionately tend to not. And so there's tension between Muslims and non-Muslims over the
00:16:08 Israel-Palestine conflict right now. And there's a lot of Muslims coming in who are going to be
00:16:12 supporting Smith, expected to support Smith in the leadership review vote. That's certainly
00:16:20 rubbed some people the wrong way. What do you expect to come from here? Do you think you're
00:16:27 going to see, you know, is that going to raise some eyebrows at the convention when we see
00:16:32 large numbers of a particular group coming in to support someone? Or do you think it's
00:16:36 going to be like, oh, great. Tent's getting bigger, welcoming more people in. How do you
00:16:40 think people are going to react to that on the floor? Well, I mean, at least as far as
00:16:42 provincial politics goes, the Israel conflict and such isn't spilling over so much as they
00:16:47 don't expect the premier to step into that mess as much as federally. I mean,
00:16:53 members of the Ontario legislature get removed for supporting Hamas. And then they've been,
00:17:00 yeah, we haven't had that extent happen here to turn it into such a test. There's been Alberta
00:17:03 NDP MLAs who have been quite vocal in their support of Hamas. That's because the NDP is
00:17:07 overloaded with anti-Semites and that happens in every province, but it hasn't blown up here as
00:17:11 it has in other areas. So I'm just saying it's not as much in that particular aspect of a factor
00:17:15 in this AGM. If, I mean, it's something that'll get us in trouble in some ways, there's not so
00:17:21 but it's just pointing out a fact large conservative conventions have not had a big diverse
00:17:26 group in them it's been no older white people for the majority and it's always been a challenge to
00:17:33 try and bring in people from other communities and and uh whether this is viewed as changing that
00:17:38 thing is to move the vote on the leadership if that's what the intent of bringing large amounts
00:17:42 of muslim individuals in you will have to bring in a couple thousand that's what we're talking
00:17:46 about when we're talking about a 6,000 person AGM, that is going to stand out in the room very
00:17:51 dramatically. And I think such, even if the intent might be something somebody kind of agrees with,
00:17:57 they would see that as pretty ill-advised tactic when we're supposed to be discussing the party as
00:18:03 a whole and a lot of other things, and it might not be received well by others. I know others
00:18:06 would label this racist, but no, I just, as you're bringing in non-traditional supporters just to win 1.00
00:18:10 one particular vote, people would find that a bit offensive. I just would be surprised again if we
00:18:16 see a couple of thousand people bust in for an event at that expense to swing a vote. But we'll
00:18:23 see. I mean, if there's that largest segment going on in there, it's going to raise some eyebrows and
00:18:28 people are going to have some discussions about how the party's being managed. All right.
00:18:33 All right. We're going to turn now to the U.S. presidential and many other elections taking
00:18:40 place Tuesday. America likes its elections. They've generally got them every two years, but
00:18:45 actually because they're on a schedule, I think they actually end up having less elections than
00:18:49 we do. They just have bigger, longer ballots where you can do state and federal at the same time as
00:18:54 things turn over. But obviously the big one everyone's always watching is the presidential
00:19:01 race. The polls are in a dead heat. Most of the polls I've seen have got Kamala Harris at 49
00:19:09 Trump at 48, well within the margin of error. Generally the way the Electoral College works. If the two are tied in the popular vote, the Republican wins. But they're not, you know, they're within the margin of error.
00:19:23 It's likely to be a close race. And it's obviously been nasty. Everyone always says, well, this is the most nasty election ever. Everyone says that always in the election that they're in.
00:19:38 I'm inclined always to say, you know, stop clutching your pearls. Everyone always thinks things were more civil in the past. And sometimes they were. I mean, Reagan-Mondale was pretty civil and nice, I think, in comparison.
00:19:50 But in general, these things have always been nasty. But good God, this one is particularly nasty. You know, Kamala Harris saying Trump is a fascist, a Nazi. The most ridiculous thing I've seen to date, I think, in this campaign was Trump has a rally at Madison Square Gardens.
00:20:11 And they say, aha, well, the American Nazi Party also had a rally at Madison Square Gardens in the 1938 or 39 or something. 0.89
00:20:18 You know who else also had rallies at Madison Square Gardens? JFK.
00:20:23 Kamala Harris just had her big kind of end of campaign rally at the National Mall in D.C. 1.00
00:20:29 You know who also had a rally there in the 30s or the 20s?
00:20:33 The Ku Klux Klan.
00:20:33 I mean, it's so like because someone held something, because you have a race, because you have a, you know, because you have a race of cars at Nuremberg doesn't mean the cars are Nazis, even though it's on literally the same grounds.
00:20:51 It's gone pretty nuts.
00:20:54 Maybe we'll just start off with predictions.
00:20:57 We'll start with you, Nigel.
00:20:59 What do you think we're going to see Tuesday?
00:21:00 I think you're going to see a Trump victory.
00:21:03 I think you'll also see it challenged, but I think that Trump will win the Electoral College.
00:21:09 The polls which you spoke of are a measure of popular support, and he may win those too.
00:21:19 Or, you know, he may get a little more than Kamala Harris and that as well. 0.97
00:21:26 But the important thing is to win the Electoral College.
00:21:29 And there I think he has it in the bag.
00:21:33 Unfortunately for Ms. Harris, she does not present well.
00:21:38 She may be a wonderful person, but I'm saying that not because I believe it,
00:21:43 but because that would seem like the, you know,
00:21:45 you must acknowledge that people don't always give all of their best when they're in public.
00:21:51 She may be a wonderful person, great qualities,
00:21:53 but she has not done well in her public presentations.
00:21:58 presentation. She's been, the word salad phrase has been tossed around frequently in her, to
00:22:05 describe her reactions. They're really quite simple questions and you just can't picture this
00:22:09 person as the commander-in-chief. I think people just feel sufficiently uneasy about her that even
00:22:18 though they may not like Trump, they will say, well, it wasn't so bad in the four years that he
00:22:22 was president, maybe that's the
00:22:24 safer choice.
00:22:26 Corey, you know, there's
00:22:28 one of the big risks with name-calling
00:22:30 on politics or
00:22:32 hyperbole about your opponents
00:22:34 is
00:22:35 the story of the boy who cried wolf.
00:22:39 And, you know,
00:22:40 Hillary Clinton said that Trump 0.98
00:22:41 was a fascist. I'm not sure if she used 0.61
00:22:44 those words. She didn't use it directly. I mean, that's a level
00:22:46 that has escalated. They'll talk around it
00:22:48 before. Now they aren't even masking
00:22:50 it. You know, misogynist,
00:22:51 sexist, racist, isms, ists, did all of that. And then we had four years of him. I mean, 0.99
00:23:00 it's certainly turbulent, colorful. These are, I mean, it was an unconventional four years
00:23:10 in some negative ways and some positive ways too. No wars. Last time that happened was Herbert Hoover.
00:23:18 So, you know, it's been a long time since we had a president that didn't get American wars, strengthened the border, economy did pretty well.
00:23:29 But there was a lot of turbulence.
00:23:31 But I don't recall any death camps.
00:23:34 I don't recall Trump invading Poland at any time.
00:23:39 None of these things happened.
00:23:41 But the rhetoric now is even more extreme.
00:23:43 Do you think, how effective is this, you know, the rhetoric coming from Kamala Harris and her surrogates that this man is Hitler, you elect him, it's going to be the Fourth Reich.
00:24:00 How effective is that when he's actually had four years and none of those things, even close to passing? 0.61
00:24:05 I don't think it's effective, and I think it's showing some desperation on the part of that campaign, actually, because they're not fools.
00:24:11 they got some smart strategists in there. And I think they're not liking some of the numbers
00:24:15 they're seeing or how close it's going to be. I mean, I say on my show quite regularly,
00:24:18 and it always gets me a bunch of emails from viewers who get upset. I'm not a fan of Trump.
00:24:22 I'm not warm on him. But if I were an American voter, and I'd watch this particularly, as you
00:24:27 said, but the ludicrousness of a headline on TV showing this was where a Nazi rally was held,
00:24:33 you know, almost 100 years ago, thus, I mean, the effort they went to, to put the word Nazi
00:24:37 and Trump into the same sentence. People see through that. And that might take me from where
00:24:43 I was thinking, I was going to watch something interesting on TV that night, but you know what?
00:24:46 I'm going to get up and cast a ballot for this man because I'm just sick of this. That's above
00:24:50 and beyond ridiculous. As you know, yes, he's been in for four years and he didn't necessarily 0.83
00:24:55 impress everybody during those four years, but no, he didn't do anything crazed despite what
00:25:01 everybody accused him. He didn't invade any countries. Actually, ironically, of all things,
00:25:05 as unstable as he might seem, he's one of the least hawkish type of politicians we've seen in the United States in a long time.
00:25:10 He seems quite averse to putting American soldiers in danger in any circumstances, whereas Obama certainly didn't hesitate to.
00:25:22 Okay.
00:25:24 Actually, just to the point about the fascists, I wonder if people actually know today what a fascist is.
00:25:31 It's never been well-defined, both when fascism was a thing today and every time in between.
00:25:38 You know, it's hard to say.
00:25:39 There was a U.S. senator who put out a tweet, and unfortunately I didn't bring it in with me,
00:25:43 but if you actually know what a fascist is, and then you watch the Democrat campaign,
00:25:50 they want to jail Trump, want to get rid of the Electoral College,
00:25:54 they want to, what was it, pack the Supreme Court.
00:25:57 He went on about three months ago. That was where the fascism was in the democratic platform.
00:26:06 Now, you don't want a politics 101 course on the definition of fascism.
00:26:09 It's just funny how these things get tossed around as a slur. Nothing more.
00:26:14 I think where a lot of people go wrong in calling everything fascist is just a misassociation with authoritarian.
00:26:22 Justin Trudeau, I believe, is an authoritarian. I don't believe he's a fascist.
00:26:25 A fascist, I can't even say that is a very specific thing, but it is not this thing.
00:26:32 It's a particular brand of authoritarianism, and authoritarianism is very broad.
00:26:37 It includes communist regimes, fascist regimes, military juntas, and certain democratic regimes that can be perfectly democratically elected, but employ, you know, the Indian government is arguably fairly authoritarian.
00:26:52 they still have elections, fascism isn't merely the absence of elections. It's a lot of different.
00:27:01 Hitler won the 1933 election fair and square. 0.90
00:27:06 It's an abuse of the term and it's ruining people on proper history anyways. I mean,
00:27:11 if they want to look and see what the Mussolini administration was about and some of those,
00:27:15 and it's being lost because it's being tossed at anybody and everybody. We're seeing it in
00:27:18 Canadian politics being thrown around, too. 0.94
00:27:20 It's getting to the point where I won't vote for someone unless the left calls them a racist and a fascist and a sexist.
00:27:26 If you don't get called those things, it means you're probably way too vanilla for me to vote for.
00:27:31 It's sad.
00:27:33 I don't want the guys I vote for.
00:27:34 I don't want to say I am a fascist, racist, etc.
00:27:37 But if they're not getting called that, that means they're not doing a very good job.
00:27:43 Communications, right?
00:27:44 Another one.
00:27:44 So this is going to come down to a couple.
00:27:47 It's electoral college.
00:27:48 everybody likes to look at the big line numbers, 49 Harris, 48 Trump, that actually doesn't matter.
00:27:56 I mean, theoretically, you could, there's actually been, what did Abraham Lincoln win?
00:28:02 It was very little, but at that time, it was a very fractured party system. You had the Republicans,
00:28:06 you had the Whigs, you had Northern Democrats and Southern Democrats. It was a very fractured
00:28:13 system, but you can win the, you can become president of the Electoral College, like in
00:28:18 Canada, Justin Trudeau is prime minister with, you know, low 30s. You don't need anywhere close
00:28:25 to a majority. It's going to come down to a few things. I'm putting Ohio pretty, I think if the
00:28:33 Republicans don't win Ohio on Tuesday, that means they're not winning, but I think they're going to
00:28:37 in Ohio. But if they also take Pennsylvania, you know, there's a few paths for Trump to win on
00:28:46 Tuesday. There's not as many paths to victory for Kamala Harris. Nigel, how do you think the math is
00:28:55 looking through the different routes to victory for each party? Well, that is actually the basis
00:29:01 of my earlier prediction that Trump was going to take it. You mentioned Pennsylvania. The media
00:29:07 has played down the attack on trump that clipped his ear and could easily have clipped his skull
00:29:15 and forgotten about it in pennsylvania nor his response to it and how he went back and greeted
00:29:21 the people who had survived comforted the people who had lost individuals in that in that attack
00:29:29 i would be quite surprised if trump does not take pennsylvania kamala the issue there is fracking
00:29:40 kamala harris has said she won't end fracking but on the other hand she said that she would end 0.95
00:29:46 fracking for about the last 10 years and certainly in the last 10 weeks that she's had a change of 0.99
00:29:51 heart on that people are stupid and i suspect that pennsylvania will go ohio yes um 0.99
00:29:58 probably Vance is helping there as well as a true son of the state. Virginia, 1.00
00:30:06 there was an important case this morning. Yeah, that's still probably staying blue.
00:30:12 Well, I mean, if the Democrats lose Virginia, it's over.
00:30:16 I will see what difference it makes when they take out the people who are not actually citizens 1.00
00:30:22 and shouldn't be voting. So it's true. I can see. But Virginia has become a blue state largely
00:30:27 because it's civil servants working in the federal government, people working for the
00:30:33 government, tend overwhelmingly to vote for leftist parties that are more favorable to
00:30:37 bigger governments and more employees, more benefits, etc. So I think it would take a lot
00:30:42 to flip Virginia. If we look, if tomorrow night, somehow, if Virginia goes red, there
00:30:50 is almost no path for Kamala Harris to win without Virginia, because that's been in the 0.92
00:30:55 solid blue column since... Did George W. Bush win Virginia?
00:30:59 It may have been the last time.
00:31:02 It's been a long time since the Republicans won Virginia.
00:31:07 We're going to move on to Saskatchewan election in a second, but
00:31:10 I actually want to talk about the assassination really quick, Corey.
00:31:15 That was a seminal moment in American history.
00:31:18 It's already probably one of the most iconic photographs in world history
00:31:23 ever do we just have the attention spans of goldfish like we're not even like we're not
00:31:30 even really thinking about it anymore that that was such a huge huge issue but I think uh was
00:31:37 Joe Biden still technically the democratic nobody when that happened he was yeah just things have
00:31:41 just changed so much since uh like why is this not you think playing a bigger role there's just
00:31:47 been so much it's just overload and it was quite a moment I mean it was a moment as I said as me
00:31:53 as a person who didn't think highly of Trump,
00:31:54 and I certainly wouldn't want him shot,
00:31:56 but that moment actually when this guy,
00:31:58 he gets shot, he gets up,
00:31:59 and he's, I probably would have been curled fetal
00:32:01 and screaming, and he's up and defiant and yelling,
00:32:04 and I had to admit, that's a strong-looking, defiant man.
00:32:08 That made me think, yeah, if I were a voter,
00:32:10 I'd be more inclined to lean that way.
00:32:12 How long that effect held or resonated with people,
00:32:15 it remains to be seen.
00:32:16 I worked for, again, it's so hard.
00:32:19 The Electoral College,
00:32:21 I spent a lot of time in Pennsylvania.
00:32:22 and it's a complicated state.
00:32:24 The west side, Butler is just north of Pittsburgh.
00:32:27 That's good blue-collar country.
00:32:30 That's, you know, old rust belt now, steel, and then manufacturing, and getting all the
00:32:35 way in.
00:32:36 But then you get towards Philadelphia and that.
00:32:39 Now you've got a high immigration population, a lot more, again, government jobs, civil
00:32:45 service, that sort of thing.
00:32:46 And the recent thing with, at least they're really trying to bring it up, is enraging
00:32:50 Puerto Ricans.
00:32:50 So if Philadelphia has hundreds of thousands of people of Puerto Rican descent, will that impact them or not?
00:32:56 I don't know. But I don't think any undecideds have swung in the last month.
00:33:01 I really don't. That polarized country is already the people who've made their camp minds up.
00:33:06 There's always some who poll as undecided. Those are the people who don't vote.
00:33:09 And the amount of movement between those two camps has been so limited.
00:33:15 And I just, it always astounds me, a country that big and diverse and how close their elections always are.
00:33:21 It's amazing.
00:33:22 So it's tough to make a call.
00:33:23 I mean, with Nigel, I think it's going to be a slim, I think, victory for Trump based more on the Electoral College than perhaps on popular vote.
00:33:30 But it's going to be close.
00:33:32 I certainly wouldn't, you know, I'm not a betting man.
00:33:34 I wouldn't want to put more than $10 on it.
00:33:35 okay all right well we're gonna turn towards uh saskatchewan now who uh just uh on our tuesday
00:33:43 i think it was tuesday had um was it tuesday chris uh it was decided almost early tuesday morning
00:33:49 but now it's monday night but uh yeah i think i call it till about 11 40 for the sass party
00:33:55 okay well we've got uh i kind of got ahead of myself here we've got uh the western standards
00:33:59 a saskatchewan reporter and uh managing editor of the saskatchewan standard chris old corn here uh
00:34:05 who has been doing God's work on the ground reporting on the Saskatchewan election.
00:34:10 Chris, it was, I mean, I really hated our segments with you for the first two weeks of the campaign.
00:34:17 Not because you're boring, but because what we were talking about was so boring.
00:34:20 The Saskatchewan election was unbearably boring,
00:34:24 as is often the case when you've got a government seeking its fifth term.
00:34:29 But, you know, the NDP became, you know, actually, let's talk about the polls.
00:34:35 the polls that were out there were showing the NDP was going to win. There was modeling based on it
00:34:39 showing the NDP winning a majority government. They won some more seats on Monday night, but they
00:34:46 came nowhere close to winning. Why do you think the pollsters got it so completely wrong in
00:34:51 Saskatchewan? Because the polls that had the NDP up are not as reputable as other pollsters who had
00:34:58 the SAS party leading. The other thing as well is that those polls overly represented the two
00:35:05 urban cities, Regina and Saskatoon, which is where the NDP won most of their votes. As a matter of
00:35:13 fact, those polls that showed the NDP was going to win had them in the popular vote, even as high
00:35:18 as 50%. Right now, we're counting the mail-in ballots, but they are sitting at about 39%,
00:35:24 which is much more accurate to other pollsters, such as Angus Reid,
00:35:29 who predicted the election with a much greater degree of accuracy.
00:35:35 All right. So they didn't all get it wrong then. But the ones we were seeing,
00:35:38 I know CTV was reporting on polls regularly. I kept on sending you these saying,
00:35:44 what do you think, Chris? And you're like, ah, they're BS. These are no good.
00:35:49 And I don't know. I'm not from Saskatchewan. We're next door here in Alberta. But I kept on seeing these thinking, it's looking tight. What do you think was, what were the defining moments of the campaign that shaped how things worked out?
00:36:08 I think that the Belgoni changing room story was actually where the campaign turned. And I think
00:36:14 that also galvanized SAS party supporters when they saw what was going on there with
00:36:22 biological boys in the grade seven female changing room. And then the very next day,
00:36:27 after we broke the story, Scott Moe is coming out saying that there's going to be a ministerial
00:36:30 order protecting biological boys and boys change rooms and biological girls and girls change rooms.
00:36:37 That then became the story basically for the rest of the election.
00:36:42 And up until that point, the SAS party was talking about, you know, reducing your income tax and extending the small business, you know, tax break by 1% for an extra year, like stuff that income tax is not sexy.
00:36:59 people very rarely pay attention to it and most don't even understand how it would even
00:37:04 change their financial picture other than you tell them it's going to save them 800 bucks a year
00:37:08 but they have to make exactly 72 000 to save the 800 bucks so things like that the average person
00:37:15 on the street doesn't really understand and they hear the word income tax and i think oh my goodness
00:37:20 is it april and then they just tune out and fortunately for the sas party there was a couple
00:37:26 issues that came up halfway through the campaign that they were able to galvanize their supporters
00:37:31 around. The NDP ran an interesting campaign, though. They had their traditional lefty,
00:37:39 socialist, democratic promises, more spending on X, more spending on Y. But they had a few things
00:37:45 that surprised me. And you get these from Prairie New Democrats sometimes, like on the gas tax,
00:37:52 where they tried to outflank the Saskatchewan party on the right.
00:37:57 Yeah, they've been actually calling for a gas tax cut for probably around two years at this point to help with affordability.
00:38:03 But that's the money that goes towards our roads here in Saskatchewan.
00:38:07 And unfortunately, we only have 1.2 million people that live here and we have a lot of space to build roads.
00:38:13 So it's even a hard sell for the NDP to talk about cutting the gas tax because people already know here like how crappy the roads can be in certain areas.
00:38:23 And if you start cutting the gas tax, you start cutting road repairs.
00:38:27 And that's a hard sell here because there are roads that are really bad in this province and the gas tax fixes them.
00:38:35 Nigel.
00:38:37 I think you had it.
00:38:38 Yeah, well, I was thinking about that gas tax promise.
00:38:43 These promises have to be believable, and when the NDB comes along and has what appears to be a very, you know, central casting playbook of socialist ideas, and then they turn around with a very conservative thing like saying, we will cut your gas taxes, it doesn't seem to fit somehow, and that lowers the credibility, not merely of that one promise,
00:39:09 but all of the entire campaign strategy.
00:39:16 The point that I took out of that result, though,
00:39:22 was that unlike Prince Edward Island, I'm sorry, New Brunswick,
00:39:27 where the premier came out quite strongly on the matter of parental authority
00:39:34 and being required for name changes when kids wanted to transition and so forth,
00:39:39 And he lost his election, and people said, well, anybody who took a stand on that is going to pay for it.
00:39:45 But in Saskatchewan, they didn't pay for it.
00:39:50 What do you think the difference was?
00:39:52 Saskatchewan is the most conservative province in Canada.
00:39:55 Sorry to disappoint you out in Alberta there.
00:39:57 But as far as you look at the federal votes, this entire province goes blue, including Regina and Saskatoon.
00:40:07 I think things like the gas tax that they were promising was actually an attempt to try and get some rural voters.
00:40:13 It just didn't work.
00:40:14 They were completely shut out.
00:40:16 Even places where they were expected to pick up a couple of rural seats, they lost them all to the SAS party.
00:40:21 And some of them they lost very convincingly.
00:40:23 Tim McLeod and Moose Jaw, it was favored that the NDP were going to win that.
00:40:28 He won a seat by almost 2,500 votes.
00:40:32 So the pollsters were really wrong on the NDP in this province.
00:40:35 What happened in Balguni?
00:40:38 That's the change room.
00:40:39 Yeah, no, no.
00:40:40 That was an NDP seat.
00:40:43 Is it still an NDP seat?
00:40:45 No, it was not an NDP seat.
00:40:46 It was White City, Fort Capel. 0.81
00:40:48 It was a redesigned seat, though.
00:40:50 So what happened was Christine Tell, she lost the rural part of her riding 1.00
00:40:56 and just had her riding inside a vagina because of the way that the redistribution happened. 1.00
00:41:02 And a matter of fact, there was actually a couple of ministers that basically lost their seats up in Saskatoon simply because they had the rural part of the riding cut out. 0.98
00:41:10 So they lost a good chunk of their conservative support.
00:41:14 Actually, this election was not as good for the NDP if we would have been using the old election map,
00:41:20 because there was there was multiple seats in both the outskirts of Saskatoon and Regina that the NDP got slaughtered in in the last election by thousands of votes.
00:41:31 But when you redesign where the boundaries are, they ended up actually picking up seats.
00:41:37 So this is not as impressive as a win for the NDP as they think it is, if you actually consider the way that some of the boundaries were redrawn, including White City for Capel, which the SAS party held on to it.
00:41:51 But unfortunately, they lost Minister Christine Tell.
00:41:55 All right, Chris. Well, thank you very much.
00:41:57 Thank you for all the work you did during Saskatchewan's election there.
00:42:01 you get to take a little break, and then we're going to get you right back to the good work you
00:42:05 do. Thank you very much. Have a good afternoon. All right, gentlemen, before we leave, it's time
00:42:10 for our parting shots. We'll start with you, Nigel. A delightful picture that Laureen Harper sent in,
00:42:16 showing her cat trying to stare down a cougar through the window. That is,
00:42:22 that was one of the best pictures I've seen this month. All right. Yeah, I think that's,
00:42:28 well, we won't name where it is. Some people don't, but it's in, let's say the greater Calgary area.
00:42:34 Corey, your parting shot. Well, I noticed that Canada Post, which lost over $700 million last
00:42:41 year, their union has now put out a strike mandate. Canada Post even offered them 11.5%
00:42:48 for these flyer delivery boys to carry on in their obsolete service, which is poorly conducted to
00:42:53 begin with, this should be the time when Canadians say, you know what, maybe it's time we cut that
00:42:59 service down to the tiny shell of what it should be for some remote areas, because they've pushed
00:43:03 it too far. This is absurd. I mean, for you guys to be demanding more money when you've got an
00:43:08 organization that's bleeding like that is, well, it's a reunion, guys. So yeah, here's my parting
00:43:13 shot, guys. You're shooting yourselves in the feet this time, I think, because Canadians are tired of 1.00
00:43:16 All right. And for me, I just want to remind everyone that Alberta NDP leader, Naheed Entry, still doesn't have a seat.
00:43:26 There's a by-election taking place. It hasn't been called yet.
00:43:31 But the Alberta NDP leader, he became leader, Entry became leader in roughly May or so, with a huge mandate from New Democrats to lead that party.
00:43:42 And he says he wants a Calgary seat.
00:43:44 The ADP have lots of Calgary seats, yet not one has seemed to open up for Nenshi.
00:43:51 So, I don't know.
00:43:53 He's either got to get someone to open up a seat for him here, or he should go around in Lothbridge.
00:43:57 Pick one.
00:43:59 All right, gentlemen.
00:44:00 And thank all of you for joining us today.
00:44:03 Remember, the Western Standard refuses to take Justin Trudeau's federal media bailout money.
00:44:10 We rely on memberships from people like you to do the work we do.
00:44:14 We are one of an extremely, extremely small number of genuinely independent media left in Canada that do not take the federal government's media bailout subsidies.
00:44:23 If you want to see us continue doing our work, please go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:44:28 Click on subscribe.
00:44:29 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year, and you'll get unlimited access to all Western Standard content straight through that pesky paywall.
00:44:37 and you'll be doing your part to put your money where your mouth is
00:44:41 and help support the work that we're doing.
00:44:43 Thank you very much for joining us today and God bless.