Western Standard - September 16, 2022


SNP EP2: The Great Sovereignty Act Debate

Topics
Mentioned
The Pipeline: Poilievre's landslide win Manufacturing dissent on your dime? Another Liberal racket

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 11 minutes

Words per minute

189.51

Word count

13,460

Sentence count

222

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Western Standard, host Sean Newman sits down with Derek and Michael Binion to discuss the Alberta sovereignty act. Derek is a Calgary lawyer specializing in Charter and Constitutional issues, co-author of the Free Alberta Strategy, and founder of Questair Energy, a public oil and gas production company operating in Quebec. Michael is the CEO of Modern Miracle Network, which advocates for a reasoned conversation around energy policy in Canada.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 well good evening and welcome to the sean newman show on the western standard we are talking the
00:00:15 alberta sovereignty act tonight i'm joined by two guests we'll bring them in the studio here in a
00:00:20 quick minute first derek from he's an alberta lawyer specializing in charter and constitutional
00:00:25 issues. He is one of the authors alongside Rob Anderson and Barry Cooper of the Free Alberta
00:00:30 Strategy, a strategy penned back in September 2021, which a cornerstone of it was the Alberta
00:00:36 Sovereignty Act. And alongside him today is Michael Binion, a charter accountant, president
00:00:41 and founder of Questair Energy, a public oil and gas production company operating in Quebec. He is
00:00:46 also the CEO of Modern Miracle Network, where they advocate for a reasoned conversation around
00:00:52 energy policy in canada welcome aboard gentlemen i hope i got all that right for you thank you sean
00:00:58 good to be here now i want to remind you two fine folks just as i did uh the previous weeks uh when
00:01:06 i had the three other gentlemen in this is this is a conversation uh so obviously be respectful and
00:01:11 and try not to talk over one another and all that good stuff but i really want to point out i don't
00:01:16 want it to be like ping pong i don't want it to come back to me every time if you guys get into
00:01:21 conversation that's what i'm here to facilitate i'm here to learn just as much as the listener
00:01:25 and i i got your two minds for the next however many minutes we can we can squeeze out of you
00:01:30 and i certainly want that to be where the topic uh or the conversation remains with all that being
00:01:36 said uh since june 15th the alberta sovereignty act has dominated headlines and in recent weeks
00:01:42 you've had everyone weigh in i mean from the living last living signatory of the canadian
00:01:47 and Charter of Rights and Freedoms, Brian Peckford, Premier Jason Kenney,
00:01:50 Lieutenant Governor of Alberta, Selma Lakhani.
00:01:53 Recently, a press conference that had four of the leadership candidates all come out,
00:01:57 Taves, Gene, Sani, and Ahir.
00:01:59 And here are some of the things they've been saying.
00:02:02 It will create anger and disillusionment amongst Albertans.
00:02:05 It will only set us back, risky and hot-headed, selling a fantasy.
00:02:08 I don't know if I need to keep going. You kind of get the point.
00:02:10 Derek, I see you laughing. You're one of the guys who helped pen this thing.
00:02:14 What are your thoughts? And we'll start there.
00:02:16 And Michael, feel free to jump in as we move along.
00:02:20 Well, I think my initial thought is none of them have actually read it.
00:02:24 And I mean, two things by that.
00:02:26 First off, the Alberta Sovereignty Act is just an idea at this point.
00:02:32 There is no Alberta Sovereignty Act, no pen to paper.
00:02:37 And so they're critiquing something that's hypothetical.
00:02:41 And so these bold claims that it's unconstitutional, it will lead to separation and angst, sure, there's no Alberta Sovereignty Act yet.
00:02:53 Now, I think the other important thing, indicating that none of these candidates that talk this way have actually read the strategy, is that the Alberta Sovereignty Act is one part of a larger strategy, and that is the Free Alberta Strategy.
00:03:10 And I just need to maybe give you an idea of the impetus behind that.
00:03:17 And the Free Alberta Strategy was born of the frustration of Albertans.
00:03:24 I can remember after the first time that the current prime minister won the election,
00:03:32 there was a lot of angst in this province.
00:03:35 And the most recent win that he had, again.
00:03:38 And it seems like Albertans have felt, and this is broadly felt by many Albertans, that the federal government is deliberately trying to shut down our oil and gas sector.
00:03:54 I mean, this is our primary industry.
00:03:57 This is how families are fed in this province.
00:04:00 And there is a deliberate strategy to end that, end within a certain period of time.
00:04:07 And so there's that problem. And so we're hearing from Albertans that what can we do to solve this?
00:04:17 And we looked at the current premier strategy and strategies from previous premiers was basically just to express discontent in some fashion.
00:04:28 There might be a meeting between bureaucrats or high ranking officials and ministers or maybe even the premiers.
00:04:37 but in the end this this is a ratchet it moves one way at least that's the feeling the perception
00:04:43 amongst albertan voters and so the free alberta strategy was a practical implementable plan
00:04:51 a strategy that is not fully fleshed out but it was a strategy to to unify a number of groups of
00:04:59 people now the first group of people are those that were just they want to separate at any cost
00:05:06 What, what can we do?
00:05:07 How do we solve this problem while we leave Canada?
00:05:09 We take our toys and go home.
00:05:11 Well, those, those sorts of folks, um, they've made up their mind, uh, and, uh, they, they
00:05:18 want to do so, but there's a whole other group of Albertans who are equally
00:05:22 frustrated with the federal government who will never separate under any circumstances.
00:05:27 And, uh, I think many of us fall into that category where I would find it very
00:05:31 difficult, not cheering for team Canada at the Olympics.
00:05:34 for instance, like I would find that very difficult.
00:05:38 I have clothing that has the maple leaf on it.
00:05:42 I would find it difficult to turn my back on that.
00:05:45 So I think that's one group of people
00:05:50 that maybe many of us fit into
00:05:53 is that we're not gonna separate under any reason.
00:05:55 But now there's a third group of people
00:05:57 and I think this is where most moderate Albertans
00:06:00 have been pushed of recognizing
00:06:03 we have a real problem here we need to do something about it what can we do and so the free alberta
00:06:10 strategy is an entire strategy document that will allow a provincial government in this province to
00:06:17 develop ways to increase its independence by pushing the federal government back into its
00:06:25 areas of jurisdiction. So this is the idea. Currently, our view was that the federal
00:06:33 government is acting lawlessly. This lawless action has resulted in the erosion of provincial
00:06:40 rights. It's a ratchet. It goes one way. And this erosion of provincial rights has no sign of ever
00:06:48 stopping it's been a honestly it's been a 100 year process and albertans have complained about this
00:06:56 for a hundred years and of late it's really picked up steam and and moved quickly and so the the whole
00:07:05 free alberta strategy is intended to keep the federal government in its lane and its constitutional
00:07:11 lane as defined by section 91 through 95 of the constitution act 1867 and so that that's
00:07:19 the impetus behind the the project it is not an attack on the rule of law quite frankly it is
00:07:25 exactly the opposite of that it is a maintenance of the rule of law it is not unconstitutional
00:07:33 for two reasons one a declaration of unconstitutionality is something that a court
00:07:39 decides there's no act yet nothing can be declared unconstitutional secondly all pains will be taken
00:07:47 to make sure that it's drafted in a way that will comply with the constitution and give the power
00:07:52 back to Albertans to decide whether or not they think the federal government is acting within its
00:07:58 own jurisdiction and so it's not unconstitutional it's not an attack on the rule of law and quite
00:08:04 frankly, I'm not certain the way that we've laid it out that it's not going to cause economic
00:08:11 chaos. It'll increase the certainty in the market because it'll force the federal government
00:08:17 to actually deal with Alberta's very legitimate concerns with how the federal government is
00:08:23 impacting upon provincial rights. Well, what do you think, Michael? You're sitting there
00:08:28 listening to Derek. What are your thoughts here in some of the things he's tabled here early on?
00:08:34 well there's there's a there's a whole bunch of points there right and um and you know i would
00:08:41 say my first of all i talked to all the campaigns and i would say all the campaigns have read the
00:08:46 free alberta strategy and i have more than i read i read it uh some months ago and i reread it again
00:08:52 for this show um so i'm so i'm you know one of my big questions for derek was you know is the
00:08:59 because when i read the alberta sovereignty act explanation that just came out recently and
00:09:04 compared it to the description in the free alberta strategy it seemed very much the same thing
00:09:09 and so i i hear derek confirming that yes it is the same thing and it is part of the bigger strategy
00:09:13 so that that's one big question i had is this is it just a coincidence it's called the alberta
00:09:19 sovereignty act or is it actually the same alberta sovereignty act as we read about in the free
00:09:23 alberta strategy and and i would say derek i mean and i don't i'll come back i want to come back to
00:09:27 this a minute because i want to talk to you about like me my biggest concern is very much the rule
00:09:33 of law issue um but but i'll just i'll just come back and say you know why do i care about this
00:09:39 i mean our uh you know first of all i was chair of the king of taxpayers federation i'm chair of
00:09:44 manning center which is now called canada strong and free i i'm as you said executive director of
00:09:50 modern miracle advocating for oil and gas and you know i certainly agree with everything derek said
00:09:55 about uh you know our oil and gas industry that's why we started modern miracle to advocate for it
00:09:59 but let me add on to this we found a giant gas field in quebec it is enough to replace 50
00:10:07 of russian imports to germany it's enough to probably take quebec 50 off of equalization
00:10:14 it's a giant giant field and we're not just being blocked from developing it for the last
00:10:21 uh you know last 10 years you know much like alberta pipeline you know pipelines lng plants
00:10:26 i mean our projects block there too it's worth billions of dollars to us it's worth probably
00:10:32 even more to the province of quebec and they're expropriating it for for for a peppercorn of
00:10:37 compensation so you know i i would say that for me this issue of that you know the the categories
00:10:44 of people that derek talked about you know i i doubt there's another albertan that has a more
00:10:48 vested interest in doing something and i also because of my 20 odd years dealing in quebec i
00:10:54 I mean, I've worked very closely with Lucien Bouchard.
00:10:57 My wife and I have had dinner with them.
00:10:59 Danielle Terp has been to my house for dinner.
00:11:02 I mean, Perry's always a shareholder.
00:11:04 I really know personally well the people that were the architects of the 1995 strategy to separate,
00:11:15 which, of course, culminated in the 1995 referendum, which was unsuccessful.
00:11:19 So I'm not sure there's another Alberta that also understands better the Quebec strategy and what they do day to day and what they were doing in 95 to gain more political power in the country.
00:11:34 I strongly advocate that, A, we have to do something.
00:11:38 I'm probably with Derek, I'd hate to not to cheer for the Canadians in the Olympics, but it's got to a point where we have no choice but to do something.
00:11:47 As I said, there's probably nobody in Alberta with a bigger reason to care than I do.
00:11:52 But what we have to do, it has to be effective, it has to work.
00:11:56 And I have to tell you, I think the Quebec strategy has been the most effective one that we've seen.
00:12:02 And my view is the free Alberta strategy goes the opposite direction.
00:12:05 My big honest concern about it is it'll take us backwards and it will take us further away from more political power in the country, not closer.
00:12:16 and I'm I'm strongly advocating that we you know learn from what Quebec did and work more to gain
00:12:23 and it's not just about holding the referendum that's the tip of the iceberg it's the 90% of
00:12:27 what they do under the surface so that so that's I guess where I'm coming from and my my worry there
00:12:32 I guess Derek I'd say first of all I do think people have read the Free Alberta Strategy I
00:12:37 don't think it's a problem that they haven't read it um I mean not everybody obviously but I
00:12:41 certainly certainly you know the campaigns have and a lot of you know there was a great article
00:12:46 um by Howard Englund recently he clearly read it um and and I hear what you're saying it's not
00:12:52 technically an act but I okay so my first thing is like would we not agree though that it's an
00:12:56 outlying policy and that we can you know we don't have to necessarily read the act to say that this
00:13:03 is an intention to make an act based on a published policy and so the two things I'd say to you is
00:13:09 of it's a published policy.
00:13:11 If the policy would be unconstitutional,
00:13:13 we could presume the act that follows would be two.
00:13:16 And then the other thing, just to reconfirm with you,
00:13:20 which is what I thought when I read it,
00:13:21 that it was very much in line with the free Alberta strategy,
00:13:26 that it is just the first step in an overall strategy.
00:13:28 Those two things that we could say are fair.
00:13:31 Yeah, I believe so.
00:13:33 I believe it's fair.
00:13:34 Now, of course, I don't speak for Danielle Smith,
00:13:39 candidate who who has uh been talking about the sovereignty act it's that's not my place
00:13:44 to speak for her obviously i don't have that authority but just your view is you would you
00:13:49 agree that when when you read that read it it's very much like i would say i didn't find any
00:13:54 inconsistency yeah i've heard a sovereignty act section of your report and what was published
00:13:59 i didn't see any inconsistency yeah i i don't i don't think there is an inconsistency but of
00:14:04 course you know political candidates once they gain office uh they often you know get advice uh
00:14:11 on uh how it will be draft or you know legislation that they propose policies they propose uh from
00:14:17 alberta justice for instance in this case and alberta justice will have very strong opinions and
00:14:22 obviously they're the ones that are going to be doing the work at that stage and uh you know this
00:14:26 is and it's again it's a strategy document it's i wouldn't even say it's to the level of policy
00:14:34 that the the policy the policy if there is one and again i don't speak for the danielle smith
00:14:39 campaign would be that we're in a tough position what can we do about it um and we need to do
00:14:44 something and we need to do something that preserves the rule of law so the most clear
00:14:48 way to do that is to enact legislation that purports and in practice does preserve the rule
00:14:56 of law so that we don't end up with a lawless alberta and with all respect to howard um howard
00:15:01 if he read the strategy completely misconstrued it in his most recent article where he said it
00:15:07 would require Albertans to be civilly disobedient and that was precisely the opposite thrust of the
00:15:14 entire report because if we want to push back against Alberta the only the only plans that
00:15:22 have been offered so far other than potentially at the end of the in in the 1980s and through
00:15:28 the 90s when Preston Manning was running the Reform Party. The only solution has been that
00:15:34 Albertans individually need to be civilly disobedient and take great personal risk.
00:15:40 And Howard Anglin fell into that trap and was complete misconstrual because what it does is
00:15:46 when we have the Alberta Sovereignty Act as part of the Free Alberta Strategy, if there is civil
00:15:52 disobedience which i would contest there is not uh if it's drafted in consultation with alberta
00:15:59 justice um what it would require is it's the provincial government that takes the risk
00:16:05 right but but there i mean all we can all we can really go by is what's written down right and
00:16:10 that's correct and so you're now saying well yeah but there's you know okay but maybe what
00:16:13 was written down we don't need oh no no that's not what i said maybe albert or maybe alberta
00:16:18 justice will change it or maybe those are all hypotheticals and I don't think fair for this
00:16:24 discussion like what I think we have to deal with is the free Alberta strategy it's written down
00:16:29 and the policy is written down and let's just deal with that and then we can and by the way I
00:16:35 I would hope that let's let's agree on this point I would very much hope given my concerns that
00:16:43 through the process of working through the the justice department and the process of working
00:16:48 through caucus and the process of working towards a vote in a democratic process i very much hope
00:16:53 there'll be some significant changes so let's agree that let's agree i'm with you on that point
00:16:57 yeah but at least for right now all we can deal with is what people are stating they want to do
00:17:01 well and that's correct and that's what i'm what i exactly what i tried to disavow was that howard
00:17:07 england didn't actually engage with the document as it is written down yeah i i sent a note to
00:17:11 howard i think i i have a couple disagreements with your article too he's a very smart constitutional
00:17:17 expert but but of course it's it's an op-ed and it's probably not as well research as the supreme
00:17:21 court brief and and i think he acknowledged that there you know that it was a very short op-ed and
00:17:26 if you want to dig into details you make some changes but just let me get to the thing that
00:17:29 you're saying and i'll get to the thing the part that i find the most troublesome and and it sounds
00:17:35 it sounds and again it's written down in both the policy and the free alberta strategy but you're
00:17:41 saying something slightly different one is you said hey declarations of constitutionally
00:17:46 constitutionality are only done by a court and and of course i i agree with that i mean that's
00:17:52 like that if we're playing hockey you know decisions about if it was if it was high sticking
00:17:57 or not are only done by the referee but everybody has an opinion right um everybody and often people
00:18:03 have a strong opinion but at the end of the day the referee decides so this is the same thing for
00:18:08 courts but but the free alberta strategy is very clear about that alberta should not follow the
00:18:14 rulings of courts where there are federally appointed judges. I find that very troublesome
00:18:21 and contradictory to what you've been saying. In addition, the policy itself says that if a court
00:18:28 finds it unconstitutional, any action taken by the Alberta government, if it's found to be
00:18:36 unconstitutional by a court, that the Alberta government will then have to decide what to do.
00:18:42 it doesn't say okay well if it's found to be unconstitutional we'll agree with that so
00:18:46 in both your strategy and the policy there's this in one case explicit in the other case implicit
00:18:54 uh claim that we will not follow the rulings of courts on constitutionality and this is the whole
00:19:00 this is where i feel like the whole rule of law problem as i said this is my biggest single
00:19:05 problem with the whole thing and as i said it's in writing so i don't yeah yeah and so that that's
00:19:10 very interesting point and i i let me try to explain what i think you said so that i'm not
00:19:15 misunderstanding and i think hearing it again might help help listeners too is basically um
00:19:20 there's this stream of thought in the in the free alberta strategy that when a court uh decision
00:19:28 is let's just say for now contrary to alberta's interests which i'm going to come back to that in
00:19:34 a moment contrary to alberta's interests in the view of the legislature in all of our mlas and
00:19:39 they'll hold a vote on it in the legislature and decide effectively during that vote what to do
00:19:45 and if they decide that look we're not going to enforce that court decision in the province
00:19:50 there'll be a time period over which that um that basically notwithstanding similar to a
00:19:55 notwithstanding will will function that i think that's a summary of what you're saying and that
00:19:59 that itself here is is an attack on the rule of law well i i mean there yeah i mean there's two
00:20:07 places i'd like to go in this conversation with you is one is to go through with what i think it
00:20:11 will be a so much so much more effective strategy which is to do what quebec does uh you know customize
00:20:16 it for alberta but do what quebec does as opposed to this this but by the way i want to tell you i
00:20:21 barry's a brilliant guy and and brought that i mean and i don't know i haven't met you before
00:20:25 but i mean i can i you if you're if you're hanging out with those guys you must be smart too right
00:20:29 um michael michael can i can i ask a question here yeah you say the quebec strategy uh we
00:20:35 should do the quebec strategy but then i go back to something you said that just has confused me
00:20:41 um you talk about this uh and i hope i'm saying this right please correct me uh this gas formation
00:20:46 you find that could be worth billions of dollars but quebecers can't even use that because the 0.97
00:20:51 federal government won't no no no that's the quebec government that's uh the quebec government
00:20:56 is expropriating it's not the federal government but the but you know we certainly what we know is
00:21:01 that the federal government's not been overly helpful in dealing with quebec blocking like 1.00
00:21:07 like the federal government the liberal federal federal government was certainly not very helpful
00:21:11 over pipelines they've certainly they've not been they've not been helpful you saw i don't know how
00:21:15 i mean i i listened to the entire press conference with the chancellor from of germany and and trudeau
00:21:23 very clear that trudeau's not really helping us on lng and i can tell you that in quebec um there
00:21:29 you know we've got an issue of being expropriated with no compensation which you know speaking of
00:21:33 rule of law is is also outside the rule of law even you know even if it might be legal so yeah
00:21:38 so but if i but it but that's not that that's a combination of provincial and federal jurisdiction
00:21:44 that is making it difficult for alberta on our oil and gas yeah so so i i mean i would like to
00:21:51 come back to you and ask ask what the what what you think the quebec strategy is but i want to
00:21:55 answer the rule of law question so i think i think what's important in um and how actually
00:22:01 howard anglin jason kenney and others have misconstrued and or misunderstood uh current
00:22:06 candidate brian gene does this repeatedly as well is um that it's just you know whatever the alberta
00:22:12 legislature doesn't like we're just going to say no it doesn't work here we're going to ignore it
00:22:16 court decisions nah we're just going to that that's not in the free alberta strategy certainly
00:22:23 we may suffer from a first draft problem if it if if someone can find that in there that's
00:22:29 not an intended result what is intended is this section 91 92 all the way to 95 lays out
00:22:38 often what's termed exclusive jurisdiction and if you go back long enough in in constitutional
00:22:46 studies and good night let's go to the quebec the quebec conference in 1864 during the quebec
00:22:53 conference 1864 john a mcdonald during the process of drafting these provisions in the constitution
00:22:59 said look the these these are so clear we're never going to have a conflict the pro we're not going
00:23:05 to have a conflict with the provinces everyone knows their jurisdiction we're going around
00:23:08 and uh you know honestly uh the problem started soon we didn't have a supreme court of canada
00:23:13 until seven years after that and uh the reason the supreme court purportedly wasn't there is
00:23:20 because the federal government didn't see a purpose for having a a court of final appeal
00:23:26 within within canada but eventually it became desirable to quote sort of sort of keep the
00:23:33 provinces in their place and so this is early on but would we did we have a senate yeah yeah we
00:23:42 wouldn't we just been the british system that your court of you would have gone to the set 0.99
00:23:46 to the bar oh yeah absolutely but there was no there was no court of final appeal within this
00:23:50 country so just saying that there was it was this idea at the time that the constitution's so clear
00:23:58 there's never going to be any conflict it didn't work out that way very obviously right and so even
00:24:04 even until 50 60 years ago this sort of uh the legalese on in the constitutional uh conversations
00:24:11 about jurisdiction was that there were watertight compartments and the metaphor had to do with
00:24:17 you know bulkheads in ships and so that when one part starts going down we put the bulkhead out
00:24:23 and it keeps the water out and the ships afloat right and the jurors but you're a lawyer right
00:24:28 so i'm going to grant you this point you're a lawyer lawyers draft contracts for me they're
00:24:32 always watertight when they're drafted they're never watertight when somebody decides to sue
00:24:36 me and challenge me in court or vice versa right so we can agree that that's just the way things
00:24:40 work and and and it's probably no huge surprise that there's been conflicts of people's economic
00:24:47 interests that have resulted in challenges to um challenges these these so-called you know water
00:24:52 tripe drafting but but i don't think anybody's going to be surprised to find that there might
00:24:56 be loopholes that people find in both constitutions statutes and contracts yeah now i i don't think
00:25:04 anyone's surprised at that but that's not what i'm saying i'm saying there's a fundamental
00:25:07 philosophical shift and now we're into the area of so-called cooperative federalism
00:25:13 which means this it's starting to mean this first off it was you know government is complicated
00:25:19 life is complicated sometimes jurisdictions overlap but now as i think all those of us
00:25:25 albertans reading the the supreme court's decision in the greenhouse gas pollution pricing act
00:25:33 reference we're very concerned uh many of us called it a trojan horse meaning that now the federal
00:25:39 government under the guise of environmental law can do whatever it wants but we all but you and
00:25:45 i we all agree on this too right like well this is this is why it's important and this is all
00:25:50 preamble to establish why the rule of law is important because now we have a lawless federal
00:25:56 government that's been you that's a that's a that's a throwaway line right what have they done
00:26:01 that's lawless that a court that a legitimate court has ruled as lawless like i mean i get
00:26:08 you're saying it's lawless this is my whole problem with the rule of law if the record
00:26:13 if the referee says it's high sticking and i say it was accidental who gets to decide me
00:26:18 michael you're the one that just told me that the expropriation of a gas field in quebec was lawless
00:26:23 no i didn't i said it didn't you said it was contrary to the rule of law it might be in
00:26:27 statutory law but it's and it might be permissible according to law but it's contrary to the rule of
00:26:31 law right but as you as you well know the rule of law is is is is an unwritten common law type
00:26:38 concept and that by statute and other reasons that there are times when the government has the legal
00:26:44 power uh under our constitution to overrule the rule of law you know that i know that no actually
00:26:50 no i'm actually very opposed to that understanding well i'm opposed to it too and as a theory
00:26:55 but but as a practice this has been the case for you know for probably a thousand years in british
00:27:00 common law right um no i don't think so so the rule of law for me maybe this is maybe this is a
00:27:06 problem that many people have with this is the rule of law is just that no one individual is
00:27:11 above the law that there's there's checks and balances that keep people within the law the king
00:27:16 is not above the law he is not the source of the law in fact our constitution explicitly denies
00:27:21 that by saying mentioning the supremacy of god alongside with that and the idea is you know
00:27:26 believe in god if you want it doesn't matter who it is but the idea is that the ruler is subject
00:27:32 to somebody else's law that's the concept and so the rule of law places the entire legal system
00:27:39 the politicians everyone within the law they cannot act contrary to the law without facing
00:27:44 the penalties of law now the westminster system they can change the law this will get way too
00:27:49 theoretical for people very quickly but the the whole point being is that there is a legally
00:27:53 passed statute that for example says i'm going to expropriate your property without compensation
00:28:00 yeah that statute is a law that's correct and that's actually in the absence of that statute
00:28:08 the common law or the rule of law would say you cannot do that that is incorrect that is in this
00:28:14 country there are no there are no common law property rights that will protect you from the
00:28:19 from the political authority expropriating your land. In fact, it's only established the principle
00:28:26 that compensation is due. I'll just say, Derek, I have a few reasons to have read the cases
00:28:38 on expropriation without compensation under the common law, and so let's just agree to disagree,
00:28:44 but but on the basis that i've read them carefully with good reason and recently but um so but what
00:28:50 i would mention i would get back to this idea to the main point here is the is that our can we the
00:28:59 your document says if we decide if the albert legislature decides that the government is being
00:29:06 lawless that we can ignore a court ruling that we also think is lawless and i'll just get back to my
00:29:11 analogy if the referee says it was high sticking but he was wrong or at least i strongly think he's
00:29:16 wrong can i just say well i'm not going to the penalty box okay so the your analogy doesn't work
00:29:22 and here's why it's because it it it puts us into the game we're not alberta government is not a
00:29:28 player in a hockey game we're not we're not a sub a subject of the federal government
00:29:34 it the the provincial government is another order of government that is equal but distinct
00:29:39 and so really what it is is uh it's it doesn't fit in the sense that we've decided we're going
00:29:46 to be subject to uh what whatever ottawa desires now this is the important thing and all this
00:29:52 preamble about the rule of law has been leading towards this but there you understand the analogy
00:29:57 i do understand the analogy and i don't think it works but the referee is the court right
00:30:02 yes oh no i do i do understand so the gp the ggpa the the carbon tax i'll just call it that from now
00:30:10 on the carbon tax was this trojan horse well what did that what did what lawyers mean and
00:30:14 commentators mean when they said that you allow the federal government to come to alberta and say
00:30:19 you know what your regulations on the type of furnaces you allow to be installed in people's
00:30:24 home we can't do that we can't allow people to have wood burning stoves because it creates too
00:30:29 much carbon dioxide or your tires aren't sufficient or refrigerators have to you know be of this type
00:30:35 it allows for such meddling in provincial rights property and civil rights that it can't be that
00:30:43 both have complete jurisdiction overlapping so in instances like that when the federal government
00:30:48 says we're bringing in the gpp what would the alberta sovereignty act do well it would say you
00:30:53 know what this is going to change fundamentally change the way uh the provincial legislature
00:30:59 controls property and civil rights in this province we're going to take a precision strike
00:31:05 and say look we're not going to allow the feds to regulate what tires you put on your car in
00:31:12 this way we have our own regulations it's our jurisdiction so did a court say did it did the
00:31:18 court in the reference case say look the federal government can control tires no it did not so
00:31:25 the court's decision allows for that it's a trojan horse but will the federal government
00:31:31 eventually try to occupy that space i think they will this is in my in my opinion on the on the on
00:31:36 the carbon tax they already are and and i think that's probably as the alberta court of appeal
00:31:41 ruled that was probably one of the most dangerous and saskatchewan yeah well yeah the alberta court
00:31:46 of appeal i thought did the best job of outlining the outlining the danger of expanding peace order
00:31:51 and good government and so i think i briefed i briefed the albert i did a briefing as the justice
00:31:56 asked me to do a briefing on that case and uh you know they they took a lot of what i told them but
00:32:01 the problem the one thing that they didn't do is i said you cannot let stand as a statement of fact
00:32:08 that there is a climate emergency because if you do then then in the when there's a climate
00:32:15 emergency getting back to rule of law issues i think that the supreme court may decide that
00:32:21 because it's an emergency there in a in a democratic and free society this will be a
00:32:27 reasonable use of the peace order and good government clause to override provincial rights
00:32:32 and the alberta none of the provinces ontario and saskatchewan didn't touch it at all uh alberta did
00:32:39 and i think that was i think that was a big error and i get why nobody wants to get into a climate
00:32:44 debate in the court but just you know taking it as you're right it's a climate emergency
00:32:50 the world is ending there's a fifth extinction coming but you know because the constitution
00:32:55 says this that alberta should get to decide for itself i mean you could see why there would have
00:32:59 been a motivation by the court to to potentially do what it does even though i strongly disagree
00:33:04 with it i think it's super dangerous for the future of the country i think in and of itself
00:33:08 it's a reason why alberta has to wake up and fight for autonomy so i'm 100 with you on that
00:33:14 I'll just come back to, and maybe we'll just agree to disagree.
00:33:17 I don't think, and I would say, if you want to talk about playing the federal game,
00:33:22 which Alberta is terrible at and Quebec is excellent at,
00:33:25 in the federal game, there is a referee.
00:33:27 It's called the Supreme Court.
00:33:29 And we all have to agree that we're going to follow what the referee says.
00:33:33 And when they say he was high-sticking, we have to go to the penalty box.
00:33:36 Even if we think it's egregious, unfair, the referee was blind, he was biased,
00:33:40 he was all these things.
00:33:41 If you don't go to the penalty box, the game is over, right?
00:33:44 And I would say, like, I'll just give a couple examples.
00:33:47 Like, what if it was an actual emergency?
00:33:49 Like, let's say it was a war.
00:33:51 And the federal government came and said, you know what?
00:33:53 We demand that you sell your oil to the armed forces, and we demand you don't sell your oil to our enemy.
00:33:58 And Alberta says, just a second, that's provincial jurisdiction.
00:34:01 It's clear.
00:34:02 It's in Section 91 to 95.
00:34:04 We get to decide that.
00:34:06 I think people would find that a bit egregious to think that Alberta could do that. 0.99
00:34:10 don't you think but don't you think michael that the you you have to have faith in your mlas as the
00:34:15 document i think lays out they would vote on it in a 24-hour period and you're acting like
00:34:21 alberta's going to abandon all of a sudden canada for sticking up for some of its rights
00:34:26 right in saying all this guys as i listen to you i don't think that i don't you don't think that
00:34:31 no the point of a constitution because if we all just thought that the mlas would always be 1.00
00:34:37 eminently reasonable and eminently fair and and and judicious that we wouldn't need a constitution
00:34:43 at all like the whole point of a constitution is to protect people from the people in power
00:34:50 and the whole reason to have courts and laws is to protect us i just find this whole idea
00:34:55 so contrary to what albertans believe the albertans are the most in favor of direct democracy
00:35:01 and here we're saying well we're going to give the power to our mlas to ignore the constitution
00:35:07 which is the only thing that actually protects us from them i find it i've got it contrary to our
00:35:12 i find it contrary to it certainly contrary to what i believe you know that the way you just
00:35:17 described it there is that i mean you're getting into brian gene territory there it's just not what
00:35:23 it's about i mean the same thing with with uh jason but i'm just reacting directly to sean's
00:35:27 point but can't we just trust our mlas and i'm going well yes i mean we do right now don't we
00:35:32 i mean what we're asking we don't know what i would say is that we have a charter of rights
00:35:38 why do i need a charter of rights because i'm worried that a politician might pass a law
00:35:42 the country okay okay so i mean you're you're off in left field to be frank uh again well okay
00:35:51 let's agree one of us is one of us is in left field for sure and i think the idea that we're
00:35:55 going to ignore court rulings is in left field and unacceptable and i think at the end of the day
00:36:00 albertans when they realize that what we're talking about is allowing a legislature to
00:36:05 decide itself when when it will follow the constitution and when it won't yeah that is
00:36:11 gonna i think i think you'll find albertans will be the most opposed to this once they figure okay
00:36:15 so there's two responses to that first that was a straw man and i'm sorry that's dismissive but i've
00:36:20 been over it already but the second one is that it's already happening we have a notwithstanding
00:36:25 clause in the constitution that applies to sections what is it two through seven and fifteen
00:36:29 and we struck we trust legislatures to do that it's been invoked a number of times
00:36:35 provisions built into the constitution act 1867 called disallowance and reservation which allow
00:36:42 the attorney general and the governor general to do the same thing so derek if you said to me
00:36:47 we would like to make a constitutional amendment to give us the equivalent of a notwithstanding
00:36:52 clause in alberta over sections 91 to 95 that's a great idea the notwithstanding clause you refer
00:36:58 to is inside the constitution yeah so now look at this what what and again i'm going to make this
00:37:04 point again i'm trying to make it clearly the idea is to stay within the constitution and essentially
00:37:11 what happens is okay the alberta government votes and okay we're not gonna we're not gonna under the
00:37:17 greenhouse gas pollution i promise to call the carbon tax i'll call it carbon carbon tax law
00:37:23 what's going to happen is uh they're going to start regulating the tires we can put on our cars
00:37:28 or the sand we can put in our sandbox is that good they're going to start regulating that
00:37:32 the alberta government then uh they have a debate in the legislature the public's involved the media
00:37:37 is there it takes a period of time rich debate they say you know what we're gonna we're not
00:37:43 going to enforce that for 60 days okay what happens is this now look when the federal government
00:37:50 infringes on our jurisdiction we have to go to court and we have to sue them and you know that
00:37:57 you know very well how long that takes the the carbon tax reference was extremely expedited
00:38:03 extremely expedited and it took how long it took a number of years now so what is that what results
00:38:10 is that going to get for us well we can wait a number of years meanwhile we have clear constitutional
00:38:15 jurisdiction in the in the in the opinion of our of our legislature which is supposed to be in a
00:38:21 dialogue with the courts right supposed to be in a dialogue with the courts and essentially what
00:38:27 happens is it makes the federal government come to us and sue us or negotiate with us say you know
00:38:34 what we're not going to regulate your your jurisdiction that way it gives the power back
00:38:38 to albertans through the legislature using the rule of law and again everything's tied back to
00:38:45 the constitution can well what will will we give the power to the legislature to ignore charter
00:38:50 rights no that's that's not that's not in ignoring the constitution okay this is the problem that
00:38:58 jason kenny has when he talks about well what if bc decides that they don't want to follow supreme
00:39:03 court decision allowing the pipeline to be built through its you know what the federal government
00:39:08 clearly has that authority bc couldn't enact a sovereignty act and dispute that that's not what
00:39:14 this is about this is about keeping different levels of government different uh levels of
00:39:19 government within their jurisdiction not expanding the jurisdiction of any level of government the
00:39:25 alberta legislature does not have the constitutional authority to violate the constitution what we're
00:39:31 saying is that your document doesn't say that right i mean you say well you know what to make
00:39:38 this work we're going to have to get our own police force because what if the federal government just
00:39:41 sent in the rcmp and then you say we have to have an independent banking act because what if the
00:39:45 federal government just were to come in and and talk to a business okay we're not going to let
00:39:50 you one of your specific examples we're not going to have a carbon tax anymore here because that's
00:39:54 unconstitutional we've decided in spite of what the supreme court says uh we've decided on our
00:39:59 own it was unconstitutional but by the way if if i had been the referee i would have come to that
00:40:03 conclusion but uh but i wasn't i wasn't and uh so but we but we're now going to set things right
00:40:10 here in alberta and we're going to say hey you know what businesses you don't have to collect
00:40:13 the carbon tax anymore people you don't have to pay the carbon tax anymore and the way we're going
00:40:17 to be able to do all that is it's not just a sovereignty act it's it's also we're going to
00:40:22 take over the all the policing we already have control over enforcement of property which i
00:40:27 by the way that that's what i think is the most interesting academic thing about your your your
00:40:31 paper is that the the intellectual academic exercise of saying hey if we wanted to do this
00:40:36 what what would it take to do it i find that fascinating and i really thought you're talking
00:40:40 was was excellently well done and then the final point you're talking about is we have to we'll
00:40:45 have to provide albertans places to put their money so that they so that the federal government
00:40:49 can't go collect that carbon tax from them directly and then then albert is going to
00:40:53 start collecting federal money and remit what we want to remit and i i'm going well let's okay
00:40:58 here's some so so there there's the you know that that's not even the illogical conclusion
00:41:04 that's actually where your paper arrives in writing right and i look at all that and say
00:41:09 well here i have a few problems with that like number one is it will take no more than a letter
00:41:15 from revenue canada telling me i forgot to remit my carbon taxes and by the way you could go to jail
00:41:20 and you'll pay a fine and i'll say well i don't know derek told me i'm keeping my money in this
00:41:24 new alberta bank and they can't get that and he's telling me the police can't come to alberta at
00:41:28 arrest me so maybe maybe it's okay for my business to continue to remit those taxes to the Alberta
00:41:33 government not to the federal government like they told me but I'll think you know what I think what
00:41:37 I find I don't know I'm a bit worried next time I fly to Toronto they'd arrest me and I'm a little
00:41:42 bit worried that maybe they'll seize my condo in Kelowna because I can't get the one in Alberta
00:41:48 and all of a sudden I'm going man oh man I have now I have I have to send the money to Alberta
00:41:52 government and I have to send the money to the federal government and so I mean I just look at
00:41:57 all of those things like wow this it goes it gets to the point where i don't think i could comply
00:42:02 with all of that idea um i will tell you though if it was if it was limited and your document is not
00:42:08 in any way shape or form limited but if it was limited to the way you're saying now we merely
00:42:13 want to put a stay on the enforcement of a federal law until it's determined if it was constitutional
00:42:20 by a by a by a court then while i'm not sure that would be technically constitutional or technically
00:42:26 legal i could see that hey as a practical matter you could at least stop the enforcement of the
00:42:31 law until so so i think michael you're you're conflating both the sovereignty act with the
00:42:37 the strategy you described the strategy very well and the strategy is you know i'm not going to say
00:42:43 that i i i want to see it implemented uh it's it was somewhat of an academic exercise and it was
00:42:50 you know a very first draft and this is a way forward to do what you said but the sovereignty
00:42:54 act is what we're talking about and the sovereignty act is different than the entire strategy well
00:43:00 is the last portion of what you described except as we established up front the sovereignty act
00:43:06 in the policy document is basically a layover for the sovereignty act in your document
00:43:11 yeah well yeah for me and not speaking for a campaign i think the reason reason we're talking
00:43:16 okay version of the sovereignty act um to my knowledge she has not endorsed the free alberta
00:43:25 strategy yeah i would agree i would agree with that i don't think she has either um i don't
00:43:32 think she has either the the the using the exact same name as in your document and using the exact
00:43:40 you know pretty much the exact same policy makes one wonder but but um but anyways i hear you on
00:43:45 that and i need to talk about the strategy in the whole because you you you laid it out and there is
00:43:55 sovereignty act was one piece of legislation i believe there's three four or five other pieces
00:43:59 of legislation that were drafted in consultation both with academics and many other lawyers and
00:44:06 the idea was look here's a possible path forward it wasn't this is the path forward this is a
00:44:13 possible path forward. This needs to be explored. This could get us to the result that we want in
00:44:18 the end of an Alberta that's freer and sovereign within Canada, that we'll finally put to bed
00:44:26 all these problems we have. Now, having said, you know, you're like my condo in Kelowna. Well,
00:44:32 there's nothing in this act that takes away the choice of individual Albertans.
00:44:38 No one's going to force you to bank in a particular place. Certainly, I didn't draft
00:44:42 with that in mind because i'm all about people making individual choice in fact that was one of
00:44:47 my biggest beefs with the last two years of code restrictions is that it removed choice and
00:44:51 socialized risk and so i am very opposed to that and what i hear you saying is that somehow we can
00:44:57 be cast as um as taking choice away from albertans with the free alberta strategy and and making uh
00:45:05 socializing the risk that that is not the case at all there was no attempt to do that if you have a
00:45:10 colonna and bc and you want to continue to remit carbon tax have at her you know what there's many
00:45:15 businesses with offices throughout canada it would be interesting and and and uh the whole strategy
00:45:22 if implemented which i have no idea if it ever will be would would have to be in a lot of
00:45:27 consultation with vested interests okay so you're probably too far down the hypothetical because
00:45:32 like even you said it was just agreed here here fellas let me let me hop in here sure sure michael
00:45:39 finish finish your thought sure your own document recognizes the problem though is that the federal
00:45:46 government has the ability to cut off money back to alberta yeah and so your own document recognizes
00:45:52 that if you're going to get away from this idea that we are not going to enforce these laws and
00:45:57 then the federal government choose to start enforcement they have a lot of tools in their
00:46:00 toolbox including the fact that they can tax you directly and then not remit the money back to
00:46:05 alberta and that you that that doesn't even get into rcmp and arresting people or anything 1.00
00:46:10 and so therefore alberta is going to run would run out of money quickly if you didn't have a find a 1.00
00:46:15 way to get some of those taxes remitted and as soon as you start doing that you're going to be
00:46:18 into all the problems i just said so and you're talking it recognizes that problem yeah yeah and
00:46:24 i agree with that i just wanted to make that point no no no i don't mean to cut off a good debate
00:46:29 going back and forth i'm just you know as i sit here and listen to you two go back and forth i go
00:46:34 okay so we get a new premiere in october okay and let's say it is danielle smith and she has
00:46:40 championed the alberta sovereignty act i don't think listening you two uh it's as easy as day
00:46:47 one the alberta sovereignty act is in effect or am i wrong in saying that after listening to you
00:46:51 two go back and forth i highly doubt the more people you add into this the more difficult and
00:46:56 And more heated a conversation could become on trying to flush out all the different ideas that this thing is talking about.
00:47:05 Alberta Provincial Police Force, independent banking, revenue agency, pension plan, you know, like it goes on and on and on.
00:47:13 There's lots.
00:47:14 And at times we go deep and at times we're just scraping the surface of going back and forth to you two.
00:47:20 Would you agree that, like, whoever comes into power, if it is Daniel Smith, day one, it isn't like all of a sudden all the laws change in Alberta?
00:47:28 What Derek said at the beginning is, I think, gives the comfort of saying, hey, look, it's a policy and it's not final.
00:47:37 And I think the policy itself says, hey, it's subject to debate.
00:47:40 It's subject to a vote.
00:47:41 It's subject to all these things.
00:47:43 And so I think the, you know, as Derek said, you know, let's not just jump to the conclusion that the statute's going to be the same as the policy is drafted.
00:47:54 Yeah, that's right.
00:47:55 Okay, so then I want to go back in the conversation earlier.
00:47:58 We talked about Quebec's strategy, but then I didn't hear what it was.
00:48:02 What does Quebec do that's so good?
00:48:06 And if you're Alberta and you could adopt it immediately, what would it be?
00:48:09 What is it?
00:48:10 Yeah, so here's what I'd say that I've learned from a long time there is that Quebec in particular is a very political culture.
00:48:18 It has, since 1763, been very focused on maintaining political power to protect itself from what it perceives to be an island of English who's out to get them, right, in order to persecute them. 0.84
00:48:31 And they would, you know, they probably would put it almost in those exact words, although I probably embellished a bit.
00:48:35 whereas I find Alberta to be a mercantile culture or a business culture mercantile not mercantilist
00:48:42 I find Ontario to be mercantileist which is to say we use business to to accumulate political power
00:48:49 and and Alberta is like I say we're we're we're like a bunch of we're we're very business oriented
00:48:55 mercantile culture and and I say we're a little bit like when Napoleon talked about we just we're
00:49:00 a nation of shopkeepers and most people in Alberta we just want to get back to running our shops I
00:49:04 derek and i i think agree on 95 of what we talked about it's just this issue of whether we're going
00:49:08 to whether we're going to follow court rulings or not it's probably what we're arguing about
00:49:12 the the uh but but what i would say is that because we have that business culture not political
00:49:17 culture in the federation we play a different game we constantly go down to ottawa and explain
00:49:22 to them like you know if you would just get out of our way and let us go back to our shops and
00:49:27 make more money it would be good for the whole country gdp would go up people would be wealthier
00:49:32 and what we don't understand is if you're in a political culture like quebec or a mercantilist
00:49:37 culture like ontario what they hear you saying is we want more political power it wouldn't even
00:49:45 occur to them that alberta would make more money and not use it for political fans because because 0.99
00:49:52 that's what they do and so what what i guess what i'm really saying is and i did on this other
00:49:57 podcast you know if we're playing rummy and they're playing euchre us getting better at playing rummy
00:50:03 is not going to win at euchre and i think what we have to do is learn to be political like quebec
00:50:10 a bit more mercantilist like ontario and start using that to make to gain political power
00:50:18 to in effect for us to keep them out of our politics but for them it's to get into our
00:50:23 politics and what i really mean by that is where does power come from power and i've done business
00:50:27 all over the world edward shiver nazi with a friend i mean so uh i i have seen how power gets
00:50:34 exercised in different cultures in different countries and to me it really comes down to
00:50:38 there's three things and just to make it glib guns votes and money and so if you know if you look at
00:50:46 pre the capitalist area in europe all the people who had all the money were the people with the
00:50:50 guns but with the invention of the company by the dutch in the 16608 or whenever it was the the
00:50:57 beginning of capitalism we've now seen that power has devolved more to the money like people with
00:51:02 money to them influence over the people with the guns and of course votes still has lots of political 0.89
00:51:06 power and in rome that would have been the mob uh throwing out an emperor today it's us exercising
00:51:12 your votes so when i look at canada well let's hope nobody's going to pull out their guns so
00:51:17 So let's put that to the side.
00:51:19 And so you're now down to votes and money.
00:51:21 Now, Alberta in particular, as we know, has less votes. 0.99
00:51:24 Certainly the West entirely has less votes than Ontario and Quebec combined.
00:51:28 The West does have more votes than Quebec, by the way.
00:51:30 People seem to forget that part.
00:51:32 But we don't have more than Ontario combined.
00:51:34 But here's what we do have.
00:51:36 We have an incredible ability to generate wealth.
00:51:39 And we do not use that wealth for political power.
00:51:43 Quebec does.
00:51:45 And I'll just tell you things that I know.
00:51:46 Well, Quebec has, and so you'll just have to take my word for this from people that I feel very lively.
00:51:53 Quebec, first of all, controls all of its own pension funds, controls all of its own money, even though it isn't a great place to generate wealth.
00:52:00 They control their money, and they have threatened explicitly or implicitly at certain times to take all of their money out of the Canadian financial institution, which would be very harmful to the banks, very harmful to investment funds, be very harmful to a lot of things.
00:52:15 But they're willing to use their money, even though they generate less of it than Alberta, they're willing to use that money for political purposes.
00:52:23 And, you know, we all go, they had a referendum vote, but that's but but they took they took a long time before they did that.
00:52:30 They first built their institutions to manage their own pensions effectively.
00:52:34 They police themselves. They collect their own revenues.
00:52:36 They have, so what I would say is they built the institutions to show they could govern themselves, and then they have used votes and money to exercise political power in the federation.
00:52:51 If you look at Alberta, what we do is we send our money down to Ottawa and let them manage it for us.
00:52:56 So here's the irony. Can you imagine this, right? Just the Canada Pension Plan, $700 billion under management. On an actuarial basis, $400 billion belongs to Albertans, right? 12% of the country. We have more than 50%. But let's talk about the power of, hey, I'm deciding where that money gets invested.
00:53:21 I'm deciding who earns a banking fee.
00:53:23 I'm deciding who's going to earn a sales fee or whatever, brokerage fees, all those things.
00:53:33 Well, if you're the RBC Dominion Securities, you go to Ottawa to ask them, could you invest
00:53:41 or could I get a fee, could I get whatever on Alberta's money?
00:53:46 So Ottawa is exercising the political power that comes from being able to generate money.
00:53:50 and in the modern capitalist world money's the big power today and it's because of capitalism
00:53:56 that's the way it is right so so that that's the way things are and we need to say i think in
00:54:00 alberta start realizing that's our one big power and here's some things people don't know alberta's 0.90
00:54:05 been running about a three billion dollar trade deficit with quebec if you take oil and gas out
00:54:10 it's closer to five for decades whatever happened to the customer is always right
00:54:16 so i so i would say what what so i think that you know in terms of this type of things that
00:54:22 quebec does alberta oh and and by the way i've been through i've been through two bap hearings
00:54:27 personally which is this environment commission in quebec where it's you know where they'll put
00:54:33 projects and you know to to kill them for political reasons if they want to right and and and our
00:54:38 project didn't fail the bap but the sagany lng project did and it got killed you know for that
00:54:44 an excuse well if quebec says i'm blocking your lng and your gas and your pipelines for you know
00:54:52 environmental esg environmental social governance for esg reasons well why doesn't alberta review
00:54:58 every product and every company and every service that we buy from quebec for for esg as well like
00:55:04 do we think that tell me what the gender impacts are of bombardier jets tell me what the full cycle
00:55:12 emissions are of bombardier jets like like like why don't we go through the same thing for your
00:55:17 products as you make us go through for our products and for that and by the way there's something
00:55:21 that is so foreign business-minded mercantile culture so you're telling me i might have to
00:55:27 pay two percent more for my jet why would i ever do that well i'll tell you why because it's a
00:55:33 because it's a sort of a penny wise pound foolish you save two percent but you lose your ability to
00:55:38 get your product to market well as we come up here on time derek uh you know any thoughts uh on on
00:55:46 on just on what michael said about how quebec operates anything there um you know before we we
00:55:52 uh we end uh on on i don't know on a few different thoughts here but uh derek if you if you got some
00:55:58 final thoughts please fire away i certainly would endorse personally endorse any any plan that works
00:56:05 i think that's what it comes down to if if what michael is proposing is is a completely different
00:56:10 species and i'm not convinced that the free alberta strategy and what he's saying are are
00:56:15 exclusive to each other i would thoroughly endorse that because i think albert is an attract an
00:56:20 intractable position it's it's becoming intolerable to have a confederation function as it currently
00:56:27 is and that doesn't mean that that's an attack on confederation as some of the candidates like to
00:56:31 think it's that we can do better and so i i think um i think by the way dick i agree with that when
00:56:38 i first saw the plan i said hey 90 of that works with what i'm saying is that let's get tough on
00:56:42 trade and start using our start using our ability so i do i do have i'm just thinking of three
00:56:47 comments on on that and that was you know this is the type of thing that i'm sure uh danielle smith
00:56:54 should she become premier is going to want to hear from you and your wealth of experience and your
00:56:58 ideas like there's it's going to be an open door because she's going to want to hear from people
00:57:03 because the last thing anyone wants to do when they step in is damage alberta but ted byfield
00:57:08 in 2001 2001 said and i'm sorry i have to read this off the screen my eyes are going to look
00:57:14 a little weird here the only way to change canada is to develop ways of getting out of canada we
00:57:20 must possess other options unless we make credible threats to set up on our own we will get absolutely
00:57:28 nothing in the way of constitutional change or any other kind of change i agree with that we'll
00:57:32 be bashed down every time thousand percent that's why we have to do what quebec did take the time 0.87
00:57:38 we need to build the institutions to manage your own money to police ourselves to collect
00:57:42 our own revenue all of which is in your free alberta strategy which is absolutely necessary
00:57:47 you nobody you know what the people in ontario they laugh by the way it's so frustrating i keep
00:57:52 talking but they laugh at me when i talk about the strategy albert alberta will never do that you
00:57:56 You guys, you guys will never do that.
00:57:58 They just don't take us seriously.
00:58:00 Well, you know, I think I remember a prime minister famously saying, just watch me.
00:58:05 Maybe, maybe we should take that sort of attitude.
00:58:08 But the reason is because we're a little bit like a teenager saying we're going to move out of the house.
00:58:12 And then the mom and dad goes, yeah, but I got all your money.
00:58:17 Yeah, yeah.
00:58:17 And so, yeah, we need we need to control that.
00:58:19 But so I want to just address what I've harped on this a little bit through this discussion today, which has been excellent.
00:58:26 that we need to actually have something credible that we can do and that there's certain things
00:58:34 that we know that will not work and flawed as it may appear to some the free Alberta strategy and
00:58:41 particularly the sovereignty act is an attempt to doing exactly what Bifield said we need to have a
00:58:46 credible threat or else we're not getting anywhere like election night federal election night the
00:58:50 elections decided for the most part by the time it gets to Manitoba as you pointed out Michael
00:58:55 But I want to point out that Taves has brought forth a strategy in response to the Sovereignty Act, which is just to willy-nilly slap tariffs on products coming in and contracts, goods, all sorts.
00:59:09 And if you want to talk about constitutionality, I spent seven years of my life on the way to the Supreme Court in the R.B. Como case, and we were discussing or addressing Section 121 of the Constitution about interprovincial trade.
00:59:24 Admitted free was the big thing.
00:59:27 And what we do know from 150 years of constitutional discussion is that Tave's plan is offside the Constitution.
00:59:35 Well, yeah, just but OK, so first of all, I think there's it's absolutely black and white clear based on Supreme Court decisions that you cannot absolutely black and white clear.
00:59:44 You cannot put a financial tariff on. But when I heard Tay's talk, I thought he was talking about the possibility of non-tariff barriers as well.
00:59:51 No, he uses the word tariff.
00:59:54 He's either misused the term or he or he doesn't understand the law.
00:59:58 It sounded to him. It sounded like a policy he came up or his campaign team came up with on the fly without actually thinking it through thoroughly, which is problematic as well. But then the other thing is we have another campaign talking about opening constitutions with the federal government.
01:00:15 Now, I am old enough to remember Charlottetown and Meech Lake and all the heartache and what actually was accomplished from those constitutional negotiations.
01:00:25 And there is no provision in the Constitution that allows someone to send notice to the federal government and say, you know what, we're opening the Constitution.
01:00:34 I don't know what that means.
01:00:36 It's never happened before.
01:00:38 And it certainly does.
01:00:39 yeah okay so first of all that's that's that's doing an extension of the precedent of the quebec
01:00:45 secession reference it is and i think i think and i think ted morton's points there have merit and
01:00:51 of course at the end of the day we'll find well maybe one day we'll find out what if a court
01:00:55 agrees or not well it's a misreading of the of the court's decision and and and they always
01:01:02 where the obligation of the rest of obligation of the federal government the rest of canada will be
01:01:07 to acknowledge acknowledge alberta's discontent and then that's that's it that's right i i i
01:01:15 hear what you're saying just getting back to the like what does quebec do differently they actively
01:01:19 look for loopholes too yeah right like they don't just like as you said hey this this this 91 to 95
01:01:26 it was ironclad but then over 100 years people find this loophole and that loophole and this
01:01:31 surprise judgment and so forth they actively look for those and that's another thing i find that
01:01:35 albertans are don't have again in our business mercantile culture we're trying to avoid contractual
01:01:40 disputes we're trying to be reasonable we're not trying to and i think we have to learn maybe to
01:01:44 start looking for some loopholes ourselves and one of them just on the tapes idea which i which i
01:01:50 which you know if he strictly means a financial tariff then you then of course you're right but
01:01:55 if he means tariffs in the broader sense of uh non-tariff barriers too then um uh non-financial
01:02:01 territories too then i think there's the loophole that quebec has found actually actually no
01:02:08 and i think the answer is that we do we do esg we do an esg trade barrier and we put those those
01:02:16 alberta's signatory both to the canada free trade agreement and to the northwest uh partnership
01:02:22 agreement and i actually had the opportunity to litigate through both of those regarding one of
01:02:28 of Joe Cece's, our former Billy Feuze Minister of Finance at the time, and had one of his illegal
01:02:34 policies, which was a tax and rebate scheme regarding beer. It was struck down by the trade
01:02:39 agreement. And so it's not just merely financial penalties. It can be slightly more convoluted. It
01:02:45 can be explicitly like it could be as simple as differential grading between products. Anything
01:02:51 that has the purpose of keeping a product or a service or a contract or eligibility out of the
01:02:57 province if that's the purpose the primary purpose of it then it's offside the constitution and the
01:03:02 trade agreements right but we just had the pog case which said that if there's a climate emergency
01:03:08 then there's exceptions to that and we just had the beer case in new brunswick which says if there's
01:03:13 a social reason there's exceptions to that and and i've also looked at the canadian free trade
01:03:18 agreement and you know what the penalty is if you're caught off first of all there's never been
01:03:22 one complaint ever done under it and second of all even if you do the penalty gets paid to some
01:03:27 some it gets paid to some um actually actually our success was was technically under the Canada
01:03:32 free trade agreement okay I don't know I don't know of a government that's that's that's done
01:03:37 that and maybe maybe you can help me but uh but getting back to though the idea but of like what
01:03:43 Quebec does these non-tariff barriers that are done for language culture environment all these
01:03:48 other reasons Supreme Court's shown both in the Fogg case in the beer case that they're very
01:03:52 supportive of the idea that if it's done for those reasons, it's an exception to free movement of
01:03:57 goods. Well, why doesn't Alberta do, why don't we do an ESG review too? Like, I'd like to call out
01:04:03 Quebec as the biggest greenwashers in the world and make them meet Alberta ESG standards. And so
01:04:08 what we're going to do is we're just not going to do business with you until you can meet Alberta
01:04:13 ESG standards. Yeah. Essentially, I think, not to use too many political jargon or talking points,
01:04:19 But this really reminds me of what Danielle Smith has been saying, that it's time for Alberta to grow up and no longer be a teenager, as you said, and start acting like a senior partner in Confederation.
01:04:31 Yes.
01:04:31 We have weight to throw around.
01:04:34 Let's start throwing it around.
01:04:35 So, you know, boys, I could probably hold you here the rest of the day and sit here and just listen to this.
01:04:40 And honestly, I got no problem with it.
01:04:42 I just want to be respectful of your guys' time.
01:04:44 Can we maybe all agree, and maybe I'm wrong on this, that one of the best things then that has come from the Alberta Sovereignty Act is people are actually listening and talking and hopefully starting to debate more on the merits of it and things that Albertans need to do.
01:05:01 I mean, I go back to what Todd Lowen said on stage in Vermilion about the firewall letter in 2001.
01:05:08 It's not like this is a new idea.
01:05:10 Actually, it's been around for a very long time.
01:05:12 can we all agree that hopefully alberta is going to maybe uh to use both your terms grow up a little 1.00
01:05:20 bit move out of the parents house uh start acting for itself and start to move in the direction of
01:05:25 maybe some of the things quebec has done right and take whether it's you know a year away or
01:05:30 whatever the time frame is i don't know um but start to pull some of the things back that allow
01:05:36 them to have a little more influence in the country is that a fair enough statement yeah
01:05:40 And you know what? I have to tell you, I think that the that every leadership candidate and maybe I should say the five out of seven who have read all their stuff, they they have all come up with a plan to get tough for Alberta.
01:05:56 And I think we can give Daniel some credit for being a catalyst for that.
01:06:01 And and I and I agree that the discussion is good to say, hey, it's time for us to grow up.
01:06:06 I like 90% of what I see in the free Alberta strategy.
01:06:10 The part about that we're not going to, that we're going to, you know, no longer, we're
01:06:13 going to decide to opt in or out of court rulings, I find goes far too far for me.
01:06:17 But the rest of it is great.
01:06:19 And I think that if we add a get tough on trade strategy to that, I think we're moving
01:06:23 in the right direction.
01:06:24 But I think this whole idea that, you know, growing up means let's find ways to, you know,
01:06:31 obey the constitution because it's our fundamental protection against government overreach ultimately
01:06:36 let's obey the constitution we don't like it let's force a change even your document free
01:06:41 alberta strategy basically says if we can't force a change ultimately in the constitution we might
01:06:45 have to separate so uh so even you at that sense are saying we're going to open up the constitution
01:06:50 at some point and i i agree that's what we have to do so but but i think growing up is i'm going
01:06:56 say growing up i think is we don't ignore our courts we we do follow we do follow constitutions
01:07:03 we understand that they can change we use our political we we we develop the institutions to
01:07:08 manage our own money to manage our our own cells so that we actually start to say hey we're grown-ups
01:07:13 then we start to show that we're willing to throw our political power around maybe we take our money
01:07:17 out of canada maybe we stop buying five billion ten billion dollars a year of stuff from quebec
01:07:23 maybe we do things like that they start to see we're willing a we've grown up b we've got the
01:07:27 institutions c we're willing to throw our weight around if we if we can't then i think uh and if
01:07:33 that doesn't work then i'm with derek then it probably comes down to a referendum but but not
01:07:38 a not a declaration by the legislature an actual referendum that we go to the people and say that
01:07:42 we want to go for autonomy okay well final final point to you derek and then uh i just appreciate
01:07:47 once again you guys hopping on and doing this and being open uh you know uh to me sitting here
01:07:53 almost as a fly on the wall i like to think because i didn't really interject a whole lot
01:07:57 i just let you guys kind of riffed on you know derek the guy who's in the band uh you know that's
01:08:03 kind of what this to me feels like uh sitting back and letting two guys um passionate about
01:08:08 a lot of different things namely alberta and the best way forward regardless derek any final
01:08:14 thoughts here before I let you two get on with your day? Well, I'm really actually quite hopeful
01:08:20 that this new leadership candidate who is selected in a few weeks will do something
01:08:28 important to advance Alberta's place in confederation. Because I think at the end of
01:08:32 the day, the Free Alberta Strategy and Sovereignty Act being one component of it is an attempt to
01:08:38 protect Albertans from what I view as a lawless federal government, a federal government that's
01:08:45 just going to do whatever it wants to us and feels like it can always rely on the courts to
01:08:51 get what it wants. That concerns me. It concerns me as I see the trajectory of that. And whichever
01:08:57 political candidate is elected, of course, I do favor one. I do favor Danielle Smith.
01:09:04 and i think it's very important that we have somebody who has displayed a willingness to
01:09:10 stand up against ottawa um and quite frankly i think uh the polling on this now shows that it's
01:09:18 it's some polls are showing as low as 64 but many are higher than that of albertans within the ucp
01:09:26 party actually support the concept of a sovereignty act and i think it's important to say the concept
01:09:31 of a sovereignty act because as we've discussed that later there is no actual written document
01:09:36 and i think it displays it displays the willingness of of conservatives in alberta to say you know what
01:09:43 it's time that we we stood up to ottawa in a meaningful way and here we have an actionable
01:09:48 plan other people can come up with their actionable plans as well and uh certainly the the door i
01:09:54 don't think will be closed in the premier's office for other input and advice and uh we may actually
01:10:00 have a leader in this province who wants to take this portfolio seriously and that's extremely
01:10:05 encouraging to me well either way fellas uh i appreciate you coming on and doing this and being
01:10:11 open to it and uh and sharing some thoughts and your knowledge because you both come with a wealth
01:10:17 of knowledge uh to not only myself but all the listeners who are tuning in and i just appreciate
01:10:23 you guys doing this and all the best here in the days to come and like i say and like we pointed
01:10:28 it out here in the next what is it less than a month few weeks away we're gonna have a new
01:10:31 premiere and we're gonna find out what it's what's gonna happen and hopefully uh you know
01:10:36 some of these ideas uh continue to get flushed out as we move along either way thanks guys for
01:10:41 hopping on yeah thank you thanks for having us and by the way i've been wanting to meet
01:10:44 there for a while so thanks for setting setting that up as well well there you go okay thanks
01:10:50 guys. Bye-bye. Bye.
01:10:57 You can become a Western
01:10:58 Standard member for just $10 a month or
01:11:00 $99 a year.