Western Standard - December 20, 2023


Standing up for Alberta’s constitutional rights

Topics
Mentioned
Update on the Calgary Ring Road The Pipeline: Ho-Ho Hamas

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

145.13

Word count

3,334

Sentence count

96

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In April 2021, the federal government declared that plastic products made of plastics are toxic under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act. Alberta challenged this decision, and the Supreme Court of Canada struck down the ban as "unreasonable and unconstitutional." Now, Alberta is intervening in the Federal Government's appeal of the decision.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thank you.
00:00:30 Thank you.
00:01:00 Thank you.
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Thank you.
00:03:00 Thank you.
00:03:30 thanks everyone for joining us i'm pleased to be here with minister of justice mickey amory
00:03:47 and minister of environment and protected areas rebecca schultz to respond to recent developments
00:03:52 in ottawa's continued attempts to ban plastics as you may remember in april 2021 ottawa unilaterally
00:03:59 declared that plastic manufactured items are toxic under the Canadian Environmental Protection
00:04:05 Act. Not only did they ignore reality, but once again, they ignored the law in doing so. Thankfully,
00:04:12 last month, the federal court of Canada found the government's actions to be unreasonable and
00:04:17 unconstitutional. The court recognized that allowing this overreach would enable Ottawa
00:04:22 to regulate nearly every aspect of the economy, upsetting the balance of federalism in Canada.
00:04:27 It's another useful reminder that the provinces are not subordinate to the central government.
00:04:33 The provinces are partners in confederation and we ought to be treated as such.
00:04:37 This message has really been driven home by the courts this year, here and in the Supreme Court's decision on the Impact Assessment Act.
00:04:45 Unfortunately, it's clear from Ottawa's appeal of the federal court's decision that the lesson isn't sinking in.
00:04:51 And more reminders are necessary.
00:04:53 So Alberta will keep standing up for what's right. 0.87
00:04:55 And in this case, what's right is the fact that plastics aren't actually toxic.
00:05:00 If they were, they wouldn't be in nearly every product in the economy.
00:05:04 And Alberta can't regulate, or Ottawa can't regulate whatever it wants by arbitrarily classifying something as a toxic substance.
00:05:11 But we shouldn't be surprised by this, which should come as no surprise to Ottawa that we intend to continue pushing back on their unreasonable and unconstitutional orders.
00:05:20 We were interveners in the original case, and we will stay involved throughout the appeals process.
00:05:25 The stakes are too high to do anything less. If Ottawa's approach ultimately wins, it will be a disaster for Alberta's and Canada's economy.
00:05:34 It would destroy our petrochemicals industry, driving away tens of billions of dollars in investment and eliminating tens of thousands of jobs.
00:05:41 And it will harm the progress that's occurring in plastics, reuse and recycling.
00:05:46 Ottawa should listen to these objections. They come from the courts and the Constitution and the provinces and the people Ottawa claims to serve.
00:05:53 Ottawa would be better served by working with provinces and industry
00:05:57 than they are by pushing forward with unconstitutional laws and regulations.
00:06:01 We continue to hope for change, but the same old pattern continues to play out.
00:06:05 Many federal policy changes on energy and the environment
00:06:08 are proving to be the power grabs that we always knew they were.
00:06:11 They're rushed efforts to please a few activists,
00:06:13 and they're focused more on rhetoric than results.
00:06:16 They're also undemocratic, unaffordable, and unacceptable.
00:06:19 All of this applies just as much to the plans for net-zero power grids, the carbon tax, and emissions as it does to plastics.
00:06:27 My promise is that Alberta will fight every step of the way on every issue that affects Albertans.
00:06:33 We will continue to put forward facts and precedents before the courts.
00:06:39 We will keep on doing this to sustain the prosperity that supports Canadian families and the public services.
00:06:44 And we will keep innovating, developing, and coming up with improved solutions to manage plastic waste, reduce emissions, and protect the environment.
00:06:52 Albertans have high expectations, and we will meet them.
00:06:54 We will deliver the growth and sustainability that Canadians want and need.
00:06:59 Minister Amory and Minister Schultz have more details about our response to the plastics ban and federal intrusions into Alberta's jurisdiction, and I will turn things over to them.
00:07:07 Thank you.
00:07:14 good afternoon as the premier mentioned alberta will be intervening in the federal government's
00:07:19 appeal of the decision holding their designation as plastics as toxics is unreasonable and
00:07:25 unconstitutional when the federal government listed plastic manufactured items as toxic
00:07:31 a number of industry groups challenged this designation in court to protect our constitutional
00:07:36 jurisdiction the alberta government intervened in the case and the federal court's decision
00:07:42 confirmed that the federal overreach was unconstitutional alberta's position is that the
00:07:47 federal government far exceeded its constitutional jurisdiction by designating plastics as toxic
00:07:54 the category of plastic manufactured items is so broad that to allow the federal government to
00:07:59 regulate them would be to allow the federal government to regulate essentially every
00:08:05 single aspect of the modern economy imagine the disturbing impact that this federal policy had on
00:08:11 every single industry that relies on manufactured plastics simply put this overreach upsets the
00:08:17 very balance of federalism in canada and that is why we are pleased that the federal court
00:08:22 recognized this but we are disappointed that the federal government chose to appeal
00:08:28 the decision by the federal government to appeal this decision highlights the very issue that we've
00:08:32 been raising for decades that this federal government's overreach is both inappropriate
00:08:37 and disrespectful to our system of federalism because alberta previously intervened in this
00:08:42 matter alberta has the right to participate in the appeal and make submissions to the federal court
00:08:48 of appeal regarding the constitutional issues at play and we intend to do exactly that we will
00:08:54 continue to defend our economy and our constitutional jurisdiction against this latest attempt by the
00:08:58 federal government to continue to overstep its jurisdiction yet again even though the court
00:09:04 decided that it was unreasonable and unconstitutional the designation of plastic manufactured items as
00:09:10 toxic remains in effect this is because the federal government re-added plastic manufactured items to
00:09:16 schedule one of the canadian environmental protection act through a legislative change
00:09:20 after the court challenge began the federal court concluded that this legislative change
00:09:26 namely bill s5 was not included in the original court challenge and therefore did not form part
00:09:31 of its decision alberta will consider its options including further legal action to remove plastic
00:09:38 manufactured items from the current schedule one as it now stands the federal court's decision that
00:09:43 it was unreasonable and unconstitutional to designate plastics as toxic is the latest rebuke
00:09:49 of the federal government's unconstitutional out of touch and ineffective environmental approach
00:09:55 and it follows the supreme court of canada's recent decision that the impact assessment act
00:10:00 was largely constitutional as well unconstitutional as well it seems that the federal government has
00:10:05 not yet learned its lesson alberta is prepared once again to make the case for a constitutional
00:10:11 jurisdiction before the courts and we will use every single legal avenue available to us to
00:10:17 defend our economy and our livelihoods from federal government overreach i would now like
00:10:22 to invite rebecca schultz minister of environment and protected areas to the podium thank you
00:10:30 Thank you so much and good afternoon, everyone.
00:10:36 As the Premier and Minister Amory have said, we will be opposing Ottawa's appeal of the
00:10:40 federal court's decision.
00:10:42 Let me remind everyone, the federal court's decision was clear.
00:10:45 The federal government's plastics, regulation and legislation is unconstitutional and completely
00:10:51 unreasonable.
00:10:52 We will continue to stand up for our province, our constitutional rights and, of course,
00:10:58 our economy.
00:10:59 Frankly, I'd hoped that we wouldn't have to be here today.
00:11:03 The federal court's initial decision was correct, and it was common sense.
00:11:08 Drinking straws and grocery bags are not the same as mercury or asbestos.
00:11:13 The federal government cannot assume regulatory authority over any substance it chooses simply by designating that substance as toxic.
00:11:21 This order was unconstitutional on the day it was written, and we will absolutely win this fight.
00:11:26 But let me be clear. This isn't about plastics. Ottawa knows their plastics bans are about virtue signaling and not actually about fixing the problems. They know that this federal designation negatively impacts Alberta's economy, and they know that plastics are important in the economy. That's why they joined us in supporting Dow's new Path to Zero facility in Fort Saskatchewan. Yet, they refuse to listen to the courts and to Canadians. So we will help take them to court. And like I said, we will win.
00:11:56 We will do it while continuing to actually reduce plastic waste in our province.
00:12:01 Right now, Alberta is implementing a transformative new system that will help reuse plastics and keep them out of landfills.
00:12:08 Our extended producer responsibility system will reduce waste, increase demand for recycled content,
00:12:14 and transform plastics into value-added products that are reused instead of being dumped into landfills.
00:12:21 We've also asked the federal government to support innovations like the compostable 100%
00:12:27 non-plastic bags developed by Calgary Co-op and LEAF Environmental Products,
00:12:32 but they've refused. They've insisted that only Ottawa knows best and that only Ottawa is right.
00:12:39 That is not how Confederation works and it is no way to fix the environmental challenges facing
00:12:44 our country so once again we will push back against this unconstitutional federal overreach
00:12:50 we will ensure that alberta remains a place of innovation and we will stand up for albertans
00:12:55 while delivering real results that benefit all of our people thank you thank you we'll now go into
00:13:03 the media q a portion of the announcement uh we'll start off with questions here in person if you
00:13:08 want to come up to the mic state your name and outlet and we'll go with one question and one
00:13:11 follow up kevin green from ctv news um so you the government was an intervener in the first case
00:13:18 where the federal court ruled against the federal government it's a natural process in law for
00:13:23 someone who doesn't like a verdict if as long as it's not all the way to the supreme court to appeal
00:13:28 the judgment what i've heard from you guys today is nothing but complaining not what you're going
00:13:34 to do so you're going to be an intervener you were the last time what are you going to do
00:13:37 rather than complain which is what you've done for the last 10 minutes
00:13:44 well there is another option having lost the supreme court decision on the impact assessment
00:13:49 statement or impact assessment act they could have said oh gee you know now we've had a second
00:13:53 decision that shows that we're wrong and they could have chosen to rewrite their plastics
00:13:59 regulation so that it is compliant with the law instead they do what they always do is they force
00:14:04 us to fight for years in the court to be able to go through all the processes and ultimately get the
00:14:09 decision which i think we will that is unconstitutional at which point they'll have to
00:14:12 change it but the the uncertainty that they create in the meantime is having a major impact on
00:14:17 business this is why dow petro dow chemical and other companies launched the action in the first
00:14:22 place there's a lot of cross-border trade that happens in plastics products getting developed
00:14:27 here sent down pelletized and then sent back here in molded form and is creating a lot of additional
00:14:32 handling a difficulty because they're treating it as if it's some kind of radioactive material.
00:14:39 That's the problem is that there's a fundamental fallacy of them trying to assert that this is toxic
00:14:45 when it's in our phones, our plastic bottles, the pen I'm using, the binder I had here today.
00:14:52 It's absurd for them to be treating this like it is a toxic material. The courts called them out on
00:14:57 it and they continue to persist a separate question for the premier here yesterday at the
00:15:02 ring road press conference when we were there you said the decision to terminate dr hinshaw's contract
00:15:07 was dr cowls today the ethics commissioner found and i'll quote no evidence that dr cowell directed
00:15:13 the termination of dr hinshaw's employment so if it wasn't dr cowell if it wasn't you as you say
00:15:19 if it wasn't dr man's or dr tail feathers who actually did terminate dr hinshaw's employment
00:15:24 well you can read the letter and you'll see that the ethics commissioner said it was alberta health
00:15:28 services and she um considered the uh the evidence and has closed the case thanks kevin
00:15:37 and we'll go next here hi there just to follow up on my colleague
00:15:43 on dr inshaw would it be acceptable for dr inshaw to have any position in any agency crown
00:15:51 public in alberta ever again in your mind look um i we're doing a major transformation of our
00:15:58 alberta health care system and we need the right people in place that have the the confidence of
00:16:02 the public that they can make the changes that are needed to get the system improving
00:16:06 and that's part of the reason why we're doing transformational change and we're asking
00:16:10 many people in management positions who aren't up to the job to uh to depart and we'll be asking
00:16:15 many more who aren't up to the job of improving the system to depart we are the uh we we are the
00:16:21 funders of the system alberta health services gets its mandate from us they get its money from us
00:16:27 we have an obligation to taxpayers to ensure that it's performing appropriately and if it's not
00:16:31 we'll make changes so i would say that uh we'll have lots of discussions about how we go about
00:16:36 doing that we have a board in place ultimately the board will make the the decision on personnel
00:16:41 and we're going to be highly involved in making sure that we get the right people in the right
00:16:45 place so just to be clear is she a person on grata in alberta um look i've i've made my my position
00:16:52 very clear um i'm when uh when i chose a new chief medical officer of health i knew we needed new
00:16:59 leadership there so i've got confidence in our new chief medical officer of health and we're going to
00:17:04 continue making changes in personnel so that we can make the changes in healthcare that we need
00:17:09 to just like the technical clarification for minister amory about the the process of the
00:17:13 intervening process will we be using uh the same firms the same lawyers that you've used successfully
00:17:19 in the past uh are you thinking about in-house uh and do you have a sort of specific dollar
00:17:25 amount on the cost of the intervening right now we are just commencing and beginning we don't have
00:17:30 an appeal date set at this point in time we've had tremendous success using both in-house and
00:17:35 and external counsel will continue to do that.
00:17:38 Right now, we're preparing, as we mentioned,
00:17:41 we have made our intentions clear.
00:17:43 We'll continue to move through the process
00:17:46 by employing those that have worked well for us in the past.
00:17:49 We continue to have great success with many firms,
00:17:51 including the in-house counsel,
00:17:54 and it will be a collaboration between the two.
00:17:59 Jonathan Bradley, Western Standard.
00:18:00 My question is for Premier Smith.
00:18:02 so you spoke about how you've begun consultations and preparing for the appeal what do you intend
00:18:10 on your legal strategy being in this case we we have uh have had dow chemical and the other
00:18:17 petrochemical companies take the lead on this it's different than when we took the lead on
00:18:20 the impact assessment act and so it had a slightly different process so we continue to watch this go
00:18:26 through its various stages and hopefully we'll be able to get the kind of outcome that we expect.
00:18:32 It's just disappointing that the federal government wouldn't accept defeat and come to the table and work
00:18:37 with us on developing a strategy so that we can all achieve what we want. What we all want to achieve
00:18:42 is making sure that plastics are not diverted into the river systems and are not diverted into
00:18:49 the environment. We want to make sure that we're recycling plastics and putting them to useful
00:18:52 purpose and as the minister mentioned with uh our new policies around extended producer liability
00:18:57 coming in in the new year we're going to have a number of different ways that we can use those
00:19:01 streams of of uh of plastic that are have been discarded and i think will demonstrate that
00:19:07 we're going to be the best steward of that program you spoke about the canadian government not
00:19:13 learning its lesson by appealing the case um do you believe this case will end up in the supreme
00:19:18 court of canada why or why not i i would anticipate if they don't back down then you know you'll have
00:19:23 to talk to micry mickey amory about the the different steps that it goes through um i mean
00:19:28 i suspect that if it if they don't back down uh then it will go to the the highest court i mean
00:19:33 so there's as i said there's different options that you can take when when we lost the case on
00:19:37 our public health act we didn't appeal it we said oh we better change our legislation because the
00:19:41 court said that we we uh we weren't in compliance with it that's an always an option that's available
00:19:46 to a government when they lose a case they can accept the judgment that they're operating outside
00:19:51 their constitutional boundaries and fix the law and the sooner they do it the better because that
00:19:55 then creates the certainty and it also restores the constitutional balance we haven't seen
00:20:00 that spirit of cooperative federalism unfortunately with this regime and so we continue to fight in
00:20:05 the courts thank you thanks uh joe horwood cbc news um we're just wondering with the amount of
00:20:12 people that are moving to alberta uh what's happened to the alberta is calling signing bonus
00:20:18 and the graduation retention tax credit when might those be introduced uh i think that my minister
00:20:24 said she needs a little bit more time on the graduation retention tax credit so i don't believe 0.94
00:20:29 that it may need another year before we implement that but my my minister matt jones is responsible
00:20:35 for the alberta's calling tax credit and he's in the final stages of working with that will look
00:20:39 like believe it will be announced in the upcoming budget you'll be able to see the details there
00:20:43 okay any any idea for how many people have applied for those credits or might be getting those we
00:20:48 haven't just put the architecture in place for it just yet and so um that'll be the first step
00:20:52 which you'll see in the budget and then now we'll we'll be able to track that and get some detail
00:20:56 for you as uh as it rolls out thanks thank you and we'll go to the phone lines operator could
00:21:03 Could you put through our first caller, please?
00:21:06 Hi, thanks for taking my question.
00:21:10 Premier, I just want to follow up on your answer there to CDC or RADPAN.
00:21:15 We talked about trying to find people who have confidence of the public
00:21:21 as you go through this major restructuring.
00:21:23 Are you saying that Dr Hinshaw did not have the confidence of Albertans?
00:21:28 I'm saying that there's going to be lots of
00:21:31 personnel changes that happen at Alberta
00:21:33 health services and nobody should be surprised
00:21:34 by that as we make sure we've got the right
00:21:36 people in the right place to make the right
00:21:38 decisions so that we can get the outcomes
00:21:40 that we want.
00:21:42 Again, to follow up, you didn't answer
00:21:44 his question the first time.
00:21:46 Is Dr Hinshaw at all,
00:21:49 is there a spot for her anywhere in the Alberta
00:21:52 health care system?
00:21:53 I understand you are making changes.
00:21:55 Does she fit in that anywhere or has she 0.85
00:21:58 disqualified herself. I believe she has a job you should go and see. I think she was hired by the 0.62
00:22:03 federal government. Thank you, Carrie. And operator, did we have any more callers on the line?
00:22:11 There are no other questions in the queue at this time. Thank you. Seeing no more questions,
00:22:15 that'll conclude today's announcement. Thank you, everybody, for joining.
00:22:28 Thank you.