Western Standard - April 22, 2022


Supply management Issues: Cory is triggered by dairy price spikes

Topics
Mentioned
Alternative Media Panel Discussion Episode 3: The Danielle Smith Show

Episode Stats


Length

7 minutes

Words per minute

198.89

Word count

1,528

Sentence count

117

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

14

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

supply management is a Soviet-style system that controls all production of dairy, egg, and poultry products in Canada. It s illegal to produce and sell any of those items if you don t have a quota issued by the state and controlled by a small number of cartels.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 So the time is now and the place is Canada. This is the moment. This is the time, guys, when supply management,
00:00:05 remember, we don't hear about it often enough in my view,
00:00:08 it's supposed to protect us from all these price spikes in food products during extraordinary circumstances.
00:00:14 This is when we should be laughing at the world as they deal with hyperinflation within their food markets
00:00:19 while we enjoy our coddled and price-protected dairy, egg, and poultry industries.
00:00:24 At least that's what proponents of supply management have been telling us for decades,
00:00:28 as Canadians have been soaked with some of the highest dairy prices on earth.
00:00:31 We were told those high prices were something of an investment.
00:00:34 Paying now would save us from paying later when we'd really need it.
00:00:38 Supply management would guarantee food security for us all when world supply becomes scarce.
00:00:44 Look, supply management's a Soviet-style system that controls all production of dairy, egg, and poultry products.
00:00:50 It's literally illegal to produce and sell any of those items if you don't have a quota issued by the state
00:00:56 and controlled by a small number of cartels.
00:00:59 Some people say it's an exaggeration to call it Soviet-style.
00:01:01 Well, when I could be criminally charged for selling milk or owning over 300 chickens,
00:01:07 what else could I compare it to?
00:01:09 The quotas make a mess of the market,
00:01:11 and some producers literally actually dump dairy products into the ditch
00:01:14 because if they overproduce and try to sell it, they'll have broken the law. 0.95
00:01:18 The system really is that ridiculous and rigid.
00:01:20 So now that we're seeing inflation spiking around the world due to a number of factors,
00:01:25 how well is supply management doing in keeping our dairy prices stable?
00:01:29 It's totally failed.
00:01:31 Not only are supply-managed products rising in price,
00:01:33 they're rising faster than any other food products.
00:01:36 They should be the slowest to rise if we were supposed to believe those people
00:01:38 who said this system's going to work for us.
00:01:40 Food produced under the supply management system is more expensive than any other products.
00:01:45 Supply management has accomplished the exact opposite of what it's supposed to do.
00:01:49 Dairy and egg inflation prices are leading all other foods right now
00:01:53 as prices are rising faster than we've seen since 1983.
00:01:57 Milk is up 8%.
00:01:58 Cheese, over 10%.
00:01:59 Butter, 16%.
00:02:01 And these products are essential ingredients in many other processed foods and restaurant dishes.
00:02:06 So those prices are going to contribute to higher costs on everything you eat.
00:02:10 The other aspect they like to talk about, well, how about protecting the family farm?
00:02:14 Proponents of supply management have insisted for decades
00:02:16 that small farms would be wiped out and we would be dominated by a small number of corporate farms
00:02:21 if we don't maintain the supply management system.
00:02:24 Well, in the 1970s, Canada had about 145,000 dairy producers.
00:02:28 Today we have less than 10,000 of them.
00:02:31 Expensive dairy quotas ensured that only large corporations and operations were sustainable
00:02:36 and the family dairy operations fell by the wayside.
00:02:38 Most of those massive dairy farms are in Quebec, of course, and that's a large factor in why
00:02:43 conservative and liberal politicians alike are terrified of speaking out against this rotten system.
00:02:48 The average Canadian dairy farm, by the way, nets $5 million a year.
00:02:52 That's net, people, not gross.
00:02:54 We're talking about the little mom-and-pop operations of yesteryear.
00:02:57 Dairy farmers love to plead poverty, but the statistics just don't show it.
00:03:01 While dairy producers around the world enjoy broad export markets and have flourishing small cottage producers
00:03:06 who make creative products such as specialty cheeses and ice creams,
00:03:10 Canada languishes with high prices, poor variety, and bans small producers from entering the market.
00:03:15 We can't pretend it's impossible to get rid of this rotten system of government control either.
00:03:19 New Zealand and Australia had systems just like ours, and they got rid of them.
00:03:23 New Zealand's agricultural sector flourished when they got rid of supply management
00:03:26 as new export opportunities appeared.
00:03:28 Getting rid of the supply management system can't be done overnight.
00:03:31 It's going to take some years, and current producers will have to be compensated
00:03:34 for the quotas they're reliant upon.
00:03:36 It can be done, though, and there's no better time to start down that road to deregulation than right now.
00:03:41 Canadians have been ripped off by supply management
00:03:43 for the tune of over $600 per year per family for decades.
00:03:47 And this is only going to get worse as we stunt our local food production
00:03:50 in order to protect a small number of corporate operations.
00:03:54 There just isn't any excuse left any longer to protect the archaic, inefficient supply,
00:03:58 management system in Canada.
00:04:00 It doesn't protect us from worldwide price fluctuations.
00:04:03 It doesn't protect small domestic farms.
00:04:05 And it certainly doesn't do Canadian consumers any favors.
00:04:08 Canada is one of the most vast and rich agricultural lands on earth.
00:04:13 We should be one of the world's leading dairy producers and poultry and egg producers
00:04:16 with a vast array of products and exporting around the world.
00:04:19 Instead, we've limited product options.
00:04:21 We have growing factory farm operations.
00:04:23 We're hardly touching our export potential.
00:04:26 And that's all due to supply management.
00:04:28 Beef, pork, grain, even mushroom producers operate without a supply management system.
00:04:32 Why is it apparently impossible for dairy, egg, chicken, and turkey producers to do so?
00:04:37 Are they really that incompetent?
00:04:38 They can't compete in the world market?
00:04:39 Then maybe it's time to flush them aside and let real producers get in there.
00:04:43 We need to tackle inflation on many fronts.
00:04:45 The world's heading into tough times, and we're not going to be immune from them.
00:04:47 One of the most obvious and effective moves we could do to reduce the food cost burden
00:04:51 among Canadian consumers would be to end our terrible supply management system.
00:04:55 Now, if we only had some politicians with the balls to do it. 1.00
00:04:58 And so even ones who claim to be conservative will not touch this rotten system. 1.00
00:05:05 And again, think of how stupid it is. 1.00
00:05:07 Literally, it's 300 or 400. 1.00
00:05:09 I've looked it up with chickens that you can own.
00:05:11 I know it's a number.
00:05:12 But if you own 401 chickens and you don't have a quota, you'll go to jail.
00:05:19 Yeah, like technically anyways, and maybe it'll start with a fine and so on.
00:05:23 But the bottom line is it's illegal.
00:05:24 It's criminal to have more than 400 chickens without a quota,
00:05:30 without this special permit from the government that they keep strangled.
00:05:32 Same with producing eggs and the rest.
00:05:35 Why?
00:05:36 Why on earth do we need this?
00:05:38 And nobody can make a living on anything less than a few thousand chickens.
00:05:41 It doesn't mean you have to be a mega operation with hundreds of thousands of chickens.
00:05:44 But you see these mid-range affordable ones cannot compete.
00:05:47 And why? 0.95
00:05:48 It's ridiculous. 0.93
00:05:49 It's absurd. 1.00
00:05:50 We don't have a minimum amount of, you know, you don't have a quota on pigs.
00:05:53 We don't have a quota on goats or on cattle.
00:05:56 And those industries make it. 0.87
00:05:57 I'm just tired of the supply management art catchers who keep making excuses for this broken system. 0.96
00:06:03 It's a Soviet-style crappy system.
00:06:05 And Canada's one of the last countries on the whole planet that still has it. 0.75
00:06:09 Denise Martin asking, is it Canada-wide?
00:06:10 Yeah, it's federal policy.
00:06:13 You, and I've used that analogy, and I'll use it again for people who haven't heard it before.
00:06:17 You know, Jane, my wife, grew up in Rockiford, Alberta, a small dairy operation.
00:06:21 And her father had a quota to sell cream, only a certain amount of it, but cream.
00:06:25 But he didn't have a quota for milk.
00:06:27 So they would milk the cows, and this story is so common, and lots of people in rural communities can share it with you, and they know about it.
00:06:33 Milk the cows, skim the cream, sell that, make some bucks for the family, use the milk as much as you can around the house.
00:06:39 If you've got pigs, you'll feed it to the pigs. 0.87
00:06:41 If you don't, you pour it in the ditch, because it's illegal to sell it. 1.00
00:06:44 That's how stupid it is, and that's really what happens. 0.99
00:06:48 So, I mean, I'm just tired of defending this. 1.00
00:06:50 Like I said, Leslie Lewis wouldn't defend it.
00:06:53 I had Sherey on.
00:06:54 That's not surprising.
00:06:55 He wouldn't, I say Lewis wouldn't speak out against the cartels.
00:07:01 Sherey predictably wouldn't. 0.99
00:07:04 And Polyev, unfortunately, I was surprised, but I guess I shouldn't be.
00:07:09 He said he would keep the dairy cartels going as well, which is too bad.
00:07:13 He's been fantastic on every other front, but nobody, nobody can pretend to be a free market conservative and support supply management.
00:07:21 You can't.
00:07:22 You're lying.
00:07:23 You're lying.
00:07:24 Supply management is the opposite of free market, the complete opposite, the complete opposite.
00:07:30 So do you cherry pick on what you support?
00:07:32 Are you, can you be part, you know, you can't.
00:07:35 You can't be half pregnant, guys.
00:07:37 You either support free markets and you don't. 0.99
00:07:38 If you support this crap, you don't support free markets. 0.99