Western Standard - July 17, 2025


The Canadian justice system is in terminal condition

Topics
Mentioned
What remains? Inside Dr. Frances Widdowson's expedition to Kamloops Can independence solve Alberta's 'Ottawa problem?'

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

179.08

Word count

8,401

Sentence count

518

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

25

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, Cory talks about why our justice system is broken and why chronic offenders should be released from prison. He also talks about a man who is serving a life sentence for a crime he didn't commit.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day
00:00:29 welcome to the cory morgan show getting into the dog days of summer mid-july now the stampede's
00:00:35 out of the way i don't have my excuse to wear jeans to work anymore so i just have my usual
00:00:40 poor wardrobe eventually we'll get a wardrobe department i can be dressed better but until then
00:00:45 uh blame the frugal ways of the western standard for not buying me a new sport coat all right lost
00:00:52 the cover though uh we're looking forward to i got a guest coming on tim hagstrom you've probably
00:00:55 seen some of those stories going on. He was, to say the least, roughly treated by the University
00:01:00 of Saskatchewan for daring to just try to question some of the policies of DEI and other exceptions
00:01:09 made, you know, I guess for exam lengths and things like that with students. He'll explain that
00:01:13 and now he's bringing a suit against the University of Saskatchewan. It's good to see people
00:01:17 not backing off in light of those sorts of things. I'll be checking in with Jen in a few minutes here
00:01:23 to get the latest on the news. And yes, I'll be talking. There's a lot of justice things going on
00:01:29 today, I guess you could say. So good to see you guys checking in there. Gord Tulk, North Run
00:01:35 Greater and Paradoxy. Gord saying terminal, really? Gord, it's social media, they're headlines,
00:01:41 and yes, they are eye catchers. And actually, I'm going to start though. I mean, I appreciate the
00:01:45 questions on what's got me wound up and what tells why I feel that our justice system is terminal
00:01:52 and broken. This is something that's been making the news
00:01:57 recently. So on July 29th, 2023, and I'm only going to
00:02:01 pronounce his first name once, Rukanesha, and they call him
00:02:05 Nakunda, but he was stabbed to death by a random stranger
00:02:08 when he tried to ride the LRT in Edmonton. He was 54 years
00:02:13 old. He's left seven children behind. Ironically, he'd escaped
00:02:17 the violent, impoverished world of Congo, only to be murdered 0.96
00:02:20 due to Canada's pathetic justice system. 0.96
00:02:23 Jamal Wheeler killed Nakunda in cold blood. 0.98
00:02:26 He didn't know his victim
00:02:27 and he wasn't provoked by his victim. 0.98
00:02:30 Wheeler has a thing for trying to kill people 0.76
00:02:32 at LRT stations. 0.82
00:02:33 Yeah, he's been doing this for years.
00:02:35 He'd been convicted with attacking people
00:02:37 with pepper spray at one station.
00:02:39 He'd been convicted for pushing a person
00:02:40 onto the train tracks at another station
00:02:42 after he beat on him.
00:02:43 And he'd been convicted of attacking people
00:02:44 with an ax at a station.
00:02:46 What do we do?
00:02:47 We kept letting him out.
00:02:49 limp-wristed sentencing ensured Wheeler was released repeatedly until he finally managed
00:02:55 to kill a man. Now Wheeler has reached the apex of his criminal career so far. He's stolen the
00:03:01 life from an innocent man. So what was his sentence? Well, he's going to be free in four
00:03:05 and a half years to kill somebody else, folks. Rest assured he won't be reformed and another 0.51
00:03:09 innocent person or people will pay the ultimate price for this. Anybody who's followed court
00:03:15 proceedings for violent chronic offenders knows the usual lines of defense. He was Métis and
00:03:19 suffered due to colonialism. He was an addict. He had a rough upbringing, blah, blah, blah. You know 0.99
00:03:25 what? I couldn't care less. When it gets to sentencing for criminals, the only thing that
00:03:31 should be taken into consideration is public safety. How the criminal got there in the first
00:03:35 place is irrelevant. Wheeler is clearly so dangerous he should never be free again, yet he
00:03:40 will be, and he will re-offend. I do understand. We must study what creates violent repeat offenders.
00:03:46 It's important to learn so we might hopefully prevent some violent crimes rather than react to
00:03:51 them. Once a person has become a habitual offender, though, and we've identified them, it's time to
00:03:55 write them off from society. Reforming criminals must be the priority with new offenders. The best
00:04:01 outcome we can all see is that a person has gone off the rails but used their time incarcerated to
00:04:05 better themselves and become a functional citizen upon release. We should provide the resources to
00:04:10 assist with that rehabilitation in that case and the investment will often be well worth it.
00:04:15 But when the efforts for reform fail and the offender becomes chronic, then it's time to
00:04:20 accept reality and remove them from the public, possibly indefinitely. The success rate in
00:04:25 reforming chronic offenders is terribly low and once the criminals reach that status, the safety
00:04:29 and rights of the public must come before those of the offender. It's not just chronic violent
00:04:33 criminals who must be incarcerated for long term. Repeat offenders from thieves to drug dealers
00:04:37 need to be removed as well. The cost and societal damage from career criminals can't be understated,
00:04:43 even if they're directly violent. They cause mistrust, stress, and damage. They've also put
00:04:48 the public at risk as they take up law enforcement resources as they're constantly arrested and
00:04:52 released. Study after study indicates the vast majority of crimes are committed by a minority
00:04:57 of chronic offenders. It stands to reason if we can keep that minority locked up, they can't 0.91
00:05:02 re-offend. How many times have we got to read about some burglar or car thief that's convicted
00:05:06 for their 30th, 50th, or 100th events, never mind the multiple murderers out there. The cost to
00:05:12 incarcerate, hey, it doesn't have to be that high when it's accepted that that inmate's never going
00:05:15 to be released. Resources then don't need to be wasted on rehabilitation, and facilities can be
00:05:20 constructed in isolated regions to inexpensively prevent escapes. Call it gulags, if you will.
00:05:26 The criminals had a choice, their victims didn't. And no, I don't support capital punishment. I still
00:05:32 don't. I don't trust our legal system or government enough to give it the power to kill a citizen.
00:05:35 and I do support hundred-year sentences, though.
00:05:37 The concept of locking up a human forever is a hard one to accept.
00:05:41 I can accept that, though, more than watching people being victimized
00:05:44 and often killed by criminals we already had in custody and then released.
00:05:49 Hey, if a magic pill is invented which cures a chronic criminal,
00:05:52 then we can reconsider their interminable incarceration.
00:05:55 Until then, though, it's time to warehouse them once we've identified them.
00:05:59 Some are secure for the sake of public safety.
00:06:01 Rest assured, it'll have a much more positive impact upon crime
00:06:04 and crime reduction than chasing people around to seize their antiquated duck hunting guns.
00:06:09 When Canada has become more unsafe than the Congo, we know it's time for a reality check. 0.91
00:06:16 And yes, Gord, that's why I say it's terminally broken. When we got a guy like that who's been
00:06:21 in custody and released him and let him kill somebody, and we're going to let him out to 0.79
00:06:24 kill somebody else in four and a half years, the system's terminal. All right, that's my rant to 0.88
00:06:30 get things off on a good note. How's it going, Jen? I'm doing good, thanks, Corey. How you doing?
00:06:34 Good, this is the Western Standard's Jen Hodson, reporter extraordinaire, to give the news update because Steve's indisposed yet again.
00:06:40 Yet again.
00:06:42 Yeah, that's right. A bit under the weather for the last couple of weeks, unfortunately.
00:06:46 Yeah, there's been a bad bug going around.
00:06:47 Bad bug going around. Yeah, that's right.
00:06:50 So, Prime Minister Mark Carney opened the day with an announcement on steel.
00:06:55 And rather than going elbows up, quote-unquote, I guess President Trump, instead, there will be no changes to current trade measures.
00:07:03 However, Ottawa will be funneling in more than a billion into the steel industry on taxpayers' dime.
00:07:10 Ah, good.
00:07:11 Yes, so that'll be a billion towards helping the steel industry, helping steel firms,
00:07:19 and then another 70 million is going towards worker compensation and those that are affected by the tariffs.
00:07:25 Well, bailouts always work well.
00:07:27 I mean, look how well the cricket industry has developed in Ontario or the battery manufacturing plants.
00:07:31 I mean, that's all blossomed for us, hasn't it?
00:07:33 The cricket industry.
00:07:34 Yeah, you say true words, Corey.
00:07:37 And there are some tariff adjustments on non-U.S. countries.
00:07:42 Most notably, the Carney Liberals are cracking down on any country that has their steel poured in China.
00:07:49 So they're leveraging tariffs on those countries, I guess, to boost up Canada's tariff war.
00:07:56 Well, it's interesting.
00:07:57 China does provide a lot of steel to Canada.
00:08:00 I mean, fair enough.
00:08:01 If you're looking at protectionism, that's one of the targets you want to go.
00:08:04 You can see what he's doing, though.
00:08:05 He's fighting back against China and trying to avoid getting further into a deeper fight with President Trump.
00:08:10 Exactly.
00:08:10 Well, China's an issue as well.
00:08:12 It's a mess.
00:08:13 I don't envy Carney.
00:08:14 I don't like him, but he's in a tough, tough position.
00:08:16 I'll give him that.
00:08:17 Yeah, between China and the U.S. is definitely between Iraq and a hard place.
00:08:22 So next on the news is we're following the Alberta Next panel quite closely here at the Western Standard.
00:08:29 So this is a series of panelists that are hearing from Albertans about how they feel on certain issues, such as whether Alberta should have its own police force, whether Alberta should collect income tax rather than having it sent to Ottawa, and whether any kind of pension plan or taxes should be through the Alberta government rather than the federal government.
00:08:55 And, of course, this is as independent sentiment is on the rise here in Alberta, too.
00:09:02 So Premier Smith will be up in Edmonton this evening.
00:09:05 Yeah, I guess last night's meeting, the open mic got a little hot, as you kind of expect.
00:09:10 I mean, you know, she's going to have an interesting time tempering it from the people who are full out, just want an independence referendum, want out, or the people who want to talk about and examine some of those other proposals.
00:09:21 Yeah.
00:09:22 We'll see if maybe they change some of the structuring types.
00:09:25 meeting at Ebiton. Yeah, for sure. And there is nuance to this issue. Some people are approaching
00:09:30 it all or nothing. We've completely had enough. And as you say, others are willing to hear out
00:09:36 other sides and negotiate. So we'll see what this Alberta Next panel produces over the course of
00:09:41 the summer and into September even. Yeah, she's going to have her hands full. Yeah, that goes 0.95
00:09:45 for a while. Yeah, into the end of September, I believe. The end of September, she'll be coming
00:09:49 to Calgary with the Alberta Next Panel.
00:09:52 Ending in, well, we'll have to go to that.
00:09:54 Yeah, we'll have to go check that out.
00:09:56 Yeah, Western Standard Field Trip.
00:09:59 Canada's poverty line is being redefined.
00:10:02 So the federal government is looking at how they're actually going to define what it means
00:10:08 to be poor or living in poverty in Canada.
00:10:12 So we'll find out exactly what their definition is of that by the end of the fall.
00:10:17 Oh, boy.
00:10:17 I mean, I guess it depends on who they put behind it.
00:10:20 Usually you see that as a precursor when they want to start talking universal basic income.
00:10:24 Wow, yeah.
00:10:24 It depends on what you're going to measure it against.
00:10:26 I mean, if you're measuring against Eastern Africa, well, our poverty line is going to be quite low.
00:10:32 But if we measure it against domestic expectations, it's kind of an arbitrary thing.
00:10:37 Nobody's starving or being thrown out in the streets with our social safety net.
00:10:41 Where's poverty land? 0.98
00:10:43 That's right.
00:10:43 Well, they could also lower the poverty line to sort of frame it as though there aren't
00:10:49 so many Canadians that are struggling and living in poverty and then make themselves
00:10:53 look a little better.
00:10:54 Look at that.
00:10:55 We've pulled all these people out of poverty or at least we moved the line. 0.93
00:10:58 At least we moved the line.
00:10:59 Yeah.
00:11:00 Yeah.
00:11:01 You can keep winning when you move the goalpost for sure.
00:11:04 Yeah.
00:11:05 All right.
00:11:06 And as for wildfires, so the feds have finally for the first time ever sat down and calculated
00:11:12 just how much wildfires cost and released a report saying that it's running up into the billions.
00:11:19 And also they established the reasons why they say that there's wildfires rampant,
00:11:24 especially in Western Canada. Guess what the first reason is, Corey?
00:11:27 Oh, probably that we elect a conservative, but better than that, it would be climate change.
00:11:31 Climate change. Yeah, climate change precisely. And as well as population growth
00:11:37 was mentioned in that as well.
00:11:39 So turn this into an immigration discussion. Exactly. Yeah. So a bit of a surprising
00:11:44 acknowledgement by the feds there. And thirdly, they also conceded forest mismanagement played
00:11:52 a role. There is a role for forest management. I'm glad they brought that up, at least having
00:11:57 a bit of an honest look at some of it. Yeah, absolutely. It does actually seem like, you
00:12:01 know, it wasn't a widely published report, of course. It took some access to information
00:12:07 to get that out, of course. Yeah, and they'll cherry pick what portions they want to use later
00:12:11 on. Yeah. So will I. Oh, we're onto them, aren't we? Right on. Yeah. And finally, we're just
00:12:18 speaking a bit before I came on about supply management. So there's an interesting poll this
00:12:23 week released by Angus Reid that found that Quebec, which isn't really surprising, is the
00:12:30 province that most widely supports the supply management system, which has been dubbed the
00:12:35 dairy cartel. Basically, I'm sure you've talked about it a lot on your show. I don't need to go
00:12:40 into details with your audience, Corey. But it's a quota system for dairy farmers that results in 0.94
00:12:46 distortion of the market, a lot of milk products having to be dumped out, inability to sell to
00:12:52 American markets. And it's been widely disputed, especially in Western Canada, especially in
00:13:01 Alberta by Alberta farmers. So the poll shows that I think it was about a third or maybe it was
00:13:09 lower maybe 20 about 24% of Albertans if I remember correctly support the supply management
00:13:15 and many many are opposed. A third point of that study was whether you support you don't support
00:13:22 or if you're okay with it being used as a bargaining chip and a terra for. So at first
00:13:28 glance at the study, it shows that Canadians are widely opposed to it. However, if you look into
00:13:33 the details of it, a large percentage are actually willing to concede that it's not a crucial part of
00:13:42 our economy. Yeah, no, it's an interesting one. But I mean, the overall headline I see they've
00:13:46 been throwing out is that most Canadians support it. That makes you wonder, well, okay, who can
00:13:50 sign the poll? That's what you got to look into, folks. Because some people say, well, it's Angus
00:13:53 Reid? No, that's who did the poll. Who paid the bill? And then when you look at the framing of
00:13:58 the questions, but that's a whole separate discussion. Yeah, absolutely. And who was
00:14:01 polled, which in this case was the Angus Reid forum. And you have to ask, well, who is nudged
00:14:06 into signing up for the Angus Reid forum? That too. But it's interesting, at least it's come
00:14:10 into the discussion because most people, I think that's part of the problem is most people don't
00:14:13 even realize the system is there or what it does, but they are under threat now due to the trade.
00:14:18 And if they have heard of it, a lot of people just heard of it through framing from the federal
00:14:22 government right is this safety net and this protectionism for farmers and don't you want to
00:14:27 save the farmers right when there's a whole other side it's very nuanced issue as well absolutely
00:14:33 all right well thanks for that update you said there wasn't much news going on yeah i guess
00:14:36 there's always something to talk about right on okay well thank you again i'll let you get back
00:14:40 into that newsroom to dig out some more stories on this apparently slow news day yeah right my
00:14:46 pleasure thank you corey thank you so that is our jen hartson yeah as we said very prolific lots of
00:14:51 stories, lots of stuff coming up out there. That's where I like to remind you folks, we are an
00:14:56 independent media outlet. That means we don't take tax dollars. The reason we can pay Jen and me and
00:15:02 John over there and the rest of us is because of subscribers. So if you've already subscribed,
00:15:06 thank you very much. But if you haven't, get on there, guys, westernstandard.news slash
00:15:11 subscription, 10 bucks a month, just like an old newspaper subscription, keeps things rolling for
00:15:15 us, keeps us independent, keeps us accountable to you. It's $100 for a year. Take advantage of that
00:15:21 volume discount for it and then we can keep providing these stories that the other outlets
00:15:27 just don't want to cover and touch. This is the future of media is independent media.
00:15:33 Yeah you know that supply management thing the funny thing is I mean I'll just throw a point out
00:15:37 before I move on to my guest with this you know and they love claiming all these things a couple
00:15:41 for one they say it's saving the family farm well I put that out in a recent column no actually in
00:15:46 in the 70s, we had like 140,000 dairy farms in Canada. Now we have less than 10,000. So if supply
00:15:52 management was supposed to save the family farm, it's done a terrible job. By the way, Gord Tulk
00:15:57 did some good work on this. I'm going to talk about that a little later. As well, the other
00:16:04 aspects I'm seeing, they're saying we have to stop it to keep the supply management to stop the big
00:16:10 bad American products from coming up because they're terrible, terrible dairy and milk products
00:16:14 and they're awful and their quality is terrible. Really? Well, and again, if that's the case,
00:16:18 you don't need to be protected, do you? Do you not trust Canadian shoppers to pick the better
00:16:22 butter? It stinks. All right, let's move on and get to my guest here. And it's Tim Hagstrom. He's 0.99
00:16:31 had rough treatment, as I said, kind of at the start of the show from the University of Saskatchewan
00:16:37 or is it Saskatoon? The University of Saskatchewan. Saskatchewan, yes. Okay, it's in Saskatoon. Okay,
00:16:42 I should know these things as a Westerner, but I appreciate it.
00:16:45 You haven't taken it lying down, and you're taking the fight back to the university.
00:16:50 I guess we'll just kind of start, though.
00:16:51 What happened?
00:16:52 We'll go from there.
00:16:53 You're a law student.
00:16:55 There were some policies you wanted to question, and what went from there?
00:16:58 Well, thank you for having me on, Corey.
00:17:00 And I'm sorry I didn't get the memo about not wearing jeans in your office.
00:17:03 Oh, well, you can't see that from there.
00:17:04 You never mention that.
00:17:05 I mean, I've done some shows with no pants, but they don't need to know that over there.
00:17:09 We'll leave it at that.
00:17:11 So, yes, this started when I was in the third year of law school in my winter semester in 2022.
00:17:19 And I'd just come back from an exchange in Ottawa in the fall and learned that there was a point of great contention among my classmates,
00:17:27 which had to do with an exam accommodation policy, because there is one policy, among others,
00:17:34 for law students at the University of Saskatchewan that is only available to students who self-declare as Indigenous.
00:17:41 I want to be clear about this. I never took a view on that policy. But what really concerned
00:17:47 me at the time, once I talked to a number of students who are really riled up about this,
00:17:52 is I saw students forming into two different factions. And people from opposite factions
00:17:57 were adopting these attitudes that I thought were quite corrosive. They didn't want to talk
00:18:02 to each other. They didn't see, you know, the highest that could be said or didn't want to
00:18:08 see that in the other side. So that's what I spoke out about. I read out a letter that I'd
00:18:14 written to my classmates. You can find it online. And I got punished for that.
00:18:22 Yeah. And I mean, it's indicative of a bigger trend. You looked at things from that traditional
00:18:27 view. It's the institution of higher learning. It's an area where there's supposed to be
00:18:30 discourse. Or if we want to go back to the ancient Greeks, you know, you're supposed to be
00:18:33 philosophizing and sharing different notions even if you differ and that concept is really quite
00:18:39 lost from most post-secondary institutions now it seems it's a bad group think approach.
00:18:44 Well that's exactly what I'm fighting to defend and I really believe in that so
00:18:49 the case we have now at the Saskatchewan Court of King's Bench is quite interesting because
00:18:55 we've got two expert reports now to explain concepts are going to be important in this
00:19:02 litigation. So one expert report is on the recognized principles of academic freedom,
00:19:06 because the University of Saskatchewan Act, which gives the university its powers,
00:19:11 requires that the Senate, the board, and the council do things having regard to the
00:19:16 recognized principles of academic freedom. And this expert report paints a picture of
00:19:21 what I believe in, which is a community of scholars and students who are openly and sincerely
00:19:26 really discussing things where the moral and intellectual autonomy of every individual is
00:19:31 prized. And to my mind, this is the only way that a university can fulfill its promise to society,
00:19:38 which is to discover knowledge and transmit it and not get stuck in attitudes that prevent
00:19:45 people from looking for their blind spots. Yeah. So, I mean, it didn't just end with
00:19:50 some hostile times. And in the end, I mean, you've completed your university and such,
00:19:55 when you got sanctioned, essentially. I mean, there were consequences they laid upon you for
00:19:59 this. Yes. So what happened is I read this letter towards the end of third year. And then as I was
00:20:06 just finishing up exams, I received a notice of a complaint that another student had made.
00:20:11 I thought it would be dismissed, and it wasn't. Then I thought we could try a mediated conversation
00:20:15 to resolve what I thought must be a misunderstanding. That didn't happen. Instead, I was found guilty
00:20:21 of having committed harassment by reading this letter we tried an appeal at the university and
00:20:27 they upheld that decision so now there's a sanction uh there's a reprimand on my file i don't know if
00:20:33 it's been written yet i'd be interested to read it and they ordered that i write an apology letter
00:20:40 that acknowledged that what i said caused harm and this would amount to denouncing my own beliefs
00:20:47 i'm not willing to do that no and and that's where it starts smacking i don't want to draw
00:20:53 too many close analogies but you know of the old oppressive regimes where they would re-educate and
00:20:59 if a person still has been found guilty of stepping outside of the line yes forced apologies forced
00:21:05 retractions and that's not healthy i mean unless it's genuine anyways whether you're right or wrong
00:21:13 forcing apologies is not beneficial. Well, I agree with that. And it's interesting when I made
00:21:19 submissions to this hearing board who decided the sanction, I looked at their policy and it says they
00:21:25 can request an apology. It doesn't say they can require one. And I told them, if you request an
00:21:30 apology from me, it will have no practical effect. You should choose something else
00:21:34 because I can't issue that apology. So kind of getting back to what you question, I mean,
00:21:39 I know part of it is questioning just the whole process and not allowing you to discuss this,
00:21:43 but I mean just so people know what was underlying with this is there's a different length of time
00:21:47 that self-identified Indigenous students may have to write exams as opposed to other students which
00:21:55 I guess you know it can be debatable on whether Indigenous students just need that extra time and
00:22:02 it'll be beneficial or it is an unfair racially based change of requirements for different
00:22:10 students. I mean these are the things we should then discuss if we're going to have it but the
00:22:14 bottom line is what you're told is you don't even talk about it. That's exactly it and that policy
00:22:20 has been around for a long time at the college. They're wanting to do something about under
00:22:24 representation for Indigenous people in the legal profession and at the College of Law and I think
00:22:29 reasonable people can come at that from different angles including the one that the college has
00:22:34 settled on but what's really an issue in this case is this broader point of are students even allowed
00:22:40 to discuss this and i think it's important that we're in this litigation wanting to be very
00:22:47 precise about what's an issue so we've uncovered a number of policy documents at the university
00:22:54 that actually had a bearing in this case even though that wasn't quite clear as i was going
00:22:59 through the proceedings and we've brought this second expert report to help explain that so what
00:23:05 we're hoping to persuade the court is that the university has taken a specific intellectual or
00:23:12 sorry an institutional commitment starting in about 2020 the summer of 2020 i don't know if
00:23:18 you remember that was a summer of racial reckoning particularly yeah that says idyll no more was
00:23:23 exploding and well and no that was after idyll no more that was the the uh summer of george floyd
00:23:30 And yes, in Canada. And so what the university did was they committed to doing more about racism.
00:23:39 And how they did this is that they appointed an individual to be a special advisor on anti-racism
00:23:46 to establish a committee which had very vast powers at the university. And this person happened
00:23:51 to be a post-colonial scholar, which is a very interesting worldview. I don't believe in it at
00:23:58 all. But I do respect people's moral and intellectual autonomy. So I respect that people
00:24:03 can have that worldview of postcolonial studies. But what happens once the university takes that
00:24:10 on as an institutional commitment? That's what's at issue in this litigation. So what our expert
00:24:16 explains is that in this worldview of postcolonial studies, there's a certain degree of moral
00:24:22 relativism. They don't completely believe in objective truth. So that's somewhere where I
00:24:27 disagree. And the way it manifests specifically is that claims made by Indigenous people are
00:24:36 thought to be on a higher level. In some instances, they're not to be questioned at all.
00:24:41 And the other sort of precept of this worldview is that every inequality of outcome between
00:24:50 Indigenous and non-Indigenous people must have been caused by some sort of moral depravity 1.00
00:24:56 that they tend to call white supremacy or other words like this.
00:25:02 What happens when you think that every unequal, unequal outcome must be caused by some sort of
00:25:08 moral depravity? Everything is always somebody else's fault. It's not a healthy mindset to take
00:25:12 on for oneself for personal growth. You can face injustice and things are unfair and can happen to
00:25:19 people. But when it's really ingrained like that, I mean, it's a questionable approach to give to
00:25:25 Well, what it does is it shuts down speech. And that's what we've seen here. The hearing board,
00:25:31 I think, read this case as, first of all, there's this debate that was going on about this policy
00:25:39 dealing with extra time on exams. And for the hearing board, there is no debate. Of course,
00:25:45 that policy is necessary, because if there are unequal outcomes in terms of Indigenous people
00:25:49 being represented in the legal profession and so on, it must be caused by white supremacy.
00:25:54 There's no defending the outcome.
00:25:56 And so there's no critiquing a measure that's meant to level that playing field.
00:26:01 And that, unfortunately, prevents people from seeking solutions, assuming they're things outside of white nationalism, supremacy that's been holding it down.
00:26:09 I mean, I was kind of talking about that a bit before the show.
00:26:13 I've been visiting reserves and sharing video and things.
00:26:15 I mean, there's just some socioeconomic challenges that are happening on reserves and in the system.
00:26:21 And we can go far enough back as to how it ended up here where it is now.
00:26:24 but those are going to hinder people making it to a higher level of post-secondary education
00:26:28 like there's some solutions we need to go into much deeper than just constantly pointing the
00:26:32 finger at colonialism and white supremacy. That's exactly right and I just go back to
00:26:37 the point I made earlier that this vision I have of academic freedom to me is the way for
00:26:42 universities to fulfill the promise to Canadian society but one of our experts actually makes
00:26:48 this point. It hadn't occurred to me before, but it's quite interesting. If the goal is to have
00:26:54 more Indigenous people in a university, in a genuine university experience, you can't turn 1.00
00:27:00 the university into something that isn't a university because they're not getting that
00:27:04 experience. So I'm here to preserve that experience and I hope everybody gets access to it,
00:27:10 but it's got to still be a university. Well, yeah, and it becomes unfair. I worry about that as
00:27:15 is somebody who will rely on professionals and on a number of levels through life,
00:27:20 whether it's doctors, lawyers, and such.
00:27:22 And you want to pick who you feel is going to be the best person to do that job.
00:27:26 And there's that unfairness that starts to come with a double standard
00:27:30 going towards certain groups and minorities,
00:27:32 whereas even unconsciously I might start ruling out other individuals
00:27:36 because, well, maybe that person went through it
00:27:38 without having the proper program and training that I expect in a university.
00:27:42 and it actually puts who could be some very fantastic lawyers, doctors, engineers at a disadvantage
00:27:47 because people look out of the corner and say, well, was it DEI or were they really
00:27:52 get to that position on merit? It's just not doing favours to the Indigenous community.
00:27:58 Well, certainly those are positions that reasonable people can take to critique these policies. I
00:28:03 think I understand where the college is coming from as well. They want to do something and
00:28:08 Are you going to have some very invasive, you know, detailed application from every single person to find out who needs how much accommodation?
00:28:19 They've decided not to do it that way.
00:28:21 So, you know, you can argue it both ways.
00:28:24 But where the university, I think, really stepped over a line here is all of this bled into disciplinary proceedings.
00:28:32 They were actually willing to use in our submissions in court.
00:28:36 we say they were willing to use their non-academic misconduct proceedings to enforce
00:28:42 as the appeal board of the university puts it that they can educate a student that it is
00:28:49 inappropriate to discuss that they're indigenous and non-indigenous groups of students and that
00:28:55 the non-indigenous students are treated unfairly that's why i was punished so i know that the 0.98
00:29:01 university doesn't mind separating people into indigenous and indigenous they're even happy to 0.99
00:29:06 make sweeping generalizations on that basis.
00:29:07 Identity politics are kind of ingrained, actually.
00:29:09 Yeah, but what I was punished for is suggesting that the wrong group is being treated unfairly.
00:29:14 So beyond the broader problems that you want to talk about in a minute with this whole
00:29:18 attitude, though, with yourself, now, do these punitive actions impact your career, or are
00:29:24 they going to, or have they?
00:29:26 They have.
00:29:28 I like to sort of, you know, endure this and not complain much about it, but you ask the
00:29:34 question it's a fair question and they have as long as these proceedings were ongoing I had to
00:29:39 disclose them I did some legal work in Saskatchewan and then I applied to be a lawyer in Alberta so
00:29:47 both law societies regulate that from each province I had to disclose when these proceedings
00:29:53 were ongoing when a decision came out and then that gave the law societies the ability to review
00:29:59 my good character so that's been an adventure let's say
00:30:05 takes up a lot of time and it just has affected I think my options in terms of being called to the
00:30:13 bar as quickly as my peers and you know being able to just launch into my profession without
00:30:20 this hanging over me is something where I still need to clear my name yeah and I just wanted to
00:30:25 establish that because you know you you have filed you know a suit against the university and then
00:30:30 it's you know not because you just have your nose out of joint or something i mean this has
00:30:34 potentially caused serious damages to you thus you know you want to see that remedied yes yeah i want
00:30:40 to see um actually i i know you said before in this segment uh you've uh you don't have a great
00:30:47 degree of faith in our justice system um i believe in our justice system i believe that the court
00:30:53 is going to get this case right.
00:30:56 I think we've got a strong case
00:30:57 and we're inviting the court to grapple with
00:31:01 what happens when a university takes on
00:31:04 as an institutional commitment
00:31:05 this worldview of post-colonial studies,
00:31:08 which isn't receptive to debate
00:31:11 about things that they take for granted.
00:31:14 And basically we say
00:31:15 it offends the principles of academic freedom.
00:31:18 So it's not lawful according to the statute
00:31:20 that gives the university its powers
00:31:21 and it offends the charter.
00:31:23 because their constitution is founded on principles of classical liberalism where individuals have the freedom to express themselves and, you know, opine on matters of the day, including controversial matters.
00:31:36 Yeah, well, and I mean, foundationally, our common law system, I think, is great and has some great things.
00:31:42 I just feel it's quite drifted from what it was supposed to be in some cases, particularly criminal law, but that's kind of side down.
00:31:48 Fair enough. This is not a criminal law case, thankfully.
00:31:51 But if they are following the tenets of what should be established in law, then you should be confidently, you know, it should serve you well through this.
00:31:59 But I mean, how long, what kind of timeline are you looking at on this now?
00:32:02 It's very hard to say. I think we're past three years now from when I first learned of the complaint.
00:32:07 We had to sort of march our way through all the proceedings in the university.
00:32:11 Now we're at the beginning stages at the Court of King's Bench.
00:32:15 It could take many more years. Who knows?
00:32:18 Well, and as you know, again, with the laws, the system of precedents, though, so I mean,
00:32:22 assuming that the things end well as they could for you in this, would this then
00:32:29 encourage universities to change or examine their policies? Like, could this have broader reaching
00:32:34 implications for them? We have approached this in a way where I think it could have very,
00:32:38 very broad reaching implications. We're taking on the policies at the University of Saskatchewan
00:32:44 that affect all members of that university. The language there is similar to what you would find
00:32:51 in other universities across Canada, and it really takes on the implications of this world view.
00:32:58 The broader world view is critical social justice, and that's detailed in our experts report.
00:33:04 Anywhere that that's happening in a university, this case could have implications.
00:33:08 Yeah, well, I'm just hoping maybe it resets things. As I kind of said before the show,
00:33:12 So I'm a little concerned as a guy who's getting a little longer in the tooth.
00:33:15 And I understand it's the next generation coming up who's going to be running this world when I'm a senior citizen.
00:33:20 And I just want to make sure they've had as good and well-rounded an education as possible.
00:33:25 And our post-secondary institutions are kind of, I think, at a point of crisis with that.
00:33:29 It's corrections.
00:33:30 I guess I'm just hoping your case can help nudge that a little back to where it belongs.
00:33:36 Well, every generation has to fight these battles, I think.
00:33:39 So you've got your eyes on the right issues.
00:33:42 I just want to specify, I'm speaking only in my personal capacity, not for any other organization.
00:33:48 Although I'm supported in this case by a charity, I wouldn't be able to do it without them.
00:33:53 Yeah, well, and the Justice Centre for Constitutional Freedoms is representing me on a different thing.
00:33:58 I've got myself into the soup with.
00:33:59 I mean, you know, there's good organizations that helps out when we've, well, if they accept those cases.
00:34:05 So there's nothing wrong with that, absolutely.
00:34:07 So before I let you go, where can people keep track of what's happening with this and what you're up to?
00:34:12 on this then so uh yes the the organization that is supporting me and making this possible is
00:34:17 called freedoms advocate they can be found at freedomsadvocate.ca they're pretty selective
00:34:22 about their cases so people should be able to find mine pretty quickly um and we rely on donations so
00:34:27 if anybody's inclined and able to make a contribution they can donate uh through that
00:34:32 website freedomsadvocate.ca to the cause of protecting the freedom of speech great and i
00:34:38 I just saw you're active with the Runnymede Society.
00:34:41 You want to maybe let the audience know what that is or what it's about?
00:34:45 Oh, yes.
00:34:45 So the Runnymede Society is a special project.
00:34:48 It's existed almost for 10 years.
00:34:50 And we're at different law schools across Canada.
00:34:55 Almost all of them.
00:34:56 We're mostly volunteer-led.
00:34:58 And we host events to grapple with legal matters of the day with intellectual diversity.
00:35:05 So we're taking a different track from what you'd find often in the classroom.
00:35:10 And the Runnymede Society, it's very important to the organization not to take a position on specific legal issues.
00:35:18 It upholds broader principles of constitutionalism, the rule of law, and fundamental freedoms.
00:35:24 Even in my case, the organization takes no position.
00:35:27 I want to make that clear, because people need to be able to come to their own conclusions.
00:35:31 Well, it's the same principle as with the university.
00:35:34 or you know you can debate it and discuss it not taking a stance necessarily that's that's the whole
00:35:38 yeah exactly well i appreciate you you know not taking it laying down i mean you could have just
00:35:43 kind of finished school complied with their things and moved on with your career but but you're
00:35:47 trying to do something proactively after the fact to to well for your own sake but i think
00:35:51 in the broader sake as well so i appreciate that you're coming in to talk to us today
00:35:55 thanks so much for having me on all right well and i wish you the best as it as you said drags
00:36:00 out it's going to take a while through the courts but hopefully it gets a good outcome
00:36:02 I hope so, Tim. Thanks again.
00:36:04 Thank you.
00:36:05 So yeah, guys, if you want to look it up, Tim Hagstrom.
00:36:08 And yes, you can help out with those societies and groups that do help in these things.
00:36:15 As I said, the Justice Center is helping me and then others are helping others.
00:36:18 So if you want to kind of lend a hand, because there's more to this, as you can see with the discussion, it's deeper, it's important.
00:36:25 And it's going to impact all of us in a way, even if you're not going to post-secondary institutions.
00:36:30 that people who graduate from them are going to have an impact on your life.
00:36:35 As I said, professionals, whether it's doctors, lawyers, chemists, engineers, you name it.
00:36:42 Let's see what we got going on in the comments here.
00:36:46 Yes, a lot of advanced fashions pointing out when the law society requires the acceptance of untruth as fact,
00:36:52 then basis sentences and career longevity on that.
00:36:56 There isn't a legal system. There's religious tyranny. 0.73
00:36:58 Yeah, the law societies are a whole other ball of wax. I've had guests on here to talk about that. I've talked with Jonathan Dennis and others because they've been given a rough go by the law societies, which are kind of becoming a little too woke and forgetting, I think, what their mandate should be, again, in trying to maintain balance.
00:37:15 law is an interesting area of education in that it's not a hard science like uh you know math
00:37:27 chemistry uh you know physics where you're going to have some solid rules that are incontrovertible
00:37:33 unless you're extremely woke and say two plus two equals five but you know what i mean law is
00:37:37 actually an area where it's an ongoing debate it's just it's more of a philosophical calling
00:37:44 I mean, it's an important one, but it's one that's changing and flowing with time.
00:37:48 So it's hard to come up with solid rules on what's right, what's wrong.
00:37:54 And it's up to those lawyers to do that task.
00:37:58 And, of course, our judges later on tend to come from the legal class.
00:38:04 And as I said to Tim, and I didn't expect him to go into that exactly, you know, but I fear for that.
00:38:10 When we do DEI on the qualifications to try and get more of people from other particular groups graduating, I worry that we're getting lesser quality graduates or, and it must be infuriating.
00:38:26 I'm certain there's some indigenous or black or other people that graduated from schools and they worked their butts off and they did fantastic and they're brilliant and they've earned every degree and recognition that they've gotten.
00:38:40 but they know that some people kind of look out the corner of their eye and
00:38:44 say, well, was that DEI?
00:38:46 Did they really go through the same process as everybody else?
00:38:49 It's unfair to them because again, as I said, I, to be honest,
00:38:54 I would question, I'd have to see, I guess,
00:38:58 a longer work time resume if I were in a position of hiring for somebody in
00:39:02 one of these positions. But if it was fresh out of school, no, I probably,
00:39:06 I'll say it bluntly. I wouldn't hire people from those minorities, 1.00
00:39:09 not because I dislike the minority, but I worry that they wouldn't be as well qualified as some 0.96
00:39:13 of the others. And this is causing harm to the people it's supposed to help. You know, getting
00:39:20 back to law, getting back to where we're going, getting back to where I, as I said, our systems
00:39:25 in terminal condition, let's talk about immigration. This is a story some others have probably seen
00:39:29 recently. I mean, this is where it gets bizarre too. How are these guys getting on the bench? So
00:39:33 this is an Ontario resident, resident, not a Canadian citizen. Let's be clear about that.
00:39:38 Tried to buy sex from what he thought was a 15 year old. Yeah. So it was a sting operation. He 0.97
00:39:45 was caught for trying to lure a minor. He's a pedophile. Let's say it for what it is. He was 1.00
00:39:52 given a conditional discharge by the judge. Why? To help him stay in Canada because he's not a 1.00
00:40:00 citizen yet. So if he got convicted of this, it might impact his ability to become a citizen.
00:40:08 Really? Yes, I want it impacted. The man's a pedophile. He pursues children. I want him the
00:40:15 hell out of our country. What kind of judge makes an allowance for scum like this to keep him in? 1.00
00:40:25 I mean, people say, how do you define who deserves to stay within Canada, who doesn't among 1.00
00:40:30 immigrants? Well, here's one of the lines that's pretty simple. If they're child predators, we don't
00:40:34 want them. Yet a judge couldn't figure that out, made an exception for this man and said, no,
00:40:43 we don't want to convict him because it might impact his ability to become a citizen. What
00:40:48 the hell is wrong with you guys? And it's this kind of garbage, this immigration crap that's 1.00
00:40:57 going on. Speaking of things that get unfair to others, but we've got to clean up our system on 1.00
00:41:05 who we're accepting, who we aren't. Canada is built on immigration. Immigrants are what, 1.00
00:41:10 immigrants are what make us strong. They bring a work ethic here. They bring professions. They
00:41:15 bring their families. They contribute to the country, but there's a bunch within them that
00:41:21 don't. There's a bunch that are sick. There's a bunch that cause problems. If you saw that 1.00
00:41:25 Western Standard story on that gang in Ontario that was busted because they'd been doing home
00:41:32 invasions all over the place. And you saw the names and the people participating in it. Guys,
00:41:38 they were all new Canadians. They should be the hell out of here. Gone. Make room for the people 1.00
00:41:46 who want to come here and abide by the law. People who want to come here and work and make a living
00:41:51 and make a better life for themselves. Why is it so difficult to just look at these things
00:41:59 objectively and figure out some of the easy ones, right? Man wants to pick up 15 year old children 1.00
00:42:05 and molest them. That's one we don't want. I don't need to be a judge to understand that. I don't
00:42:11 need a law degree to understand that. And I'm pretty confident most Canadians will accept that
00:42:16 kind of ruling. And it gets to the stupid, you know, an issue that's been big lately too with, 1.00
00:42:22 oh, the big book ban in Alberta. Oh, the Alberta government's cracking down and banning books. Oh, 1.00
00:42:26 they're virtual fascists because they're banning books. And then the people start,
00:42:32 where do you draw the line? How can we allow people to start judging which books are appropriate
00:42:36 for children within children's libraries and which aren't? And I've been posting that on X.
00:42:41 It's pretty easy to draw the line on some of them because one of the books that was in Alberta
00:42:44 of schools, in front of children, in a library, depicted a couple of men going down on each
00:42:51 other. Guess what? There, there's one you can safely remove from the list. Is it really that
00:42:59 complicated? Was it really that hard? Do you really need to allow it all? No. Pull the porn.
00:43:07 It's not that complicated. But these naval gazers, these hammerheads, then I really wonder 0.96
00:43:14 where their interests are, who want to get that in front of our kids. You know, and then there are
00:43:19 people saying, oh, they're pulling it because of homophobia. No, they're pulling it because it's
00:43:22 freaking porn. And, you know, I saw somebody speaking on X who said it well. He's a gentleman 0.87
00:43:29 from the LGBTQ community. I said, why is this always sexualized anyways? You know, they can 1.00
00:43:36 discuss LGBTQ things with kids as they're growing, as they're figuring out who they are and what
00:43:41 they're going to be without going into, oh, by the way, here's the better way to give a man head.
00:43:48 It doesn't, they reduced it to the sexual component. There's more to being gay than 0.85
00:43:54 having sex with each other, isn't there? There's the relationship. But these nutcases, we get into 1.00
00:44:04 these positions, judges, higher education, our public education system, where they really can't
00:44:12 figure out what's porn or what's not, what's appropriate to become in front of kids, what's
00:44:17 not. Again, getting back to where Gordon maybe thought it was exaggerating when I say things
00:44:23 are in terminal condition. Well, when we're seeing stuff like this going on, I'd say it's
00:44:27 getting a little terminal. If we have a society that really can't figure out when porn is
00:44:32 appropriate to put in front of children or not yeah we got a terminal problem guys and we got
00:44:38 to talk bluntly to it we got to accept it we got to get realistic about it another one i'm going
00:44:44 to just stir up the anti-vaccination folks among my own the measles outbreak it's been getting big
00:44:51 it's been getting wider look folks it's 100 preventable i'm not going to go down the rabbit
00:44:55 hole of talking about all vaccinations most people were talking about with the covid thing which is
00:44:59 separate. They're saying, I accept all the old vaccinations, the proven ones, the polio,
00:45:05 the measles, the rubella, the mumps, whatever, all that. Well, not everybody did, obviously,
00:45:09 because there haven't been enough vaccinations and now measles is going around and we don't
00:45:12 need it to be going around. I know it's not the most harmful disease in the world, but it's still
00:45:17 one you don't want your kids getting if you don't have to. I don't believe in vaccine mandates.
00:45:22 Never have, never will. It has to be a choice. It must be a choice. And I think part of the reason
00:45:28 and people aren't taking it up is because the bloody coercion and crap that came out during
00:45:32 COVID, the government actually built the mistrust that led to fewer people getting the vaccinations.
00:45:37 But guys, please look into it. We don't need to be battling measles. This is one that should be
00:45:43 behind us. So keep it in mind. All right, lots going on. Check in for the pipeline. It's going
00:45:50 to come on a little bit later tonight and the rest of our stuff. Be sure to share our links,
00:45:54 subscribe all that good stuff send me emails if you got more you want coverage stories ideas things
00:46:00 like that and of course take out a subscription with the standard if you haven't already so uh
00:46:05 thank you again for tuning in today guys and we'll see you next week at this time
00:46:24 We'll be right back.