Western Standard - December 12, 2019


The Drill - Scheer Resignation! - December 12, 2019

Guests
Mentioned
The Pipeline - Episode 2 - Federal Fiscal Update

Episode Stats


Length

19 minutes

Words per minute

176.62

Word count

3,363

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Andrew Scheer suddenly resigns as Conservative Party of Canada leader, and no one saw it coming. What does that mean for the rest of the party, and who will replace him as leader? And who will be the next leader of the Conservatives?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 You're here with The Drill and joining me today is the Western Standards publisher Derek
00:00:14 Vildebrand and Western Standard digital editor Paul Holmes and of course we have the big news
00:00:19 today Derek about Andrew Scheer just suddenly resigning no one saw it coming no one so a
00:00:29 little bit of background obviously there's been a movement to remove him what else do
00:00:34 we know at this point of the day it's 1130 Pacific time on Thursday December 12th
00:00:42 well there's obviously been quite a bit of a movement to remove him from the
00:00:48 leadership of the party we started getting some word yesterday that in the
00:00:56 review that was being done by former cabinet minister John Baird it it was
00:01:02 about to come to light that Andrew Scheer had been using party funds to pay it
00:01:09 whole or a part it's not yet clear for his children's private schooling now just
00:01:15 just to be clear is that is that is that confirmed or is that the rumor that has
00:01:20 now been confirmed today but that was about to break likely today where the
00:01:26 Western standard was not able to confirm and on the record source so we did not
00:01:30 run with the story but we knew the press gallery in Ottawa was hurrying around
00:01:35 trying to confirm it as well it probably would have been a pretty big knife and
00:01:41 shear at that point I don't think party members who are giving money to win
00:01:48 elections would be happy to see their donations going to pay towards so it's
00:01:51 private school right for someone who's lived in government resident got
00:01:56 mansions government mansions for a decade and it's obviously got the money to pay
00:02:00 for their own kids schooling if they don't want to send them to a public school
00:02:03 you probably remember in BC I believe I think it was Christy Clark that had the
00:02:09 the party was paying a stipend for her clothing allowance a fairly significant
00:02:16 clothing allowance and and that's not unprecedented it's not unprecedented for
00:02:20 parties to talk something up but in this case members were not told about it it
00:02:26 was done secretly it's it's a it's a not widely known fact actually that members
00:02:32 of the Conservative Party of Canada have no say whatsoever how the money is spent
00:02:36 even the elected National Council party it's actually run by a shadowy
00:02:39 organization called Conservative Fund of Canada right which is more or less just an
00:02:43 appointed shadowy group it's the fundraising arm right it's not just the
00:02:48 fundraising arm it gets to decide how the money is spent and so there's no
00:02:51 accountability to the and we were on a bit of attention but there was a fairly
00:02:55 significant story about to break and coupled together with really shaky caucus
00:03:03 support and very large numbers of members saying he should go with this about to
00:03:08 come I think the decision would have been made late last night that this this blow
00:03:15 would have been very painful even if he could survive it there would be more coming
00:03:20 so Andrew Scheer this morning addressed the Conservative caucus informed him he was
00:03:25 resigning and then stood up right afterwards in the House of Commons and and said he's
00:03:29 out there we go one and done but he's gonna he says he's gonna stay as the as the
00:03:35 leader on an interim basis now that he's given a notification of resignations
00:03:40 actually up to the conservative caucus to decide if they want a new interim leader
00:03:43 or not it's not up to him it's up to the caucus my guess is the caucus is
00:03:48 probably gonna fall in line and let him have this on an interim basis until the new
00:03:52 leaders chosen but we'll see if certainly the he commanded the support of the
00:04:00 previous caucus and I don't think it's changed a whole lot in this this
00:04:04 Parliament so yeah so I I suspect that's probably gonna be the I suspect he'll
00:04:09 survive till the replacement is chosen yeah and who's that gonna be Derek
00:04:16 Maxime Bernier I think I saw the Western Standard has put forth ten names don't
00:04:23 know how long that one's been already prepared actually that was written that
00:04:30 article came out either the very first day or the second day of the Western
00:04:33 standards existence there we go that was written some time ago we just
00:04:38 essentially replaced it and put it back up not much has changed the only thing we
00:04:43 would probably add to the list now is maybe Don Cherry should be on that sure
00:04:46 sure yeah I know this well so we could talk about the people on that list a
00:04:52 little bit maybe what I'll do is I'll just list the the the folks that are being
00:04:58 speculated and we could talk about the ones that maybe are not on there we have
00:05:01 Brad Wall former Saskatchewan Premier Rona Ambrose the former interim leader of the
00:05:06 Conservatives who of course did a very respectable job everybody sort of seems
00:05:12 to agree how about Jason Kenney Premier of Alberta Michelle Rample has a as a
00:05:18 popular following obviously very very significant on social media I'm not sure
00:05:25 about Maxine Bernier at this point but he's on there he's on the list
00:05:29 Max has done bolder things so as crazy as it is it wouldn't be the craziest thing
00:05:36 he's attempted to do absolutely Peter McKay that's you know waste from the
00:05:43 wilderness he'll be on any short list for the next conservative leader as long as he's
00:05:48 still draws breath absolutely John Baird takes a lot a lot of a lot of checkboxes
00:05:55 for electability Aaron O'Toole of course ran against Sheeran Bernier Pierre
00:06:02 Pauliev that's an interesting one I I'm I'm not sure about that one either and
00:06:07 then Candace Bergen I noticed that James Moore is not on the list number 11 way oh way out of there
00:06:18 yeah I mean James Moore's you know he's a respected guy he was a mid low to
00:06:24 mid-level cabinet minister under Harper jeez I can't think of a I'm not
00:06:30 including Jagmeet Singh as a British Columbian he parachuted there to get a
00:06:33 seat and that's fine that's a national leaders do that's okay the the last
00:06:37 British Columbian I can remember correct me if I'm wrong but I can't think of a
00:06:40 British Columbian leader of a national parties it's Kim Campbell yeah probably and
00:06:46 and how'd that go barely well I'm not blaming BC I'm looking to Kim Campbell
00:06:52 yeah there's been a few NDP leaders I think the Johnny Johnny McDonald was
00:06:58 representing he did a Jagmeet Singh he needed a seat and he went out to
00:07:02 Victoria he was from Kingston but yeah I suppose no but I thought
00:07:07 Victoria's recently repudiated its history with Sir John McDonnell so you don't get to
00:07:12 claim it anymore since it took the statue down yeah yeah I didn't personally
00:07:16 take the statue down just for the right I heard you didn't all right so um so yeah
00:07:23 do you want to talk about some of these these folks or should we leave that for
00:07:26 well we gotta you know some people said when we posted this article they said the
00:07:30 body's uh not even cold yet well that's because we wrote this a month and a half
00:07:34 ago uh but we you know it's obviously very topical we put it out um I I need to
00:07:42 like uh well Maxime Bernier but I don't think it's happening uh actually I talked to
00:07:49 Max this morning uh we're gonna be doing uh an exclusive with uh him on his
00:07:54 reaction but big surprise he's not coming back to run uh I actually think he did win
00:07:59 last time I I the results were destroyed before they even announced it I thought
00:08:03 I I think they were rigged I uh I don't think he's gonna try his hand again
00:08:07 I I don't uh I mean that was so close that you know anything is possible
00:08:14 it's like I I how do you feel about Epstein as well as that
00:08:17 I'm not being that conspiratorial well no no Epstein did not kill himself
00:08:23 like you don't you don't get into you don't get into inside job twin tower stuff
00:08:28 by thinking Jeffrey Epstein I think you are a conspiracy theorist if you think he did kill
00:08:33 him so um but I don't know I uh you know I think Rempel can make a strong run she's very
00:08:40 popular in uh in Alberta here especially around Calgary what about Brad Wall I uh I've always
00:08:46 respected him a lot well it'll be interesting I mean there was a lot of kerfuffle last time
00:08:53 about if there should be another western leader in a row I mean uh if you look at kind of the
00:08:58 broad historical lay of things you had Preston Manning Stockwell Day Stephen Harper and then
00:09:04 it was like well can we have another western leader and if you can if you include Andrew
00:09:09 Shearer as a western leader I mean like he's spent the vast majority of his career in Ottawa but
00:09:13 you represented us so sure um but we had a so we had another western leader you know Saskatchewan
00:09:20 being our little brother province um so that raises questions you know uh about an Ambrose
00:09:27 a Kenny a Rempel a Wall I really like Wall um I think he's probably have to have a bit more than
00:09:36 he deserves like he was a good premier of Saskatchewan but he wasn't this great reforming
00:09:41 libertarian conservative but he did a good job turning Saskatchewan around but I I think there's
00:09:48 going to be a lot of pressure to elect someone not from the west in this in this leadership
00:09:53 because if if we're kind of going through if the chronology goes to the reform party not the PCs
00:09:59 there's been western leaders since 1988 and uh so I I think Ontario is good Ontario or the east in
00:10:07 general is going to seem to want to have its turn in this leadership race so so if it is Ontario uh of
00:10:12 course one candidate that ticks every box uh is um Mulroney do you think she's uh I was wondering
00:10:20 which one I mean uh well not not the tv star but the other one well the tv star would be the more
00:10:26 comparable to our prime minister right now uh I don't yeah Karen Mulroney um I mean it's it's not
00:10:34 entirely fair to compare her to Justin Trudeau she has actually accomplished something in her life prior to
00:10:38 politics she's a she's an accomplished lawyer I think in corporate law but I can't say she's an 0.58
00:10:42 accomplished lawyer very intelligent gone on to do a lot of things um of course her family name has given
00:10:49 her uh profile that she would not otherwise have that's impossible to say it's not true uh but it's
00:10:55 much less true than it is with Trudeau where it was just simply the golden ticket that being said uh she
00:11:01 is very much a she is the definition of a Laurentian elite just on the Tory side of things uh so I I don't
00:11:09 think Westerners would be pretty happy uh the last time we had a Mulroney uh we got the reform party out
00:11:17 but will she run I don't know I mean she ran for the Ontario PC leadership did decent uh obviously didn't 0.51
00:11:25 win yeah you know there's you know there's been a lot of phone calls to her this this morning so oh yeah 0.82
00:11:30 I'm sure it's being chatted up uh it is possible that um she will I I I could see it as conceivable
00:11:39 she runs uh as the the Laurentian candidate I think uh the punditocracy has been saying that the
00:11:46 Conservative Party is too Western which drives me crazy they didn't even run on even minor tweaking of
00:11:51 equalization they didn't run on very much that was particularly strongly Western uh Westerners are generally
00:11:59 willing to vote for the Conservatives because uh they'll screw them less badly than the other main
00:12:03 parties right um but you know thank your island you're your own little world there um which is
00:12:11 kind of what I love about you guys yeah it's it's adorable it's it's a greenish orange yeah so uh but
00:12:19 yeah I know you could see someone like Carolyn Mulroney run as someone that the media like because she she 1.00
00:12:25 checks the boxes of an alarm and I don't want to take she's a very smart and capable woman but she's 0.53
00:12:30 not particularly conservative well and she's certainly not uh Western in her outlook a lot of
00:12:36 people and I would say in particular a lot of people in Ontario that are party supporters and and beyond
00:12:42 are going to be looking at electability that's where I think um you know they're going to be looking for
00:12:47 somebody moderate centrist somebody like her somebody like Peter McKay um you know I think uh I think when they
00:12:53 when the uh when the first polling numbers come in we're going to see names like that near the near
00:12:59 the top um you know in double digits anyway so well electability is important it it tends not to be at
00:13:06 the top of my list when I'm looking at candidates which is perhaps perhaps why I didn't make a
00:13:10 particularly good politician is I I just I vote for the most conservative the most Western candidate
00:13:16 every time can't imagine uh electability factors in but it's not in the top five yeah all right I don't
00:13:23 want someone who's going to get us nothing but uh you know it they want someone who's going to appeal
00:13:29 in the GTA and in Vancouver and Montreal and Quebec I mean you can do well with that if you're not winning
00:13:37 suburban Toronto you're not winning right that's the new sort of logic oh yeah that's our Ohio and
00:13:43 Florida you don't win that you're not in government that's exactly that's it but uh but I don't know
00:13:49 if I was the conservatives I would be very leery of picking someone who's not going to be very closely
00:13:54 attuned to western concerns right now uh westerners voted for the conservative party of Canada in
00:13:59 overwhelming numbers in the last election but they also did in 1988 and then in 1989 they started
00:14:06 electing reformers and by elections and senate elections uh so they've got to be very careful
00:14:13 with what to do they're between a bit of a rock and hard place are they going to uh continue to be
00:14:18 a western party as they're accused of being by the Laurentian media or are they going to be a more
00:14:24 Laurentian friendly party but risk uh giving an opening to some something new in the west which
00:14:32 has got a market for it right now but it's not yet there so long as there's a Saskatchewan leader
00:14:38 so if you had to predict today and that you know I know how much you love to do this who's uh who's
00:14:44 the front runner or who are the amongst the potential front runners uh when when uh the poll numbers start
00:14:51 coming out well we just don't know who's going to run yet um I mean the first poll will be speculative
00:14:58 anyway right yes somebody says explicitly that Jason Kenney will be on there um that being said
00:15:04 I'm really not sure he can run um I've always thought he would want to uh there's pretty strong
00:15:11 signs he does I'm not sure he will though for a number of reasons uh the RC I'm not sure how well
00:15:16 you're following this there but the there are some very serious RCMP investigations going on right now
00:15:22 that he might get away with in Alberta but could be very damaging nationally where people are less
00:15:26 willing to vote for a fence post as a conservative candidate uh as well as uh and this isn't really
00:15:34 this isn't something I thought of as an issue until about a month and a half ago until a month and a
00:15:39 half ago he could probably have a pretty safe bet of more or less appointing his successor I'm not
00:15:44 sure that's the case anymore if if he were to vacate the leadership of the Ontario uh the Alberta UCP
00:15:50 um there's a good chance a separatist could win all of a sudden you've got an independent supporting
00:15:57 government in Alberta without even an election um and I think that'd be a real danger so I I'm not
00:16:03 sure he runs I mean it is possible that he does so I think it is his ultimate ambition but I I don't
00:16:08 think he will because there's some pretty big circumstances lining up against them and as we
00:16:13 talked about on the pipeline this week you know he is um he's pretty firmly and um um um you know
00:16:20 he has a lot of fixing to do right now in Alberta and until he does that I don't see him making that
00:16:27 transition what he would claim is that he has to go to Ottawa to fix these things right I mean that
00:16:31 that would be his excuse but anyway uh if Brad Wall wins he'd be a huge uh sorry enters the race he
00:16:38 would be very hard to beat I think he'd be the instant front runner he'd have the support of the west
00:16:43 but you then have um you know the Laurentian media chirping away that oh this is just a western party
00:16:49 blah blah blah and well westerners want a western party right now and if they don't get it in the
00:16:53 conservative party they might look elsewhere there is nothing else right now uh that's likely to break
00:17:01 through I mean the PPC shares a lot of the values but it's not a western party yeah so but a western
00:17:07 party can't by definition be led by somebody from Quebec right as much as many westerners might like
00:17:13 the idea no I don't think it works fair enough all right uh any other comments before we wrap this up
00:17:20 uh geez um so much right there's a lot it's coming hot and fast uh there's a lot to take in but um
00:17:32 the conservative party is now going to have a bit of a bloodletting I Andrew Scheer did not go
00:17:36 willingly I think he was probably sat down by his inner circle and they said do it now or it's going
00:17:43 to go down bloody I I believe for some time it was inevitably he was going to go I didn't think
00:17:48 he'd go before Christmas but I think this saves him a lot of grief I think this saves the party a
00:17:52 lot of grief uh they won't have to spend uh especially since they're in a minority government
00:17:57 parliament here they have to have a leader up and running as soon as possible to face a general
00:18:03 election which will come sooner than four years from now and Andrew Scheer hanging on to the
00:18:09 spring when there was really little chance of him surviving it anyway was not very was not putting
00:18:14 his party first he's now um uh well I don't think this was necessarily done for the party it's better
00:18:20 for the party to get this out of the way so the conservatives would be probably wise to have a
00:18:25 leadership race that wraps up no later than the fall of next year all right well there you have it
00:18:33 um that is the drill the big news today um I was going to say Jason Kenney not Jason Kenney Andrew
00:18:40 Scheer vacates the leadership of the conservative party uh so lots more to come uh stay tuned to
00:18:45 westernstandardonline.com for the latest breaking news as it happens thanks for joining me today
00:18:52 derek fildebrand publisher best slice