Western Standard - June 16, 2023


The federal standoff over CCP interference

Topics
Mentioned
MPC Daily Market Update June 15, 2023 Here comes the Just Transition

Episode Stats


Length

20 minutes

Words per minute

176.78

Word count

3,538

Sentence count

187

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode, former Prime Minister Stephen Harper sits down with former Speaker of the House of Commons, Jay Sheinfeld, to discuss the Trudeau government's handling of the corruption scandal surrounding the Panetta inquiry, and what can be done to force the opposition parties to join forces to force a confidence vote.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Thanks for coming in and talk to us today, Jay.
00:00:01 My pleasure, Corey. It's always nice to be on your show.
00:00:04 Yeah. And what I kind of said in the email, what I want to get to is we've had all of this federal
00:00:09 talk. We've had all of this political games going on for months. We have a federal government that's
00:00:14 in a minority position, but they still, it appears, to be able to skate on a public inquiry. Like,
00:00:21 I'm just wondering, are there parliamentary things that can be done to address this by
00:00:25 the opposition parties or are there hands tied? Well, first of all, absolutely. There are things
00:00:31 that can be done. I think you're well aware that I hold the dubious distinction of having been the
00:00:38 only member of parliament in the history of our Canadian parliament to hold the position of
00:00:43 caucus or party whip four times. My staff did some research and couldn't find any other time that
00:00:51 anybody had been in that position twice, let alone four times. And I've also been the house leader,
00:00:57 both in opposition for the chief opposition, but also for the government, which is a cabinet position,
00:01:06 as you know. So I'm very well versed in certainly in what can happen and how a government can be held
00:01:16 accountable. Certainly part of the reason why I decided to try something else other than public
00:01:24 life in 2010 was at the time I had reached the, basically the apex of my political career. I was
00:01:30 in cabinet, I was sort of sitting on the right hand of the prime minister at the time as the government
00:01:35 house leader or the leader of the government in the house of commons. And as such, in a minority
00:01:42 parliament, it's a very, very difficult position normally, certainly for a conservative it is,
00:01:47 because you have to negotiate with the other parties, Corey, bill by bill, motion by motion,
00:01:54 daily, sometimes hourly, to try and get anything done for the government's agenda to get it through
00:01:59 parliament. And of course, with conservatives, we don't have any natural allies. All the other parties
00:02:05 are, shall we say, left of centre. And so it was immensely stressful for the two minority parliaments
00:02:14 that we had from 2006 to 2011 until Prime Minister Harper won his one and only majority. So I fully
00:02:23 recognise what can be done and what can't be done when it comes to negotiating with the other parties.
00:02:30 Sadly, for Canadians, we have an opposition party, the NDP, under the leadership of Jagmeet Singh,
00:02:37 that has given our prime minister free reign to do whatever the hell he wants. And that's totally
00:02:44 unlike the way we were held accountable, Harper Conservatives, in those two minorities that I was
00:02:49 a part of.
00:02:51 Yeah, well, and just the talking out of both sides of his mouth, though, whereas Jagmeet Singh has been
00:02:55 very critical, rightly so, of this whole scandal. I mean, see, we might as well call it that by now,
00:03:02 you know, the scandal of the Chinese Communist Party interference and the Trudeau government
00:03:06 working so hard to block an inquiry by all means. But, you know, he's tabling motions, a non-binding
00:03:11 motion, a non-binding motion. Well, big deal. It's virtue signalling. But are there things that can be
00:03:16 done that can force this then without bringing down the government? He's saying, okay, we'd have to,
00:03:22 it's not worth bringing the government down over right now. I mean, not all of us might agree, but
00:03:26 fine. But, you know, is it opposition day? Is there something they could put in as a bill or
00:03:30 something that can force this without turning it to a confidence matter?
00:03:34 Well, absolutely. I mean, the prime minister under our system always holds the Trump card,
00:03:40 Corey, I think you're aware of this, in so far as that he can declare any motion or any act,
00:03:47 any piece of legislation, a confidence motion, which means that if that motion is defeated,
00:03:54 if it falls, then we're into an election. That's what that means. But what we did,
00:04:03 what Stephen Harper did when prime minister and I as both his house leader and earlier as his
00:04:07 government whip, we negotiated on a continual basis with the other parties to say, okay, well,
00:04:14 how can we work with you to amend this so that it doesn't become a confidence measure? In fact,
00:04:20 we never played that so-called Trump card of declaring something a confidence unless we felt
00:04:27 very clearly that it was so integral to our government agenda for what we were trying to
00:04:34 accomplish for Canadians that we had no other choice. So that happened very rarely that we would
00:04:40 sort of have a showdown. And usually it was behind closed doors where you say, you know, face to face,
00:04:46 well, this is so much part of our electoral promises or whatever, that if you're insistent,
00:04:55 other house leaders, other whips about getting your caucuses to vote against it, and we lose this,
00:05:01 then we're going to go into an election. That's very rare under most circumstances.
00:05:05 The problem is, is that Jagmeet Singh never plays that card. He never, I'm sure he never says to
00:05:12 the prime minister, or maybe behind closed doors, the prime minister indicates all the time to him,
00:05:18 well, you know, if you go against this Jagmeet, we're going to be into an election. In other words,
00:05:23 he's playing that fear of a confidence motion constantly. Because stomping short of that,
00:05:29 there's lots that can be done. At committees, opposition days, as you say, in the House of
00:05:35 Commons, there's a few that are votable, that are actually driven to a vote, you could do a lot of
00:05:41 things. This is not the first scandal. There have been many. And the prime minister has done this,
00:05:48 prime minister Trudeau has done this repeatedly throughout the last number of years, where every
00:05:53 time a scandal comes up, he'll do everything possible to hide it from Canadians, even up to and
00:05:59 including calling an election, you know, which he did in 2021. So it's just really, it comes down to
00:06:09 having an extremely weak opposition party, led by someone that doesn't want to see an election,
00:06:16 because he fears for himself in his leadership position, and he fears for his party's fortunes.
00:06:23 Oh, yeah, and I understand that. I mean, Jagmeet Singh is as close to power as he will ever get. He
00:06:27 knows that, you know, come the next election, he might not be in such a position again. But I mean,
00:06:33 it just feels to me that it's a bluff that it can be called. I mean, you know, when you when you
00:06:39 declare something a confidence matter, that means that you're building a hill for yourself to die on.
00:06:43 You're saying we're gonna stand on this. And really, even Trudeau is as tone deaf as he can
00:06:48 seem to be, to go to Canadians, and we're going to call an early election, because I don't want to
00:06:53 go to an inquiry, I can't think of a more politically suicidal platform to go to the voters with, I just
00:06:59 don't think he would, he would do that. So to answer your question, yes, on opposition day,
00:07:05 certainly we had tremendous challenges at each and every committee. As you know, the procedure and
00:07:11 House Affairs Committee has been studying this issue, if you will, they called the
00:07:18 I forget what he's called now, reporter, Mr. Johnston, before them for a three hour testimony
00:07:29 about a week ago, I think a week ago yesterday. And, you know, put them on the hot seat asking
00:07:35 questions about why his report basically said, well, no, he didn't think a public inquiry was
00:07:41 necessary. Starting next month, had he stayed in his job before he resigned, he was going to start
00:07:47 public hearings. Well, public hearings do not have the strength and do not have all the tools that a
00:07:54 public inquiry have, as I'm sure you're aware. For example, a public inquiry is very much like the
00:08:00 powers of a standing committee, or even a special committee of the House of Commons. They have
00:08:06 rights very similar to courts, where they can subpoena you and say you will show up on this day
00:08:13 to give evidence and answer questions. Public hearings, which Mr. Johnston allegedly was going to do,
00:08:21 you cannot, they can, they can request, they can ask you to come. But if you sit, you know,
00:08:26 basically, say, go pound sand, nothing, nothing happened. So committees have that power. Jagmeet
00:08:34 Singh and the NDP have that power. They could easily, by dint of working with the other opposition
00:08:41 parties, they could easily force those issues at a committee and hold basically a full public inquiry
00:08:49 or something very similar to that at one of those committees. And you'll recall other instances over the
00:08:56 last number of years since Trudeau came to power in 2015, where committee started to do that. And
00:09:03 then eventually the NDP folded and didn't force it to go to its logical conclusion.
00:09:10 Okay, so they could start because I mean, people want answers. I mean, we're seeing it's rare when we
00:09:15 see such a dominant thing with polling and Canadians, the lack of faith in everything we've been hearing
00:09:20 out of this, you know, you're looking at 20 some percent of the people believing anything more out of the
00:09:25 Trudeau government when it comes to this issue. I mean, they still the numbers supporting the
00:09:30 government are higher than that. Okay, they don't want to go into election, but they want to get to
00:09:32 the bottom of this. They want to find out just what the heck is going on. I mean, we've had some
00:09:37 very direct meddling and it just flabbergasts me. I mean, our system isn't working like it should.
00:09:43 If we can't, in a minority situation, get a real deep dig into something this important,
00:09:48 it doesn't bode well for us. Well, and I think it really hinges to a large extent. And this is,
00:09:54 I say this very sort of sadly, that it hinges on the topic you were discussing just as I came into
00:10:01 the studio, which is the basic neutering of our national media. You know, why aren't they on to
00:10:12 Jagmeet? Why aren't they calling bullshit on Jagmeet Singh when he stands up and rants and raves 0.98
00:10:19 about scandal after scandal and does nothing when he has the power to do that? All he has to do is 0.98
00:10:26 sit down with the conservatives and block and say, okay, let's devise a common strategy of how to get
00:10:32 to the bottom of this at whichever committee, ethics committee, procedure and house affairs,
00:10:37 pick a committee, doesn't matter. They all have the same powers and say, we're going to work together
00:10:41 we have the majority of votes on that committee, because it's a minority government. And we're
00:10:47 going to force this starting tomorrow, next time that committee meets. And we have the power to have
00:10:54 that committee meet all summer, right through the heat of summer. You know, it doesn't have to rise
00:10:59 when the house rises, you know, next week or whenever it is. They have that power. But the media and the
00:11:07 public, you know, it's fine for, you know, the latest poll to say that 80% of Canadians, you know,
00:11:15 are opposed to this, the way the government is going on this issue, right? That's great. But is it
00:11:22 going to accomplish anything? Well, that's it. I mean, if their elected members can't bring about any,
00:11:28 you know, change or getting into this, you know, get, ask you to get, you know, a little speculative,
00:11:34 the time goes, goes fast. We still got a few minutes yet. But do you think we're going to get
00:11:38 a public inquiry eventually? I don't know. I mean, judging by the way that this prime minister is
00:11:46 skated around other issues, whether it's the SNC Lavalin thing, that should have brought him down.
00:11:51 I mean, my goodness, the Attorney General and Justice Minister of the country, Jody Wilson-Raybould,
00:11:58 resigned over it, wrote a book over it. And still Canadians put up with this? I mean, so when we
00:12:06 didn't over that, when we didn't over the we, he skated around that issue of trying to funnel
00:12:12 hundreds of millions of dollars to the we, a company that he was clearly in a conflict with,
00:12:18 with his members of his family receiving money for speaking engagements from that company,
00:12:25 the We Foundation. You know, so it's been one, and that's just two that come to mind.
00:12:30 I was looking online a few days ago out of curiosity, and I challenge your viewers to do this.
00:12:36 Go online and just Google Justin Trudeau scandals. It's page after page after page. It's almost impossible
00:12:44 for journalists to keep up with, and the few journalists like yourselves that actually want
00:12:49 to dig into it. So are we going to get one? You would think that logically he's going to be forced,
00:12:56 but it's only the media that can force him to do that. I don't understand why his own party is letting
00:13:02 this go on and on, because eventually, and I think we're reaching that point, that tipping point,
00:13:07 if you will, where his star is going to be so much in decline that it's going to be very difficult for
00:13:16 the Liberal Party to recover from it. That's where I wanted to go next, actually. I was just wondering
00:13:20 if that's one other area. I mean, there's got to, we know there's principled Liberal members of
00:13:24 Parliament, and they've got to be, you know, taking the flack from this stuff they had nothing to do
00:13:30 with. They're embarrassed. Their constituents are on their case, and they're looking to their own
00:13:33 political futures. Liberals, I mean, that's just a fact. They tend to be better at keeping them all
00:13:39 together than Conservatives. We love speaking out and ripping our own. I mean, that's our nature, but
00:13:44 at some point, as you said, that tipping point might be hit where enough in caucus, you might
00:13:49 finally get a caucus revolt, even if behind closed doors, but to say, look, that's enough. We're not
00:13:53 going to go down with this ship. Yeah, yeah, and it has happened in the past, I think, with both
00:13:58 governing parties, whether it's ours, the Conservative Party. Like you say, I think that
00:14:03 the record would show that within the Conservative Party, and it's both good and bad, that the
00:14:10 leadership is held more accountable than what we see in the Liberal Party. I mean, most recently,
00:14:15 Mr. O'Toole, right? It wasn't the general public or the media that eventually held him accountable.
00:14:23 It was his own caucus, and we don't see that from the Liberals, and as you say, I worked with,
00:14:29 well, partly because of the positions I held, I had to work daily, sometimes hourly, as I said, with
00:14:35 my counterparts, with the House leaders and the whips of all the other parties, and I found most of them
00:14:42 were very respectful and, you know, putting forward an alternate point of view, but you could work with
00:14:49 them. And so there are people in those ranks within the Liberal Party, the Liberal Caucus, that should
00:14:57 be holding him accountable, because they're not profiting. In fact, arguably, as you say, it's their
00:15:03 very futures that are in jeopardy because of the way that he acts. Every time one of these scandals
00:15:10 comes along where he does everything, well, and including, I think, on the one, I don't remember which it was,
00:15:15 where he actually launched a lawsuit against the Parliament of Canada to prevent them digging into
00:15:23 something. So, yeah, it's bizarre times. I mean, you know, another long shot, I'll throw out my
00:15:28 speculation, but it's not impossible to think that maybe at a point, Justin's going to take his walk
00:15:33 in the snow like his father did, and come back. I mean, that would be because he was getting the
00:15:37 pressure inside to think, you know what, maybe I'll just bail out now, move on, put it to a leadership
00:15:42 race, we can still kick the inquiry down the road, and maybe people will have forgotten about it,
00:15:45 and I can retire. Yeah, no, I think that everybody runs their term of office and has to come to that
00:15:53 decision, and some people are forced out. I've often remarked, I guess, that all too many
00:16:00 politicians, you know, are like bad milk in the fridge. I mean, they stay around until they start
00:16:05 to stink up the place. Well, yeah, I mean, even with great ones, it's been unfortunate, you know,
00:16:09 with Premier Klein's a good example of it. I mean, he's a legend in Alberta. He did a lot of great things,
00:16:14 but that last couple of years, it was kind of the hook was starting to come out, okay, Ralph,
00:16:18 maybe it's time to step aside, and he kind of left, you know, with his own party, he's turning
00:16:22 on him a little, which is, same with Kretchen, he was just in for too long, but just not seeing it
00:16:28 with Trudeau yet. No, we're not, and I think that partly because of a lot of things. We've never been
00:16:34 in a situation in our country where the major media has become the propaganda arm of the government
00:16:41 through subsidization. That's never happened before until Justin Trudeau. And so that puts
00:16:47 a very unique perspective on everything that's happening in and out of Ottawa. And had it not
00:16:55 been for that, there may have been enough pressure from multiple sources, not just the sort of the
00:17:00 lone, one of the lone voices in the wilderness, the Western Standard out here in Calgary is saying
00:17:06 these things, digging into these things, or rebel news, you know, they're very few and far between.
00:17:14 If you had some of the major networks doing the job they're supposed to do for Canadians,
00:17:18 I think they're, you know, maybe he would have already taken that walk.
00:17:22 Perhaps. Well, we'll see what happens. I said, you know, they're going to recess in a week or so.
00:17:28 I suspect they're going to kick this can down the road until fall, and we'll see if public interest
00:17:31 is still there when the time comes. I think so. It seems to me the leaks are going to keep coming.
00:17:35 Whoever that is, they've got more. They're not going to let this go.
00:17:39 Well, sadly, the message I want to leave your viewers with is that, don't make any mistake on
00:17:45 this. Jagmeet Singh and the NDP, every time you hear him say something critical of the government,
00:17:52 call him out for what it is. He's being a hypocrite. It's complete hypocrisy. He has the power 1.00
00:17:59 to work with the other opposition parties and drive these types of scandals to some form
00:18:05 of public disclosure at minimum. And he chooses, he and his caucus choose not to do that and instead
00:18:14 to prop up this scandal-ridden government.
00:18:19 Well, time will tell. All right. Well, thanks again for coming in, Jay. I just appreciate some
00:18:22 explanation. You know, not everybody are political weenies like us that watch the procedure and what's
00:18:27 can be done and what can't be done, committees, things like that. And just, you know, the general
00:18:31 audience, like they're frustrated, readers and what can be done, just the confirmation that
00:18:35 something can be done. They're just choosing not to and, well, we'll see what happens.
00:18:41 Well, Canadian democracy, especially in this case, Canadian democracy is the poorer for it. I mean,
00:18:46 I think that's why it's 80% of Canadians is because there is an awakening to the fact that foreign 0.90
00:18:53 interference in our election strikes at the very heart of everything that we stand for. I mean,
00:19:00 a democracy has to stand on the legitimacy of its elections. Absolutely. All right. Well,
00:19:07 thanks, Jay. It was great seeing you in here again. And thanks for asking me. We can have you back
00:19:11 again sometime soon, maybe to start talking about the next election. Hopefully we'll be into it
00:19:18 sooner rather than later, because the country is going to be destroyed if it keeps going the way
00:19:22 it is. It does seem to be. All right. Thank you. So that was Jay Hill, as you heard. And yes,
00:19:28 a regular guest here, a person who's certainly put in a long time of service on Parliament Hill and still
00:19:34 managed to maintain his marbles out of all that time in there. It's quite surprising.
00:19:38 Canadian Shooting Sports Association, without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long,
00:19:44 long ago. These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms
00:19:49 regulations and legislation in Canada. And more importantly, educating the public about how we
00:19:55 keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people. We've become a member. It's absolutely worth every penny.