Western Standard - May 16, 2025


The Food Professor says, buy beef, stockpile coffee, do it now

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Indigenous citizens have the most to gain from provincial independence Carney’s cabinet. Same dung, different pile

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

140.84

Word count

3,535

Sentence count

191

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this week's show, we talk to Dr. Sylvain Charlebois, the Director of the Agri-Food Analytics App at Dalhousie University, about why food prices are so different from what we see in the grocery store.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show.
00:00:21 It is Thursday, May the 15th.
00:00:23 I don't think there's a Canadian alive who isn't complaining about the cost of groceries. 1.00
00:00:29 Certainly, I hear about it every night over dinner.
00:00:32 More scientifically, Statistics Canada concedes that inflation is hitting groceries harder than other things.
00:00:38 Last month, food was up 3% year over year.
00:00:43 Meanwhile, in their newsletter, Loblaws is calling for more and worse as tariffs start to bite.
00:00:49 With me tonight is Dr. Sylvain Charlebois, who thinks about these things all the time.
00:00:56 Dr. Shalawa is the director of the Agri-Food Analytics App at Nova Scotia's Dalhousie University.
00:01:02 Dr. Shalawa, welcome to the show.
00:01:04 Well, thank you for having me.
00:01:06 Oh, it's a pleasure.
00:01:07 As we were saying just in the pre-show chat, my wife is a big fan and is eagerly hanging on,
00:01:13 looking for hope, I think, as she goes to the grocery.
00:01:17 We want to talk today about whether we can believe the evidence of our own till slips.
00:01:21 It feels like food is up 10% year over year, and yet the official numbers say it's only 3%.
00:01:28 So what do you see out there?
00:01:32 Well, typically, that's what happens when you have a food inflation rate be higher than the general inflation rate.
00:01:41 People will notice higher food prices.
00:01:44 Produce is higher compared to January.
00:01:47 dry goods in the center store pantry goods are much more expensive now and the freezer aisle is
00:01:54 also quite problematic these days so those are sections where we've seen higher prices but we
00:02:00 are expecting higher prices throughout the year but we're not talking 10 or 20 i know a lot of
00:02:06 people are confused if they hear 25 tariffs they think oh food prices are going to go up by 25
00:02:13 percent that's not exactly how it works uh in december we did uh release candace food price
00:02:19 report we are expecting uh food prices to increase by about five percent by the end of this year
00:02:26 now five percent is not 25 but it's it's not nothing it is uh it represents about eight hundred
00:02:34 dollars more for a family of four for the entire year so and a lot of people out there just don't
00:02:40 have that kind of money so it's it's it is going to be challenging compared to 2024. I get the
00:02:46 feeling that when you tell me that it certainly coincides with what I observe as we go through
00:02:53 the till and we pay and you know it's a lot of money for somewhat less and yet Statistics Canada
00:03:01 tells you it's three percent and that's actually good because before it was four percent and five
00:03:08 percent in 2022 and 23 so why is it so hard to rely on official numbers why are they so different
00:03:18 from what we experience in the grocery store so you you're opening up a can of worms here
00:03:24 as an academic i can certainly attest that there is a data deficit in canada uh the picture that
00:03:31 we get every month from statistics canada is is always lagging a little bit uh when you actually
00:03:36 you do some spot checks and when you actually look at prices and what actually is going on
00:03:41 out there, you can sense that there is a disconnect between what is actually going on versus what is
00:03:49 being measured by Statistics Canada. But the reality in Canada is that we only have Statistics
00:03:55 Canada. There's not much we can do about that. Unlike the US where I actually work sometimes,
00:04:00 I actually have colleagues at Texas A&M, for example. American academics have access to way
00:04:06 more data. So you have a better sense of what's happening. So that's why there is a lot of
00:04:11 frustration out there. Consumers are frustrated because they're not sure exactly what's going on.
00:04:16 Media is also quite frustrated because we don't have much data to work with to really convey to
00:04:22 the public an actual factual image of what actually is going on with food inflation.
00:04:29 The other thing that we notice fairly frequently is that things we're accustomed to be able to
00:04:35 find easily are either find with difficulty or not available at all something just disappears
00:04:42 from the shelves for three weeks at a time and finally it comes back usually yeah um and if you
00:04:48 ask in the store they say oh well you know the supply chain is broken well i guess it must be
00:04:54 but what is there something particular that is happening in the supply chain other than the
00:05:03 normal seasonal shortages of green groceries?
00:05:08 Yeah, the disappearance of certain brands
00:05:11 or the renewal of certain relationships
00:05:16 up the food chain is actually quite normal.
00:05:19 Every year we expect about 20% of products
00:05:23 that you would find in a grocery store today
00:05:26 not to be there next year.
00:05:29 So there's always a turnover of inventory
00:05:32 And of course, many products do fail to add commercialization.
00:05:39 So we are expecting a bit of a turnover.
00:05:41 So the empty shelves that you see, either there's a stock shortage, there are supply
00:05:47 issues, but it's mostly because there's some realignment with shelves.
00:05:53 For example, a grocer will just let go of a supplier and is renegotiating with its new
00:06:01 supplier.
00:06:01 In the last few months, it's been incredibly volatile. Why? Because of the pivoting. A lot of grocers had to source food beyond the United States. Canadians just weren't buying American products in the middle of winter.
00:06:17 And so a lot of grocers have to pivot and find grapes in South Africa, find produce in Egypt and other places to make sure that Cays actually had something to buy during their visit to the grocery store at an affordable price.
00:06:36 I see. All right. Well, that does answer somewhat the question.
00:06:40 And Loblaws, before we leave the United States tariff situation, in their newsletter, which I just happen to have here, the food inflation report comes out of Loblaws is, I mean, for the benefit of viewers who may not follow the numbers as closely as you do, I think there's something like 2,400 stores across Canada that are owned by Loblaws under different brand names from No Frills to, I don't know what they all are.
00:07:09 Shoppers, actually. Shoppers is a big piece of Loblaw, absolutely.
00:07:15 Well, okay. So Loblaws, as a public service, puts this very, very, very good newsletter out.
00:07:23 And their headline for the last one was that tariffs are going to cost Canadians more for food.
00:07:31 So I would hope that Loblaws knows what it's talking about and is not giving us incorrect information just to scare us.
00:07:40 But how does the tariffs affect food that you don't import?
00:07:47 Because you were not American. 0.99
00:07:49 Loblaws' communication strategy is really interesting because we do have quite a few grocers in Canada.
00:07:54 But Loblaw is the only one trying to get ahead of what's happening with inflation, warning consumers about what's happening up the food chain.
00:08:06 And I think it's a smart way to do it.
00:08:08 So they have this T right next to prices right now.
00:08:12 If you go into a Loblaw-operated store, you'll know whether or not a product was impacted by tariffs if you see a T right next to the price.
00:08:21 Yeah, absolutely.
00:08:22 And just yesterday, Pure Bank, the CEO of Loblaw, who's been on my podcast, the Food Professor podcast, he actually acknowledged that the number of products with a T was at 1,000 right now.
00:08:38 But that number could increase to up to 6,000 over the next few weeks because of counter-terrorists implemented by Ottawa.
00:08:47 The concern that Loblaw would have is that a lot of Canadians just don't understand how terrorists actually work
00:08:54 They think that if Trump applies terrorists on Canadian imports, it impacts Canadians
00:09:02 Not necessarily, it's the response from Ottawa that will impact the lives of Canadians
00:09:07 And so I think that's really the message that Loblaw is trying to convey here
00:09:12 and those counter tariffs will impact an increasing number of products because
00:09:18 well they're running out of inventory so the inventory that was not subject to tariffs before
00:09:24 say March the 4th now are subject to tariffs and prices are likely to increase for many categories
00:09:32 so that's kind of the warning that we got from Loblaws in that newsletter and yesterday on LinkedIn
00:09:39 but you're not saying that i think you talked about getting grapes from south africa a few
00:09:46 minutes ago you're not saying that if we bring in grapes from south africa that the canadian
00:09:53 government is tariffing those it's just american products is that correct that is correct exactly
00:09:58 so then why would the south african grapes have a tea beside them no they they wouldn't they wouldn't
00:10:06 It's just products coming from the U.S.
00:10:09 Or let's say that there's an ingredient bought by a manufacturer in Canada that comes from the U.S.
00:10:16 That was tariff.
00:10:17 That product would likely have a T as well.
00:10:20 But if you actually are importing grapes from Peru or South Africa, that wouldn't have a T.
00:10:26 But the problem, I'm sure you can understand that getting grapes from South Africa instead of California
00:10:32 will cost you more as a distributor to get those grapes into Canadian stores.
00:10:38 So eventually something will need to be adjusted price-wise.
00:10:45 So actually, when we apply a tariff to American imports of food, we're hurting ourselves.
00:10:54 Pretty much.
00:10:55 What I didn't expect, to be honest, is that a lot of Canadians don't seem to understand that concept at all.
00:11:02 And so we had the elbows up campaign and people were expecting Ottawa to retaliate, which is fine.
00:11:10 But the challenge here is that we are at a disadvantage for a few years.
00:11:15 One, we're up against 25% of the world economy, which is the United States.
00:11:20 That's a massive piece right there.
00:11:21 And two, their economy is much stronger than ours right now.
00:11:26 If you look at the unemployment rate, it's pretty idle.
00:11:30 the Fed, the Federal Reserve is not cutting rates, whereas in Canada, the Bank of Canada
00:11:36 is cutting rates. That's a sign. That's a sign that confidence is not necessarily there for
00:11:43 Canada. The cane dollar is basically the same, has the same value versus the American greenback
00:11:50 for months now, despite the fact that American policies have actually hurt the American dollar.
00:11:58 And so that's another sign. And lastly, and this is the most important one, food inflation is actually dropping in the US. So America can afford to implement tariffs on goods coming into the US because their economy is much more competitive, much more productive.
00:12:18 Consumers are not as much in debt as well.
00:12:22 And so you have all that happening in the U.S.
00:12:25 While in Canada, people are losing their jobs.
00:12:28 The GDP per capita is not increasing.
00:12:31 There's no wealth creation as much as in the U.S.
00:12:34 So right now, I think what Loblaw is trying to say, along with Walmart in the U.S., is
00:12:41 that the tariff game is a dangerous one, especially for Canada, because we're just not in a good
00:12:48 position economically to go against the Americans, especially right now.
00:12:56 Could you, if you live close to the border, is it worth doing your groceries across the
00:13:03 border?
00:13:04 Can you give us a few examples of, you know, butter, eggs, bread, that sort of thing?
00:13:09 It depends where you live.
00:13:10 uh i mean i would say that right now not necessarily with the exception of perhaps
00:13:17 some dairy products and some meat products particularly poultry you may find some good
00:13:23 deals but i've actually been in the u.s three times the last six months and i i do go to grocery
00:13:29 stores all the time so i went to uh oklahoma texas and new york and uh each time i didn't
00:13:39 see much of a difference because of the conversion rate. I mean, our dollars at around 71 US cents
00:13:46 versus $1. So obviously you have to pay more than a 30% premium to get the same amount of food. And
00:13:54 that's certainly not helping cross-border shopping. So my only comment about this is that you will
00:14:03 not necessarily save but you will have more more choices you will have more choices there are more
00:14:10 choices offered to canadians for sure okay um you know i do recall that prior to the last u.s
00:14:19 election on november the 5th that uh food prices egg prices were were one of the the trump talking
00:14:28 points. He managed to convince Americans that that was the fault of the administration, the Biden
00:14:34 administration. And I'm hearing now that they actually are coming down a bit. And I think you
00:14:41 confirmed that. It's just that they hadn't come down enough to really make it worth driving a
00:14:45 long way to reap the savings. That's correct. And so I think President Trump is partially correct
00:14:54 in blaming the former administration because the avian flu was not very well managed in the U.S.
00:15:00 at all. They lost control way before Mr. Trump was elected. And of course, the implications
00:15:06 came after with the loss of flocks and birds. And we're talking over 200 million birds that
00:15:14 had to be called. So obviously, egg prices became a problem early in 2025. But things are actually
00:15:22 getting back to normal slowly in most states so uh the beauty of the poultry industry is that
00:15:29 it can recover very quickly the production cycle is eight to nine weeks so if you if you are to
00:15:37 experience say a swine flu impacting the hog industry uh the recovery uh time is is is longer
00:15:45 because of the production cycle that is longer it's three to four months for example eight weeks
00:15:51 All right. I have to ask you this. How much has the carbon tax been responsible? And I'm not just talking about the 20 cents a liter or whatever it was on gasoline and diesel. I'm talking about the fact that the carbon tax is incurred at every level of production.
00:16:16 How much is the carbon tax responsible for our high food prices in Canada?
00:16:22 Well, this is the one question that I've received countless times in the last couple of years for sure.
00:16:29 Why? Because the Canadian government has never bothered to assess how the carbon pricing policy implemented through the carbon tax would impact food affordability in Canada.
00:16:40 The true answer to your question is that we can't really tell because food prices at retail are impacted by several factors, several factors, including the weather, our own behavior, what we buy, what we don't buy will impact prices, eventually promotions, loss leaders.
00:17:02 So it's very difficult to correlate the policy with retail prices.
00:17:07 However, our lab, we've done some work in this area only to realize that there is a strong correlation between wholesale prices, so prices up the food chain versus the carbon pricing policy.
00:17:22 And you can see that really the common tax has compromised the entire sector's competitiveness, which could eventually impact prices and how prices are set at retail.
00:17:39 That's as far as anybody can go.
00:17:42 If you hear an economist saying that there is no relation, there is no impact, or there's a huge impact, both of them are wrong, because you can't really state for sure exactly how the carbon tax is impacting food prices over time.
00:17:58 Okay, well, fair enough then.
00:18:01 I don't want to leave people without hope, Doc.
00:18:09 That's a good strategy.
00:18:10 You know, it just seems we have the big grocers saying it's going to get worse, and certainly the evidence every time you go to the stores seems to be getting just that little bit more and sometimes that rather much more expensive to buy the thing that you went in there for.
00:18:30 Yeah. So two questions. First is, would you care to venture a long-term prognosis on how this is going to play out? Does this just keep going or is there some reason to think that you're going to hit a plateau at some point?
00:18:49 And then the second thing is, what can the consumer do about it?
00:18:56 Should they stockpile things that keep, for example, in the belief that, you know, you're going to be in a year's time paying, eating something that you paid last year's prices for?
00:19:09 What can you do?
00:19:10 Absolutely.
00:19:11 Well, there's a stockpiling.
00:19:13 I would stockpile one thing, and that's coffee.
00:19:16 coffee has gone way up and i don't see how prices will will go down the other product is beef beef
00:19:24 is very expensive and we're not expecting prices to drop either so if you see any of these two
00:19:29 products on sale buy as much as you can for sure but i am i am hopeful that things will stabilize
00:19:37 The challenge that we have right now coming out of the Trudeau regime is that we have seen many policy-induced inflationary phenomena, essentially.
00:19:54 The GST holiday, to me, was a bad idea because you're basically playing around with market conditions, allowing opportunistic pricing to occur.
00:20:08 As soon as you actually eliminate a tax temporarily, retailers, restaurant operators will actually cover the spread.
00:20:15 And that's kind of what we think has happened in the last several months after the GST holiday.
00:20:22 And of course, we've talked about the carbon tax compromising our food security.
00:20:28 There's been other issues, the bureaucracy, interprovincial trade barriers.
00:20:33 But we're having discussions right now to eliminate all that or to at least look at some of the nonsense from a policy perspective.
00:20:44 And that's a good sign. That's a good sign.
00:20:46 So I'm hopeful that the new government, led by Mark Carney, will look at food security through an economic lens to make sure that there's no one left behind.
00:21:01 Because the last 10 years have been really, really tough for many Canadians, especially the younger generations.
00:21:10 The cost of living issue is real for many, many Canadians.
00:21:15 well yes i mean you just you would probably is it your lab that follows the food bank numbers
00:21:25 that's correct absolutely i'm actually keynoting the food bank of canada
00:21:29 convention in june in montreal so i work very closely with you mean there's a convention for
00:21:35 food banks we have that many and after in fact the convention is to raise money and awareness
00:21:42 for food banks, so it's a good
00:21:44 cause. Well, I'm sure it's
00:21:46 a good cause, but I mean, how appalling
00:21:48 in a country like Canada that
00:21:50 not only are there food banks and people
00:21:52 using them, but there are so many of them
00:21:54 that they actually need to get together once a year
00:21:56 to shop.
00:21:58 I mean, this is what you expect out of the
00:22:00 energy industry or, you know,
00:22:02 the teachers' unions or something, and the food
00:22:04 banks are getting together to have a convention?
00:22:07 I'm of the
00:22:08 mind. I'm not sure what
00:22:10 your opinion is on this
00:22:12 on this particular issue, but I'm of the mind that food banks are here to stay.
00:22:16 I mean, I know that some Polymerians believe that they should disappear.
00:22:21 The advantage that food banks have, and we saw that during COVID,
00:22:25 they can actually turn on a dime and operationalize help,
00:22:32 targeted help to help Canadians.
00:22:36 Governments can't do that.
00:22:38 They can't, within days, pivot and offer support and help to people who just lost their jobs.
00:22:45 Market failures will continue to happen.
00:22:47 And I'm a capitalist at heart, but market failures will continue to occur.
00:22:54 And I think the best unit that can actually help, which can actually help Canadians and are well-equipped to do that, are food banks.
00:23:04 Well, I don't have a principled objection to food banks.
00:23:06 I just think it's a shocking thing that in a wealthy country like Canada, it should be necessary to have them.
00:23:12 It's shocking to see so many people needing them, for sure.
00:23:16 Yes, exactly.
00:23:18 Look, we are out of time.
00:23:21 One last question, and that is, is Canada unique in having this problem, or is the whole world finding food more expensive?
00:23:30 Right now, if you look at the G7, for example, we're average.
00:23:36 we're average. The thing about Canada, though, is that we shouldn't be average. We should actually
00:23:41 have a lower food inflation rate because we are north of the only food superpower on earth.
00:23:49 And North America is a bit of a food security bubble. So having a food inflation rate of
00:23:55 3.2%, which is well above 1% compared to the US, is really unexcusable. We should actually have a
00:24:05 lower food inflation rate than what we have now.
00:24:10 Dr. Sylvan Charlebois, the food professor.
00:24:14 This has been fascinating. Thank you so much for taking the time to come
00:24:17 on the show. We really appreciate it. And I know there are an awful lot of people
00:24:21 take what you say very seriously.
00:24:26 Again, it's an honor to have you. So, thank you.
00:24:30 Thank you very much for the invitation. For the Western Standard, I'm Nigel
00:24:33 Hannaford.
00:24:35 We'll be right back.