Western Standard - December 07, 2023


The Pipeline: Alberta Kool-Aid Man’s COP28

Hosted by
Mentioned
CMS: Trudeau is down, but not out. Taking decisive steps to prevent hate-motivated violence

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

172.61

Word count

8,230

Sentence count

579

Harmful content

Misogyny

15

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Western Standard editor Nigel Hannaford and editor-in-chief Derek Fildebrandt are joined by Calgary Sun columnist Corey Morgan to talk about the Alberta premier's trip to COP28 in Dubai, her likely imminent retirement, and the potential battle to replace her.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Today is December 6, 2023. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:00:21 Thank you so much for being with us today.
00:00:24 I'm joined, I would say as usual, but actually I haven't been here very usually late,
00:00:29 but joined normally, as usual, by Western-centered opinion editor Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:35 Good to see you, Nigel.
00:00:36 Normally I'm here.
00:00:37 You don't know what happened when you weren't, did you?
00:00:40 I really have no idea.
00:00:42 I can't even say the show's gone to hell.
00:00:44 I don't know.
00:00:45 You never watched it?
00:00:47 No.
00:00:47 Come on, you did.
00:00:47 I know you did.
00:00:48 Sometimes.
00:00:49 Okay, good to be here.
00:00:49 Also got our usual as well, Western Standard, Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:57 Good evening.
00:00:58 We've got some interesting topics today.
00:01:00 Alberta Kool-Aid mans its way into COP28, very much unwelcome by the Canadian federal government,
00:01:08 and I would say very likely most of the organizers and other delegates at the COP28 confab going on in Dubai.
00:01:17 Alberta has just smashed through the wall there to pretty much rain on their parade and say, well, there are responsible oil and gas producers in the world.
00:01:28 Alberta is one. You guys should shove it where the oil comes from and let us do our thing.
00:01:38 Rachel Notley, Alberta, former Alberta Premier, current NDP leader and opposition leader.
00:01:47 It's not official yet, but I think everyone is getting the feeling.
00:01:52 She's probably headed towards the exit pretty soon here.
00:01:56 We're going to talk about her likely imminent retirement and the potential battle to replace her.
00:02:03 And speaking of retirement, the latest liberal speaker to take over in the big chair in the House of Commons.
00:02:11 Well, he's on death watch, I think, at this point.
00:02:15 The last speaker had to step down for inviting a Waffen SS soldier from the Second World War to be honored in the House of Commons.
00:02:26 This speaker, engaging in partisan activity and things that is very much not allowed and is frowned upon for someone in the so-called non-partisan role, faces the very real prospect of being essentially impeached in their position and replaced.
00:02:46 So we're going to talk about that.
00:02:47 Before we get into it, though, I just got to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:02:53 I've supported the CSSA for over a decade because they're Canada's leading firearms rights group.
00:02:59 The CSSA brings together shooters of all different types in Canada to defend their rights on Parliament Hill,
00:03:10 educating the public and working with the politicians to make our laws and regulations at least as least insane as it possibly can be.
00:03:19 Without the CSSA, I shudder to think where our right to own firearms in Canada would be today.
00:03:26 So if you're not yet a member of the CSSA, go to CSSA-CILA.org, or just Google them as I do, and become a member today.
00:03:33 It's money very well spent.
00:03:39 There was exclusive footage of Alberta Premier Daniel Smith entering the COP28 confab in Dubai.
00:03:49 I'm going to start, I'm going to start with, I'm starting with you today.
00:03:54 I don't want to do it with Nigel first and then go back.
00:03:56 I'm starting with you.
00:03:57 Not very welcome by, I think, most of the COP28 delegates, activists, and particularly the Canadian federal government, right?
00:04:06 No, I mean, these are anti-oil and gas love-ins.
00:04:10 We know that even though it's being hosted in Dubai, even though they're being unapologetic about their production,
00:04:16 And having other areas that produce oil and gas dare to come in and try to say we're not as bad as everybody else is making us out to be not a welcome presence in that crowd.
00:04:28 I mean, that's the Greta Thunberg highlight of the year.
00:04:31 That's the Stephen Gill Bowl gathering.
00:04:33 It's there.
00:04:34 You know, Joe Vipond was in there rambling.
00:04:37 He's getting stranger.
00:04:39 I didn't think it was possible.
00:04:40 Yeah.
00:04:41 So for Premier Smith to show up, I mean, I'm mixed on it.
00:04:45 I still don't like us spending that much money sending people over to these things.
00:04:49 It sounds like she's got a pretty large delegation with her.
00:04:51 I mean, I appreciate her messaging, but I don't know if necessarily we needed to send 100 Albertans over there to speak up for us.
00:04:57 I mean, you're speaking to a room of people that hate you anyway.
00:05:00 I think that that number was a bit misreported.
00:05:03 Was it?
00:05:04 There is 100 people going on the Alberta delegation, but roughly 75%, maybe even slightly more, are, you know, like they're guys running oil and gas companies or something, and they're going on their own dime.
00:05:18 So they're not going on the government dime.
00:05:19 It's just part of the delegation.
00:05:20 Yeah.
00:05:21 So there's Premier Smith and her husband, although I think he's supposed to be paying his own way.
00:05:28 But he's listed on the delegation, so he'll have access and whatnot, but he's paying his own way.
00:05:32 There's some government staffers are going who are obviously paid for by government taxpayers, but I think something like 75% of that list, they're delegates, but they're not being paid for by taxpayers.
00:05:43 It's good to confirm all the same, yeah, so that's good to know.
00:05:45 But, I mean, 70,000 of them at this thing, it's just insane.
00:05:49 I mean, are they going to break the six figures next year?
00:05:51 I wouldn't be surprised.
00:05:54 Yeah, so, Nigel, the left has been, for lack of a better term, the left.
00:06:01 But there's, you know, there's been a lot of people actually upset in Alberta that, ah, this delegation is too big.
00:06:07 Although some of that may have just become, maybe because the number got a bit confused.
00:06:13 The government list is 100 people, and there's 100 delegates from Alberta, but the vast majority are not going.
00:06:19 But they tend to be people who never had a problem with the federal government's massive delegation, or if Rachel Notley went to something like this.
00:06:28 But it's definitely been fuel on the fire of relations between Alberta and the federal government.
00:06:39 Do you think that, I don't know, has this perhaps worsened relations between the two?
00:06:46 Because Ottawa sees this as their turf, this is international, Alberta is supposed to stay at home and be quiet.
00:06:50 Oh, I don't think you could ever make it any worse than what it was a couple of weeks ago before the conference even started.
00:06:56 I mean, clearly there is no meaningful communication there are, you know, people take the stage
00:07:02 and they say the right thing, but they're clearly on a collision course, and that's,
00:07:07 and they've known they were going to be on a collision course for a very long time.
00:07:10 That's why the Sovereignty Act was the first thing that the Premier did when she was,
00:07:16 you know, when they opened the session.
00:07:18 And if there was any appetite for negotiation and compromise, there have been plenty of meetings and occasions, even phone calls, where this could have been initiated and things put on a different track. 0.95
00:07:34 Premier Smith has all kinds of political reasons for taking the stance that she's taking, which is not to say that that's the only reason she's doing it.
00:07:42 She is a true believer, and I think that she speaks for many in Alberta, when she says
00:07:48 we have to keep control of our own energy policy, it's ours anyway.
00:07:54 So, but at the same time, there's lots of reasons why it works well for the federal
00:07:59 government to have a fight with a scrappy province when there's an election in 22 months
00:08:03 time, if they can even hang on that long.
00:08:06 So I don't find the rhetoric at all surprising.
00:08:09 Well, what I would say, when you were saying, you know, maybe we, do we even need to be
00:08:15 there?
00:08:16 Yes, I think we do.
00:08:17 And we, you know, we the province of Alberta, we have a point of view.
00:08:21 At least the government of Alberta has a point of view, which is widely supported.
00:08:25 Alberta's view is obviously not represented by the federal government.
00:08:28 Exactly.
00:08:29 And so if you don't take the podium and defend what it is that you're doing, you're
00:08:35 And there's the mercy of these, you know, people who mock you, like the, what is it, the Climate Action Network, presenting them with the dinosaur of the day, fossil of the day.
00:08:46 I mean, this must take you back to your own days at the CTF, when you drew attention to something by pulling a stunt.
00:08:57 In earlier this year, they had...
00:08:58 We used to give golden pig all the things, the golden pigs to wasteful politicians.
00:09:02 They weren't even fossilized, were they?
00:09:03 And, you know, the Climate Action Network earlier this year did something on Parliament Hill where they all wore oil barrels, you know.
00:09:11 Okay, it's all good, clean fun.
00:09:13 Well, if Alberta got the Fossil of the Day Award, I mean, that's internationally prestigious.
00:09:18 Well, I said on my show, she should have done like Tom Green with the Raspberry Awards and actually been the first one to show up and claim it.
00:09:25 You know, Premier Smith said, thank you very much.
00:09:27 We do value our fossil fuels and the value they bring to citizens and people.
00:09:31 Absolutely.
00:09:32 Alberta should be very proud getting that.
00:09:33 You know, like for a province to get it.
00:09:36 I mean, they give these things to like the Koch brothers or, you know, America.
00:09:42 Very big players get the Fossil of the Day award for Alberta to win it.
00:09:47 I mean, this is like Alberta won an Olympic gold medal.
00:09:50 This is very proud.
00:09:52 That's what I mean.
00:09:52 This is just posturing these whole affairs in general.
00:09:55 But I guess, yes, if you leave it uncountered, they'll just carry on.
00:09:59 The thing is, the Climate Action Network and people like them don't actually have a solution to the very practical problem that Smith is trying to address by defending the province's right to deal with its own energy policy.
00:10:11 Well, so let's then turn to some developments that took place there.
00:10:15 So, the Alberta legislature, Smith's request has already invoked the Sovereignty Act against Ottawa's intrusion into Alberta's right to run its own electrical grid.
00:10:26 um and alberta it was announced i think just before cop 28 started alberta announced we met
00:10:34 our methane reduction targets three years early that's right i think i'm getting three years
00:10:40 early a big announcement and i thought well you know this would be an opportunity for gilbo to
00:10:46 you know you can't be bad cop all day every day everybody has to play good cop once in a once in
00:10:53 Just to show that you're capable of positivity.
00:10:56 I mean, even if it's just a show to put on, it's good diplomacy.
00:11:00 It's good politics, right?
00:11:03 Curiously, remember our energy reporter, Sean Polzer, noted this in the news.
00:11:08 I was like, oh, that is odd.
00:11:10 There wasn't so much as a tweet or news release from Mr. Gilbo, the federal environment minister.
00:11:17 Like, well, he must be happy about this.
00:11:19 This is a good thing, and it's something Alberta did and agreed to.
00:11:23 Three years early, like, I thought he'd be, like, a good cop for a day, and then he'd go back to being himself.
00:11:30 Nothing.
00:11:31 Well, now we know why.
00:11:32 He took the opportunity when he was in Dubai to announce Canada was going to slash methane emissions even more.
00:11:40 And he did it unilaterally without consulting, I don't know about any province, but certainly not the provinces that produce methane,
00:11:47 Alberta, Saskatchewan, the major oil and gas producing jurisdictions,
00:11:52 which obviously got Smith up against the wall,
00:11:56 and she's talking about invoking the software to act again right now. 1.00
00:11:58 Well, it shows the futility of trying to appease these nuts.
00:12:01 You might as well start calling them what they are.
00:12:03 I mean, Elizabeth May is saying carbon capture is evil now.
00:12:05 She's campaigning against it.
00:12:07 So carbon capture is not allowed.
00:12:08 Nuclear is not allowed.
00:12:10 Damning Rivers isn't allowed.
00:12:11 We're running out of options, and whenever we do actually comply,
00:12:14 comply, as I said, with the emissions reductions, they just move the goalposts. Like, at some point,
00:12:19 we've got to draw a line. So that's our line. We've had it with you guys.
00:12:23 A point which she actually made in her response to that.
00:12:26 Yeah. I don't know what's Alberta to do with this. Like, we meet these methane reduction targets three years early. 1.00
00:12:36 That's pretty aggressive. And I was genuinely wondering, well, why nothing from Guilbeau?
00:12:42 Well, we know now, he was planning a surprise attack.
00:12:48 I don't know what you do.
00:12:49 I mean, something like the Sovereignty Act would seem to be the only thing one can do other than submit.
00:12:55 Well, there's one other option.
00:12:57 What?
00:12:58 This one I've been proposing for 20-some years now.
00:13:03 Okay, well, we're going to start charging Corey for plugging his book on the show.
00:13:07 I was going to plug the book.
00:13:08 I was talking about the option.
00:13:10 But but I mean, if you do want to poke, you know, if you keep cornering people, then they do start to look to solutions that may seem more radical than than otherwise before.
00:13:20 He's he's fomenting more independence attitudes than I've ever been able to in 20 years of effort.
00:13:24 And it's not just what they're doing. It's the way they're doing it, because like methane, unlike carbon dioxide, is a bad thing.
00:13:32 Carbon dioxide is plant food.
00:13:37 You know, it's a perfectly natural substance of the world.
00:13:41 I'm sure if the proportion in the atmosphere gets off, it could upset balance like anything, but it's a natural thing.
00:13:48 It's normal.
00:13:49 Methane is a very extreme greenhouse gas, and it's toxic.
00:13:55 Unless it's used in very intentional, controlled circumstances as a chemical, it's not good.
00:14:01 So, okay, we want to reduce methane. You know, I'm no tree hog and hippie, but I'm okay with that. You know, as long as it's reasonable and achievable, I'm okay with that. But then Gilbo comes along and says, no, no, no, we're moving the goalposts. And at this point, you know, it's just, it's fanaticism.
00:14:20 It is pure. You can just see it in this man's eyes. It is a dangerous fanaticism that cares not for human life, but for these utopian ideological goals that is just dangerous.
00:14:34 It's a fanaticism that is informed by the very real prospect that he does not have as long as another two years to do everything that he thinks he has been mandated and ordained by a higher power to do.
00:14:50 They could be out of office quite soon, at the max, though, two years.
00:14:54 So they are going for broke.
00:14:56 And you asked just now, what does Alberta do? 1.00
00:15:00 A, wait them out. 0.50
00:15:01 B, because I don't think they're going to still be there in two years' time, and B,
00:15:06 in the meantime, you respectfully and politely but very firmly apply the law, and you resist
00:15:13 legally in any way you can against the intrusions of a federal government that clearly doesn't
00:15:19 like you, doesn't want to see you do your job and keep the lights on and the power on
00:15:25 when it's cold or hot.
00:15:27 Indeed.
00:15:28 They are doing that and good for them.
00:15:32 All right.
00:15:33 Well, Rachel Notley, former Alberta Premier and current NDP opposition leader.
00:15:43 You never know, but maybe she'll give it a fourth kick in the can, 0.85
00:15:47 but appears likely to announce a retirement fairly soon.
00:15:52 she has now she's run for premier in 2015 which he won 2019 which lost and now
00:15:59 2023 which she lost so she's had three elections which is a lot even if you win
00:16:06 them all but when you've lost two out of the back three there I mean it's pretty
00:16:12 it's very rare for a politician ever at least as a head of government to run
00:16:17 again for a second try after they've lost especially once they've already been in
00:16:23 government been the premier been the Prime Minister it's very rare in
00:16:25 Canadian history it is almost unheard of in modern Canadian political history
00:16:30 this kind of thing happened I think the last time it happened federally up a
00:16:34 Pierre Trudeau did it and before him Mackenzie King and then for him Sir
00:16:41 John MacDonald so three prime ministers Canadian history and going back pretty
00:16:46 far. The most recent was here, Trudeau in 1980. So it's pretty rare. So I think it's highly unlikely
00:16:54 that not Lee would make a fourth kick in the can after losing two already and go for a third
00:17:00 potential loss. Her reputation, though, despite losing two elections in a row, is still very
00:17:07 strong with her party. She's beloved. But I think, you know, talking with new Democrats when I'm in
00:17:12 Edmonton. The belief is it's time to go. They love her, so they're not going to push her out
00:17:19 violently. It's not going to be a Tom Mulcair kind of coup or a Jason Kenney coup, but it's time to
00:17:27 go. Nigel, do you think it's likely Notley's going to retire and that we're going to see it soon?
00:17:35 Yes, I do, for all the reasons that you just gave.
00:17:40 The problem for the party is that she is still really about the best they've got.
00:17:46 I was just looking through the list of sitting MLAs,
00:17:51 which is the first place you would look for a new leader.
00:17:54 I see a couple.
00:17:55 I mean, there's David Egan.
00:17:58 He actually ran for the leadership before lost to her.
00:18:01 he's actually the sort of man you could sit down and have a drink with and not come away feeling
00:18:07 like you'd been in a place you shouldn't. Joe Cece, we know him very well down here in Calgary.
00:18:15 You know, David Agin actually tried to help me not get beaten up by a union mob once.
00:18:19 Well, I rest my case. But I didn't take his advice. I went in and deliberately incited them
00:18:24 and they did attack me. But he warned me not to do it. So I would have to say then, Derek,
00:18:29 you owe him a drink and what a good job he's the sort of guy you should be able to sit down and
00:18:33 have a drink the mob did attack me but i did precisely the opposite of what he told me to do
00:18:37 largely because he told me not to incite them so look that having having named those two
00:18:43 individuals you very quickly run out of patience with the rest for a whole variety of reasons
00:18:49 and i'm i'm sort of thinking to myself the ndp there is a move to rebrand the party because it's
00:18:55 certainly the common perception that they're joined at the hip with the federal party and nobody
00:19:00 likes the federal party that's keeping the liberals in power so i'm sure that hurt them badly
00:19:07 in the last election so if they're going to but i you know it's not a new name that the ndp
00:19:14 needs it's uh it's it's just a new leader and i would say if i heaven forbid that i would ever
00:19:24 tell the NDP anything that might be helpful in winning the next election. But I would have to
00:19:32 say that what they need is somebody who can be equally at home dealing with... Calgary is a
00:19:44 business community, right? So you need somebody who, by their dress and appearance and rhetoric
00:19:51 and the language they use doesn't just make people listen politely
00:19:55 and then wish them well as they leave.
00:19:58 Somebody you can actually engage with.
00:20:00 And they've still got to be able to deal with the union mob up in Edmonton.
00:20:04 So you need that, and you need somebody who can be outward-looking, unpleasant, 0.64
00:20:11 and actually grow the party.
00:20:14 And I'm not sure that that person is presently serving in the legislature.
00:20:19 So they're going to have to look outside, I would say.
00:20:23 So we'll turn to successor.
00:20:26 You're really anticipating me.
00:20:27 You know I was going to get there.
00:20:28 You're anticipating the questions too much.
00:20:31 Before we get there, maybe we'll actually back up to a question I should have asked.
00:20:36 Before I asked you your question, Nigel, is should she retire?
00:20:40 Because I think a lot of what you said, Nigel, raises the question.
00:20:44 Do I think not Rachel Notley can win and be premier again? Highly doubtful. I mean, the UCP could melt and she wins by default. It damn near happened with Jason Kenney. I think if he had not stepped down as leader and successfully ousted, I think it's almost certain she would have been premier here today.
00:21:04 The right would have split again. And she's likable. She's a likable person. I know some people like to be like, I hate her, and they're going to call her all sorts of nasty words.
00:21:16 Well, yeah, sure, as a political leader, but as a person, she's warm, and she's personable. She's the happy face on socialism.
00:21:24 And she connects with people, and she's a good leader for what she's trying to achieve.
00:21:32 She keeps her party united, marching in the same direction.
00:21:36 But, yeah, barring a meltdown on the UCP, I don't think she can win.
00:21:39 But I guess that raises the question, can any NDP leader win?
00:21:43 I mean, Alberta is a two-party province now, but it is still Alberta.
00:21:47 And it's difficult to see how, you know, without a perfect storm like happened in 2015,
00:21:53 divide a conservative vote, all sorts of stuff, should she leave?
00:21:57 Is she the best they can do?
00:21:58 And should the NDP settle for being a very strong and robust opposition?
00:22:03 Well, I think she's the best we can see for now and the best they can see for now.
00:22:07 There might be something in the wings we haven't thought of or a rising star somewhere.
00:22:10 But I guess the question is, how tired is she?
00:22:12 You know, it's a tough job.
00:22:14 She's been there a long time.
00:22:15 She, you know, it's wear and tear. And I think part of what they were perhaps hoping for a lot
00:22:22 of the campaign was, of course, trying to create fear of Premier Smith. Daniel Smith's going to
00:22:26 rend Albert into shreds. She's, you know, crazy. She's going to come in and tear all our institutions 1.00
00:22:31 apart. And while she's certainly stirring up the establishment, Premier Smith hasn't gone beyond
00:22:36 the pale. She hasn't torn things to their roots or anything like that. So I think the bureaucrats
00:22:42 that AHS might disagree. They don't claim that, but the electorate in general, I don't think
00:22:46 they're seeing, you know, the fearsome lunatic that they tried to portray Smith as in the last
00:22:50 election. So if Premier Smith even just holds the course for three years, it's very, very unlikely
00:22:57 that the NDP would disrupt her in a further election. As you said, it's a two-party system,
00:23:03 but it is Alberta still. And I think that she would probably still even do better the next time 1.00
00:23:07 So what Snotley has to be asking herself is, do I want another four years as the leader of the opposition? Perhaps she does, but that's a tough and tiring job.
00:23:16 It's not a four-year commitment. It's a minimum eight years.
00:23:19 Another four years, yeah, on top of it.
00:23:21 If she wants to go, that's an eight-year commitment. And I don't know how old she is, and I don't know how old she is, but she's not a spring chicken anymore.
00:23:29 I believe she's about 60-61. So not ancient by political measure, but she's been in office for a long time, putting in a lot of service.
00:23:36 Yeah, and, you know, eventually you've got to be starting to think,
00:23:39 maybe I just don't quite need this anymore.
00:23:41 No, I think she's been there since 2001.
00:23:43 Was it 2001?
00:23:45 She was there when the NDP was a two-member caucus, her and Brian Mason.
00:23:49 Oh, yeah, no, no, 2004.
00:23:50 Okay, that's still 19 years.
00:23:52 That's a pretty long stretch of time in the legislature.
00:23:58 So, yeah, I could just, it's up to her, you know,
00:24:02 that really is where it's sitting right now.
00:24:03 As you said, the NDP aren't at a point of wanting terror out or anything.
00:24:06 Some might be saying perhaps it's time, but it's fully up to Rachel Notley to decide if she's had enough yet or not.
00:24:14 Well, let's talk about her potential successor here.
00:24:19 So, you know, I think one of the problems, every time you have an internal leadership struggle,
00:24:25 you're trying to overthrow a leader, those defending the incumbent leader always say,
00:24:31 Ah, who could possibly take over?
00:24:34 They said that about Jason Kenney.
00:24:36 They said that about Allison Redford.
00:24:39 They said that about Ed Stelbeck.
00:24:41 They said that about Jean Cretchen.
00:24:42 They did say about Jean Cretchen because it was clear that that was a leader-driven coup.
00:24:46 So you have Paul Martin.
00:24:47 But any time there's been a leadership struggle, they said about Patrick Brown in Ontario.
00:24:54 They said it about Andrew Scheer.
00:24:55 They said it about Aaron O'Toole.
00:24:57 They said it about Stephen Harper.
00:24:58 Somebody will surface.
00:24:59 You can open up.
00:25:00 These are good jobs. They pay decent money, they come with prestige, they're paying the ass, but they're fun, you get to make a difference, theoretically.
00:25:12 There's always no shortage of ambitious politicians to take the job, in most cases. 0.58
00:25:18 We did have a problem finding a Wild Rose leader after the giant floor crossing in 2014. 0.93
00:25:23 That's because it was a shitty job to take.
00:25:24 Well, yeah, you're taking a sort of like post Mulroney to a poison chalice, I think was the term with the book, you know.
00:25:31 Yeah, so, but the vast majority of cases, especially, so taking over as leader of the opposition of a very large party, you know, that's been in government, they're going to have no problem.
00:25:40 So I don't like that argument because it's said by people in every time you're getting a new leader.
00:25:46 So no good.
00:25:47 So I guess we'll talk about the main options on offer.
00:25:52 So Sarah Hoffman, still a key player in the NDP.
00:25:56 She was the health minister under Notley and the deputy premier.
00:26:01 YDB standards, fairly competent.
00:26:05 She might play a new Democrat on TV, but actually a very lovely person in person.
00:26:11 You know, I don't think a lot of people talk about her this way on the right side,
00:26:16 but Shannon Phillips, I think, actually would be a good choice for the NDP to consider.
00:26:22 Pretty well spoken. When she can keep, she gets a little yelly sometimes because she's very passionate, but passion's good. 0.64
00:26:31 She's smart, and she comes from kind of the green left part of that party, and, you know, the NDP is very tribal.
00:26:39 You know, conservatives, if there's a conservative leadership, Danielle Smith can come in.
00:26:43 She wasn't a party activist there. She was just radio, and she can Kool-Aid man her way in. 1.00
00:26:48 Or, you know, Trump.
00:26:51 Frank, he was a Democrat for a long time, but he just bullied his way.
00:26:56 And conservatives were more open to the outsider.
00:26:58 But New Democrats in particular, they like someone who's been an active party member,
00:27:03 who's been knocking on doors and putting in signs and paid their dues, so to speak.
00:27:07 The liberals are that way, too, in many ways.
00:27:10 So I think they're going to be very resistant to an outside leader.
00:27:15 Shannon Phillips, I think, has got the cred of the left.
00:27:18 And, you know, has done a bit to a position herself as a bit more of a mainstream alternative.
00:27:24 But maybe I'll start with you, Nigel, on who do you think would be kind of the top candidates to replace Notley,
00:27:31 both in terms of who would be a competitive candidate to win it,
00:27:34 but also who the new Democrats might want to look to as someone who could potentially win an election.
00:27:39 Well, all of what you said about their preference for somebody who's come through the approved
00:27:49 methods of becoming a leader, going to all the committee meetings, knocking on the doors,
00:27:53 all that. When it comes right down to it, it is true of the NDP, as it is true of any party,
00:28:01 that in the end they will take the person who will help them win. And as I said earlier,
00:28:06 that may not be somebody who is presently in in the legislature. We had some fun I think in the
00:28:16 newsroom there speculating on how it would go if the unions were allowed to choose the next leader
00:28:22 and perhaps Gil McGowan would be prepared to take a look at the job. He's actually rumored to be at
00:28:31 at the very least, very interested in the job.
00:28:32 I, for one, love it.
00:28:35 I love it.
00:28:37 It is so good.
00:28:38 You see, we do have good sources, Derek.
00:28:40 We both heard the same malicious rumor.
00:28:44 You know, I come back to the person of David Egan
00:28:47 only because he is a temperate individual
00:28:51 who can make that trip back and forwards
00:28:55 between Calgary and Edmonton,
00:28:57 talking to the different audiences.
00:28:59 I am not saying that I have any strong points of agreement with him.
00:29:05 Certainly in his time as education minister,
00:29:09 I was arguing strongly against some of the things that he was doing.
00:29:13 But I'm just wondering that you asked the kind of person who could put them over the line.
00:29:18 He perhaps could, if Premier Smith really screwed up.
00:29:23 Perhaps.
00:29:24 That being said, I get the impression from him that his heart's not in it.
00:29:27 By the way, I wasn't serious about Gil McGowan.
00:29:30 No.
00:29:31 But David Agan, I don't know.
00:29:33 He's actually a very nice guy.
00:29:35 But I don't think he's got the fire in the belly for it anymore.
00:29:41 I mean, he's been there a long time.
00:29:42 He was one of the four members of the NDP caucus before they won in 2014.
00:29:47 Sorry, 2015.
00:29:49 He's been there quite a while now.
00:29:51 Not least kind of got him on the back benches.
00:29:54 I don't think he's got the fire in the belly for it.
00:29:56 But who would be your top candidates to replace?
00:29:59 I think probably, as you said, maybe Shannon Phillips.
00:30:03 Rumor is she is not as well.
00:30:06 Again, these are just.
00:30:07 I mean, I'm throwing it.
00:30:08 You know, we could have Max Fawcett or Janice Irwin jumping into the mix there as well.
00:30:12 Max needs a job. 1.00
00:30:15 Janice Irwin. 1.00
00:30:17 That's top shelf crazy.
00:30:19 But most of what we see with people coming in are I'm seeing more leaders of the opposition. 0.78
00:30:23 I'm not seeing somebody who at least did this and things change when a race comes in.
00:30:26 Sometimes a person is in the wings.
00:30:28 You never realized they had that fire going.
00:30:31 But I'm just seeing more people who will serve perhaps diligently as a leader of a socialist leaning party, but won't take them over that line of becoming premier.
00:30:41 I think they will have to either learn to reach outside of their own circles as they're disinclined to do, or there's really got to be a rising star hiding in there that I just can't see right now.
00:30:52 See, the thing is, I'm going to make the assumption that Rainier Smith aces this and in four years' time is looking very strong.
00:31:00 You really don't want anybody coming off the back benches who is going to scare people.
00:31:06 So who could they run that wouldn't just make people instinctively back away from the TV screen or the computer screen?
00:31:13 you know for me if I'm the NDP my ideal candidate is someone from Calgary
00:31:19 someone who's got some business cred and you know can't be painted with a brush
00:31:28 of far-left activism and something like that you know you know the NDP got real
00:31:34 close with Todd Hirsch from he was chief economist for Alberta Treasury branch I
00:31:41 I mean, I don't share his politics, but unlike most new Democrats, he at least has a theoretical understanding of economics, understands that there's supply and demand and some very basic things.
00:31:52 He's not crazy.
00:31:53 He shares views that are left of center, but he's not crazy.
00:31:57 Someone like that, comfortable in a Calgary crowd, someone who doesn't make anyone who runs a business or manage people instinctively start packing their bags as soon as they see a new Democrat come by, that would be good.
00:32:10 But I'm not sure New Democrats would go for it. From what I said before, does this person have long term credit in the party?
00:32:19 The NDP do not like, they see those people as parachute candidates.
00:32:23 They want someone who started as a private before they become a general.
00:32:26 It's similar to Nenshi. You know, he could probably pull it off as a progressive, but could be pragmatic enough.
00:32:33 But the old union base would not like him because he hasn't paid his dues.
00:32:37 They would see him as an opportunist coming in.
00:32:39 So that's what the NDP kind of has to ask itself. Do we want to remain in opposition or do we start looking for somebody a little more pragmatic to take us over the line? And I suspect they're going to stick true. They're very union, very tied to their base right now. Notley was an exception, but she also was holding the reins during a particular lining of the stars of a split conservative vote, a very volatile and sour Alberta electorate.
00:33:03 As I said, yes, perhaps Premier Smith would pull off something catastrophic in the next three and a half years, but you can't count on that.
00:33:10 Well, do remember that no Premier since the last, no Conservative Premier in Alberta has even finished a term since Klein in 2004.
00:33:25 So it is now 19 years. It'll be more than 20 years by the time the next election comes.
00:33:31 At this moment, looking at Smith and the government, I say, oh, yeah, she's going to finish four years and have a great chance at re-election.
00:33:39 But remember, at this point, we all said the same thing about Ed Stalmak.
00:33:43 We all said the same thing about Alison Redford.
00:33:45 We all said the same thing about Jason Kenney.
00:33:49 Okay.
00:33:50 One year in, you knew they were done?
00:33:52 You knew they were done after a year into their term?
00:33:53 I had my doubts about them before they were even nominated.
00:33:57 Oh, me too, but I thought they'd finished the term.
00:34:00 I thought they were both bad, Redford in particular, Kenny in particular, but I thought they'd finish a term.
00:34:07 Never dawned on me one year in, but halfway through, I'd be like, I don't know, I don't think so.
00:34:14 But, you know, it's rare to be on the rocks the first year into your first term.
00:34:19 So, you know, Smith is halfway through a first year, so she's clear for now.
00:34:25 What I'm saying is there's clear historical precedence that the conservatives will blow themselves up.
00:34:32 It's not impossible, that's for sure. 0.88
00:34:33 She's still leading a hornet's nest. 1.00
00:34:37 Alberta conservatives are the hardest people to rule on the planet. 0.98
00:34:41 Worse than Somalia.
00:34:43 Okay. 1.00
00:34:45 All right.
00:34:46 Well, you know, discussing this in the newsroom today,
00:34:50 we considered setting up a cabbage with a 24-hour live camera
00:34:54 asking, can this cabbage last longer than the latest liberal speaker?
00:35:00 So I don't even know this guy's name.
00:35:02 He's the new speaker.
00:35:03 Greg Fergus.
00:35:04 Greg Fergus, yeah.
00:35:06 He's the new speaker in the House of Commons, liberal speaker,
00:35:11 because the last guy lost his job when he invited a soldier from the Vafan SS
00:35:17 who fought in the Ukrainian Legion to stand and be honored and recognized in the House of Commons.
00:35:24 uh I mean he paid a significant price I imagine the price was a lot less than if
00:35:30 he had been a conservative they probably would said well the conservative was
00:35:33 practically fighting for the SS themselves but nonetheless he took an
00:35:38 inevitable fall for what happened there also was a necessity of protecting
00:35:43 Trudeau someone had to take the fall so this guy comes in he's been here just a
00:35:48 couple of months and now in really really hot water now most MPs but every
00:35:56 MP in the House of Commons except for one is allowed to and is expected to
00:36:02 engage in partisan activity party conventions partisan speeches partisan
00:36:07 fundraising all of these things but there is one man or woman in the House
00:36:12 of Commons who is not supposed to be doing this thing by convention that is the speaker because
00:36:20 their role is no matter how they're elected is to be the impartial nonpartisan enforcer of the
00:36:26 rules to make sure that Parliament functions fairly and evenly regardless of party theoretically at
00:36:34 least. But this Fergus guy gave a speech for a Liberal Party convention or whatnot. It was very
00:36:45 partisan. Now that... Well, it was a video tribute honoring the outgoing interim Ontario Liberal.
00:36:53 Ah, yes. Yes, that was it. Okay. So there he was in his robes. And he was wearing the regalia of the
00:36:58 Yes, it would have been very taboo if he had done it, period.
00:37:04 But then he did it in his speaker's robes and regalia.
00:37:09 And I don't know.
00:37:10 It's like the difference between King Charles giving a political speech on global warming
00:37:16 and then King Charles giving, so bad enough,
00:37:20 and then King Charles giving a political speech on global warming,
00:37:23 wearing his crown and holding the scepter, sitting on the throne of England,
00:37:26 and wearing that weird tiger thingy on him.
00:37:31 I think it just accentuates how inappropriate it is
00:37:34 for someone who's in a strictly nonpartisan office
00:37:37 to be doing this.
00:37:38 So I didn't mean to be bashing the king here, but.
00:37:41 He did go and make the speech. 1.00
00:37:43 He made a total ass. 1.00
00:37:47 Sitting there looking at the screen. 1.00
00:37:49 I gave your king one toast, never again.
00:37:53 I gave him his one chance, he screwed it up.
00:37:55 Anyway, back to speaker here.
00:37:58 This speaker totally bundled it.
00:38:00 It would have been very inappropriate for him to do it, period.
00:38:03 But he did it in his speaker's robes and regalia, totally out of line, created a big kerfuffle with the opposition.
00:38:14 The opposition, because he's voted as a liberal, they now say, well, you've broken even the appearance of your nonpartisanship.
00:38:21 You got to go.
00:38:21 The NDP are quietly trying to decide what to do. They've made some public statements about kicking it out to a committee and stuff. But the NDP are, the Bloc and the Conservatives are already ready to vote non-confidence in them and replace them. The NDP are kind of waiting.
00:38:39 And remember, it's a minority government, so the opposition parties could remove him.
00:38:43 And word I'm getting from Ottawa is the Liberals are backing their guy, but not to the wall.
00:38:49 They're not going to die on this hill.
00:38:51 The Liberals know he screwed up badly.
00:38:54 And the Liberals aren't on very solid grounds, but there are speakers right now.
00:38:57 The last guy resigned for something to do with World War II.
00:39:00 So, Nigel, the guy screwed up. 0.70
00:39:07 I think he knows he screwed up.
00:39:08 He apologized, and he's a new speaker, to be fair.
00:39:13 Does this guy deserve another chance, or?
00:39:15 Oh, and then he took off to Washington
00:39:17 as the whole thing blew up on a junket.
00:39:18 I was actually trying to mention that.
00:39:19 That compounded it pretty badly.
00:39:21 Well, it's not even that it compounded.
00:39:23 I think that when he knowingly went to go and do that,
00:39:28 that he thought, well, I'm going to be done anyway.
00:39:30 I want to do this for whatever reason.
00:39:32 I want to do it as an old friend,
00:39:33 so I'm going to go down there and talk about my days
00:39:36 as a young liberal, and when I get back,
00:39:38 I may have a job and I may not, we'll see, but, you know, it's, I think he'd already given up.
00:39:45 So my strong expectation is that we will see Mr. Fergus resign or get booted out here quite shortly.
00:39:52 You know, ideally, the Speaker would not say or do anything to call attention to themselves.
00:40:01 It's just not their job.
00:40:03 It's not their office.
00:40:04 and they bring Parliament to disrepute when they do these kinds of things.
00:40:11 So any speaker, the next speaker, needs to know when to leave the ceremonial robes in the closet
00:40:20 and maybe decline, maybe just say no to some of the attractive offers that will undoubtedly come his way.
00:40:31 And if for no other reason than this, if parliamentary procedure and tradition is not enough,
00:40:38 the speaker in Canada has a most excellent official residence to live in.
00:40:45 And you know what the best part of that place is.
00:40:47 And a wine cellar to go with it.
00:40:50 No, that's not it. It's the Scotch Library.
00:40:52 They have a Scotch Library.
00:40:55 There's only one reason I want to be speaker.
00:40:57 That must have been a very awkward conversation when the last speaker departed, having to explain to the family, well, we're going to have to move out of this and back into the two-bedroom apartment, you know, whatever they have.
00:41:10 Look, it's a shame.
00:41:13 People do silly things, and so they have to pay the consequences.
00:41:16 I don't think he meant any harm, but you don't do that sort of thing.
00:41:18 You know, if I was the speaker, and I think I'm going to get the axe, I go to that Scotch library and log myself in there until they send a sergeant of arms to peel me out. 0.50
00:41:31 I mean, get your money's worth. 0.90
00:41:35 It's a good gig, you know, it's 270 a year, I believe, and you get your accommodations, a lot of prestige. 0.97
00:41:40 I mean, you also have to wrangle those fools in Parliament at times, it's going to be frustrating. 0.96
00:41:44 But he should know better. I mean, that's the cardinal rule of that job. And we know they still might hold partisan things. They were all elected initially. But you just stuff that away and you try. I mean, just to give a plug for somebody local, Nathan Cooper. I mean, talk about an exception. He loves that job. He sticks to the rules. 0.98
00:42:00 It is creepy how much he loves that job.
00:42:02 And he promotes the office of the speaker fantastically.
00:42:05 Puts out great videos.
00:42:06 He explains what the office is and what the legislature is.
00:42:09 He's a rare gem to find to take that role on.
00:42:13 But, I mean, there's Christmas for this to cool down.
00:42:15 They might let it cool down, and we'll see.
00:42:17 The public loses interest in things.
00:42:19 You know, Cooper is such a fanatical speaker that, so we were MLAs, the Wild Rose together.
00:42:25 And, you know, we'd be all navel-gazing.
00:42:26 You know, when we defeat the NDP, the different jobs we want, you know, I was finance critics.
00:42:33 I was like, finance.
00:42:34 Nixon was like, well, he was house leader.
00:42:37 He was like, I want to be house leader in the government.
00:42:39 And, you know, come to, I think we're sitting around beers and go to Cooper.
00:42:43 He was not drinking a beer because he's Cooper.
00:42:45 And he's just like, oh, I want to be the speaker.
00:42:48 And we're like, what do you mean you want me to be the speaker?
00:42:51 Like, you be speaker if you don't get ministered.
00:42:54 Like, then it's the next best job, right?
00:42:56 you want ministry. If you don't get a ministry, you want to be speaker. He's like, the hell with
00:42:59 being a minister. I want to wear the hell out of those robes and do Robert's Rules of Order every
00:43:04 day. It is absolutely nuts. And so you get a guy like that who's so very serious about the job and
00:43:13 understands its role to the point where it's very rare. It's rare. We could use another one of him
00:43:18 in Ottawa. It would do everybody a favor, but where do you find another? This Fergus guy, I don't know
00:43:22 how long he's been an MP or weeks. Oh, as an MP. Yeah, he's been a quiet back. But you know,
00:43:28 I remember, you know, like, after the 2015 election, almost the entire legislature turned
00:43:33 over the PCs wiped out. The Wild Rose had wiped itself out before crossing. So the Wild Rose came
00:43:38 in one a bunch of seats, but we were almost all new. Because we replaced floor crossers for the 1.00
00:43:43 most part. And there was a small rump of PCs. But the the MVP had to have a speaker, they had only 1.00
00:43:49 had four MLAs before that, and they all won the cabinet. So they had to pick a brand new MLA,
00:43:56 Bob Warner, and the guy knew nothing. And it was, I was tough on him, because I knew more about it
00:44:05 from watching the question period on TV once in a while. It's if you don't know the job,
00:44:10 you get into a lot of trouble real quick, because it's, you know, it's like, you're the traffic cop,
00:44:16 Right. But if you've never driven a car before, you don't know, like, you better know the traffic act.
00:44:21 Yeah, it's going to go bad. And so I don't know how experienced this guy is.
00:44:25 If I was the opposition, I'd be I'd be going for blood.
00:44:30 Part of me thinks. Give him a chance, give him one more chance, but put him on like pass a vote of censure or something like spank him, spank him hard. 0.98
00:44:40 But maybe give the guy another chance. I mean, people screw up and I don't see any malice in it.
00:44:46 It was just, it was bad.
00:44:48 Well, I think that's, I think you're being excessively generous.
00:44:52 Look, Andrew Scheer, who was the speaker.
00:44:53 I'm always accused of that.
00:44:54 Yeah, I know.
00:44:55 It's the talk of the office.
00:44:58 Andrew Scheer was the speaker himself.
00:45:00 He put it, he put it this way.
00:45:02 It got reported quite widely.
00:45:03 That it's like the, he compared the situation to the NHL.
00:45:09 And if you had a referee appearing in the locker room, one of the teams that was about to take the ice,
00:45:15 giving them a pet tool, and then going out and refereeing the game,
00:45:19 the guy wouldn't last long.
00:45:21 Everybody would understand that's just not what you do.
00:45:23 I'm not sure that's a fair equivalent, though, because they're MPs elected with a party.
00:45:28 They came from one of the locker rooms first, and then they changed their jerseys.
00:45:33 So, you know, it's appearance.
00:45:34 It's not like, I'm not sure if they still do this in Britain, but for a long time in Britain,
00:45:37 I'm not sure if it's done anymore.
00:45:39 Once someone was elected as Speaker, they sat as an independent, technically,
00:45:43 And the major parties, at least the conservatives, the liberals and labor, they would agree not even to run candidates against that person.
00:45:49 They would just be the speaker. And so they would have no real partisan attachment.
00:45:54 And that, I think, had a lot more power. But these guys are elected with parties.
00:45:59 They're elected by their parties in split partisan votes 99 percent of the time.
00:46:04 So he already came from the locker room and he's new.
00:46:08 But he is out of the locker room.
00:46:10 This is a degree of knowing your role.
00:46:12 Yeah, it's a mess. Guy deserves some punishment. I'm just not sure it's a gallows offense yet,
00:46:20 but we'll see. Oh, my God. I think we have a Christmas tree that just popped in the newsroom.
00:46:25 I donated my own artificial tree to this office last year. I don't know how we got a real tree
00:46:31 now. That wasn't in the budget. Probably cut it out from one of the buildings.
00:46:35 That's because your intern reporter, Jen Hodson, went out into the countryside of
00:46:39 north of alberta and broke back that tree well it wasn't in the budget and
00:46:44 she's not putting in a chip so you're fine there we go all right well
00:46:49 gentlemen thank you very much what fun and thank you all for joining us today
00:46:54 on the pipeline if you're not yet a member of the western standard make sure
00:46:58 you join now go to westernstandard.news you'll get full access to all western
00:47:02 standard content for ten dollars a month or a hundred dollars a year and you'll
00:47:06 be supporting proudly bailout free independent media thank you very much for joining us today
00:47:10 and god bless canadian shooting sports association without the cssa our gun rights would have been
00:47:16 taken long long ago these guys are on the front lines helping to draft smart and intelligent
00:47:23 firearms regulations and legislation in canada and more importantly educating the public about
00:47:29 how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong people who become a member it's absolutely worth
00:47:34 every penny you can become a western center member for just ten dollars a month or 99