Western Standard - June 29, 2023


The Pipeline: Big Media gets more big bailouts

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Cory Morgan Show. The age of ESG has finally ended Justin Trudeau’s contempt for individual

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

171.82

Word count

8,013

Sentence count

556

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

38

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Big Media gets more big media bailouts. Bill C-18 blows up in their faces, so they need more bailouts to bail them out. The Liberals are worried about perceptions of the China file and other things involving Liberals and China.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 G'day, I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching
00:00:16 The Pipeline. Today is a beautiful June 28th. Beautiful, at least here in sunny Calgary.
00:00:23 Joined, as usual, by Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford. How are you, Nigel?
00:00:27 Lots of opinions today, Derek.
00:00:29 Never short.
00:00:30 Never short.
00:00:31 Paul Scott, as usual, Western Standard Senior Alberta Columnist Corey Morgan.
00:00:36 Sorry.
00:00:38 I'm good.
00:00:38 There you go.
00:00:39 I didn't even ask.
00:00:40 I'm just nodding at you.
00:00:41 Subdued today.
00:00:42 Subdued.
00:00:43 Well, that'll be an unwelcome surprise.
00:00:46 I'll work myself up.
00:00:47 All right.
00:00:48 Well, today we're going to be talking about the big media in Canada getting yet another
00:00:53 big media bailout.
00:00:55 And why do they need that big media bailout? Well, because their other bailout, and I should say not their other bailout, the latest bailout, Bill C-18, to steal money from tech companies and give it to these undeserving looters, has blown up in their faces, crushing their business models yet further.
00:01:14 So they're going to need more bailouts. Wonderful news. Speaking of sort of bailouts, the two biggest media companies in Canada, or two biggest newspaper chains, I should say, are in talks for a merger.
00:01:27 That is Post Media and Torstar. And if that happens, that would be pretty much nearly every single major daily paper in English-speaking Canada will be under a single corporation, operated out of Toronto and owned out of the United States.
00:01:47 So it's a great few days for the free press in Canada, isn't it, folks?
00:01:53 And we're going to talk about the Liberals' fortune cookie here.
00:01:56 The Liberals are very awesome internal memos coming out showing how worried they are about perceptions of the China file
00:02:04 and a few other things involving Liberals and China here.
00:02:08 And, well, it's a gas.
00:02:10 you might recall, German Chancellor Olaf Scholz came to Canada, cup in hand,
00:02:17 his cup in hand saying, we need Canada's natural gas. We don't want to buy from Russia anymore.
00:02:22 We're going to freeze in the dark in the winter. And Justin Trudeau said, there's no business case
00:02:26 for it. Well, if you needed any further proof, that theory is kaput. Now that the United States 0.68
00:02:33 has signed a big liquid natural gas export deal with Germany, no business case indeed.
00:02:40 Well, probably not if you're living in Canada, at least.
00:02:45 Okay, before we get going, though, I want to thank my favorite sponsor, the Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:02:50 You know me, I've been a member of the CSSA for more than a decade because I trust them as Canada's leading firearms rights group.
00:02:55 If you are a law-abiding gun owner in Canada, you need to be a member of the CSSA because they are on the front line,
00:03:03 standing on guard for your right to own, purchase, and responsibly use firearms in Canada. Without
00:03:09 the CSSA, the federal government would have probably seized the last of our firearms long
00:03:15 ago. So if you're not yet a member, go to cssa-cila.org right now, click on membership,
00:03:21 it's worth every single penny. Okay, so we're going to get into it now. Big media gets more
00:03:28 big media bailouts. So just a quick little history to set the table. About four years ago now,
00:03:35 the Trudeau government said, hey, media guys, I guess we're not friendly enough. We're going to
00:03:40 get a little friendlier. And we're going to give you a $500 million subsidy package over a few
00:03:47 years here. And all you got to do is be considered officially approved as media by this friendly
00:03:53 group of totally non-partisan, non-liberal, liberal media panelists. Now, that's obviously
00:04:00 done nothing to actually get the media on a solid financial footing in Canada. It's just delayed
00:04:05 the evolution of the press till whatever, where we're supposed to be right now, but clearly are
00:04:11 not. Fast forward to a year and a half, big media guys say, we're still not good businesses. We
00:04:19 can't make a buck. We need more help from the federal government. So then we get Bill C18. C18
00:04:25 is designed to quite literally steal money from Facebook and Google, companies I'm not particularly
00:04:31 normally fond of, but in this case, literally steal from these companies to give to big
00:04:36 government-approved media companies because Google and Facebook help readers find our websites,
00:04:45 which I've always considered to be a good thing. They're providing us a service, generally free of charge. So but big media say that Google and Facebook need to pay them for the privilege of helping them. So, you know, you dear listener, viewer, if you owned, I don't know, a hot dog stand, and I went to your hot dog stand and said, give me a hot dog, and you gave me a hot dog.
00:05:11 And now I say, now give me $4 as well.
00:05:15 That is what the media is doing here. 0.99
00:05:17 It is the craziest, dumbest bill in history. 0.99
00:05:20 And that is saying something. 0.99
00:05:22 Google has said there's going to be consequences if this bill passes because they're not going to play ball.
00:05:26 And Facebook or Meta has outright said, if you pass this bill, we're going to turn off the news in Canada because we are not going to pay media companies for doing them a solid.
00:05:36 It's crazy.
00:05:37 It has unlimited uncapped liabilities.
00:05:39 Well, the bill just passed.
00:05:40 last week. And surprise, Facebook said they are now doing what they said they would do. And shock!
00:05:50 The media, the government, how could we have seen this coming? They only told us they would do it a
00:05:54 few hundred times in writing and in public. Well, they did do it. And so now, media is panicking,
00:06:01 saying, what are we going to do without Facebook and Google? What are we going to do? Well, just
00:06:06 proving that actually, they were providing us the service, not the other way around. And in response, the federal liberals have said, don't worry, kids, we're going to make you whole. And they haven't spelled out the details of it yet. But the federal liberals have said that there's going to be a whole new round of media bailouts, because the big media got the bill they wanted, and it predictably blew up in their faces. So that's enough ranting from me. Nigel, you used to be very
00:06:35 senior member of the Calgary Herald, you were on the editorial board. I guess it was a different
00:06:41 era in media when they were businesses and existed without sucking on the government teat. 0.75
00:06:49 How do you think the liberals are going to be able to square this? They've been bailing out 0.61
00:06:53 these bastards for years now. They've given them everything they wanted. It's blown up in their 1.00
00:07:00 faces, and now they need more money. This is probably not going to be particularly popular
00:07:06 with Canadian voters. How do you think the Liberals can square this?
00:07:10 Well, first of all, they'll make it a non-issue, and they'll just do it, and then forget about it.
00:07:16 Up to people like us to remind them, but the public has got a very short memory for anything,
00:07:20 and this will just pass. I mean, people should still be outraged at the first bailout that went
00:07:29 through the media. Now, I think you used the figure of 500 million. I've seen 600 million.
00:07:33 Somewhere between there, yeah.
00:07:35 Yeah, it's a little more than that. But frankly, it doesn't matter how much money you give them.
00:07:41 It's not going to be enough, not within the realms of common sense. It's a little bit like
00:07:46 saying the buggy whip manufacturers. Remember the cliche about how technology overtakes some old
00:07:52 trades if you had a subsidy program going for buggy whip manufacturers you could certainly
00:07:58 still have some buggy whip manufacturers around but who would be buying the buggy whips because
00:08:06 everybody drives a car you know so we're talking about a business model that was based on the sale
00:08:13 of advertising and that paid the freight in newspapers for the most part yes there were
00:08:18 a subscription with subscriptions that were paid paid for
00:08:21 that's like 10% of the revenue.
00:08:25 Subscriptions are actually more for just the delivery.
00:08:28 Generally.
00:08:29 Often didn't even cover that, but certainly the point being
00:08:33 subscriptions don't pay the costs that newspapers
00:08:37 have incurred.
00:08:39 And I just can't see how this is ever going to salvage
00:08:45 the newspaper companies.
00:08:47 I talk about newspapers. This is awesome. CBC, CTV, Global. These are not good. It's the same
00:08:54 business model. Advertising. People advertise on the internet. I mean, you could just see.
00:09:00 I remember being in the Herald when we started to see the legal ads, which were very, very profitable,
00:09:06 starting to leave Section 3 and end up on sites on the internet. Then came Kijiji. 1.00
00:09:13 and by that time I was off to Ottawa, by the time I came back, you know, the Herald was about that
00:09:19 thick and very, very little advertising in it. So they haven't come up with a way to monetize
00:09:26 their product. And I'm not sure there's one out there that they ought to have grabbed. It's not
00:09:29 like I'm sitting here where you should have just done that. I'm not sure what they should have done
00:09:33 but the thing was the whole model wasn't working. But this is dangerous for democracy.
00:09:39 Corey, a similar but slightly different question for you. The media in Canada, I mean, the media
00:09:47 across the Western world is generally going down in trust as an institution, if you can call the
00:09:51 media an institution. But in Canada, I think it's gone down particularly fast because in particular
00:09:58 because a few things hyper consolidation means you're getting one particular worldview out of
00:10:04 but I think it's generally a very Toronto-centric leftist worldview, but also the media bailouts.
00:10:09 I think have been devastating for trust in media as an institution in Canada.
00:10:14 They've gotten oodles of money. 1.00
00:10:17 They've now gotten this asinine and idiotic Bill C-18 that I can't even say predictably blew up in their face, 1.00
00:10:26 was always going to blow up in their face. 1.00
00:10:29 There was a 100% chance it was going to blow up in their face, and then they did it,
00:10:33 and that it happened. Now they're, I don't want to use too graphic a rude term, but they're doing
00:10:41 favors for Trudeau under the table. Let's put it that way. And Trudeau's doing it back to them.
00:10:48 How can the media, how's the media, the big media in Canada going to be able to square this message
00:10:56 with their readers and with Canadians more broadly that they're trying to earn some trust back 1.00
00:11:01 when all these guys do is like, they're just, they're bastards. They're greedy bastards. You 1.00
00:11:09 can tell I'm, I'm obviously a little pissed off about this one. They just ring the taxpayer for
00:11:13 money. They get this other legislation, blows up in their face. It's going to hurt the independents
00:11:18 like the Western Standard a lot more than them. But then they get to say, oh, we've been hurt by
00:11:22 these bad companies because we couldn't have perceived that they would react like this to
00:11:24 the bill. Give us more taxpayers cash. How is Post Media? You know, so the Herald, the Journal,
00:11:30 the Suns, the National Post? How's the Globe and Mail? How's the Toronto Star? How are all these
00:11:35 guys going to kind of square this with their readers and be able to convince them that they're 0.99
00:11:39 not the greedy bastards that they really are? Well, they won't, but they don't care. They don't 0.99
00:11:43 have any readers anymore. That's the whole... Well, they've still got some. Very few, though.
00:11:47 People aren't tuning into the TV anymore when the news is on. People aren't... Not the TV,
00:11:52 but people aren't still reading news online. They aren't picking up the newspaper at the
00:11:55 corner store. They're looking online, but companies like the Western Standard are eating
00:12:00 their lunch. They have a micro audience compared to what they had 10 years ago. And they're just
00:12:06 desperate. They're drowning. And, you know, as Nigel said, it's a broken model. The government
00:12:11 can pour all the money it wants in. It's flowing out the holes in the boat faster than you can pour
00:12:15 it in. And they're flailing. They're just grabbing any lifeline they can. They aren't thinking about
00:12:20 squaring it with readers or journalistic principles or anything like that. They're
00:12:24 companies that can't for the life of them figure out a successful model. So they're just begging
00:12:29 for and grabbing any little bit of money they can. And the bailout model is not sustainable
00:12:34 either. It's just a question of how much damage to, yeah, public trust, to media and to the
00:12:39 government coffers and to little outfits like ours is going to be done while they try to keep
00:12:44 this corpse animated. And it's an ugly, ugly path. So let's, this is obviously a self-interested part,
00:12:53 but let's talk about what this does to competitors. The entrepreneurial independent media that have
00:12:58 been on the rise. Canada is way beyond the eight ball from where a lot of other advanced Western
00:13:04 countries are with an independent media coming up. Those other countries have either not built
00:13:09 out their media at all or have provided significantly less forms of government assistance. But in
00:13:15 Canada, you know, we are subsidizing the buggy industry or, or the candle industry, whichever
00:13:19 way we want to slice this, and it is retarding growth is retarding innovation and entrepreneurial
00:13:25 newcomers. You know, the Western standard has since our very first day said we're not taking the 0.77
00:13:30 government bill of money of dirty money, we're not going to touch it. And that's been hard,
00:13:34 it's a competitive disadvantage for us, but we've done it. And now C18 cuts us off at the knees,
00:13:40 takes away some of our biggest sources of readership. And I know some of our dedicated
00:13:45 readers, dedicated listeners and viewers are gonna say, Well, I just go straight to you guys.
00:13:49 You know, or I get, I go in through the newsletter in the morning. That's awesome. And that's what we want. But finding new readers requires that we have to have people who are not currently on our list or people who don't have us bookmarked and going to us every day. And if you're not growing, you're dying.
00:14:04 This is just trying to kill us now.
00:14:07 And I think this is what these guys were getting at.
00:14:09 I think the big media guys in the government, they wanted the money, the free money to come from Facebook and Google.
00:14:15 But they always knew in the back of their mind, well, if Facebook and Google do what they say they're going to do,
00:14:20 worst case scenario, we'll take the bailout.
00:14:23 But we can cut off a bunch of our competitors, the Western standards and other independent non-bailed out media.
00:14:30 media but just we're cutting off the competition at the knees so let's go to
00:14:36 you Nigel do you think this was what was the design here was the design to bail
00:14:43 these guys out or was it always designed knowing it was going to fail and that
00:14:49 it'll help stifle I mean we'll put it another way your thoughts on between the
00:14:56 first bailout, C18, and now the second cash taxpayer bailout,
00:15:00 which we expect to come. What is good? What is the effect on
00:15:04 the evolution of the media industry in Canada?
00:15:08 I think it takes them back to about 1975. I think it when
00:15:13 those were the days when the only game in town were what we
00:15:18 refer to as the legacy media. Now, there was no internet, there
00:15:22 was no Western standard or anything like it and we have the Alberta report but
00:15:27 it had to be a magazine that we had to be printed under so and that was I don't
00:15:34 think that was necessarily always a money-making enterprise you know it's
00:15:37 by field on that subject but at any rate the so the government government now
00:15:43 will have this dependent entity the news media which is going to understand that
00:15:52 if it goes too far there will be consequences it may never be announced it never may never be
00:15:59 publicized but something that could have happened won't happen next time keep your boys on a tighter
00:16:05 leash so it's and you will never be able to convince people that that isn't going on and
00:16:13 this speaks to the trust issue that corey brought up just a moment ago there are other reasons to
00:16:19 to be distrustful of mainstream media product.
00:16:23 It's not all bad.
00:16:24 Some of it is good.
00:16:26 I mean, some of the work done
00:16:28 bringing the China inquiry material to light,
00:16:32 that was mainstream media and they did a good job.
00:16:34 And out of the big mainstream papers,
00:16:36 guess which one is the only one that's profitable?
00:16:39 Global mail.
00:16:40 Yeah.
00:16:41 And that's...
00:16:41 However, having said all of that,
00:16:43 most people will say, well, if the government is paying you,
00:16:47 Even if nobody even sends a letter, an email, a text saying, you better cover this this way,
00:16:53 nobody will ever believe that that doesn't happen and doesn't happen frequently.
00:16:57 So now you've got an old-style news media going on just like it did 40 years ago,
00:17:04 as if the internet didn't exist, and the government holding the leash.
00:17:10 It's a very, very sad day.
00:17:13 Only one thing will be different.
00:17:14 There will be no more 35% on revenue earnings by the traditional media.
00:17:22 How would you like 35% revenue?
00:17:25 Oh, nice.
00:17:25 Wouldn't that be nice?
00:17:26 Sounds pretty good.
00:17:28 Corey, I guess some of this is maybe internal, but it's maybe just your general thoughts.
00:17:34 We have said no to the bailouts from the beginning, but our own tax dollars that we pay are weaponized against us.
00:17:41 We pay the federal government money, and then they take those dollars, and they hand it to these multinational conglomerates that control 99% of the Canadian media, and they use it against us.
00:17:51 And now they pass legislation to cut off virtually all our new readership.
00:17:57 So maybe I want to ask the question in terms of just the Western standard, but maybe the independent, the few, very few outlets in Canada that don't take bailout money, do you think at some point they should?
00:18:09 Like, because like, are we just going to be faced with literally zero media?
00:18:13 Like the independents could all go under if, like. 0.94
00:18:16 I like to think if we get more creative, I know it seems bleak, but it's hard.
00:18:20 But I mean, if you just sink into the rest of the pile, you get lost among the heavyweights anyways.
00:18:24 You're diving into a pool with them, which is now you're in their turf and they're just going to shove you down.
00:18:30 But I mean, the desperation of being cornered and the odious nature of taking your own revenues, taxing you,
00:18:36 and then shooting back at you that is repugnant.
00:18:40 But, I mean, it's so important that the independents just somehow manage to do so.
00:18:45 But what if they're facing death?
00:18:46 Like, there's a financial reality to these.
00:18:48 These are companies, and you have to pay people competitively against your competitors.
00:18:52 Like, if it's faced with, you know, at some point, I think we're faced with, like, fighting fire with fire.
00:19:01 Like, what do you do?
00:19:02 I don't have a good, clear answer, but I just don't want to see one bigger pool.
00:19:06 Like this is, as you said, we're behind.
00:19:08 Like we're killing what should be an innovative market.
00:19:11 We should be seeing outlets like this springing up like daisies.
00:19:14 There's all kinds of talented people in the legacy media.
00:19:17 And what's happening now is they're losing their jobs altogether.
00:19:20 They should be evolving into smaller independent outlets instead.
00:19:24 I mean, the journalists themselves are losing out of this.
00:19:29 I mean, as for jumping in and fighting fire with fire, I think it's just jumping onto the pyre together then is all that's going to happen.
00:19:36 And I might buy a little more time, but I just, I know it's an ugly scenario.
00:19:40 I don't have a clear answer.
00:19:42 If I did, I'd be starting an independent outlet.
00:19:44 I don't know.
00:19:45 It's just absolutely disgusting.
00:19:47 It's not good enough that the government gets to control the media in the country. 0.97
00:19:50 Now they need to go out of their way to just do everything they can to try and kill anyone who would challenge them.
00:19:55 Yeah, you know, I don't think that's what was the original intention, but boy, oh, boy, they recognize what an interesting fringe benefit it would be if this legislation.
00:20:03 Trinch benefit, I think that's the right term.
00:20:05 It would also put some of their severest critics out of business.
00:20:09 Okay, switching to topic, but not by a lot.
00:20:14 Postmedia, the single biggest conglomerate-owning newspaper chain in Canada,
00:20:20 is now in confirmed talks with the second biggest conglomerate newspaper-owning chain in Canada, Torstar.
00:20:28 So just for those who don't know, Torstar is owned by essentially two gentlemen in Toronto. Postmedia is owned by Chatham Wealth Management Group out of the United States, just on the other side of the river from New York City there. So it's essentially a New York hedge fund, although technically located in New Jersey.
00:20:47 Between the two of them, they control,
00:20:52 other than the Daily, the Globe and Mail
00:20:54 and some publications in Quebec,
00:20:57 they control virtually every newspaper in Canada.
00:21:00 130 brands on Post Media alone.
00:21:02 Yeah, so excluding like, I don't know,
00:21:05 your Strathmore Times and...
00:21:08 No, no, actually quite a lot of the little local newspapers
00:21:10 are owned by Post Media.
00:21:11 Strathmore Times has not owned by Post Media.
00:21:13 But they do own a number of smaller ones as well,
00:21:15 But generally, like mid-sized cities,
00:21:17 it'd be something like the size of Red Deer.
00:21:19 Well, like they own the Fort McMurray Advocate.
00:21:21 Is that the name of the Fort McMurray paper?
00:21:23 Red Deer Advocate.
00:21:24 Or is it Fort McMurray Today?
00:21:25 Fort McMurray Today.
00:21:26 Yeah, whatever it is.
00:21:27 Anyway, the Fort McMurray paper, they own that.
00:21:29 So like mid-sized, you know, not really small towns,
00:21:32 but they own a bunch of those.
00:21:34 And then they own the Calgary Harrow.
00:21:35 They own every single sun across the country,
00:21:37 except for the Vancouver sun, I think.
00:21:41 Vancouver sun's part of Posta, you know?
00:21:43 Is it?
00:21:43 It's a part of Posta.
00:21:44 Okay, I'm not sure about that one.
00:21:45 But they own all the Suns in Alberta and all the Suns across Canada, except maybe Vancouver.
00:21:49 They own the Calgary Herald, the Edmonton Journal, Victoria Times Colonist.
00:21:54 I think they own the province in B.C., right?
00:21:57 Province and the Sun go together.
00:21:58 Yeah.
00:21:59 Okay, province.
00:22:00 Pacific Press.
00:22:01 They own, you know, Regina Leader, Post, Ottawa Citizen, obviously the National Post, all this stuff.
00:22:06 This would virtually mean there is one country that runs newspapers, one company that runs newspapers across all of Canada.
00:22:14 Period. Adding on to that, the fact that you already have the Canadian press wire service, which is writing half of the news in the newspapers already. Essentially, every newspaper in Canada is going to write almost the exact same thing, certainly on national stories. They'll write the same on provincial stories.
00:22:32 There might just be a tiny little bit of color on whatever little reporting is done left at town, you know, your city hall kind of thing.
00:22:40 So with you, Corey, do you think, you know, is there a role here for antitrust legislation?
00:22:50 Should the federal government stop this?
00:22:53 Well, they're discussing it.
00:22:55 I know they said they was going to go to their competition committee or whatever that might be.
00:23:01 Competition bureaus already allowed the hyper-centralization.
00:23:03 Antitrust is always such a dicey, dicey area, you know, when you want a free market.
00:23:07 But if you're getting to the point of, yeah, one media outlet controlling 90 some percent of a segment, then we have some serious concerns going on.
00:23:16 That could be one of those rare moments where me as a libertarian minded guy said, it might be the time for the government to step in.
00:23:22 Well, in this case, they're not even like they're a free market enterprise that has achieved a monopoly by any feat of capitalistic ingenuity on their own.
00:23:32 These are welfare queens. 1.00
00:23:34 These are some of the biggest scumbags in Canada who are operating with taxpayers' money to support all of their operations. 0.99
00:23:42 They've got all these regulations working for them. 0.98
00:23:44 So it's not like they're just a great bunch of entrepreneurs who could have just built up a monopoly. 1.00
00:23:49 These guys are scumbags. 0.98
00:23:50 Yeah, and I don't see it building any more a sustainable model for them anyways. 0.99
00:23:54 I mean, when Postmedia and Sun came together, it just shriveled the whole works rather than creating good merged entities.
00:24:00 And I imagine the same thing will happen if and when this is allowed.
00:24:04 Again, it's just a desperation move, though. These are last gasps of a dying industry.
00:24:10 Yeah. Nigel, do you, I mean, mergers and consolidation can sometimes make sense. You
00:24:16 can eliminate some overhead costs. Okay. So instead of, you know, 100 people in your sales
00:24:23 department, 100 people in two different sales departments might be able to do with 100 people
00:24:27 in one sales department, you know, cut the number in half from 200 to 100. Perhaps there could be
00:24:32 economies of scale and technology and maybe, you know, and, you know, he's selling your
00:24:39 advertisement, there could be economies of scale in these things. But they've, these media mergers
00:24:44 have always just gutted whatever local coverage or local culture is there. Do you think there's
00:24:49 any like your newsroom better? Is, is there an upside to this perhaps?
00:24:55 I can't see one.
00:24:57 You know, the point about scale, this is explicit.
00:25:02 Just looking at one report here, publishers involved say that this is a bit to create greater scale.
00:25:10 So all your talk, what you were saying earlier about one message coming from, shall we say, Ottawa,
00:25:17 they're not going to have two people with two different points of view.
00:25:20 You don't get more than one point of view out of the press gallery anyway.
00:25:23 But even without making snide remarks, how are you going to trim costs?
00:25:34 Well, you're going to trim costs in the newsroom because that's the biggest piece of the pie.
00:25:41 It won't be the executive suite that gets trimmed in a meaningful way.
00:25:47 People might be allowed to retire and not replace, but that's not where the big savings are going to be.
00:25:53 So I just can't see how these guys are, this is nothing more than I think one expression is a Hail Mary pass, you know, when you've got nothing, when you can't think of anything else, you do that.
00:26:08 This is there in that situation, they've got nothing else to do.
00:26:11 It's been a poorly kept secret in some media circles that PostMedia is headed for bankruptcy.
00:26:18 They are still carrying massive debt loads. They've been raiding their funds to pay the interest.
00:26:25 They're broke. They're already broke. They just haven't declared bankruptcy yet. So PostMedia
00:26:30 needs an off ramp. And I mean, yeah, the federal government keeps showering them in cash, but
00:26:35 But it's still not enough.
00:26:38 So part of this deal involves the monetization of that debt.
00:26:43 Sorry, they're going to turn that into equity.
00:26:46 And also there'll be a big dilution of shareholder value if what I'm hearing actually comes to pass.
00:26:53 So it actually looks more like, we don't know what the deal looks like, but it could be more or less Torstar kicking over post media in some ways because its investors seem to have a bit more cash.
00:27:04 I don't know, but what's your understanding? Because it's all very murky right now.
00:27:08 Well, it is. I think according to the numbers that have been published,
00:27:13 keep in mind this is all speculation by people who are a little closer to it than we are,
00:27:19 but that I think it's 56% would go to the, what do we got here?
00:27:26 the discussions are leading to post-media shareholders will hold a 56 percent interest
00:27:35 and the tour star people would hold 44 but then north star would retain 65 of the star the star
00:27:44 is the stronger of the two entities so so your theory that this may be a an off-ramp for post
00:27:52 media they hold water the one thing about it is that they've got some big money losers but they
00:27:57 also a lot of those little newspapers actually hold their own quite well even today so that
00:28:02 might be the strength of post media it's a miserable situation derek i mean look i love
00:28:10 newspapers gave my whole career to them i believe strongly in the the value of a of an active
00:28:18 newspaper in holding politicians to account and sticking up for the public there's an old cliche
00:28:25 about you know comforting the afflicted and afflicting the comfortable and newspapers do that
00:28:33 and they've done it very well they're losing their power to do it they're losing this is what's
00:28:38 they're losing their will to do it and i i'm not sure that the news media as it in terms of what
00:28:46 is becoming is going to be quite the loss that we who remember a different news media
00:28:51 feel it is going to be. Yeah. Okay, we're going to switch gears up out of kind of a
00:28:59 internal media critique here, but still kind of staying in Ottawa today, the Liberal fortune
00:29:06 cookie. Maybe I'll get you to elaborate a bit more on it, Nigel. But as one would expect,
00:29:14 The liberals are very upset about how this China business is working for them.
00:29:18 They're not upset, particularly, that China was meddling in Canadian elections.
00:29:22 In fact, they denied it was for a long time until it became, it was well beyond the point where they could deny it.
00:29:27 But we now know a bit about how they've been treating this as very much an internal communications exercise.
00:29:34 Yeah.
00:29:36 They should be upset.
00:29:40 Their chickens are coming home to roost.
00:29:42 they have not handled this well um so what is it we know now so what we know is that
00:29:50 when the story broke as a result of excellent reporting from the legacy media as we said
00:29:56 earlier then the question was how do you make the issue go away you're the government you've
00:30:02 been fingered now what are you going to do so the first strategy was to get david johnson
00:30:08 former governor general highly respected man up until that point i don't know the first first
00:30:12 strategy was denied there was anything going on at all and that the conservatives were racist
00:30:16 against chinese people that was the first one well then the leaks came out and yeah it was 0.99
00:30:20 impossible to deny i must confess i wonder sometimes whether the guy who did that leaking
00:30:25 is alive or dead i haven't heard much i wonder i haven't heard any more uh leaks if he was uh
00:30:31 if he did have a tragic fall out of window we probably wouldn't know about it no we wouldn't
00:30:36 would be. Have to wonder. Anyway, let's leave the George Smiley stuff to the people who write
00:30:44 George Smiley stuff. So there you go. You've got the leaks. Well, how do we deny this? We can't.
00:30:50 All right. We'll have a special rapporteur. That was David Johnson. But we won't give him any real
00:30:56 powers. So he'll never actually be able to uncover the truth. And anything that he does see,
00:31:01 he'll just say, well, I can't talk about it because it's classified. All right. That didn't
00:31:05 work, partly because of those very things. At the end, the report didn't tell you very much that
00:31:11 you couldn't have guessed. So he finally gets... Well, he did tell us some outright falsehoods,
00:31:17 which have been proven incorrect. He finally gets moved out of the picture. And then,
00:31:24 in their charming way, they turn around and blame the opposition for making this a partisan,
00:31:28 partisan, a partisan exercise. I mean, what's the exact word? A highly partisan atmosphere
00:31:35 that lead up to the resignation of David Johnson. So they turn around and blame the very people
00:31:42 who are holding them to account. Well, of course they would, wouldn't they? So now,
00:31:47 well, let's have a real public inquiry on who you're going to get to do it. And so we got to
00:31:54 stage where the federal government is saying well yes we'll do it but we all have to agree on who
00:32:00 it's going to be and we're not going to take any next steps on proving foreign interference until
00:32:06 the opposition gives us full buy-in well who gets to define what a buy-in is well obviously the
00:32:13 government so they'll just stall and stall and stall and in in the perfect world is in their
00:32:17 theory they would stall this thing out two years until the putative election so that's the game
00:32:22 how do you make this go away and there's something there all right uh corey is there
00:32:31 no where's this going next i mean like we we are headed towards an inquiry i think that's
00:32:36 that's been pretty much conceded but it's been some weird games with the liberals saying
00:32:40 will you give us a name of a commissioner first and the conservatives are saying no you put like
00:32:48 Like, we'll talk, or you put them up.
00:32:50 Like, we're in this weird kind of finger-pointing phase,
00:32:52 but it's inevitable we're getting to an inquiry now, right?
00:32:55 I don't know. I don't know.
00:32:57 I mean, he can really just keep dragging and dragging 1.00
00:33:00 and throwing up roadblocks and coming up with more stupid things. 1.00
00:33:03 And I really don't see an end to it any longer. 0.99
00:33:07 Maybe he'll grab another compromised individual like Johnston
00:33:11 and say, we're doing it again and waste two more months.
00:33:14 And then when that person steps down, I mean, I just see it getting circular.
00:33:18 The only linchpin in this is Jagmeet Singh.
00:33:21 Nothing's going to happen until Singh finds something and stands up for himself.
00:33:28 And there's no indication he's going to do that.
00:33:30 I think we are headed towards an inquiry.
00:33:33 It's just how tough and independent is going to be the person leading in.
00:33:36 What are the terms of reference going to be?
00:33:38 I think at this point it's been, I think the liberals have more or less conceded.
00:33:42 Yeah, we're going to an inquiry, but they're trying to, and I actually don't blame the liberals on this part.
00:33:48 This is the one part where they've maybe not been terrible, is they're just trying to make sure that the conservatives can't do to the inquiry what they did with Johnson, you know, like discredit, you know, put a bunch of light on it and discredit and drag it through the mud.
00:34:03 From the liberal perspective, they want the conservatives to have to buy into this and say, okay, we trust this guy, we're going to go with its findings, we're going to go with its conclusions, we're not going to throw shade at it if it doesn't give us our conclusions.
00:34:16 They would strike a committee by now.
00:34:17 Let's do it then.
00:34:18 An all-party committee, there you go.
00:34:19 Let's start throwing the names out there and hashing it out.
00:34:22 They're not even getting that far.
00:34:23 They're just throwing out platitudes, as you said, playing that game, ragging the puck.
00:34:28 But I don't know if they have a will to ever get to that pool.
00:34:31 I mean, they're getting away with it.
00:34:33 The polls aren't hurting them that much.
00:34:34 I mean, they're not gaining anywhere, but they're not falling.
00:34:37 It's just kind of locked in a holding pattern.
00:34:41 All right.
00:34:43 Well, speaking of maybe not foreign interference, but a foreign issue.
00:34:49 So, God, it must have been roughly, was it a year ago that Olaf Scholz came here?
00:34:55 End of August.
00:34:57 Okay. Yeah, you know, just a little shy of a year ago, then the newly elected German Chancellor Olaf Scholz came here.
00:35:06 And this was in the shadow of Russia's invasion of Ukraine.
00:35:12 The West in general, Germany in particular, is saying, well, we've got to get off of Russian gas.
00:35:18 We're funding the Putin war machine here.
00:35:21 We're clearly dependent.
00:35:23 Russia could turn it off at any time if it doesn't like what we're doing by sending munitions or aid to Ukraine.
00:35:29 Plus, even if they don't turn it off, we're funding Russia's war machine.
00:35:31 So this is clearly something that's got to stop.
00:35:34 Schultz comes here.
00:35:35 Oh, he's saying, well, Canada has got all hell for a basement.
00:35:38 There's all the natural gas in the world you would need in Canada. And they're a good ally, a member of NATO. And they're not total idiots. They must want to make some money. Let's go to Canada and do a deal. And Trudeau famously said there was no business case for it.
00:35:53 Well, not long after that, Olaf Scholz signed a deal with the United Arab Emirates, get gas from them. And now I think it was what just yesterday? Yes, just yesterday, Scholz signs a deal with the United States, I think for a Louisiana based company to bring natural gas from that country to Germany.
00:36:15 Okay, I guess the question is, are we just a stupid country? Are we a stupid people? Are we, are we, let me put it another way. Let me put it in terms of Trudeau. 1.00
00:36:29 does Trudeau really believe there wasn't a business case? Or did he know there was a business case and not want to do it anyway, because it's something that would benefit Alberta? And it's technically, even though it's a very clean fossil fuel, it's technically a fossil fuel and fossil fuels are evil. So maybe that's the question. Is it malice or incompetence on Trudeau's part that the only business case that doesn't exist in the world for exporting LNG to Germany is if it's from Canada?
00:36:57 You see, it's a little bit like what we were talking about earlier with bailing out newspapers and Bill C-18.
00:37:06 Yes, it has this primary objective, but if it happens to hurt the independent media, that's great.
00:37:11 Here, I think Mr. Trudeau, and I say I think advisedly because I don't know what's in the man's head.
00:37:17 I don't think anybody does, but I think that he is so personally committed to this idea of fighting climate change
00:37:29 and that he is going to be the person who will be able to claim to the people that he respects
00:37:35 who, you know, go to Davos every year and hang out in Paris and at COPS meetings and say,
00:37:41 I was the person who got Canada down to net zero, not by 2050, not by 2035, in some cases down to 2030.
00:37:51 I believe on the basis of what I read that that's what drives him.
00:37:56 And so never mind the fact that you could help the global atmosphere by selling Canadian natural gas to people who would otherwise be burning coal.
00:38:09 Never mind the fact that Germany is actually an ally and is in distress and needed it.
00:38:17 We had stories about Germans going around picking up firewood in the national parks over there,
00:38:22 which is illegal, but they felt such an alarm at the approaching winter that this is what they were doing.
00:38:29 None of that made any difference.
00:38:31 What he desires is to be able to say, I brought Canada down to net zero.
00:38:37 And by the way, if it hurts Alberta, that's great.
00:38:40 I don't like those guys either.
00:38:42 A lot of them have unacceptable opinions.
00:38:46 Probably us, I think.
00:38:48 Yeah.
00:38:49 I think we're very much in the unacceptable opinions camp.
00:38:52 You know, Corey, I, as a rule, after I take a deep breath on something,
00:38:59 especially in politics and whatnot,
00:39:02 I try to give the benefit of the doubt that,
00:39:05 I'm paraphrasing someone else here, but says don't attribute to malice what can be explained by incompetence. 0.99
00:39:11 Most of the time when governments do stupid things, like we might think they're being evil bastards, but they're malicious, 1.00
00:39:18 but it's generally they're just idiots. 1.00
00:39:20 They're incompetent. Government itself as an institution is incompetent, even if the people in charge of it are not incompetent. 1.00
00:39:26 You add incompetent people on top of incompetent institutions, it's kind of very predictable outcomes.
00:39:32 But I have a hard time believing in competency here.
00:39:36 We have, as the saying goes, all hell for a basement.
00:39:39 We have unlimited natural gas.
00:39:42 Just, there's no end of it.
00:39:45 Germany needs it.
00:39:47 And we've got pretty well-established shipping lines
00:39:50 across the Atlantic for it.
00:39:53 I don't know, but was it just incompetence? 1.00
00:39:55 Was it just that Trudeau was an idiot 1.00
00:39:57 or was it malicious? 1.00
00:39:59 Yes.
00:40:01 Okay, explain why you say malicious.
00:40:04 It's similar, I mean, yes to the whole works.
00:40:06 And it's maliciously incompetent.
00:40:09 Yes, and as well as he's ideologically obsessed. 0.81
00:40:14 He's got tunnel vision.
00:40:16 It's as Nigel was saying, his whole world, what legacy has he got?
00:40:21 He's been a prime minister, he's been sitting for a long time,
00:40:23 but there's not really a heck of a lot of things he can point to,
00:40:26 you know, say as an elderly man and say, I did that, I did this.
00:40:29 he's put all his eggs in the climate change basket. And if we open up a big port on the east
00:40:35 coast that's exporting LNG, even if it's Germany this year, he does have enough brains in his head
00:40:40 to realize that'll probably start exporting to other nations as well. And it's going to be a lot
00:40:44 harder to shut down the petrochemical industry when you've got this outflow and income coming
00:40:50 from it. So, I mean, for him to state sitting there, it is questionable whether it was malicious
00:40:57 or incompetence or what, when you're sitting with the gas right there and you're sitting with a
00:41:00 customer saying, I want to buy that gas and for you to say there's no business case, no, that's
00:41:05 exactly what a business case is. But he doesn't care. He just, as Nigel said, wants to be the one
00:41:11 he could say, look what I did. I stopped this from spreading further. And yeah, as he said,
00:41:17 a bit of the icing on the cake is the malicious aspect. You know, if I can give the middle finger
00:41:21 that Alberta that made Dada have such a hard time in the 70s and 80s, all the better. 0.97
00:41:26 Proven markets, proven products, no business case.
00:41:30 Theoretical products for foreign corporations, totally a business case.
00:41:35 So let's talk, yeah, like EVs.
00:41:38 Like we're just throwing the GDPs of small countries' worth of subsidies at EV stuff
00:41:44 where there is clearly no business case of any kind.
00:41:49 But he says there's a business case there.
00:41:51 But LNG, like, exporting LNG doesn't require a dime from the government.
00:41:56 Not $1 of subsidy is required.
00:41:58 Just the federal government to say, we're not going to get in the way.
00:42:01 Okay, we'll work with you for right-of-ways on some pipeline infrastructure to get it to ports
00:42:05 and the right to load these tankers and have it.
00:42:09 That's it.
00:42:10 No dollars from the taxpayer spent.
00:42:12 No business case.
00:42:13 But if you go to the federal government, you say, hey, I'm running a money-losing newspaper
00:42:16 or, hey, I'm running an electric battery operation.
00:42:19 Can I have a few billion dollars or tens of billions of dollars?
00:42:24 Well, there's clearly a business case to be made.
00:42:27 It just raises, I guess, kind of tying it all back together now.
00:42:32 Does it make sense to be a capitalist in Canada?
00:42:35 Like, especially if you're in a subsidized industry, does it make sense to start a media company?
00:42:41 Does it make sense to start, say you wanted to have an EV company in Canada.
00:42:45 I have a problem with EVs as long as people are paying for it themselves.
00:42:49 But if you didn't want to take subsidies, it'd be impossible to exist.
00:42:53 Does it make sense to be a capitalist in Canada anymore?
00:42:55 No, at all.
00:42:56 You know, we're living in the conditions described by Ayn Rand and Atlas Shrubb.
00:43:00 Exactly what I was thinking.
00:43:01 Were you really?
00:43:02 Okay.
00:43:03 We're literally sitting in the John Galt studio.
00:43:05 You know, I understand that not every viewer necessarily has read the book, but Ayn Rand just talks about the progressive destruction of capitalism.
00:43:15 and how at the end nobody does anything without a government grant
00:43:21 and all the people who are genius who actually do something
00:43:25 have withdrawn to a, you know, gulch gulch is called, yes.
00:43:29 So, I mean, that's kind of where we are.
00:43:32 But I just want to make one point about when we're trying to work out 0.98
00:43:36 whether Mr. Trudeau is foolish or malicious. 0.91
00:43:40 And what we have to remember is that he does things that a lot of people don't like, perhaps even a majority of people don't like. 0.93
00:43:52 I'll use the recent passport renewal as an example, but the sort of the destruction of the symbols of an old Canada that he doesn't like, we have not been able to stop him. 0.98
00:44:05 So is he a fool? 0.99
00:44:08 Is he incompetent? 1.00
00:44:10 He is doing what he set out to do.
00:44:13 And people who didn't like it have been unable to stop him.
00:44:17 What does that make us?
00:44:21 Dangerous thought.
00:44:22 I don't like thinking about that.
00:44:23 That's a dangerous thought.
00:44:24 Well, Nigel, Corey.
00:44:26 That's what you pay me for, dangerous thoughts.
00:44:28 Dangerous thoughts, oh, that's a good name for a show.
00:44:31 Dangerous thoughts.
00:44:32 I like it.
00:44:33 Dangerous thoughts.
00:44:35 Okay.
00:44:36 Go ahead.
00:44:37 Killed that conversation, didn't I?
00:44:39 Different gears are turning now.
00:44:41 Okay.
00:44:42 All right, gentlemen.
00:44:43 Thank you for joining us.
00:44:44 And thank all of you for joining us.
00:44:45 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard,
00:44:47 please go to westernstandard.news right now.
00:44:49 Click on membership.
00:44:50 It's only $10 a month or $100 a year for unlimited access
00:44:54 to bail out free Western Standard content.
00:44:58 You'll get access to all of our content.
00:45:00 The opinion, our great opinion columnists,
00:45:02 columnists all of our reporters spread from coast to coast thank you very much for joining us today
00:45:07 and god bless here's what commodity prices are doing in lethbridge today cash barley is steady
00:45:12 at 420 feed wheat is down five dollars at 415 and corn is down 15 at 403 per metric ton
00:45:20 in the milling wheat markets july minneapolis futures dropped 27 cents to 806 per bushel with
00:45:26 with local hardware at spring bid for July movement at $10.50 per bushel.
00:45:31 Looking at canola, nearby futures fell $29.40 at $7.0990 per tonne,
00:45:37 with delivered values for July movement at $16.32 per bushel.
00:45:41 In the pulse markets, nearby red lentil prices are trading at $0.335 per pound,
00:45:45 and yellow peas are steady at $11.25 per bushel.
00:45:49 And in the cattle markets, August live cattle are higher $0.275 at $1.79.56 per hundredweight.
00:45:56 For more information on pricing or picked up options, give me a call at 403-394-1711.
00:46:03 I'm Matt Musicum at Marketplace Commodities.
00:46:05 Accurate, real-time marketing information and pricing options.
00:46:10 Canadian Shooting Sports Association.
00:46:12 Without the CSSA, our gun rights would have been taken long, long ago.
00:46:16 These guys are on the front lines, helping to draft smart and intelligent firearms, regulations and legislation in Canada.
00:46:23 and more importantly educating the public about how we keep guns out of the hands of the wrong
00:46:28 people to become a member it's absolutely worth every penny you can become a western
00:46:35 center member for just ten dollars a month or 99