Western Standard - December 02, 2025


THE PIPELINE: Did Danielle’s demands work?

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
United Conservative Party 2025 AGM Keynote Western Standard News Update | 3 Dec 2025

Episode Stats


Length

47 minutes

Words per minute

188.88

Word count

8,939

Sentence count

760

Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

17

sentences flagged

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

The OG Pipeline crew talks abortion, the recall against Alberta's UCP MLAs, and much, much more. Plus, a new documentary explores the controversial topic of late-term abortions in Canada. Thanks to our sponsor, The OG Pipeline!

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good day. Today is November 26, 2025. I'm Derek Fildebrandt,
00:00:29 publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline. I'm here with the OG
00:00:33 Pipeline crew, former Western Standard opinion editor, Nigel Hannaford.
00:00:39 I would be late. Good to be here.
00:00:41 And Western Standard senior Alberta columnist, Corey Morgan.
00:00:44 Always a pleasure.
00:00:45 All right. Well, we're going to get into one topic that no one likes to talk about because
00:00:50 everyone gets angry. We'll probably maybe even get angry with each other on this show here.
00:00:56 Uh, we're talking about late term abortions in Canada. We're told it's exceptionally rare
00:01:01 and only in medically necessary, uh, situations. Um, a new documentary out would seem to show,
00:01:10 I think fairly definitively, that that is very much not the case. Um, so we're going to be
00:01:15 talking about a very, about the touchiest subject you could find in Canada, almost anywhere really,
00:01:22 but, uh, we're going to, we're going to talk about late term abortions. Um, the total recall 0.95
00:01:29 against, uh, Alberta UCP MLAs continues. I think we're up to what, six or eight or so
00:01:35 somewhere around there. Uh, 14 now. 14 who have bad approved petitions?
00:01:40 I believe so, yeah. Okay. But I mean, it's just an application form. It's really-
00:01:43 Yeah, yeah. It doesn't mean much yet. But, uh, efforts to recall essentially the whole, uh,
00:01:48 enough UCP MLAs to collapse the government for an election, I guess. Be careful what
00:01:52 you wish for, guys. I'm not sure you want an election right now. But, uh, some people
00:01:57 are saying that that process is being abused. We need to change the recall legislation.
00:02:03 Hmm. I'm not, I'm not so sure. You want recall, you got to accept it when it's used against
00:02:08 you too. But we'll get into it. But first, did Daniel Smith's demands of Mark Carney's federal
00:02:14 liberal government work? Um, she, uh, the premier laid down a series of nine demands. I think it may
00:02:24 have been earlier in the summer, maybe even the spring. It was some time ago. She laid down
00:02:28 these demands. Um, and this is all in the background of the looming, likely-ish, uh, Alberta
00:02:36 referendum on independence coming, saying, look, if you, uh, it was kind of an or else. And she
00:02:41 didn't say what the or else was, but it was more or else. I'm not going to be doing much
00:02:46 on the, uh, stay side of the referendum. Uh, I think it was kind of the implication. Not
00:02:51 sure if that's fair or not. But, uh, she laid out these demands. They were not all about
00:02:57 oil and gas development and pipelines, but I'd say the bulk of them were. There were some
00:03:02 items on equalization. Surprise! There hasn't been a peep on equalization. Nothing will ever
00:03:08 seem to change there. Um, but there does, knock on wood, appear to be some movement on the natural
00:03:15 resource development side of things. Tomorrow, Thursday, Daniel Smith and Mark Carney are
00:03:20 appearing at the Chamber of Commerce, where they're going to sign or present a memorandum of
00:03:25 understanding. MOUs actually don't really mean anything. They're just kind of, it's an agreement
00:03:30 to an agreement. Uh, I was a bureaucrat for one year of my life and we signed an MOU. I was like,
00:03:35 oh my God, this is a big deal. It was on internal free trade in Canada. Guess what? Nothing came of
00:03:40 it. We spent years on it to get an MOU and nothing came. So, uh, but, you know, so it's about exceptions
00:03:48 from the emissions caps, uh, exceptions from the, uh, Northwest coast tanker ban, um, the things like
00:03:58 that that would make a pipeline feasible. Um, but David EB is saying, wait a minute, you can't treat
00:04:07 me like an Albertan. I get to have some say in this. And so he, he, he's squawking that, uh, he
00:04:12 hasn't been consulted and given his permission. Uh, some of the BC native bands are saying something
00:04:18 similar. Um, I don't know. Do we have much to cheer about yet?
00:04:23 I don't think so. Uh, you know, I, I would actually love to be cheering about this, but
00:04:28 here in Alberta, we spend so much time thinking about it from our point of view that we don't
00:04:34 always think about how the federal government is seeing it and how Mr. Carney in particular
00:04:40 is seeing it. No, I mean, what does, yeah, we've got nine demands. What does, what does Mr.
00:04:46 Carney have that he wants to, to get done? He wants the problem to go away. He wants actually
00:04:53 the appearance of a settlement. He's just come back from a meeting in Brazil where everybody was
00:05:00 talking about how to, uh, how, how to take the carbon out of the climate. And now he's got to come
00:05:07 back and he's expected to do work out something with the premier of Alberta who wants to develop
00:05:13 more oil. So what he's doing is building a situation where it looks like he's agreeing, but he's got an
00:05:21 escape route. He won't have to go through with it. I am very pessimistic about, uh, this, this, uh,
00:05:27 particular, uh, I mean, I hope I'm wrong, but I actually don't see any good coming out of this.
00:05:34 He has, apart from a constituency that's interested in climate change, he himself has made it very clear
00:05:41 how he sees the climate change. He wants to, he wants to get less carbon emitted. He's come up with
00:05:51 this crazy idea that in order to produce oil in the West, you must dairy an equivalent amount of
00:06:00 carbon dioxide to what it took to, to make the oil, nothing like that in the East where they're
00:06:04 importing it. And now you just mentioned the condition that BC has to agree. And the indigenous
00:06:13 peoples there have to agree. There is his escape route. They will not agree. Thanks Danielle. It
00:06:19 was great talking, but we're not, we're not doing anything because BC doesn't agree. Well, wait a
00:06:24 minute. You intruded in our space, provincially intrude on theirs. Well, you're out.
00:06:29 Well, bring the bowl of water. Wash my hands of it. Yeah. Well, Corey, none of this requires
00:06:37 intrusion actually on provincial jurisdiction, uh, interprovincial trade of this kind, the
00:06:43 infrastructure crossing provincial and national boundaries or international boundaries is strict
00:06:47 federal jurisdiction. The Supreme court ruled on that. That was, you know, one of the rare times
00:06:53 where the Supreme courts actually made a sensible, it's written in black and white in the British
00:06:57 North America act that assigns the powers one way or another. So it's, it's pretty clear that
00:07:02 that's, that's federal jurisdiction. Uh, the court ruled the David E.B. and the BC and D.P. have no
00:07:07 standing, whatever, constitutional standing, whatever to interfere. Uh, but I mean, we haven't seen the
00:07:14 MOU yet, so I, I don't want to prejudge it. I just think as Albertans, we've, uh, you know, we've,
00:07:21 we've played the Charlie Brown football enough by now that maybe we're overly cynical. I don't know.
00:07:27 Are we overly cynical here? Or like, is he going to be, are BC natives and the BC government,
00:07:34 um, which one of those seniors soon will, who knows, but, uh, are, are, are they going to,
00:07:40 you expect they'll actually be given a real veto of some kind or it's just, you know, the MOU
00:07:45 will require some basic duty to consult, which would, that's fine. I actually think that's,
00:07:51 that's, that's appropriate. Uh, I don't know. Am I overly cynical?
00:07:55 Well, part of it is, uh, you're not overly cynical and, uh, part of it, as I was saying
00:07:58 to Nigel earlier, and I, I've got limited what I could say, but a little bird told me
00:08:02 there is nothing in the MOU that does give a veto to the First Nations or the province
00:08:08 of BC, nor should it, because it's not constitutional, as you pointed out, both with First Nations
00:08:12 and BC. So Carney has to be a prime minister and he doesn't seem to be willing to. This is
00:08:18 fully in his hands. He, he says it's getting done or it's not. And what's missing in all of
00:08:24 this, I think are not enough discussion. Maybe that'll pop over the MOU. Where's the private
00:08:28 proponent? That's the excuse they like using too. There's no private proponent. Well, none of them
00:08:31 are going to, unless they can get through. So they need to see something with the prime minister
00:08:38 saying this pipe is going to reach the coast, not this pipe. If we meet this giant long list
00:08:44 of conditions, well, nobody's going to pull their wallet out there. No, he's got to be saying,
00:08:48 I support this and I'm going to facilitate it. And we can't say that, oh, we'll need 10,
00:08:53 20 years of consultation either, because it's been done already. The Northern Gateway,
00:08:58 Enbridge already spent, what, a hundred and some million or some, they've done the consultation.
00:09:04 I know it expired, but you know what? The mountains are in the same place. The rivers are
00:09:07 in the same spot. If anything, pipelines have gotten even better. We have to fast track this or it's not
00:09:13 happening. So it's going to be interesting as you say, leading into an AGM for Premier Smith to get
00:09:18 out and try and tell the members she has accomplished something. And there has been progress
00:09:25 because they're as cynical as we are for the most part. And they want to see her either standing up
00:09:30 for Alberta or actually having an agreement that says this pipe is going to go not, oh, we've got
00:09:35 another MOU. We're going to talk about it for 10 more years while it dies on the vote.
00:09:39 Corey, to your point, the Western Standard has today published the following comment by Mr. Carney
00:09:46 in the House of Commons. Word for words, the memorandum of understanding that we're negotiating
00:09:51 with Alberta creates the necessary conditions, but not sufficient conditions because we believe in
00:09:59 cooperative federalism. We believe the government of BC has to agree. We believe that First Nations,
00:10:05 right holders in this country have to agree and support all stakeholders. So they're already, he
00:10:12 has laid down conditions under which he says, well, I did my best.
00:10:15 And there's already First Nations saying that they're never going to support it under any
00:10:19 circumstances. That's where we got to get, we got to define that difference between consultation and
00:10:23 consent. We aren't obligated to get consent. And obviously they're saying they're never going to give
00:10:27 it. So at this point, it's either tell them to go get stuffed. We're doing this or just give up.
00:10:31 That's the two options they got.
00:10:32 So I don't know how much of this is Carney saying one thing. I'm not sure if that was
00:10:36 in response to an MVP question or conservative question. I think it was conservatives were
00:10:39 putting him against the wall.
00:10:40 Yeah. So I have a hard time believing that Danielle Smith is going to be willing to stand
00:10:47 next to Mark Carney at a press conference and put her name to something that would give BC and
00:10:54 native groups in BC a veto one day before the opening of the UCP convention where she's going to face the 0.98
00:11:01 most hardcore folks in the right who are, I mean, we've been around these folks, they eat leaders
00:11:08 for brunch. So, you know, when she goes into there, she likes to flex her Alberta first bona fides. 0.99
00:11:15 So I'm hesitant to think that she's going to do this one day before facing that kind of crowd.
00:11:23 Well, from what I've heard, like I said, that's not in the MOU. So that perhaps tomorrow, it might
00:11:29 be an interesting conference because if that comes to the opportunity where she might have to put him 0.57
00:11:32 on the spot there and say, well, just to clarify, this is not giving a veto to such and such and make
00:11:38 him answer it there, because he was absent from question period on this today anyway. So that would
00:11:44 be a whole different question. Now, if it was a sabotage, I mean, we really want to see provincial
00:11:47 federal relations go bad, you know, during a conference where they're supposed to be holding
00:11:50 hands and smiling. But I mean, if she's being undercut before this thing's even signed, perhaps
00:11:56 the premier will have a good enough cause to put him to the question while they're standing in front
00:12:00 of the cameras. Yeah, I mean, it is. I mean, the United Conservative Party very much inherited
00:12:09 from the Wild Rose, the kind of Alberta first strain of DNA in that party's blood. Actually,
00:12:18 in many ways, I think the UCP is more Alberta first than the Wild Rose was. I think that's just
00:12:23 the Overton window of shit. Well, it's just that the issues are more prescient now, too, 0.99
00:12:27 than they had been at that time. Yeah. So I mean, the politics, it's always good politics
00:12:34 for the Alberta UCP premier to be fighting like hell against the federal liberal prime minister.
00:12:39 That's that's good politics. So for her to not play that card and stand next to him at a podium 1.00
00:12:46 the day before convention leads me to think in all probability, I mean, maybe she's lost her marbles
00:12:51 and gone soft. But in all probability, I would bet that she's got a fair degree of faith in it,
00:12:59 because I she doesn't like, you know, that there's going to be some people on the harder
00:13:05 independence, sovereignty, right side of the party who are critics, and they're going to just take
00:13:10 a picture of her standing at a podium. And that's a bad meme. That's a bad meme. So if she's going to
00:13:16 give them that, she's probably got to have a fair degree of certainty that no, this is a real thing.
00:13:22 Well, I think it's going to go one way or the other. There can be a mushy middle on this.
00:13:26 She has to be standing at that podium to have something that can be taken to the bank. Like 0.90
00:13:31 this is an agreement, and she has to have the prime minister very strongly saying this is going to get
00:13:35 done. Or if it's some mushy, we're just signing this again, and we're going to tread water for months,
00:13:40 as you said, well, then something has made her addled because she understands that nobody going
00:13:44 into an AGM wants a mushy middle position, or if it blows up tomorrow, that goes well going into an AGM
00:13:52 as well, because then you give the fire and brimstone speech saying, we tried, we did everything we could.
00:13:57 I took my time the day before this to try and come out and do this. And he torpedoed us before we could
00:14:01 even get it rolling. I guess we have to look at other alternatives as Albertans to get our resources to
00:14:06 market. But a middle is not going to look good. Yeah. And you know, this is in the context of a
00:14:12 probable referendum some point next year on independence. And thank you for all your hard
00:14:19 work on that, Thomas Nkazic. I appreciate you volunteering your time and your Winnebago or
00:14:26 whatever, driving around Alberta, getting signatures so that we can have a vote on independence. It was very
00:14:31 generous of the cause. He is forward thinking sometimes.
00:14:36 God, you just can't make this shit up sometimes. 1.00
00:14:39 Yeah. He was probably buzzing from the hairspray and wasn't thinking clearly. 1.00
00:14:42 Yeah. Yeah. Um, but anyway, we're, you know, there's a probable referendum on independence coming.
00:14:50 I mean, if there is tangible, like you got a shovel in the ground somewhere, I mean, it's no pipeline
00:14:57 is going to get be done and pumping by that time. I'd be honest, that's not reasonable.
00:15:00 But if you had a shovel in the ground by the time people vote, uh, I think it would make it
00:15:07 damn near impossible for the independent side to win that. And I, and I think it is sad that
00:15:11 the whole independence argument gets reduced through just pipelines. It is a hell of a lot
00:15:16 more than pipe. In fact, it should maybe be at the bottom of the top five list at this point. I'd say
00:15:24 controlling our simple borders might be at the top. If we can't control the Canadian border,
00:15:28 then let's at least control the Alberta border. Um, a lot of things, but, uh, I think in terms of
00:15:36 the discussion, I mean, the independent side always had the much bigger hill to climb to have any chance
00:15:41 of winning. If, if there's real progress and it's like, yeah, no, we're actually building this.
00:15:46 There's crews out there right now. There's pictures, there's video of guys digging holes
00:15:50 and laying pipe. I, I, I think that kills the chance of winning an independence vote.
00:15:55 It would indicate that other things can get done as well. I mean, that's one symbol. So we're saying,
00:15:59 well, if it could be negotiated to get a pipeline through, then maybe it's possible to negotiate on
00:16:04 immigration or negotiate on, uh, equalization or some of those other areas. So it will be a big
00:16:10 symbolic win that would undercut the independence movement, uh, strongly, but they got to move fast.
00:16:14 You know, people are impatient. That's the bottom line. They don't want to see it. I mean,
00:16:18 Kearney loves his hockey analogies. Well, it looks to us like he's ragging the puck and we're not,
00:16:23 people don't have time for it anymore. You get something going or quit playing us.
00:16:27 Well, people in Alberta don't have any time for it anymore. Maybe this plays really well
00:16:32 back in central Canada.
00:16:33 Oh, very bossy.
00:16:35 He's taking the cousins to Alberta and he's going to lay about the Alberta government.
00:16:40 Tell them exactly where they stand. That's good. That won't play well in Alberta,
00:16:44 but that could be Chris to his mill in Ontario, Quebec.
00:16:47 Yeah. We can't always look at it for our lenses.
00:16:49 Well, that's the thing we get. It's very easy to forget what might be in it for him.
00:16:54 Yeah. Cause where does some of his MPs are getting pretty upset with the possibility.
00:16:58 Some of the BC ones who are kind of doctrinaire on this stuff.
00:17:01 All right. Well, speaking of laying into the Alberta government, um,
00:17:04 let's talk about the recall campaign. We've gotten into this before. So this is coming out of the
00:17:12 Alberta UCP government, uh, legislating an end to the teacher strike, uh, sending them back to work.
00:17:20 They still legislated them a sweetheart deal. I mean, it was a great frigging deal that they got for 0.83
00:17:25 themselves. I thought the UCP should have legislated them back to work with a pay cut. 0.64
00:17:28 Um, like not even more charter schools to be transferred. As you said, I liked that.
00:17:34 Yeah. Yeah. Actually, I don't think they actually should have legislated them back to work. I think
00:17:37 they just should have said every day, convert a public school into a charter school until the
00:17:40 union begs for an end to the strike. Um, walk them out essentially, I'd say, uh, that's not what
00:17:46 happened. Anyway, the ATA was legislated back to work. They lost their shit. They went, uh, they got
00:17:51 very, very angry. The notwithstanding clause was used. So it's just bulletproof from a legal challenge
00:17:56 because the Supreme Court's made some bizarre rulings in the last years where, uh, apparently
00:18:04 individual rights are also now union rights. They, unions have the same rights as individuals. So, um,
00:18:12 they lost their mind and they decided to, uh, initiate recall campaigns against Alberta UCP MLAs. 1.00
00:18:19 Some of them seem pretty dumb. They're going after MLAs who had massive margins of victory. I guess 0.99
00:18:25 Daniel Smith had a big margin of victory in Brooks Medicine Hat, but she's the premier. She's very
00:18:29 symbolic. So they may as well take a shot at that. I guess, um, you know, they're going after other
00:18:34 ones who have big margins of victory, like up in Grand Prairie. Uh, and then other ones. Now,
00:18:40 the one that I think is probably their smartest to go after. Sorry, Demetrius is the education minister.
00:18:44 He's symbolic. He's the education minister. They hate him. And Calgary Bowl had an extremely,
00:18:48 uh, his constituency in Calgary Bowl had a very, very narrow margin of victory for him.
00:18:54 So strategically or tactically, that that's a, that's maybe a smarter one, but they're going
00:18:58 after all sorts of others. Angela Pitt, she had a pretty big margin of victory. Um,
00:19:03 but they're going after them very clearly based on government policy. And a lot in the UCP are
00:19:10 stating that, well, that's not fair game. Um, we need to change the rules around here. Now,
00:19:15 some of it, I think is more legitimate complaints. Like, uh, the legislation says that the people who
00:19:21 are canvassing for signatures have to live in the constituency. I actually don't think that should
00:19:25 be a rule necessarily because constituencies, as I could tell my experience, get gerrymandered.
00:19:31 I strongly differ on that part. Yeah, it is. Okay. But, but, or, or maybe they have to at least
00:19:36 be in an adjacent one because, because constituencies, particularly urban ones, I mean,
00:19:41 you live on one side of a street, you're in one constituency, you live on the other side of the street,
00:19:45 you're in another. And it's just some, some dink sitting in a commission somewhere appointed by 0.98
00:19:50 political parties who drew that. Sometimes. Well, I know it. I live 800 meters from a UCP
00:19:56 member and I have an NDP member for mine. I'm half a mile out of the border and they gerrymandered it
00:20:01 actually because they wanted an NDP rural seat. So they made that one. It frustrates me, but I still
00:20:06 think when it comes to overturning an MLA, it should only be the people living under that constituency.
00:20:11 In an election, you're allowed to campaign in any constituency you want. In fact, people come
00:20:14 from other provinces, even other countries in campaign. Yeah. So, you know, if you're allowed
00:20:18 to go and volunteer to elect someone in a different riding, we do it in general elections and by
00:20:22 elections, I think you should be allowed to do it for recall too. And you know, let's remember a lot
00:20:27 of people who are against what's happening with recall here right now. Uh, we were all gearing up to
00:20:33 recall Jason Kenney, but from the right. Yeah. Uh, but that was province wide. That was, uh, no, but to
00:20:39 recall him in his own seat. He was going to probably end up getting recalled if, if potential until, uh,
00:20:43 essentially the party recalled him by forcing a leadership review of him. They recalled him at the
00:20:48 leadership level, but he was good to otherwise probably get recalled at the MLA level.
00:20:53 So I guess there's two points. One is the rules are you have to live in the ride. I don't think it's a good
00:20:58 rule, but that is the rule. And that appears very much to be aggressively violated by the organizers
00:21:03 here. Um, I think the UCB have got a point there, even if I think it's a bad part of the law where I
00:21:10 think they don't have a point is they're saying, well, you're just disagreeing with us on government
00:21:14 policy. You have to have a very specific reason, some kind of misconduct to recall someone.
00:21:21 I don't think so. Again, you've got, you know, what's, what's, what's a big deal for someone might
00:21:28 not be like Bev Oda. People got pissed off at $28 glass of orange juice. I mean, this part was
00:21:34 15, 16, sorry. With inflation, it's 28 years. Um, $16 glass of orange juice. That is not a serious
00:21:40 thing, but it blew up into a serious thing. So then is a judge going to sit there and say, well,
00:21:44 this is worthy of recall. And this is not, um, broken promises. Sometimes promises are legitimately
00:21:51 broken. You made a promise. He got in. Turns out the facts on the ground are different, or the
00:21:55 government's got no money. Hey, we don't actually have money for this anymore. Are we really going
00:22:00 to let, uh, have a court decide if someone, if a politician broke his promise or if this scandal
00:22:06 is serious or non-serious? I think the UCP are kind of grasping at straws on this thing saying that,
00:22:11 well, you have to have a better reason that you disagree with the government policy.
00:22:14 They pulled the trigger on the government's own policy. It's the sort of thing I've done in the past.
00:22:17 Uh, my NDP nomination run when they left it wide open for anybody to register
00:22:21 policies against it. And be on there. And then it's amazing. They changed their policies within
00:22:25 two weeks and suddenly I disappeared as an NDP nomination candidate. Let's make sure we pull up
00:22:30 a picture from, uh, Corey's nomination there. He's a reference and I ran hard. Yeah. You ran for
00:22:35 the nomination. It was a bath can ask us. Yes. Yes. You had the, pardon the language,
00:22:39 you had the pussy hat and everything. Yeah. It was probably dressed in NDP wear for the time. 1.00
00:22:43 Yeah. And then they shut down my campaign. Uh, but that's using their, their policies against them. 0.99
00:22:47 That's what they're doing with the recall. Uh, as annoying as it may be, it's fair
00:22:50 game. It is. And I don't think as long as those rules are followed, that they're going to succeed
00:22:55 in many, if any of them, as you said, Highwood, they're going after RJ Sigurdsson. They've never
00:23:01 had under 70% support for the UCP there. I would not want to be a door knocker going to the door
00:23:06 saying, Hey, will you sign this petition with your name address? Cause that's the thing people got to
00:23:10 realize, but right now, all they're doing is putting in a form and a fee. Anybody can do that.
00:23:14 Yeah. That takes 20 minutes. Yeah. Uh, the news is reporting it as if there's this wave.
00:23:19 Well, then there's a vote on if there will be a bioactive. Yeah. So this is a long process. So
00:23:25 you have to get signatures from 60% of the people who voted in the last election within a timeframe.
00:23:30 You can't flood it with outside help and rest assured there will be a lot of UCP supporters
00:23:35 who will want to see a couple of violations. Cause that'll give them an excuse to say this is
00:23:39 invalid and thrown out. Uh, as you said, cover bow is maybe the closest they could come to it.
00:23:44 But even then that's a tough task. I mean, not everybody's eager to see a
00:23:47 by-election or whatnot. Even some who don't like the, the MLA, they might say, well, I'll still
00:23:51 hang on till, uh, the next election. Like I like recall and referendum legislation. I like using
00:23:57 Switzerland as a model, but something that's different there is the citizens take it very
00:24:00 seriously. So if somebody shows up with a frivolous campaign at their door and says,
00:24:04 will you sign this? They'll say, no, I'm not interested. Not that Canadian politeness.
00:24:08 So I'll just sign. No, it just, I don't like this. I won't sign. So it's incumbent,
00:24:13 I think on the same time for that culture to develop here. Like they haven't had initiative.
00:24:17 We haven't had recall, no, any practical way. Pretty much now they're putting it to the test.
00:24:21 And you know, it really wants people, if people get the idea that this is a serious 1.00
00:24:27 effort by the opposition to defrone the government, not just take out an MLA who has been an idiot, 0.97
00:24:36 then the tide is going to turn against this recall. Now that's the thing. They have to get that message 0.99
00:24:42 out because otherwise people are saying, oh, whatever, you know.
00:24:46 Yeah. Like different stuff. But the complaint is saying, like the UCP is talking about
00:24:51 changing some of the rules. They haven't said definitively. Yeah.
00:24:55 I'm not sure how you can, because it comes pretty subjective when you're getting into
00:24:58 what he is or isn't. It really should be. I've been disagreeing.
00:25:01 I think on a communications front, you can say that these guys are being frivolous or wrong.
00:25:05 Just don't change the rules. Like the example I use is, is Dara Hetherington. I keep bringing her up.
00:25:09 And for those who remember, you might not have been in Alberta at the time yet. She was a city
00:25:13 councillor in Lethbridge who went very much off the rails, a fake kidnapping story, took off to Las
00:25:18 Vegas, very bizarre, but they couldn't get rid of her. She, she still had that seat on council and as 0.99
00:25:24 loopy as she'd been and so on, she potentially could have been stuck in there for years because 0.76
00:25:29 you just have no mechanism to have somebody, even though they've proven themselves just to,
00:25:34 you know, she needed treatment, not a seat. You know, I mean, just, it's a mental health thing.
00:25:39 Oh no. Are you sure it's left? I thought it was in Edmonton.
00:25:42 It was left bridge.
00:25:43 It was an Edmonton councillor who would do that.
00:25:44 Well, you're thinking of, uh, uh, uh, Tucker Gomberg. And that poor fellow ended up committing
00:25:49 suicide jumping off Confederation Bridge. He wanted to flood the Edmonton city streets to build,
00:25:52 uh, so people could skate to work.
00:25:54 I've heard worse ideas for Edmonton.
00:25:56 Yeah. But he was a city councillor, but similar sorts of things. You see, when they are so clearly,
00:26:00 though, something has happened or whatever, or they've done something where they just are no
00:26:03 longer fit, we don't have a mechanism to remove them. But theoretically, it should just only be
00:26:08 when it gets that bad before you really start doing it. But how do you put, how do you put
00:26:14 gates to make sure that doesn't help me?
00:26:15 That's the problem. And I'm not saying this is the UCP's plan. It's not as far as we know, but
00:26:20 you know, some prominent voices within it are saying, you know, and some of the MLAs being subject to
00:26:24 this are saying, well, no, the rules should say like, there has to be clear misconduct. Well,
00:26:28 that means that's going to become a legal case. And yeah, misconduct's a different thing too.
00:26:33 Yeah. Okay. So like Sean Chu, the Calgary city councillor, uh, was in some pretty hot water,
00:26:38 but he was never charged and convicted with a crime. He did some things which were questionable
00:26:43 a long time ago and voters deserve to render their decision. Uh, but he kind of, the way with
00:26:50 advanced voting, he still got elected, couldn't be recalled. Okay. But is it always criminal behavior?
00:26:56 Like not many are going to be, I think criminal makes it more clear. They'll often just resign
00:27:01 its race anyways, but, uh, it's, it's those, but also what, like, what if it's, um, you know,
00:27:06 a politician refuses to hand over their gun to the cops. Okay. Well that's criminal technically,
00:27:12 but so, okay. Like it just gets way too subjective. You have recall or you don't have recall. And the
00:27:20 general rule of thumb is you're going to agree with the reason what it's a politician you don't want,
00:27:24 don't like, and you want to recall. And you're going to disagree with it when it's a politician
00:27:27 you do like, who's on your side. Well, if the person's principled, they wouldn't. I mean,
00:27:30 I wouldn't want to see one against Nietzsche because it would just be a waste of paper,
00:27:34 a waste of pounding the street. I'd love to see Nietzsche gone. I've got no use for the man.
00:27:37 But I wouldn't sign the petition. He was popularly elected in, in Edmonton Strathcona. Nobody
00:27:42 other than NDP is ever going to win that seat. Quit wasting time. Let's get on the bigger issues.
00:27:47 But yeah, well, it's interesting to see what's going to happen because if they come out and
00:27:50 shoot down their own legislation, it will undercut the ECP. It'll look bad. It would
00:27:55 look bad if they did. I think they could, you know, there's some tweaking on the administrative
00:27:59 side. I actually think you should not have to live specifically in it in the constituency because
00:28:04 the boundaries are so often arbitrary. You're on one side of the street or you're on the other.
00:28:08 I think maybe they should say you have to live in it or in an adjacent riding to it. So like
00:28:12 you're living in the general area. So even a gerrymandered riding, people who are naturally a part 0.83
00:28:17 of that area can still participate. I think that... But can't vote.
00:28:21 Well, no, no. Only people in that riding can vote and sign a petition to recall, but they could go
00:28:26 into there and, you know, carry... Up on jurors and carry petitions.
00:28:29 Yeah, because we allow it for elections. Why would we not allow it for this? That's...
00:28:32 Well, maybe we shouldn't allow it for elections. But with elections, it's a party and it's a
00:28:35 provincial-wide thing, which is a little different. I mean, we know exactly what will happen if you
00:28:40 open it up. But you got to buy elections.
00:28:41 You got to buy elections. You got to buy elections. Yeah.
00:28:42 People come in from around the country to go for a bargain. And that's what will happen with these
00:28:47 if we open it right up. So old Gil and his gang of union hacks are just going to flood into a
00:28:51 constituency and pound every door a hundred times over. People will sign just to get these union nuts
00:28:56 to stop harassing them. Well, that's what people were going to do against J.C. Kenney. But from the
00:28:59 right, get rid of them. They shouldn't have done that either on the local level. Get rid of them as
00:29:03 a leader. But as far as an MLA goes, I think that's up to the constituents. Yeah. Well, in this case,
00:29:08 the conservatives have a fairly thin majority. So actually, if you got just a few, boom, all of a
00:29:13 sudden, the government's lost its majority. And at that point, you're not going to get
00:29:17 by-alarm. The premier just calls an election. Yeah. Which is what would happen.
00:29:20 That's what would happen. And I mean, you never know what's going to happen. But based on the polls,
00:29:25 I don't think it's going to be... You'll be a careful what you wish for
00:29:29 circumstances like Fabio and his referendum petition. Thanks again, John. Thanks for that. Thanks for
00:29:36 calling an early election. Because I tell you, there's a lot of people in the ECP who would
00:29:40 like to call an early election right now. Renew their mandate. They're strong in the polls.
00:29:44 They got money in the bank. They're ready for an election. But it looks bad to call an early
00:29:49 election, especially when you've got a fixed election date. Daniel Smith remembers what happened
00:29:52 to Jim Prentiss. Yeah. I mean, this would give them all the excuse that they need. That'd be a pretty
00:29:58 good one. Okay. Oh, geez. Okay. We're going to talk about this one. Late-term abortions.
00:30:10 So I think what's called Right Now, it's a kind of student pro-life group came out to put out
00:30:18 a documentary around late-term abortions. And then what's the term? Live birth abortions,
00:30:26 which is about the most horrific form it can take. I mean, we're told late-term... Canada is
00:30:36 pretty much the only country, if not the only country on the planet that has no legislative
00:30:40 framework of any kind around abortion. It's just kind of a black hole. It's a legislative hole. It's
00:30:46 not technically legal. It's not technically illegal. It's just there. It's floating in space. And
00:30:54 we're told that late-term abortions do not happen on an elective basis. It's just not a thing.
00:31:03 They're extremely rare. And they're for medically necessary purposes. And if that was the case,
00:31:10 where if a woman is going to die, I mean, of course, we should not have two people die.
00:31:16 But it's a terrible situation. But yeah, of course, I think most people would agree with that.
00:31:25 But that is not actually what is happening here. So this group, they put out their documentary,
00:31:31 and they went around to a number of abortion clinics, Toronto, Vancouver, and Montreal, I think.
00:31:36 And it was a woman. She went in, over 20 weeks pregnant, says, I want an abortion. I'm like, 1.00
00:31:44 okay. Like, no problem. Casual. No, okay. She says, any restrictions? I'm like, no. I mean,
00:31:51 she's like, do I have to be at risk or anything? Or just like, I just want to end it. And she's
00:31:56 obviously got an undercover camera here. And they're just, like, blase. Like, this is just a
00:32:05 normal administrative thing. No, like, are you? They didn't even say, are you sure? Have you
00:32:11 thought about this? It's just, yeah, okay. Step right up. Don't be shy. When they've got some
00:32:18 damning numbers. Um, uh, so these late-term abortion, uh, abortions, uh, was it? See,
00:32:28 all of the, yeah, the KN Institute for Health Information says, uh, it's normally over a
00:32:33 thousand a year. Um, normally this, I think last year was down a bit, but it was normally well over
00:32:39 a thousand. There were a, not including Quebec, I guess Quebec's got different numbers. There were
00:32:44 123 live birth abortions, and that is where they attempt to kill the fetus inside the womb. 0.99
00:32:52 Um, and then they go to remove it. The child's removed, and it's still alive. And then they kill
00:32:59 it outside the womb, normally with a do not resuscitate. Uh, 28 of those were born alive and
00:33:06 viable in Alberta alone and allowed to die. I hate this topic, but like, uh, I watched this
00:33:13 thing. It's the ultimate third braille in Canadian politics. Uh, if you, you can't watch this and,
00:33:19 and, and, and read this and not think we've got to do something, Nigel.
00:33:24 Yes. Well, first of all, let's dispose of a couple of things. One is there is no credibility
00:33:32 issue here. When I first arrived in Alberta 25 years ago, the Alberta report, our distinguished
00:33:38 ancestor had just published a story about live births at, at the, uh, general hospital.
00:33:49 They had a nurse who spoke to them. They had names, they had everything. And this particular
00:33:54 nurse explained how, when babies were born alive after an abortion, they just put them on the slab 0.98
00:34:01 and let them die. And there was scandal and outrage. And in the end, they told the nurses,
00:34:07 just shut up and do your job. And that's, that, that was the government approach. Um,
00:34:15 but it happens when it, it really does happen. It's not as rare as we were told.
00:34:20 And it's been going on for 25 years that I can speak to, and I'm sure it was going on before that.
00:34:24 And then in our, in the Western standard, a few days ago, Richard Durr, who is, uh, you know,
00:34:32 he's a pro-life activist. He's definitely going to do it like Alberta. Yeah. Pro-life Alberta. Yeah.
00:34:36 I mean, this is not an entirely impartial source. Nevertheless, in a letter from Alberta's health
00:34:43 minister, Adriana Lagrange, he quotes this line, please know that there is no evidence of live birth
00:34:50 abortions in Alberta. I mean, that's just not true. We had, uh, 28. This is from the, if I'm not
00:34:59 mistaken, this is from the Canadian Institute of Health Information. Yes. So that's not some, uh,
00:35:03 right-wing pro-life Christian fanatic. Exactly. Um, and I, I don't know whether Ms. Lagrange wrote
00:35:11 that herself or whether that was prepared for a signature by, by somebody within the ministry. Um,
00:35:17 um, but it is not true. And that is the, one of the difficulties that we have with this whole issue
00:35:25 is knowing what to believe because the people who want abortion and like abortion and feel that it's
00:35:31 a right for women will certainly deny, deny, deny. Uh, in my earlier incarnation, while I was on the, 0.98
00:35:39 uh, on an editorial board, I visited an abortion clinic with other members of the editorial board.
00:35:47 We sat down with somebody who was performing abortions and I said, doesn't it bother you that 1.00
00:35:53 they, the, the thing that you are trying to abort is feeling pain? You wouldn't even do that to a puppy.
00:36:01 Oh, they don't feel pain. That is just not true. When you see images where the needle goes in,
00:36:10 the fetus, the baby is squirming and riddling and trying to get away from it. It is the most horrific
00:36:18 thing to say. Of course they feel bloody pain. What do these people believe? So it is incredibly hard
00:36:27 to have a sensible conversation about abortion because people will deny what is manifestly obvious. And
00:36:35 you have, I mean, I use CIHI statistics all the time when I'm talking about COVID. I have no reason to
00:36:43 believe that they are wrong when they say that there were a thousand hundreds to a thousand
00:36:52 live births. Yeah. That's not even just late term. That's live abortions where it, where a late term 1.00
00:36:57 abortion fails and the child is still born. So I, you know, this was something I didn't, I didn't get.
00:37:04 I had to, I had to ask the question, if you are attacking a baby inside a womb with the standard 0.75
00:37:14 vacuum cleaner apparatus that we read about, how does anything survive being sucked into a jet engine?
00:37:21 Well, the answer is that in certain circumstances, they don't use that technology.
00:37:26 They use the injection and then they hold the baby out with the forceps.
00:37:32 This is pretty graphic stuff. And I apologize for people who are put off for it. And by the way,
00:37:40 in this tragic situation, this is not an anti-woman rant on my part. So often the people who want the
00:37:48 abortion more than the woman is the man who's involved in the case. There's a lot of women who have abortions 1.00
00:37:54 who don't actually want them, but somebody else does. Anyway, leaving that aside and God bless the people
00:38:01 who do it, you know, who regret it. Here we have this, this frightful situation where the baby comes out
00:38:12 and they just leave it on the slide. Where is the humanity? I, I, I cannot.
00:38:18 Yeah. And people don't like discussing it. It's, it's a squeamish, a challenging area. And a lot of
00:38:26 people don't even realize it or know it. We are unregulated as Derek said. I think it's through
00:38:29 Morgenthaler in the past where that came about. We just have nothing there, which technically means
00:38:34 there's nothing to stop this. And we, you know, countries, most countries have some degree of
00:38:39 regulation. They draw a line usually around viability. Yeah. And kind of third trimester.
00:38:44 Yeah. And, and we're getting well beyond that when live babies are being delivered and this is
00:38:48 really problematic. And we got to quit making that excuse. Look, if you snip the umbilical cord,
00:38:52 even a premature one and put it into an incubator and then somebody came along and stabbed it,
00:38:56 they will be charged with murder. But if it turns out they're saying, well, I wanted an abortion. Well,
00:39:01 then we'll let that same child, same one, die. Now we're playing semantics with a murder is what 0.89
00:39:07 we're doing. And I know nobody likes to talk about it. I'm a libertarian. I, I do believe, you know,
00:39:12 that's a separate discussion on early term, uh, ability to do that. You've been pro-choice for a
00:39:18 very long time. I have. But even you think that there's got the alliance. The line has to be somewhere
00:39:22 in viability. We, we've got a lot of science to start in other countries we could look at with,
00:39:26 with where a line can be drawn. And right now when we have that void, but no politician wants to touch it
00:39:30 with a 10 foot pole. Also, because anyone who says there should be a line somewhere,
00:39:34 even an extremely generous to the pro-choice side line, they'll say, well, that's just the
00:39:41 split-degree slots of banning. You know, it's, it's become so fanatical. There was a great old
00:39:44 movie that really didn't do that great, I think, but, uh, it was called Citizen Ruth. If you might
00:39:48 remember it from the early nineties, it had Burt Reynolds and a few others, but it kind of showed the
00:39:52 insanity of both sides. It was a, a glue huffer who was found pregnant and pro-lifers have gotten old
00:39:58 ever. And it turned into a big fight between the crazed pro-life bunches and the crazed pro-choice
00:40:03 bunches. And it really did show both sides as being fanatically crazed on each end of it, kind of.
00:40:08 And I mean, it's serious business, but I mean, that it really, there's no room for nuance anymore.
00:40:15 Back when I was, you know, I'll give it a little personal. When I was 20, I had gotten a girl
00:40:19 pregnant. We went to, cause we weren't sure what we wanted to do. And we went down town. It used to be out
00:40:24 by the, the Cecil, actually the family planning clinic, but, uh, and by the way, that's my son.
00:40:29 We made our choice to keep, but when we chatted about it, we wanted to hear all options. We really
00:40:34 did. But that person, that counselor or whatever sat with us, there was only one option in her world.
00:40:39 Abort, abort, abort, abort. That's all she was doing was convincing. You guys are too young. You
00:40:44 aren't in a condition to deal with this. You really must. And we can set you up and giving it, well, again,
00:40:48 what were the other options? What about adoption? What about, you know, supports if we want to raise it
00:40:53 ourselves, all of that. We didn't get any of that. That's just one example, but that really did sour
00:40:58 me on the advocates for this. We really did want to come in there and hear about all the options on
00:41:03 the table. We've got advocates who were married to one end or another. And those advocates are, again,
00:41:11 they want no regulation under any circumstance. Uh, I don't want to see it as advocates on someone who
00:41:16 want to see it, you know, illegalized from the point of conception. Uh, I would like to see a line
00:41:22 drawn somewhere. And I think viability is kind of where we can start. Yeah. Well, yeah.
00:41:29 You know, the other thing, Derek, we want to see a few lines drawn around
00:41:33 life at the other end, too. Medical assistance and dying.
00:41:36 Yeah. I think we've erased lines at both ends.
00:41:39 True enough.
00:41:40 Yeah. That's a damn good point. 0.98
00:41:42 Um, I mean, where you draw the line, I mean, there's only one really clear line and that would 0.96
00:41:48 be the hard pro-life side, which is conception. Okay. I'm not prepared to draw it there. Um,
00:41:54 even if you think that is like, and you know, but I actually do think that's probably where life
00:42:00 is created.
00:42:01 It's a big debate. It's a tough one.
00:42:02 Yeah. I mean, that is probably where life is, but I mean, it's probably,
00:42:05 it's just not a practical place to draw it. Um, somewhere, you know, towards the end of the
00:42:12 first trimester is probably a reasonable place. If it's going to be after that, it's got to be where
00:42:16 it's absolutely medically necessary. The woman's life is at risk, that kind of thing. But we just
00:42:23 are so fixated ideologically in this country. I mean, look at Europe, these crazy dumb ass 1.00
00:42:32 liberal Europeans, every single one of them, every single European country has some line somewhere. 1.00
00:42:39 And, you know, and there's a spectrum about where they are.
00:42:42 Ireland, I think, had it too strict at one point and a woman died as a result.
00:42:45 That was too far in one way. Um, but very, very liberal countries, France, Germany,
00:42:52 Britain, uh, Spain, like all, all these, you know, run by lefty countries, they all don't allow this.
00:43:00 This is, this is not cool. Um, and I get the conservatives are terrified. They don't want to
00:43:06 touch it. And there are things that actually could be done provincially in the provincial
00:43:09 government's response. When I was a provincial politician to federal jurisdiction. Well, yes,
00:43:13 on the criminal code it is, the administration of healthcare is provincial. And you could decide
00:43:18 not to allow this in, in these most extreme cases, because they are not exceedingly rare.
00:43:24 They're not the majority of abortion cases, but they're not rare. And they are brutally violent.
00:43:30 I said, you wouldn't do it to a puppy. I wouldn't do it to a gopher. So at least what I do to a gopher is a lot more.
00:43:42 Jesus, you do it from a distance with a 22. I mean, here's the reality too. And that's quick. I'm glad
00:43:47 that they're bringing it to public attention. And hopefully maybe at least it has some impact on some
00:43:53 of the women, young women are making decisions and planning and then maybe see the horrors of 1.00
00:43:58 what waiting too long might turn into a doctorate. This is ghoulish. That too. This is ghoulish.
00:44:03 We also know politically, we've been at it so long, the chances of any politician initiate,
00:44:06 they're not going to, no, no one's going to touch this. So all you can do is public information and hope
00:44:11 for the best right now. Anyways, unless something dramatically changes. Yeah. Okay. I hated that,
00:44:17 but you know what? Uh, so anyway, hats off, probably for Alberta, Richard, uh, and, uh,
00:44:24 the right now group. Uh, I I'm not with them on a hundred percent of where they go with these things,
00:44:28 but I, I think they've done a real public service bringing this forward in a very
00:44:33 tasteful way. This wasn't a bunch of graphic images designed to turn so much stomach. I think
00:44:36 they, they made a logical argument actually, and they did journalism here, going out, getting
00:44:41 information, video, proving their case. So hats off to them. That was, that was good work.
00:44:46 Yeah. The front page of the national post of the weekend. Yeah. Yeah. Thanks. Good one.
00:44:50 Okay. Uh, do I have enough time for mine, but you two get a parting shot. We'll, uh, start with
00:44:57 Nigel. Well, yeah, I had something else in mind, but you know, what I would say is that if they did
00:45:02 outside the womb to a child, what they do inside the womb to an unborn baby, we wouldn't be having 1.00
00:45:07 this discussion. It wouldn't be allowed. Yeah. Well, and you know, we don't even, uh, we're not even
00:45:12 willing to, when a, when a person murders an obviously pregnant woman, uh, we don't give them
00:45:19 two counts of murder in Canada, even though that's very often the intent is it's kind of abortion by
00:45:25 execution of the mother. It's a man who doesn't want the child that happens. And we, they still
00:45:30 only get one count of murder. Uh, God, we're messed up. Corey, take us through another topic.
00:45:38 I'll just go through it. It's healthcare, but not nearly as, as, as rough, but, uh, I, I like that,
00:45:42 uh, Premier Smith has released bill 11. I just love the irony that I remember bill 11 when Ralph
00:45:46 Klein did it. Yeah. We're looking at healthcare reform and he backed off and he said that was
00:45:50 one of his great regrets. Uh, I hope Premier Smith does not because we need healthcare reform
00:45:54 terribly. Uh, please, Ms. Smith, stand your ground on this one. Let's get that, uh, private public,
00:46:00 uh, ability out there because our system's failing and people can't deny it anymore.
00:46:05 All right. Gentlemen, Nigel, Corey, John around the studio. Thank you very much.
00:46:12 Thank all of you for joining us today on the pipeline. Remember, if you're not a member,
00:46:17 you're freeloading, you cheap bastard. Go to westernsnetter.news right now, click on subscribe, 0.99
00:46:22 $10 a month or a hundred dollars a year for unlimited access to all Western standard content
00:46:26 and get past the paywall blocking you from getting the very best news in the West. Oh,
00:46:32 yeah. And one last thing, uh, the United Conservative Party's AGM is this weekend.
00:46:37 The Western standard crew is headed north, uh, to cover it all weekend in Edmonton. We are going
00:46:44 to be throwing a very large, very loud and boisterous hospitality suite. The Western standard rager,
00:46:52 we're calling it, um, free drinks, free food. It's going to be a lot of fun to be right at the
00:46:57 convention grounds. So if you're, uh, an Alberta unit conservative party member or visiting from
00:47:02 out of province and you go into the convention, uh, come on by and have a drink on us. Thank you
00:47:07 very much for joining us today and God bless.