Western Standard - October 21, 2021


The Pipeline: Fallout from the Municipal Election & Referendum

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
FILDEBRANDT: The unions bought city hall AHS drops 26,000+ employees from vaccination rate tracking

Episode Stats


Length

50 minutes

Words per minute

165.22

Word count

8,390

Sentence count

603

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this episode of The Pipeline, we discuss the results of municipal elections across Alberta and the involvement of union money in one of them. Also, the ongoing scandal around Calgary City Councillor Sean Chu. What has happened, what has been revealed, and what do we know?

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 .
00:00:30 .
00:01:00 .
00:01:30 Thank you.
00:02:00 Thank you.
00:02:30 Good day. Today is October 20th, 2021. I'm Derek Fildebrandt, publisher of the Western Standard, and you're watching The Pipeline.
00:02:55 I'm joined today by Western Standard News Editor Dave Naylor, who's always in a good mood.
00:03:01 Always in a good mood.
00:03:02 And also joined by Western Standard Alberta political columnist and host of The Cory Morgan Show, Cory Morgan.
00:03:08 Good day.
00:03:09 Well, we've got a very interesting show today.
00:03:14 Largely, we're going to be focusing very much on the fallout of elections and referendums across Alberta Monday evening.
00:03:23 We're going to be going through the Edmonton and Calgary municipal elections and the involvement of some significant union money there.
00:03:34 Also, the ongoing scandal around Calgary City Councillor re-elected Sean Chu.
00:03:39 What has happened, what do we know, and what do we expect?
00:03:43 We're going to talk about the as yet unofficial results of the equalization referendum, the results at least that we have in so far.
00:03:50 And we're going to talk about also the unofficial and incomplete results so far of the Senate election.
00:03:57 I think we have a pretty good idea of how that's likely shaking up.
00:04:00 But we're going to give you an idea of what we know and our projections and go through it.
00:04:07 First, before we begin, though, I want to thank all of our Western Standard members for your continued support. 0.89
00:04:12 You guys kick ass. Without you, we couldn't do our job.
00:04:15 Your support is absolutely crucial for our ability to provide you with independent, non-partisan, and non-government-funded Western media.
00:04:25 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, you should try it out at least.
00:04:29 You don't have to commit all the way.
00:04:31 Just try it out.
00:04:32 You can try it free for 15 days.
00:04:33 You can try it for $10 a month or $99 for an entire year, getting you unlimited access to all Western Standard content.
00:04:42 Try it free for 15 days.
00:04:44 If you like it, continue on. If not, see you later.
00:04:48 Today's show is sponsored by the Calgary Shooting Center.
00:04:52 If you were with us on Monday, you've heard about how much I love this place.
00:04:57 Hunting season's coming up. You've got to sight in your rifles.
00:05:00 This is the place that I go every year, this time of year.
00:05:03 I'm probably going to go maybe this weekend.
00:05:06 I'm going to sight in the scope for my 270 Remington, make sure it's beautiful
00:05:10 and able to find that elk that I'm looking for this year.
00:05:14 So check it out, the Calgary Shooting Center, a beautiful indoor range.
00:05:17 They've got separate pistol and long gun ranges.
00:05:20 Don't try the shotgun. I didn't even know you're not supposed to do that there.
00:05:23 There was a lot of sparks all over the place.
00:05:25 No one told me. I probably should have known.
00:05:28 And I was using steel shot. I really should have known.
00:05:30 Don't use a shotgun in there. It'll be a lot of sparks.
00:05:33 Look pretty cool, but not a good idea.
00:05:36 Check out the Calgary Shooting Center today, the sponsor of our show
00:05:40 and a great institution in Calgary and everywhere around for all the hunters and target shooters
00:05:46 around here. Let's get started with municipal elections. We're going to begin with Edmonton.
00:05:55 Dave, why don't you tell our viewers, I'm sure they already know the results, but we're going
00:05:58 to kind of break it down. How did the Edmonton mayoral race go in that city? Well, Derek,
00:06:04 it turned out it really wasn't much of a race. Edmonton's new mayor-elect is Mayor Soey, a former
00:06:11 Liberal cabinet minister who was defeated in the second to last federal election. He then turned
00:06:19 his attention to civic politics. Coming in second was Mike Nichol, a bit of a ways back.
00:06:27 So once he's sworn in, Edmonton Mayor Soey. And interestingly, Calgary's
00:06:33 Calgary and Edmonton both have a mayor of color now with Jody Gondek's election in Calgary.
00:06:40 I don't know if he's going to be happier as mayor as a cabinet minister.
00:06:45 A cabinet minister seems to have more prestige, but mayors actually have some power.
00:06:48 Most cabinet ministers actually have remarkably little power in this country.
00:06:51 It really just is the prime minister's office and maybe a select one or two others in the cabinet.
00:06:55 But he succeeds, Emergeet Sohee succeeds Don Iveson as mayor. Both of them are on the left
00:07:04 side of the spectrum. What do you think, if anything, is going to change in how Edmonton
00:07:11 is governed? I don't think it's going to change much at all. You know, as you said, Iveson has
00:07:17 a very similar mindset to Sohee. I mean, there's going to be some superficial changes. It sounds
00:07:21 like their council change was pretty similar, more of the same. You're going to see another
00:07:27 left council governance in Alberta. It's just different faces and the same policies.
00:07:32 Edmonton did elect a total of eight women. 1.00
00:07:36 Three.
00:07:37 Yeah, so that's completely shifted the balance of gender on their city council anyway. So he's an 1.00
00:07:43 interesting guy. He immigrated from India, became a taxi driver, then went back to India and was
00:07:51 thrown in jail on what sounds like trumped up terrorism charges. So he did a couple of years,
00:07:57 including solitary confinement, before he was finally released and came back and started a
00:08:03 career in politics. Interestingly, I don't want to jump too much into Calgary here,
00:08:08 but both Calgary and Edmonton have lost their unofficial leaders of the opposition. Both the
00:08:14 leader of the opposition, unofficial leaders of the opposition in Calgary. So Edmonton, you had
00:08:19 Mike Nichol. He went to run for mayor, was not successful. And it's not like federal politics
00:08:24 where, well, the runner-up is still, well, the leader of the opposition in the House of Commons
00:08:28 or in the legislature, and you still have a job and you can hold the government to account. It
00:08:32 doesn't work that way. You're mayor or you're nothing. And we lost that in Calgary too, where
00:08:37 Jeremy Farkas ran for mayor, didn't come in. So in both cases, they lost the leader of the
00:08:43 official opposition. In Edmonton, they also lost John Zadek, another fairly outspoken member of the
00:08:48 Council on the more conservative side. He failed in his bid for re-election, although I'm not
00:08:54 positive, but I'm told the candidate who replaced him is just probably a more moderate conservative
00:09:01 than himself. So, yeah, it was a tough night for conservatives across Alberta, but definitely
00:09:09 in Edmonton where Sohee is going to take the mayor's chair and the conservative
00:09:14 kind of action on that council is much diminished. But let's talk about Calgary. I'm a bit biased,
00:09:21 but I think Calgary is perhaps a bit more interesting. We expected a much closer mayor's
00:09:25 race than we got. The polls had Jeremy Farkas leading, and not just Main Street, which we used,
00:09:30 but all of them had Farkas leading going in until probably the last week or two. Then it showed it 0.55
00:09:37 pretty much in a statistical tie, sometimes with Gondek ahead by one, maximum two points.
00:09:42 but on election night not so. Wasn't even close. The expected fight just didn't develop.
00:09:50 And then she, or the Farkas campaign, excuse me, kind of fell to bits in the late running.
00:09:57 He actually went to Jeff Davison and pleaded with him to basically withdraw and throw his
00:10:04 support behind, you know, sort of anything to stop Gondek, but it just didn't work.
00:10:10 Obviously, a good chunk of those 140,000 advance polls were obviously for her and not for Farkas. 0.98
00:10:18 And yeah, as you say, Farkas is gone from Council, so there will be no fiscal hawk.
00:10:25 There's probably about five candidates, or five or four, that say they're conservative-leaning.
00:10:34 Well, if we're talking about ones who say they're conservative, there will be five with Peter DeMong.
00:10:38 but Peter DeMong is seldom seen working with the conservative bloc if it's a contentious issue.
00:10:44 He's taking the Dale Hodges Ray Jones method. He's understanding. You keep your head down,
00:10:50 you can stay there for 30 years, and he will. Yeah, I mean, he was reelected with roughly 68%.
00:10:55 He was the only non-union endorsed candidate in any ward. He was the only ward in the entire city
00:11:07 where the unions didn't even endorse a candidate because they know there's not even a sense in
00:11:10 going against them. He's just going to get there, no matter what.
00:11:15 He had the name recognition, which is key in municipal politics. So Calgary continues with
00:11:22 a left-leaning council. So the next question is, how does Gondek govern? She said the first thing
00:11:29 she's going to do is declare a climate emergency. And then she's dealing with child care. So it's 1.00
00:11:34 It's great that the new mayor is dealing with federal and provincial issues.
00:11:40 Exactly.
00:11:40 I wonder if she'll get to Rhodes or anything at some point.
00:11:43 They won't have any money for them.
00:11:45 So, I mean, will she be left of Nenshi?
00:11:49 Probably not.
00:11:51 But she's certainly going to be less bombastic, less egotistical,
00:11:55 which will probably help in a way.
00:11:59 And, you know, and as you guys hinted at, you know,
00:12:03 one of the key stories out of this was union involvement. They spent $1.7 million, way
00:12:09 more than everybody else combined, and they got themselves a pro-union city councilman.
00:12:16 So by my count, the union endorsed candidates took nine slots, added Richard Poopmans, who
00:12:25 was not endorsed by the union, but is solid liberal. The union's endorsed more NDP, full
00:12:32 socialist. I guess being a liberal was not socialist enough. But you add him to the progressive
00:12:37 union bloc, that's 10. By my count, I mean, and we'll get to Sean Chu in a bit here, but if Sean,
00:12:43 if Sean Chu somehow clears his name and continues on that before conservatives, and then Peter DeMong,
00:12:52 the five swing, but he almost always goes with the majority anyway. He knows which way the wind blows
00:12:56 and he's going to go, he'll, so he'll probably side with the progressive union bloc, I would
00:13:01 imagine on most things, just because that's where it's going. Speaking of going where the wind blows,
00:13:05 the human weather vane, Diane Colley Urquhart, finally defeated. She has been a progressive
00:13:12 conservative. She's been a wild roser. She has publicly backed the NDP when they were in
00:13:17 government at times until the NDP became unpopular. Then she went back. That chicken has crossed the
00:13:22 road many, many, many times. Long time city councilor. She's now gone replaced by Dan
00:13:31 McClain. I heard there was a lot of anger in the writing because during those crucial
00:13:37 city budget talks, Collier-Cartt buggered off to Antarctica. When she was first re-elected 1.00
00:13:43 or the last term around, they'd just gotten back in and, oh, I'm sorry, but I had this
00:13:47 trip booked, you know. Yeah, exactly. Because we don't know, because municipal elections aren't
00:13:51 fixed elections, right? You don't even know when they're going to be. Or when the budget's going to
00:13:54 be. Yeah, let's be honest. I'd rather watch penguins and go through a city detailed line
00:13:59 by line budget. But, you know, sometimes you get paid to do your job, but she wasn't there.
00:14:04 You show somebody mailing it in, and we get a lot of that in city council. Yeah. So Calgary
00:14:08 City Council, I'd say the conservative block, again, Chu is such a big asterisk around Chu.
00:14:14 don't know if he survives or not, and again, we're going to get into that.
00:14:19 But even if we're including himself in that number,
00:14:23 the Conservative block actually remains roughly the same size.
00:14:26 It was three or four last time. It'll be three or four now.
00:14:28 The difference is that the hard left block is now massive and united.
00:14:36 The left block was only slightly larger than the Conservative block last time
00:14:41 with a bunch in the middle who just kind of do the deals and get what they want.
00:14:44 and they can blow with the wind one way or another.
00:14:46 Now they have an absolute supermajority.
00:14:49 They beat the Conservatives more than two to one.
00:14:52 They've got ten on council, nine if you knock out Poopmans, 1.00
00:14:56 but I think you'll be signing with them anyway.
00:14:59 So this council, even though the Conservatives are the same number,
00:15:03 the left-wing faction, I think, is significantly more powerful.
00:15:07 I think in a long, trying to look at a bigger picture of what's going on,
00:15:11 and what I've seen in these elections this last couple of months,
00:15:13 I'm going to say something that I think most of our type of listeners aren't going to want to hear.
00:15:16 But the truth of it is, the majority of Canadians, including Calgarians, including Edmontonians,
00:15:20 right now want big nanny government taking care of them. 1.00
00:15:24 They want that rectal thermometer in there, monitoring them, taking care of them.
00:15:29 I didn't mention anything about sea life.
00:15:32 James, add it to the list.
00:15:35 But I mean, people want big government right now.
00:15:37 I mean, that was part of what really defeated Farkas. 1.00
00:15:39 You can't even look at the union in Gondek in that case.
00:15:42 A big turning point for him was the vaccination passports. You know, we have a very vocal minority
00:15:47 of people who are very against it, but every other poll shows the majority of people actually
00:15:51 want it. The majority of people want government to have restrictions. They want government to
00:15:59 some, you know, they believe government can take care of this pandemic. It frustrates me. I wish
00:16:03 it wasn't so. And we've seen that in the federal election. I think Kenny has lost more support due
00:16:08 due to his reticence on locking down
00:16:10 than the people he infuriated by locking down.
00:16:12 I mean, he's kind of lost on both sides.
00:16:14 I look at this though,
00:16:15 maybe we need this left-wing government for a little while. 1.00
00:16:17 It's like the old method of,
00:16:19 when you catch the kids smoking,
00:16:20 just send a whole pack down there.
00:16:22 Make them smoke a carton. 0.52
00:16:23 Get them sick.
00:16:24 Get your taste of socialism for four years, guys,
00:16:26 because we're gonna bottom out.
00:16:28 And then maybe you're gonna realize
00:16:30 that the government is not the solution, it's the problem.
00:16:33 But right now, we can point our fingers and blame,
00:16:36 but the electorate has spoken
00:16:37 and they want left-wing leadership.
00:16:39 Well, maybe it'll be like making the kids smoke
00:16:41 a carton of cigarettes so they get sick of it,
00:16:43 or maybe it'll be like heroin and we get hooked on it.
00:16:45 We could go one way or another.
00:16:46 Yeah, but when the heroin runs out,
00:16:48 you gotta do something, so.
00:16:49 But I just, the unions definitely impacted the ward races.
00:16:53 There's no doubt about that, and they were scattered.
00:16:55 Let's talk about the unions.
00:16:56 Dave mentioned that, so there's a super PAC
00:17:00 called Calgary's Future, very benignly named,
00:17:02 non-threatening named PAC, funded largely by QP,
00:17:06 and I think maybe one other union, they've put in $1.7 million.
00:17:10 It was more money for their candidates to spend than all others combined.
00:17:14 And I think there is, I think I sussed this out a bit in my column,
00:17:19 that the impact isn't just that they have a bunch of money to spend against, say, the conservatives.
00:17:26 It's that it helps them form an unofficial political party,
00:17:29 because there's no political parties here to ensure that each side has only one candidate on the ballot.
00:17:34 It's a free-for-all. Anyone can get on the ballot.
00:17:36 and there's not really a way to clear the field of people who would, for lack of a better term, split the vote with you.
00:17:44 So for the mayor's chair, let's just use that as an example.
00:17:48 Jody Gondek was the only credible left-leaning candidate on the ballot.
00:17:53 Any others who came along, they either dropped out like Kent Herr, they saw the writing on the wall,
00:17:57 or they ran nil campaigns, didn't register above, into the 1%.
00:18:03 On the right side, you had Jeremy Farkas, but then you also had kind of red Tory-ish type candidates like Jeff Davison, Brad Field, intelligent and credible candidates, but who couldn't win.
00:18:18 The left had this pack, and they could say, this is our candidate, and they're going to have an overwhelming financial advantage in the campaign, and so you may as well not bother, because they're just going to clear through.
00:18:32 But on the other side, well, there was no single organization that could point its finger and say,
00:18:37 Jeremy Farkas is our guy or Jeff Davison is our guy.
00:18:40 And that meant that the right, whose financing, it was not only just less, was also more diffuse.
00:18:47 They had to actually get their own donors.
00:18:50 And so I think that is effectively created a de facto political party, at least on the left in council.
00:18:57 And I know you had something to say about...
00:18:59 Yeah, well, I wrote that column on it.
00:19:01 And I think it's time for a party to come on the conservative end.
00:19:04 But I mean, that aside, and as you said, there's a de facto one.
00:19:06 And I believe the sway I said in the column is the only thing worse than an official political party is an unofficial political party.
00:19:12 This is one hiding in the shadows.
00:19:13 So if we're going to play the games, let's bring it out in the open and get actual solid organized groups because we're losing, guys.
00:19:19 We're losing.
00:19:20 And there is a law that, you know, some union members were upset that the way their fees are being used and what political things they were supporting, and the government wrote a law, and the law passed, and it hasn't been officially signed in yet.
00:19:37 This law was passed by the Alberta legislature.
00:19:39 It was a UCP bill, and it would require that if unions want to spend money on political purposes,
00:19:46 that they have to get the opt-in of individual union members to have their dues go into it.
00:19:51 Traditionally, the union just says, well, we have their money, and we're going to spend it however we like,
00:19:55 and we're going to spend it on political parties, even if many of our members don't agree with it.
00:19:59 That bill passed the Alberta legislature, I believe, a long time ago.
00:20:03 But here's a really weird, niche-y thing about Alberta.
00:20:06 A bill passes the legislature, and then it goes and gets signed by the lieutenant governor.
00:20:10 But then it goes back to cabinet, and it's still not the law until the cabinet passes it again and gets enacted.
00:20:18 Kenny's been sitting on this bill.
00:20:20 And so you have this legislation that would still allow the unions to spend money,
00:20:24 but actually, you know, ask people before they can spend their money.
00:20:27 And it wasn't proclaimed.
00:20:28 And this would have made a decisive, I don't know how much of a difference,
00:20:32 but it would have been a decisive difference in at least the finance of the campaign.
00:20:36 And as I said, I think in how just simply the candidate layout works,
00:20:40 he probably would have had more lefty candidates. 0.91
00:20:42 It beggars belief that Kenny wouldn't sign it
00:20:44 because you would think that it would benefit conservative candidates.
00:20:48 It's because he's already got like a three-front war going on
00:20:51 and he didn't want the municipal unions being the next ones exploding on him.
00:20:55 To be honest, he avoided it late in the fire, though he shouldn't.
00:20:58 Yeah. Well, let's move on to the fallout of a lot of this.
00:21:04 Days before the municipal election, documents came to light of,
00:21:13 they really only showed, the documents that we've seen,
00:21:16 really only showed, it was an invest, a review by the Law Enforcement Review Board of Alberta
00:21:21 into, why don't you say it?
00:21:26 Sure.
00:21:26 You're the news guy.
00:21:28 This is all going back to 1997, so cast your memories back a very long time, 24 years.
00:21:36 This is when Sean Chu was a constable with the Calgary Police Service.
00:21:41 I interviewed Chu yesterday, it's the only interview he's given out to any media, he's issued a few statements, but we had a very long chat, and here's his side of the story.
00:21:52 He's on duty in uniform, and he gets called to a bar on somewhere near McLeod Trail and 94th Avenue South.
00:22:00 Inside this bar, a licensed establishment, he meets a girl.
00:22:07 He assumes because it's a license, it's actually got to be a woman, legally. 0.97
00:22:11 You have to be over 18 to get in.
00:22:13 He says the girl liked him.
00:22:18 And he thought, you know, bottom line is I could be on to a good thing here.
00:22:25 So he went back to his duties, went back to the office, checked in his gun, registered his gun, he says,
00:22:32 went back home, changed into civilian clothes, went back to the bar to link up with this woman, he thought,
00:22:39 but we all know now it's a 16-year-old girl.
00:22:42 They end up going back to his house.
00:22:45 Chu told me he does not drink alcohol, and he didn't drink alcohol that night,
00:22:49 but he did not know if the girl had been drinking or was inebriated.
00:22:55 They start fooling around.
00:22:57 He said there was kissing and touching.
00:22:59 There was other intimate sex acts, which we won't get into.
00:23:04 But then all of a sudden, the girl said, look, I want to go home.
00:23:08 Chu says he immediately took the girl home.
00:23:11 The girl then files an official complaint with Calgary Police Service alleging sexual assault against Chu. 0.98
00:23:21 That then takes us to seven years of investigations, appeals, counter appeals, charges, more investigations.
00:23:30 Bottom line is, out of all those seven years, the only reprimand that Chu got was a letter of reprimand for caressing the girl's leg in the pub when he was on duty in uniform.
00:23:42 Nothing else, no criminal charges of any kind whatsoever.
00:23:48 Now the story gets murky because other media have reported things like he met the girl at the Husky House downtown, which would just be a restaurant and not a licensed establishment.
00:23:59 Let's talk about the implications of each of these things as you go through it.
00:24:05 That would mean that his defense that he assumed she was over 18 because she was in a bar that
00:24:11 would have required her to be 18, that defense falls apart if it was the Husky House. 1.00
00:24:16 And so CTV and some others, or at least CTV is reporting that it was the Husky House not
00:24:21 a bar.
00:24:23 We haven't seen any documents to that effect, but this is easily verifiable one way or another
00:24:30 because this would clearly be documented and probably agreed by all parties where they
00:24:34 were.
00:24:35 I would imagine that the person making the complaint and allegations and Mr. Chu, they
00:24:39 would all probably agree they know where they are.
00:24:41 And Chu had a partner at the time who was with him.
00:24:43 So if it was Husky House or if it was a bar, that's an important point of dispute right
00:24:49 now that is going to need some facts made public.
00:24:53 Yeah.
00:24:54 Second point of dispute is a gun.
00:24:57 Some media outlets have reported that a gun was produced in the house.
00:25:00 Obviously, that takes things up to a whole new level.
00:25:03 Chu told me no, denied it strongly, 100%.
00:25:06 He said he checked in his gun at the traffic office when he was going off duty.
00:25:12 Again, you know, easily verifiable.
00:25:14 He did tell me that he owned a shotgun, but it wasn't brought out that night.
00:25:21 So again, I would think this is easily verifiable.
00:25:25 This will clearly be in the internal documents that we have not yet seen, but CTV is again
00:25:33 saying that they're reporting that there was a gun involved or someone's alleged there's
00:25:37 a gun involved.
00:25:38 We haven't seen the document that would say that, but that document will exist somewhere.
00:25:44 It has existed, I'm sure, since the night it happened.
00:25:49 Because we know if he checked his gun into the station or not.
00:25:52 Did he keep his gun on him?
00:25:54 This is not going to be hearsay, he said, she said, forever.
00:25:59 This is a verifiable fact that we need.
00:26:03 So fast forward 24 years to last week, when details of these allegations first started
00:26:09 to leak to the media.
00:26:11 timing just days before the election. Chu told me it was nothing but a political assassination,
00:26:17 and he says he's always told the truth, and the truth will prevail. He says, you know,
00:26:24 if a gun had been brought out, there would have been weapons charges laid against him,
00:26:29 and there weren't. So I think Chu won by 52 votes over D.J. Kelly, so there's likely to be a
00:26:37 a recount in Ward 4. Chu may have only survived by getting the advance polling out.
00:26:45 Surely, I think if the advance polls hadn't been strong for him, I think it would have
00:26:49 been a different one.
00:26:50 Yeah, that would have been enough. So, now the fallout becomes political. Marilette Gondek
00:26:55 says she wants him gone, and gone immediately. There are no laws on the city books allowing
00:27:03 them to remove a candidate unless he's criminally charged. There were no criminal charges in
00:27:09 this case. So she's turned up north and asked Edmonton for help. Jason Kenney was asked about
00:27:15 the situation yesterday and he said it was appalling. And then he threw the onus back
00:27:19 onto Chu and said, if you can't prove your evidence, if you can't prove your story, then
00:27:26 perhaps you should resign. And again, we go back to what Chu says. I told the truth then,
00:27:31 I'm telling the truth now. I've always told the truth. The truth will prevail.
00:27:36 But I think this is a political storm that's not going anywhere very quickly, Derek.
00:27:41 No. I mean, if Chu's story doesn't hold up, he needs to resign.
00:27:47 I mean, there's no doubt about it.
00:27:50 I mean, even if it does hold up, it's still pretty bad.
00:27:54 It's still pretty bad.
00:27:55 But, you know, his defense was that, you know, if he's in this place that he says is not the Husky House, there was an 18 plus establishment at a certain time.
00:28:06 Well, he at least has a better case than if not.
00:28:11 So, but I mean, but if a single threat of this thing comes, and the good thing is, though, that we should be able to check every single one of these facts.
00:28:19 Chu will almost certainly have to consent to the release of any documents around this to want to clear it up.
00:28:25 I think the Calgary Police Service owes it to Calgarians to release these documents, assuming that they're legally allowed to.
00:28:34 Let's see. Was the gun checked in or was the gun out? That's a key part of the story.
00:28:40 Was this at the Husky House or was this at an 18-plus only establishment?
00:28:44 Key part of the story. Let's see the documents, see if it checks out.
00:28:48 Corey, I'm a bit baffled that Gondek and Kenny are swirling around looking for ways to remove
00:28:59 him.
00:29:00 When there is a piece of legislation that could remove him, again, that's passed the
00:29:05 legislature but has not been proclaimed by the government, by Kenny.
00:29:10 It's back of the cabinet's hands.
00:29:11 It's the recall act.
00:29:12 That's because Kenny was afraid he was going to be a UCP MLA who was going to step in it
00:29:14 before a municipal candidate.
00:29:16 We have the recall act.
00:29:17 the Recall Act. This is exactly what the Recall Act is for, because...
00:29:21 This is a perfect example of what it's for, because I mean, we've got what may still
00:29:26 amount to, I mean, we don't know, but Sean may dig his heels in, and it's a he said,
00:29:30 she said situation, and you know, there is nothing on the books to remove somebody aside
00:29:35 from that potential recall legislation. That would give the voters then the means, if it
00:29:39 was that intransigent, to say, if it's this odious, the voters are going to get up, we're
00:29:43 gonna sign that petition and dude you're out it's over. As we said I mean there's
00:29:48 so much in the air now too that we need to see some documents, we need to see
00:29:53 something, we need to see more. This is something so potentially horrific we know
00:29:58 darn well nobody had they had it known this prior to the advance polls would
00:30:02 have voted for Sean but these kinds of stories can be very convoluted and odd
00:30:07 too. I can't defend I haven't seen anything and I've known Sean for 10
00:30:10 years I consider him a friend I'm horrified by this I mean I'm horrified
00:30:14 for his children you know what they're enduring out of this I just don't know
00:30:21 where to go with this we need to see some evidence or proof one way or another
00:30:24 or even if he can't prove it maybe for the sake of your family Sean yourself
00:30:28 just back off and then move into out of the public life because this just and if
00:30:34 this is true well that's beyond the pale we just can't have an elected official
00:30:37 Correct me if I'm wrong, Derek, but doesn't the recall legislation, you can only remove
00:30:42 them after a year and a half?
00:30:44 I believe so.
00:30:45 I have to verify that, but I believe that it was put into the legislation that you can't
00:30:51 initiate a recall petition to recall your politician until a year and a half since the
00:30:56 election day.
00:30:57 The idea being that you can't just re-litigate the last election, like, oh, I didn't like
00:31:00 the results.
00:31:01 Start petitioning the day after the election every time.
00:31:03 And I understand that, but, I mean, this is the problem when you put too many caveats
00:31:07 into the legislation.
00:31:09 What if you get a situation like this?
00:31:11 Now, I mean, it's difficult to thread this needle, but I'm going to try.
00:31:19 If the allegations that are not yet proven are proven to be true, beyond a shadow of
00:31:26 a doubt, he should be on the moon.
00:31:30 If not, they're still bad, but...
00:31:35 And we should always listen to...
00:31:38 This is a very long-standing issue, going back a quarter of a century now, but it's
00:31:42 still pertinent.
00:31:45 But there is due process, and it matters. 0.97
00:31:48 I mean, the MeToo movement has seen a lot of scumbags go down, rightfully so. 0.94
00:31:55 there are some people who did get swept up in that, who did not deserve to go down 0.91
00:32:02 because there was not due process. And I'm not positive it was Voltaire, but he said,
00:32:07 I would rather a thousand guilty men go free than one innocent man be convicted.
00:32:16 And that is justice. And so we need to be careful here. If he's guilty, he should pay the
00:32:21 consequences politically. But we have to, I think it behooves us to respect due process.
00:32:28 Let it play out. Let's see the evidence. And the great thing is, this is not just the he said,
00:32:32 she said of a man and a woman in an apartment somewhere with no witnesses. There are verifiable
00:32:39 facts around this as we've discussed. Let's see the documents and then we can make a decision.
00:32:43 And the pitchforks are out. And I think a lot of it is, well, people are outraged if they believe
00:32:48 what has happened, of course, but there's political play going on here.
00:32:52 He was one of the most outspoken conservatives.
00:32:54 There are some people very eager to get him out of there at all costs.
00:32:57 Well, again, it doesn't have to happen tomorrow, as much as you guys feel like it.
00:33:01 I mean, some people, and there's misconceptions.
00:33:04 I've seen some of that in social media.
00:33:05 If Sean backs off tomorrow, there's going to be a by-election.
00:33:08 DJ Kelly doesn't immediately get in.
00:33:10 You're going to have to run again, because you can't presume that everybody who voted
00:33:15 for Sean would have voted for DJ.
00:33:16 They might have voted for another one of the candidates, so there will be another.
00:33:19 So, I mean, this doesn't have to happen today.
00:33:21 We want to resolve this as soon as possible.
00:33:23 One thing I agree with Gonda, because it's a huge distraction.
00:33:26 Well, we've got a new administration coming in, and everybody's focused on this.
00:33:29 But, you know, put the pitchforks down, and let's see what's happening here.
00:33:33 Unless he resigns, this is not going to come to a quick conclusion.
00:33:36 No.
00:33:36 Right?
00:33:37 You've got all these documents.
00:33:38 They're sealed by judges.
00:33:40 You know, it's not as though the media can just go and ask for them.
00:33:44 Does the CPS reopen the investigation?
00:33:46 All these allegations were investigated 24 years ago, and there were no charges.
00:33:51 But certainly, with the MeToo movement, you know, the attitudes have changed.
00:33:55 Well, let's remember, the girl who made the allegation here, she complained that there was a cover-up.
00:34:03 She said there was a cover-up, and that's the documents we have seen.
00:34:06 It was the appeals of the investigations into allegations of wrongdoing.
00:34:11 She alleges that there was a cover-up and that this was not handled correctly.
00:34:15 The Law Enforcement Review Board disagreed, appeal court, an appellate court overturned
00:34:23 one of those reviews and a second review and investigation was done and that was upheld.
00:34:30 But she has alleged that there was a cover up here and I have absolutely no way of saying
00:34:35 that.
00:34:36 I mean, maybe there was, but we have nothing to hang that on.
00:34:41 We have the documents and they say that they're satisfied that the officers who investigated
00:34:46 Chu's behavior that evening was fine, that the investigation was watertight and all good.
00:34:52 And you know, she, the girl, now obviously a woman, must have strong feelings about this.
00:34:58 And she's, seven years she fought for it, seven years, right?
00:35:02 This meant something to her.
00:35:05 She thought this was something to fight for.
00:35:08 And at the end she didn't get what she wanted.
00:35:11 She called it a cover-up and now, a quarter century later, the documents are coming to
00:35:16 light.
00:35:17 Yeah.
00:35:18 And I just, again, though, I mean it beggars belief that after 24 years that it just happened,
00:35:23 because some are almost saying, well, it's just a matter of timing, happened to come
00:35:26 out right when he was about to.
00:35:27 I mean, this was released with the intent to do maximum damage to the country.
00:35:31 Yeah, very certainly there was a political intent that doesn't take away from the content.
00:35:36 It doesn't mean it didn't happen.
00:35:38 There's a lot going on here.
00:35:39 Yeah, it doesn't take away from the content of the allegations.
00:35:44 The original documents, the documents that we've seen, I don't think those are shooting offenses,
00:35:49 but the other allegations that we have not seen documents to back up, they are.
00:35:54 And I have a fair degree of confidence we're going to see those documents soon enough.
00:35:59 So, very difficult situation and a massive distraction for a new city council.
00:36:05 difficult to see how Jody Gondak's going to be able to focus on global warming and federal
00:36:11 child care in the meantime. Okay, let's turn towards the equalization referendum. Maybe a
00:36:18 bit of a happier topic than the last. Albertans voted on October 18th. There's no official result
00:36:29 yet because it's done actually by every single municipality and then forwarded on to the
00:36:33 province. But what do we know so far, Dave? Well, our Western Standard Election Desk has
00:36:38 declared it passed with the magic desk that goes up and down. Yeah, our projections show that it's
00:36:50 going to pass with 60 plus percent. Calgary passed it with 58 percent. Lethbridge was 59 percent.
00:36:58 The Red Deer and Medicine Hat were way up there at 69%.
00:37:02 Edmonton didn't want to play with everybody else and they've kept their results secret.
00:37:07 As Derek mentioned, it will be released by Elections Alberta on October 26th.
00:37:14 But, you know, when you're looking at all these areas, you can see that it's probably going to pass with a, you know, 60% plus mandate.
00:37:23 mandate, but Premier Kenney seemed happy with that yesterday. He had initially said all he
00:37:32 was looking for was 50% plus one, which I think was a bit of a...
00:37:36 I've got to bridge the side if you believe that.
00:37:38 Yeah, exactly. He was hoping for a lot higher than this, but his personal unpopularity has
00:37:44 obviously kept the vote from being where he wanted it to be.
00:37:48 Yeah, so we don't have Edmonton. Obviously, that's the biggest missing chunk right now.
00:37:52 We've got a sampling of the medium municipalities, Lethbridge's, Medicine Hats, Red Deers, things like that. 1.00
00:37:58 That gives us an indication of how similar-sized communities and similarly located communities will vote.
00:38:04 I haven't seen any of the smaller towns, places like Strathmore and Drumheller.
00:38:10 I haven't seen those, and we certainly haven't seen county-level, the real rural, people who don't live as firmly on the grid.
00:38:19 I think, you know, you don't have to be a world-class pollster to predict that the smaller the community gets, the higher the yes vote gets for the equalization vote.
00:38:31 Edmonton is probably going to come in a little bit under Calgary.
00:38:35 Our polling showed as much when we did it.
00:38:38 Polling showed still that a majority of Edmontonians would probably vote for it, but it'll be a, but who knows, maybe it'll be neck and neck.
00:38:45 Maybe even the no side wins by a hair.
00:38:47 We'll see.
00:38:48 But overall, we're looking at 60% plus.
00:38:52 I think actually by simply the mechanics of having this anticlimactic announcement a week after the vote diminishes the effect of the vote.
00:39:02 Sure it does.
00:39:03 I mean, like, if you're going to send a message across Canada, we're pissed and we're doing something.
00:39:08 You need to have it like it's a provincial election.
00:39:10 It's counted that night.
00:39:12 The results are out and we're watching it and we're focused on it.
00:39:15 We're not focused on some councillor in Ward 4 in Calgary.
00:39:19 That gets more coverage in the equalization referendum on election night.
00:39:23 You need to make an event out of it.
00:39:24 There needs to be, you know, you would expect you to have the premier at the yes side headquarters
00:39:30 cheering and giving a triumphal speech and saying,
00:39:33 Justin Trudeau, I'm coming to Ottawa and I'm going to give you a noogie until we get a fair deal.
00:39:37 None of that.
00:39:38 We're going to get an anticlimactic announcement from some bureaucrats a week after the vote is actually taken.
00:39:44 Probably just a press release.
00:39:45 It'll be some press release that goes out,
00:39:48 a little note on Elections Alberta's website saying,
00:39:50 hey, Albertans said this.
00:39:54 Corey, what impact, if anything,
00:39:56 we're actually going to get out of this?
00:39:57 Well, it doesn't hurt.
00:39:58 I mean, it establishes that the majority of Albertans
00:40:00 do see it as an unfair policy,
00:40:03 one that needs to change.
00:40:04 You know, we would like to see it different.
00:40:06 Actually leading to change,
00:40:08 you know, we know that's exceedingly unlikely,
00:40:10 but we know that even if 90% of Albertans voted against it,
00:40:12 it wouldn't change anything.
00:40:13 But it does establish that, I mean, as I said earlier, Alberta's been embracing big government in any state.
00:40:20 But at least even then, the majority can still point at that and say, that program stinks.
00:40:25 You know, we want to do something well.
00:40:27 So, I mean, it didn't do harm.
00:40:28 It's not going to change many things.
00:40:30 Just due to politics and a lot of other things and Kenny's popularity, it didn't come in nearly as strongly as it should have.
00:40:37 And he can't use it the way I think he originally hoped he'd be able to.
00:40:40 It didn't hurt.
00:40:41 I think a successful no vote would hurt.
00:40:44 Then Ottawa and Quebec and other provinces can point and say, 0.93
00:40:49 look, Alberta, even you guys love giving us money, so shut up, be quiet.
00:40:54 So a no vote would have hurt. 0.89
00:40:56 A yes vote could have been positive, I think.
00:40:59 But I think the way it's done, it's going to get a reasonably decent majority,
00:41:04 probably 60% plus as we project.
00:41:06 But it's not going to be the thumping supermajority it should have gotten.
00:41:09 Again, I think the pollsters and most are agreeing that is due in a very large measure to the extreme unpopularity of Premier Jason Kenney.
00:41:21 The whole thing was just really poorly executed.
00:41:23 And even in the best of circumstances, nothing would probably still change except it would make us feel good.
00:41:29 It just seems like the whole thing was a very big missed opportunity.
00:41:32 But now, as we said in our editorial the day before this, before the vote, we said on October 18th, vote yes to end equalization.
00:41:47 But on October 19th, make sure that the federal government doesn't forget about it.
00:41:52 Sorry, the provincial government doesn't let the feds forget about it.
00:41:56 Well, I haven't heard anything.
00:41:57 Now, I guess we don't have the official results yet.
00:41:59 You won't say anything until it is official.
00:42:00 Yeah. But really, what do we honestly expect? Is Jason Kenney, so let's say Monday next week, which is approximately when we're going to have the official results. Is Jason Kenney going to get on a plane, go to Ottawa and, you know, kick Trudeau in the shins until something happens?
00:42:17 He might do something like that, actually. 0.95
00:42:19 I mean, we're at a point of the latest wave of COVID.
00:42:21 It seems to be dropping.
00:42:22 He would like to reset the clock going into the holiday season,
00:42:25 maybe some sort of press push where, okay, I've got this mandate.
00:42:29 Even if he knows, you know, you're just going to slam your face against the door,
00:42:33 it could turn the page a little for him.
00:42:34 I mean, they might have something like that.
00:42:36 I guarantee you that in Trudeau's personal day timer,
00:42:40 he may have, you know, check surfing conditions in Tofino,
00:42:43 But he is not going to have a weight Alberta referendum results on October 26th.
00:42:53 Unless Kenny does exactly what Corey said and make a big deal out of it,
00:43:00 then it's just going to disappear, I think.
00:43:03 You just gave me a great idea to deal up a faux Drudeau day timer.
00:43:07 What does this look like?
00:43:09 Man, you'd have to read it in crayon.
00:43:11 It's just about time to kick off our Halloween Trudeau costume page.
00:43:18 Well, that's racist.
00:43:19 Well, you don't have to do all of his costumes.
00:43:22 The fake eyebrows.
00:43:23 We did do a roundup of Trudeau Halloween costume ideas.
00:43:28 He likes to dress up.
00:43:31 He does.
00:43:32 You know what?
00:43:33 Let's not forget that.
00:43:35 Making a note right now.
00:43:37 Okay, well, let's move on to another vote that may do nothing, but I think is still a good idea to do nonetheless.
00:43:46 Hitting our heads against the brick wall is the national sport of Alberta, which is also Senate elections.
00:43:53 Again, like the equalization referendum, we do not have official results yet, but we get a good idea to make a reasonable projection.
00:44:01 We've got Calgary, and we've got some of these medium-sized cities with the unofficial, partial, and incomplete results so far.
00:44:10 What do we have so far, Dave?
00:44:11 What we have so far, Derek, is looking like a clean sweep for the Conservative Party of Canada candidates.
00:44:19 Erica Barutz, Pam Davidson, and M&Ms.
00:44:24 Again, I'm sorry, can't pronounce your name.
00:44:26 That's a tough name.
00:44:26 It is a tough name.
00:44:27 So if the results from the small selection we've got are confirmed by the rest of the province and there's really no reason to think that they won't be, then I guess those three have to go sit in a special padded room and wait until they get the beck and call from Justin Trudeau.
00:44:47 The PPC candidates, they had a big slate too, and Maxime Bernier, the leader of the party, came to Alberta to campaign.
00:44:58 Really didn't translate much at the polls. Their candidates were sitting around 4 or 5 percent.
00:45:03 Well, percentages are tough for this because you get three votes.
00:45:06 Yes.
00:45:07 So, like, if you're voting this slate, then you kind of actually add all three together to get a percentage.
00:45:12 pitch. So if they're around, you know, say each, if everybody voted, if you're voting
00:45:18 for one PPC candidate and say you voted the whole slate and they were averaging 5% each,
00:45:23 you would say the PPC got 15%. It's an unusual election. You know, when you vote for your
00:45:28 council, your mayor, your MP, your MLA, you get one vote. You check them off or you put
00:45:33 an X on the ballot, it's done. With this, you get three. So the percentages is tough
00:45:39 as a measure, unless you're adding the parties together.
00:45:43 Yeah, and I failed math 10, so I'm no good in this discussion.
00:45:48 That's why we put you in charge of the big stuff.
00:45:50 Exactly.
00:45:53 Corey, yeah, so it looks like the Tories, as expected,
00:45:55 are going to win.
00:45:58 Doug Horner, former Alison Redford finance minister,
00:46:02 my old best friend,
00:46:04 he's actually got a fairly surprisingly strong showing so far.
00:46:09 Again, some of this might be very regional, how, you know, if you, a lot of these candidates are going to,
00:46:15 especially independents, might do well in their zone where people might have some idea of them.
00:46:20 But, you know, if James ran for Senate, I'm sure there'd be some people in Medicine Hat
00:46:26 and the north side of the Boa River who votes for him.
00:46:29 But people in Airdrie, they may as well be in high level.
00:46:35 No one there is going to know him.
00:46:36 So some of these independents will have regional variations.
00:46:38 And that's probably why Horner is doing well, because people are looking at this long list
00:46:43 of names and, oh, Horner, geez, that rings a bell somewhere, you know, oh, click.
00:46:48 Now, if it said Horner, Allison Redford, finance minister, maybe not so well.
00:46:52 Not so well.
00:46:53 But luckily, it just says Doug Horner, independent.
00:46:59 Over under Corey, what are the chances any of these people go to the Senate?
00:47:03 I'd put a 50-50.
00:47:04 I mean, it's like a six-year, I believe, term in senator-in-waiting.
00:47:09 I'd like to think that we might have a new prime minister within six years.
00:47:14 It would require not just a new prime minister, but a prime minister from a new party.
00:47:18 Well, yes, it would be somebody other than the liberals, which is a possibility.
00:47:22 And traditionally, in the past, some conservative governments have appointed our chosen elected senators.
00:47:27 So it's not impossible.
00:47:29 The chances of it happening while Prime Minister Clowness, who sits on the throne, though, are pretty much nil.
00:47:33 So, I mean, they don't need to be picking out their seats in the Red Chamber quite yet.
00:47:38 They could probably kick back and take their time as a senator in waiting.
00:47:41 There is two spots, one of which was open before the last federal election, that he didn't fill.
00:47:48 I'm extremely hesitant to think that he's going to do it.
00:47:50 But, I mean, there are some vacancies, and one of them was, there's two vacancies now.
00:47:54 One of them was not filled from before. 0.99
00:47:56 I mean, I think it's extraordinarily unlikely, but maybe to throw a bone to show he's not a total asshole. 0.97
00:48:03 Maybe he gives us one and appoints some jag off for the other one. 0.99
00:48:08 I don't know. 1.00
00:48:08 You know, I thought on that and I thought, well, for one, he doesn't care if we think he's an asshole. 1.00
00:48:13 No. 1.00
00:48:13 He's well aware of that.
00:48:14 And the other thing is, though, it just sets, they would legitimize our process.
00:48:19 He just can't do that because then other provinces will dare to actually start thinking maybe they could elect him too.
00:48:24 Yeah, there's no chance of these people being appointed while Trudeau's in power.
00:48:27 So what I'm saying is it's more than 0% that he does, but it's less than 0.1%.
00:48:38 Yeah, getting around there.
00:48:39 If he's having a tantrum because his own party's kicking him out
00:48:42 and he wants to lob a turd into the punch bowl, he might do something like that.
00:48:46 I mean, maybe someone drugs him and puts the document in front of him and he signs it.
00:48:52 It could happen.
00:48:54 Okay, well, we're going to wrap it up there.
00:48:56 I want to thank you all for joining us today.
00:48:58 Today's show was sponsored by the Calgary Shooting Center.
00:49:02 Again, this is a fantastic facility,
00:49:04 great place to go this time of year to sight your guns before hunting season
00:49:07 if you're not already out there for bows.
00:49:10 And you can go shoot there all year round, nice and warm.
00:49:14 I mean, sometimes I go out into Crown Land
00:49:16 and blast at some innocent tree stumps,
00:49:19 but it's really cold.
00:49:20 I like going to the Calgary Shooting Center, 0.88
00:49:22 Keep my fingers warm and murder some innocent pieces of paper there.
00:49:26 So, yeah, today's show is sponsored by the Calgary Shooting Center.
00:49:29 Check them out.
00:49:30 A magical facility here in Calgary, right off of McLeod.
00:49:34 I want to thank all of our Western Standard members for your continued support.
00:49:38 Without you, we couldn't do the job we do.
00:49:40 If you're not yet a member of the Western Standard, go to westernstandardonline.com.
00:49:43 Click on membership.
00:49:45 You can try it free for 15 days.
00:49:46 It's only $10 a month or $99 a year to get you unlimited access to Western exclusive and government bailout free media.
00:49:56 Also, be sure to check out the next edition of Western Standard Uncensored this Thursday at 7 o'clock Mountain Standard Time.
00:50:05 That's Danielle Smith, Bruce McAllister, and Rob Anderson.
00:50:09 They're going to be discussing mandatory vaccination.
00:50:12 What is the constitutionality around this?
00:50:14 the ethics of this? Do the governments have any case whatsoever in a free country forcing these
00:50:22 kind of things on people? They're going to be breaking down the issue and discussing it.
00:50:27 Dave, Corey, it's been a slice. Thank you all very much for joining us today. God bless.
00:50:44 You